text
stringlengths 791
228k
| parts
listlengths 6
567
|
|---|---|
Definitions
-----------
The most common definition of a correlation function is the [canonical ensemble](/wiki/Canonical_ensemble "Canonical ensemble") (thermal) average of the scalar product of two random variables, s\_1 and s\_2, at positions R and R\+r and times t and t\+\\tau:
C (r,\\tau) \= \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t\+\\tau)\\rangle\\ \- \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t\+\\tau) \\rangle\\,.
Here the brackets, \\langle \\cdot \\rangle , indicate the above\-mentioned thermal average. It is important to note here, however, that while the brackets are called an average, they are calculated as an [expected value](/wiki/Expected_value "Expected value"), not an average value. It is a matter of convention whether one subtracts the uncorrelated average product of s\_1 and s\_2, \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t\+\\tau) \\rangle from the correlated product, \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t\+\\tau)\\rangle, with the convention differing among fields. The most common uses of correlation functions are when s\_1 and s\_2 describe the same variable, such as a spin\-spin correlation function, or a particle position\-position correlation function in an elemental liquid or a solid (often called a [Radial distribution function](/wiki/Radial_distribution_function "Radial distribution function") or a pair correlation function). Correlation functions between the same random variable are [autocorrelation functions](/wiki/Autocorrelation_function "Autocorrelation function"). However, in statistical mechanics, not all correlation functions are autocorrelation functions. For example, in multicomponent condensed phases, the pair correlation function between different elements is often of interest. Such mixed\-element pair correlation functions are an example of [cross\-correlation functions](/wiki/Cross-correlation "Cross-correlation"), as the random variables s\_1 and s\_2 represent the average variations in density as a function position for two distinct elements.
### Equilibrium equal\-time (spatial) correlation functions
Often, one is interested in solely the *spatial* influence of a given random variable, say the direction of a spin, on its local environment, without considering later times, \\tau. In this case, we neglect the time evolution of the system, so the above definition is re\-written with \\tau \= 0. This defines the **equal\-time correlation function**, C(r,0\). It is written as:
C (r,0\) \= \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t)\\rangle\\ \- \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(R\+r,t) \\rangle\\,.
Often, one omits the reference time, t, and reference radius, R, by assuming equilibrium (and thus time invariance of the ensemble) and averaging over all sample positions, yielding:
C (r) \= \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(0\) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(r)\\rangle\\ \- \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(0\) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(r) \\rangle
where, again, the choice of whether to subtract the uncorrelated variables differs among fields. The [Radial distribution function](/wiki/Radial_distribution_function "Radial distribution function") is an example of an equal\-time correlation function where the uncorrelated reference is generally not subtracted. Other equal\-time spin\-spin correlation functions are shown on this page for a variety of materials and conditions.
### Equilibrium equal\-position (temporal) correlation functions
One might also be interested in the *temporal* evolution of microscopic variables. In other words, how the value of a microscopic variable at a given position and time, R and t, influences the value of the same microscopic variable at a later time, t\+\\tau (and usually at the same position). Such temporal correlations are quantified via **equal\-position correlation functions**, C (0,\\tau). They are defined analogously to above equal\-time correlation functions, but we now neglect spatial dependencies by setting r\=0, yielding:
C (0,\\tau) \= \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(R,t\+\\tau)\\rangle\\ \- \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(R,t) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(R,t\+\\tau) \\rangle\\,.
Assuming equilibrium (and thus time invariance of the ensemble) and averaging over all sites in the sample gives a simpler expression for the equal\-position correlation function as for the equal\-time correlation function:
C (\\tau) \= \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(0\) \\cdot \\mathbf{s\_2}(\\tau)\\rangle\\ \- \\langle \\mathbf{s\_1}(0\) \\rangle\\langle \\mathbf{s\_2}(\\tau) \\rangle\\,.
The above assumption may seem non\-intuitive at first: how can an ensemble which is time\-invariant have a non\-uniform temporal correlation function? Temporal correlations remain relevant to talk about in equilibrium systems because a time\-invariant, *macroscopic* ensemble can still have non\-trivial temporal dynamics *microscopically*. One example is in diffusion. A single\-phase system at equilibrium has a homogeneous composition macroscopically. However, if one watches the microscopic movement of each atom, fluctuations in composition are constantly occurring due to the quasi\-random walks taken by the individual atoms. Statistical mechanics allows one to make insightful statements about the temporal behavior of such fluctuations of equilibrium systems. This is discussed below in the section on the [temporal evolution of correlation functions and Onsager's regression hypothesis](/wiki/%23Time_evolution_of_correlation_functions "#Time evolution of correlation functions").
### Generalization beyond equilibrium correlation functions
All of the above correlation functions have been defined in the context of equilibrium statistical mechanics. However, it is possible to define correlation functions for systems away from equilibrium. Examining the general definition of C(r,\\tau), it is clear that one can define the random variables used in these correlation functions, such as atomic positions and spins, away from equilibrium. As such, their scalar product is well\-defined away from equilibrium. The operation which is no longer well\-defined away from equilibrium is the average over the equilibrium ensemble. This averaging process for non\-equilibrium system is typically replaced by averaging the scalar product across the entire sample. This is typical in scattering experiments and computer simulations, and is often used to measure the radial distribution functions of glasses.
One can also define averages over states for systems perturbed slightly from equilibrium. See, for example, [http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/\~batista/vaa/node56\.html](http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/~batista/vaa/node56.html) {{Webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181225060259/http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/\~batista/vaa/node56\.html \|date\=2018\-12\-25 }}
|
[
"Definitions\n-----------",
"The most common definition of a correlation function is the [canonical ensemble](/wiki/Canonical_ensemble \"Canonical ensemble\") (thermal) average of the scalar product of two random variables, s\\_1 and s\\_2, at positions R and R\\+r and times t and t\\+\\\\tau:\nC (r,\\\\tau) \\= \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t\\+\\\\tau)\\\\rangle\\\\ \\- \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t\\+\\\\tau) \\\\rangle\\\\,.",
"Here the brackets, \\\\langle \\\\cdot \\\\rangle , indicate the above\\-mentioned thermal average. It is important to note here, however, that while the brackets are called an average, they are calculated as an [expected value](/wiki/Expected_value \"Expected value\"), not an average value. It is a matter of convention whether one subtracts the uncorrelated average product of s\\_1 and s\\_2, \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t\\+\\\\tau) \\\\rangle from the correlated product, \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t\\+\\\\tau)\\\\rangle, with the convention differing among fields. The most common uses of correlation functions are when s\\_1 and s\\_2 describe the same variable, such as a spin\\-spin correlation function, or a particle position\\-position correlation function in an elemental liquid or a solid (often called a [Radial distribution function](/wiki/Radial_distribution_function \"Radial distribution function\") or a pair correlation function). Correlation functions between the same random variable are [autocorrelation functions](/wiki/Autocorrelation_function \"Autocorrelation function\"). However, in statistical mechanics, not all correlation functions are autocorrelation functions. For example, in multicomponent condensed phases, the pair correlation function between different elements is often of interest. Such mixed\\-element pair correlation functions are an example of [cross\\-correlation functions](/wiki/Cross-correlation \"Cross-correlation\"), as the random variables s\\_1 and s\\_2 represent the average variations in density as a function position for two distinct elements.",
"### Equilibrium equal\\-time (spatial) correlation functions",
"Often, one is interested in solely the *spatial* influence of a given random variable, say the direction of a spin, on its local environment, without considering later times, \\\\tau. In this case, we neglect the time evolution of the system, so the above definition is re\\-written with \\\\tau \\= 0. This defines the **equal\\-time correlation function**, C(r,0\\). It is written as:\nC (r,0\\) \\= \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t)\\\\rangle\\\\ \\- \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R\\+r,t) \\\\rangle\\\\,.",
"Often, one omits the reference time, t, and reference radius, R, by assuming equilibrium (and thus time invariance of the ensemble) and averaging over all sample positions, yielding:\nC (r) \\= \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(0\\) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(r)\\\\rangle\\\\ \\- \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(0\\) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(r) \\\\rangle\nwhere, again, the choice of whether to subtract the uncorrelated variables differs among fields. The [Radial distribution function](/wiki/Radial_distribution_function \"Radial distribution function\") is an example of an equal\\-time correlation function where the uncorrelated reference is generally not subtracted. Other equal\\-time spin\\-spin correlation functions are shown on this page for a variety of materials and conditions.",
"### Equilibrium equal\\-position (temporal) correlation functions",
"One might also be interested in the *temporal* evolution of microscopic variables. In other words, how the value of a microscopic variable at a given position and time, R and t, influences the value of the same microscopic variable at a later time, t\\+\\\\tau (and usually at the same position). Such temporal correlations are quantified via **equal\\-position correlation functions**, C (0,\\\\tau). They are defined analogously to above equal\\-time correlation functions, but we now neglect spatial dependencies by setting r\\=0, yielding:\nC (0,\\\\tau) \\= \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R,t\\+\\\\tau)\\\\rangle\\\\ \\- \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(R,t) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(R,t\\+\\\\tau) \\\\rangle\\\\,.",
"Assuming equilibrium (and thus time invariance of the ensemble) and averaging over all sites in the sample gives a simpler expression for the equal\\-position correlation function as for the equal\\-time correlation function:\nC (\\\\tau) \\= \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(0\\) \\\\cdot \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(\\\\tau)\\\\rangle\\\\ \\- \\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_1}(0\\) \\\\rangle\\\\langle \\\\mathbf{s\\_2}(\\\\tau) \\\\rangle\\\\,.",
"The above assumption may seem non\\-intuitive at first: how can an ensemble which is time\\-invariant have a non\\-uniform temporal correlation function? Temporal correlations remain relevant to talk about in equilibrium systems because a time\\-invariant, *macroscopic* ensemble can still have non\\-trivial temporal dynamics *microscopically*. One example is in diffusion. A single\\-phase system at equilibrium has a homogeneous composition macroscopically. However, if one watches the microscopic movement of each atom, fluctuations in composition are constantly occurring due to the quasi\\-random walks taken by the individual atoms. Statistical mechanics allows one to make insightful statements about the temporal behavior of such fluctuations of equilibrium systems. This is discussed below in the section on the [temporal evolution of correlation functions and Onsager's regression hypothesis](/wiki/%23Time_evolution_of_correlation_functions \"#Time evolution of correlation functions\").",
"### Generalization beyond equilibrium correlation functions",
"All of the above correlation functions have been defined in the context of equilibrium statistical mechanics. However, it is possible to define correlation functions for systems away from equilibrium. Examining the general definition of C(r,\\\\tau), it is clear that one can define the random variables used in these correlation functions, such as atomic positions and spins, away from equilibrium. As such, their scalar product is well\\-defined away from equilibrium. The operation which is no longer well\\-defined away from equilibrium is the average over the equilibrium ensemble. This averaging process for non\\-equilibrium system is typically replaced by averaging the scalar product across the entire sample. This is typical in scattering experiments and computer simulations, and is often used to measure the radial distribution functions of glasses.",
"One can also define averages over states for systems perturbed slightly from equilibrium. See, for example, [http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/\\~batista/vaa/node56\\.html](http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/~batista/vaa/node56.html) {{Webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181225060259/http://xbeams.chem.yale.edu/\\~batista/vaa/node56\\.html \\|date\\=2018\\-12\\-25 }}",
""
] |
Investigation and trial
-----------------------
### Evidence
After the fire, the police investigation determined that the fire had been started using some form of a liquid accelerant. This evidence included a finding of char patterns in the floor in the shape of "puddles," a finding of multiple starting points of the fire, and a finding that the fire had burned "fast and hot," all considered to indicate a fire that had been ignited with the help of a liquid accelerant. The investigators also found charring under the aluminum front door jamb, which they believed was a further indication of a liquid accelerant and tested positive for such an accelerant in the area of the front door. No clear motive was found, and Willingham's wife denied that the couple had been fighting prior to the night of the fire.{{citation needed\|date\=May 2017}}
### Witnesses
#### Johnny Webb
In addition to the arson evidence presented at the trial, a [jailhouse informant](/wiki/Jailhouse_informant "Jailhouse informant") named Johnny Webb testified at that time. His testimony has been criticized as contentious for several reasons. Webb claimed that Willingham confessed that he set the fire to hide an injury or death of one of the girls, which was caused by his wife. But none of the girls were found at the time of death to have physical injuries that were still distinguishable after the effects of the fire.{{cite news\|title \= Man executed on disproved forensics\|first1\=Steve\|last1\=Mills\|first2\=Maurice\|last2\=Possley\|url\=http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi\-0412090169dec09,0,1173806\.story\|newspaper\=\[\[Chicago Tribune]]\|date\=December 9, 2004\|access\-date\=September 1, 2009 }} Webb later told [David Grann](/wiki/David_Grann "David Grann"), a reporter for *[The New Yorker](/wiki/The_New_Yorker "The New Yorker")*, that he might have been mistaken. He said he was prescribed many medications at that point while being treated for [bipolar disorder](/wiki/Bipolar_disorder "Bipolar disorder").
At Willingham's trial, Webb offered an explanation for the individual, distinguishable burns found on Amber's forehead and arm. He said that Willingham confessed to burning her twice with a piece of "wadded up" paper in an effort to make it appear as though the children were "playing with fire."{{cite web\|title\=Statement of Facts, Volume XI\|url\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\.pdf\|date\=August 18, 1992\|access\-date\=October 25, 2022\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040758/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\.pdf\|archive\-date\=September 28, 2011\|url\-status\=dead}}
Prosecutor John Jackson noted that Webb was considered unreliable, but he later supported an early release from prison for Webb. Webb later sent Jackson a "Motion to Recant Testimony", which declared, "Mr. Willingham is innocent of all charges." Willingham's attorneys were not notified. Webb later recanted his recantation. He later asked, "The statute of limitations has run out on [perjury](/wiki/Perjury "Perjury"), hasn't it?"
Webb and Jackson consistently denied that Webb was offered a sentence reduction in return for his testimony against Willingham. Evidence of such a deal would have eliminated Webb's testimony. In February 2014, *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times")* reported that the [Innocence Project](/wiki/Innocence_Project "Innocence Project") investigators said they had discovered a handwritten note in Webb's files indicating that such a deal was in play.{{cite news\|last\=Schwartz\|first\=John\|title\=Evidence of Concealed Jailhouse Deal Raises Questions About a Texas Execution\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/28/us/evidence\-of\-concealed\-jailhouse\-deal\-raises\-questions\-about\-a\-texas\-execution.html?\_r\=1\|access\-date\=March 29, 2014\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=February 27, 2014}}
#### James Grigson
During the penalty phase of the trial, a prosecutor said that Willingham's tattoo of a skull and serpent fit the profile of a sociopath. Two medical experts confirmed the theory. One of those experts, a psychologist who had not published any research in the field of sociopathic behavior, but only held a master's degree in marriage and family issues was asked to interpret Willingham's [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden "Iron Maiden") poster. He said that a picture of a fist punching through a skull signified violence and death. He added that Willingham's [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin "Led Zeppelin") poster of a fallen angel was "many times" an indicator of "cultive\-type" activities.
The other medical expert, psychiatrist [James Grigson](/wiki/James_Grigson "James Grigson"), known by the moniker "Dr. Death" for his repeated testimony as an expert witness in which he recommended the death penalty, said that a man of Willingham's criminal history was an "extremely severe sociopath" and was incurable. Grigson had served as an expert witness for the prosecution in murder trials across the state of Texas. Prior to his death, he was expelled by the [American Psychiatric Association](/wiki/American_Psychiatric_Association "American Psychiatric Association") and the Texas Society of Psychiatric Physicians for unethical conduct.{{cite news \|last1\=Tolson \|first1\=Mike \|title\=Effect of "Dr. Death" and his testimony lingers \|url\=https://www.chron.com/news/houston\-texas/article/Effect\-of\-Dr\-Death\-and\-his\-testimony\-lingers\-1960299\.php \|access\-date\=July 21, 2018 \|work\=Houston Chronicle \|date\=June 17, 2004}}{{cite news \|last1\=Herskovitz \|first1\=Jon \|title\=Texas appeals court halts execution of man who did not kill anyone \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-texas\-execution\-idUSKCN10U2D6 \|access\-date\=July 21, 2018 \|work\=\[\[Reuters]] \|date\=August 20, 2016}} The APA said that Grigson had violated the organization's ethics code by
> "Arriving at a psychiatric diagnosis without first having examined the individuals in question, and for indicating, while testifying in court as an expert witness, that he could predict with 100 per cent certainty that the individuals would engage in future violent acts."{{cite news \| url \= http://www.ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \| title \= Groups Expel Psychiatrist Known for Murder Cases; Witness nicknamed 'Dr. Death' says license won't be affected by allegations \| publisher \= \[\[Dallas Morning News]] \| date \= July 26, 1995 \| first \= Laura \| last \= Bell \| access\-date \= March 21, 2009 \| url\-status\=dead \| archive\-url \= https://web.archive.org/web/20090307034749/http://ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \| archive\-date \= March 7, 2009 \| df \= mdy\-all }}
The prosecution sought to establish that Willingham's conduct at the time of the fire and in the days afterward was suspicious. As the fire took hold, Willingham was driven out through the front door of his house, where he crouched down near the entrance. On seeing neighbor Diane Barbee, Willingham began to shout at her to call 911, shouting "My babies are in there!" At trial, Willingham's conduct at the scene was described as oscillating between collected and hysterical, at times screaming for assistance and at other times calmly pushing his car back from the flames that were engulfing his house. Willingham later said that he removed the car out of concern that it could explode and worsen the house fire.
#### Witnesses to the event and days after
Eyewitnesses described Willingham as having "singed hair on his chest, eyelids, and head and had a two\-inch burn injury on his right shoulder, but the prosecution highlighted the absence of any evidence of smoke inhalation. His wrists and hands were blackened with smoke. He was eventually transported to the hospital for treatment, in handcuffs."{{cite web\|url\=http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/shared\-blogs/austin/investigative/upload/2009/08/execution\_based\_on\_bad\_investi/D\_Beyler%20FINAL%20REPORT%20082509\.pdf \|title\=Analysis of the Fire Investigation Methods and Procedures Used in the Criminal Arson Cases Against Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham \|author\=Craig L. Beyler \|website\=Alt.coxnewsweb.com \|access\-date\=June 5, 2016}}
According to their sworn statements, both Brandice Barbee and Diane Barbee urged Willingham to return to the house to rescue his children. According to Brandice Barbee, "All I could see was smoke." According to Brandice, he refused, and moved his car away from the fire before returning to sit on a nearby lawn, "not once attempting to go inside to rescue his children." Once the fire had reached [flashover](/wiki/Flashover "Flashover") and the fire department arrived, Willingham became far more agitated, to the point of being restrained by emergency services. In the following days, Willingham returned to the house with some family and friends. Neighbors described this group as having an odd levity, which was seen to turn somber on the arrival of authorities.{{cite web\| title\=Statement of Facts, Volume XII \|url\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\.pdf \| date\=August 19, 1992\|access\-date\=October 25, 2022\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040823/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\.pdf \|archive\-date\=September 28, 2011\|url\-status\=dead}} On returning to the scene of the fire with firefighter Ron Franks, in an effort to recover personal property (which was described as a very usual request at trial), Willingham was visibly dismayed at being unable to find a dart set. At a local bar, where a fundraiser was held for the Willingham family, he placed an order for a replacement set, stating that "money was not a problem now."
#### Motive
The prosecution claimed that Willingham may have been motivated by a desire to rid himself of unwanted children.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.txexecutions.org/reports/320\.asp \|title\=Execution Report: Cameron Willingham – Page 1 \|website\=Txexecutions.org \|access\-date\=June 5, 2016}} The prosecutor claimed the fire that killed the children was the third attempt by Willingham to kill them, and that he had attempted to abort each of his wife's two pregnancies by kicking her in order to cause miscarriages.
Journalist David Grann reported that "...there is evidence that Willingham hit his wife, even when she was pregnant, but there were no police reports or medical evidence indicating that Willingham had tried to abort or kill his children." He wrote, "Willingham's wife insisted during the trial and under interrogation that Willingham had not physically abused the children." The trial testimony by Webb, a jailhouse informant, suggested that Willingham had set the fire in order to cover up an injury or death of one of the children due to his wife's actions. The prosecutor also said that Willingham was a serial [wife abuser](/wiki/Domestic_violence "Domestic violence"), both physically and emotionally. Jackson said Willingham had abused animals and was a [sociopath](/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder "Antisocial personality disorder"). However, those not associated with the case paint a different picture of Willingham. His former probation officer, Polly Goodin, said he had never demonstrated bizarre or sociopathic behavior and that "He was probably one of my favorite kids." Bebe Bridges, a former judge who was often on the "opposite side" of Willingham in the legal system, and who had sent him to jail for stealing, said that she could not imagine him killing his children. "He was polite, and he seemed to care", she said.
### Trial
Willingham was charged with murder on January 8, 1992\.{{cite news \|title\=A timeline of the Cameron Todd Willingham case \|url\=https://www.chicagotribune.com/2011/06/25/a\-timeline\-of\-the\-cameron\-todd\-willingham\-case/ \|access\-date\=July 21, 2018 \|work\=Los Angeles Times \|date\=June 25, 2011}} During his trial in August 1992, he was offered a life term in exchange for a guilty plea, which he turned down, insisting he was innocent.{{cite web\|publisher\=\[\[Amnesty International]]\|title\=Document – USA (Texas): Further Information on Death penalty, Cameron Todd Willingham\|url\=https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/amr51/182/2004/en/\|date\=December 13, 2004 \|access\-date\=September 1, 2009}}
At trial, the fire investigator Vasquez testified there were three points of origin for the fire, which indicated that the fire was "intentionally set by human hands." A sample of burned material near the doorway of the house tested positive for mineral spirits, indicating the presence of lighter fluid. Willingham had escaped the fire with bare feet and no burn marks. This was taken as evidence that the accelerant was poured by Willingham as he left the house. Several witnesses testified for the prosecution.
In 2009, John Jackson, the prosecutor at the trial, stated that burns suffered by Willingham were "so superficial as to suggest that the same were self\-inflicted in an attempt to divert suspicion from himself."{{cite news \|last1\=Jackson \|first1\=John \|title\=Jackson: Guest Commentary – Willingham guilt never in doubt \|url\=http://corsicanadailysun.com/thewillinghamfiles/x46870434/\-08\-28\-09\-JACKSON\-Guest\-Commentary\-Willingham\-guilt\-never\-in\-doubt \|access\-date\=July 20, 2018 \|work\=Corsicana Daily Sun \|date\=September 3, 2009 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130602110745/http://corsicanadailysun.com/thewillinghamfiles/x46870434/\-08\-28\-09\-JACKSON\-Guest\-Commentary\-Willingham\-guilt\-never\-in\-doubt \|archive\-date\=June 2, 2013 \|quote\=The event which caused the three children's deaths was the third attempt by Todd Willingham to kill his children established by the evidence. He had attempted to abort both pregnancies by vicious attacks on his wife, in which he beat and kicked his wife with the specific intent to trigger miscarriages.}} Grann, however, said fire investigators who reviewed the case told him that "Willingham's first\-degree and second\-degree burns were consistent with being in a fire before the moment of '[flashover](/wiki/Flashover "Flashover")' — that is, when everything in a room suddenly ignites."{{cite magazine\|magazine\=\[\[The New Yorker]]\|first\=David\|last\=Grann\|date\=September 4, 2009\|access\-date\=September 6, 2009\|url\=http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2009/09/david\-grann\-response\-to\-jackson.html\|title\=David Grann" The Prosecution Defends Itself}}
Commenting on the condition of the house, Jackson added, "Any escape or rescue route from the burning house was blocked by a refrigerator, which had been pushed against the back door, requiring any person attempting an escape to run through the conflagration at the front of the house." There were two refrigerators in the Willingham house. Jimmie Hensley, a police detective, and Douglas Fogg, the assistant fire chief — who both investigated the fire — told Grann that they had never believed that the refrigerator was part of the arson plot. "It didn't have \[anything] to do with the fire," Fogg said.
Jackson contradicted Willingham's account by claiming blood gas analysis at Navarro Regional Hospital shortly after the fire revealed that Willingham had not inhaled any smoke. Willingham's statement and eyewitness accounts had detailed rescue attempts.
Consistent with typical Navarro County death penalty practice, Willingham was offered the opportunity to eliminate himself as a suspect by [polygraph](/wiki/Polygraph "Polygraph") examination, which Willingham rejected, according to Jackson. Against the advice of his own counsel, Willingham declined a life sentence in exchange for his guilty plea. He insisted he would not admit to something he had not done, even if it meant sparing his life. During his trial, Willingham did not testify; the defense called only one witness, the Willinghams' babysitter, who stated that she believed that Willingham could not have killed his children.
|
[
"Investigation and trial\n-----------------------",
"### Evidence",
"After the fire, the police investigation determined that the fire had been started using some form of a liquid accelerant. This evidence included a finding of char patterns in the floor in the shape of \"puddles,\" a finding of multiple starting points of the fire, and a finding that the fire had burned \"fast and hot,\" all considered to indicate a fire that had been ignited with the help of a liquid accelerant. The investigators also found charring under the aluminum front door jamb, which they believed was a further indication of a liquid accelerant and tested positive for such an accelerant in the area of the front door. No clear motive was found, and Willingham's wife denied that the couple had been fighting prior to the night of the fire.{{citation needed\\|date\\=May 2017}}",
"### Witnesses",
"#### Johnny Webb",
"In addition to the arson evidence presented at the trial, a [jailhouse informant](/wiki/Jailhouse_informant \"Jailhouse informant\") named Johnny Webb testified at that time. His testimony has been criticized as contentious for several reasons. Webb claimed that Willingham confessed that he set the fire to hide an injury or death of one of the girls, which was caused by his wife. But none of the girls were found at the time of death to have physical injuries that were still distinguishable after the effects of the fire.{{cite news\\|title \\= Man executed on disproved forensics\\|first1\\=Steve\\|last1\\=Mills\\|first2\\=Maurice\\|last2\\=Possley\\|url\\=http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi\\-0412090169dec09,0,1173806\\.story\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Chicago Tribune]]\\|date\\=December 9, 2004\\|access\\-date\\=September 1, 2009 }} Webb later told [David Grann](/wiki/David_Grann \"David Grann\"), a reporter for *[The New Yorker](/wiki/The_New_Yorker \"The New Yorker\")*, that he might have been mistaken. He said he was prescribed many medications at that point while being treated for [bipolar disorder](/wiki/Bipolar_disorder \"Bipolar disorder\").",
"At Willingham's trial, Webb offered an explanation for the individual, distinguishable burns found on Amber's forehead and arm. He said that Willingham confessed to burning her twice with a piece of \"wadded up\" paper in an effort to make it appear as though the children were \"playing with fire.\"{{cite web\\|title\\=Statement of Facts, Volume XI\\|url\\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\\.pdf\\|date\\=August 18, 1992\\|access\\-date\\=October 25, 2022\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040758/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\\.pdf\\|archive\\-date\\=September 28, 2011\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"Prosecutor John Jackson noted that Webb was considered unreliable, but he later supported an early release from prison for Webb. Webb later sent Jackson a \"Motion to Recant Testimony\", which declared, \"Mr. Willingham is innocent of all charges.\" Willingham's attorneys were not notified. Webb later recanted his recantation. He later asked, \"The statute of limitations has run out on [perjury](/wiki/Perjury \"Perjury\"), hasn't it?\"",
"Webb and Jackson consistently denied that Webb was offered a sentence reduction in return for his testimony against Willingham. Evidence of such a deal would have eliminated Webb's testimony. In February 2014, *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\")* reported that the [Innocence Project](/wiki/Innocence_Project \"Innocence Project\") investigators said they had discovered a handwritten note in Webb's files indicating that such a deal was in play.{{cite news\\|last\\=Schwartz\\|first\\=John\\|title\\=Evidence of Concealed Jailhouse Deal Raises Questions About a Texas Execution\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/28/us/evidence\\-of\\-concealed\\-jailhouse\\-deal\\-raises\\-questions\\-about\\-a\\-texas\\-execution.html?\\_r\\=1\\|access\\-date\\=March 29, 2014\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=February 27, 2014}}",
"#### James Grigson",
"During the penalty phase of the trial, a prosecutor said that Willingham's tattoo of a skull and serpent fit the profile of a sociopath. Two medical experts confirmed the theory. One of those experts, a psychologist who had not published any research in the field of sociopathic behavior, but only held a master's degree in marriage and family issues was asked to interpret Willingham's [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden \"Iron Maiden\") poster. He said that a picture of a fist punching through a skull signified violence and death. He added that Willingham's [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin \"Led Zeppelin\") poster of a fallen angel was \"many times\" an indicator of \"cultive\\-type\" activities.",
"The other medical expert, psychiatrist [James Grigson](/wiki/James_Grigson \"James Grigson\"), known by the moniker \"Dr. Death\" for his repeated testimony as an expert witness in which he recommended the death penalty, said that a man of Willingham's criminal history was an \"extremely severe sociopath\" and was incurable. Grigson had served as an expert witness for the prosecution in murder trials across the state of Texas. Prior to his death, he was expelled by the [American Psychiatric Association](/wiki/American_Psychiatric_Association \"American Psychiatric Association\") and the Texas Society of Psychiatric Physicians for unethical conduct.{{cite news \\|last1\\=Tolson \\|first1\\=Mike \\|title\\=Effect of \"Dr. Death\" and his testimony lingers \\|url\\=https://www.chron.com/news/houston\\-texas/article/Effect\\-of\\-Dr\\-Death\\-and\\-his\\-testimony\\-lingers\\-1960299\\.php \\|access\\-date\\=July 21, 2018 \\|work\\=Houston Chronicle \\|date\\=June 17, 2004}}{{cite news \\|last1\\=Herskovitz \\|first1\\=Jon \\|title\\=Texas appeals court halts execution of man who did not kill anyone \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-texas\\-execution\\-idUSKCN10U2D6 \\|access\\-date\\=July 21, 2018 \\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\|date\\=August 20, 2016}} The APA said that Grigson had violated the organization's ethics code by",
"",
"> \"Arriving at a psychiatric diagnosis without first having examined the individuals in question, and for indicating, while testifying in court as an expert witness, that he could predict with 100 per cent certainty that the individuals would engage in future violent acts.\"{{cite news \\| url \\= http://www.ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \\| title \\= Groups Expel Psychiatrist Known for Murder Cases; Witness nicknamed 'Dr. Death' says license won't be affected by allegations \\| publisher \\= \\[\\[Dallas Morning News]] \\| date \\= July 26, 1995 \\| first \\= Laura \\| last \\= Bell \\| access\\-date \\= March 21, 2009 \\| url\\-status\\=dead \\| archive\\-url \\= https://web.archive.org/web/20090307034749/http://ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \\| archive\\-date \\= March 7, 2009 \\| df \\= mdy\\-all }}",
"The prosecution sought to establish that Willingham's conduct at the time of the fire and in the days afterward was suspicious. As the fire took hold, Willingham was driven out through the front door of his house, where he crouched down near the entrance. On seeing neighbor Diane Barbee, Willingham began to shout at her to call 911, shouting \"My babies are in there!\" At trial, Willingham's conduct at the scene was described as oscillating between collected and hysterical, at times screaming for assistance and at other times calmly pushing his car back from the flames that were engulfing his house. Willingham later said that he removed the car out of concern that it could explode and worsen the house fire.",
"#### Witnesses to the event and days after",
"Eyewitnesses described Willingham as having \"singed hair on his chest, eyelids, and head and had a two\\-inch burn injury on his right shoulder, but the prosecution highlighted the absence of any evidence of smoke inhalation. His wrists and hands were blackened with smoke. He was eventually transported to the hospital for treatment, in handcuffs.\"{{cite web\\|url\\=http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/shared\\-blogs/austin/investigative/upload/2009/08/execution\\_based\\_on\\_bad\\_investi/D\\_Beyler%20FINAL%20REPORT%20082509\\.pdf \\|title\\=Analysis of the Fire Investigation Methods and Procedures Used in the Criminal Arson Cases Against Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham \\|author\\=Craig L. Beyler \\|website\\=Alt.coxnewsweb.com \\|access\\-date\\=June 5, 2016}}",
"According to their sworn statements, both Brandice Barbee and Diane Barbee urged Willingham to return to the house to rescue his children. According to Brandice Barbee, \"All I could see was smoke.\" According to Brandice, he refused, and moved his car away from the fire before returning to sit on a nearby lawn, \"not once attempting to go inside to rescue his children.\" Once the fire had reached [flashover](/wiki/Flashover \"Flashover\") and the fire department arrived, Willingham became far more agitated, to the point of being restrained by emergency services. In the following days, Willingham returned to the house with some family and friends. Neighbors described this group as having an odd levity, which was seen to turn somber on the arrival of authorities.{{cite web\\| title\\=Statement of Facts, Volume XII \\|url\\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\\.pdf \\| date\\=August 19, 1992\\|access\\-date\\=October 25, 2022\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040823/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\\.pdf \\|archive\\-date\\=September 28, 2011\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} On returning to the scene of the fire with firefighter Ron Franks, in an effort to recover personal property (which was described as a very usual request at trial), Willingham was visibly dismayed at being unable to find a dart set. At a local bar, where a fundraiser was held for the Willingham family, he placed an order for a replacement set, stating that \"money was not a problem now.\"",
"#### Motive",
"The prosecution claimed that Willingham may have been motivated by a desire to rid himself of unwanted children.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.txexecutions.org/reports/320\\.asp \\|title\\=Execution Report: Cameron Willingham – Page 1 \\|website\\=Txexecutions.org \\|access\\-date\\=June 5, 2016}} The prosecutor claimed the fire that killed the children was the third attempt by Willingham to kill them, and that he had attempted to abort each of his wife's two pregnancies by kicking her in order to cause miscarriages.",
"Journalist David Grann reported that \"...there is evidence that Willingham hit his wife, even when she was pregnant, but there were no police reports or medical evidence indicating that Willingham had tried to abort or kill his children.\" He wrote, \"Willingham's wife insisted during the trial and under interrogation that Willingham had not physically abused the children.\" The trial testimony by Webb, a jailhouse informant, suggested that Willingham had set the fire in order to cover up an injury or death of one of the children due to his wife's actions. The prosecutor also said that Willingham was a serial [wife abuser](/wiki/Domestic_violence \"Domestic violence\"), both physically and emotionally. Jackson said Willingham had abused animals and was a [sociopath](/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder \"Antisocial personality disorder\"). However, those not associated with the case paint a different picture of Willingham. His former probation officer, Polly Goodin, said he had never demonstrated bizarre or sociopathic behavior and that \"He was probably one of my favorite kids.\" Bebe Bridges, a former judge who was often on the \"opposite side\" of Willingham in the legal system, and who had sent him to jail for stealing, said that she could not imagine him killing his children. \"He was polite, and he seemed to care\", she said.",
"### Trial",
"Willingham was charged with murder on January 8, 1992\\.{{cite news \\|title\\=A timeline of the Cameron Todd Willingham case \\|url\\=https://www.chicagotribune.com/2011/06/25/a\\-timeline\\-of\\-the\\-cameron\\-todd\\-willingham\\-case/ \\|access\\-date\\=July 21, 2018 \\|work\\=Los Angeles Times \\|date\\=June 25, 2011}} During his trial in August 1992, he was offered a life term in exchange for a guilty plea, which he turned down, insisting he was innocent.{{cite web\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Amnesty International]]\\|title\\=Document – USA (Texas): Further Information on Death penalty, Cameron Todd Willingham\\|url\\=https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/amr51/182/2004/en/\\|date\\=December 13, 2004 \\|access\\-date\\=September 1, 2009}}",
"At trial, the fire investigator Vasquez testified there were three points of origin for the fire, which indicated that the fire was \"intentionally set by human hands.\" A sample of burned material near the doorway of the house tested positive for mineral spirits, indicating the presence of lighter fluid. Willingham had escaped the fire with bare feet and no burn marks. This was taken as evidence that the accelerant was poured by Willingham as he left the house. Several witnesses testified for the prosecution.",
"In 2009, John Jackson, the prosecutor at the trial, stated that burns suffered by Willingham were \"so superficial as to suggest that the same were self\\-inflicted in an attempt to divert suspicion from himself.\"{{cite news \\|last1\\=Jackson \\|first1\\=John \\|title\\=Jackson: Guest Commentary – Willingham guilt never in doubt \\|url\\=http://corsicanadailysun.com/thewillinghamfiles/x46870434/\\-08\\-28\\-09\\-JACKSON\\-Guest\\-Commentary\\-Willingham\\-guilt\\-never\\-in\\-doubt \\|access\\-date\\=July 20, 2018 \\|work\\=Corsicana Daily Sun \\|date\\=September 3, 2009 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130602110745/http://corsicanadailysun.com/thewillinghamfiles/x46870434/\\-08\\-28\\-09\\-JACKSON\\-Guest\\-Commentary\\-Willingham\\-guilt\\-never\\-in\\-doubt \\|archive\\-date\\=June 2, 2013 \\|quote\\=The event which caused the three children's deaths was the third attempt by Todd Willingham to kill his children established by the evidence. He had attempted to abort both pregnancies by vicious attacks on his wife, in which he beat and kicked his wife with the specific intent to trigger miscarriages.}} Grann, however, said fire investigators who reviewed the case told him that \"Willingham's first\\-degree and second\\-degree burns were consistent with being in a fire before the moment of '[flashover](/wiki/Flashover \"Flashover\")' — that is, when everything in a room suddenly ignites.\"{{cite magazine\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[The New Yorker]]\\|first\\=David\\|last\\=Grann\\|date\\=September 4, 2009\\|access\\-date\\=September 6, 2009\\|url\\=http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2009/09/david\\-grann\\-response\\-to\\-jackson.html\\|title\\=David Grann\" The Prosecution Defends Itself}}",
"Commenting on the condition of the house, Jackson added, \"Any escape or rescue route from the burning house was blocked by a refrigerator, which had been pushed against the back door, requiring any person attempting an escape to run through the conflagration at the front of the house.\" There were two refrigerators in the Willingham house. Jimmie Hensley, a police detective, and Douglas Fogg, the assistant fire chief — who both investigated the fire — told Grann that they had never believed that the refrigerator was part of the arson plot. \"It didn't have \\[anything] to do with the fire,\" Fogg said.",
"Jackson contradicted Willingham's account by claiming blood gas analysis at Navarro Regional Hospital shortly after the fire revealed that Willingham had not inhaled any smoke. Willingham's statement and eyewitness accounts had detailed rescue attempts.",
"Consistent with typical Navarro County death penalty practice, Willingham was offered the opportunity to eliminate himself as a suspect by [polygraph](/wiki/Polygraph \"Polygraph\") examination, which Willingham rejected, according to Jackson. Against the advice of his own counsel, Willingham declined a life sentence in exchange for his guilty plea. He insisted he would not admit to something he had not done, even if it meant sparing his life. During his trial, Willingham did not testify; the defense called only one witness, the Willinghams' babysitter, who stated that she believed that Willingham could not have killed his children.",
""
] |
### Witnesses
#### Johnny Webb
In addition to the arson evidence presented at the trial, a [jailhouse informant](/wiki/Jailhouse_informant "Jailhouse informant") named Johnny Webb testified at that time. His testimony has been criticized as contentious for several reasons. Webb claimed that Willingham confessed that he set the fire to hide an injury or death of one of the girls, which was caused by his wife. But none of the girls were found at the time of death to have physical injuries that were still distinguishable after the effects of the fire.{{cite news\|title \= Man executed on disproved forensics\|first1\=Steve\|last1\=Mills\|first2\=Maurice\|last2\=Possley\|url\=http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi\-0412090169dec09,0,1173806\.story\|newspaper\=\[\[Chicago Tribune]]\|date\=December 9, 2004\|access\-date\=September 1, 2009 }} Webb later told [David Grann](/wiki/David_Grann "David Grann"), a reporter for *[The New Yorker](/wiki/The_New_Yorker "The New Yorker")*, that he might have been mistaken. He said he was prescribed many medications at that point while being treated for [bipolar disorder](/wiki/Bipolar_disorder "Bipolar disorder").
At Willingham's trial, Webb offered an explanation for the individual, distinguishable burns found on Amber's forehead and arm. He said that Willingham confessed to burning her twice with a piece of "wadded up" paper in an effort to make it appear as though the children were "playing with fire."{{cite web\|title\=Statement of Facts, Volume XI\|url\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\.pdf\|date\=August 18, 1992\|access\-date\=October 25, 2022\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040758/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\.pdf\|archive\-date\=September 28, 2011\|url\-status\=dead}}
Prosecutor John Jackson noted that Webb was considered unreliable, but he later supported an early release from prison for Webb. Webb later sent Jackson a "Motion to Recant Testimony", which declared, "Mr. Willingham is innocent of all charges." Willingham's attorneys were not notified. Webb later recanted his recantation. He later asked, "The statute of limitations has run out on [perjury](/wiki/Perjury "Perjury"), hasn't it?"
Webb and Jackson consistently denied that Webb was offered a sentence reduction in return for his testimony against Willingham. Evidence of such a deal would have eliminated Webb's testimony. In February 2014, *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times")* reported that the [Innocence Project](/wiki/Innocence_Project "Innocence Project") investigators said they had discovered a handwritten note in Webb's files indicating that such a deal was in play.{{cite news\|last\=Schwartz\|first\=John\|title\=Evidence of Concealed Jailhouse Deal Raises Questions About a Texas Execution\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/28/us/evidence\-of\-concealed\-jailhouse\-deal\-raises\-questions\-about\-a\-texas\-execution.html?\_r\=1\|access\-date\=March 29, 2014\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=February 27, 2014}}
#### James Grigson
During the penalty phase of the trial, a prosecutor said that Willingham's tattoo of a skull and serpent fit the profile of a sociopath. Two medical experts confirmed the theory. One of those experts, a psychologist who had not published any research in the field of sociopathic behavior, but only held a master's degree in marriage and family issues was asked to interpret Willingham's [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden "Iron Maiden") poster. He said that a picture of a fist punching through a skull signified violence and death. He added that Willingham's [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin "Led Zeppelin") poster of a fallen angel was "many times" an indicator of "cultive\-type" activities.
The other medical expert, psychiatrist [James Grigson](/wiki/James_Grigson "James Grigson"), known by the moniker "Dr. Death" for his repeated testimony as an expert witness in which he recommended the death penalty, said that a man of Willingham's criminal history was an "extremely severe sociopath" and was incurable. Grigson had served as an expert witness for the prosecution in murder trials across the state of Texas. Prior to his death, he was expelled by the [American Psychiatric Association](/wiki/American_Psychiatric_Association "American Psychiatric Association") and the Texas Society of Psychiatric Physicians for unethical conduct.{{cite news \|last1\=Tolson \|first1\=Mike \|title\=Effect of "Dr. Death" and his testimony lingers \|url\=https://www.chron.com/news/houston\-texas/article/Effect\-of\-Dr\-Death\-and\-his\-testimony\-lingers\-1960299\.php \|access\-date\=July 21, 2018 \|work\=Houston Chronicle \|date\=June 17, 2004}}{{cite news \|last1\=Herskovitz \|first1\=Jon \|title\=Texas appeals court halts execution of man who did not kill anyone \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-texas\-execution\-idUSKCN10U2D6 \|access\-date\=July 21, 2018 \|work\=\[\[Reuters]] \|date\=August 20, 2016}} The APA said that Grigson had violated the organization's ethics code by
> "Arriving at a psychiatric diagnosis without first having examined the individuals in question, and for indicating, while testifying in court as an expert witness, that he could predict with 100 per cent certainty that the individuals would engage in future violent acts."{{cite news \| url \= http://www.ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \| title \= Groups Expel Psychiatrist Known for Murder Cases; Witness nicknamed 'Dr. Death' says license won't be affected by allegations \| publisher \= \[\[Dallas Morning News]] \| date \= July 26, 1995 \| first \= Laura \| last \= Bell \| access\-date \= March 21, 2009 \| url\-status\=dead \| archive\-url \= https://web.archive.org/web/20090307034749/http://ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \| archive\-date \= March 7, 2009 \| df \= mdy\-all }}
The prosecution sought to establish that Willingham's conduct at the time of the fire and in the days afterward was suspicious. As the fire took hold, Willingham was driven out through the front door of his house, where he crouched down near the entrance. On seeing neighbor Diane Barbee, Willingham began to shout at her to call 911, shouting "My babies are in there!" At trial, Willingham's conduct at the scene was described as oscillating between collected and hysterical, at times screaming for assistance and at other times calmly pushing his car back from the flames that were engulfing his house. Willingham later said that he removed the car out of concern that it could explode and worsen the house fire.
#### Witnesses to the event and days after
Eyewitnesses described Willingham as having "singed hair on his chest, eyelids, and head and had a two\-inch burn injury on his right shoulder, but the prosecution highlighted the absence of any evidence of smoke inhalation. His wrists and hands were blackened with smoke. He was eventually transported to the hospital for treatment, in handcuffs."{{cite web\|url\=http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/shared\-blogs/austin/investigative/upload/2009/08/execution\_based\_on\_bad\_investi/D\_Beyler%20FINAL%20REPORT%20082509\.pdf \|title\=Analysis of the Fire Investigation Methods and Procedures Used in the Criminal Arson Cases Against Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham \|author\=Craig L. Beyler \|website\=Alt.coxnewsweb.com \|access\-date\=June 5, 2016}}
According to their sworn statements, both Brandice Barbee and Diane Barbee urged Willingham to return to the house to rescue his children. According to Brandice Barbee, "All I could see was smoke." According to Brandice, he refused, and moved his car away from the fire before returning to sit on a nearby lawn, "not once attempting to go inside to rescue his children." Once the fire had reached [flashover](/wiki/Flashover "Flashover") and the fire department arrived, Willingham became far more agitated, to the point of being restrained by emergency services. In the following days, Willingham returned to the house with some family and friends. Neighbors described this group as having an odd levity, which was seen to turn somber on the arrival of authorities.{{cite web\| title\=Statement of Facts, Volume XII \|url\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\.pdf \| date\=August 19, 1992\|access\-date\=October 25, 2022\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040823/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\.pdf \|archive\-date\=September 28, 2011\|url\-status\=dead}} On returning to the scene of the fire with firefighter Ron Franks, in an effort to recover personal property (which was described as a very usual request at trial), Willingham was visibly dismayed at being unable to find a dart set. At a local bar, where a fundraiser was held for the Willingham family, he placed an order for a replacement set, stating that "money was not a problem now."
#### Motive
The prosecution claimed that Willingham may have been motivated by a desire to rid himself of unwanted children.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.txexecutions.org/reports/320\.asp \|title\=Execution Report: Cameron Willingham – Page 1 \|website\=Txexecutions.org \|access\-date\=June 5, 2016}} The prosecutor claimed the fire that killed the children was the third attempt by Willingham to kill them, and that he had attempted to abort each of his wife's two pregnancies by kicking her in order to cause miscarriages.
Journalist David Grann reported that "...there is evidence that Willingham hit his wife, even when she was pregnant, but there were no police reports or medical evidence indicating that Willingham had tried to abort or kill his children." He wrote, "Willingham's wife insisted during the trial and under interrogation that Willingham had not physically abused the children." The trial testimony by Webb, a jailhouse informant, suggested that Willingham had set the fire in order to cover up an injury or death of one of the children due to his wife's actions. The prosecutor also said that Willingham was a serial [wife abuser](/wiki/Domestic_violence "Domestic violence"), both physically and emotionally. Jackson said Willingham had abused animals and was a [sociopath](/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder "Antisocial personality disorder"). However, those not associated with the case paint a different picture of Willingham. His former probation officer, Polly Goodin, said he had never demonstrated bizarre or sociopathic behavior and that "He was probably one of my favorite kids." Bebe Bridges, a former judge who was often on the "opposite side" of Willingham in the legal system, and who had sent him to jail for stealing, said that she could not imagine him killing his children. "He was polite, and he seemed to care", she said.
|
[
"### Witnesses",
"#### Johnny Webb",
"In addition to the arson evidence presented at the trial, a [jailhouse informant](/wiki/Jailhouse_informant \"Jailhouse informant\") named Johnny Webb testified at that time. His testimony has been criticized as contentious for several reasons. Webb claimed that Willingham confessed that he set the fire to hide an injury or death of one of the girls, which was caused by his wife. But none of the girls were found at the time of death to have physical injuries that were still distinguishable after the effects of the fire.{{cite news\\|title \\= Man executed on disproved forensics\\|first1\\=Steve\\|last1\\=Mills\\|first2\\=Maurice\\|last2\\=Possley\\|url\\=http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi\\-0412090169dec09,0,1173806\\.story\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Chicago Tribune]]\\|date\\=December 9, 2004\\|access\\-date\\=September 1, 2009 }} Webb later told [David Grann](/wiki/David_Grann \"David Grann\"), a reporter for *[The New Yorker](/wiki/The_New_Yorker \"The New Yorker\")*, that he might have been mistaken. He said he was prescribed many medications at that point while being treated for [bipolar disorder](/wiki/Bipolar_disorder \"Bipolar disorder\").",
"At Willingham's trial, Webb offered an explanation for the individual, distinguishable burns found on Amber's forehead and arm. He said that Willingham confessed to burning her twice with a piece of \"wadded up\" paper in an effort to make it appear as though the children were \"playing with fire.\"{{cite web\\|title\\=Statement of Facts, Volume XI\\|url\\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\\.pdf\\|date\\=August 18, 1992\\|access\\-date\\=October 25, 2022\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040758/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv11\\.pdf\\|archive\\-date\\=September 28, 2011\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"Prosecutor John Jackson noted that Webb was considered unreliable, but he later supported an early release from prison for Webb. Webb later sent Jackson a \"Motion to Recant Testimony\", which declared, \"Mr. Willingham is innocent of all charges.\" Willingham's attorneys were not notified. Webb later recanted his recantation. He later asked, \"The statute of limitations has run out on [perjury](/wiki/Perjury \"Perjury\"), hasn't it?\"",
"Webb and Jackson consistently denied that Webb was offered a sentence reduction in return for his testimony against Willingham. Evidence of such a deal would have eliminated Webb's testimony. In February 2014, *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\")* reported that the [Innocence Project](/wiki/Innocence_Project \"Innocence Project\") investigators said they had discovered a handwritten note in Webb's files indicating that such a deal was in play.{{cite news\\|last\\=Schwartz\\|first\\=John\\|title\\=Evidence of Concealed Jailhouse Deal Raises Questions About a Texas Execution\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/28/us/evidence\\-of\\-concealed\\-jailhouse\\-deal\\-raises\\-questions\\-about\\-a\\-texas\\-execution.html?\\_r\\=1\\|access\\-date\\=March 29, 2014\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=February 27, 2014}}",
"#### James Grigson",
"During the penalty phase of the trial, a prosecutor said that Willingham's tattoo of a skull and serpent fit the profile of a sociopath. Two medical experts confirmed the theory. One of those experts, a psychologist who had not published any research in the field of sociopathic behavior, but only held a master's degree in marriage and family issues was asked to interpret Willingham's [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden \"Iron Maiden\") poster. He said that a picture of a fist punching through a skull signified violence and death. He added that Willingham's [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin \"Led Zeppelin\") poster of a fallen angel was \"many times\" an indicator of \"cultive\\-type\" activities.",
"The other medical expert, psychiatrist [James Grigson](/wiki/James_Grigson \"James Grigson\"), known by the moniker \"Dr. Death\" for his repeated testimony as an expert witness in which he recommended the death penalty, said that a man of Willingham's criminal history was an \"extremely severe sociopath\" and was incurable. Grigson had served as an expert witness for the prosecution in murder trials across the state of Texas. Prior to his death, he was expelled by the [American Psychiatric Association](/wiki/American_Psychiatric_Association \"American Psychiatric Association\") and the Texas Society of Psychiatric Physicians for unethical conduct.{{cite news \\|last1\\=Tolson \\|first1\\=Mike \\|title\\=Effect of \"Dr. Death\" and his testimony lingers \\|url\\=https://www.chron.com/news/houston\\-texas/article/Effect\\-of\\-Dr\\-Death\\-and\\-his\\-testimony\\-lingers\\-1960299\\.php \\|access\\-date\\=July 21, 2018 \\|work\\=Houston Chronicle \\|date\\=June 17, 2004}}{{cite news \\|last1\\=Herskovitz \\|first1\\=Jon \\|title\\=Texas appeals court halts execution of man who did not kill anyone \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-texas\\-execution\\-idUSKCN10U2D6 \\|access\\-date\\=July 21, 2018 \\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\|date\\=August 20, 2016}} The APA said that Grigson had violated the organization's ethics code by",
"",
"> \"Arriving at a psychiatric diagnosis without first having examined the individuals in question, and for indicating, while testifying in court as an expert witness, that he could predict with 100 per cent certainty that the individuals would engage in future violent acts.\"{{cite news \\| url \\= http://www.ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \\| title \\= Groups Expel Psychiatrist Known for Murder Cases; Witness nicknamed 'Dr. Death' says license won't be affected by allegations \\| publisher \\= \\[\\[Dallas Morning News]] \\| date \\= July 26, 1995 \\| first \\= Laura \\| last \\= Bell \\| access\\-date \\= March 21, 2009 \\| url\\-status\\=dead \\| archive\\-url \\= https://web.archive.org/web/20090307034749/http://ccadp.org/DrDeath.htm \\| archive\\-date \\= March 7, 2009 \\| df \\= mdy\\-all }}",
"The prosecution sought to establish that Willingham's conduct at the time of the fire and in the days afterward was suspicious. As the fire took hold, Willingham was driven out through the front door of his house, where he crouched down near the entrance. On seeing neighbor Diane Barbee, Willingham began to shout at her to call 911, shouting \"My babies are in there!\" At trial, Willingham's conduct at the scene was described as oscillating between collected and hysterical, at times screaming for assistance and at other times calmly pushing his car back from the flames that were engulfing his house. Willingham later said that he removed the car out of concern that it could explode and worsen the house fire.",
"#### Witnesses to the event and days after",
"Eyewitnesses described Willingham as having \"singed hair on his chest, eyelids, and head and had a two\\-inch burn injury on his right shoulder, but the prosecution highlighted the absence of any evidence of smoke inhalation. His wrists and hands were blackened with smoke. He was eventually transported to the hospital for treatment, in handcuffs.\"{{cite web\\|url\\=http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/shared\\-blogs/austin/investigative/upload/2009/08/execution\\_based\\_on\\_bad\\_investi/D\\_Beyler%20FINAL%20REPORT%20082509\\.pdf \\|title\\=Analysis of the Fire Investigation Methods and Procedures Used in the Criminal Arson Cases Against Ernest Ray Willis and Cameron Todd Willingham \\|author\\=Craig L. Beyler \\|website\\=Alt.coxnewsweb.com \\|access\\-date\\=June 5, 2016}}",
"According to their sworn statements, both Brandice Barbee and Diane Barbee urged Willingham to return to the house to rescue his children. According to Brandice Barbee, \"All I could see was smoke.\" According to Brandice, he refused, and moved his car away from the fire before returning to sit on a nearby lawn, \"not once attempting to go inside to rescue his children.\" Once the fire had reached [flashover](/wiki/Flashover \"Flashover\") and the fire department arrived, Willingham became far more agitated, to the point of being restrained by emergency services. In the following days, Willingham returned to the house with some family and friends. Neighbors described this group as having an odd levity, which was seen to turn somber on the arrival of authorities.{{cite web\\| title\\=Statement of Facts, Volume XII \\|url\\=http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\\.pdf \\| date\\=August 19, 1992\\|access\\-date\\=October 25, 2022\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110928040823/http://www.innocenceproject.org/docs/Willingham\\_Transcript/Willinghamv12\\.pdf \\|archive\\-date\\=September 28, 2011\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} On returning to the scene of the fire with firefighter Ron Franks, in an effort to recover personal property (which was described as a very usual request at trial), Willingham was visibly dismayed at being unable to find a dart set. At a local bar, where a fundraiser was held for the Willingham family, he placed an order for a replacement set, stating that \"money was not a problem now.\"",
"#### Motive",
"The prosecution claimed that Willingham may have been motivated by a desire to rid himself of unwanted children.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.txexecutions.org/reports/320\\.asp \\|title\\=Execution Report: Cameron Willingham – Page 1 \\|website\\=Txexecutions.org \\|access\\-date\\=June 5, 2016}} The prosecutor claimed the fire that killed the children was the third attempt by Willingham to kill them, and that he had attempted to abort each of his wife's two pregnancies by kicking her in order to cause miscarriages.",
"Journalist David Grann reported that \"...there is evidence that Willingham hit his wife, even when she was pregnant, but there were no police reports or medical evidence indicating that Willingham had tried to abort or kill his children.\" He wrote, \"Willingham's wife insisted during the trial and under interrogation that Willingham had not physically abused the children.\" The trial testimony by Webb, a jailhouse informant, suggested that Willingham had set the fire in order to cover up an injury or death of one of the children due to his wife's actions. The prosecutor also said that Willingham was a serial [wife abuser](/wiki/Domestic_violence \"Domestic violence\"), both physically and emotionally. Jackson said Willingham had abused animals and was a [sociopath](/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder \"Antisocial personality disorder\"). However, those not associated with the case paint a different picture of Willingham. His former probation officer, Polly Goodin, said he had never demonstrated bizarre or sociopathic behavior and that \"He was probably one of my favorite kids.\" Bebe Bridges, a former judge who was often on the \"opposite side\" of Willingham in the legal system, and who had sent him to jail for stealing, said that she could not imagine him killing his children. \"He was polite, and he seemed to care\", she said.",
""
] |
Background
----------
Edward Hugh Hebern was born in [Streator, Illinois](/wiki/Streator%2C_Illinois "Streator, Illinois"), on April 23, 1869\. His parents were Charles and Rosanna (Rosy) Hebern. They met in Harris County, Texas while Charles was serving as guard and escort from the civil war. On February 4, 1866, they married in Harris, Texas. Rosanna was only fifteen years old. After mustering out of the service on May 29, 1866, Charles and his new wife returned to Springfield, Illinois, and on June 18, 1866, he received his final pay and discharge.
Edward had an older sister, Arizona (Zoa) born in 1867, two younger brothers, Daniel Boone Hebern, born on February 17, 1871, and William Hebern, born April 8, 1875, in Houston, Texas, as well as a younger sister, Nellie Hebern, born in 1874\.
At the age of 6, on August 4, 1875, Edward Hugh and three of his siblings were admitted to the Illinois Soldiers’ and Sailors’ home in Normal, Illinois. According to the Soldiers’ home register their father was listed as having died in 1874 in an unknown location, but he was admitted to the same Soldiers’ Home 40 years later. By February 13, 1879, the youngest Hebern child, William, was admitted to the Soldiers’ Home. Six months later on August 12, 1879, Rosanna married Archibald Thompson in Bloomington, Illinois.
On June 14, 1881, two months before her 14th birthday, Zoa left the Soldiers’ Home. Edward was discharged from the Soldiers’ Home in May 1883, after turning 14, and went to Odin, Illinois where he worked on a farm. By 1885, Daniel, Nellie, and William were all in Odin, Illinois. Zoa married Edward F. Clark (27 yrs. old) on August 18, 1886, in Coffey County, Kansas. Then they headed to Utah.
The rest of the children eventually moved to Madera, Ca. beginning with the two eldest boys in 1896\. Daniel Boone Hebern was in North Fork, California working as a laborer; his brother, Edward Hugh Hebern was in Madera farming. Daniel purchased two plots of land in North Fork.
|
[
"Background\n----------",
"Edward Hugh Hebern was born in [Streator, Illinois](/wiki/Streator%2C_Illinois \"Streator, Illinois\"), on April 23, 1869\\. His parents were Charles and Rosanna (Rosy) Hebern. They met in Harris County, Texas while Charles was serving as guard and escort from the civil war. On February 4, 1866, they married in Harris, Texas. Rosanna was only fifteen years old. After mustering out of the service on May 29, 1866, Charles and his new wife returned to Springfield, Illinois, and on June 18, 1866, he received his final pay and discharge.",
"Edward had an older sister, Arizona (Zoa) born in 1867, two younger brothers, Daniel Boone Hebern, born on February 17, 1871, and William Hebern, born April 8, 1875, in Houston, Texas, as well as a younger sister, Nellie Hebern, born in 1874\\.",
"At the age of 6, on August 4, 1875, Edward Hugh and three of his siblings were admitted to the Illinois Soldiers’ and Sailors’ home in Normal, Illinois. According to the Soldiers’ home register their father was listed as having died in 1874 in an unknown location, but he was admitted to the same Soldiers’ Home 40 years later. By February 13, 1879, the youngest Hebern child, William, was admitted to the Soldiers’ Home. Six months later on August 12, 1879, Rosanna married Archibald Thompson in Bloomington, Illinois.",
"On June 14, 1881, two months before her 14th birthday, Zoa left the Soldiers’ Home. Edward was discharged from the Soldiers’ Home in May 1883, after turning 14, and went to Odin, Illinois where he worked on a farm. By 1885, Daniel, Nellie, and William were all in Odin, Illinois. Zoa married Edward F. Clark (27 yrs. old) on August 18, 1886, in Coffey County, Kansas. Then they headed to Utah.",
"The rest of the children eventually moved to Madera, Ca. beginning with the two eldest boys in 1896\\. Daniel Boone Hebern was in North Fork, California working as a laborer; his brother, Edward Hugh Hebern was in Madera farming. Daniel purchased two plots of land in North Fork.",
""
] |
Selected publications
---------------------
Jones, J.F., Kumssa, A., and Herbert Williams, eds. (2011\). Conflict and Human Security in Africa: Kenya in Perspective. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Jones, J.F. (2009\) Liberty to Live: Human Security and Development. New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Jones, J.F. \& Kumssa, A., eds. (2000\). The Cost of Reform: The Social Aspect of Transitional Economies. New York: Nova Science Publishers.
Jones, J.F. \& Yogo, T. (1995\). New Training Design for Local Social Development.
Vols. I \& II. Nagoya: United Nations Center for Regional Development.
Jones, J.F., Stevenson, K., Cheung, M., \& Leung, P. (1995\). Call to Competence: Child Protective Services Training and Evaluation. Englewood, CO: American Humane Association, 1995\.
Jones, J.F. \& Wang Shek (1990\). Glossary of Social Work Terms in Chinese and English. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press.
Jones, J.F. \& Wang Shek (1983\). Research in Social Technology. Taipei: Community Research and Training, ROC. In Chinese.
Jones, J.F., ed. (1981\). The Common Welfare. Hong Kong and Manila: Chinese University Press, and United Nations Social Welfare and Development Center for Asia and the Pacific.
Jones, J.F. \& Pandey, R.S., eds. (1981\). Social Development: Conceptual, Methodological, and Policy Issues. New York: St. Martin's Press; and New Delhi: Macmillan India.
Jones, J.F., ed. (1980\). Building China. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press. Distributed in North America by the University of Washington Press.
Jones, J.F. (1979\). Education in Depth. Hong Kong: Swindon in association with Hong Kong University.
Jones, J.F. \& Li Bik\-chi (1978\). Social Welfare Administration. Taipei: Chinese Humanities Institute. In Chinese.
Jones, J.F. \& Herrick, J.M. (1976\). Citizens in Service. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press.
|
[
"Selected publications\n---------------------",
"Jones, J.F., Kumssa, A., and Herbert Williams, eds. (2011\\). Conflict and Human Security in Africa: Kenya in Perspective. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.",
"Jones, J.F. (2009\\) Liberty to Live: Human Security and Development. New York: Nova Science Publishers.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Kumssa, A., eds. (2000\\). The Cost of Reform: The Social Aspect of Transitional Economies. New York: Nova Science Publishers.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Yogo, T. (1995\\). New Training Design for Local Social Development.\nVols. I \\& II. Nagoya: United Nations Center for Regional Development.",
"Jones, J.F., Stevenson, K., Cheung, M., \\& Leung, P. (1995\\). Call to Competence: Child Protective Services Training and Evaluation. Englewood, CO: American Humane Association, 1995\\.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Wang Shek (1990\\). Glossary of Social Work Terms in Chinese and English. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Wang Shek (1983\\). Research in Social Technology. Taipei: Community Research and Training, ROC. In Chinese.",
"Jones, J.F., ed. (1981\\). The Common Welfare. Hong Kong and Manila: Chinese University Press, and United Nations Social Welfare and Development Center for Asia and the Pacific.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Pandey, R.S., eds. (1981\\). Social Development: Conceptual, Methodological, and Policy Issues. New York: St. Martin's Press; and New Delhi: Macmillan India.",
"Jones, J.F., ed. (1980\\). Building China. Hong Kong: Chinese University Press. Distributed in North America by the University of Washington Press.",
"Jones, J.F. (1979\\). Education in Depth. Hong Kong: Swindon in association with Hong Kong University.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Li Bik\\-chi (1978\\). Social Welfare Administration. Taipei: Chinese Humanities Institute. In Chinese.",
"Jones, J.F. \\& Herrick, J.M. (1976\\). Citizens in Service. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press.",
""
] |
Plot
----
Stanford student Stephanie Fleming invites her boyfriend Laird Mayhew over to "[Netflix and chill](/wiki/Netflix_and_chill "Netflix and chill")". Meanwhile, back home in [Grand Rapids](/wiki/Grand_Rapids%2C_Michigan "Grand Rapids, Michigan"), Stephanie's dad Ned is celebrating his 55th birthday with friends and family at an [Applebee's](/wiki/Applebee%27s "Applebee's"). During a slideshow presentation in his honor, Stephanie drops in via webcam to congratulate him, when suddenly Laird walks in on her and [flashes](/wiki/Exhibitionism "Exhibitionism") the camera.
Stephanie drives her family – parents Ned and Barb and younger brother Scotty – to Laird's villa to meet him. She explains to Ned that Laird is the CEO of a video game company, which has made him extremely wealthy. Laird gives the family a tour of his house, complete with curse words and inappropriate comments about Barb. He then reveals a large tattoo of the Flemings' Christmas card on his back, complete with "Happy Holidays" written underneath. In the living room is a tank with a moose filled completely with its urine. The basement has a bowling alley that Laird built with a mural of Ned, posed in a "crotch\-chop" position.
Ned talks to Stephanie about Laird's behavior and she asks him to give him a chance. Later, as Laird goes with Ned for a walk in the woods outside his house, he asks Ned for his blessing to propose to Stephanie. Ned is quick to say no, which completely blindsides Laird, who had been confident that Ned would say yes. Laird promises to win him over.
As the family gathers in Laird's living room for a Christmas party, Laird reveals that he bought Ned's struggling printing company as a gift to remove all his debts. Instead of expressing gratitude, Ned punches Laird in the face and they begin to fight, which culminates in Laird falling into the moose tank, which subsequently breaks and leaves Scotty briefly trapped under the moose. Stephanie and Barb are both angry at their partner's behaviors, and the Flemings leave Laird's home.
On Christmas Day, the Flemings are celebrating without Stephanie. They are surprised when Laird's helicopter arrives with Stephanie. She is still mad at both Ned and Laird for their behavior and refuses to talk to either of them. Ned and Laird talk and Laird gets Ned's blessing to propose to Stephanie. However, she declines the proposal saying she is not ready to get married, but she wants them to continue dating.
Later during the party, Ned and Scotty approach Laird with a new business idea, since they are all part of the same company now. Scotty suggests they sell the same toilets Laird has in his home since they would be very profitable. Laird likes the idea and agrees. The couples then dance together as music plays, with Ned referring to Laird as "son".
Scotty, Ned, and Laird eventually turn the printing company into a toilet factory and become profitable. Stephanie uses the Fleming\-Mayhew conglomerate to help underdeveloped countries with their sewage projects. Finally, Laird has what he always wanted, to be part of a family.
|
[
"Plot\n----",
"Stanford student Stephanie Fleming invites her boyfriend Laird Mayhew over to \"[Netflix and chill](/wiki/Netflix_and_chill \"Netflix and chill\")\". Meanwhile, back home in [Grand Rapids](/wiki/Grand_Rapids%2C_Michigan \"Grand Rapids, Michigan\"), Stephanie's dad Ned is celebrating his 55th birthday with friends and family at an [Applebee's](/wiki/Applebee%27s \"Applebee's\"). During a slideshow presentation in his honor, Stephanie drops in via webcam to congratulate him, when suddenly Laird walks in on her and [flashes](/wiki/Exhibitionism \"Exhibitionism\") the camera.",
"Stephanie drives her family – parents Ned and Barb and younger brother Scotty – to Laird's villa to meet him. She explains to Ned that Laird is the CEO of a video game company, which has made him extremely wealthy. Laird gives the family a tour of his house, complete with curse words and inappropriate comments about Barb. He then reveals a large tattoo of the Flemings' Christmas card on his back, complete with \"Happy Holidays\" written underneath. In the living room is a tank with a moose filled completely with its urine. The basement has a bowling alley that Laird built with a mural of Ned, posed in a \"crotch\\-chop\" position.",
"Ned talks to Stephanie about Laird's behavior and she asks him to give him a chance. Later, as Laird goes with Ned for a walk in the woods outside his house, he asks Ned for his blessing to propose to Stephanie. Ned is quick to say no, which completely blindsides Laird, who had been confident that Ned would say yes. Laird promises to win him over.",
"As the family gathers in Laird's living room for a Christmas party, Laird reveals that he bought Ned's struggling printing company as a gift to remove all his debts. Instead of expressing gratitude, Ned punches Laird in the face and they begin to fight, which culminates in Laird falling into the moose tank, which subsequently breaks and leaves Scotty briefly trapped under the moose. Stephanie and Barb are both angry at their partner's behaviors, and the Flemings leave Laird's home.",
"On Christmas Day, the Flemings are celebrating without Stephanie. They are surprised when Laird's helicopter arrives with Stephanie. She is still mad at both Ned and Laird for their behavior and refuses to talk to either of them. Ned and Laird talk and Laird gets Ned's blessing to propose to Stephanie. However, she declines the proposal saying she is not ready to get married, but she wants them to continue dating.",
"Later during the party, Ned and Scotty approach Laird with a new business idea, since they are all part of the same company now. Scotty suggests they sell the same toilets Laird has in his home since they would be very profitable. Laird likes the idea and agrees. The couples then dance together as music plays, with Ned referring to Laird as \"son\".",
"Scotty, Ned, and Laird eventually turn the printing company into a toilet factory and become profitable. Stephanie uses the Fleming\\-Mayhew conglomerate to help underdeveloped countries with their sewage projects. Finally, Laird has what he always wanted, to be part of a family.",
""
] |
Company history
---------------
The Anderson family have a long history in the film and cinema business dating back to 1948 when Kevin Anderson (Paul Anderson's father now retired) first started a film distribution business. The first films acquired were *The Hills of Donegal* and *The Rose of Tralee*, which were distributed to cinemas across Ireland.
The first cinema was purchased in Lucan in 1955\. The Andersons continued to acquire, redevelop and sell cinemas across Ireland over the subsequent decades. Their biggest acquisition came when they bought the Rank Cinemas portfolio in 1988, which included Dublin's flagship Savoy cinema and The Screen cinema, which the Andersons jointly owned as part of the Dublin Cinema Group until 2013\.
The first cinema to be branded an Omniplex was in Santry (now IMC). Since then, Omniplex has expanded in both the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland. This includes the 13 screen Cork Omniplex which opened in 2005 and the Rathmines Omniplex which completed in 2014 following a 15\-year campaign to open cinemas in The Swan SC, which the Andersons acquired in 1999\.
The company announced the acquisition of the Quayside cinema in Balbriggan, which was bought from NAMA and refurbished at a cost of €1\.5m.{{Cite web\|last\=Limited\|first\=Collaborative Software\|title\=Omniplex Cinemas \- Book film tickets \& get movie times\|url\=http://www.omniplex.ie/\|access\-date\=2021\-08\-12\|website\=Omniplex Cinemas}}
As well as screening films, Omniplex cinemas also show live events that are broadcast from around the world. This includes weekly live show from New York's Met Opera, The Bolshoi Ballet and music concerts.
Omniplex are reported to sell 5\.5m cinema tickets per year.
In 2023, Omniplex opened a concept cinema in [CastleCourt](/wiki/CastleCourt "CastleCourt"), Belfast under the name The Avenue.
On 4 December 2023, Omniplex announced it had entered [Great Britain](/wiki/Great_Britain "Great Britain"), with the acquisiton of the [Empire Cinemas](/wiki/Empire_Cinemas "Empire Cinemas") chain, which had previously entered administration in July. Omniplex would later acquire more cinemas in [Sunderland](/wiki/Sunderland "Sunderland") and [Wigan](/wiki/Wigan "Wigan").
|
[
"Company history\n---------------",
"The Anderson family have a long history in the film and cinema business dating back to 1948 when Kevin Anderson (Paul Anderson's father now retired) first started a film distribution business. The first films acquired were *The Hills of Donegal* and *The Rose of Tralee*, which were distributed to cinemas across Ireland.",
"The first cinema was purchased in Lucan in 1955\\. The Andersons continued to acquire, redevelop and sell cinemas across Ireland over the subsequent decades. Their biggest acquisition came when they bought the Rank Cinemas portfolio in 1988, which included Dublin's flagship Savoy cinema and The Screen cinema, which the Andersons jointly owned as part of the Dublin Cinema Group until 2013\\.",
"The first cinema to be branded an Omniplex was in Santry (now IMC). Since then, Omniplex has expanded in both the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland. This includes the 13 screen Cork Omniplex which opened in 2005 and the Rathmines Omniplex which completed in 2014 following a 15\\-year campaign to open cinemas in The Swan SC, which the Andersons acquired in 1999\\.",
"The company announced the acquisition of the Quayside cinema in Balbriggan, which was bought from NAMA and refurbished at a cost of €1\\.5m.{{Cite web\\|last\\=Limited\\|first\\=Collaborative Software\\|title\\=Omniplex Cinemas \\- Book film tickets \\& get movie times\\|url\\=http://www.omniplex.ie/\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-08\\-12\\|website\\=Omniplex Cinemas}}",
"As well as screening films, Omniplex cinemas also show live events that are broadcast from around the world. This includes weekly live show from New York's Met Opera, The Bolshoi Ballet and music concerts.",
"Omniplex are reported to sell 5\\.5m cinema tickets per year.",
"In 2023, Omniplex opened a concept cinema in [CastleCourt](/wiki/CastleCourt \"CastleCourt\"), Belfast under the name The Avenue.",
"On 4 December 2023, Omniplex announced it had entered [Great Britain](/wiki/Great_Britain \"Great Britain\"), with the acquisiton of the [Empire Cinemas](/wiki/Empire_Cinemas \"Empire Cinemas\") chain, which had previously entered administration in July. Omniplex would later acquire more cinemas in [Sunderland](/wiki/Sunderland \"Sunderland\") and [Wigan](/wiki/Wigan \"Wigan\").",
""
] |
Mechanisms and methods
----------------------
The most significant aspect of al\-Jazari's machines are the [mechanisms](/wiki/Mechanism_%28technology%29 "Mechanism (technology)"), components, ideas, methods, and design features which they employ.
### Camshaft
A [camshaft](/wiki/Camshaft "Camshaft"), a shaft to which [cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 "Cam (mechanism)") are attached, was described in 1206 by al\-Jazari, who employed them in his [automata](/wiki/Automaton "Automaton"),Georges Ifrah (2001\). *The Universal History of Computing: From the Abacus to the Quatum Computer*, p. 171, Trans. E.F. Harding, John Wiley \& Sons, Inc. (See <http://www.banffcentre.ca/bnmi/programs/archives/2005/refresh/docs/conferences/Gunalan_Nadarajan.pdf> {{Webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20061008113946/http://www.banffcentre.ca/bnmi/programs/archives/2005/refresh/docs/conferences/Gunalan\_Nadarajan.pdf\|date\=8 October 2006}}) [water clocks](/wiki/Water_clock "Water clock") (such as the [candle clock](/wiki/Candle_clock "Candle clock")) and water\-raising machines.
### Crankshaft and crank\-slider mechanism
The eccentrically mounted handle of the rotary [quern\-stone](/wiki/Quern-stone "Quern-stone") in fifth century BCE [Spain](/wiki/Spain "Spain") that spread across the [Roman Empire](/wiki/Roman_Empire "Roman Empire") constitutes a [crank](/wiki/Crank_%28mechanism%29 "Crank (mechanism)").Tullia Ritti, Klaus Grewe, Paul Kessener: "A Relief of a Water\-powered Stone Saw Mill on a Sarcophagus at Hierapolis and its Implications“, Journal of Roman Archaeology, Vol. 20 (2007\), pp. 138–163 (159\) The earliest evidence of a crank and [connecting rod](/wiki/Connecting_rod "Connecting rod") mechanism dates to the 3rd century AD [Hierapolis sawmill](/wiki/Hierapolis_sawmill "Hierapolis sawmill") in the [Roman Empire](/wiki/Roman_Empire "Roman Empire"). The crank also appears in the mid\-9th century in several of the hydraulic devices described by the [Banū Mūsā](/wiki/Ban%C5%AB_M%C5%ABs%C4%81 "Banū Mūsā") brothers in their *[Book of Ingenious Devices](/wiki/Book_of_Ingenious_Devices "Book of Ingenious Devices")*.{{citation\|title\=The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature\|last\=A. F. L. Beeston, M. J. L. Young\|first\=J. D. Latham, Robert Bertram Serjeant\|publisher\=\[\[Cambridge University Press]]\|year\=1990\|isbn\=0\-521\-32763\-6\|page\=266}}
In 1206, al\-Jazari invented an early [crankshaft](/wiki/Crankshaft "Crankshaft"), which he incorporated with a crank\-connecting rod mechanism in his twin\-cylinder [pump](/wiki/Pump "Pump"). Like the modern crankshaft, al\-Jazari's mechanism consisted of a wheel setting several [crankpins](/wiki/Crankpin "Crankpin") into motion, with the wheel's motion being circular and the pins moving back\-and\-forth in a straight line.{{citation\|title\=Islam and Science, Medicine, and Technology\|last\=Sally Ganchy\|first\=Sarah Gancher\|publisher\=The Rosen Publishing Group\|year\=2009\|isbn\=978\-1\-4358\-5066\-8\|page\=\[https://archive.org/details/islamsciencemedi0000ganc/page/41 41]\|url\-access\=registration\|url\=https://archive.org/details/islamsciencemedi0000ganc/page/41}} The crankshaft described by al\-Jazari transforms continuous [rotary motion](/wiki/Rotary_engine "Rotary engine") into a linear [reciprocating motion](/wiki/Reciprocating_engine "Reciprocating engine"), and is central to modern machinery such as the [steam engine](/wiki/Steam_engine "Steam engine"), [internal combustion engine](/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine "Internal combustion engine") and [automatic controls](/wiki/Automatic_control "Automatic control").Paul Vallely, [How Islamic Inventors Changed the World](https://web.archive.org/web/20080517013534/http://news.independent.co.uk/world/science_technology/article350594.ece), *[The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent "The Independent")*, 11 March 2006\.{{sfn\|Hill\|1998\|p\=231–232}}
He used the crankshaft with a connecting rod in two of his water\-raising machines: the [crank\-driven saqiya chain pump](/wiki/%23Saqiya_chain_pumps "#Saqiya chain pumps") and the [double\-action reciprocating piston suction pump](/wiki/%23Double-action_suction_pump_with_valves_and_reciprocating_piston_motion "#Double-action suction pump with valves and reciprocating piston motion").[Ahmad Y. al\-Hassan](/wiki/Ahmad_Y._al-Hassan "Ahmad Y. al-Hassan"), [The Crank\-Connecting Rod System in a Continuously Rotating Machine](http://www.history-science-technology.com/Notes/Notes%203.htm) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130312021929/http://www.history\-science\-technology.com/Notes/Notes%203\.htm \|date\=12 March 2013 }}{{citation\|title\=The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature\|last\=A. F. L. Beeston, M. J. L. Young\|first\=J. D. Latham, Robert Bertram Serjeant\|publisher\=Cambridge University Press\|year\=1990\|isbn\=0\-521\-32763\-6\|pages\=270–1}} His water pump also employed the first known [crank\-slider](/wiki/Four-bar_linkage "Four-bar linkage") mechanism.
### Design and construction methods
English technology historian [Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill "Donald Hill") writes:
{{blockquote\|text\=We see for the first time in al\-Jazari's work several concepts important for both design and construction: the \[\[lamination]] of timber to minimize warping, the \[\[Mechanical equilibrium\|static balancing]] of wheels, the use of wooden \[\[stencil\|templates]] (a kind of pattern), the use of \[\[paper model]]s to establish designs, the \[\[Calibrated orifice\|calibration of orifices]], the grinding of the seats and plugs of valves together with \[\[Emery (rock)\|emery]] powder to obtain a watertight fit, and the \[\[Casting (metalworking)\|casting]] of metals in closed \[\[Sand casting\|mold boxes]] with \[\[Molding sand\|sand]].}}
### Escapement mechanism in a rotating wheel
Al\-Jazari invented a method for controlling the speed of [rotation](/wiki/Rotation "Rotation") of a wheel using an [escapement](/wiki/Escapement "Escapement") mechanism.[Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill "Donald Hill"), "Engineering", in Roshdi Rashed, ed., *[Encyclopedia of the History of Arabic Science](/wiki/Encyclopedia_of_the_History_of_Arabic_Science "Encyclopedia of the History of Arabic Science")*, Vol. 2, pp. 751–795 \[792]. [Routledge](/wiki/Routledge "Routledge"), London and New York.
### Mechanical controls
According to [Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill "Donald Hill"), al\-Jazari described several early [mechanical controls](/wiki/Control_system "Control system"), including "a large metal door, a [combination lock](/wiki/Combination_lock "Combination lock") and a lock with four [bolts](/wiki/Bolted_joint "Bolted joint")".
### Conical valve and segmental gear
A segmental gear is "a piece for receiving or communicating [reciprocating motion](/wiki/Reciprocating_motion "Reciprocating motion") from or to a cogwheel, consisting of a sector of a circular [gear](/wiki/Gear "Gear"), or ring, having cogs on the periphery, or face."[Segment gear](http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Segment+gear), [TheFreeDictionary.com](/wiki/TheFreeDictionary.com "TheFreeDictionary.com") [Lynn Townsend White](/wiki/Lynn_Townsend_White "Lynn Townsend White") wrote:{{Sfn\|Hill\|1974\|p\=xiii}}
{{blockquote\|text\=Western scholars had thought that conical \[\[valves]] first appeared in Leonardo’s drawings, but al\-Jazarl’s pictures show them. Similarly, segmental gears first clearly appear in al\-Jazarl; in the West they emerge in \[\[Giovanni Dondi dell'Orologio\|Giovanni de’ Dondi]]’s astronomical clock finished in 1364; with the great \[\[Siena\|Sienese]] engineer \[\[Francesco di Giorgio Martini\|Francesco di Giorgio]] (d. 1501\) they entered the general vocabulary of European machine design.}}
|
[
"Mechanisms and methods\n----------------------",
"The most significant aspect of al\\-Jazari's machines are the [mechanisms](/wiki/Mechanism_%28technology%29 \"Mechanism (technology)\"), components, ideas, methods, and design features which they employ.",
"### Camshaft",
"A [camshaft](/wiki/Camshaft \"Camshaft\"), a shaft to which [cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 \"Cam (mechanism)\") are attached, was described in 1206 by al\\-Jazari, who employed them in his [automata](/wiki/Automaton \"Automaton\"),Georges Ifrah (2001\\). *The Universal History of Computing: From the Abacus to the Quatum Computer*, p. 171, Trans. E.F. Harding, John Wiley \\& Sons, Inc. (See <http://www.banffcentre.ca/bnmi/programs/archives/2005/refresh/docs/conferences/Gunalan_Nadarajan.pdf> {{Webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20061008113946/http://www.banffcentre.ca/bnmi/programs/archives/2005/refresh/docs/conferences/Gunalan\\_Nadarajan.pdf\\|date\\=8 October 2006}}) [water clocks](/wiki/Water_clock \"Water clock\") (such as the [candle clock](/wiki/Candle_clock \"Candle clock\")) and water\\-raising machines.",
"### Crankshaft and crank\\-slider mechanism",
"The eccentrically mounted handle of the rotary [quern\\-stone](/wiki/Quern-stone \"Quern-stone\") in fifth century BCE [Spain](/wiki/Spain \"Spain\") that spread across the [Roman Empire](/wiki/Roman_Empire \"Roman Empire\") constitutes a [crank](/wiki/Crank_%28mechanism%29 \"Crank (mechanism)\").Tullia Ritti, Klaus Grewe, Paul Kessener: \"A Relief of a Water\\-powered Stone Saw Mill on a Sarcophagus at Hierapolis and its Implications“, Journal of Roman Archaeology, Vol. 20 (2007\\), pp. 138–163 (159\\) The earliest evidence of a crank and [connecting rod](/wiki/Connecting_rod \"Connecting rod\") mechanism dates to the 3rd century AD [Hierapolis sawmill](/wiki/Hierapolis_sawmill \"Hierapolis sawmill\") in the [Roman Empire](/wiki/Roman_Empire \"Roman Empire\"). The crank also appears in the mid\\-9th century in several of the hydraulic devices described by the [Banū Mūsā](/wiki/Ban%C5%AB_M%C5%ABs%C4%81 \"Banū Mūsā\") brothers in their *[Book of Ingenious Devices](/wiki/Book_of_Ingenious_Devices \"Book of Ingenious Devices\")*.{{citation\\|title\\=The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature\\|last\\=A. F. L. Beeston, M. J. L. Young\\|first\\=J. D. Latham, Robert Bertram Serjeant\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Cambridge University Press]]\\|year\\=1990\\|isbn\\=0\\-521\\-32763\\-6\\|page\\=266}}",
"In 1206, al\\-Jazari invented an early [crankshaft](/wiki/Crankshaft \"Crankshaft\"), which he incorporated with a crank\\-connecting rod mechanism in his twin\\-cylinder [pump](/wiki/Pump \"Pump\"). Like the modern crankshaft, al\\-Jazari's mechanism consisted of a wheel setting several [crankpins](/wiki/Crankpin \"Crankpin\") into motion, with the wheel's motion being circular and the pins moving back\\-and\\-forth in a straight line.{{citation\\|title\\=Islam and Science, Medicine, and Technology\\|last\\=Sally Ganchy\\|first\\=Sarah Gancher\\|publisher\\=The Rosen Publishing Group\\|year\\=2009\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-4358\\-5066\\-8\\|page\\=\\[https://archive.org/details/islamsciencemedi0000ganc/page/41 41]\\|url\\-access\\=registration\\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/islamsciencemedi0000ganc/page/41}} The crankshaft described by al\\-Jazari transforms continuous [rotary motion](/wiki/Rotary_engine \"Rotary engine\") into a linear [reciprocating motion](/wiki/Reciprocating_engine \"Reciprocating engine\"), and is central to modern machinery such as the [steam engine](/wiki/Steam_engine \"Steam engine\"), [internal combustion engine](/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine \"Internal combustion engine\") and [automatic controls](/wiki/Automatic_control \"Automatic control\").Paul Vallely, [How Islamic Inventors Changed the World](https://web.archive.org/web/20080517013534/http://news.independent.co.uk/world/science_technology/article350594.ece), *[The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent \"The Independent\")*, 11 March 2006\\.{{sfn\\|Hill\\|1998\\|p\\=231–232}}",
"He used the crankshaft with a connecting rod in two of his water\\-raising machines: the [crank\\-driven saqiya chain pump](/wiki/%23Saqiya_chain_pumps \"#Saqiya chain pumps\") and the [double\\-action reciprocating piston suction pump](/wiki/%23Double-action_suction_pump_with_valves_and_reciprocating_piston_motion \"#Double-action suction pump with valves and reciprocating piston motion\").[Ahmad Y. al\\-Hassan](/wiki/Ahmad_Y._al-Hassan \"Ahmad Y. al-Hassan\"), [The Crank\\-Connecting Rod System in a Continuously Rotating Machine](http://www.history-science-technology.com/Notes/Notes%203.htm) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130312021929/http://www.history\\-science\\-technology.com/Notes/Notes%203\\.htm \\|date\\=12 March 2013 }}{{citation\\|title\\=The Cambridge History of Arabic Literature\\|last\\=A. F. L. Beeston, M. J. L. Young\\|first\\=J. D. Latham, Robert Bertram Serjeant\\|publisher\\=Cambridge University Press\\|year\\=1990\\|isbn\\=0\\-521\\-32763\\-6\\|pages\\=270–1}} His water pump also employed the first known [crank\\-slider](/wiki/Four-bar_linkage \"Four-bar linkage\") mechanism.",
"### Design and construction methods",
"English technology historian [Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill \"Donald Hill\") writes:",
"{{blockquote\\|text\\=We see for the first time in al\\-Jazari's work several concepts important for both design and construction: the \\[\\[lamination]] of timber to minimize warping, the \\[\\[Mechanical equilibrium\\|static balancing]] of wheels, the use of wooden \\[\\[stencil\\|templates]] (a kind of pattern), the use of \\[\\[paper model]]s to establish designs, the \\[\\[Calibrated orifice\\|calibration of orifices]], the grinding of the seats and plugs of valves together with \\[\\[Emery (rock)\\|emery]] powder to obtain a watertight fit, and the \\[\\[Casting (metalworking)\\|casting]] of metals in closed \\[\\[Sand casting\\|mold boxes]] with \\[\\[Molding sand\\|sand]].}}",
"### Escapement mechanism in a rotating wheel",
"Al\\-Jazari invented a method for controlling the speed of [rotation](/wiki/Rotation \"Rotation\") of a wheel using an [escapement](/wiki/Escapement \"Escapement\") mechanism.[Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill \"Donald Hill\"), \"Engineering\", in Roshdi Rashed, ed., *[Encyclopedia of the History of Arabic Science](/wiki/Encyclopedia_of_the_History_of_Arabic_Science \"Encyclopedia of the History of Arabic Science\")*, Vol. 2, pp. 751–795 \\[792]. [Routledge](/wiki/Routledge \"Routledge\"), London and New York.",
"### Mechanical controls",
"According to [Donald Hill](/wiki/Donald_Hill \"Donald Hill\"), al\\-Jazari described several early [mechanical controls](/wiki/Control_system \"Control system\"), including \"a large metal door, a [combination lock](/wiki/Combination_lock \"Combination lock\") and a lock with four [bolts](/wiki/Bolted_joint \"Bolted joint\")\".",
"### Conical valve and segmental gear",
"A segmental gear is \"a piece for receiving or communicating [reciprocating motion](/wiki/Reciprocating_motion \"Reciprocating motion\") from or to a cogwheel, consisting of a sector of a circular [gear](/wiki/Gear \"Gear\"), or ring, having cogs on the periphery, or face.\"[Segment gear](http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Segment+gear), [TheFreeDictionary.com](/wiki/TheFreeDictionary.com \"TheFreeDictionary.com\") [Lynn Townsend White](/wiki/Lynn_Townsend_White \"Lynn Townsend White\") wrote:{{Sfn\\|Hill\\|1974\\|p\\=xiii}}\n{{blockquote\\|text\\=Western scholars had thought that conical \\[\\[valves]] first appeared in Leonardo’s drawings, but al\\-Jazarl’s pictures show them. Similarly, segmental gears first clearly appear in al\\-Jazarl; in the West they emerge in \\[\\[Giovanni Dondi dell'Orologio\\|Giovanni de’ Dondi]]’s astronomical clock finished in 1364; with the great \\[\\[Siena\\|Sienese]] engineer \\[\\[Francesco di Giorgio Martini\\|Francesco di Giorgio]] (d. 1501\\) they entered the general vocabulary of European machine design.}}",
""
] |
Automata
--------
Al\-Jazari built automated moving peacocks driven by hydropower.[al\-Jazari (Islamic artist)](http://www.britannica.com/eb/topic-301961/al-Jazari), *[Encyclopædia Britannica](/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica "Encyclopædia Britannica")*. He also created automatic doors as part of one of his elaborate [water clocks](/wiki/Water_clock "Water clock"), and invented [water wheels](/wiki/Water_wheel "Water wheel") with [cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 "Cam (mechanism)") on their [axle](/wiki/Axle "Axle") used to operate automata. According to *[Encyclopædia Britannica](/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica "Encyclopædia Britannica")*, the [Italian Renaissance](/wiki/Italian_Renaissance "Italian Renaissance") inventor [Leonardo da Vinci](/wiki/Leonardo_da_Vinci "Leonardo da Vinci") may have been influenced by the classic automata of al\-Jazari.{{Cite encyclopedia\|title\=al\-Jazari\|encyclopedia\=\[\[Encyclopædia Britannica]]\|year\= 2009\|url\=http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/301961/al\-Jazari\|access\-date\=4 October 2009}}
Mark E. Rosheim summarizes the advances in [robotics](/wiki/Robotics "Robotics") made by Muslim engineers, especially al\-Jazari, as follows:
{{blockquote\|text\=Unlike the Greek designs, these Arab examples reveal an interest, not only in dramatic illusion, but in manipulating the environment for human comfort. Thus, the greatest contribution the Arabs made, besides preserving, disseminating and building on the work of the Greeks, was the concept of practical application. This was the key element that was missing in Greek robotic science.}}
{{blockquote\|text\=The Arabs, on the other hand, displayed an interest in creating human\-like machines for practical purposes but lacked, like other preindustrial societies, any real impetus to pursue their robotic science.{{citation\|title\=Robot Evolution: The Development of Anthrobotics\|first\=Mark E.\|last\=Rosheim\|year\=1994\|publisher\=Wiley\-IEEE\|isbn\=0\-471\-02622\-0\|page\=\[https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/36 36]\|url\=https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/36}}}}
### Drink\-serving waitress
One of al\-Jazari's [humanoid automata](/wiki/Humanoid_robot "Humanoid robot") was a waitress that could serve water, tea or drinks. The drink was stored in a tank with a reservoir from where the drink drips into a bucket and, after seven minutes, into a cup, after which the waitress appears out of an automatic door serving the drink.{{citation\|title\=Ancient Discoveries, Episode 12: Machines of the East\|work\=\[\[History (U.S. TV channel)\|History]]\|url\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\=v2HcjanNWFM \|archive\-url\=https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211212/v2HcjanNWFM\| archive\-date\=2021\-12\-12 \|url\-status\=live\|access\-date\=6 September 2008}}{{cbignore}}
### Hand\-washing automaton with flush mechanism
Al\-Jazari invented a hand washing [automaton](/wiki/Automaton "Automaton") incorporating a flush mechanism now used in modern [flush toilets](/wiki/Flush_toilet "Flush toilet"). This device is another example of [humanoid automata](/wiki/Humanoid_robot "Humanoid robot"). It consisted of a human figure, made from jointed copper, holding a pitcher resembling a peacock in its right hand. The pitcher is made from brass and holds within it a chamber, divided into two parts by a metal plate. This mechanism aided the pouring of the water from the spout so that it was smooth and would not splutter. The reservoir in which the water is held is situated within the right\-hand side of the human figure. An axle is fitted into the right elbow of the human figure so as to allow the liquid to pour from the reservoir through the spout of the pitcher. The left arm of the figure had a fixed weight which would raise and lower the arm which would hold a towel, comb and mirror.
This automaton was designed to aid the king whilst he performed his [ritual ablutions](/wiki/Ritual_purification "Ritual purification"). A servant of the king would carry the figure and place it next to a basin that could hold liquid. The servant then turned a knob on the back of the figure which opened a valve resulting in the pouring of water from the right hand of the figure into the basin. When the reservoir is nearly empty and most of the water has been poured a mechanism is prompted and the left hand of the figure, holding the towel, comb and mirror, is extended out in the direction of the king so that he can dry himself and tend to his beard.{{Cite book\|last\=Ibn al\-Razzaz al\-Jazari\|url\=http://archive.org/details/TheBookOfKnowledgeOfIngeniousMechanicalDevices\|title\=The Book Of Knowledge Of Ingenious Mechanical Devices\|date\=1974\-01\-01}}
### Peacock fountain with automated servants
Water and its usages holds particular importance in [Islam](/wiki/Islam "Islam"); both as being an integral part of the pre\-prayer washing processes *[wudu](/wiki/Wudu "Wudu")* and *[ghusl](/wiki/Ghusl "Ghusl")*, and a key feature in Islamic gardens – four fountains featuring in the [Paradise Garden](/wiki/Paradise_Garden_islam "Paradise Garden islam"); the Islamic final resting place referenced in the [Quran](/wiki/Quran "Quran"). Additionally, with [Mesopotamia](/wiki/Mesopotamia "Mesopotamia") being a naturally drought\-ridden place, machines relating to water held a significant function; in both a divine and practical sense.
An entire section of *The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices* was devoted to fountain mechanisms, titled: *‘On the construction in pools of fountains which change their shape, and of machines for the perpetual flute’.*{{Cite journal\|last1\=Campbell\|first1\=James W. P.\|last2\=Boyington\|first2\=Amy\|date\=2018\-07\-03\|title\=Fountains and water: the development of the hydraulic technology of display in Islamic gardens 700–1700 CE\|url\=https://doi.org/10\.1080/14601176\.2018\.1452827\|journal\=Studies in the History of Gardens \& Designed Landscapes\|volume\=38\|issue\=3\|pages\=247–267\|doi\=10\.1080/14601176\.2018\.1452827\|s2cid\=165676924\|issn\=1460\-1176}}
Al\-Jazari's "peacock fountain" was a more sophisticated hand washing device featuring humanoid automata as servants which offer soap and [towels](/wiki/Towel "Towel"). Mark E. Rosheim describes it as follows:{{citation\|title\=Robot Evolution: The Development of Anthrobotics\|first\=Mark E.\|last\=Rosheim\|year\=1994\|publisher\=Wiley\-IEEE\|isbn\=0\-471\-02622\-0\|page\=\[https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/9 9]\|url\=https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/9}}
{{blockquote\|text\=Pulling a plug on the peacock's tail releases water out of the beak; as the dirty water from the basin fills the hollow base a float rises and actuates a \[\[Linkage (mechanical)\|linkage]] which makes a servant figure appear from behind a door under the peacock and offer soap. When more water is used, a second float at a higher level trips and causes the appearance of a second servant figure – with a towel!}}
[thumb\|Al\-Jazari's Peacock Fountain](/wiki/File:Syria%2C_Damascus%2C_Mamluk_Period%2C_14th_Century_-_Peacock-shaped_Hand_Washing_Device_%28recto%29%3B_Text_Page%2C_Arabic_Prose_%28verso%29_-_1945.383_-_Cleveland_Museum_of_Art.tif "Syria, Damascus, Mamluk Period, 14th Century - Peacock-shaped Hand Washing Device (recto); Text Page, Arabic Prose (verso) - 1945.383 - Cleveland Museum of Art.tif")
The basin of the "peacock fountain" formed the basin for performing *[wudu](/wiki/Wudu "Wudu"),* and it would have been operated by a servant, who would have pulled the plug and positioned the peacock's beak; allowing the mechanism to release the water into the basin in front of the user.{{Cite web\|last\=גולן\|first\=אבי\|date\=2019\-07\-30\|title\=The basin of the Peacock and the magic of automata\|url\=https://aljazaribook.com/en/2019/07/30/the\-basin\-of\-the\-peacock\_en/\|access\-date\=2020\-10\-18\|website\=The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices\|language\=en\-US}}
However, whilst water moving objects such as the peacock fountain had ritualistic usage, there is suggestion that water\-moving hydraulics were put to profane use. Ayhan Aytes suggests that:{{Cite journal\|title\=Zentrum für Kunst und Medientechnologie Karlsruhe (ZKM)\|url\=http://dx.doi.org/10\.1163/9789004337862\_lgbo\_com\_260157\|access\-date\=2020\-10\-19\|website\=Lexikon des gesamten Buchwesens Online\|doi\=10\.1163/9789004337862\_lgbo\_com\_260157}}
> Many of the devices also had additional functions that contradicted divine omnipotence. The most profane purpose of several of his hydraulic and pnuematic automata was to get guests at parties drunk as quickly as possible.
### Musical robot band
[thumb\|right\|Al\-Jazari's musical [robot](/wiki/Robot "Robot") band.](/wiki/File:Al-jazari_robots.jpg "Al-jazari robots.jpg")
Al\-Jazari's work described fountains and musical automata, in which the flow of water alternated from one large tank to another at hourly or half\-hourly intervals. This operation was achieved through his innovative use of [hydraulic](/wiki/Hydraulics "Hydraulics") switching.
Al\-Jazari created a musical automaton, which was a boat with four automatic musicians that floated on a lake to entertain guests at royal drinking parties. Professor [Noel Sharkey](/wiki/Noel_Sharkey "Noel Sharkey") has argued that it is quite likely that it was an early [programmable](/wiki/Program_%28machine%29 "Program (machine)") automata and has produced a possible reconstruction of the mechanism; it has a programmable drum machine with [pegs](/wiki/Wiktionary:Peg "Peg") ([cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 "Cam (mechanism)")) that bump into little [levers](/wiki/Lever "Lever") that operated the percussion. The drummer could be made to play different rhythms and different drum patterns if the pegs were moved around.Professor Noel Sharkey, [A 13th Century Programmable Robot (Archive)](https://web.archive.org/web/20070629182810/http://www.shef.ac.uk/marcoms/eview/articles58/robot.html), [University of Sheffield](/wiki/University_of_Sheffield "University of Sheffield").
### The water\-clock of the drummers
[thumb\|The water\-clock of the drummers](/wiki/File:Al_jazari_Horloge_des_tambours.jpg "Al jazari Horloge des tambours.jpg")
The water\-clock of the drummers, which differs from the Musical robot band in that it lacks a flute\-playing [doll](/wiki/Doll "Doll") and instead has two [trumpeters](/wiki/Trumpeters "Trumpeters"), consists of seven wood\-jointed male figures, including the aforementioned trumpeters as well as two dolls playing [cymbals](/wiki/Cymbals "Cymbals") and the rest playing other [percussive instruments](/wiki/Percussive "Percussive").The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices by Ibn al\-Razzaz al\-Jazari Translated by Donald R. Hill, 01\-01\-1974 The mechanism in this specific automaton serves as a [clock](/wiki/Clock "Clock") by producing a musical output once every hour, illustrating [Al\-Jazari](/wiki/Al-Jazari "Al-Jazari")’s ability to create multi\-faceted automata that functioned on a practical and entertainment level. The motion of the [automaton](/wiki/Automaton "Automaton") is initiated at daybreak by another male doll, who stands at the edge of the [frieze](/wiki/Frieze "Frieze") element of the design, moving across until he reaches a specific point at which a carved [falcon](/wiki/Falcon "Falcon") leans forward dropping a ball from its beak onto a cymbal.{{Cite web\|url\=https://michaelkrzyzaniak.com/Research/PrehistoryMusicalRobots.pdf\|title\=2\. Prehistory of Musical Robots, Michael Krzyzaniak, Arizona State University, School of Arts, Media and Engineering}} All mechanical aspects of the automaton are then driven by water and a series of pistons and cables. Each hour water drains out of the main [cistern](/wiki/Cistern "Cistern") to cause another bucket to tip over driving a [water wheel](/wiki/Water_wheel "Water wheel") that is connected to the musicians. The automaton is described to ‘perform a with a clamorous sound which is heard from afar’ and could play several different tunes.[2\.Prehistory of Musical Robots, Michael Krzyzaniak, Arizona State University, School of Arts, Media and Engineering](https://michaelkrzyzaniak.com/Research/PrehistoryMusicalRobots.pdf) Like many other automatons by Al\-Jazari, this was created to entertain guests at the royal palace.
|
[
"Automata\n--------",
"Al\\-Jazari built automated moving peacocks driven by hydropower.[al\\-Jazari (Islamic artist)](http://www.britannica.com/eb/topic-301961/al-Jazari), *[Encyclopædia Britannica](/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica \"Encyclopædia Britannica\")*. He also created automatic doors as part of one of his elaborate [water clocks](/wiki/Water_clock \"Water clock\"), and invented [water wheels](/wiki/Water_wheel \"Water wheel\") with [cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 \"Cam (mechanism)\") on their [axle](/wiki/Axle \"Axle\") used to operate automata. According to *[Encyclopædia Britannica](/wiki/Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica \"Encyclopædia Britannica\")*, the [Italian Renaissance](/wiki/Italian_Renaissance \"Italian Renaissance\") inventor [Leonardo da Vinci](/wiki/Leonardo_da_Vinci \"Leonardo da Vinci\") may have been influenced by the classic automata of al\\-Jazari.{{Cite encyclopedia\\|title\\=al\\-Jazari\\|encyclopedia\\=\\[\\[Encyclopædia Britannica]]\\|year\\= 2009\\|url\\=http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/301961/al\\-Jazari\\|access\\-date\\=4 October 2009}}",
"Mark E. Rosheim summarizes the advances in [robotics](/wiki/Robotics \"Robotics\") made by Muslim engineers, especially al\\-Jazari, as follows:",
"{{blockquote\\|text\\=Unlike the Greek designs, these Arab examples reveal an interest, not only in dramatic illusion, but in manipulating the environment for human comfort. Thus, the greatest contribution the Arabs made, besides preserving, disseminating and building on the work of the Greeks, was the concept of practical application. This was the key element that was missing in Greek robotic science.}}",
"{{blockquote\\|text\\=The Arabs, on the other hand, displayed an interest in creating human\\-like machines for practical purposes but lacked, like other preindustrial societies, any real impetus to pursue their robotic science.{{citation\\|title\\=Robot Evolution: The Development of Anthrobotics\\|first\\=Mark E.\\|last\\=Rosheim\\|year\\=1994\\|publisher\\=Wiley\\-IEEE\\|isbn\\=0\\-471\\-02622\\-0\\|page\\=\\[https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/36 36]\\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/36}}}}",
"### Drink\\-serving waitress",
"One of al\\-Jazari's [humanoid automata](/wiki/Humanoid_robot \"Humanoid robot\") was a waitress that could serve water, tea or drinks. The drink was stored in a tank with a reservoir from where the drink drips into a bucket and, after seven minutes, into a cup, after which the waitress appears out of an automatic door serving the drink.{{citation\\|title\\=Ancient Discoveries, Episode 12: Machines of the East\\|work\\=\\[\\[History (U.S. TV channel)\\|History]]\\|url\\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\\=v2HcjanNWFM \\|archive\\-url\\=https://ghostarchive.org/varchive/youtube/20211212/v2HcjanNWFM\\| archive\\-date\\=2021\\-12\\-12 \\|url\\-status\\=live\\|access\\-date\\=6 September 2008}}{{cbignore}}",
"### Hand\\-washing automaton with flush mechanism",
"Al\\-Jazari invented a hand washing [automaton](/wiki/Automaton \"Automaton\") incorporating a flush mechanism now used in modern [flush toilets](/wiki/Flush_toilet \"Flush toilet\"). This device is another example of [humanoid automata](/wiki/Humanoid_robot \"Humanoid robot\"). It consisted of a human figure, made from jointed copper, holding a pitcher resembling a peacock in its right hand. The pitcher is made from brass and holds within it a chamber, divided into two parts by a metal plate. This mechanism aided the pouring of the water from the spout so that it was smooth and would not splutter. The reservoir in which the water is held is situated within the right\\-hand side of the human figure. An axle is fitted into the right elbow of the human figure so as to allow the liquid to pour from the reservoir through the spout of the pitcher. The left arm of the figure had a fixed weight which would raise and lower the arm which would hold a towel, comb and mirror.",
"This automaton was designed to aid the king whilst he performed his [ritual ablutions](/wiki/Ritual_purification \"Ritual purification\"). A servant of the king would carry the figure and place it next to a basin that could hold liquid. The servant then turned a knob on the back of the figure which opened a valve resulting in the pouring of water from the right hand of the figure into the basin. When the reservoir is nearly empty and most of the water has been poured a mechanism is prompted and the left hand of the figure, holding the towel, comb and mirror, is extended out in the direction of the king so that he can dry himself and tend to his beard.{{Cite book\\|last\\=Ibn al\\-Razzaz al\\-Jazari\\|url\\=http://archive.org/details/TheBookOfKnowledgeOfIngeniousMechanicalDevices\\|title\\=The Book Of Knowledge Of Ingenious Mechanical Devices\\|date\\=1974\\-01\\-01}}",
"### Peacock fountain with automated servants",
"Water and its usages holds particular importance in [Islam](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\"); both as being an integral part of the pre\\-prayer washing processes *[wudu](/wiki/Wudu \"Wudu\")* and *[ghusl](/wiki/Ghusl \"Ghusl\")*, and a key feature in Islamic gardens – four fountains featuring in the [Paradise Garden](/wiki/Paradise_Garden_islam \"Paradise Garden islam\"); the Islamic final resting place referenced in the [Quran](/wiki/Quran \"Quran\"). Additionally, with [Mesopotamia](/wiki/Mesopotamia \"Mesopotamia\") being a naturally drought\\-ridden place, machines relating to water held a significant function; in both a divine and practical sense.",
"An entire section of *The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices* was devoted to fountain mechanisms, titled: *‘On the construction in pools of fountains which change their shape, and of machines for the perpetual flute’.*{{Cite journal\\|last1\\=Campbell\\|first1\\=James W. P.\\|last2\\=Boyington\\|first2\\=Amy\\|date\\=2018\\-07\\-03\\|title\\=Fountains and water: the development of the hydraulic technology of display in Islamic gardens 700–1700 CE\\|url\\=https://doi.org/10\\.1080/14601176\\.2018\\.1452827\\|journal\\=Studies in the History of Gardens \\& Designed Landscapes\\|volume\\=38\\|issue\\=3\\|pages\\=247–267\\|doi\\=10\\.1080/14601176\\.2018\\.1452827\\|s2cid\\=165676924\\|issn\\=1460\\-1176}}",
"Al\\-Jazari's \"peacock fountain\" was a more sophisticated hand washing device featuring humanoid automata as servants which offer soap and [towels](/wiki/Towel \"Towel\"). Mark E. Rosheim describes it as follows:{{citation\\|title\\=Robot Evolution: The Development of Anthrobotics\\|first\\=Mark E.\\|last\\=Rosheim\\|year\\=1994\\|publisher\\=Wiley\\-IEEE\\|isbn\\=0\\-471\\-02622\\-0\\|page\\=\\[https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/9 9]\\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/robotevolutionde0000rosh/page/9}}",
"{{blockquote\\|text\\=Pulling a plug on the peacock's tail releases water out of the beak; as the dirty water from the basin fills the hollow base a float rises and actuates a \\[\\[Linkage (mechanical)\\|linkage]] which makes a servant figure appear from behind a door under the peacock and offer soap. When more water is used, a second float at a higher level trips and causes the appearance of a second servant figure – with a towel!}}\n[thumb\\|Al\\-Jazari's Peacock Fountain](/wiki/File:Syria%2C_Damascus%2C_Mamluk_Period%2C_14th_Century_-_Peacock-shaped_Hand_Washing_Device_%28recto%29%3B_Text_Page%2C_Arabic_Prose_%28verso%29_-_1945.383_-_Cleveland_Museum_of_Art.tif \"Syria, Damascus, Mamluk Period, 14th Century - Peacock-shaped Hand Washing Device (recto); Text Page, Arabic Prose (verso) - 1945.383 - Cleveland Museum of Art.tif\")\nThe basin of the \"peacock fountain\" formed the basin for performing *[wudu](/wiki/Wudu \"Wudu\"),* and it would have been operated by a servant, who would have pulled the plug and positioned the peacock's beak; allowing the mechanism to release the water into the basin in front of the user.{{Cite web\\|last\\=גולן\\|first\\=אבי\\|date\\=2019\\-07\\-30\\|title\\=The basin of the Peacock and the magic of automata\\|url\\=https://aljazaribook.com/en/2019/07/30/the\\-basin\\-of\\-the\\-peacock\\_en/\\|access\\-date\\=2020\\-10\\-18\\|website\\=The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices\\|language\\=en\\-US}}",
"However, whilst water moving objects such as the peacock fountain had ritualistic usage, there is suggestion that water\\-moving hydraulics were put to profane use. Ayhan Aytes suggests that:{{Cite journal\\|title\\=Zentrum für Kunst und Medientechnologie Karlsruhe (ZKM)\\|url\\=http://dx.doi.org/10\\.1163/9789004337862\\_lgbo\\_com\\_260157\\|access\\-date\\=2020\\-10\\-19\\|website\\=Lexikon des gesamten Buchwesens Online\\|doi\\=10\\.1163/9789004337862\\_lgbo\\_com\\_260157}}\n> Many of the devices also had additional functions that contradicted divine omnipotence. The most profane purpose of several of his hydraulic and pnuematic automata was to get guests at parties drunk as quickly as possible.",
"",
"### Musical robot band",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Al\\-Jazari's musical [robot](/wiki/Robot \"Robot\") band.](/wiki/File:Al-jazari_robots.jpg \"Al-jazari robots.jpg\")",
"Al\\-Jazari's work described fountains and musical automata, in which the flow of water alternated from one large tank to another at hourly or half\\-hourly intervals. This operation was achieved through his innovative use of [hydraulic](/wiki/Hydraulics \"Hydraulics\") switching.",
"Al\\-Jazari created a musical automaton, which was a boat with four automatic musicians that floated on a lake to entertain guests at royal drinking parties. Professor [Noel Sharkey](/wiki/Noel_Sharkey \"Noel Sharkey\") has argued that it is quite likely that it was an early [programmable](/wiki/Program_%28machine%29 \"Program (machine)\") automata and has produced a possible reconstruction of the mechanism; it has a programmable drum machine with [pegs](/wiki/Wiktionary:Peg \"Peg\") ([cams](/wiki/Cam_%28mechanism%29 \"Cam (mechanism)\")) that bump into little [levers](/wiki/Lever \"Lever\") that operated the percussion. The drummer could be made to play different rhythms and different drum patterns if the pegs were moved around.Professor Noel Sharkey, [A 13th Century Programmable Robot (Archive)](https://web.archive.org/web/20070629182810/http://www.shef.ac.uk/marcoms/eview/articles58/robot.html), [University of Sheffield](/wiki/University_of_Sheffield \"University of Sheffield\").",
"### The water\\-clock of the drummers",
"[thumb\\|The water\\-clock of the drummers](/wiki/File:Al_jazari_Horloge_des_tambours.jpg \"Al jazari Horloge des tambours.jpg\")",
"The water\\-clock of the drummers, which differs from the Musical robot band in that it lacks a flute\\-playing [doll](/wiki/Doll \"Doll\") and instead has two [trumpeters](/wiki/Trumpeters \"Trumpeters\"), consists of seven wood\\-jointed male figures, including the aforementioned trumpeters as well as two dolls playing [cymbals](/wiki/Cymbals \"Cymbals\") and the rest playing other [percussive instruments](/wiki/Percussive \"Percussive\").The Book of Knowledge of Ingenious Mechanical Devices by Ibn al\\-Razzaz al\\-Jazari Translated by Donald R. Hill, 01\\-01\\-1974 The mechanism in this specific automaton serves as a [clock](/wiki/Clock \"Clock\") by producing a musical output once every hour, illustrating [Al\\-Jazari](/wiki/Al-Jazari \"Al-Jazari\")’s ability to create multi\\-faceted automata that functioned on a practical and entertainment level. The motion of the [automaton](/wiki/Automaton \"Automaton\") is initiated at daybreak by another male doll, who stands at the edge of the [frieze](/wiki/Frieze \"Frieze\") element of the design, moving across until he reaches a specific point at which a carved [falcon](/wiki/Falcon \"Falcon\") leans forward dropping a ball from its beak onto a cymbal.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://michaelkrzyzaniak.com/Research/PrehistoryMusicalRobots.pdf\\|title\\=2\\. Prehistory of Musical Robots, Michael Krzyzaniak, Arizona State University, School of Arts, Media and Engineering}} All mechanical aspects of the automaton are then driven by water and a series of pistons and cables. Each hour water drains out of the main [cistern](/wiki/Cistern \"Cistern\") to cause another bucket to tip over driving a [water wheel](/wiki/Water_wheel \"Water wheel\") that is connected to the musicians. The automaton is described to ‘perform a with a clamorous sound which is heard from afar’ and could play several different tunes.[2\\.Prehistory of Musical Robots, Michael Krzyzaniak, Arizona State University, School of Arts, Media and Engineering](https://michaelkrzyzaniak.com/Research/PrehistoryMusicalRobots.pdf) Like many other automatons by Al\\-Jazari, this was created to entertain guests at the royal palace.",
""
] |
Career
------
### Academic economist
[thumb\|Summers in 1990](/wiki/File:Lawrence_Summers%2C_1990.jpg "Lawrence Summers, 1990.jpg")
As a researcher, Summers has made important contributions in many areas of economics, primarily [public finance](/wiki/Public_finance "Public finance"), [labor economics](/wiki/Labor_economics "Labor economics"), [financial economics](/wiki/Financial_economics "Financial economics"), and [macroeconomics](/wiki/Macroeconomics "Macroeconomics"). Summers has also worked in international economics, economic demography, [economic history](/wiki/Economic_history "Economic history") and [development economics](/wiki/Development_economics "Development economics").{{Cite journal\|last\=Poterba\|first\=James M.\|date\=Winter 1995\|title\=In Honor of Lawrence H. Summers, Winner of the John Bates Clark Medal\|journal\=Journal of Economic Perspectives\|language\=en\|volume\=9\|issue\=1\|pages\=165–182\|doi\=10\.1257/jep.9\.1\.165\|issn\=0895\-3309\|doi\-access\=}} He received the [John Bates Clark Medal](/wiki/John_Bates_Clark_Medal "John Bates Clark Medal") in 1993 from the American Economic Association.{{Cite news\|url\=http://www.businessinsider.com/30\-most\-famous\-harvard\-students\-of\-all\-time\-2010\-4\#larry\-summers\-born\-november\-30\-1954\-21\|title\=The 30 Most Famous Harvard Students Of All Time\|work\=\[\[Business Insider]]\|access\-date\=August 7, 2017\|language\=en}} In 1987, he was the first social scientist to win the [Alan T. Waterman Award](/wiki/Alan_T._Waterman_Award "Alan T. Waterman Award") from the [National Science Foundation](/wiki/National_Science_Foundation "National Science Foundation"). Summers is also a member of the [National Academy of Sciences](/wiki/United_States_National_Academy_of_Sciences "United States National Academy of Sciences"). Some of his popular courses today, as Charles W. Eliot University Professor at Harvard University, include American Economic Policy and The Political Economy of Globalization.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.hks.harvard.edu/faculty/lawrence\-h\-summers\|title\=Lawrence H. Summers\|website\=www.hks.harvard.edu}}
### Public official
Summers was on the staff of the [Council of Economic Advisers](/wiki/Council_of_Economic_Advisers "Council of Economic Advisers") under President Reagan in 1982–1983\. He also served as an economic adviser to the [Dukakis](/wiki/Michael_Dukakis "Michael Dukakis") Presidential campaign in 1988\.
### Chief Economist at the World Bank
Summers left Harvard in 1991 and served as [Vice President of Development Economics](/wiki/World_Bank_Vice_President_of_Development_Economics "World Bank Vice President of Development Economics") and [Chief Economist](/wiki/World_Bank_Chief_Economist "World Bank Chief Economist") for the [World Bank](/wiki/World_Bank "World Bank") until 1993\.
According to the World Bank's Data \& Research office (March 2017\), Summers returned to [Washington, D.C.](/wiki/Washington%2C_D.C. "Washington, D.C.") in 1991 as the World Bank's Vice President of Development Economics and Chief Economist. As such, Summers played a "key role" in designing strategies to aid developing countries, worked on the bank's loan committee, guided the bank's research and statistics operations, and guided external training programs.
The World Bank's official site also reports that Summer's research included an "influential" report that demonstrated a very high return from investments in educating girls in developing nations.
According to *The Economist,* Summers was "often at the centre of heated debates" about economic policy, to an extent exceptional for the history of the World Bank in recent decades.["New ideas: The World Bank hires a famous contrarian,"](https://www.economist.com/news/21702339-paul-romer-banks-new-chief-economist-world-bank-hires-famous-contrarian) July 18, 2016, [The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist "The Economist"), retrieved March 31, 2017
#### "Dirty industries" controversy
{{Further\|Summers memo}}
In December 1991, while at the World Bank, Summers signed [a memo](/wiki/Summers_memo "Summers memo") that was leaked to the press. [Lant Pritchett](/wiki/Lant_Pritchett "Lant Pritchett") has claimed authorship of the private memo, which both he and Summers say was intended as sarcasm.["Furor on Memo At World Bank,"](https://www.nytimes.com/1992/02/07/business/furor-on-memo-at-world-bank.html) February 7, 1992, [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times"), retrieved March 30, 2017 The memo stated that "the economic logic behind dumping a load of toxic waste in the lowest wage country is impeccable and we should face up to that. ... I've always thought that under\-populated countries in Africa are vastly underpolluted."Office Memorandum from Lawrence M. Summers, Subject: GEP, the World Bank/IMFMIGA, December 12, 1991\. This was an internal memo at the World Bank, not intended for the public \-\- reportedly sarcastic, rather than sincere, according to its authors \-\- that highlighted the economic logic of dumping waste in less\-developed countries. According to Pritchett, the memo, as leaked, was doctored to remove context and intended irony, and was "a deliberate fraud and forgery to discredit Larry and the World Bank."{{cite magazine\|url\=http://www.harvardmagazine.com/on\-line/050171\.html\|title\=Toxic Memo\|magazine\= Harvard Magazine\|date\=May–June 2001}}, also posted at: {{cite web\|title\=Toxic memo\|url\=http://www.harvardmagazine.com/2001/05/toxic\-memo.html\|publisher\=HarvardMagazine.com\|access\-date\=November 8, 2017\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20081203160404/http://www.harvardmagazine.com/on\-line/050171\.html\|archive\-date\=December 3, 2008}}
### Service in the Clinton Administration
[thumb\|right\|Summers as United States Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/File:Lawrence_Summers_Treasury_portrait.jpg "Lawrence Summers Treasury portrait.jpg")
In 1993, Summers was appointed Undersecretary for International Affairs and later in the [United States Department of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasury "United States Department of the Treasury") under the [Clinton](/wiki/Bill_Clinton "Bill Clinton") Administration. In 1995, he was promoted to Deputy Secretary of the Treasury under his long\-time political mentor [Robert Rubin](/wiki/Robert_Rubin "Robert Rubin"). In 1999, he succeeded Rubin as [Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Secretary_of_the_Treasury "United States Secretary of the Treasury").
Much of Summers's tenure at the Treasury Department was focused on international economic issues. He was deeply involved in the Clinton administration's effort to bail out Mexico and Russia when those nations had currency crises.[A New Economic Team: The Nominee; The Administration's Fiscal Closer](https://www.nytimes.com/1999/05/13/business/a-new-economic-team-the-nominee-the-administration-s-fiscal-closer.html?sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times"). May 13, 1999\.
Summers set up a project through which the [Harvard Institute for International Development](/wiki/Harvard_Institute_for_International_Development "Harvard Institute for International Development") provided advice to the Russian government between 1992 and 1997\. Later there was a scandal when it emerged that some of the Harvard project members had invested in Russia and were therefore not impartial advisors.{{cite book
\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=5ywA163EEewC\&pg\=PA79\|page\=79\|title\=Misinterpreting Modern Russia\|author\=Bruno S. Sergi\|publisher\=Continuum International Publishing Group\|year\=2009\|isbn\=978\-0\-8264\-2772\-4}}
Summers encouraged then\-Russian leader Boris Yeltsin to use the same "three\-'ations'" of policy he advocated in the Clinton Administration – "privatization, stabilization, and liberalization."Naomi Klein, "The Shock Doctrine", p. 231
Summers pressured the Korean government to raise its interest rates and balance its budget in the midst of a recession, policies criticized by [Paul Krugman](/wiki/Paul_Krugman "Paul Krugman") and [Joseph Stiglitz](/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz "Joseph Stiglitz").{{cite news\|first\=Paul\|last\=Blustein\|title\=The Chastening\|url\=http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\-cgi\-bin/display?book\=9781586481810\|publisher\=Public Affairs, New York\|year\=2001\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20101208005946/http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\-cgi\-bin/display?book\=9781586481810\|archive\-date\=December 8, 2010\|url\-status\=dead}}
According to the book *The Chastening*, by Paul Blustein, during this crisis, Summers, along with [Paul Wolfowitz](/wiki/Paul_Wolfowitz "Paul Wolfowitz"), pushed for regime change in Indonesia.{{cite news\|first\=Paul\|last\=Blustein\|title\=The Chastening\|url\=http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\-cgi\-bin/display?book\=9781586481810\|page\=232\|publisher\=Public Affairs, New York\|year\=2001\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20101208005946/http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\-cgi\-bin/display?book\=9781586481810\|archive\-date\=December 8, 2010\|url\-status\=dead}}
Summers was a leading voice within the Clinton Administration arguing against American leadership in [greenhouse gas](/wiki/Greenhouse_gas "Greenhouse gas") reductions and against US participation in the [Kyoto Protocol](/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol "Kyoto Protocol"), according to internal documents made public in 2009\.{{cite news \|first\=Robert\|last\=Wampler\|title\=Kyoto Redux? Obama's Challenges at Copenhagen Echo Clinton's at Kyoto\|url\=http://www.gwu.edu/\~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB303/index.htm\|publisher\=National Security Archive at George Washington University\|access\-date\=April 10, 2010\|date\=December 18, 2009}}
As Treasury Secretary, Summers led the Clinton Administration's opposition to tax cuts proposed by the Republican Congress in 1999\.[Aides Say Clinton Would Veto Tax Compromise](https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/budget/stories/taxes072699.htm). [The Washington Post](/wiki/The_Washington_Post "The Washington Post"). July 26, 1999\.
During the California [energy crisis of 2000](/wiki/2000%E2%80%9301_California_electricity_crisis "2000–01 California electricity crisis"), then\-Treasury Secretary Summers teamed with [Alan Greenspan](/wiki/Alan_Greenspan "Alan Greenspan") and [Enron](/wiki/Enron "Enron") executive [Kenneth Lay](/wiki/Kenneth_Lay "Kenneth Lay") to lecture California Governor [Gray Davis](/wiki/Gray_Davis "Gray Davis") on the causes of the crisis, explaining that the problem was excessive government regulation.{{cite news \|first\=Paul\|last\=Krugman\|author\-link\=Paul Krugman\|title\=California Energy Memories\|url\=https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/11/20/california\-energy\-memories/\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=November 20, 2008\|access\-date\=April 4, 2010}}
Under the advice of Kenneth Lay, Summers urged Davis to relax California's environmental standards in order to reassure the markets.{{cite web \|first\=Alex\|last\=Gibney\|author\-link\=Alex Gibney\|title\=Larry Summers' Enron Problem\|url\=http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs\-and\-stories/2008\-11\-12/larry\-summers\-and\-enron/\|website\=\[\[The Daily Beast]]}}
Summers hailed the [Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act](/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bliley_Act "Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act") in 1999, which lifted more than six decades of restrictions against banks offering [commercial banking](/wiki/Commercial_banking "Commercial banking"), insurance, and investment services (by repealing key provisions in the 1933 [Glass–Steagall Act](/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_Act "Glass–Steagall Act")): "Today Congress voted to update the rules that have governed financial services since the [Great Depression](/wiki/Great_Depression "Great Depression") and replace them with a system for the 21st century," Summers said.{{cite news\|work\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/1999/11/05/business/congress\-passes\-wide\-ranging\-bill\-easing\-bank\-laws.html\|title\=Congress Passes Wide Ranging Law Repealing Bank laws\|date\=November 5, 1999\|access\-date\=March 25, 2009\|first\=Stephen\|last\=Labaton}} "This historic legislation will better enable American companies to compete in the new economy." Many critics, including [President](/wiki/POTUS "POTUS") [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama "Barack Obama"), have suggested the [2007 subprime mortgage financial crisis](/wiki/2007_subprime_mortgage_financial_crisis "2007 subprime mortgage financial crisis") was caused by the partial repeal of the 1933 Glass–Steagall Act.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123665023774979341\|title\=Ten Questions for Those Fixing the Financial Mess\|work\=\[\[The Wall Street Journal]]\|date\=March 10, 2009\|access\-date\=March 26, 2009\|first\=Damian\|last\=Paletta}} Indeed, as a member of President Clinton's [Working Group on Financial Markets](/wiki/Working_Group_on_Financial_Markets "Working Group on Financial Markets"), Summers, along with U.S. [Securities and Exchange Commission](/wiki/Securities_and_Exchange_Commission "Securities and Exchange Commission") (SEC) Chairman [Arthur Levitt](/wiki/Arthur_Levitt "Arthur Levitt"), Fed Chairman Greenspan, and Secretary Rubin, torpedoed an effort to regulate the derivatives that many blame for bringing the financial market down in Fall 2008\.{{cite news\|work\=\[\[Frontline (U.S. TV series)\|Frontline]]/PBS\|url\=https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/warning/view/\#morelink\|title\=the warning\|date\=October 23, 2009\|access\-date\=October 26, 2009}}
#### Views on financial regulation
On May 7, 1998, the [Commodity Futures Trading Commission](/wiki/Commodity_Futures_Trading_Commission "Commodity Futures Trading Commission") (CFTC) issued a Concept Release soliciting input from regulators, academics, and practitioners to determine "how best to maintain adequate regulatory safeguards without impairing the ability of the OTC ([over\-the\-counter](/wiki/Over-the-counter_%28finance%29 "Over-the-counter (finance)")) derivatives market to grow and the ability of U.S. entities to remain competitive in the global financial marketplace."{{cite web \|title\=CFTC Issues Concept Release Concerning Over\-The\-Counter Derivatives Market\|publisher\=\[\[U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission]]\|date\=May 7, 1998\|access\-date\=September 16, 2013\|url\=http://www.cftc.gov/opa/press98/opa4142\-98\.htm}} On July 30, 1998, then\-Deputy Secretary of the Treasury Summers testified before the U.S. Congress that "the parties to these kinds of contract are largely sophisticated financial institutions that would appear to be eminently capable of protecting themselves from fraud and counterparty insolvencies." At the time Summers stated that "to date there has been no clear evidence of a need for additional regulation of the institutional OTC derivatives market, and we would submit that proponents of such regulation must bear the burden of demonstrating that need."{{cite news\|last\=Summers\|first\=Lawrence\|title\=Lawrence H. Summers Testimony\|date\=July 30, 1998\|url\=http://ustreas.gov/press/releases/rr2616\.htm\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20091025220333/http://www.ustreas.gov/press/releases/rr2616\.htm\|archive\-date\=October 25, 2009}}
In 1999 Summers endorsed the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act which removed the separation between investment and commercial banks, saying "With this bill, the American financial system takes a major step forward towards the 21st Century."{{cite book \|pages\=142–143\|lccn\=2011286013\|author\-link\=David Orrell\|last\=Orrell\|first\=David \| title\-link\=Economyths\|title\=Economyths : ten ways economics gets it wrong\|location\=\[\[Mississauga, Ontario]]\|publisher\=\[\[John Wiley \& Sons Canada, Ltd]]\|year\=2010\|isbn\=9780470677933}}
When [George Stephanopoulos](/wiki/George_Stephanopoulos "George Stephanopoulos") asked Summers about the financial crisis in an ABC interview on March 15, 2009, Summers replied that "there are a lot of terrible things that have happened in the last eighteen months, but what's happened at A.I.G. ... the way it was not regulated, the way no one was watching ... is outrageous."{{Cite book \|last\=Friedman \|first\=Jeff \|url\=https://www.worldcat.org/oclc/793012561 \|title\=What Caused the Financial Crisis \|publisher\=University of Pennsylvania Press \|year\=2011 \|isbn\=978\-0\-8122\-0493\-3 \|location\=Philadelphia \|pages\=312 \|oclc\=793012561}}
In February 2009, Summers quoted [John Maynard Keynes](/wiki/John_Maynard_Keynes "John Maynard Keynes"), saying "When circumstances change, I change my opinion", reflecting both on the failures of [Wall Street](/wiki/Wall_Street "Wall Street") deregulation and his new leadership role in the government bailout.{{cite news\|author\=Michael Hirsh\|title\=The Reeducation of Larry Summers\|url\=http://www.newsweek.com/reeducation\-larry\-summers\-82289\|access\-date\=January 4, 2014\|newspaper\=\[\[Newsweek]]\|date\=February 20, 2009}} On April 18, 2010, in an interview on ABC's "This Week" program, Clinton said Summers was wrong in the advice he gave him not to regulate derivatives.{{Cite news \|last\=Zumbrun \|first\=Joshua \|date\=April 19, 2010 \|title\=Clinton Calls Advice He Got on Derivatives 'Wrong' \|language\=en \|work\=\[\[Bloomberg News\|Bloomberg]] \|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2010\-04\-18/clinton\-says\-rubin\-summers\-gave\-him\-wrong\-advice\-on\-derivatives\-rules \|url\-access\=subscription \|access\-date\=April 27, 2023}}
{{anchor\|Harvard president}}
### President of Harvard
In 2001, when [George W. Bush](/wiki/George_W._Bush "George W. Bush") became [President](/wiki/President_of_the_United_States "President of the United States"), Summers left the Treasury Department and returned to Harvard as its 27th president, serving from July 2001 until June 2006\. He was Harvard's first Jewish president,*YUNews* [Director of the National Economic Council, Dr. Lawrence H. Summers, is Keynote Speaker at Yeshiva University's Annual Hanukkah Dinner and Convocation on December 13](https://www.yu.edu/news/director-of-the-national-economic-council-dr-lawrence-h-summers-is-keynote-speaker-at-yeshiva-universitys-annual-hanukkah-dinner-and-convocation-on-december-13), November 18, 2009*The Harvard Crimson* [Did Summers' Faith Affect His Fall?](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/3/3/did-summers-faith-affect-his-fall/), March 3, 2006*The Harvard Crimson* [A Milestone of Faith](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2001/10/14/a-milestone-of-faith-in-1922/), October 14, 2001 though his predecessor Neil Rudenstine's father was Jewish.[Harvard's First Jewish President](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511933). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson"). March 8, 2006
A number of Summers's decisions at Harvard have attracted public controversy, either at the time or since his resignation.
#### Cornel West affair
In an October 2001 meeting, Summers criticized African American Studies department head [Cornel West](/wiki/Cornel_West "Cornel West") for allegedly missing three weeks of classes to work on the [Bill Bradley](/wiki/Bill_Bradley "Bill Bradley") presidential campaign and complained that West was contributing to [grade inflation](/wiki/Grade_inflation "Grade inflation"). Summers also claimed that West's "rap" album was an "embarrassment" to the university. West pushed back strongly against the accusations.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2006/06/06/some\_seek\_a\_scholars\_return/\|title\=Some seek a scholar's return\|work\=\[\[The Boston Globe]]\|date\=June 6, 2006\|first1\=Marcella\|last1\=Bombardieri}} "The hip\-hop scared him. It's a stereotypical reaction", he said later. West, who later called Summers both "uninformed" and "an unprincipled power player" in describing this encounter in his book *Democracy Matters* (2004\), subsequently returned to [Princeton University](/wiki/Princeton_University "Princeton University"), where he had taught prior to [Harvard University](/wiki/Harvard_University "Harvard University").
#### Differences between the sexes
{{See also\|Women in science}}
In January 2005, at a Conference on Diversifying the Science \& Engineering Workforce sponsored by the [National Bureau of Economic Research](/wiki/National_Bureau_of_Economic_Research "National Bureau of Economic Research"), Summers sparked controversy with his discussion of why women may have been underrepresented "in tenured positions in science and engineering at top universities and research institutions". The conference was designed to be off\-the\-record so that participants could speak candidly without fear of public misunderstanding or disclosure later.{{cite news \|last1\=Dillon \|first1\=Sam \|title\=Harvard Chief Defends His Talk on Women \|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]] \|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/18/us/harvard\-chief\-defends\-his\-talk\-on\-women.html \|access\-date\=February 13, 2022 \|date\=February 18, 2005}}
Summers had prefaced his talk, saying he was adopting an "entirely [positive](/wiki/Positivism "Positivism"), rather than [normative](/wiki/Normative "Normative") approach" and that his remarks were intended to be an "attempt at provocation".{{cite web\|url\=http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \|title\=Archive of: Remarks at NBER Conference on Diversifying the Science \& Engineering Workforce \|access\-date\=January 30, 2008 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \|archive\-date\=January 30, 2008 }}. January 14, 2005\.
Summers then began by identifying three hypotheses for the higher proportion of men in high\-end science and engineering positions:
1. The high\-powered job hypothesis
2. Different availability of [aptitude](/wiki/Aptitude "Aptitude") at the high end
3. Different socialization and patterns of discrimination in a search
The second hypothesis, the generally [greater variability among men](/wiki/Variability_hypothesis "Variability hypothesis") (compared to women) in tests of cognitive abilities,Hedges, L. V., \& Nowell, A. (1995\). "Sex differences in mental scores, variability, and numbers of high scoring individuals". *Science*, 269, 41–45\.Lehrke, R. (1997\). *Sex linkage of intelligence: The X\-Factor*. New York: Praeger.Lubinski, D., \& Benbow, C. M. (2006\). "Study of mathematically precocious youth after 35 years". *Perspectives on Psychological Science*, 1, 316–345\. leading to proportionally more males than females at both the lower and upper tails of the test score distributions, caused the most controversy. In his discussion of this hypothesis, Summers said that "even small differences in the standard deviation \[between genders] will translate into very large differences in the available pool substantially out \[from the mean]". Summers referenced research that implied differences between the standard deviations of males and females in the top 5% of twelfth graders under various tests. He then went on to argue that, if this research were to be accepted, then "whatever the set of attributes ... that are precisely defined to correlate with being an aeronautical engineer at MIT or being a chemist at Berkeley ... are probably different in their standard deviations as well".
Summers then concluded his discussion of the three hypotheses by saying:
> So my best guess, to provoke you, of what's behind all of this is that the largest phenomenon, by far, is the general clash between people's legitimate family desires and employers' current desire for high power and high intensity, that in the special case of science and engineering, there are issues of intrinsic aptitude, and particularly of the variability of aptitude, and that those considerations are reinforced by what are in fact lesser factors involving socialization and continuing discrimination. I would like nothing better than to be proved wrong, because I would like nothing better than for these problems to be addressable simply by everybody understanding what they are, and working very hard to address them.
Summers then went on to discuss approaches to remedying the shortage of women in high\-end science and engineering positions.
This lunch\-time talk drew accusations of sexism and careless scholarship, and an intense negative response followed, both nationally and at Harvard.[Summers' Remarks on Women Draw Fire](https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2005/01/17/summers_remarks_on_women_draw_fire/){{dead link\|date\=March 2024}}. The Boston Globe. January 17, 2005 Summers apologized repeatedly.{{cite magazine \|last\=Saletan\|first\=William\|author\-link\=William Saletan\|date\=January 21, 2005\|title\=Don't Worry Your Pretty Little Head\|url\=http://www.slate.com/id/2112570/\|magazine\=\[\[Slate (magazine)\|Slate]]}} Nevertheless, the controversy is speculated to have contributed to his resigning his position as president of Harvard University the following year, as well as costing Summers the job of [Treasury Secretary](/wiki/Treasury_Secretary "Treasury Secretary") in [Obama's administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Barack_Obama "Presidency of Barack Obama").[Summers's 'sexism' costs him top Treasury job](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/summersrsquo-lsquosexismrsquo-costs-him-top-treasury-job-1033373.html). [The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent "The Independent"). November 24, 2008
Summers's protégée [Sheryl Sandberg](/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg "Sheryl Sandberg") has defended him, saying that "Larry has been a true advocate for women throughout his career" at the World Bank and Treasury. Referring to the lunch talk, Sandberg said, "What few seem to note is that it is remarkable that he was giving the speech in the first place – that he cared enough about women's careers and their trajectory in the fields of math and science to proactively analyze the issues and talk about what was going wrong".{{cite news\|author\=Sheryl Sandberg\|title\=Larry Summers' True Record on Women\|url\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/sheryl\-sandberg/what\-larry\-summers\-has\-do\_b\_142126\.html\|access\-date\=January 4, 2014\|newspaper\=\[\[HuffPost]]\|date\=November 7, 2008\|author\-link\=Sheryl Sandberg}}
In 2016, remarking upon [political correctness](/wiki/Political_correctness "Political correctness") in institutions of higher education, Summers said:
> There is a great deal of absurd political correctness. Now, I'm somebody who believes very strongly in diversity, who resists racism in all of its many incarnations, who thinks that there is a great deal that's unjust in American society that needs to be combated, but it seems to be that there is a kind of creeping totalitarianism in terms of what kind of ideas are acceptable and are debatable on college campuses.{{cite web\|url\=http://conversationswithbillkristol.org/video/larry\-summers\-ii/?start\=15\&end\=1606\|title\=Larry Summers II on Conversations with Bill Kristol\|website\=ConversationsWithBillKristol.org\|access\-date\=November 8, 2017}}
#### Summers' opposition and support at Harvard
On March 15, 2005, members of the [Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Faculty_of_Arts_and_Sciences "Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences"), which instructs graduate students in [Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Graduate_School_of_Arts_and_Sciences "Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences") and undergraduates in [Harvard College](/wiki/Harvard_College "Harvard College"), passed 218–185 a motion of "lack of confidence" in the leadership of Summers, with 18 abstentions. A second motion that offered a milder censure of the president passed 253 to 137, also with 18 abstentions.
The members of the [Harvard Corporation](/wiki/Harvard_Corporation "Harvard Corporation"), the University's highest governing body, are in charge of the selection of the president and issued statements strongly supporting Summers.
FAS faculty were not unanimous in their comments against Summers. Psychologist [Steven Pinker](/wiki/Steven_Pinker "Steven Pinker") defended the legitimacy of Summers's January lecture. When asked if Summers's talk was "within the pale of legitimate academic discourse," Pinker responded "Good grief, shouldn't everything be within the pale of legitimate academic discourse, as long as it is presented with some degree of rigor? That's the difference between a university and a [madrassa](/wiki/Madrassa "Madrassa"). There is certainly enough evidence for the hypothesis to be taken seriously."[Psychoanalysis Q\-and\-A: Steven Pinker](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2005/1/19/psychoanalysis-q-and-a-steven-pinker-in-an/). *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson")*. January 19, 2005
Summers had stronger support among Harvard College students than among the college faculty. One poll by *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson")* indicated that students opposed his resignation by a three\-to\-one margin, with 57% of responding students opposing his resignation and 19% supporting it.[Poll: Students Say Summers Should Stay](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511421). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson"). February 20, 2006
In July 2005, a board member of Harvard Corporation, [Conrad K. Harper](/wiki/Conrad_K._Harper "Conrad K. Harper"), resigned saying he was angered both by the university president's comments about women and by Summers being given a salary increase. The resignation letter to the president said, "I could not and cannot support a raise in your salary, ... I believe that Harvard's best interests require your resignation."{{cite news\|last\=Finder\|first\=Alan\|title\=A Harvard Governor, Dissatisfied, Resigns\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/29/education/29harvard.html?\_r\=0\|access\-date\=December 5, 2013\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=July 29, 2005}}[Board Member's Letter of Resignation](https://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/02/education/02htext.html). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times"). August 2, 2005
#### Support of economist Andrei Shleifer
Harvard and [Andrei Shleifer](/wiki/Andrei_Shleifer "Andrei Shleifer"), a close friend and protégé of Summers, controversially paid $28\.5 million to settle a [lawsuit](/wiki/Lawsuit "Lawsuit") by the U.S. government over the [conflict of interest](/wiki/Conflict_of_interest "Conflict of interest") Shleifer had while advising [Russia's privatization program](/wiki/Russia%27s_privatization_program "Russia's privatization program"). The US government had sued Shleifer under the [False Claims Act](/wiki/False_Claims_Act "False Claims Act"), as he bought [Russian](/wiki/Russia "Russia") stocks while designing the country's [privatization](/wiki/Privatization "Privatization"). In 2004, a federal judge ruled that while Harvard had violated the contract, Shleifer and his associate alone were liable for [treble damages](/wiki/Treble_damages "Treble damages").
In June 2005, Harvard and Shleifer announced that they had reached a tentative settlement with the US government. In August, Harvard, Shleifer, and the [Department of Justice](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Justice "United States Department of Justice") reached an agreement under which the university paid $26\.5 million to settle the five\-year\-old lawsuit. Shleifer was also responsible for paying $2 million worth of damages.
Because Harvard paid almost all of the damages and allowed Shleifer to retain his faculty position, the settlement provoked allegations of favoritism by Summers. His continued support for Shleifer strengthened Summers's unpopularity with other professors, as reported in *The Harvard Crimson*:
{{Blockquote\|I've been a member of this Faculty for over 45 years, and I am no longer easily shocked," is how Frederick H. Abernathy, the McKay professor of mechanical engineering, began his biting comments about the Shleifer case at Tuesday's fiery Faculty meeting. But, Abernathy continued, "I was deeply shocked and disappointed by the actions of this University" in the Shleifer affair.{{cite news\|title\='Tawdry Shleifer Affair' Stokes Faculty Anger Toward Summers\|url\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/2/10/tawdry\-shleifer\-affair\-stokes\-faculty\-anger/\|access\-date\=30 May 2013\|newspaper\=\[\[The Harvard Crimson]]\|date\=10 Feb 2006\|author\=Nicholas Ciarelli\|author2\=Anton Troianovski}}}}
#### In Russia
{{See also\|Loans for shares scheme}}
An 18,000\-word article "How Harvard Lost Russia" in *[Institutional Investor](/wiki/Institutional_Investor_%28magazine%29 "Institutional Investor (magazine)")* by David McClintick detailed Shleifer's alleged efforts to use his [inside knowledge](/wiki/Insider_trading "Insider trading") of and sway over the Russian economy in order to make lucrative personal investments, all while leading a Harvard group, advising the Russian government, that was under contract with the U.S. The article suggests that Summers shielded his fellow economist from disciplinary action by the university, and it noted that Summers had forewarned Shleifer and his wife Nancy Zimmerman about the conflict\-of\-interest regulations back in 1996\.{{Cite news \|last\=McClintick \|first\=David \|date\=January 13, 2006 \|title\=How Harvard Lost Russia \|work\=Institutional Investor \|url\=https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b150npp3q49x7w/how\-harvard\-lost\-russia \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140705041205/http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/Article/1020662/How\-Harvard\-lost\-Russia.html\#/.V0mIqpF97nE \|archive\-date\=July 5, 2014}} Summers's friendship with Shleifer was well known by the corporation when it selected him to succeed Rudenstine and Summers recused himself from all proceedings with Shleifer, whose case was actually handled by an independent committee led by former Harvard president [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok "Derek Bok").
#### Connection to Jeffrey Epstein
An article in *The Harvard Crimson* in 2003, during Summers's tenure as president, detailed a reportedly "special connection" between Summers and [Jeffrey Epstein](/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein "Jeffrey Epstein").{{Cite web\|last\= Scharnick\|first\=Jaquelyn M.\|date\=May 1, 2003\|url\=https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/5/1/mogul\-donor\-gives\-harvard\-more\-than/?page\=single\|title\=Mogul Donor Gives Harvard More Than Money\|work\=\[\[The Harvard Crimson]]\|language\=en\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein pledged to donate at least $25 million to Harvard during Summers's tenure to endow Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein was given an office at Harvard for his personal use.{{Cite magazine\|url\=https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/03/jeffrey\-epstein\-200303\|title\=The Talented Mr. Epstein\|last\=Ward\|first\=Vicky\|date\=March 2003\|magazine\=\[\[Vanity Fair (magazine)\|Vanity Fair]]\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019\|quote\=Epstein has pledged at least $25 million to Harvard to create the Epstein Program for Mathematical Biology and Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein will have an office at the university...He says he was reluctant to have his name attached to the program, but Summers persuaded him. }}{{Cite web\|url\=https://ped.fas.harvard.edu/home\|title\=Program for Evolutionary Dynamics\|website\=ped.fas.harvard.edu\|language\=en\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein otherwise had no formal connection to Harvard. Summers's ties to Epstein reportedly began "a number of years...before Summers became Harvard's president and even before he was the Secretary of the Treasury." Flight records introduced as evidence in the 2021 trial of Epstein associate [Ghislaine Maxwell](/wiki/Ghislaine_Maxwell "Ghislaine Maxwell") show that Summers flew on Jeffrey Epstein's private plane on at least four occasions, including once in 1998 when Summers was [United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Deputy_Secretary_of_the_Treasury "United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury") and at least three times while Harvard president.{{Cite web\|url\=https://s3\.documentcloud.org/documents/21165424/epstein\-flight\-logs\-released\-in\-usa\-vs\-maxwell.pdf\|title\=Epstein Flight Logs Released in USA vs. Maxwell\|language\=en\|access\-date\=December 27, 2021}} A charity funded by Epstein also donated to the production of a [PBS](/wiki/PBS "PBS") show hosted by Summers's wife and Harvard professor [Elisa New](/wiki/Elisa_New "Elisa New").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey\-epstein\-has\-a\-secret\-charity\-heres\-who\-it\-gave\-money\-to?ref\=scroll\|title\=REVEALED: We Found Billionaire Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein's Secret Charity\|last\=Briquelet\|first\=Kate\|date\=July 10, 2019\|work\=\[\[The Daily Beast]]\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019\|quote\=In 2016, Gratitude America Ltd. shelled out $110,000 to Verse Video Education. The Cambridge, Massachusetts\-based nonprofit produces the PBS show Poetry in America, whose creator and host is Harvard professor Elisa New. Verse's 2016 tax return named New as the group's president but doesn't include specific donors for its $1\.38 million in total contributions. New is married to Summers, Harvard University's former president, who hobnobbed with Epstein in elite international relations groups and, like Bill Clinton, flew on Epstein's private jet.}}
#### Winklevoss twins and Facebook
In February 2004, the [Winklevoss twins](/wiki/Winklevoss_twins "Winklevoss twins") requested a meeting with Summers in order to ask him to intervene on their behalf in an ongoing dispute they had with [Facebook](/wiki/Facebook "Facebook") founder [Mark Zuckerberg](/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg "Mark Zuckerberg"). The Winklevosses believed that Zuckerberg had stolen their idea for a social networking website and launched Facebook on his own, after they had asked him to be a part of their project, then called HarvardConnection. Summers believed that the matter was outside the university's jurisdiction and advised the twins to take their complaint to the courts.{{cite news \|first\=Shirin \|last\=Sharif \|title\=Harvard grads face off against thefacebook.com \|date\=August 5, 2004 \|publisher\=The Stanford Daily \|url\=http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\-grads\-face\-off\-against\-thefacebookcom/ \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100618102603/http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\-grads\-face\-off\-against\-thefacebookcom/ \|archive\-date\=June 18, 2010 \|url\-status\=dead }}
#### Resignation as Harvard President
On February 21, 2006, Summers announced his intention to step down at the end of the school year effective June 30, 2006\. Harvard agreed to provide Summers on his resignation with a one\-year paid [sabbatical](/wiki/Sabbatical "Sabbatical") leave, subsidized a $1 million outstanding loan from the university for his personal residence, and provided other payments.President and Fellows of Harvard College, [IRS](/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Service "Internal Revenue Service") Form 990, 2006 \& 2007\. Former University President [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok "Derek Bok") acted as Interim President while the University conducted a search for a replacement which ended with the naming of [Drew Gilpin Faust](/wiki/Drew_Gilpin_Faust "Drew Gilpin Faust") on February 11, 2007\.
### Post\-Harvard presidency career
[right\|thumb\|President [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama "Barack Obama"), on left, discusses with a group in the White House, including Larry Summers on far right (back to camera).](/wiki/File:Barack_Obama_talks_during_the_Daily_Economic_Briefing%2C_January_2009.jpg "Barack Obama talks during the Daily Economic Briefing, January 2009.jpg")
After a one\-year sabbatical, Summers subsequently accepted Harvard University's invitation to serve as the [Charles W. Eliot](/wiki/Charles_W._Eliot "Charles W. Eliot") University Professor, one of 20 [select University\-wide professorships](/wiki/Harvard_University_Professor "Harvard University Professor"), with offices in the Kennedy School of Government and the Harvard Business School.{{cite news \|last\=Schuker\|first\=Daniel J. T.\|title\=Summers Named Eliot Univ. Prof\|date\=July 7, 2006\|newspaper\=\[\[The Harvard Crimson]]\|url\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref\=513918}} In 2006 he was also a member of the Panel of Eminent Persons which reviewed the work of the [United Nations Conference on Trade and Development](/wiki/United_Nations_Conference_on_Trade_and_Development "United Nations Conference on Trade and Development"). He is a member in the [Group of Thirty](/wiki/Group_of_Thirty "Group of Thirty"). He also currently serves on the [Berggruen Institute](/wiki/Berggruen_Institute "Berggruen Institute")'s 21st Century Council and was part of a 2015 Berggruen\-organized meeting with Chinese president [Xi Jinping](/wiki/Xi_Jinping "Xi Jinping").{{Cite web\|url\=http://governance.berggruen.org/councils/21st\-century\-council/members\|title\=Berggruen Institute\|access\-date\=April 17, 2017\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180613084722/http://governance.berggruen.org/councils/21st\-century\-council/members\|archive\-date\=June 13, 2018\|url\-status\=dead}}["Why Nicolas Berggruen is Creating an Institute for Geniuses"](http://www.townandcountrymag.com/society/money-and-power/a5994/nicolas-berggreun-interview/), *[Town and Country](/wiki/Town_and_Country_%28magazine%29 "Town and Country (magazine)"),* May 11, 2016\. "Another wing of the Berggruen Institute has technologists like Elon Musk and Twitter co\-founder Jack Dorsey, as well as former treasury secretary Larry Summers."
### Business interests
On October 19, 2006, Summers was hired as a part\-time managing director of the New York\-based hedge fund [D. E. Shaw \& Co.](/wiki/D._E._Shaw_%26_Co. "D. E. Shaw & Co.") for which he received $5 million in salary and other compensation over a 16\-month period.{{cite news \|last\=Levy\|first\=Ari\|title\=Summers Joins Andreessen Horowitz as a Part\-Time Adviser to Entrepreneurs\|date\=June 30, 2011\|publisher\=\[\[Bloomberg News\|Bloomberg]]\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011\-06\-29/lawrence\-summers\-joins\-andreessen\-horowitz\-as\-an\-adviser\-to\-venture\-firm.html}} At the same time Summers earned $2\.7 million in speaking fees from major financial institutions, including [Goldman Sachs](/wiki/Goldman_Sachs "Goldman Sachs"), [JPMorgan Chase](/wiki/JPMorgan_Chase "JPMorgan Chase"), [Citigroup](/wiki/Citigroup "Citigroup"), [Merrill Lynch](/wiki/Merrill_Lynch "Merrill Lynch") and [Lehman Brothers](/wiki/Lehman_Brothers "Lehman Brothers").{{cite news \|url\=http://www.salon.com/2009/04/04/summers/\|title\=Larry Summers, Tim Geithner and Wall Street's ownership of government\|last1\=Greenwald\|first1\=Glenn\|date\=April 4, 2009\|work\=\[\[Salon (website)\|Salon]]\|access\-date\=August 10, 2013}} Upon being nominated Treasury Secretary by President Clinton in 1999, Summers listed assets of about $900,000 and debts, including a mortgage, of $500,000\. By the time he returned in 2009 to serve in the Obama administration, he reported a net worth between $17 million and $39 million. He is a former member of the Steering Committee of the [Bilderberg Group](/wiki/Bilderberg_Group "Bilderberg Group").{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.bilderbergmeetings.org/former\-steering\-committee\-members.html \|title\=Former Steering Committee Members \|work\=bilderbergmeetings.org \|publisher\=\[\[Bilderberg Group]] \|access\-date\=February 8, 2014 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140202095633/http://www.bilderbergmeetings.org/former\-steering\-committee\-members.html \|archive\-date\=February 2, 2014 }} In 2013, Summers became an early angel investor in India's first car rental company, [Zoomcar](/wiki/Zoomcar "Zoomcar"), which was started by his former [Harvard](/wiki/Harvard "Harvard") Teaching Fellow.{{cite web\|url\=https://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2013/08/08/indian\-drivers\-attract\-fed\-hopeful\-larry\-summers/\|title\=Indian Drivers Attract Larry Summers\|first\=W. S. J.\|last\=Staff\|date\=August 8, 2013\|website\=WSJ.com\|access\-date\=November 8, 2017}}
### National Economic Council
Upon the inauguration of [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama "Barack Obama") as president in January 2009, Summers was appointed to the post of director of the [National Economic Council](/wiki/National_Economic_Council_%28United_States%29 "National Economic Council (United States)").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp\-dyn/content/article/2010/09/21/AR2010092104828\.html\|title\=Lawrence Summers to leave economic council, return to Harvard\|last\=Montgomery\|first\=Lori\|date\=September 22, 2010\|newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]]\|access\-date\=August 7, 2017\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0190\-8286}} In this position Summers emerged as a key economic decision\-maker in the Obama administration, where he attracted both praise and criticism. There had been friction between Summers and former Federal Reserve Chairman [Paul Volcker](/wiki/Paul_Volcker "Paul Volcker"), as Volcker accused Summers of delaying the effort to organize a panel of outside economic advisers, and Summers had cut Volcker out of White House meetings and had not shown interest in collaborating on policy solutions to the economic crisis.{{cite news \| last\=Schmidt \| first\=Robert \|author2\=Julianna Goldman\|title\=Volcker Chafes at Obama Panel Delay, Strains With Summers Rise\|work\=\[\[Bloomberg News\|Bloomberg]]\|date\=February 5, 2009\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid\=washingtonstory\&sid\=aaLzJZKNcc6Y}} On the other hand, Obama himself was reportedly thrilled with the work Summers did in his first few weeks on the job. And [Peter Orszag](/wiki/Peter_Orszag "Peter Orszag"), another top economic advisor, called Summers "one of the world's most brilliant economists."{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/08/us/politics/08team.html\|work\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|title\=Obama's Economic Circle Keeps Tensions High\|first\=Jackie\|last\=Calmes\|date\=June 8, 2009\|access\-date\=April 4, 2010}} According to [Henry Kissinger](/wiki/Henry_Kissinger "Henry Kissinger") Larry Summers should "be given a White House post in which he was charged with shooting down or fixing bad ideas."{{cite news
\|last\=Leonhardt\|first\=David\|author\-link\=David Leonhardt\|title\=The Return of Larry Summers\|work\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=November 25, 2008\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/26/business/economy/26leonhardt.html}}
In January 2009, as the [Obama Administration](/wiki/Obama_Administration "Obama Administration") tried to pass an economic stimulus spending bill, Representative [Peter DeFazio](/wiki/Peter_DeFazio "Peter DeFazio") ([D](/wiki/U.S._Democratic_Party "U.S. Democratic Party")\-[OR.](/wiki/Oregon "Oregon")) criticized Summers, saying that he thought that President [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama "Barack Obama") is "ill\-advised by Larry Summers. Larry Summers hates infrastructure."{{cite news \|last\=DeFazio\|first\=Peter\|author2\=Video Interview\|title\=DeFazio Slams Summers\|date\=January 2008\|url\=http://firedoglake.com/2009/01/23/defazio\-smacks\-larry\-summers\-for\-being\-anti\-infrastructure/}} DeFazio, along with liberal economists including [Paul Krugman](/wiki/Paul_Krugman "Paul Krugman") and [Joseph Stiglitz](/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz "Joseph Stiglitz"), had argued that more of the stimulus should be spent on infrastructure,{{cite news
\|last\=Krugman\|first\=Paul\|title\=Stimulus Arithmetic (wonkish but important)\|work\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=January 6, 2009\|url\=https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/01/06/stimulus\-arithmetic\-wonkish\-but\-important/}} while Summers had supported tax cuts.["Sean Grady: Shootout at Jackson Hole: The World's Central Bankers Take Aim at Deflation."](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/sean-ogrady-shoot-out-at-jackson-hole--the-worlds-central-bankers-take-aim-at-deflation-2063222.html) *The Independent*. August 14, 2010\. In late 2008, Summers and economic advisors for then\-President\-elect Obama presented a memo with options for an economic stimulus package ranging from $550 billion to $900 billion.{{cite magazine
\|last\=Lizza\|first\=Ryan\|title\=The Obama memos\|magazine\=\[\[The New Yorker]]\|date\=January 30, 2012\|url\=https://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/01/30/120130fa\_fact\_lizza}} According to *[The New Republic](/wiki/The_New_Republic "The New Republic")*, economic advisor [Christina Romer](/wiki/Christina_Romer "Christina Romer") initially recommended a $1\.8\-trillion package, which proposal Summers quickly rejected, believing any stimulus approaching $1 trillion would not pass through Congress. Romer revised her recommendation to $1\.2 trillion, which Summers agreed to include in the memo, but Summers struck the figure at the last minute.{{cite magazine \|last\=Scheiber\|first\=Noam\|title\=The Memo that Larry Summers Didn't Want Obama to See\|magazine\=\[\[The New Republic]]\|date\=February 22, 2012\|url\=http://www.tnr.com/article/politics/100961/memo\-Larry\-Summers\-Obama}}
According to *[the Wall Street Journal](/wiki/The_Wall_Street_Journal "The Wall Street Journal")*, Summers called Senator [Chris Dodd](/wiki/Chris_Dodd "Chris Dodd") (D\-[CT](/wiki/Connecticut "Connecticut")) asking him to remove caps on executive pay at firms that have received stimulus money, including Citigroup.{{cite news \|last\=Soloman\|first\=Deborah\|author2\=Mark Maremont\|title\=Bankers Face Strict Pay Cap\|pages\=1, above the fold\|newspaper\=\[\[The Wall Street Journal]]\|date\=February 14–15, 2009}}
On April 3, 2009, Summers came under renewed criticism after it was disclosed that he was paid millions of dollars the previous year by companies which he now had influence over as a [public servant](/wiki/Public_servant "Public servant"). He earned $5 million from the [hedge fund](/wiki/Hedge_fund "Hedge fund") D. E. Shaw and collected $2\.7 million in speaking fees from [Wall Street](/wiki/Wall_Street "Wall Street") companies that received government [bailout](/wiki/Bailout "Bailout") money.{{cite news \|first\=Jeff\|last\=Zeleny\|title\=Financial Industry Paid Millions to Obama Aide\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/04/us/politics/04disclose.html\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=April 3, 2009\|access\-date\=April 4, 2009}}
### Post\-NEC career
[thumb\|Summers with [Volodymyr Groysman](/wiki/Volodymyr_Groysman "Volodymyr Groysman") in [Ukraine](/wiki/Ukraine "Ukraine")](/wiki/File:Volodymyr_Groysman_and_Lawrence_Summers_in_Ukraine_-_2018_%28MUS6894%29.jpg "Volodymyr Groysman and Lawrence Summers in Ukraine - 2018 (MUS6894).jpg")
Since leaving the NEC in December 2010, Summers has worked as an advisor to hedge fund [D. E. Shaw \& Co](/wiki/D._E._Shaw_%26_Co "D. E. Shaw & Co"), Citigroup and the [NASDAQ OMX Group](/wiki/NASDAQ_OMX_Group "NASDAQ OMX Group") while resuming his role as a tenured Harvard professor.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013\-08\-02/summers\-after\-government\-saw\-wealth\-surge\-to\-17\-million.html\|title\=Summers After Government Saw Wealth Surge to $17 Million\|last1\=Benson\|first1\=Clea\|date\=August 2, 2013\|publisher\=\[\[Bloomberg L.P.]]\|access\-date\=August 10, 2013}} In June 2011 Summers joined the board of directors of [Square](/wiki/Square_%28payment_service%29 "Square (payment service)"), a company developing an electronic payment service,TechCrunch (2011\). [Square Adds Former U.S. Secretary Of The Treasury Larry Summers To Board](https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/22/square-adds-former-u-s-secretary-of-the-treasury-larry-summers-to-board/). Retrieved June 24, 2011\. and became a special adviser at venture capital firm [Andreessen Horowitz](/wiki/Andreessen_Horowitz "Andreessen Horowitz").Dealbook (2011\). [Larry Summers Joins Andreessen Horowitz](https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/06/29/larry-summers-joins-andreessen-horowitz/?hp). Retrieved June 30, 2011\. He joined the board of person\-to\-person lending company [Lending Club](/wiki/Lending_Club "Lending Club") in December 2012\.TechCrunch (2012\). [With An IPO On Its Radar, Lending Club Adds Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers To Its Heavyweight Board](https://techcrunch.com/2012/12/13/with-an-ipo-on-its-radar-lending-club-adds-former-treasury-secretary-larry-summers-to-its-heavyweight-board/). Retrieved December 12, 2012\. In July 2015 Summers joined the Board of Directors of [Premise Data](/wiki/Premise_Data "Premise Data"), a San Francisco\-based data and analytics technology company that sources data from a global network of on\-the\-ground contributors.{{Cite web\|url\=https://medium.com/@premisedata/welcoming\-larry\-summers\-to\-premise\-s\-board\-of\-directors\-65411a2b9842\|title\=Welcoming Larry Summers to Premise's Board of Directors\|last\=Data\|first\=Premise\|date\=July 16, 2015\|website\=Medium\|access\-date\=February 22, 2018}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/04/04/larry\-summers\-data\-collection\-is\-the\-ultimate\-public\-good/\|title\=Larry Summers: Data collection is the ultimate public good\|last\=Summers\|first\=Lawrence H.\|date\=April 4, 2016\|newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]]\|access\-date\=February 22, 2018\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0190\-8286}}
In April 2016, he was one of eight former Treasury secretaries who called on the [United Kingdom](/wiki/United_Kingdom "United Kingdom") to remain a member of the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union "European Union") ahead of the [June 2016 Referendum](/wiki/2016_United_Kingdom_European_Union_membership_referendum "2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum").{{cite news\|title\=Staying in EU 'best hope' for UK's future say ex\-US Treasury secretaries\|url\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk\-politics\-eu\-referendum\-36087583\|work\=\[\[BBC News]]\|date\=April 20, 2016}}
Summers referred to the United Kingdom's Brexit vote on June 23, 2016, in favor of leaving the European Union as the "worst self\-inflicted policy wound that a country has done since the Second World War". However, Summers cautioned that the result was a "wake up call for elites everywhere" and called for "responsible nationalism" in response to simmering public sentiment.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.marketplace.org/2016/06/24/world/lawrence\-summers\-brexit\-wakeup\-call\-elites\|title\=Lawrence Summers on Brexit: A wakeup call for elites\|date\=June 24, 2016\|access\-date\=July 15, 2016}}
In June 2016, Summers also wrote, "I believe the risks to the US and global economies of Mr Trump's election as president are far greater \[than passage of Brexit]. If he is elected, I would expect a protracted recession to begin within 18 months. The damage would be felt far beyond the United States."{{Cite web\|url\=http://larrysummers.com/2016/06/06/the\-economic\-consequences\-of\-a\-trump\-win\-would\-be\-severe/\|title\=The economic consequences of a Trump win would be severe \| Larry Summers\|date\=June 6, 2016 }}
### 2020 presidential election
A coalition of progressive groups called on [Joe Biden](/wiki/Joe_Biden "Joe Biden")'s [2020 presidential campaign](/wiki/Joe_Biden_2020_presidential_campaign "Joe Biden 2020 presidential campaign") no longer to use Summers as an advisor, after reports surfaced that Summers was advising the campaign on economic policy.{{Cite web\|last\=Moreno\|first\=J. Edward\|date\=May 6, 2020\|title\=Progressive groups renew push to oust Larry Summers from Biden campaign citing environmental concerns\|url\=https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/496352\-progressive\-group\-renews\-push\-to\-oust\-larry\-summers\-from\-biden\-campaign\|access\-date\=September 16, 2020\|website\=\[\[The Hill (newspaper)\|The Hill]]}} Progressive groups like the [Sunrise Movement](/wiki/Sunrise_Movement "Sunrise Movement") and [Justice Democrats](/wiki/Justice_Democrats "Justice Democrats") petitioned the campaign to disavow Summers, saying, "Summers's legacy is advocating for policies that contributed to the skyrocketing inequality and climate crisis we're living with today."{{Cite web\|last\=Golshan\|first\=Tara\|date\=April 24, 2020\|title\=Joe Biden Under Pressure From Progressives To Cut Out Larry Summers\|url\=https://www.huffpost.com/entry/biden\-larry\-summers\-progressives\_n\_5ea3315bc5b6d376358f3670?guccounter\=1\&guce\_referrer\=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8\&guce\_referrer\_sig\=AQAAALmvgHjs6ndwwMw8S1\-kyuEgFCSUaHGkBXxw5BD1CP76GJFXrVMHJPwfF9TKd2ca\-r9t\-cs\-7q7Z6YmJg7fYEAViNYTSf6GxdcjkIurSeKgB\_4rFDSwysaoN\-UmnbDWp0Dr2C3nQxvZgICzjCDDXmH1k08jvRO0gpVkpI1Sz6Nwb\|access\-date\=September 16, 2020\|website\=\[\[HuffPost]]}} Following the outcry, Summers stated he would not be joining a future Biden administration, in the event that Biden defeated [Donald Trump](/wiki/Donald_Trump "Donald Trump") in the [2020 presidential election](/wiki/2020_United_States_presidential_election "2020 United States presidential election").{{Cite web\|last\=Matthews\|first\=Steve\|date\=August 6, 2020\|title\=Larry Summers Rules Out Taking a Job in a Biden Administration\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020\-08\-06/summers\-adviser\-to\-biden\-says\-his\-time\-in\-government\-is\-over?sref\=6OyUvLUJ\|access\-date\=September 16, 2020\|website\=\[\[Bloomberg News\|Bloomberg]]}}
### Candidacy for chairmanship of the Federal Reserve and governorship of the Bank of Israel
In 2013, Summers emerged as one of two leading candidates, along with [Janet Yellen](/wiki/Janet_Yellen "Janet Yellen"), to succeed [Ben Bernanke](/wiki/Ben_Bernanke "Ben Bernanke") as [chair of the Federal Reserve](/wiki/Chair_of_the_Federal_Reserve "Chair of the Federal Reserve"). The possibility of his nomination created a great deal of controversy with some senators of both parties declaring opposition. On September 15, Summers withdrew his name from consideration for the position, writing: "I have reluctantly concluded that any possible confirmation process for me would be acrimonious and would not serve the interest of the Federal Reserve, the Administration or, ultimately, the interests of the nation's ongoing economic recovery."{{cite web \|title\=Larry Summers withdraws name for Fed chair job \|first1\=Annalyn\|last1\=Kurtz \|first2\=Hibah \|last2\=Yousuf\|work\=\[\[CNNMoney]]\|date\=September 15, 2013\|access\-date\=September 15, 2013\|url\=https://money.cnn.com/2013/09/15/news/economy/fed\-chair\-larry\-summers\-withdraws/?hpt\=hp\_t2\|quote\=After months of contentious public debate, Larry Summers has withdrawn his name from consideration to become the next chairman of the Federal Reserve. President Obama said he spoke with Summers earlier Sunday and accepted his decision.}}{{cite news \|title\=Summers Pulls Name From Consideration for Fed Chief\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|author\-link1\=Annie Lowrey\|first1\=Annie\|last1\=Lowrey\|author\-link2\=Binyamin Appelbaum\|first2\=Binyamin\|last2\=Appelbaum\|date\=September 15, 2013\|access\-date\=September 16, 2013\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/16/business/economy/summers\-pulls\-name\-from\-consideration\-for\-fed\-chief.html?hp\&\_r\=0\|quote\=Facing growing opposition in Congress, Lawrence H. Summers, the former Treasury secretary and a top contender for Federal Reserve chairman, told President Obama that he didn't want to be considered for the job.}}
During the 2013, Summers had been reported as preferred candidate by the [Cabinet of Israel](/wiki/Cabinet_of_Israel "Cabinet of Israel") and Prime Minister [Benjamin Netanyahu](/wiki/Benjamin_Netanyahu "Benjamin Netanyahu") to succeed [Stanley Fischer](/wiki/Stanley_Fischer "Stanley Fischer") as governor of the [Bank of Israel](/wiki/Bank_of_Israel "Bank of Israel"). Netanyahu personally asked him to take the post, an offer he turned down.{{Cite news \|last\=Simpson \|first\=Connor \|date\=October 19, 2013 \|title\=Larry Summers Snubbed Netanyahu's Offer to Run Israel's Banks \|url\=https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/10/natanyahu\-wants\-larry\-summers\-running\-israels\-banks/309791/ \|archive\-url\= \|work\=\[\[The Atlantic]] \|archive\-date\= \|access\-date\=October 20, 2013}}{{cite news \|author\= \|title\=Larry Summers rejects offer to become BoI governor
\|url\=https://en.globes.co.il/en/article\-1000886969 \|archive\-url\= \|archive\-date\= \|work\=Globes \|date\=October 20, 2013 \|access\-date\=October 21, 2013}}
### Criticism of the Biden Administration, 2021
Summers emerged as an early opponent of President [Joe Biden](/wiki/Joe_Biden "Joe Biden")'s economic policy, calling the $1\.9 trillion [American Rescue Plan Act of 2021](/wiki/American_Rescue_Plan_Act_of_2021 "American Rescue Plan Act of 2021") "the least responsible macroeconomic policy we've had in the last 40 years" and arguing that it risked economic recession and market destabilization.{{Cite web\|last\=Williams\|first\=Jordan\|date\=March 20, 2021\|title\=Larry Summers blasts $1\.9 T stimulus as 'least responsible' economic policy in 40 years\|url\=https://thehill.com/policy/finance/544188\-larry\-summers\-blasts\-least\-responsible\-economic\-policy\-in\-40\-years\|access\-date\=April 25, 2021\|website\=\[\[The Hill (newspaper)\|The Hill]]\|language\=en}}
### Hamas\-led attack on Israel
In October 2023, following the [Hamas\-led attack on Israel](/wiki/2023_Hamas-led_attack_on_Israel "2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel"), several [Harvard](/wiki/Harvard_University "Harvard University") undergraduate student groups signed a letter condemning the [Israeli state](/wiki/Israeli_state "Israeli state"), and holding the "Israeli regime entirely responsible for all unfolding violence".{{cite news\|url\=https://www.the\-independent.com/news/world/americas/us\-politics/harvard\-letter\-war\-israel\-hamas\-b2427497\.html\|title\=Letter from Harvard group holding Israel 'responsible' for war with Hamas sparks backlash\|publisher\=Independent\|access\-date\=October 17, 2023}}{{cite news\|url\=https://edition.cnn.com/2023/10/11/business/harvard\-israel\-hamas\-ceos\-students/index.html\|title\=Harvard student groups issued an anti\-Israel statement. CEOs want them blacklisted\|publisher\=CNN\|access\-date\=October 17, 2023}} This letter from Harvard University student groups blaming Israel drew a backlash from several prominent alumni and from Larry Summers, who said that he was "sickened" by it.{{Cite web \|date\=October 10, 2023 \|title\=Growing backlash over Harvard students' pro\-Palestine letter \|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-us\-canada\-67067565\|access\-date\=December 7, 2023 \|website\= BBC News\|language\=en\-US}} Summers, though agreeing with [Bill Ackman](/wiki/Bill_Ackman "Bill Ackman") on the need to look at employees' political views, called Ackman's request to release the names of all the students involved in signing the letter "the stuff of [Joe McCarthy](/wiki/Joe_McCarthy "Joe McCarthy")".{{Cite web \|last\=Teo \|first\=Kai Xiang \|title\=Former Harvard president Larry Summers thinks Bill Ackman asking for lists of student names is the 'stuff of Joe McCarthy' \|url\=https://www.businessinsider.com/harvard\-larry\-summers\-bill\-ackman\-israel\-hamas\-student\-names\-list\-2023\-10 \|access\-date\=October 17, 2023 \|website\=Business Insider \|language\=en\-US}} Summers has repeatedly criticized the Harvard administration for its failure to curb what he sees as rising antisemitism at the university since the Hamas attack.{{Cite web \|last\=Ebbert \|first\=Stephanie \|last2\= \|first2\= \|last3\= \|first3\= \|last4\= \|last5\= \|first5\= \|title\=Larry Summers was ousted as Harvard president. He has a lot to say about what's wrong with the university now. \- The Boston Globe \|url\=https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/03/21/metro/larry\-summers\-vocal\-critic\-of\-harvard\-successors/ \|access\-date\=March 22, 2024 \|website\=BostonGlobe.com \|language\=en\-US}}
|
[
"Career\n------",
"### Academic economist",
"[thumb\\|Summers in 1990](/wiki/File:Lawrence_Summers%2C_1990.jpg \"Lawrence Summers, 1990.jpg\")\nAs a researcher, Summers has made important contributions in many areas of economics, primarily [public finance](/wiki/Public_finance \"Public finance\"), [labor economics](/wiki/Labor_economics \"Labor economics\"), [financial economics](/wiki/Financial_economics \"Financial economics\"), and [macroeconomics](/wiki/Macroeconomics \"Macroeconomics\"). Summers has also worked in international economics, economic demography, [economic history](/wiki/Economic_history \"Economic history\") and [development economics](/wiki/Development_economics \"Development economics\").{{Cite journal\\|last\\=Poterba\\|first\\=James M.\\|date\\=Winter 1995\\|title\\=In Honor of Lawrence H. Summers, Winner of the John Bates Clark Medal\\|journal\\=Journal of Economic Perspectives\\|language\\=en\\|volume\\=9\\|issue\\=1\\|pages\\=165–182\\|doi\\=10\\.1257/jep.9\\.1\\.165\\|issn\\=0895\\-3309\\|doi\\-access\\=}} He received the [John Bates Clark Medal](/wiki/John_Bates_Clark_Medal \"John Bates Clark Medal\") in 1993 from the American Economic Association.{{Cite news\\|url\\=http://www.businessinsider.com/30\\-most\\-famous\\-harvard\\-students\\-of\\-all\\-time\\-2010\\-4\\#larry\\-summers\\-born\\-november\\-30\\-1954\\-21\\|title\\=The 30 Most Famous Harvard Students Of All Time\\|work\\=\\[\\[Business Insider]]\\|access\\-date\\=August 7, 2017\\|language\\=en}} In 1987, he was the first social scientist to win the [Alan T. Waterman Award](/wiki/Alan_T._Waterman_Award \"Alan T. Waterman Award\") from the [National Science Foundation](/wiki/National_Science_Foundation \"National Science Foundation\"). Summers is also a member of the [National Academy of Sciences](/wiki/United_States_National_Academy_of_Sciences \"United States National Academy of Sciences\"). Some of his popular courses today, as Charles W. Eliot University Professor at Harvard University, include American Economic Policy and The Political Economy of Globalization.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.hks.harvard.edu/faculty/lawrence\\-h\\-summers\\|title\\=Lawrence H. Summers\\|website\\=www.hks.harvard.edu}}",
"### Public official",
"Summers was on the staff of the [Council of Economic Advisers](/wiki/Council_of_Economic_Advisers \"Council of Economic Advisers\") under President Reagan in 1982–1983\\. He also served as an economic adviser to the [Dukakis](/wiki/Michael_Dukakis \"Michael Dukakis\") Presidential campaign in 1988\\.",
"### Chief Economist at the World Bank",
"Summers left Harvard in 1991 and served as [Vice President of Development Economics](/wiki/World_Bank_Vice_President_of_Development_Economics \"World Bank Vice President of Development Economics\") and [Chief Economist](/wiki/World_Bank_Chief_Economist \"World Bank Chief Economist\") for the [World Bank](/wiki/World_Bank \"World Bank\") until 1993\\.",
"According to the World Bank's Data \\& Research office (March 2017\\), Summers returned to [Washington, D.C.](/wiki/Washington%2C_D.C. \"Washington, D.C.\") in 1991 as the World Bank's Vice President of Development Economics and Chief Economist. As such, Summers played a \"key role\" in designing strategies to aid developing countries, worked on the bank's loan committee, guided the bank's research and statistics operations, and guided external training programs.",
"The World Bank's official site also reports that Summer's research included an \"influential\" report that demonstrated a very high return from investments in educating girls in developing nations.",
"According to *The Economist,* Summers was \"often at the centre of heated debates\" about economic policy, to an extent exceptional for the history of the World Bank in recent decades.[\"New ideas: The World Bank hires a famous contrarian,\"](https://www.economist.com/news/21702339-paul-romer-banks-new-chief-economist-world-bank-hires-famous-contrarian) July 18, 2016, [The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist \"The Economist\"), retrieved March 31, 2017",
"#### \"Dirty industries\" controversy",
"{{Further\\|Summers memo}}\nIn December 1991, while at the World Bank, Summers signed [a memo](/wiki/Summers_memo \"Summers memo\") that was leaked to the press. [Lant Pritchett](/wiki/Lant_Pritchett \"Lant Pritchett\") has claimed authorship of the private memo, which both he and Summers say was intended as sarcasm.[\"Furor on Memo At World Bank,\"](https://www.nytimes.com/1992/02/07/business/furor-on-memo-at-world-bank.html) February 7, 1992, [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\"), retrieved March 30, 2017 The memo stated that \"the economic logic behind dumping a load of toxic waste in the lowest wage country is impeccable and we should face up to that. ... I've always thought that under\\-populated countries in Africa are vastly underpolluted.\"Office Memorandum from Lawrence M. Summers, Subject: GEP, the World Bank/IMFMIGA, December 12, 1991\\. This was an internal memo at the World Bank, not intended for the public \\-\\- reportedly sarcastic, rather than sincere, according to its authors \\-\\- that highlighted the economic logic of dumping waste in less\\-developed countries. According to Pritchett, the memo, as leaked, was doctored to remove context and intended irony, and was \"a deliberate fraud and forgery to discredit Larry and the World Bank.\"{{cite magazine\\|url\\=http://www.harvardmagazine.com/on\\-line/050171\\.html\\|title\\=Toxic Memo\\|magazine\\= Harvard Magazine\\|date\\=May–June 2001}}, also posted at: {{cite web\\|title\\=Toxic memo\\|url\\=http://www.harvardmagazine.com/2001/05/toxic\\-memo.html\\|publisher\\=HarvardMagazine.com\\|access\\-date\\=November 8, 2017\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20081203160404/http://www.harvardmagazine.com/on\\-line/050171\\.html\\|archive\\-date\\=December 3, 2008}}",
"### Service in the Clinton Administration",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Summers as United States Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/File:Lawrence_Summers_Treasury_portrait.jpg \"Lawrence Summers Treasury portrait.jpg\")\nIn 1993, Summers was appointed Undersecretary for International Affairs and later in the [United States Department of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasury \"United States Department of the Treasury\") under the [Clinton](/wiki/Bill_Clinton \"Bill Clinton\") Administration. In 1995, he was promoted to Deputy Secretary of the Treasury under his long\\-time political mentor [Robert Rubin](/wiki/Robert_Rubin \"Robert Rubin\"). In 1999, he succeeded Rubin as [Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Secretary_of_the_Treasury \"United States Secretary of the Treasury\").",
"Much of Summers's tenure at the Treasury Department was focused on international economic issues. He was deeply involved in the Clinton administration's effort to bail out Mexico and Russia when those nations had currency crises.[A New Economic Team: The Nominee; The Administration's Fiscal Closer](https://www.nytimes.com/1999/05/13/business/a-new-economic-team-the-nominee-the-administration-s-fiscal-closer.html?sec=&spon=&pagewanted=all). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\"). May 13, 1999\\.\nSummers set up a project through which the [Harvard Institute for International Development](/wiki/Harvard_Institute_for_International_Development \"Harvard Institute for International Development\") provided advice to the Russian government between 1992 and 1997\\. Later there was a scandal when it emerged that some of the Harvard project members had invested in Russia and were therefore not impartial advisors.{{cite book\n \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=5ywA163EEewC\\&pg\\=PA79\\|page\\=79\\|title\\=Misinterpreting Modern Russia\\|author\\=Bruno S. Sergi\\|publisher\\=Continuum International Publishing Group\\|year\\=2009\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-8264\\-2772\\-4}}\nSummers encouraged then\\-Russian leader Boris Yeltsin to use the same \"three\\-'ations'\" of policy he advocated in the Clinton Administration – \"privatization, stabilization, and liberalization.\"Naomi Klein, \"The Shock Doctrine\", p. 231",
"Summers pressured the Korean government to raise its interest rates and balance its budget in the midst of a recession, policies criticized by [Paul Krugman](/wiki/Paul_Krugman \"Paul Krugman\") and [Joseph Stiglitz](/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz \"Joseph Stiglitz\").{{cite news\\|first\\=Paul\\|last\\=Blustein\\|title\\=The Chastening\\|url\\=http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\\-cgi\\-bin/display?book\\=9781586481810\\|publisher\\=Public Affairs, New York\\|year\\=2001\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20101208005946/http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\\-cgi\\-bin/display?book\\=9781586481810\\|archive\\-date\\=December 8, 2010\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}\n According to the book *The Chastening*, by Paul Blustein, during this crisis, Summers, along with [Paul Wolfowitz](/wiki/Paul_Wolfowitz \"Paul Wolfowitz\"), pushed for regime change in Indonesia.{{cite news\\|first\\=Paul\\|last\\=Blustein\\|title\\=The Chastening\\|url\\=http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\\-cgi\\-bin/display?book\\=9781586481810\\|page\\=232\\|publisher\\=Public Affairs, New York\\|year\\=2001\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20101208005946/http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/publicaffairsbooks\\-cgi\\-bin/display?book\\=9781586481810\\|archive\\-date\\=December 8, 2010\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"",
"Summers was a leading voice within the Clinton Administration arguing against American leadership in [greenhouse gas](/wiki/Greenhouse_gas \"Greenhouse gas\") reductions and against US participation in the [Kyoto Protocol](/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol \"Kyoto Protocol\"), according to internal documents made public in 2009\\.{{cite news \\|first\\=Robert\\|last\\=Wampler\\|title\\=Kyoto Redux? Obama's Challenges at Copenhagen Echo Clinton's at Kyoto\\|url\\=http://www.gwu.edu/\\~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB303/index.htm\\|publisher\\=National Security Archive at George Washington University\\|access\\-date\\=April 10, 2010\\|date\\=December 18, 2009}}",
"",
"As Treasury Secretary, Summers led the Clinton Administration's opposition to tax cuts proposed by the Republican Congress in 1999\\.[Aides Say Clinton Would Veto Tax Compromise](https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/budget/stories/taxes072699.htm). [The Washington Post](/wiki/The_Washington_Post \"The Washington Post\"). July 26, 1999\\.",
"During the California [energy crisis of 2000](/wiki/2000%E2%80%9301_California_electricity_crisis \"2000–01 California electricity crisis\"), then\\-Treasury Secretary Summers teamed with [Alan Greenspan](/wiki/Alan_Greenspan \"Alan Greenspan\") and [Enron](/wiki/Enron \"Enron\") executive [Kenneth Lay](/wiki/Kenneth_Lay \"Kenneth Lay\") to lecture California Governor [Gray Davis](/wiki/Gray_Davis \"Gray Davis\") on the causes of the crisis, explaining that the problem was excessive government regulation.{{cite news \\|first\\=Paul\\|last\\=Krugman\\|author\\-link\\=Paul Krugman\\|title\\=California Energy Memories\\|url\\=https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/11/20/california\\-energy\\-memories/\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=November 20, 2008\\|access\\-date\\=April 4, 2010}}\n Under the advice of Kenneth Lay, Summers urged Davis to relax California's environmental standards in order to reassure the markets.{{cite web \\|first\\=Alex\\|last\\=Gibney\\|author\\-link\\=Alex Gibney\\|title\\=Larry Summers' Enron Problem\\|url\\=http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs\\-and\\-stories/2008\\-11\\-12/larry\\-summers\\-and\\-enron/\\|website\\=\\[\\[The Daily Beast]]}}",
"",
"Summers hailed the [Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act](/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bliley_Act \"Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act\") in 1999, which lifted more than six decades of restrictions against banks offering [commercial banking](/wiki/Commercial_banking \"Commercial banking\"), insurance, and investment services (by repealing key provisions in the 1933 [Glass–Steagall Act](/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_Act \"Glass–Steagall Act\")): \"Today Congress voted to update the rules that have governed financial services since the [Great Depression](/wiki/Great_Depression \"Great Depression\") and replace them with a system for the 21st century,\" Summers said.{{cite news\\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/1999/11/05/business/congress\\-passes\\-wide\\-ranging\\-bill\\-easing\\-bank\\-laws.html\\|title\\=Congress Passes Wide Ranging Law Repealing Bank laws\\|date\\=November 5, 1999\\|access\\-date\\=March 25, 2009\\|first\\=Stephen\\|last\\=Labaton}} \"This historic legislation will better enable American companies to compete in the new economy.\" Many critics, including [President](/wiki/POTUS \"POTUS\") [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama \"Barack Obama\"), have suggested the [2007 subprime mortgage financial crisis](/wiki/2007_subprime_mortgage_financial_crisis \"2007 subprime mortgage financial crisis\") was caused by the partial repeal of the 1933 Glass–Steagall Act.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123665023774979341\\|title\\=Ten Questions for Those Fixing the Financial Mess\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Wall Street Journal]]\\|date\\=March 10, 2009\\|access\\-date\\=March 26, 2009\\|first\\=Damian\\|last\\=Paletta}} Indeed, as a member of President Clinton's [Working Group on Financial Markets](/wiki/Working_Group_on_Financial_Markets \"Working Group on Financial Markets\"), Summers, along with U.S. [Securities and Exchange Commission](/wiki/Securities_and_Exchange_Commission \"Securities and Exchange Commission\") (SEC) Chairman [Arthur Levitt](/wiki/Arthur_Levitt \"Arthur Levitt\"), Fed Chairman Greenspan, and Secretary Rubin, torpedoed an effort to regulate the derivatives that many blame for bringing the financial market down in Fall 2008\\.{{cite news\\|work\\=\\[\\[Frontline (U.S. TV series)\\|Frontline]]/PBS\\|url\\=https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/warning/view/\\#morelink\\|title\\=the warning\\|date\\=October 23, 2009\\|access\\-date\\=October 26, 2009}}",
"#### Views on financial regulation",
"On May 7, 1998, the [Commodity Futures Trading Commission](/wiki/Commodity_Futures_Trading_Commission \"Commodity Futures Trading Commission\") (CFTC) issued a Concept Release soliciting input from regulators, academics, and practitioners to determine \"how best to maintain adequate regulatory safeguards without impairing the ability of the OTC ([over\\-the\\-counter](/wiki/Over-the-counter_%28finance%29 \"Over-the-counter (finance)\")) derivatives market to grow and the ability of U.S. entities to remain competitive in the global financial marketplace.\"{{cite web \\|title\\=CFTC Issues Concept Release Concerning Over\\-The\\-Counter Derivatives Market\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission]]\\|date\\=May 7, 1998\\|access\\-date\\=September 16, 2013\\|url\\=http://www.cftc.gov/opa/press98/opa4142\\-98\\.htm}} On July 30, 1998, then\\-Deputy Secretary of the Treasury Summers testified before the U.S. Congress that \"the parties to these kinds of contract are largely sophisticated financial institutions that would appear to be eminently capable of protecting themselves from fraud and counterparty insolvencies.\" At the time Summers stated that \"to date there has been no clear evidence of a need for additional regulation of the institutional OTC derivatives market, and we would submit that proponents of such regulation must bear the burden of demonstrating that need.\"{{cite news\\|last\\=Summers\\|first\\=Lawrence\\|title\\=Lawrence H. Summers Testimony\\|date\\=July 30, 1998\\|url\\=http://ustreas.gov/press/releases/rr2616\\.htm\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20091025220333/http://www.ustreas.gov/press/releases/rr2616\\.htm\\|archive\\-date\\=October 25, 2009}}\nIn 1999 Summers endorsed the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act which removed the separation between investment and commercial banks, saying \"With this bill, the American financial system takes a major step forward towards the 21st Century.\"{{cite book \\|pages\\=142–143\\|lccn\\=2011286013\\|author\\-link\\=David Orrell\\|last\\=Orrell\\|first\\=David \\| title\\-link\\=Economyths\\|title\\=Economyths : ten ways economics gets it wrong\\|location\\=\\[\\[Mississauga, Ontario]]\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[John Wiley \\& Sons Canada, Ltd]]\\|year\\=2010\\|isbn\\=9780470677933}}",
"When [George Stephanopoulos](/wiki/George_Stephanopoulos \"George Stephanopoulos\") asked Summers about the financial crisis in an ABC interview on March 15, 2009, Summers replied that \"there are a lot of terrible things that have happened in the last eighteen months, but what's happened at A.I.G. ... the way it was not regulated, the way no one was watching ... is outrageous.\"{{Cite book \\|last\\=Friedman \\|first\\=Jeff \\|url\\=https://www.worldcat.org/oclc/793012561 \\|title\\=What Caused the Financial Crisis \\|publisher\\=University of Pennsylvania Press \\|year\\=2011 \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-8122\\-0493\\-3 \\|location\\=Philadelphia \\|pages\\=312 \\|oclc\\=793012561}}",
"In February 2009, Summers quoted [John Maynard Keynes](/wiki/John_Maynard_Keynes \"John Maynard Keynes\"), saying \"When circumstances change, I change my opinion\", reflecting both on the failures of [Wall Street](/wiki/Wall_Street \"Wall Street\") deregulation and his new leadership role in the government bailout.{{cite news\\|author\\=Michael Hirsh\\|title\\=The Reeducation of Larry Summers\\|url\\=http://www.newsweek.com/reeducation\\-larry\\-summers\\-82289\\|access\\-date\\=January 4, 2014\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Newsweek]]\\|date\\=February 20, 2009}} On April 18, 2010, in an interview on ABC's \"This Week\" program, Clinton said Summers was wrong in the advice he gave him not to regulate derivatives.{{Cite news \\|last\\=Zumbrun \\|first\\=Joshua \\|date\\=April 19, 2010 \\|title\\=Clinton Calls Advice He Got on Derivatives 'Wrong' \\|language\\=en \\|work\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News\\|Bloomberg]] \\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2010\\-04\\-18/clinton\\-says\\-rubin\\-summers\\-gave\\-him\\-wrong\\-advice\\-on\\-derivatives\\-rules \\|url\\-access\\=subscription \\|access\\-date\\=April 27, 2023}}",
"{{anchor\\|Harvard president}}",
"### President of Harvard",
"In 2001, when [George W. Bush](/wiki/George_W._Bush \"George W. Bush\") became [President](/wiki/President_of_the_United_States \"President of the United States\"), Summers left the Treasury Department and returned to Harvard as its 27th president, serving from July 2001 until June 2006\\. He was Harvard's first Jewish president,*YUNews* [Director of the National Economic Council, Dr. Lawrence H. Summers, is Keynote Speaker at Yeshiva University's Annual Hanukkah Dinner and Convocation on December 13](https://www.yu.edu/news/director-of-the-national-economic-council-dr-lawrence-h-summers-is-keynote-speaker-at-yeshiva-universitys-annual-hanukkah-dinner-and-convocation-on-december-13), November 18, 2009*The Harvard Crimson* [Did Summers' Faith Affect His Fall?](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/3/3/did-summers-faith-affect-his-fall/), March 3, 2006*The Harvard Crimson* [A Milestone of Faith](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2001/10/14/a-milestone-of-faith-in-1922/), October 14, 2001 though his predecessor Neil Rudenstine's father was Jewish.[Harvard's First Jewish President](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511933). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\"). March 8, 2006",
"A number of Summers's decisions at Harvard have attracted public controversy, either at the time or since his resignation.",
"#### Cornel West affair",
"In an October 2001 meeting, Summers criticized African American Studies department head [Cornel West](/wiki/Cornel_West \"Cornel West\") for allegedly missing three weeks of classes to work on the [Bill Bradley](/wiki/Bill_Bradley \"Bill Bradley\") presidential campaign and complained that West was contributing to [grade inflation](/wiki/Grade_inflation \"Grade inflation\"). Summers also claimed that West's \"rap\" album was an \"embarrassment\" to the university. West pushed back strongly against the accusations.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2006/06/06/some\\_seek\\_a\\_scholars\\_return/\\|title\\=Some seek a scholar's return\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Boston Globe]]\\|date\\=June 6, 2006\\|first1\\=Marcella\\|last1\\=Bombardieri}} \"The hip\\-hop scared him. It's a stereotypical reaction\", he said later. West, who later called Summers both \"uninformed\" and \"an unprincipled power player\" in describing this encounter in his book *Democracy Matters* (2004\\), subsequently returned to [Princeton University](/wiki/Princeton_University \"Princeton University\"), where he had taught prior to [Harvard University](/wiki/Harvard_University \"Harvard University\").",
"#### Differences between the sexes",
"{{See also\\|Women in science}}",
"In January 2005, at a Conference on Diversifying the Science \\& Engineering Workforce sponsored by the [National Bureau of Economic Research](/wiki/National_Bureau_of_Economic_Research \"National Bureau of Economic Research\"), Summers sparked controversy with his discussion of why women may have been underrepresented \"in tenured positions in science and engineering at top universities and research institutions\". The conference was designed to be off\\-the\\-record so that participants could speak candidly without fear of public misunderstanding or disclosure later.{{cite news \\|last1\\=Dillon \\|first1\\=Sam \\|title\\=Harvard Chief Defends His Talk on Women \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/18/us/harvard\\-chief\\-defends\\-his\\-talk\\-on\\-women.html \\|access\\-date\\=February 13, 2022 \\|date\\=February 18, 2005}}",
"Summers had prefaced his talk, saying he was adopting an \"entirely [positive](/wiki/Positivism \"Positivism\"), rather than [normative](/wiki/Normative \"Normative\") approach\" and that his remarks were intended to be an \"attempt at provocation\".{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \\|title\\=Archive of: Remarks at NBER Conference on Diversifying the Science \\& Engineering Workforce \\|access\\-date\\=January 30, 2008 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \\|archive\\-date\\=January 30, 2008 }}. January 14, 2005\\.",
"Summers then began by identifying three hypotheses for the higher proportion of men in high\\-end science and engineering positions:",
"1. The high\\-powered job hypothesis\n2. Different availability of [aptitude](/wiki/Aptitude \"Aptitude\") at the high end\n3. Different socialization and patterns of discrimination in a search",
"The second hypothesis, the generally [greater variability among men](/wiki/Variability_hypothesis \"Variability hypothesis\") (compared to women) in tests of cognitive abilities,Hedges, L. V., \\& Nowell, A. (1995\\). \"Sex differences in mental scores, variability, and numbers of high scoring individuals\". *Science*, 269, 41–45\\.Lehrke, R. (1997\\). *Sex linkage of intelligence: The X\\-Factor*. New York: Praeger.Lubinski, D., \\& Benbow, C. M. (2006\\). \"Study of mathematically precocious youth after 35 years\". *Perspectives on Psychological Science*, 1, 316–345\\. leading to proportionally more males than females at both the lower and upper tails of the test score distributions, caused the most controversy. In his discussion of this hypothesis, Summers said that \"even small differences in the standard deviation \\[between genders] will translate into very large differences in the available pool substantially out \\[from the mean]\". Summers referenced research that implied differences between the standard deviations of males and females in the top 5% of twelfth graders under various tests. He then went on to argue that, if this research were to be accepted, then \"whatever the set of attributes ... that are precisely defined to correlate with being an aeronautical engineer at MIT or being a chemist at Berkeley ... are probably different in their standard deviations as well\".",
"Summers then concluded his discussion of the three hypotheses by saying:",
"",
"> So my best guess, to provoke you, of what's behind all of this is that the largest phenomenon, by far, is the general clash between people's legitimate family desires and employers' current desire for high power and high intensity, that in the special case of science and engineering, there are issues of intrinsic aptitude, and particularly of the variability of aptitude, and that those considerations are reinforced by what are in fact lesser factors involving socialization and continuing discrimination. I would like nothing better than to be proved wrong, because I would like nothing better than for these problems to be addressable simply by everybody understanding what they are, and working very hard to address them.",
"Summers then went on to discuss approaches to remedying the shortage of women in high\\-end science and engineering positions.",
"This lunch\\-time talk drew accusations of sexism and careless scholarship, and an intense negative response followed, both nationally and at Harvard.[Summers' Remarks on Women Draw Fire](https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2005/01/17/summers_remarks_on_women_draw_fire/){{dead link\\|date\\=March 2024}}. The Boston Globe. January 17, 2005 Summers apologized repeatedly.{{cite magazine \\|last\\=Saletan\\|first\\=William\\|author\\-link\\=William Saletan\\|date\\=January 21, 2005\\|title\\=Don't Worry Your Pretty Little Head\\|url\\=http://www.slate.com/id/2112570/\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[Slate (magazine)\\|Slate]]}} Nevertheless, the controversy is speculated to have contributed to his resigning his position as president of Harvard University the following year, as well as costing Summers the job of [Treasury Secretary](/wiki/Treasury_Secretary \"Treasury Secretary\") in [Obama's administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Barack_Obama \"Presidency of Barack Obama\").[Summers's 'sexism' costs him top Treasury job](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/summersrsquo-lsquosexismrsquo-costs-him-top-treasury-job-1033373.html). [The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent \"The Independent\"). November 24, 2008",
"Summers's protégée [Sheryl Sandberg](/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg \"Sheryl Sandberg\") has defended him, saying that \"Larry has been a true advocate for women throughout his career\" at the World Bank and Treasury. Referring to the lunch talk, Sandberg said, \"What few seem to note is that it is remarkable that he was giving the speech in the first place – that he cared enough about women's careers and their trajectory in the fields of math and science to proactively analyze the issues and talk about what was going wrong\".{{cite news\\|author\\=Sheryl Sandberg\\|title\\=Larry Summers' True Record on Women\\|url\\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/sheryl\\-sandberg/what\\-larry\\-summers\\-has\\-do\\_b\\_142126\\.html\\|access\\-date\\=January 4, 2014\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[HuffPost]]\\|date\\=November 7, 2008\\|author\\-link\\=Sheryl Sandberg}}",
"In 2016, remarking upon [political correctness](/wiki/Political_correctness \"Political correctness\") in institutions of higher education, Summers said:",
"",
"> There is a great deal of absurd political correctness. Now, I'm somebody who believes very strongly in diversity, who resists racism in all of its many incarnations, who thinks that there is a great deal that's unjust in American society that needs to be combated, but it seems to be that there is a kind of creeping totalitarianism in terms of what kind of ideas are acceptable and are debatable on college campuses.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://conversationswithbillkristol.org/video/larry\\-summers\\-ii/?start\\=15\\&end\\=1606\\|title\\=Larry Summers II on Conversations with Bill Kristol\\|website\\=ConversationsWithBillKristol.org\\|access\\-date\\=November 8, 2017}}",
"#### Summers' opposition and support at Harvard",
"On March 15, 2005, members of the [Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Faculty_of_Arts_and_Sciences \"Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences\"), which instructs graduate students in [Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Graduate_School_of_Arts_and_Sciences \"Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences\") and undergraduates in [Harvard College](/wiki/Harvard_College \"Harvard College\"), passed 218–185 a motion of \"lack of confidence\" in the leadership of Summers, with 18 abstentions. A second motion that offered a milder censure of the president passed 253 to 137, also with 18 abstentions.",
"The members of the [Harvard Corporation](/wiki/Harvard_Corporation \"Harvard Corporation\"), the University's highest governing body, are in charge of the selection of the president and issued statements strongly supporting Summers.",
"FAS faculty were not unanimous in their comments against Summers. Psychologist [Steven Pinker](/wiki/Steven_Pinker \"Steven Pinker\") defended the legitimacy of Summers's January lecture. When asked if Summers's talk was \"within the pale of legitimate academic discourse,\" Pinker responded \"Good grief, shouldn't everything be within the pale of legitimate academic discourse, as long as it is presented with some degree of rigor? That's the difference between a university and a [madrassa](/wiki/Madrassa \"Madrassa\"). There is certainly enough evidence for the hypothesis to be taken seriously.\"[Psychoanalysis Q\\-and\\-A: Steven Pinker](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2005/1/19/psychoanalysis-q-and-a-steven-pinker-in-an/). *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\")*. January 19, 2005",
"Summers had stronger support among Harvard College students than among the college faculty. One poll by *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\")* indicated that students opposed his resignation by a three\\-to\\-one margin, with 57% of responding students opposing his resignation and 19% supporting it.[Poll: Students Say Summers Should Stay](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511421). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\"). February 20, 2006",
"In July 2005, a board member of Harvard Corporation, [Conrad K. Harper](/wiki/Conrad_K._Harper \"Conrad K. Harper\"), resigned saying he was angered both by the university president's comments about women and by Summers being given a salary increase. The resignation letter to the president said, \"I could not and cannot support a raise in your salary, ... I believe that Harvard's best interests require your resignation.\"{{cite news\\|last\\=Finder\\|first\\=Alan\\|title\\=A Harvard Governor, Dissatisfied, Resigns\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/29/education/29harvard.html?\\_r\\=0\\|access\\-date\\=December 5, 2013\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=July 29, 2005}}[Board Member's Letter of Resignation](https://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/02/education/02htext.html). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\"). August 2, 2005",
"#### Support of economist Andrei Shleifer",
"Harvard and [Andrei Shleifer](/wiki/Andrei_Shleifer \"Andrei Shleifer\"), a close friend and protégé of Summers, controversially paid $28\\.5 million to settle a [lawsuit](/wiki/Lawsuit \"Lawsuit\") by the U.S. government over the [conflict of interest](/wiki/Conflict_of_interest \"Conflict of interest\") Shleifer had while advising [Russia's privatization program](/wiki/Russia%27s_privatization_program \"Russia's privatization program\"). The US government had sued Shleifer under the [False Claims Act](/wiki/False_Claims_Act \"False Claims Act\"), as he bought [Russian](/wiki/Russia \"Russia\") stocks while designing the country's [privatization](/wiki/Privatization \"Privatization\"). In 2004, a federal judge ruled that while Harvard had violated the contract, Shleifer and his associate alone were liable for [treble damages](/wiki/Treble_damages \"Treble damages\").",
"In June 2005, Harvard and Shleifer announced that they had reached a tentative settlement with the US government. In August, Harvard, Shleifer, and the [Department of Justice](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Justice \"United States Department of Justice\") reached an agreement under which the university paid $26\\.5 million to settle the five\\-year\\-old lawsuit. Shleifer was also responsible for paying $2 million worth of damages.",
"Because Harvard paid almost all of the damages and allowed Shleifer to retain his faculty position, the settlement provoked allegations of favoritism by Summers. His continued support for Shleifer strengthened Summers's unpopularity with other professors, as reported in *The Harvard Crimson*:",
"{{Blockquote\\|I've been a member of this Faculty for over 45 years, and I am no longer easily shocked,\" is how Frederick H. Abernathy, the McKay professor of mechanical engineering, began his biting comments about the Shleifer case at Tuesday's fiery Faculty meeting. But, Abernathy continued, \"I was deeply shocked and disappointed by the actions of this University\" in the Shleifer affair.{{cite news\\|title\\='Tawdry Shleifer Affair' Stokes Faculty Anger Toward Summers\\|url\\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/2/10/tawdry\\-shleifer\\-affair\\-stokes\\-faculty\\-anger/\\|access\\-date\\=30 May 2013\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Harvard Crimson]]\\|date\\=10 Feb 2006\\|author\\=Nicholas Ciarelli\\|author2\\=Anton Troianovski}}}}",
"#### In Russia",
"{{See also\\|Loans for shares scheme}}\nAn 18,000\\-word article \"How Harvard Lost Russia\" in *[Institutional Investor](/wiki/Institutional_Investor_%28magazine%29 \"Institutional Investor (magazine)\")* by David McClintick detailed Shleifer's alleged efforts to use his [inside knowledge](/wiki/Insider_trading \"Insider trading\") of and sway over the Russian economy in order to make lucrative personal investments, all while leading a Harvard group, advising the Russian government, that was under contract with the U.S. The article suggests that Summers shielded his fellow economist from disciplinary action by the university, and it noted that Summers had forewarned Shleifer and his wife Nancy Zimmerman about the conflict\\-of\\-interest regulations back in 1996\\.{{Cite news \\|last\\=McClintick \\|first\\=David \\|date\\=January 13, 2006 \\|title\\=How Harvard Lost Russia \\|work\\=Institutional Investor \\|url\\=https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b150npp3q49x7w/how\\-harvard\\-lost\\-russia \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140705041205/http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/Article/1020662/How\\-Harvard\\-lost\\-Russia.html\\#/.V0mIqpF97nE \\|archive\\-date\\=July 5, 2014}} Summers's friendship with Shleifer was well known by the corporation when it selected him to succeed Rudenstine and Summers recused himself from all proceedings with Shleifer, whose case was actually handled by an independent committee led by former Harvard president [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok \"Derek Bok\").",
"#### Connection to Jeffrey Epstein",
"An article in *The Harvard Crimson* in 2003, during Summers's tenure as president, detailed a reportedly \"special connection\" between Summers and [Jeffrey Epstein](/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein \"Jeffrey Epstein\").{{Cite web\\|last\\= Scharnick\\|first\\=Jaquelyn M.\\|date\\=May 1, 2003\\|url\\=https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/5/1/mogul\\-donor\\-gives\\-harvard\\-more\\-than/?page\\=single\\|title\\=Mogul Donor Gives Harvard More Than Money\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Harvard Crimson]]\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein pledged to donate at least $25 million to Harvard during Summers's tenure to endow Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein was given an office at Harvard for his personal use.{{Cite magazine\\|url\\=https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/03/jeffrey\\-epstein\\-200303\\|title\\=The Talented Mr. Epstein\\|last\\=Ward\\|first\\=Vicky\\|date\\=March 2003\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[Vanity Fair (magazine)\\|Vanity Fair]]\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|quote\\=Epstein has pledged at least $25 million to Harvard to create the Epstein Program for Mathematical Biology and Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein will have an office at the university...He says he was reluctant to have his name attached to the program, but Summers persuaded him. }}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://ped.fas.harvard.edu/home\\|title\\=Program for Evolutionary Dynamics\\|website\\=ped.fas.harvard.edu\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein otherwise had no formal connection to Harvard. Summers's ties to Epstein reportedly began \"a number of years...before Summers became Harvard's president and even before he was the Secretary of the Treasury.\" Flight records introduced as evidence in the 2021 trial of Epstein associate [Ghislaine Maxwell](/wiki/Ghislaine_Maxwell \"Ghislaine Maxwell\") show that Summers flew on Jeffrey Epstein's private plane on at least four occasions, including once in 1998 when Summers was [United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Deputy_Secretary_of_the_Treasury \"United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury\") and at least three times while Harvard president.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://s3\\.documentcloud.org/documents/21165424/epstein\\-flight\\-logs\\-released\\-in\\-usa\\-vs\\-maxwell.pdf\\|title\\=Epstein Flight Logs Released in USA vs. Maxwell\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=December 27, 2021}} A charity funded by Epstein also donated to the production of a [PBS](/wiki/PBS \"PBS\") show hosted by Summers's wife and Harvard professor [Elisa New](/wiki/Elisa_New \"Elisa New\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey\\-epstein\\-has\\-a\\-secret\\-charity\\-heres\\-who\\-it\\-gave\\-money\\-to?ref\\=scroll\\|title\\=REVEALED: We Found Billionaire Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein's Secret Charity\\|last\\=Briquelet\\|first\\=Kate\\|date\\=July 10, 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Daily Beast]]\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|quote\\=In 2016, Gratitude America Ltd. shelled out $110,000 to Verse Video Education. The Cambridge, Massachusetts\\-based nonprofit produces the PBS show Poetry in America, whose creator and host is Harvard professor Elisa New. Verse's 2016 tax return named New as the group's president but doesn't include specific donors for its $1\\.38 million in total contributions. New is married to Summers, Harvard University's former president, who hobnobbed with Epstein in elite international relations groups and, like Bill Clinton, flew on Epstein's private jet.}}",
"#### Winklevoss twins and Facebook",
"In February 2004, the [Winklevoss twins](/wiki/Winklevoss_twins \"Winklevoss twins\") requested a meeting with Summers in order to ask him to intervene on their behalf in an ongoing dispute they had with [Facebook](/wiki/Facebook \"Facebook\") founder [Mark Zuckerberg](/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg \"Mark Zuckerberg\"). The Winklevosses believed that Zuckerberg had stolen their idea for a social networking website and launched Facebook on his own, after they had asked him to be a part of their project, then called HarvardConnection. Summers believed that the matter was outside the university's jurisdiction and advised the twins to take their complaint to the courts.{{cite news \\|first\\=Shirin \\|last\\=Sharif \\|title\\=Harvard grads face off against thefacebook.com \\|date\\=August 5, 2004 \\|publisher\\=The Stanford Daily \\|url\\=http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\\-grads\\-face\\-off\\-against\\-thefacebookcom/ \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100618102603/http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\\-grads\\-face\\-off\\-against\\-thefacebookcom/ \\|archive\\-date\\=June 18, 2010 \\|url\\-status\\=dead }}",
"#### Resignation as Harvard President",
"On February 21, 2006, Summers announced his intention to step down at the end of the school year effective June 30, 2006\\. Harvard agreed to provide Summers on his resignation with a one\\-year paid [sabbatical](/wiki/Sabbatical \"Sabbatical\") leave, subsidized a $1 million outstanding loan from the university for his personal residence, and provided other payments.President and Fellows of Harvard College, [IRS](/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Service \"Internal Revenue Service\") Form 990, 2006 \\& 2007\\. Former University President [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok \"Derek Bok\") acted as Interim President while the University conducted a search for a replacement which ended with the naming of [Drew Gilpin Faust](/wiki/Drew_Gilpin_Faust \"Drew Gilpin Faust\") on February 11, 2007\\.",
"### Post\\-Harvard presidency career",
"[right\\|thumb\\|President [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama \"Barack Obama\"), on left, discusses with a group in the White House, including Larry Summers on far right (back to camera).](/wiki/File:Barack_Obama_talks_during_the_Daily_Economic_Briefing%2C_January_2009.jpg \"Barack Obama talks during the Daily Economic Briefing, January 2009.jpg\")\nAfter a one\\-year sabbatical, Summers subsequently accepted Harvard University's invitation to serve as the [Charles W. Eliot](/wiki/Charles_W._Eliot \"Charles W. Eliot\") University Professor, one of 20 [select University\\-wide professorships](/wiki/Harvard_University_Professor \"Harvard University Professor\"), with offices in the Kennedy School of Government and the Harvard Business School.{{cite news \\|last\\=Schuker\\|first\\=Daniel J. T.\\|title\\=Summers Named Eliot Univ. Prof\\|date\\=July 7, 2006\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Harvard Crimson]]\\|url\\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref\\=513918}} In 2006 he was also a member of the Panel of Eminent Persons which reviewed the work of the [United Nations Conference on Trade and Development](/wiki/United_Nations_Conference_on_Trade_and_Development \"United Nations Conference on Trade and Development\"). He is a member in the [Group of Thirty](/wiki/Group_of_Thirty \"Group of Thirty\"). He also currently serves on the [Berggruen Institute](/wiki/Berggruen_Institute \"Berggruen Institute\")'s 21st Century Council and was part of a 2015 Berggruen\\-organized meeting with Chinese president [Xi Jinping](/wiki/Xi_Jinping \"Xi Jinping\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://governance.berggruen.org/councils/21st\\-century\\-council/members\\|title\\=Berggruen Institute\\|access\\-date\\=April 17, 2017\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180613084722/http://governance.berggruen.org/councils/21st\\-century\\-council/members\\|archive\\-date\\=June 13, 2018\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}[\"Why Nicolas Berggruen is Creating an Institute for Geniuses\"](http://www.townandcountrymag.com/society/money-and-power/a5994/nicolas-berggreun-interview/), *[Town and Country](/wiki/Town_and_Country_%28magazine%29 \"Town and Country (magazine)\"),* May 11, 2016\\. \"Another wing of the Berggruen Institute has technologists like Elon Musk and Twitter co\\-founder Jack Dorsey, as well as former treasury secretary Larry Summers.\"",
"### Business interests",
"On October 19, 2006, Summers was hired as a part\\-time managing director of the New York\\-based hedge fund [D. E. Shaw \\& Co.](/wiki/D._E._Shaw_%26_Co. \"D. E. Shaw & Co.\") for which he received $5 million in salary and other compensation over a 16\\-month period.{{cite news \\|last\\=Levy\\|first\\=Ari\\|title\\=Summers Joins Andreessen Horowitz as a Part\\-Time Adviser to Entrepreneurs\\|date\\=June 30, 2011\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News\\|Bloomberg]]\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011\\-06\\-29/lawrence\\-summers\\-joins\\-andreessen\\-horowitz\\-as\\-an\\-adviser\\-to\\-venture\\-firm.html}} At the same time Summers earned $2\\.7 million in speaking fees from major financial institutions, including [Goldman Sachs](/wiki/Goldman_Sachs \"Goldman Sachs\"), [JPMorgan Chase](/wiki/JPMorgan_Chase \"JPMorgan Chase\"), [Citigroup](/wiki/Citigroup \"Citigroup\"), [Merrill Lynch](/wiki/Merrill_Lynch \"Merrill Lynch\") and [Lehman Brothers](/wiki/Lehman_Brothers \"Lehman Brothers\").{{cite news \\|url\\=http://www.salon.com/2009/04/04/summers/\\|title\\=Larry Summers, Tim Geithner and Wall Street's ownership of government\\|last1\\=Greenwald\\|first1\\=Glenn\\|date\\=April 4, 2009\\|work\\=\\[\\[Salon (website)\\|Salon]]\\|access\\-date\\=August 10, 2013}} Upon being nominated Treasury Secretary by President Clinton in 1999, Summers listed assets of about $900,000 and debts, including a mortgage, of $500,000\\. By the time he returned in 2009 to serve in the Obama administration, he reported a net worth between $17 million and $39 million. He is a former member of the Steering Committee of the [Bilderberg Group](/wiki/Bilderberg_Group \"Bilderberg Group\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.bilderbergmeetings.org/former\\-steering\\-committee\\-members.html \\|title\\=Former Steering Committee Members \\|work\\=bilderbergmeetings.org \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Bilderberg Group]] \\|access\\-date\\=February 8, 2014 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140202095633/http://www.bilderbergmeetings.org/former\\-steering\\-committee\\-members.html \\|archive\\-date\\=February 2, 2014 }} In 2013, Summers became an early angel investor in India's first car rental company, [Zoomcar](/wiki/Zoomcar \"Zoomcar\"), which was started by his former [Harvard](/wiki/Harvard \"Harvard\") Teaching Fellow.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2013/08/08/indian\\-drivers\\-attract\\-fed\\-hopeful\\-larry\\-summers/\\|title\\=Indian Drivers Attract Larry Summers\\|first\\=W. S. J.\\|last\\=Staff\\|date\\=August 8, 2013\\|website\\=WSJ.com\\|access\\-date\\=November 8, 2017}}",
"### National Economic Council",
"Upon the inauguration of [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama \"Barack Obama\") as president in January 2009, Summers was appointed to the post of director of the [National Economic Council](/wiki/National_Economic_Council_%28United_States%29 \"National Economic Council (United States)\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp\\-dyn/content/article/2010/09/21/AR2010092104828\\.html\\|title\\=Lawrence Summers to leave economic council, return to Harvard\\|last\\=Montgomery\\|first\\=Lori\\|date\\=September 22, 2010\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]]\\|access\\-date\\=August 7, 2017\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0190\\-8286}} In this position Summers emerged as a key economic decision\\-maker in the Obama administration, where he attracted both praise and criticism. There had been friction between Summers and former Federal Reserve Chairman [Paul Volcker](/wiki/Paul_Volcker \"Paul Volcker\"), as Volcker accused Summers of delaying the effort to organize a panel of outside economic advisers, and Summers had cut Volcker out of White House meetings and had not shown interest in collaborating on policy solutions to the economic crisis.{{cite news \\| last\\=Schmidt \\| first\\=Robert \\|author2\\=Julianna Goldman\\|title\\=Volcker Chafes at Obama Panel Delay, Strains With Summers Rise\\|work\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News\\|Bloomberg]]\\|date\\=February 5, 2009\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid\\=washingtonstory\\&sid\\=aaLzJZKNcc6Y}} On the other hand, Obama himself was reportedly thrilled with the work Summers did in his first few weeks on the job. And [Peter Orszag](/wiki/Peter_Orszag \"Peter Orszag\"), another top economic advisor, called Summers \"one of the world's most brilliant economists.\"{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/08/us/politics/08team.html\\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|title\\=Obama's Economic Circle Keeps Tensions High\\|first\\=Jackie\\|last\\=Calmes\\|date\\=June 8, 2009\\|access\\-date\\=April 4, 2010}} According to [Henry Kissinger](/wiki/Henry_Kissinger \"Henry Kissinger\") Larry Summers should \"be given a White House post in which he was charged with shooting down or fixing bad ideas.\"{{cite news\n \\|last\\=Leonhardt\\|first\\=David\\|author\\-link\\=David Leonhardt\\|title\\=The Return of Larry Summers\\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=November 25, 2008\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/26/business/economy/26leonhardt.html}}",
"In January 2009, as the [Obama Administration](/wiki/Obama_Administration \"Obama Administration\") tried to pass an economic stimulus spending bill, Representative [Peter DeFazio](/wiki/Peter_DeFazio \"Peter DeFazio\") ([D](/wiki/U.S._Democratic_Party \"U.S. Democratic Party\")\\-[OR.](/wiki/Oregon \"Oregon\")) criticized Summers, saying that he thought that President [Barack Obama](/wiki/Barack_Obama \"Barack Obama\") is \"ill\\-advised by Larry Summers. Larry Summers hates infrastructure.\"{{cite news \\|last\\=DeFazio\\|first\\=Peter\\|author2\\=Video Interview\\|title\\=DeFazio Slams Summers\\|date\\=January 2008\\|url\\=http://firedoglake.com/2009/01/23/defazio\\-smacks\\-larry\\-summers\\-for\\-being\\-anti\\-infrastructure/}} DeFazio, along with liberal economists including [Paul Krugman](/wiki/Paul_Krugman \"Paul Krugman\") and [Joseph Stiglitz](/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz \"Joseph Stiglitz\"), had argued that more of the stimulus should be spent on infrastructure,{{cite news\n \\|last\\=Krugman\\|first\\=Paul\\|title\\=Stimulus Arithmetic (wonkish but important)\\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=January 6, 2009\\|url\\=https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/01/06/stimulus\\-arithmetic\\-wonkish\\-but\\-important/}} while Summers had supported tax cuts.[\"Sean Grady: Shootout at Jackson Hole: The World's Central Bankers Take Aim at Deflation.\"](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/sean-ogrady-shoot-out-at-jackson-hole--the-worlds-central-bankers-take-aim-at-deflation-2063222.html) *The Independent*. August 14, 2010\\. In late 2008, Summers and economic advisors for then\\-President\\-elect Obama presented a memo with options for an economic stimulus package ranging from $550 billion to $900 billion.{{cite magazine\n \\|last\\=Lizza\\|first\\=Ryan\\|title\\=The Obama memos\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[The New Yorker]]\\|date\\=January 30, 2012\\|url\\=https://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/01/30/120130fa\\_fact\\_lizza}} According to *[The New Republic](/wiki/The_New_Republic \"The New Republic\")*, economic advisor [Christina Romer](/wiki/Christina_Romer \"Christina Romer\") initially recommended a $1\\.8\\-trillion package, which proposal Summers quickly rejected, believing any stimulus approaching $1 trillion would not pass through Congress. Romer revised her recommendation to $1\\.2 trillion, which Summers agreed to include in the memo, but Summers struck the figure at the last minute.{{cite magazine \\|last\\=Scheiber\\|first\\=Noam\\|title\\=The Memo that Larry Summers Didn't Want Obama to See\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[The New Republic]]\\|date\\=February 22, 2012\\|url\\=http://www.tnr.com/article/politics/100961/memo\\-Larry\\-Summers\\-Obama}}",
"According to *[the Wall Street Journal](/wiki/The_Wall_Street_Journal \"The Wall Street Journal\")*, Summers called Senator [Chris Dodd](/wiki/Chris_Dodd \"Chris Dodd\") (D\\-[CT](/wiki/Connecticut \"Connecticut\")) asking him to remove caps on executive pay at firms that have received stimulus money, including Citigroup.{{cite news \\|last\\=Soloman\\|first\\=Deborah\\|author2\\=Mark Maremont\\|title\\=Bankers Face Strict Pay Cap\\|pages\\=1, above the fold\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Wall Street Journal]]\\|date\\=February 14–15, 2009}}",
"On April 3, 2009, Summers came under renewed criticism after it was disclosed that he was paid millions of dollars the previous year by companies which he now had influence over as a [public servant](/wiki/Public_servant \"Public servant\"). He earned $5 million from the [hedge fund](/wiki/Hedge_fund \"Hedge fund\") D. E. Shaw and collected $2\\.7 million in speaking fees from [Wall Street](/wiki/Wall_Street \"Wall Street\") companies that received government [bailout](/wiki/Bailout \"Bailout\") money.{{cite news \\|first\\=Jeff\\|last\\=Zeleny\\|title\\=Financial Industry Paid Millions to Obama Aide\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/04/us/politics/04disclose.html\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=April 3, 2009\\|access\\-date\\=April 4, 2009}}",
"### Post\\-NEC career",
"[thumb\\|Summers with [Volodymyr Groysman](/wiki/Volodymyr_Groysman \"Volodymyr Groysman\") in [Ukraine](/wiki/Ukraine \"Ukraine\")](/wiki/File:Volodymyr_Groysman_and_Lawrence_Summers_in_Ukraine_-_2018_%28MUS6894%29.jpg \"Volodymyr Groysman and Lawrence Summers in Ukraine - 2018 (MUS6894).jpg\")\nSince leaving the NEC in December 2010, Summers has worked as an advisor to hedge fund [D. E. Shaw \\& Co](/wiki/D._E._Shaw_%26_Co \"D. E. Shaw & Co\"), Citigroup and the [NASDAQ OMX Group](/wiki/NASDAQ_OMX_Group \"NASDAQ OMX Group\") while resuming his role as a tenured Harvard professor.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013\\-08\\-02/summers\\-after\\-government\\-saw\\-wealth\\-surge\\-to\\-17\\-million.html\\|title\\=Summers After Government Saw Wealth Surge to $17 Million\\|last1\\=Benson\\|first1\\=Clea\\|date\\=August 2, 2013\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg L.P.]]\\|access\\-date\\=August 10, 2013}} In June 2011 Summers joined the board of directors of [Square](/wiki/Square_%28payment_service%29 \"Square (payment service)\"), a company developing an electronic payment service,TechCrunch (2011\\). [Square Adds Former U.S. Secretary Of The Treasury Larry Summers To Board](https://techcrunch.com/2011/06/22/square-adds-former-u-s-secretary-of-the-treasury-larry-summers-to-board/). Retrieved June 24, 2011\\. and became a special adviser at venture capital firm [Andreessen Horowitz](/wiki/Andreessen_Horowitz \"Andreessen Horowitz\").Dealbook (2011\\). [Larry Summers Joins Andreessen Horowitz](https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/06/29/larry-summers-joins-andreessen-horowitz/?hp). Retrieved June 30, 2011\\. He joined the board of person\\-to\\-person lending company [Lending Club](/wiki/Lending_Club \"Lending Club\") in December 2012\\.TechCrunch (2012\\). [With An IPO On Its Radar, Lending Club Adds Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers To Its Heavyweight Board](https://techcrunch.com/2012/12/13/with-an-ipo-on-its-radar-lending-club-adds-former-treasury-secretary-larry-summers-to-its-heavyweight-board/). Retrieved December 12, 2012\\. In July 2015 Summers joined the Board of Directors of [Premise Data](/wiki/Premise_Data \"Premise Data\"), a San Francisco\\-based data and analytics technology company that sources data from a global network of on\\-the\\-ground contributors.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://medium.com/@premisedata/welcoming\\-larry\\-summers\\-to\\-premise\\-s\\-board\\-of\\-directors\\-65411a2b9842\\|title\\=Welcoming Larry Summers to Premise's Board of Directors\\|last\\=Data\\|first\\=Premise\\|date\\=July 16, 2015\\|website\\=Medium\\|access\\-date\\=February 22, 2018}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/04/04/larry\\-summers\\-data\\-collection\\-is\\-the\\-ultimate\\-public\\-good/\\|title\\=Larry Summers: Data collection is the ultimate public good\\|last\\=Summers\\|first\\=Lawrence H.\\|date\\=April 4, 2016\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]]\\|access\\-date\\=February 22, 2018\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0190\\-8286}}",
"In April 2016, he was one of eight former Treasury secretaries who called on the [United Kingdom](/wiki/United_Kingdom \"United Kingdom\") to remain a member of the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union \"European Union\") ahead of the [June 2016 Referendum](/wiki/2016_United_Kingdom_European_Union_membership_referendum \"2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum\").{{cite news\\|title\\=Staying in EU 'best hope' for UK's future say ex\\-US Treasury secretaries\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk\\-politics\\-eu\\-referendum\\-36087583\\|work\\=\\[\\[BBC News]]\\|date\\=April 20, 2016}}",
"Summers referred to the United Kingdom's Brexit vote on June 23, 2016, in favor of leaving the European Union as the \"worst self\\-inflicted policy wound that a country has done since the Second World War\". However, Summers cautioned that the result was a \"wake up call for elites everywhere\" and called for \"responsible nationalism\" in response to simmering public sentiment.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.marketplace.org/2016/06/24/world/lawrence\\-summers\\-brexit\\-wakeup\\-call\\-elites\\|title\\=Lawrence Summers on Brexit: A wakeup call for elites\\|date\\=June 24, 2016\\|access\\-date\\=July 15, 2016}}",
"In June 2016, Summers also wrote, \"I believe the risks to the US and global economies of Mr Trump's election as president are far greater \\[than passage of Brexit]. If he is elected, I would expect a protracted recession to begin within 18 months. The damage would be felt far beyond the United States.\"{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://larrysummers.com/2016/06/06/the\\-economic\\-consequences\\-of\\-a\\-trump\\-win\\-would\\-be\\-severe/\\|title\\=The economic consequences of a Trump win would be severe \\| Larry Summers\\|date\\=June 6, 2016 }}",
"### 2020 presidential election",
"A coalition of progressive groups called on [Joe Biden](/wiki/Joe_Biden \"Joe Biden\")'s [2020 presidential campaign](/wiki/Joe_Biden_2020_presidential_campaign \"Joe Biden 2020 presidential campaign\") no longer to use Summers as an advisor, after reports surfaced that Summers was advising the campaign on economic policy.{{Cite web\\|last\\=Moreno\\|first\\=J. Edward\\|date\\=May 6, 2020\\|title\\=Progressive groups renew push to oust Larry Summers from Biden campaign citing environmental concerns\\|url\\=https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/496352\\-progressive\\-group\\-renews\\-push\\-to\\-oust\\-larry\\-summers\\-from\\-biden\\-campaign\\|access\\-date\\=September 16, 2020\\|website\\=\\[\\[The Hill (newspaper)\\|The Hill]]}} Progressive groups like the [Sunrise Movement](/wiki/Sunrise_Movement \"Sunrise Movement\") and [Justice Democrats](/wiki/Justice_Democrats \"Justice Democrats\") petitioned the campaign to disavow Summers, saying, \"Summers's legacy is advocating for policies that contributed to the skyrocketing inequality and climate crisis we're living with today.\"{{Cite web\\|last\\=Golshan\\|first\\=Tara\\|date\\=April 24, 2020\\|title\\=Joe Biden Under Pressure From Progressives To Cut Out Larry Summers\\|url\\=https://www.huffpost.com/entry/biden\\-larry\\-summers\\-progressives\\_n\\_5ea3315bc5b6d376358f3670?guccounter\\=1\\&guce\\_referrer\\=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8\\&guce\\_referrer\\_sig\\=AQAAALmvgHjs6ndwwMw8S1\\-kyuEgFCSUaHGkBXxw5BD1CP76GJFXrVMHJPwfF9TKd2ca\\-r9t\\-cs\\-7q7Z6YmJg7fYEAViNYTSf6GxdcjkIurSeKgB\\_4rFDSwysaoN\\-UmnbDWp0Dr2C3nQxvZgICzjCDDXmH1k08jvRO0gpVkpI1Sz6Nwb\\|access\\-date\\=September 16, 2020\\|website\\=\\[\\[HuffPost]]}} Following the outcry, Summers stated he would not be joining a future Biden administration, in the event that Biden defeated [Donald Trump](/wiki/Donald_Trump \"Donald Trump\") in the [2020 presidential election](/wiki/2020_United_States_presidential_election \"2020 United States presidential election\").{{Cite web\\|last\\=Matthews\\|first\\=Steve\\|date\\=August 6, 2020\\|title\\=Larry Summers Rules Out Taking a Job in a Biden Administration\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020\\-08\\-06/summers\\-adviser\\-to\\-biden\\-says\\-his\\-time\\-in\\-government\\-is\\-over?sref\\=6OyUvLUJ\\|access\\-date\\=September 16, 2020\\|website\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News\\|Bloomberg]]}}",
"### Candidacy for chairmanship of the Federal Reserve and governorship of the Bank of Israel",
"In 2013, Summers emerged as one of two leading candidates, along with [Janet Yellen](/wiki/Janet_Yellen \"Janet Yellen\"), to succeed [Ben Bernanke](/wiki/Ben_Bernanke \"Ben Bernanke\") as [chair of the Federal Reserve](/wiki/Chair_of_the_Federal_Reserve \"Chair of the Federal Reserve\"). The possibility of his nomination created a great deal of controversy with some senators of both parties declaring opposition. On September 15, Summers withdrew his name from consideration for the position, writing: \"I have reluctantly concluded that any possible confirmation process for me would be acrimonious and would not serve the interest of the Federal Reserve, the Administration or, ultimately, the interests of the nation's ongoing economic recovery.\"{{cite web \\|title\\=Larry Summers withdraws name for Fed chair job \\|first1\\=Annalyn\\|last1\\=Kurtz \\|first2\\=Hibah \\|last2\\=Yousuf\\|work\\=\\[\\[CNNMoney]]\\|date\\=September 15, 2013\\|access\\-date\\=September 15, 2013\\|url\\=https://money.cnn.com/2013/09/15/news/economy/fed\\-chair\\-larry\\-summers\\-withdraws/?hpt\\=hp\\_t2\\|quote\\=After months of contentious public debate, Larry Summers has withdrawn his name from consideration to become the next chairman of the Federal Reserve. President Obama said he spoke with Summers earlier Sunday and accepted his decision.}}{{cite news \\|title\\=Summers Pulls Name From Consideration for Fed Chief\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|author\\-link1\\=Annie Lowrey\\|first1\\=Annie\\|last1\\=Lowrey\\|author\\-link2\\=Binyamin Appelbaum\\|first2\\=Binyamin\\|last2\\=Appelbaum\\|date\\=September 15, 2013\\|access\\-date\\=September 16, 2013\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/16/business/economy/summers\\-pulls\\-name\\-from\\-consideration\\-for\\-fed\\-chief.html?hp\\&\\_r\\=0\\|quote\\=Facing growing opposition in Congress, Lawrence H. Summers, the former Treasury secretary and a top contender for Federal Reserve chairman, told President Obama that he didn't want to be considered for the job.}}",
"During the 2013, Summers had been reported as preferred candidate by the [Cabinet of Israel](/wiki/Cabinet_of_Israel \"Cabinet of Israel\") and Prime Minister [Benjamin Netanyahu](/wiki/Benjamin_Netanyahu \"Benjamin Netanyahu\") to succeed [Stanley Fischer](/wiki/Stanley_Fischer \"Stanley Fischer\") as governor of the [Bank of Israel](/wiki/Bank_of_Israel \"Bank of Israel\"). Netanyahu personally asked him to take the post, an offer he turned down.{{Cite news \\|last\\=Simpson \\|first\\=Connor \\|date\\=October 19, 2013 \\|title\\=Larry Summers Snubbed Netanyahu's Offer to Run Israel's Banks \\|url\\=https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/10/natanyahu\\-wants\\-larry\\-summers\\-running\\-israels\\-banks/309791/ \\|archive\\-url\\= \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Atlantic]] \\|archive\\-date\\= \\|access\\-date\\=October 20, 2013}}{{cite news \\|author\\= \\|title\\=Larry Summers rejects offer to become BoI governor\n\\|url\\=https://en.globes.co.il/en/article\\-1000886969 \\|archive\\-url\\= \\|archive\\-date\\= \\|work\\=Globes \\|date\\=October 20, 2013 \\|access\\-date\\=October 21, 2013}}",
"### Criticism of the Biden Administration, 2021",
"Summers emerged as an early opponent of President [Joe Biden](/wiki/Joe_Biden \"Joe Biden\")'s economic policy, calling the $1\\.9 trillion [American Rescue Plan Act of 2021](/wiki/American_Rescue_Plan_Act_of_2021 \"American Rescue Plan Act of 2021\") \"the least responsible macroeconomic policy we've had in the last 40 years\" and arguing that it risked economic recession and market destabilization.{{Cite web\\|last\\=Williams\\|first\\=Jordan\\|date\\=March 20, 2021\\|title\\=Larry Summers blasts $1\\.9 T stimulus as 'least responsible' economic policy in 40 years\\|url\\=https://thehill.com/policy/finance/544188\\-larry\\-summers\\-blasts\\-least\\-responsible\\-economic\\-policy\\-in\\-40\\-years\\|access\\-date\\=April 25, 2021\\|website\\=\\[\\[The Hill (newspaper)\\|The Hill]]\\|language\\=en}}",
"### Hamas\\-led attack on Israel",
"In October 2023, following the [Hamas\\-led attack on Israel](/wiki/2023_Hamas-led_attack_on_Israel \"2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel\"), several [Harvard](/wiki/Harvard_University \"Harvard University\") undergraduate student groups signed a letter condemning the [Israeli state](/wiki/Israeli_state \"Israeli state\"), and holding the \"Israeli regime entirely responsible for all unfolding violence\".{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.the\\-independent.com/news/world/americas/us\\-politics/harvard\\-letter\\-war\\-israel\\-hamas\\-b2427497\\.html\\|title\\=Letter from Harvard group holding Israel 'responsible' for war with Hamas sparks backlash\\|publisher\\=Independent\\|access\\-date\\=October 17, 2023}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://edition.cnn.com/2023/10/11/business/harvard\\-israel\\-hamas\\-ceos\\-students/index.html\\|title\\=Harvard student groups issued an anti\\-Israel statement. CEOs want them blacklisted\\|publisher\\=CNN\\|access\\-date\\=October 17, 2023}} This letter from Harvard University student groups blaming Israel drew a backlash from several prominent alumni and from Larry Summers, who said that he was \"sickened\" by it.{{Cite web \\|date\\=October 10, 2023 \\|title\\=Growing backlash over Harvard students' pro\\-Palestine letter \\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-us\\-canada\\-67067565\\|access\\-date\\=December 7, 2023 \\|website\\= BBC News\\|language\\=en\\-US}} Summers, though agreeing with [Bill Ackman](/wiki/Bill_Ackman \"Bill Ackman\") on the need to look at employees' political views, called Ackman's request to release the names of all the students involved in signing the letter \"the stuff of [Joe McCarthy](/wiki/Joe_McCarthy \"Joe McCarthy\")\".{{Cite web \\|last\\=Teo \\|first\\=Kai Xiang \\|title\\=Former Harvard president Larry Summers thinks Bill Ackman asking for lists of student names is the 'stuff of Joe McCarthy' \\|url\\=https://www.businessinsider.com/harvard\\-larry\\-summers\\-bill\\-ackman\\-israel\\-hamas\\-student\\-names\\-list\\-2023\\-10 \\|access\\-date\\=October 17, 2023 \\|website\\=Business Insider \\|language\\=en\\-US}} Summers has repeatedly criticized the Harvard administration for its failure to curb what he sees as rising antisemitism at the university since the Hamas attack.{{Cite web \\|last\\=Ebbert \\|first\\=Stephanie \\|last2\\= \\|first2\\= \\|last3\\= \\|first3\\= \\|last4\\= \\|last5\\= \\|first5\\= \\|title\\=Larry Summers was ousted as Harvard president. He has a lot to say about what's wrong with the university now. \\- The Boston Globe \\|url\\=https://www.bostonglobe.com/2024/03/21/metro/larry\\-summers\\-vocal\\-critic\\-of\\-harvard\\-successors/ \\|access\\-date\\=March 22, 2024 \\|website\\=BostonGlobe.com \\|language\\=en\\-US}}",
""
] |
### President of Harvard
In 2001, when [George W. Bush](/wiki/George_W._Bush "George W. Bush") became [President](/wiki/President_of_the_United_States "President of the United States"), Summers left the Treasury Department and returned to Harvard as its 27th president, serving from July 2001 until June 2006\. He was Harvard's first Jewish president,*YUNews* [Director of the National Economic Council, Dr. Lawrence H. Summers, is Keynote Speaker at Yeshiva University's Annual Hanukkah Dinner and Convocation on December 13](https://www.yu.edu/news/director-of-the-national-economic-council-dr-lawrence-h-summers-is-keynote-speaker-at-yeshiva-universitys-annual-hanukkah-dinner-and-convocation-on-december-13), November 18, 2009*The Harvard Crimson* [Did Summers' Faith Affect His Fall?](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/3/3/did-summers-faith-affect-his-fall/), March 3, 2006*The Harvard Crimson* [A Milestone of Faith](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2001/10/14/a-milestone-of-faith-in-1922/), October 14, 2001 though his predecessor Neil Rudenstine's father was Jewish.[Harvard's First Jewish President](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511933). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson"). March 8, 2006
A number of Summers's decisions at Harvard have attracted public controversy, either at the time or since his resignation.
#### Cornel West affair
In an October 2001 meeting, Summers criticized African American Studies department head [Cornel West](/wiki/Cornel_West "Cornel West") for allegedly missing three weeks of classes to work on the [Bill Bradley](/wiki/Bill_Bradley "Bill Bradley") presidential campaign and complained that West was contributing to [grade inflation](/wiki/Grade_inflation "Grade inflation"). Summers also claimed that West's "rap" album was an "embarrassment" to the university. West pushed back strongly against the accusations.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2006/06/06/some\_seek\_a\_scholars\_return/\|title\=Some seek a scholar's return\|work\=\[\[The Boston Globe]]\|date\=June 6, 2006\|first1\=Marcella\|last1\=Bombardieri}} "The hip\-hop scared him. It's a stereotypical reaction", he said later. West, who later called Summers both "uninformed" and "an unprincipled power player" in describing this encounter in his book *Democracy Matters* (2004\), subsequently returned to [Princeton University](/wiki/Princeton_University "Princeton University"), where he had taught prior to [Harvard University](/wiki/Harvard_University "Harvard University").
#### Differences between the sexes
{{See also\|Women in science}}
In January 2005, at a Conference on Diversifying the Science \& Engineering Workforce sponsored by the [National Bureau of Economic Research](/wiki/National_Bureau_of_Economic_Research "National Bureau of Economic Research"), Summers sparked controversy with his discussion of why women may have been underrepresented "in tenured positions in science and engineering at top universities and research institutions". The conference was designed to be off\-the\-record so that participants could speak candidly without fear of public misunderstanding or disclosure later.{{cite news \|last1\=Dillon \|first1\=Sam \|title\=Harvard Chief Defends His Talk on Women \|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]] \|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/18/us/harvard\-chief\-defends\-his\-talk\-on\-women.html \|access\-date\=February 13, 2022 \|date\=February 18, 2005}}
Summers had prefaced his talk, saying he was adopting an "entirely [positive](/wiki/Positivism "Positivism"), rather than [normative](/wiki/Normative "Normative") approach" and that his remarks were intended to be an "attempt at provocation".{{cite web\|url\=http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \|title\=Archive of: Remarks at NBER Conference on Diversifying the Science \& Engineering Workforce \|access\-date\=January 30, 2008 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \|archive\-date\=January 30, 2008 }}. January 14, 2005\.
Summers then began by identifying three hypotheses for the higher proportion of men in high\-end science and engineering positions:
1. The high\-powered job hypothesis
2. Different availability of [aptitude](/wiki/Aptitude "Aptitude") at the high end
3. Different socialization and patterns of discrimination in a search
The second hypothesis, the generally [greater variability among men](/wiki/Variability_hypothesis "Variability hypothesis") (compared to women) in tests of cognitive abilities,Hedges, L. V., \& Nowell, A. (1995\). "Sex differences in mental scores, variability, and numbers of high scoring individuals". *Science*, 269, 41–45\.Lehrke, R. (1997\). *Sex linkage of intelligence: The X\-Factor*. New York: Praeger.Lubinski, D., \& Benbow, C. M. (2006\). "Study of mathematically precocious youth after 35 years". *Perspectives on Psychological Science*, 1, 316–345\. leading to proportionally more males than females at both the lower and upper tails of the test score distributions, caused the most controversy. In his discussion of this hypothesis, Summers said that "even small differences in the standard deviation \[between genders] will translate into very large differences in the available pool substantially out \[from the mean]". Summers referenced research that implied differences between the standard deviations of males and females in the top 5% of twelfth graders under various tests. He then went on to argue that, if this research were to be accepted, then "whatever the set of attributes ... that are precisely defined to correlate with being an aeronautical engineer at MIT or being a chemist at Berkeley ... are probably different in their standard deviations as well".
Summers then concluded his discussion of the three hypotheses by saying:
> So my best guess, to provoke you, of what's behind all of this is that the largest phenomenon, by far, is the general clash between people's legitimate family desires and employers' current desire for high power and high intensity, that in the special case of science and engineering, there are issues of intrinsic aptitude, and particularly of the variability of aptitude, and that those considerations are reinforced by what are in fact lesser factors involving socialization and continuing discrimination. I would like nothing better than to be proved wrong, because I would like nothing better than for these problems to be addressable simply by everybody understanding what they are, and working very hard to address them.
Summers then went on to discuss approaches to remedying the shortage of women in high\-end science and engineering positions.
This lunch\-time talk drew accusations of sexism and careless scholarship, and an intense negative response followed, both nationally and at Harvard.[Summers' Remarks on Women Draw Fire](https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2005/01/17/summers_remarks_on_women_draw_fire/){{dead link\|date\=March 2024}}. The Boston Globe. January 17, 2005 Summers apologized repeatedly.{{cite magazine \|last\=Saletan\|first\=William\|author\-link\=William Saletan\|date\=January 21, 2005\|title\=Don't Worry Your Pretty Little Head\|url\=http://www.slate.com/id/2112570/\|magazine\=\[\[Slate (magazine)\|Slate]]}} Nevertheless, the controversy is speculated to have contributed to his resigning his position as president of Harvard University the following year, as well as costing Summers the job of [Treasury Secretary](/wiki/Treasury_Secretary "Treasury Secretary") in [Obama's administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Barack_Obama "Presidency of Barack Obama").[Summers's 'sexism' costs him top Treasury job](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/summersrsquo-lsquosexismrsquo-costs-him-top-treasury-job-1033373.html). [The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent "The Independent"). November 24, 2008
Summers's protégée [Sheryl Sandberg](/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg "Sheryl Sandberg") has defended him, saying that "Larry has been a true advocate for women throughout his career" at the World Bank and Treasury. Referring to the lunch talk, Sandberg said, "What few seem to note is that it is remarkable that he was giving the speech in the first place – that he cared enough about women's careers and their trajectory in the fields of math and science to proactively analyze the issues and talk about what was going wrong".{{cite news\|author\=Sheryl Sandberg\|title\=Larry Summers' True Record on Women\|url\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/sheryl\-sandberg/what\-larry\-summers\-has\-do\_b\_142126\.html\|access\-date\=January 4, 2014\|newspaper\=\[\[HuffPost]]\|date\=November 7, 2008\|author\-link\=Sheryl Sandberg}}
In 2016, remarking upon [political correctness](/wiki/Political_correctness "Political correctness") in institutions of higher education, Summers said:
> There is a great deal of absurd political correctness. Now, I'm somebody who believes very strongly in diversity, who resists racism in all of its many incarnations, who thinks that there is a great deal that's unjust in American society that needs to be combated, but it seems to be that there is a kind of creeping totalitarianism in terms of what kind of ideas are acceptable and are debatable on college campuses.{{cite web\|url\=http://conversationswithbillkristol.org/video/larry\-summers\-ii/?start\=15\&end\=1606\|title\=Larry Summers II on Conversations with Bill Kristol\|website\=ConversationsWithBillKristol.org\|access\-date\=November 8, 2017}}
#### Summers' opposition and support at Harvard
On March 15, 2005, members of the [Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Faculty_of_Arts_and_Sciences "Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences"), which instructs graduate students in [Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Graduate_School_of_Arts_and_Sciences "Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences") and undergraduates in [Harvard College](/wiki/Harvard_College "Harvard College"), passed 218–185 a motion of "lack of confidence" in the leadership of Summers, with 18 abstentions. A second motion that offered a milder censure of the president passed 253 to 137, also with 18 abstentions.
The members of the [Harvard Corporation](/wiki/Harvard_Corporation "Harvard Corporation"), the University's highest governing body, are in charge of the selection of the president and issued statements strongly supporting Summers.
FAS faculty were not unanimous in their comments against Summers. Psychologist [Steven Pinker](/wiki/Steven_Pinker "Steven Pinker") defended the legitimacy of Summers's January lecture. When asked if Summers's talk was "within the pale of legitimate academic discourse," Pinker responded "Good grief, shouldn't everything be within the pale of legitimate academic discourse, as long as it is presented with some degree of rigor? That's the difference between a university and a [madrassa](/wiki/Madrassa "Madrassa"). There is certainly enough evidence for the hypothesis to be taken seriously."[Psychoanalysis Q\-and\-A: Steven Pinker](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2005/1/19/psychoanalysis-q-and-a-steven-pinker-in-an/). *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson")*. January 19, 2005
Summers had stronger support among Harvard College students than among the college faculty. One poll by *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson")* indicated that students opposed his resignation by a three\-to\-one margin, with 57% of responding students opposing his resignation and 19% supporting it.[Poll: Students Say Summers Should Stay](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511421). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson "The Harvard Crimson"). February 20, 2006
In July 2005, a board member of Harvard Corporation, [Conrad K. Harper](/wiki/Conrad_K._Harper "Conrad K. Harper"), resigned saying he was angered both by the university president's comments about women and by Summers being given a salary increase. The resignation letter to the president said, "I could not and cannot support a raise in your salary, ... I believe that Harvard's best interests require your resignation."{{cite news\|last\=Finder\|first\=Alan\|title\=A Harvard Governor, Dissatisfied, Resigns\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/29/education/29harvard.html?\_r\=0\|access\-date\=December 5, 2013\|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|date\=July 29, 2005}}[Board Member's Letter of Resignation](https://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/02/education/02htext.html). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times"). August 2, 2005
#### Support of economist Andrei Shleifer
Harvard and [Andrei Shleifer](/wiki/Andrei_Shleifer "Andrei Shleifer"), a close friend and protégé of Summers, controversially paid $28\.5 million to settle a [lawsuit](/wiki/Lawsuit "Lawsuit") by the U.S. government over the [conflict of interest](/wiki/Conflict_of_interest "Conflict of interest") Shleifer had while advising [Russia's privatization program](/wiki/Russia%27s_privatization_program "Russia's privatization program"). The US government had sued Shleifer under the [False Claims Act](/wiki/False_Claims_Act "False Claims Act"), as he bought [Russian](/wiki/Russia "Russia") stocks while designing the country's [privatization](/wiki/Privatization "Privatization"). In 2004, a federal judge ruled that while Harvard had violated the contract, Shleifer and his associate alone were liable for [treble damages](/wiki/Treble_damages "Treble damages").
In June 2005, Harvard and Shleifer announced that they had reached a tentative settlement with the US government. In August, Harvard, Shleifer, and the [Department of Justice](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Justice "United States Department of Justice") reached an agreement under which the university paid $26\.5 million to settle the five\-year\-old lawsuit. Shleifer was also responsible for paying $2 million worth of damages.
Because Harvard paid almost all of the damages and allowed Shleifer to retain his faculty position, the settlement provoked allegations of favoritism by Summers. His continued support for Shleifer strengthened Summers's unpopularity with other professors, as reported in *The Harvard Crimson*:
{{Blockquote\|I've been a member of this Faculty for over 45 years, and I am no longer easily shocked," is how Frederick H. Abernathy, the McKay professor of mechanical engineering, began his biting comments about the Shleifer case at Tuesday's fiery Faculty meeting. But, Abernathy continued, "I was deeply shocked and disappointed by the actions of this University" in the Shleifer affair.{{cite news\|title\='Tawdry Shleifer Affair' Stokes Faculty Anger Toward Summers\|url\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/2/10/tawdry\-shleifer\-affair\-stokes\-faculty\-anger/\|access\-date\=30 May 2013\|newspaper\=\[\[The Harvard Crimson]]\|date\=10 Feb 2006\|author\=Nicholas Ciarelli\|author2\=Anton Troianovski}}}}
#### In Russia
{{See also\|Loans for shares scheme}}
An 18,000\-word article "How Harvard Lost Russia" in *[Institutional Investor](/wiki/Institutional_Investor_%28magazine%29 "Institutional Investor (magazine)")* by David McClintick detailed Shleifer's alleged efforts to use his [inside knowledge](/wiki/Insider_trading "Insider trading") of and sway over the Russian economy in order to make lucrative personal investments, all while leading a Harvard group, advising the Russian government, that was under contract with the U.S. The article suggests that Summers shielded his fellow economist from disciplinary action by the university, and it noted that Summers had forewarned Shleifer and his wife Nancy Zimmerman about the conflict\-of\-interest regulations back in 1996\.{{Cite news \|last\=McClintick \|first\=David \|date\=January 13, 2006 \|title\=How Harvard Lost Russia \|work\=Institutional Investor \|url\=https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b150npp3q49x7w/how\-harvard\-lost\-russia \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140705041205/http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/Article/1020662/How\-Harvard\-lost\-Russia.html\#/.V0mIqpF97nE \|archive\-date\=July 5, 2014}} Summers's friendship with Shleifer was well known by the corporation when it selected him to succeed Rudenstine and Summers recused himself from all proceedings with Shleifer, whose case was actually handled by an independent committee led by former Harvard president [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok "Derek Bok").
#### Connection to Jeffrey Epstein
An article in *The Harvard Crimson* in 2003, during Summers's tenure as president, detailed a reportedly "special connection" between Summers and [Jeffrey Epstein](/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein "Jeffrey Epstein").{{Cite web\|last\= Scharnick\|first\=Jaquelyn M.\|date\=May 1, 2003\|url\=https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/5/1/mogul\-donor\-gives\-harvard\-more\-than/?page\=single\|title\=Mogul Donor Gives Harvard More Than Money\|work\=\[\[The Harvard Crimson]]\|language\=en\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein pledged to donate at least $25 million to Harvard during Summers's tenure to endow Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein was given an office at Harvard for his personal use.{{Cite magazine\|url\=https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/03/jeffrey\-epstein\-200303\|title\=The Talented Mr. Epstein\|last\=Ward\|first\=Vicky\|date\=March 2003\|magazine\=\[\[Vanity Fair (magazine)\|Vanity Fair]]\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019\|quote\=Epstein has pledged at least $25 million to Harvard to create the Epstein Program for Mathematical Biology and Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein will have an office at the university...He says he was reluctant to have his name attached to the program, but Summers persuaded him. }}{{Cite web\|url\=https://ped.fas.harvard.edu/home\|title\=Program for Evolutionary Dynamics\|website\=ped.fas.harvard.edu\|language\=en\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein otherwise had no formal connection to Harvard. Summers's ties to Epstein reportedly began "a number of years...before Summers became Harvard's president and even before he was the Secretary of the Treasury." Flight records introduced as evidence in the 2021 trial of Epstein associate [Ghislaine Maxwell](/wiki/Ghislaine_Maxwell "Ghislaine Maxwell") show that Summers flew on Jeffrey Epstein's private plane on at least four occasions, including once in 1998 when Summers was [United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Deputy_Secretary_of_the_Treasury "United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury") and at least three times while Harvard president.{{Cite web\|url\=https://s3\.documentcloud.org/documents/21165424/epstein\-flight\-logs\-released\-in\-usa\-vs\-maxwell.pdf\|title\=Epstein Flight Logs Released in USA vs. Maxwell\|language\=en\|access\-date\=December 27, 2021}} A charity funded by Epstein also donated to the production of a [PBS](/wiki/PBS "PBS") show hosted by Summers's wife and Harvard professor [Elisa New](/wiki/Elisa_New "Elisa New").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey\-epstein\-has\-a\-secret\-charity\-heres\-who\-it\-gave\-money\-to?ref\=scroll\|title\=REVEALED: We Found Billionaire Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein's Secret Charity\|last\=Briquelet\|first\=Kate\|date\=July 10, 2019\|work\=\[\[The Daily Beast]]\|access\-date\=July 12, 2019\|quote\=In 2016, Gratitude America Ltd. shelled out $110,000 to Verse Video Education. The Cambridge, Massachusetts\-based nonprofit produces the PBS show Poetry in America, whose creator and host is Harvard professor Elisa New. Verse's 2016 tax return named New as the group's president but doesn't include specific donors for its $1\.38 million in total contributions. New is married to Summers, Harvard University's former president, who hobnobbed with Epstein in elite international relations groups and, like Bill Clinton, flew on Epstein's private jet.}}
#### Winklevoss twins and Facebook
In February 2004, the [Winklevoss twins](/wiki/Winklevoss_twins "Winklevoss twins") requested a meeting with Summers in order to ask him to intervene on their behalf in an ongoing dispute they had with [Facebook](/wiki/Facebook "Facebook") founder [Mark Zuckerberg](/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg "Mark Zuckerberg"). The Winklevosses believed that Zuckerberg had stolen their idea for a social networking website and launched Facebook on his own, after they had asked him to be a part of their project, then called HarvardConnection. Summers believed that the matter was outside the university's jurisdiction and advised the twins to take their complaint to the courts.{{cite news \|first\=Shirin \|last\=Sharif \|title\=Harvard grads face off against thefacebook.com \|date\=August 5, 2004 \|publisher\=The Stanford Daily \|url\=http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\-grads\-face\-off\-against\-thefacebookcom/ \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100618102603/http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\-grads\-face\-off\-against\-thefacebookcom/ \|archive\-date\=June 18, 2010 \|url\-status\=dead }}
#### Resignation as Harvard President
On February 21, 2006, Summers announced his intention to step down at the end of the school year effective June 30, 2006\. Harvard agreed to provide Summers on his resignation with a one\-year paid [sabbatical](/wiki/Sabbatical "Sabbatical") leave, subsidized a $1 million outstanding loan from the university for his personal residence, and provided other payments.President and Fellows of Harvard College, [IRS](/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Service "Internal Revenue Service") Form 990, 2006 \& 2007\. Former University President [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok "Derek Bok") acted as Interim President while the University conducted a search for a replacement which ended with the naming of [Drew Gilpin Faust](/wiki/Drew_Gilpin_Faust "Drew Gilpin Faust") on February 11, 2007\.
|
[
"### President of Harvard",
"In 2001, when [George W. Bush](/wiki/George_W._Bush \"George W. Bush\") became [President](/wiki/President_of_the_United_States \"President of the United States\"), Summers left the Treasury Department and returned to Harvard as its 27th president, serving from July 2001 until June 2006\\. He was Harvard's first Jewish president,*YUNews* [Director of the National Economic Council, Dr. Lawrence H. Summers, is Keynote Speaker at Yeshiva University's Annual Hanukkah Dinner and Convocation on December 13](https://www.yu.edu/news/director-of-the-national-economic-council-dr-lawrence-h-summers-is-keynote-speaker-at-yeshiva-universitys-annual-hanukkah-dinner-and-convocation-on-december-13), November 18, 2009*The Harvard Crimson* [Did Summers' Faith Affect His Fall?](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/3/3/did-summers-faith-affect-his-fall/), March 3, 2006*The Harvard Crimson* [A Milestone of Faith](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2001/10/14/a-milestone-of-faith-in-1922/), October 14, 2001 though his predecessor Neil Rudenstine's father was Jewish.[Harvard's First Jewish President](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511933). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\"). March 8, 2006",
"A number of Summers's decisions at Harvard have attracted public controversy, either at the time or since his resignation.",
"#### Cornel West affair",
"In an October 2001 meeting, Summers criticized African American Studies department head [Cornel West](/wiki/Cornel_West \"Cornel West\") for allegedly missing three weeks of classes to work on the [Bill Bradley](/wiki/Bill_Bradley \"Bill Bradley\") presidential campaign and complained that West was contributing to [grade inflation](/wiki/Grade_inflation \"Grade inflation\"). Summers also claimed that West's \"rap\" album was an \"embarrassment\" to the university. West pushed back strongly against the accusations.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2006/06/06/some\\_seek\\_a\\_scholars\\_return/\\|title\\=Some seek a scholar's return\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Boston Globe]]\\|date\\=June 6, 2006\\|first1\\=Marcella\\|last1\\=Bombardieri}} \"The hip\\-hop scared him. It's a stereotypical reaction\", he said later. West, who later called Summers both \"uninformed\" and \"an unprincipled power player\" in describing this encounter in his book *Democracy Matters* (2004\\), subsequently returned to [Princeton University](/wiki/Princeton_University \"Princeton University\"), where he had taught prior to [Harvard University](/wiki/Harvard_University \"Harvard University\").",
"#### Differences between the sexes",
"{{See also\\|Women in science}}",
"In January 2005, at a Conference on Diversifying the Science \\& Engineering Workforce sponsored by the [National Bureau of Economic Research](/wiki/National_Bureau_of_Economic_Research \"National Bureau of Economic Research\"), Summers sparked controversy with his discussion of why women may have been underrepresented \"in tenured positions in science and engineering at top universities and research institutions\". The conference was designed to be off\\-the\\-record so that participants could speak candidly without fear of public misunderstanding or disclosure later.{{cite news \\|last1\\=Dillon \\|first1\\=Sam \\|title\\=Harvard Chief Defends His Talk on Women \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/18/us/harvard\\-chief\\-defends\\-his\\-talk\\-on\\-women.html \\|access\\-date\\=February 13, 2022 \\|date\\=February 18, 2005}}",
"Summers had prefaced his talk, saying he was adopting an \"entirely [positive](/wiki/Positivism \"Positivism\"), rather than [normative](/wiki/Normative \"Normative\") approach\" and that his remarks were intended to be an \"attempt at provocation\".{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \\|title\\=Archive of: Remarks at NBER Conference on Diversifying the Science \\& Engineering Workforce \\|access\\-date\\=January 30, 2008 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080130023006/http://www.president.harvard.edu/speeches/2005/nber.html \\|archive\\-date\\=January 30, 2008 }}. January 14, 2005\\.",
"Summers then began by identifying three hypotheses for the higher proportion of men in high\\-end science and engineering positions:",
"1. The high\\-powered job hypothesis\n2. Different availability of [aptitude](/wiki/Aptitude \"Aptitude\") at the high end\n3. Different socialization and patterns of discrimination in a search",
"The second hypothesis, the generally [greater variability among men](/wiki/Variability_hypothesis \"Variability hypothesis\") (compared to women) in tests of cognitive abilities,Hedges, L. V., \\& Nowell, A. (1995\\). \"Sex differences in mental scores, variability, and numbers of high scoring individuals\". *Science*, 269, 41–45\\.Lehrke, R. (1997\\). *Sex linkage of intelligence: The X\\-Factor*. New York: Praeger.Lubinski, D., \\& Benbow, C. M. (2006\\). \"Study of mathematically precocious youth after 35 years\". *Perspectives on Psychological Science*, 1, 316–345\\. leading to proportionally more males than females at both the lower and upper tails of the test score distributions, caused the most controversy. In his discussion of this hypothesis, Summers said that \"even small differences in the standard deviation \\[between genders] will translate into very large differences in the available pool substantially out \\[from the mean]\". Summers referenced research that implied differences between the standard deviations of males and females in the top 5% of twelfth graders under various tests. He then went on to argue that, if this research were to be accepted, then \"whatever the set of attributes ... that are precisely defined to correlate with being an aeronautical engineer at MIT or being a chemist at Berkeley ... are probably different in their standard deviations as well\".",
"Summers then concluded his discussion of the three hypotheses by saying:",
"",
"> So my best guess, to provoke you, of what's behind all of this is that the largest phenomenon, by far, is the general clash between people's legitimate family desires and employers' current desire for high power and high intensity, that in the special case of science and engineering, there are issues of intrinsic aptitude, and particularly of the variability of aptitude, and that those considerations are reinforced by what are in fact lesser factors involving socialization and continuing discrimination. I would like nothing better than to be proved wrong, because I would like nothing better than for these problems to be addressable simply by everybody understanding what they are, and working very hard to address them.",
"Summers then went on to discuss approaches to remedying the shortage of women in high\\-end science and engineering positions.",
"This lunch\\-time talk drew accusations of sexism and careless scholarship, and an intense negative response followed, both nationally and at Harvard.[Summers' Remarks on Women Draw Fire](https://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2005/01/17/summers_remarks_on_women_draw_fire/){{dead link\\|date\\=March 2024}}. The Boston Globe. January 17, 2005 Summers apologized repeatedly.{{cite magazine \\|last\\=Saletan\\|first\\=William\\|author\\-link\\=William Saletan\\|date\\=January 21, 2005\\|title\\=Don't Worry Your Pretty Little Head\\|url\\=http://www.slate.com/id/2112570/\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[Slate (magazine)\\|Slate]]}} Nevertheless, the controversy is speculated to have contributed to his resigning his position as president of Harvard University the following year, as well as costing Summers the job of [Treasury Secretary](/wiki/Treasury_Secretary \"Treasury Secretary\") in [Obama's administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Barack_Obama \"Presidency of Barack Obama\").[Summers's 'sexism' costs him top Treasury job](https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/summersrsquo-lsquosexismrsquo-costs-him-top-treasury-job-1033373.html). [The Independent](/wiki/The_Independent \"The Independent\"). November 24, 2008",
"Summers's protégée [Sheryl Sandberg](/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg \"Sheryl Sandberg\") has defended him, saying that \"Larry has been a true advocate for women throughout his career\" at the World Bank and Treasury. Referring to the lunch talk, Sandberg said, \"What few seem to note is that it is remarkable that he was giving the speech in the first place – that he cared enough about women's careers and their trajectory in the fields of math and science to proactively analyze the issues and talk about what was going wrong\".{{cite news\\|author\\=Sheryl Sandberg\\|title\\=Larry Summers' True Record on Women\\|url\\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/sheryl\\-sandberg/what\\-larry\\-summers\\-has\\-do\\_b\\_142126\\.html\\|access\\-date\\=January 4, 2014\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[HuffPost]]\\|date\\=November 7, 2008\\|author\\-link\\=Sheryl Sandberg}}",
"In 2016, remarking upon [political correctness](/wiki/Political_correctness \"Political correctness\") in institutions of higher education, Summers said:",
"",
"> There is a great deal of absurd political correctness. Now, I'm somebody who believes very strongly in diversity, who resists racism in all of its many incarnations, who thinks that there is a great deal that's unjust in American society that needs to be combated, but it seems to be that there is a kind of creeping totalitarianism in terms of what kind of ideas are acceptable and are debatable on college campuses.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://conversationswithbillkristol.org/video/larry\\-summers\\-ii/?start\\=15\\&end\\=1606\\|title\\=Larry Summers II on Conversations with Bill Kristol\\|website\\=ConversationsWithBillKristol.org\\|access\\-date\\=November 8, 2017}}",
"#### Summers' opposition and support at Harvard",
"On March 15, 2005, members of the [Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Faculty_of_Arts_and_Sciences \"Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences\"), which instructs graduate students in [Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences](/wiki/Harvard_Graduate_School_of_Arts_and_Sciences \"Harvard Graduate School of Arts and Sciences\") and undergraduates in [Harvard College](/wiki/Harvard_College \"Harvard College\"), passed 218–185 a motion of \"lack of confidence\" in the leadership of Summers, with 18 abstentions. A second motion that offered a milder censure of the president passed 253 to 137, also with 18 abstentions.",
"The members of the [Harvard Corporation](/wiki/Harvard_Corporation \"Harvard Corporation\"), the University's highest governing body, are in charge of the selection of the president and issued statements strongly supporting Summers.",
"FAS faculty were not unanimous in their comments against Summers. Psychologist [Steven Pinker](/wiki/Steven_Pinker \"Steven Pinker\") defended the legitimacy of Summers's January lecture. When asked if Summers's talk was \"within the pale of legitimate academic discourse,\" Pinker responded \"Good grief, shouldn't everything be within the pale of legitimate academic discourse, as long as it is presented with some degree of rigor? That's the difference between a university and a [madrassa](/wiki/Madrassa \"Madrassa\"). There is certainly enough evidence for the hypothesis to be taken seriously.\"[Psychoanalysis Q\\-and\\-A: Steven Pinker](https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2005/1/19/psychoanalysis-q-and-a-steven-pinker-in-an/). *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\")*. January 19, 2005",
"Summers had stronger support among Harvard College students than among the college faculty. One poll by *[The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\")* indicated that students opposed his resignation by a three\\-to\\-one margin, with 57% of responding students opposing his resignation and 19% supporting it.[Poll: Students Say Summers Should Stay](http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=511421). [The Harvard Crimson](/wiki/The_Harvard_Crimson \"The Harvard Crimson\"). February 20, 2006",
"In July 2005, a board member of Harvard Corporation, [Conrad K. Harper](/wiki/Conrad_K._Harper \"Conrad K. Harper\"), resigned saying he was angered both by the university president's comments about women and by Summers being given a salary increase. The resignation letter to the president said, \"I could not and cannot support a raise in your salary, ... I believe that Harvard's best interests require your resignation.\"{{cite news\\|last\\=Finder\\|first\\=Alan\\|title\\=A Harvard Governor, Dissatisfied, Resigns\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2005/07/29/education/29harvard.html?\\_r\\=0\\|access\\-date\\=December 5, 2013\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|date\\=July 29, 2005}}[Board Member's Letter of Resignation](https://www.nytimes.com/2005/08/02/education/02htext.html). [The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\"). August 2, 2005",
"#### Support of economist Andrei Shleifer",
"Harvard and [Andrei Shleifer](/wiki/Andrei_Shleifer \"Andrei Shleifer\"), a close friend and protégé of Summers, controversially paid $28\\.5 million to settle a [lawsuit](/wiki/Lawsuit \"Lawsuit\") by the U.S. government over the [conflict of interest](/wiki/Conflict_of_interest \"Conflict of interest\") Shleifer had while advising [Russia's privatization program](/wiki/Russia%27s_privatization_program \"Russia's privatization program\"). The US government had sued Shleifer under the [False Claims Act](/wiki/False_Claims_Act \"False Claims Act\"), as he bought [Russian](/wiki/Russia \"Russia\") stocks while designing the country's [privatization](/wiki/Privatization \"Privatization\"). In 2004, a federal judge ruled that while Harvard had violated the contract, Shleifer and his associate alone were liable for [treble damages](/wiki/Treble_damages \"Treble damages\").",
"In June 2005, Harvard and Shleifer announced that they had reached a tentative settlement with the US government. In August, Harvard, Shleifer, and the [Department of Justice](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_Justice \"United States Department of Justice\") reached an agreement under which the university paid $26\\.5 million to settle the five\\-year\\-old lawsuit. Shleifer was also responsible for paying $2 million worth of damages.",
"Because Harvard paid almost all of the damages and allowed Shleifer to retain his faculty position, the settlement provoked allegations of favoritism by Summers. His continued support for Shleifer strengthened Summers's unpopularity with other professors, as reported in *The Harvard Crimson*:",
"{{Blockquote\\|I've been a member of this Faculty for over 45 years, and I am no longer easily shocked,\" is how Frederick H. Abernathy, the McKay professor of mechanical engineering, began his biting comments about the Shleifer case at Tuesday's fiery Faculty meeting. But, Abernathy continued, \"I was deeply shocked and disappointed by the actions of this University\" in the Shleifer affair.{{cite news\\|title\\='Tawdry Shleifer Affair' Stokes Faculty Anger Toward Summers\\|url\\=http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/2/10/tawdry\\-shleifer\\-affair\\-stokes\\-faculty\\-anger/\\|access\\-date\\=30 May 2013\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Harvard Crimson]]\\|date\\=10 Feb 2006\\|author\\=Nicholas Ciarelli\\|author2\\=Anton Troianovski}}}}",
"#### In Russia",
"{{See also\\|Loans for shares scheme}}\nAn 18,000\\-word article \"How Harvard Lost Russia\" in *[Institutional Investor](/wiki/Institutional_Investor_%28magazine%29 \"Institutional Investor (magazine)\")* by David McClintick detailed Shleifer's alleged efforts to use his [inside knowledge](/wiki/Insider_trading \"Insider trading\") of and sway over the Russian economy in order to make lucrative personal investments, all while leading a Harvard group, advising the Russian government, that was under contract with the U.S. The article suggests that Summers shielded his fellow economist from disciplinary action by the university, and it noted that Summers had forewarned Shleifer and his wife Nancy Zimmerman about the conflict\\-of\\-interest regulations back in 1996\\.{{Cite news \\|last\\=McClintick \\|first\\=David \\|date\\=January 13, 2006 \\|title\\=How Harvard Lost Russia \\|work\\=Institutional Investor \\|url\\=https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b150npp3q49x7w/how\\-harvard\\-lost\\-russia \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20140705041205/http://www.institutionalinvestor.com/Article/1020662/How\\-Harvard\\-lost\\-Russia.html\\#/.V0mIqpF97nE \\|archive\\-date\\=July 5, 2014}} Summers's friendship with Shleifer was well known by the corporation when it selected him to succeed Rudenstine and Summers recused himself from all proceedings with Shleifer, whose case was actually handled by an independent committee led by former Harvard president [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok \"Derek Bok\").",
"#### Connection to Jeffrey Epstein",
"An article in *The Harvard Crimson* in 2003, during Summers's tenure as president, detailed a reportedly \"special connection\" between Summers and [Jeffrey Epstein](/wiki/Jeffrey_Epstein \"Jeffrey Epstein\").{{Cite web\\|last\\= Scharnick\\|first\\=Jaquelyn M.\\|date\\=May 1, 2003\\|url\\=https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/5/1/mogul\\-donor\\-gives\\-harvard\\-more\\-than/?page\\=single\\|title\\=Mogul Donor Gives Harvard More Than Money\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Harvard Crimson]]\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein pledged to donate at least $25 million to Harvard during Summers's tenure to endow Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein was given an office at Harvard for his personal use.{{Cite magazine\\|url\\=https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2003/03/jeffrey\\-epstein\\-200303\\|title\\=The Talented Mr. Epstein\\|last\\=Ward\\|first\\=Vicky\\|date\\=March 2003\\|magazine\\=\\[\\[Vanity Fair (magazine)\\|Vanity Fair]]\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|quote\\=Epstein has pledged at least $25 million to Harvard to create the Epstein Program for Mathematical Biology and Evolutionary Dynamics, and Epstein will have an office at the university...He says he was reluctant to have his name attached to the program, but Summers persuaded him. }}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://ped.fas.harvard.edu/home\\|title\\=Program for Evolutionary Dynamics\\|website\\=ped.fas.harvard.edu\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019}} Epstein otherwise had no formal connection to Harvard. Summers's ties to Epstein reportedly began \"a number of years...before Summers became Harvard's president and even before he was the Secretary of the Treasury.\" Flight records introduced as evidence in the 2021 trial of Epstein associate [Ghislaine Maxwell](/wiki/Ghislaine_Maxwell \"Ghislaine Maxwell\") show that Summers flew on Jeffrey Epstein's private plane on at least four occasions, including once in 1998 when Summers was [United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Deputy_Secretary_of_the_Treasury \"United States Deputy Secretary of the Treasury\") and at least three times while Harvard president.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://s3\\.documentcloud.org/documents/21165424/epstein\\-flight\\-logs\\-released\\-in\\-usa\\-vs\\-maxwell.pdf\\|title\\=Epstein Flight Logs Released in USA vs. Maxwell\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=December 27, 2021}} A charity funded by Epstein also donated to the production of a [PBS](/wiki/PBS \"PBS\") show hosted by Summers's wife and Harvard professor [Elisa New](/wiki/Elisa_New \"Elisa New\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey\\-epstein\\-has\\-a\\-secret\\-charity\\-heres\\-who\\-it\\-gave\\-money\\-to?ref\\=scroll\\|title\\=REVEALED: We Found Billionaire Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein's Secret Charity\\|last\\=Briquelet\\|first\\=Kate\\|date\\=July 10, 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Daily Beast]]\\|access\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|quote\\=In 2016, Gratitude America Ltd. shelled out $110,000 to Verse Video Education. The Cambridge, Massachusetts\\-based nonprofit produces the PBS show Poetry in America, whose creator and host is Harvard professor Elisa New. Verse's 2016 tax return named New as the group's president but doesn't include specific donors for its $1\\.38 million in total contributions. New is married to Summers, Harvard University's former president, who hobnobbed with Epstein in elite international relations groups and, like Bill Clinton, flew on Epstein's private jet.}}",
"#### Winklevoss twins and Facebook",
"In February 2004, the [Winklevoss twins](/wiki/Winklevoss_twins \"Winklevoss twins\") requested a meeting with Summers in order to ask him to intervene on their behalf in an ongoing dispute they had with [Facebook](/wiki/Facebook \"Facebook\") founder [Mark Zuckerberg](/wiki/Mark_Zuckerberg \"Mark Zuckerberg\"). The Winklevosses believed that Zuckerberg had stolen their idea for a social networking website and launched Facebook on his own, after they had asked him to be a part of their project, then called HarvardConnection. Summers believed that the matter was outside the university's jurisdiction and advised the twins to take their complaint to the courts.{{cite news \\|first\\=Shirin \\|last\\=Sharif \\|title\\=Harvard grads face off against thefacebook.com \\|date\\=August 5, 2004 \\|publisher\\=The Stanford Daily \\|url\\=http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\\-grads\\-face\\-off\\-against\\-thefacebookcom/ \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100618102603/http://www.stanforddaily.com/2004/08/05/harvard\\-grads\\-face\\-off\\-against\\-thefacebookcom/ \\|archive\\-date\\=June 18, 2010 \\|url\\-status\\=dead }}",
"#### Resignation as Harvard President",
"On February 21, 2006, Summers announced his intention to step down at the end of the school year effective June 30, 2006\\. Harvard agreed to provide Summers on his resignation with a one\\-year paid [sabbatical](/wiki/Sabbatical \"Sabbatical\") leave, subsidized a $1 million outstanding loan from the university for his personal residence, and provided other payments.President and Fellows of Harvard College, [IRS](/wiki/Internal_Revenue_Service \"Internal Revenue Service\") Form 990, 2006 \\& 2007\\. Former University President [Derek Bok](/wiki/Derek_Bok \"Derek Bok\") acted as Interim President while the University conducted a search for a replacement which ended with the naming of [Drew Gilpin Faust](/wiki/Drew_Gilpin_Faust \"Drew Gilpin Faust\") on February 11, 2007\\.",
""
] |
History
-------
The Nankar custom was a labor exploitation system, much like the [Medieval](/wiki/Middle_Ages "Middle Ages") [slavery](/wiki/Slavery "Slavery") system. The feudal tradition originated during the [colonial period](/wiki/British_Bengal "British Bengal") and was practiced mainly in the [Sylheti](/wiki/Sylhet_region "Sylhet region") [thanas](/wiki/Thanas_of_Bangladesh "Thanas of Bangladesh") of [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar "Beanibazar"), [Barlekha](/wiki/Barlekha "Barlekha") and [Golapganj](/wiki/Golapganj "Golapganj").{{cite news\|url\=http://archive.prothom\-alo.com/detail/date/2011\-10\-13/news/193305 \|script\-title\=bn:নানকার বিদ্রোহের বীর\|newspaper\=Prothom\-Alo\|language\=bn\|access\-date\=10 July 2017}} In the [Sylhet region](/wiki/Sylhet_region "Sylhet region"), the landowners were called mirashdars and the greater mirashdar were called [zamindars](/wiki/Zamindar "Zamindar"). The nankars would be accommodated close to the zamindars or mirashdars residence and also had permission to use the house and agricultural land provided. However, they had to be engaged in the work of the landlord's entire house, even during late hours after midnight. The nankars would not earn wages for this work. When the call of the zamindar was not immediately accepted, untimely torture was prosecuted.
In the village of [Bahadurpur in Lauta](/wiki/Beanibazar_Upazila%23Villages_in_Lauta_Union "Beanibazar Upazila#Villages in Lauta Union"), [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar "Beanibazar"), there lived a [zamindar](/wiki/Zamindar "Zamindar") who practiced the Nankar custom. His regulations were known to be strict such as the different prohibitions in the road in front of his home which included wearing shoes and sandals, using umbrellas and riding horses. The word locally spread of the zamindar's oppression and consultations took place establishing the Communist Party and Peasants Association in 1937\. Comrade Ajay Bhattacharya, a man who was arrested multiple times by [the British](/wiki/British_Empire "British Empire") for his activism, led the Nankar movement. Other members from [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar "Beanibazar") also joined him such as Shishir Bhattacharya, Shailendra Bhattacharya and Lalitapal from Lauta, Jawad Ullah from Nandirpal and Abdus\-Subhan from South Potti. Uniting other Nankars, they publicly rebelled against the zamindar. They stopped the zamindar from earning his revenue and stopped him from entering markets. This news spread to other zamindars who, out of fear, petitioned to the [Government of Pakistan](/wiki/Government_of_Pakistan "Government of Pakistan") against the rebellion. The government later took action to suppress the rebellion. Other organizers included Varun Roy and [Hena Das](/wiki/Hena_Das "Hena Das").[http://www.jjdin.com/?view\=details\&archiev\=yes\&arch\_date\=20\-07\-2014\&feature\=yes\&type\=single\&pub\_no\=900\&cat\_id\=3\&menu\_id\=69\&news\_type\_id\=1\&index\=1](http://www.jjdin.com/?view=details&archiev=yes&arch_date=20-07-2014&feature=yes&type=single&pub_no=900&cat_id=3&menu_id=69&news_type_id=1&index=1) নারী আন্দোলনের পথিকৃৎ হেনা দাস\- The Daily Jayjaydin
According to Bhattacharya, 10% (300,000\) of the population of [Greater Sylhet](/wiki/Greater_Sylhet "Greater Sylhet") were Nankars. From 1922 to 1949, with the help of the Communist Party and Peasants Association, a Nankar movement against the feudalistic exploitation system was developed and centered in Bahadurpur, Lauta in [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar "Beanibazar"), and spread to other Nankar\-populated areas such as [Golapganj](/wiki/Golapganj "Golapganj"), [Barlekha](/wiki/Barlekha "Barlekha"), [Kulaura](/wiki/Kulaura "Kulaura"), [Balaganj](/wiki/Balaganj "Balaganj") and [Dharamapasha](/wiki/Dharamapasha "Dharamapasha").
On the 17th of August 1949, there was an important festival day, [Makar Sankranti](/wiki/Makar_Sankranti "Makar Sankranti"), in reference to deity [Surya](/wiki/Surya "Surya") (sun), for [Bengali Hindus](/wiki/Bengali_Hindus "Bengali Hindus"). During the first day of this religious festival, the Nankar Hindus in [Saneshwar Uluri](/wiki/Beanibazar_Upazila%23Villages_in_Tilpara_Union "Beanibazar Upazila#Villages in Tilpara Union") began preparing to worship [Manasa](/wiki/Manasa "Manasa") late at night until they start to feel sleepy. During sunrise, an armed force attacks the village and the Hindus begin to flee, many towards the nearby village of Uluri. Members of the rebellion staying in Uluri were Aparna Pal, Shushama De, Ashita Pal and Surath Pal. Eventually a conflict occurs between the force and Uluri villagers along the banks of the Sunai River.
### Nankar Day
On 18 August 1949, six Nankars were killed in an armed attack by [the EPR](/wiki/East_Pakistan_Rifles "East Pakistan Rifles"), [police](/wiki/East_Pakistan_Police "East Pakistan Police") and zamindars belonging to [the Muslim League](/wiki/Muslim_League_%28Pakistan%29 "Muslim League (Pakistan)"), who were armed with [lathis](/wiki/Lathi_khela "Lathi khela"). The victims were:
* Rajni Das (50\) \- killed 15 days prior by the zamindar's armed forces on the bank of the Sunai river;
* Brajanath Das (50\);
* Kutumani Das (47\);
* Prasanna Kumar Das (50\);
* Pabitra Kumar Das (45\) and
* Amulya Kumar Das (17\) \- Killed later in captivity
Being pregnant, during the persecution of police, Aparna Pal Chowdhury had a miscarriage on the spot.{{cite news\|url\=http://www.kalerkantho.com/print\-edition/rajkut/2014/11/18/152413 \|script\-title\=bn:বাংলার বিদ্রোহ, নানকার বিদ্রোহ\|last\=অনিন্দ্য আরিফ\|newspaper\=The Daily Kalerkantho\|date\=14 November 2014\|language\=bn\|access\-date\=27 December 2016}} She became lame in the severe torture and imprisoned for 5 years in [Sylhet](/wiki/Sylhet "Sylhet"), [Rajshahi](/wiki/Rajshahi "Rajshahi") and [Dhaka jail](/wiki/Old_Dhaka_Central_Jail "Old Dhaka Central Jail").{{cite book\|last\=Bose\|first\=Anjali\|year\=2004\|script\-title\=bn:Sansad Bangali Charitabhidhan\|volume\=2\|location\=Kolkata\|publisher\=Sahitya Sansad\|language\=bn\|page\=14\|isbn\=81\-86806\-99\-7}} Wounded and captured people included Hridoy Ranjan Das, Dinanath Das, Adwayta Charan Das, Sushama Dey, Asita Pal, and Prakash Chandra Das, Hiran Bala Das, Priyamoni Das, Pramod Chandra Das and Mana Chandra Das.
### Abolishment
After the incident in Beanibazar, the movement became increasingly popular throughout the country. As a result of this sacrifice, the [Pakistan government](/wiki/Government_of_Pakistan "Government of Pakistan") was forced to abolish the zamindari system and repeal the non\-governmental rule to recognize the ownership of the land of peasants.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"The Nankar custom was a labor exploitation system, much like the [Medieval](/wiki/Middle_Ages \"Middle Ages\") [slavery](/wiki/Slavery \"Slavery\") system. The feudal tradition originated during the [colonial period](/wiki/British_Bengal \"British Bengal\") and was practiced mainly in the [Sylheti](/wiki/Sylhet_region \"Sylhet region\") [thanas](/wiki/Thanas_of_Bangladesh \"Thanas of Bangladesh\") of [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar \"Beanibazar\"), [Barlekha](/wiki/Barlekha \"Barlekha\") and [Golapganj](/wiki/Golapganj \"Golapganj\").{{cite news\\|url\\=http://archive.prothom\\-alo.com/detail/date/2011\\-10\\-13/news/193305 \\|script\\-title\\=bn:নানকার বিদ্রোহের বীর\\|newspaper\\=Prothom\\-Alo\\|language\\=bn\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2017}} In the [Sylhet region](/wiki/Sylhet_region \"Sylhet region\"), the landowners were called mirashdars and the greater mirashdar were called [zamindars](/wiki/Zamindar \"Zamindar\"). The nankars would be accommodated close to the zamindars or mirashdars residence and also had permission to use the house and agricultural land provided. However, they had to be engaged in the work of the landlord's entire house, even during late hours after midnight. The nankars would not earn wages for this work. When the call of the zamindar was not immediately accepted, untimely torture was prosecuted.",
"In the village of [Bahadurpur in Lauta](/wiki/Beanibazar_Upazila%23Villages_in_Lauta_Union \"Beanibazar Upazila#Villages in Lauta Union\"), [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar \"Beanibazar\"), there lived a [zamindar](/wiki/Zamindar \"Zamindar\") who practiced the Nankar custom. His regulations were known to be strict such as the different prohibitions in the road in front of his home which included wearing shoes and sandals, using umbrellas and riding horses. The word locally spread of the zamindar's oppression and consultations took place establishing the Communist Party and Peasants Association in 1937\\. Comrade Ajay Bhattacharya, a man who was arrested multiple times by [the British](/wiki/British_Empire \"British Empire\") for his activism, led the Nankar movement. Other members from [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar \"Beanibazar\") also joined him such as Shishir Bhattacharya, Shailendra Bhattacharya and Lalitapal from Lauta, Jawad Ullah from Nandirpal and Abdus\\-Subhan from South Potti. Uniting other Nankars, they publicly rebelled against the zamindar. They stopped the zamindar from earning his revenue and stopped him from entering markets. This news spread to other zamindars who, out of fear, petitioned to the [Government of Pakistan](/wiki/Government_of_Pakistan \"Government of Pakistan\") against the rebellion. The government later took action to suppress the rebellion. Other organizers included Varun Roy and [Hena Das](/wiki/Hena_Das \"Hena Das\").[http://www.jjdin.com/?view\\=details\\&archiev\\=yes\\&arch\\_date\\=20\\-07\\-2014\\&feature\\=yes\\&type\\=single\\&pub\\_no\\=900\\&cat\\_id\\=3\\&menu\\_id\\=69\\&news\\_type\\_id\\=1\\&index\\=1](http://www.jjdin.com/?view=details&archiev=yes&arch_date=20-07-2014&feature=yes&type=single&pub_no=900&cat_id=3&menu_id=69&news_type_id=1&index=1) নারী আন্দোলনের পথিকৃৎ হেনা দাস\\- The Daily Jayjaydin",
"According to Bhattacharya, 10% (300,000\\) of the population of [Greater Sylhet](/wiki/Greater_Sylhet \"Greater Sylhet\") were Nankars. From 1922 to 1949, with the help of the Communist Party and Peasants Association, a Nankar movement against the feudalistic exploitation system was developed and centered in Bahadurpur, Lauta in [Beanibazar](/wiki/Beanibazar \"Beanibazar\"), and spread to other Nankar\\-populated areas such as [Golapganj](/wiki/Golapganj \"Golapganj\"), [Barlekha](/wiki/Barlekha \"Barlekha\"), [Kulaura](/wiki/Kulaura \"Kulaura\"), [Balaganj](/wiki/Balaganj \"Balaganj\") and [Dharamapasha](/wiki/Dharamapasha \"Dharamapasha\").",
"On the 17th of August 1949, there was an important festival day, [Makar Sankranti](/wiki/Makar_Sankranti \"Makar Sankranti\"), in reference to deity [Surya](/wiki/Surya \"Surya\") (sun), for [Bengali Hindus](/wiki/Bengali_Hindus \"Bengali Hindus\"). During the first day of this religious festival, the Nankar Hindus in [Saneshwar Uluri](/wiki/Beanibazar_Upazila%23Villages_in_Tilpara_Union \"Beanibazar Upazila#Villages in Tilpara Union\") began preparing to worship [Manasa](/wiki/Manasa \"Manasa\") late at night until they start to feel sleepy. During sunrise, an armed force attacks the village and the Hindus begin to flee, many towards the nearby village of Uluri. Members of the rebellion staying in Uluri were Aparna Pal, Shushama De, Ashita Pal and Surath Pal. Eventually a conflict occurs between the force and Uluri villagers along the banks of the Sunai River.",
"### Nankar Day",
"On 18 August 1949, six Nankars were killed in an armed attack by [the EPR](/wiki/East_Pakistan_Rifles \"East Pakistan Rifles\"), [police](/wiki/East_Pakistan_Police \"East Pakistan Police\") and zamindars belonging to [the Muslim League](/wiki/Muslim_League_%28Pakistan%29 \"Muslim League (Pakistan)\"), who were armed with [lathis](/wiki/Lathi_khela \"Lathi khela\"). The victims were: \n* Rajni Das (50\\) \\- killed 15 days prior by the zamindar's armed forces on the bank of the Sunai river;\n* Brajanath Das (50\\);\n* Kutumani Das (47\\);\n* Prasanna Kumar Das (50\\);\n* Pabitra Kumar Das (45\\) and\n* Amulya Kumar Das (17\\) \\- Killed later in captivity",
"Being pregnant, during the persecution of police, Aparna Pal Chowdhury had a miscarriage on the spot.{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.kalerkantho.com/print\\-edition/rajkut/2014/11/18/152413 \\|script\\-title\\=bn:বাংলার বিদ্রোহ, নানকার বিদ্রোহ\\|last\\=অনিন্দ্য আরিফ\\|newspaper\\=The Daily Kalerkantho\\|date\\=14 November 2014\\|language\\=bn\\|access\\-date\\=27 December 2016}} She became lame in the severe torture and imprisoned for 5 years in [Sylhet](/wiki/Sylhet \"Sylhet\"), [Rajshahi](/wiki/Rajshahi \"Rajshahi\") and [Dhaka jail](/wiki/Old_Dhaka_Central_Jail \"Old Dhaka Central Jail\").{{cite book\\|last\\=Bose\\|first\\=Anjali\\|year\\=2004\\|script\\-title\\=bn:Sansad Bangali Charitabhidhan\\|volume\\=2\\|location\\=Kolkata\\|publisher\\=Sahitya Sansad\\|language\\=bn\\|page\\=14\\|isbn\\=81\\-86806\\-99\\-7}} Wounded and captured people included Hridoy Ranjan Das, Dinanath Das, Adwayta Charan Das, Sushama Dey, Asita Pal, and Prakash Chandra Das, Hiran Bala Das, Priyamoni Das, Pramod Chandra Das and Mana Chandra Das.",
"### Abolishment",
"After the incident in Beanibazar, the movement became increasingly popular throughout the country. As a result of this sacrifice, the [Pakistan government](/wiki/Government_of_Pakistan \"Government of Pakistan\") was forced to abolish the zamindari system and repeal the non\\-governmental rule to recognize the ownership of the land of peasants.",
""
] |
Surfaces
--------
Its **outer surface** is smooth and [convex](/wiki/wikt:Convex "Convex"); it affords attachment to the [temporal muscle](/wiki/Temporal_muscle "Temporal muscle"), and forms part of the [temporal fossa](/wiki/Temporal_fossa "Temporal fossa"); on its hinder part is a vertical groove for the [middle temporal artery](/wiki/Middle_temporal_artery "Middle temporal artery"). A curved line, the *temporal line*, or *supramastoid crest*, runs backward and upward across its posterior part; it serves for the attachment of the temporal [fascia](/wiki/Fascia "Fascia"), and limits the origin of the temporalis muscle. The boundary between the squamous part and the mastoid portion of the bone, as indicated by traces of the original suture, lies about 1 cm. below this line.
Projecting from the lower part of the squamous part is a long, arched process, the *[zygomatic process](/wiki/Zygomatic_process_of_temporal_bone "Zygomatic process of temporal bone")*. This process is at first directed lateralward, its two surfaces looking upward and downward; it then appears as if twisted inward upon itself, and runs forward, its surfaces now looking medialward and lateralward. The superior border is long, thin, and sharp, and serves for the attachment of the temporal fascia; the inferior, short, thick, and arched, has attached to it some fibers of the [masseter](/wiki/Masseter "Masseter"). The lateral surface is convex and [subcutaneous](/wiki/Subcutaneous_tissue "Subcutaneous tissue"); the medial is [concave](/wiki/wiktionary:Concave "Concave"), and affords attachment to the masseter. The anterior end is deeply serrated and articulates with the [zygomatic bone](/wiki/Zygomatic_bone "Zygomatic bone"). The posterior end is connected to the squamous part by two roots, the anterior and posterior roots. The posterior root, a prolongation of the upper border, is strongly marked; it runs backward above the [external auditory meatus](/wiki/External_auditory_meatus "External auditory meatus"), and is continuous with the temporal line. The anterior root, continuous with the lower border, is short but broad and strong; it is directed medialward and ends in a rounded eminence, the [articular tubercle](/wiki/Articular_tubercle "Articular tubercle") (eminentia articularis).
This tubercle forms the front boundary of the [mandibular fossa](/wiki/Mandibular_fossa "Mandibular fossa"), and in the fresh state is covered with cartilage. In front of the articular tubercle is a small triangular area which assists in forming the [infratemporal fossa](/wiki/Infratemporal_fossa "Infratemporal fossa"); this area is separated from the outer surface of the squamous part by a ridge which is continuous behind with the anterior root of the zygomatic process, and in front, in the articulated skull, with the [infratemporal crest](/wiki/Infratemporal_crest "Infratemporal crest") on the great wing of the [sphenoid](/wiki/Sphenoid_bone "Sphenoid bone"). Between the posterior wall of the [external acoustic meatus](/wiki/External_acoustic_meatus "External acoustic meatus") and the posterior root of the zygomatic process is the area called the suprameatal triangle (Macewen), or [mastoid fossa](/wiki/Mastoid_fossa "Mastoid fossa"), through which an instrument may be pushed into the [tympanic antrum](/wiki/Tympanic_antrum "Tympanic antrum").
At the junction of the anterior root with the zygomatic process is a projection for the attachment of the [temporomandibular ligament](/wiki/Temporomandibular_ligament "Temporomandibular ligament"); and behind the anterior root is an oval depression, forming part of the mandibular fossa, for the reception of the condyle of the mandible. The mandibular fossa (glenoid fossa) is bounded, in front, by the articular tubercle; behind, by the tympanic part of the bone, which separates it from the external acoustic meatus; it is divided into two parts by a narrow slit, the petrotympanic fissure ([Glaserian fissure](/wiki/Glaserian_fissure "Glaserian fissure")). The anterior part, formed by the squamous part, is smooth, covered in the fresh state with [cartilage](/wiki/Cartilage "Cartilage"), and articulates with the [condyle of the mandible](/wiki/Ramus_mandibulae%23Condyloid_Process "Ramus mandibulae#Condyloid Process"). Behind this part of the fossa is a small conical eminence; this is the representative of a prominent tubercle which, in some mammals, descends behind the condyle of the mandible, and prevents its backward displacement. The posterior part of the mandibular fossa, formed by the [tympanic part](/wiki/Tympanic_part "Tympanic part") of the bone, is non\-articular, and sometimes lodges a portion of the [parotid gland](/wiki/Parotid_gland "Parotid gland").
The [petrotympanic fissure](/wiki/Petrotympanic_fissure "Petrotympanic fissure") leads into the [middle ear](/wiki/Middle_ear "Middle ear") or [tympanic cavity](/wiki/Tympanic_cavity "Tympanic cavity"); it lodges the anterior process of the [malleus](/wiki/Malleus "Malleus"), and transmits the tympanic branch of the [internal maxillary artery](/wiki/Internal_maxillary_artery "Internal maxillary artery"). The [chorda tympani](/wiki/Chorda_tympani "Chorda tympani") nerve passes through a canal (canal of [Huguier](/wiki/Huguier "Huguier")), separated from the anterior edge of the petrotympanic fissure by a thin scale of bone and situated on the lateral side of the [auditory tube](/wiki/Auditory_tube "Auditory tube"), in the retiring angle between the squamous part and the petrous portion of the temporal bone.
The **internal surface** of the squamous part is concave; it presents depressions corresponding to the convolutions of the temporal lobe of the brain, and grooves for the branches of the middle [meningeal vessels](/wiki/Meningeal_vessel "Meningeal vessel").
|
[
"Surfaces\n--------",
"Its **outer surface** is smooth and [convex](/wiki/wikt:Convex \"Convex\"); it affords attachment to the [temporal muscle](/wiki/Temporal_muscle \"Temporal muscle\"), and forms part of the [temporal fossa](/wiki/Temporal_fossa \"Temporal fossa\"); on its hinder part is a vertical groove for the [middle temporal artery](/wiki/Middle_temporal_artery \"Middle temporal artery\"). A curved line, the *temporal line*, or *supramastoid crest*, runs backward and upward across its posterior part; it serves for the attachment of the temporal [fascia](/wiki/Fascia \"Fascia\"), and limits the origin of the temporalis muscle. The boundary between the squamous part and the mastoid portion of the bone, as indicated by traces of the original suture, lies about 1 cm. below this line.",
"Projecting from the lower part of the squamous part is a long, arched process, the *[zygomatic process](/wiki/Zygomatic_process_of_temporal_bone \"Zygomatic process of temporal bone\")*. This process is at first directed lateralward, its two surfaces looking upward and downward; it then appears as if twisted inward upon itself, and runs forward, its surfaces now looking medialward and lateralward. The superior border is long, thin, and sharp, and serves for the attachment of the temporal fascia; the inferior, short, thick, and arched, has attached to it some fibers of the [masseter](/wiki/Masseter \"Masseter\"). The lateral surface is convex and [subcutaneous](/wiki/Subcutaneous_tissue \"Subcutaneous tissue\"); the medial is [concave](/wiki/wiktionary:Concave \"Concave\"), and affords attachment to the masseter. The anterior end is deeply serrated and articulates with the [zygomatic bone](/wiki/Zygomatic_bone \"Zygomatic bone\"). The posterior end is connected to the squamous part by two roots, the anterior and posterior roots. The posterior root, a prolongation of the upper border, is strongly marked; it runs backward above the [external auditory meatus](/wiki/External_auditory_meatus \"External auditory meatus\"), and is continuous with the temporal line. The anterior root, continuous with the lower border, is short but broad and strong; it is directed medialward and ends in a rounded eminence, the [articular tubercle](/wiki/Articular_tubercle \"Articular tubercle\") (eminentia articularis).",
"This tubercle forms the front boundary of the [mandibular fossa](/wiki/Mandibular_fossa \"Mandibular fossa\"), and in the fresh state is covered with cartilage. In front of the articular tubercle is a small triangular area which assists in forming the [infratemporal fossa](/wiki/Infratemporal_fossa \"Infratemporal fossa\"); this area is separated from the outer surface of the squamous part by a ridge which is continuous behind with the anterior root of the zygomatic process, and in front, in the articulated skull, with the [infratemporal crest](/wiki/Infratemporal_crest \"Infratemporal crest\") on the great wing of the [sphenoid](/wiki/Sphenoid_bone \"Sphenoid bone\"). Between the posterior wall of the [external acoustic meatus](/wiki/External_acoustic_meatus \"External acoustic meatus\") and the posterior root of the zygomatic process is the area called the suprameatal triangle (Macewen), or [mastoid fossa](/wiki/Mastoid_fossa \"Mastoid fossa\"), through which an instrument may be pushed into the [tympanic antrum](/wiki/Tympanic_antrum \"Tympanic antrum\").",
"At the junction of the anterior root with the zygomatic process is a projection for the attachment of the [temporomandibular ligament](/wiki/Temporomandibular_ligament \"Temporomandibular ligament\"); and behind the anterior root is an oval depression, forming part of the mandibular fossa, for the reception of the condyle of the mandible. The mandibular fossa (glenoid fossa) is bounded, in front, by the articular tubercle; behind, by the tympanic part of the bone, which separates it from the external acoustic meatus; it is divided into two parts by a narrow slit, the petrotympanic fissure ([Glaserian fissure](/wiki/Glaserian_fissure \"Glaserian fissure\")). The anterior part, formed by the squamous part, is smooth, covered in the fresh state with [cartilage](/wiki/Cartilage \"Cartilage\"), and articulates with the [condyle of the mandible](/wiki/Ramus_mandibulae%23Condyloid_Process \"Ramus mandibulae#Condyloid Process\"). Behind this part of the fossa is a small conical eminence; this is the representative of a prominent tubercle which, in some mammals, descends behind the condyle of the mandible, and prevents its backward displacement. The posterior part of the mandibular fossa, formed by the [tympanic part](/wiki/Tympanic_part \"Tympanic part\") of the bone, is non\\-articular, and sometimes lodges a portion of the [parotid gland](/wiki/Parotid_gland \"Parotid gland\").",
"The [petrotympanic fissure](/wiki/Petrotympanic_fissure \"Petrotympanic fissure\") leads into the [middle ear](/wiki/Middle_ear \"Middle ear\") or [tympanic cavity](/wiki/Tympanic_cavity \"Tympanic cavity\"); it lodges the anterior process of the [malleus](/wiki/Malleus \"Malleus\"), and transmits the tympanic branch of the [internal maxillary artery](/wiki/Internal_maxillary_artery \"Internal maxillary artery\"). The [chorda tympani](/wiki/Chorda_tympani \"Chorda tympani\") nerve passes through a canal (canal of [Huguier](/wiki/Huguier \"Huguier\")), separated from the anterior edge of the petrotympanic fissure by a thin scale of bone and situated on the lateral side of the [auditory tube](/wiki/Auditory_tube \"Auditory tube\"), in the retiring angle between the squamous part and the petrous portion of the temporal bone.",
"The **internal surface** of the squamous part is concave; it presents depressions corresponding to the convolutions of the temporal lobe of the brain, and grooves for the branches of the middle [meningeal vessels](/wiki/Meningeal_vessel \"Meningeal vessel\").",
""
] |
Economy and infrastructure
--------------------------
The most important employer is [Huf Haus GmbH \& Co](/wiki/Huf_Haus "Huf Haus") which employs 470 people.
### Hartenfelser Kopf Windfarm
In the summer of 2006, 12 Enercon E\-70 [wind turbines](/wiki/Wind_turbine "Wind turbine") were installed on the Hartenfelser Kopf. These supply roughly 12,500 households, making it one of the biggest windfarm projects in a forest that has ever been built in the Federal Republic. Four of the turbines stand within Hartenfels’s limits.
### Regular events
In January, in honour of the community’s [patron saint](/wiki/Patron_saint "Patron saint"), [Anthony](/wiki/Anthony_the_Great "Anthony the Great"), whose feast day is 17 January, two concerts are held by the community’s music club on two consecutive weekends. On the Burgberg (“Castle Mountain”), the yearly music festival *Rock am Turm* is held at [Whitsun](/wiki/Whitsun "Whitsun"). At [Christmas](/wiki/Christmas "Christmas"), a lit, real [fir](/wiki/Fir "Fir") tree (*Tannenbaum* in [German](/wiki/German_language "German language")) up to 8 m tall is put up on top of the castle tower. The [kermis](/wiki/Kermis "Kermis") in Hartenfels is usually held on the first weekend in July.
### Choirs, clubs, etc.
The community is enriched by a music club with many members, a likewise popular volunteer [fire brigade](/wiki/Fire_brigade "Fire brigade"), a *Möhnenverein* (roughly, “Foolish Women’s Club” – it is an organization devoted to the yearly [Carnival](/wiki/Carnival "Carnival") festivities) with a men’s ballet, as well as a church [choir](/wiki/Choir "Choir").
### Transport
The community lies west of *[Bundesstraße](/wiki/Bundesstra%C3%9Fe "Bundesstraße")* 8, leading from [Limburg an der Lahn](/wiki/Limburg_an_der_Lahn "Limburg an der Lahn") to [Siegburg](/wiki/Siegburg "Siegburg"). The nearest [Autobahn](/wiki/Autobahn "Autobahn") [interchange](/wiki/Interchange_%28road%29 "Interchange (road)") is *[Mogendorf](/wiki/Mogendorf "Mogendorf")* on the [A 3](/wiki/Bundesautobahn_3 "Bundesautobahn 3") ([Cologne](/wiki/Cologne "Cologne")–[Frankfurt](/wiki/Frankfurt_am_Main "Frankfurt am Main")). There are further Autobahn interchanges near [Dierdorf](/wiki/Dierdorf "Dierdorf") and [Montabaur](/wiki/Montabaur "Montabaur"). The nearest [InterCityExpress](/wiki/InterCityExpress "InterCityExpress") stop is the [railway station](/wiki/Railway_station "Railway station") at Montabaur on the [Cologne\-Frankfurt high\-speed rail line](/wiki/Cologne-Frankfurt_high-speed_rail_line "Cologne-Frankfurt high-speed rail line").
|
[
"Economy and infrastructure\n--------------------------",
"The most important employer is [Huf Haus GmbH \\& Co](/wiki/Huf_Haus \"Huf Haus\") which employs 470 people.",
"### Hartenfelser Kopf Windfarm",
"In the summer of 2006, 12 Enercon E\\-70 [wind turbines](/wiki/Wind_turbine \"Wind turbine\") were installed on the Hartenfelser Kopf. These supply roughly 12,500 households, making it one of the biggest windfarm projects in a forest that has ever been built in the Federal Republic. Four of the turbines stand within Hartenfels’s limits.",
"### Regular events",
"In January, in honour of the community’s [patron saint](/wiki/Patron_saint \"Patron saint\"), [Anthony](/wiki/Anthony_the_Great \"Anthony the Great\"), whose feast day is 17 January, two concerts are held by the community’s music club on two consecutive weekends. On the Burgberg (“Castle Mountain”), the yearly music festival *Rock am Turm* is held at [Whitsun](/wiki/Whitsun \"Whitsun\"). At [Christmas](/wiki/Christmas \"Christmas\"), a lit, real [fir](/wiki/Fir \"Fir\") tree (*Tannenbaum* in [German](/wiki/German_language \"German language\")) up to 8 m tall is put up on top of the castle tower. The [kermis](/wiki/Kermis \"Kermis\") in Hartenfels is usually held on the first weekend in July.",
"### Choirs, clubs, etc.",
"The community is enriched by a music club with many members, a likewise popular volunteer [fire brigade](/wiki/Fire_brigade \"Fire brigade\"), a *Möhnenverein* (roughly, “Foolish Women’s Club” – it is an organization devoted to the yearly [Carnival](/wiki/Carnival \"Carnival\") festivities) with a men’s ballet, as well as a church [choir](/wiki/Choir \"Choir\").",
"### Transport",
"The community lies west of *[Bundesstraße](/wiki/Bundesstra%C3%9Fe \"Bundesstraße\")* 8, leading from [Limburg an der Lahn](/wiki/Limburg_an_der_Lahn \"Limburg an der Lahn\") to [Siegburg](/wiki/Siegburg \"Siegburg\"). The nearest [Autobahn](/wiki/Autobahn \"Autobahn\") [interchange](/wiki/Interchange_%28road%29 \"Interchange (road)\") is *[Mogendorf](/wiki/Mogendorf \"Mogendorf\")* on the [A 3](/wiki/Bundesautobahn_3 \"Bundesautobahn 3\") ([Cologne](/wiki/Cologne \"Cologne\")–[Frankfurt](/wiki/Frankfurt_am_Main \"Frankfurt am Main\")). There are further Autobahn interchanges near [Dierdorf](/wiki/Dierdorf \"Dierdorf\") and [Montabaur](/wiki/Montabaur \"Montabaur\"). The nearest [InterCityExpress](/wiki/InterCityExpress \"InterCityExpress\") stop is the [railway station](/wiki/Railway_station \"Railway station\") at Montabaur on the [Cologne\\-Frankfurt high\\-speed rail line](/wiki/Cologne-Frankfurt_high-speed_rail_line \"Cologne-Frankfurt high-speed rail line\").",
""
] |
Production
----------
*Nemo* was the brainchild of producer Yutaka Fujioka, then president of [Tokyo Movie Shinsha](/wiki/TMS_Entertainment "TMS Entertainment") (TMS). He had long realized the limitations of the animation business in Japan and wanted to enter the U.S. market, so he started a new animation studio and planned to distribute U.S.\-Japan co\-produced animation films worldwide.{{cite web\|url\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782\|author\= \|title\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(1\)\|language\= ja\|date\=2021\-12\-02\|accessdate\= 2022\-04\-03\|website\= マグミクス\|publisher\= メディア・ヴァーグ}}{{cite web\|url\= https://cinemajp.com/2019/09/22/anime005/\|author\= 西川昭幸\|title\= 日本アニメ海外進出の先鞭をつけた野心作 NEMO ニモ(東宝東和)\|language\= ja\|date\= 2019\-09\-22\|accessdate\= 2022\-04\-04\|website\= \|publisher\= 日本映画100年史\|archive\-date\= November 26, 2020\|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20201126064311/https://cinemajp.com/2019/09/22/anime005/\|url\-status\= dead}}{{cite web\|url\= https://reminder.top/742391829/\|author\= \|title\=宮崎駿も降板、壮大すぎたアニメ「NEMO/ニモ」映画より面白い制作過程!\|language\= ja\|date\= 2019\-11\-22\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|website\= Re:minder\|publisher\= 株式会社リマインダー}}
He founded [Telecom Animation Film](/wiki/Telecom_Animation_Film "Telecom Animation Film") in 1975, and embarked on a film adaptation of the legendary comic strip *Little Nemo*, which was so well known in the U.S. that two film adaptations were proposed during [Walt Disney](/wiki/Walt_Disney "Walt Disney")'s lifetime.
As the first step towards realizing this project, in 1977 he personally flew to [Monterey, California](/wiki/Monterey%2C_California "Monterey, California"), to convince the McCay descendants to allow him to obtain the film rights, and he finally won it in the summer of 1978\.
Fujioka had another dream: to make a "full animation" (not Japanese limited animation) film that could compete with Disney. For this purpose, Fujioka hired newcomers with no experience in Japanese TV animation and had them trained by Sadao Tsukioka, followed by [Yasuo Ōtsuka](/wiki/Yasuo_%C5%8Ctsuka "Yasuo Ōtsuka"). Incidentally, the 1980 pilot film was created by Tsukioka.
However, a lack of funding and inexperienced animators made it difficult to go into *Nemo* production, so he hired veteran staff away from other studios to work on *[Lupin the Third Part II](/wiki/Lupin_the_Third_Part_II "Lupin the Third Part II")*, Hayao Miyazaki's film *[Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro](/wiki/Lupin_III:The_Castle_of_Cagliostro "The Castle of Cagliostro")*, and Isao Takahata's film *[Jarinko Chie](/wiki/Jarinko_Chie_%28film%29 "Jarinko Chie (film)")*. And he frequently held screenings of those two films of Miyazaki and Takahata for film professionals in the U.S. to showcase his company's capabilities.
In the spring of 1981, Fujioka launched the project after securing a 4 billion yen investment from consumer finance company Lake.
Fujioka initially approached [George Lucas](/wiki/George_Lucas "George Lucas"), who was then at the height of his career with *Star Wars* and *Indiana Jones*, about co\-producing the film as a foothold to penetrate the American market.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_016\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第16回 思弁的なハリウッド\|date\= 2009\-12\-21\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}} Lucas, however, declined the offer, citing difficulties with the initial draft plot. Fujioka also approached [Chuck Jones](/wiki/Chuck_Jones "Chuck Jones"), but Jones also declined.
So he asked Gary Kurtz, who had been recommended by Lucas to replace him, as producer of the American side, and Kurtz readily agreed, appointing Ray Bradbury as screenwriter.
In February 1982, it was announced that Kineto TMS, an American corporation, would be established as a [joint venture](/wiki/Joint_venture "Joint venture") between TMS and Kurtz's Kineto Graphic, Inc. for the purpose of producing a Japan\-US co\-production film.{{cite web\|url\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782/2\|author\= \|title\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(2\)\|language\= ja\|date\=2021\-12\-02\|accessdate\= 2022\-04\-04\|website\= マグミクス\|publisher\= メディア・ヴァーグ}} At the same time, Fujioka and Kurtz were appointed as executive producers, with Kurtz handling the film's content and Fujioka managing the budget and other aspects of production.
In the summer of 1982, Kurtz had Bradbury and his newly hired Edward Summer completely rewrite the story to reflect his intentions. Bradbury realized that the name "Nemo" (the nobody), when read backward, would be "Omen" (the omen), and prepared a script that said, "Nemo, guided by his split personality Omen, dives deep into the dream world, defeats Omen and returns to the real world." In contrast, the original draft by Hayao Miyazaki was the prototype for the later *[Laputa: Castle in the Sky](/wiki/LAPUTA:Castle_in_the_Sky "Castle in the Sky")*, which considered the "dream world" to be an alternate world that existed in reality and was "the story of a boy, a kingdom of abandoned robots and their princess, and [airship](/wiki/Airship "Airship") [bandits](/wiki/Air_pirate "Air pirate")."
At the same time, Fujioka brought in [Frank Thomas](/wiki/Frank_Thomas_%28animator%29 "Frank Thomas (animator)") and [Ollie Johnston](/wiki/Ollie_Johnston "Ollie Johnston") from the "Nine Old Men," a legendary group of animators from Disney's early days, as advisors in order to produce "full animation" in the Disney style. At the invitation of the two, a total of 12 Japanese staff members, including Isao Takahata, Hayao Miyazaki, Yasuo Ōtsuka, Yoshifumi Kondo, and Kazuhide Tomonaga, traveled to the United States to receive training in American\-style character animation. However, when they saw Miyazaki's sketch, they were puzzled: "We have nothing to teach them." The Japanese staff was also greatly inspired by their creative approach.{{cite web\|url\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782/3\|author\= \|title\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(3\)\|language\= ja\|date\=2021\-12\-02\|accessdate\= 2022\-04\-04\|website\= マグミクス\|publisher\= メディア・ヴァーグ}}
The main staff then traveled back and forth between Japan and the U.S. to work jointly with [Andy Gaskill](/wiki/Andy_Gaskill "Andy Gaskill") and [Roger Allers](/wiki/Roger_Allers "Roger Allers"), who were introduced by Thomas and Johnston and who would later support Disney's work.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_022\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第22回 演助助になる\|date\= 2010\-02\-22\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}}
Miyazaki and Takahata, who was scheduled to join the project as soon as his previous work was finished, were the two candidates for the Japanese director, but Miyazaki was negative about the project itself from the early stage, saying, "A film that professes to be set in a dream world will only make the audience blank out.
After reading the first draft of Bradbury's scenario, Miyazaki wondered if it could be considered an entertainment film, and submitted a report to Kurtz summarizing the elements of what he considered an entertaining film, but it was rejected. Next, Miyazaki proposed Fujioka with ideas such as "the story of a young man turned into a beast and a princess in the age of provincial wars," which later became *[Princess Mononoke](/wiki/Princess_Mononoke "Princess Mononoke")*, "the story of Demon Extermination of a princess and her wolf," which was based on the American comic *ROWLF*, and *Yara the windmaster* and *Princess of the dorok* derived from it, which later became the image source of *[Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind](/wiki/Nausica%C3%A4_of_the_Valley_of_the_Wind_%28film%29 "Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (film)")*.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_018\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第18回 捨てられた骨法\|date\= 2010\-01\-18\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}} However, Fujioka had no authority to intervene in the scenarios, and Kurtz never adopted them. Miyazaki then left Telecom on November 22, 1982, without waiting for Takahata to join.
Takahata, who joined the project in just after Miyazaki had left, tried to construct a story based on *[Peter Pan](/wiki/Peter_Pan "Peter Pan")* and *[Where the Wild Things Are](/wiki/Where_the_Wild_Things_Are "Where the Wild Things Are")*, among others.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_020\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第20回 ひっかしいだ新スタジオ\|date\= 2010\-02\-01\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}} He then adopted Bradbury's idea and came up with a story structure in which "the main character is split into two positions, each of which becomes a component of the story." This structure was later carried over to *[Grave of the Fireflies](/wiki/Grave_of_the_Fireflies "Grave of the Fireflies")* and *[Only Yesterday](/wiki/Only_Yesterday_%281991_film%29 "Only Yesterday (1991 film)")*.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_024\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第24回 演出補になる\|date\= 2010\-03\-08\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}} On March 12, 1983, Takahata also clashed with Kurtz over a scenario and left Telecom.
The directors who succeeded the duo were Andy Gaskill and Yoshifumi Kondo, but both soon retired from production.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\=fnL\-6yLzgWA \|title\=Little Nemo test film \|publisher\=YouTube \|date\=2008\-04\-08 \|access\-date\=2012\-02\-28}}{{cbignore}}{{Dead YouTube link\|date\=February 2022}}
At that time, Kineto TMS was frequented by animation professionals who had heard rumors of the project or were interested in Japanese animation. [John Lasseter](/wiki/John_Lasseter "John Lasseter") first met Hayao Miyazaki here and began to interact with him thereafter. [Brad Bird](/wiki/Brad_Bird "Brad Bird") is reported to have informally painted a few image boards.{{Cite news \|url \= https://kakuyomu.jp/works/1177354054888261012/episodes/1177354054889724913\|author\= \|title \= 【1980年代 (3\)】宮崎駿作品でもヒットしなかった時代\|website \= カクヨム\| publisher \= \[\[KADOKAWA]], 株式会社はてな\|language\= ja\|date \= \| accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04}}
Brad Bird and [Jerry Rees](/wiki/Jerry_Rees "Jerry Rees") also worked on the film through the American department as animators for a month, while at the same time working on an unproduced adaptation of [Will Eisner](/wiki/Will_Eisner "Will Eisner")'s *[The Spirit](/wiki/Spirit_%28comics%29 "Spirit (comics)")* with Gary Kurtz. During production, the two would regularly ask animators what they were doing, and the response they were commonly given was "We're just illustrating what Bradbury is writing." Upon meeting Bradbury in person and asking him about the story he was writing for the film, he replied "I'm just putting in writing what these wonderful artists are drawing." Bird and Rees left the project soon after their meeting with Bradbury.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.cartoonbrew.com/anime/little\-nemo\-test\-film.html \|title\=Little Nemo test film \| Cartoon Brew: Leading the Animation Conversation \|publisher\=Cartoon Brew \|access\-date\=2012\-02\-28 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120323020135/http://www.cartoonbrew.com/anime/little\-nemo\-test\-film.html \|archive\-date\=March 23, 2012 \|df\=mdy\-all }}
Two years passed without a director being selected, and the project was suspended in August 1984 when the production fund ran out.
Kurtz would eventually step down in the fall of 1984\.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.pelleas.net/hm/28\.shtml \|title\=Masami Hata Filmography \> 28 \|publisher\=Pelleas.net \|date\=1989\-07\-15 \|access\-date\=2012\-02\-28}} He was involved in other projects, so he did not show up at the *Nemo* project very often, and when he did occasionally, he caused friction with the Japanese staff, so he was removed from the project. However, the staff continued to change rapidly after that. Kondo went to the U.S. in the summer of 1984 to work with Kurtz and Gaskill, but returned home and began making a 70mm pilot film in September. It was a different film from the actual film, based on the storyboards Tomonaga had drawn when Takahata was a director; after completing it in December, Kondo left Telecom in March 1985\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_029\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第29回 パイロット・フィルム\|date\= 2010\-04\-19\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}}{{cite web\|url\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\_033\.shtml\|author\=片渕須直\|title\=β運動の岸辺で 第33回 突貫作業へのいざない\|date\= 2010\-05\-24\| accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|language\= ja\|website\=WEBアニメスタイル\|publisher\=株式会社スタイル}} Bradbury also dropped out. [Osamu Dezaki](/wiki/Osamu_Dezaki "Osamu Dezaki") was also brought to direct for a brief while and completed another pilot film, but left as well. [Jean Giraud](/wiki/Jean_Giraud "Jean Giraud") (Mœbius), who later joined the project, saw the sketches Miyazaki had left behind and asked Fujioka closely why he did not adopt them. He and Miyazaki then began to interact with each other.{{cite web\|url\= https://animeanime.jp/article/2012/07/24/10899\.html\|author\= \|title\= ユーロマンガ最新号は、メビウス追悼特集 宮崎駿コメントなど\|language\= ja\|date\= 2012\-07\-24\|accessdate \= 2022\-04\-04\|website\=アニメ!アニメ!\|publisher\= イード}}
During the hiatus, Fujioka continued to have many people write manuscripts, including Chris Columbus, Mœbius, [John Canemaker](/wiki/John_Canemaker "John Canemaker"), [Richard Martini](/wiki/Richard_Martini_%28director%29 "Richard Martini (director)") and many others. He then re\-hired Summer to do yet another screenplay. Ultimately, [Richard Outten](/wiki/Richard_Outten "Richard Outten") wrote the script based on a plot Columbus wrote between May 1985 and May 1986 before making his directorial debut with *[Adventures in Babysitting](/wiki/Adventures_in_Babysitting "Adventures in Babysitting")*.
When Lake agreed to an additional investment of 1 billion yen in 1987, Fujioka was the first to cancel his contract with Kurtz, and resume production at the newly established Los Angeles TMS. Fujioka himself became an executive producer and took full control of the project.
On the American side, William T. Hurtz was hired at the recommendation of Thomas and Johnston, and on the Japanese side, Masami Hata, who had experience in full animation films at [Sanrio](/wiki/Sanrio "Sanrio"), was hired as the director. Many [Disney Studio](/wiki/Walt_Disney_Pictures "Walt Disney Pictures") animators including [Ken Anderson](/wiki/Ken_Anderson_%28animator%29 "Ken Anderson (animator)") and Leo Salkin worked on individual sequences, and John Canemaker, Corny Cole, and [Brian Froud](/wiki/Brian_Froud "Brian Froud") provided visual development. [Frank Thomas](/wiki/Frank_Thomas_%28animator%29 "Frank Thomas (animator)"), [Oliver Johnston](/wiki/Ollie_Johnston "Ollie Johnston") and [Paul Julian](/wiki/Paul_Julian_%28artist%29 "Paul Julian (artist)") consulted to the production.
The world\-famous [Sherman Brothers](/wiki/Sherman_Brothers "Sherman Brothers") ([Richard M. Sherman](/wiki/Richard_M._Sherman "Richard M. Sherman") and [Robert B. Sherman](/wiki/Robert_B._Sherman "Robert B. Sherman")) were hired to write the songs for *Nemo*. This was their first and only [anime](/wiki/Anime "Anime") film, though not their first animated film; the pair had previously worked on most notably Disney's *[Mary Poppins](/wiki/Mary_Poppins_%28film%29 "Mary Poppins (film)")* in 1964 and several other projects for Disney, including *[The Jungle Book](/wiki/The_Jungle_Book_%281967_film%29 "The Jungle Book (1967 film)")*, the [Peanuts](/wiki/Peanuts "Peanuts") animated musical *[Snoopy Come Home](/wiki/Snoopy_Come_Home "Snoopy Come Home")*, and Hanna\-Barbera's *[Charlotte's Web](/wiki/Charlotte%27s_Web_%281973_film%29 "Charlotte's Web (1973 film)")*.
The film was completed in 1988 and released in Japan in 1989 and in the United States in 1992, but failed at the box office. Fujioka took responsibility for the film and left TMS, giving up all rights to the company, and retired from the animation industry before his death on March 30, 1996\.
|
[
"Production\n----------",
"*Nemo* was the brainchild of producer Yutaka Fujioka, then president of [Tokyo Movie Shinsha](/wiki/TMS_Entertainment \"TMS Entertainment\") (TMS). He had long realized the limitations of the animation business in Japan and wanted to enter the U.S. market, so he started a new animation studio and planned to distribute U.S.\\-Japan co\\-produced animation films worldwide.{{cite web\\|url\\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782\\|author\\= \\|title\\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(1\\)\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\=2021\\-12\\-02\\|accessdate\\= 2022\\-04\\-03\\|website\\= マグミクス\\|publisher\\= メディア・ヴァーグ}}{{cite web\\|url\\= https://cinemajp.com/2019/09/22/anime005/\\|author\\= 西川昭幸\\|title\\= 日本アニメ海外進出の先鞭をつけた野心作 NEMO ニモ(東宝東和)\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\= 2019\\-09\\-22\\|accessdate\\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|website\\= \\|publisher\\= 日本映画100年史\\|archive\\-date\\= November 26, 2020\\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20201126064311/https://cinemajp.com/2019/09/22/anime005/\\|url\\-status\\= dead}}{{cite web\\|url\\= https://reminder.top/742391829/\\|author\\= \\|title\\=宮崎駿も降板、壮大すぎたアニメ「NEMO/ニモ」映画より面白い制作過程!\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\= 2019\\-11\\-22\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|website\\= Re:minder\\|publisher\\= 株式会社リマインダー}}\nHe founded [Telecom Animation Film](/wiki/Telecom_Animation_Film \"Telecom Animation Film\") in 1975, and embarked on a film adaptation of the legendary comic strip *Little Nemo*, which was so well known in the U.S. that two film adaptations were proposed during [Walt Disney](/wiki/Walt_Disney \"Walt Disney\")'s lifetime.\nAs the first step towards realizing this project, in 1977 he personally flew to [Monterey, California](/wiki/Monterey%2C_California \"Monterey, California\"), to convince the McCay descendants to allow him to obtain the film rights, and he finally won it in the summer of 1978\\.",
"Fujioka had another dream: to make a \"full animation\" (not Japanese limited animation) film that could compete with Disney. For this purpose, Fujioka hired newcomers with no experience in Japanese TV animation and had them trained by Sadao Tsukioka, followed by [Yasuo Ōtsuka](/wiki/Yasuo_%C5%8Ctsuka \"Yasuo Ōtsuka\"). Incidentally, the 1980 pilot film was created by Tsukioka.",
"However, a lack of funding and inexperienced animators made it difficult to go into *Nemo* production, so he hired veteran staff away from other studios to work on *[Lupin the Third Part II](/wiki/Lupin_the_Third_Part_II \"Lupin the Third Part II\")*, Hayao Miyazaki's film *[Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro](/wiki/Lupin_III:The_Castle_of_Cagliostro \"The Castle of Cagliostro\")*, and Isao Takahata's film *[Jarinko Chie](/wiki/Jarinko_Chie_%28film%29 \"Jarinko Chie (film)\")*. And he frequently held screenings of those two films of Miyazaki and Takahata for film professionals in the U.S. to showcase his company's capabilities.",
"In the spring of 1981, Fujioka launched the project after securing a 4 billion yen investment from consumer finance company Lake.",
"Fujioka initially approached [George Lucas](/wiki/George_Lucas \"George Lucas\"), who was then at the height of his career with *Star Wars* and *Indiana Jones*, about co\\-producing the film as a foothold to penetrate the American market.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_016\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第16回 思弁的なハリウッド\\|date\\= 2009\\-12\\-21\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}} Lucas, however, declined the offer, citing difficulties with the initial draft plot. Fujioka also approached [Chuck Jones](/wiki/Chuck_Jones \"Chuck Jones\"), but Jones also declined.",
"So he asked Gary Kurtz, who had been recommended by Lucas to replace him, as producer of the American side, and Kurtz readily agreed, appointing Ray Bradbury as screenwriter.",
"In February 1982, it was announced that Kineto TMS, an American corporation, would be established as a [joint venture](/wiki/Joint_venture \"Joint venture\") between TMS and Kurtz's Kineto Graphic, Inc. for the purpose of producing a Japan\\-US co\\-production film.{{cite web\\|url\\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782/2\\|author\\= \\|title\\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(2\\)\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\=2021\\-12\\-02\\|accessdate\\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|website\\= マグミクス\\|publisher\\= メディア・ヴァーグ}} At the same time, Fujioka and Kurtz were appointed as executive producers, with Kurtz handling the film's content and Fujioka managing the budget and other aspects of production.",
"In the summer of 1982, Kurtz had Bradbury and his newly hired Edward Summer completely rewrite the story to reflect his intentions. Bradbury realized that the name \"Nemo\" (the nobody), when read backward, would be \"Omen\" (the omen), and prepared a script that said, \"Nemo, guided by his split personality Omen, dives deep into the dream world, defeats Omen and returns to the real world.\" In contrast, the original draft by Hayao Miyazaki was the prototype for the later *[Laputa: Castle in the Sky](/wiki/LAPUTA:Castle_in_the_Sky \"Castle in the Sky\")*, which considered the \"dream world\" to be an alternate world that existed in reality and was \"the story of a boy, a kingdom of abandoned robots and their princess, and [airship](/wiki/Airship \"Airship\") [bandits](/wiki/Air_pirate \"Air pirate\").\"",
"At the same time, Fujioka brought in [Frank Thomas](/wiki/Frank_Thomas_%28animator%29 \"Frank Thomas (animator)\") and [Ollie Johnston](/wiki/Ollie_Johnston \"Ollie Johnston\") from the \"Nine Old Men,\" a legendary group of animators from Disney's early days, as advisors in order to produce \"full animation\" in the Disney style. At the invitation of the two, a total of 12 Japanese staff members, including Isao Takahata, Hayao Miyazaki, Yasuo Ōtsuka, Yoshifumi Kondo, and Kazuhide Tomonaga, traveled to the United States to receive training in American\\-style character animation. However, when they saw Miyazaki's sketch, they were puzzled: \"We have nothing to teach them.\" The Japanese staff was also greatly inspired by their creative approach.{{cite web\\|url\\= https://magmix.jp/post/69782/3\\|author\\= \\|title\\= 宮崎駿監督幻の米デビュー作『リトル・ニモ』 企画途中で離脱も、数々の出会いと「名作」が生まれ…(3\\)\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\=2021\\-12\\-02\\|accessdate\\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|website\\= マグミクス\\|publisher\\= メディア・ヴァーグ}}",
"The main staff then traveled back and forth between Japan and the U.S. to work jointly with [Andy Gaskill](/wiki/Andy_Gaskill \"Andy Gaskill\") and [Roger Allers](/wiki/Roger_Allers \"Roger Allers\"), who were introduced by Thomas and Johnston and who would later support Disney's work.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_022\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第22回 演助助になる\\|date\\= 2010\\-02\\-22\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}}",
"Miyazaki and Takahata, who was scheduled to join the project as soon as his previous work was finished, were the two candidates for the Japanese director, but Miyazaki was negative about the project itself from the early stage, saying, \"A film that professes to be set in a dream world will only make the audience blank out.\nAfter reading the first draft of Bradbury's scenario, Miyazaki wondered if it could be considered an entertainment film, and submitted a report to Kurtz summarizing the elements of what he considered an entertaining film, but it was rejected. Next, Miyazaki proposed Fujioka with ideas such as \"the story of a young man turned into a beast and a princess in the age of provincial wars,\" which later became *[Princess Mononoke](/wiki/Princess_Mononoke \"Princess Mononoke\")*, \"the story of Demon Extermination of a princess and her wolf,\" which was based on the American comic *ROWLF*, and *Yara the windmaster* and *Princess of the dorok* derived from it, which later became the image source of *[Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind](/wiki/Nausica%C3%A4_of_the_Valley_of_the_Wind_%28film%29 \"Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (film)\")*.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_018\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第18回 捨てられた骨法\\|date\\= 2010\\-01\\-18\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}} However, Fujioka had no authority to intervene in the scenarios, and Kurtz never adopted them. Miyazaki then left Telecom on November 22, 1982, without waiting for Takahata to join.",
"Takahata, who joined the project in just after Miyazaki had left, tried to construct a story based on *[Peter Pan](/wiki/Peter_Pan \"Peter Pan\")* and *[Where the Wild Things Are](/wiki/Where_the_Wild_Things_Are \"Where the Wild Things Are\")*, among others.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_020\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第20回 ひっかしいだ新スタジオ\\|date\\= 2010\\-02\\-01\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}} He then adopted Bradbury's idea and came up with a story structure in which \"the main character is split into two positions, each of which becomes a component of the story.\" This structure was later carried over to *[Grave of the Fireflies](/wiki/Grave_of_the_Fireflies \"Grave of the Fireflies\")* and *[Only Yesterday](/wiki/Only_Yesterday_%281991_film%29 \"Only Yesterday (1991 film)\")*.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_024\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第24回 演出補になる\\|date\\= 2010\\-03\\-08\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}} On March 12, 1983, Takahata also clashed with Kurtz over a scenario and left Telecom.",
"The directors who succeeded the duo were Andy Gaskill and Yoshifumi Kondo, but both soon retired from production.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\\=fnL\\-6yLzgWA \\|title\\=Little Nemo test film \\|publisher\\=YouTube \\|date\\=2008\\-04\\-08 \\|access\\-date\\=2012\\-02\\-28}}{{cbignore}}{{Dead YouTube link\\|date\\=February 2022}}",
"At that time, Kineto TMS was frequented by animation professionals who had heard rumors of the project or were interested in Japanese animation. [John Lasseter](/wiki/John_Lasseter \"John Lasseter\") first met Hayao Miyazaki here and began to interact with him thereafter. [Brad Bird](/wiki/Brad_Bird \"Brad Bird\") is reported to have informally painted a few image boards.{{Cite news \\|url \\= https://kakuyomu.jp/works/1177354054888261012/episodes/1177354054889724913\\|author\\= \\|title \\= 【1980年代 (3\\)】宮崎駿作品でもヒットしなかった時代\\|website \\= カクヨム\\| publisher \\= \\[\\[KADOKAWA]], 株式会社はてな\\|language\\= ja\\|date \\= \\| accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04}}",
"Brad Bird and [Jerry Rees](/wiki/Jerry_Rees \"Jerry Rees\") also worked on the film through the American department as animators for a month, while at the same time working on an unproduced adaptation of [Will Eisner](/wiki/Will_Eisner \"Will Eisner\")'s *[The Spirit](/wiki/Spirit_%28comics%29 \"Spirit (comics)\")* with Gary Kurtz. During production, the two would regularly ask animators what they were doing, and the response they were commonly given was \"We're just illustrating what Bradbury is writing.\" Upon meeting Bradbury in person and asking him about the story he was writing for the film, he replied \"I'm just putting in writing what these wonderful artists are drawing.\" Bird and Rees left the project soon after their meeting with Bradbury.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.cartoonbrew.com/anime/little\\-nemo\\-test\\-film.html \\|title\\=Little Nemo test film \\| Cartoon Brew: Leading the Animation Conversation \\|publisher\\=Cartoon Brew \\|access\\-date\\=2012\\-02\\-28 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120323020135/http://www.cartoonbrew.com/anime/little\\-nemo\\-test\\-film.html \\|archive\\-date\\=March 23, 2012 \\|df\\=mdy\\-all }}",
"Two years passed without a director being selected, and the project was suspended in August 1984 when the production fund ran out.",
"Kurtz would eventually step down in the fall of 1984\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.pelleas.net/hm/28\\.shtml \\|title\\=Masami Hata Filmography \\> 28 \\|publisher\\=Pelleas.net \\|date\\=1989\\-07\\-15 \\|access\\-date\\=2012\\-02\\-28}} He was involved in other projects, so he did not show up at the *Nemo* project very often, and when he did occasionally, he caused friction with the Japanese staff, so he was removed from the project. However, the staff continued to change rapidly after that. Kondo went to the U.S. in the summer of 1984 to work with Kurtz and Gaskill, but returned home and began making a 70mm pilot film in September. It was a different film from the actual film, based on the storyboards Tomonaga had drawn when Takahata was a director; after completing it in December, Kondo left Telecom in March 1985\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_029\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第29回 パイロット・フィルム\\|date\\= 2010\\-04\\-19\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}}{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.style.fm/as/05\\_column/katabuchi/katabuchi\\_033\\.shtml\\|author\\=片渕須直\\|title\\=β運動の岸辺で 第33回 突貫作業へのいざない\\|date\\= 2010\\-05\\-24\\| accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|language\\= ja\\|website\\=WEBアニメスタイル\\|publisher\\=株式会社スタイル}} Bradbury also dropped out. [Osamu Dezaki](/wiki/Osamu_Dezaki \"Osamu Dezaki\") was also brought to direct for a brief while and completed another pilot film, but left as well. [Jean Giraud](/wiki/Jean_Giraud \"Jean Giraud\") (Mœbius), who later joined the project, saw the sketches Miyazaki had left behind and asked Fujioka closely why he did not adopt them. He and Miyazaki then began to interact with each other.{{cite web\\|url\\= https://animeanime.jp/article/2012/07/24/10899\\.html\\|author\\= \\|title\\= ユーロマンガ最新号は、メビウス追悼特集 宮崎駿コメントなど\\|language\\= ja\\|date\\= 2012\\-07\\-24\\|accessdate \\= 2022\\-04\\-04\\|website\\=アニメ!アニメ!\\|publisher\\= イード}}",
"During the hiatus, Fujioka continued to have many people write manuscripts, including Chris Columbus, Mœbius, [John Canemaker](/wiki/John_Canemaker \"John Canemaker\"), [Richard Martini](/wiki/Richard_Martini_%28director%29 \"Richard Martini (director)\") and many others. He then re\\-hired Summer to do yet another screenplay. Ultimately, [Richard Outten](/wiki/Richard_Outten \"Richard Outten\") wrote the script based on a plot Columbus wrote between May 1985 and May 1986 before making his directorial debut with *[Adventures in Babysitting](/wiki/Adventures_in_Babysitting \"Adventures in Babysitting\")*.",
"When Lake agreed to an additional investment of 1 billion yen in 1987, Fujioka was the first to cancel his contract with Kurtz, and resume production at the newly established Los Angeles TMS. Fujioka himself became an executive producer and took full control of the project.",
"On the American side, William T. Hurtz was hired at the recommendation of Thomas and Johnston, and on the Japanese side, Masami Hata, who had experience in full animation films at [Sanrio](/wiki/Sanrio \"Sanrio\"), was hired as the director. Many [Disney Studio](/wiki/Walt_Disney_Pictures \"Walt Disney Pictures\") animators including [Ken Anderson](/wiki/Ken_Anderson_%28animator%29 \"Ken Anderson (animator)\") and Leo Salkin worked on individual sequences, and John Canemaker, Corny Cole, and [Brian Froud](/wiki/Brian_Froud \"Brian Froud\") provided visual development. [Frank Thomas](/wiki/Frank_Thomas_%28animator%29 \"Frank Thomas (animator)\"), [Oliver Johnston](/wiki/Ollie_Johnston \"Ollie Johnston\") and [Paul Julian](/wiki/Paul_Julian_%28artist%29 \"Paul Julian (artist)\") consulted to the production.",
"The world\\-famous [Sherman Brothers](/wiki/Sherman_Brothers \"Sherman Brothers\") ([Richard M. Sherman](/wiki/Richard_M._Sherman \"Richard M. Sherman\") and [Robert B. Sherman](/wiki/Robert_B._Sherman \"Robert B. Sherman\")) were hired to write the songs for *Nemo*. This was their first and only [anime](/wiki/Anime \"Anime\") film, though not their first animated film; the pair had previously worked on most notably Disney's *[Mary Poppins](/wiki/Mary_Poppins_%28film%29 \"Mary Poppins (film)\")* in 1964 and several other projects for Disney, including *[The Jungle Book](/wiki/The_Jungle_Book_%281967_film%29 \"The Jungle Book (1967 film)\")*, the [Peanuts](/wiki/Peanuts \"Peanuts\") animated musical *[Snoopy Come Home](/wiki/Snoopy_Come_Home \"Snoopy Come Home\")*, and Hanna\\-Barbera's *[Charlotte's Web](/wiki/Charlotte%27s_Web_%281973_film%29 \"Charlotte's Web (1973 film)\")*.",
"The film was completed in 1988 and released in Japan in 1989 and in the United States in 1992, but failed at the box office. Fujioka took responsibility for the film and left TMS, giving up all rights to the company, and retired from the animation industry before his death on March 30, 1996\\.",
""
] |
History
-------
Azzun was established in the 17th or 18th century by the Bani Sa'b tribe.Grossman, D. (1986\). "Oscillations in the Rural Settlement of Samaria and Judaea in the Ottoman Period". in **Shomron studies**. Dar, S., Safrai, S., (eds). Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad Publishing House. p. 346 The modern village is situated on a strategically advantageous strong point that overlooks a crossroads. Ancient findings from both the [Hellenistic](/wiki/Hellenistic_period "Hellenistic period") and [Roman](/wiki/Roman_Empire "Roman Empire") periods were found at the site, including the epitaph of a third\-century CE Roman veteran.{{Cite journal \|last\=Applebaum \|first\=Shimon \|last2\=Dar \|first2\=Shimon \|last3\=Safrai \|first3\=Zeev \|date\=1978\-07\-01 \|title\=The Towers of Samaria \|url\=https://doi.org/10\.1179/peq.1978\.110\.2\.91 \|journal\=Palestine Exploration Quarterly \|volume\=110 \|issue\=2 \|pages\=91–100 \|doi\=10\.1179/peq.1978\.110\.2\.91 \|issn\=0031\-0328}}
Several kilometers north of the village are a number of ancient dry stone towers. [PEF](/wiki/PEF_Survey_of_Palestine "PEF Survey of Palestine") visited in 1873 and reported six or seven such towers, the best\-preserved of them had six [courses](/wiki/Course_%28architecture%29 "Course (architecture)") standing, and part of the roof. The locals stated that they were [ancient vineyard towers](/wiki/Watchtower_%28agricultural%29 "Watchtower (agricultural)").Conder and Kitchener, 1882, p. [171](https://archive.org/stream/surveyofwesternp02conduoft#page/171/mode/1up) The towers were surveyed by the Israel Archaeological Survey in 1967–1968, and one of them was excavated in the 1970s on behalf of the Society for the Archaeological Survey of Israel. The excavation uncovered Hellenistic and [early Roman period](/wiki/Judaea_%28Roman_province%29 "Judaea (Roman province)") pottery as well as a single ribbed fragment that may date to the [Byzantine period](/wiki/Palaestina_Prima "Palaestina Prima").
### Ottoman era
Azzun was a site of battle \- part of [Napoleon Bonaparte](/wiki/Napoleon_Bonaparte "Napoleon Bonaparte")'s [campaign](/wiki/French_campaign_in_Egypt_and_Syria "French campaign in Egypt and Syria") in [Ottoman Syria](/wiki/Ottoman_Syria "Ottoman Syria"). An Arab poet, [Ibrahim Touqan](/wiki/Ibrahim_Touqan "Ibrahim Touqan") was quoted as saying, "by means of Azzun, how soaked \[in] the blood \[of] Franks \[in the] mother valley."[Azzun Past and Present](http://www.palestineremembered.com/GeoPoints/_Azzun_2232/Article_7942.html) Abdul Aziz Arar.
When the French army marched into Palestine under the command of Napoleon in February 1799, it faced powerful and unexpected resistance from the inhabitants of Jabal Nablus under the command of their local leaders. They attacked the French army while it was marching towards Acre, especially near the valley of Azzun, taking part in the [battle of Tal\-Tabur](/wiki/Battle_of_Mount_Tabor_%281799%29 "Battle of Mount Tabor (1799)"). The participation of the inhabitants and local leaders of Nablus in the struggle against Napoleon reflected a territorial sense in resistance to a foreign army.
Ihsan al\-Nimr wrote that “the truth is that \[Bonaparte’s] morale was weakened around Jabal Nablus, in the valley of Azzun, Qaqun, and al\-Marj ... he headed for Acre with disappointment and without determination”.al\-Nimr, 1961, pp. 223\-224 Sheikh Yussuf Jarrar wrote a poem asking the inhabitants, especially the prominent families of Jabal Nablus, to march towards Acre in order to fight the French.al\-Nimr, 1961, pp. 210\-211
In Doumani's words, the poet exposes “the cohesiveness of this reign’s social formation and the shared sense of identity among its inhabitants versus the factionalism of multiple territorially based centers of power... The most striking aspect of this poem is what it does not say. Not once in its twenty\-one verses does it mention Ottoman rule, much less the need to protect the empire or the glory and honor of serving the sultan.”Doumani, 1995, pp. [16](https://books.google.com/books?id=zry-tpH3rz8C&pg=PA16)\-17<http://ifpo.revues.org/483> Revues.org [Pierre Jacotin](/wiki/Pierre_Jacotin "Pierre Jacotin") called the village *Hazoun* on his map in 1799 from the same campaign.Karmon, 1960, pp. [156](http://www.jchp.ucla.edu/Bibliography/Karmon,_Y_1960_Jacotin_Map_(IEJ_10).pdf) {{Webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191222063351/http://jchp.ucla.edu/Bibliography/Karmon,\_Y\_1960\_Jacotin\_Map\_(IEJ\_10\).pdf \|date\=2019\-12\-22 }}, 170
In 1838, the American scholar [Edward Robinson](/wiki/Edward_Robinson_%28scholar%29 "Edward Robinson (scholar)") noted *Azzun* as a village in the *Beni Sa'ab* district, west of Nablus.Robinson and Smith, 1841, vol 3, Appendix 2, p. [127](https://archive.org/stream/biblicalresearch03robiuoft#page/127/mode/1up)
In 1852 Robinson visited the village, which he described as having 290 males, all Muslim except for one family of Christians.Robinson and Smith, 1856, pp.[135](https://archive.org/stream/laterbiblicalre01smitgoog#page/n184/mode/1up)\-136 In 1882, the [PEF](/wiki/Palestine_Exploration_Fund "Palestine Exploration Fund")'s *[Survey of Western Palestine](/wiki/PEF_Survey_of_Palestine "PEF Survey of Palestine")* described Azzun as a "small village lying low on the hill\-side, with several [wells](/wiki/Water_well "Water well") and olives on every side."Conder and Kitchener, 1882, SWP II, p. [164](https://archive.org/stream/surveyofwesternp02conduoft#page/164/mode/1up)
In the 1860s, the Ottoman authorities granted the village an agricultural plot of land called Ghabat 'Azzun in the former confines of the Forest of Arsur (Ar. Al\-Ghaba) in the coastal plain, west of the village. This detached parcel of woodland became the nucleus for [Tabsur](/wiki/Tabsur "Tabsur") (Khirbat 'Azzun), founded by 'Azzuni families.Marom, Roy, "The Contribution of Conder's Tent Work in Palestine for the Understanding of Shifting Geographical, Social and Legal Realities in the Sharon during the Late Ottoman Period", in Gurevich D. and Kidron, A. (eds.), *Exploring the Holy Land: 150 Years of the Palestine Exploration Fund*, Sheffield, UK, Equinox (2019\), pp. 212\-231{{Cite web \|last\=Marom \|first\=Roy \|year\=2022 \|title\=The Oak Forest of the Sharon (al\-Ghaba) in the Ottoman Period: New Insights from Historical\- Geographical Studies, Muse 5, \|url\=https://escholarship.org/uc/item/2pc5867s \|access\-date\=2023\-10\-06 \|website\=escholarship.org}}
### British Mandate era
In the [1922 census of Palestine](/wiki/1922_census_of_Palestine "1922 census of Palestine") conducted by the [British Mandate authorities](/wiki/Mandatory_Palestine "Mandatory Palestine"), *Azzun* had a population of 700; 691 [Muslims](/wiki/Muslim "Muslim") and 9 Christians,Barron, 1923, Table IX, Sub\-district of Tulkarem, p. [28](https://archive.org/stream/PalestineCensus1922/Palestine%20Census%20%281922%29#page/n30/mode/1up) increasing in the [1931 census](/wiki/1931_census_of_Palestine "1931 census of Palestine") to 994: 980 Muslim and 14 Christians in a total of 218 houses.Mills, 1932, p. [53](https://archive.org/details/CensusOfPalestine1931.PopulationOfVillagesTownsAndAdministrativeAreas)
In the [1945 statistics](/wiki/Village_Statistics%2C_1945 "Village Statistics, 1945"), the population of Azzun together with [Nabi Ilyas](/wiki/Nabi_Ilyas "Nabi Ilyas") and [Islah](/wiki/Islah%2C_Qalqilya "Islah, Qalqilya") was 1,190; 1,170 Muslims and 20 Christians.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics, 1945, p. [20](http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/VSpages/VS1945_p20.jpg) Residents owned 23,496 [dunams](/wiki/Dunam "Dunam") of land, according to an official land and population survey.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [74](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20I/Tulkarm/Page-074.jpg) Of this, 5,494 dunams were for plantations and irrigable land and 1,420 were used for cereals,Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [124](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20II/Tulkarm/Page-124.jpg) while 55 dunams were built\-up (urban) land.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [174](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20III/Tulkarm/Page-174.jpg)
File:Azzun 1943\.jpg\|Azzun 1943 1:20,000
File:Azzun 1945\.jpg\|Azzun 1945 1:250,000
### Jordanian era
In the wake of the [1948 Arab–Israeli War](/wiki/1948_Arab%E2%80%93Israeli_War "1948 Arab–Israeli War"), and after the [1949 Armistice Agreements](/wiki/1949_Armistice_Agreements "1949 Armistice Agreements"), Azzun came under [Jordanian](/wiki/Jordan "Jordan") rule. It was [annexed by Jordan](/wiki/Jordanian_annexation_of_the_West_Bank "Jordanian annexation of the West Bank") in 1950\.
The Jordanian census of 1961 found 2,096 inhabitants in Azzun.Government of Jordan, Department of Statistics, 1964, p. [15](http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/JordanCensusPages/JordanCensus1961-p15.pdf)
### 1967 and aftermath
Since the [Six\-Day War](/wiki/Six-Day_War "Six-Day War"), Azzun has been under [Israeli occupation](/wiki/Israeli_occupation_of_the_West_Bank "Israeli occupation of the West Bank"). After the [1995 accords](/wiki/Oslo_II_Accord "Oslo II Accord"), about 24\.7% of the land was classified as [Area B](/wiki/Palestinian_enclaves "Palestinian enclaves"), the remaining 75\.3% as [Area C](/wiki/Area_C_%28West_Bank%29 "Area C (West Bank)"). Israel has expropriated 268 dunums of village land for the construction of the [Israeli settlement](/wiki/Israeli_settlement "Israeli settlement") of [Ma'ale Shomron](/wiki/Ma%27ale_Shomron "Ma'ale Shomron"). [‘Azzun Town Profile (including ‘Isla \& ‘Izbat at Tabib Localities)](https://web.archive.org/web/20170818221044/http://vprofile.arij.org/qalqiliya/pdfs/vprofile/azzun_vp_en.pdf), ARIJ, 2013, pp. 18\-19
In 1996 a [municipal council](/wiki/Municipality_%28Palestinian_Authority%29 "Municipality (Palestinian Authority)") was established to administer Azzun's civil affairs. The council has eleven members appointed by the Palestinian government. In 2012, the villages of *Islah* and *Izbat al\-Tabib* were merged into the municipality of Azzun upon decree of the Palestinian Ministry of Local Government. [‘Azzun Town Profile (including ‘Isla \& ‘Izbat at Tabib Localities)](https://web.archive.org/web/20170818221044/http://vprofile.arij.org/qalqiliya/pdfs/vprofile/azzun_vp_en.pdf), ARIJ, 2013\.
In 2008, the town's unemployment rate was 19%.[Israeli Occupation Forces closes the Northern Entrance of the Azzun Al Shamaliyya town](http://www.poica.org/editor/case_studies/view.php?recordID=1288) {{webarchive \|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120214165342/http://www.poica.org/editor/case\_studies/view.php?recordID\=1288 \|date\=February 14, 2012 }} Land Research Center 2008\-02\-20 In 2012, it had increased sharply to 39%.
Today, the town consists of 9,130 dunams of which 1,209 dunams is built\-up area. There are four mosques located in the town. Most of the population works in agriculture and herding (40%) or trade and handicrafts (41%), while the 19% work in public sectors.
As of 2018, Azzun was reported to be the village "with highest number of child arrests in the West Bank per capita."[Azzoun: The Palestinian village filling Israeli jails with children](https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/azzoun-palestinian-village-filling-israeli-jails-children-181214404), Tessa Fox, 10 August 2018, [Middle East Eye](/wiki/Middle_East_Eye "Middle East Eye")
|
[
"History\n-------",
"Azzun was established in the 17th or 18th century by the Bani Sa'b tribe.Grossman, D. (1986\\). \"Oscillations in the Rural Settlement of Samaria and Judaea in the Ottoman Period\". in **Shomron studies**. Dar, S., Safrai, S., (eds). Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad Publishing House. p. 346 The modern village is situated on a strategically advantageous strong point that overlooks a crossroads. Ancient findings from both the [Hellenistic](/wiki/Hellenistic_period \"Hellenistic period\") and [Roman](/wiki/Roman_Empire \"Roman Empire\") periods were found at the site, including the epitaph of a third\\-century CE Roman veteran.{{Cite journal \\|last\\=Applebaum \\|first\\=Shimon \\|last2\\=Dar \\|first2\\=Shimon \\|last3\\=Safrai \\|first3\\=Zeev \\|date\\=1978\\-07\\-01 \\|title\\=The Towers of Samaria \\|url\\=https://doi.org/10\\.1179/peq.1978\\.110\\.2\\.91 \\|journal\\=Palestine Exploration Quarterly \\|volume\\=110 \\|issue\\=2 \\|pages\\=91–100 \\|doi\\=10\\.1179/peq.1978\\.110\\.2\\.91 \\|issn\\=0031\\-0328}}",
"Several kilometers north of the village are a number of ancient dry stone towers. [PEF](/wiki/PEF_Survey_of_Palestine \"PEF Survey of Palestine\") visited in 1873 and reported six or seven such towers, the best\\-preserved of them had six [courses](/wiki/Course_%28architecture%29 \"Course (architecture)\") standing, and part of the roof. The locals stated that they were [ancient vineyard towers](/wiki/Watchtower_%28agricultural%29 \"Watchtower (agricultural)\").Conder and Kitchener, 1882, p. [171](https://archive.org/stream/surveyofwesternp02conduoft#page/171/mode/1up) The towers were surveyed by the Israel Archaeological Survey in 1967–1968, and one of them was excavated in the 1970s on behalf of the Society for the Archaeological Survey of Israel. The excavation uncovered Hellenistic and [early Roman period](/wiki/Judaea_%28Roman_province%29 \"Judaea (Roman province)\") pottery as well as a single ribbed fragment that may date to the [Byzantine period](/wiki/Palaestina_Prima \"Palaestina Prima\").",
"### Ottoman era",
"Azzun was a site of battle \\- part of [Napoleon Bonaparte](/wiki/Napoleon_Bonaparte \"Napoleon Bonaparte\")'s [campaign](/wiki/French_campaign_in_Egypt_and_Syria \"French campaign in Egypt and Syria\") in [Ottoman Syria](/wiki/Ottoman_Syria \"Ottoman Syria\"). An Arab poet, [Ibrahim Touqan](/wiki/Ibrahim_Touqan \"Ibrahim Touqan\") was quoted as saying, \"by means of Azzun, how soaked \\[in] the blood \\[of] Franks \\[in the] mother valley.\"[Azzun Past and Present](http://www.palestineremembered.com/GeoPoints/_Azzun_2232/Article_7942.html) Abdul Aziz Arar.",
"When the French army marched into Palestine under the command of Napoleon in February 1799, it faced powerful and unexpected resistance from the inhabitants of Jabal Nablus under the command of their local leaders. They attacked the French army while it was marching towards Acre, especially near the valley of Azzun, taking part in the [battle of Tal\\-Tabur](/wiki/Battle_of_Mount_Tabor_%281799%29 \"Battle of Mount Tabor (1799)\"). The participation of the inhabitants and local leaders of Nablus in the struggle against Napoleon reflected a territorial sense in resistance to a foreign army.",
"Ihsan al\\-Nimr wrote that “the truth is that \\[Bonaparte’s] morale was weakened around Jabal Nablus, in the valley of Azzun, Qaqun, and al\\-Marj ... he headed for Acre with disappointment and without determination”.al\\-Nimr, 1961, pp. 223\\-224 Sheikh Yussuf Jarrar wrote a poem asking the inhabitants, especially the prominent families of Jabal Nablus, to march towards Acre in order to fight the French.al\\-Nimr, 1961, pp. 210\\-211",
"In Doumani's words, the poet exposes “the cohesiveness of this reign’s social formation and the shared sense of identity among its inhabitants versus the factionalism of multiple territorially based centers of power... The most striking aspect of this poem is what it does not say. Not once in its twenty\\-one verses does it mention Ottoman rule, much less the need to protect the empire or the glory and honor of serving the sultan.”Doumani, 1995, pp. [16](https://books.google.com/books?id=zry-tpH3rz8C&pg=PA16)\\-17<http://ifpo.revues.org/483> Revues.org [Pierre Jacotin](/wiki/Pierre_Jacotin \"Pierre Jacotin\") called the village *Hazoun* on his map in 1799 from the same campaign.Karmon, 1960, pp. [156](http://www.jchp.ucla.edu/Bibliography/Karmon,_Y_1960_Jacotin_Map_(IEJ_10).pdf) {{Webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191222063351/http://jchp.ucla.edu/Bibliography/Karmon,\\_Y\\_1960\\_Jacotin\\_Map\\_(IEJ\\_10\\).pdf \\|date\\=2019\\-12\\-22 }}, 170",
"In 1838, the American scholar [Edward Robinson](/wiki/Edward_Robinson_%28scholar%29 \"Edward Robinson (scholar)\") noted *Azzun* as a village in the *Beni Sa'ab* district, west of Nablus.Robinson and Smith, 1841, vol 3, Appendix 2, p. [127](https://archive.org/stream/biblicalresearch03robiuoft#page/127/mode/1up)",
"In 1852 Robinson visited the village, which he described as having 290 males, all Muslim except for one family of Christians.Robinson and Smith, 1856, pp.[135](https://archive.org/stream/laterbiblicalre01smitgoog#page/n184/mode/1up)\\-136 In 1882, the [PEF](/wiki/Palestine_Exploration_Fund \"Palestine Exploration Fund\")'s *[Survey of Western Palestine](/wiki/PEF_Survey_of_Palestine \"PEF Survey of Palestine\")* described Azzun as a \"small village lying low on the hill\\-side, with several [wells](/wiki/Water_well \"Water well\") and olives on every side.\"Conder and Kitchener, 1882, SWP II, p. [164](https://archive.org/stream/surveyofwesternp02conduoft#page/164/mode/1up)",
"In the 1860s, the Ottoman authorities granted the village an agricultural plot of land called Ghabat 'Azzun in the former confines of the Forest of Arsur (Ar. Al\\-Ghaba) in the coastal plain, west of the village. This detached parcel of woodland became the nucleus for [Tabsur](/wiki/Tabsur \"Tabsur\") (Khirbat 'Azzun), founded by 'Azzuni families.Marom, Roy, \"The Contribution of Conder's Tent Work in Palestine for the Understanding of Shifting Geographical, Social and Legal Realities in the Sharon during the Late Ottoman Period\", in Gurevich D. and Kidron, A. (eds.), *Exploring the Holy Land: 150 Years of the Palestine Exploration Fund*, Sheffield, UK, Equinox (2019\\), pp. 212\\-231{{Cite web \\|last\\=Marom \\|first\\=Roy \\|year\\=2022 \\|title\\=The Oak Forest of the Sharon (al\\-Ghaba) in the Ottoman Period: New Insights from Historical\\- Geographical Studies, Muse 5, \\|url\\=https://escholarship.org/uc/item/2pc5867s \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-10\\-06 \\|website\\=escholarship.org}}",
"### British Mandate era",
"In the [1922 census of Palestine](/wiki/1922_census_of_Palestine \"1922 census of Palestine\") conducted by the [British Mandate authorities](/wiki/Mandatory_Palestine \"Mandatory Palestine\"), *Azzun* had a population of 700; 691 [Muslims](/wiki/Muslim \"Muslim\") and 9 Christians,Barron, 1923, Table IX, Sub\\-district of Tulkarem, p. [28](https://archive.org/stream/PalestineCensus1922/Palestine%20Census%20%281922%29#page/n30/mode/1up) increasing in the [1931 census](/wiki/1931_census_of_Palestine \"1931 census of Palestine\") to 994: 980 Muslim and 14 Christians in a total of 218 houses.Mills, 1932, p. [53](https://archive.org/details/CensusOfPalestine1931.PopulationOfVillagesTownsAndAdministrativeAreas)",
"In the [1945 statistics](/wiki/Village_Statistics%2C_1945 \"Village Statistics, 1945\"), the population of Azzun together with [Nabi Ilyas](/wiki/Nabi_Ilyas \"Nabi Ilyas\") and [Islah](/wiki/Islah%2C_Qalqilya \"Islah, Qalqilya\") was 1,190; 1,170 Muslims and 20 Christians.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics, 1945, p. [20](http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/VSpages/VS1945_p20.jpg) Residents owned 23,496 [dunams](/wiki/Dunam \"Dunam\") of land, according to an official land and population survey.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [74](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20I/Tulkarm/Page-074.jpg) Of this, 5,494 dunams were for plantations and irrigable land and 1,420 were used for cereals,Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [124](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20II/Tulkarm/Page-124.jpg) while 55 dunams were built\\-up (urban) land.Government of Palestine, Department of Statistics. *Village Statistics, April, 1945\\.* Quoted in Hadawi, 1970, p. [174](http://www.palestineremembered.com/download/VillageStatistics/Table%20III/Tulkarm/Page-174.jpg)",
"",
"File:Azzun 1943\\.jpg\\|Azzun 1943 1:20,000\nFile:Azzun 1945\\.jpg\\|Azzun 1945 1:250,000",
"",
"### Jordanian era",
"In the wake of the [1948 Arab–Israeli War](/wiki/1948_Arab%E2%80%93Israeli_War \"1948 Arab–Israeli War\"), and after the [1949 Armistice Agreements](/wiki/1949_Armistice_Agreements \"1949 Armistice Agreements\"), Azzun came under [Jordanian](/wiki/Jordan \"Jordan\") rule. It was [annexed by Jordan](/wiki/Jordanian_annexation_of_the_West_Bank \"Jordanian annexation of the West Bank\") in 1950\\.",
"The Jordanian census of 1961 found 2,096 inhabitants in Azzun.Government of Jordan, Department of Statistics, 1964, p. [15](http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/JordanCensusPages/JordanCensus1961-p15.pdf)",
"### 1967 and aftermath",
"Since the [Six\\-Day War](/wiki/Six-Day_War \"Six-Day War\"), Azzun has been under [Israeli occupation](/wiki/Israeli_occupation_of_the_West_Bank \"Israeli occupation of the West Bank\"). After the [1995 accords](/wiki/Oslo_II_Accord \"Oslo II Accord\"), about 24\\.7% of the land was classified as [Area B](/wiki/Palestinian_enclaves \"Palestinian enclaves\"), the remaining 75\\.3% as [Area C](/wiki/Area_C_%28West_Bank%29 \"Area C (West Bank)\"). Israel has expropriated 268 dunums of village land for the construction of the [Israeli settlement](/wiki/Israeli_settlement \"Israeli settlement\") of [Ma'ale Shomron](/wiki/Ma%27ale_Shomron \"Ma'ale Shomron\"). [‘Azzun Town Profile (including ‘Isla \\& ‘Izbat at Tabib Localities)](https://web.archive.org/web/20170818221044/http://vprofile.arij.org/qalqiliya/pdfs/vprofile/azzun_vp_en.pdf), ARIJ, 2013, pp. 18\\-19",
"In 1996 a [municipal council](/wiki/Municipality_%28Palestinian_Authority%29 \"Municipality (Palestinian Authority)\") was established to administer Azzun's civil affairs. The council has eleven members appointed by the Palestinian government. In 2012, the villages of *Islah* and *Izbat al\\-Tabib* were merged into the municipality of Azzun upon decree of the Palestinian Ministry of Local Government. [‘Azzun Town Profile (including ‘Isla \\& ‘Izbat at Tabib Localities)](https://web.archive.org/web/20170818221044/http://vprofile.arij.org/qalqiliya/pdfs/vprofile/azzun_vp_en.pdf), ARIJ, 2013\\.",
"In 2008, the town's unemployment rate was 19%.[Israeli Occupation Forces closes the Northern Entrance of the Azzun Al Shamaliyya town](http://www.poica.org/editor/case_studies/view.php?recordID=1288) {{webarchive \\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120214165342/http://www.poica.org/editor/case\\_studies/view.php?recordID\\=1288 \\|date\\=February 14, 2012 }} Land Research Center 2008\\-02\\-20 In 2012, it had increased sharply to 39%.",
"Today, the town consists of 9,130 dunams of which 1,209 dunams is built\\-up area. There are four mosques located in the town. Most of the population works in agriculture and herding (40%) or trade and handicrafts (41%), while the 19% work in public sectors.",
"As of 2018, Azzun was reported to be the village \"with highest number of child arrests in the West Bank per capita.\"[Azzoun: The Palestinian village filling Israeli jails with children](https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/azzoun-palestinian-village-filling-israeli-jails-children-181214404), Tessa Fox, 10 August 2018, [Middle East Eye](/wiki/Middle_East_Eye \"Middle East Eye\")",
""
] |
Demographics
------------
{{US Census population
\| 1870 \= 4517
\| 1880 \= 6188
\| 1890 \= 8270
\| 1900 \= 12902
\| 1910 \= 15958
\| 1920 \= 14403
\| 1930 \= 15709
\| 1940 \= 15933
\| 1950 \= 14263
\| 1960 \= 13330
\| 1970 \= 13671
\| 1980 \= 16703
\| 1990 \= 17526
\| 2000 \= 18698
\| 2010 \= 22309
\| 2020 \= 22169
\| estyear \=
\| estimate \=
\| estref \=
\| align\-fn \= center
\| footnote \= U.S. Decennial Census{{cite web\|url\=https://www.census.gov/programs\-surveys/decennial\-census.html\|title\=U.S. Decennial Census\|publisher\=United States Census Bureau\|access\-date\=August 20, 2014}}
1790\-1960{{cite web\|url\=http://mapserver.lib.virginia.edu\|title\=Historical Census Browser\|publisher\=University of Virginia Library\|access\-date\=August 20, 2014}} 1900\-1990{{cite web\|url\=https://www.census.gov/population/cencounts/la190090\.txt\|title\=Population of Counties by Decennial Census: 1900 to 1990\|publisher\=United States Census Bureau\|access\-date\=August 20, 2014}}
1990\-2000{{cite web\|url\=https://www.census.gov/population/www/cen2000/briefs/phc\-t4/tables/tab02\.pdf \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100327165705/http://www.census.gov/population/www/cen2000/briefs/phc\-t4/tables/tab02\.pdf \|archive\-date\=March 27, 2010 \|url\-status\=live\|title\=Census 2000 PHC\-T\-4\. Ranking Tables for Counties: 1990 and 2000\|publisher\=United States Census Bureau\|access\-date\=August 20, 2014}} 2010{{cite web\|title\=State \& County QuickFacts\|url\=http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/22/22043\.html\|publisher\=United States Census Bureau\|access\-date\=August 9, 2013\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110606152722/http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/22/22043\.html\|archive\-date\=June 6, 2011}}
}}
### 2020 census
| \+Grant Parish racial composition{{Cite web\|title\=Explore Census Data\|url\=https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?g\=0500000US22043\&tid\=DECENNIALPL2020\.P2\|access\-date\=December 29, 2021\|website\=data.census.gov}} | Race | Number | Percentage |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 "White (U.S. Census)") (non\-Hispanic) | 16,678 | 75\.23% |
| [Black or African American](/wiki/African_American_%28U.S._Census%29 "African American (U.S. Census)") (non\-Hispanic) | 3,060 | 13\.8% |
| [Native American](/wiki/Native_American_%28U.S._Census%29 "Native American (U.S. Census)") | 193 | 0\.87% |
| [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 "Asian (U.S. Census)") | 67 | 0\.3% |
| [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Pacific_Islander_%28U.S._Census%29 "Pacific Islander (U.S. Census)") | 6 | 0\.03% |
| [Other/Mixed](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)") | 832 | 3\.75% |
| [Hispanic](/wiki/Hispanic_%28U.S._Census%29 "Hispanic (U.S. Census)") or [Latino](/wiki/Latino_%28U.S._Census%29 "Latino (U.S. Census)") | 1,333 | 6\.01% |
As of the [2020 United States census](/wiki/2020_United_States_census "2020 United States census"), there were 22,169 people, 6,989 households, and 4,651 families residing in the parish.
### 2000 census
As of the [census](/wiki/Census "Census"){{cite web\|url\=https://www.census.gov \|publisher\=\[\[United States Census Bureau]] \|access\-date\=January 31, 2008 \|title\=U.S. Census website }} of 2000, there were 18,698 people, 7,073 households, and 5,276 families residing in the parish. The population density was {{convert\|29\|PD/sqmi\|PD/km2\|sp\=us\|adj\=off}}. There were 8,531 housing units at an average density of {{convert\|13\|/mi2\|/km2\|}}. The racial makeup of the parish was 85\.43% [White](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), 11\.88% [Black](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)") or [African American](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), 0\.89% [Native American](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), 0\.14% [Asian](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), 0\.03% [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), 0\.36% from [other races](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), and 1\.28% from two or more races. 1\.14% of the population were [Hispanic](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)") or [Latino](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)") of any race.
The decreases in population from 1910 to 1920, and from 1940 to 1960, were chiefly caused by different phases of the [Great Migration](/wiki/Great_Migration_%28African_American%29 "Great Migration (African American)"), as African Americans left [segregation](/wiki/Racial_segregation "Racial segregation") and oppression of the South to seek better opportunities in the North, during the first phase, and in the West, especially [California](/wiki/California "California")'s defense industry, in the second phase. Tens of thousands of migrants left Louisiana during times of agricultural difficulties and the collapse of agricultural labor after mechanization.["African American Migration Experience: The Second Great Migration", New York Public Library, Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture](http://www.inmotionaame.org/migrations/landing.cfm?migration=9) {{Webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20131104202248/http://www.inmotionaame.org/migrations/landing.cfm?migration\=9 \|date\=November 4, 2013 }}, accessed April 24, 2008
In 2000, there were 7,073 households, out of which 36\.50% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 57\.20% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage "Marriage") living together, 12\.90% had a female householder with no husband present, and 25\.40% were non\-families. 22\.60% of all households were made up of individuals, and 10\.10% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2\.61 and the average family size was 3\.06\.
In the parish the population was spread out, with 28\.30% under the age of 18, 7\.90% from 18 to 24, 28\.10% from 25 to 44, 23\.00% from 45 to 64, and 12\.70% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 36 years. For every 100 females there were 96\.10 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 93\.00 males.
The median income for a household in the parish was $29,622, and the median income for a family was $34,878\. Males had a median income of $31,235 versus $20,470 for females. The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income "Per capita income") for the parish was $14,410\. About 16\.90% of families and 21\.50% of the population were below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line "Poverty line"), including 27\.30% of those under age 18 and 16\.20% of those age 65 or over.
|
[
"Demographics\n------------",
"{{US Census population\n\\| 1870 \\= 4517\n\\| 1880 \\= 6188\n\\| 1890 \\= 8270\n\\| 1900 \\= 12902\n\\| 1910 \\= 15958\n\\| 1920 \\= 14403\n\\| 1930 \\= 15709\n\\| 1940 \\= 15933\n\\| 1950 \\= 14263\n\\| 1960 \\= 13330\n\\| 1970 \\= 13671\n\\| 1980 \\= 16703\n\\| 1990 \\= 17526\n\\| 2000 \\= 18698\n\\| 2010 \\= 22309\n\\| 2020 \\= 22169\n\\| estyear \\= \n\\| estimate \\= \n\\| estref \\= \n\\| align\\-fn \\= center\n\\| footnote \\= U.S. Decennial Census{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.census.gov/programs\\-surveys/decennial\\-census.html\\|title\\=U.S. Decennial Census\\|publisher\\=United States Census Bureau\\|access\\-date\\=August 20, 2014}} \n1790\\-1960{{cite web\\|url\\=http://mapserver.lib.virginia.edu\\|title\\=Historical Census Browser\\|publisher\\=University of Virginia Library\\|access\\-date\\=August 20, 2014}} 1900\\-1990{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.census.gov/population/cencounts/la190090\\.txt\\|title\\=Population of Counties by Decennial Census: 1900 to 1990\\|publisher\\=United States Census Bureau\\|access\\-date\\=August 20, 2014}} \n1990\\-2000{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.census.gov/population/www/cen2000/briefs/phc\\-t4/tables/tab02\\.pdf \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100327165705/http://www.census.gov/population/www/cen2000/briefs/phc\\-t4/tables/tab02\\.pdf \\|archive\\-date\\=March 27, 2010 \\|url\\-status\\=live\\|title\\=Census 2000 PHC\\-T\\-4\\. Ranking Tables for Counties: 1990 and 2000\\|publisher\\=United States Census Bureau\\|access\\-date\\=August 20, 2014}} 2010{{cite web\\|title\\=State \\& County QuickFacts\\|url\\=http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/22/22043\\.html\\|publisher\\=United States Census Bureau\\|access\\-date\\=August 9, 2013\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110606152722/http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/22/22043\\.html\\|archive\\-date\\=June 6, 2011}}\n}}",
"### 2020 census",
"",
"| \\+Grant Parish racial composition{{Cite web\\|title\\=Explore Census Data\\|url\\=https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?g\\=0500000US22043\\&tid\\=DECENNIALPL2020\\.P2\\|access\\-date\\=December 29, 2021\\|website\\=data.census.gov}} | Race | Number | Percentage |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 \"White (U.S. Census)\") (non\\-Hispanic) | 16,678 | 75\\.23% |\n| [Black or African American](/wiki/African_American_%28U.S._Census%29 \"African American (U.S. Census)\") (non\\-Hispanic) | 3,060 | 13\\.8% |\n| [Native American](/wiki/Native_American_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Native American (U.S. Census)\") | 193 | 0\\.87% |\n| [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Asian (U.S. Census)\") | 67 | 0\\.3% |\n| [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Pacific_Islander_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Pacific Islander (U.S. Census)\") | 6 | 0\\.03% |\n| [Other/Mixed](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\") | 832 | 3\\.75% |\n| [Hispanic](/wiki/Hispanic_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Hispanic (U.S. Census)\") or [Latino](/wiki/Latino_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Latino (U.S. Census)\") | 1,333 | 6\\.01% |",
"As of the [2020 United States census](/wiki/2020_United_States_census \"2020 United States census\"), there were 22,169 people, 6,989 households, and 4,651 families residing in the parish.",
"### 2000 census",
"As of the [census](/wiki/Census \"Census\"){{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.census.gov \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Census Bureau]] \\|access\\-date\\=January 31, 2008 \\|title\\=U.S. Census website }} of 2000, there were 18,698 people, 7,073 households, and 5,276 families residing in the parish. The population density was {{convert\\|29\\|PD/sqmi\\|PD/km2\\|sp\\=us\\|adj\\=off}}. There were 8,531 housing units at an average density of {{convert\\|13\\|/mi2\\|/km2\\|}}. The racial makeup of the parish was 85\\.43% [White](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), 11\\.88% [Black](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\") or [African American](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), 0\\.89% [Native American](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), 0\\.14% [Asian](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), 0\\.03% [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), 0\\.36% from [other races](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), and 1\\.28% from two or more races. 1\\.14% of the population were [Hispanic](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\") or [Latino](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\") of any race.",
"The decreases in population from 1910 to 1920, and from 1940 to 1960, were chiefly caused by different phases of the [Great Migration](/wiki/Great_Migration_%28African_American%29 \"Great Migration (African American)\"), as African Americans left [segregation](/wiki/Racial_segregation \"Racial segregation\") and oppression of the South to seek better opportunities in the North, during the first phase, and in the West, especially [California](/wiki/California \"California\")'s defense industry, in the second phase. Tens of thousands of migrants left Louisiana during times of agricultural difficulties and the collapse of agricultural labor after mechanization.[\"African American Migration Experience: The Second Great Migration\", New York Public Library, Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture](http://www.inmotionaame.org/migrations/landing.cfm?migration=9) {{Webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20131104202248/http://www.inmotionaame.org/migrations/landing.cfm?migration\\=9 \\|date\\=November 4, 2013 }}, accessed April 24, 2008",
"In 2000, there were 7,073 households, out of which 36\\.50% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 57\\.20% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage \"Marriage\") living together, 12\\.90% had a female householder with no husband present, and 25\\.40% were non\\-families. 22\\.60% of all households were made up of individuals, and 10\\.10% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2\\.61 and the average family size was 3\\.06\\.",
"In the parish the population was spread out, with 28\\.30% under the age of 18, 7\\.90% from 18 to 24, 28\\.10% from 25 to 44, 23\\.00% from 45 to 64, and 12\\.70% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 36 years. For every 100 females there were 96\\.10 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 93\\.00 males.",
"The median income for a household in the parish was $29,622, and the median income for a family was $34,878\\. Males had a median income of $31,235 versus $20,470 for females. The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income \"Per capita income\") for the parish was $14,410\\. About 16\\.90% of families and 21\\.50% of the population were below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line \"Poverty line\"), including 27\\.30% of those under age 18 and 16\\.20% of those age 65 or over.",
""
] |
Career
------
{{Main\|List of Native American politicians}}
Shannon worked as a field representative for former Congressman [J. C. Watts](/wiki/J._C._Watts "J. C. Watts") and later served in the same position for Congressman [Tom Cole](/wiki/Tom_Cole "Tom Cole"). An enrolled citizen of the [Chickasaw Nation](/wiki/Chickasaw_Nation "Chickasaw Nation"), he worked as the chief administrative officer for Chickasaw Nation Enterprises.
### Oklahoma House of Representatives
[thumb\|left\|Shannon is sworn in as Speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives.](/wiki/File:7G2U5163.jpg "7G2U5163.jpg")
[thumb\|right\|Shannon speaks to the 2013 Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC).](/wiki/File:T.W._Shannon_%288570279853%29.jpg "T.W. Shannon (8570279853).jpg")
Shannon was first elected to the [Oklahoma House of Representatives](/wiki/Oklahoma_House_of_Representatives "Oklahoma House of Representatives") in 2006, defeating opponent Janice Drewry in the general election.[2006 General Election](http://www.ok.gov/elections/documents/06sh.pdf), Oklahoma State Election Board (accessed May 27, 2013\) He rose to leadership in the state House, where he served as deputy majority whip in his first term, chaired the transportation committee in his second term and was elected speaker\-designate in his third term. On January 8, 2013, Shannon took the oath of office to be the [speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives](/wiki/Speaker_of_the_Oklahoma_House_of_Representatives "Speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives").McNutt, Michael. "[T.W. Shannon of Lawton officially takes Oklahoma House speakers post](http://newsok.com/t.w.-shannon-of-lawton-officially-takes-oklahoma-house-speakers-post/article/3744284)," *The Oklahoman*, January 9, 2013 (accessed March 21, 2013\).
He has advocated for identifying and selling off state\-owned properties that were not being fully utilized.McNutt, Michael. [Oklahoma should sell some buildings to fund capitol repairs, lawmaker says](http://newsok.com/oklahoma-should-sell-some-buildings-to-fund-capitol-repairs-lawmaker-says/article/3623053)*The Oklahoman* November 14, 2011\. (accessed March 23, 2013\). Shannon sponsored an eight\-year plan to divert state income tax revenue to repairing Oklahoma's structurally deficient bridges.Hoberock, Barbara. [Oklahoma funding to increase bridge repairs](http://www.tulsaworld.com/news/article.aspx?subjectid=336&articleid=20120605_16_A1_CUTLIN537471), *Tulsa World*, June 12, 2012\. (accessed March 23, 2013\)
As speaker, Shannon authored legislation to create a long\-term plan to address the maintenance of state\-owned properties and consolidate property management entities."[Effort to sell Oklahoma's unused buildings, properties](http://newsok.com/effort-to-sell-oklahomas-unused-buildings-properties-continues/article/3764283)", *The Oklahoman* March 10, 2013 (accessed March 23, 2013\).
The first sale under the program to sell off state\-owned properties was the sale of a former studio for the state public television station for $130,000\. The next properties up for sale are a townlot in Buffalo and 5\.58 acres in Marietta.Krehbiel, Randy. "[Ex\-OETA studio sold through new state program](http://www.tulsaworld.com/article.aspx/Former_Oklahoma_Educational_Television_Authority_studio/20130704_11_A10_Thesta696335)", *Tulsa World*, July 4, 2013\. (accessed July 11, 2013\)
Shannon advocated a controversial measure to require Oklahoma recipients of the [Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program](/wiki/Supplemental_Nutrition_Assistance_Program "Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program") (food stamps) to perform at least 35 hours of work activities or be denied aid. The work requirement was scaled back after the cost of providing job training to SNAP recipients became clear.McNutt, Michael and Kemp, Adam. "[Oklahoma House speaker scales back food stamp work requirement](http://newsok.com/oklahoma-house-speaker-scales-back-food-stamp-work-requirement/article/3763518/)", *The Oklahoman*, March 8, 2011\. (accessed June 27, 2013\).
[GOPAC](/wiki/GOPAC "GOPAC"), an organization whose mission it is to support up\-and\-coming Republican leaders, added Shannon to its national advisory board in 2013\.[CPAC](http://conservative.org/cpac/) (accessed March 21, 2013\).
House district 62 encompasses [Lawton, Oklahoma](/wiki/Lawton%2C_Oklahoma "Lawton, Oklahoma") and its surrounding communities.[House Districts, Congressional and Other Maps](http://www.okhouse.gov/Research/HouseDistricts.aspx) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090507095639/http://www.okhouse.gov/Research/HouseDistricts.aspx \|date\=May 7, 2009 }}, [Oklahoma House of Representatives](http://www.okhouse.gov) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130622043630/http://okhouse.gov/ \|date\=June 22, 2013 }}. (access March 21, 2013\).
### US Senate campaigns
Shannon stepped down as the speaker to run for the Republican nomination in the [2014 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma](/wiki/2014_United_States_Senate_special_election_in_Oklahoma "2014 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma") to succeed [Tom Coburn](/wiki/Tom_Coburn "Tom Coburn").
Despite [Tea Party](/wiki/Tea_Party_movement "Tea Party movement") support and endorsements that included U.S. Senator [Ted Cruz](/wiki/Ted_Cruz "Ted Cruz") of Texas and former Alaska Governor [Sarah Palin](/wiki/Sarah_Palin "Sarah Palin"), Shannon lost the Republican nomination for the Senate to [U.S. Representative](/wiki/United_States_House_of_Representatives "United States House of Representatives") [James Lankford](/wiki/James_Lankford "James Lankford") by almost 20 points.
In March 2022, Shannon announced that he was running in the [2022 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma](/wiki/2022_United_States_Senate_special_election_in_Oklahoma "2022 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma") to succeed the retiring Republican [Jim Inhofe](/wiki/Jim_Inhofe "Jim Inhofe"). He was endorsed by [Bill Anoatubby](/wiki/Bill_Anoatubby "Bill Anoatubby"), the Governor of the [Chickasaw Nation](/wiki/Chickasaw_Nation "Chickasaw Nation").{{cite news \|title\=After eight years, Shannon ready for one more race \|url\=https://tulsaworld.com/news/state\-and\-regional/govt\-and\-politics/after\-eight\-years\-shannon\-ready\-for\-one\-more\-race/article\_cd6fe3c0\-a08a\-11ec\-a957\-5b95c2684f38\.html \|access\-date\=March 10, 2022 \|publisher\=Tulsa World \|date\=March 10, 2022}} Shannon finished in second place in the 13 candidate field, advancing to a runoff against [Markwayne Mullin](/wiki/Markwayne_Mullin "Markwayne Mullin").{{cite web \| url\=https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2022/06/28/mullin\-shannon\-head\-gop\-runoff\-race\-inhofe\-seat/7697900001/ \| title\=Mullin, Shannon head to GOP primary runoff election in race for Inhofe seat }} Mullin defeated Shannon in the runoff.{{cite news \|last1\=Phippen \|first1\=Thomas \|title\=Rep. Markwayne Mullin defeats TW Shannon in Oklahoma GOP Senate runoff \|url\=https://www.foxnews.com/politics/rep\-markwayne\-mullin\-defeats\-tw\-shannon\-oklahoma\-gop\-senate\-runoff \|work\=Fox News \|date\=August 23, 2022}}
|
[
"Career\n------",
"{{Main\\|List of Native American politicians}}",
"Shannon worked as a field representative for former Congressman [J. C. Watts](/wiki/J._C._Watts \"J. C. Watts\") and later served in the same position for Congressman [Tom Cole](/wiki/Tom_Cole \"Tom Cole\"). An enrolled citizen of the [Chickasaw Nation](/wiki/Chickasaw_Nation \"Chickasaw Nation\"), he worked as the chief administrative officer for Chickasaw Nation Enterprises.",
"### Oklahoma House of Representatives",
"[thumb\\|left\\|Shannon is sworn in as Speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives.](/wiki/File:7G2U5163.jpg \"7G2U5163.jpg\")\n[thumb\\|right\\|Shannon speaks to the 2013 Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC).](/wiki/File:T.W._Shannon_%288570279853%29.jpg \"T.W. Shannon (8570279853).jpg\")",
"Shannon was first elected to the [Oklahoma House of Representatives](/wiki/Oklahoma_House_of_Representatives \"Oklahoma House of Representatives\") in 2006, defeating opponent Janice Drewry in the general election.[2006 General Election](http://www.ok.gov/elections/documents/06sh.pdf), Oklahoma State Election Board (accessed May 27, 2013\\) He rose to leadership in the state House, where he served as deputy majority whip in his first term, chaired the transportation committee in his second term and was elected speaker\\-designate in his third term. On January 8, 2013, Shannon took the oath of office to be the [speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives](/wiki/Speaker_of_the_Oklahoma_House_of_Representatives \"Speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives\").McNutt, Michael. \"[T.W. Shannon of Lawton officially takes Oklahoma House speakers post](http://newsok.com/t.w.-shannon-of-lawton-officially-takes-oklahoma-house-speakers-post/article/3744284),\" *The Oklahoman*, January 9, 2013 (accessed March 21, 2013\\).",
"He has advocated for identifying and selling off state\\-owned properties that were not being fully utilized.McNutt, Michael. [Oklahoma should sell some buildings to fund capitol repairs, lawmaker says](http://newsok.com/oklahoma-should-sell-some-buildings-to-fund-capitol-repairs-lawmaker-says/article/3623053)*The Oklahoman* November 14, 2011\\. (accessed March 23, 2013\\). Shannon sponsored an eight\\-year plan to divert state income tax revenue to repairing Oklahoma's structurally deficient bridges.Hoberock, Barbara. [Oklahoma funding to increase bridge repairs](http://www.tulsaworld.com/news/article.aspx?subjectid=336&articleid=20120605_16_A1_CUTLIN537471), *Tulsa World*, June 12, 2012\\. (accessed March 23, 2013\\)",
"As speaker, Shannon authored legislation to create a long\\-term plan to address the maintenance of state\\-owned properties and consolidate property management entities.\"[Effort to sell Oklahoma's unused buildings, properties](http://newsok.com/effort-to-sell-oklahomas-unused-buildings-properties-continues/article/3764283)\", *The Oklahoman* March 10, 2013 (accessed March 23, 2013\\).",
"The first sale under the program to sell off state\\-owned properties was the sale of a former studio for the state public television station for $130,000\\. The next properties up for sale are a townlot in Buffalo and 5\\.58 acres in Marietta.Krehbiel, Randy. \"[Ex\\-OETA studio sold through new state program](http://www.tulsaworld.com/article.aspx/Former_Oklahoma_Educational_Television_Authority_studio/20130704_11_A10_Thesta696335)\", *Tulsa World*, July 4, 2013\\. (accessed July 11, 2013\\)",
"Shannon advocated a controversial measure to require Oklahoma recipients of the [Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program](/wiki/Supplemental_Nutrition_Assistance_Program \"Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program\") (food stamps) to perform at least 35 hours of work activities or be denied aid. The work requirement was scaled back after the cost of providing job training to SNAP recipients became clear.McNutt, Michael and Kemp, Adam. \"[Oklahoma House speaker scales back food stamp work requirement](http://newsok.com/oklahoma-house-speaker-scales-back-food-stamp-work-requirement/article/3763518/)\", *The Oklahoman*, March 8, 2011\\. (accessed June 27, 2013\\).",
"[GOPAC](/wiki/GOPAC \"GOPAC\"), an organization whose mission it is to support up\\-and\\-coming Republican leaders, added Shannon to its national advisory board in 2013\\.[CPAC](http://conservative.org/cpac/) (accessed March 21, 2013\\).",
"House district 62 encompasses [Lawton, Oklahoma](/wiki/Lawton%2C_Oklahoma \"Lawton, Oklahoma\") and its surrounding communities.[House Districts, Congressional and Other Maps](http://www.okhouse.gov/Research/HouseDistricts.aspx) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090507095639/http://www.okhouse.gov/Research/HouseDistricts.aspx \\|date\\=May 7, 2009 }}, [Oklahoma House of Representatives](http://www.okhouse.gov) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130622043630/http://okhouse.gov/ \\|date\\=June 22, 2013 }}. (access March 21, 2013\\).",
"### US Senate campaigns",
"Shannon stepped down as the speaker to run for the Republican nomination in the [2014 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma](/wiki/2014_United_States_Senate_special_election_in_Oklahoma \"2014 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma\") to succeed [Tom Coburn](/wiki/Tom_Coburn \"Tom Coburn\").",
"Despite [Tea Party](/wiki/Tea_Party_movement \"Tea Party movement\") support and endorsements that included U.S. Senator [Ted Cruz](/wiki/Ted_Cruz \"Ted Cruz\") of Texas and former Alaska Governor [Sarah Palin](/wiki/Sarah_Palin \"Sarah Palin\"), Shannon lost the Republican nomination for the Senate to [U.S. Representative](/wiki/United_States_House_of_Representatives \"United States House of Representatives\") [James Lankford](/wiki/James_Lankford \"James Lankford\") by almost 20 points.",
"In March 2022, Shannon announced that he was running in the [2022 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma](/wiki/2022_United_States_Senate_special_election_in_Oklahoma \"2022 United States Senate special election in Oklahoma\") to succeed the retiring Republican [Jim Inhofe](/wiki/Jim_Inhofe \"Jim Inhofe\"). He was endorsed by [Bill Anoatubby](/wiki/Bill_Anoatubby \"Bill Anoatubby\"), the Governor of the [Chickasaw Nation](/wiki/Chickasaw_Nation \"Chickasaw Nation\").{{cite news \\|title\\=After eight years, Shannon ready for one more race \\|url\\=https://tulsaworld.com/news/state\\-and\\-regional/govt\\-and\\-politics/after\\-eight\\-years\\-shannon\\-ready\\-for\\-one\\-more\\-race/article\\_cd6fe3c0\\-a08a\\-11ec\\-a957\\-5b95c2684f38\\.html \\|access\\-date\\=March 10, 2022 \\|publisher\\=Tulsa World \\|date\\=March 10, 2022}} Shannon finished in second place in the 13 candidate field, advancing to a runoff against [Markwayne Mullin](/wiki/Markwayne_Mullin \"Markwayne Mullin\").{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2022/06/28/mullin\\-shannon\\-head\\-gop\\-runoff\\-race\\-inhofe\\-seat/7697900001/ \\| title\\=Mullin, Shannon head to GOP primary runoff election in race for Inhofe seat }} Mullin defeated Shannon in the runoff.{{cite news \\|last1\\=Phippen \\|first1\\=Thomas \\|title\\=Rep. Markwayne Mullin defeats TW Shannon in Oklahoma GOP Senate runoff \\|url\\=https://www.foxnews.com/politics/rep\\-markwayne\\-mullin\\-defeats\\-tw\\-shannon\\-oklahoma\\-gop\\-senate\\-runoff \\|work\\=Fox News \\|date\\=August 23, 2022}}",
""
] |
Career
------
Tichy began playing drums at age eight and started playing guitar at age 12\. His earliest influences include [Kiss](/wiki/Kiss_%28band%29 "Kiss (band)") with [Peter Criss](/wiki/Peter_Criss "Peter Criss") as his main influence, [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin "Led Zeppelin"), [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden "Iron Maiden") with [Nicko McBrain](/wiki/Nicko_McBrain "Nicko McBrain"), [Aerosmith](/wiki/Aerosmith "Aerosmith"), [AC/DC](/wiki/AC/DC "AC/DC"), and [Van Halen](/wiki/Van_Halen "Van Halen")
Since attending [Berklee College of Music](/wiki/Berklee_College_of_Music "Berklee College of Music") from 1986 until 1990, Tichy has toured/recorded with a multitude of artists including [Billy Idol](/wiki/Billy_Idol "Billy Idol"), [Ozzy Osbourne](/wiki/Ozzy_Osbourne "Ozzy Osbourne"), [Seether](/wiki/Seether "Seether"), [Velvet Revolver](/wiki/Velvet_Revolver "Velvet Revolver"), [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 "Foreigner (band)"), [Pride \& Glory](/wiki/Pride_%26_Glory_%28band%29 "Pride & Glory (band)"), [Glenn Hughes](/wiki/Glenn_Hughes_%28British_musician%29 "Glenn Hughes (British musician)"), [Sass Jordan](/wiki/Sass_Jordan "Sass Jordan"), [Slash's Snakepit](/wiki/Slash%27s_Snakepit "Slash's Snakepit"), China Rain, [Whitesnake](/wiki/Whitesnake "Whitesnake") and most recently [The Dead Daisies](/wiki/The_Dead_Daisies "The Dead Daisies").
### Ball
While Tichy has primarily toured and recorded with others playing drums, he has fronted his own band, Ball, in which he sings and plays guitar. Due to the demise of his record label (Time Bomb Recordings), Ball's *American Aggression* CD never was formally released. Ball did manage to release a CD, *The Grand Human Disaster Scenario* (only in Japan) in May 1999\. This CD contains what were essentially the demos that led to the record deal with Time Bomb at the end of 1999\. His increasing role as co\-songwriter with [Billy Idol](/wiki/Billy_Idol "Billy Idol") that started at the end of 2003 limited his time to focus on Ball.
### Billy Idol
The Idol/Tichy writing partnership sparked the recording of Billy Idol's first CD since 1993\. *[Devil's Playground](/wiki/Devil%27s_Playground_%28album%29 "Devil's Playground (album)")* ([Sanctuary Records](/wiki/Sanctuary_Records "Sanctuary Records")) was recorded in 2004 and contained 8 Idol/Tichy tracks. The CD was released in March 2005 and they toured for the remainder of the year.
While writing in 2006 for a follow\-up Idol CD, Tichy and Idol recorded a Christmas album. This was done on their own, in Idol and Tichy's rehearsal studio with Tichy performing drums, guitar, and bass, as well as engineering and co\-producing. *[Happy Holidays](/wiki/Happy_Holidays_%28Billy_Idol_album%29 "Happy Holidays (Billy Idol album)")* by Idol was released in November 2006 through [Best Buy](/wiki/Best_Buy "Best Buy") and in Europe.
### Foreigner
Tichy joined [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 "Foreigner (band)") in 1998 and remained until 2000\. He rejoined briefly in 2007 substituting for [Jason Bonham](/wiki/Jason_Bonham "Jason Bonham"). He then returned from 2008 until 2010, recording the album *[Can't Slow Down](/wiki/Can%27t_Slow_Down_%28Foreigner_album%29 "Can't Slow Down (Foreigner album)")*. He returned for one show in summer 2011, substituting for Mark Schulman, who had recently lost his father. Tichy rejoined Foreigner for the month of August 2012 for live performances, replacing the departed Schulman once again.
### Other projects
Tichy filled in for [Seether](/wiki/Seether "Seether") drummer John Humphrey in April 2007, toured with [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 "Foreigner (band)") through spring of 2009 (replacing Jason Bonham), and recently completed a multi\-year involvement with Billy Idol. He has written music for television and film, and recorded with European female metal singer [Marya Roxx](/wiki/Marya_Roxx "Marya Roxx").
On September 25, 2010, Tichy organized, produced and played in the drummer tribute "Bonzo, The Groove Remains the Same", commemorating the 30th anniversary of the death of Led Zeppelin's [John Bonham](/wiki/John_Bonham "John Bonham"). In 2011, Tichy formed S.U.N. (Something Unto Nothing) as guitarist, with vocalist [Sass Jordan](/wiki/Sass_Jordan "Sass Jordan"), bassist Michael Devin, and drummer [Tommy Stewart](/wiki/Tommy_Stewart "Tommy Stewart"). In 2014, Tichy joined 'Sweet \& Lynch', featuring Michael Sweet, George Lynch and James Lomenzo. In 2018 Tichy replaced Shane Gaalaas as the support drummer for Japanese rock band [B'z](/wiki/B%27z "B'z"), a band he had worked with previously as a session musician.
{{Citation
\| title \= MICHAEL SWEET Reveals Possible Name For Project With GEORGE LYNCH, JAMES LOMENZO, BRIAN TICHY
\| magazine \= Modern Drummer
\| date \= June 25, 2014
\| url \= http://www.blabbermouth.net/news/michael\-sweet\-reveals\-possible\-name\-for\-project\-with\-george\-lynch\-james\-lomenzo\-brian\-tichy
\| access\-date \=
}}
### Whitesnake
Tichy was announced as the new drummer for [Whitesnake](/wiki/Whitesnake "Whitesnake") on June 18, 2010\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\=Article\&newsitemID\=141791 \|title\=WHITESNAKE Parts Ways With DUFFY, FRAZIER; New Drummer Announced \|publisher\=Roadrunnerrecords.com \|access\-date\=2011\-10\-29 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110607023212/http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\=Article\&newsitemID\=141791 \|archive\-date\=2011\-06\-07 }} After several years of worldwide touring, Tichy quit Whitesnake on January 4, 2013, as he planned to focus more time on S.U.N.{{cite web \|url\=http://blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\=Article\&newsitemID\=184421 \|title\=Drummer BRIAN TICHY Quits WHITESNAKE \|publisher\=Roadrunnerrecords.com \|access\-date\=2013\-01\-04 \|archive\-date\=January 7, 2013 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130107030239/http://www.blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\=Article\&newsitemID\=184421 \|url\-status\=dead }}
|
[
"Career\n------",
"Tichy began playing drums at age eight and started playing guitar at age 12\\. His earliest influences include [Kiss](/wiki/Kiss_%28band%29 \"Kiss (band)\") with [Peter Criss](/wiki/Peter_Criss \"Peter Criss\") as his main influence, [Led Zeppelin](/wiki/Led_Zeppelin \"Led Zeppelin\"), [Iron Maiden](/wiki/Iron_Maiden \"Iron Maiden\") with [Nicko McBrain](/wiki/Nicko_McBrain \"Nicko McBrain\"), [Aerosmith](/wiki/Aerosmith \"Aerosmith\"), [AC/DC](/wiki/AC/DC \"AC/DC\"), and [Van Halen](/wiki/Van_Halen \"Van Halen\")",
"Since attending [Berklee College of Music](/wiki/Berklee_College_of_Music \"Berklee College of Music\") from 1986 until 1990, Tichy has toured/recorded with a multitude of artists including [Billy Idol](/wiki/Billy_Idol \"Billy Idol\"), [Ozzy Osbourne](/wiki/Ozzy_Osbourne \"Ozzy Osbourne\"), [Seether](/wiki/Seether \"Seether\"), [Velvet Revolver](/wiki/Velvet_Revolver \"Velvet Revolver\"), [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 \"Foreigner (band)\"), [Pride \\& Glory](/wiki/Pride_%26_Glory_%28band%29 \"Pride & Glory (band)\"), [Glenn Hughes](/wiki/Glenn_Hughes_%28British_musician%29 \"Glenn Hughes (British musician)\"), [Sass Jordan](/wiki/Sass_Jordan \"Sass Jordan\"), [Slash's Snakepit](/wiki/Slash%27s_Snakepit \"Slash's Snakepit\"), China Rain, [Whitesnake](/wiki/Whitesnake \"Whitesnake\") and most recently [The Dead Daisies](/wiki/The_Dead_Daisies \"The Dead Daisies\").",
"### Ball",
"While Tichy has primarily toured and recorded with others playing drums, he has fronted his own band, Ball, in which he sings and plays guitar. Due to the demise of his record label (Time Bomb Recordings), Ball's *American Aggression* CD never was formally released. Ball did manage to release a CD, *The Grand Human Disaster Scenario* (only in Japan) in May 1999\\. This CD contains what were essentially the demos that led to the record deal with Time Bomb at the end of 1999\\. His increasing role as co\\-songwriter with [Billy Idol](/wiki/Billy_Idol \"Billy Idol\") that started at the end of 2003 limited his time to focus on Ball.",
"### Billy Idol",
"The Idol/Tichy writing partnership sparked the recording of Billy Idol's first CD since 1993\\. *[Devil's Playground](/wiki/Devil%27s_Playground_%28album%29 \"Devil's Playground (album)\")* ([Sanctuary Records](/wiki/Sanctuary_Records \"Sanctuary Records\")) was recorded in 2004 and contained 8 Idol/Tichy tracks. The CD was released in March 2005 and they toured for the remainder of the year.",
"While writing in 2006 for a follow\\-up Idol CD, Tichy and Idol recorded a Christmas album. This was done on their own, in Idol and Tichy's rehearsal studio with Tichy performing drums, guitar, and bass, as well as engineering and co\\-producing. *[Happy Holidays](/wiki/Happy_Holidays_%28Billy_Idol_album%29 \"Happy Holidays (Billy Idol album)\")* by Idol was released in November 2006 through [Best Buy](/wiki/Best_Buy \"Best Buy\") and in Europe.",
"### Foreigner",
"Tichy joined [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 \"Foreigner (band)\") in 1998 and remained until 2000\\. He rejoined briefly in 2007 substituting for [Jason Bonham](/wiki/Jason_Bonham \"Jason Bonham\"). He then returned from 2008 until 2010, recording the album *[Can't Slow Down](/wiki/Can%27t_Slow_Down_%28Foreigner_album%29 \"Can't Slow Down (Foreigner album)\")*. He returned for one show in summer 2011, substituting for Mark Schulman, who had recently lost his father. Tichy rejoined Foreigner for the month of August 2012 for live performances, replacing the departed Schulman once again.",
"### Other projects",
"Tichy filled in for [Seether](/wiki/Seether \"Seether\") drummer John Humphrey in April 2007, toured with [Foreigner](/wiki/Foreigner_%28band%29 \"Foreigner (band)\") through spring of 2009 (replacing Jason Bonham), and recently completed a multi\\-year involvement with Billy Idol. He has written music for television and film, and recorded with European female metal singer [Marya Roxx](/wiki/Marya_Roxx \"Marya Roxx\").\nOn September 25, 2010, Tichy organized, produced and played in the drummer tribute \"Bonzo, The Groove Remains the Same\", commemorating the 30th anniversary of the death of Led Zeppelin's [John Bonham](/wiki/John_Bonham \"John Bonham\"). In 2011, Tichy formed S.U.N. (Something Unto Nothing) as guitarist, with vocalist [Sass Jordan](/wiki/Sass_Jordan \"Sass Jordan\"), bassist Michael Devin, and drummer [Tommy Stewart](/wiki/Tommy_Stewart \"Tommy Stewart\"). In 2014, Tichy joined 'Sweet \\& Lynch', featuring Michael Sweet, George Lynch and James Lomenzo. In 2018 Tichy replaced Shane Gaalaas as the support drummer for Japanese rock band [B'z](/wiki/B%27z \"B'z\"), a band he had worked with previously as a session musician. \n{{Citation\n \\| title \\= MICHAEL SWEET Reveals Possible Name For Project With GEORGE LYNCH, JAMES LOMENZO, BRIAN TICHY\n \\| magazine \\= Modern Drummer\n \\| date \\= June 25, 2014\n \\| url \\= http://www.blabbermouth.net/news/michael\\-sweet\\-reveals\\-possible\\-name\\-for\\-project\\-with\\-george\\-lynch\\-james\\-lomenzo\\-brian\\-tichy\n \\| access\\-date \\= \n}}",
"### Whitesnake",
"Tichy was announced as the new drummer for [Whitesnake](/wiki/Whitesnake \"Whitesnake\") on June 18, 2010\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\\=Article\\&newsitemID\\=141791 \\|title\\=WHITESNAKE Parts Ways With DUFFY, FRAZIER; New Drummer Announced \\|publisher\\=Roadrunnerrecords.com \\|access\\-date\\=2011\\-10\\-29 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110607023212/http://www.roadrunnerrecords.com/blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\\=Article\\&newsitemID\\=141791 \\|archive\\-date\\=2011\\-06\\-07 }} After several years of worldwide touring, Tichy quit Whitesnake on January 4, 2013, as he planned to focus more time on S.U.N.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\\=Article\\&newsitemID\\=184421 \\|title\\=Drummer BRIAN TICHY Quits WHITESNAKE \\|publisher\\=Roadrunnerrecords.com \\|access\\-date\\=2013\\-01\\-04 \\|archive\\-date\\=January 7, 2013 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130107030239/http://www.blabbermouth.net/news.aspx?mode\\=Article\\&newsitemID\\=184421 \\|url\\-status\\=dead }}",
""
] |
Clubs and organizations
-----------------------
Hudson Bay has a number of established groups whose mandates are to provide cultural and artistic opportunities for the residents of Hudson Bay and District.
The Hudson Bay Allied Arts Council is very active in bringing professional performing artists to the Community.
The forest, rivers, and lakes surrounding Hudson Bay provide inspirations for the members of the Hudson Bay Art Club. The active club organizes classes by professional artists for adults wishing to hone their skills and acquire new techniques.
Choral groups and instrumental ensembles from Stewart Hawke Elementary School consistently bring home trophies from the district musical festival. Both the elementary and high school have active drama clubs which attend Provincial adjudications. The High School has a well\-equipped fine arts wing which houses its drama area and stage and its arts department.
Hudson Bay's active volunteer network provides a wide variety of cultural and artistic activities with the support of the Town of Hudson Bay and the School Division.
The Hudson Bay Economic Development and Tourism Committee is appointed by the Councils of the town of Hudson Bay, the Rural Municipality of Hudson Bay \#394 and the Hudson Bay Chamber of Commerce. The purpose of the Committee is to provide aid to local economic opportunities, striving to renew and revitalize the economic interest of the community and to examine and investigate all alternatives that are available. The Committee keeps an up\-to\-date list of local business opportunities as well as a current list of business / office space and industrial sites available.
Service Clubs include: [Rotary Club](/wiki/Rotary_Club "Rotary Club"), [Lions Club](/wiki/Lions_Club "Lions Club"), [Knights of Columbus](/wiki/Knights_of_Columbus "Knights of Columbus"), [Masons](/wiki/Freemasonry "Freemasonry"), [Elks](/wiki/Elks "Elks") and [Royal Purple](/wiki/Royal_Purple "Royal Purple"), [Royal Canadian Legion](/wiki/Royal_Canadian_Legion "Royal Canadian Legion"), Legion Ladies Auxiliary, and Health Care Auxiliary. Other organizations focused on the youth in this area are: [4\-H](/wiki/4-H "4-H"), [Beavers](/wiki/Beaver_Scouts_%28Scouts_Canada%29 "Beaver Scouts (Scouts Canada)"), [Cubs](/wiki/Cub_Scouts_%28Scouts_Canada%29 "Cub Scouts (Scouts Canada)"), [AWANA](/wiki/AWANA "AWANA"), [Scouts](/wiki/Scouts_Canada "Scouts Canada"), and [Army Cadets](/wiki/Royal_Canadian_Army_Cadets "Royal Canadian Army Cadets").
|
[
"Clubs and organizations\n-----------------------",
"Hudson Bay has a number of established groups whose mandates are to provide cultural and artistic opportunities for the residents of Hudson Bay and District.",
"The Hudson Bay Allied Arts Council is very active in bringing professional performing artists to the Community.",
"The forest, rivers, and lakes surrounding Hudson Bay provide inspirations for the members of the Hudson Bay Art Club. The active club organizes classes by professional artists for adults wishing to hone their skills and acquire new techniques.",
"Choral groups and instrumental ensembles from Stewart Hawke Elementary School consistently bring home trophies from the district musical festival. Both the elementary and high school have active drama clubs which attend Provincial adjudications. The High School has a well\\-equipped fine arts wing which houses its drama area and stage and its arts department.",
"Hudson Bay's active volunteer network provides a wide variety of cultural and artistic activities with the support of the Town of Hudson Bay and the School Division.",
"The Hudson Bay Economic Development and Tourism Committee is appointed by the Councils of the town of Hudson Bay, the Rural Municipality of Hudson Bay \\#394 and the Hudson Bay Chamber of Commerce. The purpose of the Committee is to provide aid to local economic opportunities, striving to renew and revitalize the economic interest of the community and to examine and investigate all alternatives that are available. The Committee keeps an up\\-to\\-date list of local business opportunities as well as a current list of business / office space and industrial sites available.",
"Service Clubs include: [Rotary Club](/wiki/Rotary_Club \"Rotary Club\"), [Lions Club](/wiki/Lions_Club \"Lions Club\"), [Knights of Columbus](/wiki/Knights_of_Columbus \"Knights of Columbus\"), [Masons](/wiki/Freemasonry \"Freemasonry\"), [Elks](/wiki/Elks \"Elks\") and [Royal Purple](/wiki/Royal_Purple \"Royal Purple\"), [Royal Canadian Legion](/wiki/Royal_Canadian_Legion \"Royal Canadian Legion\"), Legion Ladies Auxiliary, and Health Care Auxiliary. Other organizations focused on the youth in this area are: [4\\-H](/wiki/4-H \"4-H\"), [Beavers](/wiki/Beaver_Scouts_%28Scouts_Canada%29 \"Beaver Scouts (Scouts Canada)\"), [Cubs](/wiki/Cub_Scouts_%28Scouts_Canada%29 \"Cub Scouts (Scouts Canada)\"), [AWANA](/wiki/AWANA \"AWANA\"), [Scouts](/wiki/Scouts_Canada \"Scouts Canada\"), and [Army Cadets](/wiki/Royal_Canadian_Army_Cadets \"Royal Canadian Army Cadets\").",
""
] |
History
-------
The palace is one of the largest historic residences of [Lower Silesia](/wiki/Lower_Silesia "Lower Silesia"), with the main building dating back to 1590\. It was expanded several times, most notably in the 18th century when a chapel dedicated to [John of Nepomuk](/wiki/John_of_Nepomuk "John of Nepomuk") was added to the main building, featuring an extensive polychrome decoration. A summer palace was also redeveloped in the 18th century. The compound features a total of 15 buildings.
A park was created in the 18th century, redeveloped in the late 19th century by Prussian landscape gardener [Eduard Petzold](/wiki/Eduard_Petzold "Eduard Petzold").
Originally built for the [Reichenbach](/wiki/Reichenbach-Wappen_1730.png "Reichenbach-Wappen 1730.png") [family](/wiki/Reichenbach_%28surname%29 "Reichenbach (surname)"), the palace was a property of the Counts [von Götzen](/wiki/G%C3%B6tz-Wappen_SWP.png "Götz-Wappen SWP.png") between the 17th and the 19th century. Sold in the late 19th century to a wealthy merchant, the palace gradually began falling into disrepair. The last [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans") owner was heiress Lilly Poppler and her husband Prof. Franz Poppler.
After [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II "World War II") because of the decisions made during the [Yalta Conference](/wiki/Yalta_Conference "Yalta Conference"), the [Kłodzko Land](/wiki/K%C5%82odzko_Land "Kłodzko Land") was transferred from [Germany](/wiki/Germany "Germany") to [Poland](/wiki/Poland "Poland") and Scharfeneck was renamed [Sarny](/wiki/Sarny%2C_Lower_Silesian_Voivodeship "Sarny, Lower Silesian Voivodeship"). The palace compound was first occupied by the [Red Army](/wiki/Red_Army "Red Army") to later be nationalized in communist Poland and turned into [a collective farm](/wiki/Collective_farming "Collective farming"). After [communism](/wiki/Communism "Communism") collapsed in 1989, the property remained in the state's hands, largely abandoned and falling into deeper ruin.
In late 2013, it was sold to private individuals who established a charitable trust running Sarny Castle. In the first year of operation, a collapsed roof over a 17th\-century granary was replaced with a new structure. Structural reconstruction was done on the castle in 2016\-2020\.
In May 2017, a visitor center and cafe opened in the castle's gatehouse after more than three years of refurbishment, also making the chapel available to tourists on a daily basis. In 2020, a hotel opened in two farm buildings.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"The palace is one of the largest historic residences of [Lower Silesia](/wiki/Lower_Silesia \"Lower Silesia\"), with the main building dating back to 1590\\. It was expanded several times, most notably in the 18th century when a chapel dedicated to [John of Nepomuk](/wiki/John_of_Nepomuk \"John of Nepomuk\") was added to the main building, featuring an extensive polychrome decoration. A summer palace was also redeveloped in the 18th century. The compound features a total of 15 buildings.",
"A park was created in the 18th century, redeveloped in the late 19th century by Prussian landscape gardener [Eduard Petzold](/wiki/Eduard_Petzold \"Eduard Petzold\").",
"Originally built for the [Reichenbach](/wiki/Reichenbach-Wappen_1730.png \"Reichenbach-Wappen 1730.png\") [family](/wiki/Reichenbach_%28surname%29 \"Reichenbach (surname)\"), the palace was a property of the Counts [von Götzen](/wiki/G%C3%B6tz-Wappen_SWP.png \"Götz-Wappen SWP.png\") between the 17th and the 19th century. Sold in the late 19th century to a wealthy merchant, the palace gradually began falling into disrepair. The last [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\") owner was heiress Lilly Poppler and her husband Prof. Franz Poppler.",
"After [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II \"World War II\") because of the decisions made during the [Yalta Conference](/wiki/Yalta_Conference \"Yalta Conference\"), the [Kłodzko Land](/wiki/K%C5%82odzko_Land \"Kłodzko Land\") was transferred from [Germany](/wiki/Germany \"Germany\") to [Poland](/wiki/Poland \"Poland\") and Scharfeneck was renamed [Sarny](/wiki/Sarny%2C_Lower_Silesian_Voivodeship \"Sarny, Lower Silesian Voivodeship\"). The palace compound was first occupied by the [Red Army](/wiki/Red_Army \"Red Army\") to later be nationalized in communist Poland and turned into [a collective farm](/wiki/Collective_farming \"Collective farming\"). After [communism](/wiki/Communism \"Communism\") collapsed in 1989, the property remained in the state's hands, largely abandoned and falling into deeper ruin.",
"In late 2013, it was sold to private individuals who established a charitable trust running Sarny Castle. In the first year of operation, a collapsed roof over a 17th\\-century granary was replaced with a new structure. Structural reconstruction was done on the castle in 2016\\-2020\\.",
"In May 2017, a visitor center and cafe opened in the castle's gatehouse after more than three years of refurbishment, also making the chapel available to tourists on a daily basis. In 2020, a hotel opened in two farm buildings.",
""
] |
Life
----
He studied art history and obtained his [Ph D](/wiki/Ph_D "Ph D") on *Burgundische Kleinkirchen bis zum Jahre 1200* (small churches in [Burgundy](/wiki/Burgundy "Burgundy") until 1200\). During the [Eulenburg affair](/wiki/Eulenburg_affair "Eulenburg affair") he tried to bring [Maximilian Harden](/wiki/Maximilian_Harden "Maximilian Harden") to reason with a long conversation in April 1908\. Since 1907 his hobby had been [ballooning](/wiki/Balloon_%28aircraft%29 "Balloon (aircraft)"), resulting in his fighting as an airship officer during World War I. He then became a scholar of [Rudolf Steiner](/wiki/Rudolf_Steiner "Rudolf Steiner") and was a lifetime follower of his esoteric spiritual movement, [anthroposophy](/wiki/Anthroposophy "Anthroposophy"). After the war he was first the head of a small publishing house in Munich, then an art and antiques dealer in Berlin. In Munich he came into contact with the influential literary group [George\-Kreis](/wiki/George-Kreis "George-Kreis"). The author [Alfred Schuler](/wiki/Alfred_Schuler "Alfred Schuler") died in his arms in 1923\. In 1925 he financially supported the physician [Magnus Hirschfeld](/wiki/Magnus_Hirschfeld "Magnus Hirschfeld"), an outspoken advocate for sexual minorities, with whom he had been in contact since 1909\. He stood up for many of his homosexual artist friends, financially and with moral courage when they were prosecuted.
[thumb\|[Ostrau](/wiki/Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29 "Ostrau (Petersberg)") Castle](/wiki/File:Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29%2C_the_ch%C3%A2teau.jpg "Ostrau (Petersberg), the château.jpg")
[thumb\|A room at Ostrau](/wiki/File:Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29_Schlo%C3%9F_04.jpg "Ostrau (Petersberg) Schloß 04.jpg")
In 1927 he inherited [Ostrau](/wiki/Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29 "Ostrau (Petersberg)") Castle and its large agricultural estate near [Halle](/wiki/Halle_%28Saale%29 "Halle (Saale)"). He had the castle extensively renovated and furnished with his collections of antiques, [expressionist](/wiki/Expressionism "Expressionism") paintings (such as [Marsden Hartley](/wiki/Marsden_Hartley "Marsden Hartley")'s *Light House*) as well as ethnological objects from all over the world. Until the Second World War, he turned his home into a meeting place for scientists, writers, artists, esotericists, politicians, musicians, dancers, and numerous visitors from Asia, especially India. Initially his interests revolved around China, which he was never to set foot in and whose art and philosophy he was taught by the Sinologist [Richard Wilhelm](/wiki/Richard_Wilhelm_%28sinologist%29 "Richard Wilhelm (sinologist)"), but gradually India came to the fore, especially through theosophical and spiritual contacts. Through [Annie Besant](/wiki/Annie_Besant "Annie Besant") who called the gigantic grand\-seigneur „my crusader“, he came close to [theosophy](/wiki/Theosophy_%28Blavatskian%29 "Theosophy (Blavatskian)"), especially to the *world savior*, whom she temporarily postulated, [Jiddu Krishnamurti](/wiki/Jiddu_Krishnamurti "Jiddu Krishnamurti"), who stayed in Ostrau for a week in 1931\. But he also maintained good contacts with influential politicians of the [Weimar Republic](/wiki/Weimar_Republic "Weimar Republic"), such as the President of the Reichstag [Paul Löbe](/wiki/Paul_L%C3%B6be "Paul Löbe") and a number of cabinet ministers, as well as with domestic and foreign diplomats who visited and invited him. The papal nuntius (and later pope [Pius XII](/wiki/Pius_XII "Pius XII")) Eugenio Pacelli was known to him from his Munich and Berlin times.
After [Adolf Hitler's rise to power](/wiki/Adolf_Hitler%27s_rise_to_power "Adolf Hitler's rise to power"), numerous members of his circle of friends emigrated from 1933, like the dancers [Harald Kreutzberg](/wiki/Harald_Kreutzberg "Harald Kreutzberg") and [Kurt Jooss](/wiki/Kurt_Jooss "Kurt Jooss") or the Indologist [Heinrich Zimmer](/wiki/Heinrich_Zimmer "Heinrich Zimmer") and the anthroposophist [Eugen Kolisko](/wiki/Eugen_Kolisko "Eugen Kolisko"), others were harassed by the Nazi regime. Nevertheless, he tried to maintain his cosmopolitan intellectual meeting place, which he succeeded in doing thanks to clever private diplomacy and influential contacts. He hosted a [synod](/wiki/Synod "Synod") of the [Christian Community](/wiki/Christian_Community "Christian Community") in 1935, when it was already threatened by closure. Many of his guests stayed for weeks, sometimes months. During the day people worked, in the evenings there were large discussions or artistic performances. Veltheim had \- in addition to high intellect and deep education \- the talent to respond intensively to each of his guests and to give them his full attention. Ostrau's charisma as an intellectual meeting point soon extended far beyond Germany. Among his guests were [Ambalal Sarabhai](/wiki/Ambalal_Sarabhai "Ambalal Sarabhai"), [Bijoy Prasad Singh Roy](/wiki/Bijoy_Prasad_Singh_Roy "Bijoy Prasad Singh Roy"), [Ram Nath Chopra](/wiki/Ram_Nath_Chopra "Ram Nath Chopra") and many other Indian visitors.
In spite of [foreign exchange controls](/wiki/Foreign_exchange_controls "Foreign exchange controls") and travel restrictions, he managed to undertake a number of trips abroad, supported by a friend in the Foreign Department. In order to enable these, as well as to protect his cosmopolitan center, he even joined the [NSDAP](/wiki/NSDAP "NSDAP") in 1937\. These travels included two trips to London for the *World Congress of Faiths* organized by [Francis Younghusband](/wiki/Francis_Younghusband "Francis Younghusband"), to Chicago for the World's Fair *[Century of Progress](/wiki/Century_of_Progress "Century of Progress")*, and two trips to Asia. On the first in 1935/36, he met [Sivananda Saraswati](/wiki/Sivananda_Saraswati "Sivananda Saraswati") whose business expansion and personality cult he later criticized. On the second, 1937−39, he travelled to Bombay and Calcutta for a conference of the [Indian Science Congress Association](/wiki/Indian_Science_Congress_Association "Indian Science Congress Association"), then to Afghanistan (where [Shah Mahmud Khan](/wiki/Shah_Mahmud_Khan "Shah Mahmud Khan"), who had been his guest in Ostrau in 1936, received him like a state guest, as did several Indian courts), further on to Nepal (then almost inaccessible), Burma, British Malaya, the Dutch East Indies, Java, Singapore and Bali (where he visited [Walter Spies](/wiki/Walter_Spies "Walter Spies")). The outbreak of World War II prevented his planned onward journey to China, Japan and the USA. He had to return to Germany via Egypt, Libya, Italy, France, Belgium and the Netherlands (where he once again visited the exiled Emperor [Wilhelm II](/wiki/Wilhelm_II%2C_German_Emperor "Wilhelm II, German Emperor"), whom his mother had known well).
He had been sending his travel diaries home, where they were duplicated on matrices and sent in 500 to 750 copies to his circle of acquaintances, including the Foreign Office. Upon his return, he set about revising and looking for book publication opportunities. The war hindered this project as well as the continuation of his conference activities. He spent the war years on his estate, only visited by a few friends, but was always well informed about the war situation through foreign broadcasters and contacts with soldiers at the front. He provided spiritual support to his cousin [Elisabeth von Thadden](/wiki/Elisabeth_von_Thadden "Elisabeth von Thadden") in letters before she was executed as a resistance fighter against the Nazi régime in September 1944, as was his close friend [Carl Wentzel](/wiki/Carl_Wentzel "Carl Wentzel").
[thumb\|upright\|[Marsden Hartley](/wiki/Marsden_Hartley "Marsden Hartley"): *Light House* (1915\), from Veltheim's collection](/wiki/File:Hartley_Lighthouse.jpg "Hartley Lighthouse.jpg")
After the Second World War, the American occupying forces immediately took Veltheim's advice to administer the region. In June 1945, he traveled with [Erhard Hübener](/wiki/Erhard_H%C3%BCbener "Erhard Hübener") to US headquarters in Frankfurt am Main, where Hübener was appointed governor of the province of Saxony by General [Dwight D. Eisenhower](/wiki/Dwight_D._Eisenhower "Dwight D. Eisenhower"). There, however, they also received certainty that parts of Central Germany would be surrendered to the [Soviet occupation zone of Germany](/wiki/Soviet_occupation_zone_of_Germany "Soviet occupation zone of Germany"), which was planned for July. Nevertheless, Veltheim refused to flee, which had been recommended to him on many occasions, and stayed. At first the Soviets provided him with guards of honor, like the Americans before them, as a result of sovereign private diplomacy, such as Veltheim had used against National Socialism. The authorities in the Soviet occupation zone, who were not yet fully aligned with the communist party, initially employed Veltheim as trustee and manager of his palace and park; they even offered him a professorship at the University of Halle; his refusal to accept made it impossible for him to stay and he fled to the British Zone of [Allied\-occupied Germany](/wiki/Allied-occupied_Germany "Allied-occupied Germany") in November 1945\. His castle was plundered and the land confiscated.
Hans\-Hasso von Veltheim was cared for in the West by his ex\-wife and friends from home and abroad. For years he stayed with different hosts who had once been his guests. A special relationship existed with [Leo Baeck](/wiki/Leo_Baeck "Leo Baeck"), the Jewish rabbi, scholar, and theologian whom he had known since 1923 and who came to Ostrau several times after 1933\. Despite the strictest ban, Veltheim continued to visit the president of the umbrella organization of German Jews in Berlin until the end of 1942 and had food delivered to him until his deportation in January 1943\. Baeck, in turn, sent him the newly created manuscript chapters of his work *“This People Israel: the Meaning of Jewish Existence”* to keep them safe. Before he fled in 1945, Veltheim handed it over to a state curator. After Baeck had miraculously survived the end of the war in a concentration camp and was able to emigrate to England and the US, they resumed their correspondence and now Baeck in return supported the refugee Veltheim financially.
From 1948 he worked on new manuscripts based on the reports sent and his memories, since his notes and film recordings were left (and lost) in Ostrau. The travel diaries, first published by *Greven\-Verlag* in Cologne and then by *Claassen\-Verlag* from 1951, received a great deal of attention in the press and were a sales success. His reports are written in a clear, understandable way, but they differ from many other travel reports by profound knowledge and deep empathy for the spirituality of the Orient. Spiritual leaders had discovered qualities in Veltheim that they usually looked for in vain in white people: unusual empathy, a certain mental training, sense of the occult, familiarity with meditation, the ability to recognize the aura of people and places and to face it with reverence. In their eyes, no one had absorbed as much *enlightened Asia* as he had.
Suffering severely from asthma, he died in 1956\. His friend [Udo von Alvensleben](/wiki/Udo_von_Alvensleben "Udo von Alvensleben") wrote: "Living in exile as a [sannyasin](/wiki/Sannyasin "Sannyasin"), a propertyless pilgrim to the Absolute, seemed like an Asian finale. To be sure, he remained a European in that the *problem confusion of our world* continued to trouble his heart while his spirit carried out the final clarification." His urn was brought back to Ostrau in 1990, after the fall of the [Berlin Wall](/wiki/Berlin_Wall "Berlin Wall"), and buried in a crypt chapel in the Castle Church, which he had converted into an anthroposophical meditation room in 1933\.
|
[
"Life\n----",
"He studied art history and obtained his [Ph D](/wiki/Ph_D \"Ph D\") on *Burgundische Kleinkirchen bis zum Jahre 1200* (small churches in [Burgundy](/wiki/Burgundy \"Burgundy\") until 1200\\). During the [Eulenburg affair](/wiki/Eulenburg_affair \"Eulenburg affair\") he tried to bring [Maximilian Harden](/wiki/Maximilian_Harden \"Maximilian Harden\") to reason with a long conversation in April 1908\\. Since 1907 his hobby had been [ballooning](/wiki/Balloon_%28aircraft%29 \"Balloon (aircraft)\"), resulting in his fighting as an airship officer during World War I. He then became a scholar of [Rudolf Steiner](/wiki/Rudolf_Steiner \"Rudolf Steiner\") and was a lifetime follower of his esoteric spiritual movement, [anthroposophy](/wiki/Anthroposophy \"Anthroposophy\"). After the war he was first the head of a small publishing house in Munich, then an art and antiques dealer in Berlin. In Munich he came into contact with the influential literary group [George\\-Kreis](/wiki/George-Kreis \"George-Kreis\"). The author [Alfred Schuler](/wiki/Alfred_Schuler \"Alfred Schuler\") died in his arms in 1923\\. In 1925 he financially supported the physician [Magnus Hirschfeld](/wiki/Magnus_Hirschfeld \"Magnus Hirschfeld\"), an outspoken advocate for sexual minorities, with whom he had been in contact since 1909\\. He stood up for many of his homosexual artist friends, financially and with moral courage when they were prosecuted.",
"[thumb\\|[Ostrau](/wiki/Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29 \"Ostrau (Petersberg)\") Castle](/wiki/File:Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29%2C_the_ch%C3%A2teau.jpg \"Ostrau (Petersberg), the château.jpg\")\n[thumb\\|A room at Ostrau](/wiki/File:Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29_Schlo%C3%9F_04.jpg \"Ostrau (Petersberg) Schloß 04.jpg\")\nIn 1927 he inherited [Ostrau](/wiki/Ostrau_%28Petersberg%29 \"Ostrau (Petersberg)\") Castle and its large agricultural estate near [Halle](/wiki/Halle_%28Saale%29 \"Halle (Saale)\"). He had the castle extensively renovated and furnished with his collections of antiques, [expressionist](/wiki/Expressionism \"Expressionism\") paintings (such as [Marsden Hartley](/wiki/Marsden_Hartley \"Marsden Hartley\")'s *Light House*) as well as ethnological objects from all over the world. Until the Second World War, he turned his home into a meeting place for scientists, writers, artists, esotericists, politicians, musicians, dancers, and numerous visitors from Asia, especially India. Initially his interests revolved around China, which he was never to set foot in and whose art and philosophy he was taught by the Sinologist [Richard Wilhelm](/wiki/Richard_Wilhelm_%28sinologist%29 \"Richard Wilhelm (sinologist)\"), but gradually India came to the fore, especially through theosophical and spiritual contacts. Through [Annie Besant](/wiki/Annie_Besant \"Annie Besant\") who called the gigantic grand\\-seigneur „my crusader“, he came close to [theosophy](/wiki/Theosophy_%28Blavatskian%29 \"Theosophy (Blavatskian)\"), especially to the *world savior*, whom she temporarily postulated, [Jiddu Krishnamurti](/wiki/Jiddu_Krishnamurti \"Jiddu Krishnamurti\"), who stayed in Ostrau for a week in 1931\\. But he also maintained good contacts with influential politicians of the [Weimar Republic](/wiki/Weimar_Republic \"Weimar Republic\"), such as the President of the Reichstag [Paul Löbe](/wiki/Paul_L%C3%B6be \"Paul Löbe\") and a number of cabinet ministers, as well as with domestic and foreign diplomats who visited and invited him. The papal nuntius (and later pope [Pius XII](/wiki/Pius_XII \"Pius XII\")) Eugenio Pacelli was known to him from his Munich and Berlin times.",
"After [Adolf Hitler's rise to power](/wiki/Adolf_Hitler%27s_rise_to_power \"Adolf Hitler's rise to power\"), numerous members of his circle of friends emigrated from 1933, like the dancers [Harald Kreutzberg](/wiki/Harald_Kreutzberg \"Harald Kreutzberg\") and [Kurt Jooss](/wiki/Kurt_Jooss \"Kurt Jooss\") or the Indologist [Heinrich Zimmer](/wiki/Heinrich_Zimmer \"Heinrich Zimmer\") and the anthroposophist [Eugen Kolisko](/wiki/Eugen_Kolisko \"Eugen Kolisko\"), others were harassed by the Nazi regime. Nevertheless, he tried to maintain his cosmopolitan intellectual meeting place, which he succeeded in doing thanks to clever private diplomacy and influential contacts. He hosted a [synod](/wiki/Synod \"Synod\") of the [Christian Community](/wiki/Christian_Community \"Christian Community\") in 1935, when it was already threatened by closure. Many of his guests stayed for weeks, sometimes months. During the day people worked, in the evenings there were large discussions or artistic performances. Veltheim had \\- in addition to high intellect and deep education \\- the talent to respond intensively to each of his guests and to give them his full attention. Ostrau's charisma as an intellectual meeting point soon extended far beyond Germany. Among his guests were [Ambalal Sarabhai](/wiki/Ambalal_Sarabhai \"Ambalal Sarabhai\"), [Bijoy Prasad Singh Roy](/wiki/Bijoy_Prasad_Singh_Roy \"Bijoy Prasad Singh Roy\"), [Ram Nath Chopra](/wiki/Ram_Nath_Chopra \"Ram Nath Chopra\") and many other Indian visitors.",
"In spite of [foreign exchange controls](/wiki/Foreign_exchange_controls \"Foreign exchange controls\") and travel restrictions, he managed to undertake a number of trips abroad, supported by a friend in the Foreign Department. In order to enable these, as well as to protect his cosmopolitan center, he even joined the [NSDAP](/wiki/NSDAP \"NSDAP\") in 1937\\. These travels included two trips to London for the *World Congress of Faiths* organized by [Francis Younghusband](/wiki/Francis_Younghusband \"Francis Younghusband\"), to Chicago for the World's Fair *[Century of Progress](/wiki/Century_of_Progress \"Century of Progress\")*, and two trips to Asia. On the first in 1935/36, he met [Sivananda Saraswati](/wiki/Sivananda_Saraswati \"Sivananda Saraswati\") whose business expansion and personality cult he later criticized. On the second, 1937−39, he travelled to Bombay and Calcutta for a conference of the [Indian Science Congress Association](/wiki/Indian_Science_Congress_Association \"Indian Science Congress Association\"), then to Afghanistan (where [Shah Mahmud Khan](/wiki/Shah_Mahmud_Khan \"Shah Mahmud Khan\"), who had been his guest in Ostrau in 1936, received him like a state guest, as did several Indian courts), further on to Nepal (then almost inaccessible), Burma, British Malaya, the Dutch East Indies, Java, Singapore and Bali (where he visited [Walter Spies](/wiki/Walter_Spies \"Walter Spies\")). The outbreak of World War II prevented his planned onward journey to China, Japan and the USA. He had to return to Germany via Egypt, Libya, Italy, France, Belgium and the Netherlands (where he once again visited the exiled Emperor [Wilhelm II](/wiki/Wilhelm_II%2C_German_Emperor \"Wilhelm II, German Emperor\"), whom his mother had known well).",
"He had been sending his travel diaries home, where they were duplicated on matrices and sent in 500 to 750 copies to his circle of acquaintances, including the Foreign Office. Upon his return, he set about revising and looking for book publication opportunities. The war hindered this project as well as the continuation of his conference activities. He spent the war years on his estate, only visited by a few friends, but was always well informed about the war situation through foreign broadcasters and contacts with soldiers at the front. He provided spiritual support to his cousin [Elisabeth von Thadden](/wiki/Elisabeth_von_Thadden \"Elisabeth von Thadden\") in letters before she was executed as a resistance fighter against the Nazi régime in September 1944, as was his close friend [Carl Wentzel](/wiki/Carl_Wentzel \"Carl Wentzel\").",
"[thumb\\|upright\\|[Marsden Hartley](/wiki/Marsden_Hartley \"Marsden Hartley\"): *Light House* (1915\\), from Veltheim's collection](/wiki/File:Hartley_Lighthouse.jpg \"Hartley Lighthouse.jpg\")\nAfter the Second World War, the American occupying forces immediately took Veltheim's advice to administer the region. In June 1945, he traveled with [Erhard Hübener](/wiki/Erhard_H%C3%BCbener \"Erhard Hübener\") to US headquarters in Frankfurt am Main, where Hübener was appointed governor of the province of Saxony by General [Dwight D. Eisenhower](/wiki/Dwight_D._Eisenhower \"Dwight D. Eisenhower\"). There, however, they also received certainty that parts of Central Germany would be surrendered to the [Soviet occupation zone of Germany](/wiki/Soviet_occupation_zone_of_Germany \"Soviet occupation zone of Germany\"), which was planned for July. Nevertheless, Veltheim refused to flee, which had been recommended to him on many occasions, and stayed. At first the Soviets provided him with guards of honor, like the Americans before them, as a result of sovereign private diplomacy, such as Veltheim had used against National Socialism. The authorities in the Soviet occupation zone, who were not yet fully aligned with the communist party, initially employed Veltheim as trustee and manager of his palace and park; they even offered him a professorship at the University of Halle; his refusal to accept made it impossible for him to stay and he fled to the British Zone of [Allied\\-occupied Germany](/wiki/Allied-occupied_Germany \"Allied-occupied Germany\") in November 1945\\. His castle was plundered and the land confiscated.",
"Hans\\-Hasso von Veltheim was cared for in the West by his ex\\-wife and friends from home and abroad. For years he stayed with different hosts who had once been his guests. A special relationship existed with [Leo Baeck](/wiki/Leo_Baeck \"Leo Baeck\"), the Jewish rabbi, scholar, and theologian whom he had known since 1923 and who came to Ostrau several times after 1933\\. Despite the strictest ban, Veltheim continued to visit the president of the umbrella organization of German Jews in Berlin until the end of 1942 and had food delivered to him until his deportation in January 1943\\. Baeck, in turn, sent him the newly created manuscript chapters of his work *“This People Israel: the Meaning of Jewish Existence”* to keep them safe. Before he fled in 1945, Veltheim handed it over to a state curator. After Baeck had miraculously survived the end of the war in a concentration camp and was able to emigrate to England and the US, they resumed their correspondence and now Baeck in return supported the refugee Veltheim financially.",
"From 1948 he worked on new manuscripts based on the reports sent and his memories, since his notes and film recordings were left (and lost) in Ostrau. The travel diaries, first published by *Greven\\-Verlag* in Cologne and then by *Claassen\\-Verlag* from 1951, received a great deal of attention in the press and were a sales success. His reports are written in a clear, understandable way, but they differ from many other travel reports by profound knowledge and deep empathy for the spirituality of the Orient. Spiritual leaders had discovered qualities in Veltheim that they usually looked for in vain in white people: unusual empathy, a certain mental training, sense of the occult, familiarity with meditation, the ability to recognize the aura of people and places and to face it with reverence. In their eyes, no one had absorbed as much *enlightened Asia* as he had.",
"Suffering severely from asthma, he died in 1956\\. His friend [Udo von Alvensleben](/wiki/Udo_von_Alvensleben \"Udo von Alvensleben\") wrote: \"Living in exile as a [sannyasin](/wiki/Sannyasin \"Sannyasin\"), a propertyless pilgrim to the Absolute, seemed like an Asian finale. To be sure, he remained a European in that the *problem confusion of our world* continued to trouble his heart while his spirit carried out the final clarification.\" His urn was brought back to Ostrau in 1990, after the fall of the [Berlin Wall](/wiki/Berlin_Wall \"Berlin Wall\"), and buried in a crypt chapel in the Castle Church, which he had converted into an anthroposophical meditation room in 1933\\.",
""
] |
Career
------
[thumb\|In 2016 at Cosmopolite Scene in Oslo](/wiki/File:MeShell_Ndege%C3%B2Cello_%28222747%29.jpg "MeShell NdegeòCello (222747).jpg")
Ndegeocello honed her skills on the D.C. [go\-go](/wiki/Go-go "Go-go") circuit in the late 1980s with the bands Prophecy, Little Benny and the Masters, and [Rare Essence](/wiki/Rare_Essence "Rare Essence").{{Cite news\|last \= Wiltz\|first\=Teresa\|title\=Meshell Ndegeocello Breaks Step With Pop \| newspaper \= \[\[The Washington Post]]\|pages\=N01\|date\=June 19, 2005\|url\= https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp\-dyn/content/article/2005/06/17/AR2005061700715\_pf.html}} Going solo, she was one of the first artists to sign with [Maverick Records](/wiki/Maverick_Records "Maverick Records"), where she released her debut album, *[Plantation Lullabies](/wiki/Plantation_Lullabies "Plantation Lullabies")*. This recording presented a distinctly [androgynous](/wiki/Androgynous "Androgynous") persona.
Her biggest hit is a [duet](/wiki/Duet "Duet") with [John Mellencamp](/wiki/John_Mellencamp "John Mellencamp"), a [cover version](/wiki/Cover_version "Cover version") of [Van Morrison](/wiki/Van_Morrison "Van Morrison")'s "[Wild Night](/wiki/Wild_Night "Wild Night")", which reached No. 3 on the *[Billboard](/wiki/Billboard_%28magazine%29 "Billboard (magazine)")* charts. Her only other [*Billboard* Hot 100](/wiki/Billboard_Hot_100 "Billboard Hot 100") hit besides "[Wild Night](/wiki/Wild_Night "Wild Night")" has been her self\-penned "[If That's Your Boyfriend (He Wasn't Last Night)](/wiki/If_That%27s_Your_Boyfriend_%28He_Wasn%27t_Last_Night%29 "If That's Your Boyfriend (He Wasn't Last Night)")", which peaked at No. 73 in 1994\. Also in 1994, Ndegeocello collaborated with [Herbie Hancock](/wiki/Herbie_Hancock "Herbie Hancock") on "Nocturnal Sunshine," a track for the [Red Hot Organization](/wiki/Red_Hot_Organization "Red Hot Organization")'s compilation album, *[Stolen Moments: Red Hot \+ Cool](/wiki/Stolen_Moments:Red_Hot_%2B_Cool "Red Hot + Cool")*. The album, meant to raise awareness and funds in support of the AIDS epidemic in relation to the African American community, was heralded as "Album of the Year" by *[Time](/wiki/Time_%28magazine%29 "Time (magazine)")* magazine.
She had a No. 1 dance hit in 1996 with a [Bill Withers](/wiki/Bill_Withers "Bill Withers") [cover song](/wiki/Cover_song "Cover song") called "[Who Is He (And What Is He to You)?](/wiki/Who_Is_He_%28And_What_Is_He_to_You%29%3F "Who Is He (And What Is He to You)?")" (briefly featured in the film *[Jerry Maguire](/wiki/Jerry_Maguire "Jerry Maguire")*) as well as Dance Top 20 hits with "Earth", "[Leviticus: Faggot](/wiki/Leviticus:Faggot "Faggot")", "Stay" and the aforementioned "If That's Your Boyfriend.. Last Night)". Ndegeocello played bass on the song "I'd Rather be Your Lover" for [Madonna](/wiki/Madonna "Madonna") on her album *[Bedtime Stories](/wiki/Bedtime_Stories_%28Madonna_album%29 "Bedtime Stories (Madonna album)")*. Ndegeocello was also tapped, at the last minute, to perform spoken word on the same song. This came after Madonna and producers decided to remove [Tupac Shakur](/wiki/Tupac_Shakur "Tupac Shakur")'s rap (which he did while he and Madonna were dating in 1994\), after he had criminal charges filed against him. Ndegeocello also performed spoken word on [Chaka Khan](/wiki/Chaka_Khan "Chaka Khan")'s single "[Never Miss the Water](/wiki/Never_Miss_the_Water "Never Miss the Water")", from the album *[Epiphany: The Best of Chaka Khan, Vol. 1](/wiki/Epiphany:The_Best_of_Chaka_Khan%2C_Vol._1 "The Best of Chaka Khan, Vol. 1")*, released in 1996\. The song reached \#1 on Billboard's Dance Club Play Chart and \#36 on the Hot R\&B/Hip\-Hop Singles Chart.
Her music has been featured in a number of film soundtracks including *[How Stella Got Her Groove Back](/wiki/How_Stella_Got_Her_Groove_Back "How Stella Got Her Groove Back")*, *[Lost \& Delirious](/wiki/Lost_%26_Delirious "Lost & Delirious")*, *[Batman \& Robin](/wiki/Batman_%26_Robin_%28film%29 "Batman & Robin (film)")*, *[Love Jones](/wiki/Love_Jones_%28film%29 "Love Jones (film)")*, *[Love \& Basketball](/wiki/Love_%26_Basketball_%28film%29 "Love & Basketball (film)")*, *[Talk to Me](/wiki/Talk_to_Me_%281996_film%29 "Talk to Me (1996 film)")*, *[Tyler Perry's Daddy's Little Girls](/wiki/Tyler_Perry%27s_Daddy%27s_Little_Girls "Tyler Perry's Daddy's Little Girls")*, *[The Best Man](/wiki/The_Best_Man_%281999_film%29 "The Best Man (1999 film)")*, *[Higher Learning](/wiki/Higher_Learning "Higher Learning")*, *[Down in the Delta](/wiki/Down_in_the_Delta "Down in the Delta")*, *[The Hurricane](/wiki/The_Hurricane_%281999_film%29 "The Hurricane (1999 film)")*, *[Noah's Arc: Jumping the Broom](/wiki/Noah%27s_Arc:Jumping_the_Broom "Jumping the Broom")*, *[Soul Men](/wiki/Soul_Men "Soul Men")*, and *[Biker Boyz](/wiki/Biker_Boyz "Biker Boyz")*.
She has appeared on recordings by [Basement Jaxx](/wiki/Basement_Jaxx "Basement Jaxx"), [Indigo Girls](/wiki/Indigo_Girls "Indigo Girls"), [Scritti Politti](/wiki/Scritti_Politti "Scritti Politti"), and [The Blind Boys of Alabama](/wiki/The_Blind_Boys_of_Alabama "The Blind Boys of Alabama"). On [The Rolling Stones](/wiki/The_Rolling_Stones "The Rolling Stones")' 1997 album *[Bridges to Babylon](/wiki/Bridges_to_Babylon "Bridges to Babylon")* she plays bass on the song "[Saint of Me](/wiki/Saint_of_Me "Saint of Me")". On [Alanis Morissette](/wiki/Alanis_Morissette "Alanis Morissette")'s 2002 album *[Under Rug Swept](/wiki/Under_Rug_Swept "Under Rug Swept")*, she plays bass on the songs "[So Unsexy](/wiki/So_Unsexy "So Unsexy")" and "You Owe Me Nothing in Return". Also that year, she appeared on [Gov’t Mule](/wiki/Gov%E2%80%99t_Mule "Gov’t Mule")’s record *[The Deep End, Volume 2](/wiki/The_Deep_End%2C_Volume_2 "The Deep End, Volume 2")*, playing on a cover of The [Staple Singers](/wiki/Staple_Singers "Staple Singers")’ song "Hammer And Nails". And in 2009, she appeared on [Zap Mama](/wiki/Zap_Mama "Zap Mama")'s album *ReCreation*, playing bass on the song "African Diamond".
She can also be seen in the documentary *[Standing in the Shadows of Motown](/wiki/Standing_in_the_Shadows_of_Motown_%28film%29 "Standing in the Shadows of Motown (film)")*, singing [The Miracles](/wiki/The_Miracles "The Miracles")' "[You've Really Got a Hold on Me](/wiki/You%27ve_Really_Got_a_Hold_on_Me "You've Really Got a Hold on Me")" and [The Temptations](/wiki/The_Temptations "The Temptations")' "[Cloud Nine](/wiki/Cloud_Nine_%28The_Temptations_song%29 "Cloud Nine (The Temptations song)")". In the late 1990s, she toured with [Lilith Fair](/wiki/Lilith_Fair "Lilith Fair"). She also did a remake of the song "[Two Doors Down](/wiki/Two_Doors_Down_%28Dolly_Parton_song%29 "Two Doors Down (Dolly Parton song)")" on the 2003 release *[Just Because I'm a Woman: Songs of Dolly Parton](/wiki/Just_Because_I%27m_a_Woman:Songs_of_Dolly_Parton "Songs of Dolly Parton")*.
Ndegeocello was also a judge for The 2nd, 12th, 13 and the 2015 14th Annual Independent Music Awards to support independent artists' careers.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.independentmusicawards.com/ima\_new/pastjudges.asp \|title\=Past Judges \|publisher\=Independent Music Awards \|access\-date\=July 18, 2011 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110713024722/http://www.independentmusicawards.com/ima\_new/pastjudges.asp \|archive\-date\=July 13, 2011 }}
Her song "Tie One On" was chosen as the [Starbucks](/wiki/Starbucks "Starbucks") [iTunes](/wiki/ITunes "ITunes") Pick of the Week on February 23, 2010\.{{Cite web \|last\=Heringer \|title\=Starbucks iTunes Pick of the Week – Meshell Ndegeocello – Tie One On \|url\=https://www.mark\-heringer.com/2010/02/starbucks\-itunes\-pick\-of\-week\-meshell.html \|website\=Mark\-heringer.com\|access\-date\=2022\-08\-04 \|language\=en}}{{Cite web \|last\=Heringer \|title\=Starbucks iTunes Pick of the Week list \|url\=https://www.mark\-heringer.com/2008/04/starbucks\-itunes\-pick\-of\-week\-list.html\|website\=Mark\-heringer.com \|access\-date\=2022\-04\-12 \|language\=en}}
In 2016, she provided the theme song, "Nova", for the [Oprah Winfrey](/wiki/Oprah_Winfrey "Oprah Winfrey")\-produced show *[Queen Sugar](/wiki/Queen_Sugar "Queen Sugar")*.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.what\-song.com/Tvshow/187/Queen\-Sugar \|title\=Queen Sugar Soundtrack \|website\=What\-song.com \|access\-date\=November 23, 2016}} She also collaborated with French\-Cuban duo [Ibeyi](/wiki/Ibeyi "Ibeyi") in the song "Transmission/Michaelion" for the album *[Ash](/wiki/Ash_%28album%29 "Ash (album)")* reciting a poem by [Frida Kahlo](/wiki/Frida_Kahlo "Frida Kahlo").
In December 2016, the world premiere of Ndegeocello's *[Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin](/wiki/Can_I_Get_a_Witness%3F_The_Gospel_of_James_Baldwin "Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin")*, a new theatrical music and art work, was held in Harlem, New York.{{cite web\|url\=http://thestagereview.net/2016/11/29/harlem\-stage\-present\-world\-premiere\-meshell\-ndegeocellos\-can\-get\-witness\-gospel\-james\-baldwin\-december\-7\-11/\|publisher\=The Stage Review\|date\=November 29, 2016\|title\=Harlem Stage to present the world premiere of Meshell Ndegeocello's 'Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin,' December 7–11}}
In June 2021, [The Beatles Channel](/wiki/The_Beatles_Channel "The Beatles Channel") on [Sirius XM Radio](/wiki/Sirius_XM_Radio "Sirius XM Radio") began broadcasting *A Shot of Rhythm and Blues: Exploring The Beatles and Black Music*, a four\-part series hosted by Ndegeocello.{{cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/article/data\-privacy\-race\-and\-ethnicity\-technology\-business\-music\-3d9352ad2c927cd8cd03ff0bd6b9c601\|title\=Celebrate Black Music Month on SiriusXM, Pandora, and Stitcher with Exclusive Music Channels, Streaming Stations, and an Original Podcast\|author\=\[\[PR Newswire]]\|date\=June 1, 2021\|website\=\[\[Associated Press]]\|access\-date\=June 8, 2021}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.thebeatles.com/news/%E2%80%9C\-shot\-rhythm\-and\-blues\-exploring\-beatles\-and\-black\-music%E2%80%9D\-beatles\-channel\|title\="A Shot of Rhythm and Blues: Exploring The Beatles and Black Music" on The Beatles Channel\|website\=TheBeatles.com\|access\-date\=June 8, 2021\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210609030013/https://www.thebeatles.com/news/%E2%80%9C\-shot\-rhythm\-and\-blues\-exploring\-beatles\-and\-black\-music%E2%80%9D\-beatles\-channel\|archive\-date\=June 9, 2021\|url\-status\=live}}{{cite web\|url\=https://blog.siriusxm.com/explore\-connection\-between\-the\-beatles\-black\-music\-during\-a\-new\-series/\|title\=Explore the connection between The Beatles \& Black music during a new SiriusXM series\|date\=June 7, 2021\|website\=\[\[Sirius XM]]\|access\-date\=June 8, 2021}} The series explores the relationship between the English rock band [the Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles "The Beatles") and the black musicians that inspired them.
Ndegeocello joined the Blue Note label with the debut release of her 13th studio album *[The Omnichord Real Book](/wiki/The_Omnichord_Real_Book "The Omnichord Real Book")* (2023\). The title refers to a set of lead sheets from songs from funk, soul, gospel and more influenced by her father as if a compilation of standards like a [real book](/wiki/Real_Book "Real Book") in jazz repertoire.{{Cite web \|date\=2023\-06\-12 \|title\=Album: Meshell Ndegeocello – The Omnichord Real Book \|url\=https://theartsdesk.com/new\-music/album\-meshell\-ndegeocello\-omnichord\-real\-book \|access\-date\=2023\-06\-12 \|website\=Theartsdesk.com \|language\=en}}
|
[
"Career\n------",
"[thumb\\|In 2016 at Cosmopolite Scene in Oslo](/wiki/File:MeShell_Ndege%C3%B2Cello_%28222747%29.jpg \"MeShell NdegeòCello (222747).jpg\")\nNdegeocello honed her skills on the D.C. [go\\-go](/wiki/Go-go \"Go-go\") circuit in the late 1980s with the bands Prophecy, Little Benny and the Masters, and [Rare Essence](/wiki/Rare_Essence \"Rare Essence\").{{Cite news\\|last \\= Wiltz\\|first\\=Teresa\\|title\\=Meshell Ndegeocello Breaks Step With Pop \\| newspaper \\= \\[\\[The Washington Post]]\\|pages\\=N01\\|date\\=June 19, 2005\\|url\\= https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp\\-dyn/content/article/2005/06/17/AR2005061700715\\_pf.html}} Going solo, she was one of the first artists to sign with [Maverick Records](/wiki/Maverick_Records \"Maverick Records\"), where she released her debut album, *[Plantation Lullabies](/wiki/Plantation_Lullabies \"Plantation Lullabies\")*. This recording presented a distinctly [androgynous](/wiki/Androgynous \"Androgynous\") persona.",
"Her biggest hit is a [duet](/wiki/Duet \"Duet\") with [John Mellencamp](/wiki/John_Mellencamp \"John Mellencamp\"), a [cover version](/wiki/Cover_version \"Cover version\") of [Van Morrison](/wiki/Van_Morrison \"Van Morrison\")'s \"[Wild Night](/wiki/Wild_Night \"Wild Night\")\", which reached No. 3 on the *[Billboard](/wiki/Billboard_%28magazine%29 \"Billboard (magazine)\")* charts. Her only other [*Billboard* Hot 100](/wiki/Billboard_Hot_100 \"Billboard Hot 100\") hit besides \"[Wild Night](/wiki/Wild_Night \"Wild Night\")\" has been her self\\-penned \"[If That's Your Boyfriend (He Wasn't Last Night)](/wiki/If_That%27s_Your_Boyfriend_%28He_Wasn%27t_Last_Night%29 \"If That's Your Boyfriend (He Wasn't Last Night)\")\", which peaked at No. 73 in 1994\\. Also in 1994, Ndegeocello collaborated with [Herbie Hancock](/wiki/Herbie_Hancock \"Herbie Hancock\") on \"Nocturnal Sunshine,\" a track for the [Red Hot Organization](/wiki/Red_Hot_Organization \"Red Hot Organization\")'s compilation album, *[Stolen Moments: Red Hot \\+ Cool](/wiki/Stolen_Moments:Red_Hot_%2B_Cool \"Red Hot + Cool\")*. The album, meant to raise awareness and funds in support of the AIDS epidemic in relation to the African American community, was heralded as \"Album of the Year\" by *[Time](/wiki/Time_%28magazine%29 \"Time (magazine)\")* magazine.",
"She had a No. 1 dance hit in 1996 with a [Bill Withers](/wiki/Bill_Withers \"Bill Withers\") [cover song](/wiki/Cover_song \"Cover song\") called \"[Who Is He (And What Is He to You)?](/wiki/Who_Is_He_%28And_What_Is_He_to_You%29%3F \"Who Is He (And What Is He to You)?\")\" (briefly featured in the film *[Jerry Maguire](/wiki/Jerry_Maguire \"Jerry Maguire\")*) as well as Dance Top 20 hits with \"Earth\", \"[Leviticus: Faggot](/wiki/Leviticus:Faggot \"Faggot\")\", \"Stay\" and the aforementioned \"If That's Your Boyfriend.. Last Night)\". Ndegeocello played bass on the song \"I'd Rather be Your Lover\" for [Madonna](/wiki/Madonna \"Madonna\") on her album *[Bedtime Stories](/wiki/Bedtime_Stories_%28Madonna_album%29 \"Bedtime Stories (Madonna album)\")*. Ndegeocello was also tapped, at the last minute, to perform spoken word on the same song. This came after Madonna and producers decided to remove [Tupac Shakur](/wiki/Tupac_Shakur \"Tupac Shakur\")'s rap (which he did while he and Madonna were dating in 1994\\), after he had criminal charges filed against him. Ndegeocello also performed spoken word on [Chaka Khan](/wiki/Chaka_Khan \"Chaka Khan\")'s single \"[Never Miss the Water](/wiki/Never_Miss_the_Water \"Never Miss the Water\")\", from the album *[Epiphany: The Best of Chaka Khan, Vol. 1](/wiki/Epiphany:The_Best_of_Chaka_Khan%2C_Vol._1 \"The Best of Chaka Khan, Vol. 1\")*, released in 1996\\. The song reached \\#1 on Billboard's Dance Club Play Chart and \\#36 on the Hot R\\&B/Hip\\-Hop Singles Chart.",
"Her music has been featured in a number of film soundtracks including *[How Stella Got Her Groove Back](/wiki/How_Stella_Got_Her_Groove_Back \"How Stella Got Her Groove Back\")*, *[Lost \\& Delirious](/wiki/Lost_%26_Delirious \"Lost & Delirious\")*, *[Batman \\& Robin](/wiki/Batman_%26_Robin_%28film%29 \"Batman & Robin (film)\")*, *[Love Jones](/wiki/Love_Jones_%28film%29 \"Love Jones (film)\")*, *[Love \\& Basketball](/wiki/Love_%26_Basketball_%28film%29 \"Love & Basketball (film)\")*, *[Talk to Me](/wiki/Talk_to_Me_%281996_film%29 \"Talk to Me (1996 film)\")*, *[Tyler Perry's Daddy's Little Girls](/wiki/Tyler_Perry%27s_Daddy%27s_Little_Girls \"Tyler Perry's Daddy's Little Girls\")*, *[The Best Man](/wiki/The_Best_Man_%281999_film%29 \"The Best Man (1999 film)\")*, *[Higher Learning](/wiki/Higher_Learning \"Higher Learning\")*, *[Down in the Delta](/wiki/Down_in_the_Delta \"Down in the Delta\")*, *[The Hurricane](/wiki/The_Hurricane_%281999_film%29 \"The Hurricane (1999 film)\")*, *[Noah's Arc: Jumping the Broom](/wiki/Noah%27s_Arc:Jumping_the_Broom \"Jumping the Broom\")*, *[Soul Men](/wiki/Soul_Men \"Soul Men\")*, and *[Biker Boyz](/wiki/Biker_Boyz \"Biker Boyz\")*.",
"She has appeared on recordings by [Basement Jaxx](/wiki/Basement_Jaxx \"Basement Jaxx\"), [Indigo Girls](/wiki/Indigo_Girls \"Indigo Girls\"), [Scritti Politti](/wiki/Scritti_Politti \"Scritti Politti\"), and [The Blind Boys of Alabama](/wiki/The_Blind_Boys_of_Alabama \"The Blind Boys of Alabama\"). On [The Rolling Stones](/wiki/The_Rolling_Stones \"The Rolling Stones\")' 1997 album *[Bridges to Babylon](/wiki/Bridges_to_Babylon \"Bridges to Babylon\")* she plays bass on the song \"[Saint of Me](/wiki/Saint_of_Me \"Saint of Me\")\". On [Alanis Morissette](/wiki/Alanis_Morissette \"Alanis Morissette\")'s 2002 album *[Under Rug Swept](/wiki/Under_Rug_Swept \"Under Rug Swept\")*, she plays bass on the songs \"[So Unsexy](/wiki/So_Unsexy \"So Unsexy\")\" and \"You Owe Me Nothing in Return\". Also that year, she appeared on [Gov’t Mule](/wiki/Gov%E2%80%99t_Mule \"Gov’t Mule\")’s record *[The Deep End, Volume 2](/wiki/The_Deep_End%2C_Volume_2 \"The Deep End, Volume 2\")*, playing on a cover of The [Staple Singers](/wiki/Staple_Singers \"Staple Singers\")’ song \"Hammer And Nails\". And in 2009, she appeared on [Zap Mama](/wiki/Zap_Mama \"Zap Mama\")'s album *ReCreation*, playing bass on the song \"African Diamond\".",
"She can also be seen in the documentary *[Standing in the Shadows of Motown](/wiki/Standing_in_the_Shadows_of_Motown_%28film%29 \"Standing in the Shadows of Motown (film)\")*, singing [The Miracles](/wiki/The_Miracles \"The Miracles\")' \"[You've Really Got a Hold on Me](/wiki/You%27ve_Really_Got_a_Hold_on_Me \"You've Really Got a Hold on Me\")\" and [The Temptations](/wiki/The_Temptations \"The Temptations\")' \"[Cloud Nine](/wiki/Cloud_Nine_%28The_Temptations_song%29 \"Cloud Nine (The Temptations song)\")\". In the late 1990s, she toured with [Lilith Fair](/wiki/Lilith_Fair \"Lilith Fair\"). She also did a remake of the song \"[Two Doors Down](/wiki/Two_Doors_Down_%28Dolly_Parton_song%29 \"Two Doors Down (Dolly Parton song)\")\" on the 2003 release *[Just Because I'm a Woman: Songs of Dolly Parton](/wiki/Just_Because_I%27m_a_Woman:Songs_of_Dolly_Parton \"Songs of Dolly Parton\")*.",
"Ndegeocello was also a judge for The 2nd, 12th, 13 and the 2015 14th Annual Independent Music Awards to support independent artists' careers.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.independentmusicawards.com/ima\\_new/pastjudges.asp \\|title\\=Past Judges \\|publisher\\=Independent Music Awards \\|access\\-date\\=July 18, 2011 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110713024722/http://www.independentmusicawards.com/ima\\_new/pastjudges.asp \\|archive\\-date\\=July 13, 2011 }}",
"Her song \"Tie One On\" was chosen as the [Starbucks](/wiki/Starbucks \"Starbucks\") [iTunes](/wiki/ITunes \"ITunes\") Pick of the Week on February 23, 2010\\.{{Cite web \\|last\\=Heringer \\|title\\=Starbucks iTunes Pick of the Week – Meshell Ndegeocello – Tie One On \\|url\\=https://www.mark\\-heringer.com/2010/02/starbucks\\-itunes\\-pick\\-of\\-week\\-meshell.html \\|website\\=Mark\\-heringer.com\\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-08\\-04 \\|language\\=en}}{{Cite web \\|last\\=Heringer \\|title\\=Starbucks iTunes Pick of the Week list \\|url\\=https://www.mark\\-heringer.com/2008/04/starbucks\\-itunes\\-pick\\-of\\-week\\-list.html\\|website\\=Mark\\-heringer.com \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-04\\-12 \\|language\\=en}}",
"In 2016, she provided the theme song, \"Nova\", for the [Oprah Winfrey](/wiki/Oprah_Winfrey \"Oprah Winfrey\")\\-produced show *[Queen Sugar](/wiki/Queen_Sugar \"Queen Sugar\")*.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.what\\-song.com/Tvshow/187/Queen\\-Sugar \\|title\\=Queen Sugar Soundtrack \\|website\\=What\\-song.com \\|access\\-date\\=November 23, 2016}} She also collaborated with French\\-Cuban duo [Ibeyi](/wiki/Ibeyi \"Ibeyi\") in the song \"Transmission/Michaelion\" for the album *[Ash](/wiki/Ash_%28album%29 \"Ash (album)\")* reciting a poem by [Frida Kahlo](/wiki/Frida_Kahlo \"Frida Kahlo\").",
"In December 2016, the world premiere of Ndegeocello's *[Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin](/wiki/Can_I_Get_a_Witness%3F_The_Gospel_of_James_Baldwin \"Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin\")*, a new theatrical music and art work, was held in Harlem, New York.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://thestagereview.net/2016/11/29/harlem\\-stage\\-present\\-world\\-premiere\\-meshell\\-ndegeocellos\\-can\\-get\\-witness\\-gospel\\-james\\-baldwin\\-december\\-7\\-11/\\|publisher\\=The Stage Review\\|date\\=November 29, 2016\\|title\\=Harlem Stage to present the world premiere of Meshell Ndegeocello's 'Can I Get a Witness? The Gospel of James Baldwin,' December 7–11}}",
"In June 2021, [The Beatles Channel](/wiki/The_Beatles_Channel \"The Beatles Channel\") on [Sirius XM Radio](/wiki/Sirius_XM_Radio \"Sirius XM Radio\") began broadcasting *A Shot of Rhythm and Blues: Exploring The Beatles and Black Music*, a four\\-part series hosted by Ndegeocello.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/article/data\\-privacy\\-race\\-and\\-ethnicity\\-technology\\-business\\-music\\-3d9352ad2c927cd8cd03ff0bd6b9c601\\|title\\=Celebrate Black Music Month on SiriusXM, Pandora, and Stitcher with Exclusive Music Channels, Streaming Stations, and an Original Podcast\\|author\\=\\[\\[PR Newswire]]\\|date\\=June 1, 2021\\|website\\=\\[\\[Associated Press]]\\|access\\-date\\=June 8, 2021}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.thebeatles.com/news/%E2%80%9C\\-shot\\-rhythm\\-and\\-blues\\-exploring\\-beatles\\-and\\-black\\-music%E2%80%9D\\-beatles\\-channel\\|title\\=\"A Shot of Rhythm and Blues: Exploring The Beatles and Black Music\" on The Beatles Channel\\|website\\=TheBeatles.com\\|access\\-date\\=June 8, 2021\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210609030013/https://www.thebeatles.com/news/%E2%80%9C\\-shot\\-rhythm\\-and\\-blues\\-exploring\\-beatles\\-and\\-black\\-music%E2%80%9D\\-beatles\\-channel\\|archive\\-date\\=June 9, 2021\\|url\\-status\\=live}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://blog.siriusxm.com/explore\\-connection\\-between\\-the\\-beatles\\-black\\-music\\-during\\-a\\-new\\-series/\\|title\\=Explore the connection between The Beatles \\& Black music during a new SiriusXM series\\|date\\=June 7, 2021\\|website\\=\\[\\[Sirius XM]]\\|access\\-date\\=June 8, 2021}} The series explores the relationship between the English rock band [the Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles \"The Beatles\") and the black musicians that inspired them.",
"Ndegeocello joined the Blue Note label with the debut release of her 13th studio album *[The Omnichord Real Book](/wiki/The_Omnichord_Real_Book \"The Omnichord Real Book\")* (2023\\). The title refers to a set of lead sheets from songs from funk, soul, gospel and more influenced by her father as if a compilation of standards like a [real book](/wiki/Real_Book \"Real Book\") in jazz repertoire.{{Cite web \\|date\\=2023\\-06\\-12 \\|title\\=Album: Meshell Ndegeocello – The Omnichord Real Book \\|url\\=https://theartsdesk.com/new\\-music/album\\-meshell\\-ndegeocello\\-omnichord\\-real\\-book \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-06\\-12 \\|website\\=Theartsdesk.com \\|language\\=en}}",
""
] |
United Kingdom
--------------
### Knights Bachelor
* [Professor Mansel Aylward, CB](/wiki/Mansel_Aylward "Mansel Aylward"), Chairman, Wales Centre for Health. For services to Healthcare.
* [Paul John James Britton](/wiki/Paul_Britton "Paul Britton"), CB, lately Director\-General and Head, Economic and Domestic Affairs Secretariat, Cabinet Office.
* [Professor Robert George Burgess](/wiki/Robert_Burgess_%28sociologist%29 "Robert Burgess (sociologist)"), Vice\-Chancellor, [University of Leicester](/wiki/University_of_Leicester "University of Leicester"). For services to local and national Higher Education.
* [Professor John Burn](/wiki/John_Burn_%28geneticist%29 "John Burn (geneticist)"), Professor of Clinical Genetics, [Newcastle University](/wiki/Newcastle_University "Newcastle University"). For services to Medicine.
* [Professor David Alan Chipperfield, CBE](/wiki/David_Chipperfield "David Chipperfield"), Architect and CEO, [David Chipperfield Architects](/wiki/David_Chipperfield_Architects "David Chipperfield Architects"). For services to architecture in the UK and Germany.
* [Jonathan Stephen Cunliffe, CB](/wiki/Jon_Cunliffe "Jon Cunliffe"), Second Permanent Secretary and Head of International Economic Affairs, Europe and G8 Sherpa, Prime Minister's Office.
* [Andrew Patrick Dillon, CBE](/wiki/Andrew_Dillon "Andrew Dillon"), Chief Executive, [National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence](/wiki/National_Institute_for_Health_and_Clinical_Excellence "National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Ian David Grant, CBE](/wiki/Ian_David_Grant "Ian David Grant"), lately Chairman, The [Crown Estate](/wiki/Crown_Estate "Crown Estate").
* [Professor John Stranger Holman](/wiki/John_Holman_%28chemist%29 "John Holman (chemist)"), National Director, Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Programme. For services to Education.
* [Nicholas Hytner](/wiki/Nicholas_Hytner "Nicholas Hytner"), Director, [National Theatre](/wiki/Royal_National_Theatre "Royal National Theatre"). For services to Drama.
* [Mark Ellis Powell Jones](/wiki/Mark_Jones_%28museum_director%29 "Mark Jones (museum director)"), Director, [Victoria and Albert Museum](/wiki/Victoria_and_Albert_Museum "Victoria and Albert Museum"). For services to the Arts.
* [Dr. Ralph Kohn, FRS](/wiki/Ralph_Kohn "Ralph Kohn"). For services to Science, Music and to Charity.
* [Richard Douglas Lapthorne, CBE](/wiki/Richard_Lapthorne "Richard Lapthorne"), Chairman, [Cable \& Wireless plc](/wiki/Cable_%26_Wireless_plc "Cable & Wireless plc"). For services to telecommunications.
* [Michael John Marshall](/wiki/Michael_John_Marshall "Michael John Marshall"), CBE, Chairman, [Marshall of Cambridge](/wiki/Marshall_of_Cambridge "Marshall of Cambridge") (Holdings) Ltd. For services to Business, Charity and to the community in Cambridgeshire.
* [Ian Robert McGeechan, OBE](/wiki/Ian_McGeechan "Ian McGeechan"). For services to Rugby.
* [Professor Paul Anthony Mellars, FBA](/wiki/Paul_Mellars "Paul Mellars"), Professor of Prehistory and Human Evolution, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge "University of Cambridge"). For services to Scholarship.
* [Professor Salvador Moncada](/wiki/Salvador_Moncada "Salvador Moncada"), Director, Wolfson Institute of Biomedical Research, [University College London](/wiki/University_College_London "University College London"). For services to Science.
* [Erich Arieh Reich](/wiki/Erich_Reich "Erich Reich"), Chairman, Kindertransport Group, [Association of Jewish Refugees](/wiki/Association_of_Jewish_Refugees "Association of Jewish Refugees"). For charitable services.
* [Professor Michael Adrian Richards, CBE](/wiki/Michael_Adrian_Richards "Michael Adrian Richards"), National Cancer Director. For services to Medicine.
* [His Honour Mota Singh](/wiki/Mota_Singh "Mota Singh"). For services to the Administration of Justice, Community Relations and to the Voluntary Sector.
* [Patrick Stewart, OBE](/wiki/Patrick_Stewart "Patrick Stewart"), Actor. For services to Drama.
* [Graham Robert Wynne](/wiki/Graham_Wynne "Graham Wynne"), CBE, Chief Executive, [Royal Society for the Protection of Birds](/wiki/Royal_Society_for_the_Protection_of_Birds "Royal Society for the Protection of Birds"). For services to Nature Conservation.
### Order of the Bath
#### Knights Commander of the Order of the Bath (KCB)
Military Division
Army
* [Lieutenant General William Raoul Rollo, CBE](/wiki/Bill_Rollo "Bill Rollo"), late The Blues and Royals (Royal Horse Guards and 1st Dragoons)
* [Lieutenant General Alexander Richard David Shirreff, CBE](/wiki/Richard_Shirreff "Richard Shirreff"), late The King's Royal Hussars
Civil Division
* [David Nicholson](/wiki/David_Nicholson_%28civil_servant%29 "David Nicholson (civil servant)") CBE
#### Companions of the Order of the Bath (CB)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* [The Venerable John Green, QHC](/wiki/John_Green_%28chaplain%29 "John Green (chaplain)")
* [Rear Admiral Richard Derek Leaman, OBE](/wiki/Richard_Leaman "Richard Leaman")
Army
* [Major General Simon Francis Neil Lalor, TD](/wiki/Simon_Lalor "Simon Lalor"), late The Honourable Artillery Company, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant General Simon Vincent Mayall](/wiki/Simon_Mayall "Simon Mayall"), late 1st The Queen's Dragoon Guards
* [Lieutenant General Peter Thomas Clayton Pearson, CBE](/wiki/Peter_Pearson_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Peter Pearson (British Army officer)"), late The Royal Gurkha Rifles
Royal Air Force
* [The Reverend (Air Vice\-Marshal) Peter Watson Mills](/wiki/Peter_Watson_Mills "Peter Watson Mills")
Civil Division
* [Christopher Bolt](/wiki/Chris_Bolt "Chris Bolt"), Arbiter, London Underground Public Private Partnership Agreements and lately chairman, Office of Rail Regulation, Department for Transport
* [Lawrence Conway](/wiki/Lawrence_Conway "Lawrence Conway"), lately Director, Department of the First Minister, Welsh Assembly Government
* [Gloria Linda Craig](/wiki/Gloria_Craig "Gloria Craig"), director, International Security Policy, Ministry of Defence
* [Elizabeth Anne Jackson](/wiki/Elizabeth_Anne_Jackson "Elizabeth Anne Jackson"), director, Child Wellbeing, Children and Families Directorate, Department for Children, Schools and Families
* [Helen Kilpatrick](/wiki/Helen_Kilpatrick "Helen Kilpatrick"), Director\-General, Financial and Commercial, Home Office
* [William Francis Sebastian Rickett](/wiki/William_Francis_Sebastian_Rickett "William Francis Sebastian Rickett"), Director\-General of Energy, Department for Energy and Climate Change.
### Order of Saint Michael and Saint George
#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of St. Michael and St. George (KCMG / DCMG)
Civil Division
* [Dr. Fazle Hasan Abed](/wiki/Fazle_Hasan_Abed "Fazle Hasan Abed"), Founder and Chairman, [Building Resources Across Communities (BRAC)](/wiki/BRAC_%28organization%29 "BRAC (organization)"). For services to tackling poverty and empowering the poor in Bangladesh and more globally.
* [Dr. Rosalind Mary Marsden, CMG](/wiki/Rosalind_Marsden "Rosalind Marsden"), [H.M. Ambassador, Sudan](/wiki/List_of_ambassadors_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Sudan "List of ambassadors of the United Kingdom to Sudan").
* [Anne Fyfe Pringle, CMG](/wiki/Anne_Pringle "Anne Pringle"), [H.M. Ambassador, Russia](/wiki/List_of_ambassadors_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Russia "List of ambassadors of the United Kingdom to Russia").
#### Companions of the Order of St. Michael and St. George (CMG)
Military Division
Army
* Brigadier Stephen Frederick Sherry, OBE, late [Corps of Royal Engineers](/wiki/Corps_of_Royal_Engineers "Corps of Royal Engineers")
Civil Division
* Timothy Michael Everton Dowse, lately Chief of Assessments Staff, [Joint Intelligence Organisation](/wiki/Joint_Intelligence_Organisation_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Joint Intelligence Organisation (United Kingdom)"), [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office "Cabinet Office")
* Dr. Silvia Suzen Giovanna Casale, lately Chairperson, UN Sub\-Committee on the Prevention of Torture, Geneva. Lately Member, [European Committee for the Prevention of Torture](/wiki/European_Committee_for_the_Prevention_of_Torture "European Committee for the Prevention of Torture"), Strasbourg. For services to the prevention of torture, and prison reform
* [Susan le Jeune d'Allegeershecque](/wiki/Susan_le_Jeune_d%27Allegeershecque "Susan le Jeune d'Allegeershecque"), Counsellor, [Foreign and Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_and_Commonwealth_Office "Foreign and Commonwealth Office")
* [The Rt Hon. Terence Davis, PC](/wiki/Terry_Davis_%28politician%29 "Terry Davis (politician)"), lately [Secretary General, Council of Europe](/wiki/Secretary_General_of_the_Council_of_Europe "Secretary General of the Council of Europe"), Strasbourg. For services to institutional reform
* [Charles Blandford Farr, OBE](/wiki/Charles_Farr_%28civil_servant%29 "Charles Farr (civil servant)"), Counsellor, Foreign and Commonwealth Office
* [William Boyd McCleary, CVO](/wiki/William_Boyd_McCleary "William Boyd McCleary"), [British High Commissioner, Malaysia](/wiki/List_of_High_Commissioners_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Malaysia "List of High Commissioners of the United Kingdom to Malaysia")
* [Edward Mortimer](/wiki/Edward_Mortimer "Edward Mortimer"), Senior Vice\-President and Chief Program Officer, The [Salzburg Global Seminar](/wiki/Salzburg_Global_Seminar "Salzburg Global Seminar"), Austria. For services to international communications and journalism
* Hugh Powell, lately UK Senior Representative in Helmand, Afghanistan
* Michael Peter Wareing, International CEO, [KPMG](/wiki/KPMG "KPMG"), and lately co\-Chair, Basra Development Commission. For services to the [economic reconstruction](/wiki/Economic_reconstruction "Economic reconstruction") and redevelopment of Basra, and Iraq more generally
### Royal Victorian Order
#### Knights Commander of the Royal Victorian Order (KCVO)
* [The Right Reverend David John Conner](/wiki/David_Conner_%28bishop%29 "David Conner (bishop)") – Dean of Windsor
* [William Arthur Bromley\-Davenport](/wiki/William_Bromley-Davenport_%28Lord_Lieutenant%29 "William Bromley-Davenport (Lord Lieutenant)") – Lord\-Lieutenant of Cheshire
* [Angus Durie Miller Farquharson](/wiki/Angus_Durie_Miller_Farquharson "Angus Durie Miller Farquharson"), OBE, – Lord\-Lieutenant of Aberdeenshire
* [Robin Denys Gill](/wiki/Robin_Denys_Gill "Robin Denys Gill"), CVO – Chairman, The [Royal Anniversary Trust](/wiki/Royal_Anniversary_Trust "Royal Anniversary Trust")
* [Peter Gwynn\-Jones](/wiki/Peter_Gwynn-Jones "Peter Gwynn-Jones"), CVO – Garter Principal King of Arms
#### Commanders of the Royal Victorian Order (CVO)
* Gregory Scott Belton – Chairman, The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association
* Robin Shedden Broadhurst, CBE – formerly Member of Council, Duchy of Cornwall
* [Romayne Winifred, Lady Carswell](/wiki/Robert_Carswell%2C_Baron_Carswell "Robert Carswell, Baron Carswell"), OBE – formerly Lord\-Lieutenant of the County Borough of Belfast
* Alexander Pieter van Heeren, MBE – Chairman, The World Fellowship of The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association
* [John Henry Pascoe, AO](/wiki/John_Pascoe "John Pascoe") – formerly Trustee, The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association
#### Lieutenants of the Royal Victorian Order (LVO)
* Major Charles Samuel Enderby – formerly Lieutenant, The Queen's Body Guard of the Yeomen of the Guard
* Patrick Gregory Birch Harrison – Press Secretary, Household of The Prince of Wales and The Duchess of Cornwall
* Charles Benedict Morris – Architectural Designer
* Dr. [Kirsten Aschengreen Piacenti](/wiki/Kirsten_Aschengreen_Piacenti "Kirsten Aschengreen Piacenti") – for services to the Royal Collection (*Honorary*)
* [Brigadier John Edward Bruce Smedley](/wiki/John_Smedley_%28British_Army_officer%29 "John Smedley (British Army officer)") – Private Secretary to The Earl and Countess of Wessex
* Dr. [Anthony Douglas Toft](/wiki/Anthony_Douglas_Toft "Anthony Douglas Toft"), CBE – formerly Physician to The Queen in Scotland
* Richard John Verrall – Aviation Consultant
#### Members of the Royal Victorian Order (MVO)
* David Anderson, MBE – formerly Hospitality Manager, Hillsborough Castle, Northern Ireland Office
* Inspector Mark Peter Andrews – Metropolitan Police, for services to Royalty Protection
* Catherine Carruthers – Membership Development Director, Business in the Community
* Julian Charles George Clare, RVM – Drawings Conservator, Royal Collection
* Kenneth Brendan Eccles – for services to the Police Service of Northern Ireland
* Patricia Ann Lawrence – Personal Assistant to The Duke of Kent
* Paul Alexander Miller – IT Projects and Business Manager
* Roger Peter Smith – formerly Clerk of Works, Crown Estate, Windsor
* Peter Charles Taylor – Fire Safety Manager, Windsor Castle
* Christopher Robin Weatherley – Fire Safety Manager, Buckingham Palace
* Andrew James Wilson, DL – Under Sheriff, The Bailiwick of Lancashire
### Royal Victorian Medal
#### Bar to the Royal Victorian Medal (Silver)
* Anthony John Hardingham, RVM – Tractor Driver, Sandringham Estate
#### Royal Victorian Medal (Silver)
* Glen Andrew Beveridge – Executive Butler, Government House, Melbourne
* Patricia Joyce Earl – Housekeeper, Sandringham House
* Constable Kevin Gande – Metropolitan Police, for services to Royalty Protection
* Andrea Elizabeth Hudson – Cook, Royal Lodge
* Beverley Jones – Assistant Dresser to The Queen
* George David Main – Gamekeeper, Balmoral Estate
* David James McIntosh – Security Office Team Leader, Palace of Holyroodhouse
* Vivienne Oates – Linen Room Assistant, Buckingham Palace
* Richard Sands – Yeoman Warder, HM Tower of London
### Order of the British Empire
#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE / DBE)
Civil Division
* [Professor Valerie Beral](/wiki/Val_Beral "Val Beral"). For services to Science
* [Dr. Claire Bertschinger](/wiki/Claire_Bertschinger "Claire Bertschinger"). For services to Nursing and to International Humanitarian Aid
* [Councillor Ellen Margaret Eaton, OBE](/wiki/Ellen_Margaret_Eaton "Ellen Margaret Eaton"), Chair, Local Government Association. For services to Local Government
* [Dr. Susan Elizabeth Ion, OBE](/wiki/Sue_Ion "Sue Ion"), Visiting Professor, Imperial College, London and Chair, UK Fusion Advisory Board. For services to Science and Engineering
* [Clare Oriana Tickell](/wiki/Clare_Tickell "Clare Tickell"), Chief Executive, Action for Children. For services to Young People
* [Marcia Twelftree](/wiki/Marcia_Twelftree "Marcia Twelftree"), lately Headteacher, Charters School, Windsor and Maidenhead, Berkshire. For services to local and national Education
#### Commanders of the Order of the British Empire (CBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* Commodore Stephen Redvers Kirby
* Commodore Christopher Laurence Palmer
Army
* Colonel Mark Cuthbert\-Brown – late [Adjutant General's Corps](/wiki/Adjutant_General%27s_Corps "Adjutant General's Corps") ([Royal Military Police](/wiki/Royal_Military_Police "Royal Military Police"))
* Colonel David James Eadie – late The [Queen's Royal Lancers](/wiki/Queen%27s_Royal_Lancers "Queen's Royal Lancers")
* Colonel Christopher William Manning – late [Army Air Corps](/wiki/Army_Air_Corps_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Army Air Corps (United Kingdom)")
* Brigadier Simon John Marriner, MBE – late Adjutant General's Corps (Staff and Personnel Support Branch)
* Colonel Michael Peter Macgregor Stewart, QHS – late [Royal Army Medical Corps](/wiki/Royal_Army_Medical_Corps "Royal Army Medical Corps")
Royal Air Force
* [Air Commodore Clive Arthur Bairsto](/wiki/Clive_Bairsto "Clive Bairsto")
* Group Captain Keith Ronald Dipper
* Group Captain Alistair Monkman
* [Group Captain Andrew Mark Turner, OBE](/wiki/Andrew_Turner_%28RAF_officer%29 "Andrew Turner (RAF officer)")
Civil Division
* [James Christopher Armfield, OBE](/wiki/Jimmy_Armfield "Jimmy Armfield"). For services to the community in Lancashire.
* [David Ogilvy Barrie](/wiki/David_Ogilvy_Barrie "David Ogilvy Barrie"), lately Director, [Art Fund](/wiki/Art_Fund "Art Fund"). For services to the Visual Arts.
* Parmajit Paul Singh Bassi, DL, Chairman, Bond Wolfe. For services to Business and to the community in the West Midlands.
* [William Robert Baxter](/wiki/William_Robert_Baxter "William Robert Baxter"), Deputy chief executive, Baxter Storey. For services to the Catering Industry.
* Ann Beasley, Director of Finance and Performance, [National Offender Management Service](/wiki/National_Offender_Management_Service "National Offender Management Service"), Ministry of Justice.
* Edward Farquharson Bowen, [Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders](/wiki/Sheriff_Principal_of_Lothian_and_Borders "Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders"). For services to the Administration of Justice in Scotland.
* Councillor Peter Box, Leader, [Wakefield Metropolitan District Council](/wiki/Wakefield_Metropolitan_District_Council "Wakefield Metropolitan District Council") and chairman, [Yorkshire and Humber Assembly](/wiki/Yorkshire_and_Humber_Assembly "Yorkshire and Humber Assembly"). For services to Local Government.
* [Professor Donal Donat Conor Bradley, FRS](/wiki/Donal_Bradley "Donal Bradley"), Lee\-Lucas Professor of Experimental Physics and Deputy Principal, Faculty of Natural Sciences, [Imperial College London](/wiki/Imperial_College_London "Imperial College London"). For services to Science.
* [Professor Alice Brown](/wiki/Alice_Brown_%28ombudsman%29 "Alice Brown (ombudsman)"), lately [Scottish Public Services Ombudsman](/wiki/Scottish_Public_Services_Ombudsman "Scottish Public Services Ombudsman"). For public service.
* [Natalie Ceeney](/wiki/Natalie_Ceeney "Natalie Ceeney"), chief executive, National Archives, [Ministry of Justice](/wiki/Ministry_of_Justice "Ministry of Justice").
* Lauran Margaret Chatburn, Principal and chief executive, [Bury College](/wiki/Bury_College "Bury College"). For services to Further Education.
* Professor David Martin Chiddick, lately Vice\-Chancellor, [University of Lincoln](/wiki/University_of_Lincoln "University of Lincoln"). For services to local and national Higher Education.
* Lawrence Churchill, Chairman, [Pension Protection Fund](/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund "Pension Protection Fund"). For public service.
* [Robert Brodie Clark](/wiki/Brodie_Clark "Brodie Clark"), Head of Border Force, [UK Border Agency](/wiki/UK_Border_Agency "UK Border Agency"), Home Office.
* [Barry Michael Cockcroft](/wiki/Barry_Cockcroft_%28dentist%29 "Barry Cockcroft (dentist)"), [Chief Dental Officer](/wiki/Chief_Dental_Officer_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Chief Dental Officer (United Kingdom)"), Department of Health.
* Christopher Cohen, lately chairman, Athletics Sports Assembly Executive Committee, [International Paralympic Committee](/wiki/International_Paralympic_Committee "International Paralympic Committee"). For services to Sport.
* [Sarah Patricia Connolly](/wiki/Sarah_Connolly "Sarah Connolly"), Opera Singer. For services to Classical Music.
* Rodney Cousens, chief executive officer, [Codemasters](/wiki/Codemasters "Codemasters"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.
* Dr. Michael John Cresswell, Director\-General, [Assessment and Qualifications Alliance](/wiki/Assessment_and_Qualifications_Alliance "Assessment and Qualifications Alliance"). For services to Education.
* Professor Ian Richard Crute, lately Director, [Rothamsted Research](/wiki/Rothamsted_Research "Rothamsted Research"). For services to Plant Science.
* [His Honour Judge Keith Charles Cutler](/wiki/Keith_Cutler "Keith Cutler"), Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* [Dr. George Daniels, MBE](/wiki/George_Daniels_%28watchmaker%29 "George Daniels (watchmaker)"), Master Watchmaker. For services to Horology.
* [Professor Janet Howard Darbyshire, OBE](/wiki/Janet_Darbyshire "Janet Darbyshire"), Director, Clinical Trials Unit, [Medical Research Council](/wiki/Medical_Research_Council_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Medical Research Council (United Kingdom)"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Helen Anne Dent, chief executive, [Family Action](/wiki/Family_Action "Family Action"). For services to Children and Families.
* Graham Thomas Devlin. For services to the Arts.
* Professor Carol Dezateux, Professor of Paediatric Epidemiology, [UCL Institute of Child Health](/wiki/UCL_Institute_of_Child_Health "UCL Institute of Child Health"). For services to Science.
* Mary Elizabeth Dodd, lately Consultant Physiotherapist, Cystic Fibrosis, [South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust](/wiki/South_Manchester_University_Hospital_NHS_Trust "South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Peter Donohoe](/wiki/Peter_Donohoe_%28pianist%29 "Peter Donohoe (pianist)"), pianist, for services to Classical Music.
* Trudi Margaret Elliott, Regional Director, Government Office for the West Midlands, [Department for Communities and Local Government](/wiki/Department_for_Communities_and_Local_Government "Department for Communities and Local Government").
* Margaret Fay, OBE. For services to the Regional Development Agency, [One North East](/wiki/One_NorthEast "One NorthEast").
* [George Ferguson](/wiki/George_Ferguson_%28architect%29 "George Ferguson (architect)"). For services to Architecture and to the community in the South West.
* [Professor Stephen John Field](/wiki/Steve_Field_%28medical_doctor%29 "Steve Field (medical doctor)"), Head of Workforce and Regional Postgraduate Dean, NHS West Midlands and Chairman of College Council, [Royal College of General Practitioners](/wiki/Royal_College_of_General_Practitioners "Royal College of General Practitioners"). For services to Medicine.
* Christopher Mark Fisher, Director, Jobseekers and Skills, Employment Group, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions "Department for Work and Pensions").
* [Professor Alastair Hugh Fitter, FRS](/wiki/Alastair_Fitter "Alastair Fitter"), Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor for Research, [University of York](/wiki/University_of_York "University of York"). For services to Environmental Science.
* Brian Roy Fleet, MBE, Senior [Airbus UK](/wiki/Airbus_UK "Airbus UK") Vice\-President. For services to the Aerospace Industry.
* His Honour Judge David Robert Fletcher, Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice in Merseyside.
* Winston Fletcher, lately chairman, Advertising Standards Board of Finance. For services to the Creative Industries.
* Neil Raymond Flint, Deputy Director, New Academies Division, [Department for Children, Schools and Families](/wiki/Department_for_Children%2C_Schools_and_Families "Department for Children, Schools and Families").
* [Helen Fraser](/wiki/Helen_Fraser_%28executive%29 "Helen Fraser (executive)"), lately managing director, [Penguin UK](/wiki/Penguin_UK "Penguin UK"). For services to the Publishing Industry.
* Professor John Fyfe. For services to Partnership Working and to Regeneration Worldwide, particularly in West Cumbria.
* David Goldstone. For public service.
* Anthony Simonds\-Gooding, Chairman, [D\&AD](/wiki/D%26AD "D&AD"). For services to the Creative Industries.
* Professor Sean Patrick Gorman, Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Life Sciences and Professor of Pharmaceutical Microbiology, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast "Queen's University Belfast"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Lucian Charles Grainge](/wiki/Lucian_Grainge "Lucian Grainge"), Chairman and chief executive officer, [Universal Music Group International](/wiki/Universal_Music_Group_International "Universal Music Group International"). For services to the Creative Industries.
* Robert Douglas Greig, chief executive, National Development Team for Inclusion. For services to People with Special Needs.
* Bethan Haulwen Guilfoyle, Headteacher, [Treorchy Comprehensive School](/wiki/Treorchy_Comprehensive_School "Treorchy Comprehensive School"). For services to Education in Wales.
* [Maggi Hambling, OBE](/wiki/Maggi_Hambling "Maggi Hambling"), Painter and Sculptor. For services to Art.
* Ian Hardie, Deputy Director, Corporation Tax and VAT, Business Tax, [H.M. Revenue and Customs](/wiki/H.M._Revenue_and_Customs "H.M. Revenue and Customs").
* Dr. Christopher Charles Harling, Director, [NHS Plus](/wiki/NHS_Plus "NHS Plus"). For services to Occupational Health.
* Martin Harman. For services to International Trade and to the Legal Profession.
* Dr. Colin Robert Harrison, Chairman, Chemistry Innovation Knowledge Transfer Network. For services to Technology.
* [Emma Harrison](/wiki/Emma_Harrison_%28entrepreneur%29 "Emma Harrison (entrepreneur)"), Chair, [A4e](/wiki/A4e "A4e"). For services to Unemployed People and to the Voluntary Sector.
* Frances Hartley, lately Headteacher, Deans Primary School, Salford. For services to Education.
* Sally Lorinda Hobbs, HM Deputy Chief Inspector, [Crown Prosecution Service](/wiki/Crown_Prosecution_Service "Crown Prosecution Service") Inspectorate.
* Peter Michael Holland, QFSM, Chief Fire Officer, [Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service](/wiki/Lancashire_Fire_and_Rescue_Service "Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service"). For services to Local Government.
* Timothy Stancliffe Hollis, QPM, Chief Constable, [Humberside Police](/wiki/Humberside_Police "Humberside Police"). For services to the Police.
* [Helen Jackson](/wiki/Helen_Jackson_%28politician%29 "Helen Jackson (politician)"). For services to the Women and Pensions Network and to the community in South Yorkshire.
* Dyfrig Dafydd Joseff John, lately Deputy chairman and chief executive, [HSBC Bank](/wiki/HSBC_Bank "HSBC Bank"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* [Penny Johnson](/wiki/Penny_Johnson "Penny Johnson"), Director, Government Art Collection, [Department for Culture, Media and Sport](/wiki/Department_for_Culture%2C_Media_and_Sport "Department for Culture, Media and Sport").
* Julie Jones, OBE, chief executive, [Social Care Institute for Excellence](/wiki/Social_Care_Institute_for_Excellence "Social Care Institute for Excellence"). For services to Local Government.
* Robert Jones, lately chairman, Association of Police Authorities. For services to the Police.
* Professor Peter Graham Edward Kennedy, Burton Professor of Neurology, [University of Glasgow](/wiki/University_of_Glasgow "University of Glasgow"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Lowri Alice Khan, Team Leader, Intervention, Strategy and Markets Team, [H.M. Treasury](/wiki/H.M._Treasury "H.M. Treasury").
* Paul Leighton, QPM, lately Deputy Chief Constable, [Police Service of Northern Ireland](/wiki/Police_Service_of_Northern_Ireland "Police Service of Northern Ireland"). For services to the Police.
* Rosa Lady Lipworth. For charitable services.
* [Phyllida Lloyd](/wiki/Phyllida_Lloyd "Phyllida Lloyd"), Theatre Director. For services to Drama.
* [James Loughran](/wiki/James_Loughran "James Loughran"), Conductor. For services to Classical Music.
* David Clifford Loughton, chief executive, [Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust](/wiki/Royal_Wolverhampton_Hospitals_NHS_Trust "Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Ian David Luder](/wiki/Ian_Luder "Ian Luder"), lately [Lord Mayor of the City of London](/wiki/Lord_Mayor_of_London "Lord Mayor of London"). For public service.
* Mary Elizabeth Madden. For public service.
* [Professor Robert James Mair, FREng FICE FRS](/wiki/Robert_James_Mair "Robert James Mair"), Master of [Jesus College](/wiki/Jesus_College%2C_Cambridge "Jesus College, Cambridge") and Professor of Geotechnical Engineering, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge "University of Cambridge"). For services to Engineering.
* Hew Mathewson, President, [General Dental Council](/wiki/General_Dental_Council "General Dental Council"). For services to Healthcare.
* Professor Denise Angela McAlister, Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor, Teaching and Learning, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster "University of Ulster"). For services to Higher Education in Northern Ireland.
* William David McWilliam, Superintendent, [Merseyside Police](/wiki/Merseyside_Police "Merseyside Police"). For services to the Police and to Young People.
* David Leonard Moore, lately Her Majesty's Inspector of Education and Assistant Divisional Manager, [Ofsted](/wiki/Ofsted "Ofsted").
* Candy Morris, chief executive, NHS South East Coast [Strategic Health Authority](/wiki/Strategic_health_authority "Strategic health authority"). For services to Healthcare.
* Diana Lesley Morrison, Headteacher, St. Martin\-in\-the\-Fields High School for Girls, Lambeth, London. For services to local and national Education.
* Stephen Thurston Munby, chief executive, National College for Leadership of Schools and Children's Services. For services to Education.
* [Professor Adrian Charles Newland](/wiki/Adrian_Charles_Newland "Adrian Charles Newland"), Professor of Haematology and director, Pathology Clinical Academic Unit, [Barts and the London NHS Trust](/wiki/Barts_and_the_London_NHS_Trust "Barts and the London NHS Trust"). For services to Medicine.
* Dr. William Gerard O'Hare, Chairman, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster "University of Ulster") Foundation. For services to Higher Education and to Regeneration in Northern Ireland.
* [David Malcolm Orr](/wiki/David_Malcolm_Orr "David Malcolm Orr"), Director Corporate Services, Department of Finance and Personnel, [Northern Ireland Executive](/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Executive "Northern Ireland Executive").
* John Scott Perry, chief executive, [Scottish Enterprise](/wiki/Scottish_Enterprise "Scottish Enterprise"). For services to Business.
* Dr. David Price, chief executive, [Chemring Group](/wiki/Chemring_Group "Chemring Group") plc. For services to the Defence Industry.
* Imelda Redmond, chief executive, [Carers UK](/wiki/Carers_UK "Carers UK"). For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Dr. Sian Eluned Rees, Inspector of Ancient Monuments, [Cadw](/wiki/Cadw "Cadw"), Welsh Assembly Government.
* Caroline Mary Rookes, Director, Planning for Retirement and Older People, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions "Department for Work and Pensions").
* [Tessa Sarah Ross (Mrs. Scantlebury)](/wiki/Tessa_Ross "Tessa Ross"), Controller of Film and Drama, [Channel 4](/wiki/Channel_4 "Channel 4"). For services to Broadcasting.
* [Alastair Eric Hotson Salvesen](/wiki/Alastair_Salvesen "Alastair Salvesen"). For services to the Arts and to Charity in Scotland.
* [Graham Edward Sheffield](/wiki/Graham_Sheffield "Graham Sheffield"), Artistic Director, [Barbican Centre](/wiki/Barbican_Centre "Barbican Centre"), London. For services to the Arts.
* [Adrian Shooter](/wiki/Adrian_Shooter "Adrian Shooter"), Chairman, [Chiltern Railway Company Ltd](/wiki/Chiltern_Railways "Chiltern Railways"). For services to the Rail Industry.
* Ruth Sims, OBE. For voluntary service to Palliative Care in [Uganda](/wiki/Uganda "Uganda").
* John Brian Sinnott, chief executive, [Leicestershire County Council](/wiki/Leicestershire_County_Council "Leicestershire County Council"). For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Christopher John Skinner](/wiki/Chris_Skinner_%28statistician%29 "Chris Skinner (statistician)"), FBA, Professor, Southampton Statistical Sciences Research Institute, [University of Southampton](/wiki/University_of_Southampton "University of Southampton"). For services to Social Science.
* Paul Spencer, lately chairman, [National Savings and Investments](/wiki/National_Savings_and_Investments "National Savings and Investments"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* Janice Stevens, National Director, Healthcare Associated Infections Programme, Department of Health. For services to Nursing.
* Professor William James Swindall, OBE, Consulting Director, QUILL Centre, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast "Queen's University Belfast"). For services to Environmental Science.
* Kathleen Thomas, Principal, [Oldham College](/wiki/Oldham_College "Oldham College"), Manchester. For services to Further Education.
* [Margaret Maud Tyzack, OBE](/wiki/Margaret_Tyzack "Margaret Tyzack"), actress. For services to Drama.
* [Professor Karen Vousden, FRS FRSE FMedSci](/wiki/Karen_Vousden "Karen Vousden"), Director, [Beatson Institute for Cancer Research](/wiki/Beatson_Institute_for_Cancer_Research "Beatson Institute for Cancer Research"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Susan Toni Wardell, Director, Middle East, Caribbean, Asia (East, Central) and British Overseas Territories, [Department for International Development](/wiki/Department_for_International_Development "Department for International Development").
* John David Whittaker, Deputy Director, Employment Policy, [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office "Cabinet Office").
* Vanessa Wiseman, lately Headteacher, Langdon School and Sports College, Newham, London. For services to Education.
* John Briscoe Wright. For services to the [Federation of Small Businesses](/wiki/Federation_of_Small_Businesses "Federation of Small Businesses").
* Professor Michael Wright, DL, Vice\-Chancellor, [Canterbury Christ Church University](/wiki/Canterbury_Christ_Church_University "Canterbury Christ Church University"). For services to Higher Education and to the community in Kent.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* Larry Thomas Dennis, lately Auditor General of Bermuda. For services to good governance in Bermuda.
* Rabbi [David Shlomo Rosen](/wiki/David_Shlomo_Rosen "David Shlomo Rosen"), Honorary Adviser on Interfaith relations to the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. For services to interfaith relations in the Middle East, and between the UK and Israel.
#### Officers of the Order of the British Empire (OBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* [Commander Nicholas Trevor Blackman](/wiki/Nicholas_Trevor_Blackman "Nicholas Trevor Blackman")
* [Commander Richard George Fox](/wiki/Richard_George_Fox "Richard George Fox")
* [Commander David John Hunkin](/wiki/David_John_Hunkin "David John Hunkin")
* [Commander Charles David Lightfoot](/wiki/Charles_David_Lightfoot "Charles David Lightfoot")
* [Commander Peter Moss](/wiki/Peter_Moss_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "Peter Moss (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Commander Gerard Rodney Northwood](/wiki/Gerard_Rodney_Northwood "Gerard Rodney Northwood")
Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Allan Barnes](/wiki/Allan_Barnes_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Allan Barnes (British Army officer)") – Coldstream Guards
* [Colonel John Etherington](/wiki/John_Etherington "John Etherington") – late Royal Army Medical Corps
* [Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley](/wiki/Alexander_Gilbert_Carew_Hatherley "Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley") – Grenadier Guards
* [Colonel Ian David MacLeod](/wiki/Ian_David_MacLeod "Ian David MacLeod") – Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Army Cadet Force
* [Colonel Iain George David Moles, QVRM TD](/wiki/Iain_George_David_Moles "Iain George David Moles") – late Royal Army Medical Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Leanda Jane Pitt, TD DL](/wiki/Leanda_Jane_Pitt "Leanda Jane Pitt") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel John Richard James Powell](/wiki/John_Richard_James_Powell "John Richard James Powell") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Mark Reginald Rusby](/wiki/Mark_Reginald_Rusby "Mark Reginald Rusby") – The Mercian Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Andrew John Teskey](/wiki/Andrew_John_Teskey "Andrew John Teskey") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
Royal Air Force
* [Wing Commander Stephen Robert Chaskin](/wiki/Stephen_Robert_Chaskin "Stephen Robert Chaskin")
* [Wing Commander Mark Nicholas Day](/wiki/Mark_Nicholas_Day "Mark Nicholas Day")
* [Wing Commander Simon Andrew Harper](/wiki/Simon_Andrew_Harper "Simon Andrew Harper")
* [Wing Commander Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid](/wiki/Jonathan_Peter_Quentin_Reid "Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid")
* [Wing Commander Malcolm Leslie Symonds](/wiki/Malcolm_Leslie_Symonds "Malcolm Leslie Symonds")
* [Wing Commander Andrew David Wallis](/wiki/Andrew_David_Wallis "Andrew David Wallis")
* [Wing Commander Robert Alan Woods](/wiki/Robert_Alan_Woods "Robert Alan Woods")
Civil Division
* William Abbott, National Security Adviser, Secure Mental Health Services, Department of Health. For services to Healthcare.
* [Victor Akers](/wiki/Victor_Akers "Victor Akers"), lately Manager, [Arsenal Ladies' Football Team](/wiki/Arsenal_W.F.C. "Arsenal W.F.C."). For services to Sport.
* Professor [Alan Alexander](/wiki/Alan_Alexander_%28academic%29 "Alan Alexander (academic)"), Emeritus Professor of Local and Public Management, [University of Strathclyde](/wiki/University_of_Strathclyde "University of Strathclyde"). For services to Social Science.
* Alexander Beveridge Anderson, D.L., Chairman of Governors, University of Teesside. For services to the community in the North East.
* Deirdre Anne, Mrs. Kinloch Anderson, Director, Kinloch Anderson. For services to the Textile Industry.
* John Huxley Fordyce Anderson. For services to St. Martin\-in\-the\-Fields, London and to the Construction Industry.
* [Craig Armstrong](/wiki/Craig_Armstrong_%28composer%29 "Craig Armstrong (composer)"). For services to Music.
* Anthony John William Attard, Chief Executive, Panaz Ltd. For services to the Textile Industry and to International Trade.
* [Sir Nicholas Hickman Ponsonby Bacon, Bt., D.L](/wiki/Sir_Nicholas_Bacon%2C_14th_Baronet "Sir Nicholas Bacon, 14th Baronet"). For services to the community in Norfolk.
* Linda Margaret, Mrs. Costelloe Baker. For public service.
* Stuart Kemp Baker, Deputy Director, National Projects, Rail and National Networks, Department for Transport.
* Dr. Michael Thomas Barlow. For services to Intellectual Property Law.
* Professor [Ann Barrett](/wiki/Ann_Barrett "Ann Barrett"), Professor of [Oncology](/wiki/Oncology "Oncology") and lately Deputy Head of School, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia "University of East Anglia"). For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Hillary Anna Bauer, Head, International and Cultural Property Unit, Department for Culture, Media and Sport.
* Ms Margaret Baxter. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Miss Ailsa Elizabeth Beaton, Director of Information, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.
* Alan Kenneth Bowers Beavis. For services to the Scouts.
* Dr. John William Beer, lately Executive Director of Social Services, Southampton City Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ms [Anthea Bell](/wiki/Anthea_Bell "Anthea Bell"). For services to Literature and to Literary Translations.
* Arlene, Mrs. Bell, Headteacher, Beechdale Nursery School, Durham. For services to local and national Early Years Education.
* Thomas Bell. For services to the Wooden Spoon Children's Charity.
* [Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough](/wiki/Madeleine_Ponsonby%2C_Countess_of_Bessborough "Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough"). For services to the Visual Arts.
* Dr. Anthony Bernard Best. For services to the Education of Deafblind Children.
* Kay, Mrs. Bews, Chief Executive, Home\-Start UK. For services to Children and Families.
* Professor Alison Blenkinsopp, Professor of the Practice of Pharmacy, Keele University. For services to Healthcare.
* Ronald John Bowers, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.
* Paul Vincent Boyle, lately Chief Executive, Financial Reporting Council. For services to the Financial Services Industry and Accountancy.
* Ms Anne Elizabeth Brannagan, Complex Trauma Manager, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.
* [Ross Brawn](/wiki/Ross_Brawn "Ross Brawn"), Team Principal, [Brawn GP](/wiki/Brawn_GP "Brawn GP"). For services to Motorsport.
* [Dr. Michael Peter Briggs](/wiki/Peter_Briggs_%28scientist%29 "Peter Briggs (scientist)"), lately [Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor](/wiki/Pro-Vice-Chancellor "Pro-Vice-Chancellor"), [Roehampton University](/wiki/Roehampton_University "Roehampton University"). For services to Higher Education.
* Dr. Alison Fiona Campbell, Managing Director, King's College London Business Ltd. For services to Knowledge Transfer.
* Peter Carne, lately National Champion, Learning Outside the Classroom and Programme Manager, Growing Schools Programme. For services to Education.
* David Brian Cassells. For services to the Inland Waterways Association of Ireland.
* Eileen, Mrs. Cavalier (Mrs. Schatunowski), Founder, London College of Beauty Therapy. For services to Further Education.
* Pamela, Mrs. Challis, Leader, Castle Point Borough Council. For services to Local Government in South East Essex.
* [Mavis Lurline, Mrs. Champagnie](/wiki/Lurline_Champagnie "Lurline Champagnie"), Councillor, [London Borough of Harrow](/wiki/London_Borough_of_Harrow "London Borough of Harrow"). For services to Local Government and to Diversity.
* Captain Kandiah Chandran, M.B.E., Chief Executive, Preset Charitable Trust. For services to Young People in London.
* Gillian, Mrs. Coffey, Headteacher, Lynch Hill Foundation Primary School, Slough. For services to Education.
* Yvonne, Mrs. Coghill, National Lead, Breaking Through Programme, NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement. For services to Healthcare.
* Maureen, Mrs. Cooke, Head of Capability and First Line Service Management, Customer Service Delivery, Corporate IT, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Gordon Raymond Couch. For services to disabled people.
* David John Cowie, lately District Manager, Jobcentre Plus, Forth Valley, Fife and Tayside, Department for Work and Pensions.
* John Andrew Craig, Chairman, British Record Industry Trust. For services to Music and to Charity.
* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Craig, Chief Executive, Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Bruce Millson Crook, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Ms [Frances Crook](/wiki/Frances_Crook "Frances Crook"), Director, [Howard League for Penal Reform](/wiki/Howard_League_for_Penal_Reform "Howard League for Penal Reform"). For services to Youth Justice.
* Neil Philip Cunliffe, Group Manager, Road Safety Group, Lancashire County Council. For services to Road Safety.
* Phillip Leyland Darnton, Chairman, Cycling England. For services to Transport.
* Frederick Geoffrey Davies, lately Chairman, Gwent Magistrates Bench and Wales Bench Chairmen's Forum. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Derek John Davis, lately Chairman, Stoke\-on\-Trent and Staffordshire Combined Fire Authority. For services to Local Government.
* Amanda, Mrs. Deeks, Chief Executive Officer, South Gloucestershire Council and Founder, West of England Partnership for Bristol. For services to Local Government.
* Paul Deneen, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Herefordshire and Worcestershire.
* John Henry Derbyshire, Sailing Coach and Manager. For services to Sport.
* Professor [Fiona Devine](/wiki/Fiona_Devine "Fiona Devine"), Professor of Sociology, [University of Manchester](/wiki/University_of_Manchester "University of Manchester"). For services to Social Science.
* Ian Laidlaw\-Dickson, Chairman, Hertfordshire Police Authority. For services to the Police.
* Michael Donnelly, Chief Executive Officer, Habinteg Housing Association. For services to the Housing Sector.
* Jacqueline Ann, Mrs. Dowell, Customer Operations Business Design Manager, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Professor [Marcus Peter Francis du Sautoy](/wiki/Marcus_du_Sautoy "Marcus du Sautoy"), Professor of Mathematics, [University of Oxford](/wiki/University_of_Oxford "University of Oxford"). For services to Science.
* Brigadier Hedley Dennis Cardew Duncan, M.B.E., lately Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod, House of Lords.
* Martin Donald Dunford, Chairman, Association of Learning Providers and Chief Executive, Skills Training UK. For services to Skills.
* Antony Dunne, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Dr. Linda Ebbatson, Leader, Chester\-le\-Street District Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ms Janette Morag Faherty, Chief Executive, TNG/ Avanta. For services to Unemployed People and to Entrepreneurship.
* Ms Julia Fawcett, Chief Executive, Lowry Centre, Salford Quays. For services to the Arts in the North West.
* Derek Forest, Detective Superintendent, West Midlands Police. For services to the Police.
* Diana, Mrs. Fulbrook, Chief Officer, Wiltshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.
* Elizabeth Laureen, Mrs. Fullerton, lately Chair, NHS Shetland. For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Lucy Diana Gampell (Mrs. Itkin), lately Director, Action for Prisoners' Families. For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Professor Mary Gibby, Director of Science, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh. For services to Botany.
* Captain Duncan Colin Glass, lately Director of Navigation Requirements, Trinity House, Department for Transport.
* Celia Jane, Mrs. Godsall. For services to Sport.
* Dr. James Desmond Hall, General Medical Practitioner, Belfast. For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Susan Elizabeth Hall, Chief Officer, West Yorkshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Catherine Graham\-Harrison. For services to Heritage.
* David James Harrison. For services to Golf.
* Michael Clifford Hart, Director, Ffestinog Railway Company and Chairman, Welsh Highland Railway Construction Ltd. For services to the Rail Industry.
* Maurice Adrian Sylvester Heaster, Deputy Leader, Wandsworth Council. For services to Local Government.
* Elizabeth Irene, Mrs. Henderson, Network Nurse Director, Northern Ireland Cancer Network. For services to Healthcare.
* Tom Henderson. For services to Humanitarian Aid.
* Dr. Barbara Hendrie, lately Deputy Director, Iraq, Department for International Development.
* David Henry, Chairman, National Association for Mental Health. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. [Andrew James Herbert](/wiki/Andrew_Herbert "Andrew Herbert"), Managing Director, [Microsoft Research](/wiki/Microsoft_Research "Microsoft Research"), Cambridge. For services to Computer Science.
* [Donald Peter Herbert](/wiki/Peter_Herbert_%28lawyer%29 "Peter Herbert (lawyer)"), Barrister. For voluntary service to Equality, Diversity and Human Rights.
* Ms Susan Ann Higham, Business Design Manager, Modernising Pay As You Earn, Telford, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Ms Stephanie Hilborne, Chief Executive, The Wildlife Trusts. For services to Nature Conservation.
* Professor Anthony Edward Hill, Director, National Oceanography Centre, Southampton. For services to Environmental Science.
* Professor William Stewart Hillis, Medical Adviser, Scottish Football Association. For services to Medicine and to Sport.
* Helen Jane, Mrs. Clegg\-Hood, Headteacher, Shiremoor Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For services to Education.
* Ms Katharine Sarah Julian Horner, lately Specialist Counsellor and Senior Analyst, Assessments Staff, Cabinet Office.
* Peter John Hosker. For services to the community in Preston, Lancashire.
* [Gareth Dale Hoskins](/wiki/Gareth_Hoskins "Gareth Hoskins"). For services to Architecture.
* Kevin Houston, Managing Director, Anderson Manning Associates. For services to Business.
* Nicholas Howard, Parliamentary Clerk, Prime Minister's Office.
* Susan, Mrs. Huggins, Head of Network Development. For services to the Post Office.
* Shirley, Mrs. Hughes, Chief Executive Officer, Cerebral Palsy Sport. For services to Disability Sport.
* Robert Alfred Hutchings. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Wales.
* William Anthony Hynett, Group Chief Executive Officer, [B\-N Group Ltd](/wiki/Britten-Norman "Britten-Norman"). For services to the Defence Industry.
* [Paul Stafford Jackson](/wiki/Paul_Jackson_%28game_producer%29 "Paul Jackson (game producer)"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.
* Marc Jaffrey. For services to Music Education.
* Anthony Paul Jakimciw, Principal and Chief Executive Officer, Dumfries and Galloway College. For services to Further Education in Scotland.
* Professor Ian Miller Jamieson, lately Pro\-Vice\- Chancellor (Learning and Teaching), University of Bath. For services to local and national Education.
* Ms Marion Juliette Janner. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Ms Deborah Jeffery, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence. Martin John Jenkins, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Jane, Mrs. Johnson, Headteacher, St. Stephen's Primary School, Newham, London. For services to Education.
* Glenys, Mrs. Johnston, Chair, Local Safeguarding Children Board, Leicestershire and Rutland. For services to Local Government.
* Paul Lloyd Jones, Executive Headteacher, Blackpool and Chudleigh Knighton Lady Seaward's and Salcombe Primary Schools, Devon. For services to local and national Education.
* [Stephen Jones](/wiki/Stephen_Jones_%28milliner%29 "Stephen Jones (milliner)"), Milliner. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Professor Vijay Vir Kakkar, Emeritus Professor, University of London. For services to Clinical Science.
* Ms Jeanne Kaniuk, Head of Adoption Services, Thomas Coram Foundation for Children. For services to Children.
* Professor Paul Keane, Dean, School of Health and Social Care, Teesside University. For services to Healthcare.
* Anna, Mrs. Kendall, lately Headteacher, Christ Church Church of England Primary School, Kensington and Chelsea, London. For services to Education.
* Nigel Kershaw, Chief Executive, Big Issue Invest and Chairman, The Big Issue. For services to Social Enterprise.
* [Simon Henry King](/wiki/Simon_King_%28television%29 "Simon King (television)"). For services to Wildlife Photography and to Conservation.
* John Gordon Kingston. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Ms Anne Kirkham, Grade 5, Decent Homes and Housing Finance Division, Department for Communities and Local Government.
* Richard Philip Kitson, lately Chief Executive, Aster Group. For services to the Housing Sector.
* Susan, Mrs. Knox. For services to Food Safety.
* Silas Krendel. For charitable services.
* [Ram Parkash Lakha](/wiki/Ram_Parkash_Lakha "Ram Parkash Lakha"). For services to the Sikh community in Coventry, West Midlands.
* Anthony Edward Langford, Non\-Executive Director, John Smedley. For services to the Knitwear Industry.
* Heather, Mrs. Lawrence, Chief Executive, Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Jurat and Lieutenant Bailiff Sally Carolyn Ann Le Brocq. For services to the Administration of Justice and to the community in Jersey.
* Andrew John Leigh. For public service.
* Eva, Mrs. Loeffler, Vice\-President, WheelPower. For services to Disability Sport.
* Helen, Mrs. MacKenzie, Headteacher, Shevington High School, Wigan. For services to Education.
* John Graham Marks. For charitable services.
* Victor Alan Marshall, Detective Superintendent, Sussex Police and Adviser to the Home Office. For services to the Police.
* Ms Wendy Martinson, Consultant Dietitian, British Olympic Association. For services to Sport and to Nutrition.
* June Colette, Mrs. Mason, Grade 7, Cohesion and Migration Directorate, Department for Communities and Local Government.
* Samuel Abraham McCrea, Principal, Ballyclare Secondary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Professor John Alexander McDermid. For services to the Defence Industry.
* William John McGawley, Executive Vice\-Chairman, TDR Group. For services to Business and to Skills Training in the North East.
* The Very Reverend Dr. Robert Samuel James Houston McKelvey, Q.V.R.M., T.D., Dean, St. Anne's Cathedral, Belfast. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Ms Alison Mary McLean. For services to Rural Affairs in the West Midlands.
* Bishop Louis Richard McLeod, For services to Southwark Credit Union.
* Ronald McNab, lately Managing Director, Caledonian Alloys Ltd. For services to the Recycling Industry.
* Ms [Loretta Minghella](/wiki/Loretta_Minghella "Loretta Minghella"), Chief Executive, [Financial Services Compensation Scheme](/wiki/Financial_Services_Compensation_Scheme "Financial Services Compensation Scheme"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* [Michelle, Mrs. Mone](/wiki/Michelle_Mone%2C_Baroness_Mone "Michelle Mone, Baroness Mone"), Founder and Owner, MJM International Group. For services to the Lingerie Industry.
* [Kenneth Montgomery](/wiki/Kenneth_Montgomery "Kenneth Montgomery"), Principal Conductor, [Ulster Orchestra](/wiki/Ulster_Orchestra "Ulster Orchestra"). For services to Music in Northern Ireland.
* Ms [Debbie Moore](/wiki/Debbie_Moore "Debbie Moore"), Founder and Chair, [Pineapple Dance Studios](/wiki/Pineapple_Dance_Studios "Pineapple Dance Studios"). For services to Business.
* [Heidi, Mrs. Mottram](/wiki/Heidi_Mottram "Heidi Mottram"), Managing Director, Northern Rail. For services to the Rail Industry.
* Ms Diane Mulligan. For services to disabled people and to Equal Opportunities.
* [Braham Sydney Murray](/wiki/Braham_Murray "Braham Murray"), [Artistic Director](/wiki/Artistic_Director "Artistic Director"), [Royal Exchange, Manchester](/wiki/Royal_Exchange%2C_Manchester "Royal Exchange, Manchester"). For services to Drama.
* Peter Murray, Co\-Founder, Ormiston Trust. For services to Children and Families.
* Dr. Sydney Donnelly Neill, Director, Agriculture Food and Environmental Sciences Division, Agri\-Food and Biosciences Institute, Northern Ireland Executive.
* [David Nixon](/wiki/David_Nixon_%28choreographer%29 "David Nixon (choreographer)"), Artistic Director, [Northern Ballet](/wiki/Northern_Ballet "Northern Ballet") Theatre. For services to Dance.
* Edward James O'Gorman. For charitable services to the Foundation for Children with Leukaemia.
* Professor [Timothy O'Riordan](/wiki/Tim_O%27Riordan "Tim O'Riordan"), D.L., Emeritus Professor of Environmental Sciences, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia "University of East Anglia"). For services to Sustainable Development.
* Gary Oldman. For public service.
* Dr. Jane Overbury, Principal, Christ the King Sixth Form College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.
* [Richard Parfitt](/wiki/Rick_Parfitt "Rick Parfitt"), Co\-Founder, Singer and Guitarist, [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 "Status Quo (band)"). For services to Music and to Charity.
* Dr. Louise Mary Perrotta. For public service.
* Peter Phillipson, Chairman, Merlin Entertainments Group. For services to the Leisure Industry.
* Raymond Pollock, Principal, Banbridge Academy. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Diane, Mrs. Poole, General Manager, Passengers Norfolkline Irish Sea Ferry Services. For services to the Tourist Industry.
* Melloney, Mrs. Poole, Deputy Director, Legal Services and Governance, Big Lottery Fund. For public service.
* Andrew Richard Pope, J.P., National Business Crime Partnership Manager, Co\-operative Group. For public service.
* Ms [Rachel Portman](/wiki/Rachel_Portman "Rachel Portman"), Film Composer. For services to Music.
* Colin Preece, lately Director, Social Services, Neath Port Talbot. For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Michael Charles Prestwich](/wiki/Michael_Prestwich "Michael Prestwich"), Emeritus Professor of History, [Durham University](/wiki/Durham_University "Durham University"). For services to Scholarship.
* Richard Edward Priest, Chief Executive, Riverside Centre. For services to the community in the Isle of Wight.
* Walter Rader, Director, Big Lottery Fund. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Judith, Mrs. Ragan, Headteacher, Queensmill Special School for Autism, Hammersmith and Fulham, London. For services to Special Needs Education.
* Bernardine, Mrs. Rees, lately Chief Executive, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire Local Health Board. For services to the NHS in Wales.
* Raymond Victor Refausse, lately Director and Chief Executive, South West College. For services to Further and Higher Education in Northern Ireland.
* Professor Margaret Reid, Professor of Women's Health, University of Glasgow. For services to Healthcare and to Higher Education.
* Ms Lyndy Reynolds, lately Deputy Head, Government Legal Service Secretariat, Treasury Solicitor's Department.
* Ms [Menna Richards](/wiki/Menna_Richards "Menna Richards"), Director, [BBC Wales](/wiki/BBC_Wales "BBC Wales"). For services to Broadcasting.
* Anne, Mrs. Roberts, Chief Executive, Crossroads Association. For services to Carers.
* Edmund Caerwyn Roberts, M.B.E., Chairman, Snowdonia National Park Authority. For services to the community in Gwynedd.
* Elizabeth Regina Oluyemika, Mrs. Atere\-Roberts, Older People's Nurse Specialist. For services to Healthcare in London.
* Brian Keith Rockliffe, Director, Voluntary Service Overseas. For services to International Development.
* [Francis Dominic Nicholas Michael Rossi](/wiki/Francis_Rossi "Francis Rossi"), Co\-Founder and Singer, Status Quo. For services to Music and to Charity.
* John Kenneth Rostill, Chief Executive, Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Henry James Griffin Russell, lately Chairman, National Association of General Commissioners. For public service.
* Professor Edward Sallis, Principal and Chief Executive, Highlands College, Jersey. For services to Education.
* Sujinder Singh Sangha, Principal, Stockton Riverside College, County Durham. For services to local and national Further Education.
* Professor Danny Saunders, Professor and Head of the Centre for Lifelong Learning, University of Glamorgan. For services to Higher Education in Wales.
* Professor Joseph Maurice Savage, Consultant Paediatric Nephrologist, Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children. For services to Medicine.
* Dr. Caroline Ann Bodley\-Scott, Civilian Medical Practitioner, British Forces Germany Health Service, Ministry of Defence.
* Gordon Scott. For services to Regeneration in South Yorkshire.
* [Jane Antoinette, Mrs. Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook "Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook"), Leader, [Wiltshire Council](/wiki/Wiltshire_Council "Wiltshire Council"). For services to Local Government.
* Ahmad Shahzad. For services to Black and Minority Ethnic People.
* Ghulam Rasul Shahzad. For services to Social Housing and to the community in Rochdale.
* Peter Sheldon. For services to the Jewish Community.
* Miss Julie May Shenton, Departmental Strategic Business Continuity Manager, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Dr. David Sibbald, F.R.S.E., Chairman, Sumerian Networks. For charitable services in Scotland and Overseas.
* [Alice, Mrs. Sluckin](/wiki/Alice_Sluckin "Alice Sluckin"), Chair, Selective Mutism Information and Research Association. For services to Children and Families.
* [Ronald Gordon King\-Smith](/wiki/Dick_King-Smith "Dick King-Smith"), Author. For services to Children's Literature.
* John Thomas Smith, lately Principal, Burnley College. For services to Further Education.
* Ms Laraine Smith, Principal, Uxbridge College. For services to Further Education.
* Peter Arthur Smith. For services to the Optometric Profession.
* Gerard Smyth. For services to the Police in the North East.
* Margaret, Mrs. Snowdon, Chair, Pensions Advisory Service. For services to Pensioners.
* The Honourable [Rupert Christopher Soames](/wiki/Rupert_Soames "Rupert Soames"), Chief Executive Officer, [Aggreko](/wiki/Aggreko "Aggreko") plc. For services to the Power Industry.
* Pauline Joan, Mrs. Spencer, lately Head, Victim and Witness Care Delivery Unit, Crown Prosecution Service.
* Eric Spicer. For services to the Telecommunications Industry.
* The Right Reverend James Theophilus Stapleton. For services to Inter\-Faith and Community Relations in Nottingham.
* Dr. [Miriam Stoppard](/wiki/Miriam_Stoppard "Miriam Stoppard"). For services to Healthcare and to Charity.
* Professor David Storey, lately Director, Centre for Small and Medium Enterprise, Warwick Business School. For services to Business.
* Stephen Szemerenyi, Pay and Conditions Specialist, Association of School and College Leaders. For services to Education.
* Alexander Tait, lately Governing Governor, H.M. Young Offenders' Institution Castington, Northumberland, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Jeremy James Taylor. For services to Young People and to Musical Theatre.
* David Ralph Thompson, Governor H.M. Prison Frankland, Durham, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Gillian Jane Thompson, lately Chief Executive, Accountant in Bankruptcy, Scottish Executive.
* [Cyrus Todiwala](/wiki/Cyrus_Todiwala "Cyrus Todiwala"), M.B.E., Proprietor and Executive Chef, Cafe ́ Spice Namaste ́ Restaurant Group. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Iqbal Wahhab, Chairman, Department for Work and Pensions, Ethnic Minority Advisory Group. For public service and for services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Ms [Amanda Jane Wakeley](/wiki/Amanda_Wakeley "Amanda Wakeley"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Professor Janet Anne Walker, Deputy Chair, Social Security Advisory Committee. For public service.
* James Arneil Wardrop. For services to the community in Renfrewshire.
* Caroline, Mrs. Waters, Director, People and Policy for BT Group. For services to Diversity and to Equal Opportunities.
* Norma Anne, Mrs. Watson. For services to Education in Scotland.
* Dr. John Alexander Watt, Director of Strengthening Communities, Highlands and Islands Enterprise. For services to Community Development.
* Professor Maureen Wayman, lately Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor and Dean, Art and Design, Manchester Metropolitan University. For services to local and national Higher Education.
* John Wilkinson, Chief Executive, Ecuomed. For services to the Healthcare Industry.
* [Mark Roger Wilkinson](/wiki/Mark_Wilkinson_%28designer%29 "Mark Wilkinson (designer)"). For services to the Furniture Industry and to Charity.
* Susan Jean, Mrs. Willan, lately Inspector, Her Majesty's Inspectorate for Education and Training in Wales. For services to Education.
* Professor Richard James Willson Williams, T.D., Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, Aneurin Bevan Health Board. For services to Medicine.
* Jessie, Mrs. Wojciechowski, Headteacher, Borestone Primary School, Stirling. For services to Education.
* Professor Charles Roland Wolf, Director, Biomedical Research Centre, University of Dundee. For services to Science.
* David Mark Wood, Chief Executive, ATTEND. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Dr. Eric Wood, D.L. For services to Education and to the community in Warwickshire.
* Thomas Greenaway Woods. For public service.
* Ms Louise Wright, Fraud and Error Consultant, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Stephen Frederick Wright, Head, Business, Improvement and Support Team, London, Valuation Office Agency, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Woon Wing Yip, Chairman, Wing Yip plc. For services to the Oriental Food Industry.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* [Mockbul Ali](/wiki/Mockbul_Ali "Mockbul Ali") \- Adviser to the then [Foreign \& Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_%26_Commonwealth_Office "Foreign & Commonwealth Office"). For services to British foreign policy.
* David Belgrove – lately Head, Counter Narcotics Team, British Embassy, Afghanistan.
* [Thomas Yates Benyon](/wiki/Thomas_Benyon "Thomas Benyon") – Founder and director, ZANE (Zimbabwe A National Emergency). For services to vulnerable people in Zimbabwe.
* James Gordon Davidson Blakely – Director Youth (Education, Science and Society), British Council.
* The Right Reverend Leroy Errol Brooks – For services to the community in Anguilla.
* Norma Po Yee Chan – lately Chief, Security Council Secretariat, United Nations. For services to the United Nations in New York.
* John Joseph\-Devine, LVO – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* Dr. Roderic William Dutton – Adviser on the Middle East, International Office, Durham University. For services to higher education and research links between the UK and the Middle East, especially Jordan.
* Simon John Gillham – President, Franco\-British Chamber of Commerce. For services to Franco\-British business interests in France.
* Richard Wingfield Hyde, MBE – British Honorary Consul, Madagascar. For services to the British community in Madagascar.
* [Graham King](/wiki/Graham_King "Graham King") – Film Producer. For services to the British film industry in the US and UK.
* Beverley Elizabeth Lewis – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* Nicholas Roy Mason – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Margaret Marian McPartland](/wiki/Marian_McPartland "Marian McPartland") – Pianist and Radio Show Host, National Public Radio, USA. For services to jazz and to aspiring young musicians in the USA.
* [Diane Mulligan](/wiki/Diane_Mulligan "Diane Mulligan") – for services to disabled people and to equal opportunities.
* William Smith MacDonald Murray – Economic and Financial Attaché, British Embassy, Spain.
* Brian David Outlaw – Director, China\-Britain Business Council. For services to British business interests in China.
* Mehr Tahir Kamran – British Foreign Officer, Ambassador to Russia. For services towards a better mutual co\-ordination in trade with Russia.
* Ian George Purves – lately Stabilisation Adviser, Civil Military Mission in Helmand. For services to security and stabilisation in Afghanistan.
* Michael Charles Ramscar – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Jane Antoinette Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook "Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook") – For services to local government in Wiltshire.
* Olga May Scott – For services to the health, education and development of Bermuda's youth.
* Stephen Rowland Thomas – Founder and former Chairman of OPAL, Oman. For services to British business interests and to the community in Oman.
* Paul Williams – Offsets Adviser, UK Trade and Investment, South Africa. For services to British business interests.
#### Members of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Warfare Specialist (Abovewater Warfare Tactical) Russell Graham Billings](/wiki/Russell_Graham_Billings "Russell Graham Billings")
* [Logistician (Catering Services) Class 1 Rosemary Anne Brodrick](/wiki/Rosemary_Anne_Brodrick "Rosemary Anne Brodrick")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Air Engineering Technician Kenneth Michael Davidson](/wiki/Kenneth_Michael_Davidson "Kenneth Michael Davidson")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Barry Dawe](/wiki/Barry_Dawe "Barry Dawe")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Robert John Ewen](/wiki/Robert_John_Ewen "Robert John Ewen")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) John Ronald Hendren](/wiki/John_Ronald_Hendren "John Ronald Hendren")
* [Lieutenant Commander Steven David Hopkins](/wiki/Steven_David_Hopkins "Steven David Hopkins")
* [Lieutenant Anthony Jackson](/wiki/Anthony_Jackson_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "Anthony Jackson (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Lieutenant Commander Bryan John Nicholas](/wiki/Bryan_John_Nicholas "Bryan John Nicholas")
* [Chief Petty Officer Engineering Technician (Marine Engineering) David Parker](/wiki/David_Parker_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "David Parker (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) Andrew Mark Rainey](/wiki/Andrew_Mark_Rainey "Andrew Mark Rainey")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Philip David Slocombe](/wiki/Philip_David_Slocombe "Philip David Slocombe")
* [Lieutenant Commander Graham Gilbey Trewhella](/wiki/Graham_Gilbey_Trewhella "Graham Gilbey Trewhella")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 (Bugler) James Whitwham](/wiki/James_Whitwham "James Whitwham")
Army
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Justin Mark Brooks](/wiki/Justin_Mark_Brooks "Justin Mark Brooks") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Major Neil James Mark Budd](/wiki/Neil_James_Mark_Budd "Neil James Mark Budd") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Major Richard Ronald Coomber](/wiki/Richard_Ronald_Coomber "Richard Ronald Coomber") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Major Jonathan Edward Cunningham](/wiki/Jonathan_Edward_Cunningham "Jonathan Edward Cunningham") – The Yorkshire Regiment
* [Major Robert Anthony Davies](/wiki/Robert_Anthony_Davies "Robert Anthony Davies") – The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment
* [Major Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood](/wiki/Mark_Christopher_Preston_Ellwood "Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood") – The Mercian Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Michael Richard Elviss](/wiki/Mike_Elviss "Mike Elviss") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Major Graham Roy Emond](/wiki/Graham_Roy_Emond "Graham Roy Emond") – Devon Army Cadet Force
* [Major Christopher Gill](/wiki/Christopher_Gill_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Christopher Gill (British Army officer)") – Army Air Corps, Territorial Army
* [Major Paul Harrison](/wiki/Paul_Harrison_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Paul Harrison (British Army officer)") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Captain Philip John Hawkins](/wiki/Philip_John_Hawkins "Philip John Hawkins") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Anthony Mark Hobbins](/wiki/Anthony_Mark_Hobbins "Anthony Mark Hobbins") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Staff Sergeant Gary Holdham](/wiki/Gary_Holdham "Gary Holdham") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Charles Henry James Holdsworth](/wiki/Charles_Henry_James_Holdsworth "Charles Henry James Holdsworth") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Sergeant Barry John](/wiki/Barry_John_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Barry John (British Army officer)") – The Royal Welsh
* Captain Susan King – Royal Corps of Signals
* [Major Joanna Catherine Maynard](/wiki/Joanna_Catherine_Maynard "Joanna Catherine Maynard") – Royal Corps of Signals
* [Captain Richard Andrew Peters](/wiki/Richard_Andrew_Peters "Richard Andrew Peters") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Damien Daniel Place](/wiki/Damien_Daniel_Place "Damien Daniel Place") – The Royal Irish Regiment
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Iestyn David Plummer](/wiki/Iestyn_David_Plummer "Iestyn David Plummer") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Major James Samuel Robert Priest](/wiki/James_Samuel_Robert_Priest "James Samuel Robert Priest") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Major Jonathan Howard Scott](/wiki/Jonathan_Howard_Scott "Jonathan Howard Scott") – Corps of Royal Engineers
* [Major Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe](/wiki/Jeremy_Edward_Gavin_Sharpe "Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Paul Philip Shipley](/wiki/Paul_Philip_Shipley "Paul Philip Shipley") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Lieutenant Colonel Hugh Campbell\-Smith](/wiki/Hugh_Campbell-Smith "Hugh Campbell-Smith") – The Royal Dragoon Guards
* [Major Oliver William Stokes](/wiki/Oliver_William_Stokes "Oliver William Stokes") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Major Sonya Adams Summersgill](/wiki/Sonya_Adams_Summersgill "Sonya Adams Summersgill") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army
* [Major Alasdair James Eli Truett](/wiki/Alasdair_James_Eli_Truett "Alasdair James Eli Truett") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Captain Thomas Georg John Tugendhat](/wiki/Thomas_Tugendhat "Thomas Tugendhat") – Intelligence Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Colin Richard James Weir](/wiki/Colin_Weir "Colin Weir") – The Royal Irish Regiment
* [Major Robert John Wells](/wiki/Robert_John_Wells "Robert John Wells") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Major Christopher James White](/wiki/Christopher_James_White "Christopher James White") – Surrey Army Cadet Force
* Lieutenant Colonel John Wilson – Cumbria Army Cadet Force
Royal Air Force
* [Warrant Officer Peter Allen Akers](/wiki/Peter_Allen_Akers "Peter Allen Akers")
* [Chief Technician Paul Andrew Blackah](/wiki/Paul_Andrew_Blackah "Paul Andrew Blackah")
* [Squadron Leader Ian Bryant](/wiki/Ian_Bryant_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "Ian Bryant (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Squadron Leader John Cairns](/wiki/John_Cairns_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "John Cairns (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Warrant Officer Alexander Michael Dykes](/wiki/Alexander_Michael_Dykes "Alexander Michael Dykes")
* [Flight Sergeant Douglas Stuart Law](/wiki/Douglas_Stuart_Law "Douglas Stuart Law")
* [Warrant Officer Rachel MacKenzie](/wiki/Rachel_MacKenzie "Rachel MacKenzie")
* [Flying Officer Leslie Edward Wall McCammont](/wiki/Leslie_Edward_Wall_McCammont "Leslie Edward Wall McCammont")
* [Sergeant Rodney Christian Munday](/wiki/Rodney_Christian_Munday "Rodney Christian Munday")
* [Squadron Leader John Nelson](/wiki/John_Nelson_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "John Nelson (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Squadron Leader Gordon William Henry Parry](/wiki/Gordon_William_Henry_Parry "Gordon William Henry Parry")
* [Flight Sergeant Christopher Edward Read](/wiki/Christopher_Edward_Read "Christopher Edward Read")
* [Warrant Officer Stephen Kenneth Roberts](/wiki/Stephen_Kenneth_Roberts "Stephen Kenneth Roberts")
* [Squadron Leader Colin Terence Sullivan](/wiki/Colin_Terence_Sullivan "Colin Terence Sullivan")
* [Senior Aircraftman Darren Mark Swift](/wiki/Darren_Mark_Swift "Darren Mark Swift")
Civil Division
* Gwendolen June, Mrs. Abraham. For services to the community in Braunstone, Leicestershire.
* Hemant Acharya, Policy Adviser, Office of the Third Sector, Cabinet Office.
* Samuel Adair, Director, Waterside Credit Union Ltd. For services to the Financial Services Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Valerie Edith, Mrs. Adams, Principal, Lisbellaw Primary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Manus Blake Adamson, Chairman, Adamson Group and Executive Chairman, Construction Confederation. For services to the Construction Industry.
* Robin Agascar. For voluntary service to the Police in Gloucester.
* Matilda, Mrs. Akhigbe, Communications Officer, Local Compliance, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Ms Foluke Akinlose, Founder and Editor, Precious Online. For services to the Creative Industries.
* Gerald Akroyd. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Scotland.
* Anthony John Alderman, Special Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Ms Angela Cecile Alessendre, Founder, Alessendre Special Needs Dance School and the Larondina Dance Company. For services to Dance.
* Anne Maria Palma, Mrs. Allan, Deputy Head Teacher, inverclyde Academy, Greenock. For services to Education.
* Dr. Geoffrey Walter Allan. For services to the community in Kirkintilloch, Dunbartonshire.
* Shulah, Mrs. Allan, lately Director, Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations Council. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Lynda, Mrs. Allen, Chair of Governors, Sir John Deane's Sixth Form College, Northwich, Cheshire. For voluntary service to Education.
* Andrew Paul Andrews. For voluntary service to St. John Ambulance Brigade.
* John Charles Ankcorn, President, Birmingham Crisis Centre. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence.
* Linda Joyce, Mrs. Ansell. For charitable services in Southend\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Miss Kerry Anthony, Chief Executive, DePaul Northern Ireland. For services to Social Housing.
* David Archbold. For services to the Water Industry in the North East.
* James Armitage. For services to the Royal Mail and to the community in the West Midlands.
* Carol, Mrs. Armstrong, Claims Receipts Manager, Benefits and Credits Operations, Washington, Tyne and Wear, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Mohammed Aslam, Executive Chef and Managing Director, Aagrah Group Restaurants. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Jean, Mrs. Atkinson, lately Staff Side Chair, UNISON, Mersey Care NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.
* Barbara May, Mrs. Austin. For services to the community in Lyme Regis, Dorset.
* Kenneth Edwin Ayers. For services to the City of London Corporation.
* Gloria, Mrs. Bailey. For services to the community in Lambeth, South London.
* Joan Debra, Mrs. Bailey. For services to Youth Justice in Luton, Bedfordshire.
* Sharon Gail, Mrs. Bailey, J.P., Head of Service Learning Disabilities, Birmingham City Council. For services to Local Government.
* Lilian, Mrs. Baker. For services to Mental Healthcare in the Wirral.
* Warner James Baker, Special Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Robert Henry Ball. For services to Young People in Exeter, Devon.
* Susan, Mrs. Banton, Director, Steps Charity Worldwide. For services to People with Skeletal Disabilities.
* Ramanbhai Barber. For services to the Asian community in Leicester.
* Grace, Mrs. Barnett. For services to the community in Failsworth, Oldham.
* [Norman Barrett](/wiki/Norman_Barrett_%28ringmaster%29 "Norman Barrett (ringmaster)"), Circus Ringmaster. For services to Entertainment.
* Derek Anthony Bartley. For services to the Midland Association of Mountaineering and to Rhyl Music Club, Denbighshire.
* Miss [Luella Dayrell Bartley](/wiki/Luella_Bartley "Luella Bartley"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Patricia, Mrs. Bate. For services to the community in Warrington, Cheshire.
* Thomas Frederick Beesley. For services to the community in Halewood, Liverpool.
* Antony Romer Beevor. For voluntary service to Fairbridge youth organisation.
* Gulrook, Mrs. Begum. For services to Disabled Bangladeshi People in Tower Hamlets, London.
* Stephen Avery Bell, Managing Director, Davy Roll Company. For services to Business in the North East.
* Mavis, Mrs. Bent. For voluntary service to Swimming and Water Polo in Greater Manchester.
* John Alfred Bigny. For services to Edenbridge and District Rail Travellers' Association Kent.
* Helen, Mrs. Bird. For services to the community in Hastings, East Sussex.
* Dr. [Charles William Handley Bird](/wiki/William_Bird_%28doctor%29 "William Bird (doctor)"), General Medical Practitioner and Strategic Health Adviser to Natural England. For services to Healthcare and to Physical Activity.
* Arthur Birkby. For services to the community in Runnymede, Surrey.
* Paul Blakey. For services to Community Safety in Halifax.
* Alan Blocksidge, Officer, H.M. Prison Manchester, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* June, Mrs. Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.
* Roy Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Boswell. For services to the community in Sheerness, Kent.
* John Stephen Morton Bower. For services to the British Veterinary Association Animal Welfare Foundation.
* Miss Jennifer Boyd, Principal, Enniskillen Nursery School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Scott Michael Bradbury. For services to the community in Tamworth, Staffordshire.
* Barbara Evelyn Turner, Mrs. Braithwaite. For voluntary service to the community in Linlithgow, West Lothian.
* [Rosa, Mrs. Branson](/wiki/Rosa_Branson "Rosa Branson"), Painter. For services to Art and to Charity.
* Richard Oliver Brantingham, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* David Keith Bray. For services to the community in Lincolnshire.
* Valerie, Mrs. Braybrooks, Dean and Associate Professor, Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Animal Sciences, University of Lincoln. For services to Education and to the Food Industry.
* John Frederick Brignall. For services to the community in the East Riding of Yorkshire.
* Philip Britton, Headmaster, Boys' Division, Bolton School. For services to Physics.
* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Bromley. For charitable services in Oswestry, Shropshire.
* Robert Patrick Brooks. For voluntary service to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Clwyd.
* Felicity, Mrs. Brown, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Ms Marie Therese Brown. For services to the Victims of Domestic Violence in Northern Ireland.
* Norman Henry Parson Brown. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion in Hampshire.
* Robert Brown. For services to the community in Lower Bevendean, Brighton.
* David Buchanan. For voluntary service to the Environment and to Heritage in Northern Ireland.
* Diana Hill, Mrs. Bucknall. For voluntary service to the community in Dorset.
* Lieutenant Commander James Frederic Budgen, R.N.R. For voluntary service to the Sea Cadet Corps in Ruislip, London Borough of Hillingdon.
* Frederick Henry Ernest Buller. For services to Angling.
* Yvonne, Mrs. Burdge. For services to the Trust for Chernobyl Children.
* Kenneth Burgin. For voluntary service to the Casualties Union.
* Richard John Burningham, Manager, Devon and Cornwall Rail Partnership. For services to the Rail Industry in the South West.
* Dr. Stephen Brian Burns. For services to Healthcare and to the community in Rotherham, South Yorkshire.
* William Henry Burt. For voluntary service to Education in Bridgend, South Wales.
* David John Butler, Chairman, British Motorsport Association for the Disabled. For services to Disability Sport.
* [Jenson Alexander Lyons Button](/wiki/Jenson_Button "Jenson Button"). For services to Motorsport.
* Ian Caddy. For services to the community in Birtley, County Durham.
* Dr. Timothy Alan Carney, General Medical Practitioner, Hexham and Tynedale, Northumberland. For services to Healthcare.
* The Reverend Barry Edward Carter. For services to the community in Brockley, South East London.
* Colin Richard Carter. For services to the Road Haulage Industry and to Charity.
* Rosalind Ella, Mrs. Carter, EAL Education Adviser, Language Service, London Borough of Hounslow. For services to Education.
* Dr. Susan Carver, Senior Programme Manager, Arts and Humanities Research Council. For services to the Research Councils.
* Wing Commander Alan Charles Cassidy RAF (Ret'd). For services to Aerobatics and to Charity.
* Robin William Castle. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Sheerness, Kent.
* Judith Evelyn, Mrs. Catterick. For services to Music in Ashwell, Hertfordshire.
* James Joseph Caulfield. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged People in Kenya.
* Miss Susan Caulfield, Assistant Director, Immigration Fingerprint Bureau, UK Border Agency, Home Office.
* Peter Geoffrey Challinor, Curator and Manager, Anson Engine Museum. For services to Industrial Heritage.
* Harry Chambers. For services to Poetry.
* Patricia, Mrs. Chapman. For services to Young People and to the community in Ealing, West London.
* Glendon Austin Chappelle, Project Manager, Global Combat Systems—Munitions, BAE Systems. For services to the Defence Industry and to Industrial Heritage.
* Deborah Ann, Mrs. Chedgey. For services to Disadvantaged People in Norwich, Norfolk.
* Rex Chester. For services to Young People through the Explore Charity.
* Ms [Lauren Child](/wiki/Lauren_Child "Lauren Child"), Author and Illustrator. For services to Literature.
* Stanley Charles Church. For voluntary service to Conservation in Essex.
* Donna, Mrs. Clark, Assistant Practitioner, Podiatry Service, Sefton Primary Care Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Leonard Durbin Clark. For services to Young People in Westminster and to the community in North West London.
* Peter Mansfield\-Clark, Director, Crawley Open House. For services to Disadvantaged People in West Sussex.
* Dr. Janet Ruth Clarke, Chair, Central Committee for Community and Public Health Dentistry, British Dental Association. For services to Healthcare.
* Susan, Mrs. Clarke. For voluntary service to Disability Swimming in Stockton\-on\-Tees.
* Dr. Peter David Clarkson, Emeritus Associate, Scott Polar Research Institute. For services to Science.
* Professor Timothy Charles Claypole, Director, Welsh Centre for Printing and Coating, Swansea University. For services to Graphic Arts Research.
* Barry Clewer. For voluntary service to Birmingham Advisory Council of Older People.
* [Oliver Charles Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 "Collyer brothers (game designers)"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to Computer Games Industry.
* [Paul Edward Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 "Collyer brothers (game designers)"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to the Computer Game Industry.
* David Constantine, Co\-Founder and Executive Officer Motivation. For services to disabled people.
* Teresa Mary, Mrs. Copp, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* David John Couch. For charitable services in Fife.
* Thelma Selina, Mrs. Couch. For charitable services in Fife.
* Ms Margaret Joan Coulter. For services to Social Care in Northern Ireland.
* [The Reverend Dr. Robert James Coulter](/wiki/Robert_Coulter_%28Northern_Ireland_politician%29 "Robert Coulter (Northern Ireland politician)"), Member, Northern Ireland Assembly Commission. For public service.
* David Robert Coulthard, Senior Technician, University of York. For services to Science Communication.
* Beryl, Mrs. Cox, Administrator, Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, York. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Theresa, Mrs. Coyle. For voluntary service to the community in Islington, London.
* Dorothy Dawn, Mrs. Cragg, Medical Tattooist. For services to Healthcare.
* Heather, Mrs. Crawford. For services to Speech and Language Therapy in Northern Ireland.
* Arthur Graves Credland. For services to Maritime History.
* Margaret, Mrs. Crennell, Senior Assistant Headteacher and Head of Learning Support Faculty, Marriotts School, Stevenage. For services to Special Needs Education.
* Ms Heather Alice Crouch, Chair, Netball South West. For voluntary service to Sport.
* John Cunningham. For charitable services in County Durham.
* Gordon Curry. For public service.
* Leonard James Curtis. For services to the community in Lancashire.
* Ms Nicola Kim Dale, Chief Inspector, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.
* David Dallison. For public service.
* Ashish Dasgupta, Non\-Executive Director, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* John Kenneth Davies. For charitable services in Rochdale.
* Patricia Ann, Mrs. Davies. For voluntary service to Young People in Brownhills, Walsall, West Midlands.
* Sandra Irwin, Mrs. Davies. For services to the community in Craven Arms, Shropshire.
* Vanessa Marion, Mrs. Davies, Physiotherapist, Artificial Limb and Appliance Centre, Morriston Hospital, Swansea. For services to Healthcare.
* Barbara Jane, Mrs. Davis. For services to Young People in Buckinghamshire.
* Ian Davis. For services to the House of Commons.
* Eric George Dawkins. For services to the community in Penryn and Falmouth, Cornwall.
* Terence Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Victoria, Mrs. Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Ms Ilene Daisy Ming\-Deans. For services to Clapham Youth Centre, Lambeth, London.
* Sister Lynda Dearlove. For services to Vulnerable Women.
* Sarinder Kaur, Mrs. Dev, Constable, South Yorkshire Police. For services to the Police.
* Achhar Paul Dharni. For services to Business and to the community in Bradford, West Yorkshire.
* Gwyneth Muriel, Mrs. Dickinson, President, Macular Disease Society. For services to Visually Impaired People.
* Valerie Anne, Mrs. Dilcock. For services to the North York Moors National Park Authority.
* Ronald Dodd, Chairman, Training and Development Resource Ltd, Tyneside. For services to Skills.
* Ian Henry Donaghey. For services to Regeneration in Coleraine, Northern Ireland.
* Mary Maya, Mrs. Donelan. For services to the community in Hammersmith and Fulham, London.
* Ms Norah Donnelly. For public service.
* Jennifer, Mrs. Doolan. Harpist. For services to Music.
* Muriel Margaret, Mrs. Douglas, Manager, Scottish NHS Central Register, General Register Office for Scotland, Scottish Executive.
* Dr. Andrew Frank Dove. For services to St. John Ambulance Brigade in Nottinghamshire.
* Carol Ann, Mrs. Downes, Divisional Officer, Derbyshire Special Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Ray Downey. For charitable services to Sunderland Kidney Patient Group.
* John Ernest Drake, lately Chief Executive, YMCA Norfolk. For services to Young People.
* Alan Gordon Drinkall. For services to the community In North Yorkshire.
* Councillor Elizabeth Ann Ducker, Leader, South Oxfordshire District Council. For services to Local Government.
* David John Duke, Principal Technician, Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge. For services to Science.
* Karen, Mrs. Duncan, Senior Executive Officer, Student Finance Policy, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.
* William Duncan. For services to Horticulture in Scotland.
* Miss Elizabeth Dunlop. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Scotland.
* Terrance Dunne. For voluntary service to St. Andrew's Hospice, Airdrie, Lanarkshire.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Dupres. For services to St. Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Egham, Surrey.
* Sheila, Mrs. Eaglefield. For charitable services in Derbyshire.
* Eric James Eames. For services to the community in Birmingham.
* Ewan Easton. For voluntary service to H.M. Young Offenders' Institution, Thorn Cross, Warrington, Cheshire.
* The Reverend Mark Antony Edwards. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the North East.
* Gillian, Mrs. Elkins. For services to the community in Clacton\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Miss Susan Ellis, lately Principal Officer, South East Area, National Offender Management Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Miss Cathryn Ellsmore, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence. Dr. John Richard England. For services to Retail Planning.
* Eileen, Mrs. Entwistle. For services to Local Government and to the community in Darwen and Blackburn, Lancashire.
* Geraint Evans. For voluntary service to Education in the Vale of Glamorgan.
* Sheila, Mrs. Evans, lately Administrative Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Thomas Eurfyl Evans, Councillor, Ceredigion County Council. For services to Local Government in West Wales.
* [Timothy Everest](/wiki/Timothy_Everest "Timothy Everest"), Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Margaret, Mrs. Fairbrother, Senior Probation Officer, Sussex Probation Area. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Kelly, Mrs. Fairman. For services to the Fire and Rescue Service.
* Donald Fava, lately Business and Performance Reporting Manager, Finance and Operations Directorate, Department of Health.
* Janis Elizabeth, Mrs. Feely, Founder and Project Director, Living Room, Stevenage, Hertfordshire. For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Ms Ann Ferguson. For services to Older People in Scotland.
* Ms Margaret Hilary Ferriman, Chair, Banbury District Racial Equality Council. For services to Community Relations.
* Ms Deirdre Figueiredo, Director of Craftspace. For services to the Visual Arts in the West Midlands.
* Lyndon Filer, Chief Executive, Police Rehabilitation Centre, Goring\-on\-Thames. For services to the Police.
* Michael Peter Findley. For charitable services in Redcar, Cleveland.
* Dr. Doreen Elizabeth Finneron. For services to Inter\-Faith Relations.
* Peggy Rita, Mrs. Finnie. For services to the community in Aberdeen.
* Peter James Fisher, Policy Adviser, Office of the Judge Advocate\-General, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Honor Wilson\-Fletcher, lately Director, National Year of Reading. For services to Education.
* Anthony Fowler. For services to the community in Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire.
* Dereck Fowles, lately Chairman, Forth Valley and Lomond Local Action Group. For services to Rural Communities in Scotland.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Fox. For voluntary service to Deeside Community Hospital League of Friends, North Wales.
* Jennifer Lesley, Mrs. Foxon, Senior Technician, Department of Genetics, University of Leicester. For services to Science.
* David Victor Freeborn. For services to the Patterdale Mountain Rescue Team in the Lake District.
* Peter French, Deputy Chairman, London Board of Crimestoppers. For services to the Police.
* Timothy Enis French. For services to the community in Haywards Heath, West Sussex.
* Pino Frumiento, Singer and Songwriter, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.
* Dr. Ian David Robert Fry, Director, Partnership Pathology, Frimley Park Hospital NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare in the South East.
* Michael Fuller. For services to the NHS and to the Unite Trade Union in Scotland.
* Richard Gagan, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Irene Lorraine, Mrs. Galloway, lately Caseworker, Customer Operation, Lisburn, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Sarah Elizabeth, Mrs. Gamble. For services to the community in County Antrim.
* Stuart Mitchell Gay, J.P. For services to the community in Lancashire and Overseas.
* Mary Helen, Mrs. George, Catering Supervisor, Crossroads Primary School, Keith. For services to Education.
* Asquith Gibbes. For voluntary service to the Police in South East London.
* Henry Atherton Derek Gibson. For services to the community in Bridgwater, Somerset.
* Mary, Mrs. Gibson. For services to Education and to the community in North London.
* Robert Stewart Gibson, Officer, H.M. Prison Gartree, Leicestershire, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Margaret Helen, Mrs. Gilbert. For services to Older People in County Tyrone.
* Atma Singh Gill. For services to the community in the North East.
* Joy, Mrs. Gillies. For voluntary service to the Children's Panel in Scotland.
* Bernard John Godding. For voluntary service to Adult Learning and the Educational Centres Association.
* Alan John Godfrey, Publisher of Historic Ordnance Survey Maps. For services to Heritage.
* Professor [Michael Goodfellow](/wiki/Michael_Goodfellow "Michael Goodfellow"), Chairman of Governors, Gosforth High School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For voluntary service to Education.
* Sheila, Mrs. Gow. For services to Regional Journalism.
* Ms Agnes Graham. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Western Scotland.
* Dr. Maria Jadwiga Dlugolecka\-Graham. For services to Polish\-Scottish Relations and to Medicine.
* Robert Oliver David Graham, lately Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Barbara, Mrs. Grant, Clinical Nurse Manager, NHS Fife. For services to Ophthalmology.
* [Clemency Anne Rose, Mrs. Gray](/wiki/Rose_Gray "Rose Gray"), Co\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* William Gray. For services to Diversity and to Disability Training in Scotland.
* Angela Margaret, Mrs. Green. For charitable services Overseas and in Malvern, Worcestershire.
* Charles Anthony Green. For voluntary service to Industrial Heritage in the Staffordshire Potteries.
* Susan, Mrs. Greenwood, Specialist Community Public Health Nurse, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly. For services to Healthcare.
* David Grey, Group Managing Director, OSL Group Holdings Ltd. For services to Business and to Regeneration in Sheffield.
* Pauline, Mrs. Grice, Chief Executive, South Yorkshire Community Foundation. For services to Flood Relief.
* Joan, Mrs. Griffiths. For services to People with Learning Disabilities in Scotland.
* Mary Beatrice, Mrs. Guest. For services to People with Sensory Impairment.
* Mavis Ann, Mrs. Gunning. For voluntary service to Victims of Sexual Assault.
* Gordon William Guthrie. For services to Derby County Football Club.
* Ms Anna\-Marie Hale (Mrs. Byrne), Matron, Division One Trauma and Orthopaedics, Selly Oak Hospital, Birmingham. For services to Healthcare.
* Colonel Alan Edmund Hall, T.D., D.L. For services to the community in the London Borough of Redbridge.
* Iain Murray Halliday. For services to the Arts in Perth.
* David Halpin. For services to disabled people in the North West.
* Pauline Jane, Mrs. Handy, Clinical Lead Nurse, Genito\-Urinary Medicine, Newcastle General Hospital. For services to Healthcare.
* Frank Hannah, President, Manchester County Football Association. For services to Sport.
* Ms Belinda Harding, Constable, City of London Police. For services to the Police.
* Gillian Carol, Mrs. Hardy, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* [Terence Harris](/wiki/Jet_Harris "Jet Harris"). For services to Music.
* Ms Karen Harrison, Head, Business Crime Preventions Team, Wakefield Partnership. For services to the Police.
* Peter Brantford Hartland. For services to the community in Ashton Keynes, Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Colin Hartley. For services to the community in Halifax, West Yorkshire.
* Faith Ingrid Evelyn, Mrs. Harvey. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire.
* Ms Susan Harvey. For services to Orienteering and to the community in Doune and Deanston, Perth and Kinross.
* Margaret Lynne, Mrs. Harwood, Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Margaret Vine, Mrs. Haugh, Adviser for Creative and Expressive Studies, Southern Education and Library Board. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Jean, Mrs. Hayley. Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.
* Rodney James Hayley, Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.
* Lewis Charles Haywood. For services to the Energy Learning Centre, Elliot Durham School, Nottingham.
* Professor John William Stanley Hearle. For services to Archaeology in Mellor, Stockport, Greater Manchester.
* Jean, Mrs. Heath. For services to Chadlington Primary School, Oxfordshire.
* Roberta, Mrs. Heavens. For services to the Tourism Industry.
* Jean Marion Anne, Mrs. Hedley. For voluntary service to Nature Conservation in Hampshire and the Isle of Wight.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Heeley. For voluntary service to Somerset Rural Life Museum.
* Ms [Anna Hemmings](/wiki/Anna_Hemmings "Anna Hemmings"), Canoeist. For services to Sport.
* John Graham Hemmings, Chairman, Blurton Ladsandads, Stoke\-on\-Trent. For services to Grass Roots Football.
* John Patrick Hennigan, Superintendent, British Transport Police. For services to the Police.
* Miss Sylvia Jean Herbert, Chaplain, H.M. Prison Leicester. For services to Prisoners.
* John Coleman Hick, Vice\-President, British Holiday and Home Parks Association. For services to the Tourist Industry.
* Major Antony Stanley Hill. For services to Military Heritage in Essex.
* Lyn Joy, Mrs. Hill, Band 5, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Richard Wendle Hill, Branch Manager, Ulster Bank. For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* Margaret, Mrs. Hillman. For services to Girlguiding Cymru and to the Community of Hope.
* Christopher Hilton, lately General Manager, Odeon Leicester Square Cinema. For services to the Film Industry.
* Barry Hitchcock, Director of Sport, University of Surrey. For services to Sport and to Higher Education.
* Raymond Hodgkinson, Director\-General, British Healthcare Trades Association. For services to the Healthcare Industry.
* Linda Mary, Mrs. Hoggarth. For services to disabled people in Suffolk.
* Ms Jean Florence Holder. For voluntary service to the Women's Library.
* Miss Rhiannon Sarah Holder. For services to Young People's Healthcare.
* Valerie Lois, Mrs. Holt. For services to Fisheries Management and to Conservation.
* Lady Lavinia Caroline Douglas\-Home, D.L. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross and Macmillan Cancer Support in the Scottish Borders.
* Michael John Hopper, lately Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Douglas Horrill. For voluntary service to Age Concern, New Forest East, Hampshire.
* Doreen Grace, Mrs. Hosey. For services to the community in Fawley, Southampton.
* Ms Rebecca Ann Hosking. For services to the Environment in Modbury, Dorset.
* Donna Maria, Mrs. Hough, Dental Workforce Development Lead for Dental Care Professionals, North Western and Mersey Postgraduate Deaneries. For services to Healthcare.
* Edward Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.
* Winifred, Mrs. Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.
* Ms Sheila Hudson. For services to Disadvantaged Young People in Hartlepool.
* Joe Human. For services to Oxfam and to Fair Trade in Cumbria.
* Brenda, Mrs. Hunt. For services to Older People in East Manchester.
* Carl Peter Hunt, Watch Manager, Humberside Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.
* Alderman Edna, Lady Hunter. For services to the community in County Durham.
* The Reverend Canon Michael Oram Hunter. For services to the Church of England and to the community in Grimsby.
* Professor John Margarson Huthnance, Deputy Director, Proudman Oceanographic Laboratory. For services to Marine Science.
* Dr. Thomas George Hyde. For services to the community in Repton, Derbyshire.
* Brian Ibell, lately Assistant Chief Executive, Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Andrew Ingram, Executive Officer, Output Services Group, Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, Swansea, Department for Transport.
* Peter David John Ingram. For services to Paper Making Industrial Heritage.
* James John Jack. For services to Children and Young People at Kibble Education and Care Centre.
* Mona, Mrs. Jack. For services to the community in Dumfries.
* Florence, Mrs. Jackson. For voluntary service to Hatton Hill Primary School, Sefton, Merseyside.
* Valerie, Mrs. Jackson, Founder and Principal, Stage 84\. For services to the Performing Arts in the North.
* Valerie Hazel, Mrs. Jackson. For services to the community in Newcastle Emlyn, Carmarthenshire.
* [John Alexander Jameson](/wiki/John_Jameson_%28cricketer%29 "John Jameson (cricketer)"). For services to cricket.
* Waltraud Anna Luise, Mrs. Jarrold. For services to the community in Norwich.
* Susan Kay, Mrs. Jay, Area Manager, West Suffolk MIND. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Helen Adair, Mrs. Jenkins. For services to the community in Durrington, Wiltshire.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Jenkins, Senior Case Adviser, Freedom of Information Team, H.M. Treasury.
* Sidney Johnson. For services to the community in Helston, Cornwall.
* John Johnstone, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Henry Jones, Project Manager, ISIS Second Target Station, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Oxfordshire. For services to Science.
* Jane Eryl, Mrs. Jones, lately Senior Nurse, Eryri Hospital, Caernarfon. For services to Healthcare for Older People.
* Penelope, Mrs. Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.
* Ronald Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.
* Charles Ernest Jukes. For services to the community in Dursley, Gloucestershire.
* Ms Maureen Kavanagh, Messenger, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Kay, Co\-Founder and Project Leader, Bolton University of the Third Age. For voluntary service to Adult Education.
* Bernard John Keay, Chairman, Health and Social Security Recreational Association, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Virginia Anne Pickering, Mrs. Keen. For services to the community in Wiltshire.
* Victor Walter Keene. For services to the community in Coventry.
* William Ernest James Kelley. For voluntary service to the RAF Halton Apprentices' Association.
* Patricia Alexandra, Mrs. Kelly. Foster Carer, Cornwall. For services to Children and Families.
* Graham Kennedy. For charitable services to People with [Friedreich's ataxia](/wiki/Friedreich%27s_ataxia "Friedreich's ataxia").
* Miss Linda Margaret Kennedy, Manager, Banqueting House, Whitehall. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Anne, Mrs. Kenyon, Administrative Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Hilary, Mrs. Kerr. For services to Children and Young People with Special Needs in Warrington, Cheshire.
* Dr. David John Kerridge, Head of Science, Earth Hazards and Earth Systems Science, British Geological Survey. For services to Geophysics.
* Ms Imtaz Khaliq, Designer and Master Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Ms Shahda Khan, Principal Community Cohesion Officer, Middlesbrough Council. For services to Local Government and to Diversity.
* Ms [Catherine Isabel Audrey Kidston](/wiki/Cath_Kidston "Cath Kidston"), Founder and Creative Director, Cath Kidston. For services to Business.
* Patrick Kieran, Senior Design Engineer. For services to Science.
* Anne Elizabeth, Mrs. King, Director, Building Services Research and Information Association. For services to Industry.
* Debra Ann, Mrs. King, Chair, Thornhill New Deal for Communities. For services to the community in Southampton, Hampshire.
* Jacqueline, Mrs. Upton\-King, Chair, Management Team, SturQuest Community Partnership. For services to the community in Sturminster Newton, Dorset.
* Brenda Patricia, Mrs. Kirby. For services to the community in Croydon.
* Ms Marjorie Kirk. For voluntary service to H.M. Prison Nottingham.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Kirkwood. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northern Ireland.
* Ms Anna Kucewicz (Mrs. Lee\-Potter). For voluntary service to the Polish Scouting Association, Girl Scouts Division (UK).
* Paul Lambert, Chairman, Derbyshire Family Association. For services to Maritime Safety.
* John Lewis George Lamotte. For voluntary service to Animal Welfare in Scotland.
* Gabriel Lancaster. For services to the community in Medway, Kent.
* Miss Irene Langlands. For services to Dance in Central Scotland.
* Huw John Launder, Senior Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Derek Law, Corporate Director, Adult and Community Services, North Yorkshire County Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ronald Lawrence. For services to the Police and to the community in Nottinghamshire.
* Miss Kathleen Lawrenson, Diagnostic Audiologist, St. Helens and Knowsley Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Sheila Irene, Mrs. Layton, Founder, Contessa Riding Centre, Hertfordshire. For services to Equestrian Sport.
* Margaret, Mrs. Lee, Chief Executive, Cresco Trust. For services to Social Enterprise in Northern Ireland.
* Bryan Lewin, lately Head of Trading Standards, Northamptonshire County Council. For services to Consumers and to Business.
* Miss Judith Anne Lewis. For services to the Environment in the North East.
* Councillor Leonard Lewis. For services to Local Government and to the community in Caerphilly, South Wales.
* Neil Lewis. For services to Industrial Heritage and to the community in Blaenavon, Torfaen.
* David Robin Littlewood. For voluntary service to Athletics.
* Dr. Stephen Nicholas Liversedge, General Medical Practitioner, Bolton. For services to Healthcare.
* Wesley Courtney Livingstone, President, Newry Musical and Orchestral Society. For services to Music and to the community in County Down.
* Mary Constance, Mrs. Lloyd. For services to the community in Rutland.
* Pauline, Mrs. Lockett. For services to the community of Ackworth, West Yorkshire.
* Arthur Clifford Lockyear. For services to the community in Sunderland.
* Ian Douglas Loe, Wildlife Stamp Designer. For services to Art.
* Jeffrey Long. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion.
* Ronald Hedley Longford, Chiropractor and Physiotherapist. For services to Animal Welfare.
* Carmel, Mrs. Lyddall, Executive Assistant, Local Government and Regional Policy Team, Department of Health.
* Alexander McKay Lynch. Group Finance Director, David MacBrayne Ltd, Gourock. For services to Transport and Charity in Scotland.
* Ms Ann MacKay, Policy Adviser, English Community Care Association. For services to Social Care.
* Professor [Margaret MacLean](/wiki/Margaret_MacLean "Margaret MacLean"), Professor of Pulmonary Pharmacology. For services to Science.
* Geraldine, Mrs. MacPhee, Principal Teacher in Home Economics, Clyde Valley High School. For services to Education and to the community in North Lanarkshire.
* Sydney Mair. For services to Local Government and to the community in Macduff, Aberdeenshire.
* Jean Isabella, Mrs. Malkin. For services to Young People in the Cartmel Peninsula, Cumbria.
* Edna, Mrs. March. For services to the community in Crook, County Durham.
* Kenneth Marsh, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.
* Michael Thomas Martin. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Reading, Berkshire.
* Stuart Andrew Martin. For services to the community in Ripon, North Yorkshire.
* William Martin, Chairman, H. and J. Martin Ltd. For services to the Construction Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Philip Mason. For services to disabled people in Hampshire.
* Ms Valerie Mason (Mrs. Hendry). For services to the British Heart Foundation.
* Hilary, Mrs. Massarella. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged Young People in South Yorkshire.
* George Lewis Mathias. For services to Agriculture.
* [Catriona, Mrs. Matthew](/wiki/Catriona_Matthew "Catriona Matthew"). For services to Golf.
* Edwin Alexander Maxwell. For services to the New Art Exchange and to the community in Nottingham.
* Denise Jane, Mrs. May, Director of Sport and Assistant Headteacher, Budehaven Community School, Cornwall. For services to Education.
* Leslie Holden McAdoo, Chairman, Ballyclare Committee, Macmillan Cancer Support. For charitable services in Northern Ireland.
* Margaret Mary, Mrs. McCluskie, Manager, Major Investigation Team, Identity and Passport Service, Home Office.
* William McCrory. For services to Children with Cancer in Northern Ireland.
* Helen Muir, Mrs. McDonald. For services to the community in Crieff, Perthshire.
* Ken McElroy. For services to the Tourist Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Jean, Mrs. McEwen. For services to the community in Norwich.
* Peter McFall, Janitor, St. Peter 's Primary School, Dumbarton, West Dunbartonshire. For services to Education.
* Dr. David Douglas Murray McGavin, Ophthalmologist. For services to Eye Care in Developing Countries.
* Andrew Fraser McKay, Detective Superintendent, Strathclyde Police Force. For services to the Police.
* Ms Annie McKean, Senior Lecturer in Drama, University of Winchester. For services to Higher Education.
* Fiona Mary, Mrs. McLean, Grade C2, Ministry of Defence.
* Terrence McLernon. For services to Table Tennis and to the community in Drumchapel, Glasgow.
* Ms Melanie Justine McLoughlin. For services to the Devon Community Foundation.
* Ivan Lewis McMichael. For services to Journalism in Northern Ireland.
* Dr. Mary Brigeen McNee, General Medical Practitioner, Glasgow. For voluntary service to Cancer Research and to Healthcare in Lourdes.
* Alexander Ian McNeill, Administration Officer, Customer Operations, Thornaby, Cleveland, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Marian, Mrs. McNeir. For services to the community In Bath.
* Marjory, Mrs. McQueen. For services to the community In Lockerbie, Dumfries and Galloway.
* Dr. Noel Henri Joseph Meeke. For voluntary service to Herefordshire Waterworks Museum.
* David Melrose, Chairman, Scottish Prison Officers' Association, Scottish Executive.
* Jean, Mrs. Messenger. For services to the After School Club, Bude, Cornwall.
* Faruk Miah, Programme Manager, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education and to the community in Leeds.
* Moira Sheelagh, Mrs. Michelmore. For services to the community in Sidmouth, Devon.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Milburn, Chair, West Suffolk College Corporation. For services to Further Education and to the community in Suffolk.
* [Frederick Roy Millar](/wiki/Roy_Millar "Roy Millar"), Director of Coaching, Irish Football Association. For services to Youth Football in Northern Ireland.
* Ian Duncan Millar. For services to Agriculture in Scotland.
* Patrick Millard. For services to the charity Taxhelp for Older People.
* Katherine, Mrs. Miller, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Marcia Anne, Mrs. Miller. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross Society in Cambridgeshire.
* Gerald David Mills. For services to School Sport in Nottinghamshire.
* Laura, Mrs. Mitchell, Consultant Orthodontist and Clinical Lead, St Luke's Hospital Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Nasrullah Khan Moghal. For services to Community Relations in Manchester.
* Michael Monaghan. For charitable services to Ex\- Service Men and Women.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Montgomery. For charitable services in Northern Ireland and Overseas.
* Roger Ivan Moore. For services to the community in Potters Bar, Hertfordshire.
* Christopher Morgan, Security Manager, Aberafan Shopping Centre. For services to the community in Neath Port Talbot.
* Daphne, Mrs. Morgan. For voluntary service to Hertfordshire Constabulary and to Feltham Young Offenders' Institution.
* John Francis Morgan. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Newcastle, County Down.
* Alderman Peter James Morgan. For services to the community in Sittingbourne, Kent.
* Heather Dalton, Mrs. Morris, School Crossing Warden, Sale, Cheshire. For services to Education.
* Helen Elizabeth, Mrs. Morris. Crown Advocate, Merseyside and Cheshire Group, Crown Prosecution Service.
* John Harold Morris. For services to the Post Office.
* Thomas Geraint Morris. For services to the NHS and to the community in Dersingham, Norfolk.
* Nigel Peter Morse, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Keith Hedley Moss, President, Bradford Cricket League and Pudsey St. Lawrence Cricket Club. For voluntary service to Sport.
* Maureen Anne, Mrs. Muckle, Chair, Batchley First School, Redditch. For services to Education and to the community in North Worcestershire.
* [Maurice Harrison Murphy](/wiki/Maurice_Murphy_%28musician%29 "Maurice Murphy (musician)"). Trumpeter. For services to Music.
* Janice Elizabeth, Mrs. Naylor. For services to Swimming.
* Peter David Needham, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.
* Terence Charles Nelson, Security Officer, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education.
* Harold Newman. For services to the community in Mill Hill, London.
* Gilda, Mrs. Newsham. For voluntary service to the Alzheimer's Society, New Forest, Hampshire.
* Fionnuala Eileen, Mrs. Newton, Executive Administrative Assistant, Queen's University Belfast. For services to Higher Education.
* Vicky, Mrs. Norman, Senior Executive Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Sheila Maureen, Mrs. O'Neill. For services to Music in Ackworth, West Yorkshire.
* Valerie Ann, Mrs. O'Riordan. For services to the community in Berkshire.
* Barbara, Mrs. Oakes, Manager, High Street Library. For services to Local Government in Bolton.
* Marjorie Frances, Mrs. Oaten. For voluntary service to People with Eating Disorders.
* Margaret May, Mrs. Oatey. For services to the community in East Anglia.
* Stella, Mrs. Okeahialam, Programme Director, Croydon Enterprise. For service to Business.
* Michael Joseph Rolfe Orbell. For services to the Scouts in Wimbledon and Merton, London.
* Noel George Ormrod, lately Chairman, Wallasey Arts Council. For services to the Arts in Merseyside.
* Alexander Orr, Craftsman, Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Scotland.
* Arnold Jenkin Owen. For services to the community in Blackmill, Bridgend and to Welsh International Brigaders.
* Margaret Mcalister, Mrs. Owen. For services to the community in Shrewsbury, Shropshire.
* Ms Margaret Paisley, College Manager, Elmwood College, Residence and Student Union. For services to Further Education in Fife.
* Margaret Frances Elizabeth, Mrs. Palmer. For public service.
* Ms Lydia Joy Parbury. For services to People with Special Needs and Disabilities.
* Dorothy Mary, Mrs. Parker, Community Support Worker, West Wirral Community Mental Health Team. For services to Healthcare.
* John Bywell Parker. For voluntary service to the Hadrian Trust in the North East.
* Ann Rosemary, Mrs. Parr, Community Care Development Manager, Age Concern, Woodley. For services to Older People in Berkshire.
* Rabindara Nath Pathak, Chairman of Governors, Featherstone High School, Ealing, London. For voluntary service to Education.
* Trevor James Patton, Principal Nursing Officer, Northern Ireland Prison Service.
* Margaret Elsie, Mrs. Perfect. For voluntary service to the Boys' Brigade in Watford, Hertfordshire.
* Alderman Fred Perry. For services to the community in Tipton, West Midlands.
* Joan, Mrs. Phillips. For voluntary service to the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester.
* [Roger Phillips](/wiki/Roger_Phillips_%28photographer%29 "Roger Phillips (photographer)"). For services to London Garden Squares.
* [Jean Catherine, Mrs. Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Pickering "Jean Pickering"). For services to Athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.
* Alice Kirsty, Lady Pilkington. For voluntary service to Willowbrook Hospice, St. Helens and Knowsley, Merseyside.
* Pauline, Mrs. Pilkington, Director, Children's Services, Walsall Council. For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Robert Michael Pittilo](/wiki/Mike_Pittilo "Mike Pittilo"), Principal and Vice\-Chancellor, Robert Gordon University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. Jaswant Kaur Jutley\-Plested, Manager, Sydenham Children's Centre, Bridgwater, Somerset. For services to Children.
* Peter Pocock. For services to Workplace First Aid Training.
* Miss Rashmi Amritlal Popat, Executive Officer, Work Welfare and Equality Group, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Ms Prudence Alexine Regina Porretta. For services to Community Cohesion and to the Tourist Industry in Coventry.
* Iain David Russell Prain, Vice\-Principal, Royal Blind School, Craigmillar Park, Edinburgh. For services to Education.
* [Stephen Prescott](/wiki/Steve_Prescott "Steve Prescott"). For services to Rugby League and to Charity.
* Gres, Mrs. Pritchard, Peripatetic Music Teacher, Ynys Mon. For services to Education.
* The Reverend Dr. Jean Prosser. For services to Conservation and to the community in Monmouthshire.
* Isabel, Mrs. Quinliven, Founder, Caring Canines. For services to Older People in Northern Ireland.
* Brenda, Mrs. Quinn, Service Manager, Recovery Services, Belfast Health and Social Care Trust. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Toaha Bashir Zulqarnain Qureshi. For services to Community Relations in Stockwell, South West London.
* Maureen, Mrs. Raine, Office Manager, English Language Teaching Unit, University of Leicester. For services to Higher Education.
* Dr. Kathleen Rankin. For voluntary service to the Living Linen Project in Northern Ireland.
* Mohamad Rashied, President, Caribbean Islamic Cultural Society. For services to Community Relations in London.
* Robert David Richard Ray. For services to Rugby Union and to Young People in Rugby, Warwickshire.
* Ms Janet Mary Reed, Senior Social Worker, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.
* Angela Mary, Mrs. Rees, Assistant Head, Debt Management and Banking, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Abdul Rehman. For services to the community in Derby.
* Miss Marion Reynolds. For services to Vulnerable Children in Northern Ireland.
* Alan Ribchester. For charitable services in the City of Durham.
* The Reverend James Manson Richards. For services to Children and Families.
* George Edmund Richardson, lately Chairman, Calderdale College and Chairman, Association of Colleges, Yorkshire and the Humber Region. For voluntary service to Further Education.
* Miss Rosalyn Elizabeth Richardson, lately Deputy Director of Health Informatics, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.
* [Andrew William Ritchie](/wiki/Andrew_Ritchie_%28Brompton%29 "Andrew Ritchie (Brompton)"), Technical Director, Brompton Bicycle Ltd. For services to Business and to International Trade.
* Christopher David Medwyn Roberts. For services to the community in Merseyside.
* Clarissa Elizabeth, Mrs. Roberts. For services to Older People in Stratford\-upon\-Avon, Warwickshire.
* Jean Sylvia, Mrs. Roberts, Ministerial Messenger, Department for Transport.
* Peter Adrian Roberts, Chairman, Association of Community Rail Partnerships. For services to Rural Transport.
* Angus John Robertson, Principal Fellow in Clinical Illustration, Leeds Dental Institute. For services to Healthcare.
* Matthew Robertson, Sergeant, Ministry of Defence Police.
* Norman Robertson, lately Curriculum Leader in Hospitality, Ayr College. For services to Further Education.
* Margaret, Mrs. Robinson. For services to the community in Trimdon, County Durham.
* The Reverend Father George Edward Robson, Chairman, North Huyton New Deal for Communities Board. For services to the community in Merseyside.
* Ms Jennifer Van Krieken Robson, Head of Minority Achievement Service, Kent County Council. For services to Education.
* Sheila Ruth, Mrs. Rodmell. For services to the community in Elvington, Kent.
* Ms Susan Rogers. For services to Trade Unions.
* [Ruth Lady Rogers of Riverside](/wiki/Ruth_Rogers "Ruth Rogers"), Chef and Co\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* William Andrew Taylor Roulston. For services to Equestrian Sport in Northern Ireland.
* Beryl Lillian, Mrs. Rowe. For services to the community in Lilley, Bedfordshire.
* Dr. Christopher Giles Rowland. For services to the Friends of the Oncology and Radiotherapy Centre, Exeter.
* John Rowlands, Economics Teacher, John Ruskin Sixth Form College, Croydon, London. For services to Education.
* Marion, Mrs. Roy, lately Headteacher, Auchenback Primary School, East Renfrewshire. For services to Education.
* Colonel John Anthony Nutter Read Royle. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northamptonshire.
* [Chrissie, Mrs. Rucker](/wiki/Chrissie_Rucker "Chrissie Rucker"), Founder and Creative Director, White Company. For services to the Retail Industry.
* Anthony Michael Hurst Rumsey, Collections Manager, National Monuments Record. For services to Photography.
* Annette, Mrs. Rushton, lately Matron, Severn Hospice, Shrewsbury. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. Andrew Oldrey Russell, lately Chairman, League of Friends, Edenbridge and District War Memorial Hospital. For services to Healthcare.
* Ezriel Salomon. For services to the community in Gateshead, Tyne and Wear.
* Ahmed Ali Sasso, Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For services to the Police.
* Mary Ann Landsborough, Mrs. Saunders. For services to the Diocese of Oxford and to the Church of England.
* Ms Susan Saunders, Co\-Ordinator, Disability Support Network, Home Office.
* Keith Savage. For voluntary service to the Air Training Corps in Rutland.
* Lynn, Mrs. Savill. For services to People with Epilepsy in Gravesend, Kent.
* Ms Cherryl Lynn Sawyer, Business and Development Director, Threshold Housing Link. For services to Homeless People in Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Callie, Mrs. Saxty, lately Head of Visitor Operations for Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, English Heritage. For services to Heritage.
* Nora Gladys Elsie, Mrs. Schneider. For services to the community in Newbury, Berkshire.
* Robert Sinclair Scott. For voluntary service to the community in County Armagh.
* The Reverend Christopher John Sears. For services to Disadvantaged People in Hastings, East Sussex.
* Dr. Claude Doumet Serhal, Special Assistant, British Museum. For services to Archaeology.
* Thomas Richard Sermon, Chairman, London Youth. For services to Young People.
* Terence Brian Shead. For services to the community in East Peckham, Kent.
* Alan William Sherriff. For services to the community in South Yorkshire.
* Ann, Mrs. Shreeve, Senior Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Jasvinder Singh Sidhu. For services to Social Housing.
* Phillip Edward Sillick, J.P. For services to the community in Gorseinon, Swansea.
* Benjamin David Simpson, J.P. For services to the community in Oxford.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Simpson. For services to the community in Moston, Manchester.
* [Lemn Sissay](/wiki/Lemn_Sissay "Lemn Sissay"), Poet and Performer. For services to Literature.
* John William Skinner, Director of Music, Haberdashers' Aske's Hatcham College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.
* Catherine, Mrs. Slow. For services to West Exmoor Federation of Schools, Devon.
* Alison Mary, Mrs. Smedley. For services to Inland Waterways.
* Amanda Jane, Mrs. Smith, Executive Assistant, Youth Task Force Strategy, Department for Children, Schools and Families.
* Dr. Angela Owen\-Smith. For services to Medicine and to the community in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire.
* Miss Charlotte Lilian Smith. For services to the community in Porthyrhyd, Carmarthenshire.
* Colin Smith, Retained Crew Manager, West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Smith, Vice\-Chair and Board Member, Colchester Institute. For voluntary service to Further and Higher Education.
* Ian Graham Smith. For services to the community in Ramsbury, Wiltshire.
* James Smith. For voluntary service to Youth Football in Glasgow.
* Eric Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Mary, Mrs. Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Dr. Richard Alfred Sparks, lately Consultant in Genito\-Urinary Medicine, Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust. For services to Medicine.
* Councillor Josephine Elizabeth Spencer. For services to the community in Christchurch, Dorset.
* Dr. Richard Anthony Spencer, Biology Subject Leader, SRC Bede Sixth Form, Billingham, Teesside. For services to Science Communication.
* Sally Louise, Mrs. Hughes\-Stanton, Executive Secretary, Prime Minister's Office.
* Roger Carlton Steele. For services to Young People in Sheffield.
* Cheryl, Mrs. Stevens, Principal Practitioner, Benefits and Credits, Preston, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Mary, Mrs. Stevens. For services to the community in Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Edward Craig Stevenson, lately Engineer of Medical Physics, University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare and to Charity.
* Karen, Mrs. Stock, Extended Schools Co\-ordinator, Shoeburyness and Chair of Governors, Shoeburyness High School, Essex. For services to Education.
* Rodney Ernest Stoddart. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Tayside.
* Eric Arthur Stott. For services to the community in the West Midlands.
* Janet, Mrs. Stoyel. For services to the Textile Industry.
* Miss Judith Anne Strange, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Councillor Phyllis Zaphne Stretton. For services to the community in Cannock, Staffordshire.
* Ivy Alberta, Mrs. Sturgeon, Personal Secretary, H.M. Prison Littlehey, Huntingdon, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Rozelle Elizabeth, Mrs. Sutherland. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence in Jersey.
* Roderick John Symonds. For services to the community in Reading, Berkshire.
* Ranjula, Mrs. Takodra. For services to the community in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire.
* Gwynneth Mary, Mrs. Tame. For services to Heritage and to the community of Dorchester\-on\-Thames in Oxfordshire.
* Susan, Mrs. Tamlyn. For services to Heritage in Suffolk.
* Miss [Samantha Claire Taylor](/wiki/Claire_Taylor "Claire Taylor"), Cricketer. For services to Sport.
* James Graham Taylor, Music Director, City of Glasgow Chorus. For services to Music.
* Josephine May, Mrs. Taylor. For services to the community in Plumpton Green, East Sussex.
* Mary, Mrs. Thirlwell. For voluntary service to Young People in Lanarkshire.
* Ms Melanie Anne Thody, Head of Outreach, Imperial College London. For services to Science Communication.
* Margaret Jean, Mrs. Thomas, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Bristol.
* Peter Thomas, lately Project Director Devonport, Interserve plc. For services to the Defence Industry.
* Jonathan Bryan Thornes. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the East Midlands.
* Gordon Owen Thornhill. For services to the community in Foston and Scropton, Derbyshire.
* Angus Tilston. For services to the Historical Film Industry in the North West.
* Thomas Todd. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Pamela, Mrs. Towning, Assistant Officer, Customer Contact, Shipley, West Yorkshire, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Maureen Ivy, Mrs. Townley. For charitable services in Southend\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Van Cuong Truong. For services to the Indo\-Chinese community in South East London.
* Evelyn Roberta, Mrs. Turkington. For voluntary service to The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Scheme in Northern Ireland.
* [Mary Josephine, Mrs. Turner](/wiki/Mary_Turner_%28trade_unionist%29 "Mary Turner (trade unionist)"), President, GMB. For services to Trade Unions.
* [Edward Jonathan Turpie](/wiki/Jonnie_Turpie "Jonnie Turpie"), Director, Maverick Television.
* Dr. Alan Manson Turtle. For voluntary service to the community in Richhill, County Armagh.
* Miss [Elizabeth Kimberley Tweddle](/wiki/Beth_Tweddle "Beth Tweddle"). For services to Gymnastics.
* John Christopher Tyzack, Chairman of Governors, Enborne Church of England Primary School and Willow Primary School, Newbury, Berkshire. For voluntary service to Education.
* Wendy Margaret, Mrs. Vaughan. For services to the community in South East Surrey.
* Ronald Derek Vaulter. For services to the community in South Devon.
* Christine, Mrs. Ruston\-Wadsworth, Superintendent, Warwickshire Police. For services to the Police.
* Julian Wadsworth. For services to Young People in Portsmouth.
* Janice Irene, Mrs. Walker, Officer, H.M. Prison Wormwood Scrubs, London, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Pamela, Mrs. Walker, Chair of Governors, Cambo First School, Morpeth, Northumberland. For voluntary service to Education.
* Gillian Karen, Mrs. Walnes (formerly Mrs. Bogush). For services to the Anne Frank Trust UK.
* Joan Patricia, Mrs. Warwick. For charitable services to Darent Valley Hospital, Dartford, Kent.
* Amir Waseem, Officer, Customer Contact, Brierley Hill, West Midlands, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Shirley Irene, Mrs. Watson. For services to the Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura Support Association.
* The Reverend Canon Michael John Wedgeworth, lately Chairman of Governors, Blackburn College. For voluntary service to Further Education and to the communityin Lancashire.
* Michael Edwin Weeding, Senior Officer, Customs and International, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* James Weir, Lecturer, Forth Valley College. For services to Further Education in Clackmannanshire.
* David Anthony Westcott, J.P. For services to the community in Essex.
* Audrey, Mrs. Wheeler. For voluntary service to Oxfam in St. Albans, Hertfordshire.
* Norman Edward Whereat. For services to the community in Cirencester, Gloucestershire.
* Hilary John White, Chairman of Governors, Willingdon Community School, Eastbourne, East Sussex. For voluntary service to Education.
* John Samuel Byard White, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Somerset.
* Nicholas Stephen Whitehouse. For services to the Building Industry.
* David Widdowson. For services to Young People with Learning Disabilities in Chesterfield, Derbyshire.
* Alan Bertram Wiggins. For services to the community in Clacton\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Philip Julian Wilde. For voluntary service to Young People in Lytham St Anne's, Lancashire.
* Dr. Henry Austin Will. For voluntary service to Ford Park Cemetery Trust in Plymouth, Devon.
* Doreen, Mrs. Willcocks. For services to Netball and to the community in Pinehurst, Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Paul Willgoss, Band 3, Chief Scientists' Advisory Group and Chairman, Disability Network, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Christopher Mark Williams, Director, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.
* David Michael Williams. For services to the community in Flintshire.
* Gwilym Alun Williams. For services to Sport for Young People in Wales.
* Professor Robert Joseph Paton Williams. For services to the community in North Oxford.
* Gerald Willmott, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.
* Albert Leslie Wills, Q.F.S.M. For services to the community in the West Midlands.
* Patrick Andrew John Wilson, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Sydney Wiltshire. For services to the community in Petersfield, Hampshire.
* Andrew Nicholas Wood, Manager and Head Coach, Ipswich Gymnastics Centre. For services to Sport.
* Maureen, Mrs. Woodcock, lately Non\-Executive Director, Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Agnes Brown Marchbank, Mrs. Wright. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Stewartry of Kirkcudbright.
* Clare Margaret, Mrs. Wright, Personal Assistant, Warwickshire College. For services to Further Education.
* Richard Kelsey Wright, Chief Executive Officer, Intertius Ltd. For services to the Manufacturing Industry.
* Beryl Joan, Mrs. Wyatt, Gardening Assistant, Writtle College, Chelmsford. For services to Higher Education.
* Claire Judith, Mrs. Wylot, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Councillor Yogan Mylvaganam Yoganathan. For services to Local Government and to Community Relations in North Surrey.
* Jeannie, Mrs. Young, For voluntary service to St. Richard's Hospice, Worcester.
* Pauline Margaret, Mrs. Young. For voluntary service to disabled people in Wales.
* Mavis, Mrs. Yuill, Classroom Assistant, Kilmartin Primary School, Argyll and Bute. For services to Education.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* [Christopher Barr](/wiki/Christopher_Barr "Christopher Barr") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Paul William Bellamy](/wiki/Paul_William_Bellamy "Paul William Bellamy") – lately Entrance Clearance Manager, British Embassy, Iran.
* [Steve Chandler](/wiki/Steve_Chandler "Steve Chandler") – lately Third Secretary, Counter\-Narcotics, UK Provincial Reconstruction Team, Lashkar Gah.
* [Jeanette Anne Coogan](/wiki/Jeanette_Coogan "Jeanette Coogan") – Manager, British Council English Training Centre, Al Azhar University in Cairo. For services to UK\-Egypt intercultural relations.
* [Rossalyn Demelza Crotty](/wiki/Rossalyn_Crotty "Rossalyn Crotty") – Vice\-Consul/Deputy Head, British Consulate, Málaga, Spain.
* [Dr. Margaret Cumberland](/wiki/Margaret_Cumberland "Margaret Cumberland") – Co\-ordinator, Community Health. For services to community health care in Mozambique.
* [Elyse Anne Dodgson](/wiki/Elyse_Dodgson "Elyse Dodgson") – Head, International Department, Royal Court Theatre, London. For services to international theatre, and to young writers overseas.
* [Dr. Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan](/wiki/Alexander_Charles_Weeks_Duncan "Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.
* [Eleanor Frances Duncan](/wiki/Eleanor_Duncan "Eleanor Duncan") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.
* [Michael Feeney](/wiki/Michael_Feeney%2C_MBE "Michael Feeney, MBE") – Founder, County Mayo Peace Park. For services to UK\-Ireland relations.
* [Anne Ferguson](/wiki/Anne_Ferguson_OBE "Anne Ferguson OBE") For services to older people in Scotland
* [Judith Anne Ferris](/wiki/Judith_Ferris "Judith Ferris") – lately President, Age Concern, Costa Blanca. For services to the British elderly community in Alicante, Spain.
* [Wendi Nixon Fiedler](/wiki/Wendi_Fiedler "Wendi Fiedler") – Founder and Manager, Panatel Production Company. For services to heritage conservation in Bermuda.
* [Norman Keith Goodall](/wiki/Norman_Goodall "Norman Goodall") – For charitable activities and services to the community in Tenerife, Spain.
* [Nicholas John Hancocks](/wiki/Nicholas_Hancocks "Nicholas Hancocks") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Peter Anthony Hibbard](/wiki/Peter_Hibbard "Peter Hibbard") – President, Royal Asiatic Society. For services to heritage conservation in Shanghai, China.
* [Garry Horlacher](/wiki/Garry_Horlacher "Garry Horlacher") – Security Co\-ordinator and Adviser to the Government of Sierra Leone. For services to international policing, and promoting democracy in Sierra Leone.
* [Victor Malvern Jackopson](/wiki/Victor_Jackopson "Victor Jackopson") – Founder and Head, Hope Now. For charitable activities, and services to orphans and other young people in Cherkassy, Ukraine.
* [Renee Jacqueline Jordan](/wiki/Renee_Jordan "Renee Jordan") – Head of Registry, British Embassy Office, Basra.
* [Mairwen Karydis](/wiki/Mairwen_Karydis "Mairwen Karydis") – British Consular Correspondent, Lesvos. For services to consular work in Greece.
* [Nigel Jeffery Randle Kay](/wiki/Nigel_Kay "Nigel Kay") – Founder and Head, Homes in Zimbabwe. For services to the elderly in Zimbabwe.
* [Christopher Kealey](/wiki/Christopher_Kealey "Christopher Kealey") – lately First Secretary Political, British Embassy, Afghanistan.
* [Paul Lawrence](/wiki/Paul_David_Lawrence "Paul David Lawrence") – lately British Vice Consul, Thailand.
* [Cynthia Albrecht\-Lelliott](/wiki/Cynthia_Albrecht-Lelliott "Cynthia Albrecht-Lelliott") – Honorary Vice\-President, British Ladies Club. For services to the British community in Luxembourg and UK\-Luxembourg relations.
* [Dr. Raymond George\-MacKay](/wiki/Raymond_George-MacKay "Raymond George-MacKay") – Educational Consultant. For services to English teaching, especially in West Bengal, India.
* Bryan Andrew Morgan – Second Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Hazel Jane Nelder](/wiki/Hazel_Nelder "Hazel Nelder") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Anthony John Nott](/wiki/Anthony_Nott "Anthony Nott") – UK Policing Adviser, Office of the United States Co\-ordinator, Palestine. For services to international policing, more recently in Iraq and Palestine.
* [Jean Catherine Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Desforges "Jean Desforges") – For services to athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.
* [Stephen Peter John Schembri](/wiki/Stephen_Schembri "Stephen Schembri") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Joanna Wright\-Serra](/wiki/Joanna_Wright-Serra "Joanna Wright-Serra") – Founding member, JUCONI (Juntos con los Ninos—Together with Children). For services to street children and other charitable activities in Mexico.
* [Keith Shonfeld](/wiki/Keith_Nigel_Shonfeld "Keith Nigel Shonfeld") – Cemetery Administrator, British Cemetery Committee – For services to the British community in Cyprus.
* [Dr. Malcolm Swann](/wiki/Malcolm_Swann "Malcolm Swann") – Medical Director, [Beit Cure International Hospital](/wiki/CURE_International "CURE International"), Lusaka. For medical services in Zambia.
* [Peter Dyce Tear](/wiki/Peter_Tear "Peter Tear") – Executive Producer, 59E59 Theatres in New York. For services to UK/USA cultural relations.
* [David Richard Vaughan Thomas](/wiki/David_Richard_Vaughan_Thomas "David Richard Vaughan Thomas") – Chairman, British\-Polish Chamber of Commerce. For services to British business interests and charitable activities in Poland.
* [Iwona Thomas](/wiki/Iwona_Thomas "Iwona Thomas") – Founder and Manager, The British School, Warsaw. For services to education.
* [Sally Thompson](/wiki/Sally_Thompson "Sally Thompson") – Deputy Executive Director, Thailand\-Burma Border Consortium. For services to Burmese refugees in Thailand.
* [Kedell Melody Worboys](/wiki/Kedell_Worboys "Kedell Worboys") – St. Helena Government Representative in the UK. For services to St. Helena.
### Royal Red Cross
#### Royal Red Cross (Second Class)
Army
* Major John Clark
### Queen's Police Medal (QPM)
England and Wales
* Christopher Adams, Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary.
* Andrew Bliss, Deputy Chief Constable, Essex Police.
* David Keith Cook, Acting Detective Chief Inspector, West Midlands Police.
* Ms [Cressida Rose Dick](/wiki/Cressida_Dick "Cressida Dick"), Assistant Commissioner, Metropolitan Police Service.
* Robert Arthur Evans, Assistant Chief Constable, South Wales Police (Home Office Seconded).
* Michael Field, Detective Superintendent, British Transport Police.
* Kevin Trevor Flint, Detective Superintendent, Nottinghamshire Police.
* Christopher David Lee, Deputy Chief Constable, Dorset Police.
* Paul O'Connor, Inspector, Hertfordshire Police.
* Sir [Hugh Stephen Roden Orde](/wiki/Hugh_Orde "Hugh Orde"), O.B.E., President, Association of Chief Police Officers.
* Geoffrey William Owen, lately Constable, Metropolitan Police Service.
* Gary Richardson, Detective Superintendent, Metropolitan Police Service.
* Ms Susan Karen Sim, Deputy Chief Constable, Northumbria Police.
* Julie Anne, Mrs. Spence, O.B.E., Chief Constable, Cambridgeshire Police.
* Stephen John Thomas, Assistant Chief Constable, British Transport Police.
* Malcolm Philip Tillyer, lately Chief Superintendent, Metropolitan Police Service.
* Ms Wendy Ann Walker, Assistant Chief Constable, Lancashire Constabulary.
* David John Whatton, Chief Constable, Cheshire Police.
Scotland
* Ms Maureen Brown, lately Assistant Chief Constable, Central Scotland Police.
* Iain Clark Howie, Constable, Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary.
* Gordon Meldrum, Director General, Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency.
Northern Ireland
* Robert Lindsay Ellison, Sergeant, Police Service of Northern Ireland.
* Mark William James McDowell, Detective Chief Superintendent, Police Service of Northern Ireland.
* David Robert Adams McFall, Sergeant, Police Service of Northern Ireland.
### Queen's Volunteer Reserves Medal (QVRM)
Army
* Major Mark Brotherston
Royal Air Force
* Sergeant Terence Morton
|
[
"United Kingdom\n--------------",
"### Knights Bachelor",
"* [Professor Mansel Aylward, CB](/wiki/Mansel_Aylward \"Mansel Aylward\"), Chairman, Wales Centre for Health. For services to Healthcare.\n* [Paul John James Britton](/wiki/Paul_Britton \"Paul Britton\"), CB, lately Director\\-General and Head, Economic and Domestic Affairs Secretariat, Cabinet Office.\n* [Professor Robert George Burgess](/wiki/Robert_Burgess_%28sociologist%29 \"Robert Burgess (sociologist)\"), Vice\\-Chancellor, [University of Leicester](/wiki/University_of_Leicester \"University of Leicester\"). For services to local and national Higher Education.\n* [Professor John Burn](/wiki/John_Burn_%28geneticist%29 \"John Burn (geneticist)\"), Professor of Clinical Genetics, [Newcastle University](/wiki/Newcastle_University \"Newcastle University\"). For services to Medicine.\n* [Professor David Alan Chipperfield, CBE](/wiki/David_Chipperfield \"David Chipperfield\"), Architect and CEO, [David Chipperfield Architects](/wiki/David_Chipperfield_Architects \"David Chipperfield Architects\"). For services to architecture in the UK and Germany.\n* [Jonathan Stephen Cunliffe, CB](/wiki/Jon_Cunliffe \"Jon Cunliffe\"), Second Permanent Secretary and Head of International Economic Affairs, Europe and G8 Sherpa, Prime Minister's Office.\n* [Andrew Patrick Dillon, CBE](/wiki/Andrew_Dillon \"Andrew Dillon\"), Chief Executive, [National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence](/wiki/National_Institute_for_Health_and_Clinical_Excellence \"National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Ian David Grant, CBE](/wiki/Ian_David_Grant \"Ian David Grant\"), lately Chairman, The [Crown Estate](/wiki/Crown_Estate \"Crown Estate\").\n* [Professor John Stranger Holman](/wiki/John_Holman_%28chemist%29 \"John Holman (chemist)\"), National Director, Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Programme. For services to Education.\n* [Nicholas Hytner](/wiki/Nicholas_Hytner \"Nicholas Hytner\"), Director, [National Theatre](/wiki/Royal_National_Theatre \"Royal National Theatre\"). For services to Drama.\n* [Mark Ellis Powell Jones](/wiki/Mark_Jones_%28museum_director%29 \"Mark Jones (museum director)\"), Director, [Victoria and Albert Museum](/wiki/Victoria_and_Albert_Museum \"Victoria and Albert Museum\"). For services to the Arts.\n* [Dr. Ralph Kohn, FRS](/wiki/Ralph_Kohn \"Ralph Kohn\"). For services to Science, Music and to Charity.\n* [Richard Douglas Lapthorne, CBE](/wiki/Richard_Lapthorne \"Richard Lapthorne\"), Chairman, [Cable \\& Wireless plc](/wiki/Cable_%26_Wireless_plc \"Cable & Wireless plc\"). For services to telecommunications.\n* [Michael John Marshall](/wiki/Michael_John_Marshall \"Michael John Marshall\"), CBE, Chairman, [Marshall of Cambridge](/wiki/Marshall_of_Cambridge \"Marshall of Cambridge\") (Holdings) Ltd. For services to Business, Charity and to the community in Cambridgeshire.\n* [Ian Robert McGeechan, OBE](/wiki/Ian_McGeechan \"Ian McGeechan\"). For services to Rugby.\n* [Professor Paul Anthony Mellars, FBA](/wiki/Paul_Mellars \"Paul Mellars\"), Professor of Prehistory and Human Evolution, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge \"University of Cambridge\"). For services to Scholarship.\n* [Professor Salvador Moncada](/wiki/Salvador_Moncada \"Salvador Moncada\"), Director, Wolfson Institute of Biomedical Research, [University College London](/wiki/University_College_London \"University College London\"). For services to Science.\n* [Erich Arieh Reich](/wiki/Erich_Reich \"Erich Reich\"), Chairman, Kindertransport Group, [Association of Jewish Refugees](/wiki/Association_of_Jewish_Refugees \"Association of Jewish Refugees\"). For charitable services.\n* [Professor Michael Adrian Richards, CBE](/wiki/Michael_Adrian_Richards \"Michael Adrian Richards\"), National Cancer Director. For services to Medicine.\n* [His Honour Mota Singh](/wiki/Mota_Singh \"Mota Singh\"). For services to the Administration of Justice, Community Relations and to the Voluntary Sector.\n* [Patrick Stewart, OBE](/wiki/Patrick_Stewart \"Patrick Stewart\"), Actor. For services to Drama.\n* [Graham Robert Wynne](/wiki/Graham_Wynne \"Graham Wynne\"), CBE, Chief Executive, [Royal Society for the Protection of Birds](/wiki/Royal_Society_for_the_Protection_of_Birds \"Royal Society for the Protection of Birds\"). For services to Nature Conservation.",
"### Order of the Bath",
"#### Knights Commander of the Order of the Bath (KCB)",
"Military Division\n Army\n* [Lieutenant General William Raoul Rollo, CBE](/wiki/Bill_Rollo \"Bill Rollo\"), late The Blues and Royals (Royal Horse Guards and 1st Dragoons)\n* [Lieutenant General Alexander Richard David Shirreff, CBE](/wiki/Richard_Shirreff \"Richard Shirreff\"), late The King's Royal Hussars",
"Civil Division\n* [David Nicholson](/wiki/David_Nicholson_%28civil_servant%29 \"David Nicholson (civil servant)\") CBE",
"#### Companions of the Order of the Bath (CB)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* [The Venerable John Green, QHC](/wiki/John_Green_%28chaplain%29 \"John Green (chaplain)\")\n* [Rear Admiral Richard Derek Leaman, OBE](/wiki/Richard_Leaman \"Richard Leaman\")",
"Army\n* [Major General Simon Francis Neil Lalor, TD](/wiki/Simon_Lalor \"Simon Lalor\"), late The Honourable Artillery Company, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant General Simon Vincent Mayall](/wiki/Simon_Mayall \"Simon Mayall\"), late 1st The Queen's Dragoon Guards\n* [Lieutenant General Peter Thomas Clayton Pearson, CBE](/wiki/Peter_Pearson_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Peter Pearson (British Army officer)\"), late The Royal Gurkha Rifles",
"Royal Air Force\n* [The Reverend (Air Vice\\-Marshal) Peter Watson Mills](/wiki/Peter_Watson_Mills \"Peter Watson Mills\")",
"Civil Division\n* [Christopher Bolt](/wiki/Chris_Bolt \"Chris Bolt\"), Arbiter, London Underground Public Private Partnership Agreements and lately chairman, Office of Rail Regulation, Department for Transport\n* [Lawrence Conway](/wiki/Lawrence_Conway \"Lawrence Conway\"), lately Director, Department of the First Minister, Welsh Assembly Government\n* [Gloria Linda Craig](/wiki/Gloria_Craig \"Gloria Craig\"), director, International Security Policy, Ministry of Defence\n* [Elizabeth Anne Jackson](/wiki/Elizabeth_Anne_Jackson \"Elizabeth Anne Jackson\"), director, Child Wellbeing, Children and Families Directorate, Department for Children, Schools and Families\n* [Helen Kilpatrick](/wiki/Helen_Kilpatrick \"Helen Kilpatrick\"), Director\\-General, Financial and Commercial, Home Office\n* [William Francis Sebastian Rickett](/wiki/William_Francis_Sebastian_Rickett \"William Francis Sebastian Rickett\"), Director\\-General of Energy, Department for Energy and Climate Change.",
"### Order of Saint Michael and Saint George",
"#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of St. Michael and St. George (KCMG / DCMG)",
"Civil Division\n* [Dr. Fazle Hasan Abed](/wiki/Fazle_Hasan_Abed \"Fazle Hasan Abed\"), Founder and Chairman, [Building Resources Across Communities (BRAC)](/wiki/BRAC_%28organization%29 \"BRAC (organization)\"). For services to tackling poverty and empowering the poor in Bangladesh and more globally.\n* [Dr. Rosalind Mary Marsden, CMG](/wiki/Rosalind_Marsden \"Rosalind Marsden\"), [H.M. Ambassador, Sudan](/wiki/List_of_ambassadors_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Sudan \"List of ambassadors of the United Kingdom to Sudan\").\n* [Anne Fyfe Pringle, CMG](/wiki/Anne_Pringle \"Anne Pringle\"), [H.M. Ambassador, Russia](/wiki/List_of_ambassadors_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Russia \"List of ambassadors of the United Kingdom to Russia\").",
"#### Companions of the Order of St. Michael and St. George (CMG)",
"Military Division\n Army\n* Brigadier Stephen Frederick Sherry, OBE, late [Corps of Royal Engineers](/wiki/Corps_of_Royal_Engineers \"Corps of Royal Engineers\")",
"Civil Division\n* Timothy Michael Everton Dowse, lately Chief of Assessments Staff, [Joint Intelligence Organisation](/wiki/Joint_Intelligence_Organisation_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Joint Intelligence Organisation (United Kingdom)\"), [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office \"Cabinet Office\")\n* Dr. Silvia Suzen Giovanna Casale, lately Chairperson, UN Sub\\-Committee on the Prevention of Torture, Geneva. Lately Member, [European Committee for the Prevention of Torture](/wiki/European_Committee_for_the_Prevention_of_Torture \"European Committee for the Prevention of Torture\"), Strasbourg. For services to the prevention of torture, and prison reform\n* [Susan le Jeune d'Allegeershecque](/wiki/Susan_le_Jeune_d%27Allegeershecque \"Susan le Jeune d'Allegeershecque\"), Counsellor, [Foreign and Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_and_Commonwealth_Office \"Foreign and Commonwealth Office\")\n* [The Rt Hon. Terence Davis, PC](/wiki/Terry_Davis_%28politician%29 \"Terry Davis (politician)\"), lately [Secretary General, Council of Europe](/wiki/Secretary_General_of_the_Council_of_Europe \"Secretary General of the Council of Europe\"), Strasbourg. For services to institutional reform\n* [Charles Blandford Farr, OBE](/wiki/Charles_Farr_%28civil_servant%29 \"Charles Farr (civil servant)\"), Counsellor, Foreign and Commonwealth Office\n* [William Boyd McCleary, CVO](/wiki/William_Boyd_McCleary \"William Boyd McCleary\"), [British High Commissioner, Malaysia](/wiki/List_of_High_Commissioners_of_the_United_Kingdom_to_Malaysia \"List of High Commissioners of the United Kingdom to Malaysia\")\n* [Edward Mortimer](/wiki/Edward_Mortimer \"Edward Mortimer\"), Senior Vice\\-President and Chief Program Officer, The [Salzburg Global Seminar](/wiki/Salzburg_Global_Seminar \"Salzburg Global Seminar\"), Austria. For services to international communications and journalism\n* Hugh Powell, lately UK Senior Representative in Helmand, Afghanistan\n* Michael Peter Wareing, International CEO, [KPMG](/wiki/KPMG \"KPMG\"), and lately co\\-Chair, Basra Development Commission. For services to the [economic reconstruction](/wiki/Economic_reconstruction \"Economic reconstruction\") and redevelopment of Basra, and Iraq more generally",
"### Royal Victorian Order",
"#### Knights Commander of the Royal Victorian Order (KCVO)",
"* [The Right Reverend David John Conner](/wiki/David_Conner_%28bishop%29 \"David Conner (bishop)\") – Dean of Windsor\n* [William Arthur Bromley\\-Davenport](/wiki/William_Bromley-Davenport_%28Lord_Lieutenant%29 \"William Bromley-Davenport (Lord Lieutenant)\") – Lord\\-Lieutenant of Cheshire\n* [Angus Durie Miller Farquharson](/wiki/Angus_Durie_Miller_Farquharson \"Angus Durie Miller Farquharson\"), OBE, – Lord\\-Lieutenant of Aberdeenshire\n* [Robin Denys Gill](/wiki/Robin_Denys_Gill \"Robin Denys Gill\"), CVO – Chairman, The [Royal Anniversary Trust](/wiki/Royal_Anniversary_Trust \"Royal Anniversary Trust\")\n* [Peter Gwynn\\-Jones](/wiki/Peter_Gwynn-Jones \"Peter Gwynn-Jones\"), CVO – Garter Principal King of Arms",
"#### Commanders of the Royal Victorian Order (CVO)",
"* Gregory Scott Belton – Chairman, The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association\n* Robin Shedden Broadhurst, CBE – formerly Member of Council, Duchy of Cornwall\n* [Romayne Winifred, Lady Carswell](/wiki/Robert_Carswell%2C_Baron_Carswell \"Robert Carswell, Baron Carswell\"), OBE – formerly Lord\\-Lieutenant of the County Borough of Belfast\n* Alexander Pieter van Heeren, MBE – Chairman, The World Fellowship of The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association\n* [John Henry Pascoe, AO](/wiki/John_Pascoe \"John Pascoe\") – formerly Trustee, The Duke of Edinburgh's International Award Association",
"#### Lieutenants of the Royal Victorian Order (LVO)",
"* Major Charles Samuel Enderby – formerly Lieutenant, The Queen's Body Guard of the Yeomen of the Guard\n* Patrick Gregory Birch Harrison – Press Secretary, Household of The Prince of Wales and The Duchess of Cornwall\n* Charles Benedict Morris – Architectural Designer\n* Dr. [Kirsten Aschengreen Piacenti](/wiki/Kirsten_Aschengreen_Piacenti \"Kirsten Aschengreen Piacenti\") – for services to the Royal Collection (*Honorary*)\n* [Brigadier John Edward Bruce Smedley](/wiki/John_Smedley_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"John Smedley (British Army officer)\") – Private Secretary to The Earl and Countess of Wessex\n* Dr. [Anthony Douglas Toft](/wiki/Anthony_Douglas_Toft \"Anthony Douglas Toft\"), CBE – formerly Physician to The Queen in Scotland\n* Richard John Verrall – Aviation Consultant",
"#### Members of the Royal Victorian Order (MVO)",
"* David Anderson, MBE – formerly Hospitality Manager, Hillsborough Castle, Northern Ireland Office\n* Inspector Mark Peter Andrews – Metropolitan Police, for services to Royalty Protection\n* Catherine Carruthers – Membership Development Director, Business in the Community\n* Julian Charles George Clare, RVM – Drawings Conservator, Royal Collection\n* Kenneth Brendan Eccles – for services to the Police Service of Northern Ireland\n* Patricia Ann Lawrence – Personal Assistant to The Duke of Kent\n* Paul Alexander Miller – IT Projects and Business Manager\n* Roger Peter Smith – formerly Clerk of Works, Crown Estate, Windsor\n* Peter Charles Taylor – Fire Safety Manager, Windsor Castle\n* Christopher Robin Weatherley – Fire Safety Manager, Buckingham Palace\n* Andrew James Wilson, DL – Under Sheriff, The Bailiwick of Lancashire",
"### Royal Victorian Medal",
"#### Bar to the Royal Victorian Medal (Silver)",
"* Anthony John Hardingham, RVM – Tractor Driver, Sandringham Estate",
"#### Royal Victorian Medal (Silver)",
"* Glen Andrew Beveridge – Executive Butler, Government House, Melbourne\n* Patricia Joyce Earl – Housekeeper, Sandringham House\n* Constable Kevin Gande – Metropolitan Police, for services to Royalty Protection\n* Andrea Elizabeth Hudson – Cook, Royal Lodge\n* Beverley Jones – Assistant Dresser to The Queen\n* George David Main – Gamekeeper, Balmoral Estate\n* David James McIntosh – Security Office Team Leader, Palace of Holyroodhouse\n* Vivienne Oates – Linen Room Assistant, Buckingham Palace\n* Richard Sands – Yeoman Warder, HM Tower of London",
"### Order of the British Empire",
"#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE / DBE)",
"Civil Division\n* [Professor Valerie Beral](/wiki/Val_Beral \"Val Beral\"). For services to Science\n* [Dr. Claire Bertschinger](/wiki/Claire_Bertschinger \"Claire Bertschinger\"). For services to Nursing and to International Humanitarian Aid\n* [Councillor Ellen Margaret Eaton, OBE](/wiki/Ellen_Margaret_Eaton \"Ellen Margaret Eaton\"), Chair, Local Government Association. For services to Local Government\n* [Dr. Susan Elizabeth Ion, OBE](/wiki/Sue_Ion \"Sue Ion\"), Visiting Professor, Imperial College, London and Chair, UK Fusion Advisory Board. For services to Science and Engineering\n* [Clare Oriana Tickell](/wiki/Clare_Tickell \"Clare Tickell\"), Chief Executive, Action for Children. For services to Young People\n* [Marcia Twelftree](/wiki/Marcia_Twelftree \"Marcia Twelftree\"), lately Headteacher, Charters School, Windsor and Maidenhead, Berkshire. For services to local and national Education",
"#### Commanders of the Order of the British Empire (CBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* Commodore Stephen Redvers Kirby\n* Commodore Christopher Laurence Palmer",
"Army\n* Colonel Mark Cuthbert\\-Brown – late [Adjutant General's Corps](/wiki/Adjutant_General%27s_Corps \"Adjutant General's Corps\") ([Royal Military Police](/wiki/Royal_Military_Police \"Royal Military Police\"))\n* Colonel David James Eadie – late The [Queen's Royal Lancers](/wiki/Queen%27s_Royal_Lancers \"Queen's Royal Lancers\")\n* Colonel Christopher William Manning – late [Army Air Corps](/wiki/Army_Air_Corps_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Army Air Corps (United Kingdom)\")\n* Brigadier Simon John Marriner, MBE – late Adjutant General's Corps (Staff and Personnel Support Branch)\n* Colonel Michael Peter Macgregor Stewart, QHS – late [Royal Army Medical Corps](/wiki/Royal_Army_Medical_Corps \"Royal Army Medical Corps\")",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Air Commodore Clive Arthur Bairsto](/wiki/Clive_Bairsto \"Clive Bairsto\")\n* Group Captain Keith Ronald Dipper\n* Group Captain Alistair Monkman\n* [Group Captain Andrew Mark Turner, OBE](/wiki/Andrew_Turner_%28RAF_officer%29 \"Andrew Turner (RAF officer)\")",
"Civil Division\n* [James Christopher Armfield, OBE](/wiki/Jimmy_Armfield \"Jimmy Armfield\"). For services to the community in Lancashire.\n* [David Ogilvy Barrie](/wiki/David_Ogilvy_Barrie \"David Ogilvy Barrie\"), lately Director, [Art Fund](/wiki/Art_Fund \"Art Fund\"). For services to the Visual Arts.\n* Parmajit Paul Singh Bassi, DL, Chairman, Bond Wolfe. For services to Business and to the community in the West Midlands.\n* [William Robert Baxter](/wiki/William_Robert_Baxter \"William Robert Baxter\"), Deputy chief executive, Baxter Storey. For services to the Catering Industry.\n* Ann Beasley, Director of Finance and Performance, [National Offender Management Service](/wiki/National_Offender_Management_Service \"National Offender Management Service\"), Ministry of Justice.\n* Edward Farquharson Bowen, [Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders](/wiki/Sheriff_Principal_of_Lothian_and_Borders \"Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders\"). For services to the Administration of Justice in Scotland.\n* Councillor Peter Box, Leader, [Wakefield Metropolitan District Council](/wiki/Wakefield_Metropolitan_District_Council \"Wakefield Metropolitan District Council\") and chairman, [Yorkshire and Humber Assembly](/wiki/Yorkshire_and_Humber_Assembly \"Yorkshire and Humber Assembly\"). For services to Local Government.\n* [Professor Donal Donat Conor Bradley, FRS](/wiki/Donal_Bradley \"Donal Bradley\"), Lee\\-Lucas Professor of Experimental Physics and Deputy Principal, Faculty of Natural Sciences, [Imperial College London](/wiki/Imperial_College_London \"Imperial College London\"). For services to Science.\n* [Professor Alice Brown](/wiki/Alice_Brown_%28ombudsman%29 \"Alice Brown (ombudsman)\"), lately [Scottish Public Services Ombudsman](/wiki/Scottish_Public_Services_Ombudsman \"Scottish Public Services Ombudsman\"). For public service.\n* [Natalie Ceeney](/wiki/Natalie_Ceeney \"Natalie Ceeney\"), chief executive, National Archives, [Ministry of Justice](/wiki/Ministry_of_Justice \"Ministry of Justice\").\n* Lauran Margaret Chatburn, Principal and chief executive, [Bury College](/wiki/Bury_College \"Bury College\"). For services to Further Education.\n* Professor David Martin Chiddick, lately Vice\\-Chancellor, [University of Lincoln](/wiki/University_of_Lincoln \"University of Lincoln\"). For services to local and national Higher Education.\n* Lawrence Churchill, Chairman, [Pension Protection Fund](/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund \"Pension Protection Fund\"). For public service.\n* [Robert Brodie Clark](/wiki/Brodie_Clark \"Brodie Clark\"), Head of Border Force, [UK Border Agency](/wiki/UK_Border_Agency \"UK Border Agency\"), Home Office.\n* [Barry Michael Cockcroft](/wiki/Barry_Cockcroft_%28dentist%29 \"Barry Cockcroft (dentist)\"), [Chief Dental Officer](/wiki/Chief_Dental_Officer_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Chief Dental Officer (United Kingdom)\"), Department of Health.\n* Christopher Cohen, lately chairman, Athletics Sports Assembly Executive Committee, [International Paralympic Committee](/wiki/International_Paralympic_Committee \"International Paralympic Committee\"). For services to Sport.\n* [Sarah Patricia Connolly](/wiki/Sarah_Connolly \"Sarah Connolly\"), Opera Singer. For services to Classical Music.\n* Rodney Cousens, chief executive officer, [Codemasters](/wiki/Codemasters \"Codemasters\"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.\n* Dr. Michael John Cresswell, Director\\-General, [Assessment and Qualifications Alliance](/wiki/Assessment_and_Qualifications_Alliance \"Assessment and Qualifications Alliance\"). For services to Education.\n* Professor Ian Richard Crute, lately Director, [Rothamsted Research](/wiki/Rothamsted_Research \"Rothamsted Research\"). For services to Plant Science.\n* [His Honour Judge Keith Charles Cutler](/wiki/Keith_Cutler \"Keith Cutler\"), Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* [Dr. George Daniels, MBE](/wiki/George_Daniels_%28watchmaker%29 \"George Daniels (watchmaker)\"), Master Watchmaker. For services to Horology.\n* [Professor Janet Howard Darbyshire, OBE](/wiki/Janet_Darbyshire \"Janet Darbyshire\"), Director, Clinical Trials Unit, [Medical Research Council](/wiki/Medical_Research_Council_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Medical Research Council (United Kingdom)\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Helen Anne Dent, chief executive, [Family Action](/wiki/Family_Action \"Family Action\"). For services to Children and Families.\n* Graham Thomas Devlin. For services to the Arts.\n* Professor Carol Dezateux, Professor of Paediatric Epidemiology, [UCL Institute of Child Health](/wiki/UCL_Institute_of_Child_Health \"UCL Institute of Child Health\"). For services to Science.\n* Mary Elizabeth Dodd, lately Consultant Physiotherapist, Cystic Fibrosis, [South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust](/wiki/South_Manchester_University_Hospital_NHS_Trust \"South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Peter Donohoe](/wiki/Peter_Donohoe_%28pianist%29 \"Peter Donohoe (pianist)\"), pianist, for services to Classical Music.\n* Trudi Margaret Elliott, Regional Director, Government Office for the West Midlands, [Department for Communities and Local Government](/wiki/Department_for_Communities_and_Local_Government \"Department for Communities and Local Government\").\n* Margaret Fay, OBE. For services to the Regional Development Agency, [One North East](/wiki/One_NorthEast \"One NorthEast\").\n* [George Ferguson](/wiki/George_Ferguson_%28architect%29 \"George Ferguson (architect)\"). For services to Architecture and to the community in the South West.\n* [Professor Stephen John Field](/wiki/Steve_Field_%28medical_doctor%29 \"Steve Field (medical doctor)\"), Head of Workforce and Regional Postgraduate Dean, NHS West Midlands and Chairman of College Council, [Royal College of General Practitioners](/wiki/Royal_College_of_General_Practitioners \"Royal College of General Practitioners\"). For services to Medicine.\n* Christopher Mark Fisher, Director, Jobseekers and Skills, Employment Group, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions \"Department for Work and Pensions\").\n* [Professor Alastair Hugh Fitter, FRS](/wiki/Alastair_Fitter \"Alastair Fitter\"), Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor for Research, [University of York](/wiki/University_of_York \"University of York\"). For services to Environmental Science.\n* Brian Roy Fleet, MBE, Senior [Airbus UK](/wiki/Airbus_UK \"Airbus UK\") Vice\\-President. For services to the Aerospace Industry.\n* His Honour Judge David Robert Fletcher, Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice in Merseyside.\n* Winston Fletcher, lately chairman, Advertising Standards Board of Finance. For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Neil Raymond Flint, Deputy Director, New Academies Division, [Department for Children, Schools and Families](/wiki/Department_for_Children%2C_Schools_and_Families \"Department for Children, Schools and Families\").\n* [Helen Fraser](/wiki/Helen_Fraser_%28executive%29 \"Helen Fraser (executive)\"), lately managing director, [Penguin UK](/wiki/Penguin_UK \"Penguin UK\"). For services to the Publishing Industry.\n* Professor John Fyfe. For services to Partnership Working and to Regeneration Worldwide, particularly in West Cumbria.\n* David Goldstone. For public service.\n* Anthony Simonds\\-Gooding, Chairman, [D\\&AD](/wiki/D%26AD \"D&AD\"). For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Professor Sean Patrick Gorman, Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Life Sciences and Professor of Pharmaceutical Microbiology, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast \"Queen's University Belfast\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Lucian Charles Grainge](/wiki/Lucian_Grainge \"Lucian Grainge\"), Chairman and chief executive officer, [Universal Music Group International](/wiki/Universal_Music_Group_International \"Universal Music Group International\"). For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Robert Douglas Greig, chief executive, National Development Team for Inclusion. For services to People with Special Needs.\n* Bethan Haulwen Guilfoyle, Headteacher, [Treorchy Comprehensive School](/wiki/Treorchy_Comprehensive_School \"Treorchy Comprehensive School\"). For services to Education in Wales.\n* [Maggi Hambling, OBE](/wiki/Maggi_Hambling \"Maggi Hambling\"), Painter and Sculptor. For services to Art.\n* Ian Hardie, Deputy Director, Corporation Tax and VAT, Business Tax, [H.M. Revenue and Customs](/wiki/H.M._Revenue_and_Customs \"H.M. Revenue and Customs\").\n* Dr. Christopher Charles Harling, Director, [NHS Plus](/wiki/NHS_Plus \"NHS Plus\"). For services to Occupational Health.\n* Martin Harman. For services to International Trade and to the Legal Profession.\n* Dr. Colin Robert Harrison, Chairman, Chemistry Innovation Knowledge Transfer Network. For services to Technology.\n* [Emma Harrison](/wiki/Emma_Harrison_%28entrepreneur%29 \"Emma Harrison (entrepreneur)\"), Chair, [A4e](/wiki/A4e \"A4e\"). For services to Unemployed People and to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Frances Hartley, lately Headteacher, Deans Primary School, Salford. For services to Education.\n* Sally Lorinda Hobbs, HM Deputy Chief Inspector, [Crown Prosecution Service](/wiki/Crown_Prosecution_Service \"Crown Prosecution Service\") Inspectorate.\n* Peter Michael Holland, QFSM, Chief Fire Officer, [Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service](/wiki/Lancashire_Fire_and_Rescue_Service \"Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Timothy Stancliffe Hollis, QPM, Chief Constable, [Humberside Police](/wiki/Humberside_Police \"Humberside Police\"). For services to the Police.\n* [Helen Jackson](/wiki/Helen_Jackson_%28politician%29 \"Helen Jackson (politician)\"). For services to the Women and Pensions Network and to the community in South Yorkshire.\n* Dyfrig Dafydd Joseff John, lately Deputy chairman and chief executive, [HSBC Bank](/wiki/HSBC_Bank \"HSBC Bank\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* [Penny Johnson](/wiki/Penny_Johnson \"Penny Johnson\"), Director, Government Art Collection, [Department for Culture, Media and Sport](/wiki/Department_for_Culture%2C_Media_and_Sport \"Department for Culture, Media and Sport\").\n* Julie Jones, OBE, chief executive, [Social Care Institute for Excellence](/wiki/Social_Care_Institute_for_Excellence \"Social Care Institute for Excellence\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Robert Jones, lately chairman, Association of Police Authorities. For services to the Police.\n* Professor Peter Graham Edward Kennedy, Burton Professor of Neurology, [University of Glasgow](/wiki/University_of_Glasgow \"University of Glasgow\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Lowri Alice Khan, Team Leader, Intervention, Strategy and Markets Team, [H.M. Treasury](/wiki/H.M._Treasury \"H.M. Treasury\").\n* Paul Leighton, QPM, lately Deputy Chief Constable, [Police Service of Northern Ireland](/wiki/Police_Service_of_Northern_Ireland \"Police Service of Northern Ireland\"). For services to the Police.\n* Rosa Lady Lipworth. For charitable services.\n* [Phyllida Lloyd](/wiki/Phyllida_Lloyd \"Phyllida Lloyd\"), Theatre Director. For services to Drama.\n* [James Loughran](/wiki/James_Loughran \"James Loughran\"), Conductor. For services to Classical Music.\n* David Clifford Loughton, chief executive, [Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust](/wiki/Royal_Wolverhampton_Hospitals_NHS_Trust \"Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Ian David Luder](/wiki/Ian_Luder \"Ian Luder\"), lately [Lord Mayor of the City of London](/wiki/Lord_Mayor_of_London \"Lord Mayor of London\"). For public service.\n* Mary Elizabeth Madden. For public service.\n* [Professor Robert James Mair, FREng FICE FRS](/wiki/Robert_James_Mair \"Robert James Mair\"), Master of [Jesus College](/wiki/Jesus_College%2C_Cambridge \"Jesus College, Cambridge\") and Professor of Geotechnical Engineering, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge \"University of Cambridge\"). For services to Engineering.\n* Hew Mathewson, President, [General Dental Council](/wiki/General_Dental_Council \"General Dental Council\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Professor Denise Angela McAlister, Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor, Teaching and Learning, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster \"University of Ulster\"). For services to Higher Education in Northern Ireland.\n* William David McWilliam, Superintendent, [Merseyside Police](/wiki/Merseyside_Police \"Merseyside Police\"). For services to the Police and to Young People.\n* David Leonard Moore, lately Her Majesty's Inspector of Education and Assistant Divisional Manager, [Ofsted](/wiki/Ofsted \"Ofsted\").\n* Candy Morris, chief executive, NHS South East Coast [Strategic Health Authority](/wiki/Strategic_health_authority \"Strategic health authority\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Diana Lesley Morrison, Headteacher, St. Martin\\-in\\-the\\-Fields High School for Girls, Lambeth, London. For services to local and national Education.\n* Stephen Thurston Munby, chief executive, National College for Leadership of Schools and Children's Services. For services to Education.\n* [Professor Adrian Charles Newland](/wiki/Adrian_Charles_Newland \"Adrian Charles Newland\"), Professor of Haematology and director, Pathology Clinical Academic Unit, [Barts and the London NHS Trust](/wiki/Barts_and_the_London_NHS_Trust \"Barts and the London NHS Trust\"). For services to Medicine.\n* Dr. William Gerard O'Hare, Chairman, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster \"University of Ulster\") Foundation. For services to Higher Education and to Regeneration in Northern Ireland.\n* [David Malcolm Orr](/wiki/David_Malcolm_Orr \"David Malcolm Orr\"), Director Corporate Services, Department of Finance and Personnel, [Northern Ireland Executive](/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Executive \"Northern Ireland Executive\").\n* John Scott Perry, chief executive, [Scottish Enterprise](/wiki/Scottish_Enterprise \"Scottish Enterprise\"). For services to Business.\n* Dr. David Price, chief executive, [Chemring Group](/wiki/Chemring_Group \"Chemring Group\") plc. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* Imelda Redmond, chief executive, [Carers UK](/wiki/Carers_UK \"Carers UK\"). For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Dr. Sian Eluned Rees, Inspector of Ancient Monuments, [Cadw](/wiki/Cadw \"Cadw\"), Welsh Assembly Government.\n* Caroline Mary Rookes, Director, Planning for Retirement and Older People, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions \"Department for Work and Pensions\").\n* [Tessa Sarah Ross (Mrs. Scantlebury)](/wiki/Tessa_Ross \"Tessa Ross\"), Controller of Film and Drama, [Channel 4](/wiki/Channel_4 \"Channel 4\"). For services to Broadcasting.\n* [Alastair Eric Hotson Salvesen](/wiki/Alastair_Salvesen \"Alastair Salvesen\"). For services to the Arts and to Charity in Scotland.\n* [Graham Edward Sheffield](/wiki/Graham_Sheffield \"Graham Sheffield\"), Artistic Director, [Barbican Centre](/wiki/Barbican_Centre \"Barbican Centre\"), London. For services to the Arts.\n* [Adrian Shooter](/wiki/Adrian_Shooter \"Adrian Shooter\"), Chairman, [Chiltern Railway Company Ltd](/wiki/Chiltern_Railways \"Chiltern Railways\"). For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Ruth Sims, OBE. For voluntary service to Palliative Care in [Uganda](/wiki/Uganda \"Uganda\").\n* John Brian Sinnott, chief executive, [Leicestershire County Council](/wiki/Leicestershire_County_Council \"Leicestershire County Council\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Christopher John Skinner](/wiki/Chris_Skinner_%28statistician%29 \"Chris Skinner (statistician)\"), FBA, Professor, Southampton Statistical Sciences Research Institute, [University of Southampton](/wiki/University_of_Southampton \"University of Southampton\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Paul Spencer, lately chairman, [National Savings and Investments](/wiki/National_Savings_and_Investments \"National Savings and Investments\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* Janice Stevens, National Director, Healthcare Associated Infections Programme, Department of Health. For services to Nursing.\n* Professor William James Swindall, OBE, Consulting Director, QUILL Centre, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast \"Queen's University Belfast\"). For services to Environmental Science.\n* Kathleen Thomas, Principal, [Oldham College](/wiki/Oldham_College \"Oldham College\"), Manchester. For services to Further Education.\n* [Margaret Maud Tyzack, OBE](/wiki/Margaret_Tyzack \"Margaret Tyzack\"), actress. For services to Drama.\n* [Professor Karen Vousden, FRS FRSE FMedSci](/wiki/Karen_Vousden \"Karen Vousden\"), Director, [Beatson Institute for Cancer Research](/wiki/Beatson_Institute_for_Cancer_Research \"Beatson Institute for Cancer Research\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Susan Toni Wardell, Director, Middle East, Caribbean, Asia (East, Central) and British Overseas Territories, [Department for International Development](/wiki/Department_for_International_Development \"Department for International Development\").\n* John David Whittaker, Deputy Director, Employment Policy, [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office \"Cabinet Office\").\n* Vanessa Wiseman, lately Headteacher, Langdon School and Sports College, Newham, London. For services to Education.\n* John Briscoe Wright. For services to the [Federation of Small Businesses](/wiki/Federation_of_Small_Businesses \"Federation of Small Businesses\").\n* Professor Michael Wright, DL, Vice\\-Chancellor, [Canterbury Christ Church University](/wiki/Canterbury_Christ_Church_University \"Canterbury Christ Church University\"). For services to Higher Education and to the community in Kent.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* Larry Thomas Dennis, lately Auditor General of Bermuda. For services to good governance in Bermuda.\n* Rabbi [David Shlomo Rosen](/wiki/David_Shlomo_Rosen \"David Shlomo Rosen\"), Honorary Adviser on Interfaith relations to the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. For services to interfaith relations in the Middle East, and between the UK and Israel.",
"#### Officers of the Order of the British Empire (OBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* [Commander Nicholas Trevor Blackman](/wiki/Nicholas_Trevor_Blackman \"Nicholas Trevor Blackman\")\n* [Commander Richard George Fox](/wiki/Richard_George_Fox \"Richard George Fox\")\n* [Commander David John Hunkin](/wiki/David_John_Hunkin \"David John Hunkin\")\n* [Commander Charles David Lightfoot](/wiki/Charles_David_Lightfoot \"Charles David Lightfoot\")\n* [Commander Peter Moss](/wiki/Peter_Moss_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"Peter Moss (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Commander Gerard Rodney Northwood](/wiki/Gerard_Rodney_Northwood \"Gerard Rodney Northwood\")",
"Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Allan Barnes](/wiki/Allan_Barnes_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Allan Barnes (British Army officer)\") – Coldstream Guards\n* [Colonel John Etherington](/wiki/John_Etherington \"John Etherington\") – late Royal Army Medical Corps\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley](/wiki/Alexander_Gilbert_Carew_Hatherley \"Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley\") – Grenadier Guards\n* [Colonel Ian David MacLeod](/wiki/Ian_David_MacLeod \"Ian David MacLeod\") – Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Army Cadet Force\n* [Colonel Iain George David Moles, QVRM TD](/wiki/Iain_George_David_Moles \"Iain George David Moles\") – late Royal Army Medical Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Leanda Jane Pitt, TD DL](/wiki/Leanda_Jane_Pitt \"Leanda Jane Pitt\") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel John Richard James Powell](/wiki/John_Richard_James_Powell \"John Richard James Powell\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Mark Reginald Rusby](/wiki/Mark_Reginald_Rusby \"Mark Reginald Rusby\") – The Mercian Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Andrew John Teskey](/wiki/Andrew_John_Teskey \"Andrew John Teskey\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Wing Commander Stephen Robert Chaskin](/wiki/Stephen_Robert_Chaskin \"Stephen Robert Chaskin\")\n* [Wing Commander Mark Nicholas Day](/wiki/Mark_Nicholas_Day \"Mark Nicholas Day\")\n* [Wing Commander Simon Andrew Harper](/wiki/Simon_Andrew_Harper \"Simon Andrew Harper\")\n* [Wing Commander Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid](/wiki/Jonathan_Peter_Quentin_Reid \"Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid\")\n* [Wing Commander Malcolm Leslie Symonds](/wiki/Malcolm_Leslie_Symonds \"Malcolm Leslie Symonds\")\n* [Wing Commander Andrew David Wallis](/wiki/Andrew_David_Wallis \"Andrew David Wallis\")\n* [Wing Commander Robert Alan Woods](/wiki/Robert_Alan_Woods \"Robert Alan Woods\")",
"Civil Division\n* William Abbott, National Security Adviser, Secure Mental Health Services, Department of Health. For services to Healthcare.\n* [Victor Akers](/wiki/Victor_Akers \"Victor Akers\"), lately Manager, [Arsenal Ladies' Football Team](/wiki/Arsenal_W.F.C. \"Arsenal W.F.C.\"). For services to Sport.\n* Professor [Alan Alexander](/wiki/Alan_Alexander_%28academic%29 \"Alan Alexander (academic)\"), Emeritus Professor of Local and Public Management, [University of Strathclyde](/wiki/University_of_Strathclyde \"University of Strathclyde\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Alexander Beveridge Anderson, D.L., Chairman of Governors, University of Teesside. For services to the community in the North East.\n* Deirdre Anne, Mrs. Kinloch Anderson, Director, Kinloch Anderson. For services to the Textile Industry.\n* John Huxley Fordyce Anderson. For services to St. Martin\\-in\\-the\\-Fields, London and to the Construction Industry.\n* [Craig Armstrong](/wiki/Craig_Armstrong_%28composer%29 \"Craig Armstrong (composer)\"). For services to Music.\n* Anthony John William Attard, Chief Executive, Panaz Ltd. For services to the Textile Industry and to International Trade.\n* [Sir Nicholas Hickman Ponsonby Bacon, Bt., D.L](/wiki/Sir_Nicholas_Bacon%2C_14th_Baronet \"Sir Nicholas Bacon, 14th Baronet\"). For services to the community in Norfolk.\n* Linda Margaret, Mrs. Costelloe Baker. For public service.\n* Stuart Kemp Baker, Deputy Director, National Projects, Rail and National Networks, Department for Transport.\n* Dr. Michael Thomas Barlow. For services to Intellectual Property Law.\n* Professor [Ann Barrett](/wiki/Ann_Barrett \"Ann Barrett\"), Professor of [Oncology](/wiki/Oncology \"Oncology\") and lately Deputy Head of School, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia \"University of East Anglia\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Hillary Anna Bauer, Head, International and Cultural Property Unit, Department for Culture, Media and Sport.\n* Ms Margaret Baxter. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Miss Ailsa Elizabeth Beaton, Director of Information, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.\n* Alan Kenneth Bowers Beavis. For services to the Scouts.\n* Dr. John William Beer, lately Executive Director of Social Services, Southampton City Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ms [Anthea Bell](/wiki/Anthea_Bell \"Anthea Bell\"). For services to Literature and to Literary Translations.\n* Arlene, Mrs. Bell, Headteacher, Beechdale Nursery School, Durham. For services to local and national Early Years Education.\n* Thomas Bell. For services to the Wooden Spoon Children's Charity.\n* [Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough](/wiki/Madeleine_Ponsonby%2C_Countess_of_Bessborough \"Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough\"). For services to the Visual Arts.\n* Dr. Anthony Bernard Best. For services to the Education of Deafblind Children.\n* Kay, Mrs. Bews, Chief Executive, Home\\-Start UK. For services to Children and Families.\n* Professor Alison Blenkinsopp, Professor of the Practice of Pharmacy, Keele University. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ronald John Bowers, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Paul Vincent Boyle, lately Chief Executive, Financial Reporting Council. For services to the Financial Services Industry and Accountancy.\n* Ms Anne Elizabeth Brannagan, Complex Trauma Manager, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.\n* [Ross Brawn](/wiki/Ross_Brawn \"Ross Brawn\"), Team Principal, [Brawn GP](/wiki/Brawn_GP \"Brawn GP\"). For services to Motorsport.\n* [Dr. Michael Peter Briggs](/wiki/Peter_Briggs_%28scientist%29 \"Peter Briggs (scientist)\"), lately [Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor](/wiki/Pro-Vice-Chancellor \"Pro-Vice-Chancellor\"), [Roehampton University](/wiki/Roehampton_University \"Roehampton University\"). For services to Higher Education.\n* Dr. Alison Fiona Campbell, Managing Director, King's College London Business Ltd. For services to Knowledge Transfer.\n* Peter Carne, lately National Champion, Learning Outside the Classroom and Programme Manager, Growing Schools Programme. For services to Education.\n* David Brian Cassells. For services to the Inland Waterways Association of Ireland.\n* Eileen, Mrs. Cavalier (Mrs. Schatunowski), Founder, London College of Beauty Therapy. For services to Further Education.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Challis, Leader, Castle Point Borough Council. For services to Local Government in South East Essex.\n* [Mavis Lurline, Mrs. Champagnie](/wiki/Lurline_Champagnie \"Lurline Champagnie\"), Councillor, [London Borough of Harrow](/wiki/London_Borough_of_Harrow \"London Borough of Harrow\"). For services to Local Government and to Diversity.\n* Captain Kandiah Chandran, M.B.E., Chief Executive, Preset Charitable Trust. For services to Young People in London.\n* Gillian, Mrs. Coffey, Headteacher, Lynch Hill Foundation Primary School, Slough. For services to Education.\n* Yvonne, Mrs. Coghill, National Lead, Breaking Through Programme, NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement. For services to Healthcare.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Cooke, Head of Capability and First Line Service Management, Customer Service Delivery, Corporate IT, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Gordon Raymond Couch. For services to disabled people.\n* David John Cowie, lately District Manager, Jobcentre Plus, Forth Valley, Fife and Tayside, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* John Andrew Craig, Chairman, British Record Industry Trust. For services to Music and to Charity.\n* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Craig, Chief Executive, Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Bruce Millson Crook, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Ms [Frances Crook](/wiki/Frances_Crook \"Frances Crook\"), Director, [Howard League for Penal Reform](/wiki/Howard_League_for_Penal_Reform \"Howard League for Penal Reform\"). For services to Youth Justice.\n* Neil Philip Cunliffe, Group Manager, Road Safety Group, Lancashire County Council. For services to Road Safety.\n* Phillip Leyland Darnton, Chairman, Cycling England. For services to Transport.\n* Frederick Geoffrey Davies, lately Chairman, Gwent Magistrates Bench and Wales Bench Chairmen's Forum. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Derek John Davis, lately Chairman, Stoke\\-on\\-Trent and Staffordshire Combined Fire Authority. For services to Local Government.\n* Amanda, Mrs. Deeks, Chief Executive Officer, South Gloucestershire Council and Founder, West of England Partnership for Bristol. For services to Local Government.\n* Paul Deneen, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Herefordshire and Worcestershire.\n* John Henry Derbyshire, Sailing Coach and Manager. For services to Sport.\n* Professor [Fiona Devine](/wiki/Fiona_Devine \"Fiona Devine\"), Professor of Sociology, [University of Manchester](/wiki/University_of_Manchester \"University of Manchester\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Ian Laidlaw\\-Dickson, Chairman, Hertfordshire Police Authority. For services to the Police.\n* Michael Donnelly, Chief Executive Officer, Habinteg Housing Association. For services to the Housing Sector.\n* Jacqueline Ann, Mrs. Dowell, Customer Operations Business Design Manager, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Professor [Marcus Peter Francis du Sautoy](/wiki/Marcus_du_Sautoy \"Marcus du Sautoy\"), Professor of Mathematics, [University of Oxford](/wiki/University_of_Oxford \"University of Oxford\"). For services to Science.\n* Brigadier Hedley Dennis Cardew Duncan, M.B.E., lately Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod, House of Lords.\n* Martin Donald Dunford, Chairman, Association of Learning Providers and Chief Executive, Skills Training UK. For services to Skills.\n* Antony Dunne, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Dr. Linda Ebbatson, Leader, Chester\\-le\\-Street District Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ms Janette Morag Faherty, Chief Executive, TNG/ Avanta. For services to Unemployed People and to Entrepreneurship.\n* Ms Julia Fawcett, Chief Executive, Lowry Centre, Salford Quays. For services to the Arts in the North West.\n* Derek Forest, Detective Superintendent, West Midlands Police. For services to the Police.\n* Diana, Mrs. Fulbrook, Chief Officer, Wiltshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.\n* Elizabeth Laureen, Mrs. Fullerton, lately Chair, NHS Shetland. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Lucy Diana Gampell (Mrs. Itkin), lately Director, Action for Prisoners' Families. For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Professor Mary Gibby, Director of Science, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh. For services to Botany.\n* Captain Duncan Colin Glass, lately Director of Navigation Requirements, Trinity House, Department for Transport.\n* Celia Jane, Mrs. Godsall. For services to Sport.\n* Dr. James Desmond Hall, General Medical Practitioner, Belfast. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Susan Elizabeth Hall, Chief Officer, West Yorkshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Catherine Graham\\-Harrison. For services to Heritage.\n* David James Harrison. For services to Golf.\n* Michael Clifford Hart, Director, Ffestinog Railway Company and Chairman, Welsh Highland Railway Construction Ltd. For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Maurice Adrian Sylvester Heaster, Deputy Leader, Wandsworth Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Elizabeth Irene, Mrs. Henderson, Network Nurse Director, Northern Ireland Cancer Network. For services to Healthcare.\n* Tom Henderson. For services to Humanitarian Aid.\n* Dr. Barbara Hendrie, lately Deputy Director, Iraq, Department for International Development.\n* David Henry, Chairman, National Association for Mental Health. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. [Andrew James Herbert](/wiki/Andrew_Herbert \"Andrew Herbert\"), Managing Director, [Microsoft Research](/wiki/Microsoft_Research \"Microsoft Research\"), Cambridge. For services to Computer Science.\n* [Donald Peter Herbert](/wiki/Peter_Herbert_%28lawyer%29 \"Peter Herbert (lawyer)\"), Barrister. For voluntary service to Equality, Diversity and Human Rights.\n* Ms Susan Ann Higham, Business Design Manager, Modernising Pay As You Earn, Telford, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Ms Stephanie Hilborne, Chief Executive, The Wildlife Trusts. For services to Nature Conservation.\n* Professor Anthony Edward Hill, Director, National Oceanography Centre, Southampton. For services to Environmental Science.\n* Professor William Stewart Hillis, Medical Adviser, Scottish Football Association. For services to Medicine and to Sport.\n* Helen Jane, Mrs. Clegg\\-Hood, Headteacher, Shiremoor Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For services to Education.\n* Ms Katharine Sarah Julian Horner, lately Specialist Counsellor and Senior Analyst, Assessments Staff, Cabinet Office.\n* Peter John Hosker. For services to the community in Preston, Lancashire.\n* [Gareth Dale Hoskins](/wiki/Gareth_Hoskins \"Gareth Hoskins\"). For services to Architecture.\n* Kevin Houston, Managing Director, Anderson Manning Associates. For services to Business.\n* Nicholas Howard, Parliamentary Clerk, Prime Minister's Office.\n* Susan, Mrs. Huggins, Head of Network Development. For services to the Post Office.\n* Shirley, Mrs. Hughes, Chief Executive Officer, Cerebral Palsy Sport. For services to Disability Sport.\n* Robert Alfred Hutchings. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Wales.\n* William Anthony Hynett, Group Chief Executive Officer, [B\\-N Group Ltd](/wiki/Britten-Norman \"Britten-Norman\"). For services to the Defence Industry.\n* [Paul Stafford Jackson](/wiki/Paul_Jackson_%28game_producer%29 \"Paul Jackson (game producer)\"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.\n* Marc Jaffrey. For services to Music Education.\n* Anthony Paul Jakimciw, Principal and Chief Executive Officer, Dumfries and Galloway College. For services to Further Education in Scotland.\n* Professor Ian Miller Jamieson, lately Pro\\-Vice\\- Chancellor (Learning and Teaching), University of Bath. For services to local and national Education.\n* Ms Marion Juliette Janner. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Ms Deborah Jeffery, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence. Martin John Jenkins, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Jane, Mrs. Johnson, Headteacher, St. Stephen's Primary School, Newham, London. For services to Education.\n* Glenys, Mrs. Johnston, Chair, Local Safeguarding Children Board, Leicestershire and Rutland. For services to Local Government.\n* Paul Lloyd Jones, Executive Headteacher, Blackpool and Chudleigh Knighton Lady Seaward's and Salcombe Primary Schools, Devon. For services to local and national Education.\n* [Stephen Jones](/wiki/Stephen_Jones_%28milliner%29 \"Stephen Jones (milliner)\"), Milliner. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Professor Vijay Vir Kakkar, Emeritus Professor, University of London. For services to Clinical Science.\n* Ms Jeanne Kaniuk, Head of Adoption Services, Thomas Coram Foundation for Children. For services to Children.\n* Professor Paul Keane, Dean, School of Health and Social Care, Teesside University. For services to Healthcare.\n* Anna, Mrs. Kendall, lately Headteacher, Christ Church Church of England Primary School, Kensington and Chelsea, London. For services to Education.\n* Nigel Kershaw, Chief Executive, Big Issue Invest and Chairman, The Big Issue. For services to Social Enterprise.\n* [Simon Henry King](/wiki/Simon_King_%28television%29 \"Simon King (television)\"). For services to Wildlife Photography and to Conservation.\n* John Gordon Kingston. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Ms Anne Kirkham, Grade 5, Decent Homes and Housing Finance Division, Department for Communities and Local Government.\n* Richard Philip Kitson, lately Chief Executive, Aster Group. For services to the Housing Sector.\n* Susan, Mrs. Knox. For services to Food Safety.\n* Silas Krendel. For charitable services.\n* [Ram Parkash Lakha](/wiki/Ram_Parkash_Lakha \"Ram Parkash Lakha\"). For services to the Sikh community in Coventry, West Midlands.\n* Anthony Edward Langford, Non\\-Executive Director, John Smedley. For services to the Knitwear Industry.\n* Heather, Mrs. Lawrence, Chief Executive, Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Jurat and Lieutenant Bailiff Sally Carolyn Ann Le Brocq. For services to the Administration of Justice and to the community in Jersey.\n* Andrew John Leigh. For public service.\n* Eva, Mrs. Loeffler, Vice\\-President, WheelPower. For services to Disability Sport.\n* Helen, Mrs. MacKenzie, Headteacher, Shevington High School, Wigan. For services to Education.\n* John Graham Marks. For charitable services.\n* Victor Alan Marshall, Detective Superintendent, Sussex Police and Adviser to the Home Office. For services to the Police.\n* Ms Wendy Martinson, Consultant Dietitian, British Olympic Association. For services to Sport and to Nutrition.\n* June Colette, Mrs. Mason, Grade 7, Cohesion and Migration Directorate, Department for Communities and Local Government.\n* Samuel Abraham McCrea, Principal, Ballyclare Secondary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Professor John Alexander McDermid. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* William John McGawley, Executive Vice\\-Chairman, TDR Group. For services to Business and to Skills Training in the North East.\n* The Very Reverend Dr. Robert Samuel James Houston McKelvey, Q.V.R.M., T.D., Dean, St. Anne's Cathedral, Belfast. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms Alison Mary McLean. For services to Rural Affairs in the West Midlands.\n* Bishop Louis Richard McLeod, For services to Southwark Credit Union.\n* Ronald McNab, lately Managing Director, Caledonian Alloys Ltd. For services to the Recycling Industry.\n* Ms [Loretta Minghella](/wiki/Loretta_Minghella \"Loretta Minghella\"), Chief Executive, [Financial Services Compensation Scheme](/wiki/Financial_Services_Compensation_Scheme \"Financial Services Compensation Scheme\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* [Michelle, Mrs. Mone](/wiki/Michelle_Mone%2C_Baroness_Mone \"Michelle Mone, Baroness Mone\"), Founder and Owner, MJM International Group. For services to the Lingerie Industry.\n* [Kenneth Montgomery](/wiki/Kenneth_Montgomery \"Kenneth Montgomery\"), Principal Conductor, [Ulster Orchestra](/wiki/Ulster_Orchestra \"Ulster Orchestra\"). For services to Music in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms [Debbie Moore](/wiki/Debbie_Moore \"Debbie Moore\"), Founder and Chair, [Pineapple Dance Studios](/wiki/Pineapple_Dance_Studios \"Pineapple Dance Studios\"). For services to Business.\n* [Heidi, Mrs. Mottram](/wiki/Heidi_Mottram \"Heidi Mottram\"), Managing Director, Northern Rail. For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Ms Diane Mulligan. For services to disabled people and to Equal Opportunities.\n* [Braham Sydney Murray](/wiki/Braham_Murray \"Braham Murray\"), [Artistic Director](/wiki/Artistic_Director \"Artistic Director\"), [Royal Exchange, Manchester](/wiki/Royal_Exchange%2C_Manchester \"Royal Exchange, Manchester\"). For services to Drama.\n* Peter Murray, Co\\-Founder, Ormiston Trust. For services to Children and Families.\n* Dr. Sydney Donnelly Neill, Director, Agriculture Food and Environmental Sciences Division, Agri\\-Food and Biosciences Institute, Northern Ireland Executive.\n* [David Nixon](/wiki/David_Nixon_%28choreographer%29 \"David Nixon (choreographer)\"), Artistic Director, [Northern Ballet](/wiki/Northern_Ballet \"Northern Ballet\") Theatre. For services to Dance.\n* Edward James O'Gorman. For charitable services to the Foundation for Children with Leukaemia.\n* Professor [Timothy O'Riordan](/wiki/Tim_O%27Riordan \"Tim O'Riordan\"), D.L., Emeritus Professor of Environmental Sciences, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia \"University of East Anglia\"). For services to Sustainable Development.\n* Gary Oldman. For public service.\n* Dr. Jane Overbury, Principal, Christ the King Sixth Form College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.\n* [Richard Parfitt](/wiki/Rick_Parfitt \"Rick Parfitt\"), Co\\-Founder, Singer and Guitarist, [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 \"Status Quo (band)\"). For services to Music and to Charity.\n* Dr. Louise Mary Perrotta. For public service.\n* Peter Phillipson, Chairman, Merlin Entertainments Group. For services to the Leisure Industry.\n* Raymond Pollock, Principal, Banbridge Academy. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Diane, Mrs. Poole, General Manager, Passengers Norfolkline Irish Sea Ferry Services. For services to the Tourist Industry.\n* Melloney, Mrs. Poole, Deputy Director, Legal Services and Governance, Big Lottery Fund. For public service.\n* Andrew Richard Pope, J.P., National Business Crime Partnership Manager, Co\\-operative Group. For public service.\n* Ms [Rachel Portman](/wiki/Rachel_Portman \"Rachel Portman\"), Film Composer. For services to Music.\n* Colin Preece, lately Director, Social Services, Neath Port Talbot. For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Michael Charles Prestwich](/wiki/Michael_Prestwich \"Michael Prestwich\"), Emeritus Professor of History, [Durham University](/wiki/Durham_University \"Durham University\"). For services to Scholarship.\n* Richard Edward Priest, Chief Executive, Riverside Centre. For services to the community in the Isle of Wight.\n* Walter Rader, Director, Big Lottery Fund. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Judith, Mrs. Ragan, Headteacher, Queensmill Special School for Autism, Hammersmith and Fulham, London. For services to Special Needs Education.\n* Bernardine, Mrs. Rees, lately Chief Executive, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire Local Health Board. For services to the NHS in Wales.\n* Raymond Victor Refausse, lately Director and Chief Executive, South West College. For services to Further and Higher Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Professor Margaret Reid, Professor of Women's Health, University of Glasgow. For services to Healthcare and to Higher Education.\n* Ms Lyndy Reynolds, lately Deputy Head, Government Legal Service Secretariat, Treasury Solicitor's Department.\n* Ms [Menna Richards](/wiki/Menna_Richards \"Menna Richards\"), Director, [BBC Wales](/wiki/BBC_Wales \"BBC Wales\"). For services to Broadcasting.\n* Anne, Mrs. Roberts, Chief Executive, Crossroads Association. For services to Carers.\n* Edmund Caerwyn Roberts, M.B.E., Chairman, Snowdonia National Park Authority. For services to the community in Gwynedd.\n* Elizabeth Regina Oluyemika, Mrs. Atere\\-Roberts, Older People's Nurse Specialist. For services to Healthcare in London.\n* Brian Keith Rockliffe, Director, Voluntary Service Overseas. For services to International Development.\n* [Francis Dominic Nicholas Michael Rossi](/wiki/Francis_Rossi \"Francis Rossi\"), Co\\-Founder and Singer, Status Quo. For services to Music and to Charity.\n* John Kenneth Rostill, Chief Executive, Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Henry James Griffin Russell, lately Chairman, National Association of General Commissioners. For public service.\n* Professor Edward Sallis, Principal and Chief Executive, Highlands College, Jersey. For services to Education.\n* Sujinder Singh Sangha, Principal, Stockton Riverside College, County Durham. For services to local and national Further Education.\n* Professor Danny Saunders, Professor and Head of the Centre for Lifelong Learning, University of Glamorgan. For services to Higher Education in Wales.\n* Professor Joseph Maurice Savage, Consultant Paediatric Nephrologist, Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children. For services to Medicine.\n* Dr. Caroline Ann Bodley\\-Scott, Civilian Medical Practitioner, British Forces Germany Health Service, Ministry of Defence.\n* Gordon Scott. For services to Regeneration in South Yorkshire.\n* [Jane Antoinette, Mrs. Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook \"Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook\"), Leader, [Wiltshire Council](/wiki/Wiltshire_Council \"Wiltshire Council\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Ahmad Shahzad. For services to Black and Minority Ethnic People.\n* Ghulam Rasul Shahzad. For services to Social Housing and to the community in Rochdale.\n* Peter Sheldon. For services to the Jewish Community.\n* Miss Julie May Shenton, Departmental Strategic Business Continuity Manager, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Dr. David Sibbald, F.R.S.E., Chairman, Sumerian Networks. For charitable services in Scotland and Overseas.\n* [Alice, Mrs. Sluckin](/wiki/Alice_Sluckin \"Alice Sluckin\"), Chair, Selective Mutism Information and Research Association. For services to Children and Families.\n* [Ronald Gordon King\\-Smith](/wiki/Dick_King-Smith \"Dick King-Smith\"), Author. For services to Children's Literature.\n* John Thomas Smith, lately Principal, Burnley College. For services to Further Education.\n* Ms Laraine Smith, Principal, Uxbridge College. For services to Further Education.\n* Peter Arthur Smith. For services to the Optometric Profession.\n* Gerard Smyth. For services to the Police in the North East.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Snowdon, Chair, Pensions Advisory Service. For services to Pensioners.\n* The Honourable [Rupert Christopher Soames](/wiki/Rupert_Soames \"Rupert Soames\"), Chief Executive Officer, [Aggreko](/wiki/Aggreko \"Aggreko\") plc. For services to the Power Industry.\n* Pauline Joan, Mrs. Spencer, lately Head, Victim and Witness Care Delivery Unit, Crown Prosecution Service.\n* Eric Spicer. For services to the Telecommunications Industry.\n* The Right Reverend James Theophilus Stapleton. For services to Inter\\-Faith and Community Relations in Nottingham.\n* Dr. [Miriam Stoppard](/wiki/Miriam_Stoppard \"Miriam Stoppard\"). For services to Healthcare and to Charity.\n* Professor David Storey, lately Director, Centre for Small and Medium Enterprise, Warwick Business School. For services to Business.\n* Stephen Szemerenyi, Pay and Conditions Specialist, Association of School and College Leaders. For services to Education.\n* Alexander Tait, lately Governing Governor, H.M. Young Offenders' Institution Castington, Northumberland, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Jeremy James Taylor. For services to Young People and to Musical Theatre.\n* David Ralph Thompson, Governor H.M. Prison Frankland, Durham, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Gillian Jane Thompson, lately Chief Executive, Accountant in Bankruptcy, Scottish Executive.\n* [Cyrus Todiwala](/wiki/Cyrus_Todiwala \"Cyrus Todiwala\"), M.B.E., Proprietor and Executive Chef, Cafe ́ Spice Namaste ́ Restaurant Group. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Iqbal Wahhab, Chairman, Department for Work and Pensions, Ethnic Minority Advisory Group. For public service and for services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Ms [Amanda Jane Wakeley](/wiki/Amanda_Wakeley \"Amanda Wakeley\"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Professor Janet Anne Walker, Deputy Chair, Social Security Advisory Committee. For public service.\n* James Arneil Wardrop. For services to the community in Renfrewshire.\n* Caroline, Mrs. Waters, Director, People and Policy for BT Group. For services to Diversity and to Equal Opportunities.\n* Norma Anne, Mrs. Watson. For services to Education in Scotland.\n* Dr. John Alexander Watt, Director of Strengthening Communities, Highlands and Islands Enterprise. For services to Community Development.\n* Professor Maureen Wayman, lately Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor and Dean, Art and Design, Manchester Metropolitan University. For services to local and national Higher Education.\n* John Wilkinson, Chief Executive, Ecuomed. For services to the Healthcare Industry.\n* [Mark Roger Wilkinson](/wiki/Mark_Wilkinson_%28designer%29 \"Mark Wilkinson (designer)\"). For services to the Furniture Industry and to Charity.\n* Susan Jean, Mrs. Willan, lately Inspector, Her Majesty's Inspectorate for Education and Training in Wales. For services to Education.\n* Professor Richard James Willson Williams, T.D., Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, Aneurin Bevan Health Board. For services to Medicine.\n* Jessie, Mrs. Wojciechowski, Headteacher, Borestone Primary School, Stirling. For services to Education.\n* Professor Charles Roland Wolf, Director, Biomedical Research Centre, University of Dundee. For services to Science.\n* David Mark Wood, Chief Executive, ATTEND. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Dr. Eric Wood, D.L. For services to Education and to the community in Warwickshire.\n* Thomas Greenaway Woods. For public service.\n* Ms Louise Wright, Fraud and Error Consultant, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Stephen Frederick Wright, Head, Business, Improvement and Support Team, London, Valuation Office Agency, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Woon Wing Yip, Chairman, Wing Yip plc. For services to the Oriental Food Industry.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* [Mockbul Ali](/wiki/Mockbul_Ali \"Mockbul Ali\") \\- Adviser to the then [Foreign \\& Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_%26_Commonwealth_Office \"Foreign & Commonwealth Office\"). For services to British foreign policy.\n* David Belgrove – lately Head, Counter Narcotics Team, British Embassy, Afghanistan.\n* [Thomas Yates Benyon](/wiki/Thomas_Benyon \"Thomas Benyon\") – Founder and director, ZANE (Zimbabwe A National Emergency). For services to vulnerable people in Zimbabwe.\n* James Gordon Davidson Blakely – Director Youth (Education, Science and Society), British Council.\n* The Right Reverend Leroy Errol Brooks – For services to the community in Anguilla.\n* Norma Po Yee Chan – lately Chief, Security Council Secretariat, United Nations. For services to the United Nations in New York.\n* John Joseph\\-Devine, LVO – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* Dr. Roderic William Dutton – Adviser on the Middle East, International Office, Durham University. For services to higher education and research links between the UK and the Middle East, especially Jordan.\n* Simon John Gillham – President, Franco\\-British Chamber of Commerce. For services to Franco\\-British business interests in France.\n* Richard Wingfield Hyde, MBE – British Honorary Consul, Madagascar. For services to the British community in Madagascar.\n* [Graham King](/wiki/Graham_King \"Graham King\") – Film Producer. For services to the British film industry in the US and UK.\n* Beverley Elizabeth Lewis – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* Nicholas Roy Mason – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Margaret Marian McPartland](/wiki/Marian_McPartland \"Marian McPartland\") – Pianist and Radio Show Host, National Public Radio, USA. For services to jazz and to aspiring young musicians in the USA.\n* [Diane Mulligan](/wiki/Diane_Mulligan \"Diane Mulligan\") – for services to disabled people and to equal opportunities.\n* William Smith MacDonald Murray – Economic and Financial Attaché, British Embassy, Spain.\n* Brian David Outlaw – Director, China\\-Britain Business Council. For services to British business interests in China.\n* Mehr Tahir Kamran – British Foreign Officer, Ambassador to Russia. For services towards a better mutual co\\-ordination in trade with Russia.\n* Ian George Purves – lately Stabilisation Adviser, Civil Military Mission in Helmand. For services to security and stabilisation in Afghanistan.\n* Michael Charles Ramscar – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Jane Antoinette Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook \"Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook\") – For services to local government in Wiltshire.\n* Olga May Scott – For services to the health, education and development of Bermuda's youth.\n* Stephen Rowland Thomas – Founder and former Chairman of OPAL, Oman. For services to British business interests and to the community in Oman.\n* Paul Williams – Offsets Adviser, UK Trade and Investment, South Africa. For services to British business interests.",
"#### Members of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Warfare Specialist (Abovewater Warfare Tactical) Russell Graham Billings](/wiki/Russell_Graham_Billings \"Russell Graham Billings\")\n* [Logistician (Catering Services) Class 1 Rosemary Anne Brodrick](/wiki/Rosemary_Anne_Brodrick \"Rosemary Anne Brodrick\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Air Engineering Technician Kenneth Michael Davidson](/wiki/Kenneth_Michael_Davidson \"Kenneth Michael Davidson\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Barry Dawe](/wiki/Barry_Dawe \"Barry Dawe\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Robert John Ewen](/wiki/Robert_John_Ewen \"Robert John Ewen\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) John Ronald Hendren](/wiki/John_Ronald_Hendren \"John Ronald Hendren\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Steven David Hopkins](/wiki/Steven_David_Hopkins \"Steven David Hopkins\")\n* [Lieutenant Anthony Jackson](/wiki/Anthony_Jackson_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"Anthony Jackson (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Bryan John Nicholas](/wiki/Bryan_John_Nicholas \"Bryan John Nicholas\")\n* [Chief Petty Officer Engineering Technician (Marine Engineering) David Parker](/wiki/David_Parker_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"David Parker (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) Andrew Mark Rainey](/wiki/Andrew_Mark_Rainey \"Andrew Mark Rainey\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Philip David Slocombe](/wiki/Philip_David_Slocombe \"Philip David Slocombe\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Graham Gilbey Trewhella](/wiki/Graham_Gilbey_Trewhella \"Graham Gilbey Trewhella\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 (Bugler) James Whitwham](/wiki/James_Whitwham \"James Whitwham\")",
"Army\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Justin Mark Brooks](/wiki/Justin_Mark_Brooks \"Justin Mark Brooks\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Major Neil James Mark Budd](/wiki/Neil_James_Mark_Budd \"Neil James Mark Budd\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Major Richard Ronald Coomber](/wiki/Richard_Ronald_Coomber \"Richard Ronald Coomber\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Major Jonathan Edward Cunningham](/wiki/Jonathan_Edward_Cunningham \"Jonathan Edward Cunningham\") – The Yorkshire Regiment\n* [Major Robert Anthony Davies](/wiki/Robert_Anthony_Davies \"Robert Anthony Davies\") – The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment\n* [Major Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood](/wiki/Mark_Christopher_Preston_Ellwood \"Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood\") – The Mercian Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Michael Richard Elviss](/wiki/Mike_Elviss \"Mike Elviss\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Major Graham Roy Emond](/wiki/Graham_Roy_Emond \"Graham Roy Emond\") – Devon Army Cadet Force\n* [Major Christopher Gill](/wiki/Christopher_Gill_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Christopher Gill (British Army officer)\") – Army Air Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Major Paul Harrison](/wiki/Paul_Harrison_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Paul Harrison (British Army officer)\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Captain Philip John Hawkins](/wiki/Philip_John_Hawkins \"Philip John Hawkins\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Anthony Mark Hobbins](/wiki/Anthony_Mark_Hobbins \"Anthony Mark Hobbins\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Staff Sergeant Gary Holdham](/wiki/Gary_Holdham \"Gary Holdham\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Charles Henry James Holdsworth](/wiki/Charles_Henry_James_Holdsworth \"Charles Henry James Holdsworth\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Sergeant Barry John](/wiki/Barry_John_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Barry John (British Army officer)\") – The Royal Welsh\n* Captain Susan King – Royal Corps of Signals\n* [Major Joanna Catherine Maynard](/wiki/Joanna_Catherine_Maynard \"Joanna Catherine Maynard\") – Royal Corps of Signals\n* [Captain Richard Andrew Peters](/wiki/Richard_Andrew_Peters \"Richard Andrew Peters\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Damien Daniel Place](/wiki/Damien_Daniel_Place \"Damien Daniel Place\") – The Royal Irish Regiment\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Iestyn David Plummer](/wiki/Iestyn_David_Plummer \"Iestyn David Plummer\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Major James Samuel Robert Priest](/wiki/James_Samuel_Robert_Priest \"James Samuel Robert Priest\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Major Jonathan Howard Scott](/wiki/Jonathan_Howard_Scott \"Jonathan Howard Scott\") – Corps of Royal Engineers\n* [Major Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe](/wiki/Jeremy_Edward_Gavin_Sharpe \"Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Paul Philip Shipley](/wiki/Paul_Philip_Shipley \"Paul Philip Shipley\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Hugh Campbell\\-Smith](/wiki/Hugh_Campbell-Smith \"Hugh Campbell-Smith\") – The Royal Dragoon Guards\n* [Major Oliver William Stokes](/wiki/Oliver_William_Stokes \"Oliver William Stokes\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Major Sonya Adams Summersgill](/wiki/Sonya_Adams_Summersgill \"Sonya Adams Summersgill\") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Major Alasdair James Eli Truett](/wiki/Alasdair_James_Eli_Truett \"Alasdair James Eli Truett\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Captain Thomas Georg John Tugendhat](/wiki/Thomas_Tugendhat \"Thomas Tugendhat\") – Intelligence Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Colin Richard James Weir](/wiki/Colin_Weir \"Colin Weir\") – The Royal Irish Regiment\n* [Major Robert John Wells](/wiki/Robert_John_Wells \"Robert John Wells\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Major Christopher James White](/wiki/Christopher_James_White \"Christopher James White\") – Surrey Army Cadet Force\n* Lieutenant Colonel John Wilson – Cumbria Army Cadet Force",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Warrant Officer Peter Allen Akers](/wiki/Peter_Allen_Akers \"Peter Allen Akers\")\n* [Chief Technician Paul Andrew Blackah](/wiki/Paul_Andrew_Blackah \"Paul Andrew Blackah\")\n* [Squadron Leader Ian Bryant](/wiki/Ian_Bryant_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"Ian Bryant (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Squadron Leader John Cairns](/wiki/John_Cairns_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"John Cairns (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Warrant Officer Alexander Michael Dykes](/wiki/Alexander_Michael_Dykes \"Alexander Michael Dykes\")\n* [Flight Sergeant Douglas Stuart Law](/wiki/Douglas_Stuart_Law \"Douglas Stuart Law\")\n* [Warrant Officer Rachel MacKenzie](/wiki/Rachel_MacKenzie \"Rachel MacKenzie\")\n* [Flying Officer Leslie Edward Wall McCammont](/wiki/Leslie_Edward_Wall_McCammont \"Leslie Edward Wall McCammont\")\n* [Sergeant Rodney Christian Munday](/wiki/Rodney_Christian_Munday \"Rodney Christian Munday\")\n* [Squadron Leader John Nelson](/wiki/John_Nelson_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"John Nelson (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Squadron Leader Gordon William Henry Parry](/wiki/Gordon_William_Henry_Parry \"Gordon William Henry Parry\")\n* [Flight Sergeant Christopher Edward Read](/wiki/Christopher_Edward_Read \"Christopher Edward Read\")\n* [Warrant Officer Stephen Kenneth Roberts](/wiki/Stephen_Kenneth_Roberts \"Stephen Kenneth Roberts\")\n* [Squadron Leader Colin Terence Sullivan](/wiki/Colin_Terence_Sullivan \"Colin Terence Sullivan\")\n* [Senior Aircraftman Darren Mark Swift](/wiki/Darren_Mark_Swift \"Darren Mark Swift\")",
"Civil Division\n* Gwendolen June, Mrs. Abraham. For services to the community in Braunstone, Leicestershire.\n* Hemant Acharya, Policy Adviser, Office of the Third Sector, Cabinet Office.\n* Samuel Adair, Director, Waterside Credit Union Ltd. For services to the Financial Services Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Valerie Edith, Mrs. Adams, Principal, Lisbellaw Primary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Manus Blake Adamson, Chairman, Adamson Group and Executive Chairman, Construction Confederation. For services to the Construction Industry.\n* Robin Agascar. For voluntary service to the Police in Gloucester.\n* Matilda, Mrs. Akhigbe, Communications Officer, Local Compliance, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Ms Foluke Akinlose, Founder and Editor, Precious Online. For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Gerald Akroyd. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Scotland.\n* Anthony John Alderman, Special Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Ms Angela Cecile Alessendre, Founder, Alessendre Special Needs Dance School and the Larondina Dance Company. For services to Dance.\n* Anne Maria Palma, Mrs. Allan, Deputy Head Teacher, inverclyde Academy, Greenock. For services to Education.\n* Dr. Geoffrey Walter Allan. For services to the community in Kirkintilloch, Dunbartonshire.\n* Shulah, Mrs. Allan, lately Director, Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations Council. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Lynda, Mrs. Allen, Chair of Governors, Sir John Deane's Sixth Form College, Northwich, Cheshire. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Andrew Paul Andrews. For voluntary service to St. John Ambulance Brigade.\n* John Charles Ankcorn, President, Birmingham Crisis Centre. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence.\n* Linda Joyce, Mrs. Ansell. For charitable services in Southend\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Miss Kerry Anthony, Chief Executive, DePaul Northern Ireland. For services to Social Housing.\n* David Archbold. For services to the Water Industry in the North East.\n* James Armitage. For services to the Royal Mail and to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Carol, Mrs. Armstrong, Claims Receipts Manager, Benefits and Credits Operations, Washington, Tyne and Wear, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Mohammed Aslam, Executive Chef and Managing Director, Aagrah Group Restaurants. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Jean, Mrs. Atkinson, lately Staff Side Chair, UNISON, Mersey Care NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.\n* Barbara May, Mrs. Austin. For services to the community in Lyme Regis, Dorset.\n* Kenneth Edwin Ayers. For services to the City of London Corporation.\n* Gloria, Mrs. Bailey. For services to the community in Lambeth, South London.\n* Joan Debra, Mrs. Bailey. For services to Youth Justice in Luton, Bedfordshire.\n* Sharon Gail, Mrs. Bailey, J.P., Head of Service Learning Disabilities, Birmingham City Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Lilian, Mrs. Baker. For services to Mental Healthcare in the Wirral.\n* Warner James Baker, Special Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Robert Henry Ball. For services to Young People in Exeter, Devon.\n* Susan, Mrs. Banton, Director, Steps Charity Worldwide. For services to People with Skeletal Disabilities.\n* Ramanbhai Barber. For services to the Asian community in Leicester.\n* Grace, Mrs. Barnett. For services to the community in Failsworth, Oldham.\n* [Norman Barrett](/wiki/Norman_Barrett_%28ringmaster%29 \"Norman Barrett (ringmaster)\"), Circus Ringmaster. For services to Entertainment.\n* Derek Anthony Bartley. For services to the Midland Association of Mountaineering and to Rhyl Music Club, Denbighshire.\n* Miss [Luella Dayrell Bartley](/wiki/Luella_Bartley \"Luella Bartley\"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Patricia, Mrs. Bate. For services to the community in Warrington, Cheshire.\n* Thomas Frederick Beesley. For services to the community in Halewood, Liverpool.\n* Antony Romer Beevor. For voluntary service to Fairbridge youth organisation.\n* Gulrook, Mrs. Begum. For services to Disabled Bangladeshi People in Tower Hamlets, London.\n* Stephen Avery Bell, Managing Director, Davy Roll Company. For services to Business in the North East.\n* Mavis, Mrs. Bent. For voluntary service to Swimming and Water Polo in Greater Manchester.\n* John Alfred Bigny. For services to Edenbridge and District Rail Travellers' Association Kent.\n* Helen, Mrs. Bird. For services to the community in Hastings, East Sussex.\n* Dr. [Charles William Handley Bird](/wiki/William_Bird_%28doctor%29 \"William Bird (doctor)\"), General Medical Practitioner and Strategic Health Adviser to Natural England. For services to Healthcare and to Physical Activity.\n* Arthur Birkby. For services to the community in Runnymede, Surrey.\n* Paul Blakey. For services to Community Safety in Halifax.\n* Alan Blocksidge, Officer, H.M. Prison Manchester, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* June, Mrs. Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.\n* Roy Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Boswell. For services to the community in Sheerness, Kent.\n* John Stephen Morton Bower. For services to the British Veterinary Association Animal Welfare Foundation.\n* Miss Jennifer Boyd, Principal, Enniskillen Nursery School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Scott Michael Bradbury. For services to the community in Tamworth, Staffordshire.\n* Barbara Evelyn Turner, Mrs. Braithwaite. For voluntary service to the community in Linlithgow, West Lothian.\n* [Rosa, Mrs. Branson](/wiki/Rosa_Branson \"Rosa Branson\"), Painter. For services to Art and to Charity.\n* Richard Oliver Brantingham, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* David Keith Bray. For services to the community in Lincolnshire.\n* Valerie, Mrs. Braybrooks, Dean and Associate Professor, Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Animal Sciences, University of Lincoln. For services to Education and to the Food Industry.\n* John Frederick Brignall. For services to the community in the East Riding of Yorkshire.\n* Philip Britton, Headmaster, Boys' Division, Bolton School. For services to Physics.\n* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Bromley. For charitable services in Oswestry, Shropshire.\n* Robert Patrick Brooks. For voluntary service to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Clwyd.\n* Felicity, Mrs. Brown, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ms Marie Therese Brown. For services to the Victims of Domestic Violence in Northern Ireland.\n* Norman Henry Parson Brown. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion in Hampshire.\n* Robert Brown. For services to the community in Lower Bevendean, Brighton.\n* David Buchanan. For voluntary service to the Environment and to Heritage in Northern Ireland.\n* Diana Hill, Mrs. Bucknall. For voluntary service to the community in Dorset.\n* Lieutenant Commander James Frederic Budgen, R.N.R. For voluntary service to the Sea Cadet Corps in Ruislip, London Borough of Hillingdon.\n* Frederick Henry Ernest Buller. For services to Angling.\n* Yvonne, Mrs. Burdge. For services to the Trust for Chernobyl Children.\n* Kenneth Burgin. For voluntary service to the Casualties Union.\n* Richard John Burningham, Manager, Devon and Cornwall Rail Partnership. For services to the Rail Industry in the South West.\n* Dr. Stephen Brian Burns. For services to Healthcare and to the community in Rotherham, South Yorkshire.\n* William Henry Burt. For voluntary service to Education in Bridgend, South Wales.\n* David John Butler, Chairman, British Motorsport Association for the Disabled. For services to Disability Sport.\n* [Jenson Alexander Lyons Button](/wiki/Jenson_Button \"Jenson Button\"). For services to Motorsport.\n* Ian Caddy. For services to the community in Birtley, County Durham.\n* Dr. Timothy Alan Carney, General Medical Practitioner, Hexham and Tynedale, Northumberland. For services to Healthcare.\n* The Reverend Barry Edward Carter. For services to the community in Brockley, South East London.\n* Colin Richard Carter. For services to the Road Haulage Industry and to Charity.\n* Rosalind Ella, Mrs. Carter, EAL Education Adviser, Language Service, London Borough of Hounslow. For services to Education.\n* Dr. Susan Carver, Senior Programme Manager, Arts and Humanities Research Council. For services to the Research Councils.\n* Wing Commander Alan Charles Cassidy RAF (Ret'd). For services to Aerobatics and to Charity.\n* Robin William Castle. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Sheerness, Kent.\n* Judith Evelyn, Mrs. Catterick. For services to Music in Ashwell, Hertfordshire.\n* James Joseph Caulfield. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged People in Kenya.\n* Miss Susan Caulfield, Assistant Director, Immigration Fingerprint Bureau, UK Border Agency, Home Office.\n* Peter Geoffrey Challinor, Curator and Manager, Anson Engine Museum. For services to Industrial Heritage.\n* Harry Chambers. For services to Poetry.\n* Patricia, Mrs. Chapman. For services to Young People and to the community in Ealing, West London.\n* Glendon Austin Chappelle, Project Manager, Global Combat Systems—Munitions, BAE Systems. For services to the Defence Industry and to Industrial Heritage.\n* Deborah Ann, Mrs. Chedgey. For services to Disadvantaged People in Norwich, Norfolk.\n* Rex Chester. For services to Young People through the Explore Charity.\n* Ms [Lauren Child](/wiki/Lauren_Child \"Lauren Child\"), Author and Illustrator. For services to Literature.\n* Stanley Charles Church. For voluntary service to Conservation in Essex.\n* Donna, Mrs. Clark, Assistant Practitioner, Podiatry Service, Sefton Primary Care Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Leonard Durbin Clark. For services to Young People in Westminster and to the community in North West London.\n* Peter Mansfield\\-Clark, Director, Crawley Open House. For services to Disadvantaged People in West Sussex.\n* Dr. Janet Ruth Clarke, Chair, Central Committee for Community and Public Health Dentistry, British Dental Association. For services to Healthcare.\n* Susan, Mrs. Clarke. For voluntary service to Disability Swimming in Stockton\\-on\\-Tees.\n* Dr. Peter David Clarkson, Emeritus Associate, Scott Polar Research Institute. For services to Science.\n* Professor Timothy Charles Claypole, Director, Welsh Centre for Printing and Coating, Swansea University. For services to Graphic Arts Research.\n* Barry Clewer. For voluntary service to Birmingham Advisory Council of Older People.\n* [Oliver Charles Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 \"Collyer brothers (game designers)\"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to Computer Games Industry.\n* [Paul Edward Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 \"Collyer brothers (game designers)\"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to the Computer Game Industry.\n* David Constantine, Co\\-Founder and Executive Officer Motivation. For services to disabled people.\n* Teresa Mary, Mrs. Copp, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* David John Couch. For charitable services in Fife.\n* Thelma Selina, Mrs. Couch. For charitable services in Fife.\n* Ms Margaret Joan Coulter. For services to Social Care in Northern Ireland.\n* [The Reverend Dr. Robert James Coulter](/wiki/Robert_Coulter_%28Northern_Ireland_politician%29 \"Robert Coulter (Northern Ireland politician)\"), Member, Northern Ireland Assembly Commission. For public service.\n* David Robert Coulthard, Senior Technician, University of York. For services to Science Communication.\n* Beryl, Mrs. Cox, Administrator, Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, York. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Theresa, Mrs. Coyle. For voluntary service to the community in Islington, London.\n* Dorothy Dawn, Mrs. Cragg, Medical Tattooist. For services to Healthcare.\n* Heather, Mrs. Crawford. For services to Speech and Language Therapy in Northern Ireland.\n* Arthur Graves Credland. For services to Maritime History.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Crennell, Senior Assistant Headteacher and Head of Learning Support Faculty, Marriotts School, Stevenage. For services to Special Needs Education.\n* Ms Heather Alice Crouch, Chair, Netball South West. For voluntary service to Sport.\n* John Cunningham. For charitable services in County Durham.\n* Gordon Curry. For public service.\n* Leonard James Curtis. For services to the community in Lancashire.\n* Ms Nicola Kim Dale, Chief Inspector, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.\n* David Dallison. For public service.\n* Ashish Dasgupta, Non\\-Executive Director, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* John Kenneth Davies. For charitable services in Rochdale.\n* Patricia Ann, Mrs. Davies. For voluntary service to Young People in Brownhills, Walsall, West Midlands.\n* Sandra Irwin, Mrs. Davies. For services to the community in Craven Arms, Shropshire.\n* Vanessa Marion, Mrs. Davies, Physiotherapist, Artificial Limb and Appliance Centre, Morriston Hospital, Swansea. For services to Healthcare.\n* Barbara Jane, Mrs. Davis. For services to Young People in Buckinghamshire.\n* Ian Davis. For services to the House of Commons.\n* Eric George Dawkins. For services to the community in Penryn and Falmouth, Cornwall.\n* Terence Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Victoria, Mrs. Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ms Ilene Daisy Ming\\-Deans. For services to Clapham Youth Centre, Lambeth, London.\n* Sister Lynda Dearlove. For services to Vulnerable Women.\n* Sarinder Kaur, Mrs. Dev, Constable, South Yorkshire Police. For services to the Police.\n* Achhar Paul Dharni. For services to Business and to the community in Bradford, West Yorkshire.\n* Gwyneth Muriel, Mrs. Dickinson, President, Macular Disease Society. For services to Visually Impaired People.\n* Valerie Anne, Mrs. Dilcock. For services to the North York Moors National Park Authority.\n* Ronald Dodd, Chairman, Training and Development Resource Ltd, Tyneside. For services to Skills.\n* Ian Henry Donaghey. For services to Regeneration in Coleraine, Northern Ireland.\n* Mary Maya, Mrs. Donelan. For services to the community in Hammersmith and Fulham, London.\n* Ms Norah Donnelly. For public service.\n* Jennifer, Mrs. Doolan. Harpist. For services to Music.\n* Muriel Margaret, Mrs. Douglas, Manager, Scottish NHS Central Register, General Register Office for Scotland, Scottish Executive.\n* Dr. Andrew Frank Dove. For services to St. John Ambulance Brigade in Nottinghamshire.\n* Carol Ann, Mrs. Downes, Divisional Officer, Derbyshire Special Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Ray Downey. For charitable services to Sunderland Kidney Patient Group.\n* John Ernest Drake, lately Chief Executive, YMCA Norfolk. For services to Young People.\n* Alan Gordon Drinkall. For services to the community In North Yorkshire.\n* Councillor Elizabeth Ann Ducker, Leader, South Oxfordshire District Council. For services to Local Government.\n* David John Duke, Principal Technician, Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge. For services to Science.\n* Karen, Mrs. Duncan, Senior Executive Officer, Student Finance Policy, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.\n* William Duncan. For services to Horticulture in Scotland.\n* Miss Elizabeth Dunlop. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Scotland.\n* Terrance Dunne. For voluntary service to St. Andrew's Hospice, Airdrie, Lanarkshire.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Dupres. For services to St. Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Egham, Surrey.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Eaglefield. For charitable services in Derbyshire.\n* Eric James Eames. For services to the community in Birmingham.\n* Ewan Easton. For voluntary service to H.M. Young Offenders' Institution, Thorn Cross, Warrington, Cheshire.\n* The Reverend Mark Antony Edwards. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the North East.\n* Gillian, Mrs. Elkins. For services to the community in Clacton\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Miss Susan Ellis, lately Principal Officer, South East Area, National Offender Management Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Miss Cathryn Ellsmore, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence. Dr. John Richard England. For services to Retail Planning.\n* Eileen, Mrs. Entwistle. For services to Local Government and to the community in Darwen and Blackburn, Lancashire.\n* Geraint Evans. For voluntary service to Education in the Vale of Glamorgan.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Evans, lately Administrative Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Thomas Eurfyl Evans, Councillor, Ceredigion County Council. For services to Local Government in West Wales.\n* [Timothy Everest](/wiki/Timothy_Everest \"Timothy Everest\"), Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Fairbrother, Senior Probation Officer, Sussex Probation Area. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Kelly, Mrs. Fairman. For services to the Fire and Rescue Service.\n* Donald Fava, lately Business and Performance Reporting Manager, Finance and Operations Directorate, Department of Health.\n* Janis Elizabeth, Mrs. Feely, Founder and Project Director, Living Room, Stevenage, Hertfordshire. For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Ms Ann Ferguson. For services to Older People in Scotland.\n* Ms Margaret Hilary Ferriman, Chair, Banbury District Racial Equality Council. For services to Community Relations.\n* Ms Deirdre Figueiredo, Director of Craftspace. For services to the Visual Arts in the West Midlands.\n* Lyndon Filer, Chief Executive, Police Rehabilitation Centre, Goring\\-on\\-Thames. For services to the Police.\n* Michael Peter Findley. For charitable services in Redcar, Cleveland.\n* Dr. Doreen Elizabeth Finneron. For services to Inter\\-Faith Relations.\n* Peggy Rita, Mrs. Finnie. For services to the community in Aberdeen.\n* Peter James Fisher, Policy Adviser, Office of the Judge Advocate\\-General, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Honor Wilson\\-Fletcher, lately Director, National Year of Reading. For services to Education.\n* Anthony Fowler. For services to the community in Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire.\n* Dereck Fowles, lately Chairman, Forth Valley and Lomond Local Action Group. For services to Rural Communities in Scotland.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Fox. For voluntary service to Deeside Community Hospital League of Friends, North Wales.\n* Jennifer Lesley, Mrs. Foxon, Senior Technician, Department of Genetics, University of Leicester. For services to Science.\n* David Victor Freeborn. For services to the Patterdale Mountain Rescue Team in the Lake District.\n* Peter French, Deputy Chairman, London Board of Crimestoppers. For services to the Police.\n* Timothy Enis French. For services to the community in Haywards Heath, West Sussex.\n* Pino Frumiento, Singer and Songwriter, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.\n* Dr. Ian David Robert Fry, Director, Partnership Pathology, Frimley Park Hospital NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare in the South East.\n* Michael Fuller. For services to the NHS and to the Unite Trade Union in Scotland.\n* Richard Gagan, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Irene Lorraine, Mrs. Galloway, lately Caseworker, Customer Operation, Lisburn, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Sarah Elizabeth, Mrs. Gamble. For services to the community in County Antrim.\n* Stuart Mitchell Gay, J.P. For services to the community in Lancashire and Overseas.\n* Mary Helen, Mrs. George, Catering Supervisor, Crossroads Primary School, Keith. For services to Education.\n* Asquith Gibbes. For voluntary service to the Police in South East London.\n* Henry Atherton Derek Gibson. For services to the community in Bridgwater, Somerset.\n* Mary, Mrs. Gibson. For services to Education and to the community in North London.\n* Robert Stewart Gibson, Officer, H.M. Prison Gartree, Leicestershire, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Margaret Helen, Mrs. Gilbert. For services to Older People in County Tyrone.\n* Atma Singh Gill. For services to the community in the North East.\n* Joy, Mrs. Gillies. For voluntary service to the Children's Panel in Scotland.\n* Bernard John Godding. For voluntary service to Adult Learning and the Educational Centres Association.\n* Alan John Godfrey, Publisher of Historic Ordnance Survey Maps. For services to Heritage.\n* Professor [Michael Goodfellow](/wiki/Michael_Goodfellow \"Michael Goodfellow\"), Chairman of Governors, Gosforth High School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Gow. For services to Regional Journalism.\n* Ms Agnes Graham. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Western Scotland.\n* Dr. Maria Jadwiga Dlugolecka\\-Graham. For services to Polish\\-Scottish Relations and to Medicine.\n* Robert Oliver David Graham, lately Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Barbara, Mrs. Grant, Clinical Nurse Manager, NHS Fife. For services to Ophthalmology.\n* [Clemency Anne Rose, Mrs. Gray](/wiki/Rose_Gray \"Rose Gray\"), Co\\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* William Gray. For services to Diversity and to Disability Training in Scotland.\n* Angela Margaret, Mrs. Green. For charitable services Overseas and in Malvern, Worcestershire.\n* Charles Anthony Green. For voluntary service to Industrial Heritage in the Staffordshire Potteries.\n* Susan, Mrs. Greenwood, Specialist Community Public Health Nurse, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly. For services to Healthcare.\n* David Grey, Group Managing Director, OSL Group Holdings Ltd. For services to Business and to Regeneration in Sheffield.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Grice, Chief Executive, South Yorkshire Community Foundation. For services to Flood Relief.\n* Joan, Mrs. Griffiths. For services to People with Learning Disabilities in Scotland.\n* Mary Beatrice, Mrs. Guest. For services to People with Sensory Impairment.\n* Mavis Ann, Mrs. Gunning. For voluntary service to Victims of Sexual Assault.\n* Gordon William Guthrie. For services to Derby County Football Club.\n* Ms Anna\\-Marie Hale (Mrs. Byrne), Matron, Division One Trauma and Orthopaedics, Selly Oak Hospital, Birmingham. For services to Healthcare.\n* Colonel Alan Edmund Hall, T.D., D.L. For services to the community in the London Borough of Redbridge.\n* Iain Murray Halliday. For services to the Arts in Perth.\n* David Halpin. For services to disabled people in the North West.\n* Pauline Jane, Mrs. Handy, Clinical Lead Nurse, Genito\\-Urinary Medicine, Newcastle General Hospital. For services to Healthcare.\n* Frank Hannah, President, Manchester County Football Association. For services to Sport.\n* Ms Belinda Harding, Constable, City of London Police. For services to the Police.\n* Gillian Carol, Mrs. Hardy, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* [Terence Harris](/wiki/Jet_Harris \"Jet Harris\"). For services to Music.\n* Ms Karen Harrison, Head, Business Crime Preventions Team, Wakefield Partnership. For services to the Police.\n* Peter Brantford Hartland. For services to the community in Ashton Keynes, Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Colin Hartley. For services to the community in Halifax, West Yorkshire.\n* Faith Ingrid Evelyn, Mrs. Harvey. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire.\n* Ms Susan Harvey. For services to Orienteering and to the community in Doune and Deanston, Perth and Kinross.\n* Margaret Lynne, Mrs. Harwood, Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Margaret Vine, Mrs. Haugh, Adviser for Creative and Expressive Studies, Southern Education and Library Board. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Jean, Mrs. Hayley. Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.\n* Rodney James Hayley, Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.\n* Lewis Charles Haywood. For services to the Energy Learning Centre, Elliot Durham School, Nottingham.\n* Professor John William Stanley Hearle. For services to Archaeology in Mellor, Stockport, Greater Manchester.\n* Jean, Mrs. Heath. For services to Chadlington Primary School, Oxfordshire.\n* Roberta, Mrs. Heavens. For services to the Tourism Industry.\n* Jean Marion Anne, Mrs. Hedley. For voluntary service to Nature Conservation in Hampshire and the Isle of Wight.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Heeley. For voluntary service to Somerset Rural Life Museum.\n* Ms [Anna Hemmings](/wiki/Anna_Hemmings \"Anna Hemmings\"), Canoeist. For services to Sport.\n* John Graham Hemmings, Chairman, Blurton Ladsandads, Stoke\\-on\\-Trent. For services to Grass Roots Football.\n* John Patrick Hennigan, Superintendent, British Transport Police. For services to the Police.\n* Miss Sylvia Jean Herbert, Chaplain, H.M. Prison Leicester. For services to Prisoners.\n* John Coleman Hick, Vice\\-President, British Holiday and Home Parks Association. For services to the Tourist Industry.\n* Major Antony Stanley Hill. For services to Military Heritage in Essex.\n* Lyn Joy, Mrs. Hill, Band 5, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Richard Wendle Hill, Branch Manager, Ulster Bank. For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Hillman. For services to Girlguiding Cymru and to the Community of Hope.\n* Christopher Hilton, lately General Manager, Odeon Leicester Square Cinema. For services to the Film Industry.\n* Barry Hitchcock, Director of Sport, University of Surrey. For services to Sport and to Higher Education.\n* Raymond Hodgkinson, Director\\-General, British Healthcare Trades Association. For services to the Healthcare Industry.\n* Linda Mary, Mrs. Hoggarth. For services to disabled people in Suffolk.\n* Ms Jean Florence Holder. For voluntary service to the Women's Library.\n* Miss Rhiannon Sarah Holder. For services to Young People's Healthcare.\n* Valerie Lois, Mrs. Holt. For services to Fisheries Management and to Conservation.\n* Lady Lavinia Caroline Douglas\\-Home, D.L. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross and Macmillan Cancer Support in the Scottish Borders.\n* Michael John Hopper, lately Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Douglas Horrill. For voluntary service to Age Concern, New Forest East, Hampshire.\n* Doreen Grace, Mrs. Hosey. For services to the community in Fawley, Southampton.\n* Ms Rebecca Ann Hosking. For services to the Environment in Modbury, Dorset.\n* Donna Maria, Mrs. Hough, Dental Workforce Development Lead for Dental Care Professionals, North Western and Mersey Postgraduate Deaneries. For services to Healthcare.\n* Edward Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.\n* Winifred, Mrs. Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.\n* Ms Sheila Hudson. For services to Disadvantaged Young People in Hartlepool.\n* Joe Human. For services to Oxfam and to Fair Trade in Cumbria.\n* Brenda, Mrs. Hunt. For services to Older People in East Manchester.\n* Carl Peter Hunt, Watch Manager, Humberside Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.\n* Alderman Edna, Lady Hunter. For services to the community in County Durham.\n* The Reverend Canon Michael Oram Hunter. For services to the Church of England and to the community in Grimsby.\n* Professor John Margarson Huthnance, Deputy Director, Proudman Oceanographic Laboratory. For services to Marine Science.\n* Dr. Thomas George Hyde. For services to the community in Repton, Derbyshire.\n* Brian Ibell, lately Assistant Chief Executive, Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Andrew Ingram, Executive Officer, Output Services Group, Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, Swansea, Department for Transport.\n* Peter David John Ingram. For services to Paper Making Industrial Heritage.\n* James John Jack. For services to Children and Young People at Kibble Education and Care Centre.\n* Mona, Mrs. Jack. For services to the community in Dumfries.\n* Florence, Mrs. Jackson. For voluntary service to Hatton Hill Primary School, Sefton, Merseyside.\n* Valerie, Mrs. Jackson, Founder and Principal, Stage 84\\. For services to the Performing Arts in the North.\n* Valerie Hazel, Mrs. Jackson. For services to the community in Newcastle Emlyn, Carmarthenshire.\n* [John Alexander Jameson](/wiki/John_Jameson_%28cricketer%29 \"John Jameson (cricketer)\"). For services to cricket.\n* Waltraud Anna Luise, Mrs. Jarrold. For services to the community in Norwich.\n* Susan Kay, Mrs. Jay, Area Manager, West Suffolk MIND. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Helen Adair, Mrs. Jenkins. For services to the community in Durrington, Wiltshire.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Jenkins, Senior Case Adviser, Freedom of Information Team, H.M. Treasury.\n* Sidney Johnson. For services to the community in Helston, Cornwall.\n* John Johnstone, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Henry Jones, Project Manager, ISIS Second Target Station, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Oxfordshire. For services to Science.\n* Jane Eryl, Mrs. Jones, lately Senior Nurse, Eryri Hospital, Caernarfon. For services to Healthcare for Older People.\n* Penelope, Mrs. Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ronald Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.\n* Charles Ernest Jukes. For services to the community in Dursley, Gloucestershire.\n* Ms Maureen Kavanagh, Messenger, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Kay, Co\\-Founder and Project Leader, Bolton University of the Third Age. For voluntary service to Adult Education.\n* Bernard John Keay, Chairman, Health and Social Security Recreational Association, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Virginia Anne Pickering, Mrs. Keen. For services to the community in Wiltshire.\n* Victor Walter Keene. For services to the community in Coventry.\n* William Ernest James Kelley. For voluntary service to the RAF Halton Apprentices' Association.\n* Patricia Alexandra, Mrs. Kelly. Foster Carer, Cornwall. For services to Children and Families.\n* Graham Kennedy. For charitable services to People with [Friedreich's ataxia](/wiki/Friedreich%27s_ataxia \"Friedreich's ataxia\").\n* Miss Linda Margaret Kennedy, Manager, Banqueting House, Whitehall. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Anne, Mrs. Kenyon, Administrative Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Hilary, Mrs. Kerr. For services to Children and Young People with Special Needs in Warrington, Cheshire.\n* Dr. David John Kerridge, Head of Science, Earth Hazards and Earth Systems Science, British Geological Survey. For services to Geophysics.\n* Ms Imtaz Khaliq, Designer and Master Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Ms Shahda Khan, Principal Community Cohesion Officer, Middlesbrough Council. For services to Local Government and to Diversity.\n* Ms [Catherine Isabel Audrey Kidston](/wiki/Cath_Kidston \"Cath Kidston\"), Founder and Creative Director, Cath Kidston. For services to Business.\n* Patrick Kieran, Senior Design Engineer. For services to Science.\n* Anne Elizabeth, Mrs. King, Director, Building Services Research and Information Association. For services to Industry.\n* Debra Ann, Mrs. King, Chair, Thornhill New Deal for Communities. For services to the community in Southampton, Hampshire.\n* Jacqueline, Mrs. Upton\\-King, Chair, Management Team, SturQuest Community Partnership. For services to the community in Sturminster Newton, Dorset.\n* Brenda Patricia, Mrs. Kirby. For services to the community in Croydon.\n* Ms Marjorie Kirk. For voluntary service to H.M. Prison Nottingham.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Kirkwood. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms Anna Kucewicz (Mrs. Lee\\-Potter). For voluntary service to the Polish Scouting Association, Girl Scouts Division (UK).\n* Paul Lambert, Chairman, Derbyshire Family Association. For services to Maritime Safety.\n* John Lewis George Lamotte. For voluntary service to Animal Welfare in Scotland.\n* Gabriel Lancaster. For services to the community in Medway, Kent.\n* Miss Irene Langlands. For services to Dance in Central Scotland.\n* Huw John Launder, Senior Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Derek Law, Corporate Director, Adult and Community Services, North Yorkshire County Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ronald Lawrence. For services to the Police and to the community in Nottinghamshire.\n* Miss Kathleen Lawrenson, Diagnostic Audiologist, St. Helens and Knowsley Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Sheila Irene, Mrs. Layton, Founder, Contessa Riding Centre, Hertfordshire. For services to Equestrian Sport.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Lee, Chief Executive, Cresco Trust. For services to Social Enterprise in Northern Ireland.\n* Bryan Lewin, lately Head of Trading Standards, Northamptonshire County Council. For services to Consumers and to Business.\n* Miss Judith Anne Lewis. For services to the Environment in the North East.\n* Councillor Leonard Lewis. For services to Local Government and to the community in Caerphilly, South Wales.\n* Neil Lewis. For services to Industrial Heritage and to the community in Blaenavon, Torfaen.\n* David Robin Littlewood. For voluntary service to Athletics.\n* Dr. Stephen Nicholas Liversedge, General Medical Practitioner, Bolton. For services to Healthcare.\n* Wesley Courtney Livingstone, President, Newry Musical and Orchestral Society. For services to Music and to the community in County Down.\n* Mary Constance, Mrs. Lloyd. For services to the community in Rutland.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Lockett. For services to the community of Ackworth, West Yorkshire.\n* Arthur Clifford Lockyear. For services to the community in Sunderland.\n* Ian Douglas Loe, Wildlife Stamp Designer. For services to Art.\n* Jeffrey Long. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion.\n* Ronald Hedley Longford, Chiropractor and Physiotherapist. For services to Animal Welfare.\n* Carmel, Mrs. Lyddall, Executive Assistant, Local Government and Regional Policy Team, Department of Health.\n* Alexander McKay Lynch. Group Finance Director, David MacBrayne Ltd, Gourock. For services to Transport and Charity in Scotland.\n* Ms Ann MacKay, Policy Adviser, English Community Care Association. For services to Social Care.\n* Professor [Margaret MacLean](/wiki/Margaret_MacLean \"Margaret MacLean\"), Professor of Pulmonary Pharmacology. For services to Science.\n* Geraldine, Mrs. MacPhee, Principal Teacher in Home Economics, Clyde Valley High School. For services to Education and to the community in North Lanarkshire.\n* Sydney Mair. For services to Local Government and to the community in Macduff, Aberdeenshire.\n* Jean Isabella, Mrs. Malkin. For services to Young People in the Cartmel Peninsula, Cumbria.\n* Edna, Mrs. March. For services to the community in Crook, County Durham.\n* Kenneth Marsh, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.\n* Michael Thomas Martin. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Reading, Berkshire.\n* Stuart Andrew Martin. For services to the community in Ripon, North Yorkshire.\n* William Martin, Chairman, H. and J. Martin Ltd. For services to the Construction Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Philip Mason. For services to disabled people in Hampshire.\n* Ms Valerie Mason (Mrs. Hendry). For services to the British Heart Foundation.\n* Hilary, Mrs. Massarella. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged Young People in South Yorkshire.\n* George Lewis Mathias. For services to Agriculture.\n* [Catriona, Mrs. Matthew](/wiki/Catriona_Matthew \"Catriona Matthew\"). For services to Golf.\n* Edwin Alexander Maxwell. For services to the New Art Exchange and to the community in Nottingham.\n* Denise Jane, Mrs. May, Director of Sport and Assistant Headteacher, Budehaven Community School, Cornwall. For services to Education.\n* Leslie Holden McAdoo, Chairman, Ballyclare Committee, Macmillan Cancer Support. For charitable services in Northern Ireland.\n* Margaret Mary, Mrs. McCluskie, Manager, Major Investigation Team, Identity and Passport Service, Home Office.\n* William McCrory. For services to Children with Cancer in Northern Ireland.\n* Helen Muir, Mrs. McDonald. For services to the community in Crieff, Perthshire.\n* Ken McElroy. For services to the Tourist Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Jean, Mrs. McEwen. For services to the community in Norwich.\n* Peter McFall, Janitor, St. Peter 's Primary School, Dumbarton, West Dunbartonshire. For services to Education.\n* Dr. David Douglas Murray McGavin, Ophthalmologist. For services to Eye Care in Developing Countries.\n* Andrew Fraser McKay, Detective Superintendent, Strathclyde Police Force. For services to the Police.\n* Ms Annie McKean, Senior Lecturer in Drama, University of Winchester. For services to Higher Education.\n* Fiona Mary, Mrs. McLean, Grade C2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Terrence McLernon. For services to Table Tennis and to the community in Drumchapel, Glasgow.\n* Ms Melanie Justine McLoughlin. For services to the Devon Community Foundation.\n* Ivan Lewis McMichael. For services to Journalism in Northern Ireland.\n* Dr. Mary Brigeen McNee, General Medical Practitioner, Glasgow. For voluntary service to Cancer Research and to Healthcare in Lourdes.\n* Alexander Ian McNeill, Administration Officer, Customer Operations, Thornaby, Cleveland, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Marian, Mrs. McNeir. For services to the community In Bath.\n* Marjory, Mrs. McQueen. For services to the community In Lockerbie, Dumfries and Galloway.\n* Dr. Noel Henri Joseph Meeke. For voluntary service to Herefordshire Waterworks Museum.\n* David Melrose, Chairman, Scottish Prison Officers' Association, Scottish Executive.\n* Jean, Mrs. Messenger. For services to the After School Club, Bude, Cornwall.\n* Faruk Miah, Programme Manager, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education and to the community in Leeds.\n* Moira Sheelagh, Mrs. Michelmore. For services to the community in Sidmouth, Devon.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Milburn, Chair, West Suffolk College Corporation. For services to Further Education and to the community in Suffolk.\n* [Frederick Roy Millar](/wiki/Roy_Millar \"Roy Millar\"), Director of Coaching, Irish Football Association. For services to Youth Football in Northern Ireland.\n* Ian Duncan Millar. For services to Agriculture in Scotland.\n* Patrick Millard. For services to the charity Taxhelp for Older People.\n* Katherine, Mrs. Miller, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Marcia Anne, Mrs. Miller. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross Society in Cambridgeshire.\n* Gerald David Mills. For services to School Sport in Nottinghamshire.\n* Laura, Mrs. Mitchell, Consultant Orthodontist and Clinical Lead, St Luke's Hospital Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Nasrullah Khan Moghal. For services to Community Relations in Manchester.\n* Michael Monaghan. For charitable services to Ex\\- Service Men and Women.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Montgomery. For charitable services in Northern Ireland and Overseas.\n* Roger Ivan Moore. For services to the community in Potters Bar, Hertfordshire.\n* Christopher Morgan, Security Manager, Aberafan Shopping Centre. For services to the community in Neath Port Talbot.\n* Daphne, Mrs. Morgan. For voluntary service to Hertfordshire Constabulary and to Feltham Young Offenders' Institution.\n* John Francis Morgan. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Newcastle, County Down.\n* Alderman Peter James Morgan. For services to the community in Sittingbourne, Kent.\n* Heather Dalton, Mrs. Morris, School Crossing Warden, Sale, Cheshire. For services to Education.\n* Helen Elizabeth, Mrs. Morris. Crown Advocate, Merseyside and Cheshire Group, Crown Prosecution Service.\n* John Harold Morris. For services to the Post Office.\n* Thomas Geraint Morris. For services to the NHS and to the community in Dersingham, Norfolk.\n* Nigel Peter Morse, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Keith Hedley Moss, President, Bradford Cricket League and Pudsey St. Lawrence Cricket Club. For voluntary service to Sport.\n* Maureen Anne, Mrs. Muckle, Chair, Batchley First School, Redditch. For services to Education and to the community in North Worcestershire.\n* [Maurice Harrison Murphy](/wiki/Maurice_Murphy_%28musician%29 \"Maurice Murphy (musician)\"). Trumpeter. For services to Music.\n* Janice Elizabeth, Mrs. Naylor. For services to Swimming.\n* Peter David Needham, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Terence Charles Nelson, Security Officer, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education.\n* Harold Newman. For services to the community in Mill Hill, London.\n* Gilda, Mrs. Newsham. For voluntary service to the Alzheimer's Society, New Forest, Hampshire.\n* Fionnuala Eileen, Mrs. Newton, Executive Administrative Assistant, Queen's University Belfast. For services to Higher Education.\n* Vicky, Mrs. Norman, Senior Executive Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Sheila Maureen, Mrs. O'Neill. For services to Music in Ackworth, West Yorkshire.\n* Valerie Ann, Mrs. O'Riordan. For services to the community in Berkshire.\n* Barbara, Mrs. Oakes, Manager, High Street Library. For services to Local Government in Bolton.\n* Marjorie Frances, Mrs. Oaten. For voluntary service to People with Eating Disorders.\n* Margaret May, Mrs. Oatey. For services to the community in East Anglia.\n* Stella, Mrs. Okeahialam, Programme Director, Croydon Enterprise. For service to Business.\n* Michael Joseph Rolfe Orbell. For services to the Scouts in Wimbledon and Merton, London.\n* Noel George Ormrod, lately Chairman, Wallasey Arts Council. For services to the Arts in Merseyside.\n* Alexander Orr, Craftsman, Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Scotland.\n* Arnold Jenkin Owen. For services to the community in Blackmill, Bridgend and to Welsh International Brigaders.\n* Margaret Mcalister, Mrs. Owen. For services to the community in Shrewsbury, Shropshire.\n* Ms Margaret Paisley, College Manager, Elmwood College, Residence and Student Union. For services to Further Education in Fife.\n* Margaret Frances Elizabeth, Mrs. Palmer. For public service.\n* Ms Lydia Joy Parbury. For services to People with Special Needs and Disabilities.\n* Dorothy Mary, Mrs. Parker, Community Support Worker, West Wirral Community Mental Health Team. For services to Healthcare.\n* John Bywell Parker. For voluntary service to the Hadrian Trust in the North East.\n* Ann Rosemary, Mrs. Parr, Community Care Development Manager, Age Concern, Woodley. For services to Older People in Berkshire.\n* Rabindara Nath Pathak, Chairman of Governors, Featherstone High School, Ealing, London. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Trevor James Patton, Principal Nursing Officer, Northern Ireland Prison Service.\n* Margaret Elsie, Mrs. Perfect. For voluntary service to the Boys' Brigade in Watford, Hertfordshire.\n* Alderman Fred Perry. For services to the community in Tipton, West Midlands.\n* Joan, Mrs. Phillips. For voluntary service to the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester.\n* [Roger Phillips](/wiki/Roger_Phillips_%28photographer%29 \"Roger Phillips (photographer)\"). For services to London Garden Squares.\n* [Jean Catherine, Mrs. Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Pickering \"Jean Pickering\"). For services to Athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.\n* Alice Kirsty, Lady Pilkington. For voluntary service to Willowbrook Hospice, St. Helens and Knowsley, Merseyside.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Pilkington, Director, Children's Services, Walsall Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Robert Michael Pittilo](/wiki/Mike_Pittilo \"Mike Pittilo\"), Principal and Vice\\-Chancellor, Robert Gordon University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. Jaswant Kaur Jutley\\-Plested, Manager, Sydenham Children's Centre, Bridgwater, Somerset. For services to Children.\n* Peter Pocock. For services to Workplace First Aid Training.\n* Miss Rashmi Amritlal Popat, Executive Officer, Work Welfare and Equality Group, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Ms Prudence Alexine Regina Porretta. For services to Community Cohesion and to the Tourist Industry in Coventry.\n* Iain David Russell Prain, Vice\\-Principal, Royal Blind School, Craigmillar Park, Edinburgh. For services to Education.\n* [Stephen Prescott](/wiki/Steve_Prescott \"Steve Prescott\"). For services to Rugby League and to Charity.\n* Gres, Mrs. Pritchard, Peripatetic Music Teacher, Ynys Mon. For services to Education.\n* The Reverend Dr. Jean Prosser. For services to Conservation and to the community in Monmouthshire.\n* Isabel, Mrs. Quinliven, Founder, Caring Canines. For services to Older People in Northern Ireland.\n* Brenda, Mrs. Quinn, Service Manager, Recovery Services, Belfast Health and Social Care Trust. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Toaha Bashir Zulqarnain Qureshi. For services to Community Relations in Stockwell, South West London.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Raine, Office Manager, English Language Teaching Unit, University of Leicester. For services to Higher Education.\n* Dr. Kathleen Rankin. For voluntary service to the Living Linen Project in Northern Ireland.\n* Mohamad Rashied, President, Caribbean Islamic Cultural Society. For services to Community Relations in London.\n* Robert David Richard Ray. For services to Rugby Union and to Young People in Rugby, Warwickshire.\n* Ms Janet Mary Reed, Senior Social Worker, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.\n* Angela Mary, Mrs. Rees, Assistant Head, Debt Management and Banking, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Abdul Rehman. For services to the community in Derby.\n* Miss Marion Reynolds. For services to Vulnerable Children in Northern Ireland.\n* Alan Ribchester. For charitable services in the City of Durham.\n* The Reverend James Manson Richards. For services to Children and Families.\n* George Edmund Richardson, lately Chairman, Calderdale College and Chairman, Association of Colleges, Yorkshire and the Humber Region. For voluntary service to Further Education.\n* Miss Rosalyn Elizabeth Richardson, lately Deputy Director of Health Informatics, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.\n* [Andrew William Ritchie](/wiki/Andrew_Ritchie_%28Brompton%29 \"Andrew Ritchie (Brompton)\"), Technical Director, Brompton Bicycle Ltd. For services to Business and to International Trade.\n* Christopher David Medwyn Roberts. For services to the community in Merseyside.\n* Clarissa Elizabeth, Mrs. Roberts. For services to Older People in Stratford\\-upon\\-Avon, Warwickshire.\n* Jean Sylvia, Mrs. Roberts, Ministerial Messenger, Department for Transport.\n* Peter Adrian Roberts, Chairman, Association of Community Rail Partnerships. For services to Rural Transport.\n* Angus John Robertson, Principal Fellow in Clinical Illustration, Leeds Dental Institute. For services to Healthcare.\n* Matthew Robertson, Sergeant, Ministry of Defence Police.\n* Norman Robertson, lately Curriculum Leader in Hospitality, Ayr College. For services to Further Education.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Robinson. For services to the community in Trimdon, County Durham.\n* The Reverend Father George Edward Robson, Chairman, North Huyton New Deal for Communities Board. For services to the community in Merseyside.\n* Ms Jennifer Van Krieken Robson, Head of Minority Achievement Service, Kent County Council. For services to Education.\n* Sheila Ruth, Mrs. Rodmell. For services to the community in Elvington, Kent.\n* Ms Susan Rogers. For services to Trade Unions.\n* [Ruth Lady Rogers of Riverside](/wiki/Ruth_Rogers \"Ruth Rogers\"), Chef and Co\\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* William Andrew Taylor Roulston. For services to Equestrian Sport in Northern Ireland.\n* Beryl Lillian, Mrs. Rowe. For services to the community in Lilley, Bedfordshire.\n* Dr. Christopher Giles Rowland. For services to the Friends of the Oncology and Radiotherapy Centre, Exeter.\n* John Rowlands, Economics Teacher, John Ruskin Sixth Form College, Croydon, London. For services to Education.\n* Marion, Mrs. Roy, lately Headteacher, Auchenback Primary School, East Renfrewshire. For services to Education.\n* Colonel John Anthony Nutter Read Royle. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northamptonshire.\n* [Chrissie, Mrs. Rucker](/wiki/Chrissie_Rucker \"Chrissie Rucker\"), Founder and Creative Director, White Company. For services to the Retail Industry.\n* Anthony Michael Hurst Rumsey, Collections Manager, National Monuments Record. For services to Photography.\n* Annette, Mrs. Rushton, lately Matron, Severn Hospice, Shrewsbury. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. Andrew Oldrey Russell, lately Chairman, League of Friends, Edenbridge and District War Memorial Hospital. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ezriel Salomon. For services to the community in Gateshead, Tyne and Wear.\n* Ahmed Ali Sasso, Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For services to the Police.\n* Mary Ann Landsborough, Mrs. Saunders. For services to the Diocese of Oxford and to the Church of England.\n* Ms Susan Saunders, Co\\-Ordinator, Disability Support Network, Home Office.\n* Keith Savage. For voluntary service to the Air Training Corps in Rutland.\n* Lynn, Mrs. Savill. For services to People with Epilepsy in Gravesend, Kent.\n* Ms Cherryl Lynn Sawyer, Business and Development Director, Threshold Housing Link. For services to Homeless People in Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Callie, Mrs. Saxty, lately Head of Visitor Operations for Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, English Heritage. For services to Heritage.\n* Nora Gladys Elsie, Mrs. Schneider. For services to the community in Newbury, Berkshire.\n* Robert Sinclair Scott. For voluntary service to the community in County Armagh.\n* The Reverend Christopher John Sears. For services to Disadvantaged People in Hastings, East Sussex.\n* Dr. Claude Doumet Serhal, Special Assistant, British Museum. For services to Archaeology.\n* Thomas Richard Sermon, Chairman, London Youth. For services to Young People.\n* Terence Brian Shead. For services to the community in East Peckham, Kent.\n* Alan William Sherriff. For services to the community in South Yorkshire.\n* Ann, Mrs. Shreeve, Senior Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Jasvinder Singh Sidhu. For services to Social Housing.\n* Phillip Edward Sillick, J.P. For services to the community in Gorseinon, Swansea.\n* Benjamin David Simpson, J.P. For services to the community in Oxford.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Simpson. For services to the community in Moston, Manchester.\n* [Lemn Sissay](/wiki/Lemn_Sissay \"Lemn Sissay\"), Poet and Performer. For services to Literature.\n* John William Skinner, Director of Music, Haberdashers' Aske's Hatcham College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.\n* Catherine, Mrs. Slow. For services to West Exmoor Federation of Schools, Devon.\n* Alison Mary, Mrs. Smedley. For services to Inland Waterways.\n* Amanda Jane, Mrs. Smith, Executive Assistant, Youth Task Force Strategy, Department for Children, Schools and Families.\n* Dr. Angela Owen\\-Smith. For services to Medicine and to the community in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire.\n* Miss Charlotte Lilian Smith. For services to the community in Porthyrhyd, Carmarthenshire.\n* Colin Smith, Retained Crew Manager, West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Smith, Vice\\-Chair and Board Member, Colchester Institute. For voluntary service to Further and Higher Education.\n* Ian Graham Smith. For services to the community in Ramsbury, Wiltshire.\n* James Smith. For voluntary service to Youth Football in Glasgow.\n* Eric Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Mary, Mrs. Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Dr. Richard Alfred Sparks, lately Consultant in Genito\\-Urinary Medicine, Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust. For services to Medicine.\n* Councillor Josephine Elizabeth Spencer. For services to the community in Christchurch, Dorset.\n* Dr. Richard Anthony Spencer, Biology Subject Leader, SRC Bede Sixth Form, Billingham, Teesside. For services to Science Communication.\n* Sally Louise, Mrs. Hughes\\-Stanton, Executive Secretary, Prime Minister's Office.\n* Roger Carlton Steele. For services to Young People in Sheffield.\n* Cheryl, Mrs. Stevens, Principal Practitioner, Benefits and Credits, Preston, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Mary, Mrs. Stevens. For services to the community in Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Edward Craig Stevenson, lately Engineer of Medical Physics, University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare and to Charity.\n* Karen, Mrs. Stock, Extended Schools Co\\-ordinator, Shoeburyness and Chair of Governors, Shoeburyness High School, Essex. For services to Education.\n* Rodney Ernest Stoddart. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Tayside.\n* Eric Arthur Stott. For services to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Janet, Mrs. Stoyel. For services to the Textile Industry.\n* Miss Judith Anne Strange, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Councillor Phyllis Zaphne Stretton. For services to the community in Cannock, Staffordshire.\n* Ivy Alberta, Mrs. Sturgeon, Personal Secretary, H.M. Prison Littlehey, Huntingdon, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Rozelle Elizabeth, Mrs. Sutherland. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence in Jersey.\n* Roderick John Symonds. For services to the community in Reading, Berkshire.\n* Ranjula, Mrs. Takodra. For services to the community in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire.\n* Gwynneth Mary, Mrs. Tame. For services to Heritage and to the community of Dorchester\\-on\\-Thames in Oxfordshire.\n* Susan, Mrs. Tamlyn. For services to Heritage in Suffolk.\n* Miss [Samantha Claire Taylor](/wiki/Claire_Taylor \"Claire Taylor\"), Cricketer. For services to Sport.\n* James Graham Taylor, Music Director, City of Glasgow Chorus. For services to Music.\n* Josephine May, Mrs. Taylor. For services to the community in Plumpton Green, East Sussex.\n* Mary, Mrs. Thirlwell. For voluntary service to Young People in Lanarkshire.\n* Ms Melanie Anne Thody, Head of Outreach, Imperial College London. For services to Science Communication.\n* Margaret Jean, Mrs. Thomas, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Bristol.\n* Peter Thomas, lately Project Director Devonport, Interserve plc. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* Jonathan Bryan Thornes. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the East Midlands.\n* Gordon Owen Thornhill. For services to the community in Foston and Scropton, Derbyshire.\n* Angus Tilston. For services to the Historical Film Industry in the North West.\n* Thomas Todd. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Towning, Assistant Officer, Customer Contact, Shipley, West Yorkshire, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Maureen Ivy, Mrs. Townley. For charitable services in Southend\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Van Cuong Truong. For services to the Indo\\-Chinese community in South East London.\n* Evelyn Roberta, Mrs. Turkington. For voluntary service to The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Scheme in Northern Ireland.\n* [Mary Josephine, Mrs. Turner](/wiki/Mary_Turner_%28trade_unionist%29 \"Mary Turner (trade unionist)\"), President, GMB. For services to Trade Unions.\n* [Edward Jonathan Turpie](/wiki/Jonnie_Turpie \"Jonnie Turpie\"), Director, Maverick Television.\n* Dr. Alan Manson Turtle. For voluntary service to the community in Richhill, County Armagh.\n* Miss [Elizabeth Kimberley Tweddle](/wiki/Beth_Tweddle \"Beth Tweddle\"). For services to Gymnastics.\n* John Christopher Tyzack, Chairman of Governors, Enborne Church of England Primary School and Willow Primary School, Newbury, Berkshire. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Wendy Margaret, Mrs. Vaughan. For services to the community in South East Surrey.\n* Ronald Derek Vaulter. For services to the community in South Devon.\n* Christine, Mrs. Ruston\\-Wadsworth, Superintendent, Warwickshire Police. For services to the Police.\n* Julian Wadsworth. For services to Young People in Portsmouth.\n* Janice Irene, Mrs. Walker, Officer, H.M. Prison Wormwood Scrubs, London, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Walker, Chair of Governors, Cambo First School, Morpeth, Northumberland. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Gillian Karen, Mrs. Walnes (formerly Mrs. Bogush). For services to the Anne Frank Trust UK.\n* Joan Patricia, Mrs. Warwick. For charitable services to Darent Valley Hospital, Dartford, Kent.\n* Amir Waseem, Officer, Customer Contact, Brierley Hill, West Midlands, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Shirley Irene, Mrs. Watson. For services to the Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura Support Association.\n* The Reverend Canon Michael John Wedgeworth, lately Chairman of Governors, Blackburn College. For voluntary service to Further Education and to the communityin Lancashire.\n* Michael Edwin Weeding, Senior Officer, Customs and International, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* James Weir, Lecturer, Forth Valley College. For services to Further Education in Clackmannanshire.\n* David Anthony Westcott, J.P. For services to the community in Essex.\n* Audrey, Mrs. Wheeler. For voluntary service to Oxfam in St. Albans, Hertfordshire.\n* Norman Edward Whereat. For services to the community in Cirencester, Gloucestershire.\n* Hilary John White, Chairman of Governors, Willingdon Community School, Eastbourne, East Sussex. For voluntary service to Education.\n* John Samuel Byard White, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Somerset.\n* Nicholas Stephen Whitehouse. For services to the Building Industry.\n* David Widdowson. For services to Young People with Learning Disabilities in Chesterfield, Derbyshire.\n* Alan Bertram Wiggins. For services to the community in Clacton\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Philip Julian Wilde. For voluntary service to Young People in Lytham St Anne's, Lancashire.\n* Dr. Henry Austin Will. For voluntary service to Ford Park Cemetery Trust in Plymouth, Devon.\n* Doreen, Mrs. Willcocks. For services to Netball and to the community in Pinehurst, Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Paul Willgoss, Band 3, Chief Scientists' Advisory Group and Chairman, Disability Network, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Christopher Mark Williams, Director, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.\n* David Michael Williams. For services to the community in Flintshire.\n* Gwilym Alun Williams. For services to Sport for Young People in Wales.\n* Professor Robert Joseph Paton Williams. For services to the community in North Oxford.\n* Gerald Willmott, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.\n* Albert Leslie Wills, Q.F.S.M. For services to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Patrick Andrew John Wilson, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Sydney Wiltshire. For services to the community in Petersfield, Hampshire.\n* Andrew Nicholas Wood, Manager and Head Coach, Ipswich Gymnastics Centre. For services to Sport.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Woodcock, lately Non\\-Executive Director, Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Agnes Brown Marchbank, Mrs. Wright. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Stewartry of Kirkcudbright.\n* Clare Margaret, Mrs. Wright, Personal Assistant, Warwickshire College. For services to Further Education.\n* Richard Kelsey Wright, Chief Executive Officer, Intertius Ltd. For services to the Manufacturing Industry.\n* Beryl Joan, Mrs. Wyatt, Gardening Assistant, Writtle College, Chelmsford. For services to Higher Education.\n* Claire Judith, Mrs. Wylot, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Councillor Yogan Mylvaganam Yoganathan. For services to Local Government and to Community Relations in North Surrey.\n* Jeannie, Mrs. Young, For voluntary service to St. Richard's Hospice, Worcester.\n* Pauline Margaret, Mrs. Young. For voluntary service to disabled people in Wales.\n* Mavis, Mrs. Yuill, Classroom Assistant, Kilmartin Primary School, Argyll and Bute. For services to Education.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* [Christopher Barr](/wiki/Christopher_Barr \"Christopher Barr\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Paul William Bellamy](/wiki/Paul_William_Bellamy \"Paul William Bellamy\") – lately Entrance Clearance Manager, British Embassy, Iran.\n* [Steve Chandler](/wiki/Steve_Chandler \"Steve Chandler\") – lately Third Secretary, Counter\\-Narcotics, UK Provincial Reconstruction Team, Lashkar Gah.\n* [Jeanette Anne Coogan](/wiki/Jeanette_Coogan \"Jeanette Coogan\") – Manager, British Council English Training Centre, Al Azhar University in Cairo. For services to UK\\-Egypt intercultural relations.\n* [Rossalyn Demelza Crotty](/wiki/Rossalyn_Crotty \"Rossalyn Crotty\") – Vice\\-Consul/Deputy Head, British Consulate, Málaga, Spain.\n* [Dr. Margaret Cumberland](/wiki/Margaret_Cumberland \"Margaret Cumberland\") – Co\\-ordinator, Community Health. For services to community health care in Mozambique.\n* [Elyse Anne Dodgson](/wiki/Elyse_Dodgson \"Elyse Dodgson\") – Head, International Department, Royal Court Theatre, London. For services to international theatre, and to young writers overseas.\n* [Dr. Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan](/wiki/Alexander_Charles_Weeks_Duncan \"Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan\") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.\n* [Eleanor Frances Duncan](/wiki/Eleanor_Duncan \"Eleanor Duncan\") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.\n* [Michael Feeney](/wiki/Michael_Feeney%2C_MBE \"Michael Feeney, MBE\") – Founder, County Mayo Peace Park. For services to UK\\-Ireland relations.\n* [Anne Ferguson](/wiki/Anne_Ferguson_OBE \"Anne Ferguson OBE\") For services to older people in Scotland\n* [Judith Anne Ferris](/wiki/Judith_Ferris \"Judith Ferris\") – lately President, Age Concern, Costa Blanca. For services to the British elderly community in Alicante, Spain.\n* [Wendi Nixon Fiedler](/wiki/Wendi_Fiedler \"Wendi Fiedler\") – Founder and Manager, Panatel Production Company. For services to heritage conservation in Bermuda.\n* [Norman Keith Goodall](/wiki/Norman_Goodall \"Norman Goodall\") – For charitable activities and services to the community in Tenerife, Spain.\n* [Nicholas John Hancocks](/wiki/Nicholas_Hancocks \"Nicholas Hancocks\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Peter Anthony Hibbard](/wiki/Peter_Hibbard \"Peter Hibbard\") – President, Royal Asiatic Society. For services to heritage conservation in Shanghai, China.\n* [Garry Horlacher](/wiki/Garry_Horlacher \"Garry Horlacher\") – Security Co\\-ordinator and Adviser to the Government of Sierra Leone. For services to international policing, and promoting democracy in Sierra Leone.\n* [Victor Malvern Jackopson](/wiki/Victor_Jackopson \"Victor Jackopson\") – Founder and Head, Hope Now. For charitable activities, and services to orphans and other young people in Cherkassy, Ukraine.\n* [Renee Jacqueline Jordan](/wiki/Renee_Jordan \"Renee Jordan\") – Head of Registry, British Embassy Office, Basra.\n* [Mairwen Karydis](/wiki/Mairwen_Karydis \"Mairwen Karydis\") – British Consular Correspondent, Lesvos. For services to consular work in Greece.\n* [Nigel Jeffery Randle Kay](/wiki/Nigel_Kay \"Nigel Kay\") – Founder and Head, Homes in Zimbabwe. For services to the elderly in Zimbabwe.\n* [Christopher Kealey](/wiki/Christopher_Kealey \"Christopher Kealey\") – lately First Secretary Political, British Embassy, Afghanistan.\n* [Paul Lawrence](/wiki/Paul_David_Lawrence \"Paul David Lawrence\") – lately British Vice Consul, Thailand.\n* [Cynthia Albrecht\\-Lelliott](/wiki/Cynthia_Albrecht-Lelliott \"Cynthia Albrecht-Lelliott\") – Honorary Vice\\-President, British Ladies Club. For services to the British community in Luxembourg and UK\\-Luxembourg relations.\n* [Dr. Raymond George\\-MacKay](/wiki/Raymond_George-MacKay \"Raymond George-MacKay\") – Educational Consultant. For services to English teaching, especially in West Bengal, India.\n* Bryan Andrew Morgan – Second Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Hazel Jane Nelder](/wiki/Hazel_Nelder \"Hazel Nelder\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Anthony John Nott](/wiki/Anthony_Nott \"Anthony Nott\") – UK Policing Adviser, Office of the United States Co\\-ordinator, Palestine. For services to international policing, more recently in Iraq and Palestine.\n* [Jean Catherine Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Desforges \"Jean Desforges\") – For services to athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.\n* [Stephen Peter John Schembri](/wiki/Stephen_Schembri \"Stephen Schembri\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Joanna Wright\\-Serra](/wiki/Joanna_Wright-Serra \"Joanna Wright-Serra\") – Founding member, JUCONI (Juntos con los Ninos—Together with Children). For services to street children and other charitable activities in Mexico.\n* [Keith Shonfeld](/wiki/Keith_Nigel_Shonfeld \"Keith Nigel Shonfeld\") – Cemetery Administrator, British Cemetery Committee – For services to the British community in Cyprus.\n* [Dr. Malcolm Swann](/wiki/Malcolm_Swann \"Malcolm Swann\") – Medical Director, [Beit Cure International Hospital](/wiki/CURE_International \"CURE International\"), Lusaka. For medical services in Zambia.\n* [Peter Dyce Tear](/wiki/Peter_Tear \"Peter Tear\") – Executive Producer, 59E59 Theatres in New York. For services to UK/USA cultural relations.\n* [David Richard Vaughan Thomas](/wiki/David_Richard_Vaughan_Thomas \"David Richard Vaughan Thomas\") – Chairman, British\\-Polish Chamber of Commerce. For services to British business interests and charitable activities in Poland.\n* [Iwona Thomas](/wiki/Iwona_Thomas \"Iwona Thomas\") – Founder and Manager, The British School, Warsaw. For services to education.\n* [Sally Thompson](/wiki/Sally_Thompson \"Sally Thompson\") – Deputy Executive Director, Thailand\\-Burma Border Consortium. For services to Burmese refugees in Thailand.\n* [Kedell Melody Worboys](/wiki/Kedell_Worboys \"Kedell Worboys\") – St. Helena Government Representative in the UK. For services to St. Helena.",
"### Royal Red Cross",
"#### Royal Red Cross (Second Class)",
"Army\n* Major John Clark",
"### Queen's Police Medal (QPM)",
"England and Wales\n* Christopher Adams, Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary.\n* Andrew Bliss, Deputy Chief Constable, Essex Police.\n* David Keith Cook, Acting Detective Chief Inspector, West Midlands Police.\n* Ms [Cressida Rose Dick](/wiki/Cressida_Dick \"Cressida Dick\"), Assistant Commissioner, Metropolitan Police Service.\n* Robert Arthur Evans, Assistant Chief Constable, South Wales Police (Home Office Seconded).\n* Michael Field, Detective Superintendent, British Transport Police.\n* Kevin Trevor Flint, Detective Superintendent, Nottinghamshire Police.\n* Christopher David Lee, Deputy Chief Constable, Dorset Police.\n* Paul O'Connor, Inspector, Hertfordshire Police.\n* Sir [Hugh Stephen Roden Orde](/wiki/Hugh_Orde \"Hugh Orde\"), O.B.E., President, Association of Chief Police Officers.\n* Geoffrey William Owen, lately Constable, Metropolitan Police Service.\n* Gary Richardson, Detective Superintendent, Metropolitan Police Service.\n* Ms Susan Karen Sim, Deputy Chief Constable, Northumbria Police.\n* Julie Anne, Mrs. Spence, O.B.E., Chief Constable, Cambridgeshire Police.\n* Stephen John Thomas, Assistant Chief Constable, British Transport Police.\n* Malcolm Philip Tillyer, lately Chief Superintendent, Metropolitan Police Service.\n* Ms Wendy Ann Walker, Assistant Chief Constable, Lancashire Constabulary.\n* David John Whatton, Chief Constable, Cheshire Police.",
"Scotland\n* Ms Maureen Brown, lately Assistant Chief Constable, Central Scotland Police.\n* Iain Clark Howie, Constable, Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary.\n* Gordon Meldrum, Director General, Scottish Crime and Drug Enforcement Agency.",
"Northern Ireland\n* Robert Lindsay Ellison, Sergeant, Police Service of Northern Ireland.\n* Mark William James McDowell, Detective Chief Superintendent, Police Service of Northern Ireland.\n* David Robert Adams McFall, Sergeant, Police Service of Northern Ireland.",
"### Queen's Volunteer Reserves Medal (QVRM)",
"Army\n* Major Mark Brotherston",
"Royal Air Force\n* Sergeant Terence Morton"
] |
### Order of the British Empire
#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE / DBE)
Civil Division
* [Professor Valerie Beral](/wiki/Val_Beral "Val Beral"). For services to Science
* [Dr. Claire Bertschinger](/wiki/Claire_Bertschinger "Claire Bertschinger"). For services to Nursing and to International Humanitarian Aid
* [Councillor Ellen Margaret Eaton, OBE](/wiki/Ellen_Margaret_Eaton "Ellen Margaret Eaton"), Chair, Local Government Association. For services to Local Government
* [Dr. Susan Elizabeth Ion, OBE](/wiki/Sue_Ion "Sue Ion"), Visiting Professor, Imperial College, London and Chair, UK Fusion Advisory Board. For services to Science and Engineering
* [Clare Oriana Tickell](/wiki/Clare_Tickell "Clare Tickell"), Chief Executive, Action for Children. For services to Young People
* [Marcia Twelftree](/wiki/Marcia_Twelftree "Marcia Twelftree"), lately Headteacher, Charters School, Windsor and Maidenhead, Berkshire. For services to local and national Education
#### Commanders of the Order of the British Empire (CBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* Commodore Stephen Redvers Kirby
* Commodore Christopher Laurence Palmer
Army
* Colonel Mark Cuthbert\-Brown – late [Adjutant General's Corps](/wiki/Adjutant_General%27s_Corps "Adjutant General's Corps") ([Royal Military Police](/wiki/Royal_Military_Police "Royal Military Police"))
* Colonel David James Eadie – late The [Queen's Royal Lancers](/wiki/Queen%27s_Royal_Lancers "Queen's Royal Lancers")
* Colonel Christopher William Manning – late [Army Air Corps](/wiki/Army_Air_Corps_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Army Air Corps (United Kingdom)")
* Brigadier Simon John Marriner, MBE – late Adjutant General's Corps (Staff and Personnel Support Branch)
* Colonel Michael Peter Macgregor Stewart, QHS – late [Royal Army Medical Corps](/wiki/Royal_Army_Medical_Corps "Royal Army Medical Corps")
Royal Air Force
* [Air Commodore Clive Arthur Bairsto](/wiki/Clive_Bairsto "Clive Bairsto")
* Group Captain Keith Ronald Dipper
* Group Captain Alistair Monkman
* [Group Captain Andrew Mark Turner, OBE](/wiki/Andrew_Turner_%28RAF_officer%29 "Andrew Turner (RAF officer)")
Civil Division
* [James Christopher Armfield, OBE](/wiki/Jimmy_Armfield "Jimmy Armfield"). For services to the community in Lancashire.
* [David Ogilvy Barrie](/wiki/David_Ogilvy_Barrie "David Ogilvy Barrie"), lately Director, [Art Fund](/wiki/Art_Fund "Art Fund"). For services to the Visual Arts.
* Parmajit Paul Singh Bassi, DL, Chairman, Bond Wolfe. For services to Business and to the community in the West Midlands.
* [William Robert Baxter](/wiki/William_Robert_Baxter "William Robert Baxter"), Deputy chief executive, Baxter Storey. For services to the Catering Industry.
* Ann Beasley, Director of Finance and Performance, [National Offender Management Service](/wiki/National_Offender_Management_Service "National Offender Management Service"), Ministry of Justice.
* Edward Farquharson Bowen, [Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders](/wiki/Sheriff_Principal_of_Lothian_and_Borders "Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders"). For services to the Administration of Justice in Scotland.
* Councillor Peter Box, Leader, [Wakefield Metropolitan District Council](/wiki/Wakefield_Metropolitan_District_Council "Wakefield Metropolitan District Council") and chairman, [Yorkshire and Humber Assembly](/wiki/Yorkshire_and_Humber_Assembly "Yorkshire and Humber Assembly"). For services to Local Government.
* [Professor Donal Donat Conor Bradley, FRS](/wiki/Donal_Bradley "Donal Bradley"), Lee\-Lucas Professor of Experimental Physics and Deputy Principal, Faculty of Natural Sciences, [Imperial College London](/wiki/Imperial_College_London "Imperial College London"). For services to Science.
* [Professor Alice Brown](/wiki/Alice_Brown_%28ombudsman%29 "Alice Brown (ombudsman)"), lately [Scottish Public Services Ombudsman](/wiki/Scottish_Public_Services_Ombudsman "Scottish Public Services Ombudsman"). For public service.
* [Natalie Ceeney](/wiki/Natalie_Ceeney "Natalie Ceeney"), chief executive, National Archives, [Ministry of Justice](/wiki/Ministry_of_Justice "Ministry of Justice").
* Lauran Margaret Chatburn, Principal and chief executive, [Bury College](/wiki/Bury_College "Bury College"). For services to Further Education.
* Professor David Martin Chiddick, lately Vice\-Chancellor, [University of Lincoln](/wiki/University_of_Lincoln "University of Lincoln"). For services to local and national Higher Education.
* Lawrence Churchill, Chairman, [Pension Protection Fund](/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund "Pension Protection Fund"). For public service.
* [Robert Brodie Clark](/wiki/Brodie_Clark "Brodie Clark"), Head of Border Force, [UK Border Agency](/wiki/UK_Border_Agency "UK Border Agency"), Home Office.
* [Barry Michael Cockcroft](/wiki/Barry_Cockcroft_%28dentist%29 "Barry Cockcroft (dentist)"), [Chief Dental Officer](/wiki/Chief_Dental_Officer_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Chief Dental Officer (United Kingdom)"), Department of Health.
* Christopher Cohen, lately chairman, Athletics Sports Assembly Executive Committee, [International Paralympic Committee](/wiki/International_Paralympic_Committee "International Paralympic Committee"). For services to Sport.
* [Sarah Patricia Connolly](/wiki/Sarah_Connolly "Sarah Connolly"), Opera Singer. For services to Classical Music.
* Rodney Cousens, chief executive officer, [Codemasters](/wiki/Codemasters "Codemasters"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.
* Dr. Michael John Cresswell, Director\-General, [Assessment and Qualifications Alliance](/wiki/Assessment_and_Qualifications_Alliance "Assessment and Qualifications Alliance"). For services to Education.
* Professor Ian Richard Crute, lately Director, [Rothamsted Research](/wiki/Rothamsted_Research "Rothamsted Research"). For services to Plant Science.
* [His Honour Judge Keith Charles Cutler](/wiki/Keith_Cutler "Keith Cutler"), Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* [Dr. George Daniels, MBE](/wiki/George_Daniels_%28watchmaker%29 "George Daniels (watchmaker)"), Master Watchmaker. For services to Horology.
* [Professor Janet Howard Darbyshire, OBE](/wiki/Janet_Darbyshire "Janet Darbyshire"), Director, Clinical Trials Unit, [Medical Research Council](/wiki/Medical_Research_Council_%28United_Kingdom%29 "Medical Research Council (United Kingdom)"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Helen Anne Dent, chief executive, [Family Action](/wiki/Family_Action "Family Action"). For services to Children and Families.
* Graham Thomas Devlin. For services to the Arts.
* Professor Carol Dezateux, Professor of Paediatric Epidemiology, [UCL Institute of Child Health](/wiki/UCL_Institute_of_Child_Health "UCL Institute of Child Health"). For services to Science.
* Mary Elizabeth Dodd, lately Consultant Physiotherapist, Cystic Fibrosis, [South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust](/wiki/South_Manchester_University_Hospital_NHS_Trust "South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Peter Donohoe](/wiki/Peter_Donohoe_%28pianist%29 "Peter Donohoe (pianist)"), pianist, for services to Classical Music.
* Trudi Margaret Elliott, Regional Director, Government Office for the West Midlands, [Department for Communities and Local Government](/wiki/Department_for_Communities_and_Local_Government "Department for Communities and Local Government").
* Margaret Fay, OBE. For services to the Regional Development Agency, [One North East](/wiki/One_NorthEast "One NorthEast").
* [George Ferguson](/wiki/George_Ferguson_%28architect%29 "George Ferguson (architect)"). For services to Architecture and to the community in the South West.
* [Professor Stephen John Field](/wiki/Steve_Field_%28medical_doctor%29 "Steve Field (medical doctor)"), Head of Workforce and Regional Postgraduate Dean, NHS West Midlands and Chairman of College Council, [Royal College of General Practitioners](/wiki/Royal_College_of_General_Practitioners "Royal College of General Practitioners"). For services to Medicine.
* Christopher Mark Fisher, Director, Jobseekers and Skills, Employment Group, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions "Department for Work and Pensions").
* [Professor Alastair Hugh Fitter, FRS](/wiki/Alastair_Fitter "Alastair Fitter"), Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor for Research, [University of York](/wiki/University_of_York "University of York"). For services to Environmental Science.
* Brian Roy Fleet, MBE, Senior [Airbus UK](/wiki/Airbus_UK "Airbus UK") Vice\-President. For services to the Aerospace Industry.
* His Honour Judge David Robert Fletcher, Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice in Merseyside.
* Winston Fletcher, lately chairman, Advertising Standards Board of Finance. For services to the Creative Industries.
* Neil Raymond Flint, Deputy Director, New Academies Division, [Department for Children, Schools and Families](/wiki/Department_for_Children%2C_Schools_and_Families "Department for Children, Schools and Families").
* [Helen Fraser](/wiki/Helen_Fraser_%28executive%29 "Helen Fraser (executive)"), lately managing director, [Penguin UK](/wiki/Penguin_UK "Penguin UK"). For services to the Publishing Industry.
* Professor John Fyfe. For services to Partnership Working and to Regeneration Worldwide, particularly in West Cumbria.
* David Goldstone. For public service.
* Anthony Simonds\-Gooding, Chairman, [D\&AD](/wiki/D%26AD "D&AD"). For services to the Creative Industries.
* Professor Sean Patrick Gorman, Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Life Sciences and Professor of Pharmaceutical Microbiology, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast "Queen's University Belfast"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Lucian Charles Grainge](/wiki/Lucian_Grainge "Lucian Grainge"), Chairman and chief executive officer, [Universal Music Group International](/wiki/Universal_Music_Group_International "Universal Music Group International"). For services to the Creative Industries.
* Robert Douglas Greig, chief executive, National Development Team for Inclusion. For services to People with Special Needs.
* Bethan Haulwen Guilfoyle, Headteacher, [Treorchy Comprehensive School](/wiki/Treorchy_Comprehensive_School "Treorchy Comprehensive School"). For services to Education in Wales.
* [Maggi Hambling, OBE](/wiki/Maggi_Hambling "Maggi Hambling"), Painter and Sculptor. For services to Art.
* Ian Hardie, Deputy Director, Corporation Tax and VAT, Business Tax, [H.M. Revenue and Customs](/wiki/H.M._Revenue_and_Customs "H.M. Revenue and Customs").
* Dr. Christopher Charles Harling, Director, [NHS Plus](/wiki/NHS_Plus "NHS Plus"). For services to Occupational Health.
* Martin Harman. For services to International Trade and to the Legal Profession.
* Dr. Colin Robert Harrison, Chairman, Chemistry Innovation Knowledge Transfer Network. For services to Technology.
* [Emma Harrison](/wiki/Emma_Harrison_%28entrepreneur%29 "Emma Harrison (entrepreneur)"), Chair, [A4e](/wiki/A4e "A4e"). For services to Unemployed People and to the Voluntary Sector.
* Frances Hartley, lately Headteacher, Deans Primary School, Salford. For services to Education.
* Sally Lorinda Hobbs, HM Deputy Chief Inspector, [Crown Prosecution Service](/wiki/Crown_Prosecution_Service "Crown Prosecution Service") Inspectorate.
* Peter Michael Holland, QFSM, Chief Fire Officer, [Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service](/wiki/Lancashire_Fire_and_Rescue_Service "Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service"). For services to Local Government.
* Timothy Stancliffe Hollis, QPM, Chief Constable, [Humberside Police](/wiki/Humberside_Police "Humberside Police"). For services to the Police.
* [Helen Jackson](/wiki/Helen_Jackson_%28politician%29 "Helen Jackson (politician)"). For services to the Women and Pensions Network and to the community in South Yorkshire.
* Dyfrig Dafydd Joseff John, lately Deputy chairman and chief executive, [HSBC Bank](/wiki/HSBC_Bank "HSBC Bank"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* [Penny Johnson](/wiki/Penny_Johnson "Penny Johnson"), Director, Government Art Collection, [Department for Culture, Media and Sport](/wiki/Department_for_Culture%2C_Media_and_Sport "Department for Culture, Media and Sport").
* Julie Jones, OBE, chief executive, [Social Care Institute for Excellence](/wiki/Social_Care_Institute_for_Excellence "Social Care Institute for Excellence"). For services to Local Government.
* Robert Jones, lately chairman, Association of Police Authorities. For services to the Police.
* Professor Peter Graham Edward Kennedy, Burton Professor of Neurology, [University of Glasgow](/wiki/University_of_Glasgow "University of Glasgow"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Lowri Alice Khan, Team Leader, Intervention, Strategy and Markets Team, [H.M. Treasury](/wiki/H.M._Treasury "H.M. Treasury").
* Paul Leighton, QPM, lately Deputy Chief Constable, [Police Service of Northern Ireland](/wiki/Police_Service_of_Northern_Ireland "Police Service of Northern Ireland"). For services to the Police.
* Rosa Lady Lipworth. For charitable services.
* [Phyllida Lloyd](/wiki/Phyllida_Lloyd "Phyllida Lloyd"), Theatre Director. For services to Drama.
* [James Loughran](/wiki/James_Loughran "James Loughran"), Conductor. For services to Classical Music.
* David Clifford Loughton, chief executive, [Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust](/wiki/Royal_Wolverhampton_Hospitals_NHS_Trust "Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust"). For services to Healthcare.
* [Ian David Luder](/wiki/Ian_Luder "Ian Luder"), lately [Lord Mayor of the City of London](/wiki/Lord_Mayor_of_London "Lord Mayor of London"). For public service.
* Mary Elizabeth Madden. For public service.
* [Professor Robert James Mair, FREng FICE FRS](/wiki/Robert_James_Mair "Robert James Mair"), Master of [Jesus College](/wiki/Jesus_College%2C_Cambridge "Jesus College, Cambridge") and Professor of Geotechnical Engineering, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge "University of Cambridge"). For services to Engineering.
* Hew Mathewson, President, [General Dental Council](/wiki/General_Dental_Council "General Dental Council"). For services to Healthcare.
* Professor Denise Angela McAlister, Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor, Teaching and Learning, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster "University of Ulster"). For services to Higher Education in Northern Ireland.
* William David McWilliam, Superintendent, [Merseyside Police](/wiki/Merseyside_Police "Merseyside Police"). For services to the Police and to Young People.
* David Leonard Moore, lately Her Majesty's Inspector of Education and Assistant Divisional Manager, [Ofsted](/wiki/Ofsted "Ofsted").
* Candy Morris, chief executive, NHS South East Coast [Strategic Health Authority](/wiki/Strategic_health_authority "Strategic health authority"). For services to Healthcare.
* Diana Lesley Morrison, Headteacher, St. Martin\-in\-the\-Fields High School for Girls, Lambeth, London. For services to local and national Education.
* Stephen Thurston Munby, chief executive, National College for Leadership of Schools and Children's Services. For services to Education.
* [Professor Adrian Charles Newland](/wiki/Adrian_Charles_Newland "Adrian Charles Newland"), Professor of Haematology and director, Pathology Clinical Academic Unit, [Barts and the London NHS Trust](/wiki/Barts_and_the_London_NHS_Trust "Barts and the London NHS Trust"). For services to Medicine.
* Dr. William Gerard O'Hare, Chairman, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster "University of Ulster") Foundation. For services to Higher Education and to Regeneration in Northern Ireland.
* [David Malcolm Orr](/wiki/David_Malcolm_Orr "David Malcolm Orr"), Director Corporate Services, Department of Finance and Personnel, [Northern Ireland Executive](/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Executive "Northern Ireland Executive").
* John Scott Perry, chief executive, [Scottish Enterprise](/wiki/Scottish_Enterprise "Scottish Enterprise"). For services to Business.
* Dr. David Price, chief executive, [Chemring Group](/wiki/Chemring_Group "Chemring Group") plc. For services to the Defence Industry.
* Imelda Redmond, chief executive, [Carers UK](/wiki/Carers_UK "Carers UK"). For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Dr. Sian Eluned Rees, Inspector of Ancient Monuments, [Cadw](/wiki/Cadw "Cadw"), Welsh Assembly Government.
* Caroline Mary Rookes, Director, Planning for Retirement and Older People, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions "Department for Work and Pensions").
* [Tessa Sarah Ross (Mrs. Scantlebury)](/wiki/Tessa_Ross "Tessa Ross"), Controller of Film and Drama, [Channel 4](/wiki/Channel_4 "Channel 4"). For services to Broadcasting.
* [Alastair Eric Hotson Salvesen](/wiki/Alastair_Salvesen "Alastair Salvesen"). For services to the Arts and to Charity in Scotland.
* [Graham Edward Sheffield](/wiki/Graham_Sheffield "Graham Sheffield"), Artistic Director, [Barbican Centre](/wiki/Barbican_Centre "Barbican Centre"), London. For services to the Arts.
* [Adrian Shooter](/wiki/Adrian_Shooter "Adrian Shooter"), Chairman, [Chiltern Railway Company Ltd](/wiki/Chiltern_Railways "Chiltern Railways"). For services to the Rail Industry.
* Ruth Sims, OBE. For voluntary service to Palliative Care in [Uganda](/wiki/Uganda "Uganda").
* John Brian Sinnott, chief executive, [Leicestershire County Council](/wiki/Leicestershire_County_Council "Leicestershire County Council"). For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Christopher John Skinner](/wiki/Chris_Skinner_%28statistician%29 "Chris Skinner (statistician)"), FBA, Professor, Southampton Statistical Sciences Research Institute, [University of Southampton](/wiki/University_of_Southampton "University of Southampton"). For services to Social Science.
* Paul Spencer, lately chairman, [National Savings and Investments](/wiki/National_Savings_and_Investments "National Savings and Investments"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* Janice Stevens, National Director, Healthcare Associated Infections Programme, Department of Health. For services to Nursing.
* Professor William James Swindall, OBE, Consulting Director, QUILL Centre, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast "Queen's University Belfast"). For services to Environmental Science.
* Kathleen Thomas, Principal, [Oldham College](/wiki/Oldham_College "Oldham College"), Manchester. For services to Further Education.
* [Margaret Maud Tyzack, OBE](/wiki/Margaret_Tyzack "Margaret Tyzack"), actress. For services to Drama.
* [Professor Karen Vousden, FRS FRSE FMedSci](/wiki/Karen_Vousden "Karen Vousden"), Director, [Beatson Institute for Cancer Research](/wiki/Beatson_Institute_for_Cancer_Research "Beatson Institute for Cancer Research"). For services to Clinical Science.
* Susan Toni Wardell, Director, Middle East, Caribbean, Asia (East, Central) and British Overseas Territories, [Department for International Development](/wiki/Department_for_International_Development "Department for International Development").
* John David Whittaker, Deputy Director, Employment Policy, [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office "Cabinet Office").
* Vanessa Wiseman, lately Headteacher, Langdon School and Sports College, Newham, London. For services to Education.
* John Briscoe Wright. For services to the [Federation of Small Businesses](/wiki/Federation_of_Small_Businesses "Federation of Small Businesses").
* Professor Michael Wright, DL, Vice\-Chancellor, [Canterbury Christ Church University](/wiki/Canterbury_Christ_Church_University "Canterbury Christ Church University"). For services to Higher Education and to the community in Kent.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* Larry Thomas Dennis, lately Auditor General of Bermuda. For services to good governance in Bermuda.
* Rabbi [David Shlomo Rosen](/wiki/David_Shlomo_Rosen "David Shlomo Rosen"), Honorary Adviser on Interfaith relations to the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. For services to interfaith relations in the Middle East, and between the UK and Israel.
#### Officers of the Order of the British Empire (OBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* [Commander Nicholas Trevor Blackman](/wiki/Nicholas_Trevor_Blackman "Nicholas Trevor Blackman")
* [Commander Richard George Fox](/wiki/Richard_George_Fox "Richard George Fox")
* [Commander David John Hunkin](/wiki/David_John_Hunkin "David John Hunkin")
* [Commander Charles David Lightfoot](/wiki/Charles_David_Lightfoot "Charles David Lightfoot")
* [Commander Peter Moss](/wiki/Peter_Moss_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "Peter Moss (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Commander Gerard Rodney Northwood](/wiki/Gerard_Rodney_Northwood "Gerard Rodney Northwood")
Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Allan Barnes](/wiki/Allan_Barnes_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Allan Barnes (British Army officer)") – Coldstream Guards
* [Colonel John Etherington](/wiki/John_Etherington "John Etherington") – late Royal Army Medical Corps
* [Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley](/wiki/Alexander_Gilbert_Carew_Hatherley "Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley") – Grenadier Guards
* [Colonel Ian David MacLeod](/wiki/Ian_David_MacLeod "Ian David MacLeod") – Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Army Cadet Force
* [Colonel Iain George David Moles, QVRM TD](/wiki/Iain_George_David_Moles "Iain George David Moles") – late Royal Army Medical Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Leanda Jane Pitt, TD DL](/wiki/Leanda_Jane_Pitt "Leanda Jane Pitt") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel John Richard James Powell](/wiki/John_Richard_James_Powell "John Richard James Powell") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Mark Reginald Rusby](/wiki/Mark_Reginald_Rusby "Mark Reginald Rusby") – The Mercian Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Andrew John Teskey](/wiki/Andrew_John_Teskey "Andrew John Teskey") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
Royal Air Force
* [Wing Commander Stephen Robert Chaskin](/wiki/Stephen_Robert_Chaskin "Stephen Robert Chaskin")
* [Wing Commander Mark Nicholas Day](/wiki/Mark_Nicholas_Day "Mark Nicholas Day")
* [Wing Commander Simon Andrew Harper](/wiki/Simon_Andrew_Harper "Simon Andrew Harper")
* [Wing Commander Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid](/wiki/Jonathan_Peter_Quentin_Reid "Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid")
* [Wing Commander Malcolm Leslie Symonds](/wiki/Malcolm_Leslie_Symonds "Malcolm Leslie Symonds")
* [Wing Commander Andrew David Wallis](/wiki/Andrew_David_Wallis "Andrew David Wallis")
* [Wing Commander Robert Alan Woods](/wiki/Robert_Alan_Woods "Robert Alan Woods")
Civil Division
* William Abbott, National Security Adviser, Secure Mental Health Services, Department of Health. For services to Healthcare.
* [Victor Akers](/wiki/Victor_Akers "Victor Akers"), lately Manager, [Arsenal Ladies' Football Team](/wiki/Arsenal_W.F.C. "Arsenal W.F.C."). For services to Sport.
* Professor [Alan Alexander](/wiki/Alan_Alexander_%28academic%29 "Alan Alexander (academic)"), Emeritus Professor of Local and Public Management, [University of Strathclyde](/wiki/University_of_Strathclyde "University of Strathclyde"). For services to Social Science.
* Alexander Beveridge Anderson, D.L., Chairman of Governors, University of Teesside. For services to the community in the North East.
* Deirdre Anne, Mrs. Kinloch Anderson, Director, Kinloch Anderson. For services to the Textile Industry.
* John Huxley Fordyce Anderson. For services to St. Martin\-in\-the\-Fields, London and to the Construction Industry.
* [Craig Armstrong](/wiki/Craig_Armstrong_%28composer%29 "Craig Armstrong (composer)"). For services to Music.
* Anthony John William Attard, Chief Executive, Panaz Ltd. For services to the Textile Industry and to International Trade.
* [Sir Nicholas Hickman Ponsonby Bacon, Bt., D.L](/wiki/Sir_Nicholas_Bacon%2C_14th_Baronet "Sir Nicholas Bacon, 14th Baronet"). For services to the community in Norfolk.
* Linda Margaret, Mrs. Costelloe Baker. For public service.
* Stuart Kemp Baker, Deputy Director, National Projects, Rail and National Networks, Department for Transport.
* Dr. Michael Thomas Barlow. For services to Intellectual Property Law.
* Professor [Ann Barrett](/wiki/Ann_Barrett "Ann Barrett"), Professor of [Oncology](/wiki/Oncology "Oncology") and lately Deputy Head of School, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia "University of East Anglia"). For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Hillary Anna Bauer, Head, International and Cultural Property Unit, Department for Culture, Media and Sport.
* Ms Margaret Baxter. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Miss Ailsa Elizabeth Beaton, Director of Information, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.
* Alan Kenneth Bowers Beavis. For services to the Scouts.
* Dr. John William Beer, lately Executive Director of Social Services, Southampton City Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ms [Anthea Bell](/wiki/Anthea_Bell "Anthea Bell"). For services to Literature and to Literary Translations.
* Arlene, Mrs. Bell, Headteacher, Beechdale Nursery School, Durham. For services to local and national Early Years Education.
* Thomas Bell. For services to the Wooden Spoon Children's Charity.
* [Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough](/wiki/Madeleine_Ponsonby%2C_Countess_of_Bessborough "Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough"). For services to the Visual Arts.
* Dr. Anthony Bernard Best. For services to the Education of Deafblind Children.
* Kay, Mrs. Bews, Chief Executive, Home\-Start UK. For services to Children and Families.
* Professor Alison Blenkinsopp, Professor of the Practice of Pharmacy, Keele University. For services to Healthcare.
* Ronald John Bowers, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.
* Paul Vincent Boyle, lately Chief Executive, Financial Reporting Council. For services to the Financial Services Industry and Accountancy.
* Ms Anne Elizabeth Brannagan, Complex Trauma Manager, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.
* [Ross Brawn](/wiki/Ross_Brawn "Ross Brawn"), Team Principal, [Brawn GP](/wiki/Brawn_GP "Brawn GP"). For services to Motorsport.
* [Dr. Michael Peter Briggs](/wiki/Peter_Briggs_%28scientist%29 "Peter Briggs (scientist)"), lately [Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor](/wiki/Pro-Vice-Chancellor "Pro-Vice-Chancellor"), [Roehampton University](/wiki/Roehampton_University "Roehampton University"). For services to Higher Education.
* Dr. Alison Fiona Campbell, Managing Director, King's College London Business Ltd. For services to Knowledge Transfer.
* Peter Carne, lately National Champion, Learning Outside the Classroom and Programme Manager, Growing Schools Programme. For services to Education.
* David Brian Cassells. For services to the Inland Waterways Association of Ireland.
* Eileen, Mrs. Cavalier (Mrs. Schatunowski), Founder, London College of Beauty Therapy. For services to Further Education.
* Pamela, Mrs. Challis, Leader, Castle Point Borough Council. For services to Local Government in South East Essex.
* [Mavis Lurline, Mrs. Champagnie](/wiki/Lurline_Champagnie "Lurline Champagnie"), Councillor, [London Borough of Harrow](/wiki/London_Borough_of_Harrow "London Borough of Harrow"). For services to Local Government and to Diversity.
* Captain Kandiah Chandran, M.B.E., Chief Executive, Preset Charitable Trust. For services to Young People in London.
* Gillian, Mrs. Coffey, Headteacher, Lynch Hill Foundation Primary School, Slough. For services to Education.
* Yvonne, Mrs. Coghill, National Lead, Breaking Through Programme, NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement. For services to Healthcare.
* Maureen, Mrs. Cooke, Head of Capability and First Line Service Management, Customer Service Delivery, Corporate IT, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Gordon Raymond Couch. For services to disabled people.
* David John Cowie, lately District Manager, Jobcentre Plus, Forth Valley, Fife and Tayside, Department for Work and Pensions.
* John Andrew Craig, Chairman, British Record Industry Trust. For services to Music and to Charity.
* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Craig, Chief Executive, Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Bruce Millson Crook, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Ms [Frances Crook](/wiki/Frances_Crook "Frances Crook"), Director, [Howard League for Penal Reform](/wiki/Howard_League_for_Penal_Reform "Howard League for Penal Reform"). For services to Youth Justice.
* Neil Philip Cunliffe, Group Manager, Road Safety Group, Lancashire County Council. For services to Road Safety.
* Phillip Leyland Darnton, Chairman, Cycling England. For services to Transport.
* Frederick Geoffrey Davies, lately Chairman, Gwent Magistrates Bench and Wales Bench Chairmen's Forum. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Derek John Davis, lately Chairman, Stoke\-on\-Trent and Staffordshire Combined Fire Authority. For services to Local Government.
* Amanda, Mrs. Deeks, Chief Executive Officer, South Gloucestershire Council and Founder, West of England Partnership for Bristol. For services to Local Government.
* Paul Deneen, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Herefordshire and Worcestershire.
* John Henry Derbyshire, Sailing Coach and Manager. For services to Sport.
* Professor [Fiona Devine](/wiki/Fiona_Devine "Fiona Devine"), Professor of Sociology, [University of Manchester](/wiki/University_of_Manchester "University of Manchester"). For services to Social Science.
* Ian Laidlaw\-Dickson, Chairman, Hertfordshire Police Authority. For services to the Police.
* Michael Donnelly, Chief Executive Officer, Habinteg Housing Association. For services to the Housing Sector.
* Jacqueline Ann, Mrs. Dowell, Customer Operations Business Design Manager, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Professor [Marcus Peter Francis du Sautoy](/wiki/Marcus_du_Sautoy "Marcus du Sautoy"), Professor of Mathematics, [University of Oxford](/wiki/University_of_Oxford "University of Oxford"). For services to Science.
* Brigadier Hedley Dennis Cardew Duncan, M.B.E., lately Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod, House of Lords.
* Martin Donald Dunford, Chairman, Association of Learning Providers and Chief Executive, Skills Training UK. For services to Skills.
* Antony Dunne, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Dr. Linda Ebbatson, Leader, Chester\-le\-Street District Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ms Janette Morag Faherty, Chief Executive, TNG/ Avanta. For services to Unemployed People and to Entrepreneurship.
* Ms Julia Fawcett, Chief Executive, Lowry Centre, Salford Quays. For services to the Arts in the North West.
* Derek Forest, Detective Superintendent, West Midlands Police. For services to the Police.
* Diana, Mrs. Fulbrook, Chief Officer, Wiltshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.
* Elizabeth Laureen, Mrs. Fullerton, lately Chair, NHS Shetland. For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Lucy Diana Gampell (Mrs. Itkin), lately Director, Action for Prisoners' Families. For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Professor Mary Gibby, Director of Science, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh. For services to Botany.
* Captain Duncan Colin Glass, lately Director of Navigation Requirements, Trinity House, Department for Transport.
* Celia Jane, Mrs. Godsall. For services to Sport.
* Dr. James Desmond Hall, General Medical Practitioner, Belfast. For services to Healthcare.
* Ms Susan Elizabeth Hall, Chief Officer, West Yorkshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Catherine Graham\-Harrison. For services to Heritage.
* David James Harrison. For services to Golf.
* Michael Clifford Hart, Director, Ffestinog Railway Company and Chairman, Welsh Highland Railway Construction Ltd. For services to the Rail Industry.
* Maurice Adrian Sylvester Heaster, Deputy Leader, Wandsworth Council. For services to Local Government.
* Elizabeth Irene, Mrs. Henderson, Network Nurse Director, Northern Ireland Cancer Network. For services to Healthcare.
* Tom Henderson. For services to Humanitarian Aid.
* Dr. Barbara Hendrie, lately Deputy Director, Iraq, Department for International Development.
* David Henry, Chairman, National Association for Mental Health. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. [Andrew James Herbert](/wiki/Andrew_Herbert "Andrew Herbert"), Managing Director, [Microsoft Research](/wiki/Microsoft_Research "Microsoft Research"), Cambridge. For services to Computer Science.
* [Donald Peter Herbert](/wiki/Peter_Herbert_%28lawyer%29 "Peter Herbert (lawyer)"), Barrister. For voluntary service to Equality, Diversity and Human Rights.
* Ms Susan Ann Higham, Business Design Manager, Modernising Pay As You Earn, Telford, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Ms Stephanie Hilborne, Chief Executive, The Wildlife Trusts. For services to Nature Conservation.
* Professor Anthony Edward Hill, Director, National Oceanography Centre, Southampton. For services to Environmental Science.
* Professor William Stewart Hillis, Medical Adviser, Scottish Football Association. For services to Medicine and to Sport.
* Helen Jane, Mrs. Clegg\-Hood, Headteacher, Shiremoor Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For services to Education.
* Ms Katharine Sarah Julian Horner, lately Specialist Counsellor and Senior Analyst, Assessments Staff, Cabinet Office.
* Peter John Hosker. For services to the community in Preston, Lancashire.
* [Gareth Dale Hoskins](/wiki/Gareth_Hoskins "Gareth Hoskins"). For services to Architecture.
* Kevin Houston, Managing Director, Anderson Manning Associates. For services to Business.
* Nicholas Howard, Parliamentary Clerk, Prime Minister's Office.
* Susan, Mrs. Huggins, Head of Network Development. For services to the Post Office.
* Shirley, Mrs. Hughes, Chief Executive Officer, Cerebral Palsy Sport. For services to Disability Sport.
* Robert Alfred Hutchings. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Wales.
* William Anthony Hynett, Group Chief Executive Officer, [B\-N Group Ltd](/wiki/Britten-Norman "Britten-Norman"). For services to the Defence Industry.
* [Paul Stafford Jackson](/wiki/Paul_Jackson_%28game_producer%29 "Paul Jackson (game producer)"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.
* Marc Jaffrey. For services to Music Education.
* Anthony Paul Jakimciw, Principal and Chief Executive Officer, Dumfries and Galloway College. For services to Further Education in Scotland.
* Professor Ian Miller Jamieson, lately Pro\-Vice\- Chancellor (Learning and Teaching), University of Bath. For services to local and national Education.
* Ms Marion Juliette Janner. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Ms Deborah Jeffery, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence. Martin John Jenkins, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.
* Jane, Mrs. Johnson, Headteacher, St. Stephen's Primary School, Newham, London. For services to Education.
* Glenys, Mrs. Johnston, Chair, Local Safeguarding Children Board, Leicestershire and Rutland. For services to Local Government.
* Paul Lloyd Jones, Executive Headteacher, Blackpool and Chudleigh Knighton Lady Seaward's and Salcombe Primary Schools, Devon. For services to local and national Education.
* [Stephen Jones](/wiki/Stephen_Jones_%28milliner%29 "Stephen Jones (milliner)"), Milliner. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Professor Vijay Vir Kakkar, Emeritus Professor, University of London. For services to Clinical Science.
* Ms Jeanne Kaniuk, Head of Adoption Services, Thomas Coram Foundation for Children. For services to Children.
* Professor Paul Keane, Dean, School of Health and Social Care, Teesside University. For services to Healthcare.
* Anna, Mrs. Kendall, lately Headteacher, Christ Church Church of England Primary School, Kensington and Chelsea, London. For services to Education.
* Nigel Kershaw, Chief Executive, Big Issue Invest and Chairman, The Big Issue. For services to Social Enterprise.
* [Simon Henry King](/wiki/Simon_King_%28television%29 "Simon King (television)"). For services to Wildlife Photography and to Conservation.
* John Gordon Kingston. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Ms Anne Kirkham, Grade 5, Decent Homes and Housing Finance Division, Department for Communities and Local Government.
* Richard Philip Kitson, lately Chief Executive, Aster Group. For services to the Housing Sector.
* Susan, Mrs. Knox. For services to Food Safety.
* Silas Krendel. For charitable services.
* [Ram Parkash Lakha](/wiki/Ram_Parkash_Lakha "Ram Parkash Lakha"). For services to the Sikh community in Coventry, West Midlands.
* Anthony Edward Langford, Non\-Executive Director, John Smedley. For services to the Knitwear Industry.
* Heather, Mrs. Lawrence, Chief Executive, Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Jurat and Lieutenant Bailiff Sally Carolyn Ann Le Brocq. For services to the Administration of Justice and to the community in Jersey.
* Andrew John Leigh. For public service.
* Eva, Mrs. Loeffler, Vice\-President, WheelPower. For services to Disability Sport.
* Helen, Mrs. MacKenzie, Headteacher, Shevington High School, Wigan. For services to Education.
* John Graham Marks. For charitable services.
* Victor Alan Marshall, Detective Superintendent, Sussex Police and Adviser to the Home Office. For services to the Police.
* Ms Wendy Martinson, Consultant Dietitian, British Olympic Association. For services to Sport and to Nutrition.
* June Colette, Mrs. Mason, Grade 7, Cohesion and Migration Directorate, Department for Communities and Local Government.
* Samuel Abraham McCrea, Principal, Ballyclare Secondary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Professor John Alexander McDermid. For services to the Defence Industry.
* William John McGawley, Executive Vice\-Chairman, TDR Group. For services to Business and to Skills Training in the North East.
* The Very Reverend Dr. Robert Samuel James Houston McKelvey, Q.V.R.M., T.D., Dean, St. Anne's Cathedral, Belfast. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Ms Alison Mary McLean. For services to Rural Affairs in the West Midlands.
* Bishop Louis Richard McLeod, For services to Southwark Credit Union.
* Ronald McNab, lately Managing Director, Caledonian Alloys Ltd. For services to the Recycling Industry.
* Ms [Loretta Minghella](/wiki/Loretta_Minghella "Loretta Minghella"), Chief Executive, [Financial Services Compensation Scheme](/wiki/Financial_Services_Compensation_Scheme "Financial Services Compensation Scheme"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* [Michelle, Mrs. Mone](/wiki/Michelle_Mone%2C_Baroness_Mone "Michelle Mone, Baroness Mone"), Founder and Owner, MJM International Group. For services to the Lingerie Industry.
* [Kenneth Montgomery](/wiki/Kenneth_Montgomery "Kenneth Montgomery"), Principal Conductor, [Ulster Orchestra](/wiki/Ulster_Orchestra "Ulster Orchestra"). For services to Music in Northern Ireland.
* Ms [Debbie Moore](/wiki/Debbie_Moore "Debbie Moore"), Founder and Chair, [Pineapple Dance Studios](/wiki/Pineapple_Dance_Studios "Pineapple Dance Studios"). For services to Business.
* [Heidi, Mrs. Mottram](/wiki/Heidi_Mottram "Heidi Mottram"), Managing Director, Northern Rail. For services to the Rail Industry.
* Ms Diane Mulligan. For services to disabled people and to Equal Opportunities.
* [Braham Sydney Murray](/wiki/Braham_Murray "Braham Murray"), [Artistic Director](/wiki/Artistic_Director "Artistic Director"), [Royal Exchange, Manchester](/wiki/Royal_Exchange%2C_Manchester "Royal Exchange, Manchester"). For services to Drama.
* Peter Murray, Co\-Founder, Ormiston Trust. For services to Children and Families.
* Dr. Sydney Donnelly Neill, Director, Agriculture Food and Environmental Sciences Division, Agri\-Food and Biosciences Institute, Northern Ireland Executive.
* [David Nixon](/wiki/David_Nixon_%28choreographer%29 "David Nixon (choreographer)"), Artistic Director, [Northern Ballet](/wiki/Northern_Ballet "Northern Ballet") Theatre. For services to Dance.
* Edward James O'Gorman. For charitable services to the Foundation for Children with Leukaemia.
* Professor [Timothy O'Riordan](/wiki/Tim_O%27Riordan "Tim O'Riordan"), D.L., Emeritus Professor of Environmental Sciences, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia "University of East Anglia"). For services to Sustainable Development.
* Gary Oldman. For public service.
* Dr. Jane Overbury, Principal, Christ the King Sixth Form College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.
* [Richard Parfitt](/wiki/Rick_Parfitt "Rick Parfitt"), Co\-Founder, Singer and Guitarist, [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 "Status Quo (band)"). For services to Music and to Charity.
* Dr. Louise Mary Perrotta. For public service.
* Peter Phillipson, Chairman, Merlin Entertainments Group. For services to the Leisure Industry.
* Raymond Pollock, Principal, Banbridge Academy. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Diane, Mrs. Poole, General Manager, Passengers Norfolkline Irish Sea Ferry Services. For services to the Tourist Industry.
* Melloney, Mrs. Poole, Deputy Director, Legal Services and Governance, Big Lottery Fund. For public service.
* Andrew Richard Pope, J.P., National Business Crime Partnership Manager, Co\-operative Group. For public service.
* Ms [Rachel Portman](/wiki/Rachel_Portman "Rachel Portman"), Film Composer. For services to Music.
* Colin Preece, lately Director, Social Services, Neath Port Talbot. For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Michael Charles Prestwich](/wiki/Michael_Prestwich "Michael Prestwich"), Emeritus Professor of History, [Durham University](/wiki/Durham_University "Durham University"). For services to Scholarship.
* Richard Edward Priest, Chief Executive, Riverside Centre. For services to the community in the Isle of Wight.
* Walter Rader, Director, Big Lottery Fund. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Judith, Mrs. Ragan, Headteacher, Queensmill Special School for Autism, Hammersmith and Fulham, London. For services to Special Needs Education.
* Bernardine, Mrs. Rees, lately Chief Executive, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire Local Health Board. For services to the NHS in Wales.
* Raymond Victor Refausse, lately Director and Chief Executive, South West College. For services to Further and Higher Education in Northern Ireland.
* Professor Margaret Reid, Professor of Women's Health, University of Glasgow. For services to Healthcare and to Higher Education.
* Ms Lyndy Reynolds, lately Deputy Head, Government Legal Service Secretariat, Treasury Solicitor's Department.
* Ms [Menna Richards](/wiki/Menna_Richards "Menna Richards"), Director, [BBC Wales](/wiki/BBC_Wales "BBC Wales"). For services to Broadcasting.
* Anne, Mrs. Roberts, Chief Executive, Crossroads Association. For services to Carers.
* Edmund Caerwyn Roberts, M.B.E., Chairman, Snowdonia National Park Authority. For services to the community in Gwynedd.
* Elizabeth Regina Oluyemika, Mrs. Atere\-Roberts, Older People's Nurse Specialist. For services to Healthcare in London.
* Brian Keith Rockliffe, Director, Voluntary Service Overseas. For services to International Development.
* [Francis Dominic Nicholas Michael Rossi](/wiki/Francis_Rossi "Francis Rossi"), Co\-Founder and Singer, Status Quo. For services to Music and to Charity.
* John Kenneth Rostill, Chief Executive, Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Henry James Griffin Russell, lately Chairman, National Association of General Commissioners. For public service.
* Professor Edward Sallis, Principal and Chief Executive, Highlands College, Jersey. For services to Education.
* Sujinder Singh Sangha, Principal, Stockton Riverside College, County Durham. For services to local and national Further Education.
* Professor Danny Saunders, Professor and Head of the Centre for Lifelong Learning, University of Glamorgan. For services to Higher Education in Wales.
* Professor Joseph Maurice Savage, Consultant Paediatric Nephrologist, Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children. For services to Medicine.
* Dr. Caroline Ann Bodley\-Scott, Civilian Medical Practitioner, British Forces Germany Health Service, Ministry of Defence.
* Gordon Scott. For services to Regeneration in South Yorkshire.
* [Jane Antoinette, Mrs. Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook "Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook"), Leader, [Wiltshire Council](/wiki/Wiltshire_Council "Wiltshire Council"). For services to Local Government.
* Ahmad Shahzad. For services to Black and Minority Ethnic People.
* Ghulam Rasul Shahzad. For services to Social Housing and to the community in Rochdale.
* Peter Sheldon. For services to the Jewish Community.
* Miss Julie May Shenton, Departmental Strategic Business Continuity Manager, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Dr. David Sibbald, F.R.S.E., Chairman, Sumerian Networks. For charitable services in Scotland and Overseas.
* [Alice, Mrs. Sluckin](/wiki/Alice_Sluckin "Alice Sluckin"), Chair, Selective Mutism Information and Research Association. For services to Children and Families.
* [Ronald Gordon King\-Smith](/wiki/Dick_King-Smith "Dick King-Smith"), Author. For services to Children's Literature.
* John Thomas Smith, lately Principal, Burnley College. For services to Further Education.
* Ms Laraine Smith, Principal, Uxbridge College. For services to Further Education.
* Peter Arthur Smith. For services to the Optometric Profession.
* Gerard Smyth. For services to the Police in the North East.
* Margaret, Mrs. Snowdon, Chair, Pensions Advisory Service. For services to Pensioners.
* The Honourable [Rupert Christopher Soames](/wiki/Rupert_Soames "Rupert Soames"), Chief Executive Officer, [Aggreko](/wiki/Aggreko "Aggreko") plc. For services to the Power Industry.
* Pauline Joan, Mrs. Spencer, lately Head, Victim and Witness Care Delivery Unit, Crown Prosecution Service.
* Eric Spicer. For services to the Telecommunications Industry.
* The Right Reverend James Theophilus Stapleton. For services to Inter\-Faith and Community Relations in Nottingham.
* Dr. [Miriam Stoppard](/wiki/Miriam_Stoppard "Miriam Stoppard"). For services to Healthcare and to Charity.
* Professor David Storey, lately Director, Centre for Small and Medium Enterprise, Warwick Business School. For services to Business.
* Stephen Szemerenyi, Pay and Conditions Specialist, Association of School and College Leaders. For services to Education.
* Alexander Tait, lately Governing Governor, H.M. Young Offenders' Institution Castington, Northumberland, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Jeremy James Taylor. For services to Young People and to Musical Theatre.
* David Ralph Thompson, Governor H.M. Prison Frankland, Durham, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Gillian Jane Thompson, lately Chief Executive, Accountant in Bankruptcy, Scottish Executive.
* [Cyrus Todiwala](/wiki/Cyrus_Todiwala "Cyrus Todiwala"), M.B.E., Proprietor and Executive Chef, Cafe ́ Spice Namaste ́ Restaurant Group. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Iqbal Wahhab, Chairman, Department for Work and Pensions, Ethnic Minority Advisory Group. For public service and for services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Ms [Amanda Jane Wakeley](/wiki/Amanda_Wakeley "Amanda Wakeley"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Professor Janet Anne Walker, Deputy Chair, Social Security Advisory Committee. For public service.
* James Arneil Wardrop. For services to the community in Renfrewshire.
* Caroline, Mrs. Waters, Director, People and Policy for BT Group. For services to Diversity and to Equal Opportunities.
* Norma Anne, Mrs. Watson. For services to Education in Scotland.
* Dr. John Alexander Watt, Director of Strengthening Communities, Highlands and Islands Enterprise. For services to Community Development.
* Professor Maureen Wayman, lately Pro\-Vice\-Chancellor and Dean, Art and Design, Manchester Metropolitan University. For services to local and national Higher Education.
* John Wilkinson, Chief Executive, Ecuomed. For services to the Healthcare Industry.
* [Mark Roger Wilkinson](/wiki/Mark_Wilkinson_%28designer%29 "Mark Wilkinson (designer)"). For services to the Furniture Industry and to Charity.
* Susan Jean, Mrs. Willan, lately Inspector, Her Majesty's Inspectorate for Education and Training in Wales. For services to Education.
* Professor Richard James Willson Williams, T.D., Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, Aneurin Bevan Health Board. For services to Medicine.
* Jessie, Mrs. Wojciechowski, Headteacher, Borestone Primary School, Stirling. For services to Education.
* Professor Charles Roland Wolf, Director, Biomedical Research Centre, University of Dundee. For services to Science.
* David Mark Wood, Chief Executive, ATTEND. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Dr. Eric Wood, D.L. For services to Education and to the community in Warwickshire.
* Thomas Greenaway Woods. For public service.
* Ms Louise Wright, Fraud and Error Consultant, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Stephen Frederick Wright, Head, Business, Improvement and Support Team, London, Valuation Office Agency, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Woon Wing Yip, Chairman, Wing Yip plc. For services to the Oriental Food Industry.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* [Mockbul Ali](/wiki/Mockbul_Ali "Mockbul Ali") \- Adviser to the then [Foreign \& Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_%26_Commonwealth_Office "Foreign & Commonwealth Office"). For services to British foreign policy.
* David Belgrove – lately Head, Counter Narcotics Team, British Embassy, Afghanistan.
* [Thomas Yates Benyon](/wiki/Thomas_Benyon "Thomas Benyon") – Founder and director, ZANE (Zimbabwe A National Emergency). For services to vulnerable people in Zimbabwe.
* James Gordon Davidson Blakely – Director Youth (Education, Science and Society), British Council.
* The Right Reverend Leroy Errol Brooks – For services to the community in Anguilla.
* Norma Po Yee Chan – lately Chief, Security Council Secretariat, United Nations. For services to the United Nations in New York.
* John Joseph\-Devine, LVO – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* Dr. Roderic William Dutton – Adviser on the Middle East, International Office, Durham University. For services to higher education and research links between the UK and the Middle East, especially Jordan.
* Simon John Gillham – President, Franco\-British Chamber of Commerce. For services to Franco\-British business interests in France.
* Richard Wingfield Hyde, MBE – British Honorary Consul, Madagascar. For services to the British community in Madagascar.
* [Graham King](/wiki/Graham_King "Graham King") – Film Producer. For services to the British film industry in the US and UK.
* Beverley Elizabeth Lewis – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* Nicholas Roy Mason – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Margaret Marian McPartland](/wiki/Marian_McPartland "Marian McPartland") – Pianist and Radio Show Host, National Public Radio, USA. For services to jazz and to aspiring young musicians in the USA.
* [Diane Mulligan](/wiki/Diane_Mulligan "Diane Mulligan") – for services to disabled people and to equal opportunities.
* William Smith MacDonald Murray – Economic and Financial Attaché, British Embassy, Spain.
* Brian David Outlaw – Director, China\-Britain Business Council. For services to British business interests in China.
* Mehr Tahir Kamran – British Foreign Officer, Ambassador to Russia. For services towards a better mutual co\-ordination in trade with Russia.
* Ian George Purves – lately Stabilisation Adviser, Civil Military Mission in Helmand. For services to security and stabilisation in Afghanistan.
* Michael Charles Ramscar – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Jane Antoinette Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook "Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook") – For services to local government in Wiltshire.
* Olga May Scott – For services to the health, education and development of Bermuda's youth.
* Stephen Rowland Thomas – Founder and former Chairman of OPAL, Oman. For services to British business interests and to the community in Oman.
* Paul Williams – Offsets Adviser, UK Trade and Investment, South Africa. For services to British business interests.
#### Members of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)
Military Division
Royal Navy
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Warfare Specialist (Abovewater Warfare Tactical) Russell Graham Billings](/wiki/Russell_Graham_Billings "Russell Graham Billings")
* [Logistician (Catering Services) Class 1 Rosemary Anne Brodrick](/wiki/Rosemary_Anne_Brodrick "Rosemary Anne Brodrick")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Air Engineering Technician Kenneth Michael Davidson](/wiki/Kenneth_Michael_Davidson "Kenneth Michael Davidson")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Barry Dawe](/wiki/Barry_Dawe "Barry Dawe")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Robert John Ewen](/wiki/Robert_John_Ewen "Robert John Ewen")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) John Ronald Hendren](/wiki/John_Ronald_Hendren "John Ronald Hendren")
* [Lieutenant Commander Steven David Hopkins](/wiki/Steven_David_Hopkins "Steven David Hopkins")
* [Lieutenant Anthony Jackson](/wiki/Anthony_Jackson_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "Anthony Jackson (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Lieutenant Commander Bryan John Nicholas](/wiki/Bryan_John_Nicholas "Bryan John Nicholas")
* [Chief Petty Officer Engineering Technician (Marine Engineering) David Parker](/wiki/David_Parker_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 "David Parker (Royal Navy officer)")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) Andrew Mark Rainey](/wiki/Andrew_Mark_Rainey "Andrew Mark Rainey")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Philip David Slocombe](/wiki/Philip_David_Slocombe "Philip David Slocombe")
* [Lieutenant Commander Graham Gilbey Trewhella](/wiki/Graham_Gilbey_Trewhella "Graham Gilbey Trewhella")
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 (Bugler) James Whitwham](/wiki/James_Whitwham "James Whitwham")
Army
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Justin Mark Brooks](/wiki/Justin_Mark_Brooks "Justin Mark Brooks") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Major Neil James Mark Budd](/wiki/Neil_James_Mark_Budd "Neil James Mark Budd") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Major Richard Ronald Coomber](/wiki/Richard_Ronald_Coomber "Richard Ronald Coomber") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Major Jonathan Edward Cunningham](/wiki/Jonathan_Edward_Cunningham "Jonathan Edward Cunningham") – The Yorkshire Regiment
* [Major Robert Anthony Davies](/wiki/Robert_Anthony_Davies "Robert Anthony Davies") – The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment
* [Major Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood](/wiki/Mark_Christopher_Preston_Ellwood "Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood") – The Mercian Regiment
* [Lieutenant Colonel Michael Richard Elviss](/wiki/Mike_Elviss "Mike Elviss") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Major Graham Roy Emond](/wiki/Graham_Roy_Emond "Graham Roy Emond") – Devon Army Cadet Force
* [Major Christopher Gill](/wiki/Christopher_Gill_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Christopher Gill (British Army officer)") – Army Air Corps, Territorial Army
* [Major Paul Harrison](/wiki/Paul_Harrison_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Paul Harrison (British Army officer)") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Captain Philip John Hawkins](/wiki/Philip_John_Hawkins "Philip John Hawkins") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Anthony Mark Hobbins](/wiki/Anthony_Mark_Hobbins "Anthony Mark Hobbins") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Staff Sergeant Gary Holdham](/wiki/Gary_Holdham "Gary Holdham") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Charles Henry James Holdsworth](/wiki/Charles_Henry_James_Holdsworth "Charles Henry James Holdsworth") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Sergeant Barry John](/wiki/Barry_John_%28British_Army_officer%29 "Barry John (British Army officer)") – The Royal Welsh
* Captain Susan King – Royal Corps of Signals
* [Major Joanna Catherine Maynard](/wiki/Joanna_Catherine_Maynard "Joanna Catherine Maynard") – Royal Corps of Signals
* [Captain Richard Andrew Peters](/wiki/Richard_Andrew_Peters "Richard Andrew Peters") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Damien Daniel Place](/wiki/Damien_Daniel_Place "Damien Daniel Place") – The Royal Irish Regiment
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Iestyn David Plummer](/wiki/Iestyn_David_Plummer "Iestyn David Plummer") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Major James Samuel Robert Priest](/wiki/James_Samuel_Robert_Priest "James Samuel Robert Priest") – The Royal Logistic Corps
* [Major Jonathan Howard Scott](/wiki/Jonathan_Howard_Scott "Jonathan Howard Scott") – Corps of Royal Engineers
* [Major Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe](/wiki/Jeremy_Edward_Gavin_Sharpe "Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Paul Philip Shipley](/wiki/Paul_Philip_Shipley "Paul Philip Shipley") – Royal Regiment of Artillery
* [Lieutenant Colonel Hugh Campbell\-Smith](/wiki/Hugh_Campbell-Smith "Hugh Campbell-Smith") – The Royal Dragoon Guards
* [Major Oliver William Stokes](/wiki/Oliver_William_Stokes "Oliver William Stokes") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Major Sonya Adams Summersgill](/wiki/Sonya_Adams_Summersgill "Sonya Adams Summersgill") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army
* [Major Alasdair James Eli Truett](/wiki/Alasdair_James_Eli_Truett "Alasdair James Eli Truett") – The Parachute Regiment
* [Captain Thomas Georg John Tugendhat](/wiki/Thomas_Tugendhat "Thomas Tugendhat") – Intelligence Corps, Territorial Army
* [Lieutenant Colonel Colin Richard James Weir](/wiki/Colin_Weir "Colin Weir") – The Royal Irish Regiment
* [Major Robert John Wells](/wiki/Robert_John_Wells "Robert John Wells") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment
* [Major Christopher James White](/wiki/Christopher_James_White "Christopher James White") – Surrey Army Cadet Force
* Lieutenant Colonel John Wilson – Cumbria Army Cadet Force
Royal Air Force
* [Warrant Officer Peter Allen Akers](/wiki/Peter_Allen_Akers "Peter Allen Akers")
* [Chief Technician Paul Andrew Blackah](/wiki/Paul_Andrew_Blackah "Paul Andrew Blackah")
* [Squadron Leader Ian Bryant](/wiki/Ian_Bryant_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "Ian Bryant (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Squadron Leader John Cairns](/wiki/John_Cairns_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "John Cairns (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Warrant Officer Alexander Michael Dykes](/wiki/Alexander_Michael_Dykes "Alexander Michael Dykes")
* [Flight Sergeant Douglas Stuart Law](/wiki/Douglas_Stuart_Law "Douglas Stuart Law")
* [Warrant Officer Rachel MacKenzie](/wiki/Rachel_MacKenzie "Rachel MacKenzie")
* [Flying Officer Leslie Edward Wall McCammont](/wiki/Leslie_Edward_Wall_McCammont "Leslie Edward Wall McCammont")
* [Sergeant Rodney Christian Munday](/wiki/Rodney_Christian_Munday "Rodney Christian Munday")
* [Squadron Leader John Nelson](/wiki/John_Nelson_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 "John Nelson (Royal Air Force officer)")
* [Squadron Leader Gordon William Henry Parry](/wiki/Gordon_William_Henry_Parry "Gordon William Henry Parry")
* [Flight Sergeant Christopher Edward Read](/wiki/Christopher_Edward_Read "Christopher Edward Read")
* [Warrant Officer Stephen Kenneth Roberts](/wiki/Stephen_Kenneth_Roberts "Stephen Kenneth Roberts")
* [Squadron Leader Colin Terence Sullivan](/wiki/Colin_Terence_Sullivan "Colin Terence Sullivan")
* [Senior Aircraftman Darren Mark Swift](/wiki/Darren_Mark_Swift "Darren Mark Swift")
Civil Division
* Gwendolen June, Mrs. Abraham. For services to the community in Braunstone, Leicestershire.
* Hemant Acharya, Policy Adviser, Office of the Third Sector, Cabinet Office.
* Samuel Adair, Director, Waterside Credit Union Ltd. For services to the Financial Services Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Valerie Edith, Mrs. Adams, Principal, Lisbellaw Primary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Manus Blake Adamson, Chairman, Adamson Group and Executive Chairman, Construction Confederation. For services to the Construction Industry.
* Robin Agascar. For voluntary service to the Police in Gloucester.
* Matilda, Mrs. Akhigbe, Communications Officer, Local Compliance, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Ms Foluke Akinlose, Founder and Editor, Precious Online. For services to the Creative Industries.
* Gerald Akroyd. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Scotland.
* Anthony John Alderman, Special Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Ms Angela Cecile Alessendre, Founder, Alessendre Special Needs Dance School and the Larondina Dance Company. For services to Dance.
* Anne Maria Palma, Mrs. Allan, Deputy Head Teacher, inverclyde Academy, Greenock. For services to Education.
* Dr. Geoffrey Walter Allan. For services to the community in Kirkintilloch, Dunbartonshire.
* Shulah, Mrs. Allan, lately Director, Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations Council. For services to the Voluntary Sector.
* Lynda, Mrs. Allen, Chair of Governors, Sir John Deane's Sixth Form College, Northwich, Cheshire. For voluntary service to Education.
* Andrew Paul Andrews. For voluntary service to St. John Ambulance Brigade.
* John Charles Ankcorn, President, Birmingham Crisis Centre. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence.
* Linda Joyce, Mrs. Ansell. For charitable services in Southend\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Miss Kerry Anthony, Chief Executive, DePaul Northern Ireland. For services to Social Housing.
* David Archbold. For services to the Water Industry in the North East.
* James Armitage. For services to the Royal Mail and to the community in the West Midlands.
* Carol, Mrs. Armstrong, Claims Receipts Manager, Benefits and Credits Operations, Washington, Tyne and Wear, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Mohammed Aslam, Executive Chef and Managing Director, Aagrah Group Restaurants. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Jean, Mrs. Atkinson, lately Staff Side Chair, UNISON, Mersey Care NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.
* Barbara May, Mrs. Austin. For services to the community in Lyme Regis, Dorset.
* Kenneth Edwin Ayers. For services to the City of London Corporation.
* Gloria, Mrs. Bailey. For services to the community in Lambeth, South London.
* Joan Debra, Mrs. Bailey. For services to Youth Justice in Luton, Bedfordshire.
* Sharon Gail, Mrs. Bailey, J.P., Head of Service Learning Disabilities, Birmingham City Council. For services to Local Government.
* Lilian, Mrs. Baker. For services to Mental Healthcare in the Wirral.
* Warner James Baker, Special Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Robert Henry Ball. For services to Young People in Exeter, Devon.
* Susan, Mrs. Banton, Director, Steps Charity Worldwide. For services to People with Skeletal Disabilities.
* Ramanbhai Barber. For services to the Asian community in Leicester.
* Grace, Mrs. Barnett. For services to the community in Failsworth, Oldham.
* [Norman Barrett](/wiki/Norman_Barrett_%28ringmaster%29 "Norman Barrett (ringmaster)"), Circus Ringmaster. For services to Entertainment.
* Derek Anthony Bartley. For services to the Midland Association of Mountaineering and to Rhyl Music Club, Denbighshire.
* Miss [Luella Dayrell Bartley](/wiki/Luella_Bartley "Luella Bartley"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Patricia, Mrs. Bate. For services to the community in Warrington, Cheshire.
* Thomas Frederick Beesley. For services to the community in Halewood, Liverpool.
* Antony Romer Beevor. For voluntary service to Fairbridge youth organisation.
* Gulrook, Mrs. Begum. For services to Disabled Bangladeshi People in Tower Hamlets, London.
* Stephen Avery Bell, Managing Director, Davy Roll Company. For services to Business in the North East.
* Mavis, Mrs. Bent. For voluntary service to Swimming and Water Polo in Greater Manchester.
* John Alfred Bigny. For services to Edenbridge and District Rail Travellers' Association Kent.
* Helen, Mrs. Bird. For services to the community in Hastings, East Sussex.
* Dr. [Charles William Handley Bird](/wiki/William_Bird_%28doctor%29 "William Bird (doctor)"), General Medical Practitioner and Strategic Health Adviser to Natural England. For services to Healthcare and to Physical Activity.
* Arthur Birkby. For services to the community in Runnymede, Surrey.
* Paul Blakey. For services to Community Safety in Halifax.
* Alan Blocksidge, Officer, H.M. Prison Manchester, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* June, Mrs. Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.
* Roy Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Boswell. For services to the community in Sheerness, Kent.
* John Stephen Morton Bower. For services to the British Veterinary Association Animal Welfare Foundation.
* Miss Jennifer Boyd, Principal, Enniskillen Nursery School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Scott Michael Bradbury. For services to the community in Tamworth, Staffordshire.
* Barbara Evelyn Turner, Mrs. Braithwaite. For voluntary service to the community in Linlithgow, West Lothian.
* [Rosa, Mrs. Branson](/wiki/Rosa_Branson "Rosa Branson"), Painter. For services to Art and to Charity.
* Richard Oliver Brantingham, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* David Keith Bray. For services to the community in Lincolnshire.
* Valerie, Mrs. Braybrooks, Dean and Associate Professor, Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Animal Sciences, University of Lincoln. For services to Education and to the Food Industry.
* John Frederick Brignall. For services to the community in the East Riding of Yorkshire.
* Philip Britton, Headmaster, Boys' Division, Bolton School. For services to Physics.
* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Bromley. For charitable services in Oswestry, Shropshire.
* Robert Patrick Brooks. For voluntary service to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Clwyd.
* Felicity, Mrs. Brown, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Ms Marie Therese Brown. For services to the Victims of Domestic Violence in Northern Ireland.
* Norman Henry Parson Brown. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion in Hampshire.
* Robert Brown. For services to the community in Lower Bevendean, Brighton.
* David Buchanan. For voluntary service to the Environment and to Heritage in Northern Ireland.
* Diana Hill, Mrs. Bucknall. For voluntary service to the community in Dorset.
* Lieutenant Commander James Frederic Budgen, R.N.R. For voluntary service to the Sea Cadet Corps in Ruislip, London Borough of Hillingdon.
* Frederick Henry Ernest Buller. For services to Angling.
* Yvonne, Mrs. Burdge. For services to the Trust for Chernobyl Children.
* Kenneth Burgin. For voluntary service to the Casualties Union.
* Richard John Burningham, Manager, Devon and Cornwall Rail Partnership. For services to the Rail Industry in the South West.
* Dr. Stephen Brian Burns. For services to Healthcare and to the community in Rotherham, South Yorkshire.
* William Henry Burt. For voluntary service to Education in Bridgend, South Wales.
* David John Butler, Chairman, British Motorsport Association for the Disabled. For services to Disability Sport.
* [Jenson Alexander Lyons Button](/wiki/Jenson_Button "Jenson Button"). For services to Motorsport.
* Ian Caddy. For services to the community in Birtley, County Durham.
* Dr. Timothy Alan Carney, General Medical Practitioner, Hexham and Tynedale, Northumberland. For services to Healthcare.
* The Reverend Barry Edward Carter. For services to the community in Brockley, South East London.
* Colin Richard Carter. For services to the Road Haulage Industry and to Charity.
* Rosalind Ella, Mrs. Carter, EAL Education Adviser, Language Service, London Borough of Hounslow. For services to Education.
* Dr. Susan Carver, Senior Programme Manager, Arts and Humanities Research Council. For services to the Research Councils.
* Wing Commander Alan Charles Cassidy RAF (Ret'd). For services to Aerobatics and to Charity.
* Robin William Castle. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Sheerness, Kent.
* Judith Evelyn, Mrs. Catterick. For services to Music in Ashwell, Hertfordshire.
* James Joseph Caulfield. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged People in Kenya.
* Miss Susan Caulfield, Assistant Director, Immigration Fingerprint Bureau, UK Border Agency, Home Office.
* Peter Geoffrey Challinor, Curator and Manager, Anson Engine Museum. For services to Industrial Heritage.
* Harry Chambers. For services to Poetry.
* Patricia, Mrs. Chapman. For services to Young People and to the community in Ealing, West London.
* Glendon Austin Chappelle, Project Manager, Global Combat Systems—Munitions, BAE Systems. For services to the Defence Industry and to Industrial Heritage.
* Deborah Ann, Mrs. Chedgey. For services to Disadvantaged People in Norwich, Norfolk.
* Rex Chester. For services to Young People through the Explore Charity.
* Ms [Lauren Child](/wiki/Lauren_Child "Lauren Child"), Author and Illustrator. For services to Literature.
* Stanley Charles Church. For voluntary service to Conservation in Essex.
* Donna, Mrs. Clark, Assistant Practitioner, Podiatry Service, Sefton Primary Care Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Leonard Durbin Clark. For services to Young People in Westminster and to the community in North West London.
* Peter Mansfield\-Clark, Director, Crawley Open House. For services to Disadvantaged People in West Sussex.
* Dr. Janet Ruth Clarke, Chair, Central Committee for Community and Public Health Dentistry, British Dental Association. For services to Healthcare.
* Susan, Mrs. Clarke. For voluntary service to Disability Swimming in Stockton\-on\-Tees.
* Dr. Peter David Clarkson, Emeritus Associate, Scott Polar Research Institute. For services to Science.
* Professor Timothy Charles Claypole, Director, Welsh Centre for Printing and Coating, Swansea University. For services to Graphic Arts Research.
* Barry Clewer. For voluntary service to Birmingham Advisory Council of Older People.
* [Oliver Charles Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 "Collyer brothers (game designers)"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to Computer Games Industry.
* [Paul Edward Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 "Collyer brothers (game designers)"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to the Computer Game Industry.
* David Constantine, Co\-Founder and Executive Officer Motivation. For services to disabled people.
* Teresa Mary, Mrs. Copp, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* David John Couch. For charitable services in Fife.
* Thelma Selina, Mrs. Couch. For charitable services in Fife.
* Ms Margaret Joan Coulter. For services to Social Care in Northern Ireland.
* [The Reverend Dr. Robert James Coulter](/wiki/Robert_Coulter_%28Northern_Ireland_politician%29 "Robert Coulter (Northern Ireland politician)"), Member, Northern Ireland Assembly Commission. For public service.
* David Robert Coulthard, Senior Technician, University of York. For services to Science Communication.
* Beryl, Mrs. Cox, Administrator, Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, York. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Theresa, Mrs. Coyle. For voluntary service to the community in Islington, London.
* Dorothy Dawn, Mrs. Cragg, Medical Tattooist. For services to Healthcare.
* Heather, Mrs. Crawford. For services to Speech and Language Therapy in Northern Ireland.
* Arthur Graves Credland. For services to Maritime History.
* Margaret, Mrs. Crennell, Senior Assistant Headteacher and Head of Learning Support Faculty, Marriotts School, Stevenage. For services to Special Needs Education.
* Ms Heather Alice Crouch, Chair, Netball South West. For voluntary service to Sport.
* John Cunningham. For charitable services in County Durham.
* Gordon Curry. For public service.
* Leonard James Curtis. For services to the community in Lancashire.
* Ms Nicola Kim Dale, Chief Inspector, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.
* David Dallison. For public service.
* Ashish Dasgupta, Non\-Executive Director, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* John Kenneth Davies. For charitable services in Rochdale.
* Patricia Ann, Mrs. Davies. For voluntary service to Young People in Brownhills, Walsall, West Midlands.
* Sandra Irwin, Mrs. Davies. For services to the community in Craven Arms, Shropshire.
* Vanessa Marion, Mrs. Davies, Physiotherapist, Artificial Limb and Appliance Centre, Morriston Hospital, Swansea. For services to Healthcare.
* Barbara Jane, Mrs. Davis. For services to Young People in Buckinghamshire.
* Ian Davis. For services to the House of Commons.
* Eric George Dawkins. For services to the community in Penryn and Falmouth, Cornwall.
* Terence Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Victoria, Mrs. Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Ms Ilene Daisy Ming\-Deans. For services to Clapham Youth Centre, Lambeth, London.
* Sister Lynda Dearlove. For services to Vulnerable Women.
* Sarinder Kaur, Mrs. Dev, Constable, South Yorkshire Police. For services to the Police.
* Achhar Paul Dharni. For services to Business and to the community in Bradford, West Yorkshire.
* Gwyneth Muriel, Mrs. Dickinson, President, Macular Disease Society. For services to Visually Impaired People.
* Valerie Anne, Mrs. Dilcock. For services to the North York Moors National Park Authority.
* Ronald Dodd, Chairman, Training and Development Resource Ltd, Tyneside. For services to Skills.
* Ian Henry Donaghey. For services to Regeneration in Coleraine, Northern Ireland.
* Mary Maya, Mrs. Donelan. For services to the community in Hammersmith and Fulham, London.
* Ms Norah Donnelly. For public service.
* Jennifer, Mrs. Doolan. Harpist. For services to Music.
* Muriel Margaret, Mrs. Douglas, Manager, Scottish NHS Central Register, General Register Office for Scotland, Scottish Executive.
* Dr. Andrew Frank Dove. For services to St. John Ambulance Brigade in Nottinghamshire.
* Carol Ann, Mrs. Downes, Divisional Officer, Derbyshire Special Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.
* Ray Downey. For charitable services to Sunderland Kidney Patient Group.
* John Ernest Drake, lately Chief Executive, YMCA Norfolk. For services to Young People.
* Alan Gordon Drinkall. For services to the community In North Yorkshire.
* Councillor Elizabeth Ann Ducker, Leader, South Oxfordshire District Council. For services to Local Government.
* David John Duke, Principal Technician, Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge. For services to Science.
* Karen, Mrs. Duncan, Senior Executive Officer, Student Finance Policy, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.
* William Duncan. For services to Horticulture in Scotland.
* Miss Elizabeth Dunlop. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Scotland.
* Terrance Dunne. For voluntary service to St. Andrew's Hospice, Airdrie, Lanarkshire.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Dupres. For services to St. Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Egham, Surrey.
* Sheila, Mrs. Eaglefield. For charitable services in Derbyshire.
* Eric James Eames. For services to the community in Birmingham.
* Ewan Easton. For voluntary service to H.M. Young Offenders' Institution, Thorn Cross, Warrington, Cheshire.
* The Reverend Mark Antony Edwards. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the North East.
* Gillian, Mrs. Elkins. For services to the community in Clacton\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Miss Susan Ellis, lately Principal Officer, South East Area, National Offender Management Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Miss Cathryn Ellsmore, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence. Dr. John Richard England. For services to Retail Planning.
* Eileen, Mrs. Entwistle. For services to Local Government and to the community in Darwen and Blackburn, Lancashire.
* Geraint Evans. For voluntary service to Education in the Vale of Glamorgan.
* Sheila, Mrs. Evans, lately Administrative Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Thomas Eurfyl Evans, Councillor, Ceredigion County Council. For services to Local Government in West Wales.
* [Timothy Everest](/wiki/Timothy_Everest "Timothy Everest"), Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Margaret, Mrs. Fairbrother, Senior Probation Officer, Sussex Probation Area. For services to the Administration of Justice.
* Kelly, Mrs. Fairman. For services to the Fire and Rescue Service.
* Donald Fava, lately Business and Performance Reporting Manager, Finance and Operations Directorate, Department of Health.
* Janis Elizabeth, Mrs. Feely, Founder and Project Director, Living Room, Stevenage, Hertfordshire. For services to Disadvantaged People.
* Ms Ann Ferguson. For services to Older People in Scotland.
* Ms Margaret Hilary Ferriman, Chair, Banbury District Racial Equality Council. For services to Community Relations.
* Ms Deirdre Figueiredo, Director of Craftspace. For services to the Visual Arts in the West Midlands.
* Lyndon Filer, Chief Executive, Police Rehabilitation Centre, Goring\-on\-Thames. For services to the Police.
* Michael Peter Findley. For charitable services in Redcar, Cleveland.
* Dr. Doreen Elizabeth Finneron. For services to Inter\-Faith Relations.
* Peggy Rita, Mrs. Finnie. For services to the community in Aberdeen.
* Peter James Fisher, Policy Adviser, Office of the Judge Advocate\-General, Ministry of Justice.
* Ms Honor Wilson\-Fletcher, lately Director, National Year of Reading. For services to Education.
* Anthony Fowler. For services to the community in Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire.
* Dereck Fowles, lately Chairman, Forth Valley and Lomond Local Action Group. For services to Rural Communities in Scotland.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Fox. For voluntary service to Deeside Community Hospital League of Friends, North Wales.
* Jennifer Lesley, Mrs. Foxon, Senior Technician, Department of Genetics, University of Leicester. For services to Science.
* David Victor Freeborn. For services to the Patterdale Mountain Rescue Team in the Lake District.
* Peter French, Deputy Chairman, London Board of Crimestoppers. For services to the Police.
* Timothy Enis French. For services to the community in Haywards Heath, West Sussex.
* Pino Frumiento, Singer and Songwriter, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.
* Dr. Ian David Robert Fry, Director, Partnership Pathology, Frimley Park Hospital NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare in the South East.
* Michael Fuller. For services to the NHS and to the Unite Trade Union in Scotland.
* Richard Gagan, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Irene Lorraine, Mrs. Galloway, lately Caseworker, Customer Operation, Lisburn, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Sarah Elizabeth, Mrs. Gamble. For services to the community in County Antrim.
* Stuart Mitchell Gay, J.P. For services to the community in Lancashire and Overseas.
* Mary Helen, Mrs. George, Catering Supervisor, Crossroads Primary School, Keith. For services to Education.
* Asquith Gibbes. For voluntary service to the Police in South East London.
* Henry Atherton Derek Gibson. For services to the community in Bridgwater, Somerset.
* Mary, Mrs. Gibson. For services to Education and to the community in North London.
* Robert Stewart Gibson, Officer, H.M. Prison Gartree, Leicestershire, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Margaret Helen, Mrs. Gilbert. For services to Older People in County Tyrone.
* Atma Singh Gill. For services to the community in the North East.
* Joy, Mrs. Gillies. For voluntary service to the Children's Panel in Scotland.
* Bernard John Godding. For voluntary service to Adult Learning and the Educational Centres Association.
* Alan John Godfrey, Publisher of Historic Ordnance Survey Maps. For services to Heritage.
* Professor [Michael Goodfellow](/wiki/Michael_Goodfellow "Michael Goodfellow"), Chairman of Governors, Gosforth High School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For voluntary service to Education.
* Sheila, Mrs. Gow. For services to Regional Journalism.
* Ms Agnes Graham. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Western Scotland.
* Dr. Maria Jadwiga Dlugolecka\-Graham. For services to Polish\-Scottish Relations and to Medicine.
* Robert Oliver David Graham, lately Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Barbara, Mrs. Grant, Clinical Nurse Manager, NHS Fife. For services to Ophthalmology.
* [Clemency Anne Rose, Mrs. Gray](/wiki/Rose_Gray "Rose Gray"), Co\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* William Gray. For services to Diversity and to Disability Training in Scotland.
* Angela Margaret, Mrs. Green. For charitable services Overseas and in Malvern, Worcestershire.
* Charles Anthony Green. For voluntary service to Industrial Heritage in the Staffordshire Potteries.
* Susan, Mrs. Greenwood, Specialist Community Public Health Nurse, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly. For services to Healthcare.
* David Grey, Group Managing Director, OSL Group Holdings Ltd. For services to Business and to Regeneration in Sheffield.
* Pauline, Mrs. Grice, Chief Executive, South Yorkshire Community Foundation. For services to Flood Relief.
* Joan, Mrs. Griffiths. For services to People with Learning Disabilities in Scotland.
* Mary Beatrice, Mrs. Guest. For services to People with Sensory Impairment.
* Mavis Ann, Mrs. Gunning. For voluntary service to Victims of Sexual Assault.
* Gordon William Guthrie. For services to Derby County Football Club.
* Ms Anna\-Marie Hale (Mrs. Byrne), Matron, Division One Trauma and Orthopaedics, Selly Oak Hospital, Birmingham. For services to Healthcare.
* Colonel Alan Edmund Hall, T.D., D.L. For services to the community in the London Borough of Redbridge.
* Iain Murray Halliday. For services to the Arts in Perth.
* David Halpin. For services to disabled people in the North West.
* Pauline Jane, Mrs. Handy, Clinical Lead Nurse, Genito\-Urinary Medicine, Newcastle General Hospital. For services to Healthcare.
* Frank Hannah, President, Manchester County Football Association. For services to Sport.
* Ms Belinda Harding, Constable, City of London Police. For services to the Police.
* Gillian Carol, Mrs. Hardy, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* [Terence Harris](/wiki/Jet_Harris "Jet Harris"). For services to Music.
* Ms Karen Harrison, Head, Business Crime Preventions Team, Wakefield Partnership. For services to the Police.
* Peter Brantford Hartland. For services to the community in Ashton Keynes, Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Colin Hartley. For services to the community in Halifax, West Yorkshire.
* Faith Ingrid Evelyn, Mrs. Harvey. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire.
* Ms Susan Harvey. For services to Orienteering and to the community in Doune and Deanston, Perth and Kinross.
* Margaret Lynne, Mrs. Harwood, Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Margaret Vine, Mrs. Haugh, Adviser for Creative and Expressive Studies, Southern Education and Library Board. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.
* Jean, Mrs. Hayley. Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.
* Rodney James Hayley, Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.
* Lewis Charles Haywood. For services to the Energy Learning Centre, Elliot Durham School, Nottingham.
* Professor John William Stanley Hearle. For services to Archaeology in Mellor, Stockport, Greater Manchester.
* Jean, Mrs. Heath. For services to Chadlington Primary School, Oxfordshire.
* Roberta, Mrs. Heavens. For services to the Tourism Industry.
* Jean Marion Anne, Mrs. Hedley. For voluntary service to Nature Conservation in Hampshire and the Isle of Wight.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Heeley. For voluntary service to Somerset Rural Life Museum.
* Ms [Anna Hemmings](/wiki/Anna_Hemmings "Anna Hemmings"), Canoeist. For services to Sport.
* John Graham Hemmings, Chairman, Blurton Ladsandads, Stoke\-on\-Trent. For services to Grass Roots Football.
* John Patrick Hennigan, Superintendent, British Transport Police. For services to the Police.
* Miss Sylvia Jean Herbert, Chaplain, H.M. Prison Leicester. For services to Prisoners.
* John Coleman Hick, Vice\-President, British Holiday and Home Parks Association. For services to the Tourist Industry.
* Major Antony Stanley Hill. For services to Military Heritage in Essex.
* Lyn Joy, Mrs. Hill, Band 5, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Richard Wendle Hill, Branch Manager, Ulster Bank. For services to the Financial Services Industry.
* Margaret, Mrs. Hillman. For services to Girlguiding Cymru and to the Community of Hope.
* Christopher Hilton, lately General Manager, Odeon Leicester Square Cinema. For services to the Film Industry.
* Barry Hitchcock, Director of Sport, University of Surrey. For services to Sport and to Higher Education.
* Raymond Hodgkinson, Director\-General, British Healthcare Trades Association. For services to the Healthcare Industry.
* Linda Mary, Mrs. Hoggarth. For services to disabled people in Suffolk.
* Ms Jean Florence Holder. For voluntary service to the Women's Library.
* Miss Rhiannon Sarah Holder. For services to Young People's Healthcare.
* Valerie Lois, Mrs. Holt. For services to Fisheries Management and to Conservation.
* Lady Lavinia Caroline Douglas\-Home, D.L. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross and Macmillan Cancer Support in the Scottish Borders.
* Michael John Hopper, lately Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Douglas Horrill. For voluntary service to Age Concern, New Forest East, Hampshire.
* Doreen Grace, Mrs. Hosey. For services to the community in Fawley, Southampton.
* Ms Rebecca Ann Hosking. For services to the Environment in Modbury, Dorset.
* Donna Maria, Mrs. Hough, Dental Workforce Development Lead for Dental Care Professionals, North Western and Mersey Postgraduate Deaneries. For services to Healthcare.
* Edward Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.
* Winifred, Mrs. Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.
* Ms Sheila Hudson. For services to Disadvantaged Young People in Hartlepool.
* Joe Human. For services to Oxfam and to Fair Trade in Cumbria.
* Brenda, Mrs. Hunt. For services to Older People in East Manchester.
* Carl Peter Hunt, Watch Manager, Humberside Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.
* Alderman Edna, Lady Hunter. For services to the community in County Durham.
* The Reverend Canon Michael Oram Hunter. For services to the Church of England and to the community in Grimsby.
* Professor John Margarson Huthnance, Deputy Director, Proudman Oceanographic Laboratory. For services to Marine Science.
* Dr. Thomas George Hyde. For services to the community in Repton, Derbyshire.
* Brian Ibell, lately Assistant Chief Executive, Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Andrew Ingram, Executive Officer, Output Services Group, Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, Swansea, Department for Transport.
* Peter David John Ingram. For services to Paper Making Industrial Heritage.
* James John Jack. For services to Children and Young People at Kibble Education and Care Centre.
* Mona, Mrs. Jack. For services to the community in Dumfries.
* Florence, Mrs. Jackson. For voluntary service to Hatton Hill Primary School, Sefton, Merseyside.
* Valerie, Mrs. Jackson, Founder and Principal, Stage 84\. For services to the Performing Arts in the North.
* Valerie Hazel, Mrs. Jackson. For services to the community in Newcastle Emlyn, Carmarthenshire.
* [John Alexander Jameson](/wiki/John_Jameson_%28cricketer%29 "John Jameson (cricketer)"). For services to cricket.
* Waltraud Anna Luise, Mrs. Jarrold. For services to the community in Norwich.
* Susan Kay, Mrs. Jay, Area Manager, West Suffolk MIND. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Helen Adair, Mrs. Jenkins. For services to the community in Durrington, Wiltshire.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Jenkins, Senior Case Adviser, Freedom of Information Team, H.M. Treasury.
* Sidney Johnson. For services to the community in Helston, Cornwall.
* John Johnstone, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Henry Jones, Project Manager, ISIS Second Target Station, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Oxfordshire. For services to Science.
* Jane Eryl, Mrs. Jones, lately Senior Nurse, Eryri Hospital, Caernarfon. For services to Healthcare for Older People.
* Penelope, Mrs. Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.
* Ronald Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.
* Charles Ernest Jukes. For services to the community in Dursley, Gloucestershire.
* Ms Maureen Kavanagh, Messenger, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Kay, Co\-Founder and Project Leader, Bolton University of the Third Age. For voluntary service to Adult Education.
* Bernard John Keay, Chairman, Health and Social Security Recreational Association, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Virginia Anne Pickering, Mrs. Keen. For services to the community in Wiltshire.
* Victor Walter Keene. For services to the community in Coventry.
* William Ernest James Kelley. For voluntary service to the RAF Halton Apprentices' Association.
* Patricia Alexandra, Mrs. Kelly. Foster Carer, Cornwall. For services to Children and Families.
* Graham Kennedy. For charitable services to People with [Friedreich's ataxia](/wiki/Friedreich%27s_ataxia "Friedreich's ataxia").
* Miss Linda Margaret Kennedy, Manager, Banqueting House, Whitehall. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* Anne, Mrs. Kenyon, Administrative Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Hilary, Mrs. Kerr. For services to Children and Young People with Special Needs in Warrington, Cheshire.
* Dr. David John Kerridge, Head of Science, Earth Hazards and Earth Systems Science, British Geological Survey. For services to Geophysics.
* Ms Imtaz Khaliq, Designer and Master Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.
* Ms Shahda Khan, Principal Community Cohesion Officer, Middlesbrough Council. For services to Local Government and to Diversity.
* Ms [Catherine Isabel Audrey Kidston](/wiki/Cath_Kidston "Cath Kidston"), Founder and Creative Director, Cath Kidston. For services to Business.
* Patrick Kieran, Senior Design Engineer. For services to Science.
* Anne Elizabeth, Mrs. King, Director, Building Services Research and Information Association. For services to Industry.
* Debra Ann, Mrs. King, Chair, Thornhill New Deal for Communities. For services to the community in Southampton, Hampshire.
* Jacqueline, Mrs. Upton\-King, Chair, Management Team, SturQuest Community Partnership. For services to the community in Sturminster Newton, Dorset.
* Brenda Patricia, Mrs. Kirby. For services to the community in Croydon.
* Ms Marjorie Kirk. For voluntary service to H.M. Prison Nottingham.
* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Kirkwood. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northern Ireland.
* Ms Anna Kucewicz (Mrs. Lee\-Potter). For voluntary service to the Polish Scouting Association, Girl Scouts Division (UK).
* Paul Lambert, Chairman, Derbyshire Family Association. For services to Maritime Safety.
* John Lewis George Lamotte. For voluntary service to Animal Welfare in Scotland.
* Gabriel Lancaster. For services to the community in Medway, Kent.
* Miss Irene Langlands. For services to Dance in Central Scotland.
* Huw John Launder, Senior Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Derek Law, Corporate Director, Adult and Community Services, North Yorkshire County Council. For services to Local Government.
* Ronald Lawrence. For services to the Police and to the community in Nottinghamshire.
* Miss Kathleen Lawrenson, Diagnostic Audiologist, St. Helens and Knowsley Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Sheila Irene, Mrs. Layton, Founder, Contessa Riding Centre, Hertfordshire. For services to Equestrian Sport.
* Margaret, Mrs. Lee, Chief Executive, Cresco Trust. For services to Social Enterprise in Northern Ireland.
* Bryan Lewin, lately Head of Trading Standards, Northamptonshire County Council. For services to Consumers and to Business.
* Miss Judith Anne Lewis. For services to the Environment in the North East.
* Councillor Leonard Lewis. For services to Local Government and to the community in Caerphilly, South Wales.
* Neil Lewis. For services to Industrial Heritage and to the community in Blaenavon, Torfaen.
* David Robin Littlewood. For voluntary service to Athletics.
* Dr. Stephen Nicholas Liversedge, General Medical Practitioner, Bolton. For services to Healthcare.
* Wesley Courtney Livingstone, President, Newry Musical and Orchestral Society. For services to Music and to the community in County Down.
* Mary Constance, Mrs. Lloyd. For services to the community in Rutland.
* Pauline, Mrs. Lockett. For services to the community of Ackworth, West Yorkshire.
* Arthur Clifford Lockyear. For services to the community in Sunderland.
* Ian Douglas Loe, Wildlife Stamp Designer. For services to Art.
* Jeffrey Long. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion.
* Ronald Hedley Longford, Chiropractor and Physiotherapist. For services to Animal Welfare.
* Carmel, Mrs. Lyddall, Executive Assistant, Local Government and Regional Policy Team, Department of Health.
* Alexander McKay Lynch. Group Finance Director, David MacBrayne Ltd, Gourock. For services to Transport and Charity in Scotland.
* Ms Ann MacKay, Policy Adviser, English Community Care Association. For services to Social Care.
* Professor [Margaret MacLean](/wiki/Margaret_MacLean "Margaret MacLean"), Professor of Pulmonary Pharmacology. For services to Science.
* Geraldine, Mrs. MacPhee, Principal Teacher in Home Economics, Clyde Valley High School. For services to Education and to the community in North Lanarkshire.
* Sydney Mair. For services to Local Government and to the community in Macduff, Aberdeenshire.
* Jean Isabella, Mrs. Malkin. For services to Young People in the Cartmel Peninsula, Cumbria.
* Edna, Mrs. March. For services to the community in Crook, County Durham.
* Kenneth Marsh, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.
* Michael Thomas Martin. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Reading, Berkshire.
* Stuart Andrew Martin. For services to the community in Ripon, North Yorkshire.
* William Martin, Chairman, H. and J. Martin Ltd. For services to the Construction Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Philip Mason. For services to disabled people in Hampshire.
* Ms Valerie Mason (Mrs. Hendry). For services to the British Heart Foundation.
* Hilary, Mrs. Massarella. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged Young People in South Yorkshire.
* George Lewis Mathias. For services to Agriculture.
* [Catriona, Mrs. Matthew](/wiki/Catriona_Matthew "Catriona Matthew"). For services to Golf.
* Edwin Alexander Maxwell. For services to the New Art Exchange and to the community in Nottingham.
* Denise Jane, Mrs. May, Director of Sport and Assistant Headteacher, Budehaven Community School, Cornwall. For services to Education.
* Leslie Holden McAdoo, Chairman, Ballyclare Committee, Macmillan Cancer Support. For charitable services in Northern Ireland.
* Margaret Mary, Mrs. McCluskie, Manager, Major Investigation Team, Identity and Passport Service, Home Office.
* William McCrory. For services to Children with Cancer in Northern Ireland.
* Helen Muir, Mrs. McDonald. For services to the community in Crieff, Perthshire.
* Ken McElroy. For services to the Tourist Industry in Northern Ireland.
* Jean, Mrs. McEwen. For services to the community in Norwich.
* Peter McFall, Janitor, St. Peter 's Primary School, Dumbarton, West Dunbartonshire. For services to Education.
* Dr. David Douglas Murray McGavin, Ophthalmologist. For services to Eye Care in Developing Countries.
* Andrew Fraser McKay, Detective Superintendent, Strathclyde Police Force. For services to the Police.
* Ms Annie McKean, Senior Lecturer in Drama, University of Winchester. For services to Higher Education.
* Fiona Mary, Mrs. McLean, Grade C2, Ministry of Defence.
* Terrence McLernon. For services to Table Tennis and to the community in Drumchapel, Glasgow.
* Ms Melanie Justine McLoughlin. For services to the Devon Community Foundation.
* Ivan Lewis McMichael. For services to Journalism in Northern Ireland.
* Dr. Mary Brigeen McNee, General Medical Practitioner, Glasgow. For voluntary service to Cancer Research and to Healthcare in Lourdes.
* Alexander Ian McNeill, Administration Officer, Customer Operations, Thornaby, Cleveland, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Marian, Mrs. McNeir. For services to the community In Bath.
* Marjory, Mrs. McQueen. For services to the community In Lockerbie, Dumfries and Galloway.
* Dr. Noel Henri Joseph Meeke. For voluntary service to Herefordshire Waterworks Museum.
* David Melrose, Chairman, Scottish Prison Officers' Association, Scottish Executive.
* Jean, Mrs. Messenger. For services to the After School Club, Bude, Cornwall.
* Faruk Miah, Programme Manager, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education and to the community in Leeds.
* Moira Sheelagh, Mrs. Michelmore. For services to the community in Sidmouth, Devon.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Milburn, Chair, West Suffolk College Corporation. For services to Further Education and to the community in Suffolk.
* [Frederick Roy Millar](/wiki/Roy_Millar "Roy Millar"), Director of Coaching, Irish Football Association. For services to Youth Football in Northern Ireland.
* Ian Duncan Millar. For services to Agriculture in Scotland.
* Patrick Millard. For services to the charity Taxhelp for Older People.
* Katherine, Mrs. Miller, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Marcia Anne, Mrs. Miller. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross Society in Cambridgeshire.
* Gerald David Mills. For services to School Sport in Nottinghamshire.
* Laura, Mrs. Mitchell, Consultant Orthodontist and Clinical Lead, St Luke's Hospital Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Nasrullah Khan Moghal. For services to Community Relations in Manchester.
* Michael Monaghan. For charitable services to Ex\- Service Men and Women.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Montgomery. For charitable services in Northern Ireland and Overseas.
* Roger Ivan Moore. For services to the community in Potters Bar, Hertfordshire.
* Christopher Morgan, Security Manager, Aberafan Shopping Centre. For services to the community in Neath Port Talbot.
* Daphne, Mrs. Morgan. For voluntary service to Hertfordshire Constabulary and to Feltham Young Offenders' Institution.
* John Francis Morgan. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Newcastle, County Down.
* Alderman Peter James Morgan. For services to the community in Sittingbourne, Kent.
* Heather Dalton, Mrs. Morris, School Crossing Warden, Sale, Cheshire. For services to Education.
* Helen Elizabeth, Mrs. Morris. Crown Advocate, Merseyside and Cheshire Group, Crown Prosecution Service.
* John Harold Morris. For services to the Post Office.
* Thomas Geraint Morris. For services to the NHS and to the community in Dersingham, Norfolk.
* Nigel Peter Morse, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Keith Hedley Moss, President, Bradford Cricket League and Pudsey St. Lawrence Cricket Club. For voluntary service to Sport.
* Maureen Anne, Mrs. Muckle, Chair, Batchley First School, Redditch. For services to Education and to the community in North Worcestershire.
* [Maurice Harrison Murphy](/wiki/Maurice_Murphy_%28musician%29 "Maurice Murphy (musician)"). Trumpeter. For services to Music.
* Janice Elizabeth, Mrs. Naylor. For services to Swimming.
* Peter David Needham, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.
* Terence Charles Nelson, Security Officer, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education.
* Harold Newman. For services to the community in Mill Hill, London.
* Gilda, Mrs. Newsham. For voluntary service to the Alzheimer's Society, New Forest, Hampshire.
* Fionnuala Eileen, Mrs. Newton, Executive Administrative Assistant, Queen's University Belfast. For services to Higher Education.
* Vicky, Mrs. Norman, Senior Executive Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Sheila Maureen, Mrs. O'Neill. For services to Music in Ackworth, West Yorkshire.
* Valerie Ann, Mrs. O'Riordan. For services to the community in Berkshire.
* Barbara, Mrs. Oakes, Manager, High Street Library. For services to Local Government in Bolton.
* Marjorie Frances, Mrs. Oaten. For voluntary service to People with Eating Disorders.
* Margaret May, Mrs. Oatey. For services to the community in East Anglia.
* Stella, Mrs. Okeahialam, Programme Director, Croydon Enterprise. For service to Business.
* Michael Joseph Rolfe Orbell. For services to the Scouts in Wimbledon and Merton, London.
* Noel George Ormrod, lately Chairman, Wallasey Arts Council. For services to the Arts in Merseyside.
* Alexander Orr, Craftsman, Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Scotland.
* Arnold Jenkin Owen. For services to the community in Blackmill, Bridgend and to Welsh International Brigaders.
* Margaret Mcalister, Mrs. Owen. For services to the community in Shrewsbury, Shropshire.
* Ms Margaret Paisley, College Manager, Elmwood College, Residence and Student Union. For services to Further Education in Fife.
* Margaret Frances Elizabeth, Mrs. Palmer. For public service.
* Ms Lydia Joy Parbury. For services to People with Special Needs and Disabilities.
* Dorothy Mary, Mrs. Parker, Community Support Worker, West Wirral Community Mental Health Team. For services to Healthcare.
* John Bywell Parker. For voluntary service to the Hadrian Trust in the North East.
* Ann Rosemary, Mrs. Parr, Community Care Development Manager, Age Concern, Woodley. For services to Older People in Berkshire.
* Rabindara Nath Pathak, Chairman of Governors, Featherstone High School, Ealing, London. For voluntary service to Education.
* Trevor James Patton, Principal Nursing Officer, Northern Ireland Prison Service.
* Margaret Elsie, Mrs. Perfect. For voluntary service to the Boys' Brigade in Watford, Hertfordshire.
* Alderman Fred Perry. For services to the community in Tipton, West Midlands.
* Joan, Mrs. Phillips. For voluntary service to the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester.
* [Roger Phillips](/wiki/Roger_Phillips_%28photographer%29 "Roger Phillips (photographer)"). For services to London Garden Squares.
* [Jean Catherine, Mrs. Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Pickering "Jean Pickering"). For services to Athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.
* Alice Kirsty, Lady Pilkington. For voluntary service to Willowbrook Hospice, St. Helens and Knowsley, Merseyside.
* Pauline, Mrs. Pilkington, Director, Children's Services, Walsall Council. For services to Local Government.
* Professor [Robert Michael Pittilo](/wiki/Mike_Pittilo "Mike Pittilo"), Principal and Vice\-Chancellor, Robert Gordon University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. Jaswant Kaur Jutley\-Plested, Manager, Sydenham Children's Centre, Bridgwater, Somerset. For services to Children.
* Peter Pocock. For services to Workplace First Aid Training.
* Miss Rashmi Amritlal Popat, Executive Officer, Work Welfare and Equality Group, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Ms Prudence Alexine Regina Porretta. For services to Community Cohesion and to the Tourist Industry in Coventry.
* Iain David Russell Prain, Vice\-Principal, Royal Blind School, Craigmillar Park, Edinburgh. For services to Education.
* [Stephen Prescott](/wiki/Steve_Prescott "Steve Prescott"). For services to Rugby League and to Charity.
* Gres, Mrs. Pritchard, Peripatetic Music Teacher, Ynys Mon. For services to Education.
* The Reverend Dr. Jean Prosser. For services to Conservation and to the community in Monmouthshire.
* Isabel, Mrs. Quinliven, Founder, Caring Canines. For services to Older People in Northern Ireland.
* Brenda, Mrs. Quinn, Service Manager, Recovery Services, Belfast Health and Social Care Trust. For services to Mental Healthcare.
* Toaha Bashir Zulqarnain Qureshi. For services to Community Relations in Stockwell, South West London.
* Maureen, Mrs. Raine, Office Manager, English Language Teaching Unit, University of Leicester. For services to Higher Education.
* Dr. Kathleen Rankin. For voluntary service to the Living Linen Project in Northern Ireland.
* Mohamad Rashied, President, Caribbean Islamic Cultural Society. For services to Community Relations in London.
* Robert David Richard Ray. For services to Rugby Union and to Young People in Rugby, Warwickshire.
* Ms Janet Mary Reed, Senior Social Worker, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.
* Angela Mary, Mrs. Rees, Assistant Head, Debt Management and Banking, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Abdul Rehman. For services to the community in Derby.
* Miss Marion Reynolds. For services to Vulnerable Children in Northern Ireland.
* Alan Ribchester. For charitable services in the City of Durham.
* The Reverend James Manson Richards. For services to Children and Families.
* George Edmund Richardson, lately Chairman, Calderdale College and Chairman, Association of Colleges, Yorkshire and the Humber Region. For voluntary service to Further Education.
* Miss Rosalyn Elizabeth Richardson, lately Deputy Director of Health Informatics, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.
* [Andrew William Ritchie](/wiki/Andrew_Ritchie_%28Brompton%29 "Andrew Ritchie (Brompton)"), Technical Director, Brompton Bicycle Ltd. For services to Business and to International Trade.
* Christopher David Medwyn Roberts. For services to the community in Merseyside.
* Clarissa Elizabeth, Mrs. Roberts. For services to Older People in Stratford\-upon\-Avon, Warwickshire.
* Jean Sylvia, Mrs. Roberts, Ministerial Messenger, Department for Transport.
* Peter Adrian Roberts, Chairman, Association of Community Rail Partnerships. For services to Rural Transport.
* Angus John Robertson, Principal Fellow in Clinical Illustration, Leeds Dental Institute. For services to Healthcare.
* Matthew Robertson, Sergeant, Ministry of Defence Police.
* Norman Robertson, lately Curriculum Leader in Hospitality, Ayr College. For services to Further Education.
* Margaret, Mrs. Robinson. For services to the community in Trimdon, County Durham.
* The Reverend Father George Edward Robson, Chairman, North Huyton New Deal for Communities Board. For services to the community in Merseyside.
* Ms Jennifer Van Krieken Robson, Head of Minority Achievement Service, Kent County Council. For services to Education.
* Sheila Ruth, Mrs. Rodmell. For services to the community in Elvington, Kent.
* Ms Susan Rogers. For services to Trade Unions.
* [Ruth Lady Rogers of Riverside](/wiki/Ruth_Rogers "Ruth Rogers"), Chef and Co\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.
* William Andrew Taylor Roulston. For services to Equestrian Sport in Northern Ireland.
* Beryl Lillian, Mrs. Rowe. For services to the community in Lilley, Bedfordshire.
* Dr. Christopher Giles Rowland. For services to the Friends of the Oncology and Radiotherapy Centre, Exeter.
* John Rowlands, Economics Teacher, John Ruskin Sixth Form College, Croydon, London. For services to Education.
* Marion, Mrs. Roy, lately Headteacher, Auchenback Primary School, East Renfrewshire. For services to Education.
* Colonel John Anthony Nutter Read Royle. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northamptonshire.
* [Chrissie, Mrs. Rucker](/wiki/Chrissie_Rucker "Chrissie Rucker"), Founder and Creative Director, White Company. For services to the Retail Industry.
* Anthony Michael Hurst Rumsey, Collections Manager, National Monuments Record. For services to Photography.
* Annette, Mrs. Rushton, lately Matron, Severn Hospice, Shrewsbury. For services to Healthcare.
* Dr. Andrew Oldrey Russell, lately Chairman, League of Friends, Edenbridge and District War Memorial Hospital. For services to Healthcare.
* Ezriel Salomon. For services to the community in Gateshead, Tyne and Wear.
* Ahmed Ali Sasso, Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For services to the Police.
* Mary Ann Landsborough, Mrs. Saunders. For services to the Diocese of Oxford and to the Church of England.
* Ms Susan Saunders, Co\-Ordinator, Disability Support Network, Home Office.
* Keith Savage. For voluntary service to the Air Training Corps in Rutland.
* Lynn, Mrs. Savill. For services to People with Epilepsy in Gravesend, Kent.
* Ms Cherryl Lynn Sawyer, Business and Development Director, Threshold Housing Link. For services to Homeless People in Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Callie, Mrs. Saxty, lately Head of Visitor Operations for Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, English Heritage. For services to Heritage.
* Nora Gladys Elsie, Mrs. Schneider. For services to the community in Newbury, Berkshire.
* Robert Sinclair Scott. For voluntary service to the community in County Armagh.
* The Reverend Christopher John Sears. For services to Disadvantaged People in Hastings, East Sussex.
* Dr. Claude Doumet Serhal, Special Assistant, British Museum. For services to Archaeology.
* Thomas Richard Sermon, Chairman, London Youth. For services to Young People.
* Terence Brian Shead. For services to the community in East Peckham, Kent.
* Alan William Sherriff. For services to the community in South Yorkshire.
* Ann, Mrs. Shreeve, Senior Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Jasvinder Singh Sidhu. For services to Social Housing.
* Phillip Edward Sillick, J.P. For services to the community in Gorseinon, Swansea.
* Benjamin David Simpson, J.P. For services to the community in Oxford.
* Kathleen, Mrs. Simpson. For services to the community in Moston, Manchester.
* [Lemn Sissay](/wiki/Lemn_Sissay "Lemn Sissay"), Poet and Performer. For services to Literature.
* John William Skinner, Director of Music, Haberdashers' Aske's Hatcham College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.
* Catherine, Mrs. Slow. For services to West Exmoor Federation of Schools, Devon.
* Alison Mary, Mrs. Smedley. For services to Inland Waterways.
* Amanda Jane, Mrs. Smith, Executive Assistant, Youth Task Force Strategy, Department for Children, Schools and Families.
* Dr. Angela Owen\-Smith. For services to Medicine and to the community in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire.
* Miss Charlotte Lilian Smith. For services to the community in Porthyrhyd, Carmarthenshire.
* Colin Smith, Retained Crew Manager, West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.
* Elizabeth, Mrs. Smith, Vice\-Chair and Board Member, Colchester Institute. For voluntary service to Further and Higher Education.
* Ian Graham Smith. For services to the community in Ramsbury, Wiltshire.
* James Smith. For voluntary service to Youth Football in Glasgow.
* Eric Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Mary, Mrs. Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.
* Dr. Richard Alfred Sparks, lately Consultant in Genito\-Urinary Medicine, Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust. For services to Medicine.
* Councillor Josephine Elizabeth Spencer. For services to the community in Christchurch, Dorset.
* Dr. Richard Anthony Spencer, Biology Subject Leader, SRC Bede Sixth Form, Billingham, Teesside. For services to Science Communication.
* Sally Louise, Mrs. Hughes\-Stanton, Executive Secretary, Prime Minister's Office.
* Roger Carlton Steele. For services to Young People in Sheffield.
* Cheryl, Mrs. Stevens, Principal Practitioner, Benefits and Credits, Preston, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Mary, Mrs. Stevens. For services to the community in Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Edward Craig Stevenson, lately Engineer of Medical Physics, University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare and to Charity.
* Karen, Mrs. Stock, Extended Schools Co\-ordinator, Shoeburyness and Chair of Governors, Shoeburyness High School, Essex. For services to Education.
* Rodney Ernest Stoddart. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Tayside.
* Eric Arthur Stott. For services to the community in the West Midlands.
* Janet, Mrs. Stoyel. For services to the Textile Industry.
* Miss Judith Anne Strange, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Councillor Phyllis Zaphne Stretton. For services to the community in Cannock, Staffordshire.
* Ivy Alberta, Mrs. Sturgeon, Personal Secretary, H.M. Prison Littlehey, Huntingdon, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Rozelle Elizabeth, Mrs. Sutherland. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence in Jersey.
* Roderick John Symonds. For services to the community in Reading, Berkshire.
* Ranjula, Mrs. Takodra. For services to the community in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire.
* Gwynneth Mary, Mrs. Tame. For services to Heritage and to the community of Dorchester\-on\-Thames in Oxfordshire.
* Susan, Mrs. Tamlyn. For services to Heritage in Suffolk.
* Miss [Samantha Claire Taylor](/wiki/Claire_Taylor "Claire Taylor"), Cricketer. For services to Sport.
* James Graham Taylor, Music Director, City of Glasgow Chorus. For services to Music.
* Josephine May, Mrs. Taylor. For services to the community in Plumpton Green, East Sussex.
* Mary, Mrs. Thirlwell. For voluntary service to Young People in Lanarkshire.
* Ms Melanie Anne Thody, Head of Outreach, Imperial College London. For services to Science Communication.
* Margaret Jean, Mrs. Thomas, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Bristol.
* Peter Thomas, lately Project Director Devonport, Interserve plc. For services to the Defence Industry.
* Jonathan Bryan Thornes. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the East Midlands.
* Gordon Owen Thornhill. For services to the community in Foston and Scropton, Derbyshire.
* Angus Tilston. For services to the Historical Film Industry in the North West.
* Thomas Todd. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.
* Pamela, Mrs. Towning, Assistant Officer, Customer Contact, Shipley, West Yorkshire, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Maureen Ivy, Mrs. Townley. For charitable services in Southend\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Van Cuong Truong. For services to the Indo\-Chinese community in South East London.
* Evelyn Roberta, Mrs. Turkington. For voluntary service to The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Scheme in Northern Ireland.
* [Mary Josephine, Mrs. Turner](/wiki/Mary_Turner_%28trade_unionist%29 "Mary Turner (trade unionist)"), President, GMB. For services to Trade Unions.
* [Edward Jonathan Turpie](/wiki/Jonnie_Turpie "Jonnie Turpie"), Director, Maverick Television.
* Dr. Alan Manson Turtle. For voluntary service to the community in Richhill, County Armagh.
* Miss [Elizabeth Kimberley Tweddle](/wiki/Beth_Tweddle "Beth Tweddle"). For services to Gymnastics.
* John Christopher Tyzack, Chairman of Governors, Enborne Church of England Primary School and Willow Primary School, Newbury, Berkshire. For voluntary service to Education.
* Wendy Margaret, Mrs. Vaughan. For services to the community in South East Surrey.
* Ronald Derek Vaulter. For services to the community in South Devon.
* Christine, Mrs. Ruston\-Wadsworth, Superintendent, Warwickshire Police. For services to the Police.
* Julian Wadsworth. For services to Young People in Portsmouth.
* Janice Irene, Mrs. Walker, Officer, H.M. Prison Wormwood Scrubs, London, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.
* Pamela, Mrs. Walker, Chair of Governors, Cambo First School, Morpeth, Northumberland. For voluntary service to Education.
* Gillian Karen, Mrs. Walnes (formerly Mrs. Bogush). For services to the Anne Frank Trust UK.
* Joan Patricia, Mrs. Warwick. For charitable services to Darent Valley Hospital, Dartford, Kent.
* Amir Waseem, Officer, Customer Contact, Brierley Hill, West Midlands, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* Shirley Irene, Mrs. Watson. For services to the Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura Support Association.
* The Reverend Canon Michael John Wedgeworth, lately Chairman of Governors, Blackburn College. For voluntary service to Further Education and to the communityin Lancashire.
* Michael Edwin Weeding, Senior Officer, Customs and International, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.
* James Weir, Lecturer, Forth Valley College. For services to Further Education in Clackmannanshire.
* David Anthony Westcott, J.P. For services to the community in Essex.
* Audrey, Mrs. Wheeler. For voluntary service to Oxfam in St. Albans, Hertfordshire.
* Norman Edward Whereat. For services to the community in Cirencester, Gloucestershire.
* Hilary John White, Chairman of Governors, Willingdon Community School, Eastbourne, East Sussex. For voluntary service to Education.
* John Samuel Byard White, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Somerset.
* Nicholas Stephen Whitehouse. For services to the Building Industry.
* David Widdowson. For services to Young People with Learning Disabilities in Chesterfield, Derbyshire.
* Alan Bertram Wiggins. For services to the community in Clacton\-on\-Sea, Essex.
* Philip Julian Wilde. For voluntary service to Young People in Lytham St Anne's, Lancashire.
* Dr. Henry Austin Will. For voluntary service to Ford Park Cemetery Trust in Plymouth, Devon.
* Doreen, Mrs. Willcocks. For services to Netball and to the community in Pinehurst, Swindon, Wiltshire.
* Paul Willgoss, Band 3, Chief Scientists' Advisory Group and Chairman, Disability Network, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.
* Christopher Mark Williams, Director, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.
* David Michael Williams. For services to the community in Flintshire.
* Gwilym Alun Williams. For services to Sport for Young People in Wales.
* Professor Robert Joseph Paton Williams. For services to the community in North Oxford.
* Gerald Willmott, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.
* Albert Leslie Wills, Q.F.S.M. For services to the community in the West Midlands.
* Patrick Andrew John Wilson, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Sydney Wiltshire. For services to the community in Petersfield, Hampshire.
* Andrew Nicholas Wood, Manager and Head Coach, Ipswich Gymnastics Centre. For services to Sport.
* Maureen, Mrs. Woodcock, lately Non\-Executive Director, Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.
* Agnes Brown Marchbank, Mrs. Wright. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Stewartry of Kirkcudbright.
* Clare Margaret, Mrs. Wright, Personal Assistant, Warwickshire College. For services to Further Education.
* Richard Kelsey Wright, Chief Executive Officer, Intertius Ltd. For services to the Manufacturing Industry.
* Beryl Joan, Mrs. Wyatt, Gardening Assistant, Writtle College, Chelmsford. For services to Higher Education.
* Claire Judith, Mrs. Wylot, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.
* Councillor Yogan Mylvaganam Yoganathan. For services to Local Government and to Community Relations in North Surrey.
* Jeannie, Mrs. Young, For voluntary service to St. Richard's Hospice, Worcester.
* Pauline Margaret, Mrs. Young. For voluntary service to disabled people in Wales.
* Mavis, Mrs. Yuill, Classroom Assistant, Kilmartin Primary School, Argyll and Bute. For services to Education.
Diplomatic and Overseas List
* [Christopher Barr](/wiki/Christopher_Barr "Christopher Barr") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Paul William Bellamy](/wiki/Paul_William_Bellamy "Paul William Bellamy") – lately Entrance Clearance Manager, British Embassy, Iran.
* [Steve Chandler](/wiki/Steve_Chandler "Steve Chandler") – lately Third Secretary, Counter\-Narcotics, UK Provincial Reconstruction Team, Lashkar Gah.
* [Jeanette Anne Coogan](/wiki/Jeanette_Coogan "Jeanette Coogan") – Manager, British Council English Training Centre, Al Azhar University in Cairo. For services to UK\-Egypt intercultural relations.
* [Rossalyn Demelza Crotty](/wiki/Rossalyn_Crotty "Rossalyn Crotty") – Vice\-Consul/Deputy Head, British Consulate, Málaga, Spain.
* [Dr. Margaret Cumberland](/wiki/Margaret_Cumberland "Margaret Cumberland") – Co\-ordinator, Community Health. For services to community health care in Mozambique.
* [Elyse Anne Dodgson](/wiki/Elyse_Dodgson "Elyse Dodgson") – Head, International Department, Royal Court Theatre, London. For services to international theatre, and to young writers overseas.
* [Dr. Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan](/wiki/Alexander_Charles_Weeks_Duncan "Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.
* [Eleanor Frances Duncan](/wiki/Eleanor_Duncan "Eleanor Duncan") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.
* [Michael Feeney](/wiki/Michael_Feeney%2C_MBE "Michael Feeney, MBE") – Founder, County Mayo Peace Park. For services to UK\-Ireland relations.
* [Anne Ferguson](/wiki/Anne_Ferguson_OBE "Anne Ferguson OBE") For services to older people in Scotland
* [Judith Anne Ferris](/wiki/Judith_Ferris "Judith Ferris") – lately President, Age Concern, Costa Blanca. For services to the British elderly community in Alicante, Spain.
* [Wendi Nixon Fiedler](/wiki/Wendi_Fiedler "Wendi Fiedler") – Founder and Manager, Panatel Production Company. For services to heritage conservation in Bermuda.
* [Norman Keith Goodall](/wiki/Norman_Goodall "Norman Goodall") – For charitable activities and services to the community in Tenerife, Spain.
* [Nicholas John Hancocks](/wiki/Nicholas_Hancocks "Nicholas Hancocks") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Peter Anthony Hibbard](/wiki/Peter_Hibbard "Peter Hibbard") – President, Royal Asiatic Society. For services to heritage conservation in Shanghai, China.
* [Garry Horlacher](/wiki/Garry_Horlacher "Garry Horlacher") – Security Co\-ordinator and Adviser to the Government of Sierra Leone. For services to international policing, and promoting democracy in Sierra Leone.
* [Victor Malvern Jackopson](/wiki/Victor_Jackopson "Victor Jackopson") – Founder and Head, Hope Now. For charitable activities, and services to orphans and other young people in Cherkassy, Ukraine.
* [Renee Jacqueline Jordan](/wiki/Renee_Jordan "Renee Jordan") – Head of Registry, British Embassy Office, Basra.
* [Mairwen Karydis](/wiki/Mairwen_Karydis "Mairwen Karydis") – British Consular Correspondent, Lesvos. For services to consular work in Greece.
* [Nigel Jeffery Randle Kay](/wiki/Nigel_Kay "Nigel Kay") – Founder and Head, Homes in Zimbabwe. For services to the elderly in Zimbabwe.
* [Christopher Kealey](/wiki/Christopher_Kealey "Christopher Kealey") – lately First Secretary Political, British Embassy, Afghanistan.
* [Paul Lawrence](/wiki/Paul_David_Lawrence "Paul David Lawrence") – lately British Vice Consul, Thailand.
* [Cynthia Albrecht\-Lelliott](/wiki/Cynthia_Albrecht-Lelliott "Cynthia Albrecht-Lelliott") – Honorary Vice\-President, British Ladies Club. For services to the British community in Luxembourg and UK\-Luxembourg relations.
* [Dr. Raymond George\-MacKay](/wiki/Raymond_George-MacKay "Raymond George-MacKay") – Educational Consultant. For services to English teaching, especially in West Bengal, India.
* Bryan Andrew Morgan – Second Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Hazel Jane Nelder](/wiki/Hazel_Nelder "Hazel Nelder") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Anthony John Nott](/wiki/Anthony_Nott "Anthony Nott") – UK Policing Adviser, Office of the United States Co\-ordinator, Palestine. For services to international policing, more recently in Iraq and Palestine.
* [Jean Catherine Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Desforges "Jean Desforges") – For services to athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.
* [Stephen Peter John Schembri](/wiki/Stephen_Schembri "Stephen Schembri") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.
* [Joanna Wright\-Serra](/wiki/Joanna_Wright-Serra "Joanna Wright-Serra") – Founding member, JUCONI (Juntos con los Ninos—Together with Children). For services to street children and other charitable activities in Mexico.
* [Keith Shonfeld](/wiki/Keith_Nigel_Shonfeld "Keith Nigel Shonfeld") – Cemetery Administrator, British Cemetery Committee – For services to the British community in Cyprus.
* [Dr. Malcolm Swann](/wiki/Malcolm_Swann "Malcolm Swann") – Medical Director, [Beit Cure International Hospital](/wiki/CURE_International "CURE International"), Lusaka. For medical services in Zambia.
* [Peter Dyce Tear](/wiki/Peter_Tear "Peter Tear") – Executive Producer, 59E59 Theatres in New York. For services to UK/USA cultural relations.
* [David Richard Vaughan Thomas](/wiki/David_Richard_Vaughan_Thomas "David Richard Vaughan Thomas") – Chairman, British\-Polish Chamber of Commerce. For services to British business interests and charitable activities in Poland.
* [Iwona Thomas](/wiki/Iwona_Thomas "Iwona Thomas") – Founder and Manager, The British School, Warsaw. For services to education.
* [Sally Thompson](/wiki/Sally_Thompson "Sally Thompson") – Deputy Executive Director, Thailand\-Burma Border Consortium. For services to Burmese refugees in Thailand.
* [Kedell Melody Worboys](/wiki/Kedell_Worboys "Kedell Worboys") – St. Helena Government Representative in the UK. For services to St. Helena.
|
[
"### Order of the British Empire",
"#### Knights / Dames Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE / DBE)",
"Civil Division\n* [Professor Valerie Beral](/wiki/Val_Beral \"Val Beral\"). For services to Science\n* [Dr. Claire Bertschinger](/wiki/Claire_Bertschinger \"Claire Bertschinger\"). For services to Nursing and to International Humanitarian Aid\n* [Councillor Ellen Margaret Eaton, OBE](/wiki/Ellen_Margaret_Eaton \"Ellen Margaret Eaton\"), Chair, Local Government Association. For services to Local Government\n* [Dr. Susan Elizabeth Ion, OBE](/wiki/Sue_Ion \"Sue Ion\"), Visiting Professor, Imperial College, London and Chair, UK Fusion Advisory Board. For services to Science and Engineering\n* [Clare Oriana Tickell](/wiki/Clare_Tickell \"Clare Tickell\"), Chief Executive, Action for Children. For services to Young People\n* [Marcia Twelftree](/wiki/Marcia_Twelftree \"Marcia Twelftree\"), lately Headteacher, Charters School, Windsor and Maidenhead, Berkshire. For services to local and national Education",
"#### Commanders of the Order of the British Empire (CBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* Commodore Stephen Redvers Kirby\n* Commodore Christopher Laurence Palmer",
"Army\n* Colonel Mark Cuthbert\\-Brown – late [Adjutant General's Corps](/wiki/Adjutant_General%27s_Corps \"Adjutant General's Corps\") ([Royal Military Police](/wiki/Royal_Military_Police \"Royal Military Police\"))\n* Colonel David James Eadie – late The [Queen's Royal Lancers](/wiki/Queen%27s_Royal_Lancers \"Queen's Royal Lancers\")\n* Colonel Christopher William Manning – late [Army Air Corps](/wiki/Army_Air_Corps_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Army Air Corps (United Kingdom)\")\n* Brigadier Simon John Marriner, MBE – late Adjutant General's Corps (Staff and Personnel Support Branch)\n* Colonel Michael Peter Macgregor Stewart, QHS – late [Royal Army Medical Corps](/wiki/Royal_Army_Medical_Corps \"Royal Army Medical Corps\")",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Air Commodore Clive Arthur Bairsto](/wiki/Clive_Bairsto \"Clive Bairsto\")\n* Group Captain Keith Ronald Dipper\n* Group Captain Alistair Monkman\n* [Group Captain Andrew Mark Turner, OBE](/wiki/Andrew_Turner_%28RAF_officer%29 \"Andrew Turner (RAF officer)\")",
"Civil Division\n* [James Christopher Armfield, OBE](/wiki/Jimmy_Armfield \"Jimmy Armfield\"). For services to the community in Lancashire.\n* [David Ogilvy Barrie](/wiki/David_Ogilvy_Barrie \"David Ogilvy Barrie\"), lately Director, [Art Fund](/wiki/Art_Fund \"Art Fund\"). For services to the Visual Arts.\n* Parmajit Paul Singh Bassi, DL, Chairman, Bond Wolfe. For services to Business and to the community in the West Midlands.\n* [William Robert Baxter](/wiki/William_Robert_Baxter \"William Robert Baxter\"), Deputy chief executive, Baxter Storey. For services to the Catering Industry.\n* Ann Beasley, Director of Finance and Performance, [National Offender Management Service](/wiki/National_Offender_Management_Service \"National Offender Management Service\"), Ministry of Justice.\n* Edward Farquharson Bowen, [Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders](/wiki/Sheriff_Principal_of_Lothian_and_Borders \"Sheriff Principal of Lothian and Borders\"). For services to the Administration of Justice in Scotland.\n* Councillor Peter Box, Leader, [Wakefield Metropolitan District Council](/wiki/Wakefield_Metropolitan_District_Council \"Wakefield Metropolitan District Council\") and chairman, [Yorkshire and Humber Assembly](/wiki/Yorkshire_and_Humber_Assembly \"Yorkshire and Humber Assembly\"). For services to Local Government.\n* [Professor Donal Donat Conor Bradley, FRS](/wiki/Donal_Bradley \"Donal Bradley\"), Lee\\-Lucas Professor of Experimental Physics and Deputy Principal, Faculty of Natural Sciences, [Imperial College London](/wiki/Imperial_College_London \"Imperial College London\"). For services to Science.\n* [Professor Alice Brown](/wiki/Alice_Brown_%28ombudsman%29 \"Alice Brown (ombudsman)\"), lately [Scottish Public Services Ombudsman](/wiki/Scottish_Public_Services_Ombudsman \"Scottish Public Services Ombudsman\"). For public service.\n* [Natalie Ceeney](/wiki/Natalie_Ceeney \"Natalie Ceeney\"), chief executive, National Archives, [Ministry of Justice](/wiki/Ministry_of_Justice \"Ministry of Justice\").\n* Lauran Margaret Chatburn, Principal and chief executive, [Bury College](/wiki/Bury_College \"Bury College\"). For services to Further Education.\n* Professor David Martin Chiddick, lately Vice\\-Chancellor, [University of Lincoln](/wiki/University_of_Lincoln \"University of Lincoln\"). For services to local and national Higher Education.\n* Lawrence Churchill, Chairman, [Pension Protection Fund](/wiki/Pension_Protection_Fund \"Pension Protection Fund\"). For public service.\n* [Robert Brodie Clark](/wiki/Brodie_Clark \"Brodie Clark\"), Head of Border Force, [UK Border Agency](/wiki/UK_Border_Agency \"UK Border Agency\"), Home Office.\n* [Barry Michael Cockcroft](/wiki/Barry_Cockcroft_%28dentist%29 \"Barry Cockcroft (dentist)\"), [Chief Dental Officer](/wiki/Chief_Dental_Officer_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Chief Dental Officer (United Kingdom)\"), Department of Health.\n* Christopher Cohen, lately chairman, Athletics Sports Assembly Executive Committee, [International Paralympic Committee](/wiki/International_Paralympic_Committee \"International Paralympic Committee\"). For services to Sport.\n* [Sarah Patricia Connolly](/wiki/Sarah_Connolly \"Sarah Connolly\"), Opera Singer. For services to Classical Music.\n* Rodney Cousens, chief executive officer, [Codemasters](/wiki/Codemasters \"Codemasters\"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.\n* Dr. Michael John Cresswell, Director\\-General, [Assessment and Qualifications Alliance](/wiki/Assessment_and_Qualifications_Alliance \"Assessment and Qualifications Alliance\"). For services to Education.\n* Professor Ian Richard Crute, lately Director, [Rothamsted Research](/wiki/Rothamsted_Research \"Rothamsted Research\"). For services to Plant Science.\n* [His Honour Judge Keith Charles Cutler](/wiki/Keith_Cutler \"Keith Cutler\"), Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* [Dr. George Daniels, MBE](/wiki/George_Daniels_%28watchmaker%29 \"George Daniels (watchmaker)\"), Master Watchmaker. For services to Horology.\n* [Professor Janet Howard Darbyshire, OBE](/wiki/Janet_Darbyshire \"Janet Darbyshire\"), Director, Clinical Trials Unit, [Medical Research Council](/wiki/Medical_Research_Council_%28United_Kingdom%29 \"Medical Research Council (United Kingdom)\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Helen Anne Dent, chief executive, [Family Action](/wiki/Family_Action \"Family Action\"). For services to Children and Families.\n* Graham Thomas Devlin. For services to the Arts.\n* Professor Carol Dezateux, Professor of Paediatric Epidemiology, [UCL Institute of Child Health](/wiki/UCL_Institute_of_Child_Health \"UCL Institute of Child Health\"). For services to Science.\n* Mary Elizabeth Dodd, lately Consultant Physiotherapist, Cystic Fibrosis, [South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust](/wiki/South_Manchester_University_Hospital_NHS_Trust \"South Manchester University Hospital NHS Trust\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Peter Donohoe](/wiki/Peter_Donohoe_%28pianist%29 \"Peter Donohoe (pianist)\"), pianist, for services to Classical Music.\n* Trudi Margaret Elliott, Regional Director, Government Office for the West Midlands, [Department for Communities and Local Government](/wiki/Department_for_Communities_and_Local_Government \"Department for Communities and Local Government\").\n* Margaret Fay, OBE. For services to the Regional Development Agency, [One North East](/wiki/One_NorthEast \"One NorthEast\").\n* [George Ferguson](/wiki/George_Ferguson_%28architect%29 \"George Ferguson (architect)\"). For services to Architecture and to the community in the South West.\n* [Professor Stephen John Field](/wiki/Steve_Field_%28medical_doctor%29 \"Steve Field (medical doctor)\"), Head of Workforce and Regional Postgraduate Dean, NHS West Midlands and Chairman of College Council, [Royal College of General Practitioners](/wiki/Royal_College_of_General_Practitioners \"Royal College of General Practitioners\"). For services to Medicine.\n* Christopher Mark Fisher, Director, Jobseekers and Skills, Employment Group, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions \"Department for Work and Pensions\").\n* [Professor Alastair Hugh Fitter, FRS](/wiki/Alastair_Fitter \"Alastair Fitter\"), Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor for Research, [University of York](/wiki/University_of_York \"University of York\"). For services to Environmental Science.\n* Brian Roy Fleet, MBE, Senior [Airbus UK](/wiki/Airbus_UK \"Airbus UK\") Vice\\-President. For services to the Aerospace Industry.\n* His Honour Judge David Robert Fletcher, Circuit Judge. For services to the Administration of Justice in Merseyside.\n* Winston Fletcher, lately chairman, Advertising Standards Board of Finance. For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Neil Raymond Flint, Deputy Director, New Academies Division, [Department for Children, Schools and Families](/wiki/Department_for_Children%2C_Schools_and_Families \"Department for Children, Schools and Families\").\n* [Helen Fraser](/wiki/Helen_Fraser_%28executive%29 \"Helen Fraser (executive)\"), lately managing director, [Penguin UK](/wiki/Penguin_UK \"Penguin UK\"). For services to the Publishing Industry.\n* Professor John Fyfe. For services to Partnership Working and to Regeneration Worldwide, particularly in West Cumbria.\n* David Goldstone. For public service.\n* Anthony Simonds\\-Gooding, Chairman, [D\\&AD](/wiki/D%26AD \"D&AD\"). For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Professor Sean Patrick Gorman, Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Health and Life Sciences and Professor of Pharmaceutical Microbiology, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast \"Queen's University Belfast\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Lucian Charles Grainge](/wiki/Lucian_Grainge \"Lucian Grainge\"), Chairman and chief executive officer, [Universal Music Group International](/wiki/Universal_Music_Group_International \"Universal Music Group International\"). For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Robert Douglas Greig, chief executive, National Development Team for Inclusion. For services to People with Special Needs.\n* Bethan Haulwen Guilfoyle, Headteacher, [Treorchy Comprehensive School](/wiki/Treorchy_Comprehensive_School \"Treorchy Comprehensive School\"). For services to Education in Wales.\n* [Maggi Hambling, OBE](/wiki/Maggi_Hambling \"Maggi Hambling\"), Painter and Sculptor. For services to Art.\n* Ian Hardie, Deputy Director, Corporation Tax and VAT, Business Tax, [H.M. Revenue and Customs](/wiki/H.M._Revenue_and_Customs \"H.M. Revenue and Customs\").\n* Dr. Christopher Charles Harling, Director, [NHS Plus](/wiki/NHS_Plus \"NHS Plus\"). For services to Occupational Health.\n* Martin Harman. For services to International Trade and to the Legal Profession.\n* Dr. Colin Robert Harrison, Chairman, Chemistry Innovation Knowledge Transfer Network. For services to Technology.\n* [Emma Harrison](/wiki/Emma_Harrison_%28entrepreneur%29 \"Emma Harrison (entrepreneur)\"), Chair, [A4e](/wiki/A4e \"A4e\"). For services to Unemployed People and to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Frances Hartley, lately Headteacher, Deans Primary School, Salford. For services to Education.\n* Sally Lorinda Hobbs, HM Deputy Chief Inspector, [Crown Prosecution Service](/wiki/Crown_Prosecution_Service \"Crown Prosecution Service\") Inspectorate.\n* Peter Michael Holland, QFSM, Chief Fire Officer, [Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service](/wiki/Lancashire_Fire_and_Rescue_Service \"Lancashire Fire and Rescue Service\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Timothy Stancliffe Hollis, QPM, Chief Constable, [Humberside Police](/wiki/Humberside_Police \"Humberside Police\"). For services to the Police.\n* [Helen Jackson](/wiki/Helen_Jackson_%28politician%29 \"Helen Jackson (politician)\"). For services to the Women and Pensions Network and to the community in South Yorkshire.\n* Dyfrig Dafydd Joseff John, lately Deputy chairman and chief executive, [HSBC Bank](/wiki/HSBC_Bank \"HSBC Bank\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* [Penny Johnson](/wiki/Penny_Johnson \"Penny Johnson\"), Director, Government Art Collection, [Department for Culture, Media and Sport](/wiki/Department_for_Culture%2C_Media_and_Sport \"Department for Culture, Media and Sport\").\n* Julie Jones, OBE, chief executive, [Social Care Institute for Excellence](/wiki/Social_Care_Institute_for_Excellence \"Social Care Institute for Excellence\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Robert Jones, lately chairman, Association of Police Authorities. For services to the Police.\n* Professor Peter Graham Edward Kennedy, Burton Professor of Neurology, [University of Glasgow](/wiki/University_of_Glasgow \"University of Glasgow\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Lowri Alice Khan, Team Leader, Intervention, Strategy and Markets Team, [H.M. Treasury](/wiki/H.M._Treasury \"H.M. Treasury\").\n* Paul Leighton, QPM, lately Deputy Chief Constable, [Police Service of Northern Ireland](/wiki/Police_Service_of_Northern_Ireland \"Police Service of Northern Ireland\"). For services to the Police.\n* Rosa Lady Lipworth. For charitable services.\n* [Phyllida Lloyd](/wiki/Phyllida_Lloyd \"Phyllida Lloyd\"), Theatre Director. For services to Drama.\n* [James Loughran](/wiki/James_Loughran \"James Loughran\"), Conductor. For services to Classical Music.\n* David Clifford Loughton, chief executive, [Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust](/wiki/Royal_Wolverhampton_Hospitals_NHS_Trust \"Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* [Ian David Luder](/wiki/Ian_Luder \"Ian Luder\"), lately [Lord Mayor of the City of London](/wiki/Lord_Mayor_of_London \"Lord Mayor of London\"). For public service.\n* Mary Elizabeth Madden. For public service.\n* [Professor Robert James Mair, FREng FICE FRS](/wiki/Robert_James_Mair \"Robert James Mair\"), Master of [Jesus College](/wiki/Jesus_College%2C_Cambridge \"Jesus College, Cambridge\") and Professor of Geotechnical Engineering, [University of Cambridge](/wiki/University_of_Cambridge \"University of Cambridge\"). For services to Engineering.\n* Hew Mathewson, President, [General Dental Council](/wiki/General_Dental_Council \"General Dental Council\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Professor Denise Angela McAlister, Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor, Teaching and Learning, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster \"University of Ulster\"). For services to Higher Education in Northern Ireland.\n* William David McWilliam, Superintendent, [Merseyside Police](/wiki/Merseyside_Police \"Merseyside Police\"). For services to the Police and to Young People.\n* David Leonard Moore, lately Her Majesty's Inspector of Education and Assistant Divisional Manager, [Ofsted](/wiki/Ofsted \"Ofsted\").\n* Candy Morris, chief executive, NHS South East Coast [Strategic Health Authority](/wiki/Strategic_health_authority \"Strategic health authority\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Diana Lesley Morrison, Headteacher, St. Martin\\-in\\-the\\-Fields High School for Girls, Lambeth, London. For services to local and national Education.\n* Stephen Thurston Munby, chief executive, National College for Leadership of Schools and Children's Services. For services to Education.\n* [Professor Adrian Charles Newland](/wiki/Adrian_Charles_Newland \"Adrian Charles Newland\"), Professor of Haematology and director, Pathology Clinical Academic Unit, [Barts and the London NHS Trust](/wiki/Barts_and_the_London_NHS_Trust \"Barts and the London NHS Trust\"). For services to Medicine.\n* Dr. William Gerard O'Hare, Chairman, [University of Ulster](/wiki/University_of_Ulster \"University of Ulster\") Foundation. For services to Higher Education and to Regeneration in Northern Ireland.\n* [David Malcolm Orr](/wiki/David_Malcolm_Orr \"David Malcolm Orr\"), Director Corporate Services, Department of Finance and Personnel, [Northern Ireland Executive](/wiki/Northern_Ireland_Executive \"Northern Ireland Executive\").\n* John Scott Perry, chief executive, [Scottish Enterprise](/wiki/Scottish_Enterprise \"Scottish Enterprise\"). For services to Business.\n* Dr. David Price, chief executive, [Chemring Group](/wiki/Chemring_Group \"Chemring Group\") plc. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* Imelda Redmond, chief executive, [Carers UK](/wiki/Carers_UK \"Carers UK\"). For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Dr. Sian Eluned Rees, Inspector of Ancient Monuments, [Cadw](/wiki/Cadw \"Cadw\"), Welsh Assembly Government.\n* Caroline Mary Rookes, Director, Planning for Retirement and Older People, [Department for Work and Pensions](/wiki/Department_for_Work_and_Pensions \"Department for Work and Pensions\").\n* [Tessa Sarah Ross (Mrs. Scantlebury)](/wiki/Tessa_Ross \"Tessa Ross\"), Controller of Film and Drama, [Channel 4](/wiki/Channel_4 \"Channel 4\"). For services to Broadcasting.\n* [Alastair Eric Hotson Salvesen](/wiki/Alastair_Salvesen \"Alastair Salvesen\"). For services to the Arts and to Charity in Scotland.\n* [Graham Edward Sheffield](/wiki/Graham_Sheffield \"Graham Sheffield\"), Artistic Director, [Barbican Centre](/wiki/Barbican_Centre \"Barbican Centre\"), London. For services to the Arts.\n* [Adrian Shooter](/wiki/Adrian_Shooter \"Adrian Shooter\"), Chairman, [Chiltern Railway Company Ltd](/wiki/Chiltern_Railways \"Chiltern Railways\"). For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Ruth Sims, OBE. For voluntary service to Palliative Care in [Uganda](/wiki/Uganda \"Uganda\").\n* John Brian Sinnott, chief executive, [Leicestershire County Council](/wiki/Leicestershire_County_Council \"Leicestershire County Council\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Christopher John Skinner](/wiki/Chris_Skinner_%28statistician%29 \"Chris Skinner (statistician)\"), FBA, Professor, Southampton Statistical Sciences Research Institute, [University of Southampton](/wiki/University_of_Southampton \"University of Southampton\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Paul Spencer, lately chairman, [National Savings and Investments](/wiki/National_Savings_and_Investments \"National Savings and Investments\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* Janice Stevens, National Director, Healthcare Associated Infections Programme, Department of Health. For services to Nursing.\n* Professor William James Swindall, OBE, Consulting Director, QUILL Centre, [Queen's University Belfast](/wiki/Queen%27s_University_Belfast \"Queen's University Belfast\"). For services to Environmental Science.\n* Kathleen Thomas, Principal, [Oldham College](/wiki/Oldham_College \"Oldham College\"), Manchester. For services to Further Education.\n* [Margaret Maud Tyzack, OBE](/wiki/Margaret_Tyzack \"Margaret Tyzack\"), actress. For services to Drama.\n* [Professor Karen Vousden, FRS FRSE FMedSci](/wiki/Karen_Vousden \"Karen Vousden\"), Director, [Beatson Institute for Cancer Research](/wiki/Beatson_Institute_for_Cancer_Research \"Beatson Institute for Cancer Research\"). For services to Clinical Science.\n* Susan Toni Wardell, Director, Middle East, Caribbean, Asia (East, Central) and British Overseas Territories, [Department for International Development](/wiki/Department_for_International_Development \"Department for International Development\").\n* John David Whittaker, Deputy Director, Employment Policy, [Cabinet Office](/wiki/Cabinet_Office \"Cabinet Office\").\n* Vanessa Wiseman, lately Headteacher, Langdon School and Sports College, Newham, London. For services to Education.\n* John Briscoe Wright. For services to the [Federation of Small Businesses](/wiki/Federation_of_Small_Businesses \"Federation of Small Businesses\").\n* Professor Michael Wright, DL, Vice\\-Chancellor, [Canterbury Christ Church University](/wiki/Canterbury_Christ_Church_University \"Canterbury Christ Church University\"). For services to Higher Education and to the community in Kent.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* Larry Thomas Dennis, lately Auditor General of Bermuda. For services to good governance in Bermuda.\n* Rabbi [David Shlomo Rosen](/wiki/David_Shlomo_Rosen \"David Shlomo Rosen\"), Honorary Adviser on Interfaith relations to the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. For services to interfaith relations in the Middle East, and between the UK and Israel.",
"#### Officers of the Order of the British Empire (OBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* [Commander Nicholas Trevor Blackman](/wiki/Nicholas_Trevor_Blackman \"Nicholas Trevor Blackman\")\n* [Commander Richard George Fox](/wiki/Richard_George_Fox \"Richard George Fox\")\n* [Commander David John Hunkin](/wiki/David_John_Hunkin \"David John Hunkin\")\n* [Commander Charles David Lightfoot](/wiki/Charles_David_Lightfoot \"Charles David Lightfoot\")\n* [Commander Peter Moss](/wiki/Peter_Moss_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"Peter Moss (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Commander Gerard Rodney Northwood](/wiki/Gerard_Rodney_Northwood \"Gerard Rodney Northwood\")",
"Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Allan Barnes](/wiki/Allan_Barnes_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Allan Barnes (British Army officer)\") – Coldstream Guards\n* [Colonel John Etherington](/wiki/John_Etherington \"John Etherington\") – late Royal Army Medical Corps\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley](/wiki/Alexander_Gilbert_Carew_Hatherley \"Alexander Gilbert Carew Hatherley\") – Grenadier Guards\n* [Colonel Ian David MacLeod](/wiki/Ian_David_MacLeod \"Ian David MacLeod\") – Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Army Cadet Force\n* [Colonel Iain George David Moles, QVRM TD](/wiki/Iain_George_David_Moles \"Iain George David Moles\") – late Royal Army Medical Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Leanda Jane Pitt, TD DL](/wiki/Leanda_Jane_Pitt \"Leanda Jane Pitt\") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel John Richard James Powell](/wiki/John_Richard_James_Powell \"John Richard James Powell\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Mark Reginald Rusby](/wiki/Mark_Reginald_Rusby \"Mark Reginald Rusby\") – The Mercian Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Andrew John Teskey](/wiki/Andrew_John_Teskey \"Andrew John Teskey\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Wing Commander Stephen Robert Chaskin](/wiki/Stephen_Robert_Chaskin \"Stephen Robert Chaskin\")\n* [Wing Commander Mark Nicholas Day](/wiki/Mark_Nicholas_Day \"Mark Nicholas Day\")\n* [Wing Commander Simon Andrew Harper](/wiki/Simon_Andrew_Harper \"Simon Andrew Harper\")\n* [Wing Commander Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid](/wiki/Jonathan_Peter_Quentin_Reid \"Jonathan Peter Quentin Reid\")\n* [Wing Commander Malcolm Leslie Symonds](/wiki/Malcolm_Leslie_Symonds \"Malcolm Leslie Symonds\")\n* [Wing Commander Andrew David Wallis](/wiki/Andrew_David_Wallis \"Andrew David Wallis\")\n* [Wing Commander Robert Alan Woods](/wiki/Robert_Alan_Woods \"Robert Alan Woods\")",
"Civil Division\n* William Abbott, National Security Adviser, Secure Mental Health Services, Department of Health. For services to Healthcare.\n* [Victor Akers](/wiki/Victor_Akers \"Victor Akers\"), lately Manager, [Arsenal Ladies' Football Team](/wiki/Arsenal_W.F.C. \"Arsenal W.F.C.\"). For services to Sport.\n* Professor [Alan Alexander](/wiki/Alan_Alexander_%28academic%29 \"Alan Alexander (academic)\"), Emeritus Professor of Local and Public Management, [University of Strathclyde](/wiki/University_of_Strathclyde \"University of Strathclyde\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Alexander Beveridge Anderson, D.L., Chairman of Governors, University of Teesside. For services to the community in the North East.\n* Deirdre Anne, Mrs. Kinloch Anderson, Director, Kinloch Anderson. For services to the Textile Industry.\n* John Huxley Fordyce Anderson. For services to St. Martin\\-in\\-the\\-Fields, London and to the Construction Industry.\n* [Craig Armstrong](/wiki/Craig_Armstrong_%28composer%29 \"Craig Armstrong (composer)\"). For services to Music.\n* Anthony John William Attard, Chief Executive, Panaz Ltd. For services to the Textile Industry and to International Trade.\n* [Sir Nicholas Hickman Ponsonby Bacon, Bt., D.L](/wiki/Sir_Nicholas_Bacon%2C_14th_Baronet \"Sir Nicholas Bacon, 14th Baronet\"). For services to the community in Norfolk.\n* Linda Margaret, Mrs. Costelloe Baker. For public service.\n* Stuart Kemp Baker, Deputy Director, National Projects, Rail and National Networks, Department for Transport.\n* Dr. Michael Thomas Barlow. For services to Intellectual Property Law.\n* Professor [Ann Barrett](/wiki/Ann_Barrett \"Ann Barrett\"), Professor of [Oncology](/wiki/Oncology \"Oncology\") and lately Deputy Head of School, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia \"University of East Anglia\"). For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Hillary Anna Bauer, Head, International and Cultural Property Unit, Department for Culture, Media and Sport.\n* Ms Margaret Baxter. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Miss Ailsa Elizabeth Beaton, Director of Information, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.\n* Alan Kenneth Bowers Beavis. For services to the Scouts.\n* Dr. John William Beer, lately Executive Director of Social Services, Southampton City Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ms [Anthea Bell](/wiki/Anthea_Bell \"Anthea Bell\"). For services to Literature and to Literary Translations.\n* Arlene, Mrs. Bell, Headteacher, Beechdale Nursery School, Durham. For services to local and national Early Years Education.\n* Thomas Bell. For services to the Wooden Spoon Children's Charity.\n* [Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough](/wiki/Madeleine_Ponsonby%2C_Countess_of_Bessborough \"Madeleine Ponsonby, Countess of Bessborough\"). For services to the Visual Arts.\n* Dr. Anthony Bernard Best. For services to the Education of Deafblind Children.\n* Kay, Mrs. Bews, Chief Executive, Home\\-Start UK. For services to Children and Families.\n* Professor Alison Blenkinsopp, Professor of the Practice of Pharmacy, Keele University. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ronald John Bowers, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Paul Vincent Boyle, lately Chief Executive, Financial Reporting Council. For services to the Financial Services Industry and Accountancy.\n* Ms Anne Elizabeth Brannagan, Complex Trauma Manager, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.\n* [Ross Brawn](/wiki/Ross_Brawn \"Ross Brawn\"), Team Principal, [Brawn GP](/wiki/Brawn_GP \"Brawn GP\"). For services to Motorsport.\n* [Dr. Michael Peter Briggs](/wiki/Peter_Briggs_%28scientist%29 \"Peter Briggs (scientist)\"), lately [Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor](/wiki/Pro-Vice-Chancellor \"Pro-Vice-Chancellor\"), [Roehampton University](/wiki/Roehampton_University \"Roehampton University\"). For services to Higher Education.\n* Dr. Alison Fiona Campbell, Managing Director, King's College London Business Ltd. For services to Knowledge Transfer.\n* Peter Carne, lately National Champion, Learning Outside the Classroom and Programme Manager, Growing Schools Programme. For services to Education.\n* David Brian Cassells. For services to the Inland Waterways Association of Ireland.\n* Eileen, Mrs. Cavalier (Mrs. Schatunowski), Founder, London College of Beauty Therapy. For services to Further Education.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Challis, Leader, Castle Point Borough Council. For services to Local Government in South East Essex.\n* [Mavis Lurline, Mrs. Champagnie](/wiki/Lurline_Champagnie \"Lurline Champagnie\"), Councillor, [London Borough of Harrow](/wiki/London_Borough_of_Harrow \"London Borough of Harrow\"). For services to Local Government and to Diversity.\n* Captain Kandiah Chandran, M.B.E., Chief Executive, Preset Charitable Trust. For services to Young People in London.\n* Gillian, Mrs. Coffey, Headteacher, Lynch Hill Foundation Primary School, Slough. For services to Education.\n* Yvonne, Mrs. Coghill, National Lead, Breaking Through Programme, NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement. For services to Healthcare.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Cooke, Head of Capability and First Line Service Management, Customer Service Delivery, Corporate IT, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Gordon Raymond Couch. For services to disabled people.\n* David John Cowie, lately District Manager, Jobcentre Plus, Forth Valley, Fife and Tayside, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* John Andrew Craig, Chairman, British Record Industry Trust. For services to Music and to Charity.\n* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Craig, Chief Executive, Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Bruce Millson Crook, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Ms [Frances Crook](/wiki/Frances_Crook \"Frances Crook\"), Director, [Howard League for Penal Reform](/wiki/Howard_League_for_Penal_Reform \"Howard League for Penal Reform\"). For services to Youth Justice.\n* Neil Philip Cunliffe, Group Manager, Road Safety Group, Lancashire County Council. For services to Road Safety.\n* Phillip Leyland Darnton, Chairman, Cycling England. For services to Transport.\n* Frederick Geoffrey Davies, lately Chairman, Gwent Magistrates Bench and Wales Bench Chairmen's Forum. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Derek John Davis, lately Chairman, Stoke\\-on\\-Trent and Staffordshire Combined Fire Authority. For services to Local Government.\n* Amanda, Mrs. Deeks, Chief Executive Officer, South Gloucestershire Council and Founder, West of England Partnership for Bristol. For services to Local Government.\n* Paul Deneen, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Herefordshire and Worcestershire.\n* John Henry Derbyshire, Sailing Coach and Manager. For services to Sport.\n* Professor [Fiona Devine](/wiki/Fiona_Devine \"Fiona Devine\"), Professor of Sociology, [University of Manchester](/wiki/University_of_Manchester \"University of Manchester\"). For services to Social Science.\n* Ian Laidlaw\\-Dickson, Chairman, Hertfordshire Police Authority. For services to the Police.\n* Michael Donnelly, Chief Executive Officer, Habinteg Housing Association. For services to the Housing Sector.\n* Jacqueline Ann, Mrs. Dowell, Customer Operations Business Design Manager, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Professor [Marcus Peter Francis du Sautoy](/wiki/Marcus_du_Sautoy \"Marcus du Sautoy\"), Professor of Mathematics, [University of Oxford](/wiki/University_of_Oxford \"University of Oxford\"). For services to Science.\n* Brigadier Hedley Dennis Cardew Duncan, M.B.E., lately Yeoman Usher of the Black Rod, House of Lords.\n* Martin Donald Dunford, Chairman, Association of Learning Providers and Chief Executive, Skills Training UK. For services to Skills.\n* Antony Dunne, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Dr. Linda Ebbatson, Leader, Chester\\-le\\-Street District Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ms Janette Morag Faherty, Chief Executive, TNG/ Avanta. For services to Unemployed People and to Entrepreneurship.\n* Ms Julia Fawcett, Chief Executive, Lowry Centre, Salford Quays. For services to the Arts in the North West.\n* Derek Forest, Detective Superintendent, West Midlands Police. For services to the Police.\n* Diana, Mrs. Fulbrook, Chief Officer, Wiltshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.\n* Elizabeth Laureen, Mrs. Fullerton, lately Chair, NHS Shetland. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Lucy Diana Gampell (Mrs. Itkin), lately Director, Action for Prisoners' Families. For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Professor Mary Gibby, Director of Science, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh. For services to Botany.\n* Captain Duncan Colin Glass, lately Director of Navigation Requirements, Trinity House, Department for Transport.\n* Celia Jane, Mrs. Godsall. For services to Sport.\n* Dr. James Desmond Hall, General Medical Practitioner, Belfast. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ms Susan Elizabeth Hall, Chief Officer, West Yorkshire Probation Area, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Catherine Graham\\-Harrison. For services to Heritage.\n* David James Harrison. For services to Golf.\n* Michael Clifford Hart, Director, Ffestinog Railway Company and Chairman, Welsh Highland Railway Construction Ltd. For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Maurice Adrian Sylvester Heaster, Deputy Leader, Wandsworth Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Elizabeth Irene, Mrs. Henderson, Network Nurse Director, Northern Ireland Cancer Network. For services to Healthcare.\n* Tom Henderson. For services to Humanitarian Aid.\n* Dr. Barbara Hendrie, lately Deputy Director, Iraq, Department for International Development.\n* David Henry, Chairman, National Association for Mental Health. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. [Andrew James Herbert](/wiki/Andrew_Herbert \"Andrew Herbert\"), Managing Director, [Microsoft Research](/wiki/Microsoft_Research \"Microsoft Research\"), Cambridge. For services to Computer Science.\n* [Donald Peter Herbert](/wiki/Peter_Herbert_%28lawyer%29 \"Peter Herbert (lawyer)\"), Barrister. For voluntary service to Equality, Diversity and Human Rights.\n* Ms Susan Ann Higham, Business Design Manager, Modernising Pay As You Earn, Telford, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Ms Stephanie Hilborne, Chief Executive, The Wildlife Trusts. For services to Nature Conservation.\n* Professor Anthony Edward Hill, Director, National Oceanography Centre, Southampton. For services to Environmental Science.\n* Professor William Stewart Hillis, Medical Adviser, Scottish Football Association. For services to Medicine and to Sport.\n* Helen Jane, Mrs. Clegg\\-Hood, Headteacher, Shiremoor Primary School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For services to Education.\n* Ms Katharine Sarah Julian Horner, lately Specialist Counsellor and Senior Analyst, Assessments Staff, Cabinet Office.\n* Peter John Hosker. For services to the community in Preston, Lancashire.\n* [Gareth Dale Hoskins](/wiki/Gareth_Hoskins \"Gareth Hoskins\"). For services to Architecture.\n* Kevin Houston, Managing Director, Anderson Manning Associates. For services to Business.\n* Nicholas Howard, Parliamentary Clerk, Prime Minister's Office.\n* Susan, Mrs. Huggins, Head of Network Development. For services to the Post Office.\n* Shirley, Mrs. Hughes, Chief Executive Officer, Cerebral Palsy Sport. For services to Disability Sport.\n* Robert Alfred Hutchings. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Wales.\n* William Anthony Hynett, Group Chief Executive Officer, [B\\-N Group Ltd](/wiki/Britten-Norman \"Britten-Norman\"). For services to the Defence Industry.\n* [Paul Stafford Jackson](/wiki/Paul_Jackson_%28game_producer%29 \"Paul Jackson (game producer)\"). For services to the Computer Games Industry.\n* Marc Jaffrey. For services to Music Education.\n* Anthony Paul Jakimciw, Principal and Chief Executive Officer, Dumfries and Galloway College. For services to Further Education in Scotland.\n* Professor Ian Miller Jamieson, lately Pro\\-Vice\\- Chancellor (Learning and Teaching), University of Bath. For services to local and national Education.\n* Ms Marion Juliette Janner. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Ms Deborah Jeffery, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence. Martin John Jenkins, Grade B1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Jane, Mrs. Johnson, Headteacher, St. Stephen's Primary School, Newham, London. For services to Education.\n* Glenys, Mrs. Johnston, Chair, Local Safeguarding Children Board, Leicestershire and Rutland. For services to Local Government.\n* Paul Lloyd Jones, Executive Headteacher, Blackpool and Chudleigh Knighton Lady Seaward's and Salcombe Primary Schools, Devon. For services to local and national Education.\n* [Stephen Jones](/wiki/Stephen_Jones_%28milliner%29 \"Stephen Jones (milliner)\"), Milliner. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Professor Vijay Vir Kakkar, Emeritus Professor, University of London. For services to Clinical Science.\n* Ms Jeanne Kaniuk, Head of Adoption Services, Thomas Coram Foundation for Children. For services to Children.\n* Professor Paul Keane, Dean, School of Health and Social Care, Teesside University. For services to Healthcare.\n* Anna, Mrs. Kendall, lately Headteacher, Christ Church Church of England Primary School, Kensington and Chelsea, London. For services to Education.\n* Nigel Kershaw, Chief Executive, Big Issue Invest and Chairman, The Big Issue. For services to Social Enterprise.\n* [Simon Henry King](/wiki/Simon_King_%28television%29 \"Simon King (television)\"). For services to Wildlife Photography and to Conservation.\n* John Gordon Kingston. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Ms Anne Kirkham, Grade 5, Decent Homes and Housing Finance Division, Department for Communities and Local Government.\n* Richard Philip Kitson, lately Chief Executive, Aster Group. For services to the Housing Sector.\n* Susan, Mrs. Knox. For services to Food Safety.\n* Silas Krendel. For charitable services.\n* [Ram Parkash Lakha](/wiki/Ram_Parkash_Lakha \"Ram Parkash Lakha\"). For services to the Sikh community in Coventry, West Midlands.\n* Anthony Edward Langford, Non\\-Executive Director, John Smedley. For services to the Knitwear Industry.\n* Heather, Mrs. Lawrence, Chief Executive, Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Jurat and Lieutenant Bailiff Sally Carolyn Ann Le Brocq. For services to the Administration of Justice and to the community in Jersey.\n* Andrew John Leigh. For public service.\n* Eva, Mrs. Loeffler, Vice\\-President, WheelPower. For services to Disability Sport.\n* Helen, Mrs. MacKenzie, Headteacher, Shevington High School, Wigan. For services to Education.\n* John Graham Marks. For charitable services.\n* Victor Alan Marshall, Detective Superintendent, Sussex Police and Adviser to the Home Office. For services to the Police.\n* Ms Wendy Martinson, Consultant Dietitian, British Olympic Association. For services to Sport and to Nutrition.\n* June Colette, Mrs. Mason, Grade 7, Cohesion and Migration Directorate, Department for Communities and Local Government.\n* Samuel Abraham McCrea, Principal, Ballyclare Secondary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Professor John Alexander McDermid. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* William John McGawley, Executive Vice\\-Chairman, TDR Group. For services to Business and to Skills Training in the North East.\n* The Very Reverend Dr. Robert Samuel James Houston McKelvey, Q.V.R.M., T.D., Dean, St. Anne's Cathedral, Belfast. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms Alison Mary McLean. For services to Rural Affairs in the West Midlands.\n* Bishop Louis Richard McLeod, For services to Southwark Credit Union.\n* Ronald McNab, lately Managing Director, Caledonian Alloys Ltd. For services to the Recycling Industry.\n* Ms [Loretta Minghella](/wiki/Loretta_Minghella \"Loretta Minghella\"), Chief Executive, [Financial Services Compensation Scheme](/wiki/Financial_Services_Compensation_Scheme \"Financial Services Compensation Scheme\"). For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* [Michelle, Mrs. Mone](/wiki/Michelle_Mone%2C_Baroness_Mone \"Michelle Mone, Baroness Mone\"), Founder and Owner, MJM International Group. For services to the Lingerie Industry.\n* [Kenneth Montgomery](/wiki/Kenneth_Montgomery \"Kenneth Montgomery\"), Principal Conductor, [Ulster Orchestra](/wiki/Ulster_Orchestra \"Ulster Orchestra\"). For services to Music in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms [Debbie Moore](/wiki/Debbie_Moore \"Debbie Moore\"), Founder and Chair, [Pineapple Dance Studios](/wiki/Pineapple_Dance_Studios \"Pineapple Dance Studios\"). For services to Business.\n* [Heidi, Mrs. Mottram](/wiki/Heidi_Mottram \"Heidi Mottram\"), Managing Director, Northern Rail. For services to the Rail Industry.\n* Ms Diane Mulligan. For services to disabled people and to Equal Opportunities.\n* [Braham Sydney Murray](/wiki/Braham_Murray \"Braham Murray\"), [Artistic Director](/wiki/Artistic_Director \"Artistic Director\"), [Royal Exchange, Manchester](/wiki/Royal_Exchange%2C_Manchester \"Royal Exchange, Manchester\"). For services to Drama.\n* Peter Murray, Co\\-Founder, Ormiston Trust. For services to Children and Families.\n* Dr. Sydney Donnelly Neill, Director, Agriculture Food and Environmental Sciences Division, Agri\\-Food and Biosciences Institute, Northern Ireland Executive.\n* [David Nixon](/wiki/David_Nixon_%28choreographer%29 \"David Nixon (choreographer)\"), Artistic Director, [Northern Ballet](/wiki/Northern_Ballet \"Northern Ballet\") Theatre. For services to Dance.\n* Edward James O'Gorman. For charitable services to the Foundation for Children with Leukaemia.\n* Professor [Timothy O'Riordan](/wiki/Tim_O%27Riordan \"Tim O'Riordan\"), D.L., Emeritus Professor of Environmental Sciences, [University of East Anglia](/wiki/University_of_East_Anglia \"University of East Anglia\"). For services to Sustainable Development.\n* Gary Oldman. For public service.\n* Dr. Jane Overbury, Principal, Christ the King Sixth Form College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.\n* [Richard Parfitt](/wiki/Rick_Parfitt \"Rick Parfitt\"), Co\\-Founder, Singer and Guitarist, [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 \"Status Quo (band)\"). For services to Music and to Charity.\n* Dr. Louise Mary Perrotta. For public service.\n* Peter Phillipson, Chairman, Merlin Entertainments Group. For services to the Leisure Industry.\n* Raymond Pollock, Principal, Banbridge Academy. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Diane, Mrs. Poole, General Manager, Passengers Norfolkline Irish Sea Ferry Services. For services to the Tourist Industry.\n* Melloney, Mrs. Poole, Deputy Director, Legal Services and Governance, Big Lottery Fund. For public service.\n* Andrew Richard Pope, J.P., National Business Crime Partnership Manager, Co\\-operative Group. For public service.\n* Ms [Rachel Portman](/wiki/Rachel_Portman \"Rachel Portman\"), Film Composer. For services to Music.\n* Colin Preece, lately Director, Social Services, Neath Port Talbot. For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Michael Charles Prestwich](/wiki/Michael_Prestwich \"Michael Prestwich\"), Emeritus Professor of History, [Durham University](/wiki/Durham_University \"Durham University\"). For services to Scholarship.\n* Richard Edward Priest, Chief Executive, Riverside Centre. For services to the community in the Isle of Wight.\n* Walter Rader, Director, Big Lottery Fund. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Judith, Mrs. Ragan, Headteacher, Queensmill Special School for Autism, Hammersmith and Fulham, London. For services to Special Needs Education.\n* Bernardine, Mrs. Rees, lately Chief Executive, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire Local Health Board. For services to the NHS in Wales.\n* Raymond Victor Refausse, lately Director and Chief Executive, South West College. For services to Further and Higher Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Professor Margaret Reid, Professor of Women's Health, University of Glasgow. For services to Healthcare and to Higher Education.\n* Ms Lyndy Reynolds, lately Deputy Head, Government Legal Service Secretariat, Treasury Solicitor's Department.\n* Ms [Menna Richards](/wiki/Menna_Richards \"Menna Richards\"), Director, [BBC Wales](/wiki/BBC_Wales \"BBC Wales\"). For services to Broadcasting.\n* Anne, Mrs. Roberts, Chief Executive, Crossroads Association. For services to Carers.\n* Edmund Caerwyn Roberts, M.B.E., Chairman, Snowdonia National Park Authority. For services to the community in Gwynedd.\n* Elizabeth Regina Oluyemika, Mrs. Atere\\-Roberts, Older People's Nurse Specialist. For services to Healthcare in London.\n* Brian Keith Rockliffe, Director, Voluntary Service Overseas. For services to International Development.\n* [Francis Dominic Nicholas Michael Rossi](/wiki/Francis_Rossi \"Francis Rossi\"), Co\\-Founder and Singer, Status Quo. For services to Music and to Charity.\n* John Kenneth Rostill, Chief Executive, Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Henry James Griffin Russell, lately Chairman, National Association of General Commissioners. For public service.\n* Professor Edward Sallis, Principal and Chief Executive, Highlands College, Jersey. For services to Education.\n* Sujinder Singh Sangha, Principal, Stockton Riverside College, County Durham. For services to local and national Further Education.\n* Professor Danny Saunders, Professor and Head of the Centre for Lifelong Learning, University of Glamorgan. For services to Higher Education in Wales.\n* Professor Joseph Maurice Savage, Consultant Paediatric Nephrologist, Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children. For services to Medicine.\n* Dr. Caroline Ann Bodley\\-Scott, Civilian Medical Practitioner, British Forces Germany Health Service, Ministry of Defence.\n* Gordon Scott. For services to Regeneration in South Yorkshire.\n* [Jane Antoinette, Mrs. Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook \"Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook\"), Leader, [Wiltshire Council](/wiki/Wiltshire_Council \"Wiltshire Council\"). For services to Local Government.\n* Ahmad Shahzad. For services to Black and Minority Ethnic People.\n* Ghulam Rasul Shahzad. For services to Social Housing and to the community in Rochdale.\n* Peter Sheldon. For services to the Jewish Community.\n* Miss Julie May Shenton, Departmental Strategic Business Continuity Manager, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Dr. David Sibbald, F.R.S.E., Chairman, Sumerian Networks. For charitable services in Scotland and Overseas.\n* [Alice, Mrs. Sluckin](/wiki/Alice_Sluckin \"Alice Sluckin\"), Chair, Selective Mutism Information and Research Association. For services to Children and Families.\n* [Ronald Gordon King\\-Smith](/wiki/Dick_King-Smith \"Dick King-Smith\"), Author. For services to Children's Literature.\n* John Thomas Smith, lately Principal, Burnley College. For services to Further Education.\n* Ms Laraine Smith, Principal, Uxbridge College. For services to Further Education.\n* Peter Arthur Smith. For services to the Optometric Profession.\n* Gerard Smyth. For services to the Police in the North East.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Snowdon, Chair, Pensions Advisory Service. For services to Pensioners.\n* The Honourable [Rupert Christopher Soames](/wiki/Rupert_Soames \"Rupert Soames\"), Chief Executive Officer, [Aggreko](/wiki/Aggreko \"Aggreko\") plc. For services to the Power Industry.\n* Pauline Joan, Mrs. Spencer, lately Head, Victim and Witness Care Delivery Unit, Crown Prosecution Service.\n* Eric Spicer. For services to the Telecommunications Industry.\n* The Right Reverend James Theophilus Stapleton. For services to Inter\\-Faith and Community Relations in Nottingham.\n* Dr. [Miriam Stoppard](/wiki/Miriam_Stoppard \"Miriam Stoppard\"). For services to Healthcare and to Charity.\n* Professor David Storey, lately Director, Centre for Small and Medium Enterprise, Warwick Business School. For services to Business.\n* Stephen Szemerenyi, Pay and Conditions Specialist, Association of School and College Leaders. For services to Education.\n* Alexander Tait, lately Governing Governor, H.M. Young Offenders' Institution Castington, Northumberland, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Jeremy James Taylor. For services to Young People and to Musical Theatre.\n* David Ralph Thompson, Governor H.M. Prison Frankland, Durham, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Gillian Jane Thompson, lately Chief Executive, Accountant in Bankruptcy, Scottish Executive.\n* [Cyrus Todiwala](/wiki/Cyrus_Todiwala \"Cyrus Todiwala\"), M.B.E., Proprietor and Executive Chef, Cafe ́ Spice Namaste ́ Restaurant Group. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Iqbal Wahhab, Chairman, Department for Work and Pensions, Ethnic Minority Advisory Group. For public service and for services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Ms [Amanda Jane Wakeley](/wiki/Amanda_Wakeley \"Amanda Wakeley\"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Professor Janet Anne Walker, Deputy Chair, Social Security Advisory Committee. For public service.\n* James Arneil Wardrop. For services to the community in Renfrewshire.\n* Caroline, Mrs. Waters, Director, People and Policy for BT Group. For services to Diversity and to Equal Opportunities.\n* Norma Anne, Mrs. Watson. For services to Education in Scotland.\n* Dr. John Alexander Watt, Director of Strengthening Communities, Highlands and Islands Enterprise. For services to Community Development.\n* Professor Maureen Wayman, lately Pro\\-Vice\\-Chancellor and Dean, Art and Design, Manchester Metropolitan University. For services to local and national Higher Education.\n* John Wilkinson, Chief Executive, Ecuomed. For services to the Healthcare Industry.\n* [Mark Roger Wilkinson](/wiki/Mark_Wilkinson_%28designer%29 \"Mark Wilkinson (designer)\"). For services to the Furniture Industry and to Charity.\n* Susan Jean, Mrs. Willan, lately Inspector, Her Majesty's Inspectorate for Education and Training in Wales. For services to Education.\n* Professor Richard James Willson Williams, T.D., Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, Aneurin Bevan Health Board. For services to Medicine.\n* Jessie, Mrs. Wojciechowski, Headteacher, Borestone Primary School, Stirling. For services to Education.\n* Professor Charles Roland Wolf, Director, Biomedical Research Centre, University of Dundee. For services to Science.\n* David Mark Wood, Chief Executive, ATTEND. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Dr. Eric Wood, D.L. For services to Education and to the community in Warwickshire.\n* Thomas Greenaway Woods. For public service.\n* Ms Louise Wright, Fraud and Error Consultant, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Stephen Frederick Wright, Head, Business, Improvement and Support Team, London, Valuation Office Agency, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Woon Wing Yip, Chairman, Wing Yip plc. For services to the Oriental Food Industry.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* [Mockbul Ali](/wiki/Mockbul_Ali \"Mockbul Ali\") \\- Adviser to the then [Foreign \\& Commonwealth Office](/wiki/Foreign_%26_Commonwealth_Office \"Foreign & Commonwealth Office\"). For services to British foreign policy.\n* David Belgrove – lately Head, Counter Narcotics Team, British Embassy, Afghanistan.\n* [Thomas Yates Benyon](/wiki/Thomas_Benyon \"Thomas Benyon\") – Founder and director, ZANE (Zimbabwe A National Emergency). For services to vulnerable people in Zimbabwe.\n* James Gordon Davidson Blakely – Director Youth (Education, Science and Society), British Council.\n* The Right Reverend Leroy Errol Brooks – For services to the community in Anguilla.\n* Norma Po Yee Chan – lately Chief, Security Council Secretariat, United Nations. For services to the United Nations in New York.\n* John Joseph\\-Devine, LVO – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* Dr. Roderic William Dutton – Adviser on the Middle East, International Office, Durham University. For services to higher education and research links between the UK and the Middle East, especially Jordan.\n* Simon John Gillham – President, Franco\\-British Chamber of Commerce. For services to Franco\\-British business interests in France.\n* Richard Wingfield Hyde, MBE – British Honorary Consul, Madagascar. For services to the British community in Madagascar.\n* [Graham King](/wiki/Graham_King \"Graham King\") – Film Producer. For services to the British film industry in the US and UK.\n* Beverley Elizabeth Lewis – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* Nicholas Roy Mason – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Margaret Marian McPartland](/wiki/Marian_McPartland \"Marian McPartland\") – Pianist and Radio Show Host, National Public Radio, USA. For services to jazz and to aspiring young musicians in the USA.\n* [Diane Mulligan](/wiki/Diane_Mulligan \"Diane Mulligan\") – for services to disabled people and to equal opportunities.\n* William Smith MacDonald Murray – Economic and Financial Attaché, British Embassy, Spain.\n* Brian David Outlaw – Director, China\\-Britain Business Council. For services to British business interests in China.\n* Mehr Tahir Kamran – British Foreign Officer, Ambassador to Russia. For services towards a better mutual co\\-ordination in trade with Russia.\n* Ian George Purves – lately Stabilisation Adviser, Civil Military Mission in Helmand. For services to security and stabilisation in Afghanistan.\n* Michael Charles Ramscar – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Jane Antoinette Scott](/wiki/Jane_Scott%2C_Baroness_Scott_of_Bybrook \"Jane Scott, Baroness Scott of Bybrook\") – For services to local government in Wiltshire.\n* Olga May Scott – For services to the health, education and development of Bermuda's youth.\n* Stephen Rowland Thomas – Founder and former Chairman of OPAL, Oman. For services to British business interests and to the community in Oman.\n* Paul Williams – Offsets Adviser, UK Trade and Investment, South Africa. For services to British business interests.",
"#### Members of the Order of the British Empire (MBE)",
"Military Division\n Royal Navy\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Warfare Specialist (Abovewater Warfare Tactical) Russell Graham Billings](/wiki/Russell_Graham_Billings \"Russell Graham Billings\")\n* [Logistician (Catering Services) Class 1 Rosemary Anne Brodrick](/wiki/Rosemary_Anne_Brodrick \"Rosemary Anne Brodrick\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Air Engineering Technician Kenneth Michael Davidson](/wiki/Kenneth_Michael_Davidson \"Kenneth Michael Davidson\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Barry Dawe](/wiki/Barry_Dawe \"Barry Dawe\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Robert John Ewen](/wiki/Robert_John_Ewen \"Robert John Ewen\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) John Ronald Hendren](/wiki/John_Ronald_Hendren \"John Ronald Hendren\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Steven David Hopkins](/wiki/Steven_David_Hopkins \"Steven David Hopkins\")\n* [Lieutenant Anthony Jackson](/wiki/Anthony_Jackson_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"Anthony Jackson (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Bryan John Nicholas](/wiki/Bryan_John_Nicholas \"Bryan John Nicholas\")\n* [Chief Petty Officer Engineering Technician (Marine Engineering) David Parker](/wiki/David_Parker_%28Royal_Navy_officer%29 \"David Parker (Royal Navy officer)\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Coxswain (Submarines) Andrew Mark Rainey](/wiki/Andrew_Mark_Rainey \"Andrew Mark Rainey\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Philip David Slocombe](/wiki/Philip_David_Slocombe \"Philip David Slocombe\")\n* [Lieutenant Commander Graham Gilbey Trewhella](/wiki/Graham_Gilbey_Trewhella \"Graham Gilbey Trewhella\")\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 (Bugler) James Whitwham](/wiki/James_Whitwham \"James Whitwham\")",
"Army\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Justin Mark Brooks](/wiki/Justin_Mark_Brooks \"Justin Mark Brooks\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Major Neil James Mark Budd](/wiki/Neil_James_Mark_Budd \"Neil James Mark Budd\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Major Richard Ronald Coomber](/wiki/Richard_Ronald_Coomber \"Richard Ronald Coomber\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Major Jonathan Edward Cunningham](/wiki/Jonathan_Edward_Cunningham \"Jonathan Edward Cunningham\") – The Yorkshire Regiment\n* [Major Robert Anthony Davies](/wiki/Robert_Anthony_Davies \"Robert Anthony Davies\") – The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment\n* [Major Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood](/wiki/Mark_Christopher_Preston_Ellwood \"Mark Christopher Preston Ellwood\") – The Mercian Regiment\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Michael Richard Elviss](/wiki/Mike_Elviss \"Mike Elviss\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Major Graham Roy Emond](/wiki/Graham_Roy_Emond \"Graham Roy Emond\") – Devon Army Cadet Force\n* [Major Christopher Gill](/wiki/Christopher_Gill_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Christopher Gill (British Army officer)\") – Army Air Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Major Paul Harrison](/wiki/Paul_Harrison_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Paul Harrison (British Army officer)\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Captain Philip John Hawkins](/wiki/Philip_John_Hawkins \"Philip John Hawkins\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Anthony Mark Hobbins](/wiki/Anthony_Mark_Hobbins \"Anthony Mark Hobbins\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Staff Sergeant Gary Holdham](/wiki/Gary_Holdham \"Gary Holdham\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Warrant Officer Class 1 Charles Henry James Holdsworth](/wiki/Charles_Henry_James_Holdsworth \"Charles Henry James Holdsworth\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Sergeant Barry John](/wiki/Barry_John_%28British_Army_officer%29 \"Barry John (British Army officer)\") – The Royal Welsh\n* Captain Susan King – Royal Corps of Signals\n* [Major Joanna Catherine Maynard](/wiki/Joanna_Catherine_Maynard \"Joanna Catherine Maynard\") – Royal Corps of Signals\n* [Captain Richard Andrew Peters](/wiki/Richard_Andrew_Peters \"Richard Andrew Peters\") – Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Damien Daniel Place](/wiki/Damien_Daniel_Place \"Damien Daniel Place\") – The Royal Irish Regiment\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Iestyn David Plummer](/wiki/Iestyn_David_Plummer \"Iestyn David Plummer\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Major James Samuel Robert Priest](/wiki/James_Samuel_Robert_Priest \"James Samuel Robert Priest\") – The Royal Logistic Corps\n* [Major Jonathan Howard Scott](/wiki/Jonathan_Howard_Scott \"Jonathan Howard Scott\") – Corps of Royal Engineers\n* [Major Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe](/wiki/Jeremy_Edward_Gavin_Sharpe \"Jeremy Edward Gavin Sharpe\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Warrant Officer Class 2 Paul Philip Shipley](/wiki/Paul_Philip_Shipley \"Paul Philip Shipley\") – Royal Regiment of Artillery\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Hugh Campbell\\-Smith](/wiki/Hugh_Campbell-Smith \"Hugh Campbell-Smith\") – The Royal Dragoon Guards\n* [Major Oliver William Stokes](/wiki/Oliver_William_Stokes \"Oliver William Stokes\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Major Sonya Adams Summersgill](/wiki/Sonya_Adams_Summersgill \"Sonya Adams Summersgill\") – The Royal Logistic Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Major Alasdair James Eli Truett](/wiki/Alasdair_James_Eli_Truett \"Alasdair James Eli Truett\") – The Parachute Regiment\n* [Captain Thomas Georg John Tugendhat](/wiki/Thomas_Tugendhat \"Thomas Tugendhat\") – Intelligence Corps, Territorial Army\n* [Lieutenant Colonel Colin Richard James Weir](/wiki/Colin_Weir \"Colin Weir\") – The Royal Irish Regiment\n* [Major Robert John Wells](/wiki/Robert_John_Wells \"Robert John Wells\") – The Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment\n* [Major Christopher James White](/wiki/Christopher_James_White \"Christopher James White\") – Surrey Army Cadet Force\n* Lieutenant Colonel John Wilson – Cumbria Army Cadet Force",
"Royal Air Force\n* [Warrant Officer Peter Allen Akers](/wiki/Peter_Allen_Akers \"Peter Allen Akers\")\n* [Chief Technician Paul Andrew Blackah](/wiki/Paul_Andrew_Blackah \"Paul Andrew Blackah\")\n* [Squadron Leader Ian Bryant](/wiki/Ian_Bryant_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"Ian Bryant (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Squadron Leader John Cairns](/wiki/John_Cairns_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"John Cairns (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Warrant Officer Alexander Michael Dykes](/wiki/Alexander_Michael_Dykes \"Alexander Michael Dykes\")\n* [Flight Sergeant Douglas Stuart Law](/wiki/Douglas_Stuart_Law \"Douglas Stuart Law\")\n* [Warrant Officer Rachel MacKenzie](/wiki/Rachel_MacKenzie \"Rachel MacKenzie\")\n* [Flying Officer Leslie Edward Wall McCammont](/wiki/Leslie_Edward_Wall_McCammont \"Leslie Edward Wall McCammont\")\n* [Sergeant Rodney Christian Munday](/wiki/Rodney_Christian_Munday \"Rodney Christian Munday\")\n* [Squadron Leader John Nelson](/wiki/John_Nelson_%28Royal_Air_Force_officer%29 \"John Nelson (Royal Air Force officer)\")\n* [Squadron Leader Gordon William Henry Parry](/wiki/Gordon_William_Henry_Parry \"Gordon William Henry Parry\")\n* [Flight Sergeant Christopher Edward Read](/wiki/Christopher_Edward_Read \"Christopher Edward Read\")\n* [Warrant Officer Stephen Kenneth Roberts](/wiki/Stephen_Kenneth_Roberts \"Stephen Kenneth Roberts\")\n* [Squadron Leader Colin Terence Sullivan](/wiki/Colin_Terence_Sullivan \"Colin Terence Sullivan\")\n* [Senior Aircraftman Darren Mark Swift](/wiki/Darren_Mark_Swift \"Darren Mark Swift\")",
"Civil Division\n* Gwendolen June, Mrs. Abraham. For services to the community in Braunstone, Leicestershire.\n* Hemant Acharya, Policy Adviser, Office of the Third Sector, Cabinet Office.\n* Samuel Adair, Director, Waterside Credit Union Ltd. For services to the Financial Services Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Valerie Edith, Mrs. Adams, Principal, Lisbellaw Primary School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Manus Blake Adamson, Chairman, Adamson Group and Executive Chairman, Construction Confederation. For services to the Construction Industry.\n* Robin Agascar. For voluntary service to the Police in Gloucester.\n* Matilda, Mrs. Akhigbe, Communications Officer, Local Compliance, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Ms Foluke Akinlose, Founder and Editor, Precious Online. For services to the Creative Industries.\n* Gerald Akroyd. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Scotland.\n* Anthony John Alderman, Special Constable, Avon and Somerset Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Ms Angela Cecile Alessendre, Founder, Alessendre Special Needs Dance School and the Larondina Dance Company. For services to Dance.\n* Anne Maria Palma, Mrs. Allan, Deputy Head Teacher, inverclyde Academy, Greenock. For services to Education.\n* Dr. Geoffrey Walter Allan. For services to the community in Kirkintilloch, Dunbartonshire.\n* Shulah, Mrs. Allan, lately Director, Edinburgh Voluntary Organisations Council. For services to the Voluntary Sector.\n* Lynda, Mrs. Allen, Chair of Governors, Sir John Deane's Sixth Form College, Northwich, Cheshire. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Andrew Paul Andrews. For voluntary service to St. John Ambulance Brigade.\n* John Charles Ankcorn, President, Birmingham Crisis Centre. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence.\n* Linda Joyce, Mrs. Ansell. For charitable services in Southend\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Miss Kerry Anthony, Chief Executive, DePaul Northern Ireland. For services to Social Housing.\n* David Archbold. For services to the Water Industry in the North East.\n* James Armitage. For services to the Royal Mail and to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Carol, Mrs. Armstrong, Claims Receipts Manager, Benefits and Credits Operations, Washington, Tyne and Wear, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Mohammed Aslam, Executive Chef and Managing Director, Aagrah Group Restaurants. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Jean, Mrs. Atkinson, lately Staff Side Chair, UNISON, Mersey Care NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.\n* Barbara May, Mrs. Austin. For services to the community in Lyme Regis, Dorset.\n* Kenneth Edwin Ayers. For services to the City of London Corporation.\n* Gloria, Mrs. Bailey. For services to the community in Lambeth, South London.\n* Joan Debra, Mrs. Bailey. For services to Youth Justice in Luton, Bedfordshire.\n* Sharon Gail, Mrs. Bailey, J.P., Head of Service Learning Disabilities, Birmingham City Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Lilian, Mrs. Baker. For services to Mental Healthcare in the Wirral.\n* Warner James Baker, Special Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Robert Henry Ball. For services to Young People in Exeter, Devon.\n* Susan, Mrs. Banton, Director, Steps Charity Worldwide. For services to People with Skeletal Disabilities.\n* Ramanbhai Barber. For services to the Asian community in Leicester.\n* Grace, Mrs. Barnett. For services to the community in Failsworth, Oldham.\n* [Norman Barrett](/wiki/Norman_Barrett_%28ringmaster%29 \"Norman Barrett (ringmaster)\"), Circus Ringmaster. For services to Entertainment.\n* Derek Anthony Bartley. For services to the Midland Association of Mountaineering and to Rhyl Music Club, Denbighshire.\n* Miss [Luella Dayrell Bartley](/wiki/Luella_Bartley \"Luella Bartley\"), Designer. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Patricia, Mrs. Bate. For services to the community in Warrington, Cheshire.\n* Thomas Frederick Beesley. For services to the community in Halewood, Liverpool.\n* Antony Romer Beevor. For voluntary service to Fairbridge youth organisation.\n* Gulrook, Mrs. Begum. For services to Disabled Bangladeshi People in Tower Hamlets, London.\n* Stephen Avery Bell, Managing Director, Davy Roll Company. For services to Business in the North East.\n* Mavis, Mrs. Bent. For voluntary service to Swimming and Water Polo in Greater Manchester.\n* John Alfred Bigny. For services to Edenbridge and District Rail Travellers' Association Kent.\n* Helen, Mrs. Bird. For services to the community in Hastings, East Sussex.\n* Dr. [Charles William Handley Bird](/wiki/William_Bird_%28doctor%29 \"William Bird (doctor)\"), General Medical Practitioner and Strategic Health Adviser to Natural England. For services to Healthcare and to Physical Activity.\n* Arthur Birkby. For services to the community in Runnymede, Surrey.\n* Paul Blakey. For services to Community Safety in Halifax.\n* Alan Blocksidge, Officer, H.M. Prison Manchester, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* June, Mrs. Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.\n* Roy Bloom. For services to the community in Treeton, South Yorkshire.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Boswell. For services to the community in Sheerness, Kent.\n* John Stephen Morton Bower. For services to the British Veterinary Association Animal Welfare Foundation.\n* Miss Jennifer Boyd, Principal, Enniskillen Nursery School. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Scott Michael Bradbury. For services to the community in Tamworth, Staffordshire.\n* Barbara Evelyn Turner, Mrs. Braithwaite. For voluntary service to the community in Linlithgow, West Lothian.\n* [Rosa, Mrs. Branson](/wiki/Rosa_Branson \"Rosa Branson\"), Painter. For services to Art and to Charity.\n* Richard Oliver Brantingham, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* David Keith Bray. For services to the community in Lincolnshire.\n* Valerie, Mrs. Braybrooks, Dean and Associate Professor, Faculty of Agriculture, Food and Animal Sciences, University of Lincoln. For services to Education and to the Food Industry.\n* John Frederick Brignall. For services to the community in the East Riding of Yorkshire.\n* Philip Britton, Headmaster, Boys' Division, Bolton School. For services to Physics.\n* Mary Elizabeth, Mrs. Bromley. For charitable services in Oswestry, Shropshire.\n* Robert Patrick Brooks. For voluntary service to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Clwyd.\n* Felicity, Mrs. Brown, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ms Marie Therese Brown. For services to the Victims of Domestic Violence in Northern Ireland.\n* Norman Henry Parson Brown. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion in Hampshire.\n* Robert Brown. For services to the community in Lower Bevendean, Brighton.\n* David Buchanan. For voluntary service to the Environment and to Heritage in Northern Ireland.\n* Diana Hill, Mrs. Bucknall. For voluntary service to the community in Dorset.\n* Lieutenant Commander James Frederic Budgen, R.N.R. For voluntary service to the Sea Cadet Corps in Ruislip, London Borough of Hillingdon.\n* Frederick Henry Ernest Buller. For services to Angling.\n* Yvonne, Mrs. Burdge. For services to the Trust for Chernobyl Children.\n* Kenneth Burgin. For voluntary service to the Casualties Union.\n* Richard John Burningham, Manager, Devon and Cornwall Rail Partnership. For services to the Rail Industry in the South West.\n* Dr. Stephen Brian Burns. For services to Healthcare and to the community in Rotherham, South Yorkshire.\n* William Henry Burt. For voluntary service to Education in Bridgend, South Wales.\n* David John Butler, Chairman, British Motorsport Association for the Disabled. For services to Disability Sport.\n* [Jenson Alexander Lyons Button](/wiki/Jenson_Button \"Jenson Button\"). For services to Motorsport.\n* Ian Caddy. For services to the community in Birtley, County Durham.\n* Dr. Timothy Alan Carney, General Medical Practitioner, Hexham and Tynedale, Northumberland. For services to Healthcare.\n* The Reverend Barry Edward Carter. For services to the community in Brockley, South East London.\n* Colin Richard Carter. For services to the Road Haulage Industry and to Charity.\n* Rosalind Ella, Mrs. Carter, EAL Education Adviser, Language Service, London Borough of Hounslow. For services to Education.\n* Dr. Susan Carver, Senior Programme Manager, Arts and Humanities Research Council. For services to the Research Councils.\n* Wing Commander Alan Charles Cassidy RAF (Ret'd). For services to Aerobatics and to Charity.\n* Robin William Castle. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Sheerness, Kent.\n* Judith Evelyn, Mrs. Catterick. For services to Music in Ashwell, Hertfordshire.\n* James Joseph Caulfield. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged People in Kenya.\n* Miss Susan Caulfield, Assistant Director, Immigration Fingerprint Bureau, UK Border Agency, Home Office.\n* Peter Geoffrey Challinor, Curator and Manager, Anson Engine Museum. For services to Industrial Heritage.\n* Harry Chambers. For services to Poetry.\n* Patricia, Mrs. Chapman. For services to Young People and to the community in Ealing, West London.\n* Glendon Austin Chappelle, Project Manager, Global Combat Systems—Munitions, BAE Systems. For services to the Defence Industry and to Industrial Heritage.\n* Deborah Ann, Mrs. Chedgey. For services to Disadvantaged People in Norwich, Norfolk.\n* Rex Chester. For services to Young People through the Explore Charity.\n* Ms [Lauren Child](/wiki/Lauren_Child \"Lauren Child\"), Author and Illustrator. For services to Literature.\n* Stanley Charles Church. For voluntary service to Conservation in Essex.\n* Donna, Mrs. Clark, Assistant Practitioner, Podiatry Service, Sefton Primary Care Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Leonard Durbin Clark. For services to Young People in Westminster and to the community in North West London.\n* Peter Mansfield\\-Clark, Director, Crawley Open House. For services to Disadvantaged People in West Sussex.\n* Dr. Janet Ruth Clarke, Chair, Central Committee for Community and Public Health Dentistry, British Dental Association. For services to Healthcare.\n* Susan, Mrs. Clarke. For voluntary service to Disability Swimming in Stockton\\-on\\-Tees.\n* Dr. Peter David Clarkson, Emeritus Associate, Scott Polar Research Institute. For services to Science.\n* Professor Timothy Charles Claypole, Director, Welsh Centre for Printing and Coating, Swansea University. For services to Graphic Arts Research.\n* Barry Clewer. For voluntary service to Birmingham Advisory Council of Older People.\n* [Oliver Charles Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 \"Collyer brothers (game designers)\"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to Computer Games Industry.\n* [Paul Edward Collyer](/wiki/Collyer_brothers_%28game_designers%29 \"Collyer brothers (game designers)\"), Co Founder, Sports Interactive. For services to the Computer Game Industry.\n* David Constantine, Co\\-Founder and Executive Officer Motivation. For services to disabled people.\n* Teresa Mary, Mrs. Copp, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* David John Couch. For charitable services in Fife.\n* Thelma Selina, Mrs. Couch. For charitable services in Fife.\n* Ms Margaret Joan Coulter. For services to Social Care in Northern Ireland.\n* [The Reverend Dr. Robert James Coulter](/wiki/Robert_Coulter_%28Northern_Ireland_politician%29 \"Robert Coulter (Northern Ireland politician)\"), Member, Northern Ireland Assembly Commission. For public service.\n* David Robert Coulthard, Senior Technician, University of York. For services to Science Communication.\n* Beryl, Mrs. Cox, Administrator, Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service, York. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Theresa, Mrs. Coyle. For voluntary service to the community in Islington, London.\n* Dorothy Dawn, Mrs. Cragg, Medical Tattooist. For services to Healthcare.\n* Heather, Mrs. Crawford. For services to Speech and Language Therapy in Northern Ireland.\n* Arthur Graves Credland. For services to Maritime History.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Crennell, Senior Assistant Headteacher and Head of Learning Support Faculty, Marriotts School, Stevenage. For services to Special Needs Education.\n* Ms Heather Alice Crouch, Chair, Netball South West. For voluntary service to Sport.\n* John Cunningham. For charitable services in County Durham.\n* Gordon Curry. For public service.\n* Leonard James Curtis. For services to the community in Lancashire.\n* Ms Nicola Kim Dale, Chief Inspector, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police.\n* David Dallison. For public service.\n* Ashish Dasgupta, Non\\-Executive Director, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* John Kenneth Davies. For charitable services in Rochdale.\n* Patricia Ann, Mrs. Davies. For voluntary service to Young People in Brownhills, Walsall, West Midlands.\n* Sandra Irwin, Mrs. Davies. For services to the community in Craven Arms, Shropshire.\n* Vanessa Marion, Mrs. Davies, Physiotherapist, Artificial Limb and Appliance Centre, Morriston Hospital, Swansea. For services to Healthcare.\n* Barbara Jane, Mrs. Davis. For services to Young People in Buckinghamshire.\n* Ian Davis. For services to the House of Commons.\n* Eric George Dawkins. For services to the community in Penryn and Falmouth, Cornwall.\n* Terence Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Victoria, Mrs. Day, Foster Carer, Bedfordshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ms Ilene Daisy Ming\\-Deans. For services to Clapham Youth Centre, Lambeth, London.\n* Sister Lynda Dearlove. For services to Vulnerable Women.\n* Sarinder Kaur, Mrs. Dev, Constable, South Yorkshire Police. For services to the Police.\n* Achhar Paul Dharni. For services to Business and to the community in Bradford, West Yorkshire.\n* Gwyneth Muriel, Mrs. Dickinson, President, Macular Disease Society. For services to Visually Impaired People.\n* Valerie Anne, Mrs. Dilcock. For services to the North York Moors National Park Authority.\n* Ronald Dodd, Chairman, Training and Development Resource Ltd, Tyneside. For services to Skills.\n* Ian Henry Donaghey. For services to Regeneration in Coleraine, Northern Ireland.\n* Mary Maya, Mrs. Donelan. For services to the community in Hammersmith and Fulham, London.\n* Ms Norah Donnelly. For public service.\n* Jennifer, Mrs. Doolan. Harpist. For services to Music.\n* Muriel Margaret, Mrs. Douglas, Manager, Scottish NHS Central Register, General Register Office for Scotland, Scottish Executive.\n* Dr. Andrew Frank Dove. For services to St. John Ambulance Brigade in Nottinghamshire.\n* Carol Ann, Mrs. Downes, Divisional Officer, Derbyshire Special Constabulary. For voluntary service to the Police.\n* Ray Downey. For charitable services to Sunderland Kidney Patient Group.\n* John Ernest Drake, lately Chief Executive, YMCA Norfolk. For services to Young People.\n* Alan Gordon Drinkall. For services to the community In North Yorkshire.\n* Councillor Elizabeth Ann Ducker, Leader, South Oxfordshire District Council. For services to Local Government.\n* David John Duke, Principal Technician, Department of Materials Science and Metallurgy, University of Cambridge. For services to Science.\n* Karen, Mrs. Duncan, Senior Executive Officer, Student Finance Policy, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.\n* William Duncan. For services to Horticulture in Scotland.\n* Miss Elizabeth Dunlop. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Scotland.\n* Terrance Dunne. For voluntary service to St. Andrew's Hospice, Airdrie, Lanarkshire.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Dupres. For services to St. Cuthbert's Catholic Primary School, Egham, Surrey.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Eaglefield. For charitable services in Derbyshire.\n* Eric James Eames. For services to the community in Birmingham.\n* Ewan Easton. For voluntary service to H.M. Young Offenders' Institution, Thorn Cross, Warrington, Cheshire.\n* The Reverend Mark Antony Edwards. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the North East.\n* Gillian, Mrs. Elkins. For services to the community in Clacton\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Miss Susan Ellis, lately Principal Officer, South East Area, National Offender Management Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Miss Cathryn Ellsmore, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence. Dr. John Richard England. For services to Retail Planning.\n* Eileen, Mrs. Entwistle. For services to Local Government and to the community in Darwen and Blackburn, Lancashire.\n* Geraint Evans. For voluntary service to Education in the Vale of Glamorgan.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Evans, lately Administrative Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Thomas Eurfyl Evans, Councillor, Ceredigion County Council. For services to Local Government in West Wales.\n* [Timothy Everest](/wiki/Timothy_Everest \"Timothy Everest\"), Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Fairbrother, Senior Probation Officer, Sussex Probation Area. For services to the Administration of Justice.\n* Kelly, Mrs. Fairman. For services to the Fire and Rescue Service.\n* Donald Fava, lately Business and Performance Reporting Manager, Finance and Operations Directorate, Department of Health.\n* Janis Elizabeth, Mrs. Feely, Founder and Project Director, Living Room, Stevenage, Hertfordshire. For services to Disadvantaged People.\n* Ms Ann Ferguson. For services to Older People in Scotland.\n* Ms Margaret Hilary Ferriman, Chair, Banbury District Racial Equality Council. For services to Community Relations.\n* Ms Deirdre Figueiredo, Director of Craftspace. For services to the Visual Arts in the West Midlands.\n* Lyndon Filer, Chief Executive, Police Rehabilitation Centre, Goring\\-on\\-Thames. For services to the Police.\n* Michael Peter Findley. For charitable services in Redcar, Cleveland.\n* Dr. Doreen Elizabeth Finneron. For services to Inter\\-Faith Relations.\n* Peggy Rita, Mrs. Finnie. For services to the community in Aberdeen.\n* Peter James Fisher, Policy Adviser, Office of the Judge Advocate\\-General, Ministry of Justice.\n* Ms Honor Wilson\\-Fletcher, lately Director, National Year of Reading. For services to Education.\n* Anthony Fowler. For services to the community in Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire.\n* Dereck Fowles, lately Chairman, Forth Valley and Lomond Local Action Group. For services to Rural Communities in Scotland.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Fox. For voluntary service to Deeside Community Hospital League of Friends, North Wales.\n* Jennifer Lesley, Mrs. Foxon, Senior Technician, Department of Genetics, University of Leicester. For services to Science.\n* David Victor Freeborn. For services to the Patterdale Mountain Rescue Team in the Lake District.\n* Peter French, Deputy Chairman, London Board of Crimestoppers. For services to the Police.\n* Timothy Enis French. For services to the community in Haywards Heath, West Sussex.\n* Pino Frumiento, Singer and Songwriter, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.\n* Dr. Ian David Robert Fry, Director, Partnership Pathology, Frimley Park Hospital NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare in the South East.\n* Michael Fuller. For services to the NHS and to the Unite Trade Union in Scotland.\n* Richard Gagan, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Irene Lorraine, Mrs. Galloway, lately Caseworker, Customer Operation, Lisburn, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Sarah Elizabeth, Mrs. Gamble. For services to the community in County Antrim.\n* Stuart Mitchell Gay, J.P. For services to the community in Lancashire and Overseas.\n* Mary Helen, Mrs. George, Catering Supervisor, Crossroads Primary School, Keith. For services to Education.\n* Asquith Gibbes. For voluntary service to the Police in South East London.\n* Henry Atherton Derek Gibson. For services to the community in Bridgwater, Somerset.\n* Mary, Mrs. Gibson. For services to Education and to the community in North London.\n* Robert Stewart Gibson, Officer, H.M. Prison Gartree, Leicestershire, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Margaret Helen, Mrs. Gilbert. For services to Older People in County Tyrone.\n* Atma Singh Gill. For services to the community in the North East.\n* Joy, Mrs. Gillies. For voluntary service to the Children's Panel in Scotland.\n* Bernard John Godding. For voluntary service to Adult Learning and the Educational Centres Association.\n* Alan John Godfrey, Publisher of Historic Ordnance Survey Maps. For services to Heritage.\n* Professor [Michael Goodfellow](/wiki/Michael_Goodfellow \"Michael Goodfellow\"), Chairman of Governors, Gosforth High School, Newcastle upon Tyne. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Sheila, Mrs. Gow. For services to Regional Journalism.\n* Ms Agnes Graham. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Western Scotland.\n* Dr. Maria Jadwiga Dlugolecka\\-Graham. For services to Polish\\-Scottish Relations and to Medicine.\n* Robert Oliver David Graham, lately Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Barbara, Mrs. Grant, Clinical Nurse Manager, NHS Fife. For services to Ophthalmology.\n* [Clemency Anne Rose, Mrs. Gray](/wiki/Rose_Gray \"Rose Gray\"), Co\\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* William Gray. For services to Diversity and to Disability Training in Scotland.\n* Angela Margaret, Mrs. Green. For charitable services Overseas and in Malvern, Worcestershire.\n* Charles Anthony Green. For voluntary service to Industrial Heritage in the Staffordshire Potteries.\n* Susan, Mrs. Greenwood, Specialist Community Public Health Nurse, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly. For services to Healthcare.\n* David Grey, Group Managing Director, OSL Group Holdings Ltd. For services to Business and to Regeneration in Sheffield.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Grice, Chief Executive, South Yorkshire Community Foundation. For services to Flood Relief.\n* Joan, Mrs. Griffiths. For services to People with Learning Disabilities in Scotland.\n* Mary Beatrice, Mrs. Guest. For services to People with Sensory Impairment.\n* Mavis Ann, Mrs. Gunning. For voluntary service to Victims of Sexual Assault.\n* Gordon William Guthrie. For services to Derby County Football Club.\n* Ms Anna\\-Marie Hale (Mrs. Byrne), Matron, Division One Trauma and Orthopaedics, Selly Oak Hospital, Birmingham. For services to Healthcare.\n* Colonel Alan Edmund Hall, T.D., D.L. For services to the community in the London Borough of Redbridge.\n* Iain Murray Halliday. For services to the Arts in Perth.\n* David Halpin. For services to disabled people in the North West.\n* Pauline Jane, Mrs. Handy, Clinical Lead Nurse, Genito\\-Urinary Medicine, Newcastle General Hospital. For services to Healthcare.\n* Frank Hannah, President, Manchester County Football Association. For services to Sport.\n* Ms Belinda Harding, Constable, City of London Police. For services to the Police.\n* Gillian Carol, Mrs. Hardy, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* [Terence Harris](/wiki/Jet_Harris \"Jet Harris\"). For services to Music.\n* Ms Karen Harrison, Head, Business Crime Preventions Team, Wakefield Partnership. For services to the Police.\n* Peter Brantford Hartland. For services to the community in Ashton Keynes, Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Colin Hartley. For services to the community in Halifax, West Yorkshire.\n* Faith Ingrid Evelyn, Mrs. Harvey. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire.\n* Ms Susan Harvey. For services to Orienteering and to the community in Doune and Deanston, Perth and Kinross.\n* Margaret Lynne, Mrs. Harwood, Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Margaret Vine, Mrs. Haugh, Adviser for Creative and Expressive Studies, Southern Education and Library Board. For services to Education in Northern Ireland.\n* Jean, Mrs. Hayley. Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.\n* Rodney James Hayley, Foster Carer. For services to Children and Families in Northern Ireland.\n* Lewis Charles Haywood. For services to the Energy Learning Centre, Elliot Durham School, Nottingham.\n* Professor John William Stanley Hearle. For services to Archaeology in Mellor, Stockport, Greater Manchester.\n* Jean, Mrs. Heath. For services to Chadlington Primary School, Oxfordshire.\n* Roberta, Mrs. Heavens. For services to the Tourism Industry.\n* Jean Marion Anne, Mrs. Hedley. For voluntary service to Nature Conservation in Hampshire and the Isle of Wight.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Heeley. For voluntary service to Somerset Rural Life Museum.\n* Ms [Anna Hemmings](/wiki/Anna_Hemmings \"Anna Hemmings\"), Canoeist. For services to Sport.\n* John Graham Hemmings, Chairman, Blurton Ladsandads, Stoke\\-on\\-Trent. For services to Grass Roots Football.\n* John Patrick Hennigan, Superintendent, British Transport Police. For services to the Police.\n* Miss Sylvia Jean Herbert, Chaplain, H.M. Prison Leicester. For services to Prisoners.\n* John Coleman Hick, Vice\\-President, British Holiday and Home Parks Association. For services to the Tourist Industry.\n* Major Antony Stanley Hill. For services to Military Heritage in Essex.\n* Lyn Joy, Mrs. Hill, Band 5, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Richard Wendle Hill, Branch Manager, Ulster Bank. For services to the Financial Services Industry.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Hillman. For services to Girlguiding Cymru and to the Community of Hope.\n* Christopher Hilton, lately General Manager, Odeon Leicester Square Cinema. For services to the Film Industry.\n* Barry Hitchcock, Director of Sport, University of Surrey. For services to Sport and to Higher Education.\n* Raymond Hodgkinson, Director\\-General, British Healthcare Trades Association. For services to the Healthcare Industry.\n* Linda Mary, Mrs. Hoggarth. For services to disabled people in Suffolk.\n* Ms Jean Florence Holder. For voluntary service to the Women's Library.\n* Miss Rhiannon Sarah Holder. For services to Young People's Healthcare.\n* Valerie Lois, Mrs. Holt. For services to Fisheries Management and to Conservation.\n* Lady Lavinia Caroline Douglas\\-Home, D.L. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross and Macmillan Cancer Support in the Scottish Borders.\n* Michael John Hopper, lately Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Douglas Horrill. For voluntary service to Age Concern, New Forest East, Hampshire.\n* Doreen Grace, Mrs. Hosey. For services to the community in Fawley, Southampton.\n* Ms Rebecca Ann Hosking. For services to the Environment in Modbury, Dorset.\n* Donna Maria, Mrs. Hough, Dental Workforce Development Lead for Dental Care Professionals, North Western and Mersey Postgraduate Deaneries. For services to Healthcare.\n* Edward Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.\n* Winifred, Mrs. Howes. For services to the community in Prestatyn and Rhyl, Denbighshire.\n* Ms Sheila Hudson. For services to Disadvantaged Young People in Hartlepool.\n* Joe Human. For services to Oxfam and to Fair Trade in Cumbria.\n* Brenda, Mrs. Hunt. For services to Older People in East Manchester.\n* Carl Peter Hunt, Watch Manager, Humberside Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.\n* Alderman Edna, Lady Hunter. For services to the community in County Durham.\n* The Reverend Canon Michael Oram Hunter. For services to the Church of England and to the community in Grimsby.\n* Professor John Margarson Huthnance, Deputy Director, Proudman Oceanographic Laboratory. For services to Marine Science.\n* Dr. Thomas George Hyde. For services to the community in Repton, Derbyshire.\n* Brian Ibell, lately Assistant Chief Executive, Derby Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Andrew Ingram, Executive Officer, Output Services Group, Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency, Swansea, Department for Transport.\n* Peter David John Ingram. For services to Paper Making Industrial Heritage.\n* James John Jack. For services to Children and Young People at Kibble Education and Care Centre.\n* Mona, Mrs. Jack. For services to the community in Dumfries.\n* Florence, Mrs. Jackson. For voluntary service to Hatton Hill Primary School, Sefton, Merseyside.\n* Valerie, Mrs. Jackson, Founder and Principal, Stage 84\\. For services to the Performing Arts in the North.\n* Valerie Hazel, Mrs. Jackson. For services to the community in Newcastle Emlyn, Carmarthenshire.\n* [John Alexander Jameson](/wiki/John_Jameson_%28cricketer%29 \"John Jameson (cricketer)\"). For services to cricket.\n* Waltraud Anna Luise, Mrs. Jarrold. For services to the community in Norwich.\n* Susan Kay, Mrs. Jay, Area Manager, West Suffolk MIND. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Helen Adair, Mrs. Jenkins. For services to the community in Durrington, Wiltshire.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Jenkins, Senior Case Adviser, Freedom of Information Team, H.M. Treasury.\n* Sidney Johnson. For services to the community in Helston, Cornwall.\n* John Johnstone, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Henry Jones, Project Manager, ISIS Second Target Station, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Oxfordshire. For services to Science.\n* Jane Eryl, Mrs. Jones, lately Senior Nurse, Eryri Hospital, Caernarfon. For services to Healthcare for Older People.\n* Penelope, Mrs. Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.\n* Ronald Jones, Foster Carer, Surrey. For services to Children and Families.\n* Charles Ernest Jukes. For services to the community in Dursley, Gloucestershire.\n* Ms Maureen Kavanagh, Messenger, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Kay, Co\\-Founder and Project Leader, Bolton University of the Third Age. For voluntary service to Adult Education.\n* Bernard John Keay, Chairman, Health and Social Security Recreational Association, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Virginia Anne Pickering, Mrs. Keen. For services to the community in Wiltshire.\n* Victor Walter Keene. For services to the community in Coventry.\n* William Ernest James Kelley. For voluntary service to the RAF Halton Apprentices' Association.\n* Patricia Alexandra, Mrs. Kelly. Foster Carer, Cornwall. For services to Children and Families.\n* Graham Kennedy. For charitable services to People with [Friedreich's ataxia](/wiki/Friedreich%27s_ataxia \"Friedreich's ataxia\").\n* Miss Linda Margaret Kennedy, Manager, Banqueting House, Whitehall. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* Anne, Mrs. Kenyon, Administrative Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Hilary, Mrs. Kerr. For services to Children and Young People with Special Needs in Warrington, Cheshire.\n* Dr. David John Kerridge, Head of Science, Earth Hazards and Earth Systems Science, British Geological Survey. For services to Geophysics.\n* Ms Imtaz Khaliq, Designer and Master Tailor. For services to the Fashion Industry.\n* Ms Shahda Khan, Principal Community Cohesion Officer, Middlesbrough Council. For services to Local Government and to Diversity.\n* Ms [Catherine Isabel Audrey Kidston](/wiki/Cath_Kidston \"Cath Kidston\"), Founder and Creative Director, Cath Kidston. For services to Business.\n* Patrick Kieran, Senior Design Engineer. For services to Science.\n* Anne Elizabeth, Mrs. King, Director, Building Services Research and Information Association. For services to Industry.\n* Debra Ann, Mrs. King, Chair, Thornhill New Deal for Communities. For services to the community in Southampton, Hampshire.\n* Jacqueline, Mrs. Upton\\-King, Chair, Management Team, SturQuest Community Partnership. For services to the community in Sturminster Newton, Dorset.\n* Brenda Patricia, Mrs. Kirby. For services to the community in Croydon.\n* Ms Marjorie Kirk. For voluntary service to H.M. Prison Nottingham.\n* Elizabeth Ann, Mrs. Kirkwood. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northern Ireland.\n* Ms Anna Kucewicz (Mrs. Lee\\-Potter). For voluntary service to the Polish Scouting Association, Girl Scouts Division (UK).\n* Paul Lambert, Chairman, Derbyshire Family Association. For services to Maritime Safety.\n* John Lewis George Lamotte. For voluntary service to Animal Welfare in Scotland.\n* Gabriel Lancaster. For services to the community in Medway, Kent.\n* Miss Irene Langlands. For services to Dance in Central Scotland.\n* Huw John Launder, Senior Executive Officer, Pension, Disability and Carers' Service, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Derek Law, Corporate Director, Adult and Community Services, North Yorkshire County Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Ronald Lawrence. For services to the Police and to the community in Nottinghamshire.\n* Miss Kathleen Lawrenson, Diagnostic Audiologist, St. Helens and Knowsley Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Sheila Irene, Mrs. Layton, Founder, Contessa Riding Centre, Hertfordshire. For services to Equestrian Sport.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Lee, Chief Executive, Cresco Trust. For services to Social Enterprise in Northern Ireland.\n* Bryan Lewin, lately Head of Trading Standards, Northamptonshire County Council. For services to Consumers and to Business.\n* Miss Judith Anne Lewis. For services to the Environment in the North East.\n* Councillor Leonard Lewis. For services to Local Government and to the community in Caerphilly, South Wales.\n* Neil Lewis. For services to Industrial Heritage and to the community in Blaenavon, Torfaen.\n* David Robin Littlewood. For voluntary service to Athletics.\n* Dr. Stephen Nicholas Liversedge, General Medical Practitioner, Bolton. For services to Healthcare.\n* Wesley Courtney Livingstone, President, Newry Musical and Orchestral Society. For services to Music and to the community in County Down.\n* Mary Constance, Mrs. Lloyd. For services to the community in Rutland.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Lockett. For services to the community of Ackworth, West Yorkshire.\n* Arthur Clifford Lockyear. For services to the community in Sunderland.\n* Ian Douglas Loe, Wildlife Stamp Designer. For services to Art.\n* Jeffrey Long. For voluntary service to the Royal British Legion.\n* Ronald Hedley Longford, Chiropractor and Physiotherapist. For services to Animal Welfare.\n* Carmel, Mrs. Lyddall, Executive Assistant, Local Government and Regional Policy Team, Department of Health.\n* Alexander McKay Lynch. Group Finance Director, David MacBrayne Ltd, Gourock. For services to Transport and Charity in Scotland.\n* Ms Ann MacKay, Policy Adviser, English Community Care Association. For services to Social Care.\n* Professor [Margaret MacLean](/wiki/Margaret_MacLean \"Margaret MacLean\"), Professor of Pulmonary Pharmacology. For services to Science.\n* Geraldine, Mrs. MacPhee, Principal Teacher in Home Economics, Clyde Valley High School. For services to Education and to the community in North Lanarkshire.\n* Sydney Mair. For services to Local Government and to the community in Macduff, Aberdeenshire.\n* Jean Isabella, Mrs. Malkin. For services to Young People in the Cartmel Peninsula, Cumbria.\n* Edna, Mrs. March. For services to the community in Crook, County Durham.\n* Kenneth Marsh, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.\n* Michael Thomas Martin. For services to the Voluntary Sector in Reading, Berkshire.\n* Stuart Andrew Martin. For services to the community in Ripon, North Yorkshire.\n* William Martin, Chairman, H. and J. Martin Ltd. For services to the Construction Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Philip Mason. For services to disabled people in Hampshire.\n* Ms Valerie Mason (Mrs. Hendry). For services to the British Heart Foundation.\n* Hilary, Mrs. Massarella. For voluntary service to Disadvantaged Young People in South Yorkshire.\n* George Lewis Mathias. For services to Agriculture.\n* [Catriona, Mrs. Matthew](/wiki/Catriona_Matthew \"Catriona Matthew\"). For services to Golf.\n* Edwin Alexander Maxwell. For services to the New Art Exchange and to the community in Nottingham.\n* Denise Jane, Mrs. May, Director of Sport and Assistant Headteacher, Budehaven Community School, Cornwall. For services to Education.\n* Leslie Holden McAdoo, Chairman, Ballyclare Committee, Macmillan Cancer Support. For charitable services in Northern Ireland.\n* Margaret Mary, Mrs. McCluskie, Manager, Major Investigation Team, Identity and Passport Service, Home Office.\n* William McCrory. For services to Children with Cancer in Northern Ireland.\n* Helen Muir, Mrs. McDonald. For services to the community in Crieff, Perthshire.\n* Ken McElroy. For services to the Tourist Industry in Northern Ireland.\n* Jean, Mrs. McEwen. For services to the community in Norwich.\n* Peter McFall, Janitor, St. Peter 's Primary School, Dumbarton, West Dunbartonshire. For services to Education.\n* Dr. David Douglas Murray McGavin, Ophthalmologist. For services to Eye Care in Developing Countries.\n* Andrew Fraser McKay, Detective Superintendent, Strathclyde Police Force. For services to the Police.\n* Ms Annie McKean, Senior Lecturer in Drama, University of Winchester. For services to Higher Education.\n* Fiona Mary, Mrs. McLean, Grade C2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Terrence McLernon. For services to Table Tennis and to the community in Drumchapel, Glasgow.\n* Ms Melanie Justine McLoughlin. For services to the Devon Community Foundation.\n* Ivan Lewis McMichael. For services to Journalism in Northern Ireland.\n* Dr. Mary Brigeen McNee, General Medical Practitioner, Glasgow. For voluntary service to Cancer Research and to Healthcare in Lourdes.\n* Alexander Ian McNeill, Administration Officer, Customer Operations, Thornaby, Cleveland, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Marian, Mrs. McNeir. For services to the community In Bath.\n* Marjory, Mrs. McQueen. For services to the community In Lockerbie, Dumfries and Galloway.\n* Dr. Noel Henri Joseph Meeke. For voluntary service to Herefordshire Waterworks Museum.\n* David Melrose, Chairman, Scottish Prison Officers' Association, Scottish Executive.\n* Jean, Mrs. Messenger. For services to the After School Club, Bude, Cornwall.\n* Faruk Miah, Programme Manager, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education and to the community in Leeds.\n* Moira Sheelagh, Mrs. Michelmore. For services to the community in Sidmouth, Devon.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Milburn, Chair, West Suffolk College Corporation. For services to Further Education and to the community in Suffolk.\n* [Frederick Roy Millar](/wiki/Roy_Millar \"Roy Millar\"), Director of Coaching, Irish Football Association. For services to Youth Football in Northern Ireland.\n* Ian Duncan Millar. For services to Agriculture in Scotland.\n* Patrick Millard. For services to the charity Taxhelp for Older People.\n* Katherine, Mrs. Miller, Administrative Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Marcia Anne, Mrs. Miller. For voluntary service to the British Red Cross Society in Cambridgeshire.\n* Gerald David Mills. For services to School Sport in Nottinghamshire.\n* Laura, Mrs. Mitchell, Consultant Orthodontist and Clinical Lead, St Luke's Hospital Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Nasrullah Khan Moghal. For services to Community Relations in Manchester.\n* Michael Monaghan. For charitable services to Ex\\- Service Men and Women.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Montgomery. For charitable services in Northern Ireland and Overseas.\n* Roger Ivan Moore. For services to the community in Potters Bar, Hertfordshire.\n* Christopher Morgan, Security Manager, Aberafan Shopping Centre. For services to the community in Neath Port Talbot.\n* Daphne, Mrs. Morgan. For voluntary service to Hertfordshire Constabulary and to Feltham Young Offenders' Institution.\n* John Francis Morgan. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Newcastle, County Down.\n* Alderman Peter James Morgan. For services to the community in Sittingbourne, Kent.\n* Heather Dalton, Mrs. Morris, School Crossing Warden, Sale, Cheshire. For services to Education.\n* Helen Elizabeth, Mrs. Morris. Crown Advocate, Merseyside and Cheshire Group, Crown Prosecution Service.\n* John Harold Morris. For services to the Post Office.\n* Thomas Geraint Morris. For services to the NHS and to the community in Dersingham, Norfolk.\n* Nigel Peter Morse, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Keith Hedley Moss, President, Bradford Cricket League and Pudsey St. Lawrence Cricket Club. For voluntary service to Sport.\n* Maureen Anne, Mrs. Muckle, Chair, Batchley First School, Redditch. For services to Education and to the community in North Worcestershire.\n* [Maurice Harrison Murphy](/wiki/Maurice_Murphy_%28musician%29 \"Maurice Murphy (musician)\"). Trumpeter. For services to Music.\n* Janice Elizabeth, Mrs. Naylor. For services to Swimming.\n* Peter David Needham, Grade B2, Ministry of Defence.\n* Terence Charles Nelson, Security Officer, Leeds City College. For services to Further Education.\n* Harold Newman. For services to the community in Mill Hill, London.\n* Gilda, Mrs. Newsham. For voluntary service to the Alzheimer's Society, New Forest, Hampshire.\n* Fionnuala Eileen, Mrs. Newton, Executive Administrative Assistant, Queen's University Belfast. For services to Higher Education.\n* Vicky, Mrs. Norman, Senior Executive Officer, Child Support Agency, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Sheila Maureen, Mrs. O'Neill. For services to Music in Ackworth, West Yorkshire.\n* Valerie Ann, Mrs. O'Riordan. For services to the community in Berkshire.\n* Barbara, Mrs. Oakes, Manager, High Street Library. For services to Local Government in Bolton.\n* Marjorie Frances, Mrs. Oaten. For voluntary service to People with Eating Disorders.\n* Margaret May, Mrs. Oatey. For services to the community in East Anglia.\n* Stella, Mrs. Okeahialam, Programme Director, Croydon Enterprise. For service to Business.\n* Michael Joseph Rolfe Orbell. For services to the Scouts in Wimbledon and Merton, London.\n* Noel George Ormrod, lately Chairman, Wallasey Arts Council. For services to the Arts in Merseyside.\n* Alexander Orr, Craftsman, Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Scotland.\n* Arnold Jenkin Owen. For services to the community in Blackmill, Bridgend and to Welsh International Brigaders.\n* Margaret Mcalister, Mrs. Owen. For services to the community in Shrewsbury, Shropshire.\n* Ms Margaret Paisley, College Manager, Elmwood College, Residence and Student Union. For services to Further Education in Fife.\n* Margaret Frances Elizabeth, Mrs. Palmer. For public service.\n* Ms Lydia Joy Parbury. For services to People with Special Needs and Disabilities.\n* Dorothy Mary, Mrs. Parker, Community Support Worker, West Wirral Community Mental Health Team. For services to Healthcare.\n* John Bywell Parker. For voluntary service to the Hadrian Trust in the North East.\n* Ann Rosemary, Mrs. Parr, Community Care Development Manager, Age Concern, Woodley. For services to Older People in Berkshire.\n* Rabindara Nath Pathak, Chairman of Governors, Featherstone High School, Ealing, London. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Trevor James Patton, Principal Nursing Officer, Northern Ireland Prison Service.\n* Margaret Elsie, Mrs. Perfect. For voluntary service to the Boys' Brigade in Watford, Hertfordshire.\n* Alderman Fred Perry. For services to the community in Tipton, West Midlands.\n* Joan, Mrs. Phillips. For voluntary service to the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester.\n* [Roger Phillips](/wiki/Roger_Phillips_%28photographer%29 \"Roger Phillips (photographer)\"). For services to London Garden Squares.\n* [Jean Catherine, Mrs. Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Pickering \"Jean Pickering\"). For services to Athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.\n* Alice Kirsty, Lady Pilkington. For voluntary service to Willowbrook Hospice, St. Helens and Knowsley, Merseyside.\n* Pauline, Mrs. Pilkington, Director, Children's Services, Walsall Council. For services to Local Government.\n* Professor [Robert Michael Pittilo](/wiki/Mike_Pittilo \"Mike Pittilo\"), Principal and Vice\\-Chancellor, Robert Gordon University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. Jaswant Kaur Jutley\\-Plested, Manager, Sydenham Children's Centre, Bridgwater, Somerset. For services to Children.\n* Peter Pocock. For services to Workplace First Aid Training.\n* Miss Rashmi Amritlal Popat, Executive Officer, Work Welfare and Equality Group, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Ms Prudence Alexine Regina Porretta. For services to Community Cohesion and to the Tourist Industry in Coventry.\n* Iain David Russell Prain, Vice\\-Principal, Royal Blind School, Craigmillar Park, Edinburgh. For services to Education.\n* [Stephen Prescott](/wiki/Steve_Prescott \"Steve Prescott\"). For services to Rugby League and to Charity.\n* Gres, Mrs. Pritchard, Peripatetic Music Teacher, Ynys Mon. For services to Education.\n* The Reverend Dr. Jean Prosser. For services to Conservation and to the community in Monmouthshire.\n* Isabel, Mrs. Quinliven, Founder, Caring Canines. For services to Older People in Northern Ireland.\n* Brenda, Mrs. Quinn, Service Manager, Recovery Services, Belfast Health and Social Care Trust. For services to Mental Healthcare.\n* Toaha Bashir Zulqarnain Qureshi. For services to Community Relations in Stockwell, South West London.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Raine, Office Manager, English Language Teaching Unit, University of Leicester. For services to Higher Education.\n* Dr. Kathleen Rankin. For voluntary service to the Living Linen Project in Northern Ireland.\n* Mohamad Rashied, President, Caribbean Islamic Cultural Society. For services to Community Relations in London.\n* Robert David Richard Ray. For services to Rugby Union and to Young People in Rugby, Warwickshire.\n* Ms Janet Mary Reed, Senior Social Worker, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre, Headley Court, Surrey, Ministry of Defence.\n* Angela Mary, Mrs. Rees, Assistant Head, Debt Management and Banking, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Abdul Rehman. For services to the community in Derby.\n* Miss Marion Reynolds. For services to Vulnerable Children in Northern Ireland.\n* Alan Ribchester. For charitable services in the City of Durham.\n* The Reverend James Manson Richards. For services to Children and Families.\n* George Edmund Richardson, lately Chairman, Calderdale College and Chairman, Association of Colleges, Yorkshire and the Humber Region. For voluntary service to Further Education.\n* Miss Rosalyn Elizabeth Richardson, lately Deputy Director of Health Informatics, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to the NHS.\n* [Andrew William Ritchie](/wiki/Andrew_Ritchie_%28Brompton%29 \"Andrew Ritchie (Brompton)\"), Technical Director, Brompton Bicycle Ltd. For services to Business and to International Trade.\n* Christopher David Medwyn Roberts. For services to the community in Merseyside.\n* Clarissa Elizabeth, Mrs. Roberts. For services to Older People in Stratford\\-upon\\-Avon, Warwickshire.\n* Jean Sylvia, Mrs. Roberts, Ministerial Messenger, Department for Transport.\n* Peter Adrian Roberts, Chairman, Association of Community Rail Partnerships. For services to Rural Transport.\n* Angus John Robertson, Principal Fellow in Clinical Illustration, Leeds Dental Institute. For services to Healthcare.\n* Matthew Robertson, Sergeant, Ministry of Defence Police.\n* Norman Robertson, lately Curriculum Leader in Hospitality, Ayr College. For services to Further Education.\n* Margaret, Mrs. Robinson. For services to the community in Trimdon, County Durham.\n* The Reverend Father George Edward Robson, Chairman, North Huyton New Deal for Communities Board. For services to the community in Merseyside.\n* Ms Jennifer Van Krieken Robson, Head of Minority Achievement Service, Kent County Council. For services to Education.\n* Sheila Ruth, Mrs. Rodmell. For services to the community in Elvington, Kent.\n* Ms Susan Rogers. For services to Trade Unions.\n* [Ruth Lady Rogers of Riverside](/wiki/Ruth_Rogers \"Ruth Rogers\"), Chef and Co\\-Founder, River Cafe ́. For services to the Hospitality Industry.\n* William Andrew Taylor Roulston. For services to Equestrian Sport in Northern Ireland.\n* Beryl Lillian, Mrs. Rowe. For services to the community in Lilley, Bedfordshire.\n* Dr. Christopher Giles Rowland. For services to the Friends of the Oncology and Radiotherapy Centre, Exeter.\n* John Rowlands, Economics Teacher, John Ruskin Sixth Form College, Croydon, London. For services to Education.\n* Marion, Mrs. Roy, lately Headteacher, Auchenback Primary School, East Renfrewshire. For services to Education.\n* Colonel John Anthony Nutter Read Royle. For services to the Soldiers', Sailors', Airmen and Families Association in Northamptonshire.\n* [Chrissie, Mrs. Rucker](/wiki/Chrissie_Rucker \"Chrissie Rucker\"), Founder and Creative Director, White Company. For services to the Retail Industry.\n* Anthony Michael Hurst Rumsey, Collections Manager, National Monuments Record. For services to Photography.\n* Annette, Mrs. Rushton, lately Matron, Severn Hospice, Shrewsbury. For services to Healthcare.\n* Dr. Andrew Oldrey Russell, lately Chairman, League of Friends, Edenbridge and District War Memorial Hospital. For services to Healthcare.\n* Ezriel Salomon. For services to the community in Gateshead, Tyne and Wear.\n* Ahmed Ali Sasso, Constable, Hampshire Constabulary. For services to the Police.\n* Mary Ann Landsborough, Mrs. Saunders. For services to the Diocese of Oxford and to the Church of England.\n* Ms Susan Saunders, Co\\-Ordinator, Disability Support Network, Home Office.\n* Keith Savage. For voluntary service to the Air Training Corps in Rutland.\n* Lynn, Mrs. Savill. For services to People with Epilepsy in Gravesend, Kent.\n* Ms Cherryl Lynn Sawyer, Business and Development Director, Threshold Housing Link. For services to Homeless People in Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Callie, Mrs. Saxty, lately Head of Visitor Operations for Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, English Heritage. For services to Heritage.\n* Nora Gladys Elsie, Mrs. Schneider. For services to the community in Newbury, Berkshire.\n* Robert Sinclair Scott. For voluntary service to the community in County Armagh.\n* The Reverend Christopher John Sears. For services to Disadvantaged People in Hastings, East Sussex.\n* Dr. Claude Doumet Serhal, Special Assistant, British Museum. For services to Archaeology.\n* Thomas Richard Sermon, Chairman, London Youth. For services to Young People.\n* Terence Brian Shead. For services to the community in East Peckham, Kent.\n* Alan William Sherriff. For services to the community in South Yorkshire.\n* Ann, Mrs. Shreeve, Senior Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Jasvinder Singh Sidhu. For services to Social Housing.\n* Phillip Edward Sillick, J.P. For services to the community in Gorseinon, Swansea.\n* Benjamin David Simpson, J.P. For services to the community in Oxford.\n* Kathleen, Mrs. Simpson. For services to the community in Moston, Manchester.\n* [Lemn Sissay](/wiki/Lemn_Sissay \"Lemn Sissay\"), Poet and Performer. For services to Literature.\n* John William Skinner, Director of Music, Haberdashers' Aske's Hatcham College, Lewisham, London. For services to Education.\n* Catherine, Mrs. Slow. For services to West Exmoor Federation of Schools, Devon.\n* Alison Mary, Mrs. Smedley. For services to Inland Waterways.\n* Amanda Jane, Mrs. Smith, Executive Assistant, Youth Task Force Strategy, Department for Children, Schools and Families.\n* Dr. Angela Owen\\-Smith. For services to Medicine and to the community in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire.\n* Miss Charlotte Lilian Smith. For services to the community in Porthyrhyd, Carmarthenshire.\n* Colin Smith, Retained Crew Manager, West Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service. For services to Local Government.\n* Elizabeth, Mrs. Smith, Vice\\-Chair and Board Member, Colchester Institute. For voluntary service to Further and Higher Education.\n* Ian Graham Smith. For services to the community in Ramsbury, Wiltshire.\n* James Smith. For voluntary service to Youth Football in Glasgow.\n* Eric Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Mary, Mrs. Snook, Foster Carer, Hampshire. For services to Children and Families.\n* Dr. Richard Alfred Sparks, lately Consultant in Genito\\-Urinary Medicine, Cardiff and Vale NHS Trust. For services to Medicine.\n* Councillor Josephine Elizabeth Spencer. For services to the community in Christchurch, Dorset.\n* Dr. Richard Anthony Spencer, Biology Subject Leader, SRC Bede Sixth Form, Billingham, Teesside. For services to Science Communication.\n* Sally Louise, Mrs. Hughes\\-Stanton, Executive Secretary, Prime Minister's Office.\n* Roger Carlton Steele. For services to Young People in Sheffield.\n* Cheryl, Mrs. Stevens, Principal Practitioner, Benefits and Credits, Preston, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Mary, Mrs. Stevens. For services to the community in Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Edward Craig Stevenson, lately Engineer of Medical Physics, University of Aberdeen. For services to Healthcare and to Charity.\n* Karen, Mrs. Stock, Extended Schools Co\\-ordinator, Shoeburyness and Chair of Governors, Shoeburyness High School, Essex. For services to Education.\n* Rodney Ernest Stoddart. For voluntary service to Mountain Rescue in Tayside.\n* Eric Arthur Stott. For services to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Janet, Mrs. Stoyel. For services to the Textile Industry.\n* Miss Judith Anne Strange, Higher Executive Officer, Jobcentre Plus, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Councillor Phyllis Zaphne Stretton. For services to the community in Cannock, Staffordshire.\n* Ivy Alberta, Mrs. Sturgeon, Personal Secretary, H.M. Prison Littlehey, Huntingdon, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Rozelle Elizabeth, Mrs. Sutherland. For voluntary service to Victims of Domestic Violence in Jersey.\n* Roderick John Symonds. For services to the community in Reading, Berkshire.\n* Ranjula, Mrs. Takodra. For services to the community in Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire.\n* Gwynneth Mary, Mrs. Tame. For services to Heritage and to the community of Dorchester\\-on\\-Thames in Oxfordshire.\n* Susan, Mrs. Tamlyn. For services to Heritage in Suffolk.\n* Miss [Samantha Claire Taylor](/wiki/Claire_Taylor \"Claire Taylor\"), Cricketer. For services to Sport.\n* James Graham Taylor, Music Director, City of Glasgow Chorus. For services to Music.\n* Josephine May, Mrs. Taylor. For services to the community in Plumpton Green, East Sussex.\n* Mary, Mrs. Thirlwell. For voluntary service to Young People in Lanarkshire.\n* Ms Melanie Anne Thody, Head of Outreach, Imperial College London. For services to Science Communication.\n* Margaret Jean, Mrs. Thomas, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Bristol.\n* Peter Thomas, lately Project Director Devonport, Interserve plc. For services to the Defence Industry.\n* Jonathan Bryan Thornes. For services to the Voluntary Sector in the East Midlands.\n* Gordon Owen Thornhill. For services to the community in Foston and Scropton, Derbyshire.\n* Angus Tilston. For services to the Historical Film Industry in the North West.\n* Thomas Todd. For services to the community in Northern Ireland.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Towning, Assistant Officer, Customer Contact, Shipley, West Yorkshire, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Maureen Ivy, Mrs. Townley. For charitable services in Southend\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Van Cuong Truong. For services to the Indo\\-Chinese community in South East London.\n* Evelyn Roberta, Mrs. Turkington. For voluntary service to The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Scheme in Northern Ireland.\n* [Mary Josephine, Mrs. Turner](/wiki/Mary_Turner_%28trade_unionist%29 \"Mary Turner (trade unionist)\"), President, GMB. For services to Trade Unions.\n* [Edward Jonathan Turpie](/wiki/Jonnie_Turpie \"Jonnie Turpie\"), Director, Maverick Television.\n* Dr. Alan Manson Turtle. For voluntary service to the community in Richhill, County Armagh.\n* Miss [Elizabeth Kimberley Tweddle](/wiki/Beth_Tweddle \"Beth Tweddle\"). For services to Gymnastics.\n* John Christopher Tyzack, Chairman of Governors, Enborne Church of England Primary School and Willow Primary School, Newbury, Berkshire. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Wendy Margaret, Mrs. Vaughan. For services to the community in South East Surrey.\n* Ronald Derek Vaulter. For services to the community in South Devon.\n* Christine, Mrs. Ruston\\-Wadsworth, Superintendent, Warwickshire Police. For services to the Police.\n* Julian Wadsworth. For services to Young People in Portsmouth.\n* Janice Irene, Mrs. Walker, Officer, H.M. Prison Wormwood Scrubs, London, H.M. Prison Service, Ministry of Justice.\n* Pamela, Mrs. Walker, Chair of Governors, Cambo First School, Morpeth, Northumberland. For voluntary service to Education.\n* Gillian Karen, Mrs. Walnes (formerly Mrs. Bogush). For services to the Anne Frank Trust UK.\n* Joan Patricia, Mrs. Warwick. For charitable services to Darent Valley Hospital, Dartford, Kent.\n* Amir Waseem, Officer, Customer Contact, Brierley Hill, West Midlands, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* Shirley Irene, Mrs. Watson. For services to the Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura Support Association.\n* The Reverend Canon Michael John Wedgeworth, lately Chairman of Governors, Blackburn College. For voluntary service to Further Education and to the communityin Lancashire.\n* Michael Edwin Weeding, Senior Officer, Customs and International, London, H.M. Revenue and Customs.\n* James Weir, Lecturer, Forth Valley College. For services to Further Education in Clackmannanshire.\n* David Anthony Westcott, J.P. For services to the community in Essex.\n* Audrey, Mrs. Wheeler. For voluntary service to Oxfam in St. Albans, Hertfordshire.\n* Norman Edward Whereat. For services to the community in Cirencester, Gloucestershire.\n* Hilary John White, Chairman of Governors, Willingdon Community School, Eastbourne, East Sussex. For voluntary service to Education.\n* John Samuel Byard White, J.P., D.L. For services to the community in Somerset.\n* Nicholas Stephen Whitehouse. For services to the Building Industry.\n* David Widdowson. For services to Young People with Learning Disabilities in Chesterfield, Derbyshire.\n* Alan Bertram Wiggins. For services to the community in Clacton\\-on\\-Sea, Essex.\n* Philip Julian Wilde. For voluntary service to Young People in Lytham St Anne's, Lancashire.\n* Dr. Henry Austin Will. For voluntary service to Ford Park Cemetery Trust in Plymouth, Devon.\n* Doreen, Mrs. Willcocks. For services to Netball and to the community in Pinehurst, Swindon, Wiltshire.\n* Paul Willgoss, Band 3, Chief Scientists' Advisory Group and Chairman, Disability Network, Health and Safety Executive, Department for Work and Pensions.\n* Christopher Mark Williams, Director, Heart n Soul. For services to Disability Arts.\n* David Michael Williams. For services to the community in Flintshire.\n* Gwilym Alun Williams. For services to Sport for Young People in Wales.\n* Professor Robert Joseph Paton Williams. For services to the community in North Oxford.\n* Gerald Willmott, Constable, Metropolitan Police Service. For services to the Police and to Boxing in the London Borough of Haringey.\n* Albert Leslie Wills, Q.F.S.M. For services to the community in the West Midlands.\n* Patrick Andrew John Wilson, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Sydney Wiltshire. For services to the community in Petersfield, Hampshire.\n* Andrew Nicholas Wood, Manager and Head Coach, Ipswich Gymnastics Centre. For services to Sport.\n* Maureen, Mrs. Woodcock, lately Non\\-Executive Director, Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust. For services to Healthcare.\n* Agnes Brown Marchbank, Mrs. Wright. For voluntary service to the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, Stewartry of Kirkcudbright.\n* Clare Margaret, Mrs. Wright, Personal Assistant, Warwickshire College. For services to Further Education.\n* Richard Kelsey Wright, Chief Executive Officer, Intertius Ltd. For services to the Manufacturing Industry.\n* Beryl Joan, Mrs. Wyatt, Gardening Assistant, Writtle College, Chelmsford. For services to Higher Education.\n* Claire Judith, Mrs. Wylot, Grade C1, Ministry of Defence.\n* Councillor Yogan Mylvaganam Yoganathan. For services to Local Government and to Community Relations in North Surrey.\n* Jeannie, Mrs. Young, For voluntary service to St. Richard's Hospice, Worcester.\n* Pauline Margaret, Mrs. Young. For voluntary service to disabled people in Wales.\n* Mavis, Mrs. Yuill, Classroom Assistant, Kilmartin Primary School, Argyll and Bute. For services to Education.",
"Diplomatic and Overseas List\n* [Christopher Barr](/wiki/Christopher_Barr \"Christopher Barr\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Paul William Bellamy](/wiki/Paul_William_Bellamy \"Paul William Bellamy\") – lately Entrance Clearance Manager, British Embassy, Iran.\n* [Steve Chandler](/wiki/Steve_Chandler \"Steve Chandler\") – lately Third Secretary, Counter\\-Narcotics, UK Provincial Reconstruction Team, Lashkar Gah.\n* [Jeanette Anne Coogan](/wiki/Jeanette_Coogan \"Jeanette Coogan\") – Manager, British Council English Training Centre, Al Azhar University in Cairo. For services to UK\\-Egypt intercultural relations.\n* [Rossalyn Demelza Crotty](/wiki/Rossalyn_Crotty \"Rossalyn Crotty\") – Vice\\-Consul/Deputy Head, British Consulate, Málaga, Spain.\n* [Dr. Margaret Cumberland](/wiki/Margaret_Cumberland \"Margaret Cumberland\") – Co\\-ordinator, Community Health. For services to community health care in Mozambique.\n* [Elyse Anne Dodgson](/wiki/Elyse_Dodgson \"Elyse Dodgson\") – Head, International Department, Royal Court Theatre, London. For services to international theatre, and to young writers overseas.\n* [Dr. Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan](/wiki/Alexander_Charles_Weeks_Duncan \"Alexander Charles Weeks Duncan\") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.\n* [Eleanor Frances Duncan](/wiki/Eleanor_Duncan \"Eleanor Duncan\") – Health worker. For services to primary health care in north Afghanistan.\n* [Michael Feeney](/wiki/Michael_Feeney%2C_MBE \"Michael Feeney, MBE\") – Founder, County Mayo Peace Park. For services to UK\\-Ireland relations.\n* [Anne Ferguson](/wiki/Anne_Ferguson_OBE \"Anne Ferguson OBE\") For services to older people in Scotland\n* [Judith Anne Ferris](/wiki/Judith_Ferris \"Judith Ferris\") – lately President, Age Concern, Costa Blanca. For services to the British elderly community in Alicante, Spain.\n* [Wendi Nixon Fiedler](/wiki/Wendi_Fiedler \"Wendi Fiedler\") – Founder and Manager, Panatel Production Company. For services to heritage conservation in Bermuda.\n* [Norman Keith Goodall](/wiki/Norman_Goodall \"Norman Goodall\") – For charitable activities and services to the community in Tenerife, Spain.\n* [Nicholas John Hancocks](/wiki/Nicholas_Hancocks \"Nicholas Hancocks\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Peter Anthony Hibbard](/wiki/Peter_Hibbard \"Peter Hibbard\") – President, Royal Asiatic Society. For services to heritage conservation in Shanghai, China.\n* [Garry Horlacher](/wiki/Garry_Horlacher \"Garry Horlacher\") – Security Co\\-ordinator and Adviser to the Government of Sierra Leone. For services to international policing, and promoting democracy in Sierra Leone.\n* [Victor Malvern Jackopson](/wiki/Victor_Jackopson \"Victor Jackopson\") – Founder and Head, Hope Now. For charitable activities, and services to orphans and other young people in Cherkassy, Ukraine.\n* [Renee Jacqueline Jordan](/wiki/Renee_Jordan \"Renee Jordan\") – Head of Registry, British Embassy Office, Basra.\n* [Mairwen Karydis](/wiki/Mairwen_Karydis \"Mairwen Karydis\") – British Consular Correspondent, Lesvos. For services to consular work in Greece.\n* [Nigel Jeffery Randle Kay](/wiki/Nigel_Kay \"Nigel Kay\") – Founder and Head, Homes in Zimbabwe. For services to the elderly in Zimbabwe.\n* [Christopher Kealey](/wiki/Christopher_Kealey \"Christopher Kealey\") – lately First Secretary Political, British Embassy, Afghanistan.\n* [Paul Lawrence](/wiki/Paul_David_Lawrence \"Paul David Lawrence\") – lately British Vice Consul, Thailand.\n* [Cynthia Albrecht\\-Lelliott](/wiki/Cynthia_Albrecht-Lelliott \"Cynthia Albrecht-Lelliott\") – Honorary Vice\\-President, British Ladies Club. For services to the British community in Luxembourg and UK\\-Luxembourg relations.\n* [Dr. Raymond George\\-MacKay](/wiki/Raymond_George-MacKay \"Raymond George-MacKay\") – Educational Consultant. For services to English teaching, especially in West Bengal, India.\n* Bryan Andrew Morgan – Second Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Hazel Jane Nelder](/wiki/Hazel_Nelder \"Hazel Nelder\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Anthony John Nott](/wiki/Anthony_Nott \"Anthony Nott\") – UK Policing Adviser, Office of the United States Co\\-ordinator, Palestine. For services to international policing, more recently in Iraq and Palestine.\n* [Jean Catherine Pickering](/wiki/Jean_Desforges \"Jean Desforges\") – For services to athletics and to the Ron Pickering Memorial Fund.\n* [Stephen Peter John Schembri](/wiki/Stephen_Schembri \"Stephen Schembri\") – First Secretary, Foreign and Commonwealth Office.\n* [Joanna Wright\\-Serra](/wiki/Joanna_Wright-Serra \"Joanna Wright-Serra\") – Founding member, JUCONI (Juntos con los Ninos—Together with Children). For services to street children and other charitable activities in Mexico.\n* [Keith Shonfeld](/wiki/Keith_Nigel_Shonfeld \"Keith Nigel Shonfeld\") – Cemetery Administrator, British Cemetery Committee – For services to the British community in Cyprus.\n* [Dr. Malcolm Swann](/wiki/Malcolm_Swann \"Malcolm Swann\") – Medical Director, [Beit Cure International Hospital](/wiki/CURE_International \"CURE International\"), Lusaka. For medical services in Zambia.\n* [Peter Dyce Tear](/wiki/Peter_Tear \"Peter Tear\") – Executive Producer, 59E59 Theatres in New York. For services to UK/USA cultural relations.\n* [David Richard Vaughan Thomas](/wiki/David_Richard_Vaughan_Thomas \"David Richard Vaughan Thomas\") – Chairman, British\\-Polish Chamber of Commerce. For services to British business interests and charitable activities in Poland.\n* [Iwona Thomas](/wiki/Iwona_Thomas \"Iwona Thomas\") – Founder and Manager, The British School, Warsaw. For services to education.\n* [Sally Thompson](/wiki/Sally_Thompson \"Sally Thompson\") – Deputy Executive Director, Thailand\\-Burma Border Consortium. For services to Burmese refugees in Thailand.\n* [Kedell Melody Worboys](/wiki/Kedell_Worboys \"Kedell Worboys\") – St. Helena Government Representative in the UK. For services to St. Helena."
] |
Stratigraphy
------------
Since 1935, the Westphalian has been split into four substages, from oldest to youngest: Langsettian (Westphalian A), Duckmantian (Westphalian B), Bolsovian (Westphalian C), and "Asturian" (Westphalian D). These substages are defined by [guide fossils, or "index fossils](/wiki/Index_fossils "Index fossils")," particularly [plant macrofossils](/wiki/Macrofossil "Macrofossil"), [miospores](/wiki/Miospore "Miospore"), and [ammonoids](/wiki/Ammonoidea "Ammonoidea").{{Citation \|last\=Waters \|first\=C.N. \|title\=Definitions of chronostratigraphic subdivisions: geochronology and event stratigraphy \|date\=2011\-07\-13 \|url\=https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/books/book/1774/chapter/107660806 \|work\=A Revised Correlation of Carboniferous Rocks in the British Isles \|pages\=3–10 \|editor\-last\=Waters \|editor\-first\=C.N. \|access\-date\=2023\-10\-09 \|edition\=First \|publisher\=The Geological Society of London \|language\=en \|doi\=10\.1144/sr26\.2 \|isbn\=978\-1\-86239\-694\-4 \|editor2\-last\=Somerville \|editor2\-first\=I.D. \|editor3\-last\=Jones \|editor3\-first\=N.S. \|editor4\-last\=Cleal \|editor4\-first\=C.J.}}{{Citation \|last1\=Waters \|first1\=C.N. \|title\=Biostratigraphy \|date\=2011\-07\-13 \|url\=https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/books/book/1774/chapter/107660861 \|work\=A Revised Correlation of Carboniferous Rocks in the British Isles \|pages\=11–22 \|editor\-last\=Waters \|editor\-first\=C.N. \|access\-date\=2023\-10\-09 \|edition\=First \|publisher\=The Geological Society of London \|language\=en \|doi\=10\.1144/sr26\.3 \|isbn\=978\-1\-86239\-694\-4 \|last2\=Somerville \|first2\=I.D. \|last3\=Stephenson \|first3\=M.H. \|last4\=Cleal \|first4\=C.J. \|last5\=Long \|first5\=S.L. \|editor2\-last\=Somerville \|editor2\-first\=I.D. \|editor3\-last\=Jones \|editor3\-first\=N.S. \|editor4\-last\=Cleal \|editor4\-first\=C.J.}}{{Citation \|last1\=Aretz \|first1\=M. \|title\=The Carboniferous Period \|date\=2020 \|url\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/B9780128243602000231 \|work\=Geologic Time Scale 2020 \|pages\=811–874 \|access\-date\=2023\-10\-09 \|publisher\=Elsevier \|language\=en \|doi\=10\.1016/b978\-0\-12\-824360\-2\.00023\-1 \|isbn\=978\-0\-12\-824360\-2 \|last2\=Herbig \|first2\=H.G. \|last3\=Wang \|first3\=X.D. \|last4\=Gradstein \|first4\=F.M. \|last5\=Agterberg \|first5\=F.P. \|last6\=Ogg \|first6\=J.G.}} The Westphalian exhibits distinctive changes in plant diversity, and many plant macrofossil [assemblage zones](/wiki/Assemblage_Zone "Assemblage Zone") have been defined across an area encompassing Europe, [Turkey](/wiki/Turkey "Turkey"), and the [Maritime Provinces](/wiki/The_Maritimes "The Maritimes") of Canada.{{Cite journal \|last1\=Opluštil \|first1\=Stanislav \|last2\=Cleal \|first2\=Christopher J. \|last3\=Wang \|first3\=Jun \|last4\=Wan \|first4\=Mingli \|date\=2022 \|title\=Carboniferous macrofloral biostratigraphy: an overview \|url\=https://www.lyellcollection.org/doi/10\.1144/SP512\-2020\-97 \|journal\=Geological Society, London, Special Publications \|language\=en \|volume\=512 \|issue\=1 \|pages\=813–863 \|doi\=10\.1144/SP512\-2020\-97 \|bibcode\=2022GSLSP.512\..813O \|issn\=0305\-8719}}
### Langsettian
The **Langsettian**, previously known as **Westphalian A**, is named after the village of [Langsett](/wiki/Langsett "Langsett") in [South Yorkshire](/wiki/South_Yorkshire "South Yorkshire"), England. It marks the base of the Westphalian regional stage, as defined by the ammonoid *[Gastrioceras subcrenatum](/wiki/Gastrioceras "Gastrioceras")*. The base of the Langsettian (and the Westphalian as a whole) has been dated to around 319\.9{{Cite journal \|last1\=Pointon \|first1\=Michael A. \|last2\=Chew \|first2\=David M. \|last3\=Ovtcharova \|first3\=Maria \|last4\=Sevastopulo \|first4\=George D. \|last5\=Crowley \|first5\=Quentin G. \|date\=2012 \|title\=New high\-precision U–Pb dates from western European Carboniferous tuffs; implications for time scale calibration, the periodicity of late Carboniferous cycles and stratigraphical correlation \|url\=https://www.lyellcollection.org/doi/10\.1144/jgs2011\-092 \|journal\=Journal of the Geological Society \|language\=en \|volume\=169 \|issue\=6 \|pages\=713–721 \|doi\=10\.1144/jgs2011\-092 \|bibcode\=2012JGSoc.169\..713P \|issn\=0016\-7649\|hdl\=2262/79149 \|hdl\-access\=free }} or 319\.2 Ma.
The Langsettian corresponds to the *[Calymmotheca ("Lyginopteris") hoeninghausii](/wiki/Calymmotheca "Calymmotheca")* assemblage zone. Many widespread plant species first appear near the base of the Langsettian, indicating a spike of diversification in tropical [coal swamp](/wiki/Coal_forest "Coal forest") habitats.{{Cite journal \|last1\=Molina\-Solís \|first1\=Azucena \|last2\=Cleal \|first2\=Christopher J. \|last3\=Capel \|first3\=Eliott \|last4\=Cascales\-Miñana \|first4\=Borja \|date\=2023 \|title\=Vegetation dynamics in the Early–Middle Pennsylvanian coal swamps of the Nord\-Pas\-de\-Calais Coalfield, France \|url\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1871174X2300046X \|journal\=Palaeoworld \|volume\=33 \|issue\=2 \|pages\=328–340 \|language\=en \|doi\=10\.1016/j.palwor.2023\.04\.005}} Plant diversity steadily increases through the entire Langsettian, though this may be a result of ecological factors such as the receding coastline.
### Duckmantian
The **Duckmantian**, previously known as **Westphalian B**, is named after the village of [Duckmanton](/wiki/Duckmanton "Duckmanton") in [Derbyshire](/wiki/Derbyshire "Derbyshire"), England. The base of the Duckmantian is defined by the ammonoid *[Anthracoceratites vaderbeckei](/wiki/Anthracoceratites "Anthracoceratites")*. The boundary between the global Bashkirian and Moscovian stages (\~315\.2 Ma) corresponds to the mid\-late part of the Duckmantian.
The lower\-middle part of the Duckmantian corresponds to the *[Lonchopteris rugosa](/wiki/Lonchopteris "Lonchopteris")* Assemblage\-zone, the most diverse plant biozone in the Carboniferous coalfields of Europe. The rising diversity trend of the Langsettian continues into this biozone, with few notable changes in species composition. In the majority of European coalfields, plant diversity reached a plateau around halfway through the Duckmantian. Coal swamps became increasingly unstable in the *[Paripteris linguaefolia](/wiki/Paripteris_linguaefolia "Paripteris linguaefolia")* assemblage zone, which begins in the upper part of the Duckmantian.
### Bolsovian
The **Bolsovian**, previously known as **Westphalian C**, is named after the town of [Bolsover](/wiki/Bolsover "Bolsover") in Derbyshire. The base of the Bolsovian is defined by the ammonoid *[Donetzoceras aegiranum](/wiki/Donetzoceras "Donetzoceras")*, and has an estimated age of around 313\.8 or 313\.7{{Cite journal \|last1\=Opluštil \|first1\=Stanislav \|last2\=Schmitz \|first2\=Mark \|last3\=Cleal \|first3\=Christopher J. \|last4\=Martínek \|first4\=Karel \|date\=2016 \|title\=A review of the Middle–Late Pennsylvanian west European regional substages and floral biozones, and their correlation to the Geological Time Scale based on new U–Pb ages \|url\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0012825216300046 \|journal\=Earth\-Science Reviews \|language\=en \|volume\=154 \|pages\=301–335 \|doi\=10\.1016/j.earscirev.2016\.01\.004\|bibcode\=2016ESRv..154\..301O }} Ma.
The *Paripteris linguaefolia* assemblage zone continues into the Bolsovian, and a decline in plant diversity is apparent across the entirety of Europe. In a few coalfields, such as the [Nord\-Pas\-des\-Calais basin](/wiki/Nord-Pas_de_Calais_Mining_Basin "Nord-Pas de Calais Mining Basin") of northern France, the decline is delayed until the mid\-Bolsovian, while in other areas it may begin as early as the late Duckmantian. The overall downward diversity trend is slight, but several notable [lycopsid](/wiki/Lycopsid "Lycopsid") and [sphenopsid](/wiki/Equisetidae "Equisetidae") species disappear from European coal swamps at this time.
### Westphalian D
**Westphalian D** is often referred to as the **Asturian**, named after the [Asturias](/wiki/Asturias "Asturias") region of northwest [Spain](/wiki/Spain "Spain").{{Cite journal \|last1\=Wagner \|first1\=R.H. \|last2\=Sánchez de Posada \|first2\=L.C. \|last3\=Martínez Chacón \|first3\=M.L. \|last4\=Fernández \|first4\=L.P. \|last5\=Villa \|first5\=E. \|last6\=Winkler Prins \|first6\=C.F. \|date\=2002 \|title\=The Asturian Stage: a preliminary proposal for the definition of a substitute for Westphalian D \|journal\=Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, Memoir \|volume\=19 \|pages\=832–850}} In most of Europe, Westphalian D is distinguished by plant fossils. Asturias is one of the few European regions with enough late Westphalian marine fossils to allow for precise correlations with other marine strata. The proposal to fully implement the name "Asturian" has yet to be ratified, as some stratigraphic difficulties in Spain are not fully resolved.{{Cite journal \|last1\=Knight \|first1\=John A. \|last2\=Cleal \|first2\=Christopher J. \|last3\=Álvarez\-Vázquez \|first3\=Carmen \|date\=2023\-06\-14 \|title\=The challenge of relating the Kasimovian to west European chronostratigraphy: a critical review of the Cantabrian and Barruelian substages of the Stephanian Stage \|journal\=Geological Society, London, Special Publications \|language\=en \|volume\=535 \|issue\=1 \|pages\=31–71 \|doi\=10\.1144/SP535\-2022\-189 \|issn\=0305\-8719\|doi\-access\=free \|bibcode\=2023GSLSP.535\..189K }}
The lower part of the Asturian belongs to the *[Linopteris obliqua](/wiki/Linopteris "Linopteris")* assemblage zone (sometimes termed the *[Linopteris bunburii](/wiki/Linopteris "Linopteris")* zone). This biozone is notably lower in diversity than previous Westphalian biozones. Plant fossils are still common over much of Europe, with *[Neuropteris ovata](/wiki/Neuropteris "Neuropteris")* as a particularly abundant species. An important ecological turnover occurs about halfway through the Asturian (\~309 Ma), with the arrival of the *[Crenulopteris acadica](/wiki/Crenulopteris "Crenulopteris")* assemblage zone{{Cite journal \|last1\=Wittry \|first1\=Jack \|last2\=Glasspool \|first2\=Ian J. \|last3\=Béthoux \|first3\=Olivier \|last4\=Koll \|first4\=Rebecca \|last5\=Cleal \|first5\=Christopher J. \|date\=2015\-08\-03 \|title\=A revision of the Pennsylvanian marattialean fern Lobatopteris vestita auct . and related species \|url\=http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10\.1080/14772019\.2014\.936915 \|journal\=Journal of Systematic Palaeontology \|language\=en \|volume\=13 \|issue\=8 \|pages\=615–643 \|doi\=10\.1080/14772019\.2014\.936915 \|bibcode\=2015JSPal..13\..615W \|issn\=1477\-2019}} (previously known as the *[Lobatopteris vestita](/wiki/Lobatopteris "Lobatopteris")* zone). Lycopsid fossils become very rare, while [marattialean](/wiki/Marattiaceae "Marattiaceae") ferns become abundant in coal swamp deposits. Many European coalfields were positioned in a [foreland basin](/wiki/Foreland_basin "Foreland basin") north of the [Variscan orogeny](/wiki/Variscan_orogeny "Variscan orogeny"). As mountain\-building continued, uplift accelerated in the basin, endangering the survival of coal swamp environments.
Plant fossils (and coal deposits as a whole) are uncommon in the following "Cantabrian" substage of the Stephanian Stage. The end of the Asturian is a topic of strong debate; most estimates place the Westphalian\-Stephanian boundary before the start of the Kasimovian global stage (\~307 Ma), whereas a few place the boundary within the Kasimovian. U\-Pb radiometric dating of [tonstein](/wiki/Tonstein "Tonstein") beds in Spain estimate that the Asturian lasted from 310\.7 to 307\.5 Ma, ending just prior to the Kasimovian.
|
[
"Stratigraphy\n------------",
"Since 1935, the Westphalian has been split into four substages, from oldest to youngest: Langsettian (Westphalian A), Duckmantian (Westphalian B), Bolsovian (Westphalian C), and \"Asturian\" (Westphalian D). These substages are defined by [guide fossils, or \"index fossils](/wiki/Index_fossils \"Index fossils\"),\" particularly [plant macrofossils](/wiki/Macrofossil \"Macrofossil\"), [miospores](/wiki/Miospore \"Miospore\"), and [ammonoids](/wiki/Ammonoidea \"Ammonoidea\").{{Citation \\|last\\=Waters \\|first\\=C.N. \\|title\\=Definitions of chronostratigraphic subdivisions: geochronology and event stratigraphy \\|date\\=2011\\-07\\-13 \\|url\\=https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/books/book/1774/chapter/107660806 \\|work\\=A Revised Correlation of Carboniferous Rocks in the British Isles \\|pages\\=3–10 \\|editor\\-last\\=Waters \\|editor\\-first\\=C.N. \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-10\\-09 \\|edition\\=First \\|publisher\\=The Geological Society of London \\|language\\=en \\|doi\\=10\\.1144/sr26\\.2 \\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-86239\\-694\\-4 \\|editor2\\-last\\=Somerville \\|editor2\\-first\\=I.D. \\|editor3\\-last\\=Jones \\|editor3\\-first\\=N.S. \\|editor4\\-last\\=Cleal \\|editor4\\-first\\=C.J.}}{{Citation \\|last1\\=Waters \\|first1\\=C.N. \\|title\\=Biostratigraphy \\|date\\=2011\\-07\\-13 \\|url\\=https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/books/book/1774/chapter/107660861 \\|work\\=A Revised Correlation of Carboniferous Rocks in the British Isles \\|pages\\=11–22 \\|editor\\-last\\=Waters \\|editor\\-first\\=C.N. \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-10\\-09 \\|edition\\=First \\|publisher\\=The Geological Society of London \\|language\\=en \\|doi\\=10\\.1144/sr26\\.3 \\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-86239\\-694\\-4 \\|last2\\=Somerville \\|first2\\=I.D. \\|last3\\=Stephenson \\|first3\\=M.H. \\|last4\\=Cleal \\|first4\\=C.J. \\|last5\\=Long \\|first5\\=S.L. \\|editor2\\-last\\=Somerville \\|editor2\\-first\\=I.D. \\|editor3\\-last\\=Jones \\|editor3\\-first\\=N.S. \\|editor4\\-last\\=Cleal \\|editor4\\-first\\=C.J.}}{{Citation \\|last1\\=Aretz \\|first1\\=M. \\|title\\=The Carboniferous Period \\|date\\=2020 \\|url\\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/B9780128243602000231 \\|work\\=Geologic Time Scale 2020 \\|pages\\=811–874 \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-10\\-09 \\|publisher\\=Elsevier \\|language\\=en \\|doi\\=10\\.1016/b978\\-0\\-12\\-824360\\-2\\.00023\\-1 \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-12\\-824360\\-2 \\|last2\\=Herbig \\|first2\\=H.G. \\|last3\\=Wang \\|first3\\=X.D. \\|last4\\=Gradstein \\|first4\\=F.M. \\|last5\\=Agterberg \\|first5\\=F.P. \\|last6\\=Ogg \\|first6\\=J.G.}} The Westphalian exhibits distinctive changes in plant diversity, and many plant macrofossil [assemblage zones](/wiki/Assemblage_Zone \"Assemblage Zone\") have been defined across an area encompassing Europe, [Turkey](/wiki/Turkey \"Turkey\"), and the [Maritime Provinces](/wiki/The_Maritimes \"The Maritimes\") of Canada.{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Opluštil \\|first1\\=Stanislav \\|last2\\=Cleal \\|first2\\=Christopher J. \\|last3\\=Wang \\|first3\\=Jun \\|last4\\=Wan \\|first4\\=Mingli \\|date\\=2022 \\|title\\=Carboniferous macrofloral biostratigraphy: an overview \\|url\\=https://www.lyellcollection.org/doi/10\\.1144/SP512\\-2020\\-97 \\|journal\\=Geological Society, London, Special Publications \\|language\\=en \\|volume\\=512 \\|issue\\=1 \\|pages\\=813–863 \\|doi\\=10\\.1144/SP512\\-2020\\-97 \\|bibcode\\=2022GSLSP.512\\..813O \\|issn\\=0305\\-8719}}",
"### Langsettian",
"The **Langsettian**, previously known as **Westphalian A**, is named after the village of [Langsett](/wiki/Langsett \"Langsett\") in [South Yorkshire](/wiki/South_Yorkshire \"South Yorkshire\"), England. It marks the base of the Westphalian regional stage, as defined by the ammonoid *[Gastrioceras subcrenatum](/wiki/Gastrioceras \"Gastrioceras\")*. The base of the Langsettian (and the Westphalian as a whole) has been dated to around 319\\.9{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Pointon \\|first1\\=Michael A. \\|last2\\=Chew \\|first2\\=David M. \\|last3\\=Ovtcharova \\|first3\\=Maria \\|last4\\=Sevastopulo \\|first4\\=George D. \\|last5\\=Crowley \\|first5\\=Quentin G. \\|date\\=2012 \\|title\\=New high\\-precision U–Pb dates from western European Carboniferous tuffs; implications for time scale calibration, the periodicity of late Carboniferous cycles and stratigraphical correlation \\|url\\=https://www.lyellcollection.org/doi/10\\.1144/jgs2011\\-092 \\|journal\\=Journal of the Geological Society \\|language\\=en \\|volume\\=169 \\|issue\\=6 \\|pages\\=713–721 \\|doi\\=10\\.1144/jgs2011\\-092 \\|bibcode\\=2012JGSoc.169\\..713P \\|issn\\=0016\\-7649\\|hdl\\=2262/79149 \\|hdl\\-access\\=free }} or 319\\.2 Ma.",
"The Langsettian corresponds to the *[Calymmotheca (\"Lyginopteris\") hoeninghausii](/wiki/Calymmotheca \"Calymmotheca\")* assemblage zone. Many widespread plant species first appear near the base of the Langsettian, indicating a spike of diversification in tropical [coal swamp](/wiki/Coal_forest \"Coal forest\") habitats.{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Molina\\-Solís \\|first1\\=Azucena \\|last2\\=Cleal \\|first2\\=Christopher J. \\|last3\\=Capel \\|first3\\=Eliott \\|last4\\=Cascales\\-Miñana \\|first4\\=Borja \\|date\\=2023 \\|title\\=Vegetation dynamics in the Early–Middle Pennsylvanian coal swamps of the Nord\\-Pas\\-de\\-Calais Coalfield, France \\|url\\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1871174X2300046X \\|journal\\=Palaeoworld \\|volume\\=33 \\|issue\\=2 \\|pages\\=328–340 \\|language\\=en \\|doi\\=10\\.1016/j.palwor.2023\\.04\\.005}} Plant diversity steadily increases through the entire Langsettian, though this may be a result of ecological factors such as the receding coastline.",
"### Duckmantian",
"The **Duckmantian**, previously known as **Westphalian B**, is named after the village of [Duckmanton](/wiki/Duckmanton \"Duckmanton\") in [Derbyshire](/wiki/Derbyshire \"Derbyshire\"), England. The base of the Duckmantian is defined by the ammonoid *[Anthracoceratites vaderbeckei](/wiki/Anthracoceratites \"Anthracoceratites\")*. The boundary between the global Bashkirian and Moscovian stages (\\~315\\.2 Ma) corresponds to the mid\\-late part of the Duckmantian.",
"The lower\\-middle part of the Duckmantian corresponds to the *[Lonchopteris rugosa](/wiki/Lonchopteris \"Lonchopteris\")* Assemblage\\-zone, the most diverse plant biozone in the Carboniferous coalfields of Europe. The rising diversity trend of the Langsettian continues into this biozone, with few notable changes in species composition. In the majority of European coalfields, plant diversity reached a plateau around halfway through the Duckmantian. Coal swamps became increasingly unstable in the *[Paripteris linguaefolia](/wiki/Paripteris_linguaefolia \"Paripteris linguaefolia\")* assemblage zone, which begins in the upper part of the Duckmantian.",
"### Bolsovian",
"The **Bolsovian**, previously known as **Westphalian C**, is named after the town of [Bolsover](/wiki/Bolsover \"Bolsover\") in Derbyshire. The base of the Bolsovian is defined by the ammonoid *[Donetzoceras aegiranum](/wiki/Donetzoceras \"Donetzoceras\")*, and has an estimated age of around 313\\.8 or 313\\.7{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Opluštil \\|first1\\=Stanislav \\|last2\\=Schmitz \\|first2\\=Mark \\|last3\\=Cleal \\|first3\\=Christopher J. \\|last4\\=Martínek \\|first4\\=Karel \\|date\\=2016 \\|title\\=A review of the Middle–Late Pennsylvanian west European regional substages and floral biozones, and their correlation to the Geological Time Scale based on new U–Pb ages \\|url\\=https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0012825216300046 \\|journal\\=Earth\\-Science Reviews \\|language\\=en \\|volume\\=154 \\|pages\\=301–335 \\|doi\\=10\\.1016/j.earscirev.2016\\.01\\.004\\|bibcode\\=2016ESRv..154\\..301O }} Ma.",
"The *Paripteris linguaefolia* assemblage zone continues into the Bolsovian, and a decline in plant diversity is apparent across the entirety of Europe. In a few coalfields, such as the [Nord\\-Pas\\-des\\-Calais basin](/wiki/Nord-Pas_de_Calais_Mining_Basin \"Nord-Pas de Calais Mining Basin\") of northern France, the decline is delayed until the mid\\-Bolsovian, while in other areas it may begin as early as the late Duckmantian. The overall downward diversity trend is slight, but several notable [lycopsid](/wiki/Lycopsid \"Lycopsid\") and [sphenopsid](/wiki/Equisetidae \"Equisetidae\") species disappear from European coal swamps at this time.",
"### Westphalian D",
"**Westphalian D** is often referred to as the **Asturian**, named after the [Asturias](/wiki/Asturias \"Asturias\") region of northwest [Spain](/wiki/Spain \"Spain\").{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Wagner \\|first1\\=R.H. \\|last2\\=Sánchez de Posada \\|first2\\=L.C. \\|last3\\=Martínez Chacón \\|first3\\=M.L. \\|last4\\=Fernández \\|first4\\=L.P. \\|last5\\=Villa \\|first5\\=E. \\|last6\\=Winkler Prins \\|first6\\=C.F. \\|date\\=2002 \\|title\\=The Asturian Stage: a preliminary proposal for the definition of a substitute for Westphalian D \\|journal\\=Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, Memoir \\|volume\\=19 \\|pages\\=832–850}} In most of Europe, Westphalian D is distinguished by plant fossils. Asturias is one of the few European regions with enough late Westphalian marine fossils to allow for precise correlations with other marine strata. The proposal to fully implement the name \"Asturian\" has yet to be ratified, as some stratigraphic difficulties in Spain are not fully resolved.{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Knight \\|first1\\=John A. \\|last2\\=Cleal \\|first2\\=Christopher J. \\|last3\\=Álvarez\\-Vázquez \\|first3\\=Carmen \\|date\\=2023\\-06\\-14 \\|title\\=The challenge of relating the Kasimovian to west European chronostratigraphy: a critical review of the Cantabrian and Barruelian substages of the Stephanian Stage \\|journal\\=Geological Society, London, Special Publications \\|language\\=en \\|volume\\=535 \\|issue\\=1 \\|pages\\=31–71 \\|doi\\=10\\.1144/SP535\\-2022\\-189 \\|issn\\=0305\\-8719\\|doi\\-access\\=free \\|bibcode\\=2023GSLSP.535\\..189K }}",
"The lower part of the Asturian belongs to the *[Linopteris obliqua](/wiki/Linopteris \"Linopteris\")* assemblage zone (sometimes termed the *[Linopteris bunburii](/wiki/Linopteris \"Linopteris\")* zone). This biozone is notably lower in diversity than previous Westphalian biozones. Plant fossils are still common over much of Europe, with *[Neuropteris ovata](/wiki/Neuropteris \"Neuropteris\")* as a particularly abundant species. An important ecological turnover occurs about halfway through the Asturian (\\~309 Ma), with the arrival of the *[Crenulopteris acadica](/wiki/Crenulopteris \"Crenulopteris\")* assemblage zone{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Wittry \\|first1\\=Jack \\|last2\\=Glasspool \\|first2\\=Ian J. \\|last3\\=Béthoux \\|first3\\=Olivier \\|last4\\=Koll \\|first4\\=Rebecca \\|last5\\=Cleal \\|first5\\=Christopher J. \\|date\\=2015\\-08\\-03 \\|title\\=A revision of the Pennsylvanian marattialean fern Lobatopteris vestita auct . and related species \\|url\\=http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10\\.1080/14772019\\.2014\\.936915 \\|journal\\=Journal of Systematic Palaeontology \\|language\\=en \\|volume\\=13 \\|issue\\=8 \\|pages\\=615–643 \\|doi\\=10\\.1080/14772019\\.2014\\.936915 \\|bibcode\\=2015JSPal..13\\..615W \\|issn\\=1477\\-2019}} (previously known as the *[Lobatopteris vestita](/wiki/Lobatopteris \"Lobatopteris\")* zone). Lycopsid fossils become very rare, while [marattialean](/wiki/Marattiaceae \"Marattiaceae\") ferns become abundant in coal swamp deposits. Many European coalfields were positioned in a [foreland basin](/wiki/Foreland_basin \"Foreland basin\") north of the [Variscan orogeny](/wiki/Variscan_orogeny \"Variscan orogeny\"). As mountain\\-building continued, uplift accelerated in the basin, endangering the survival of coal swamp environments.",
"Plant fossils (and coal deposits as a whole) are uncommon in the following \"Cantabrian\" substage of the Stephanian Stage. The end of the Asturian is a topic of strong debate; most estimates place the Westphalian\\-Stephanian boundary before the start of the Kasimovian global stage (\\~307 Ma), whereas a few place the boundary within the Kasimovian. U\\-Pb radiometric dating of [tonstein](/wiki/Tonstein \"Tonstein\") beds in Spain estimate that the Asturian lasted from 310\\.7 to 307\\.5 Ma, ending just prior to the Kasimovian.",
""
] |
History
-------
Medieval [alchemists](/wiki/Alchemy "Alchemy") in the [Czech lands](/wiki/Czech_lands "Czech lands") used obscure and inconsistent terminology to describe their experiments. [Edward Kelley](/wiki/Edward_Kelley "Edward Kelley"), an alchemist at the [court](/wiki/Noble_court "Noble court") of [Rudolf II](/wiki/Rudolf%C2%A0II "Rudolf II"), even invented his own secret language. Growth of the industry in the region during the 19th century, and the nationalistic fervour of the [Czech National Revival](/wiki/Czech_National_Revival "Czech National Revival"), led to the development of Czech terminologies for [natural](/wiki/Natural_science "Natural science") and [applied sciences](/wiki/Applied_science "Applied science").
Jan Svatopluk Presl (1791–1849\), an all\-round natural scientist, proposed a new Czech nomenclature and terminology in the books *Lučba čili chemie zkusná* (1828–1835\) and *Nerostopis* (1837\). Presl had invented Czech neologisms for most of the then known [chemical elements](/wiki/Chemical_element "Chemical element"); ten of these, including {{lang\|cs\|vodík}} {{gloss\|\[\[hydrogen]]}}, {{lang\|cs\|kyslík}} {{gloss\|\[\[oxygen]]}}, {{lang\|cs\|uhlík}} {{gloss\|\[\[carbon]]}}, {{lang\|cs\|dusík}} {{gloss\|\[\[nitrogen]]}} and {{lang\|cs\|křemík}} {{gloss\|\[\[silicon]]}}, have entered the language.{{cite web\|url\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/tabulka.html\|title\=Czech names for chemical elements by Presl and Amerling\|language\=Czech\|accessdate\=2007\-12\-08}} Presl also created naming conventions for [oxides](/wiki/Oxides "Oxides"), in which the electronegative component of the compound became the [noun](/wiki/Noun "Noun") and the electropositive component became an [adjective](/wiki/Adjective "Adjective"). The adjectives were associated with a suffix, according to the [valence number](/wiki/Valence_%28chemistry%29 "Valence (chemistry)") of the component they represented. Originally there were five suffixes: {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ný}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-natý}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-itý}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ový}}}}, and {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-elý}}}}. These were later expanded to eight by [Vojtěch Šafařík](/wiki/Vojt%C4%9Bch_%C5%A0afa%C5%99%C3%ADk "Vojtěch Šafařík"): {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ný}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-natý}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-itý}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ičitý}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ičný}}}} and {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ečný}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ový}}}}, {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-istý}}}}, and {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-ičelý}}}}, representing oxidation numbers from 1 to 8\. For example, {{lang\|cs\|železnatý}} corresponds to {{gloss\|ferrous}} and {{lang\|cs\|železitý}} to {{gloss\|ferric}}.
[Salts](/wiki/Salt_%28chemistry%29 "Salt (chemistry)") were identified by the suffix {{nowrap\|{{lang\|cs\|\-an}}}} added to the noun. Many of the terms created by Presl derive from [Latin](/wiki/Latin "Latin"), [German](/wiki/German_language "German language") or [Russian](/wiki/Russian_language "Russian language"); only some were retained in use.
A similar attempt published in *Orbis pictus* (1852\) by [Karel Slavoj Amerling](/wiki/Karel_Slavoj_Amerling "Karel Slavoj Amerling") (1807–1884\) to create Czech names for the chemical elements (and to order the elements into a structure, similar to the work of Russian chemist [Nikolay Beketov](/wiki/Nikolay_Beketov "Nikolay Beketov")) was not successful.{{cite web\|url\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/mluna.html\|title\=Amerling's line of elements\|language\=Czech}}
Later work on the nomenclature was performed by [Vojtěch Šafařík](/wiki/Vojt%C4%9Bch_%C5%A0afa%C5%99%C3%ADk "Vojtěch Šafařík") (1829–1902\). In 1876 Šafařík started to publish the journal *Listy chemické*, the first chemistry journal in [Austria\-Hungary](/wiki/Austria-Hungary "Austria-Hungary") (today issued under the name *[Chemické Listy](/wiki/Chemick%C3%A9_Listy "Chemické Listy")*), and this journal has played an important role in the codification of the nomenclature and terminology. During a congress of Czech chemists in 1914, the nomenclature was reworked, and the new system became normative in 1918\. [Alexandr Sommer\-Batěk](/wiki/Alexandr_Sommer-Bat%C4%9Bk "Alexandr Sommer-Batěk") (1874–1944\) and [Emil Votoček](/wiki/Emil_Voto%C4%8Dek "Emil Votoček") (1872–1950\) were the major proponents of this change. Presl's original conventions remained in use, but formed only a small part of the naming system.
Several changes were applied to the basic terminology during the second half of the 20th century, usually moving closer to the international nomenclature. For example, the former term {{lang\|cs\|kysličník}} {{gloss\|\[\[oxide]]}} was officially replaced by {{lang\|cs\|oxid}}, {{lang\|cs\|uhlovodan}} {{gloss\|\[\[carbohydrate]]}} by {{lang\|cs\|sacharid}} and later even {{lang\|cs\|karbohydrát}}.{{Citation needed\|date\=November 2014}} The spelling of some chemical elements also changed: {{lang\|cs\|berylium}} {{gloss\|\[\[beryllium]]}} should now be written {{lang\|cs\|beryllium}}.{{cite web\|url\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/tabulka3\.html\|title\=Comparison between the names of chemical elements in 1946 and today\|language\=Czech}} Adoption of these changes by the Czech public has been quite slow, and the older terms are still used decades later.
The [Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences](/wiki/Czechoslovak_Academy_of_Sciences "Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences"), founded in 1953, took over responsibility for maintenance of the nomenclature and proper implementation of the IUPAC recommendations. Since the [Velvet Revolution](/wiki/Velvet_Revolution "Velvet Revolution") (1989\) this activity has slowed down considerably.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"Medieval [alchemists](/wiki/Alchemy \"Alchemy\") in the [Czech lands](/wiki/Czech_lands \"Czech lands\") used obscure and inconsistent terminology to describe their experiments. [Edward Kelley](/wiki/Edward_Kelley \"Edward Kelley\"), an alchemist at the [court](/wiki/Noble_court \"Noble court\") of [Rudolf II](/wiki/Rudolf%C2%A0II \"Rudolf II\"), even invented his own secret language. Growth of the industry in the region during the 19th century, and the nationalistic fervour of the [Czech National Revival](/wiki/Czech_National_Revival \"Czech National Revival\"), led to the development of Czech terminologies for [natural](/wiki/Natural_science \"Natural science\") and [applied sciences](/wiki/Applied_science \"Applied science\").",
"Jan Svatopluk Presl (1791–1849\\), an all\\-round natural scientist, proposed a new Czech nomenclature and terminology in the books *Lučba čili chemie zkusná* (1828–1835\\) and *Nerostopis* (1837\\). Presl had invented Czech neologisms for most of the then known [chemical elements](/wiki/Chemical_element \"Chemical element\"); ten of these, including {{lang\\|cs\\|vodík}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[hydrogen]]}}, {{lang\\|cs\\|kyslík}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[oxygen]]}}, {{lang\\|cs\\|uhlík}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[carbon]]}}, {{lang\\|cs\\|dusík}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[nitrogen]]}} and {{lang\\|cs\\|křemík}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[silicon]]}}, have entered the language.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/tabulka.html\\|title\\=Czech names for chemical elements by Presl and Amerling\\|language\\=Czech\\|accessdate\\=2007\\-12\\-08}} Presl also created naming conventions for [oxides](/wiki/Oxides \"Oxides\"), in which the electronegative component of the compound became the [noun](/wiki/Noun \"Noun\") and the electropositive component became an [adjective](/wiki/Adjective \"Adjective\"). The adjectives were associated with a suffix, according to the [valence number](/wiki/Valence_%28chemistry%29 \"Valence (chemistry)\") of the component they represented. Originally there were five suffixes: {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ný}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-natý}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-itý}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ový}}}}, and {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-elý}}}}. These were later expanded to eight by [Vojtěch Šafařík](/wiki/Vojt%C4%9Bch_%C5%A0afa%C5%99%C3%ADk \"Vojtěch Šafařík\"): {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ný}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-natý}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-itý}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ičitý}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ičný}}}} and {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ečný}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ový}}}}, {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-istý}}}}, and {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-ičelý}}}}, representing oxidation numbers from 1 to 8\\. For example, {{lang\\|cs\\|železnatý}} corresponds to {{gloss\\|ferrous}} and {{lang\\|cs\\|železitý}} to {{gloss\\|ferric}}.",
"[Salts](/wiki/Salt_%28chemistry%29 \"Salt (chemistry)\") were identified by the suffix {{nowrap\\|{{lang\\|cs\\|\\-an}}}} added to the noun. Many of the terms created by Presl derive from [Latin](/wiki/Latin \"Latin\"), [German](/wiki/German_language \"German language\") or [Russian](/wiki/Russian_language \"Russian language\"); only some were retained in use.",
"A similar attempt published in *Orbis pictus* (1852\\) by [Karel Slavoj Amerling](/wiki/Karel_Slavoj_Amerling \"Karel Slavoj Amerling\") (1807–1884\\) to create Czech names for the chemical elements (and to order the elements into a structure, similar to the work of Russian chemist [Nikolay Beketov](/wiki/Nikolay_Beketov \"Nikolay Beketov\")) was not successful.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/mluna.html\\|title\\=Amerling's line of elements\\|language\\=Czech}}",
"Later work on the nomenclature was performed by [Vojtěch Šafařík](/wiki/Vojt%C4%9Bch_%C5%A0afa%C5%99%C3%ADk \"Vojtěch Šafařík\") (1829–1902\\). In 1876 Šafařík started to publish the journal *Listy chemické*, the first chemistry journal in [Austria\\-Hungary](/wiki/Austria-Hungary \"Austria-Hungary\") (today issued under the name *[Chemické Listy](/wiki/Chemick%C3%A9_Listy \"Chemické Listy\")*), and this journal has played an important role in the codification of the nomenclature and terminology. During a congress of Czech chemists in 1914, the nomenclature was reworked, and the new system became normative in 1918\\. [Alexandr Sommer\\-Batěk](/wiki/Alexandr_Sommer-Bat%C4%9Bk \"Alexandr Sommer-Batěk\") (1874–1944\\) and [Emil Votoček](/wiki/Emil_Voto%C4%8Dek \"Emil Votoček\") (1872–1950\\) were the major proponents of this change. Presl's original conventions remained in use, but formed only a small part of the naming system.",
"Several changes were applied to the basic terminology during the second half of the 20th century, usually moving closer to the international nomenclature. For example, the former term {{lang\\|cs\\|kysličník}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[oxide]]}} was officially replaced by {{lang\\|cs\\|oxid}}, {{lang\\|cs\\|uhlovodan}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[carbohydrate]]}} by {{lang\\|cs\\|sacharid}} and later even {{lang\\|cs\\|karbohydrát}}.{{Citation needed\\|date\\=November 2014}} The spelling of some chemical elements also changed: {{lang\\|cs\\|berylium}} {{gloss\\|\\[\\[beryllium]]}} should now be written {{lang\\|cs\\|beryllium}}.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://canov.jergym.cz/objevite/objevite/tabulka3\\.html\\|title\\=Comparison between the names of chemical elements in 1946 and today\\|language\\=Czech}} Adoption of these changes by the Czech public has been quite slow, and the older terms are still used decades later.",
"The [Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences](/wiki/Czechoslovak_Academy_of_Sciences \"Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences\"), founded in 1953, took over responsibility for maintenance of the nomenclature and proper implementation of the IUPAC recommendations. Since the [Velvet Revolution](/wiki/Velvet_Revolution \"Velvet Revolution\") (1989\\) this activity has slowed down considerably.",
""
] |
Professional career
-------------------
### Chicago Cubs
Godley attended [Bamberg\-Ehrhardt High School](/wiki/Bamberg-Ehrhardt_High_School "Bamberg-Ehrhardt High School"). In 2009, as a senior, he went 9–3 with a 2\.24 ERA.{{Cite web\|url\=https://thetandd.com/sports/b\-es\-godley\-sandifer\-share\-t\-ds\-2009\-baseball\-player\-of\-the\-year\-honor/article\_ae25e98b\-019f\-5c7e\-8bb9\-beee80cd87a6\.html\|title\=B\-E's Godley, Sandifer share T\&D's 2009 Baseball Player of the Year honor\|first\=EMERY GLOVER, T\&D Sports\|last\=Writer\|website\=The Times and Democrat\|date\=10 July 2009 }} He was drafted by the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets "New York Mets") in the 50th round of the [2009 MLB draft](/wiki/2009_MLB_draft "2009 MLB draft") but did not sign and instead enrolled at [Spartanburg Methodist College](/wiki/Spartanburg_Methodist_College "Spartanburg Methodist College") where he played [college baseball](/wiki/College_baseball "College baseball"). After his freshman season, he transferred to the [University of Tennessee](/wiki/University_of_Tennessee "University of Tennessee").{{Cite web\|url\=https://thetandd.com/sports/b\-e\-star\-godley\-selected\-by\-mets/article\_ad3dd0e0\-cfed\-50a4\-8baf\-284c813d699f.html\|title\=B\-E star Godley selected by Mets\|first\=THOMAS GRANT JR T\&D Senior Sports\|last\=Writer\|website\=The Times and Democrat\|date\=12 June 2009 }} In 2013, his senior year, he went 5–7 with a 3\.49 ERA in 16 games (14 starts). After the season, he was then drafted by the [Chicago Cubs](/wiki/Chicago_Cubs "Chicago Cubs") in the 10th round of the [2013 MLB draft](/wiki/2013_MLB_draft "2013 MLB draft") and signed.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.knoxnews.com/govolsxtra/other\-sports/tennessee\-pitcher\-zack\-goldey\-drafted\-chicago\-cubs\|title\=Chicago Cubs draft Tennessee pitcher Zack Godley in 10th round}}
Godley signed and made his professional debut that season with the [AZL Cubs](/wiki/AZL_Cubs "AZL Cubs") and was promoted to the [Boise Hawks](/wiki/Boise_Hawks "Boise Hawks") after one game. In 13 relief appearances for Boise he compiled a 2–0 record and 2\.03 ERA. Godley spent 2014 with the [Kane County Cougars](/wiki/Kane_County_Cougars "Kane County Cougars") and [Daytona Cubs](/wiki/Daytona_Cubs "Daytona Cubs"), pitching to a combined 4–3 record and 3\.09 ERA in 55\.1 relief innings pitched.
### Arizona Diamondbacks
On December 9, 2014, Godley, along with Jeferson Mejia, was traded to the [Arizona Diamondbacks](/wiki/Arizona_Diamondbacks "Arizona Diamondbacks") for [Miguel Montero](/wiki/Miguel_Montero "Miguel Montero").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlb.com/news/d\-backs\-get\-pair\-of\-cubs\-pitching\-prospects\-for\-miguel\-montero/c\-103577034\|title\=D\-backs get 2 pitching prospects for Montero\|website\=MLB.com\|date\=9 December 2014 }} He began 2015 with [Visalia Rawhide](/wiki/Visalia_Rawhide "Visalia Rawhide") and was promoted to the [Mobile BayBears](/wiki/Mobile_BayBears "Mobile BayBears") in June.
Godley made his MLB debut on July 23, 2015, against the [Milwaukee Brewers](/wiki/Milwaukee_Brewers "Milwaukee Brewers").{{Cite web\|url\=http://arizonasports.com/42/1851898/Dbacks\-CBO\-Tony\-La\-Russa\-announces\-Zack\-Godley\-will\-get\-start\-Thursday\-vs\-Milwaukee\|title\=D\-backs' CBO Tony La Russa announces Zack Godley will get start Thursday vs. Milwaukee}} He threw six scoreless innings, striking out seven and walking none as he earned the win as Arizona defeated Milwaukee, 8–3\. He became the first pitcher since 1900 with 6\-plus scoreless innings, no walks and 7 or more strikeouts in his MLB debut.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.azcentral.com/story/sports/mlb/diamondbacks/2015/07/24/arizona\-diamondbacks\-zack\-godley\-stymies\-brewers\-mlb/30606971/\|title\=Arizona Diamondbacks rookie pitcher Zack Godley impresses in MLB debut\|first\=Zach\|last\=Buchanan\|website\=The Arizona Republic}} Godley was recalled and demoted multiple times during the 2015 season after his debut. In nine games (six starts) for Arizona he was 5–1 with a 3\.19 ERA, and in 21 games (17 starts) between Visalia and Mobile, he was 10–4 with a 2\.71 ERA.
Godley began 2016 with Mobile and was promoted to the [Reno Aces](/wiki/Reno_Aces "Reno Aces") in May. He was recalled and demoted twice before being called up for the remainder of the season in July. In 15 games (14 starts) between Mobile and Reno he pitched to a 4–6 record and 3\.62 ERA, and in 27 games for Arizona, he compiled a 5–4 record and 6\.39 ERA.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.milb.com/player/index.jsp?player\_id\=643327\#/career/R/pitching/2018/ALL\|title\=Zack Godley Stats, Highlights, Bio – MiLB.com Stats – The Official Site of Minor League Baseball\|publisher\=MiLB.com\|access\-date\=January 28, 2018}}
In 2017, Godley began the season back with Reno. He was recalled in June and spent the rest of 2017 with Arizona. In 26 games (25 starts) for the Diamondbacks he was 8–9 with a 3\.37 ERA.
Godley began the 2018 season with Arizona as a member of the starting rotation. He finished the season with a 15–11 record in 33 games (32 starts), with a 4\.74 ERA. He struck out 185 batters in {{frac\|178\|1\|3}} innings. He led the major leagues in [wild pitches](/wiki/Wild_pitch "Wild pitch"), with 17\.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos\=all\&stats\=pit≶\=all\&qual\=10\&type\=0\&season\=2018\&month\=0\&season1\=2018\&ind\=0\&team\=0\&rost\=0\&age\=0\&filter\=\&players\=0\&sort\=22,d\|title\=Major League Leaderboards » 2018 » Pitchers » Standard Statistics \| FanGraphs Baseball\|website\=www.fangraphs.com}} He also led all major league pitchers in [curveball](/wiki/Curveball "Curveball") percentage (40\.3%).{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos\=all\&stats\=pit≶\=all\&qual\=y\&type\=4\&season\=2018\&month\=0\&season1\=2018\&ind\=0\&team\=0\&rost\=0\&age\=0\&filter\=\&players\=0\&sort\=9,d\|title\=Major League Leaderboards » 2018 » Pitchers » Pitch Type Statistics \| FanGraphs Baseball\|website\=www.fangraphs.com}}
During the 2019 season, Godley appeared in 27 games for Arizona (nine starts), compiling a 3–5 record with 6\.39 ERA in 76 innings pitched. On August 5, Godley was [designated for assignment](/wiki/Designated_for_assignment "Designated for assignment").{{cite web\|url\=https://www.mlb.com/news/zack\-godley\-dfa\-d\-backs\-call\-up\-kevin\-ginkel\|title\=D\-backs DFA Godley, call up Ginkel\|author\=Steve Gilbert\|work\=\[\[MLB.com]]\|date\=August 5, 2019\|access\-date\=August 5, 2019}}{{cite news \|first\=Hunter \|last\=Hippel \|title\= Derrick Hall says Godley DFA sends a message to D\-backs \|url\= https://arizonasports.com/story/2038529/hall\-discusses\-godleys\-dfa\-impact\-on\-dbacks/ \|publisher\= Arizona Sports 98\.7FM \|date\= 8 August 2019 \|access\-date\=19 January 2021}}
### Toronto Blue Jays
The [Toronto Blue Jays](/wiki/Toronto_Blue_Jays "Toronto Blue Jays") claimed Godley off waivers on August 7, 2019\.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/report\-blue\-jays\-claim\-pitcher\-zack\-godley\-off\-waivers\-diamondbacks/ \|title\=Blue Jays claim pitcher Zack Godley off waivers from Diamondbacks \|date\=August 7, 2019 \|access\-date\=August 7, 2019 \|work\=sportsnet.ca}} He appeared in six games for the Blue Jays, recording one win and registering a 3\.94 ERA in 16 innings pitched. On September 3, Godley was designated for assignment. He elected free agency on September 8\.
### Detroit Tigers
On December 20, 2019, the [Detroit Tigers](/wiki/Detroit_Tigers "Detroit Tigers") signed Godley to a minor league contract with an invitation to spring training.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/\_/id/28342103/zack\-godley\-tigers\-agree\-minor\-league\-deal\|title\=Godley, Tigers agree to minor league deal\|date\=2019\-12\-20\|website\=ESPN.com\|language\=en\|access\-date\=2019\-12\-21}} In March 2020, Godley was released, then re\-signed by the Tigers on a minor league pact. On July 13, 2020, Godley was again released by the Tigers.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.freep.com/story/sports/mlb/tigers/2020/07/13/detroit\-tigers\-release\-zack\-godley/5430052002/ \|title\=Detroit Tigers release right\-hander Zack Godley, give him time to find new team \|newspaper\=\[\[Detroit Free Press]] \|first\=Evan \|last\=Petzold \|date\=July 13, 2020 \|access\-date\=July 13, 2020}}
### Boston Red Sox
On July 17, 2020, Godley signed a minor league deal with the [Boston Red Sox](/wiki/Boston_Red_Sox "Boston Red Sox").{{cite news \|url\=https://www.bostonglobe.com/2020/07/17/sports/chaim\-bloom\-navigating\-uncharted\-waters\-while\-evaluating\-unsettled\-red\-sox\-pitching\-situation/ \|title\=Chaim Bloom navigating uncharted waters while evaluating 'unsettled' Red Sox pitching situation \|first\=Alex \|last\=Speier \|quote\=On Friday, the team announced the signing of righthander Zack Godley — recently released by the Tigers — to a minor league deal. \|website\=\[\[The Boston Globe]] \|url\-access\=limited \|date\=July 17, 2020 \|access\-date\=July 17, 2020}} He was added to the team's active roster on July 26,{{cite web \|url\=https://www.mlb.com/redsox/roster/transactions/2020/07 \|title\=Red Sox Roster \& Staff – Transactions \|website\=\[\[MLB.com]] \|date\=July 2020 \|access\-date\=July 26, 2020}} and made his first appearance with Boston the next day, pitching four innings of scoreless relief in a 7–4 loss to the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets "New York Mets").{{cite web \|url\=https://www.espn.com/mlb/boxscore?gameId\=401225719 \|title\=Mets vs. Red Sox \|website\=ESPN.com \|date\=July 27, 2020 \|access\-date\=July 27, 2020}} He was placed on the 10\-day [injured list](/wiki/Injured_list "Injured list") on September 10, and moved to the 45\-day injured list on September 19\.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.mlb.com/redsox/roster/transactions/2020/09 \|title\=Red Sox Roster \& Staff – Transactions \|website\=\[\[MLB.com]] \|date\=September 2020 \|access\-date\=September 19, 2020}} Overall with the [2020 Red Sox](/wiki/2020_Boston_Red_Sox_season "2020 Boston Red Sox season"), Godley appeared in eight games (seven starts), compiling an 0–4 record with 8\.16 ERA and 28 strikeouts in {{frac\|28\|2\|3}} innings.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.baseball\-reference.com/players/g/godleza01\.shtml \|title\=Zack Godley Stats \|website\=\[\[Baseball\-Reference.com]] \|access\-date\=September 19, 2020}} On October 26, Godley was outrighted off of the 40\-man roster and elected free agency.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2020/10/red\-sox\-outright\-5\-players.html \|title\=Red Sox Outright 5 Players \|first\=Connor \|last\=Byrne \|website\=mlbtraderumors.com \|date\=October 26, 2020 \|access\-date\=October 26, 2020}}
### Milwaukee Brewers
On March 19, 2021, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Milwaukee Brewers](/wiki/Milwaukee_Brewers "Milwaukee Brewers") organization.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/03/brewers\-sign\-zack\-godley\-to\-minor\-league\-deal.html\|title\=Brewers Sign Zack Godley To Minor League Deal\|website\=MLB Trade Rumors\|date\=19 March 2021 }} On April 28, 2021, Godley was selected to the active roster to be the starting pitcher in the Brewers’ game against the [Miami Marlins](/wiki/Miami_Marlins "Miami Marlins") and allowed 3 earned runs in 3\.0 innings, taking the loss.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/04/brewers\-designate\-phil\-bickford\-for\-assignment.html\|title\=Brewers Designate Phil Bickford For Assignment\|website\=MLB Trade Rumors\|date\=28 April 2021 }}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/04/brewers\-to\-select\-zack\-godley.html\|title\=Brewers To Select Zack Godley\|website\=MLB Trade Rumors\|date\=27 April 2021 }} The next day, he was placed on the injured list with a right index finger contusion. On May 10, Godley was activated from the injured list and designated for assignment.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/05/brewers\-designate\-zack\-godley\-for\-assignment.html\|title\=Zack Godley Accepts Outright Assignment With Brewers\|website\=MLB Trade Rumors\|date\=14 May 2021 }} He cleared outright waivers on May 12 and was assigned outright to Triple\-A.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/05/brewers\-notes\-burnes\-yelich\-godley.html\|title\=Brewers Notes: Burnes, Yelich, Godley\|website\=MLB Trade Rumors\|date\=12 May 2021 }} On June 18, Godley was re\-selected to the active roster.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/brewers\-activate\-kolten\-wong\-select\-zack\-godley.html\|title \= Brewers Activate Kolten Wong, Select Zack Godley\| date\=18 June 2021 }} After allowing 3 earned runs in a third of an inning, Godley was again designated for assignment on June 21\.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/brewers\-dfa\-zack\-godley.html\|title \= Brewers DFA Zack Godley\| date\=21 June 2021 }} He was outrighted to the Triple\-A [Nashville Sounds](/wiki/Nashville_Sounds "Nashville Sounds") on June 24\.{{cite web\| url \= http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/transactions/\#month\=6\&year\=2021\| title \= Major League Baseball Transactions {{!}} MLB.com}} However, Godley rejected the outright assignment and elected free agency the next day.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/zack\-godley\-elects\-free\-agency\-brewers.html\|title \= Zack Godley Elects Free Agency\| date\=25 June 2021 }}
### Cleveland Indians
On June 28, 2021, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Cleveland Indians](/wiki/Cleveland_Indians "Cleveland Indians") organization and was assigned to the [Columbus Clippers](/wiki/Columbus_Clippers "Columbus Clippers") of the [Triple\-A East](/wiki/Triple-A_East "Triple-A East").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/indians\-to\-sign\-zack\-godley.html\|title \= Indians to Sign Zack Godley\| date\=28 June 2021 }} Godley was released by the Indians on August 2, 2021\.
### New York Mets
On August 7, 2021, Godley signed a minor league deal with the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets "New York Mets").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/08/mets\-sign\-zack\-godley\-to\-minors\-deal.html\|title \= Mets Sign Zack Godley to Minors Deal\| date\=7 August 2021 }} Godley made 4 starts for the Triple\-A [Syracuse Mets](/wiki/Syracuse_Mets "Syracuse Mets"), going 2–0 with a 2\.33 ERA and 17 strikeouts. On August 30, Godley was granted his release by the Mets.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/08/mets\-release\-zack\-godley.html\|title \= Mets Release Zack Godley\| date\=30 August 2021 }}
### Cincinnati Reds
On February 21, 2022, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Cincinnati Reds](/wiki/Cincinnati_Reds "Cincinnati Reds").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2022/02/reds\-sign\-zack\-godley.html\|title \= Reds Sign Zack Godley to Minor League Deal\| date\=21 February 2022 }} In 14 games for the Triple–A [Louisville Bats](/wiki/Louisville_Bats "Louisville Bats"), he struggled to an 8\.06 ERA with 29 strikeouts across {{fraction\|22\|1\|3}} innings pitched. On May 26, Godley was released by the Reds organization.{{cite web \| url\=https://www.milb.com/player/zack\-godley\-643327 \| title\=Zack Godley Stats, Fantasy \& News }}
### Gastonia Honey Hunters
On June 7, 2022, Godley signed with the [Gastonia Honey Hunters](/wiki/Gastonia_Honey_Hunters "Gastonia Honey Hunters") of the [Atlantic League of Professional Baseball](/wiki/Atlantic_League_of_Professional_Baseball "Atlantic League of Professional Baseball"). In 15 games (11 starts) for Gastonia, he recorded a 4\.64 ERA with 64 strikeouts in {{fraction\|54\|1\|3}} innings. Godley became a free agent following the season.
On April 19, 2023, Godley re\-signed with the Honey Hunters for the 2023 season. In 13 starts for Gastonia, he registered a 5–3 record and 4\.79 ERA with 86 strikeouts in {{fraction\|71\|1\|3}} innings pitched.
### Oakland Athletics
On July 18, 2023, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Oakland Athletics](/wiki/Oakland_Athletics "Oakland Athletics") organization.{{Cite web\|title\=Athletics' Zack Godley: Gets minors deal from A's\|url\=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/athletics\-zack\-godley\-gets\-minors\-deal\-from\-as/\|access\-date\=July 19, 2023\|website\=cbssports.com\|language\=en}} He made 12 appearances (10 starts) for the Triple–A [Las Vegas Aviators](/wiki/Las_Vegas_Aviators "Las Vegas Aviators"), registering a 5\.21 ERA with 57 strikeouts across 57 innings of work. Godley elected free agency following the season on November 6\.{{Cite web\|title\=2023 MiLB Free Agents\|url\=https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/2023\-milb\-free\-agents/\|access\-date\=May 23, 2024\|website\=baseballamerica.com\|language\=en}}
|
[
"Professional career\n-------------------",
"### Chicago Cubs",
"Godley attended [Bamberg\\-Ehrhardt High School](/wiki/Bamberg-Ehrhardt_High_School \"Bamberg-Ehrhardt High School\"). In 2009, as a senior, he went 9–3 with a 2\\.24 ERA.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://thetandd.com/sports/b\\-es\\-godley\\-sandifer\\-share\\-t\\-ds\\-2009\\-baseball\\-player\\-of\\-the\\-year\\-honor/article\\_ae25e98b\\-019f\\-5c7e\\-8bb9\\-beee80cd87a6\\.html\\|title\\=B\\-E's Godley, Sandifer share T\\&D's 2009 Baseball Player of the Year honor\\|first\\=EMERY GLOVER, T\\&D Sports\\|last\\=Writer\\|website\\=The Times and Democrat\\|date\\=10 July 2009 }} He was drafted by the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets \"New York Mets\") in the 50th round of the [2009 MLB draft](/wiki/2009_MLB_draft \"2009 MLB draft\") but did not sign and instead enrolled at [Spartanburg Methodist College](/wiki/Spartanburg_Methodist_College \"Spartanburg Methodist College\") where he played [college baseball](/wiki/College_baseball \"College baseball\"). After his freshman season, he transferred to the [University of Tennessee](/wiki/University_of_Tennessee \"University of Tennessee\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://thetandd.com/sports/b\\-e\\-star\\-godley\\-selected\\-by\\-mets/article\\_ad3dd0e0\\-cfed\\-50a4\\-8baf\\-284c813d699f.html\\|title\\=B\\-E star Godley selected by Mets\\|first\\=THOMAS GRANT JR T\\&D Senior Sports\\|last\\=Writer\\|website\\=The Times and Democrat\\|date\\=12 June 2009 }} In 2013, his senior year, he went 5–7 with a 3\\.49 ERA in 16 games (14 starts). After the season, he was then drafted by the [Chicago Cubs](/wiki/Chicago_Cubs \"Chicago Cubs\") in the 10th round of the [2013 MLB draft](/wiki/2013_MLB_draft \"2013 MLB draft\") and signed.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.knoxnews.com/govolsxtra/other\\-sports/tennessee\\-pitcher\\-zack\\-goldey\\-drafted\\-chicago\\-cubs\\|title\\=Chicago Cubs draft Tennessee pitcher Zack Godley in 10th round}}",
"Godley signed and made his professional debut that season with the [AZL Cubs](/wiki/AZL_Cubs \"AZL Cubs\") and was promoted to the [Boise Hawks](/wiki/Boise_Hawks \"Boise Hawks\") after one game. In 13 relief appearances for Boise he compiled a 2–0 record and 2\\.03 ERA. Godley spent 2014 with the [Kane County Cougars](/wiki/Kane_County_Cougars \"Kane County Cougars\") and [Daytona Cubs](/wiki/Daytona_Cubs \"Daytona Cubs\"), pitching to a combined 4–3 record and 3\\.09 ERA in 55\\.1 relief innings pitched.",
"### Arizona Diamondbacks",
"On December 9, 2014, Godley, along with Jeferson Mejia, was traded to the [Arizona Diamondbacks](/wiki/Arizona_Diamondbacks \"Arizona Diamondbacks\") for [Miguel Montero](/wiki/Miguel_Montero \"Miguel Montero\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlb.com/news/d\\-backs\\-get\\-pair\\-of\\-cubs\\-pitching\\-prospects\\-for\\-miguel\\-montero/c\\-103577034\\|title\\=D\\-backs get 2 pitching prospects for Montero\\|website\\=MLB.com\\|date\\=9 December 2014 }} He began 2015 with [Visalia Rawhide](/wiki/Visalia_Rawhide \"Visalia Rawhide\") and was promoted to the [Mobile BayBears](/wiki/Mobile_BayBears \"Mobile BayBears\") in June.",
"Godley made his MLB debut on July 23, 2015, against the [Milwaukee Brewers](/wiki/Milwaukee_Brewers \"Milwaukee Brewers\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://arizonasports.com/42/1851898/Dbacks\\-CBO\\-Tony\\-La\\-Russa\\-announces\\-Zack\\-Godley\\-will\\-get\\-start\\-Thursday\\-vs\\-Milwaukee\\|title\\=D\\-backs' CBO Tony La Russa announces Zack Godley will get start Thursday vs. Milwaukee}} He threw six scoreless innings, striking out seven and walking none as he earned the win as Arizona defeated Milwaukee, 8–3\\. He became the first pitcher since 1900 with 6\\-plus scoreless innings, no walks and 7 or more strikeouts in his MLB debut.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.azcentral.com/story/sports/mlb/diamondbacks/2015/07/24/arizona\\-diamondbacks\\-zack\\-godley\\-stymies\\-brewers\\-mlb/30606971/\\|title\\=Arizona Diamondbacks rookie pitcher Zack Godley impresses in MLB debut\\|first\\=Zach\\|last\\=Buchanan\\|website\\=The Arizona Republic}} Godley was recalled and demoted multiple times during the 2015 season after his debut. In nine games (six starts) for Arizona he was 5–1 with a 3\\.19 ERA, and in 21 games (17 starts) between Visalia and Mobile, he was 10–4 with a 2\\.71 ERA.",
"Godley began 2016 with Mobile and was promoted to the [Reno Aces](/wiki/Reno_Aces \"Reno Aces\") in May. He was recalled and demoted twice before being called up for the remainder of the season in July. In 15 games (14 starts) between Mobile and Reno he pitched to a 4–6 record and 3\\.62 ERA, and in 27 games for Arizona, he compiled a 5–4 record and 6\\.39 ERA.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.milb.com/player/index.jsp?player\\_id\\=643327\\#/career/R/pitching/2018/ALL\\|title\\=Zack Godley Stats, Highlights, Bio – MiLB.com Stats – The Official Site of Minor League Baseball\\|publisher\\=MiLB.com\\|access\\-date\\=January 28, 2018}}",
"In 2017, Godley began the season back with Reno. He was recalled in June and spent the rest of 2017 with Arizona. In 26 games (25 starts) for the Diamondbacks he was 8–9 with a 3\\.37 ERA.",
"Godley began the 2018 season with Arizona as a member of the starting rotation. He finished the season with a 15–11 record in 33 games (32 starts), with a 4\\.74 ERA. He struck out 185 batters in {{frac\\|178\\|1\\|3}} innings. He led the major leagues in [wild pitches](/wiki/Wild_pitch \"Wild pitch\"), with 17\\.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos\\=all\\&stats\\=pit≶\\=all\\&qual\\=10\\&type\\=0\\&season\\=2018\\&month\\=0\\&season1\\=2018\\&ind\\=0\\&team\\=0\\&rost\\=0\\&age\\=0\\&filter\\=\\&players\\=0\\&sort\\=22,d\\|title\\=Major League Leaderboards » 2018 » Pitchers » Standard Statistics \\| FanGraphs Baseball\\|website\\=www.fangraphs.com}} He also led all major league pitchers in [curveball](/wiki/Curveball \"Curveball\") percentage (40\\.3%).{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos\\=all\\&stats\\=pit≶\\=all\\&qual\\=y\\&type\\=4\\&season\\=2018\\&month\\=0\\&season1\\=2018\\&ind\\=0\\&team\\=0\\&rost\\=0\\&age\\=0\\&filter\\=\\&players\\=0\\&sort\\=9,d\\|title\\=Major League Leaderboards » 2018 » Pitchers » Pitch Type Statistics \\| FanGraphs Baseball\\|website\\=www.fangraphs.com}}",
"During the 2019 season, Godley appeared in 27 games for Arizona (nine starts), compiling a 3–5 record with 6\\.39 ERA in 76 innings pitched. On August 5, Godley was [designated for assignment](/wiki/Designated_for_assignment \"Designated for assignment\").{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlb.com/news/zack\\-godley\\-dfa\\-d\\-backs\\-call\\-up\\-kevin\\-ginkel\\|title\\=D\\-backs DFA Godley, call up Ginkel\\|author\\=Steve Gilbert\\|work\\=\\[\\[MLB.com]]\\|date\\=August 5, 2019\\|access\\-date\\=August 5, 2019}}{{cite news \\|first\\=Hunter \\|last\\=Hippel \\|title\\= Derrick Hall says Godley DFA sends a message to D\\-backs \\|url\\= https://arizonasports.com/story/2038529/hall\\-discusses\\-godleys\\-dfa\\-impact\\-on\\-dbacks/ \\|publisher\\= Arizona Sports 98\\.7FM \\|date\\= 8 August 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=19 January 2021}}",
"### Toronto Blue Jays",
"The [Toronto Blue Jays](/wiki/Toronto_Blue_Jays \"Toronto Blue Jays\") claimed Godley off waivers on August 7, 2019\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/report\\-blue\\-jays\\-claim\\-pitcher\\-zack\\-godley\\-off\\-waivers\\-diamondbacks/ \\|title\\=Blue Jays claim pitcher Zack Godley off waivers from Diamondbacks \\|date\\=August 7, 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=August 7, 2019 \\|work\\=sportsnet.ca}} He appeared in six games for the Blue Jays, recording one win and registering a 3\\.94 ERA in 16 innings pitched. On September 3, Godley was designated for assignment. He elected free agency on September 8\\.",
"### Detroit Tigers",
"On December 20, 2019, the [Detroit Tigers](/wiki/Detroit_Tigers \"Detroit Tigers\") signed Godley to a minor league contract with an invitation to spring training.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/\\_/id/28342103/zack\\-godley\\-tigers\\-agree\\-minor\\-league\\-deal\\|title\\=Godley, Tigers agree to minor league deal\\|date\\=2019\\-12\\-20\\|website\\=ESPN.com\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-12\\-21}} In March 2020, Godley was released, then re\\-signed by the Tigers on a minor league pact. On July 13, 2020, Godley was again released by the Tigers.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.freep.com/story/sports/mlb/tigers/2020/07/13/detroit\\-tigers\\-release\\-zack\\-godley/5430052002/ \\|title\\=Detroit Tigers release right\\-hander Zack Godley, give him time to find new team \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Detroit Free Press]] \\|first\\=Evan \\|last\\=Petzold \\|date\\=July 13, 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=July 13, 2020}}",
"### Boston Red Sox",
"On July 17, 2020, Godley signed a minor league deal with the [Boston Red Sox](/wiki/Boston_Red_Sox \"Boston Red Sox\").{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.bostonglobe.com/2020/07/17/sports/chaim\\-bloom\\-navigating\\-uncharted\\-waters\\-while\\-evaluating\\-unsettled\\-red\\-sox\\-pitching\\-situation/ \\|title\\=Chaim Bloom navigating uncharted waters while evaluating 'unsettled' Red Sox pitching situation \\|first\\=Alex \\|last\\=Speier \\|quote\\=On Friday, the team announced the signing of righthander Zack Godley — recently released by the Tigers — to a minor league deal. \\|website\\=\\[\\[The Boston Globe]] \\|url\\-access\\=limited \\|date\\=July 17, 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=July 17, 2020}} He was added to the team's active roster on July 26,{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.mlb.com/redsox/roster/transactions/2020/07 \\|title\\=Red Sox Roster \\& Staff – Transactions \\|website\\=\\[\\[MLB.com]] \\|date\\=July 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=July 26, 2020}} and made his first appearance with Boston the next day, pitching four innings of scoreless relief in a 7–4 loss to the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets \"New York Mets\").{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.espn.com/mlb/boxscore?gameId\\=401225719 \\|title\\=Mets vs. Red Sox \\|website\\=ESPN.com \\|date\\=July 27, 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=July 27, 2020}} He was placed on the 10\\-day [injured list](/wiki/Injured_list \"Injured list\") on September 10, and moved to the 45\\-day injured list on September 19\\.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.mlb.com/redsox/roster/transactions/2020/09 \\|title\\=Red Sox Roster \\& Staff – Transactions \\|website\\=\\[\\[MLB.com]] \\|date\\=September 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=September 19, 2020}} Overall with the [2020 Red Sox](/wiki/2020_Boston_Red_Sox_season \"2020 Boston Red Sox season\"), Godley appeared in eight games (seven starts), compiling an 0–4 record with 8\\.16 ERA and 28 strikeouts in {{frac\\|28\\|2\\|3}} innings.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.baseball\\-reference.com/players/g/godleza01\\.shtml \\|title\\=Zack Godley Stats \\|website\\=\\[\\[Baseball\\-Reference.com]] \\|access\\-date\\=September 19, 2020}} On October 26, Godley was outrighted off of the 40\\-man roster and elected free agency.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2020/10/red\\-sox\\-outright\\-5\\-players.html \\|title\\=Red Sox Outright 5 Players \\|first\\=Connor \\|last\\=Byrne \\|website\\=mlbtraderumors.com \\|date\\=October 26, 2020 \\|access\\-date\\=October 26, 2020}}",
"### Milwaukee Brewers",
"On March 19, 2021, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Milwaukee Brewers](/wiki/Milwaukee_Brewers \"Milwaukee Brewers\") organization.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/03/brewers\\-sign\\-zack\\-godley\\-to\\-minor\\-league\\-deal.html\\|title\\=Brewers Sign Zack Godley To Minor League Deal\\|website\\=MLB Trade Rumors\\|date\\=19 March 2021 }} On April 28, 2021, Godley was selected to the active roster to be the starting pitcher in the Brewers’ game against the [Miami Marlins](/wiki/Miami_Marlins \"Miami Marlins\") and allowed 3 earned runs in 3\\.0 innings, taking the loss.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/04/brewers\\-designate\\-phil\\-bickford\\-for\\-assignment.html\\|title\\=Brewers Designate Phil Bickford For Assignment\\|website\\=MLB Trade Rumors\\|date\\=28 April 2021 }}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/04/brewers\\-to\\-select\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title\\=Brewers To Select Zack Godley\\|website\\=MLB Trade Rumors\\|date\\=27 April 2021 }} The next day, he was placed on the injured list with a right index finger contusion. On May 10, Godley was activated from the injured list and designated for assignment.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/05/brewers\\-designate\\-zack\\-godley\\-for\\-assignment.html\\|title\\=Zack Godley Accepts Outright Assignment With Brewers\\|website\\=MLB Trade Rumors\\|date\\=14 May 2021 }} He cleared outright waivers on May 12 and was assigned outright to Triple\\-A.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/05/brewers\\-notes\\-burnes\\-yelich\\-godley.html\\|title\\=Brewers Notes: Burnes, Yelich, Godley\\|website\\=MLB Trade Rumors\\|date\\=12 May 2021 }} On June 18, Godley was re\\-selected to the active roster.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/brewers\\-activate\\-kolten\\-wong\\-select\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title \\= Brewers Activate Kolten Wong, Select Zack Godley\\| date\\=18 June 2021 }} After allowing 3 earned runs in a third of an inning, Godley was again designated for assignment on June 21\\.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/brewers\\-dfa\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title \\= Brewers DFA Zack Godley\\| date\\=21 June 2021 }} He was outrighted to the Triple\\-A [Nashville Sounds](/wiki/Nashville_Sounds \"Nashville Sounds\") on June 24\\.{{cite web\\| url \\= http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/transactions/\\#month\\=6\\&year\\=2021\\| title \\= Major League Baseball Transactions {{!}} MLB.com}} However, Godley rejected the outright assignment and elected free agency the next day.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/zack\\-godley\\-elects\\-free\\-agency\\-brewers.html\\|title \\= Zack Godley Elects Free Agency\\| date\\=25 June 2021 }}",
"### Cleveland Indians",
"On June 28, 2021, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Cleveland Indians](/wiki/Cleveland_Indians \"Cleveland Indians\") organization and was assigned to the [Columbus Clippers](/wiki/Columbus_Clippers \"Columbus Clippers\") of the [Triple\\-A East](/wiki/Triple-A_East \"Triple-A East\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/06/indians\\-to\\-sign\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title \\= Indians to Sign Zack Godley\\| date\\=28 June 2021 }} Godley was released by the Indians on August 2, 2021\\.",
"### New York Mets",
"On August 7, 2021, Godley signed a minor league deal with the [New York Mets](/wiki/New_York_Mets \"New York Mets\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/08/mets\\-sign\\-zack\\-godley\\-to\\-minors\\-deal.html\\|title \\= Mets Sign Zack Godley to Minors Deal\\| date\\=7 August 2021 }} Godley made 4 starts for the Triple\\-A [Syracuse Mets](/wiki/Syracuse_Mets \"Syracuse Mets\"), going 2–0 with a 2\\.33 ERA and 17 strikeouts. On August 30, Godley was granted his release by the Mets.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/08/mets\\-release\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title \\= Mets Release Zack Godley\\| date\\=30 August 2021 }}",
"### Cincinnati Reds",
"On February 21, 2022, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Cincinnati Reds](/wiki/Cincinnati_Reds \"Cincinnati Reds\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2022/02/reds\\-sign\\-zack\\-godley.html\\|title \\= Reds Sign Zack Godley to Minor League Deal\\| date\\=21 February 2022 }} In 14 games for the Triple–A [Louisville Bats](/wiki/Louisville_Bats \"Louisville Bats\"), he struggled to an 8\\.06 ERA with 29 strikeouts across {{fraction\\|22\\|1\\|3}} innings pitched. On May 26, Godley was released by the Reds organization.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.milb.com/player/zack\\-godley\\-643327 \\| title\\=Zack Godley Stats, Fantasy \\& News }}",
"### Gastonia Honey Hunters",
"On June 7, 2022, Godley signed with the [Gastonia Honey Hunters](/wiki/Gastonia_Honey_Hunters \"Gastonia Honey Hunters\") of the [Atlantic League of Professional Baseball](/wiki/Atlantic_League_of_Professional_Baseball \"Atlantic League of Professional Baseball\"). In 15 games (11 starts) for Gastonia, he recorded a 4\\.64 ERA with 64 strikeouts in {{fraction\\|54\\|1\\|3}} innings. Godley became a free agent following the season.",
"On April 19, 2023, Godley re\\-signed with the Honey Hunters for the 2023 season. In 13 starts for Gastonia, he registered a 5–3 record and 4\\.79 ERA with 86 strikeouts in {{fraction\\|71\\|1\\|3}} innings pitched.",
"### Oakland Athletics",
"On July 18, 2023, Godley signed a minor league contract with the [Oakland Athletics](/wiki/Oakland_Athletics \"Oakland Athletics\") organization.{{Cite web\\|title\\=Athletics' Zack Godley: Gets minors deal from A's\\|url\\=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/athletics\\-zack\\-godley\\-gets\\-minors\\-deal\\-from\\-as/\\|access\\-date\\=July 19, 2023\\|website\\=cbssports.com\\|language\\=en}} He made 12 appearances (10 starts) for the Triple–A [Las Vegas Aviators](/wiki/Las_Vegas_Aviators \"Las Vegas Aviators\"), registering a 5\\.21 ERA with 57 strikeouts across 57 innings of work. Godley elected free agency following the season on November 6\\.{{Cite web\\|title\\=2023 MiLB Free Agents\\|url\\=https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/2023\\-milb\\-free\\-agents/\\|access\\-date\\=May 23, 2024\\|website\\=baseballamerica.com\\|language\\=en}}",
""
] |
Naive fermion discretization
----------------------------
For simplicity we will consider a four\-dimensional theory of a free fermion, although the fermion doubling problem remains in arbitrary dimensions and even if [interactions](/wiki/Lattice_gauge_theory "Lattice gauge theory") are included. Lattice field theory is usually carried out in Euclidean spacetime arrived at from [Minkowski spacetime](/wiki/Minkowski_space "Minkowski space") after a [Wick rotation](/wiki/Wick_rotation "Wick rotation"), where the continuum [Dirac](/wiki/Dirac_equation "Dirac equation") [action](/wiki/Action_%28physics%29 "Action (physics)") takes the form
S\_F\[\\psi, \\bar \\psi] \= \\int d^4x\\bar \\psi(x)(\\gamma^\\mu \\partial\_\\mu \+ m)\\psi(x).
This is discretized by introducing a lattice with lattice spacing a and points indexed by a vector of integers n \= (n\_1,n\_2,n\_3,n\_4\). The integral becomes a sum over all lattice points, while the fermionic fields are replaced by four\-component [Grassmann variables](/wiki/Grassmann_number "Grassmann number") at each lattice site denoted by \\psi\_n and \\bar \\psi\_n. The [derivative](/wiki/Derivative "Derivative") discretization used is the symmetric [derivative discretization](/wiki/Finite_difference "Finite difference"), with the vectors \\hat \\mu being unit vectors in the \\mu direction. These steps give the naive free fermion action{{cite journal\|last1\=Gupta\|first1\=R.\|authorlink1\=\|date\=1997\|title\=Introduction to lattice QCD: Course\|url\=\|journal\=Les Houches Summer School in Theoretical Physics, Session 68: Probing the Standard Model of Particle Interactions\|volume\=\|issue\=\|pages\=83–219\|doi\=\|pmid\=\|arxiv\=hep\-lat/9807028\|s2cid\=\|access\-date\=}}
S\_F^L\[\\psi, \\bar \\psi] \= a^4 \\sum\_n \\bar \\psi\_n \\bigg(\\sum^4\_{\\mu\=1} \\gamma\_\\mu \\frac{\\psi\_{n\+\\hat \\mu}\-\\psi\_{n\-\\hat \\mu}}{2a}\+m\\psi\_n\\bigg).
This action reduces down to the continuum Dirac action in the continuum limit, so is expect to be a theory of a single fermion. However, it instead describes sixteen identical fermions, with each fermion said to have a different taste, analogously to how particles have different [flavours](/wiki/Flavour_%28particle_physics%29 "Flavour (particle physics)") in [particle physics](/wiki/Particle_physics "Particle physics"). The fifteen additional fermions are often referred to as doublers. This extended [particle](/wiki/Particle "Particle") content can be seen by analyzing the [symmetries](/wiki/Symmetry_%28physics%29 "Symmetry (physics)") or the [correlation functions](/wiki/Correlation_function_%28quantum_field_theory%29 "Correlation function (quantum field theory)") of the lattice theory.
### Doubling symmetry
The naive fermion action possesses a new taste\-exchange symmetry not found in the continuum theory acting on the fermion fields as{{cite journal\|last1\=Follana\|first1\=E.\|authorlink1\=\|collaboration\=HPQCD,UKQCD\|year\=2007\|title\=Highly Improved Staggered Quarks on the Lattice, with Applications to Charm Physics\|url\=\|journal\=Phys. Rev. D\|volume\=75\|issue\=5\|page\=054502 \|doi\=10\.1103/PhysRevD.75\.054502\|pmid\=\|arxiv\=hep\-lat/0610092\|bibcode\=2007PhRvD..75e4502F \|s2cid\=119506250\|access\-date\=}}
\\psi\_n \\rightarrow e^{\-in\\cdot \\pi\_A}S\_A \\psi\_n, \\ \\ \\ \\ \\ \\ \\bar \\psi\_n \\rightarrow \\bar \\psi\_n S\_A^\\dagger e^{in\\cdot \\pi\_A},
where the vectors \\pi\_A are the sixteen vectors with non\-zero entries of \\pi specified by A. For example, \\pi\_0 \= (0,0,0,0\), \\pi\_{2} \= (0,\\pi,0,0\), \\pi\_{14} \= (\\pi,0,0,\\pi), and \\pi\_{1234} \= (\\pi,\\pi,\\pi,\\pi). The [Dirac structure](/wiki/Gamma_matrices "Gamma matrices") in the symmetry is similarly defined by the indices of A as S\_A \= S\_{\\nu\_1}S\_{\\nu\_2}S\_{\\nu\_3}S\_{\\nu\_4} where S\_0 \= I and S\_\\nu \= i\\gamma\_5 \\gamma\_\\nu; for example with S\_{14} \= (i\\gamma\_5 \\gamma\_1\)(i\\gamma\_5\\gamma\_4\).
The presence of these sixteen symmetry transformations implies the existence of sixteen identical fermion states rather than just one. Starting with a fermion field \\psi\_n, the symmetry maps it to another field \\psi'\_n \= e^{\-in\\cdot \\pi\_A}S\_A\\psi\_n. [Fourier transforming](/wiki/Fourier_transform "Fourier transform") this shows that its [momentum](/wiki/Momentum "Momentum") has been shifted as p^\\mu \\rightarrow p^\\mu \+ \\pi\_A^\\mu. Therefore, a fermion with momentum near the center of the [Brillouin zone](/wiki/Brillouin_zone "Brillouin zone") is mapped to one of its corners while one of the corner fermions comes in to replace the center fermion, showing that the transformation acts to exchange the tastes of the fermions. Since this is a symmetry of the action, the different tastes must be physically indistinguishable from each other. Here the Brillouin momentum k^\\mu \= p^\\mu\+ \\pi\_A^\\mu for small p^\\mu is not the physical momentum of the particle, rather that is p^\\mu. Instead \\pi\_A^\\mu acts more as an additional [quantum number](/wiki/Quantum_number "Quantum number") specifying the taste of a fermion.
The S\_A term is responsible for changing the [representation](/wiki/Group_representation "Group representation") of the \\gamma\-matrices of the doublers to \\gamma\_\\mu^{(A)} \= S\_A^\\dagger \\gamma\_\\mu S\_A, which has the effect of changing the signs of the matrices as (\\gamma\_1, \\gamma\_2, \\gamma\_3, \\gamma\_4\) \\rightarrow (\\pm \\gamma\_1, \\pm \\gamma\_2, \\pm \\gamma\_3, \\pm \\gamma\_4\). Since any such sign change results in a set of matrices still satisfying the [Dirac algebra](/wiki/Dirac_algebra "Dirac algebra"), the resulting matrices form a valid representation. It is also the term that enters the [wave function](/wiki/Wave_function "Wave function") of the doublers given by S\_A^\\dagger u(\\boldsymbol p) and S^\\dagger\_A v(\\boldsymbol p), where u(\\boldsymbol p) and v(\\boldsymbol p) are the usual Dirac equation solutions with momentum \\boldsymbol p.{{cite book\|last1\=DeGrand\|first1\=T.\|last2\=DeTar\|first2\=C.\|date\=2006\|title\=Lattice Methods for Quantum Chromodynamics\|series\=\|url\=\|doi\=10\.1142/6065\|location\=\|publisher\=World Scientific Publishing\|chapter\=6\|page\=103\|bibcode\=2006lmqc.book.....D \|isbn\=978\-9812567277}}
### Propagator and dispersion relation
In the continuum theory, the Dirac [propagator](/wiki/Propagator "Propagator") has a single [pole](/wiki/Zeros_and_poles "Zeros and poles") as the theory describes only a single particle. However, calculating the propagator from the naive action yields
S(p) \= \\frac{m \- ia^{\-1}\\sum\_\\mu \\gamma\_\\mu \\sin(p^\\mu a)}{m^2\+a^{\-2}\\sum\_\\mu \\sin(p^\\mu a)^2},
for a fermion with momentum p^\\mu.{{cite book\|last1\=Gattringer\|first1\=C.\|last2\=Lang\|first2\=C.B.\|date\=2009\|title\=Quantum Chromodynamics on the Lattice: An Introductory Presentation\|series\=Lecture Notes in Physics 788\|url\=\|doi\=10\.1007/978\-3\-642\-01850\-3\|location\=\|publisher\=Springer\|chapter\=5\|pages\=111–112\|isbn\=978\-3642018497}} For low momenta \\sin(p^\\mu a)\\approx p^\\mu a this still has the expected pole at ap^\\mu \= (am,0,0,0\), but there are fifteen additional poles when ap^\\mu \= (am,0,0,0\)\+\\pi\_A^\\mu. Each of these is a new fermion species with doubling arising because the \\sin(p^\\mu a) function has two poles over the range p^\\mu \\in \[\-\\pi/a,\\pi/a]. This is in contrast to what happens when particles of different [spins](/wiki/Spin_%28physics%29 "Spin (physics)") are discretized. For example, [scalars](/wiki/Scalar_boson "Scalar boson") acquire propagators taking a similar form except with \\sin(p^\\mu a/2\), which only has a single pole over the momentum range and so the theory does not suffer from a doubling problem.{{cite book\|last\=Rothe\|first\=H.J.\|author\-link\=\|date\=2005\|title\=Lattice Gauge Theories: An Introduction\|series\=World Scientific Lecture Notes in Physics: Volume 43\|url\=https://library.oapen.org/handle/20\.500\.12657/50492\|doi\=10\.1142/8229\|location\=\|publisher\=World Scientific Publishing\|chapter\=3\|volume\=82 \|pages\=39–40\|hdl\=20\.500\.12657/50492 \|isbn\=978\-9814365857}}
[270px\|thumb\|right\|alt\=Comparison of the free continuum fermion dispersion relation which is linear, versus the lattice fermion dispersion relation which is sinusoidal, crossing the x\-axis at the Brillouin zone boundary, corresponding to a fermion doubler state.\|Comparison between the continuum and lattice dispersion relations of a free fermion, with the latter having a doubler at the Brillouin zone boundary.](/wiki/File:Fermion_doubling_dispersion_relation.svg "Fermion doubling dispersion relation.svg")
The necessity of fermion doubling can be deduced from the fact that the [massless](/wiki/Massless_particle "Massless particle") fermion propagator is [odd](/wiki/Even_and_odd_functions "Even and odd functions") around the [origin](/wiki/Origin_%28mathematics%29 "Origin (mathematics)").{{cite book\|last\=Makeenko\|first\=Y.\|date\=2002\|title\=Methods of Contemporary Gauge Theory\|series\=Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics\|url\=\|doi\=10\.1017/CBO9780511535147\|location\=Cambridge\|publisher\=Cambridge University Press\|chapter\=8\|pages\=149–150\|hdl\=20\.500\.12657/64018 \|isbn\=978\-0521809115}} That is, in the continuum limit it is proportional to \\gamma\_\\mu p^\\mu, which must still be the case on the lattice in the small momentum limit. But since any [local](/wiki/Principle_of_locality "Principle of locality") lattice theory that can be constructed must have a propagator that is [continuous](/wiki/Continuous_function "Continuous function") and [periodic](/wiki/Periodic_function "Periodic function"), it must cross the zero axis at least once more, which is exactly what occurs on the Brillouin zone corners where ap\_\\mu \= \\pi\_A^\\mu for the naive fermion propagator. This is in contrast to the [bosonic](/wiki/Boson "Boson") propagator which is [quadratic](/wiki/Quadratic_function "Quadratic function") around the origin and so does not have such problem. Doubling can be avoided if a discontinuous propagator is used, but this results in a non\-local theory.
The presence of doublers is also reflected in the fermion [dispersion relation](/wiki/Dispersion_relation "Dispersion relation"). Since this is a relation between the [energy](/wiki/Energy "Energy") \\omega of the fermion and its momentum, it requires performing an inverse Wick transformation p\_4 \= \\pm i \\omega, with the dispersion relation arising from the pole of the propagator{{cite book\|last1\=Montvay\|first1\=I.\|last2\=Munster\|first2\=G.\|date\=1994\|title\=Quantum Fields on a Lattice\|series\=Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics\|url\=\|doi\=10\.1017/CBO9780511470783\|location\=Cambridge\|publisher\=Cambridge University Press\|chapter\=4\|pages\=116–117\|isbn\=9780511470783\|s2cid\=118339104 }}
\\sinh \\omega(\\boldsymbol p) \= \\sqrt{m^2 \+ \\sum^3\_{j\=1}\\sin^2 p\_j}.
The zeros of this dispersion relation are local energy [minima](/wiki/Maxima_and_minima "Maxima and minima") around which excitations correspond to different particle species. The above has eight different species arising due to doubling in the three spatial directions. The remaining eight doublers occur due to another doubling in the Euclidean temporal direction, which seems to have been lost. But this is due to a naive application of the inverse Wick transformation. The theory has an obstruction that does not allow for the simple replacement of p\_4 \= \\pm i \\omega and instead requires performing the full [contour integration](/wiki/Contour_integration "Contour integration"). Doing this for the [position space](/wiki/Position_and_momentum_spaces "Position and momentum spaces") propagator results in two separate terms, each of which has the same dispersion relation of eight fermion species, giving a total of sixteen.{{cite book\|last\=Smit\|first\=Jan\|author\-link\=Jan Smit (physicist)\|date\=2002\|title\=Introduction to Quantum Fields on a Lattice\|series\=Cambridge Lecture Notes in Physics\|url\=\|doi\=10\.1017/CBO9780511583971\|location\=Cambridge\|publisher\=Cambridge University Press\|chapter\=6\|pages\=153–156\|hdl\=20\.500\.12657/64022 \|isbn\=9780511583971}} The obstruction between the Minkowski and Euclidean naive fermion lattice theories occurs because doubling does not occur in the Minkowski temporal direction, so the two theories differ in their particle content.
|
[
"Naive fermion discretization\n----------------------------",
"For simplicity we will consider a four\\-dimensional theory of a free fermion, although the fermion doubling problem remains in arbitrary dimensions and even if [interactions](/wiki/Lattice_gauge_theory \"Lattice gauge theory\") are included. Lattice field theory is usually carried out in Euclidean spacetime arrived at from [Minkowski spacetime](/wiki/Minkowski_space \"Minkowski space\") after a [Wick rotation](/wiki/Wick_rotation \"Wick rotation\"), where the continuum [Dirac](/wiki/Dirac_equation \"Dirac equation\") [action](/wiki/Action_%28physics%29 \"Action (physics)\") takes the form",
"",
"S\\_F\\[\\\\psi, \\\\bar \\\\psi] \\= \\\\int d^4x\\\\bar \\\\psi(x)(\\\\gamma^\\\\mu \\\\partial\\_\\\\mu \\+ m)\\\\psi(x).",
"This is discretized by introducing a lattice with lattice spacing a and points indexed by a vector of integers n \\= (n\\_1,n\\_2,n\\_3,n\\_4\\). The integral becomes a sum over all lattice points, while the fermionic fields are replaced by four\\-component [Grassmann variables](/wiki/Grassmann_number \"Grassmann number\") at each lattice site denoted by \\\\psi\\_n and \\\\bar \\\\psi\\_n. The [derivative](/wiki/Derivative \"Derivative\") discretization used is the symmetric [derivative discretization](/wiki/Finite_difference \"Finite difference\"), with the vectors \\\\hat \\\\mu being unit vectors in the \\\\mu direction. These steps give the naive free fermion action{{cite journal\\|last1\\=Gupta\\|first1\\=R.\\|authorlink1\\=\\|date\\=1997\\|title\\=Introduction to lattice QCD: Course\\|url\\=\\|journal\\=Les Houches Summer School in Theoretical Physics, Session 68: Probing the Standard Model of Particle Interactions\\|volume\\=\\|issue\\=\\|pages\\=83–219\\|doi\\=\\|pmid\\=\\|arxiv\\=hep\\-lat/9807028\\|s2cid\\=\\|access\\-date\\=}}",
"",
"S\\_F^L\\[\\\\psi, \\\\bar \\\\psi] \\= a^4 \\\\sum\\_n \\\\bar \\\\psi\\_n \\\\bigg(\\\\sum^4\\_{\\\\mu\\=1} \\\\gamma\\_\\\\mu \\\\frac{\\\\psi\\_{n\\+\\\\hat \\\\mu}\\-\\\\psi\\_{n\\-\\\\hat \\\\mu}}{2a}\\+m\\\\psi\\_n\\\\bigg).",
"This action reduces down to the continuum Dirac action in the continuum limit, so is expect to be a theory of a single fermion. However, it instead describes sixteen identical fermions, with each fermion said to have a different taste, analogously to how particles have different [flavours](/wiki/Flavour_%28particle_physics%29 \"Flavour (particle physics)\") in [particle physics](/wiki/Particle_physics \"Particle physics\"). The fifteen additional fermions are often referred to as doublers. This extended [particle](/wiki/Particle \"Particle\") content can be seen by analyzing the [symmetries](/wiki/Symmetry_%28physics%29 \"Symmetry (physics)\") or the [correlation functions](/wiki/Correlation_function_%28quantum_field_theory%29 \"Correlation function (quantum field theory)\") of the lattice theory.",
"### Doubling symmetry",
"The naive fermion action possesses a new taste\\-exchange symmetry not found in the continuum theory acting on the fermion fields as{{cite journal\\|last1\\=Follana\\|first1\\=E.\\|authorlink1\\=\\|collaboration\\=HPQCD,UKQCD\\|year\\=2007\\|title\\=Highly Improved Staggered Quarks on the Lattice, with Applications to Charm Physics\\|url\\=\\|journal\\=Phys. Rev. D\\|volume\\=75\\|issue\\=5\\|page\\=054502 \\|doi\\=10\\.1103/PhysRevD.75\\.054502\\|pmid\\=\\|arxiv\\=hep\\-lat/0610092\\|bibcode\\=2007PhRvD..75e4502F \\|s2cid\\=119506250\\|access\\-date\\=}}",
"",
"\\\\psi\\_n \\\\rightarrow e^{\\-in\\\\cdot \\\\pi\\_A}S\\_A \\\\psi\\_n, \\\\ \\\\ \\\\ \\\\ \\\\ \\\\ \\\\bar \\\\psi\\_n \\\\rightarrow \\\\bar \\\\psi\\_n S\\_A^\\\\dagger e^{in\\\\cdot \\\\pi\\_A},",
"where the vectors \\\\pi\\_A are the sixteen vectors with non\\-zero entries of \\\\pi specified by A. For example, \\\\pi\\_0 \\= (0,0,0,0\\), \\\\pi\\_{2} \\= (0,\\\\pi,0,0\\), \\\\pi\\_{14} \\= (\\\\pi,0,0,\\\\pi), and \\\\pi\\_{1234} \\= (\\\\pi,\\\\pi,\\\\pi,\\\\pi). The [Dirac structure](/wiki/Gamma_matrices \"Gamma matrices\") in the symmetry is similarly defined by the indices of A as S\\_A \\= S\\_{\\\\nu\\_1}S\\_{\\\\nu\\_2}S\\_{\\\\nu\\_3}S\\_{\\\\nu\\_4} where S\\_0 \\= I and S\\_\\\\nu \\= i\\\\gamma\\_5 \\\\gamma\\_\\\\nu; for example with S\\_{14} \\= (i\\\\gamma\\_5 \\\\gamma\\_1\\)(i\\\\gamma\\_5\\\\gamma\\_4\\).",
"The presence of these sixteen symmetry transformations implies the existence of sixteen identical fermion states rather than just one. Starting with a fermion field \\\\psi\\_n, the symmetry maps it to another field \\\\psi'\\_n \\= e^{\\-in\\\\cdot \\\\pi\\_A}S\\_A\\\\psi\\_n. [Fourier transforming](/wiki/Fourier_transform \"Fourier transform\") this shows that its [momentum](/wiki/Momentum \"Momentum\") has been shifted as p^\\\\mu \\\\rightarrow p^\\\\mu \\+ \\\\pi\\_A^\\\\mu. Therefore, a fermion with momentum near the center of the [Brillouin zone](/wiki/Brillouin_zone \"Brillouin zone\") is mapped to one of its corners while one of the corner fermions comes in to replace the center fermion, showing that the transformation acts to exchange the tastes of the fermions. Since this is a symmetry of the action, the different tastes must be physically indistinguishable from each other. Here the Brillouin momentum k^\\\\mu \\= p^\\\\mu\\+ \\\\pi\\_A^\\\\mu for small p^\\\\mu is not the physical momentum of the particle, rather that is p^\\\\mu. Instead \\\\pi\\_A^\\\\mu acts more as an additional [quantum number](/wiki/Quantum_number \"Quantum number\") specifying the taste of a fermion.",
"The S\\_A term is responsible for changing the [representation](/wiki/Group_representation \"Group representation\") of the \\\\gamma\\-matrices of the doublers to \\\\gamma\\_\\\\mu^{(A)} \\= S\\_A^\\\\dagger \\\\gamma\\_\\\\mu S\\_A, which has the effect of changing the signs of the matrices as (\\\\gamma\\_1, \\\\gamma\\_2, \\\\gamma\\_3, \\\\gamma\\_4\\) \\\\rightarrow (\\\\pm \\\\gamma\\_1, \\\\pm \\\\gamma\\_2, \\\\pm \\\\gamma\\_3, \\\\pm \\\\gamma\\_4\\). Since any such sign change results in a set of matrices still satisfying the [Dirac algebra](/wiki/Dirac_algebra \"Dirac algebra\"), the resulting matrices form a valid representation. It is also the term that enters the [wave function](/wiki/Wave_function \"Wave function\") of the doublers given by S\\_A^\\\\dagger u(\\\\boldsymbol p) and S^\\\\dagger\\_A v(\\\\boldsymbol p), where u(\\\\boldsymbol p) and v(\\\\boldsymbol p) are the usual Dirac equation solutions with momentum \\\\boldsymbol p.{{cite book\\|last1\\=DeGrand\\|first1\\=T.\\|last2\\=DeTar\\|first2\\=C.\\|date\\=2006\\|title\\=Lattice Methods for Quantum Chromodynamics\\|series\\=\\|url\\=\\|doi\\=10\\.1142/6065\\|location\\=\\|publisher\\=World Scientific Publishing\\|chapter\\=6\\|page\\=103\\|bibcode\\=2006lmqc.book.....D \\|isbn\\=978\\-9812567277}}",
"### Propagator and dispersion relation",
"In the continuum theory, the Dirac [propagator](/wiki/Propagator \"Propagator\") has a single [pole](/wiki/Zeros_and_poles \"Zeros and poles\") as the theory describes only a single particle. However, calculating the propagator from the naive action yields",
"",
"S(p) \\= \\\\frac{m \\- ia^{\\-1}\\\\sum\\_\\\\mu \\\\gamma\\_\\\\mu \\\\sin(p^\\\\mu a)}{m^2\\+a^{\\-2}\\\\sum\\_\\\\mu \\\\sin(p^\\\\mu a)^2},",
"for a fermion with momentum p^\\\\mu.{{cite book\\|last1\\=Gattringer\\|first1\\=C.\\|last2\\=Lang\\|first2\\=C.B.\\|date\\=2009\\|title\\=Quantum Chromodynamics on the Lattice: An Introductory Presentation\\|series\\=Lecture Notes in Physics 788\\|url\\=\\|doi\\=10\\.1007/978\\-3\\-642\\-01850\\-3\\|location\\=\\|publisher\\=Springer\\|chapter\\=5\\|pages\\=111–112\\|isbn\\=978\\-3642018497}} For low momenta \\\\sin(p^\\\\mu a)\\\\approx p^\\\\mu a this still has the expected pole at ap^\\\\mu \\= (am,0,0,0\\), but there are fifteen additional poles when ap^\\\\mu \\= (am,0,0,0\\)\\+\\\\pi\\_A^\\\\mu. Each of these is a new fermion species with doubling arising because the \\\\sin(p^\\\\mu a) function has two poles over the range p^\\\\mu \\\\in \\[\\-\\\\pi/a,\\\\pi/a]. This is in contrast to what happens when particles of different [spins](/wiki/Spin_%28physics%29 \"Spin (physics)\") are discretized. For example, [scalars](/wiki/Scalar_boson \"Scalar boson\") acquire propagators taking a similar form except with \\\\sin(p^\\\\mu a/2\\), which only has a single pole over the momentum range and so the theory does not suffer from a doubling problem.{{cite book\\|last\\=Rothe\\|first\\=H.J.\\|author\\-link\\=\\|date\\=2005\\|title\\=Lattice Gauge Theories: An Introduction\\|series\\=World Scientific Lecture Notes in Physics: Volume 43\\|url\\=https://library.oapen.org/handle/20\\.500\\.12657/50492\\|doi\\=10\\.1142/8229\\|location\\=\\|publisher\\=World Scientific Publishing\\|chapter\\=3\\|volume\\=82 \\|pages\\=39–40\\|hdl\\=20\\.500\\.12657/50492 \\|isbn\\=978\\-9814365857}}",
"[270px\\|thumb\\|right\\|alt\\=Comparison of the free continuum fermion dispersion relation which is linear, versus the lattice fermion dispersion relation which is sinusoidal, crossing the x\\-axis at the Brillouin zone boundary, corresponding to a fermion doubler state.\\|Comparison between the continuum and lattice dispersion relations of a free fermion, with the latter having a doubler at the Brillouin zone boundary.](/wiki/File:Fermion_doubling_dispersion_relation.svg \"Fermion doubling dispersion relation.svg\")",
"The necessity of fermion doubling can be deduced from the fact that the [massless](/wiki/Massless_particle \"Massless particle\") fermion propagator is [odd](/wiki/Even_and_odd_functions \"Even and odd functions\") around the [origin](/wiki/Origin_%28mathematics%29 \"Origin (mathematics)\").{{cite book\\|last\\=Makeenko\\|first\\=Y.\\|date\\=2002\\|title\\=Methods of Contemporary Gauge Theory\\|series\\=Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics\\|url\\=\\|doi\\=10\\.1017/CBO9780511535147\\|location\\=Cambridge\\|publisher\\=Cambridge University Press\\|chapter\\=8\\|pages\\=149–150\\|hdl\\=20\\.500\\.12657/64018 \\|isbn\\=978\\-0521809115}} That is, in the continuum limit it is proportional to \\\\gamma\\_\\\\mu p^\\\\mu, which must still be the case on the lattice in the small momentum limit. But since any [local](/wiki/Principle_of_locality \"Principle of locality\") lattice theory that can be constructed must have a propagator that is [continuous](/wiki/Continuous_function \"Continuous function\") and [periodic](/wiki/Periodic_function \"Periodic function\"), it must cross the zero axis at least once more, which is exactly what occurs on the Brillouin zone corners where ap\\_\\\\mu \\= \\\\pi\\_A^\\\\mu for the naive fermion propagator. This is in contrast to the [bosonic](/wiki/Boson \"Boson\") propagator which is [quadratic](/wiki/Quadratic_function \"Quadratic function\") around the origin and so does not have such problem. Doubling can be avoided if a discontinuous propagator is used, but this results in a non\\-local theory.",
"The presence of doublers is also reflected in the fermion [dispersion relation](/wiki/Dispersion_relation \"Dispersion relation\"). Since this is a relation between the [energy](/wiki/Energy \"Energy\") \\\\omega of the fermion and its momentum, it requires performing an inverse Wick transformation p\\_4 \\= \\\\pm i \\\\omega, with the dispersion relation arising from the pole of the propagator{{cite book\\|last1\\=Montvay\\|first1\\=I.\\|last2\\=Munster\\|first2\\=G.\\|date\\=1994\\|title\\=Quantum Fields on a Lattice\\|series\\=Cambridge Monographs on Mathematical Physics\\|url\\=\\|doi\\=10\\.1017/CBO9780511470783\\|location\\=Cambridge\\|publisher\\=Cambridge University Press\\|chapter\\=4\\|pages\\=116–117\\|isbn\\=9780511470783\\|s2cid\\=118339104 }}",
"",
"\\\\sinh \\\\omega(\\\\boldsymbol p) \\= \\\\sqrt{m^2 \\+ \\\\sum^3\\_{j\\=1}\\\\sin^2 p\\_j}.",
"The zeros of this dispersion relation are local energy [minima](/wiki/Maxima_and_minima \"Maxima and minima\") around which excitations correspond to different particle species. The above has eight different species arising due to doubling in the three spatial directions. The remaining eight doublers occur due to another doubling in the Euclidean temporal direction, which seems to have been lost. But this is due to a naive application of the inverse Wick transformation. The theory has an obstruction that does not allow for the simple replacement of p\\_4 \\= \\\\pm i \\\\omega and instead requires performing the full [contour integration](/wiki/Contour_integration \"Contour integration\"). Doing this for the [position space](/wiki/Position_and_momentum_spaces \"Position and momentum spaces\") propagator results in two separate terms, each of which has the same dispersion relation of eight fermion species, giving a total of sixteen.{{cite book\\|last\\=Smit\\|first\\=Jan\\|author\\-link\\=Jan Smit (physicist)\\|date\\=2002\\|title\\=Introduction to Quantum Fields on a Lattice\\|series\\=Cambridge Lecture Notes in Physics\\|url\\=\\|doi\\=10\\.1017/CBO9780511583971\\|location\\=Cambridge\\|publisher\\=Cambridge University Press\\|chapter\\=6\\|pages\\=153–156\\|hdl\\=20\\.500\\.12657/64022 \\|isbn\\=9780511583971}} The obstruction between the Minkowski and Euclidean naive fermion lattice theories occurs because doubling does not occur in the Minkowski temporal direction, so the two theories differ in their particle content.",
""
] |
Work undertaken
---------------
### Repair and rebuilding
Initially, the work supervised by Millholland at the Mt. Savage Shops was limited to repairing and rebuilding the Winans Camels and other early C\&P locomotives. The shop force gained much hands\-on experience during the first twenty years; at least 15 of the C\&P's camel\-backed locos were rebuilt at Mt. Savage (some twice). Typical of the rebuilds was the engine Highlander, a Winans Camel inherited from the [Mount Savage Railroad](/wiki/Mount_Savage_Railroad "Mount Savage Railroad"). It was a modernization project in which, among other things, the cab was relocated from on top of the boiler to the rear position. The C\&P shops also provided repair services to its rivals in the [Georges Creek](/wiki/Georges_Creek_%28Potomac_River%29 "Georges Creek (Potomac River)") coal region.
### New build
Initially, the Winans Camels and other early locomotives were extensively rebuilt, and much hands\-on experience was gained during the period from 1866 to 1888\. The first recorded engine 'build' was a [0\-10\-0](/wiki/0-10-0 "0-10-0") unit in 1868\. This could have been a modification to a Winans Camel. By the 1880s, the shops that Millholland had set up apparently had built quite an extensive operation, able to offer custom built locomotives for sale in addition to meeting the requirements of the parent C\&P.
The period beginning in 1883 was an exciting one for heavy manufacturing in Mount Savage. A locomotive catalog was issued for the Works by their agent, Thomas B. Inness \& Co. of Broadway, [New York](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City"). The catalog listed five types of engines for sale, and their specifications. Evidence was that the catalog was successful, and numerous sales to other roads resulted. This helped finance production for the home road, spurred development, and helped employment. [Narrow gauge](/wiki/Narrow_gauge "Narrow gauge") engines proved so popular a product that the works installed a [third rail](/wiki/Dual_gauge "Dual gauge") up the main line from Mount Savage for customer acceptance testing.
Engine production was active between 1885 and 1917\. Engines were produced for other roads as well. The production figures for 1882 list 19 passenger and freight engines outshopped, with 16 more in 1883\.
One particularly good customer was T. H. Paul \& Sons of [Frostburg](/wiki/Frostburg "Frostburg"). A former C\&P master mechanic himself (1854–1855\), Paul established shops in Cumberland and Frostburg. He built mine engines and smaller narrow gauge locomotives at his shops, but contracted with Mount Savage for his larger orders. His Frostburg works were located near the existing C\&P Passenger station, and some of the buildings still stand in 1999\.
|
[
"Work undertaken\n---------------",
"### Repair and rebuilding",
"Initially, the work supervised by Millholland at the Mt. Savage Shops was limited to repairing and rebuilding the Winans Camels and other early C\\&P locomotives. The shop force gained much hands\\-on experience during the first twenty years; at least 15 of the C\\&P's camel\\-backed locos were rebuilt at Mt. Savage (some twice). Typical of the rebuilds was the engine Highlander, a Winans Camel inherited from the [Mount Savage Railroad](/wiki/Mount_Savage_Railroad \"Mount Savage Railroad\"). It was a modernization project in which, among other things, the cab was relocated from on top of the boiler to the rear position. The C\\&P shops also provided repair services to its rivals in the [Georges Creek](/wiki/Georges_Creek_%28Potomac_River%29 \"Georges Creek (Potomac River)\") coal region.",
"### New build",
"Initially, the Winans Camels and other early locomotives were extensively rebuilt, and much hands\\-on experience was gained during the period from 1866 to 1888\\. The first recorded engine 'build' was a [0\\-10\\-0](/wiki/0-10-0 \"0-10-0\") unit in 1868\\. This could have been a modification to a Winans Camel. By the 1880s, the shops that Millholland had set up apparently had built quite an extensive operation, able to offer custom built locomotives for sale in addition to meeting the requirements of the parent C\\&P.",
"The period beginning in 1883 was an exciting one for heavy manufacturing in Mount Savage. A locomotive catalog was issued for the Works by their agent, Thomas B. Inness \\& Co. of Broadway, [New York](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\"). The catalog listed five types of engines for sale, and their specifications. Evidence was that the catalog was successful, and numerous sales to other roads resulted. This helped finance production for the home road, spurred development, and helped employment. [Narrow gauge](/wiki/Narrow_gauge \"Narrow gauge\") engines proved so popular a product that the works installed a [third rail](/wiki/Dual_gauge \"Dual gauge\") up the main line from Mount Savage for customer acceptance testing.",
"Engine production was active between 1885 and 1917\\. Engines were produced for other roads as well. The production figures for 1882 list 19 passenger and freight engines outshopped, with 16 more in 1883\\.",
"One particularly good customer was T. H. Paul \\& Sons of [Frostburg](/wiki/Frostburg \"Frostburg\"). A former C\\&P master mechanic himself (1854–1855\\), Paul established shops in Cumberland and Frostburg. He built mine engines and smaller narrow gauge locomotives at his shops, but contracted with Mount Savage for his larger orders. His Frostburg works were located near the existing C\\&P Passenger station, and some of the buildings still stand in 1999\\.",
""
] |
Manufacturing procedures
------------------------
Locomotive manufacturing during this period was hard, heavy, dangerous work. It proceeded according to numerous 'rules of thumb' developed by the master mechanic over the years. Innovations were introduced slowly. There were continuous efforts to reduce costs, and increase performance. Weight reduction was not desirable, as weight\-on\-drivers contributed directly to tractive effort. Locomotive frames were usually riveted, built\-up construction, of [wrought iron](/wiki/Wrought_iron "Wrought iron") and later, [steel](/wiki/Steel "Steel").
According to White, experience at the [Norris Locomotive Works](/wiki/Norris_Locomotive_Works "Norris Locomotive Works") showed that a team of 14 men could build a locomotive in 15 days. This was assuming the parts were on hand. A locomotive is a carefully integrated collection of a large number of specialty parts.
### Boilers
The typical [boiler](/wiki/Boiler "Boiler") was constructed of 5/16\-inch wrought iron, starting as plate, and rolled to shape. The lap joints were single [riveted](/wiki/Rivet "Rivet"). There is a long way between watertight and steam tight. Later, double riveting, and reinforced butt joints were used. [Welding](/wiki/Welding "Welding") was not yet a developed technology, particularly for a pressure vessel. Boiler tubes were typically iron tubing of 2 inches diameter. They were lap welded, and reportedly difficult to flange.
#### Lagging
Boilers were covered, or [lagged](/wiki/Thermal_insulation "Thermal insulation"), to reduce heat loss, and increase efficiency. Wood slats were used originally. After 1900, [asbestos](/wiki/Asbestos "Asbestos") was a favored lagging material. It was common for the slabs of the mineral to be machined to fit. This produced large clouds of asbestos dust that is now known to be a major carcinogen, a significant cause of lung cancer. The use of dust masks, hearing protection, and safety glasses was unknown at the time. The boiler shops were a haze of asbestos dust.
#### Water feed
Millholland favored [Giffard's](/wiki/Henri_Giffard "Henri Giffard") water [injectors](/wiki/Injector "Injector"), based on the favorable experience with them on the Reading line. He was also an early advocate of [feedwater heaters](/wiki/Feedwater_heater "Feedwater heater"), using them as early as 1855\. His designs have them on the right side, under the engine running board. They are about 10 feet long, and 8 inches in diameter. These are a visible clue to engines produced in Mount Savage. Millholland is also responsible for the development of the poppet throttle, originally retrofitted on Camel engines in Pennsylvania.
### Cylinders
The [cylinders](/wiki/Cylinder_%28engine%29 "Cylinder (engine)") were usually cast in halves, assembled, and bored to size. This represented the most complex and expensive operation of the whole locomotive assembly. In 1856, it was common for the boring operation to consume 2 days. The [pistons](/wiki/Piston "Piston") were [cast iron](/wiki/Cast_iron "Cast iron"), with fitted [brass](/wiki/Brass "Brass") [piston rings](/wiki/Piston_ring "Piston ring").
### Driving wheels
The [driving wheels](/wiki/Driving_wheel "Driving wheel") were typically cast iron, and [axles](/wiki/Axle "Axle") were usually 6\-inch\-diameter wrought iron. Driving wheels were fitted with replaceable [tires](/wiki/Railway_tires "Railway tires"). On the basis of his previous experience, Millholland favored cast\-iron tires, shrunk onto the wheels. His father had experimented with steel tires around 1851–52, and they became standard later. Some early accidents on the C\&P involved wheel failures. In 1872, Engine No. 11 broke a wheel below Frostburg, requiring the assistance of the work train, and delaying the pay car, according to the Frostburg Mining Journal.
### Connecting rods
Connecting rods were [cast](/wiki/Casting "Casting"), and [bearings](/wiki/Bearing_%28mechanical%29 "Bearing (mechanical)") were brass and/or [Babbitt metal](/wiki/Babbitt_%28metal%29 "Babbitt (metal)"). The early [lubricants](/wiki/Lubricant "Lubricant") were all animal fat based, and only suitable for low temperature applications. Later, [petroleum](/wiki/Petroleum "Petroleum") based lubricants provided much better performance.
### Gauges
Engine safety appliances were sparse. The [Bourdon gauge](/wiki/Bourdon_gauge "Bourdon gauge") for pressure readings was patented in 1849\. A rival gauge was developed in 1857 by Wooten. Glass [sight gauges](/wiki/Sight_glass "Sight glass") for boiler water level were not popular until the 1890s. Part of the problem was production of the proper glass, and the sealing of the gauge.
### Lamps
Head lights were originally oil lamps. These units were box\-shaped, and had an 18\- to 22\-inch parabolic reflector. They could cast a 1000\-foot beam, sufficient for low\-speed operation in darkness. An important improvement was introduced with the advent of lamps powered by carbide. Similar to the lamps used by miners, these lamps used the reaction of water and the mineral [calcium carbide](/wiki/Calcium_carbide "Calcium carbide") to produce [acetylene gas](/wiki/Acetylene_gas "Acetylene gas"), which burned with a bright light. Later, electric lamps and generators were fitted. C\&P tenders were also fitted with lamps on the rear, since the engines frequently operated in reverse on the various coal branches where they could not be turned.
|
[
"Manufacturing procedures\n------------------------",
"Locomotive manufacturing during this period was hard, heavy, dangerous work. It proceeded according to numerous 'rules of thumb' developed by the master mechanic over the years. Innovations were introduced slowly. There were continuous efforts to reduce costs, and increase performance. Weight reduction was not desirable, as weight\\-on\\-drivers contributed directly to tractive effort. Locomotive frames were usually riveted, built\\-up construction, of [wrought iron](/wiki/Wrought_iron \"Wrought iron\") and later, [steel](/wiki/Steel \"Steel\").",
"According to White, experience at the [Norris Locomotive Works](/wiki/Norris_Locomotive_Works \"Norris Locomotive Works\") showed that a team of 14 men could build a locomotive in 15 days. This was assuming the parts were on hand. A locomotive is a carefully integrated collection of a large number of specialty parts.",
"### Boilers",
"The typical [boiler](/wiki/Boiler \"Boiler\") was constructed of 5/16\\-inch wrought iron, starting as plate, and rolled to shape. The lap joints were single [riveted](/wiki/Rivet \"Rivet\"). There is a long way between watertight and steam tight. Later, double riveting, and reinforced butt joints were used. [Welding](/wiki/Welding \"Welding\") was not yet a developed technology, particularly for a pressure vessel. Boiler tubes were typically iron tubing of 2 inches diameter. They were lap welded, and reportedly difficult to flange.",
"#### Lagging",
"Boilers were covered, or [lagged](/wiki/Thermal_insulation \"Thermal insulation\"), to reduce heat loss, and increase efficiency. Wood slats were used originally. After 1900, [asbestos](/wiki/Asbestos \"Asbestos\") was a favored lagging material. It was common for the slabs of the mineral to be machined to fit. This produced large clouds of asbestos dust that is now known to be a major carcinogen, a significant cause of lung cancer. The use of dust masks, hearing protection, and safety glasses was unknown at the time. The boiler shops were a haze of asbestos dust.",
"#### Water feed",
"Millholland favored [Giffard's](/wiki/Henri_Giffard \"Henri Giffard\") water [injectors](/wiki/Injector \"Injector\"), based on the favorable experience with them on the Reading line. He was also an early advocate of [feedwater heaters](/wiki/Feedwater_heater \"Feedwater heater\"), using them as early as 1855\\. His designs have them on the right side, under the engine running board. They are about 10 feet long, and 8 inches in diameter. These are a visible clue to engines produced in Mount Savage. Millholland is also responsible for the development of the poppet throttle, originally retrofitted on Camel engines in Pennsylvania.",
"### Cylinders",
"The [cylinders](/wiki/Cylinder_%28engine%29 \"Cylinder (engine)\") were usually cast in halves, assembled, and bored to size. This represented the most complex and expensive operation of the whole locomotive assembly. In 1856, it was common for the boring operation to consume 2 days. The [pistons](/wiki/Piston \"Piston\") were [cast iron](/wiki/Cast_iron \"Cast iron\"), with fitted [brass](/wiki/Brass \"Brass\") [piston rings](/wiki/Piston_ring \"Piston ring\").",
"### Driving wheels",
"The [driving wheels](/wiki/Driving_wheel \"Driving wheel\") were typically cast iron, and [axles](/wiki/Axle \"Axle\") were usually 6\\-inch\\-diameter wrought iron. Driving wheels were fitted with replaceable [tires](/wiki/Railway_tires \"Railway tires\"). On the basis of his previous experience, Millholland favored cast\\-iron tires, shrunk onto the wheels. His father had experimented with steel tires around 1851–52, and they became standard later. Some early accidents on the C\\&P involved wheel failures. In 1872, Engine No. 11 broke a wheel below Frostburg, requiring the assistance of the work train, and delaying the pay car, according to the Frostburg Mining Journal.",
"### Connecting rods",
"Connecting rods were [cast](/wiki/Casting \"Casting\"), and [bearings](/wiki/Bearing_%28mechanical%29 \"Bearing (mechanical)\") were brass and/or [Babbitt metal](/wiki/Babbitt_%28metal%29 \"Babbitt (metal)\"). The early [lubricants](/wiki/Lubricant \"Lubricant\") were all animal fat based, and only suitable for low temperature applications. Later, [petroleum](/wiki/Petroleum \"Petroleum\") based lubricants provided much better performance.",
"### Gauges",
"Engine safety appliances were sparse. The [Bourdon gauge](/wiki/Bourdon_gauge \"Bourdon gauge\") for pressure readings was patented in 1849\\. A rival gauge was developed in 1857 by Wooten. Glass [sight gauges](/wiki/Sight_glass \"Sight glass\") for boiler water level were not popular until the 1890s. Part of the problem was production of the proper glass, and the sealing of the gauge.",
"### Lamps",
"Head lights were originally oil lamps. These units were box\\-shaped, and had an 18\\- to 22\\-inch parabolic reflector. They could cast a 1000\\-foot beam, sufficient for low\\-speed operation in darkness. An important improvement was introduced with the advent of lamps powered by carbide. Similar to the lamps used by miners, these lamps used the reaction of water and the mineral [calcium carbide](/wiki/Calcium_carbide \"Calcium carbide\") to produce [acetylene gas](/wiki/Acetylene_gas \"Acetylene gas\"), which burned with a bright light. Later, electric lamps and generators were fitted. C\\&P tenders were also fitted with lamps on the rear, since the engines frequently operated in reverse on the various coal branches where they could not be turned.",
""
] |
Background
----------
### Multiple entries
One\-hundred and eleven singles charted in the top 10 in 1968, with one\-hundred and three singles reaching their peak this year.
Nineteen artists scored multiple entries in the top 10 in 1968\. [The Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles "The Beatles") secured the record for most top 10 hits in 1968 with four hit singles.
[Manfred Mann](/wiki/Manfred_Mann "Manfred Mann") was one of a number of artists with two top\-ten entries, including the number\-one single "[The Mighty Quinn (Quinn the Eskimo)](/wiki/Quinn_the_Eskimo_%28Mighty_Quinn%29 "Quinn the Eskimo (Mighty Quinn)")". [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 "Amen Corner (band)"), [Bee Gees](/wiki/Bee_Gees "Bee Gees"), [Donovan](/wiki/Donovan "Donovan"), [Lulu](/wiki/Lulu_%28singer%29 "Lulu (singer)") and [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 "Status Quo (band)") were among the other artists who had multiple top 10 entries in 1968\.
### Chart debuts
Forty\-nine artists achieved their first top 10 single in 1968, either as a lead or featured artist. Of these, four went on to record another hit single that year: [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 "Amen Corner (band)"), [Don Partridge](/wiki/Don_Partridge "Don Partridge"), [Marmalade](/wiki/Marmalade_%28band%29 "Marmalade (band)") and [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 "Status Quo (band)"). [Love Affair](/wiki/Love_Affair_%28band%29 "Love Affair (band)") had two other entries in their breakthrough year.
The following table (collapsed on desktop site) does not include acts who had previously charted as part of a group and secured their first top 10 solo single.
| Artist | Number of top 10s | First entry | Chart position | Other entries |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Simon Dupree and the Big Sound](/wiki/Simon_Dupree_and_the_Big_Sound "Simon Dupree and the Big Sound") | 1 | "[Kites](/wiki/Kites_%28song%29 "Kites (song)")" | 9 | — |
| [Love Affair](/wiki/Love_Affair_%28band%29 "Love Affair (band)") | 3 | "[Everlasting Love](/wiki/Everlasting_Love "Everlasting Love")" | 1 | "[Rainbow Valley](/wiki/My_Rainbow_Valley "My Rainbow Valley")" (5\), "[A Day Without Love](/wiki/A_Day_Without_Love "A Day Without Love")" (6\) |
| [John Fred \& His Playboy Band](/wiki/John_Fred "John Fred") | 1 | "[Judy in Disguise (With Glasses)](/wiki/Judy_in_Disguise_%28With_Glasses%29 "Judy in Disguise (With Glasses)")" | 3 | — |
| [Plastic Penny](/wiki/Plastic_Penny "Plastic Penny") | 1 | "Everything I Am" | 6 | — |
| [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 "Amen Corner (band)") | 2 | "[Bend Me, Shape Me](/wiki/Bend_Me%2C_Shape_Me "Bend Me, Shape Me")" | 3 | "High in the Sky" (6\) |
| [Solomon King](/wiki/Solomon_King "Solomon King") | 1 | "[She Wears My Ring](/wiki/La_golondrina "La golondrina")" | 3 | — |
| [Brenton Wood](/wiki/Brenton_Wood "Brenton Wood") | 1 | "[Gimme Little Sign](/wiki/Gimme_Little_Sign "Gimme Little Sign")" | 8 | — |
| [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 "Status Quo (band)") | 2 | "[Pictures of Matchstick Men](/wiki/Pictures_of_Matchstick_Men "Pictures of Matchstick Men")" | 7 | "[Ice in the Sun](/wiki/Ice_in_the_Sun "Ice in the Sun")" (8\) |
| [Esther \& Abi Ofarim](/wiki/Esther_%26_Abi_Ofarim "Esther & Abi Ofarim") | 1 | "[Cinderella Rockefella](/wiki/Cinderella_Rockefella "Cinderella Rockefella")" | 1 | — |
| [Don Partridge](/wiki/Don_Partridge "Don Partridge") | 2 | "Rosie" | 4 | "Blue Eyes" (3\) |
| {{sortname\|The\|Lemon Pipers}} | 1 | "[Green Tambourine](/wiki/Green_Tambourine "Green Tambourine")" | 7 | — |
| [Otis Redding](/wiki/Otis_Redding "Otis Redding") | 1 | "[(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay](/wiki/%28Sittin%27_On%29_The_Dock_of_the_Bay "(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay")" | 3 | — |
| [John Rowles](/wiki/John_Rowles "John Rowles") | 1 | "[If I Only Had Time](/wiki/If_I_Only_Had_Time "If I Only Had Time")" | 3 | — |
| [1910 Fruitgum Company](/wiki/1910_Fruitgum_Company "1910 Fruitgum Company") | 1 | "[Simon Says](/wiki/Simon_Says_%281910_Fruitgum_Company_song%29 "Simon Says (1910 Fruitgum Company song)")" | 2 | — |
| [Honeybus](/wiki/Honeybus "Honeybus") | 1 | "[I Can't Let Maggie Go](/wiki/I_Can%27t_Let_Maggie_Go "I Can't Let Maggie Go")" | 8 | — |
| [Gary Puckett \& The Union Gap](/wiki/Gary_Puckett_%26_The_Union_Gap "Gary Puckett & The Union Gap") | 1 | "[Young Girl](/wiki/Young_Girl_%28song%29 "Young Girl (song)")" | 1 | "[Lady Willpower](/wiki/Lady_Willpower "Lady Willpower")" (5\) |
| [Bobby Goldsboro](/wiki/Bobby_Goldsboro "Bobby Goldsboro") | 1 | "[Honey](/wiki/Honey_%28Bobby_Goldsboro_song%29 "Honey (Bobby Goldsboro song)")" | 2 | — |
| [Jacky](/wiki/Jackie_Lee_%28Irish_singer%29 "Jackie Lee (Irish singer)") | 1 | "[White Horses](/wiki/The_White_Horses%23Theme_song "The White Horses#Theme song")" | 10 | — |
| [Julie Driscoll](/wiki/Julie_Driscoll_Tippetts "Julie Driscoll Tippetts") |1
"[This Wheel's on Fire](/wiki/This_Wheel%27s_on_Fire "This Wheel's on Fire")"
5
—
| [Brian Auger and the Trinity](/wiki/Brian_Auger_and_the_Trinity "Brian Auger and the Trinity") |
| {{sortname\|The\|Equals}} | 1 | "[Baby, Come Back](/wiki/Baby%2C_Come_Back_%28The_Equals_song%29 "Baby, Come Back (The Equals song)")" | 1 | — |
| [O. C. Smith](/wiki/O._C._Smith "O. C. Smith") | 1 | "[The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp](/wiki/The_Son_of_Hickory_Holler%27s_Tramp "The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp")" | 2 | — |
| [Marmalade](/wiki/Marmalade_%28band%29 "Marmalade (band)") | 2 | "[Lovin' Things](/wiki/Lovin%27_Things_%28song%29 "Lovin' Things (song)")" | 6 | "[Ob\-La\-Di, Ob\-La\-Da](/wiki/Ob-La-Di%2C_Ob-La-Da%23Marmalade "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da#Marmalade")" (1\) {{ref label\|Ob\-La\-Di\|A\|a}} |
| [Cupid's Inspiration](/wiki/Cupid%27s_Inspiration "Cupid's Inspiration") | 1 | "Yesterday Has Gone" | 4 | — |
| [Ohio Express](/wiki/Ohio_Express "Ohio Express") | 1 | "[Yummy Yummy Yummy](/wiki/Yummy_Yummy_Yummy "Yummy Yummy Yummy")" | 5 | — |
| [Tommy James and the Shondells](/wiki/Tommy_James_and_the_Shondells "Tommy James and the Shondells") | 1 | "[Mony Mony](/wiki/Mony_Mony "Mony Mony")" | 1 | — |
| [Richard Harris](/wiki/Richard_Harris "Richard Harris") | 1 | "[MacArthur Park](/wiki/MacArthur_Park_%28song%29 "MacArthur Park (song)")" | 4 | — |
| {{sortname\|The\|Crazy World of Arthur Brown}} | 1 | "[Fire](/wiki/Fire_%28Arthur_Brown_song%29 "Fire (Arthur Brown song)")" | 1 | — |
| [Sly and the Family Stone](/wiki/Sly_and_the_Family_Stone "Sly and the Family Stone") | 1 | "[Dance to the Music](/wiki/Dance_to_the_Music_%28song%29 "Dance to the Music (song)")" | 7 | — |
| [Johnny Nash](/wiki/Johnny_Nash "Johnny Nash") | 1 | "Hold Me Tight" | 5 | — |
| [Canned Heat](/wiki/Canned_Heat "Canned Heat") | 1 | "[On the Road Again](/wiki/On_the_Road_Again_%28Canned_Heat_song%29 "On the Road Again (Canned Heat song)")" | 8 | — |
| [Mary Hopkin](/wiki/Mary_Hopkin "Mary Hopkin") | 1 | "[Those Were the Days](/wiki/Those_Were_the_Days_%28song%29 "Those Were the Days (song)")" | 1 | — |
| {{sortname\|The\|Casuals}} | 1 | "Jesamine" | 2 | — |
| [Leapy Lee](/wiki/Leapy_Lee "Leapy Lee") | 1 | "[Little Arrows](/wiki/Little_Arrows "Little Arrows")" | 2 | — |
| [Mason Williams](/wiki/Mason_Williams "Mason Williams") | 1 | "[Classical Gas](/wiki/Classical_Gas "Classical Gas")" | 9 | — |
| [José Feliciano](/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Feliciano "José Feliciano") | 1 | "[Light My Fire](/wiki/Light_My_Fire "Light My Fire")" | 6 | — |
| [Hugo Montenegro](/wiki/Hugo_Montenegro "Hugo Montenegro") | 1 | "[The Good, the Bad and the Ugly](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly_%28theme%29 "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (theme)")" | 1 | — |
| [Joe Cocker](/wiki/Joe_Cocker "Joe Cocker") | 1 | "[With a Little Help from My Friends](/wiki/With_a_Little_Help_from_My_Friends%23Joe_Cocker_version "With a Little Help from My Friends#Joe Cocker version")" | 1 | — |
| [Barry Ryan](/wiki/Barry_Ryan_%28singer%29 "Barry Ryan (singer)") | 1 | "[Eloise](/wiki/Eloise_%28Paul_Ryan_song%29 "Eloise (Paul Ryan song)")" | 2 | — |
| {{sortname\|The\|Marbles\|The Marbles (duo)}} | 1 | "[Only One Woman](/wiki/Only_One_Woman "Only One Woman")" | 5 | — |
| {{sortname\|The\|Isley Brothers}} | 1 | "[This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak for You)](/wiki/This_Old_Heart_of_Mine_%28Is_Weak_for_You%29 "This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak for You)")" | 3 | — |
| [The Bandwagon](/wiki/Johnny_Johnson_and_the_Bandwagon "Johnny Johnson and the Bandwagon") | 1 | "[Breakin' Down the Walls of Heartache](/wiki/Breakin%27_Down_the_Walls_of_Heartache "Breakin' Down the Walls of Heartache")" | 4 | — |
| [Nina Simone](/wiki/Nina_Simone "Nina Simone") | 1 | "[Ain't Got No, I Got Life](/wiki/Ain%27t_Got_No%2C_I_Got_Life "Ain't Got No, I Got Life")"/"Do What You Gotta Do" | 2 | — |
| [Malcolm Roberts](/wiki/Malcolm_Roberts_%28singer%29 "Malcolm Roberts (singer)") | 1 | "May I Have the Next Dream with You" | 8 | — |
| [Bonzo Dog Doo\-Dah Band](/wiki/Bonzo_Dog_Doo-Dah_Band "Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band") | 1 | "[I'm the Urban Spaceman](/wiki/I%27m_the_Urban_Spaceman "I'm the Urban Spaceman")" | 5 | — |
| [Love Sculpture](/wiki/Love_Sculpture "Love Sculpture") | 1 | "[Sabre Dance](/wiki/Sabre_Dance "Sabre Dance")" | 5 | — |
| {{sortname\|The\|Gun\|The Gun (band)}} | 1 | "Race with the Devil" | 8 | — |
| [Fleetwood Mac](/wiki/Fleetwood_Mac "Fleetwood Mac") | 1 | "[Albatross](/wiki/Albatross_%28instrumental%29 "Albatross (instrumental)")" {{ref label\|Albatross\|B\|b}} | 1 | — |
### Songs from films
Original songs from various films entered the top 10 throughout the year. These included "[Mrs. Robinson](/wiki/Mrs._Robinson "Mrs. Robinson")" (from *[The Graduate](/wiki/The_Graduate "The Graduate")*) and "[Les Bicyclettes de Belsize](/wiki/Les_Bicyclettes_de_Belsize_%28song%29 "Les Bicyclettes de Belsize (song)")" (*[Les Bicyclettes de Belsize](/wiki/Les_Bicyclettes_de_Belsize "Les Bicyclettes de Belsize")*).
Additionally, "[The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo)](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly_%28theme%29 "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (theme)")" from the *[film of the same name](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly")*, originally recorded by [Ennio Morricone](/wiki/Ennio_Morricone "Ennio Morricone"), topped the chart when it was covered by [Hugo Montenegro](/wiki/Hugo_Montenegro "Hugo Montenegro").
### Best\-selling singles
Until 1970 there was no universally recognised year\-end best\-sellers list. However, in 2011 the Official Charts Company released a list of the best\-selling single of each year in chart history from 1952 to date. According to the list, "[Hey Jude](/wiki/Hey_Jude "Hey Jude")" by [The Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles "The Beatles") is officially recorded as the [biggest\-selling single](/wiki/List_of_best-selling_singles_by_year_in_the_United_Kingdom "List of best-selling singles by year in the United Kingdom") of 1968\.
|
[
"Background\n----------",
"### Multiple entries",
"One\\-hundred and eleven singles charted in the top 10 in 1968, with one\\-hundred and three singles reaching their peak this year.",
"Nineteen artists scored multiple entries in the top 10 in 1968\\. [The Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles \"The Beatles\") secured the record for most top 10 hits in 1968 with four hit singles.",
"[Manfred Mann](/wiki/Manfred_Mann \"Manfred Mann\") was one of a number of artists with two top\\-ten entries, including the number\\-one single \"[The Mighty Quinn (Quinn the Eskimo)](/wiki/Quinn_the_Eskimo_%28Mighty_Quinn%29 \"Quinn the Eskimo (Mighty Quinn)\")\". [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 \"Amen Corner (band)\"), [Bee Gees](/wiki/Bee_Gees \"Bee Gees\"), [Donovan](/wiki/Donovan \"Donovan\"), [Lulu](/wiki/Lulu_%28singer%29 \"Lulu (singer)\") and [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 \"Status Quo (band)\") were among the other artists who had multiple top 10 entries in 1968\\.",
"### Chart debuts",
"Forty\\-nine artists achieved their first top 10 single in 1968, either as a lead or featured artist. Of these, four went on to record another hit single that year: [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 \"Amen Corner (band)\"), [Don Partridge](/wiki/Don_Partridge \"Don Partridge\"), [Marmalade](/wiki/Marmalade_%28band%29 \"Marmalade (band)\") and [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 \"Status Quo (band)\"). [Love Affair](/wiki/Love_Affair_%28band%29 \"Love Affair (band)\") had two other entries in their breakthrough year.",
"The following table (collapsed on desktop site) does not include acts who had previously charted as part of a group and secured their first top 10 solo single.",
"",
"| Artist | Number of top 10s | First entry | Chart position | Other entries |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| [Simon Dupree and the Big Sound](/wiki/Simon_Dupree_and_the_Big_Sound \"Simon Dupree and the Big Sound\") | 1 | \"[Kites](/wiki/Kites_%28song%29 \"Kites (song)\")\" | 9 | — |\n| [Love Affair](/wiki/Love_Affair_%28band%29 \"Love Affair (band)\") | 3 | \"[Everlasting Love](/wiki/Everlasting_Love \"Everlasting Love\")\" | 1 | \"[Rainbow Valley](/wiki/My_Rainbow_Valley \"My Rainbow Valley\")\" (5\\), \"[A Day Without Love](/wiki/A_Day_Without_Love \"A Day Without Love\")\" (6\\) |\n| [John Fred \\& His Playboy Band](/wiki/John_Fred \"John Fred\") | 1 | \"[Judy in Disguise (With Glasses)](/wiki/Judy_in_Disguise_%28With_Glasses%29 \"Judy in Disguise (With Glasses)\")\" | 3 | — |\n| [Plastic Penny](/wiki/Plastic_Penny \"Plastic Penny\") | 1 | \"Everything I Am\" | 6 | — |\n| [Amen Corner](/wiki/Amen_Corner_%28band%29 \"Amen Corner (band)\") | 2 | \"[Bend Me, Shape Me](/wiki/Bend_Me%2C_Shape_Me \"Bend Me, Shape Me\")\" | 3 | \"High in the Sky\" (6\\) |\n| [Solomon King](/wiki/Solomon_King \"Solomon King\") | 1 | \"[She Wears My Ring](/wiki/La_golondrina \"La golondrina\")\" | 3 | — |\n| [Brenton Wood](/wiki/Brenton_Wood \"Brenton Wood\") | 1 | \"[Gimme Little Sign](/wiki/Gimme_Little_Sign \"Gimme Little Sign\")\" | 8 | — |\n| [Status Quo](/wiki/Status_Quo_%28band%29 \"Status Quo (band)\") | 2 | \"[Pictures of Matchstick Men](/wiki/Pictures_of_Matchstick_Men \"Pictures of Matchstick Men\")\" | 7 | \"[Ice in the Sun](/wiki/Ice_in_the_Sun \"Ice in the Sun\")\" (8\\) |\n| [Esther \\& Abi Ofarim](/wiki/Esther_%26_Abi_Ofarim \"Esther & Abi Ofarim\") | 1 | \"[Cinderella Rockefella](/wiki/Cinderella_Rockefella \"Cinderella Rockefella\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [Don Partridge](/wiki/Don_Partridge \"Don Partridge\") | 2 | \"Rosie\" | 4 | \"Blue Eyes\" (3\\) |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Lemon Pipers}} | 1 | \"[Green Tambourine](/wiki/Green_Tambourine \"Green Tambourine\")\" | 7 | — |\n| [Otis Redding](/wiki/Otis_Redding \"Otis Redding\") | 1 | \"[(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay](/wiki/%28Sittin%27_On%29_The_Dock_of_the_Bay \"(Sittin' On) The Dock of the Bay\")\" | 3 | — |\n| [John Rowles](/wiki/John_Rowles \"John Rowles\") | 1 | \"[If I Only Had Time](/wiki/If_I_Only_Had_Time \"If I Only Had Time\")\" | 3 | — |\n| [1910 Fruitgum Company](/wiki/1910_Fruitgum_Company \"1910 Fruitgum Company\") | 1 | \"[Simon Says](/wiki/Simon_Says_%281910_Fruitgum_Company_song%29 \"Simon Says (1910 Fruitgum Company song)\")\" | 2 | — |\n| [Honeybus](/wiki/Honeybus \"Honeybus\") | 1 | \"[I Can't Let Maggie Go](/wiki/I_Can%27t_Let_Maggie_Go \"I Can't Let Maggie Go\")\" | 8 | — |\n| [Gary Puckett \\& The Union Gap](/wiki/Gary_Puckett_%26_The_Union_Gap \"Gary Puckett & The Union Gap\") | 1 | \"[Young Girl](/wiki/Young_Girl_%28song%29 \"Young Girl (song)\")\" | 1 | \"[Lady Willpower](/wiki/Lady_Willpower \"Lady Willpower\")\" (5\\) |\n| [Bobby Goldsboro](/wiki/Bobby_Goldsboro \"Bobby Goldsboro\") | 1 | \"[Honey](/wiki/Honey_%28Bobby_Goldsboro_song%29 \"Honey (Bobby Goldsboro song)\")\" | 2 | — |\n| [Jacky](/wiki/Jackie_Lee_%28Irish_singer%29 \"Jackie Lee (Irish singer)\") | 1 | \"[White Horses](/wiki/The_White_Horses%23Theme_song \"The White Horses#Theme song\")\" | 10 | — |\n| [Julie Driscoll](/wiki/Julie_Driscoll_Tippetts \"Julie Driscoll Tippetts\") |1",
"\"[This Wheel's on Fire](/wiki/This_Wheel%27s_on_Fire \"This Wheel's on Fire\")\"",
"5",
"—",
"| [Brian Auger and the Trinity](/wiki/Brian_Auger_and_the_Trinity \"Brian Auger and the Trinity\") |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Equals}} | 1 | \"[Baby, Come Back](/wiki/Baby%2C_Come_Back_%28The_Equals_song%29 \"Baby, Come Back (The Equals song)\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [O. C. Smith](/wiki/O._C._Smith \"O. C. Smith\") | 1 | \"[The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp](/wiki/The_Son_of_Hickory_Holler%27s_Tramp \"The Son of Hickory Holler's Tramp\")\" | 2 | — |\n| [Marmalade](/wiki/Marmalade_%28band%29 \"Marmalade (band)\") | 2 | \"[Lovin' Things](/wiki/Lovin%27_Things_%28song%29 \"Lovin' Things (song)\")\" | 6 | \"[Ob\\-La\\-Di, Ob\\-La\\-Da](/wiki/Ob-La-Di%2C_Ob-La-Da%23Marmalade \"Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da#Marmalade\")\" (1\\) {{ref label\\|Ob\\-La\\-Di\\|A\\|a}} |\n| [Cupid's Inspiration](/wiki/Cupid%27s_Inspiration \"Cupid's Inspiration\") | 1 | \"Yesterday Has Gone\" | 4 | — |\n| [Ohio Express](/wiki/Ohio_Express \"Ohio Express\") | 1 | \"[Yummy Yummy Yummy](/wiki/Yummy_Yummy_Yummy \"Yummy Yummy Yummy\")\" | 5 | — |\n| [Tommy James and the Shondells](/wiki/Tommy_James_and_the_Shondells \"Tommy James and the Shondells\") | 1 | \"[Mony Mony](/wiki/Mony_Mony \"Mony Mony\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [Richard Harris](/wiki/Richard_Harris \"Richard Harris\") | 1 | \"[MacArthur Park](/wiki/MacArthur_Park_%28song%29 \"MacArthur Park (song)\")\" | 4 | — |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Crazy World of Arthur Brown}} | 1 | \"[Fire](/wiki/Fire_%28Arthur_Brown_song%29 \"Fire (Arthur Brown song)\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [Sly and the Family Stone](/wiki/Sly_and_the_Family_Stone \"Sly and the Family Stone\") | 1 | \"[Dance to the Music](/wiki/Dance_to_the_Music_%28song%29 \"Dance to the Music (song)\")\" | 7 | — |\n| [Johnny Nash](/wiki/Johnny_Nash \"Johnny Nash\") | 1 | \"Hold Me Tight\" | 5 | — |\n| [Canned Heat](/wiki/Canned_Heat \"Canned Heat\") | 1 | \"[On the Road Again](/wiki/On_the_Road_Again_%28Canned_Heat_song%29 \"On the Road Again (Canned Heat song)\")\" | 8 | — |\n| [Mary Hopkin](/wiki/Mary_Hopkin \"Mary Hopkin\") | 1 | \"[Those Were the Days](/wiki/Those_Were_the_Days_%28song%29 \"Those Were the Days (song)\")\" | 1 | — |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Casuals}} | 1 | \"Jesamine\" | 2 | — |\n| [Leapy Lee](/wiki/Leapy_Lee \"Leapy Lee\") | 1 | \"[Little Arrows](/wiki/Little_Arrows \"Little Arrows\")\" | 2 | — |\n| [Mason Williams](/wiki/Mason_Williams \"Mason Williams\") | 1 | \"[Classical Gas](/wiki/Classical_Gas \"Classical Gas\")\" | 9 | — |\n| [José Feliciano](/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Feliciano \"José Feliciano\") | 1 | \"[Light My Fire](/wiki/Light_My_Fire \"Light My Fire\")\" | 6 | — |\n| [Hugo Montenegro](/wiki/Hugo_Montenegro \"Hugo Montenegro\") | 1 | \"[The Good, the Bad and the Ugly](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly_%28theme%29 \"The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (theme)\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [Joe Cocker](/wiki/Joe_Cocker \"Joe Cocker\") | 1 | \"[With a Little Help from My Friends](/wiki/With_a_Little_Help_from_My_Friends%23Joe_Cocker_version \"With a Little Help from My Friends#Joe Cocker version\")\" | 1 | — |\n| [Barry Ryan](/wiki/Barry_Ryan_%28singer%29 \"Barry Ryan (singer)\") | 1 | \"[Eloise](/wiki/Eloise_%28Paul_Ryan_song%29 \"Eloise (Paul Ryan song)\")\" | 2 | — |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Marbles\\|The Marbles (duo)}} | 1 | \"[Only One Woman](/wiki/Only_One_Woman \"Only One Woman\")\" | 5 | — |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Isley Brothers}} | 1 | \"[This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak for You)](/wiki/This_Old_Heart_of_Mine_%28Is_Weak_for_You%29 \"This Old Heart of Mine (Is Weak for You)\")\" | 3 | — |\n| [The Bandwagon](/wiki/Johnny_Johnson_and_the_Bandwagon \"Johnny Johnson and the Bandwagon\") | 1 | \"[Breakin' Down the Walls of Heartache](/wiki/Breakin%27_Down_the_Walls_of_Heartache \"Breakin' Down the Walls of Heartache\")\" | 4 | — |\n| [Nina Simone](/wiki/Nina_Simone \"Nina Simone\") | 1 | \"[Ain't Got No, I Got Life](/wiki/Ain%27t_Got_No%2C_I_Got_Life \"Ain't Got No, I Got Life\")\"/\"Do What You Gotta Do\" | 2 | — |\n| [Malcolm Roberts](/wiki/Malcolm_Roberts_%28singer%29 \"Malcolm Roberts (singer)\") | 1 | \"May I Have the Next Dream with You\" | 8 | — |\n| [Bonzo Dog Doo\\-Dah Band](/wiki/Bonzo_Dog_Doo-Dah_Band \"Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band\") | 1 | \"[I'm the Urban Spaceman](/wiki/I%27m_the_Urban_Spaceman \"I'm the Urban Spaceman\")\" | 5 | — |\n| [Love Sculpture](/wiki/Love_Sculpture \"Love Sculpture\") | 1 | \"[Sabre Dance](/wiki/Sabre_Dance \"Sabre Dance\")\" | 5 | — |\n| {{sortname\\|The\\|Gun\\|The Gun (band)}} | 1 | \"Race with the Devil\" | 8 | — |\n| [Fleetwood Mac](/wiki/Fleetwood_Mac \"Fleetwood Mac\") | 1 | \"[Albatross](/wiki/Albatross_%28instrumental%29 \"Albatross (instrumental)\")\" {{ref label\\|Albatross\\|B\\|b}} | 1 | — |",
"### Songs from films",
"Original songs from various films entered the top 10 throughout the year. These included \"[Mrs. Robinson](/wiki/Mrs._Robinson \"Mrs. Robinson\")\" (from *[The Graduate](/wiki/The_Graduate \"The Graduate\")*) and \"[Les Bicyclettes de Belsize](/wiki/Les_Bicyclettes_de_Belsize_%28song%29 \"Les Bicyclettes de Belsize (song)\")\" (*[Les Bicyclettes de Belsize](/wiki/Les_Bicyclettes_de_Belsize \"Les Bicyclettes de Belsize\")*).",
"Additionally, \"[The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo)](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly_%28theme%29 \"The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (theme)\")\" from the *[film of the same name](/wiki/The_Good%2C_the_Bad_and_the_Ugly \"The Good, the Bad and the Ugly\")*, originally recorded by [Ennio Morricone](/wiki/Ennio_Morricone \"Ennio Morricone\"), topped the chart when it was covered by [Hugo Montenegro](/wiki/Hugo_Montenegro \"Hugo Montenegro\").",
"### Best\\-selling singles",
"Until 1970 there was no universally recognised year\\-end best\\-sellers list. However, in 2011 the Official Charts Company released a list of the best\\-selling single of each year in chart history from 1952 to date. According to the list, \"[Hey Jude](/wiki/Hey_Jude \"Hey Jude\")\" by [The Beatles](/wiki/The_Beatles \"The Beatles\") is officially recorded as the [biggest\\-selling single](/wiki/List_of_best-selling_singles_by_year_in_the_United_Kingdom \"List of best-selling singles by year in the United Kingdom\") of 1968\\.",
""
] |
Geographic characteristics and early history
--------------------------------------------
[thumb\|upright\=1\.2\|A dust storm approaches [Stratford, Texas](/wiki/Stratford%2C_Texas "Stratford, Texas"), in 1935\.](/wiki/File:Dust_storm_approaching_Stratford%2C_Texas.jpg "Dust storm approaching Stratford, Texas.jpg")
The Dust Bowl area lies principally west of the [100th meridian](/wiki/100th_meridian_west "100th meridian west") on the [High Plains](/wiki/High_Plains_%28United_States%29 "High Plains (United States)"), characterized by plains that vary from rolling in the north to flat in the [Llano Estacado](/wiki/Llano_Estacado "Llano Estacado"). Elevation ranges from {{cvt\|2500\|ft\|m}} in the east to {{cvt\|6000\|ft\|m}} at the base of the [Rocky Mountains](/wiki/Rocky_Mountains "Rocky Mountains"). The area is [semiarid](/wiki/Semiarid "Semiarid"), receiving less than {{cvt\|20\|in\|mm}} of rain annually; this rainfall supports the [shortgrass prairie](/wiki/Shortgrass_prairie "Shortgrass prairie") biome originally present in the area. The region is also prone to extended drought, alternating with unusual wetness of equivalent duration.{{cite web \|date\=February 2000 \|url\=http://ccc.atmos.colostate.edu/pdfs/ahistoryofdrought.pdf \|title\=A History of Drought in Colorado: lessons learned and what lies ahead \|publisher\=Colorado Water Resources Research Institute \|access\-date\=December 6, 2007 \|archive\-date\=August 21, 2011 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110821222601/http://ccc.atmos.colostate.edu/pdfs/ahistoryofdrought.pdf \|url\-status\=live }} During wet years, the rich soil provides bountiful agricultural output, but crops fail during dry years. The region is also subject to high winds.{{cite web \|date\=August 27, 1936 \|url\=http://newdeal.feri.org/hopkins/hop27\.htm \|title\=A Report of the Great Plains Area Drought Committee \|publisher\=Hopkins Papers, Franklin D. Roosevelt Library \|access\-date\=December 6, 2007 \|archive\-date\=November 11, 2007 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20071111012245/http://newdeal.feri.org/hopkins/hop27\.htm \|url\-status\=live }} During early European and American exploration of the [Great Plains](/wiki/Great_Plains "Great Plains"), this region was thought unsuitable for European\-style agriculture; explorers called it the [Great American Desert](/wiki/Great_American_Desert "Great American Desert"). The lack of surface water and timber made the region less attractive than other areas for [pioneer settlement](/wiki/Plantation_%28settlement_or_colony%29 "Plantation (settlement or colony)") and agriculture.
The federal government encouraged settlement and development of the Plains for agriculture via the [Homestead Act of 1862](/wiki/Homestead_Act_of_1862 "Homestead Act of 1862"), offering settlers "[quarter section](/wiki/Section_%28United_States_land_surveying%29 "Section (United States land surveying)")" {{cvt\|160\|acre\|adj\=on}} plots. With the end of the [Civil War](/wiki/American_Civil_War "American Civil War") in 1865 and the completion of the [first transcontinental railroad](/wiki/First_transcontinental_railroad "First transcontinental railroad") in 1869, waves of new migrants and immigrants reached the Great Plains and greatly increased the acreage under cultivation.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.planning.org/25anniversary/planning/1987dec.htm \|title\=The Great Plains: from dust to dust \|publisher\=Planning Magazine \|date\=December 1987\| access\-date \= December 6, 2007 \|archive\-url \= https://web.archive.org/web/20071006015832/http://www.planning.org/25anniversary/planning/1987dec.htm \|archive\-date \= October 6, 2007}}{{cite book \|year\=1995 \|url\=http://www.unu.edu/unupress/unupbooks/uu14re/uu14re00\.htm \|title\=Regions at Risk: a comparison of threatened environments \|publisher\=United Nations University Press \|access\-date\=December 6, 2007 \|archive\-date\=December 16, 2007 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20071216233621/http://www.unu.edu/unupress/unupbooks/uu14re/uu14re00\.htm \|url\-status\=live }} An unusually wet period in the Great Plains [mistakenly led](/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation "Correlation does not imply causation") settlers and the federal government to believe that "[rain follows the plow](/wiki/Rain_follows_the_plow "Rain follows the plow")" (a popular phrase among real estate promoters) and that the region's climate had permanently changed.{{cite book \|year\=2006 \|url\=http://drought.unl.edu/DroughtBasics/DustBowl/DroughtintheDustBowlYears.aspx \|title\=Drought in the Dust Bowl Years \|publisher\=National Drought Mitigation Center \|location\=US \|access\-date\=December 6, 2007 \|archive\-date\=January 24, 2016 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20160124105928/http://drought.unl.edu/DroughtBasics/DustBowl/DroughtintheDustBowlYears.aspx \|url\-status\=live }} While initial agricultural endeavors were primarily [cattle ranching](/wiki/Cattle_ranch "Cattle ranch"), the harsh winters' adverse effect on the cattle, beginning in 1886, a short drought in 1890, and general [overgrazing](/wiki/Overgrazing "Overgrazing"), led many landowners to increase the amount of land under cultivation.
Recognizing the challenge of cultivating marginal arid land, the U.S. government expanded on the {{cvt\|160\|acre}} offered under the Homestead Act, granting {{cvt\|640\|acre}} to homesteaders in western Nebraska under the [Kinkaid Act](/wiki/Kinkaid_Act "Kinkaid Act") (1904\) and {{cvt\|320\|acres}} elsewhere in the Great Plains under the [Enlarged Homestead Act of 1909](/wiki/Enlarged_Homestead_Act_of_1909 "Enlarged Homestead Act of 1909"). Waves of European settlers arrived in the plains at the beginning of the 20th century. A return of unusually wet weather seemingly confirmed a previously held opinion that the "formerly" semiarid area could support large\-scale agriculture. At the same time, technological improvements such as mechanized plowing and mechanized harvesting made it possible to operate larger properties without increasing labor costs.
With insufficient understanding of the ecology of the plains, farmers had conducted extensive [deep plowing](/wiki/Deep_plowing "Deep plowing") of the [Great Plains](/wiki/Great_Plains "Great Plains")' virgin [topsoil](/wiki/Topsoil "Topsoil") during the previous decade; this displaced the native, deep\-rooted [grasses](/wiki/Grass "Grass") that normally trapped soil and moisture even during periods of [drought](/wiki/Drought "Drought") and high winds. The rapid mechanization of farm equipment, especially small gasoline tractors, and widespread use of the [combine harvester](/wiki/Combine_harvester "Combine harvester") contributed to farmers' decisions to convert arid grassland (much of which received no more than {{convert\|10\|in\|mm}} of precipitation per year) to cultivated cropland.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general\-article/dustbowl\-drought/ \|title\=The American Experience: Drought \|publisher\=PBS \|access\-date\=March 15, 2015 \|archive\-date\=March 10, 2015 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150310174144/http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general\-article/dustbowl\-drought/ \|url\-status\=live }} During the drought of the 1930s, the unanchored soil turned to [dust](/wiki/Dust "Dust"), which prevailing winds blew away in huge clouds that sometimes blackened the sky. These choking billows of dust{{snd}}named "black blizzards" or "black rollers"{{snd}}traveled cross\-country, reaching as far as the [East Coast](/wiki/East_Coast_of_the_United_States "East Coast of the United States") and striking such cities as [New York City](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City") and [Washington, D.C.](/wiki/Washington%2C_D.C. "Washington, D.C.") On the plains, they often reduced visibility to {{convert\|3\|ft\|m\|0\|spell\=in}} or less. [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press "Associated Press") reporter Robert E. Geiger happened to be in [Boise City, Oklahoma](/wiki/Boise_City%2C_Oklahoma "Boise City, Oklahoma"), to witness the "[Black Sunday](/wiki/Black_Sunday_%28storm%29 "Black Sunday (storm)")" black blizzards of April 14, 1935; Edward Stanley, the Kansas City news editor of the Associated Press, coined the term "Dust Bowl" while rewriting Geiger's news story.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/?n\=blacksunday \|title\=The Black Sunday Dust Storm of 14 April 1935 \|publisher\=\[\[National Weather Service]] \|location\=\[\[Norman, Oklahoma]] \|date\=August 24, 2010 \|access\-date\=November 23, 2012 \|archive\-date\=November 25, 2012 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20121125235449/http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/?n\=blacksunday \|url\-status\=live }}{{cite book \|last\=Mencken \|first\=H. L. \|title\=The American Language \|year\=1979 \|publisher\=Alfred A. Knopf \|location\=New York \|isbn\=978\-0\-394\-40075\-4 \|edition\=One\-Volume Abridged \|editor\=Raven I. McDavid Jr. \|page\=206}}
The term "the Dust Bowl" originally referred to the geographical area affected by the dust, but today it usually refers to the event itself (the term "Dirty Thirties" is also sometimes used). The drought and erosion of the Dust Bowl affected {{convert\|100\|e6acre\|km2\|abbr\=unit}} that centered on the [Texas Panhandle](/wiki/Texas_Panhandle "Texas Panhandle") and [Oklahoma Panhandle](/wiki/Oklahoma_Panhandle "Oklahoma Panhandle") and touched adjacent sections of New Mexico, Colorado, and Kansas.{{cite book \|last\=Hakim \|first\=Joy \|title\=A History of Us: War, Peace and all that Jazz \|publisher\=Oxford University Press \|year\=1995 \|location\=New York \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=kwke\_hhx8Z8C\&pg\=PP1 \|isbn\=978\-0\-19\-509514\-2 \|access\-date\=December 22, 2018 \|archive\-date\=April 29, 2021 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210429050637/https://books.google.com/books?id\=kwke\_hhx8Z8C\&pg\=PP1 \|url\-status\=live }}{{Page needed\|date\=February 2011}} The Dust Bowl forced tens of thousands of poverty\-stricken families, who were unable to pay mortgages or grow crops, to abandon their farms, and losses reached $25 million per day by 1936 (equivalent to ${{inflation\|US\|25\|1936\|r\=\-1}} million in {{Inflation/year\|US}}).{{Inflation\-fn\|US}}{{Cite AV media \|title\=Bust: America – The Story of Us \|year\=2010 \|oclc\=783245601 \|publisher\=A\&E Television Networks}} Many of these families, often called "[Okies](/wiki/Okie "Okie")" because many of them came from Oklahoma, migrated to [California](/wiki/California "California") and other states to find that the [Great Depression](/wiki/Great_Depression "Great Depression") had rendered economic conditions there little better than those they had left.
The combined effects of [World War I](/wiki/World_War_I "World War I") and the disruption of the [Russian Revolution](/wiki/Russian_Revolution "Russian Revolution"), which decreased the supply of wheat and other commodity crops, increased agricultural prices; this demand encouraged farmers to dramatically increase cultivation. For example, in the [Llano Estacado](/wiki/Llano_Estacado "Llano Estacado") of [eastern New Mexico](/wiki/Eastern_New_Mexico "Eastern New Mexico") and northwestern [Texas](/wiki/Texas "Texas"), the area of farmland doubled between 1900 and 1920, then tripled between 1925 and 1930\. The agricultural methods farmers favored during this period created the conditions for large\-scale [erosion](/wiki/Erosion "Erosion") under certain environmental conditions. The widespread conversion of the land by deep plowing and other soil preparation methods to enable agriculture eliminated the native grasses that held the soil in place and helped retain moisture during dry periods. Furthermore, [cotton](/wiki/Cotton "Cotton") farmers left fields bare during the winter, when winds in the High Plains are highest, and [burned](/wiki/Stubble_burning "Stubble burning") the [stubble](/wiki/Crop_residue "Crop residue") as a means to control weeds before planting, thereby depriving the soil of organic nutrients and surface vegetation.
|
[
"Geographic characteristics and early history\n--------------------------------------------",
"[thumb\\|upright\\=1\\.2\\|A dust storm approaches [Stratford, Texas](/wiki/Stratford%2C_Texas \"Stratford, Texas\"), in 1935\\.](/wiki/File:Dust_storm_approaching_Stratford%2C_Texas.jpg \"Dust storm approaching Stratford, Texas.jpg\")",
"The Dust Bowl area lies principally west of the [100th meridian](/wiki/100th_meridian_west \"100th meridian west\") on the [High Plains](/wiki/High_Plains_%28United_States%29 \"High Plains (United States)\"), characterized by plains that vary from rolling in the north to flat in the [Llano Estacado](/wiki/Llano_Estacado \"Llano Estacado\"). Elevation ranges from {{cvt\\|2500\\|ft\\|m}} in the east to {{cvt\\|6000\\|ft\\|m}} at the base of the [Rocky Mountains](/wiki/Rocky_Mountains \"Rocky Mountains\"). The area is [semiarid](/wiki/Semiarid \"Semiarid\"), receiving less than {{cvt\\|20\\|in\\|mm}} of rain annually; this rainfall supports the [shortgrass prairie](/wiki/Shortgrass_prairie \"Shortgrass prairie\") biome originally present in the area. The region is also prone to extended drought, alternating with unusual wetness of equivalent duration.{{cite web \\|date\\=February 2000 \\|url\\=http://ccc.atmos.colostate.edu/pdfs/ahistoryofdrought.pdf \\|title\\=A History of Drought in Colorado: lessons learned and what lies ahead \\|publisher\\=Colorado Water Resources Research Institute \\|access\\-date\\=December 6, 2007 \\|archive\\-date\\=August 21, 2011 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110821222601/http://ccc.atmos.colostate.edu/pdfs/ahistoryofdrought.pdf \\|url\\-status\\=live }} During wet years, the rich soil provides bountiful agricultural output, but crops fail during dry years. The region is also subject to high winds.{{cite web \\|date\\=August 27, 1936 \\|url\\=http://newdeal.feri.org/hopkins/hop27\\.htm \\|title\\=A Report of the Great Plains Area Drought Committee \\|publisher\\=Hopkins Papers, Franklin D. Roosevelt Library \\|access\\-date\\=December 6, 2007 \\|archive\\-date\\=November 11, 2007 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20071111012245/http://newdeal.feri.org/hopkins/hop27\\.htm \\|url\\-status\\=live }} During early European and American exploration of the [Great Plains](/wiki/Great_Plains \"Great Plains\"), this region was thought unsuitable for European\\-style agriculture; explorers called it the [Great American Desert](/wiki/Great_American_Desert \"Great American Desert\"). The lack of surface water and timber made the region less attractive than other areas for [pioneer settlement](/wiki/Plantation_%28settlement_or_colony%29 \"Plantation (settlement or colony)\") and agriculture.",
"The federal government encouraged settlement and development of the Plains for agriculture via the [Homestead Act of 1862](/wiki/Homestead_Act_of_1862 \"Homestead Act of 1862\"), offering settlers \"[quarter section](/wiki/Section_%28United_States_land_surveying%29 \"Section (United States land surveying)\")\" {{cvt\\|160\\|acre\\|adj\\=on}} plots. With the end of the [Civil War](/wiki/American_Civil_War \"American Civil War\") in 1865 and the completion of the [first transcontinental railroad](/wiki/First_transcontinental_railroad \"First transcontinental railroad\") in 1869, waves of new migrants and immigrants reached the Great Plains and greatly increased the acreage under cultivation.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.planning.org/25anniversary/planning/1987dec.htm \\|title\\=The Great Plains: from dust to dust \\|publisher\\=Planning Magazine \\|date\\=December 1987\\| access\\-date \\= December 6, 2007 \\|archive\\-url \\= https://web.archive.org/web/20071006015832/http://www.planning.org/25anniversary/planning/1987dec.htm \\|archive\\-date \\= October 6, 2007}}{{cite book \\|year\\=1995 \\|url\\=http://www.unu.edu/unupress/unupbooks/uu14re/uu14re00\\.htm \\|title\\=Regions at Risk: a comparison of threatened environments \\|publisher\\=United Nations University Press \\|access\\-date\\=December 6, 2007 \\|archive\\-date\\=December 16, 2007 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20071216233621/http://www.unu.edu/unupress/unupbooks/uu14re/uu14re00\\.htm \\|url\\-status\\=live }} An unusually wet period in the Great Plains [mistakenly led](/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation \"Correlation does not imply causation\") settlers and the federal government to believe that \"[rain follows the plow](/wiki/Rain_follows_the_plow \"Rain follows the plow\")\" (a popular phrase among real estate promoters) and that the region's climate had permanently changed.{{cite book \\|year\\=2006 \\|url\\=http://drought.unl.edu/DroughtBasics/DustBowl/DroughtintheDustBowlYears.aspx \\|title\\=Drought in the Dust Bowl Years \\|publisher\\=National Drought Mitigation Center \\|location\\=US \\|access\\-date\\=December 6, 2007 \\|archive\\-date\\=January 24, 2016 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20160124105928/http://drought.unl.edu/DroughtBasics/DustBowl/DroughtintheDustBowlYears.aspx \\|url\\-status\\=live }} While initial agricultural endeavors were primarily [cattle ranching](/wiki/Cattle_ranch \"Cattle ranch\"), the harsh winters' adverse effect on the cattle, beginning in 1886, a short drought in 1890, and general [overgrazing](/wiki/Overgrazing \"Overgrazing\"), led many landowners to increase the amount of land under cultivation.",
"Recognizing the challenge of cultivating marginal arid land, the U.S. government expanded on the {{cvt\\|160\\|acre}} offered under the Homestead Act, granting {{cvt\\|640\\|acre}} to homesteaders in western Nebraska under the [Kinkaid Act](/wiki/Kinkaid_Act \"Kinkaid Act\") (1904\\) and {{cvt\\|320\\|acres}} elsewhere in the Great Plains under the [Enlarged Homestead Act of 1909](/wiki/Enlarged_Homestead_Act_of_1909 \"Enlarged Homestead Act of 1909\"). Waves of European settlers arrived in the plains at the beginning of the 20th century. A return of unusually wet weather seemingly confirmed a previously held opinion that the \"formerly\" semiarid area could support large\\-scale agriculture. At the same time, technological improvements such as mechanized plowing and mechanized harvesting made it possible to operate larger properties without increasing labor costs.",
"With insufficient understanding of the ecology of the plains, farmers had conducted extensive [deep plowing](/wiki/Deep_plowing \"Deep plowing\") of the [Great Plains](/wiki/Great_Plains \"Great Plains\")' virgin [topsoil](/wiki/Topsoil \"Topsoil\") during the previous decade; this displaced the native, deep\\-rooted [grasses](/wiki/Grass \"Grass\") that normally trapped soil and moisture even during periods of [drought](/wiki/Drought \"Drought\") and high winds. The rapid mechanization of farm equipment, especially small gasoline tractors, and widespread use of the [combine harvester](/wiki/Combine_harvester \"Combine harvester\") contributed to farmers' decisions to convert arid grassland (much of which received no more than {{convert\\|10\\|in\\|mm}} of precipitation per year) to cultivated cropland.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general\\-article/dustbowl\\-drought/ \\|title\\=The American Experience: Drought \\|publisher\\=PBS \\|access\\-date\\=March 15, 2015 \\|archive\\-date\\=March 10, 2015 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150310174144/http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general\\-article/dustbowl\\-drought/ \\|url\\-status\\=live }} During the drought of the 1930s, the unanchored soil turned to [dust](/wiki/Dust \"Dust\"), which prevailing winds blew away in huge clouds that sometimes blackened the sky. These choking billows of dust{{snd}}named \"black blizzards\" or \"black rollers\"{{snd}}traveled cross\\-country, reaching as far as the [East Coast](/wiki/East_Coast_of_the_United_States \"East Coast of the United States\") and striking such cities as [New York City](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\") and [Washington, D.C.](/wiki/Washington%2C_D.C. \"Washington, D.C.\") On the plains, they often reduced visibility to {{convert\\|3\\|ft\\|m\\|0\\|spell\\=in}} or less. [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press \"Associated Press\") reporter Robert E. Geiger happened to be in [Boise City, Oklahoma](/wiki/Boise_City%2C_Oklahoma \"Boise City, Oklahoma\"), to witness the \"[Black Sunday](/wiki/Black_Sunday_%28storm%29 \"Black Sunday (storm)\")\" black blizzards of April 14, 1935; Edward Stanley, the Kansas City news editor of the Associated Press, coined the term \"Dust Bowl\" while rewriting Geiger's news story.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/?n\\=blacksunday \\|title\\=The Black Sunday Dust Storm of 14 April 1935 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[National Weather Service]] \\|location\\=\\[\\[Norman, Oklahoma]] \\|date\\=August 24, 2010 \\|access\\-date\\=November 23, 2012 \\|archive\\-date\\=November 25, 2012 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20121125235449/http://www.srh.noaa.gov/oun/?n\\=blacksunday \\|url\\-status\\=live }}{{cite book \\|last\\=Mencken \\|first\\=H. L. \\|title\\=The American Language \\|year\\=1979 \\|publisher\\=Alfred A. Knopf \\|location\\=New York \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-394\\-40075\\-4 \\|edition\\=One\\-Volume Abridged \\|editor\\=Raven I. McDavid Jr. \\|page\\=206}}",
"The term \"the Dust Bowl\" originally referred to the geographical area affected by the dust, but today it usually refers to the event itself (the term \"Dirty Thirties\" is also sometimes used). The drought and erosion of the Dust Bowl affected {{convert\\|100\\|e6acre\\|km2\\|abbr\\=unit}} that centered on the [Texas Panhandle](/wiki/Texas_Panhandle \"Texas Panhandle\") and [Oklahoma Panhandle](/wiki/Oklahoma_Panhandle \"Oklahoma Panhandle\") and touched adjacent sections of New Mexico, Colorado, and Kansas.{{cite book \\|last\\=Hakim \\|first\\=Joy \\|title\\=A History of Us: War, Peace and all that Jazz \\|publisher\\=Oxford University Press \\|year\\=1995 \\|location\\=New York \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=kwke\\_hhx8Z8C\\&pg\\=PP1 \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-19\\-509514\\-2 \\|access\\-date\\=December 22, 2018 \\|archive\\-date\\=April 29, 2021 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210429050637/https://books.google.com/books?id\\=kwke\\_hhx8Z8C\\&pg\\=PP1 \\|url\\-status\\=live }}{{Page needed\\|date\\=February 2011}} The Dust Bowl forced tens of thousands of poverty\\-stricken families, who were unable to pay mortgages or grow crops, to abandon their farms, and losses reached $25 million per day by 1936 (equivalent to ${{inflation\\|US\\|25\\|1936\\|r\\=\\-1}} million in {{Inflation/year\\|US}}).{{Inflation\\-fn\\|US}}{{Cite AV media \\|title\\=Bust: America – The Story of Us \\|year\\=2010 \\|oclc\\=783245601 \\|publisher\\=A\\&E Television Networks}} Many of these families, often called \"[Okies](/wiki/Okie \"Okie\")\" because many of them came from Oklahoma, migrated to [California](/wiki/California \"California\") and other states to find that the [Great Depression](/wiki/Great_Depression \"Great Depression\") had rendered economic conditions there little better than those they had left.",
"The combined effects of [World War I](/wiki/World_War_I \"World War I\") and the disruption of the [Russian Revolution](/wiki/Russian_Revolution \"Russian Revolution\"), which decreased the supply of wheat and other commodity crops, increased agricultural prices; this demand encouraged farmers to dramatically increase cultivation. For example, in the [Llano Estacado](/wiki/Llano_Estacado \"Llano Estacado\") of [eastern New Mexico](/wiki/Eastern_New_Mexico \"Eastern New Mexico\") and northwestern [Texas](/wiki/Texas \"Texas\"), the area of farmland doubled between 1900 and 1920, then tripled between 1925 and 1930\\. The agricultural methods farmers favored during this period created the conditions for large\\-scale [erosion](/wiki/Erosion \"Erosion\") under certain environmental conditions. The widespread conversion of the land by deep plowing and other soil preparation methods to enable agriculture eliminated the native grasses that held the soil in place and helped retain moisture during dry periods. Furthermore, [cotton](/wiki/Cotton \"Cotton\") farmers left fields bare during the winter, when winds in the High Plains are highest, and [burned](/wiki/Stubble_burning \"Stubble burning\") the [stubble](/wiki/Crop_residue \"Crop residue\") as a means to control weeds before planting, thereby depriving the soil of organic nutrients and surface vegetation.",
""
] |
Life and work
-------------
Houben Tcherkelov was born on January 23, 1970, in [Kardzhali](/wiki/Kardzhali "Kardzhali"), a town in southeastern Bulgaria. Tcherkelov studied painting at the [National Academy of Arts](/wiki/National_Academy_of_Arts "National Academy of Arts") in [Sofia](/wiki/Sofia "Sofia"), Bulgaria's capital, and was associated with the radical movement around the XXL Gallery.Phillips, Christopher. "Report From Sofia: The View from Europe's Lower East Side." *Art in America.* October, 1997\. pg. 49\.
Tcherkelov's early works in Sofia analyze space and life structures in a society transitioning at once to a new social system and acclimating to the rapid pace of globalization. *Freezing*, a 1994 exhibit of frozen animals in Sofia's [National Museum of Natural History (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Museum_of_Natural_History_%28Bulgaria%29 "National Museum of Natural History (Bulgaria)") pointed to the moribund state of museums in Bulgaria, grossly out\-of\-sync with the normal pace of events.Balkanski, Kamen. "Houben Tcherkelov: Interventions in various fields of life". *Siksi.* Winter, 1997\. 81\. Perhaps Tcherkelov's most well\-known work from his series of interventions is *Suitable Suit*, a video still from which served as the cover of *Menschenbilder: Foto\- und Videokunst aus Bulgarien*.*Menschenbilder: Foto\- und Videokunst aus Bulgarien.* Institut für Auslandsbeziehungen. Berlin, Germany. 1997\. In this video the artist lumbers through a field in a suit many sizes too large. Tcherkelov's analysis of Bulgarian society culminated in *Reality Show* (1998\), a video that, with numerous art historical references, satirizes the affluence and decadence of the international film and music industry transferred to Sofia.Seidl, Walter. "Reality Show." *ROTOR.* Graz, Austria.
In 1995, Tcherkelov studied impasto painting with [Jörg Immendorff](/wiki/J%C3%B6rg_Immendorff "Jörg Immendorff") in Amsterdam with a grant from the Felix Meritis Foundation.*Houben R. T.: $ Paintings*, 30\. Not until he arrived in New York City in 2000, however, did he begin to work exclusively using this technique.Henry, 2\. Art critic [Eleanor Heartney](/wiki/Eleanor_Heartney "Eleanor Heartney"), in an introduction to Tcherkelov's series of impasto paintings based on images from currency, writes that they present "symbols mined from American currency as keys to understand national dreams and fantasies."Heartney, Eleanor. Houben R. T.: Recent Paintings. Introduction. DTR Modern Galleries. Boston/Palm Beach. 2\. Concentrating on details in both new and old forms of money, Tcherkelov "exhumes their meanings and contradictions, revealing the subliminal power that currency images have."Heartney, 1\. Artist, musician, and performer [Genesis P\-Orridge](/wiki/Genesis_P-Orridge "Genesis P-Orridge") writes of one of Tcherkelov's paintings that "it seemed to explode with sheer exuberance." He continues: "We wonder how the artist trapped a living spirit inside the painting and yet maintained its happiness!".Russeth, Andrew. "Genesis Breyer P\-Orridge in New York." Artinfo. [http://www.artinfo.com/news/story/32578/genesis\-breyer\-p\-orridge\-in\-new\-york/?page\=3](http://www.artinfo.com/news/story/32578/genesis-breyer-p-orridge-in-new-york/?page=3). 18 September 2009\.
Tcherkelov cites the panic in the Bulgarian banking sector in the 1990s, which forced the government to devaluate the national currency, the Lev, by removing three zeroes, as the initial impetus that drove his consideration, from an aesthetic perspective, of the symbolic power of money.Karadzhova, Lilyana. "I paint money, I do not print banknotes." Europost. [http://www.europost.bg/bin/marticle?id\=11280](http://www.europost.bg/bin/marticle?id=11280). 25 July 2014\. He also points to his arrival in New York as an immigrant, and his reliance on coins to make calls from payphones, as having "left \[him] with the feeling of communication," and that money is a component of expression."I am not an elitist artist." Europost. [http://www.europost.eu/article?id\=4585](http://www.europost.eu/article?id=4585). 12 May 2012\. Cultural critic Georgette Gouveia notes that Houben's aesthetic "is related to 20th\-century Pop Art, but rather than focus on manufactured Pepsi\-Cola or Brillo boxes as Warhol famously did, he focuses on the financial instruments that are engines of wealth.""Show me the Money, the New Art of the Deal/the Art of the New Deal: Art and Money in Contemporary Culture." Lehman College Art Gallery. Exhibition Catalogue. June 3, 2019\.
In 2011, Houben was selected to represent Bulgaria in the 54th Venice Biennale.Bergamin, Luca. "L'Uomo Vogue." May–June 2011 (n. 421\), p. 209\.
In February and March 2018, Houben held solo shows at the [National Art Gallery (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Art_Gallery_%28Bulgaria%29 "National Art Gallery (Bulgaria)"), Sofia Arsenal and the [National Archaeological Museum (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Archaeological_Museum_%28Bulgaria%29 "National Archaeological Museum (Bulgaria)"), both in Sofia."What's On: Exhibitions Tcherkelov's '120 Bills' and Ushev's 'In the mirror, dimly.'" The Sofia Globe. [https://sofiaglobe.com/2018/02/21/whats\-on\-exhibitions\-tcherkelovs\-120\-bills\-and\-ushevs\-in\-the\-mirror\-dimly](https://sofiaglobe.com/2018/02/21/whats-on-exhibitions-tcherkelovs-120-bills-and-ushevs-in-the-mirror-dimly)"Worth \- An Exhibition of Houben Tcherkelov in Sofia." Diplomatic Spectrum. [http://diplomaticspectrum.com/en/bulgaria/culture/1030\-worth\-%E2%80%93\-an\-exhibition\-of\-houben\-tcherkelov\-in\-sofia.html](http://diplomaticspectrum.com/en/bulgaria/culture/1030-worth-%E2%80%93-an-exhibition-of-houben-tcherkelov-in-sofia.html) In interviews, Houben was asked to talk about the role of art in the age of digitalization and bitcoin. The mission of art "is in the statics \- to stop the flying time, to talk with the past, and with the future," Tcherkelov stated. "To not turn into ephemera, unlike the built\-in interchangeability of almost everything that surrounds us. In 25 years, artificial intelligence will make many professions redundant, but there will be room for traditional human activity that cannot be multiplied or created by robots."Mircheva, Nevena. "Houben Tcherkelov: My art is not a provocation but an invitation for dialogue." Economic.bg. [http://www.economic.bg/bg/news/9/houben\-tcherkelov\-my\-art\-is\-not\-a\-provocation\-but\-an\-invitation\-for\-dialogue.html](http://www.economic.bg/bg/news/9/houben-tcherkelov-my-art-is-not-a-provocation-but-an-invitation-for-dialogue.html)
From November 2020 through March 2021, Houben held a solo show at the Museum of Humour and Satire in Gabrovo, Bulgaria. The museum director, Margarita Dorovska, described Houben's works as "beyond generous to the viewer" who is "compelled to move around and is yet never certain to have seen it all." In order to experience Houben's works, "\[o]ne has to move, to change their stance, to exhaust the spatial relations, and there will still be an elusive remainder."Dorovska, Margarita. Forward and Acknowledgements. Houben Tcherkelov: Why So Serious? Museum of Humour and Satire. 2020\.
During a solo show in Taiwan at InSian Gallery, Houben explained the inspiration for his work: "Now I am in New York, where nothing is produced anymore. Only financial services remain. This is why I want to reflect this in my art. In a way, I am a traditional painter painting everything around me. This is the influence of global finance."Chen, Xi. The Invisible Hand and its Handprint: The Substitution, Appropriation, and Encoding of Imagery in Houben Tcherkelov's "Currency". InSian Gallery. 2024\.
As art critic Xi Chen, in an introduction to the catalogue for this exhibit, states, "The artist, through the financial symbols inherent in currency—and the collective memory such symbols reflect—references the fluid exchange and translation between art and finance."Xi, 1 For the same exhibit, [Christian Viveros\-Fauné](/wiki/Christian_Viveros-Faun%C3%A9 "Christian Viveros-Fauné") described Houben's oeuvre as a "global treasury" of images that "depict\[s] money as a phenomenon that is . . . reflective" requiring that the viewer "look beneath the surface of a thing."Viveros\-Fauné, Christiane. The (Cultural) Currency Trader: The Art of Houben R. Tcherkelov. InSian Gallery. 2024\.
|
[
"Life and work\n-------------",
"Houben Tcherkelov was born on January 23, 1970, in [Kardzhali](/wiki/Kardzhali \"Kardzhali\"), a town in southeastern Bulgaria. Tcherkelov studied painting at the [National Academy of Arts](/wiki/National_Academy_of_Arts \"National Academy of Arts\") in [Sofia](/wiki/Sofia \"Sofia\"), Bulgaria's capital, and was associated with the radical movement around the XXL Gallery.Phillips, Christopher. \"Report From Sofia: The View from Europe's Lower East Side.\" *Art in America.* October, 1997\\. pg. 49\\.\nTcherkelov's early works in Sofia analyze space and life structures in a society transitioning at once to a new social system and acclimating to the rapid pace of globalization. *Freezing*, a 1994 exhibit of frozen animals in Sofia's [National Museum of Natural History (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Museum_of_Natural_History_%28Bulgaria%29 \"National Museum of Natural History (Bulgaria)\") pointed to the moribund state of museums in Bulgaria, grossly out\\-of\\-sync with the normal pace of events.Balkanski, Kamen. \"Houben Tcherkelov: Interventions in various fields of life\". *Siksi.* Winter, 1997\\. 81\\. Perhaps Tcherkelov's most well\\-known work from his series of interventions is *Suitable Suit*, a video still from which served as the cover of *Menschenbilder: Foto\\- und Videokunst aus Bulgarien*.*Menschenbilder: Foto\\- und Videokunst aus Bulgarien.* Institut für Auslandsbeziehungen. Berlin, Germany. 1997\\. In this video the artist lumbers through a field in a suit many sizes too large. Tcherkelov's analysis of Bulgarian society culminated in *Reality Show* (1998\\), a video that, with numerous art historical references, satirizes the affluence and decadence of the international film and music industry transferred to Sofia.Seidl, Walter. \"Reality Show.\" *ROTOR.* Graz, Austria.",
"In 1995, Tcherkelov studied impasto painting with [Jörg Immendorff](/wiki/J%C3%B6rg_Immendorff \"Jörg Immendorff\") in Amsterdam with a grant from the Felix Meritis Foundation.*Houben R. T.: $ Paintings*, 30\\. Not until he arrived in New York City in 2000, however, did he begin to work exclusively using this technique.Henry, 2\\. Art critic [Eleanor Heartney](/wiki/Eleanor_Heartney \"Eleanor Heartney\"), in an introduction to Tcherkelov's series of impasto paintings based on images from currency, writes that they present \"symbols mined from American currency as keys to understand national dreams and fantasies.\"Heartney, Eleanor. Houben R. T.: Recent Paintings. Introduction. DTR Modern Galleries. Boston/Palm Beach. 2\\. Concentrating on details in both new and old forms of money, Tcherkelov \"exhumes their meanings and contradictions, revealing the subliminal power that currency images have.\"Heartney, 1\\. Artist, musician, and performer [Genesis P\\-Orridge](/wiki/Genesis_P-Orridge \"Genesis P-Orridge\") writes of one of Tcherkelov's paintings that \"it seemed to explode with sheer exuberance.\" He continues: \"We wonder how the artist trapped a living spirit inside the painting and yet maintained its happiness!\".Russeth, Andrew. \"Genesis Breyer P\\-Orridge in New York.\" Artinfo. [http://www.artinfo.com/news/story/32578/genesis\\-breyer\\-p\\-orridge\\-in\\-new\\-york/?page\\=3](http://www.artinfo.com/news/story/32578/genesis-breyer-p-orridge-in-new-york/?page=3). 18 September 2009\\.",
"Tcherkelov cites the panic in the Bulgarian banking sector in the 1990s, which forced the government to devaluate the national currency, the Lev, by removing three zeroes, as the initial impetus that drove his consideration, from an aesthetic perspective, of the symbolic power of money.Karadzhova, Lilyana. \"I paint money, I do not print banknotes.\" Europost. [http://www.europost.bg/bin/marticle?id\\=11280](http://www.europost.bg/bin/marticle?id=11280). 25 July 2014\\. He also points to his arrival in New York as an immigrant, and his reliance on coins to make calls from payphones, as having \"left \\[him] with the feeling of communication,\" and that money is a component of expression.\"I am not an elitist artist.\" Europost. [http://www.europost.eu/article?id\\=4585](http://www.europost.eu/article?id=4585). 12 May 2012\\. Cultural critic Georgette Gouveia notes that Houben's aesthetic \"is related to 20th\\-century Pop Art, but rather than focus on manufactured Pepsi\\-Cola or Brillo boxes as Warhol famously did, he focuses on the financial instruments that are engines of wealth.\"\"Show me the Money, the New Art of the Deal/the Art of the New Deal: Art and Money in Contemporary Culture.\" Lehman College Art Gallery. Exhibition Catalogue. June 3, 2019\\.",
"In 2011, Houben was selected to represent Bulgaria in the 54th Venice Biennale.Bergamin, Luca. \"L'Uomo Vogue.\" May–June 2011 (n. 421\\), p. 209\\.",
"In February and March 2018, Houben held solo shows at the [National Art Gallery (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Art_Gallery_%28Bulgaria%29 \"National Art Gallery (Bulgaria)\"), Sofia Arsenal and the [National Archaeological Museum (Bulgaria)](/wiki/National_Archaeological_Museum_%28Bulgaria%29 \"National Archaeological Museum (Bulgaria)\"), both in Sofia.\"What's On: Exhibitions Tcherkelov's '120 Bills' and Ushev's 'In the mirror, dimly.'\" The Sofia Globe. [https://sofiaglobe.com/2018/02/21/whats\\-on\\-exhibitions\\-tcherkelovs\\-120\\-bills\\-and\\-ushevs\\-in\\-the\\-mirror\\-dimly](https://sofiaglobe.com/2018/02/21/whats-on-exhibitions-tcherkelovs-120-bills-and-ushevs-in-the-mirror-dimly)\"Worth \\- An Exhibition of Houben Tcherkelov in Sofia.\" Diplomatic Spectrum. [http://diplomaticspectrum.com/en/bulgaria/culture/1030\\-worth\\-%E2%80%93\\-an\\-exhibition\\-of\\-houben\\-tcherkelov\\-in\\-sofia.html](http://diplomaticspectrum.com/en/bulgaria/culture/1030-worth-%E2%80%93-an-exhibition-of-houben-tcherkelov-in-sofia.html) In interviews, Houben was asked to talk about the role of art in the age of digitalization and bitcoin. The mission of art \"is in the statics \\- to stop the flying time, to talk with the past, and with the future,\" Tcherkelov stated. \"To not turn into ephemera, unlike the built\\-in interchangeability of almost everything that surrounds us. In 25 years, artificial intelligence will make many professions redundant, but there will be room for traditional human activity that cannot be multiplied or created by robots.\"Mircheva, Nevena. \"Houben Tcherkelov: My art is not a provocation but an invitation for dialogue.\" Economic.bg. [http://www.economic.bg/bg/news/9/houben\\-tcherkelov\\-my\\-art\\-is\\-not\\-a\\-provocation\\-but\\-an\\-invitation\\-for\\-dialogue.html](http://www.economic.bg/bg/news/9/houben-tcherkelov-my-art-is-not-a-provocation-but-an-invitation-for-dialogue.html)",
"From November 2020 through March 2021, Houben held a solo show at the Museum of Humour and Satire in Gabrovo, Bulgaria. The museum director, Margarita Dorovska, described Houben's works as \"beyond generous to the viewer\" who is \"compelled to move around and is yet never certain to have seen it all.\" In order to experience Houben's works, \"\\[o]ne has to move, to change their stance, to exhaust the spatial relations, and there will still be an elusive remainder.\"Dorovska, Margarita. Forward and Acknowledgements. Houben Tcherkelov: Why So Serious? Museum of Humour and Satire. 2020\\.",
"During a solo show in Taiwan at InSian Gallery, Houben explained the inspiration for his work: \"Now I am in New York, where nothing is produced anymore. Only financial services remain. This is why I want to reflect this in my art. In a way, I am a traditional painter painting everything around me. This is the influence of global finance.\"Chen, Xi. The Invisible Hand and its Handprint: The Substitution, Appropriation, and Encoding of Imagery in Houben Tcherkelov's \"Currency\". InSian Gallery. 2024\\.",
"As art critic Xi Chen, in an introduction to the catalogue for this exhibit, states, \"The artist, through the financial symbols inherent in currency—and the collective memory such symbols reflect—references the fluid exchange and translation between art and finance.\"Xi, 1 For the same exhibit, [Christian Viveros\\-Fauné](/wiki/Christian_Viveros-Faun%C3%A9 \"Christian Viveros-Fauné\") described Houben's oeuvre as a \"global treasury\" of images that \"depict\\[s] money as a phenomenon that is . . . reflective\" requiring that the viewer \"look beneath the surface of a thing.\"Viveros\\-Fauné, Christiane. The (Cultural) Currency Trader: The Art of Houben R. Tcherkelov. InSian Gallery. 2024\\.",
""
] |
History
-------
### Industrial Revolution
[thumb\|[British industrial architecture](/wiki/British_industrial_architecture "British industrial architecture"): Murrays' Mills (for cotton) on the [Rochdale Canal](/wiki/Rochdale_Canal "Rochdale Canal"), Manchester, begun in 1797, and then forming the longest mill range in the world](/wiki/File:Rochdale_Canal_5268.JPG "Rochdale Canal 5268.JPG")
Britain played an important role in the [Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Industrial_Revolution "Industrial Revolution"), which stimulated the expansion of trade and distribution of goods amongst Europe and the Atlantic Ocean. The technological advances from Europe were later spread to the United States in the late 1700s. [Samuel Slater](/wiki/Samuel_Slater "Samuel Slater") fled to the United States and later opened a textile mill in Rhode Island; shortly after that the cotton gin was invented by [Eli Whitney](/wiki/Eli_Whitney "Eli Whitney").{{Cite web \|last\=Yuko \|first\=Elizabeth \|date\=November 18, 2021 \|title\=How the Industrial Revolution fueled the Growth of Cities? \|url\=https://www.history.com/news/industrial\-revolution\-cities \|access\-date\=March 17, 2023 \|website\=History}}
One of the first industrial buildings were built in [Britain](/wiki/Britain_%28country%29 "Britain (country)") in the 1700s during the First [Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Industrial_Revolution "Industrial Revolution"), which later inspired other industrial architecture to arise throughout the world. The First Industrial Revolution lasted from mid\-1700s to the mid\-1800s and then later the [Second Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution "Second Industrial Revolution") came about which mainly focused on the use of new materials and production of goods.
#### 1700s
One of the earliest industrial buildings were relativity built at a domestic scale, for instance workshops for local craftsmen.
#### 1700s–1850s
This time period was the transformation of the British economy. The population in England had increased to 16 million people around 1841, with the majority moving to Northern Europe. Factories had been built and production in the factories had become dominant; production was not on a large\-scale.
### Post\-Industrial Revolution
[thumb\|The *Moulin Saulnier*, originally a watermill, now part of the Menier chocolate factory in [Noisiel](/wiki/Noisiel "Noisiel"), France. Built in 1872, it was the first building in the world with a visible metallic structure.](/wiki/File:Moulin_Saulnier.jpg "Moulin Saulnier.jpg")
The birth of all industrial architecture stemmed from [England](/wiki/England "England") and the continuing expansions of the architecture was a product of the Industrial Revolution.{{Cite web \|date\=May 7, 2020 \|title\=Victorian Industrial Structure \|url\=https://victorian\-era.org/victorian\-industrial\-architecture.html \|access\-date\=March 20, 2023 \|website\=Victorian Era}} The usage and production of [iron](/wiki/Iron "Iron") and [steel](/wiki/Steel "Steel") became more prominent since they were used as the foundation for the industrial buildings. Steel is a durable material and was also used in other parts of the industry such as [infrastructure](/wiki/Infrastructure "Infrastructure"), but it was difficult to make because it required high temperature to melt the metal.
#### 1850s–1914
Britain saw a increase in production during this time period. Railways played an important role in transportation and distribution of resources throughout Europe and the United States. Industrial buildings were built at a larger scale to accommodate large machinery used in food production such as flour mills and [breweries](/wiki/Brewery "Brewery"). With the implementation of the [Planning Act of 1909](/wiki/Housing%2C_Town_Planning%2C_%26c._Act_1909 "Housing, Town Planning, &c. Act 1909"), the industry had a significant impact on the siting and layout of industrial facilities as it continued to progress throughout the years.
#### 1914 to present
As architecture became modernized throughout the years, the more traditional industrial sites throughout Europe and the United States continued to decrease. For instance, [coal](/wiki/Coal "Coal") is a raw material that was heavily used throughout the industrial revolution, so there were coal mines. Buildings continued to increase in size to accommodate mass production. The overall design of modern\-day buildings is sleeker and more spacious.
### Some key elements to industrial buildings
* High ceilings
* Functionality and design
* Large windows
* Large, open floor plans
* Built to safety standards
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Industrial Revolution",
"[thumb\\|[British industrial architecture](/wiki/British_industrial_architecture \"British industrial architecture\"): Murrays' Mills (for cotton) on the [Rochdale Canal](/wiki/Rochdale_Canal \"Rochdale Canal\"), Manchester, begun in 1797, and then forming the longest mill range in the world](/wiki/File:Rochdale_Canal_5268.JPG \"Rochdale Canal 5268.JPG\")\nBritain played an important role in the [Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Industrial_Revolution \"Industrial Revolution\"), which stimulated the expansion of trade and distribution of goods amongst Europe and the Atlantic Ocean. The technological advances from Europe were later spread to the United States in the late 1700s. [Samuel Slater](/wiki/Samuel_Slater \"Samuel Slater\") fled to the United States and later opened a textile mill in Rhode Island; shortly after that the cotton gin was invented by [Eli Whitney](/wiki/Eli_Whitney \"Eli Whitney\").{{Cite web \\|last\\=Yuko \\|first\\=Elizabeth \\|date\\=November 18, 2021 \\|title\\=How the Industrial Revolution fueled the Growth of Cities? \\|url\\=https://www.history.com/news/industrial\\-revolution\\-cities \\|access\\-date\\=March 17, 2023 \\|website\\=History}}",
"One of the first industrial buildings were built in [Britain](/wiki/Britain_%28country%29 \"Britain (country)\") in the 1700s during the First [Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Industrial_Revolution \"Industrial Revolution\"), which later inspired other industrial architecture to arise throughout the world. The First Industrial Revolution lasted from mid\\-1700s to the mid\\-1800s and then later the [Second Industrial Revolution](/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution \"Second Industrial Revolution\") came about which mainly focused on the use of new materials and production of goods.",
"#### 1700s",
"One of the earliest industrial buildings were relativity built at a domestic scale, for instance workshops for local craftsmen.",
"#### 1700s–1850s",
"This time period was the transformation of the British economy. The population in England had increased to 16 million people around 1841, with the majority moving to Northern Europe. Factories had been built and production in the factories had become dominant; production was not on a large\\-scale.",
"### Post\\-Industrial Revolution",
"[thumb\\|The *Moulin Saulnier*, originally a watermill, now part of the Menier chocolate factory in [Noisiel](/wiki/Noisiel \"Noisiel\"), France. Built in 1872, it was the first building in the world with a visible metallic structure.](/wiki/File:Moulin_Saulnier.jpg \"Moulin Saulnier.jpg\")\nThe birth of all industrial architecture stemmed from [England](/wiki/England \"England\") and the continuing expansions of the architecture was a product of the Industrial Revolution.{{Cite web \\|date\\=May 7, 2020 \\|title\\=Victorian Industrial Structure \\|url\\=https://victorian\\-era.org/victorian\\-industrial\\-architecture.html \\|access\\-date\\=March 20, 2023 \\|website\\=Victorian Era}} The usage and production of [iron](/wiki/Iron \"Iron\") and [steel](/wiki/Steel \"Steel\") became more prominent since they were used as the foundation for the industrial buildings. Steel is a durable material and was also used in other parts of the industry such as [infrastructure](/wiki/Infrastructure \"Infrastructure\"), but it was difficult to make because it required high temperature to melt the metal.",
"#### 1850s–1914",
"Britain saw a increase in production during this time period. Railways played an important role in transportation and distribution of resources throughout Europe and the United States. Industrial buildings were built at a larger scale to accommodate large machinery used in food production such as flour mills and [breweries](/wiki/Brewery \"Brewery\"). With the implementation of the [Planning Act of 1909](/wiki/Housing%2C_Town_Planning%2C_%26c._Act_1909 \"Housing, Town Planning, &c. Act 1909\"), the industry had a significant impact on the siting and layout of industrial facilities as it continued to progress throughout the years.",
"#### 1914 to present",
"As architecture became modernized throughout the years, the more traditional industrial sites throughout Europe and the United States continued to decrease. For instance, [coal](/wiki/Coal \"Coal\") is a raw material that was heavily used throughout the industrial revolution, so there were coal mines. Buildings continued to increase in size to accommodate mass production. The overall design of modern\\-day buildings is sleeker and more spacious.",
"### Some key elements to industrial buildings",
"* High ceilings\n* Functionality and design\n* Large windows\n* Large, open floor plans\n* Built to safety standards"
] |
Description
-----------
The "original construction program for the Permanent System" was completed in May 1952,{{r\|VIchapterII}}{{rp\|61}} [USAF AC\&W squadrons](/wiki/List_of_United_States_Air_Force_aircraft_control_and_warning_squadrons "List of United States Air Force aircraft control and warning squadrons") were established (renamed Radar Squadrons in the mid\-1950s), and the [Ground Observation Corps](/wiki/Ground_Observation_Corps "Ground Observation Corps") was expanded in 1952 ([Operation Skywatch](/wiki/Operation_Skywatch "Operation Skywatch")) with over 750,000 volunteers at over 16 thousand posts (98 per post in shifts) and 75 centers.
| \+ Air Defense Command MCCs |
| --- |
| Air Division | {{align\|left\|\# }} {{align\|right\| Coordinates}} | {{align\|left\| AFB, etc. }} {{align\|right\| DC }} | ST | Years |
| n/a | \[command center at HQ ADC/NORAD/CONAC] | [Ent](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base "Ent Air Force Base") | CO | 1951\-63 |
| {{Specify\|date\=February 2013}} | MCC\-01 | | |
| [29th](/wiki/29th_Air_Division "29th Air Division") | MCC\-02 {{align\|right\| {{Coord\|38\|50\|48\|N\|094\|22\|50\|W\|display\=inline\|name\=ADC MCC\-02 (Kansas City sector)}} }} | [Richards\-Gebaur](/wiki/Richards-Gebaur_Air_Force_Base "Richards-Gebaur Air Force Base") {{align\|right\| DC\-08 }} | MO | 1957\-69 |
| | MCC\-03 | {{Specify\|date\=February 2013}} | |
| [28th](/wiki/28th_Air_Division "28th Air Division") | MCC\-06 | [Hamilton](/wiki/Hamilton_Air_Force_Base "Hamilton Air Force Base") | CA |
| | MCC\-07 | | {{Specify\|date\=February 2013}} |
| ([Oklahoma City](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_Air_Defense_Sector "Oklahoma City Air Defense Sector")) | MCC\-11 {{align\|right\| {{Coord\|35\|24\|13\|N\|097\|21\|27\|W\|display\=inline\|name\=ADC MCC\-11 (Oklahoma City sector)}} }} | [Oklahoma City AFS](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_Air_Force_Station "Oklahoma City Air Force Station") | OK |
| | MCC\-16 | | |
| | MCC\-17 | | |
### Manual Air Defense Control Centers
**Manual Air Defense Control Center**s (ADCC, MCC) of the Permanent System were [USAF](/wiki/United_States_Air_Force_command_posts "United States Air Force command posts") command posts for [command, control, and coordination](/wiki/Command%2C_control%2C_and_coordination_system "Command, control, and coordination system") by [Air Defense Command](/wiki/Air_Defense_Command "Air Defense Command"), including early [Cold War](/wiki/Cold_War "Cold War") [ground\-controlled interception](/wiki/Ground-controlled_interception "Ground-controlled interception") of enemy aircraft. Each MCC networked radar stations of the sector, plotted radar tracks \& visual observations, and forwarded information to ADC command center at [Mitchel Field](/wiki/Mitchel_Field "Mitchel Field"), [Ent Air Force Base](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base "Ent Air Force Base") in 1951, and the new 1954 Ent blockhouse subsequently used by the 1954 [CONAD](/wiki/CONAD "CONAD") and the 1957 [NORAD](/wiki/NORAD "NORAD").
MCCs were generally located at or near a radar station, e.g., [Andrews Air Force Base](/wiki/Andrews_Air_Force_Base "Andrews Air Force Base") MCC in Maryland (at/near radar station SM\-171\), [Dobbins AFB](/wiki/Dobbins_AFB "Dobbins AFB") GA (M\-87\), [Geiger Field](/wiki/Geiger_Field "Geiger Field") WA (SM\-172\), [Kirtland AFB](/wiki/Kirtland_AFB "Kirtland AFB") NM (P\-41\), [Norton AFB](/wiki/Norton_AFB "Norton AFB") CA (P\-84\), [Oklahoma City AFS](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_AFS "Oklahoma City AFS") OK (P\-52\), [Roslyn AFS](/wiki/Roslyn_Air_Force_Station "Roslyn Air Force Station") NY (P\-3\), [Snelling AFS](/wiki/Snelling_AFS "Snelling AFS") MN (P\-36\), [Willow Run AFS](/wiki/Willow_Run_AFS "Willow Run AFS") MI (P\-23\), and [Wright\-Patterson AFB](/wiki/Wright-Patterson_AFB "Wright-Patterson AFB") OH (SM\-170\).
Some MCCs were replaced by Direction Centers of the subsequent [SAGE Radar Network](/wiki/Semi_Automatic_Ground_Environment "Semi Automatic Ground Environment"), e.g., when [McGuire DC\-01](/wiki/McGuire_Air_Force_Base "McGuire Air Force Base") was established, the [Roslyn Air Force Station](/wiki/Roslyn_Air_Force_Station "Roslyn Air Force Station") MCC became the "Combat Alert Center (Manual)". MCCs continued at several sites where DCs were planned but never built for sectors at [Albuquerque](/wiki/Albuquerque_Air_Defense_Sector "Albuquerque Air Defense Sector"), [Fort Knox](/wiki/Fort_Knox_Air_Defense_Sector "Fort Knox Air Defense Sector"), [Kansas City](/wiki/Kansas_City_Air_Defense_Sector "Kansas City Air Defense Sector"), [Miami](/wiki/Miami_Air_Defense_Sector "Miami Air Defense Sector"), [Raleigh](/wiki/Raleigh_Air_Defense_Sector "Raleigh Air Defense Sector"), [San Antonio](/wiki/San_Antonio_Air_Defense_Sector "San Antonio Air Defense Sector"), [Shreveport](/wiki/Shreveport_Air_Defense_Sector "Shreveport Air Defense Sector"), and [St Louis](/wiki/St_Louis_Air_Defense_Sector "St Louis Air Defense Sector").
Filter Centers **Filter Centers** of the [Ground Observation Corps](/wiki/Ground_Observation_Corps "Ground Observation Corps") (e.g., in [New Haven, Connecticut](https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=B6NHAAAAIBAJ&sjid=-v4MAAAAIBAJ&pg=1160,4794388&dq=observation-corps&hl=en) and [Baltimore, Maryland](/wiki/Baltimore%2C_Maryland "Baltimore, Maryland")).{{Cite news \|date\=5 April 1954 \|title\=Less Than Half Spotter Time Filled In Week \|url\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id\=riYmAAAAIBAJ\&sjid\=Bf4FAAAAIBAJ\&dq\=round\-hill%20gettysburg\&pg\=2238%2C4455496 \|format\=Google News Archive \|publisher\=Times and News Publishing Company \|newspaper\=\[\[The Gettysburg Times]] \|accessdate\=2012\-01\-04}} processed reports from \~8,000 CONUS watch posts. As with ranger stations for forest fires, watch posts measured the azimuth of a target aircraft or formation, and Filter Centers triangulated azimuth observations from 2 or more stations, assessed the reliability of observations, and provided visual track information to MCCs.
### Radar stations
Five radar stations of the [Lashup Radar Network](/wiki/Lashup_Radar_Network "Lashup Radar Network") were redesignated as Permanent System stations (3 later upgraded{{When\|date\=February 2013}} with newer radars developed for the Permanent System): [Montauk L\-10/LP\-45/P\-45](/wiki/Montauk_Air_Force_Station "Montauk Air Force Station"), [Fort Custis L\-15/LP\-56](/wiki/Cape_Charles_Air_Force_Station "Cape Charles Air Force Station"), [Palermo L\-13/LP\-54/P\-54](/wiki/Palermo_Air_Force_Station "Palermo Air Force Station"), Sault Sainte Marie L\-17/LP\-20, and [Highlands L\-12/LP\-9/P\-9](/wiki/Highlands_Air_Force_Station "Highlands Air Force Station"). From March to November 1951, the "LP" designation was also used for 23 new stations for the Permanent System that were outfitted, instead of with radars developed for the Permanent System, with older radars such as the January 1945 General Electric [AN/CPS\-5](/wiki/AN/CPS-5 "AN/CPS-5") radar, 1948 [Western Electric AN/TPS\-1B Radar](/wiki/Western_Electric_AN/TPS-1B_Radar "Western Electric AN/TPS-1B Radar"), and Bendix [AN/TPS\-1C](/wiki/AN/TPS-1C "AN/TPS-1C") radar.[MX\-1000 to MX\-1499 Listing](http://www.designation-systems.net/usmilav/mx/1000-1499.html). Designation\-systems.net (2005\-11\-20\). Retrieved on 2013\-09\-18\.
The LP designator was also used for 1 station opened with [AN/FPS\-3](/wiki/AN/FPS-3 "AN/FPS-3") and [AN/FPS\-5](/wiki/AN/FPS-5 "AN/FPS-5") radars in 1950 ([Tierra Amarilla LP\-8](/wiki/Tierra_Amarilla_Air_Force_Station "Tierra Amarilla Air Force Station")). More than 15 of the new LP stations were subsequently upgraded and designated P\-xx stations, and some of the squadrons at LP stations that closed moved to new P stations.
New LP sites not previously designated L sites:
* [Bellefontaine LP\-73/P\-73](/wiki/Bellefontaine_Air_Force_Station "Bellefontaine Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B in November 1951\),
* Blue Knob LP\-63 (TPS\-1C 30 November 1951—station moved to Gibbsboro RP\-63 in 1961\),
* [Cambria LP\-2/P\-2](/wiki/Cambria_Air_Force_Station "Cambria Air Force Station") (TPS\-1C November 1951\)
* [Caswell LP\-80/P\-80](/wiki/Caswell_Air_Force_Station "Caswell Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B March 1951\),
* [Colville LP\-60/P\-60](/wiki/Colville_Air_Force_Station "Colville Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B March 1951, TPS\-1C November 1951\),
* [Condon LP\-32/P\-32](/wiki/Condon_Air_Force_Station "Condon Air Force Station") (TPS\-1C November 1951\),
* [Curlew LP\-6/P\-6](/wiki/Curlew_Air_Force_Station "Curlew Air Force Station") Mt Bonaparte TPS\-1B 1950
* [Del Bonita LP\-24](/wiki/Cut_Bank_Air_Force_Station "Cut Bank Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B November 1951\) (P\-24 is Cut Bank AFS),
* [Williams Bay AFS](/wiki/Williams_Bay_Air_Force_Station "Williams Bay Air Force Station") Elkhorn LP\-31 (moved to RP\-31 at [Arlington Heights AFS](/wiki/Arlington_Heights_Air_Force_Station "Arlington Heights Air Force Station")),
* [Finland LP\-69/P\-69](/wiki/Finland_Air_Force_Station "Finland Air Force Station") (CPS\-5 30 November 1951\),
* [Fort Custer LP\-67/P\-67](/wiki/Custer_Air_Force_Station "Custer Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B 30 November 1951\),
* [Godman Field LP\-82](/wiki/Godman_Army_Airfield "Godman Army Airfield") (TPS\-1C 30 April 1952\) (P\-82 [Snow Mountain AFS](/wiki/Snow_Mountain_Air_Force_Station "Snow Mountain Air Force Station")),
* Gonzales LP\-7 (P\-7 [Continental Divide AFS](/wiki/Continental_Divide_Air_Force_Station "Continental Divide Air Force Station")),
* Hill Peak Road LP\-37 (P\-37 [Point Arena AFS](/wiki/Point_Arena_Air_Force_Station "Point Arena Air Force Station")),
* Keweenaw LP\-16 (P\-16 [Calumet AFS](/wiki/Calumet_Air_Force_Station "Calumet Air Force Station")),
* [Klamath LP\-33/P\-33](/wiki/Klamath_Air_Force_Station "Klamath Air Force Station") TPS\-1B (Apr 51\)
* [Madera LP\-74/P\-74](/wiki/Madera_Air_Force_Station "Madera Air Force Station") (TPS\-1B in March 51\),
* [Moriarty LP\-51/P\-51](/wiki/Moriarty_Air_Force_Station "Moriarty Air Force Station") CPS\-5 (30 Nov 51\)
* [Port Austin LP\-61/P\-61](/wiki/Port_Austin_Air_Force_Station "Port Austin Air Force Station") TPS\-1C 30\-Nov\-51
* [Rockville LP\-53/P\-53](/wiki/Rockville_Air_Force_Station "Rockville Air Force Station") TPS\-1B (30 Nov 51\)
* Saddle Mountain/[Othello LP\-40/P\-40](/wiki/Othello_Air_Force_Station "Othello Air Force Station") TPS\-1B
* [San Clemente Island LP\-39/P\-39](/wiki/San_Clemente_Island_AFS "San Clemente Island AFS") TPS\-1C Nov\-51
* [Tierra Amarilla LP\-8/P\-8](/wiki/Tierra_Amarilla_Air_Force_Station "Tierra Amarilla Air Force Station") FPS\-3; FPS\-5; 1950
Permanent System radars were developed in various programs such as the [AN/FPS\-6](/wiki/AN/FPS-6 "AN/FPS-6") (in program MX\-1353 \- "Long range S\-band height finder") and [AN/MPS\-10](/wiki/AN/MPS-10 "AN/MPS-10") (MX\-1354 \- "Mobile long range search radar set").
Priority Permanent System The "Priority Permanent System" with the initial (priority) radar stations having new radar systems included "[ADC](/wiki/Air_Defense_Command "Air Defense Command") radar site" P\-1 at [McChord AFB](/wiki/Joint_Base_Lewis-McChord "Joint Base Lewis-McChord") on 1 June 1950\. Completed in May 1952 to replace the 1950 [Lashup Radar Network](/wiki/Lashup_Radar_Network "Lashup Radar Network"),{{r\|VIchapterII}}{{rp\|61}} the Priority Permanent System had 5 redesignated LASHUP stations, 23 new stations in 1951 with older radars, 62 stations in 1951 with new equipment, and several of the 10 newly equipped 1952 stations (including [Manassas RP\-55](/wiki/Manassas_Air_Force_Station "Manassas Air Force Station")). The Priority Permanent System used Manual ADCCs, e.g., with [Plexiglas](/wiki/Plexiglas "Plexiglas") plotting boards as at the 1954 [Ent Air Force Base](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base "Ent Air Force Base") command center for ADC.{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|151}}
P system extension The "first extension of the P system into Canada" ("Canadian extensions") for the [Pinetree Line](/wiki/Pinetree_Line "Pinetree Line"){{r\|VolumeI}}{{rp\|134}} was planned by the "Radar Extension Program" for 33 stations and was agreed by the US and Canada in November 1950\. The plan "was submitted to the Permanent Joint Board on Defense on February 6, 1951, and" was subsequently approved by both nations,{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|159}} but by "April 1951 the United States still had not contributed to the Radar Extension Program".{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|160}} On 13 June 1951, the US released $20 million for the stations and by June 1952, the joint Canadian\-American committee on the Radar Extension Program was replaced with the "Project Pinetree Office" in [Ottawa, Ontario](/wiki/Ottawa%2C_Ontario "Ottawa, Ontario").{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|160}}
Gap\-filler and semi\-mobile radar stations On 18 January 1952, ADC proposed the construction of small, unmanned stations with gap filler radars.{{r\|VolumeI}}{{rp\|227}} The USAF [Directorate of Plans](/wiki/Directorate_of_Plans "Directorate of Plans") (War Plans Division) "prepared the proposal … to add 29 mobile and 135 low\-altitude stations to ADC's radar system" for completion by the end of 1955\.{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|187}} The first phase began with three 1953 stations at [Walker M\-90](/wiki/Walker_Air_Force_Base "Walker Air Force Base"), [Ellsworth M\-97](/wiki/Ellsworth_Air_Force_Base "Ellsworth Air Force Base"), and [Houma M\-126 (Z\-126\)](/wiki/Houma_Air_Force_Station "Houma Air Force Station"); and was completed with 1957 stations at [Almaden M\-96 (Z\-96\)](/wiki/Almaden_Air_Force_Station "Almaden Air Force Station"), [Mount Hebo M\-100](/wiki/Mount_Hebo_Air_Force_Station "Mount Hebo Air Force Station"), [Jacksonville M\-114 (Z\-114\)](/wiki/Jacksonville_Naval_Air_Station "Jacksonville Naval Air Station"), and [Cherry Point M\-116](/wiki/Cherry_Point_MCAS "Cherry Point MCAS").
The "second\-phase mobile radar program" was requested by the [ADC commander](/wiki/Benjamin_W._Chidlaw "Benjamin W. Chidlaw") in October 1952{{r\|Schaffel}} and was completed from 1954 starting with [Geiger Field](/wiki/Geiger_Field "Geiger Field") SM\-172 through 1962 with [Hastings SM\-133 (Z\-133\)](/wiki/Hastings_Air_Force_Station "Hastings Air Force Station"). The *Planning Guide for the Third Phase Augmentation Radar Program'* was issued 5 April 1954, and the 3rd phase was for 29 stations, many for coverage along the U.S.\-Mexican border and the Gulf of Mexico (the [Air Force Council](/wiki/Air_Force_Council "Air Force Council") had agreed with ADC's request for the third phase on 28 October 1953\.){{r\|Schaffel}} The "resulting 104 stations were all to be operational by 1956",{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|154}} and a mock 1956 attack blinded ground defense radars.{{r\|Winkler}} The third phase of 29 stations{{r\|VolumeI}}{{rp\|137}} was deployed beginning with 5 1957 stations and ended with the 1960 [Sundance TM\-201 (Z\-201\)](/wiki/Sundance_Air_Force_Station "Sundance Air Force Station"). Gap\-filler annexes of [Mather P\-58](/wiki/Mather_Air_Force_Base "Mather Air Force Base") (P\-58A at [Modesto](/wiki/Modesto%2C_California "Modesto, California") \& P\-58B at [Oroville](/wiki/Oroville%2C_California "Oroville, California")) were some of the Permanent System stations planned, but never built.
Texas Towers were approved on 11 January 1954,{{r\|VolumeI}} and despite 11 Permanent System radar stations closing in 1957 ([N\-28 Pinetree station](/wiki/Hopedale_Air_Station "Hopedale Air Station") and the [M\-87](/wiki/Dobbins_Air_Force_Base "Dobbins Air Force Base"), [M\-101](/wiki/Rochester_Air_Force_Station "Rochester Air Force Station"), [M\-104](/wiki/Rye_Air_Force_Station "Rye Air Force Station"), [M\-105](/wiki/Alpena_Air_Force_Station "Alpena Air Force Station"), [M\-106](/wiki/Two_Creeks_Air_Force_Station "Two Creeks Air Force Station"), [M\-109](/wiki/Grand_Marais_Air_Force_Station "Grand Marais Air Force Station"), [M\-122](/wiki/Dallas_Center_Air_Force_Station "Dallas Center Air Force Station"), [M\-128](/wiki/Kingman_Air_Force_Station "Kingman Air Force Station"), [M\-131](/wiki/Owingsville_Air_Force_Station "Owingsville Air Force Station"), \& [SM\-137](/wiki/Carmi_Air_Force_Station "Carmi Air Force Station") stations), at "the end of 1957, ADC operated 182 radar stations…32 had been added during the last half of the year as low\-altitude, unmanned gap\-filler radars. The total consisted of 47 gap\-filler stations, 75 Permanent System radars, 39 semimobile radars, 19 Pinetree stations,…1 Lashup\[\-era radar and a] single [Texas Tower](/wiki/Texas_Tower "Texas Tower")".{{r\|Schaffel}}{{rp\|223}}
Relocated stations When radar stations began converting to SAGE, 8 Permanent stations that closed from 1959\-1964 had their squadrons relocated to stations with "RP" designations, including the radar squadrons from the last 2 remaining "LP" stations: ([Elkhorn/Williams Bay LP\-31](/wiki/Williams_Bay_Air_Force_Station "Williams Bay Air Force Station") and [Blue Knob/Claysburg LP\-63](/wiki/Claysburg_Air_Force_Station "Claysburg Air Force Station")). All but 1 of the relocating squadrons went to new sites (the [770th](/wiki/770th_Radar_Squadron "770th Radar Squadron") moved{{When\|date\=February 2013}} to a [1955 Army radar station](/wiki/Fort_Meade_radar_station "Fort Meade radar station") designated USAF RP\-54 in 1961\), and 5 of the units co\-located with [Project Nike](/wiki/Project_Nike "Project Nike") [Missile Master](/wiki/Missile_Master "Missile Master") units. A 1959\-1961 USAF radar squadron was at the [Fort Heath](/wiki/Fort_Heath "Fort Heath") radar station of the [joint\-use site system (JUSS)](/wiki/List_of_USAF_Aerospace_Defense_Command_General_Surveillance_Radar_Stations%23Joint-use_site_system "List of USAF Aerospace Defense Command General Surveillance Radar Stations#Joint-use site system").
|
[
"Description\n-----------",
"The \"original construction program for the Permanent System\" was completed in May 1952,{{r\\|VIchapterII}}{{rp\\|61}} [USAF AC\\&W squadrons](/wiki/List_of_United_States_Air_Force_aircraft_control_and_warning_squadrons \"List of United States Air Force aircraft control and warning squadrons\") were established (renamed Radar Squadrons in the mid\\-1950s), and the [Ground Observation Corps](/wiki/Ground_Observation_Corps \"Ground Observation Corps\") was expanded in 1952 ([Operation Skywatch](/wiki/Operation_Skywatch \"Operation Skywatch\")) with over 750,000 volunteers at over 16 thousand posts (98 per post in shifts) and 75 centers.",
"",
"| \\+ Air Defense Command MCCs |\n| --- |\n| Air Division | {{align\\|left\\|\\# }} {{align\\|right\\| Coordinates}} | {{align\\|left\\| AFB, etc. }} {{align\\|right\\| DC }} | ST | Years |\n| n/a | \\[command center at HQ ADC/NORAD/CONAC] | [Ent](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base \"Ent Air Force Base\") | CO | 1951\\-63 |\n| {{Specify\\|date\\=February 2013}} | MCC\\-01 | | |\n| [29th](/wiki/29th_Air_Division \"29th Air Division\") | MCC\\-02 {{align\\|right\\| {{Coord\\|38\\|50\\|48\\|N\\|094\\|22\\|50\\|W\\|display\\=inline\\|name\\=ADC MCC\\-02 (Kansas City sector)}} }} | [Richards\\-Gebaur](/wiki/Richards-Gebaur_Air_Force_Base \"Richards-Gebaur Air Force Base\") {{align\\|right\\| DC\\-08 }} | MO | 1957\\-69 |\n| | MCC\\-03 | {{Specify\\|date\\=February 2013}} | |\n| [28th](/wiki/28th_Air_Division \"28th Air Division\") | MCC\\-06 | [Hamilton](/wiki/Hamilton_Air_Force_Base \"Hamilton Air Force Base\") | CA |\n| | MCC\\-07 | | {{Specify\\|date\\=February 2013}} |\n| ([Oklahoma City](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_Air_Defense_Sector \"Oklahoma City Air Defense Sector\")) | MCC\\-11 {{align\\|right\\| {{Coord\\|35\\|24\\|13\\|N\\|097\\|21\\|27\\|W\\|display\\=inline\\|name\\=ADC MCC\\-11 (Oklahoma City sector)}} }} | [Oklahoma City AFS](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_Air_Force_Station \"Oklahoma City Air Force Station\") | OK |\n| | MCC\\-16 | | |\n| | MCC\\-17 | | |",
"### Manual Air Defense Control Centers",
"**Manual Air Defense Control Center**s (ADCC, MCC) of the Permanent System were [USAF](/wiki/United_States_Air_Force_command_posts \"United States Air Force command posts\") command posts for [command, control, and coordination](/wiki/Command%2C_control%2C_and_coordination_system \"Command, control, and coordination system\") by [Air Defense Command](/wiki/Air_Defense_Command \"Air Defense Command\"), including early [Cold War](/wiki/Cold_War \"Cold War\") [ground\\-controlled interception](/wiki/Ground-controlled_interception \"Ground-controlled interception\") of enemy aircraft. Each MCC networked radar stations of the sector, plotted radar tracks \\& visual observations, and forwarded information to ADC command center at [Mitchel Field](/wiki/Mitchel_Field \"Mitchel Field\"), [Ent Air Force Base](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base \"Ent Air Force Base\") in 1951, and the new 1954 Ent blockhouse subsequently used by the 1954 [CONAD](/wiki/CONAD \"CONAD\") and the 1957 [NORAD](/wiki/NORAD \"NORAD\").",
"MCCs were generally located at or near a radar station, e.g., [Andrews Air Force Base](/wiki/Andrews_Air_Force_Base \"Andrews Air Force Base\") MCC in Maryland (at/near radar station SM\\-171\\), [Dobbins AFB](/wiki/Dobbins_AFB \"Dobbins AFB\") GA (M\\-87\\), [Geiger Field](/wiki/Geiger_Field \"Geiger Field\") WA (SM\\-172\\), [Kirtland AFB](/wiki/Kirtland_AFB \"Kirtland AFB\") NM (P\\-41\\), [Norton AFB](/wiki/Norton_AFB \"Norton AFB\") CA (P\\-84\\), [Oklahoma City AFS](/wiki/Oklahoma_City_AFS \"Oklahoma City AFS\") OK (P\\-52\\), [Roslyn AFS](/wiki/Roslyn_Air_Force_Station \"Roslyn Air Force Station\") NY (P\\-3\\), [Snelling AFS](/wiki/Snelling_AFS \"Snelling AFS\") MN (P\\-36\\), [Willow Run AFS](/wiki/Willow_Run_AFS \"Willow Run AFS\") MI (P\\-23\\), and [Wright\\-Patterson AFB](/wiki/Wright-Patterson_AFB \"Wright-Patterson AFB\") OH (SM\\-170\\).",
"Some MCCs were replaced by Direction Centers of the subsequent [SAGE Radar Network](/wiki/Semi_Automatic_Ground_Environment \"Semi Automatic Ground Environment\"), e.g., when [McGuire DC\\-01](/wiki/McGuire_Air_Force_Base \"McGuire Air Force Base\") was established, the [Roslyn Air Force Station](/wiki/Roslyn_Air_Force_Station \"Roslyn Air Force Station\") MCC became the \"Combat Alert Center (Manual)\". MCCs continued at several sites where DCs were planned but never built for sectors at [Albuquerque](/wiki/Albuquerque_Air_Defense_Sector \"Albuquerque Air Defense Sector\"), [Fort Knox](/wiki/Fort_Knox_Air_Defense_Sector \"Fort Knox Air Defense Sector\"), [Kansas City](/wiki/Kansas_City_Air_Defense_Sector \"Kansas City Air Defense Sector\"), [Miami](/wiki/Miami_Air_Defense_Sector \"Miami Air Defense Sector\"), [Raleigh](/wiki/Raleigh_Air_Defense_Sector \"Raleigh Air Defense Sector\"), [San Antonio](/wiki/San_Antonio_Air_Defense_Sector \"San Antonio Air Defense Sector\"), [Shreveport](/wiki/Shreveport_Air_Defense_Sector \"Shreveport Air Defense Sector\"), and [St Louis](/wiki/St_Louis_Air_Defense_Sector \"St Louis Air Defense Sector\").",
"Filter Centers **Filter Centers** of the [Ground Observation Corps](/wiki/Ground_Observation_Corps \"Ground Observation Corps\") (e.g., in [New Haven, Connecticut](https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=B6NHAAAAIBAJ&sjid=-v4MAAAAIBAJ&pg=1160,4794388&dq=observation-corps&hl=en) and [Baltimore, Maryland](/wiki/Baltimore%2C_Maryland \"Baltimore, Maryland\")).{{Cite news \\|date\\=5 April 1954 \\|title\\=Less Than Half Spotter Time Filled In Week \\|url\\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id\\=riYmAAAAIBAJ\\&sjid\\=Bf4FAAAAIBAJ\\&dq\\=round\\-hill%20gettysburg\\&pg\\=2238%2C4455496 \\|format\\=Google News Archive \\|publisher\\=Times and News Publishing Company \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Gettysburg Times]] \\|accessdate\\=2012\\-01\\-04}} processed reports from \\~8,000 CONUS watch posts. As with ranger stations for forest fires, watch posts measured the azimuth of a target aircraft or formation, and Filter Centers triangulated azimuth observations from 2 or more stations, assessed the reliability of observations, and provided visual track information to MCCs.\n### Radar stations",
"Five radar stations of the [Lashup Radar Network](/wiki/Lashup_Radar_Network \"Lashup Radar Network\") were redesignated as Permanent System stations (3 later upgraded{{When\\|date\\=February 2013}} with newer radars developed for the Permanent System): [Montauk L\\-10/LP\\-45/P\\-45](/wiki/Montauk_Air_Force_Station \"Montauk Air Force Station\"), [Fort Custis L\\-15/LP\\-56](/wiki/Cape_Charles_Air_Force_Station \"Cape Charles Air Force Station\"), [Palermo L\\-13/LP\\-54/P\\-54](/wiki/Palermo_Air_Force_Station \"Palermo Air Force Station\"), Sault Sainte Marie L\\-17/LP\\-20, and [Highlands L\\-12/LP\\-9/P\\-9](/wiki/Highlands_Air_Force_Station \"Highlands Air Force Station\"). From March to November 1951, the \"LP\" designation was also used for 23 new stations for the Permanent System that were outfitted, instead of with radars developed for the Permanent System, with older radars such as the January 1945 General Electric [AN/CPS\\-5](/wiki/AN/CPS-5 \"AN/CPS-5\") radar, 1948 [Western Electric AN/TPS\\-1B Radar](/wiki/Western_Electric_AN/TPS-1B_Radar \"Western Electric AN/TPS-1B Radar\"), and Bendix [AN/TPS\\-1C](/wiki/AN/TPS-1C \"AN/TPS-1C\") radar.[MX\\-1000 to MX\\-1499 Listing](http://www.designation-systems.net/usmilav/mx/1000-1499.html). Designation\\-systems.net (2005\\-11\\-20\\). Retrieved on 2013\\-09\\-18\\.",
"The LP designator was also used for 1 station opened with [AN/FPS\\-3](/wiki/AN/FPS-3 \"AN/FPS-3\") and [AN/FPS\\-5](/wiki/AN/FPS-5 \"AN/FPS-5\") radars in 1950 ([Tierra Amarilla LP\\-8](/wiki/Tierra_Amarilla_Air_Force_Station \"Tierra Amarilla Air Force Station\")). More than 15 of the new LP stations were subsequently upgraded and designated P\\-xx stations, and some of the squadrons at LP stations that closed moved to new P stations.",
"New LP sites not previously designated L sites: \n* [Bellefontaine LP\\-73/P\\-73](/wiki/Bellefontaine_Air_Force_Station \"Bellefontaine Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B in November 1951\\),\n* Blue Knob LP\\-63 (TPS\\-1C 30 November 1951—station moved to Gibbsboro RP\\-63 in 1961\\),\n* [Cambria LP\\-2/P\\-2](/wiki/Cambria_Air_Force_Station \"Cambria Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1C November 1951\\)\n* [Caswell LP\\-80/P\\-80](/wiki/Caswell_Air_Force_Station \"Caswell Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B March 1951\\),\n* [Colville LP\\-60/P\\-60](/wiki/Colville_Air_Force_Station \"Colville Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B March 1951, TPS\\-1C November 1951\\),\n* [Condon LP\\-32/P\\-32](/wiki/Condon_Air_Force_Station \"Condon Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1C November 1951\\),\n* [Curlew LP\\-6/P\\-6](/wiki/Curlew_Air_Force_Station \"Curlew Air Force Station\") Mt Bonaparte TPS\\-1B 1950\n* [Del Bonita LP\\-24](/wiki/Cut_Bank_Air_Force_Station \"Cut Bank Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B November 1951\\) (P\\-24 is Cut Bank AFS),\n* [Williams Bay AFS](/wiki/Williams_Bay_Air_Force_Station \"Williams Bay Air Force Station\") Elkhorn LP\\-31 (moved to RP\\-31 at [Arlington Heights AFS](/wiki/Arlington_Heights_Air_Force_Station \"Arlington Heights Air Force Station\")),\n* [Finland LP\\-69/P\\-69](/wiki/Finland_Air_Force_Station \"Finland Air Force Station\") (CPS\\-5 30 November 1951\\),\n* [Fort Custer LP\\-67/P\\-67](/wiki/Custer_Air_Force_Station \"Custer Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B 30 November 1951\\),\n* [Godman Field LP\\-82](/wiki/Godman_Army_Airfield \"Godman Army Airfield\") (TPS\\-1C 30 April 1952\\) (P\\-82 [Snow Mountain AFS](/wiki/Snow_Mountain_Air_Force_Station \"Snow Mountain Air Force Station\")),\n* Gonzales LP\\-7 (P\\-7 [Continental Divide AFS](/wiki/Continental_Divide_Air_Force_Station \"Continental Divide Air Force Station\")),\n* Hill Peak Road LP\\-37 (P\\-37 [Point Arena AFS](/wiki/Point_Arena_Air_Force_Station \"Point Arena Air Force Station\")),\n* Keweenaw LP\\-16 (P\\-16 [Calumet AFS](/wiki/Calumet_Air_Force_Station \"Calumet Air Force Station\")),\n* [Klamath LP\\-33/P\\-33](/wiki/Klamath_Air_Force_Station \"Klamath Air Force Station\") TPS\\-1B (Apr 51\\)\n* [Madera LP\\-74/P\\-74](/wiki/Madera_Air_Force_Station \"Madera Air Force Station\") (TPS\\-1B in March 51\\),\n* [Moriarty LP\\-51/P\\-51](/wiki/Moriarty_Air_Force_Station \"Moriarty Air Force Station\") CPS\\-5 (30 Nov 51\\)\n* [Port Austin LP\\-61/P\\-61](/wiki/Port_Austin_Air_Force_Station \"Port Austin Air Force Station\") TPS\\-1C 30\\-Nov\\-51\n* [Rockville LP\\-53/P\\-53](/wiki/Rockville_Air_Force_Station \"Rockville Air Force Station\") TPS\\-1B (30 Nov 51\\)\n* Saddle Mountain/[Othello LP\\-40/P\\-40](/wiki/Othello_Air_Force_Station \"Othello Air Force Station\") TPS\\-1B\n* [San Clemente Island LP\\-39/P\\-39](/wiki/San_Clemente_Island_AFS \"San Clemente Island AFS\") TPS\\-1C Nov\\-51\n* [Tierra Amarilla LP\\-8/P\\-8](/wiki/Tierra_Amarilla_Air_Force_Station \"Tierra Amarilla Air Force Station\") FPS\\-3; FPS\\-5; 1950",
"Permanent System radars were developed in various programs such as the [AN/FPS\\-6](/wiki/AN/FPS-6 \"AN/FPS-6\") (in program MX\\-1353 \\- \"Long range S\\-band height finder\") and [AN/MPS\\-10](/wiki/AN/MPS-10 \"AN/MPS-10\") (MX\\-1354 \\- \"Mobile long range search radar set\").",
"Priority Permanent System The \"Priority Permanent System\" with the initial (priority) radar stations having new radar systems included \"[ADC](/wiki/Air_Defense_Command \"Air Defense Command\") radar site\" P\\-1 at [McChord AFB](/wiki/Joint_Base_Lewis-McChord \"Joint Base Lewis-McChord\") on 1 June 1950\\. Completed in May 1952 to replace the 1950 [Lashup Radar Network](/wiki/Lashup_Radar_Network \"Lashup Radar Network\"),{{r\\|VIchapterII}}{{rp\\|61}} the Priority Permanent System had 5 redesignated LASHUP stations, 23 new stations in 1951 with older radars, 62 stations in 1951 with new equipment, and several of the 10 newly equipped 1952 stations (including [Manassas RP\\-55](/wiki/Manassas_Air_Force_Station \"Manassas Air Force Station\")). The Priority Permanent System used Manual ADCCs, e.g., with [Plexiglas](/wiki/Plexiglas \"Plexiglas\") plotting boards as at the 1954 [Ent Air Force Base](/wiki/Ent_Air_Force_Base \"Ent Air Force Base\") command center for ADC.{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|151}}\nP system extension The \"first extension of the P system into Canada\" (\"Canadian extensions\") for the [Pinetree Line](/wiki/Pinetree_Line \"Pinetree Line\"){{r\\|VolumeI}}{{rp\\|134}} was planned by the \"Radar Extension Program\" for 33 stations and was agreed by the US and Canada in November 1950\\. The plan \"was submitted to the Permanent Joint Board on Defense on February 6, 1951, and\" was subsequently approved by both nations,{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|159}} but by \"April 1951 the United States still had not contributed to the Radar Extension Program\".{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|160}} On 13 June 1951, the US released $20 million for the stations and by June 1952, the joint Canadian\\-American committee on the Radar Extension Program was replaced with the \"Project Pinetree Office\" in [Ottawa, Ontario](/wiki/Ottawa%2C_Ontario \"Ottawa, Ontario\").{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|160}}\nGap\\-filler and semi\\-mobile radar stations On 18 January 1952, ADC proposed the construction of small, unmanned stations with gap filler radars.{{r\\|VolumeI}}{{rp\\|227}} The USAF [Directorate of Plans](/wiki/Directorate_of_Plans \"Directorate of Plans\") (War Plans Division) \"prepared the proposal … to add 29 mobile and 135 low\\-altitude stations to ADC's radar system\" for completion by the end of 1955\\.{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|187}} The first phase began with three 1953 stations at [Walker M\\-90](/wiki/Walker_Air_Force_Base \"Walker Air Force Base\"), [Ellsworth M\\-97](/wiki/Ellsworth_Air_Force_Base \"Ellsworth Air Force Base\"), and [Houma M\\-126 (Z\\-126\\)](/wiki/Houma_Air_Force_Station \"Houma Air Force Station\"); and was completed with 1957 stations at [Almaden M\\-96 (Z\\-96\\)](/wiki/Almaden_Air_Force_Station \"Almaden Air Force Station\"), [Mount Hebo M\\-100](/wiki/Mount_Hebo_Air_Force_Station \"Mount Hebo Air Force Station\"), [Jacksonville M\\-114 (Z\\-114\\)](/wiki/Jacksonville_Naval_Air_Station \"Jacksonville Naval Air Station\"), and [Cherry Point M\\-116](/wiki/Cherry_Point_MCAS \"Cherry Point MCAS\"). \n The \"second\\-phase mobile radar program\" was requested by the [ADC commander](/wiki/Benjamin_W._Chidlaw \"Benjamin W. Chidlaw\") in October 1952{{r\\|Schaffel}} and was completed from 1954 starting with [Geiger Field](/wiki/Geiger_Field \"Geiger Field\") SM\\-172 through 1962 with [Hastings SM\\-133 (Z\\-133\\)](/wiki/Hastings_Air_Force_Station \"Hastings Air Force Station\"). The *Planning Guide for the Third Phase Augmentation Radar Program'* was issued 5 April 1954, and the 3rd phase was for 29 stations, many for coverage along the U.S.\\-Mexican border and the Gulf of Mexico (the [Air Force Council](/wiki/Air_Force_Council \"Air Force Council\") had agreed with ADC's request for the third phase on 28 October 1953\\.){{r\\|Schaffel}} The \"resulting 104 stations were all to be operational by 1956\",{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|154}} and a mock 1956 attack blinded ground defense radars.{{r\\|Winkler}} The third phase of 29 stations{{r\\|VolumeI}}{{rp\\|137}} was deployed beginning with 5 1957 stations and ended with the 1960 [Sundance TM\\-201 (Z\\-201\\)](/wiki/Sundance_Air_Force_Station \"Sundance Air Force Station\"). Gap\\-filler annexes of [Mather P\\-58](/wiki/Mather_Air_Force_Base \"Mather Air Force Base\") (P\\-58A at [Modesto](/wiki/Modesto%2C_California \"Modesto, California\") \\& P\\-58B at [Oroville](/wiki/Oroville%2C_California \"Oroville, California\")) were some of the Permanent System stations planned, but never built.\nTexas Towers were approved on 11 January 1954,{{r\\|VolumeI}} and despite 11 Permanent System radar stations closing in 1957 ([N\\-28 Pinetree station](/wiki/Hopedale_Air_Station \"Hopedale Air Station\") and the [M\\-87](/wiki/Dobbins_Air_Force_Base \"Dobbins Air Force Base\"), [M\\-101](/wiki/Rochester_Air_Force_Station \"Rochester Air Force Station\"), [M\\-104](/wiki/Rye_Air_Force_Station \"Rye Air Force Station\"), [M\\-105](/wiki/Alpena_Air_Force_Station \"Alpena Air Force Station\"), [M\\-106](/wiki/Two_Creeks_Air_Force_Station \"Two Creeks Air Force Station\"), [M\\-109](/wiki/Grand_Marais_Air_Force_Station \"Grand Marais Air Force Station\"), [M\\-122](/wiki/Dallas_Center_Air_Force_Station \"Dallas Center Air Force Station\"), [M\\-128](/wiki/Kingman_Air_Force_Station \"Kingman Air Force Station\"), [M\\-131](/wiki/Owingsville_Air_Force_Station \"Owingsville Air Force Station\"), \\& [SM\\-137](/wiki/Carmi_Air_Force_Station \"Carmi Air Force Station\") stations), at \"the end of 1957, ADC operated 182 radar stations…32 had been added during the last half of the year as low\\-altitude, unmanned gap\\-filler radars. The total consisted of 47 gap\\-filler stations, 75 Permanent System radars, 39 semimobile radars, 19 Pinetree stations,…1 Lashup\\[\\-era radar and a] single [Texas Tower](/wiki/Texas_Tower \"Texas Tower\")\".{{r\\|Schaffel}}{{rp\\|223}}",
"Relocated stations When radar stations began converting to SAGE, 8 Permanent stations that closed from 1959\\-1964 had their squadrons relocated to stations with \"RP\" designations, including the radar squadrons from the last 2 remaining \"LP\" stations: ([Elkhorn/Williams Bay LP\\-31](/wiki/Williams_Bay_Air_Force_Station \"Williams Bay Air Force Station\") and [Blue Knob/Claysburg LP\\-63](/wiki/Claysburg_Air_Force_Station \"Claysburg Air Force Station\")). All but 1 of the relocating squadrons went to new sites (the [770th](/wiki/770th_Radar_Squadron \"770th Radar Squadron\") moved{{When\\|date\\=February 2013}} to a [1955 Army radar station](/wiki/Fort_Meade_radar_station \"Fort Meade radar station\") designated USAF RP\\-54 in 1961\\), and 5 of the units co\\-located with [Project Nike](/wiki/Project_Nike \"Project Nike\") [Missile Master](/wiki/Missile_Master \"Missile Master\") units. A 1959\\-1961 USAF radar squadron was at the [Fort Heath](/wiki/Fort_Heath \"Fort Heath\") radar station of the [joint\\-use site system (JUSS)](/wiki/List_of_USAF_Aerospace_Defense_Command_General_Surveillance_Radar_Stations%23Joint-use_site_system \"List of USAF Aerospace Defense Command General Surveillance Radar Stations#Joint-use site system\")."
] |
Lens designations
-----------------
[thumb\|right\|Pentax smc M 50mm f2](/wiki/File:Pentax_SMC_M_50mm_f2.jpg "Pentax SMC M 50mm f2.jpg")
Below is a list of K\-Mount Lens Lines produced by Pentax.{{Cite web \| url\=http://www.mosphotos.com/PentaxLensesExplained.html \| title\=Pentax K\-Mount Lenses Explained: The differences between various Pentax lens series}}
### K lenses
The first generation of Pentax K\-mount lenses. Officially not referred to as K series lenses, they usually are given this designation to distinguish them from later K\-mount lenses (such as the M, A, F, FA and DA series). These were exclusively manual focus lenses with no electronic features. The name of each lens started with an upper case "SMC" for the earlier versions and the lower case "smc" for the later versions. For example SMC/smc Pentax 28mm F3\.5, where SMC/smc stands for Super\-Multi\-Coated, the lens coating introduced in the early 1970s at the end of the M42\-mount era.
### M lenses
The M series of lenses followed on from the earlier K series lenses. As with the earlier lenses, these were manual K\-mount lenses without any electronic features. They behave just like the K series but are generally smaller in size, to match the more compact bodies of the same era, e.g. the [Pentax MX](/wiki/Pentax_MX "Pentax MX") and the [Pentax ME Super](/wiki/Pentax_ME_Super "Pentax ME Super").
### A lenses
Another K\-mount lens, the A series of lenses saw the introduction of "automatic" aperture settings. The lenses had an aperture ring (unlike the later DA series), and thus the aperture could be set manually, but they also had an "A" mode, which allowed the camera to control the aperture automatically.
### F lenses
[thumb\|right\|SMC Pentax\-F 50mm F1\.7 K\-mount prime lens](/wiki/File:SMC_Pentax-F_50mm_F1.7_side.jpg "SMC Pentax-F 50mm F1.7 side.jpg")
The F series were the first autofocus lenses (excluding the rare smc Pentax\-AF 35\-70mm F2\.8, made only for the ME\-F camera). The autofocus is of screw\-drive type, still supported by all Pentax DSLRs. They featured an aperture ring, which allowed the aperture to be controlled manually. Thus F lenses are able to be used on older cameras which do not support automatic setting of the aperture, such as the [Pentax K1000](/wiki/Pentax_K1000 "Pentax K1000").
### FA lenses
These lenses are designed with use for full\-frame film SLR cameras. As with the F series, they feature an aperture ring providing compatibility with older camera bodies. Autofocus is like the F series of screw\-drive type. The FA\* lenses are professional grade lenses and the FA Limited lenses are all metal high quality primes. The FA series has been superseded by the DA and D FA series optimized for digital cameras, but as of March 2017 the three FA limited as well as the FA 35 mm f2 and 50 mm f1\.4 are still in production.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.ricoh\-imaging.co.jp/japan/products/lens/images/K\_Mount\_Lens.pdf \|title\=Pentax K\-Mount Lens Line Up \|date\=February 2017 \|website\=ricoh\-imaging.co.jp \|publisher\=\[\[Ricoh\|Ricoh imaging]]\|access\-date\=27 March 2017}}
#### FA\-J lenses
The FA\-J series consisted of three lower\-priced zoom lenses, that were largely identical to the FA series of lenses, but like later DA series lenses lacked the aperture ring. As a result, they are not fully compatible with some older manual film cameras, as there was no method of setting the aperture other than through the camera body.
### D FA lenses
[thumb\|smc Pentax\-D FA 100mm F2\.8 Macro WR](/wiki/File:PentaxMacroLens100WR.jpg "PentaxMacroLens100WR.jpg")
These lenses are coated with glazes that make the lenses more suitable for digital cameras. However, they also support older 35mm camera formats, as they provide [full frame](/wiki/Full-frame_digital_SLR "Full-frame digital SLR") coverage. The series originally consisted only of two macro lenses – a 50mm and a 100mm – which both featured an aperture ring. In 2009 the 100mm was replaced by [a weather resistant (WR) version](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA_100mm_WR_lens "Pentax D FA 100mm WR lens") without an aperture ring,{{cite web \|url\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/8214311760/pentax100mm \|title\=Press Release: The smc Pentax\-D FA Macro 100mm F2\.8 WR\|author\= \|date\=9 December 2009 \|publisher\=\[\[Hoya Corporation]]\| via\=\[\[dpreview]] \|access\-date\=16 March 2015}} that was co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina").[Tokina\#History](/wiki/Tokina%23History "Tokina#History") The series was revived in February 2015 when the [D FA\* 70\-200mm f2\.8](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA%2A_70-200mm_lens "Pentax D FA* 70-200mm lens") and [D FA 150\-450mm f4\.5\-5\.6](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA_150-450mm_lens "Pentax D FA 150-450mm lens") telephoto zoom lenses were announced{{cite web \|url\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/5760258369/ricoh\-introduces\-hd\-pentax\-d\-fa\-70\-200mm\-f2\-8\-and\-hd\-pentax\-d\-fa\-150\-450mm\-f4\-5\-5\-6\-zooms \|title\=Press Release: The smc Pentax\-D FA Macro 100mm F2\.8 WR\|author\= \|date\=4 February 2015 \|publisher\=\[\[Ricoh\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\| via\=\[\[dpreview]] \|access\-date\=16 March 2015}} along with first pictures of a (then unnamed) [K\-1](/wiki/Pentax_K-1 "Pentax K-1") mock\-up.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/3071796575/ricoh\-announces\-development\-of\-long\-awaited\-full\-frame\-pentax\-dslr \|title\=Ricoh announces development of long\-awaited full\-frame Pentax DSLR\|date\=4 February 2015 \|website\=\[\[dpreview]] \|access\-date\=16 March 2015}}
### DA lenses
The DA lenses were designed specifically for the Pentax digital cameras incorporating an [APS\-C](/wiki/APS-C "APS-C") digital sensor. As the APS\-C sensor has a smaller surface area than 35mm film, these lenses are not generally considered to be compatible with older cameras. They also lack an aperture ring, limiting their use on cameras that do not support automatic aperture settings. Most of the DA zoom lenses are available in weather resistant (WR) versions to match the weather sealed capabilities of the medium to upper level Pentax DSLR camera bodies. While older models still have the in\-body screw drive autofocus system, newer designs marked "DC", "SDM" or "PLM" feature silent, in\-lens autofocus motors.
Some lenses of this product line such as the DA 10\-17 Fisheye were co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina").{{Cite journal\|last\=Keppler\|first\=Herbert\|year\=2007\|title\=The Name Game – Just who made your favourite lens?\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=If3xcPm2ZqYC\&dq\=pentax\+tokina\+cooperation\&pg\=PA46\|journal\=\[\[Popular Photography]]\|issue\=January 2007\|pages\=46\|via\=Google Books}}
#### DA\-L lenses
These are lighter and cheaper versions of DA series zoom lenses. They have a plastic (as opposed to steel) mount and lack the quick\-shift focusing system of their heavier siblings. They are only sold in kits with entry\-level bodies.
#### DA\* lenses
[thumb\|right\|Pentax DA\* 16\-50mm f2\.8 alongside the smaller Pentax DA 18\-55mm f3\.5\-5\.6 lens](/wiki/File:Pentax16-50_Pentax18-55.jpg "Pentax16-50 Pentax18-55.jpg")
The DA\* lenses are designed for use with Pentax digital SLR cameras. DA\* lenses have higher quality optics and feature a higher level of weather sealing (AW) than most DA lenses (WR). The DA\* lenses are more expensive and generally feature improved light transmission and larger aperture openings for better low light performance. Some DA\* lenses also feature both body driven screw drive focusing and the Pentax SDM (Supersonic Drive Motor) lens based focus mechanism.
Some lenses of this product line were co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina"). Examples include the DA\* 16\-50 and DA\* 50\-135\.
#### DA Limited lenses
These are high quality (mostly prime) lenses with the lens housing made of metal. They usually have a wider maximum aperture compared to zooms but narrower as compared to other prime lenses. This is a compromise as DA Limited lenses are usually made to be much more compact than other primes lenses. In August 2013 the DA Limited lenses were upgraded with Pentax new HD coating, replacing the previous smc coating.{{Cite web \| url\=http://www.dpreview.com/news/2013/08/27/ricoh\-announces\-hd\-update\-to\-pentax\-limited\-primes\-15mm\-f4\-21mm\-f32\-35mm\-f28\-macro\-40mm\-f28\-70mm\-f24 \| title\=Ricoh announces 'HD' update to Pentax DA Limited primes}} The new HD lenses are also available in both silver and black, as opposed to only black.
The DA 35/2\.8 Macro was co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina"). As of February 2015, the *DA 20\-40mm F2\.8\-4 Limited DC WR* announced in November 2013{{cite web \|url\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/1853330480/weather\-resistant\-pentax\-limited\-20\-40mm\-f2\-8\-4\-zoom\-lens\-announced \|title\=Press Release: HD Pentax\-DA 20\-40mm F2\.8\-4ED Limited DC WR \|author\= \|date\=6 November 2013 \|publisher\=\[\[Ricoh\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\| via\=\[\[dpreview]] \|access\-date\=12 February 2015}} stands out for being both the only zoom as well as the only weather resistant lens of the series.
|
[
"Lens designations\n-----------------",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Pentax smc M 50mm f2](/wiki/File:Pentax_SMC_M_50mm_f2.jpg \"Pentax SMC M 50mm f2.jpg\")",
"Below is a list of K\\-Mount Lens Lines produced by Pentax.{{Cite web \\| url\\=http://www.mosphotos.com/PentaxLensesExplained.html \\| title\\=Pentax K\\-Mount Lenses Explained: The differences between various Pentax lens series}}",
"### K lenses",
"The first generation of Pentax K\\-mount lenses. Officially not referred to as K series lenses, they usually are given this designation to distinguish them from later K\\-mount lenses (such as the M, A, F, FA and DA series). These were exclusively manual focus lenses with no electronic features. The name of each lens started with an upper case \"SMC\" for the earlier versions and the lower case \"smc\" for the later versions. For example SMC/smc Pentax 28mm F3\\.5, where SMC/smc stands for Super\\-Multi\\-Coated, the lens coating introduced in the early 1970s at the end of the M42\\-mount era.",
"### M lenses",
"The M series of lenses followed on from the earlier K series lenses. As with the earlier lenses, these were manual K\\-mount lenses without any electronic features. They behave just like the K series but are generally smaller in size, to match the more compact bodies of the same era, e.g. the [Pentax MX](/wiki/Pentax_MX \"Pentax MX\") and the [Pentax ME Super](/wiki/Pentax_ME_Super \"Pentax ME Super\").",
"### A lenses",
"Another K\\-mount lens, the A series of lenses saw the introduction of \"automatic\" aperture settings. The lenses had an aperture ring (unlike the later DA series), and thus the aperture could be set manually, but they also had an \"A\" mode, which allowed the camera to control the aperture automatically.",
"### F lenses",
"[thumb\\|right\\|SMC Pentax\\-F 50mm F1\\.7 K\\-mount prime lens](/wiki/File:SMC_Pentax-F_50mm_F1.7_side.jpg \"SMC Pentax-F 50mm F1.7 side.jpg\")\nThe F series were the first autofocus lenses (excluding the rare smc Pentax\\-AF 35\\-70mm F2\\.8, made only for the ME\\-F camera). The autofocus is of screw\\-drive type, still supported by all Pentax DSLRs. They featured an aperture ring, which allowed the aperture to be controlled manually. Thus F lenses are able to be used on older cameras which do not support automatic setting of the aperture, such as the [Pentax K1000](/wiki/Pentax_K1000 \"Pentax K1000\").",
"### FA lenses",
"These lenses are designed with use for full\\-frame film SLR cameras. As with the F series, they feature an aperture ring providing compatibility with older camera bodies. Autofocus is like the F series of screw\\-drive type. The FA\\* lenses are professional grade lenses and the FA Limited lenses are all metal high quality primes. The FA series has been superseded by the DA and D FA series optimized for digital cameras, but as of March 2017 the three FA limited as well as the FA 35 mm f2 and 50 mm f1\\.4 are still in production.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.ricoh\\-imaging.co.jp/japan/products/lens/images/K\\_Mount\\_Lens.pdf \\|title\\=Pentax K\\-Mount Lens Line Up \\|date\\=February 2017 \\|website\\=ricoh\\-imaging.co.jp \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Ricoh\\|Ricoh imaging]]\\|access\\-date\\=27 March 2017}}",
"#### FA\\-J lenses",
"The FA\\-J series consisted of three lower\\-priced zoom lenses, that were largely identical to the FA series of lenses, but like later DA series lenses lacked the aperture ring. As a result, they are not fully compatible with some older manual film cameras, as there was no method of setting the aperture other than through the camera body.",
"### D FA lenses",
"[thumb\\|smc Pentax\\-D FA 100mm F2\\.8 Macro WR](/wiki/File:PentaxMacroLens100WR.jpg \"PentaxMacroLens100WR.jpg\")\nThese lenses are coated with glazes that make the lenses more suitable for digital cameras. However, they also support older 35mm camera formats, as they provide [full frame](/wiki/Full-frame_digital_SLR \"Full-frame digital SLR\") coverage. The series originally consisted only of two macro lenses – a 50mm and a 100mm – which both featured an aperture ring. In 2009 the 100mm was replaced by [a weather resistant (WR) version](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA_100mm_WR_lens \"Pentax D FA 100mm WR lens\") without an aperture ring,{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/8214311760/pentax100mm \\|title\\=Press Release: The smc Pentax\\-D FA Macro 100mm F2\\.8 WR\\|author\\= \\|date\\=9 December 2009 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Hoya Corporation]]\\| via\\=\\[\\[dpreview]] \\|access\\-date\\=16 March 2015}} that was co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\").[Tokina\\#History](/wiki/Tokina%23History \"Tokina#History\") The series was revived in February 2015 when the [D FA\\* 70\\-200mm f2\\.8](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA%2A_70-200mm_lens \"Pentax D FA* 70-200mm lens\") and [D FA 150\\-450mm f4\\.5\\-5\\.6](/wiki/Pentax_D_FA_150-450mm_lens \"Pentax D FA 150-450mm lens\") telephoto zoom lenses were announced{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/5760258369/ricoh\\-introduces\\-hd\\-pentax\\-d\\-fa\\-70\\-200mm\\-f2\\-8\\-and\\-hd\\-pentax\\-d\\-fa\\-150\\-450mm\\-f4\\-5\\-5\\-6\\-zooms \\|title\\=Press Release: The smc Pentax\\-D FA Macro 100mm F2\\.8 WR\\|author\\= \\|date\\=4 February 2015 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Ricoh\\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\\| via\\=\\[\\[dpreview]] \\|access\\-date\\=16 March 2015}} along with first pictures of a (then unnamed) [K\\-1](/wiki/Pentax_K-1 \"Pentax K-1\") mock\\-up.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/3071796575/ricoh\\-announces\\-development\\-of\\-long\\-awaited\\-full\\-frame\\-pentax\\-dslr \\|title\\=Ricoh announces development of long\\-awaited full\\-frame Pentax DSLR\\|date\\=4 February 2015 \\|website\\=\\[\\[dpreview]] \\|access\\-date\\=16 March 2015}}",
"### DA lenses",
"The DA lenses were designed specifically for the Pentax digital cameras incorporating an [APS\\-C](/wiki/APS-C \"APS-C\") digital sensor. As the APS\\-C sensor has a smaller surface area than 35mm film, these lenses are not generally considered to be compatible with older cameras. They also lack an aperture ring, limiting their use on cameras that do not support automatic aperture settings. Most of the DA zoom lenses are available in weather resistant (WR) versions to match the weather sealed capabilities of the medium to upper level Pentax DSLR camera bodies. While older models still have the in\\-body screw drive autofocus system, newer designs marked \"DC\", \"SDM\" or \"PLM\" feature silent, in\\-lens autofocus motors.",
"Some lenses of this product line such as the DA 10\\-17 Fisheye were co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\").{{Cite journal\\|last\\=Keppler\\|first\\=Herbert\\|year\\=2007\\|title\\=The Name Game – Just who made your favourite lens?\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=If3xcPm2ZqYC\\&dq\\=pentax\\+tokina\\+cooperation\\&pg\\=PA46\\|journal\\=\\[\\[Popular Photography]]\\|issue\\=January 2007\\|pages\\=46\\|via\\=Google Books}}",
"#### DA\\-L lenses",
"These are lighter and cheaper versions of DA series zoom lenses. They have a plastic (as opposed to steel) mount and lack the quick\\-shift focusing system of their heavier siblings. They are only sold in kits with entry\\-level bodies.",
"#### DA\\* lenses",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Pentax DA\\* 16\\-50mm f2\\.8 alongside the smaller Pentax DA 18\\-55mm f3\\.5\\-5\\.6 lens](/wiki/File:Pentax16-50_Pentax18-55.jpg \"Pentax16-50 Pentax18-55.jpg\")\nThe DA\\* lenses are designed for use with Pentax digital SLR cameras. DA\\* lenses have higher quality optics and feature a higher level of weather sealing (AW) than most DA lenses (WR). The DA\\* lenses are more expensive and generally feature improved light transmission and larger aperture openings for better low light performance. Some DA\\* lenses also feature both body driven screw drive focusing and the Pentax SDM (Supersonic Drive Motor) lens based focus mechanism.",
"Some lenses of this product line were co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\"). Examples include the DA\\* 16\\-50 and DA\\* 50\\-135\\.",
"#### DA Limited lenses",
"These are high quality (mostly prime) lenses with the lens housing made of metal. They usually have a wider maximum aperture compared to zooms but narrower as compared to other prime lenses. This is a compromise as DA Limited lenses are usually made to be much more compact than other primes lenses. In August 2013 the DA Limited lenses were upgraded with Pentax new HD coating, replacing the previous smc coating.{{Cite web \\| url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/news/2013/08/27/ricoh\\-announces\\-hd\\-update\\-to\\-pentax\\-limited\\-primes\\-15mm\\-f4\\-21mm\\-f32\\-35mm\\-f28\\-macro\\-40mm\\-f28\\-70mm\\-f24 \\| title\\=Ricoh announces 'HD' update to Pentax DA Limited primes}} The new HD lenses are also available in both silver and black, as opposed to only black.",
"The DA 35/2\\.8 Macro was co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\"). As of February 2015, the *DA 20\\-40mm F2\\.8\\-4 Limited DC WR* announced in November 2013{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/1853330480/weather\\-resistant\\-pentax\\-limited\\-20\\-40mm\\-f2\\-8\\-4\\-zoom\\-lens\\-announced \\|title\\=Press Release: HD Pentax\\-DA 20\\-40mm F2\\.8\\-4ED Limited DC WR \\|author\\= \\|date\\=6 November 2013 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Ricoh\\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\\| via\\=\\[\\[dpreview]] \\|access\\-date\\=12 February 2015}} stands out for being both the only zoom as well as the only weather resistant lens of the series.",
""
] |
### DA lenses
The DA lenses were designed specifically for the Pentax digital cameras incorporating an [APS\-C](/wiki/APS-C "APS-C") digital sensor. As the APS\-C sensor has a smaller surface area than 35mm film, these lenses are not generally considered to be compatible with older cameras. They also lack an aperture ring, limiting their use on cameras that do not support automatic aperture settings. Most of the DA zoom lenses are available in weather resistant (WR) versions to match the weather sealed capabilities of the medium to upper level Pentax DSLR camera bodies. While older models still have the in\-body screw drive autofocus system, newer designs marked "DC", "SDM" or "PLM" feature silent, in\-lens autofocus motors.
Some lenses of this product line such as the DA 10\-17 Fisheye were co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina").{{Cite journal\|last\=Keppler\|first\=Herbert\|year\=2007\|title\=The Name Game – Just who made your favourite lens?\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=If3xcPm2ZqYC\&dq\=pentax\+tokina\+cooperation\&pg\=PA46\|journal\=\[\[Popular Photography]]\|issue\=January 2007\|pages\=46\|via\=Google Books}}
#### DA\-L lenses
These are lighter and cheaper versions of DA series zoom lenses. They have a plastic (as opposed to steel) mount and lack the quick\-shift focusing system of their heavier siblings. They are only sold in kits with entry\-level bodies.
#### DA\* lenses
[thumb\|right\|Pentax DA\* 16\-50mm f2\.8 alongside the smaller Pentax DA 18\-55mm f3\.5\-5\.6 lens](/wiki/File:Pentax16-50_Pentax18-55.jpg "Pentax16-50 Pentax18-55.jpg")
The DA\* lenses are designed for use with Pentax digital SLR cameras. DA\* lenses have higher quality optics and feature a higher level of weather sealing (AW) than most DA lenses (WR). The DA\* lenses are more expensive and generally feature improved light transmission and larger aperture openings for better low light performance. Some DA\* lenses also feature both body driven screw drive focusing and the Pentax SDM (Supersonic Drive Motor) lens based focus mechanism.
Some lenses of this product line were co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina"). Examples include the DA\* 16\-50 and DA\* 50\-135\.
#### DA Limited lenses
These are high quality (mostly prime) lenses with the lens housing made of metal. They usually have a wider maximum aperture compared to zooms but narrower as compared to other prime lenses. This is a compromise as DA Limited lenses are usually made to be much more compact than other primes lenses. In August 2013 the DA Limited lenses were upgraded with Pentax new HD coating, replacing the previous smc coating.{{Cite web \| url\=http://www.dpreview.com/news/2013/08/27/ricoh\-announces\-hd\-update\-to\-pentax\-limited\-primes\-15mm\-f4\-21mm\-f32\-35mm\-f28\-macro\-40mm\-f28\-70mm\-f24 \| title\=Ricoh announces 'HD' update to Pentax DA Limited primes}} The new HD lenses are also available in both silver and black, as opposed to only black.
The DA 35/2\.8 Macro was co\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina "Tokina"). As of February 2015, the *DA 20\-40mm F2\.8\-4 Limited DC WR* announced in November 2013{{cite web \|url\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/1853330480/weather\-resistant\-pentax\-limited\-20\-40mm\-f2\-8\-4\-zoom\-lens\-announced \|title\=Press Release: HD Pentax\-DA 20\-40mm F2\.8\-4ED Limited DC WR \|author\= \|date\=6 November 2013 \|publisher\=\[\[Ricoh\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\| via\=\[\[dpreview]] \|access\-date\=12 February 2015}} stands out for being both the only zoom as well as the only weather resistant lens of the series.
|
[
"### DA lenses",
"The DA lenses were designed specifically for the Pentax digital cameras incorporating an [APS\\-C](/wiki/APS-C \"APS-C\") digital sensor. As the APS\\-C sensor has a smaller surface area than 35mm film, these lenses are not generally considered to be compatible with older cameras. They also lack an aperture ring, limiting their use on cameras that do not support automatic aperture settings. Most of the DA zoom lenses are available in weather resistant (WR) versions to match the weather sealed capabilities of the medium to upper level Pentax DSLR camera bodies. While older models still have the in\\-body screw drive autofocus system, newer designs marked \"DC\", \"SDM\" or \"PLM\" feature silent, in\\-lens autofocus motors.",
"Some lenses of this product line such as the DA 10\\-17 Fisheye were co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\").{{Cite journal\\|last\\=Keppler\\|first\\=Herbert\\|year\\=2007\\|title\\=The Name Game – Just who made your favourite lens?\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=If3xcPm2ZqYC\\&dq\\=pentax\\+tokina\\+cooperation\\&pg\\=PA46\\|journal\\=\\[\\[Popular Photography]]\\|issue\\=January 2007\\|pages\\=46\\|via\\=Google Books}}",
"#### DA\\-L lenses",
"These are lighter and cheaper versions of DA series zoom lenses. They have a plastic (as opposed to steel) mount and lack the quick\\-shift focusing system of their heavier siblings. They are only sold in kits with entry\\-level bodies.",
"#### DA\\* lenses",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Pentax DA\\* 16\\-50mm f2\\.8 alongside the smaller Pentax DA 18\\-55mm f3\\.5\\-5\\.6 lens](/wiki/File:Pentax16-50_Pentax18-55.jpg \"Pentax16-50 Pentax18-55.jpg\")\nThe DA\\* lenses are designed for use with Pentax digital SLR cameras. DA\\* lenses have higher quality optics and feature a higher level of weather sealing (AW) than most DA lenses (WR). The DA\\* lenses are more expensive and generally feature improved light transmission and larger aperture openings for better low light performance. Some DA\\* lenses also feature both body driven screw drive focusing and the Pentax SDM (Supersonic Drive Motor) lens based focus mechanism.",
"Some lenses of this product line were co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\"). Examples include the DA\\* 16\\-50 and DA\\* 50\\-135\\.",
"#### DA Limited lenses",
"These are high quality (mostly prime) lenses with the lens housing made of metal. They usually have a wider maximum aperture compared to zooms but narrower as compared to other prime lenses. This is a compromise as DA Limited lenses are usually made to be much more compact than other primes lenses. In August 2013 the DA Limited lenses were upgraded with Pentax new HD coating, replacing the previous smc coating.{{Cite web \\| url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/news/2013/08/27/ricoh\\-announces\\-hd\\-update\\-to\\-pentax\\-limited\\-primes\\-15mm\\-f4\\-21mm\\-f32\\-35mm\\-f28\\-macro\\-40mm\\-f28\\-70mm\\-f24 \\| title\\=Ricoh announces 'HD' update to Pentax DA Limited primes}} The new HD lenses are also available in both silver and black, as opposed to only black.",
"The DA 35/2\\.8 Macro was co\\-developed with [Tokina](/wiki/Tokina \"Tokina\"). As of February 2015, the *DA 20\\-40mm F2\\.8\\-4 Limited DC WR* announced in November 2013{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.dpreview.com/articles/1853330480/weather\\-resistant\\-pentax\\-limited\\-20\\-40mm\\-f2\\-8\\-4\\-zoom\\-lens\\-announced \\|title\\=Press Release: HD Pentax\\-DA 20\\-40mm F2\\.8\\-4ED Limited DC WR \\|author\\= \\|date\\=6 November 2013 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Ricoh\\|Pentax Ricoh Imaging Company]]\\| via\\=\\[\\[dpreview]] \\|access\\-date\\=12 February 2015}} stands out for being both the only zoom as well as the only weather resistant lens of the series.",
""
] |
Violins
-------
Deconet was often traveling outside of Venice, and therefore it is not plausible that he ever held an [apprenticeship](/wiki/Apprentice "Apprentice"). Apprenticeships required regular attendance and would not have paid enough to support his family. All documents in reference to Deconet list him as a *sonadore*, which means "player".
Deconet most likely took previously bought violins with him on his travels and resold them at fairs and markets, where he would play and showcase his talent. This theory could explain the varying labels, some handwritten, that he or his buyers would place upon the instruments to remember its origins and garner publicity.
Analysis of instruments attributed to Deconet seem to confirm this theory. All of "his" instruments are obviously of Venetian making, but there are huge differences in style, form, and workmanship. Limited instruments with his label between 1750 and 1760 reveal a probable privileged source of violins from some Venetian maker who was interested in profit. The changes of style of the instruments can be explained by changes of sources for the instruments, as they are seemingly incoherent for the usual artisan development changes.
His instruments have features that are typical of Venetian violin makers of the time, such as Pietro Guarnieri and Giorgio Serafin. Violins made in workshops were rarely the work of the *maestro* (means master), but usually made by the many workers. Instruments made by the workers were generally of the same quality, but much cheaper. Cheaper instruments led to Deconet making a profit.
While Deconet lived in Bragara, he lived next to Domenico Garlato, "a violin maker with a workshop in his home and three sons," and Giacomo Codeghin, "a violin maker without a family living in Calle della Morte." It is extremely likely that Deconet bought instruments for resale from these violin makers.
|
[
"Violins\n-------",
"Deconet was often traveling outside of Venice, and therefore it is not plausible that he ever held an [apprenticeship](/wiki/Apprentice \"Apprentice\"). Apprenticeships required regular attendance and would not have paid enough to support his family. All documents in reference to Deconet list him as a *sonadore*, which means \"player\".",
"Deconet most likely took previously bought violins with him on his travels and resold them at fairs and markets, where he would play and showcase his talent. This theory could explain the varying labels, some handwritten, that he or his buyers would place upon the instruments to remember its origins and garner publicity.",
"Analysis of instruments attributed to Deconet seem to confirm this theory. All of \"his\" instruments are obviously of Venetian making, but there are huge differences in style, form, and workmanship. Limited instruments with his label between 1750 and 1760 reveal a probable privileged source of violins from some Venetian maker who was interested in profit. The changes of style of the instruments can be explained by changes of sources for the instruments, as they are seemingly incoherent for the usual artisan development changes.",
"His instruments have features that are typical of Venetian violin makers of the time, such as Pietro Guarnieri and Giorgio Serafin. Violins made in workshops were rarely the work of the *maestro* (means master), but usually made by the many workers. Instruments made by the workers were generally of the same quality, but much cheaper. Cheaper instruments led to Deconet making a profit.",
"While Deconet lived in Bragara, he lived next to Domenico Garlato, \"a violin maker with a workshop in his home and three sons,\" and Giacomo Codeghin, \"a violin maker without a family living in Calle della Morte.\" It is extremely likely that Deconet bought instruments for resale from these violin makers.",
""
] |
Phonology
---------
### Vowels
T.Givon (2011\) gives the following orthography and phonetic information for Southern Ute. Northern Ute differs from Southern and Central in some lexical and phonological areas.
Southern Ute has five vowels, as well as several allophones, which are not shown in the orthography. Each vowel can be short or long, and vowel length is marked orthographically by doubling the vowel. In Ute, the length of a vowel is often phonemic, and relevant for determining meaning. For example, *whca\-y*, meaning 'wrapping,' versus *whcáa\-y*, meaning 'swirling'. In some cases, however, the difference between a long and a short vowel is purely phonetic, and does not change word meaning. Ute devoices vowels in certain phonological or grammatical environments, as described in later sections. Devoiced vowels are marked in the orthography by underlining them, or, when the identity of the underlying vowel has been lost, with the letter \[h].
Here bold text indicates a practical orthographic representation, while the [IPA](/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alphabet "International Phonetic Alphabet") representation is included in brackets.
| | [Front](/wiki/Front_vowel "Front vowel") | | [Central](/wiki/Central_vowel "Central vowel") | [Back](/wiki/Back_vowel "Back vowel") | |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| unrounded | rounded | unrounded | rounded |
| [High](/wiki/Close_vowel "Close vowel") | **i** {{IPAblink\|i}} | | | **ʉ** {{IPAblink\|ɯ}} | **u** {{IPAblink\|u}} |
| [Mid](/wiki/Mid_vowel "Mid vowel") | | **ɵ** {{IPAblink\|œ}} | | | |
| [Low](/wiki/Open_vowel "Open vowel") | | | **a** {{IPAblink\|ä}} | | |
#### Allophones
* {{IPAblink\|ɨ}} is an allophone of **ʉ**
* {{IPAblink\|e}} and {{IPAblink\|æ}} are both allophones of **a**; the former is used more often by younger speakers, while older speakers use the latter
* {{IPAblink\|o}} is an allophone of **ɵ**.
### Consonants
Southern Ute consonants are given in the table below. As above, orthographic representations are bold and the IPA representations are in brackets. All stops in Ute are voiceless. Thus, **g** here does not indicate a [voiced velar stop](/wiki/Voiced_velar_stop "Voiced velar stop") but rather a [voiced velar fricative](/wiki/Voiced_velar_fricative "Voiced velar fricative"), similar to *luego* in Spanish. Also similar to Spanish is the [voiced bilabial fricative](/wiki/Voiced_bilabial_fricative "Voiced bilabial fricative") **v**, as in the Spanish phrase *la verdad*, in contrast with the voiced labiodental fricative {{IPA\|\[v]}} which does not appear in Ute. The velar sounds **k** and **g** have [uvular](/wiki/Uvular_consonant "Uvular consonant") [allophones](/wiki/Allophones "Allophones"): **k** becomes either a [voiceless uvular stop](/wiki/Voiceless_uvular_stop "Voiceless uvular stop") {{IPA\|\[q]}} or a [voiceless uvular fricative](/wiki/Voiceless_uvular_fricative "Voiceless uvular fricative") {{IPA\|\[χ]}} when either between two vowels or adjacent to the vowel {{IPA\|\[o]}};{{clarify\|date\=April 2013}} likewise **g** becomes a voiced uvular fricative {{IPA\|\[ʁ]}} under the same conditions. Either **k** or **g** can become a [voiceless velar fricative](/wiki/Voiceless_velar_fricative "Voiceless velar fricative") {{IPA\|\[x]}} when before a de\-voiced word ending.
Note here that [coronals](/wiki/Coronal_consonant "Coronal consonant") are produced as dental sounds rather than the [alveolar](/wiki/Alveolar_consonant "Alveolar consonant") sounds used in English.
| | [Labial](/wiki/Labial_consonant "Labial consonant") | [Dental](/wiki/Dental_consonant "Dental consonant") | [Palatal](/wiki/Palatal_consonant "Palatal consonant") | [Velar](/wiki/Velar_consonant "Velar consonant") | [Glottal](/wiki/Glottal_consonant "Glottal consonant") |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [Stop](/wiki/Stop_consonant "Stop consonant") | **p** {{IPAblink\|p}} | **t** {{IPAblink\|t}} | **ch** {{IPAblink\|tʃ}} | **k** {{IPAblink\|k}} | **'** {{IPAblink\|ʔ}} |
| [Fricative](/wiki/Fricative_consonant "Fricative consonant") | **v** {{IPAblink\|β}} | **s** {{IPAblink\|s}} | | **g** {{IPAblink\|ɣ}} | |
| [Nasal](/wiki/Nasal_consonant "Nasal consonant") | **m** {{IPAblink\|m}} | **n** {{IPAblink\|n}} | | | |
| [Semivowel](/wiki/Semivowel "Semivowel") | **w** {{IPAblink\|w}} | | **y** {{IPAblink\|j}} | | |
| [Flap](/wiki/Flap_consonant "Flap consonant") | | **r** {{IPAblink\|ɾ}} | | | |
#### Allophones
* {{IPAblink\|q}}, and **qh (**or {{IPAblink\|χ}}), are allophones of **k**
* **kh (**or {{IPAblink\|x}}), is an allophone of **k** or **g**
* **gh,** or {{IPAblink\|ʁ}}, is an allophone of **g**
### Syllable structure
[Syllables](/wiki/Syllable "Syllable") usually follow the CVCV pattern. All words must begin with a consonant, but other syllables may or may not include an onset. When an onset is present, it is usually composed of only one consonant. Words with suffixes like *\-'ni, \-'na,* and *'wa*, can have a two\-consonant onset, though they were historically \-*ni\-'i, \-na\-'a,* and *\-wa\-'a* respectively. These earlier suffix forms did have single\-consonant onsets. Most syllables do not have codas, but some codas do appear at word\-end, such as in *pʉi\-n*, 'I'm sleeping'.
### Stress
Each Southern Ute word must have one [stressed](/wiki/Stress_%28linguistics%29 "Stress (linguistics)") vowel. Either the first or second vowel of a word in Ute may be stressed, with the latter situation being the most common. Stress is orthographically marked when it occurs on the first vowel. In compound words, the primary stress is applied to the first stem, and a secondary stress may also occur on a later stem.
Vowel stress is contrastive in pairs such as, *suwá*, meaning 'almost', and *súwa*, meaning 'straight out'. Note that the [high back unrounded vowel](/wiki/Close_back_unrounded_vowel "Close back unrounded vowel") **ʉ** often is pronounced as a high central {{IPA\|\[ɨ]}} when unstressed. Though this change produces some [minimal pairs](/wiki/Minimal_pair "Minimal pair"), it is the destressing, rather than the vowel change, that produces the change in meaning and thus {{IPA\|\[ɨ]}} is excluded from the orthography.
### Phonological processes
Ute has several phonological processes that affect the realization of underlying phonemes. Below is a representative sample.
* **a** changes to \[e] or \[æ] (usually for younger and older speakers respectively) when near **y, i,** or ɵ**,** such as in *ɵæ\-qar~~u~~,* 'yellow', or *'ura\-'æ*y*,* 'is'. Although **a** often makes the alternation when directly preceding or following **y**, **i**, or **ɵ**, it does not have to be directly next to one of those phonemes, such as in *sinaævi*, 'wolf'
* **ɵ** becomes \[o] when directly preceding or following \[ʁ], \[q], or \[χ]—however, **k** becomes \[q] and \[qh] between two as or directly preceding or following \[o], so the precise mechanism is unknown. *qhoqh*, 'bull\-snake', is one word where this process occurs
* **g** becomes \[ʁ] when between two **a**s or directly preceding or following \[o], such as in *pagha\-'ni,* 'walking about'
* **w** is inserted after **g** and **k** if the **g** or **k** directly follow **u**, \[o], or **ɵ**, such as in *tagu\-kwa*, 's/he was thirsty'
+ **y** is also inserted if directly follow **i**, such as in *ini\-kya* 's/he did'
* vowels are sometimes devoiced in unstressed word\-initial or word\-final syllables, or unstressed syllables that begin with a voiceless consonant, nasal consonant, or glide, such as in *whcaay*, 'swirl'. In marginal pairs, they may be considered distinct, such as in *tʉkápi* 'food (nominative)' and *tʉkápi̱* 'food (accusative)'.
|
[
"Phonology\n---------",
"### Vowels",
"T.Givon (2011\\) gives the following orthography and phonetic information for Southern Ute. Northern Ute differs from Southern and Central in some lexical and phonological areas.",
"Southern Ute has five vowels, as well as several allophones, which are not shown in the orthography. Each vowel can be short or long, and vowel length is marked orthographically by doubling the vowel. In Ute, the length of a vowel is often phonemic, and relevant for determining meaning. For example, *whca\\-y*, meaning 'wrapping,' versus *whcáa\\-y*, meaning 'swirling'. In some cases, however, the difference between a long and a short vowel is purely phonetic, and does not change word meaning. Ute devoices vowels in certain phonological or grammatical environments, as described in later sections. Devoiced vowels are marked in the orthography by underlining them, or, when the identity of the underlying vowel has been lost, with the letter \\[h].",
"Here bold text indicates a practical orthographic representation, while the [IPA](/wiki/International_Phonetic_Alphabet \"International Phonetic Alphabet\") representation is included in brackets.",
"| | [Front](/wiki/Front_vowel \"Front vowel\") | | [Central](/wiki/Central_vowel \"Central vowel\") | [Back](/wiki/Back_vowel \"Back vowel\") | |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| unrounded | rounded | unrounded | rounded |\n| [High](/wiki/Close_vowel \"Close vowel\") | **i** {{IPAblink\\|i}} | | | **ʉ** {{IPAblink\\|ɯ}} | **u** {{IPAblink\\|u}} |\n| [Mid](/wiki/Mid_vowel \"Mid vowel\") | | **ɵ** {{IPAblink\\|œ}} | | | |\n| [Low](/wiki/Open_vowel \"Open vowel\") | | | **a** {{IPAblink\\|ä}} | | |",
"",
"#### Allophones",
"* {{IPAblink\\|ɨ}} is an allophone of **ʉ**\n* {{IPAblink\\|e}} and {{IPAblink\\|æ}} are both allophones of **a**; the former is used more often by younger speakers, while older speakers use the latter\n* {{IPAblink\\|o}} is an allophone of **ɵ**.",
"### Consonants",
"Southern Ute consonants are given in the table below. As above, orthographic representations are bold and the IPA representations are in brackets. All stops in Ute are voiceless. Thus, **g** here does not indicate a [voiced velar stop](/wiki/Voiced_velar_stop \"Voiced velar stop\") but rather a [voiced velar fricative](/wiki/Voiced_velar_fricative \"Voiced velar fricative\"), similar to *luego* in Spanish. Also similar to Spanish is the [voiced bilabial fricative](/wiki/Voiced_bilabial_fricative \"Voiced bilabial fricative\") **v**, as in the Spanish phrase *la verdad*, in contrast with the voiced labiodental fricative {{IPA\\|\\[v]}} which does not appear in Ute. The velar sounds **k** and **g** have [uvular](/wiki/Uvular_consonant \"Uvular consonant\") [allophones](/wiki/Allophones \"Allophones\"): **k** becomes either a [voiceless uvular stop](/wiki/Voiceless_uvular_stop \"Voiceless uvular stop\") {{IPA\\|\\[q]}} or a [voiceless uvular fricative](/wiki/Voiceless_uvular_fricative \"Voiceless uvular fricative\") {{IPA\\|\\[χ]}} when either between two vowels or adjacent to the vowel {{IPA\\|\\[o]}};{{clarify\\|date\\=April 2013}} likewise **g** becomes a voiced uvular fricative {{IPA\\|\\[ʁ]}} under the same conditions. Either **k** or **g** can become a [voiceless velar fricative](/wiki/Voiceless_velar_fricative \"Voiceless velar fricative\") {{IPA\\|\\[x]}} when before a de\\-voiced word ending.",
"Note here that [coronals](/wiki/Coronal_consonant \"Coronal consonant\") are produced as dental sounds rather than the [alveolar](/wiki/Alveolar_consonant \"Alveolar consonant\") sounds used in English.",
"| | [Labial](/wiki/Labial_consonant \"Labial consonant\") | [Dental](/wiki/Dental_consonant \"Dental consonant\") | [Palatal](/wiki/Palatal_consonant \"Palatal consonant\") | [Velar](/wiki/Velar_consonant \"Velar consonant\") | [Glottal](/wiki/Glottal_consonant \"Glottal consonant\") |\n| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |\n| [Stop](/wiki/Stop_consonant \"Stop consonant\") | **p** {{IPAblink\\|p}} | **t** {{IPAblink\\|t}} | **ch** {{IPAblink\\|tʃ}} | **k** {{IPAblink\\|k}} | **'** {{IPAblink\\|ʔ}} |\n| [Fricative](/wiki/Fricative_consonant \"Fricative consonant\") | **v** {{IPAblink\\|β}} | **s** {{IPAblink\\|s}} | | **g** {{IPAblink\\|ɣ}} | |\n| [Nasal](/wiki/Nasal_consonant \"Nasal consonant\") | **m** {{IPAblink\\|m}} | **n** {{IPAblink\\|n}} | | | |\n| [Semivowel](/wiki/Semivowel \"Semivowel\") | **w** {{IPAblink\\|w}} | | **y** {{IPAblink\\|j}} | | |\n| [Flap](/wiki/Flap_consonant \"Flap consonant\") | | **r** {{IPAblink\\|ɾ}} | | | |",
"",
"#### Allophones",
"* {{IPAblink\\|q}}, and **qh (**or {{IPAblink\\|χ}}), are allophones of **k**\n* **kh (**or {{IPAblink\\|x}}), is an allophone of **k** or **g**\n* **gh,** or {{IPAblink\\|ʁ}}, is an allophone of **g**",
"### Syllable structure",
"[Syllables](/wiki/Syllable \"Syllable\") usually follow the CVCV pattern. All words must begin with a consonant, but other syllables may or may not include an onset. When an onset is present, it is usually composed of only one consonant. Words with suffixes like *\\-'ni, \\-'na,* and *'wa*, can have a two\\-consonant onset, though they were historically \\-*ni\\-'i, \\-na\\-'a,* and *\\-wa\\-'a* respectively. These earlier suffix forms did have single\\-consonant onsets. Most syllables do not have codas, but some codas do appear at word\\-end, such as in *pʉi\\-n*, 'I'm sleeping'.",
"### Stress",
"Each Southern Ute word must have one [stressed](/wiki/Stress_%28linguistics%29 \"Stress (linguistics)\") vowel. Either the first or second vowel of a word in Ute may be stressed, with the latter situation being the most common. Stress is orthographically marked when it occurs on the first vowel. In compound words, the primary stress is applied to the first stem, and a secondary stress may also occur on a later stem.",
"Vowel stress is contrastive in pairs such as, *suwá*, meaning 'almost', and *súwa*, meaning 'straight out'. Note that the [high back unrounded vowel](/wiki/Close_back_unrounded_vowel \"Close back unrounded vowel\") **ʉ** often is pronounced as a high central {{IPA\\|\\[ɨ]}} when unstressed. Though this change produces some [minimal pairs](/wiki/Minimal_pair \"Minimal pair\"), it is the destressing, rather than the vowel change, that produces the change in meaning and thus {{IPA\\|\\[ɨ]}} is excluded from the orthography.",
"### Phonological processes",
"Ute has several phonological processes that affect the realization of underlying phonemes. Below is a representative sample.\n* **a** changes to \\[e] or \\[æ] (usually for younger and older speakers respectively) when near **y, i,** or ɵ**,** such as in *ɵæ\\-qar~~u~~,* 'yellow', or *'ura\\-'æ*y*,* 'is'. Although **a** often makes the alternation when directly preceding or following **y**, **i**, or **ɵ**, it does not have to be directly next to one of those phonemes, such as in *sinaævi*, 'wolf'\n* **ɵ** becomes \\[o] when directly preceding or following \\[ʁ], \\[q], or \\[χ]—however, **k** becomes \\[q] and \\[qh] between two as or directly preceding or following \\[o], so the precise mechanism is unknown. *qhoqh*, 'bull\\-snake', is one word where this process occurs\n* **g** becomes \\[ʁ] when between two **a**s or directly preceding or following \\[o], such as in *pagha\\-'ni,* 'walking about'\n* **w** is inserted after **g** and **k** if the **g** or **k** directly follow **u**, \\[o], or **ɵ**, such as in *tagu\\-kwa*, 's/he was thirsty'\n\t+ **y** is also inserted if directly follow **i**, such as in *ini\\-kya* 's/he did'\n* vowels are sometimes devoiced in unstressed word\\-initial or word\\-final syllables, or unstressed syllables that begin with a voiceless consonant, nasal consonant, or glide, such as in *whcaay*, 'swirl'. In marginal pairs, they may be considered distinct, such as in *tʉkápi* 'food (nominative)' and *tʉkápi̱* 'food (accusative)'.",
""
] |
Morphology
----------
Ute is [polysynthetic](/wiki/Polysynthetic_language "Polysynthetic language"). Affixes are mostly [suffixes](/wiki/Suffix "Suffix"), but there are three major types of [prefixes](/wiki/Prefix "Prefix") for verbs and one for nouns.
### Nouns
Most nouns in Ute obligatorily have suffixes. Inanimate nouns usually take the suffix \-*p~~u~~*/*\-v~~u~~*. However, this suffix can also sometimes denote animate nouns or body parts. Animate nouns usually take the *\-chi* suffix, but can also take *\-vi/\-pi* or *\-t~~u~~/\-r~~u~~*. The consonant pairs p/v and t/r were once allophones, but are no longer predictable; this produces the suffixes separated by a slash. Some older animate nouns have a silent final vowel rather than an explicit suffix.
\-*p~~u~~* is also used to derive inanimate nouns from verbs, such as *piki*\-*p~~u~~* "rotten thing" from *piki\-* "be rotten". *\-t~~u~~/\-r~~u~~* are used for animate nouns that derive from verbs or possession: thus, *kaá\-mi\-t~~u~~* "singer" derives from *kaá\-miya* "sings" and *piwa\-gha\-t~~u~~* "married person, spouse" derives from *piwa\-n* "my spouse".
There are three ways plurality can be marked, and only animate nouns are marked for plurality. *\-u* is the most common plural suffix, and *\-mu* is usually used for plural nouns that derive from verbs or possession. These suffixes are placed after the obligatory noun suffix. Finally, some nouns show plurality by [reduplication](/wiki/Reduplication "Reduplication") of the first syllable in combination with the *\-u* suffix, such as in *táa\-ta'wa\-chi\-u* "men" from *ta'wa\-chi.* In this case, *\-u* without reduplication would create the dual form: "two men".
### Verbs
Ute verbs can take many suffixes and several prefixes. Negation is marked with both the suffix *\-wa* and prefix *ka\-*. Alternatively, instead of the prefix, the full form *kách\-* can appear as a separate word somewhere before the verb being negated.
First syllable reduplication in verbs denotes the [distributive case](/wiki/Distributive_case "Distributive case"). Thus, *táa\-p~~u~~gay\-'u* "\[s/he] kicked him (once)" becomes *ta\-táa\-p~~u~~gay\-'u* "\[s/he] kicked him repeatedly".
[Incorporation](/wiki/Incorporation_%28linguistics%29 "Incorporation (linguistics)") can take place at the leftmost prefix position to add the meanings of the incorporated word to the verb. For example, *'apagha\-y* "\[s/he] is talking" and *pia\-'apagha\-y* "\[s/he] is sweet\-talking".
Verbs usually take the suffix*\-ka* after the stem when the subject is plural. *\-ka* can also be realized as *\-qa, \-kwa, \-kya*, etc. according to the phonological processes above. Many suffixes are used to denote [tense, aspect, and modality](/wiki/Tense%E2%80%93aspect%E2%80%93mood "Tense–aspect–mood"). Some of the more common of these suffixes include *\-y* for the present tense, *\-vaa\-ni* for the future, and *\-miya*. for the habitual. Other suffixes include *\-ti, \-k~~u~~,* and *\-ta*, which mark the causative, [benefactive](/wiki/Benefactive_case "Benefactive case"), and [passive](/wiki/Passive_voice "Passive voice") case respectively.
|
[
"Morphology\n----------",
"Ute is [polysynthetic](/wiki/Polysynthetic_language \"Polysynthetic language\"). Affixes are mostly [suffixes](/wiki/Suffix \"Suffix\"), but there are three major types of [prefixes](/wiki/Prefix \"Prefix\") for verbs and one for nouns.",
"### Nouns",
"Most nouns in Ute obligatorily have suffixes. Inanimate nouns usually take the suffix \\-*p~~u~~*/*\\-v~~u~~*. However, this suffix can also sometimes denote animate nouns or body parts. Animate nouns usually take the *\\-chi* suffix, but can also take *\\-vi/\\-pi* or *\\-t~~u~~/\\-r~~u~~*. The consonant pairs p/v and t/r were once allophones, but are no longer predictable; this produces the suffixes separated by a slash. Some older animate nouns have a silent final vowel rather than an explicit suffix.",
"\\-*p~~u~~* is also used to derive inanimate nouns from verbs, such as *piki*\\-*p~~u~~* \"rotten thing\" from *piki\\-* \"be rotten\". *\\-t~~u~~/\\-r~~u~~* are used for animate nouns that derive from verbs or possession: thus, *kaá\\-mi\\-t~~u~~* \"singer\" derives from *kaá\\-miya* \"sings\" and *piwa\\-gha\\-t~~u~~* \"married person, spouse\" derives from *piwa\\-n* \"my spouse\".",
"There are three ways plurality can be marked, and only animate nouns are marked for plurality. *\\-u* is the most common plural suffix, and *\\-mu* is usually used for plural nouns that derive from verbs or possession. These suffixes are placed after the obligatory noun suffix. Finally, some nouns show plurality by [reduplication](/wiki/Reduplication \"Reduplication\") of the first syllable in combination with the *\\-u* suffix, such as in *táa\\-ta'wa\\-chi\\-u* \"men\" from *ta'wa\\-chi.* In this case, *\\-u* without reduplication would create the dual form: \"two men\".",
"### Verbs",
"Ute verbs can take many suffixes and several prefixes. Negation is marked with both the suffix *\\-wa* and prefix *ka\\-*. Alternatively, instead of the prefix, the full form *kách\\-* can appear as a separate word somewhere before the verb being negated.",
"First syllable reduplication in verbs denotes the [distributive case](/wiki/Distributive_case \"Distributive case\"). Thus, *táa\\-p~~u~~gay\\-'u* \"\\[s/he] kicked him (once)\" becomes *ta\\-táa\\-p~~u~~gay\\-'u* \"\\[s/he] kicked him repeatedly\".",
"[Incorporation](/wiki/Incorporation_%28linguistics%29 \"Incorporation (linguistics)\") can take place at the leftmost prefix position to add the meanings of the incorporated word to the verb. For example, *'apagha\\-y* \"\\[s/he] is talking\" and *pia\\-'apagha\\-y* \"\\[s/he] is sweet\\-talking\".",
"Verbs usually take the suffix*\\-ka* after the stem when the subject is plural. *\\-ka* can also be realized as *\\-qa, \\-kwa, \\-kya*, etc. according to the phonological processes above. Many suffixes are used to denote [tense, aspect, and modality](/wiki/Tense%E2%80%93aspect%E2%80%93mood \"Tense–aspect–mood\"). Some of the more common of these suffixes include *\\-y* for the present tense, *\\-vaa\\-ni* for the future, and *\\-miya*. for the habitual. Other suffixes include *\\-ti, \\-k~~u~~,* and *\\-ta*, which mark the causative, [benefactive](/wiki/Benefactive_case \"Benefactive case\"), and [passive](/wiki/Passive_voice \"Passive voice\") case respectively.",
""
] |
Combat History
--------------
The 218th Infantry division saw its first action in the German invasion of Poland. On 1 September it was Army reserve for the 4th Army stationed in [Pomerania](/wiki/Pomerania "Pomerania") in northern Germany.{{Cite book\|last\=Zaloga\|first\=Steven\|title\=Poland 1939: The Birth of Blitzkrieg\|publisher\=Osprey Publishing\|year\=2003\|isbn\=1841764086\|location\=Oxford\|pages\=35\|orig\-year\=2002}} It crossed into Poland, into the corridor which had given Poland access to the Baltic sea, and towards the [River Vistula](/wiki/Vistula "Vistula") and the border with [East Prussia](/wiki/East_Prussia "East Prussia").
The division advanced behind the main fighting front and saw little fighting in the campaign.
### France 1940
[thumb\|Soldiers from the 218th division on parade past [Joseph Goebbels](/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels "Joseph Goebbels") and *Generaloberst* [Friedrich Fromm](/wiki/Friedrich_Fromm "Friedrich Fromm") after the Battle of France.](/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-L07593%2C_Berlin%2C_R%C3%BCckkehr_vom_Westfeldzug%2C_Parade.jpg "Bundesarchiv Bild 183-L07593, Berlin, Rückkehr vom Westfeldzug, Parade.jpg")
In May 1940, the division was moved to the [Western Front](/wiki/Western_Front_%28World_War_II%29 "Western Front (World War II)"), assigned to the reserve of 7th Army.
On 15 June 1940 218 Infantry Division became one of 5 Infantry divisions committed by 7th Army in Operation *Kleiner Bär*, a crossing of the [Rhine](/wiki/Rhine "Rhine") in the [Colmar](/wiki/Fortified_Sector_of_Colmar "Fortified Sector of Colmar") area.M Romanych \& M Rupp, Maginot Line 1940, p 81\-90 They were to cross the river and attack a [portion of the Maginot](/wiki/Fortified_Sector_of_the_Lower_Rhine "Fortified Sector of the Lower Rhine") line defended by 3 French fortress divisions. The 218th attack at Schoenau, led by Infantry Regiment 397, was held up by French fortifications which although damaged by the artillery preparation were not put out of action and forced the Regimental commander to suspend the river crossing in the face of mounting casualties. The divisions 386 Regiment had more success. Crossing the Rhine in an area of fewer fortifications, the regiments assault teams captured the French forward line and several casements, and by noon were engaging the French rearward defensive lines.
The following day, with the assistance of further artillery, Stuka dive bomber strikes, the 218th was able to pierce the French defenses, together with [21st](/wiki/21st_Infantry_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 "21st Infantry Division (Wehrmacht)") and 239th infantry divisions. By 19 June, the division had advanced a further 15 miles into the [Vosges](/wiki/Vosges "Vosges") Mountains. The French Army was in a state of collapse, as on the previous day, [Guderian](/wiki/Heinz_Guderian "Heinz Guderian")'s Panzer forces had reached the Swiss border, effectively surrounding the French defenders in the Vosges and 3 days later the [armistice](/wiki/Armistice_of_Compi%C3%A8gne_%281940%29 "Armistice of Compiègne (1940)") was signed at [Compiègne](/wiki/Compi%C3%A8gne "Compiègne"), marking the end of hostilities.
The division remained in occupation duty in the [Alsace](/wiki/Alsace "Alsace") region until February 1941, when its soldiers were stood down.
### Eastern Front
Although the beginning of the German\-Soviet War ([Operation Barbarossa](/wiki/Operation_Barbarossa "Operation Barbarossa")) involved much of the German army, the 218th Infantry Division had initially remained on occupation duty in [Denmark](/wiki/Denmark_in_World_War_II "Denmark in World War II"). The beginning of the Soviet Winter Offensive 1941/42 in early December 1941 did however cause significant concern among the German leadership, causing Adolf Hitler to order on 15 December 1941 the preparation of the deployment of additional forces to the Eastern Front from various theaters. The 218th Infantry Division was earmarked for replacement by a less well\-equipped 'static' (German: *bodenständig*) occupation force in Denmark so that the core of the division could be used within weeks on the Eastern Front.{{Cite book \|last\=Klink, Ernst \|title\=Der Angriff auf die Sowjetunion \|publisher\=Deutsche Verlags\-Anstalt \|year\=1983 \|isbn\=3421060983 \|editor\-last\=Boog, Horst \|series\=Das Deutsche Reich und der Zweite Weltkrieg \|volume\=4 \|location\=Stuttgart \|pages\=451–651 \|chapter\=Heer und Kriegsmarine \|display\-editors\=et al.}}{{Rp\|1\=609f.}}
[left\|thumb\|German soldiers in the ruins of [Kholm](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast "Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast")](/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-004-3636-37A%2C_Russland%2C_Cholm%2C_Soldaten_vor_Hausruine.jpg "Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-004-3636-37A, Russland, Cholm, Soldaten vor Hausruine.jpg")
Whilst en route to [Riga](/wiki/Riga "Riga"), for commitment with [Army Group North](/wiki/Army_Group_North "Army Group North"), Generaloberst [Busch](/wiki/Ernst_Busch_%28military%29 "Ernst Busch (military)"), commander of the [16th Army](/wiki/16th_Army_%28Wehrmacht%29 "16th Army (Wehrmacht)") ordered the forward elements of the division rushed into [Kholm](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast "Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast").Forczyk, Robert, Demyansk 1942–43 (Campaign)
Detraining at [Loknya](/wiki/Loknya%2C_Pskov_Oblast "Loknya, Pskov Oblast"), a small stop on the Dno Nevel railway line, but still 50 miles from Kholm,Gen. Lt. a.D, Max Bork, COMMENTS ON RUSSIAN RAILROADS AND HIGHWAYS the first battalion to arrive, the I/386, was rushed by all available trucks to Kholm along with a convoy carrying food and ammunition. Oberstleutnant [Johannes Manitius](/wiki/Johannes_Manitius "Johannes Manitius"), the commander of Infantry Regiment 386, joined his unit in Kholm and another battalion from the Regiment managed slipped past advancing units of the Soviet [3rd Shock Army](/wiki/3rd_Shock_Army "3rd Shock Army"), before the Soviets threw a solid cordon around the town. The Germans had barely beaten the Soviets to Kholm, and positioned a mixed battlegroup (*[kampfgruppe](/wiki/Kampfgruppe "Kampfgruppe"))* of around 4,500 soldiers under the leadership of Generalmajor [Scherer](/wiki/Theodor_Scherer "Theodor Scherer"), but the group had virtually no artillery or anti tank guns. By 28 January 1942, the Soviets had closed the ring around the city and drove additional forces from the 218th Division under the divisional commander, Generalmajor Ukermann, back down the road to [Loknya](/wiki/Loknya%2C_Pskov_Oblast "Loknya, Pskov Oblast"), where the remainder of the division was still arriving.
Hitler designated Kholm as a 'Festung' (fortress), which meant the garrison of Kholm would have to hold out until relieved. The remainder of the 218th Infantry Division, joined by a battle group from [8th Panzer Division](/wiki/8th_Panzer_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 "8th Panzer Division (Wehrmacht)") became the main components of the relief force, known as Groupe Uckermann, which attempted to fight their way back towards Kholm. Meanwhile, the only means of supply, of reinforcements and of replacements for the Kholm garrison was by air transport.
After the success of the relief effort, the 218 took over the defense of the German line at Kholm and remained there for the next 18 months.
In January 1944 the defensive positions around [Leningrad](/wiki/Leningrad "Leningrad") of Army Group North collapsed, and Hitler finally authorized a withdrawal to the [Panther–Wotan line](/wiki/Panther%E2%80%93Wotan_line "Panther–Wotan line"). With the collapse of [Army Group Center](/wiki/Army_Group_Centre "Army Group Centre") to the south meant that the Panther positions were no longer tenable, and the 218th Infantry retreated with the Army group through Estonia to Riga, and then on into [Courland](/wiki/Courland "Courland").
[right\|thumb\|Soviet assault on Baltic island of Saaremaa (Ösel) in October/November 1944](/wiki/File:Baltic-islands-2.jpg "Baltic-islands-2.jpg")
### On the defensive in the Baltic
Upon hearing news of the [Finland's armistice with the Soviet Union](/wiki/Moscow_Armistice "Moscow Armistice"), Hitler ordered the Baltic Islands to be reinforced
Hitler, Donitz, and the Baltic Sea: The Third Reich's Last Hope, 1944\-1945, Chapter 4, The Struggle for the Baltic Islands
During the Soviet [Moonsund Landing Operation](/wiki/Moonsund_Landing_Operation "Moonsund Landing Operation"), the [23rd Infantry Division](/wiki/23rd_Infantry_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 "23rd Infantry Division (Wehrmacht)") was backed by miscellaneous [Kriegsmarine](/wiki/Kriegsmarine "Kriegsmarine") and army artillery troops. Its forces were made considerably stronger by the transfer of [12th Luftwaffe Division](/wiki/12th_Luftwaffe_Field_Division_%28Germany%29 "12th Luftwaffe Field Division (Germany)") and 218th Infantry division. The 218th division started to land on the island of [Saaremaa](/wiki/Saaremaa "Saaremaa") (Ösel) on 30 September 1944 and marched north. The Soviet forces were not far behind and landed on the northern shores 5 days later. After some sharp clashes [General Schörner](/wiki/Ferdinand_Sch%C3%B6rner "Ferdinand Schörner"), commander of [Army Group Courland](/wiki/Army_Group_Courland "Army Group Courland"), ordered a withdrawal to the more defensible [Sõrve Peninsula](/wiki/S%C3%B5rve_Peninsula "Sõrve Peninsula") (Sworbe Peninsula.)
Soviet forces, numerically superior to the Germans, kept up the pressure in October, forcing the Germans back, but a landing behind the German lines near [Vintri](/wiki/Vintri "Vintri") failed to displace them.
After a period of calm the Russian forces struck again in mid November, and smashed through the defenses and forced 218th Infantry and other German formations back to the very tip of the peninsula. Against Hitler's orders to hold on to the last man, General Schörner ordered an evacuation.
Reduced to battle group strength, the 218th was nevertheless soon returned to the front line in Courland.
{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lexikon\-der\-wehrmacht.de/Gliederungen/Infanteriedivisionen/218ID.htm\|title \= Lexikon der Wehrmacht \- 218\. Infanterie\-Division}}
The 218 remained in Courland for the final months of the war, finally surrendering to the Soviet Army near [Tuckum](/wiki/Tukums "Tukums").
|
[
"Combat History\n--------------",
"The 218th Infantry division saw its first action in the German invasion of Poland. On 1 September it was Army reserve for the 4th Army stationed in [Pomerania](/wiki/Pomerania \"Pomerania\") in northern Germany.{{Cite book\\|last\\=Zaloga\\|first\\=Steven\\|title\\=Poland 1939: The Birth of Blitzkrieg\\|publisher\\=Osprey Publishing\\|year\\=2003\\|isbn\\=1841764086\\|location\\=Oxford\\|pages\\=35\\|orig\\-year\\=2002}} It crossed into Poland, into the corridor which had given Poland access to the Baltic sea, and towards the [River Vistula](/wiki/Vistula \"Vistula\") and the border with [East Prussia](/wiki/East_Prussia \"East Prussia\").\nThe division advanced behind the main fighting front and saw little fighting in the campaign.",
"### France 1940",
"[thumb\\|Soldiers from the 218th division on parade past [Joseph Goebbels](/wiki/Joseph_Goebbels \"Joseph Goebbels\") and *Generaloberst* [Friedrich Fromm](/wiki/Friedrich_Fromm \"Friedrich Fromm\") after the Battle of France.](/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-L07593%2C_Berlin%2C_R%C3%BCckkehr_vom_Westfeldzug%2C_Parade.jpg \"Bundesarchiv Bild 183-L07593, Berlin, Rückkehr vom Westfeldzug, Parade.jpg\")\nIn May 1940, the division was moved to the [Western Front](/wiki/Western_Front_%28World_War_II%29 \"Western Front (World War II)\"), assigned to the reserve of 7th Army.\nOn 15 June 1940 218 Infantry Division became one of 5 Infantry divisions committed by 7th Army in Operation *Kleiner Bär*, a crossing of the [Rhine](/wiki/Rhine \"Rhine\") in the [Colmar](/wiki/Fortified_Sector_of_Colmar \"Fortified Sector of Colmar\") area.M Romanych \\& M Rupp, Maginot Line 1940, p 81\\-90 They were to cross the river and attack a [portion of the Maginot](/wiki/Fortified_Sector_of_the_Lower_Rhine \"Fortified Sector of the Lower Rhine\") line defended by 3 French fortress divisions. The 218th attack at Schoenau, led by Infantry Regiment 397, was held up by French fortifications which although damaged by the artillery preparation were not put out of action and forced the Regimental commander to suspend the river crossing in the face of mounting casualties. The divisions 386 Regiment had more success. Crossing the Rhine in an area of fewer fortifications, the regiments assault teams captured the French forward line and several casements, and by noon were engaging the French rearward defensive lines.\nThe following day, with the assistance of further artillery, Stuka dive bomber strikes, the 218th was able to pierce the French defenses, together with [21st](/wiki/21st_Infantry_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 \"21st Infantry Division (Wehrmacht)\") and 239th infantry divisions. By 19 June, the division had advanced a further 15 miles into the [Vosges](/wiki/Vosges \"Vosges\") Mountains. The French Army was in a state of collapse, as on the previous day, [Guderian](/wiki/Heinz_Guderian \"Heinz Guderian\")'s Panzer forces had reached the Swiss border, effectively surrounding the French defenders in the Vosges and 3 days later the [armistice](/wiki/Armistice_of_Compi%C3%A8gne_%281940%29 \"Armistice of Compiègne (1940)\") was signed at [Compiègne](/wiki/Compi%C3%A8gne \"Compiègne\"), marking the end of hostilities.",
"The division remained in occupation duty in the [Alsace](/wiki/Alsace \"Alsace\") region until February 1941, when its soldiers were stood down.",
"### Eastern Front",
"Although the beginning of the German\\-Soviet War ([Operation Barbarossa](/wiki/Operation_Barbarossa \"Operation Barbarossa\")) involved much of the German army, the 218th Infantry Division had initially remained on occupation duty in [Denmark](/wiki/Denmark_in_World_War_II \"Denmark in World War II\"). The beginning of the Soviet Winter Offensive 1941/42 in early December 1941 did however cause significant concern among the German leadership, causing Adolf Hitler to order on 15 December 1941 the preparation of the deployment of additional forces to the Eastern Front from various theaters. The 218th Infantry Division was earmarked for replacement by a less well\\-equipped 'static' (German: *bodenständig*) occupation force in Denmark so that the core of the division could be used within weeks on the Eastern Front.{{Cite book \\|last\\=Klink, Ernst \\|title\\=Der Angriff auf die Sowjetunion \\|publisher\\=Deutsche Verlags\\-Anstalt \\|year\\=1983 \\|isbn\\=3421060983 \\|editor\\-last\\=Boog, Horst \\|series\\=Das Deutsche Reich und der Zweite Weltkrieg \\|volume\\=4 \\|location\\=Stuttgart \\|pages\\=451–651 \\|chapter\\=Heer und Kriegsmarine \\|display\\-editors\\=et al.}}{{Rp\\|1\\=609f.}}\n[left\\|thumb\\|German soldiers in the ruins of [Kholm](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast \"Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast\")](/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-004-3636-37A%2C_Russland%2C_Cholm%2C_Soldaten_vor_Hausruine.jpg \"Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-004-3636-37A, Russland, Cholm, Soldaten vor Hausruine.jpg\")\nWhilst en route to [Riga](/wiki/Riga \"Riga\"), for commitment with [Army Group North](/wiki/Army_Group_North \"Army Group North\"), Generaloberst [Busch](/wiki/Ernst_Busch_%28military%29 \"Ernst Busch (military)\"), commander of the [16th Army](/wiki/16th_Army_%28Wehrmacht%29 \"16th Army (Wehrmacht)\") ordered the forward elements of the division rushed into [Kholm](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast \"Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast\").Forczyk, Robert, Demyansk 1942–43 (Campaign)\nDetraining at [Loknya](/wiki/Loknya%2C_Pskov_Oblast \"Loknya, Pskov Oblast\"), a small stop on the Dno Nevel railway line, but still 50 miles from Kholm,Gen. Lt. a.D, Max Bork, COMMENTS ON RUSSIAN RAILROADS AND HIGHWAYS the first battalion to arrive, the I/386, was rushed by all available trucks to Kholm along with a convoy carrying food and ammunition. Oberstleutnant [Johannes Manitius](/wiki/Johannes_Manitius \"Johannes Manitius\"), the commander of Infantry Regiment 386, joined his unit in Kholm and another battalion from the Regiment managed slipped past advancing units of the Soviet [3rd Shock Army](/wiki/3rd_Shock_Army \"3rd Shock Army\"), before the Soviets threw a solid cordon around the town. The Germans had barely beaten the Soviets to Kholm, and positioned a mixed battlegroup (*[kampfgruppe](/wiki/Kampfgruppe \"Kampfgruppe\"))* of around 4,500 soldiers under the leadership of Generalmajor [Scherer](/wiki/Theodor_Scherer \"Theodor Scherer\"), but the group had virtually no artillery or anti tank guns. By 28 January 1942, the Soviets had closed the ring around the city and drove additional forces from the 218th Division under the divisional commander, Generalmajor Ukermann, back down the road to [Loknya](/wiki/Loknya%2C_Pskov_Oblast \"Loknya, Pskov Oblast\"), where the remainder of the division was still arriving.",
"Hitler designated Kholm as a 'Festung' (fortress), which meant the garrison of Kholm would have to hold out until relieved. The remainder of the 218th Infantry Division, joined by a battle group from [8th Panzer Division](/wiki/8th_Panzer_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 \"8th Panzer Division (Wehrmacht)\") became the main components of the relief force, known as Groupe Uckermann, which attempted to fight their way back towards Kholm. Meanwhile, the only means of supply, of reinforcements and of replacements for the Kholm garrison was by air transport.",
"After the success of the relief effort, the 218 took over the defense of the German line at Kholm and remained there for the next 18 months.",
"In January 1944 the defensive positions around [Leningrad](/wiki/Leningrad \"Leningrad\") of Army Group North collapsed, and Hitler finally authorized a withdrawal to the [Panther–Wotan line](/wiki/Panther%E2%80%93Wotan_line \"Panther–Wotan line\"). With the collapse of [Army Group Center](/wiki/Army_Group_Centre \"Army Group Centre\") to the south meant that the Panther positions were no longer tenable, and the 218th Infantry retreated with the Army group through Estonia to Riga, and then on into [Courland](/wiki/Courland \"Courland\").",
"[right\\|thumb\\|Soviet assault on Baltic island of Saaremaa (Ösel) in October/November 1944](/wiki/File:Baltic-islands-2.jpg \"Baltic-islands-2.jpg\")",
"### On the defensive in the Baltic",
"Upon hearing news of the [Finland's armistice with the Soviet Union](/wiki/Moscow_Armistice \"Moscow Armistice\"), Hitler ordered the Baltic Islands to be reinforced\nHitler, Donitz, and the Baltic Sea: The Third Reich's Last Hope, 1944\\-1945, Chapter 4, The Struggle for the Baltic Islands",
"During the Soviet [Moonsund Landing Operation](/wiki/Moonsund_Landing_Operation \"Moonsund Landing Operation\"), the [23rd Infantry Division](/wiki/23rd_Infantry_Division_%28Wehrmacht%29 \"23rd Infantry Division (Wehrmacht)\") was backed by miscellaneous [Kriegsmarine](/wiki/Kriegsmarine \"Kriegsmarine\") and army artillery troops. Its forces were made considerably stronger by the transfer of [12th Luftwaffe Division](/wiki/12th_Luftwaffe_Field_Division_%28Germany%29 \"12th Luftwaffe Field Division (Germany)\") and 218th Infantry division. The 218th division started to land on the island of [Saaremaa](/wiki/Saaremaa \"Saaremaa\") (Ösel) on 30 September 1944 and marched north. The Soviet forces were not far behind and landed on the northern shores 5 days later. After some sharp clashes [General Schörner](/wiki/Ferdinand_Sch%C3%B6rner \"Ferdinand Schörner\"), commander of [Army Group Courland](/wiki/Army_Group_Courland \"Army Group Courland\"), ordered a withdrawal to the more defensible [Sõrve Peninsula](/wiki/S%C3%B5rve_Peninsula \"Sõrve Peninsula\") (Sworbe Peninsula.)\nSoviet forces, numerically superior to the Germans, kept up the pressure in October, forcing the Germans back, but a landing behind the German lines near [Vintri](/wiki/Vintri \"Vintri\") failed to displace them.",
"After a period of calm the Russian forces struck again in mid November, and smashed through the defenses and forced 218th Infantry and other German formations back to the very tip of the peninsula. Against Hitler's orders to hold on to the last man, General Schörner ordered an evacuation.\nReduced to battle group strength, the 218th was nevertheless soon returned to the front line in Courland.\n{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lexikon\\-der\\-wehrmacht.de/Gliederungen/Infanteriedivisionen/218ID.htm\\|title \\= Lexikon der Wehrmacht \\- 218\\. Infanterie\\-Division}}",
"The 218 remained in Courland for the final months of the war, finally surrendering to the Soviet Army near [Tuckum](/wiki/Tukums \"Tukums\").",
""
] |
History
-------
### Piarist High School
In [Central Europe](/wiki/Central_Europe "Central Europe"), there were Piarist schools in six provinces ("[ordinariates](/wiki/Ordinariate "Ordinariate")"): [Austria](/wiki/Austria "Austria"), [Bohemia](/wiki/Bohemia "Bohemia")\-[Moravia](/wiki/Moravia "Moravia"), [Hungary](/wiki/Hungary "Hungary"), [Poland](/wiki/Poland "Poland"), [Romania](/wiki/Romania "Romania") and [Slovakia](/wiki/Slovakia "Slovakia"). The first Piarist school in [Transylvania](/wiki/Transylvania "Transylvania") was the [gymnasium](/wiki/Gymnasium_%28school%29 "Gymnasium (school)") founded in 1717 in [Bistrița](/wiki/Bistri%C8%9Ba "Bistrița"). It was followed by those from [Carei](/wiki/Carei "Carei") and [Sighetu Marmației](/wiki/Sighetu_Marma%C8%9Biei "Sighetu Marmației"). [Cluj](/wiki/Cluj-Napoca "Cluj-Napoca") also boasted a Piarist institution.
In [Banat](/wiki/Banat "Banat"), the activity of monk\-teachers began in 1747 when the Serbian nobleman Iacob Bibici and his wife Margareta Tomian built a church and a monastery on their estate in [Sântana](/wiki/S%C3%A2ntana "Sântana"), which in 1750 they donated, together with the sum of 15,000 [Rhenish florins](/wiki/Florin "Florin"), to the [Piarist Order](/wiki/Piarist_Order "Piarist Order"), for them to set up a gymnasium there. The gymnasium was inaugurated in 1751 with three classes: lower, middle and upper. The classes were apparently run by Bulgarian monks at first, but soon priest\-teachers trained in several languages were called up here. From the very beginning classes were taught in all the languages spoken then in the empire, providing a revolutionary system for the teaching methods of the 18th century.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.banatulazi.ro/calugarii\-piaristi\-au\-lasat\-timisoarei\-una\-din\-cele\-mai\-moderne\-scoli/ \|title\=Călugării piariști au lăsat Timișoarei una din cele mai moderne școli \|work\=Banatul Azi \|last\=Bălan \|first\=Titus \|date\=26 June 2016 \|access\-date\=23 February 2022 \|archive\-date\=4 August 2020 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200804113249/https://www.banatulazi.ro/calugarii\-piaristi\-au\-lasat\-timisoarei\-una\-din\-cele\-mai\-moderne\-scoli/ \|url\-status\=live }} In 1772, two more classes were added, the fourth and the fifth, which, together with three classes of the [primary school](/wiki/Primary_school "Primary school"), formed the eight classes of education of the time.{{cite book \|title\=Timișoara: monografie istorică \|last\=Ilieșiu \|first\=Nicolae \|publisher\=Planetarium \|location\=Timișoara \|date\=2003 \|edition\=2nd \|isbn\=973\-97327\-2\-0}}{{rp\|184}} 1784 brings the closure of the boarding school next to the school, by order of the emperor, and in 1788 the school premises are requisitioned for the military hospital of the [Timișoara](/wiki/Timi%C8%99oara "Timișoara") garrison.{{rp\|184}} In the short time in Sântana, an estimated 17,000 students from all over the region attended school.
According to an imperial patent of Emperor [Joseph II](/wiki/Joseph_II%2C_Holy_Roman_Emperor "Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor"), the order will be established in Timișoara from 1788, where shortly after arrival they will have to transform the school they ran into an eight\-grade gymnasium.{{cite web \|url\=https://gerhardus.ro/educatie/liceul\-teologic\-romano\-catolic\-gerhardinum/ \|title\=Liceul Teologic Romano\-Catolic Gerhardinum \|work\=Dieceza Romano\-Catolică de Timișoara \|access\-date\=2022\-02\-23 \|archive\-date\=2021\-11\-04 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20211104174445/https://gerhardus.ro/educatie/liceul\-teologic\-romano\-catolic\-gerhardinum/ \|url\-status\=live }} As previously said, the Jesuits already had a church and a school in Timișoara, built in 1726, somewhere in the perimeter delimited by the north side of the [Liberty Square](/wiki/Liberty_Square%2C_Timi%C8%99oara "Liberty Square, Timișoara") and on the current Emanuil Ungureanu Street, but the number of students was very small. In 1769 there were only 20 students in all six classes. In 1778 the gymnasium was closed, after the abolition of the Jesuit Order in 1773\. Franciscans from [Bosnia](/wiki/Bosnia "Bosnia") built a [Baroque](/wiki/Baroque_architecture "Baroque architecture") church between 1733 and 1736\. After the arrival of the Piarists, the activity of the Franciscans decreases, and their church becomes the property of the Piarists, who will use it until 1911, when it will be demolished, and in its place the Palace of the Credit Bank will be built next year.{{rp\|185}}
The language of instruction was initially, for a short time, [Latin](/wiki/Latin_language "Latin language"). But, by a decree of [Joseph II](/wiki/Joseph_II%2C_Holy_Roman_Emperor "Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor"), [German](/wiki/German_language "German language") was imposed as the official language of the high school. From the middle of the 19th century until the end of World War I, classes were taught in [Hungarian](/wiki/Hungarian_language "Hungarian language"), and from 1920 the teaching system in [Romanian](/wiki/Romanian_language "Romanian language") was applied. At the beginning of the 19th century, there were few Romanian students in high school, but this situation may also be due to the fact that they were Orthodox and, by order of the Serbian patriarch [Stefan Stratimirović](/wiki/Stefan_Stratimirovi%C4%87 "Stefan Stratimirović"), Orthodox students could not enroll in German schools unless they had Serbian names.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.banaterra.eu/romana/biblioteca\_banat/articole/varias/Vechimea\_elementului\_romanesc\_in\_spatiul\_variesean.pdf \|title\=Vechimea elementului românesc în spațiul varieșean \|last\=Zamfir \|first\=Florin \|page\=4\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180131201209/http://www.banaterra.eu/romana/biblioteca\_banat/articole/varias/Vechimea\_elementului\_romanesc\_in\_spatiul\_variesean.pdf \|archive\-date\=2018\-01\-31 }}
In 1802, the sixth grade was added to the Piarist gymnasium, which operated in the Catholic seminary. Since 1841 it has been elevated to the rank of high school (upper gymnasium). In 1850 it became a complete high school (with eight classes).{{rp\|185}} At that time the high school had 12 teachers, a [physics](/wiki/Physics "Physics") laboratory, a [mineralogy](/wiki/Mineralogy "Mineralogy") collection and a [herbarium](/wiki/Herbarium "Herbarium"). In the school year 1852–1853, the high school had 184 students, of whom 41 were Germans, 66 Hungarians, 45 Serbs, 26 Romanians, 4 Croats, and 2 Slovenes.{{cite book \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=dx8uAAAAYAAJ \|title\=Monographie der königlichen Freistadt Temesvár \|last\=Preyer \|first\=Johann N. \|location\=Timișoara \|publisher\=Rösch \& Comp. \|date\=1853 \|page\=140 \|access\-date\=2022\-02\-23 \|archive\-date\=2022\-02\-23 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20220223221919/https://books.google.ro/books?id\=dx8uAAAAYAAJ \|url\-status\=live }} Among the high school students was the future writer [Ioan Slavici](/wiki/Ioan_Slavici "Ioan Slavici"), who attended the sixth and seventh grades of high school here between 1865 and 1867\.{{cite book \|chapter\=Slavici, Ioan \|title\=Dicționarul literaturii române de la origini până la 1900 \|publisher\=Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste România \|last\=Crețu \|first\=Stănuța \|display\-authors\=etal \|location\=Bucharest \|date\=1979 \|page\=788}}
[thumb\|left\|Bas\-relief of the architect {{ill\|László Székely (architect)\|lt\=László Székely\|ro}} on the facade of the Piarist High School](/wiki/File:Szekely_Laszlo.jpg "Szekely Laszlo.jpg")
The old Jesuit monastery is gradually becoming too small for the needs of the school and moving solutions are being sought. In this old building, the Popular Art School on Emanuil Ungureanu Street still operates today. But the adjoining church no longer exists. The architectural complex of the Piarist High School, existing to this day, with classrooms, boarding school, dormitory and chapel, was built between 1908 and 1909, with the ministerial authorization issued on 26 March 1907\. The building project was designed by Alexander Baumgarten, a technical expert, whereas the detailed plans of the building were designed by the City Engineers' Office. The buildings were raised by the construction masters from Arnold Merbl \& Co. under the supervision of the architect {{ill\|László Székely (architect)\|lt\=László Székely\|ro}}. The whole complex is elaborated in the [Secession style](/wiki/Vienna_Secession "Vienna Secession"), popular at that time, but with much more faded touches, resembling in some details a [classicism](/wiki/Classical_architecture "Classical architecture") adapted to the place. The newly established school soon became an elite unit of Banat, so many students from all neighboring areas attended it. They also came here from [Serbia](/wiki/Serbia "Serbia"), [Slovenia](/wiki/Slovenia "Slovenia"), [Galicia](/wiki/Galicia_%28Eastern_Europe%29 "Galicia (Eastern Europe)") and [Wallachia](/wiki/Wallachia "Wallachia") (for example, the sons of the Bibescu family). By 1918, 46,000 students had graduated here. The [lazaretto](/wiki/Lazaretto "Lazaretto") of the *[Wehrmacht](/wiki/Wehrmacht "Wehrmacht")* was housed within the massive walls of this high school during World War II.
### Polytechnic Institute
After World War II, following the ban by the communist authorities on the activities of the monastic orders of the [Roman Catholic Church](/wiki/Roman_Catholic_Church "Roman Catholic Church"), the activity of the Piarist High School ceased. In 1946, the high school and boarding school buildings were assigned to the [Timișoara Polytechnic School](/wiki/Politehnica_University_of_Timi%C8%99oara "Politehnica University of Timișoara").{{cite book \|title\=Monografia Facultății de Mecanică din Timișoara: 1920\-1948\-2003 \|last\=Neguț \|first\=Nicolae \|location\=Timișoara \|publisher\=Politehnica \|date\=2005 \|page\=26 \|isbn\=973\-625\-231\-0}} The building on Piatra Craiului Street became the [library of the Polytechnic](/wiki/Central_Library_of_Politehnica_University_of_Timi%C8%99oara "Central Library of Politehnica University of Timișoara"). Only the chapel could keep its original destination.
After 1948, following its reorganization into a Polytechnic Institute, most of the newly established Faculty of Electrotechnics moved in the high school building, which is why the ensemble was called *Electro*. Some of the laboratories of the Faculty of Chemistry also moved in the library building. In the 1970s, amid a development of [electronics](/wiki/Electronics "Electronics") and [computer science](/wiki/Computer_science "Computer science"), the high school building became too small and the topic of building a new headquarters for the Faculty of Electrotechnics was raised; it will be put into use in 1976\. Most of the Faculty of Electrotechnics is moved to the new headquarters, which is why after this date the Piarist ensemble was called *Old Electro*.
After 1989, the issue of returning the ensemble to the Roman Catholic Church arose. The Faculty of Electrotechnics is completely relocated to the new headquarters, so the high school building was retroceded relatively quickly in 1992\. The laboratories of the Faculty of Chemistry could also be moved, as a new headquarters was built in 1982 for the Faculty of Chemistry. The library was the last to be moved; its new headquarters was inaugurated in 2014\.
### Gerhardinum High School
After the 1990s, the [Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara](/wiki/Roman_Catholic_Diocese_of_Timi%C8%99oara "Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara") managed to regain its school complex and established here the Gerhardinum Roman Catholic High School, after the name of [Saint Gerard](/wiki/Gerard_of_Csan%C3%A1d "Gerard of Csanád"), the first bishop and patron saint of the diocese. Priest\-teacher Petru Szabó was appointed first principal on 8 September 1992\. The transfer to possession was gradually made in several stages; the final handover took place in 2006\. Also in 2006, a boarding school with 80 places was created in the old Piarist dormitory.
The school is a state high school, which operates under the protection of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara, with teaching departments in Romanian and Hungarian. The profile of the high school is theological\-humanistic. It also teaches real subjects, such as [computer operator](/wiki/Computer_operator "Computer operator") courses. Upon graduating high school, after taking an exam of professional skills, students have the right to teach [religion](/wiki/Religion "Religion") in schools with grades I–VIII. The graduation exam of the computer operator course ensures the [International Computer Driving Licence](/wiki/International_Computer_Driving_Licence "International Computer Driving Licence"), an internationally recognized certificate.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Piarist High School",
"In [Central Europe](/wiki/Central_Europe \"Central Europe\"), there were Piarist schools in six provinces (\"[ordinariates](/wiki/Ordinariate \"Ordinariate\")\"): [Austria](/wiki/Austria \"Austria\"), [Bohemia](/wiki/Bohemia \"Bohemia\")\\-[Moravia](/wiki/Moravia \"Moravia\"), [Hungary](/wiki/Hungary \"Hungary\"), [Poland](/wiki/Poland \"Poland\"), [Romania](/wiki/Romania \"Romania\") and [Slovakia](/wiki/Slovakia \"Slovakia\"). The first Piarist school in [Transylvania](/wiki/Transylvania \"Transylvania\") was the [gymnasium](/wiki/Gymnasium_%28school%29 \"Gymnasium (school)\") founded in 1717 in [Bistrița](/wiki/Bistri%C8%9Ba \"Bistrița\"). It was followed by those from [Carei](/wiki/Carei \"Carei\") and [Sighetu Marmației](/wiki/Sighetu_Marma%C8%9Biei \"Sighetu Marmației\"). [Cluj](/wiki/Cluj-Napoca \"Cluj-Napoca\") also boasted a Piarist institution.",
"In [Banat](/wiki/Banat \"Banat\"), the activity of monk\\-teachers began in 1747 when the Serbian nobleman Iacob Bibici and his wife Margareta Tomian built a church and a monastery on their estate in [Sântana](/wiki/S%C3%A2ntana \"Sântana\"), which in 1750 they donated, together with the sum of 15,000 [Rhenish florins](/wiki/Florin \"Florin\"), to the [Piarist Order](/wiki/Piarist_Order \"Piarist Order\"), for them to set up a gymnasium there. The gymnasium was inaugurated in 1751 with three classes: lower, middle and upper. The classes were apparently run by Bulgarian monks at first, but soon priest\\-teachers trained in several languages were called up here. From the very beginning classes were taught in all the languages spoken then in the empire, providing a revolutionary system for the teaching methods of the 18th century.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.banatulazi.ro/calugarii\\-piaristi\\-au\\-lasat\\-timisoarei\\-una\\-din\\-cele\\-mai\\-moderne\\-scoli/ \\|title\\=Călugării piariști au lăsat Timișoarei una din cele mai moderne școli \\|work\\=Banatul Azi \\|last\\=Bălan \\|first\\=Titus \\|date\\=26 June 2016 \\|access\\-date\\=23 February 2022 \\|archive\\-date\\=4 August 2020 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200804113249/https://www.banatulazi.ro/calugarii\\-piaristi\\-au\\-lasat\\-timisoarei\\-una\\-din\\-cele\\-mai\\-moderne\\-scoli/ \\|url\\-status\\=live }} In 1772, two more classes were added, the fourth and the fifth, which, together with three classes of the [primary school](/wiki/Primary_school \"Primary school\"), formed the eight classes of education of the time.{{cite book \\|title\\=Timișoara: monografie istorică \\|last\\=Ilieșiu \\|first\\=Nicolae \\|publisher\\=Planetarium \\|location\\=Timișoara \\|date\\=2003 \\|edition\\=2nd \\|isbn\\=973\\-97327\\-2\\-0}}{{rp\\|184}} 1784 brings the closure of the boarding school next to the school, by order of the emperor, and in 1788 the school premises are requisitioned for the military hospital of the [Timișoara](/wiki/Timi%C8%99oara \"Timișoara\") garrison.{{rp\\|184}} In the short time in Sântana, an estimated 17,000 students from all over the region attended school.",
"According to an imperial patent of Emperor [Joseph II](/wiki/Joseph_II%2C_Holy_Roman_Emperor \"Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor\"), the order will be established in Timișoara from 1788, where shortly after arrival they will have to transform the school they ran into an eight\\-grade gymnasium.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://gerhardus.ro/educatie/liceul\\-teologic\\-romano\\-catolic\\-gerhardinum/ \\|title\\=Liceul Teologic Romano\\-Catolic Gerhardinum \\|work\\=Dieceza Romano\\-Catolică de Timișoara \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-02\\-23 \\|archive\\-date\\=2021\\-11\\-04 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20211104174445/https://gerhardus.ro/educatie/liceul\\-teologic\\-romano\\-catolic\\-gerhardinum/ \\|url\\-status\\=live }} As previously said, the Jesuits already had a church and a school in Timișoara, built in 1726, somewhere in the perimeter delimited by the north side of the [Liberty Square](/wiki/Liberty_Square%2C_Timi%C8%99oara \"Liberty Square, Timișoara\") and on the current Emanuil Ungureanu Street, but the number of students was very small. In 1769 there were only 20 students in all six classes. In 1778 the gymnasium was closed, after the abolition of the Jesuit Order in 1773\\. Franciscans from [Bosnia](/wiki/Bosnia \"Bosnia\") built a [Baroque](/wiki/Baroque_architecture \"Baroque architecture\") church between 1733 and 1736\\. After the arrival of the Piarists, the activity of the Franciscans decreases, and their church becomes the property of the Piarists, who will use it until 1911, when it will be demolished, and in its place the Palace of the Credit Bank will be built next year.{{rp\\|185}}",
"The language of instruction was initially, for a short time, [Latin](/wiki/Latin_language \"Latin language\"). But, by a decree of [Joseph II](/wiki/Joseph_II%2C_Holy_Roman_Emperor \"Joseph II, Holy Roman Emperor\"), [German](/wiki/German_language \"German language\") was imposed as the official language of the high school. From the middle of the 19th century until the end of World War I, classes were taught in [Hungarian](/wiki/Hungarian_language \"Hungarian language\"), and from 1920 the teaching system in [Romanian](/wiki/Romanian_language \"Romanian language\") was applied. At the beginning of the 19th century, there were few Romanian students in high school, but this situation may also be due to the fact that they were Orthodox and, by order of the Serbian patriarch [Stefan Stratimirović](/wiki/Stefan_Stratimirovi%C4%87 \"Stefan Stratimirović\"), Orthodox students could not enroll in German schools unless they had Serbian names.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.banaterra.eu/romana/biblioteca\\_banat/articole/varias/Vechimea\\_elementului\\_romanesc\\_in\\_spatiul\\_variesean.pdf \\|title\\=Vechimea elementului românesc în spațiul varieșean \\|last\\=Zamfir \\|first\\=Florin \\|page\\=4\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180131201209/http://www.banaterra.eu/romana/biblioteca\\_banat/articole/varias/Vechimea\\_elementului\\_romanesc\\_in\\_spatiul\\_variesean.pdf \\|archive\\-date\\=2018\\-01\\-31 }}",
"In 1802, the sixth grade was added to the Piarist gymnasium, which operated in the Catholic seminary. Since 1841 it has been elevated to the rank of high school (upper gymnasium). In 1850 it became a complete high school (with eight classes).{{rp\\|185}} At that time the high school had 12 teachers, a [physics](/wiki/Physics \"Physics\") laboratory, a [mineralogy](/wiki/Mineralogy \"Mineralogy\") collection and a [herbarium](/wiki/Herbarium \"Herbarium\"). In the school year 1852–1853, the high school had 184 students, of whom 41 were Germans, 66 Hungarians, 45 Serbs, 26 Romanians, 4 Croats, and 2 Slovenes.{{cite book \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=dx8uAAAAYAAJ \\|title\\=Monographie der königlichen Freistadt Temesvár \\|last\\=Preyer \\|first\\=Johann N. \\|location\\=Timișoara \\|publisher\\=Rösch \\& Comp. \\|date\\=1853 \\|page\\=140 \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-02\\-23 \\|archive\\-date\\=2022\\-02\\-23 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20220223221919/https://books.google.ro/books?id\\=dx8uAAAAYAAJ \\|url\\-status\\=live }} Among the high school students was the future writer [Ioan Slavici](/wiki/Ioan_Slavici \"Ioan Slavici\"), who attended the sixth and seventh grades of high school here between 1865 and 1867\\.{{cite book \\|chapter\\=Slavici, Ioan \\|title\\=Dicționarul literaturii române de la origini până la 1900 \\|publisher\\=Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste România \\|last\\=Crețu \\|first\\=Stănuța \\|display\\-authors\\=etal \\|location\\=Bucharest \\|date\\=1979 \\|page\\=788}}\n[thumb\\|left\\|Bas\\-relief of the architect {{ill\\|László Székely (architect)\\|lt\\=László Székely\\|ro}} on the facade of the Piarist High School](/wiki/File:Szekely_Laszlo.jpg \"Szekely Laszlo.jpg\")\nThe old Jesuit monastery is gradually becoming too small for the needs of the school and moving solutions are being sought. In this old building, the Popular Art School on Emanuil Ungureanu Street still operates today. But the adjoining church no longer exists. The architectural complex of the Piarist High School, existing to this day, with classrooms, boarding school, dormitory and chapel, was built between 1908 and 1909, with the ministerial authorization issued on 26 March 1907\\. The building project was designed by Alexander Baumgarten, a technical expert, whereas the detailed plans of the building were designed by the City Engineers' Office. The buildings were raised by the construction masters from Arnold Merbl \\& Co. under the supervision of the architect {{ill\\|László Székely (architect)\\|lt\\=László Székely\\|ro}}. The whole complex is elaborated in the [Secession style](/wiki/Vienna_Secession \"Vienna Secession\"), popular at that time, but with much more faded touches, resembling in some details a [classicism](/wiki/Classical_architecture \"Classical architecture\") adapted to the place. The newly established school soon became an elite unit of Banat, so many students from all neighboring areas attended it. They also came here from [Serbia](/wiki/Serbia \"Serbia\"), [Slovenia](/wiki/Slovenia \"Slovenia\"), [Galicia](/wiki/Galicia_%28Eastern_Europe%29 \"Galicia (Eastern Europe)\") and [Wallachia](/wiki/Wallachia \"Wallachia\") (for example, the sons of the Bibescu family). By 1918, 46,000 students had graduated here. The [lazaretto](/wiki/Lazaretto \"Lazaretto\") of the *[Wehrmacht](/wiki/Wehrmacht \"Wehrmacht\")* was housed within the massive walls of this high school during World War II.",
"### Polytechnic Institute",
"After World War II, following the ban by the communist authorities on the activities of the monastic orders of the [Roman Catholic Church](/wiki/Roman_Catholic_Church \"Roman Catholic Church\"), the activity of the Piarist High School ceased. In 1946, the high school and boarding school buildings were assigned to the [Timișoara Polytechnic School](/wiki/Politehnica_University_of_Timi%C8%99oara \"Politehnica University of Timișoara\").{{cite book \\|title\\=Monografia Facultății de Mecanică din Timișoara: 1920\\-1948\\-2003 \\|last\\=Neguț \\|first\\=Nicolae \\|location\\=Timișoara \\|publisher\\=Politehnica \\|date\\=2005 \\|page\\=26 \\|isbn\\=973\\-625\\-231\\-0}} The building on Piatra Craiului Street became the [library of the Polytechnic](/wiki/Central_Library_of_Politehnica_University_of_Timi%C8%99oara \"Central Library of Politehnica University of Timișoara\"). Only the chapel could keep its original destination.",
"After 1948, following its reorganization into a Polytechnic Institute, most of the newly established Faculty of Electrotechnics moved in the high school building, which is why the ensemble was called *Electro*. Some of the laboratories of the Faculty of Chemistry also moved in the library building. In the 1970s, amid a development of [electronics](/wiki/Electronics \"Electronics\") and [computer science](/wiki/Computer_science \"Computer science\"), the high school building became too small and the topic of building a new headquarters for the Faculty of Electrotechnics was raised; it will be put into use in 1976\\. Most of the Faculty of Electrotechnics is moved to the new headquarters, which is why after this date the Piarist ensemble was called *Old Electro*.",
"After 1989, the issue of returning the ensemble to the Roman Catholic Church arose. The Faculty of Electrotechnics is completely relocated to the new headquarters, so the high school building was retroceded relatively quickly in 1992\\. The laboratories of the Faculty of Chemistry could also be moved, as a new headquarters was built in 1982 for the Faculty of Chemistry. The library was the last to be moved; its new headquarters was inaugurated in 2014\\.",
"### Gerhardinum High School",
"After the 1990s, the [Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara](/wiki/Roman_Catholic_Diocese_of_Timi%C8%99oara \"Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara\") managed to regain its school complex and established here the Gerhardinum Roman Catholic High School, after the name of [Saint Gerard](/wiki/Gerard_of_Csan%C3%A1d \"Gerard of Csanád\"), the first bishop and patron saint of the diocese. Priest\\-teacher Petru Szabó was appointed first principal on 8 September 1992\\. The transfer to possession was gradually made in several stages; the final handover took place in 2006\\. Also in 2006, a boarding school with 80 places was created in the old Piarist dormitory.",
"The school is a state high school, which operates under the protection of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Timișoara, with teaching departments in Romanian and Hungarian. The profile of the high school is theological\\-humanistic. It also teaches real subjects, such as [computer operator](/wiki/Computer_operator \"Computer operator\") courses. Upon graduating high school, after taking an exam of professional skills, students have the right to teach [religion](/wiki/Religion \"Religion\") in schools with grades I–VIII. The graduation exam of the computer operator course ensures the [International Computer Driving Licence](/wiki/International_Computer_Driving_Licence \"International Computer Driving Licence\"), an internationally recognized certificate.",
""
] |
Relationships
-------------
[thumb\|right\|150px\|Panel of the famous [polyptych of St. Vicent](/wiki/Saint_Vincent_Panels "Saint Vincent Panels") by painter [Nuno Gonçalves](/wiki/Nuno_Gon%C3%A7alves "Nuno Gonçalves"), believed to represent the four younger sons of [John I](/wiki/John_I_of_Portugal "John I of Portugal"): [Ferdinand the Holy](/wiki/Ferdinand_the_Holy_Prince "Ferdinand the Holy Prince") (on top, in black), [John of Reguengos](/wiki/John%2C_Lord_of_Reguengos_de_Monsaraz "John, Lord of Reguengos de Monsaraz") (left, red), [Peter of Coimbra](/wiki/Infante_Peter%2C_Duke_of_Coimbra "Infante Peter, Duke of Coimbra") (right, green), [Henry the Navigator](/wiki/Henry_the_Navigator "Henry the Navigator") (bottom, purple)](/wiki/Image:Nu%C3%B1o_Gon%C3%A7alves_001.jpg "Nuño Gonçalves 001.jpg")
According to the chronicler [Gomes Eanes de Zurara](/wiki/Gomes_Eanes_de_Zurara "Gomes Eanes de Zurara"), all of the five brothers participated in the [conquest of Ceuta](/wiki/Conquest_of_Ceuta "Conquest of Ceuta") of 1415 and were knighted in the aftermath by their father, King John I, with [arming swords](/wiki/Arming_sword "Arming sword") supplied by their dying mother, [Philippa of Lancaster](/wiki/Philippa_of_Lancaster "Philippa of Lancaster").Zurara (1450\) They began receiving their lordships shortly after, e.g. in 1416, Peter was made [duke of Coimbra](/wiki/Duke_of_Coimbra "Duke of Coimbra") and Henry [duke of Viseu](/wiki/Duke_of_Viseu "Duke of Viseu"), etc. John I also began to seize control of the main [military orders](/wiki/Military_order_%28society%29 "Military order (society)") of Portugal by securing from the pope the appointment of his sons as their grand masters. John took the Order of Saint James of the Sword in 1418, Henry the [Order of Christ](/wiki/Order_of_Christ_%28Portugal%29 "Order of Christ (Portugal)") in 1420 and Ferdinand the [Order of Aviz](/wiki/Order_of_Aviz "Order of Aviz"). John I appointed young John to succeed his loyal lieutenant [Nuno Álvares Pereira](/wiki/Nuno_%C3%81lvares_Pereira "Nuno Álvares Pereira") as [Constable of Portugal](/wiki/Constable_of_Portugal "Constable of Portugal") (i.e., high military chief) in 1431\.
Despite the high titles, John I retained careful control over the activities of his sons, deploying them as deputies of his will, and not allowing them too much room for independent manoeuver, responsibility or authority. It is probably as a result of this that, through the 1420s, the princes dedicated themselves to individual pursuits \- Edward to philosophy, Peter to celebrated tours of [Renaissance](/wiki/Renaissance "Renaissance") Europe and Henry to his nautical charts. The "illustrious" label for this generation of princes refers in good part to their intellectual achievements. The nature of these accomplishments also justifies the inclusion of [Isabella of Portugal](/wiki/Isabella_of_Portugal_%281397%E2%80%931471%29 "Isabella of Portugal (1397–1471)") in the list, as she helped transpose much of the Renaissance spirit and flair of the [Burgundian](/wiki/Duchy_of_Burgundy "Duchy of Burgundy") court back to Medieval Lisbon.
It is really only after the death of their father in 1433 that the princes came into their own. Now king, [Edward of Portugal](/wiki/Edward_of_Portugal "Edward of Portugal") ran his court almost jointly with his brothers, who were his intimate counsellors. Edward generously handed out lucrative benefices and monopolies to his brothers, giving them the means for independent action. Flush with new grants, Henry the Navigator's naval expeditions kicked into high gear after 1433\.
Disagreements over policy soon produced fraternal fissures. In 1436, Edward assembled the Cortes of Évora to consider the ambitious scheme proposed by Henry the Navigator to conquer [Tangiers](/wiki/Tangiers "Tangiers") from Morocco. Peter of Coimbra and John of Reguengos argued vigorously against the plan, urging Edward to focus on domestic priorities, but Ferdinand the Holy backed Henry's plan. Against Edward's misgivings, the plan went forward, with Henry personally leading the expeditionary force in 1437\. It was a fiasco. The Portuguese army was quickly surrounded and starved into submission. The humiliation was complete when Henry agreed to deliver [Ceuta](/wiki/Ceuta "Ceuta") back to the [Marinids](/wiki/Marinid "Marinid") and left his youngest brother Ferdinand as hostage for the fulfillment of the treaty. Despite Peter and John's entreaties, the Portuguese Cortes refused to ratify the treaty, and left Ferdinand in captivity in [Fez, Morocco](/wiki/Fez%2C_Morocco "Fez, Morocco"), where he eventually died in 1443\.
The Tangiers debacle and the harrowing fate of Prince Ferdinand may have contributed to Edward's premature death in 1438\. The country was surprised by Edward's will, which appointed his consort [Eleanor of Aragon](/wiki/Eleanor_of_Aragon%2C_Queen_of_Portugal "Eleanor of Aragon, Queen of Portugal"), rather than his brothers, as [regent](/wiki/Regent "Regent") of the kingdom on behalf of his young son, the new king [Afonso V of Portugal](/wiki/Afonso_V_of_Portugal "Afonso V of Portugal"). Many commoners believed the foreign\-born Eleanor would be a pliable puppet of the Portuguese high aristocracy, who were itching to claw back the authority they lost to the burghers since the [revolution of the 1380s](/wiki/1383%E2%80%931385_Crisis "1383–1385 Crisis"). The country seemed to be careening towards civil war, when John of Reguengos, in his capacity as constable, quickly seized control of the city of [Lisbon](/wiki/Lisbon "Lisbon") and assembled a burgher\-packed Cortes that promptly elected his brother and ally Peter of Coimbra as regent. The Portuguese high nobility, now rallied around the half\-brother Afonso, urged Eleanor to refuse to step down. The crisis was finally defused when Henry the Navigator offered to arbitrate between the parties; he negotiated a tense power\-sharing arrangement between Peter, Eleanor and Afonso. For many commoners, who were steadfast behind Peter and John and believed they had the upper hand, Henry's intervention was not welcome.
Despite the strange regency agreement, Peter of Coimbra quickly seized the lion's share of power, buying off noble opponents one by one with promises of new titles and benefices (which he was not quick to fulfill). The death of John of Reguengos, Peter's loyal brother and ally in 1442, was a setback. But he quickly began to cultivate the support of the ambivalent Henry the Navigator, renewing and expanding his benefices, most notably granting him a lucrative monopoly on trade in Africa south of Cape Bojador in 1443\. To seal his position and influence, Peter persuaded his nephew, the young king Afonso V, to marry his own daughter, [Isabella of Coimbra](/wiki/Isabella_of_Coimbra "Isabella of Coimbra"), in 1445\. By 1446, Peter felt confident enough to unveil his Afonsine Ordinances, a new Portuguese legal code uniting Visigothic, Roman and common law. The Portuguese burghers applauded the move, while the upper nobility was appalled and turned to the half\-brother Afonso for redress.
Afonso's tense relationship with Peter had turned decidedly for the worse after the death of John of Reguengos in 1442, when Peter decided to appoint John's son, [Diogo of Portugal](/wiki/Diogo_of_Portugal "Diogo of Portugal"), as the successor to his father's important title of [Constable of Portugal](/wiki/Constable_of_Portugal "Constable of Portugal"), which had been promised to Afonso and his sons. Things only got worse after Diogo's sudden death in 1443, when, once again, Peter overlooked Afonso and appointed his own son, [Peter of Portugal](/wiki/Peter_V_of_Aragon "Peter V of Aragon"), as Constable. To appease Afonso, Peter of Coimbra created him the first [Duke of Braganza](/wiki/Duke_of_Braganza "Duke of Braganza") in 1443\.
The Afonsine Ordinances of 1446 brought the bulk of the nobility to rally behind the discontented Afonso and urged him to do something about it. Afonso set about ingratiating himself with the impressionable young King Afonso and soon displaced Peter as his favorite uncle.
In June 1448, Afonso V finally came of age and dismissed Peter of Coimbra as regent. The machinations of Afonso of Braganza soon bore fruit when, in September 1448, Afonso V nullified all of the edicts and laws passed under Peter's regency and began rooting out Peter's appointees and passing their positions over to Braganza's men.
In 1449, Peter of Coimbra gathered his loyalists, knights and bureaucrats who had been dismissed by Afonso V's purge and set out on what he claimed was a peaceful mass march on Lisbon to protest the dismissals and petition the king to allow his men to defend themselves against the false accusations being lobbed at them in court. But Afonso of Braganza persuaded Afonso V that Peter intended to lay siege to the city and provoke a popular uprising by the overwhelmingly supportive burghers. The latter interpretation gained currency, and Afonso V declared Peter a rebel and outlaw and led the royal army out to intercept his uncle's march. The armies met at the [Battle of Alfarrobeira](/wiki/Battle_of_Alfarrobeira "Battle of Alfarrobeira") in May 1449\. It was not much of a battle \- Peter of Coimbra was killed by missile fire near the start, and his "army" quickly laid down their arms.
[thumb\|right\|350px\|Tombs of the high princes, Founder's Chapel, [Batalha Monastery](/wiki/Batalha_Monastery "Batalha Monastery"). From left to right, [Ferdinand the Holy](/wiki/Ferdinand_the_Holy_Prince "Ferdinand the Holy Prince"), [John of Reguengos](/wiki/John%2C_Lord_of_Reguengos_de_Monsaraz "John, Lord of Reguengos de Monsaraz"), [Henry the Navigator](/wiki/Henry_the_Navigator "Henry the Navigator") and [Peter of Coimbra](/wiki/Peter_of_Coimbra "Peter of Coimbra")](/wiki/File:T%C3%BAmulos_de_los_Infantes_%28Monasterio_de_Batalha%29.jpg "Túmulos de los Infantes (Monasterio de Batalha).jpg")
The victory of Afonso of Braganza and the rest of the nobility was now complete, and they remained high in the saddle throughout the rest of Afonso V's reign. In the aftermath, Henry the Navigator, the last surviving member of the illustrious generation, went into near\-hermitical seclusion in [Sagres](/wiki/Sagres%2C_Portugal "Sagres, Portugal"). Having allowed his household knights to join field with the king's army against Peter, Henry reputation as dynastic traitor was cemented in the popular mindset; he became thoroughly hated by Peter's partisans and the burghers. To the new order of Braganza and the high nobility, Henry was a useless relic, a quirky old man who liked to play with ships. Henry spent his last remaining years launching a new set of naval expeditions, stretching Portuguese discoveries as far as the [Gold Coast](/wiki/Gold_Coast_%28region%29 "Gold Coast (region)") of west Africa. Henry died in 1460, a bachelor without heirs, largely unlamented, save perhaps by the Order of Christ, whose fortunes he had so enlarged.
|
[
"Relationships\n-------------",
"[thumb\\|right\\|150px\\|Panel of the famous [polyptych of St. Vicent](/wiki/Saint_Vincent_Panels \"Saint Vincent Panels\") by painter [Nuno Gonçalves](/wiki/Nuno_Gon%C3%A7alves \"Nuno Gonçalves\"), believed to represent the four younger sons of [John I](/wiki/John_I_of_Portugal \"John I of Portugal\"): [Ferdinand the Holy](/wiki/Ferdinand_the_Holy_Prince \"Ferdinand the Holy Prince\") (on top, in black), [John of Reguengos](/wiki/John%2C_Lord_of_Reguengos_de_Monsaraz \"John, Lord of Reguengos de Monsaraz\") (left, red), [Peter of Coimbra](/wiki/Infante_Peter%2C_Duke_of_Coimbra \"Infante Peter, Duke of Coimbra\") (right, green), [Henry the Navigator](/wiki/Henry_the_Navigator \"Henry the Navigator\") (bottom, purple)](/wiki/Image:Nu%C3%B1o_Gon%C3%A7alves_001.jpg \"Nuño Gonçalves 001.jpg\")\nAccording to the chronicler [Gomes Eanes de Zurara](/wiki/Gomes_Eanes_de_Zurara \"Gomes Eanes de Zurara\"), all of the five brothers participated in the [conquest of Ceuta](/wiki/Conquest_of_Ceuta \"Conquest of Ceuta\") of 1415 and were knighted in the aftermath by their father, King John I, with [arming swords](/wiki/Arming_sword \"Arming sword\") supplied by their dying mother, [Philippa of Lancaster](/wiki/Philippa_of_Lancaster \"Philippa of Lancaster\").Zurara (1450\\) They began receiving their lordships shortly after, e.g. in 1416, Peter was made [duke of Coimbra](/wiki/Duke_of_Coimbra \"Duke of Coimbra\") and Henry [duke of Viseu](/wiki/Duke_of_Viseu \"Duke of Viseu\"), etc. John I also began to seize control of the main [military orders](/wiki/Military_order_%28society%29 \"Military order (society)\") of Portugal by securing from the pope the appointment of his sons as their grand masters. John took the Order of Saint James of the Sword in 1418, Henry the [Order of Christ](/wiki/Order_of_Christ_%28Portugal%29 \"Order of Christ (Portugal)\") in 1420 and Ferdinand the [Order of Aviz](/wiki/Order_of_Aviz \"Order of Aviz\"). John I appointed young John to succeed his loyal lieutenant [Nuno Álvares Pereira](/wiki/Nuno_%C3%81lvares_Pereira \"Nuno Álvares Pereira\") as [Constable of Portugal](/wiki/Constable_of_Portugal \"Constable of Portugal\") (i.e., high military chief) in 1431\\.",
"Despite the high titles, John I retained careful control over the activities of his sons, deploying them as deputies of his will, and not allowing them too much room for independent manoeuver, responsibility or authority. It is probably as a result of this that, through the 1420s, the princes dedicated themselves to individual pursuits \\- Edward to philosophy, Peter to celebrated tours of [Renaissance](/wiki/Renaissance \"Renaissance\") Europe and Henry to his nautical charts. The \"illustrious\" label for this generation of princes refers in good part to their intellectual achievements. The nature of these accomplishments also justifies the inclusion of [Isabella of Portugal](/wiki/Isabella_of_Portugal_%281397%E2%80%931471%29 \"Isabella of Portugal (1397–1471)\") in the list, as she helped transpose much of the Renaissance spirit and flair of the [Burgundian](/wiki/Duchy_of_Burgundy \"Duchy of Burgundy\") court back to Medieval Lisbon.",
"It is really only after the death of their father in 1433 that the princes came into their own. Now king, [Edward of Portugal](/wiki/Edward_of_Portugal \"Edward of Portugal\") ran his court almost jointly with his brothers, who were his intimate counsellors. Edward generously handed out lucrative benefices and monopolies to his brothers, giving them the means for independent action. Flush with new grants, Henry the Navigator's naval expeditions kicked into high gear after 1433\\.",
"Disagreements over policy soon produced fraternal fissures. In 1436, Edward assembled the Cortes of Évora to consider the ambitious scheme proposed by Henry the Navigator to conquer [Tangiers](/wiki/Tangiers \"Tangiers\") from Morocco. Peter of Coimbra and John of Reguengos argued vigorously against the plan, urging Edward to focus on domestic priorities, but Ferdinand the Holy backed Henry's plan. Against Edward's misgivings, the plan went forward, with Henry personally leading the expeditionary force in 1437\\. It was a fiasco. The Portuguese army was quickly surrounded and starved into submission. The humiliation was complete when Henry agreed to deliver [Ceuta](/wiki/Ceuta \"Ceuta\") back to the [Marinids](/wiki/Marinid \"Marinid\") and left his youngest brother Ferdinand as hostage for the fulfillment of the treaty. Despite Peter and John's entreaties, the Portuguese Cortes refused to ratify the treaty, and left Ferdinand in captivity in [Fez, Morocco](/wiki/Fez%2C_Morocco \"Fez, Morocco\"), where he eventually died in 1443\\.",
"The Tangiers debacle and the harrowing fate of Prince Ferdinand may have contributed to Edward's premature death in 1438\\. The country was surprised by Edward's will, which appointed his consort [Eleanor of Aragon](/wiki/Eleanor_of_Aragon%2C_Queen_of_Portugal \"Eleanor of Aragon, Queen of Portugal\"), rather than his brothers, as [regent](/wiki/Regent \"Regent\") of the kingdom on behalf of his young son, the new king [Afonso V of Portugal](/wiki/Afonso_V_of_Portugal \"Afonso V of Portugal\"). Many commoners believed the foreign\\-born Eleanor would be a pliable puppet of the Portuguese high aristocracy, who were itching to claw back the authority they lost to the burghers since the [revolution of the 1380s](/wiki/1383%E2%80%931385_Crisis \"1383–1385 Crisis\"). The country seemed to be careening towards civil war, when John of Reguengos, in his capacity as constable, quickly seized control of the city of [Lisbon](/wiki/Lisbon \"Lisbon\") and assembled a burgher\\-packed Cortes that promptly elected his brother and ally Peter of Coimbra as regent. The Portuguese high nobility, now rallied around the half\\-brother Afonso, urged Eleanor to refuse to step down. The crisis was finally defused when Henry the Navigator offered to arbitrate between the parties; he negotiated a tense power\\-sharing arrangement between Peter, Eleanor and Afonso. For many commoners, who were steadfast behind Peter and John and believed they had the upper hand, Henry's intervention was not welcome.",
"Despite the strange regency agreement, Peter of Coimbra quickly seized the lion's share of power, buying off noble opponents one by one with promises of new titles and benefices (which he was not quick to fulfill). The death of John of Reguengos, Peter's loyal brother and ally in 1442, was a setback. But he quickly began to cultivate the support of the ambivalent Henry the Navigator, renewing and expanding his benefices, most notably granting him a lucrative monopoly on trade in Africa south of Cape Bojador in 1443\\. To seal his position and influence, Peter persuaded his nephew, the young king Afonso V, to marry his own daughter, [Isabella of Coimbra](/wiki/Isabella_of_Coimbra \"Isabella of Coimbra\"), in 1445\\. By 1446, Peter felt confident enough to unveil his Afonsine Ordinances, a new Portuguese legal code uniting Visigothic, Roman and common law. The Portuguese burghers applauded the move, while the upper nobility was appalled and turned to the half\\-brother Afonso for redress.",
"Afonso's tense relationship with Peter had turned decidedly for the worse after the death of John of Reguengos in 1442, when Peter decided to appoint John's son, [Diogo of Portugal](/wiki/Diogo_of_Portugal \"Diogo of Portugal\"), as the successor to his father's important title of [Constable of Portugal](/wiki/Constable_of_Portugal \"Constable of Portugal\"), which had been promised to Afonso and his sons. Things only got worse after Diogo's sudden death in 1443, when, once again, Peter overlooked Afonso and appointed his own son, [Peter of Portugal](/wiki/Peter_V_of_Aragon \"Peter V of Aragon\"), as Constable. To appease Afonso, Peter of Coimbra created him the first [Duke of Braganza](/wiki/Duke_of_Braganza \"Duke of Braganza\") in 1443\\.",
"The Afonsine Ordinances of 1446 brought the bulk of the nobility to rally behind the discontented Afonso and urged him to do something about it. Afonso set about ingratiating himself with the impressionable young King Afonso and soon displaced Peter as his favorite uncle.",
"In June 1448, Afonso V finally came of age and dismissed Peter of Coimbra as regent. The machinations of Afonso of Braganza soon bore fruit when, in September 1448, Afonso V nullified all of the edicts and laws passed under Peter's regency and began rooting out Peter's appointees and passing their positions over to Braganza's men.",
"In 1449, Peter of Coimbra gathered his loyalists, knights and bureaucrats who had been dismissed by Afonso V's purge and set out on what he claimed was a peaceful mass march on Lisbon to protest the dismissals and petition the king to allow his men to defend themselves against the false accusations being lobbed at them in court. But Afonso of Braganza persuaded Afonso V that Peter intended to lay siege to the city and provoke a popular uprising by the overwhelmingly supportive burghers. The latter interpretation gained currency, and Afonso V declared Peter a rebel and outlaw and led the royal army out to intercept his uncle's march. The armies met at the [Battle of Alfarrobeira](/wiki/Battle_of_Alfarrobeira \"Battle of Alfarrobeira\") in May 1449\\. It was not much of a battle \\- Peter of Coimbra was killed by missile fire near the start, and his \"army\" quickly laid down their arms. \n[thumb\\|right\\|350px\\|Tombs of the high princes, Founder's Chapel, [Batalha Monastery](/wiki/Batalha_Monastery \"Batalha Monastery\"). From left to right, [Ferdinand the Holy](/wiki/Ferdinand_the_Holy_Prince \"Ferdinand the Holy Prince\"), [John of Reguengos](/wiki/John%2C_Lord_of_Reguengos_de_Monsaraz \"John, Lord of Reguengos de Monsaraz\"), [Henry the Navigator](/wiki/Henry_the_Navigator \"Henry the Navigator\") and [Peter of Coimbra](/wiki/Peter_of_Coimbra \"Peter of Coimbra\")](/wiki/File:T%C3%BAmulos_de_los_Infantes_%28Monasterio_de_Batalha%29.jpg \"Túmulos de los Infantes (Monasterio de Batalha).jpg\")\nThe victory of Afonso of Braganza and the rest of the nobility was now complete, and they remained high in the saddle throughout the rest of Afonso V's reign. In the aftermath, Henry the Navigator, the last surviving member of the illustrious generation, went into near\\-hermitical seclusion in [Sagres](/wiki/Sagres%2C_Portugal \"Sagres, Portugal\"). Having allowed his household knights to join field with the king's army against Peter, Henry reputation as dynastic traitor was cemented in the popular mindset; he became thoroughly hated by Peter's partisans and the burghers. To the new order of Braganza and the high nobility, Henry was a useless relic, a quirky old man who liked to play with ships. Henry spent his last remaining years launching a new set of naval expeditions, stretching Portuguese discoveries as far as the [Gold Coast](/wiki/Gold_Coast_%28region%29 \"Gold Coast (region)\") of west Africa. Henry died in 1460, a bachelor without heirs, largely unlamented, save perhaps by the Order of Christ, whose fortunes he had so enlarged.",
""
] |
Bat echolocation calls
----------------------
Bats can either produce echolocation calls of a constant frequency or that are frequency modulated. DSC is a unique strategy employed by constant frequency (CF) bats, which exclusively produce CF calls. These bats have a narrowly defined range of frequencies over which they are maximally sensitive, which is termed the [acoustic fovea](/wiki/Acoustic_fovea "Acoustic fovea").
### Constant frequency vs. frequency modulated pulses
DSC is only found in CF bats. This is because they have a narrow range of frequencies to which they are optimally sensitive, and have a specialized cochlea that is adapted to responding to one frequency with high resolution. DSC however is not employed by frequency\-modulated, or FM, bats. These bats have a broad range of frequencies to which they are maximally sensitive, and thus do not need to tightly modulate the echo frequency. For FM bats, the frequency of the Doppler shifted echoes still falls within their range of auditory responsiveness. Hence, they do not need a DSC mechanism to optimize their echolocation behavior.
FM bats produce short pulses, often less than 5 ms in duration, that contain a broad range of frequencies covering up to 80–100 kHz.Neuweiler, G. 2003\. Evolutionary aspects of bat echolocation. Journal of Comparative Physiology A. 189(4\): 245–256\. Bats use FM pulses to determine target distance, by using the delay between multiple emitted pulses and their returning echoes to calculate range.Suga, N. 1990\. Biosonar and Neural Computation in Bats. Scientific American. 60–68\. In CF\-FM bats, a short, upward FM sweep precedes the long, CF component of the pulse. The pulse is then terminated with a short, downward FM sweep. Bats that produce these types of compound signals still use the DSC to modulate the frequency of the returning echoes, due to the CF component of the pulse. These pulses are best suited for the precise determination of target distance.
CF pulses are long pulses that are 10–100 ms in duration, which consist of a single component of a relatively constant frequency. These types of pulses are produced by CF bats, and are also incorporated into the calls of CF\-FM bats, which produce compound pulses that contain both CF and FM elements. The CF pulse is preceded by a short, upward FM sweep, and is terminated by a brief, downward FM sweep. The second harmonic of the CF\-FM pulse is typically the dominant (highest amplitude) sound, and is usually about 80 kHz. The fundamental frequency of the pulse is usually about 40 kHz, and is of a lower amplitude than the second harmonic. These types of echolocation pulses afford the bat the ability to classify, detect flutter (e.g. the fluttering wings of insects), and determine velocity information about the target. Both CF and CF\-FM bats use the Doppler shift compensation mechanism in order to maximize the efficiency of their echolocation behavior.
A bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its own echolocation pulses. The resting call pulses of CF and CF\-FM bats are largely characterized by notes of a single frequency, while the resting calls of FM bats span an extensive range of frequencies. Stated differently, CF bats produce narrow bandwidth sounds, or sounds over a restricted range of frequencies. Contrastingly, FM bats produce broad bandwidth pulses, which contain a wide range of frequencies. It follows that CF bats have auditory systems that are highly sensitive to a limited range of frequencies, while the auditory systems of FM bats are sensitive to a vast range of frequencies.
### The acoustic fovea
#### Illustration
The original figure found in Metzner, Zhang, and Smotherman (2002\)
This plot shows behavioral threshold, in decibels, vs. frequency, in kilohertz, obtained from the greater horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum). In other words, on the y\-axis is the threshold for which the bat will show a response, with a lower number indicating that the bat is more responsive (e.g. more sensitive) to a particular frequency.Metzner, W., Zhang, S., and Smotherman, M. 2002\. Doppler\-shift compensation behavior in horseshoe bats revisited: auditory feedback controls both a decrease and an increase in call frequency. Journal of Experimental Biology. 205(11\): 1607–1616 The very sharp tuning curve, which is shown by the short bar below the graph, shows that the bat is maximally responsive to an extremely narrow range of frequencies. This sharp tuning curve is referred to as the acoustic, or auditory, fovea, and is demarcated on the plot by the short bar beneath the graph.
#### Description
As described in the previous section, a bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its natural echolocation pulses. In the case of a CF bat (such as the greater horseshoe bat), the narrow bandwidth of the frequencies contained within the pulse is reflected within the narrow range of frequencies to which the bat is optimally sensitive (which is shown in the tuning curve above). CF bats’ auditory systems are finely tuned to the narrowband frequencies in the calls they produce. This results in a sharp acoustic fovea, as illustrated in the audiogram above.
The disproportionate number of receptors in the cochlea that respond to frequencies within a narrow range ultimately gives rise to the acoustic fovea. This cochlear morphology is the anatomical correlate of the acoustic fovea. As a result, bats are able to respond preferentially to sounds of these frequencies.
#### Function of acoustic fovea
The specificity of the auditory system is proportional to the range of frequencies found in the resting call frequency (RF) of the bat. Therefore, the narrow range of frequencies found within the RF of a CF bat is reflected in the sharp sensitivity of the auditory system (the auditory fovea).
FM bats do not possess an acoustic fovea, because the broad range of frequencies in the RF does not lend itself to the formation of a sharply tuned auditory system. Rather, the vast range of frequencies in the resting call is reflected in the extensive range of frequencies to which an FM bat is responsive. Conversely, the narrow, well\-defined span of frequencies within CF element of the CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).
Evolutionarily, this proportionality between the tuning of the auditory system and the natural frequencies within the resting bat's calls is logical. It is advantageous to be maximally responsive to the frequencies found within the calls of conspecifics, and it follows that the frequencies found within conspecific calls is mimicked by the frequencies in one's own call. Thus, the narrow, well\-defined span of frequencies within CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).
### Which species have DSC?
CF bats use the DSC, to maintain a constant echo frequency.Schnitzler, H.U. and Denzinger, A. 2011\. Auditory fovea and Doppler shift compensation: adaptations for flutter detection in echolocating bats using CF\-FM signals. Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 197(5\): 541–559 Bats of the families Rhinolophidae, Hipposideridae, and some species within Mormoopidae employ the DSC to modulate the echo frequency. The Doppler shift compensation mechanism appears to have evolved independently in these families. Species within these families include those of the genus *Rhinolophus*, such as *Rhinolophus ferrumequinum* (the greater horseshoe bat), in the family Rhinolophidae, and those of the genus *Pteronotus*, in the family Mormoopidae. Bats of the genus Pteronotus include *P. parnellii* (Parnell's mustached bat, discovered by Suga et al., 1975Suga, N., Simmons, J.A., Jen, P.S. (1975\). Peripheral specialization for fine analysis of Doppler\-shifted echoes in the auditory system of the CF\-FM bat Pteronotus parnellii. J Exp Biol. 63:161–192\.) and *P. personatus* (Wagner's mustached bat).Smotherman, M., and Guillén\-Servent, A. 2008\. Doppler\-shift compensation behavior by Wagner’s mustached bat, Pteronotus personatus. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 123(6\), 4331–4339
|
[
"Bat echolocation calls\n----------------------",
"Bats can either produce echolocation calls of a constant frequency or that are frequency modulated. DSC is a unique strategy employed by constant frequency (CF) bats, which exclusively produce CF calls. These bats have a narrowly defined range of frequencies over which they are maximally sensitive, which is termed the [acoustic fovea](/wiki/Acoustic_fovea \"Acoustic fovea\").",
"### Constant frequency vs. frequency modulated pulses",
"DSC is only found in CF bats. This is because they have a narrow range of frequencies to which they are optimally sensitive, and have a specialized cochlea that is adapted to responding to one frequency with high resolution. DSC however is not employed by frequency\\-modulated, or FM, bats. These bats have a broad range of frequencies to which they are maximally sensitive, and thus do not need to tightly modulate the echo frequency. For FM bats, the frequency of the Doppler shifted echoes still falls within their range of auditory responsiveness. Hence, they do not need a DSC mechanism to optimize their echolocation behavior.",
"FM bats produce short pulses, often less than 5 ms in duration, that contain a broad range of frequencies covering up to 80–100 kHz.Neuweiler, G. 2003\\. Evolutionary aspects of bat echolocation. Journal of Comparative Physiology A. 189(4\\): 245–256\\. Bats use FM pulses to determine target distance, by using the delay between multiple emitted pulses and their returning echoes to calculate range.Suga, N. 1990\\. Biosonar and Neural Computation in Bats. Scientific American. 60–68\\. In CF\\-FM bats, a short, upward FM sweep precedes the long, CF component of the pulse. The pulse is then terminated with a short, downward FM sweep. Bats that produce these types of compound signals still use the DSC to modulate the frequency of the returning echoes, due to the CF component of the pulse. These pulses are best suited for the precise determination of target distance.",
"CF pulses are long pulses that are 10–100 ms in duration, which consist of a single component of a relatively constant frequency. These types of pulses are produced by CF bats, and are also incorporated into the calls of CF\\-FM bats, which produce compound pulses that contain both CF and FM elements. The CF pulse is preceded by a short, upward FM sweep, and is terminated by a brief, downward FM sweep. The second harmonic of the CF\\-FM pulse is typically the dominant (highest amplitude) sound, and is usually about 80 kHz. The fundamental frequency of the pulse is usually about 40 kHz, and is of a lower amplitude than the second harmonic. These types of echolocation pulses afford the bat the ability to classify, detect flutter (e.g. the fluttering wings of insects), and determine velocity information about the target. Both CF and CF\\-FM bats use the Doppler shift compensation mechanism in order to maximize the efficiency of their echolocation behavior.",
"A bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its own echolocation pulses. The resting call pulses of CF and CF\\-FM bats are largely characterized by notes of a single frequency, while the resting calls of FM bats span an extensive range of frequencies. Stated differently, CF bats produce narrow bandwidth sounds, or sounds over a restricted range of frequencies. Contrastingly, FM bats produce broad bandwidth pulses, which contain a wide range of frequencies. It follows that CF bats have auditory systems that are highly sensitive to a limited range of frequencies, while the auditory systems of FM bats are sensitive to a vast range of frequencies.",
"### The acoustic fovea",
"#### Illustration",
"",
"",
"The original figure found in Metzner, Zhang, and Smotherman (2002\\)",
"This plot shows behavioral threshold, in decibels, vs. frequency, in kilohertz, obtained from the greater horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum). In other words, on the y\\-axis is the threshold for which the bat will show a response, with a lower number indicating that the bat is more responsive (e.g. more sensitive) to a particular frequency.Metzner, W., Zhang, S., and Smotherman, M. 2002\\. Doppler\\-shift compensation behavior in horseshoe bats revisited: auditory feedback controls both a decrease and an increase in call frequency. Journal of Experimental Biology. 205(11\\): 1607–1616 The very sharp tuning curve, which is shown by the short bar below the graph, shows that the bat is maximally responsive to an extremely narrow range of frequencies. This sharp tuning curve is referred to as the acoustic, or auditory, fovea, and is demarcated on the plot by the short bar beneath the graph.",
"#### Description",
"As described in the previous section, a bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its natural echolocation pulses. In the case of a CF bat (such as the greater horseshoe bat), the narrow bandwidth of the frequencies contained within the pulse is reflected within the narrow range of frequencies to which the bat is optimally sensitive (which is shown in the tuning curve above). CF bats’ auditory systems are finely tuned to the narrowband frequencies in the calls they produce. This results in a sharp acoustic fovea, as illustrated in the audiogram above.",
"The disproportionate number of receptors in the cochlea that respond to frequencies within a narrow range ultimately gives rise to the acoustic fovea. This cochlear morphology is the anatomical correlate of the acoustic fovea. As a result, bats are able to respond preferentially to sounds of these frequencies.",
"#### Function of acoustic fovea",
"The specificity of the auditory system is proportional to the range of frequencies found in the resting call frequency (RF) of the bat. Therefore, the narrow range of frequencies found within the RF of a CF bat is reflected in the sharp sensitivity of the auditory system (the auditory fovea).",
"FM bats do not possess an acoustic fovea, because the broad range of frequencies in the RF does not lend itself to the formation of a sharply tuned auditory system. Rather, the vast range of frequencies in the resting call is reflected in the extensive range of frequencies to which an FM bat is responsive. Conversely, the narrow, well\\-defined span of frequencies within CF element of the CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).",
"Evolutionarily, this proportionality between the tuning of the auditory system and the natural frequencies within the resting bat's calls is logical. It is advantageous to be maximally responsive to the frequencies found within the calls of conspecifics, and it follows that the frequencies found within conspecific calls is mimicked by the frequencies in one's own call. Thus, the narrow, well\\-defined span of frequencies within CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).",
"### Which species have DSC?",
"CF bats use the DSC, to maintain a constant echo frequency.Schnitzler, H.U. and Denzinger, A. 2011\\. Auditory fovea and Doppler shift compensation: adaptations for flutter detection in echolocating bats using CF\\-FM signals. Journal of Comparative Physiology A, 197(5\\): 541–559 Bats of the families Rhinolophidae, Hipposideridae, and some species within Mormoopidae employ the DSC to modulate the echo frequency. The Doppler shift compensation mechanism appears to have evolved independently in these families. Species within these families include those of the genus *Rhinolophus*, such as *Rhinolophus ferrumequinum* (the greater horseshoe bat), in the family Rhinolophidae, and those of the genus *Pteronotus*, in the family Mormoopidae. Bats of the genus Pteronotus include *P. parnellii* (Parnell's mustached bat, discovered by Suga et al., 1975Suga, N., Simmons, J.A., Jen, P.S. (1975\\). Peripheral specialization for fine analysis of Doppler\\-shifted echoes in the auditory system of the CF\\-FM bat Pteronotus parnellii. J Exp Biol. 63:161–192\\.) and *P. personatus* (Wagner's mustached bat).Smotherman, M., and Guillén\\-Servent, A. 2008\\. Doppler\\-shift compensation behavior by Wagner’s mustached bat, Pteronotus personatus. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 123(6\\), 4331–4339",
""
] |
### The acoustic fovea
#### Illustration
The original figure found in Metzner, Zhang, and Smotherman (2002\)
This plot shows behavioral threshold, in decibels, vs. frequency, in kilohertz, obtained from the greater horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum). In other words, on the y\-axis is the threshold for which the bat will show a response, with a lower number indicating that the bat is more responsive (e.g. more sensitive) to a particular frequency.Metzner, W., Zhang, S., and Smotherman, M. 2002\. Doppler\-shift compensation behavior in horseshoe bats revisited: auditory feedback controls both a decrease and an increase in call frequency. Journal of Experimental Biology. 205(11\): 1607–1616 The very sharp tuning curve, which is shown by the short bar below the graph, shows that the bat is maximally responsive to an extremely narrow range of frequencies. This sharp tuning curve is referred to as the acoustic, or auditory, fovea, and is demarcated on the plot by the short bar beneath the graph.
#### Description
As described in the previous section, a bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its natural echolocation pulses. In the case of a CF bat (such as the greater horseshoe bat), the narrow bandwidth of the frequencies contained within the pulse is reflected within the narrow range of frequencies to which the bat is optimally sensitive (which is shown in the tuning curve above). CF bats’ auditory systems are finely tuned to the narrowband frequencies in the calls they produce. This results in a sharp acoustic fovea, as illustrated in the audiogram above.
The disproportionate number of receptors in the cochlea that respond to frequencies within a narrow range ultimately gives rise to the acoustic fovea. This cochlear morphology is the anatomical correlate of the acoustic fovea. As a result, bats are able to respond preferentially to sounds of these frequencies.
#### Function of acoustic fovea
The specificity of the auditory system is proportional to the range of frequencies found in the resting call frequency (RF) of the bat. Therefore, the narrow range of frequencies found within the RF of a CF bat is reflected in the sharp sensitivity of the auditory system (the auditory fovea).
FM bats do not possess an acoustic fovea, because the broad range of frequencies in the RF does not lend itself to the formation of a sharply tuned auditory system. Rather, the vast range of frequencies in the resting call is reflected in the extensive range of frequencies to which an FM bat is responsive. Conversely, the narrow, well\-defined span of frequencies within CF element of the CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).
Evolutionarily, this proportionality between the tuning of the auditory system and the natural frequencies within the resting bat's calls is logical. It is advantageous to be maximally responsive to the frequencies found within the calls of conspecifics, and it follows that the frequencies found within conspecific calls is mimicked by the frequencies in one's own call. Thus, the narrow, well\-defined span of frequencies within CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).
|
[
"### The acoustic fovea",
"#### Illustration",
"",
"",
"The original figure found in Metzner, Zhang, and Smotherman (2002\\)",
"This plot shows behavioral threshold, in decibels, vs. frequency, in kilohertz, obtained from the greater horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum). In other words, on the y\\-axis is the threshold for which the bat will show a response, with a lower number indicating that the bat is more responsive (e.g. more sensitive) to a particular frequency.Metzner, W., Zhang, S., and Smotherman, M. 2002\\. Doppler\\-shift compensation behavior in horseshoe bats revisited: auditory feedback controls both a decrease and an increase in call frequency. Journal of Experimental Biology. 205(11\\): 1607–1616 The very sharp tuning curve, which is shown by the short bar below the graph, shows that the bat is maximally responsive to an extremely narrow range of frequencies. This sharp tuning curve is referred to as the acoustic, or auditory, fovea, and is demarcated on the plot by the short bar beneath the graph.",
"#### Description",
"As described in the previous section, a bat's hearing is especially sensitive to sounds that have similar frequencies to its natural echolocation pulses. In the case of a CF bat (such as the greater horseshoe bat), the narrow bandwidth of the frequencies contained within the pulse is reflected within the narrow range of frequencies to which the bat is optimally sensitive (which is shown in the tuning curve above). CF bats’ auditory systems are finely tuned to the narrowband frequencies in the calls they produce. This results in a sharp acoustic fovea, as illustrated in the audiogram above.",
"The disproportionate number of receptors in the cochlea that respond to frequencies within a narrow range ultimately gives rise to the acoustic fovea. This cochlear morphology is the anatomical correlate of the acoustic fovea. As a result, bats are able to respond preferentially to sounds of these frequencies.",
"#### Function of acoustic fovea",
"The specificity of the auditory system is proportional to the range of frequencies found in the resting call frequency (RF) of the bat. Therefore, the narrow range of frequencies found within the RF of a CF bat is reflected in the sharp sensitivity of the auditory system (the auditory fovea).",
"FM bats do not possess an acoustic fovea, because the broad range of frequencies in the RF does not lend itself to the formation of a sharply tuned auditory system. Rather, the vast range of frequencies in the resting call is reflected in the extensive range of frequencies to which an FM bat is responsive. Conversely, the narrow, well\\-defined span of frequencies within CF element of the CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).",
"Evolutionarily, this proportionality between the tuning of the auditory system and the natural frequencies within the resting bat's calls is logical. It is advantageous to be maximally responsive to the frequencies found within the calls of conspecifics, and it follows that the frequencies found within conspecific calls is mimicked by the frequencies in one's own call. Thus, the narrow, well\\-defined span of frequencies within CF pulses is reflected in the auditory system's sharp range of optimal sensitivity (e.g. a fovea).",
""
] |
Problems
--------
One of the biggest problems in a revenue center is that costs are mostly ignored. If costs are not monitored by another division of the business, profits can be hindered. Furthermore, the manager of a revenue center does not have the insight required for marketing decisions, consequently responsibility for a marketing decision cannot be given to a revenue center manager. Setting prices on products or services is an example of revenue center managers being unable to undertake marketing decisions.
It is easy to calculate the performance of a revenue center as revenue is the only variable being performed against. However, this means that performance evaluations are also limited to one variable, which is usually not enough to see the performance of a business division.{{cite book\|author1\=Michael Kinney\|author2\=Cecily Raiborn\|title\=Cost Accounting: Foundations and Evolutions\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=Nm3uBQP7cTIC\&pg\=PA509\|accessdate\=18 October 2014\|date\=31 May 2012\|publisher\=Cengage Learning\|isbn\=978\-1\-111\-97172\-4\|page\=509}}
Pure revenue centers hardly exist. This is due to the fact that costs cannot be completely ignored. Usually (as stated above) revenue center managers control expenses.
Revenue center managers should not be allowed to make marketing decisions. For example, if a revenue center manager is allowed to set the revenue target, he will maximise revenue. This will cause the marginal revenue to become zero.
In large companies with multiple products, revenue centers will be responsible for meeting revenue target for each product. The problem will arise if all revenues are added together into a total of all products. The revenue manager will then be able to make up any losses in revenue by taking the revenue from the ones that outperformed the targets to the ones that underperformed, thereby causing a loss in overall profits.
Businesses may decide to open revenue centers when entering new markets or industries. The initial cost of these centers is high, and it is highly likely that a lot of time is required in order for those centers to become profitable and cover the start\-up expenditures.
|
[
"Problems\n--------",
"One of the biggest problems in a revenue center is that costs are mostly ignored. If costs are not monitored by another division of the business, profits can be hindered. Furthermore, the manager of a revenue center does not have the insight required for marketing decisions, consequently responsibility for a marketing decision cannot be given to a revenue center manager. Setting prices on products or services is an example of revenue center managers being unable to undertake marketing decisions.",
"It is easy to calculate the performance of a revenue center as revenue is the only variable being performed against. However, this means that performance evaluations are also limited to one variable, which is usually not enough to see the performance of a business division.{{cite book\\|author1\\=Michael Kinney\\|author2\\=Cecily Raiborn\\|title\\=Cost Accounting: Foundations and Evolutions\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=Nm3uBQP7cTIC\\&pg\\=PA509\\|accessdate\\=18 October 2014\\|date\\=31 May 2012\\|publisher\\=Cengage Learning\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-111\\-97172\\-4\\|page\\=509}}",
"Pure revenue centers hardly exist. This is due to the fact that costs cannot be completely ignored. Usually (as stated above) revenue center managers control expenses.",
"Revenue center managers should not be allowed to make marketing decisions. For example, if a revenue center manager is allowed to set the revenue target, he will maximise revenue. This will cause the marginal revenue to become zero.",
"In large companies with multiple products, revenue centers will be responsible for meeting revenue target for each product. The problem will arise if all revenues are added together into a total of all products. The revenue manager will then be able to make up any losses in revenue by taking the revenue from the ones that outperformed the targets to the ones that underperformed, thereby causing a loss in overall profits.",
"Businesses may decide to open revenue centers when entering new markets or industries. The initial cost of these centers is high, and it is highly likely that a lot of time is required in order for those centers to become profitable and cover the start\\-up expenditures.",
""
] |
Archaeological basis
--------------------
### Architecture
The archaeological record is replete with excavations of built structures across time, but due to the natural decay of materials and the vagaries of preservation, the further backward in time, the less likely it is for artifacts to have survived. For example, [Paleolithic](/wiki/Paleolithic "Paleolithic") shelter constructions from the [Lower Paleolithic](/wiki/Lower_Paleolithic "Lower Paleolithic") (c. 2,600,000–300,000 BP) and Middle Paleolithic (c. 300,000–45,000 BP) are generally less complete and thus subject to interpretation, while those dating to the Upper Paleolithic (c. 45,000–10,000 BP) are both more numerous and better preserved. Paleolithic structures generally have no remaining superstructure, and must be inferred from a footprint of artifacts.For a good overview of Palaeolithic dwellings structures and strategies see Cattelain, P. and Hauzeur, A. (1998\). "Des premiers abris aux premières maisons." In Les grandes inventions de la Préhistoire (Bellier C. and Cattelain, P. eds.) (Guides archéologiques du Malgré\-Tout) Treignes: CEDARC. 37–46; and De Beaune, S. (2012\). "Aux origins de la construction." In Édifice et Artifice (R. Carvais, A. Guillerme, V. Nègre, J. Sakarovitch, eds.) Premier Congrès francophone d’histoire de la construction Paris, 2008 Paris: Piccard. 77–89\.
By contrast, some [Neolithic](/wiki/Neolithic "Neolithic") structures retain above ground elements. The Neolithic saw the rise of agriculture and the establishment of settlements, which produced a surplus of foodstuffs and an increase in population density. A large, coordinated labor force enabled the process of hauling enormous stones to build large, permanent structures. By about 5,000 BP, many groups of people over a widespread area were erecting large timbers and stones, or megaliths, to enclose communal spaces. Into historical times, the development of writing offered another layer of information, with descriptions of the physical appearance, materials, design, use, and events related to structures. This combination of remnants and records enhances the accuracy of archaeo\-optical analysis.
### Archaeological optics and archaeoastronomy
There is some evidence that prehistorical structures oriented upon the sun's position on the horizon also created camera obscura situations. Examples in Western Europe include midwinter sunrise at [Newgrange](/wiki/Newgrange "Newgrange"),O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson. 117, 123–5\. midwinter sunset at [Maeshowe](/wiki/Maeshowe "Maeshowe"),MacKie, E.W. (1997\). "Maeshowe and the Winter Solstice: ceremonial aspects of the Orkney Grooved Ware culture." Antiquity 71\. 338\-59\. and midsummer sunrise at [Bryn Celli Ddu](/wiki/Bryn_Celli_Ddu "Bryn Celli Ddu").Burrow, S. (2010\). "Bryn Celli Ddu Passage Tomb, Anglesey: Alignment, Construction, Date and Ritual." In Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 76\. 261\.
While archaeoastronomical studies have traditionally discussed these kinds of monument as observatories, fieldwork conducted in the 1990s at [Balnuaran](/wiki/Clava_cairn "Clava cairn") of Clava by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips suggests the midwinter sunset would have cast images inside two [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_Tombs "Passage Tombs"). By temporarily reconstructing the collapsed roofs of these monuments, they noted that the act of viewing the sun along their passageways was not only potentially blinding but could only be clearly viewed by one person at a time. In contrast, an audience of over twenty people could stand with their backs to the opening to observe the effects of sunlight falling upon deliberately patterned stonework built into walls of both chambers.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\). "Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel." Current Archaeology 165\. 332\-5\. These observations inspired Scott to speculate that these structures were camera obscuras, and that an optical projection of the sun's disc would reproduce the movements of the sun through the sky for many people to see at once.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1998\). "Archaeological experiment at Balnuaran of Clava North Eastern cairn on 20th and 22nd December 1997\." In Sites and Monuments Archive: \<[http://her.highland.gov.uk/hbsmrgatewayhighland/DataFiles/LibraryLinkFiles/37677\.pdf](http://her.highland.gov.uk/hbsmrgatewayhighland/DataFiles/LibraryLinkFiles/37677.pdf)\>
### Archaeological optics and the archaeology of the senses
Archaeological optics contributes to a wider discipline, the archaeology of the senses. Rather than just recording the remains of the past such as standing stones or built walls, this wider discipline emphasizes how the spaces in\-between these features could have been arenas for sensory experiences, even if parts of the original structures have disappeared. Among the senses, vision has been a major consideration, including studies of visibility between sites,Woodward, A.B. and Woodwood, P.J. (1996\). "The topography of some barrow cemeteries in Bronze Age Wessex." In Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 62\. 275\-91\. interactions with geology and topography,Bradley, R. (1998\). Ruined buildings, ruined stones: enclosures, tombs and natural places in the Neolithic of south\-west England. World Archaeology 30\. 13\-22\. archaeoastronomical alignment,Ruggles, C. (1999\). Astronomy in Prehistoric Britain and Ireland. London: Yale University Press. or color symbolism.Jones, A. and MacGregor, G., eds. (2002\). Colouring the past: the significance of colour in archaeological research. London: Berg. At the same time, anthropology has revealed societies that emphasize the other sensesHowes, D. and Classen, C., eds. (1991\). The varieties of sensory experience. London: Berg. including qualities such as scent and smell.Classen, C., Howes, D., and Synnott, A. (1994\). Aroma: the cultural history of smell. London: Routledge. The social significance of the sensory of food and drink,Hamilakis, Y. (1999\). "Food technologies/technologies of the body: the social context of wine and oil production and consumption in Bronze Age Crete." In World Archaeology 31(1\). 38\-54\. and touch and textureCummings, V. (2002\). "Experiencing texture and transformation in the British Neolithic."In Oxford Journal of Archaeology 21(3\). 249\-61\. can also be considered.
Other studies have examined archaeomusicology and archaeoacoustics.Scarre, C and Lawson, G., eds. (2006\). Archaeoacoustics. Cambridge: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research. Palaeolithic bone artifacts have been interpreted as musical instruments,Megaw, J.V.S. (1960\). "Penny whistles and prehistory." Antiquity 34, 6\-13\. or ‘sound producing devices’,Lund. C. (1981\). "The archaeomusicology of Scandinavia." In World Archaeology 12\. 246\-65\. while some natural features within caves have been found to emit unusual sounds.Dams, L. (1984\). "Preliminary findings at the ‘Organ’ Sanctuary in the cave of Nerja, Malaga, Spain." In Oxford Journal of Archaeology 3\. 1\-14\. There have also been suggestions that Paleolithic cave art clusters in locations where caverns have especially resonant properties.Reznikoff, I. and Dauvois, M. (1988\). "La dimension sonore des grottes ornées." In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française 85\. 238\-46\. In the 1990s the sonic properties of built architecture came under increasing scrutiny with investigations into vocally induced resonances inside chambered Neolithic sites,Devereux, P. and Jahn, R (1996\). "Preliminary investigations and cognitive considerations of the acoustical resonances of selected archaeological sites." In Antiquity 70\. 665\-6\. as well as the wider acoustic phenomenon within a variety of megalithic structures.Watson, A. and Keating. D. (1999\). "Architecture and sound: an acoustic analysis of megalithic monuments in prehistoric Britain." In Antiquity 73\. 325\-36\.
An archaeology of the senses, including archaeological optics, emphasizes that the past was inhabited by living people whose experiences were inherently partial and subjective. Indeed, this subjectivity might have lent both meaning and mystery to events occurring within ancient structures. This acknowledges that the senses were likely to have been used and understood in very different ways by people through time.
|
[
"Archaeological basis\n--------------------",
"### Architecture",
"The archaeological record is replete with excavations of built structures across time, but due to the natural decay of materials and the vagaries of preservation, the further backward in time, the less likely it is for artifacts to have survived. For example, [Paleolithic](/wiki/Paleolithic \"Paleolithic\") shelter constructions from the [Lower Paleolithic](/wiki/Lower_Paleolithic \"Lower Paleolithic\") (c. 2,600,000–300,000 BP) and Middle Paleolithic (c. 300,000–45,000 BP) are generally less complete and thus subject to interpretation, while those dating to the Upper Paleolithic (c. 45,000–10,000 BP) are both more numerous and better preserved. Paleolithic structures generally have no remaining superstructure, and must be inferred from a footprint of artifacts.For a good overview of Palaeolithic dwellings structures and strategies see Cattelain, P. and Hauzeur, A. (1998\\). \"Des premiers abris aux premières maisons.\" In Les grandes inventions de la Préhistoire (Bellier C. and Cattelain, P. eds.) (Guides archéologiques du Malgré\\-Tout) Treignes: CEDARC. 37–46; and De Beaune, S. (2012\\). \"Aux origins de la construction.\" In Édifice et Artifice (R. Carvais, A. Guillerme, V. Nègre, J. Sakarovitch, eds.) Premier Congrès francophone d’histoire de la construction Paris, 2008 Paris: Piccard. 77–89\\.",
"By contrast, some [Neolithic](/wiki/Neolithic \"Neolithic\") structures retain above ground elements. The Neolithic saw the rise of agriculture and the establishment of settlements, which produced a surplus of foodstuffs and an increase in population density. A large, coordinated labor force enabled the process of hauling enormous stones to build large, permanent structures. By about 5,000 BP, many groups of people over a widespread area were erecting large timbers and stones, or megaliths, to enclose communal spaces. Into historical times, the development of writing offered another layer of information, with descriptions of the physical appearance, materials, design, use, and events related to structures. This combination of remnants and records enhances the accuracy of archaeo\\-optical analysis.",
"### Archaeological optics and archaeoastronomy",
"There is some evidence that prehistorical structures oriented upon the sun's position on the horizon also created camera obscura situations. Examples in Western Europe include midwinter sunrise at [Newgrange](/wiki/Newgrange \"Newgrange\"),O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson. 117, 123–5\\. midwinter sunset at [Maeshowe](/wiki/Maeshowe \"Maeshowe\"),MacKie, E.W. (1997\\). \"Maeshowe and the Winter Solstice: ceremonial aspects of the Orkney Grooved Ware culture.\" Antiquity 71\\. 338\\-59\\. and midsummer sunrise at [Bryn Celli Ddu](/wiki/Bryn_Celli_Ddu \"Bryn Celli Ddu\").Burrow, S. (2010\\). \"Bryn Celli Ddu Passage Tomb, Anglesey: Alignment, Construction, Date and Ritual.\" In Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 76\\. 261\\.",
"While archaeoastronomical studies have traditionally discussed these kinds of monument as observatories, fieldwork conducted in the 1990s at [Balnuaran](/wiki/Clava_cairn \"Clava cairn\") of Clava by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips suggests the midwinter sunset would have cast images inside two [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_Tombs \"Passage Tombs\"). By temporarily reconstructing the collapsed roofs of these monuments, they noted that the act of viewing the sun along their passageways was not only potentially blinding but could only be clearly viewed by one person at a time. In contrast, an audience of over twenty people could stand with their backs to the opening to observe the effects of sunlight falling upon deliberately patterned stonework built into walls of both chambers.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\\). \"Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel.\" Current Archaeology 165\\. 332\\-5\\. These observations inspired Scott to speculate that these structures were camera obscuras, and that an optical projection of the sun's disc would reproduce the movements of the sun through the sky for many people to see at once.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1998\\). \"Archaeological experiment at Balnuaran of Clava North Eastern cairn on 20th and 22nd December 1997\\.\" In Sites and Monuments Archive: \\<[http://her.highland.gov.uk/hbsmrgatewayhighland/DataFiles/LibraryLinkFiles/37677\\.pdf](http://her.highland.gov.uk/hbsmrgatewayhighland/DataFiles/LibraryLinkFiles/37677.pdf)\\>",
"### Archaeological optics and the archaeology of the senses",
"Archaeological optics contributes to a wider discipline, the archaeology of the senses. Rather than just recording the remains of the past such as standing stones or built walls, this wider discipline emphasizes how the spaces in\\-between these features could have been arenas for sensory experiences, even if parts of the original structures have disappeared. Among the senses, vision has been a major consideration, including studies of visibility between sites,Woodward, A.B. and Woodwood, P.J. (1996\\). \"The topography of some barrow cemeteries in Bronze Age Wessex.\" In Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 62\\. 275\\-91\\. interactions with geology and topography,Bradley, R. (1998\\). Ruined buildings, ruined stones: enclosures, tombs and natural places in the Neolithic of south\\-west England. World Archaeology 30\\. 13\\-22\\. archaeoastronomical alignment,Ruggles, C. (1999\\). Astronomy in Prehistoric Britain and Ireland. London: Yale University Press. or color symbolism.Jones, A. and MacGregor, G., eds. (2002\\). Colouring the past: the significance of colour in archaeological research. London: Berg. At the same time, anthropology has revealed societies that emphasize the other sensesHowes, D. and Classen, C., eds. (1991\\). The varieties of sensory experience. London: Berg. including qualities such as scent and smell.Classen, C., Howes, D., and Synnott, A. (1994\\). Aroma: the cultural history of smell. London: Routledge. The social significance of the sensory of food and drink,Hamilakis, Y. (1999\\). \"Food technologies/technologies of the body: the social context of wine and oil production and consumption in Bronze Age Crete.\" In World Archaeology 31(1\\). 38\\-54\\. and touch and textureCummings, V. (2002\\). \"Experiencing texture and transformation in the British Neolithic.\"In Oxford Journal of Archaeology 21(3\\). 249\\-61\\. can also be considered.",
"Other studies have examined archaeomusicology and archaeoacoustics.Scarre, C and Lawson, G., eds. (2006\\). Archaeoacoustics. Cambridge: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research. Palaeolithic bone artifacts have been interpreted as musical instruments,Megaw, J.V.S. (1960\\). \"Penny whistles and prehistory.\" Antiquity 34, 6\\-13\\. or ‘sound producing devices’,Lund. C. (1981\\). \"The archaeomusicology of Scandinavia.\" In World Archaeology 12\\. 246\\-65\\. while some natural features within caves have been found to emit unusual sounds.Dams, L. (1984\\). \"Preliminary findings at the ‘Organ’ Sanctuary in the cave of Nerja, Malaga, Spain.\" In Oxford Journal of Archaeology 3\\. 1\\-14\\. There have also been suggestions that Paleolithic cave art clusters in locations where caverns have especially resonant properties.Reznikoff, I. and Dauvois, M. (1988\\). \"La dimension sonore des grottes ornées.\" In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française 85\\. 238\\-46\\. In the 1990s the sonic properties of built architecture came under increasing scrutiny with investigations into vocally induced resonances inside chambered Neolithic sites,Devereux, P. and Jahn, R (1996\\). \"Preliminary investigations and cognitive considerations of the acoustical resonances of selected archaeological sites.\" In Antiquity 70\\. 665\\-6\\. as well as the wider acoustic phenomenon within a variety of megalithic structures.Watson, A. and Keating. D. (1999\\). \"Architecture and sound: an acoustic analysis of megalithic monuments in prehistoric Britain.\" In Antiquity 73\\. 325\\-36\\.",
"An archaeology of the senses, including archaeological optics, emphasizes that the past was inhabited by living people whose experiences were inherently partial and subjective. Indeed, this subjectivity might have lent both meaning and mystery to events occurring within ancient structures. This acknowledges that the senses were likely to have been used and understood in very different ways by people through time.",
""
] |
Palaeolithic archaeological optics
----------------------------------
### Paleolithic structures
The Lower Paleolithic was a time of early humans such as [Homo habilis](/wiki/Homo_habilis "Homo habilis") and [Homo erectus](/wiki/Homo_erectus "Homo erectus"). Possible indications of the early development of shelter construction during the Lower Paleolithic come from excavations at [Olduvai Gorge](/wiki/Olduvai_Gorge "Olduvai Gorge"),Leakey, M.D. (1971\). Olduvai Gorge, Volume 3: Excavations in beds I \& II 1960–1963\. New York: Cambridge University Press. 24\. Melka Kunturé,Chavaillon, J. (2004\). "The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble." In Studies on the early Paleolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Pont\-de\-Lavaud,Chavaillon, J. (2004\). "The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble." In Studies on the early Palaeolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Isernia La Pineta,Giusberti, G., Guerreschi, A., and Peretto, C. (1983\). "Le strutture d’abitato dell’accampamento Paleolitico di Isernia La Pineta: Prime considerazioni." In Isernia La Pineta: Un accampamento più antico di 700\.000 anni. Calderini: Bologna. 100\. Maozhushan,Fang, Y., Huang, Y., and Shen, C. (2004\). "Pebble semicircle structure from a Lower Palaeolithic site in Southern China." In Eurasian Prehistory 2(2\). 3\-12\. Bilzingsleben,Mania D. and Mania U., (2005\). "The natural and socio\-cultural environment of Homo erectus at Bilzingsleben, Germany." In Gamble and Porr (eds.) The Hominid Individual in Context: Archaeological investigations of Lower and Middle Palaeolithic landscapes, locales, and artefacts. New York: Routledge. 98\-114\. and Terra Amata.de Lumley, H. (1966\). "Les fouilles de Terra Amata à Nice: Premier résultats." In Bulletin du Musée d’Anthropologie Préhistorique de Monaco 13\. 29\-51; de Lumley, H. (1969\). "A Palaeolithic camp at Nice." In Scientific American 22, No. 5\. 33\-41\.
The Middle Paleolithic saw Homo erectus decline as [Homo neanderthalensis](/wiki/Homo_neanderthalensis "Homo neanderthalensis") developed in Eurasia, and [Homo sapiens](/wiki/Homo_sapiens "Homo sapiens") developed in Africa. Possible evidence of shelter construction in the Middle Paleolithic can be found at sites such as Port\-Pignot,Michel, D. (1982\). "Le gisement préhistorique de Port Pignot à Fermanville (Manche)." In Gallia Préhistoire, Vol. 25, Issue 1\. 1\-68; Michel, D. (1983\). "Structures d’habitat du paléolithique inférieur du Nord Cotentin." In Bulletin de la Société Normande d’Etudes Préhistoriques et Historiques, XLVIII. 11\-13\. Saint\-Vaast\-la\-Hougue,Fosse, G. (1981\). "Le site moustérien de Saint\-Vaast\-la\-Hougue (Manche): Premiers résultats at problématiques generals." In Gallia Préhistoire 24, 2\. 383\-386\. Le Lazaret,de Lumley, H. (1969\). "Une Cabane Acheuléenne dans la Grotte du Lazaret (Nice)." In Mémoires de la Société Préhistorique Française, vol. 7 Paris. La Baume des Peyrards,de Lumley, H. (1957\). "Le Moustérien de la Baume des Peyrards (Vaucluse): Note Préliminaire." In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 1\-23\.
de Lumley, H. (1962\). "Paléolithique ancien et moyen en Vaucluse: notes préliminaires (1957\-1962\)." In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 29\-79\. Combe Grenal,Mellars, P. (1995\). The Neanderthal legacy: An archaeological perspective from Western Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 292\-308\. La Butte d’Arvigny,Gouédo, J\-M., Bats, J\-C., Krier, V., Pernot, P., and Ricard, J\-L. (1994\). "Le Gisement Moustérien de la ‘Butte d’Arvigny’ Commune de Moissy\-Cramayel (Seine\-et\-Marne): Premiers Résultats." In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française, Vol. 91, Issue 6\. 369\-377\. La Folie,Bourguignon, L., Sellami, F., Deloze, V., Sellier\-Segard, N., Beyries, S., and Emery\-Barbier, A. (2012\). "L’habitat moustérien de « La Folie » (Poitiers, Vienne): synthèse des premiers résultats." In Paleo: Revue d’archéologie Préhistorique vol 14\. 29\-48\. La Ferrassie,Peyrony, D. (1934\) "La Ferrassie" in Préhistoire III. Paris. 1\-92\. Biśnek,Cyrek, K. (2003\). "Biśnik Cave: A reconstruction of the site’s occupation in the context of environmental changes." In Eurasian Prehistory 1(1\). 5\-29\. Vilas Ruivas,Zilhão, J. (2001\). "Middle Palaeolithic Settlement Patterns in Portugal." In Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age (Nicholas Conard, ed.) Tübingen: Kerns Verlag. 597\-608\. Ripiceni\-Izvor,Păunescu, A. (1965\). "Sur la succession des habitats paléolithiques et post\-paléolithiques de Ripiceni Izvor." In Dacia N.S. 9\. 5–31\. and Molodava I.Demay, L., Péan, S., and [Patou\-Mathis](/wiki/Maryl%C3%A8ne_Patou-Mathis "Marylène Patou-Mathis"), M. (2012\). "Mammoths used as food and building resources by Neanderthals: Zooarchaeological study applied to layer 4, Molodova I (Ukraine)." In Quaternary International vol. 276\-277\. 212\-226\.
The Upper Paleolithic saw the expansion of Homo sapiens and the dwindling and ultimate extinction of Homo neanderthalensis. The best examples of Upper Paleolithic shelter practices come from excavations at such places as Kostienki,Sinitsyn, A. (2007\). "Variabilité du Gravettien de Kostienki (Bassin moyen du Don) et des territoires associés." In Paléo, 19\. 181\-201; Hoffecker, J., Holliday, V., Anikovich, M.V., Sinitsyn, A.A. and Popov, V.V. (2009\). Early Palaeolithic Settlement at Kostenki, Russia. A Research Report to the National Geographic Society: Grant 8528\-08\. Cueva Morín,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\). "Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain)." In Nature, 226\. 722\-726\. Grotte du Renne,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\). "Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain)." In Nature, 226\. 722\-726\. Vigne\-Brune,Combier, J. (1988\). "L’Organisation de l’espace habité des hommes du Paléolithique Supérieur en France." In Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, Serie I, Number I, Prehistoria y Arqueología. 111\-124\.; Digan, M. (2008\). "New technological and economic data from La Vigne\-Brun (unit KL19\), Loire: a contribution to the identification of early Gravettian lithic technological expertise." In Quartär 55\. 115\-125\. Dolní Věstonice,Martin Oliva, M. (2014\). "Dolní Věstonice (1922\-1942\): Karel Absolon, Hans Freising, and Assien Bohmers." In Anthropos\-Studies, Vol. 37 N.S. 29 (2014\). Les Peyrugues,Allard, M. (2006\). "25\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues" (C67\-16\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\); Allard, M. (1993\). "Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot)." In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\. 179\-191\. Mezin,Allard, M. (2006\). "25\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues" (C67\-16\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\).
Allard, M. (1993\). "Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot)." In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\. 179\-191\. Ohalo II,Nadel, D., Weiss, E., Simchoni, O., Tsatskin, A., Danin, A., and Kislev, M. (2004\). "Stone age hut in Israel yields world’s oldest evidence of bedding." In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) vol. 101 no. 17\. 6821\- 6826 Mal'ta,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\). "Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta." in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Le Cerisier,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\). "Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta." in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Plateau Perrain,Gaussen, J. (1994\). "Le Plateau Parrain: l’orginisation." In L’Anthropologie 98 (2\-3\). 418\-426\. Gontsy,Iakovleva, L., Djindjian, F., Maschenko, E.N., Konik, S., Moigne, A.\-M. (2012\). "The late Upper Palaeolithic site of Gontsy (Ukraine): A reference for the reconstruction of the hunter\-gatherer system based on a mammoth economy." In Quaternary International 255\. 86\-93\. Mezhirich,Soffer, O., Adovasio, J., Kornietz, N., Velichko, A., Gribchenko, Y., Lenz, B., and Suntsov, V. (1997\). "Cultural Stratigraphy at Mezhirich, an Upper Palaeolithic Site in Ukraine with Multiple Occupations" in Antiquity 71\. 48\-62\.
Svoboda, J., Péan, S., and Wojtal, P. (2005\). "Mammoth Bone Deposits and Subsistence Practices during Mid\-Upper Palaeolithic in Central Europe: Three cases from Moravia and Poland." In Quaternary International 126–128\. 209\-221\.
Gladkikh, M.I., Kornietz, N.L., and Soffer, O. (1984\). "Mammoth Bone Dwellings on the Russian Plain." In Scientific American (November, 1984\). 164\-75\. Gönnersdorf,Bosinski, G. (2008\). Tierdarstellungen von Gönnersdorf: Nachträge zu Mammut und Pferd sowie die übrigen Tierdarstellungen, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 9\. Mainz: RGZM.
Bosinski, G., d'Errico, F., and Schiller, P. (2001\). Die gravierten Frauendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 8\. Stuttgart: Steiner.
Franken, E. and Veil, S. (1983\). Die Steinartefakte von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 7\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Terberger, T. (1997\). Die Siedlungsbefunde von Gönnersdorf: Konzentrationen III und IV, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 6\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1980\). Mammut\- und Pferdedarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 5\. Weisbaden: Steiner, 1980\.
Brunnacker, K. (1978\). Geowissenschaftliche Untersuchungen in Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 4\. Weisbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. (1978\) Die Ausgrabungen in Gönnersdorf 1968\-1976 und die Siedlungsbefunde der Grabung 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 3\. Weisbaden: Steiner.
F. Poplin, F. (1976\). Les grands vertébrés de Gönnersdorf, Fouilles 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 2\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1974\). Die Menschendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf der Ausgrabung von 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 1\. Wiesbaden: Steiner. Pincevent,Leroi\-Gourhan, A. (1984\). Pincevent: Campement magdalénien de chasseurs de rennes. Guides Archeologiques de la France: L'Imprimerie Nationale.
Leroi\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1972\). "Fouilles de Pincevent: Essai d’analyse ethnographique d’un habitat magdalénien (la section 36\)." In Gallia Préhistoire, supplement VIIè.
Leroi\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1966\). "L'habitation magdalénienne n° 1 de Pincevent près Monterau (Seine\-et\-Marne)." In Gallia Préhistoire Vol. 9, Issue 9\-2\. 263\-385\.
To learn more about the distribution of materials see Enloe, J.G., David, F. and Hare, T. (1994\). "Patterns of Faunal Processing at Section 27 of Pincevent: The use of spatial analysis and ethnoarchaeological data in the interpretation of archaeological site structure." In the Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 13\. 105\-124\. and Borneck.Rust, A. (1962\). Vor 20 000 Jahren: Rentierjäger der Eiszeit. Neumünster: Karl Wachholtz Verlag. Fischer, A. and Tauber, H. (1986\). "New C\-14 Datings of Late Palaeolithic Cultures from Northwestern Europe" in Journal of Danish Archaeology, Vol. 5\. 7\-13\.
#### Taphonomy
The actual physical evidence of Paleolithic shelters is limited to permanent materials like stone and bone. No wooden post or animal hide has been found, because these materials disintegrate over the course of time. But the existence of the perishable elements can be established. Postholes prove the existence of the wooden supports. The alignment of the holes or a circle of support stones describes a footprint of a framework. The area covered by flint scattered from blade work, and other household activities, further demarcates the interior shape of the structure.
The types of stones, bones, and minerals found at the campsites further describe the use of animal hides as tent covering. Butchered and burned animal bones found around the fire pit show which types of animals were hunted and eaten. Stone tools such as hide scrapers and deposits of minerals employed in preparing skins show the routine use of animal hides. In addition, there are a host of ethnographic parallels, as indigenous cultures throughout the world relied on animal hides as a shelter covering material until the onset of the modern era.
#### Lifeways
The people of the Paleolithic existed prior to agriculture and the domestication of animals, and they would have lived as small bands of [hunter\-gatherers](/wiki/Hunter-gatherers "Hunter-gatherers"), moving from place to place, exploiting plant, animal, and mineral resources. Two of the factors that influenced choice of location were proximity to fresh water and animal migration routes.Bahn, P.G. (1985\). Pyrenean Prehistory: A Palaeoeconomic Survey of the French Sites. Warminster: Aris \& Phillips. 336\. Paleolithic foragers would also set up camp overlooking fields inhabited by herds of hoofed herbivores.Lambert, D. (1987\). The Field Guide to Early Man. New York: Diagram Group. 164\.
Paleolithic campsites were characterized by repeated, seasonal, short\-term occupation. While the inhabitants were quite mobile, without beasts of burden, shelters were not transported. A tent might stand at its location for a few years before it deteriorated and had to be rebuilt. The archaeological record describes shelters rebuilt over\-and\-over on roughly the same spot. Bands of Paleolithic hunter\-gatherers followed an annual circuit with shelters built at strategic points along the way.
#### Hearths
Paleolithic campsites were dotted with external fire pits and internal hearths. The internal hearths were not open\-burning fires, but were hollow areas that held heated stones and charcoal.Leesch, D. and Bullinger, J. (2012\). "Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest." In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 167\-168\.
Leesch and Bullinger also cite Coudret, P., Larrière, M., and Valentine, B. (1989\) "Comparer des Foyers: Une entreprise difficile." In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.). Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du [Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\-de\-France](/wiki/Mus%C3%A9e_de_Pr%C3%A9histoire_d%27%C3%8Ele-de-France "Musée de Préhistoire d'Île-de-France") 2\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\-de\-France, Nemours, 37\-45\.
Valentin, B. (1989\). "Nature et Fonction des Foyers de l’habitation n°1 à Pincevent." In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.) Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\-de\-France 2\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\-de\-France, Nemours, 209\-219\.
Valentin, B. and Bodu, P. (1991\). "Perspectives de l’expérimentation appliquée à l’étude des foyers paléolithiques: Le cas des foyers del’habitation n°1 à Pincevent (Seine\-et\-Marne)." In Archéologie Experimentale\-2, l’os et la pierre, la Maison et les champs. Colloque International ‘Expérimentation en Archéologie: bilan et perspectives’, Archéodrome de Beaune, 6–9 April 1988\. Editions Errance: Paris. 138\-145\.
Leesch, D. (1997\). "Hauterive\-Champréveyres, 10\. Un campement magdalénien au bord du lac de Neuchâtel: cadre chronologique et culturel, mobilier et structures (secteur 1\)." In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 19 (Musée Cantonal d’archéologie, Neuchâtel, 1997\) 170\-172\.
Plumettaz, N. (2007\). "Le site magdalénien de Monruz, 2\. Étude des foyers à partir de l’analyse des pierres de leurs remontages." In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 38\. Office et Musée Cantonal d’Archéologie Neuchâtel. The hearths acted as heat sinks, or heat traps, where thermal energy was stored and released slowly over time, to keep the dwelling warm. Hot stones and charcoals would be rolled, with sticks or bones, onto a thick animal hide and conveyed a couple of meters from the fire pit to the hearth. The next day the task would be repeated: hearths were taken apart and reassembled routinely. Frequent heating caused the rocks to discolor and crumble. Once a rock was no longer effective at holding heat, it was thrown in a nearby refuse pit along with animal bones and other household waste. An internal stone hearth is an effective strategy for staying warm, but it did not provide any light.Leesch, D., and Bullinger, J. (2012\). "Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest." In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 168\. The interiors of the tents were then dim places, where ancient people would have witnessed the camera obscura effect.
### Paleolithic archaeological optics
Paleolithic archaeological optics involves investigations into the image projection capacities of Paleolithic tent reconstructions.
#### Reconstructions
The suitability of Paleolithic tents/shelters for coincidental camera obscura formation was explored during a set of experiments under the direction of Matt Gatton in 2005 and 2006\.Gatton, M. (2005\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 6 October 2005\. The first set of experiments took place on a bison ranch in Oldham County, Kentucky, where a small, rudimentary bison hide [teepee](/wiki/Teepee "Teepee") was erected next to a pasture, and images of the bison were cast through a hole in the hides and projected into the tent. The second set of experiments occurred at a rock shelter outside of Irvine, Estill County, Kentucky, where the investigators leaned a framework of tree branches against a rock wall and covered it with bison hides. The image of a horse outside was projected through a rough hole in the hides and into the interior space. The third set of experiments took place at the Musée du Malgré\-Tout in Belgium, where archaeologists Pierre Cattelain and Claire Bellier reconstructed a variety of Paleolithic structures in several places in France, Germany and Ukraine. A smattering of holes was present in the hide coverings of each tent. At the German site, images were projected inside the reconstruction onto a rabbit hide.
#### Statistical analysis
The tent reconstructions established some plausibility of accidental camera obscura formation during the Paleolithic, but plausibility is not probability, so the question of the probable frequency of projected images was explored by [Bayesian](/wiki/Bayesian_probability "Bayesian probability") statistical modeling.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\). "Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\-camera Theory." In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\. 181\-190 Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2012\). "Projecting Projection: A statistical analysis of cast\-light images." In Pleistocene Coalition Newsletter \#18\.
To evaluate the probability of an unknown event a series of conditional probabilities were used to create a chance tree using [TreeAge Pro 2011](https://www.treeage.com/products/) (Williamstown, MA). The conditions affecting the appearance of projected images are the general context of the shelter, aperture existence, aperture size, sunlight exposure, weather, occupancy, and the specific context of the dwelling. Given the different situations regarding variables; the probability of a person observing a projected image inside a Palaeolithic dwelling ranged from 1% to 8% per day, or 4 to 29 times per year.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\). "Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\-camera Theory." In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\. 185\. Multiplying the yearly occurrences by the range of years and the estimated human population; camera obscura images could have been observed anywhere from 54\.8 billion to 4\.38 trillion times (5\.48x1010 to 4\.38x1012) over the course of prehistory.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\). "Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\-camera Theory." In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\. 185\.
### Implications
The likely prevalence of prehistoric camera obscuras throughout the human experience suggests several important implications for the development of art, religious beliefs, philosophy and existing cave art.
#### Art
The origins of art have been a significant mystery, because art, as a form of communication, is largely a [social construct](/wiki/Social_constructionism "Social constructionism"). The core issue is that there can be no intention to represent an object or scene without first knowing that such a depiction is possible.Davidson, I. and Noble, W. (1989\). "The Archaeology of Perception: Traces of Depiction and Language." In Current Anthropology 30\. 129\. Researchers have encountered great difficulty coming up with explanations of how prehistoric people first stumbled upon the idea of the possibility of representation.Lewis\-Williams, D. (2002\). Mind in the Cave. London: Thames \& Hudson, 2002\. 184\. The archaeo\-optical explanation is that images projected inside a dwelling space provided, according to Cambridge professor Nigel Spivey, "… a prototypical visual experience that triggers the concept of representation…"Personal correspondence, E\-mail from Nigel Spivey to Matt Gatton sent on Monday, 6 March 2006\. In addition, the images would be shared experiences, visible by everyone in the tent or structure at the same time.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W., and Scott, V. (2010\). "The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic." In the Official Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Lisbon 2006, Global State of the Art\-\-SO7 (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) Oxford: Archaeopress. 138\. The group could thus collectively experience, discuss, verify, confirm, investigate, and interpret the images projected on the surfaces before them. It is the communal aspect of the images that makes the development of visual art socially feasible.
"A randomly projected image stands for a real object; it says bison without being a flesh and blood bison, planting the idea of a referent, the conceptual beginning of art." \-Matt GattonGatton, M. "First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura" in Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\.
#### Faith
It is also possible that camera obscura images could have fostered religious belief. A broad definition of religion is a belief in an alternative realm that influences physical reality. Theologian Rudolf Otto held that the origins of religion are to be found in the concept of the sacred, the divine presenting itself as something "wholly other" (ganz andere).Otto, R. (1950 ed.). [The Idea of the Holy](/wiki/The_Idea_of_the_Holy "The Idea of the Holy"); an inquiry into the non\-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational \[Harvey, J.W., trans.]. New York: Oxford University Press, 1950 ed. Originally published in German as Das Heilige (1917\). The images projected in Paleolithic tents would have offered an early gateway to the concept of an alternative realm, a glimpse of an "other", that initiated a belief in something that was not seen moment to moment. The images, once seen, lingered in the mind, and took root in the culture.
> “The camera’s image instantly splits a quasi\-reality away from reality, peeling off an ‘other’ from the ‘is’; instilling the very idea that animals, plants, and humans have existences in other forms, spirits, on other planes.” \- Matt GattonGatton, M. (2010\). “Paleo\-camera and the Concept of Representation." In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\.
Once the concept of an alternative realm had taken root, it would have provided a domain for agents of an "other" world to intervene in human affairs. The notion of spirit forms is the very root of animism, the oldest known, and perhaps first, form of religion. The incidental image is possibly the first glimpse of the "divine".Gatton, M. (2010\). "Paleo\-camera and the Concept of Representation." In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\.
#### Philosophy
The core issue of metaphysics is the investigation of the nature of reality. The images in a Paleolithic tent would trigger a cascade of thoughts about the essence of reality: What is *that* plane of existence? And reflexively, what is *this* plane?Gatton, M. (2009\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\. Only by glimpsing an alternative reality does this reality become open to question — the very start of abstract examination.
#### Schematicized distortions
The projections by camera obscura can also explain some common features among cave paintings of animals and people. Paleolithic [cave art](/wiki/Cave_painting "Cave painting") is well known for iconic, schematicized figures, usually with extremely small heads and enormous, often bowed, bodies. Examples of the core elements of some Paleolithic cultures’ visual lexicon — repetition, disconnection, movement, superimposition, and distortion — are expressed in engravings on flat stones and bones within the habitation sites and also on the walls of deep caves.Gatton, M. (2010\). “The Camera and the Cave: Understanding the style of Palaeolithic art.” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 5 (Feliks, J., ed.) September–October.
Gatton, M. (2010\). “Paleo\-camera, Phase II: Projected images in art and ritual (or why European Upper Palaeolithic art looks the way it does).” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 4 (Feliks, J., ed.) July–August.
In May 2005, Matt Gatton, Walter Brock, and Dylan Brock set up a room\-sized camera obscura on a farm in Harrodsburg, Kentucky. The image of a horse was projected on to a small flat stone. It was natural for the artist to catch the image with his torso, the engraving stone secured against the body, and the eyes looking down on the inverted image. In this scenario it was advantageous to tilt the stone slightly. The more the stone was tilted the more the image of the animal distorted, the animal's head reducing in size and the stomach bowing downward, quite like the distortions seen in some deep cave art.Gatton, M. (2009\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 151\. This distortion is known as the [keystone effect](/wiki/Keystone_effect "Keystone effect"). Gatton proposed that the deep cave distortions may have resulted from the camera obscura effects within the tents.Gatton, M. (2005\). “Drawing experiments” in “Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville.” In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> May 2005\.
### Paleolithic archaeo\-optic concepts in wider culture
{{in popular culture\|date\=April 2020}}
The hypothesis that paleolithic people would have seen camera obscura effects within their shelters—Gatton's Paleolithic Camera Obscura Theory—has gained wider exposure in the last several years, including specific references in the following venues.
* Dr. Nigel Spivey in How Art Made the World: Cambridge Interviews: Episode 2, “The Day Pictures Were Born” KCET/BBC, June 22, 2006\. Series produced by Mark Hedgecoe and directed by Robin Dashwood{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.pbs.org/howartmadetheworld/interviews/\|title \= How Art Made the World . Cambridge Interviews \| PBS\| website\=\[\[PBS]] }}
* The exposition “Le cinéma/Pré\-cinéma” at the Malle Pédagogique, Collège of Cinéma at Calvados in Caen, France (2009\-2010\).
* The 2014 Artefact Festival in Leuven, Belgium was themed on Gatton's Palaeolithic Camera Obscura Theory, “De Prehistorie van het Beeld” (The Prehistory of the Image). Pierre Cattelain and Claire Bellier and their team from the Musée du Malgré\-Tout built a replica of the Paleolithic Le Ceriser tent (c. 18,000 BP) in the atrium in the Tweebronnen public library. Gatton was on hand to show visitors how images were projected inside the tent.Television coverage: De Prehistorie van Het Beeld, Vlaamse Radio\- en Televisieomroeporganisatie (VRT). (Feb. 13, 2014\).
\<[http://cobra.canvas.be/cm/cobra/videozone/rubriek/kunst\-videozone/1\.1874453](http://cobra.canvas.be/cm/cobra/videozone/rubriek/kunst-videozone/1.1874453)\>
```
Radio coverage: Radio 1, Helena De Groot and Marc de Bie
```
\<[http://www.radio1\.be/programmas/bar\-du\-matin/artefact\-de\-prehistorie\-van\-het\-beeld{{dead link\|date\=October 2016 \|bot\=InternetArchiveBot \|fix\-attempted\=yes }}](http://www.radio1.be/programmas/bar-du-matin/artefact-de-prehistorie-van-het-beeld{{dead link|date=October 2016 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }})\> After the festival the tent was disassembled, and transported to the Musée du Malgré\-Tout for permanent installation.
* The introduction of Season 1, Episode 5 "Hiding in the Light" of Cosmos: A Space Time Odyssey, which first aired in the USA on 6 April 2014\. The series was produced by a partnership of the National Geographic Channel and FOX, and was written by Ann Druyan and Steven Soter, and narrated by Neil deGrasse Tyson.
* Picture THIS, Podcast \#1: The Ancient Camera (Camera Obscura). Hosted by Chelsea and Tony Northrup, The Art and Science of Photography, 25 January 2016
|
[
"Palaeolithic archaeological optics\n----------------------------------",
"### Paleolithic structures",
"The Lower Paleolithic was a time of early humans such as [Homo habilis](/wiki/Homo_habilis \"Homo habilis\") and [Homo erectus](/wiki/Homo_erectus \"Homo erectus\"). Possible indications of the early development of shelter construction during the Lower Paleolithic come from excavations at [Olduvai Gorge](/wiki/Olduvai_Gorge \"Olduvai Gorge\"),Leakey, M.D. (1971\\). Olduvai Gorge, Volume 3: Excavations in beds I \\& II 1960–1963\\. New York: Cambridge University Press. 24\\. Melka Kunturé,Chavaillon, J. (2004\\). \"The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble.\" In Studies on the early Paleolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Pont\\-de\\-Lavaud,Chavaillon, J. (2004\\). \"The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble.\" In Studies on the early Palaeolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Isernia La Pineta,Giusberti, G., Guerreschi, A., and Peretto, C. (1983\\). \"Le strutture d’abitato dell’accampamento Paleolitico di Isernia La Pineta: Prime considerazioni.\" In Isernia La Pineta: Un accampamento più antico di 700\\.000 anni. Calderini: Bologna. 100\\. Maozhushan,Fang, Y., Huang, Y., and Shen, C. (2004\\). \"Pebble semicircle structure from a Lower Palaeolithic site in Southern China.\" In Eurasian Prehistory 2(2\\). 3\\-12\\. Bilzingsleben,Mania D. and Mania U., (2005\\). \"The natural and socio\\-cultural environment of Homo erectus at Bilzingsleben, Germany.\" In Gamble and Porr (eds.) The Hominid Individual in Context: Archaeological investigations of Lower and Middle Palaeolithic landscapes, locales, and artefacts. New York: Routledge. 98\\-114\\. and Terra Amata.de Lumley, H. (1966\\). \"Les fouilles de Terra Amata à Nice: Premier résultats.\" In Bulletin du Musée d’Anthropologie Préhistorique de Monaco 13\\. 29\\-51; de Lumley, H. (1969\\). \"A Palaeolithic camp at Nice.\" In Scientific American 22, No. 5\\. 33\\-41\\.",
"The Middle Paleolithic saw Homo erectus decline as [Homo neanderthalensis](/wiki/Homo_neanderthalensis \"Homo neanderthalensis\") developed in Eurasia, and [Homo sapiens](/wiki/Homo_sapiens \"Homo sapiens\") developed in Africa. Possible evidence of shelter construction in the Middle Paleolithic can be found at sites such as Port\\-Pignot,Michel, D. (1982\\). \"Le gisement préhistorique de Port Pignot à Fermanville (Manche).\" In Gallia Préhistoire, Vol. 25, Issue 1\\. 1\\-68; Michel, D. (1983\\). \"Structures d’habitat du paléolithique inférieur du Nord Cotentin.\" In Bulletin de la Société Normande d’Etudes Préhistoriques et Historiques, XLVIII. 11\\-13\\. Saint\\-Vaast\\-la\\-Hougue,Fosse, G. (1981\\). \"Le site moustérien de Saint\\-Vaast\\-la\\-Hougue (Manche): Premiers résultats at problématiques generals.\" In Gallia Préhistoire 24, 2\\. 383\\-386\\. Le Lazaret,de Lumley, H. (1969\\). \"Une Cabane Acheuléenne dans la Grotte du Lazaret (Nice).\" In Mémoires de la Société Préhistorique Française, vol. 7 Paris. La Baume des Peyrards,de Lumley, H. (1957\\). \"Le Moustérien de la Baume des Peyrards (Vaucluse): Note Préliminaire.\" In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 1\\-23\\.\nde Lumley, H. (1962\\). \"Paléolithique ancien et moyen en Vaucluse: notes préliminaires (1957\\-1962\\).\" In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 29\\-79\\. Combe Grenal,Mellars, P. (1995\\). The Neanderthal legacy: An archaeological perspective from Western Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 292\\-308\\. La Butte d’Arvigny,Gouédo, J\\-M., Bats, J\\-C., Krier, V., Pernot, P., and Ricard, J\\-L. (1994\\). \"Le Gisement Moustérien de la ‘Butte d’Arvigny’ Commune de Moissy\\-Cramayel (Seine\\-et\\-Marne): Premiers Résultats.\" In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française, Vol. 91, Issue 6\\. 369\\-377\\. La Folie,Bourguignon, L., Sellami, F., Deloze, V., Sellier\\-Segard, N., Beyries, S., and Emery\\-Barbier, A. (2012\\). \"L’habitat moustérien de « La Folie » (Poitiers, Vienne): synthèse des premiers résultats.\" In Paleo: Revue d’archéologie Préhistorique vol 14\\. 29\\-48\\. La Ferrassie,Peyrony, D. (1934\\) \"La Ferrassie\" in Préhistoire III. Paris. 1\\-92\\. Biśnek,Cyrek, K. (2003\\). \"Biśnik Cave: A reconstruction of the site’s occupation in the context of environmental changes.\" In Eurasian Prehistory 1(1\\). 5\\-29\\. Vilas Ruivas,Zilhão, J. (2001\\). \"Middle Palaeolithic Settlement Patterns in Portugal.\" In Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age (Nicholas Conard, ed.) Tübingen: Kerns Verlag. 597\\-608\\. Ripiceni\\-Izvor,Păunescu, A. (1965\\). \"Sur la succession des habitats paléolithiques et post\\-paléolithiques de Ripiceni Izvor.\" In Dacia N.S. 9\\. 5–31\\. and Molodava I.Demay, L., Péan, S., and [Patou\\-Mathis](/wiki/Maryl%C3%A8ne_Patou-Mathis \"Marylène Patou-Mathis\"), M. (2012\\). \"Mammoths used as food and building resources by Neanderthals: Zooarchaeological study applied to layer 4, Molodova I (Ukraine).\" In Quaternary International vol. 276\\-277\\. 212\\-226\\.",
"The Upper Paleolithic saw the expansion of Homo sapiens and the dwindling and ultimate extinction of Homo neanderthalensis. The best examples of Upper Paleolithic shelter practices come from excavations at such places as Kostienki,Sinitsyn, A. (2007\\). \"Variabilité du Gravettien de Kostienki (Bassin moyen du Don) et des territoires associés.\" In Paléo, 19\\. 181\\-201; Hoffecker, J., Holliday, V., Anikovich, M.V., Sinitsyn, A.A. and Popov, V.V. (2009\\). Early Palaeolithic Settlement at Kostenki, Russia. A Research Report to the National Geographic Society: Grant 8528\\-08\\. Cueva Morín,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\\). \"Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain).\" In Nature, 226\\. 722\\-726\\. Grotte du Renne,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\\). \"Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain).\" In Nature, 226\\. 722\\-726\\. Vigne\\-Brune,Combier, J. (1988\\). \"L’Organisation de l’espace habité des hommes du Paléolithique Supérieur en France.\" In Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, Serie I, Number I, Prehistoria y Arqueología. 111\\-124\\.; Digan, M. (2008\\). \"New technological and economic data from La Vigne\\-Brun (unit KL19\\), Loire: a contribution to the identification of early Gravettian lithic technological expertise.\" In Quartär 55\\. 115\\-125\\. Dolní Věstonice,Martin Oliva, M. (2014\\). \"Dolní Věstonice (1922\\-1942\\): Karel Absolon, Hans Freising, and Assien Bohmers.\" In Anthropos\\-Studies, Vol. 37 N.S. 29 (2014\\). Les Peyrugues,Allard, M. (2006\\). \"25\\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues\" (C67\\-16\\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\\); Allard, M. (1993\\). \"Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot).\" In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\\. 179\\-191\\. Mezin,Allard, M. (2006\\). \"25\\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues\" (C67\\-16\\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\\). \nAllard, M. (1993\\). \"Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot).\" In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\\. 179\\-191\\. Ohalo II,Nadel, D., Weiss, E., Simchoni, O., Tsatskin, A., Danin, A., and Kislev, M. (2004\\). \"Stone age hut in Israel yields world’s oldest evidence of bedding.\" In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) vol. 101 no. 17\\. 6821\\- 6826 Mal'ta,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\\). \"Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta.\" in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Le Cerisier,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\\). \"Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta.\" in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Plateau Perrain,Gaussen, J. (1994\\). \"Le Plateau Parrain: l’orginisation.\" In L’Anthropologie 98 (2\\-3\\). 418\\-426\\. Gontsy,Iakovleva, L., Djindjian, F., Maschenko, E.N., Konik, S., Moigne, A.\\-M. (2012\\). \"The late Upper Palaeolithic site of Gontsy (Ukraine): A reference for the reconstruction of the hunter\\-gatherer system based on a mammoth economy.\" In Quaternary International 255\\. 86\\-93\\. Mezhirich,Soffer, O., Adovasio, J., Kornietz, N., Velichko, A., Gribchenko, Y., Lenz, B., and Suntsov, V. (1997\\). \"Cultural Stratigraphy at Mezhirich, an Upper Palaeolithic Site in Ukraine with Multiple Occupations\" in Antiquity 71\\. 48\\-62\\. \nSvoboda, J., Péan, S., and Wojtal, P. (2005\\). \"Mammoth Bone Deposits and Subsistence Practices during Mid\\-Upper Palaeolithic in Central Europe: Three cases from Moravia and Poland.\" In Quaternary International 126–128\\. 209\\-221\\.\nGladkikh, M.I., Kornietz, N.L., and Soffer, O. (1984\\). \"Mammoth Bone Dwellings on the Russian Plain.\" In Scientific American (November, 1984\\). 164\\-75\\. Gönnersdorf,Bosinski, G. (2008\\). Tierdarstellungen von Gönnersdorf: Nachträge zu Mammut und Pferd sowie die übrigen Tierdarstellungen, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 9\\. Mainz: RGZM.\nBosinski, G., d'Errico, F., and Schiller, P. (2001\\). Die gravierten Frauendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 8\\. Stuttgart: Steiner.\nFranken, E. and Veil, S. (1983\\). Die Steinartefakte von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 7\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nTerberger, T. (1997\\). Die Siedlungsbefunde von Gönnersdorf: Konzentrationen III und IV, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 6\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1980\\). Mammut\\- und Pferdedarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 5\\. Weisbaden: Steiner, 1980\\.\nBrunnacker, K. (1978\\). Geowissenschaftliche Untersuchungen in Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 4\\. Weisbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. (1978\\) Die Ausgrabungen in Gönnersdorf 1968\\-1976 und die Siedlungsbefunde der Grabung 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 3\\. Weisbaden: Steiner.\nF. Poplin, F. (1976\\). Les grands vertébrés de Gönnersdorf, Fouilles 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 2\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1974\\). Die Menschendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf der Ausgrabung von 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 1\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner. Pincevent,Leroi\\-Gourhan, A. (1984\\). Pincevent: Campement magdalénien de chasseurs de rennes. Guides Archeologiques de la France: L'Imprimerie Nationale.\nLeroi\\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1972\\). \"Fouilles de Pincevent: Essai d’analyse ethnographique d’un habitat magdalénien (la section 36\\).\" In Gallia Préhistoire, supplement VIIè.\nLeroi\\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1966\\). \"L'habitation magdalénienne n° 1 de Pincevent près Monterau (Seine\\-et\\-Marne).\" In Gallia Préhistoire Vol. 9, Issue 9\\-2\\. 263\\-385\\. \nTo learn more about the distribution of materials see Enloe, J.G., David, F. and Hare, T. (1994\\). \"Patterns of Faunal Processing at Section 27 of Pincevent: The use of spatial analysis and ethnoarchaeological data in the interpretation of archaeological site structure.\" In the Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 13\\. 105\\-124\\. and Borneck.Rust, A. (1962\\). Vor 20 000 Jahren: Rentierjäger der Eiszeit. Neumünster: Karl Wachholtz Verlag. Fischer, A. and Tauber, H. (1986\\). \"New C\\-14 Datings of Late Palaeolithic Cultures from Northwestern Europe\" in Journal of Danish Archaeology, Vol. 5\\. 7\\-13\\.",
"#### Taphonomy",
"The actual physical evidence of Paleolithic shelters is limited to permanent materials like stone and bone. No wooden post or animal hide has been found, because these materials disintegrate over the course of time. But the existence of the perishable elements can be established. Postholes prove the existence of the wooden supports. The alignment of the holes or a circle of support stones describes a footprint of a framework. The area covered by flint scattered from blade work, and other household activities, further demarcates the interior shape of the structure.",
"The types of stones, bones, and minerals found at the campsites further describe the use of animal hides as tent covering. Butchered and burned animal bones found around the fire pit show which types of animals were hunted and eaten. Stone tools such as hide scrapers and deposits of minerals employed in preparing skins show the routine use of animal hides. In addition, there are a host of ethnographic parallels, as indigenous cultures throughout the world relied on animal hides as a shelter covering material until the onset of the modern era.",
"#### Lifeways",
"The people of the Paleolithic existed prior to agriculture and the domestication of animals, and they would have lived as small bands of [hunter\\-gatherers](/wiki/Hunter-gatherers \"Hunter-gatherers\"), moving from place to place, exploiting plant, animal, and mineral resources. Two of the factors that influenced choice of location were proximity to fresh water and animal migration routes.Bahn, P.G. (1985\\). Pyrenean Prehistory: A Palaeoeconomic Survey of the French Sites. Warminster: Aris \\& Phillips. 336\\. Paleolithic foragers would also set up camp overlooking fields inhabited by herds of hoofed herbivores.Lambert, D. (1987\\). The Field Guide to Early Man. New York: Diagram Group. 164\\.",
"Paleolithic campsites were characterized by repeated, seasonal, short\\-term occupation. While the inhabitants were quite mobile, without beasts of burden, shelters were not transported. A tent might stand at its location for a few years before it deteriorated and had to be rebuilt. The archaeological record describes shelters rebuilt over\\-and\\-over on roughly the same spot. Bands of Paleolithic hunter\\-gatherers followed an annual circuit with shelters built at strategic points along the way.",
"#### Hearths",
"Paleolithic campsites were dotted with external fire pits and internal hearths. The internal hearths were not open\\-burning fires, but were hollow areas that held heated stones and charcoal.Leesch, D. and Bullinger, J. (2012\\). \"Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest.\" In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 167\\-168\\. \nLeesch and Bullinger also cite Coudret, P., Larrière, M., and Valentine, B. (1989\\) \"Comparer des Foyers: Une entreprise difficile.\" In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.). Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du [Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\\-de\\-France](/wiki/Mus%C3%A9e_de_Pr%C3%A9histoire_d%27%C3%8Ele-de-France \"Musée de Préhistoire d'Île-de-France\") 2\\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\\-de\\-France, Nemours, 37\\-45\\. \nValentin, B. (1989\\). \"Nature et Fonction des Foyers de l’habitation n°1 à Pincevent.\" In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.) Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\\-de\\-France 2\\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\\-de\\-France, Nemours, 209\\-219\\.\nValentin, B. and Bodu, P. (1991\\). \"Perspectives de l’expérimentation appliquée à l’étude des foyers paléolithiques: Le cas des foyers del’habitation n°1 à Pincevent (Seine\\-et\\-Marne).\" In Archéologie Experimentale\\-2, l’os et la pierre, la Maison et les champs. Colloque International ‘Expérimentation en Archéologie: bilan et perspectives’, Archéodrome de Beaune, 6–9 April 1988\\. Editions Errance: Paris. 138\\-145\\.\nLeesch, D. (1997\\). \"Hauterive\\-Champréveyres, 10\\. Un campement magdalénien au bord du lac de Neuchâtel: cadre chronologique et culturel, mobilier et structures (secteur 1\\).\" In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 19 (Musée Cantonal d’archéologie, Neuchâtel, 1997\\) 170\\-172\\.\nPlumettaz, N. (2007\\). \"Le site magdalénien de Monruz, 2\\. Étude des foyers à partir de l’analyse des pierres de leurs remontages.\" In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 38\\. Office et Musée Cantonal d’Archéologie Neuchâtel. The hearths acted as heat sinks, or heat traps, where thermal energy was stored and released slowly over time, to keep the dwelling warm. Hot stones and charcoals would be rolled, with sticks or bones, onto a thick animal hide and conveyed a couple of meters from the fire pit to the hearth. The next day the task would be repeated: hearths were taken apart and reassembled routinely. Frequent heating caused the rocks to discolor and crumble. Once a rock was no longer effective at holding heat, it was thrown in a nearby refuse pit along with animal bones and other household waste. An internal stone hearth is an effective strategy for staying warm, but it did not provide any light.Leesch, D., and Bullinger, J. (2012\\). \"Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest.\" In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 168\\. The interiors of the tents were then dim places, where ancient people would have witnessed the camera obscura effect.",
"### Paleolithic archaeological optics",
"Paleolithic archaeological optics involves investigations into the image projection capacities of Paleolithic tent reconstructions.",
"#### Reconstructions",
"The suitability of Paleolithic tents/shelters for coincidental camera obscura formation was explored during a set of experiments under the direction of Matt Gatton in 2005 and 2006\\.Gatton, M. (2005\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 6 October 2005\\. The first set of experiments took place on a bison ranch in Oldham County, Kentucky, where a small, rudimentary bison hide [teepee](/wiki/Teepee \"Teepee\") was erected next to a pasture, and images of the bison were cast through a hole in the hides and projected into the tent. The second set of experiments occurred at a rock shelter outside of Irvine, Estill County, Kentucky, where the investigators leaned a framework of tree branches against a rock wall and covered it with bison hides. The image of a horse outside was projected through a rough hole in the hides and into the interior space. The third set of experiments took place at the Musée du Malgré\\-Tout in Belgium, where archaeologists Pierre Cattelain and Claire Bellier reconstructed a variety of Paleolithic structures in several places in France, Germany and Ukraine. A smattering of holes was present in the hide coverings of each tent. At the German site, images were projected inside the reconstruction onto a rabbit hide.",
"#### Statistical analysis",
"The tent reconstructions established some plausibility of accidental camera obscura formation during the Paleolithic, but plausibility is not probability, so the question of the probable frequency of projected images was explored by [Bayesian](/wiki/Bayesian_probability \"Bayesian probability\") statistical modeling.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\\). \"Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\\-camera Theory.\" In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\\. 181\\-190 Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2012\\). \"Projecting Projection: A statistical analysis of cast\\-light images.\" In Pleistocene Coalition Newsletter \\#18\\.",
"To evaluate the probability of an unknown event a series of conditional probabilities were used to create a chance tree using [TreeAge Pro 2011](https://www.treeage.com/products/) (Williamstown, MA). The conditions affecting the appearance of projected images are the general context of the shelter, aperture existence, aperture size, sunlight exposure, weather, occupancy, and the specific context of the dwelling. Given the different situations regarding variables; the probability of a person observing a projected image inside a Palaeolithic dwelling ranged from 1% to 8% per day, or 4 to 29 times per year.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\\). \"Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\\-camera Theory.\" In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\\. 185\\. Multiplying the yearly occurrences by the range of years and the estimated human population; camera obscura images could have been observed anywhere from 54\\.8 billion to 4\\.38 trillion times (5\\.48x1010 to 4\\.38x1012) over the course of prehistory.Gatton, M. and Carreon, L. (2011\\). \"Probability and the Origin of Art: Simulations of the Paleo\\-camera Theory.\" In APLIMAT, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Volume 4\\. 185\\.",
"### Implications",
"The likely prevalence of prehistoric camera obscuras throughout the human experience suggests several important implications for the development of art, religious beliefs, philosophy and existing cave art.",
"#### Art",
"The origins of art have been a significant mystery, because art, as a form of communication, is largely a [social construct](/wiki/Social_constructionism \"Social constructionism\"). The core issue is that there can be no intention to represent an object or scene without first knowing that such a depiction is possible.Davidson, I. and Noble, W. (1989\\). \"The Archaeology of Perception: Traces of Depiction and Language.\" In Current Anthropology 30\\. 129\\. Researchers have encountered great difficulty coming up with explanations of how prehistoric people first stumbled upon the idea of the possibility of representation.Lewis\\-Williams, D. (2002\\). Mind in the Cave. London: Thames \\& Hudson, 2002\\. 184\\. The archaeo\\-optical explanation is that images projected inside a dwelling space provided, according to Cambridge professor Nigel Spivey, \"… a prototypical visual experience that triggers the concept of representation…\"Personal correspondence, E\\-mail from Nigel Spivey to Matt Gatton sent on Monday, 6 March 2006\\. In addition, the images would be shared experiences, visible by everyone in the tent or structure at the same time.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W., and Scott, V. (2010\\). \"The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic.\" In the Official Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Lisbon 2006, Global State of the Art\\-\\-SO7 (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) Oxford: Archaeopress. 138\\. The group could thus collectively experience, discuss, verify, confirm, investigate, and interpret the images projected on the surfaces before them. It is the communal aspect of the images that makes the development of visual art socially feasible.",
"\"A randomly projected image stands for a real object; it says bison without being a flesh and blood bison, planting the idea of a referent, the conceptual beginning of art.\" \\-Matt GattonGatton, M. \"First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura\" in Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\\.",
"#### Faith",
"It is also possible that camera obscura images could have fostered religious belief. A broad definition of religion is a belief in an alternative realm that influences physical reality. Theologian Rudolf Otto held that the origins of religion are to be found in the concept of the sacred, the divine presenting itself as something \"wholly other\" (ganz andere).Otto, R. (1950 ed.). [The Idea of the Holy](/wiki/The_Idea_of_the_Holy \"The Idea of the Holy\"); an inquiry into the non\\-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational \\[Harvey, J.W., trans.]. New York: Oxford University Press, 1950 ed. Originally published in German as Das Heilige (1917\\). The images projected in Paleolithic tents would have offered an early gateway to the concept of an alternative realm, a glimpse of an \"other\", that initiated a belief in something that was not seen moment to moment. The images, once seen, lingered in the mind, and took root in the culture.",
"",
"> “The camera’s image instantly splits a quasi\\-reality away from reality, peeling off an ‘other’ from the ‘is’; instilling the very idea that animals, plants, and humans have existences in other forms, spirits, on other planes.” \\- Matt GattonGatton, M. (2010\\). “Paleo\\-camera and the Concept of Representation.\" In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\\.",
"Once the concept of an alternative realm had taken root, it would have provided a domain for agents of an \"other\" world to intervene in human affairs. The notion of spirit forms is the very root of animism, the oldest known, and perhaps first, form of religion. The incidental image is possibly the first glimpse of the \"divine\".Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Paleo\\-camera and the Concept of Representation.\" In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\\.",
"#### Philosophy",
"The core issue of metaphysics is the investigation of the nature of reality. The images in a Paleolithic tent would trigger a cascade of thoughts about the essence of reality: What is *that* plane of existence? And reflexively, what is *this* plane?Gatton, M. (2009\\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\\. Only by glimpsing an alternative reality does this reality become open to question — the very start of abstract examination.",
"#### Schematicized distortions",
"The projections by camera obscura can also explain some common features among cave paintings of animals and people. Paleolithic [cave art](/wiki/Cave_painting \"Cave painting\") is well known for iconic, schematicized figures, usually with extremely small heads and enormous, often bowed, bodies. Examples of the core elements of some Paleolithic cultures’ visual lexicon — repetition, disconnection, movement, superimposition, and distortion — are expressed in engravings on flat stones and bones within the habitation sites and also on the walls of deep caves.Gatton, M. (2010\\). “The Camera and the Cave: Understanding the style of Palaeolithic art.” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 5 (Feliks, J., ed.) September–October.\nGatton, M. (2010\\). “Paleo\\-camera, Phase II: Projected images in art and ritual (or why European Upper Palaeolithic art looks the way it does).” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 4 (Feliks, J., ed.) July–August.",
"In May 2005, Matt Gatton, Walter Brock, and Dylan Brock set up a room\\-sized camera obscura on a farm in Harrodsburg, Kentucky. The image of a horse was projected on to a small flat stone. It was natural for the artist to catch the image with his torso, the engraving stone secured against the body, and the eyes looking down on the inverted image. In this scenario it was advantageous to tilt the stone slightly. The more the stone was tilted the more the image of the animal distorted, the animal's head reducing in size and the stomach bowing downward, quite like the distortions seen in some deep cave art.Gatton, M. (2009\\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 151\\. This distortion is known as the [keystone effect](/wiki/Keystone_effect \"Keystone effect\"). Gatton proposed that the deep cave distortions may have resulted from the camera obscura effects within the tents.Gatton, M. (2005\\). “Drawing experiments” in “Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville.” In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> May 2005\\.",
"### Paleolithic archaeo\\-optic concepts in wider culture",
"{{in popular culture\\|date\\=April 2020}}\nThe hypothesis that paleolithic people would have seen camera obscura effects within their shelters—Gatton's Paleolithic Camera Obscura Theory—has gained wider exposure in the last several years, including specific references in the following venues.",
"* Dr. Nigel Spivey in How Art Made the World: Cambridge Interviews: Episode 2, “The Day Pictures Were Born” KCET/BBC, June 22, 2006\\. Series produced by Mark Hedgecoe and directed by Robin Dashwood{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.pbs.org/howartmadetheworld/interviews/\\|title \\= How Art Made the World . Cambridge Interviews \\| PBS\\| website\\=\\[\\[PBS]] }}\n* The exposition “Le cinéma/Pré\\-cinéma” at the Malle Pédagogique, Collège of Cinéma at Calvados in Caen, France (2009\\-2010\\).\n* The 2014 Artefact Festival in Leuven, Belgium was themed on Gatton's Palaeolithic Camera Obscura Theory, “De Prehistorie van het Beeld” (The Prehistory of the Image). Pierre Cattelain and Claire Bellier and their team from the Musée du Malgré\\-Tout built a replica of the Paleolithic Le Ceriser tent (c. 18,000 BP) in the atrium in the Tweebronnen public library. Gatton was on hand to show visitors how images were projected inside the tent.Television coverage: De Prehistorie van Het Beeld, Vlaamse Radio\\- en Televisieomroeporganisatie (VRT). (Feb. 13, 2014\\).\n\\<[http://cobra.canvas.be/cm/cobra/videozone/rubriek/kunst\\-videozone/1\\.1874453](http://cobra.canvas.be/cm/cobra/videozone/rubriek/kunst-videozone/1.1874453)\\>",
"```\nRadio coverage: Radio 1, Helena De Groot and Marc de Bie",
"```\n\\<[http://www.radio1\\.be/programmas/bar\\-du\\-matin/artefact\\-de\\-prehistorie\\-van\\-het\\-beeld{{dead link\\|date\\=October 2016 \\|bot\\=InternetArchiveBot \\|fix\\-attempted\\=yes }}](http://www.radio1.be/programmas/bar-du-matin/artefact-de-prehistorie-van-het-beeld{{dead link|date=October 2016 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }})\\> After the festival the tent was disassembled, and transported to the Musée du Malgré\\-Tout for permanent installation.\n* The introduction of Season 1, Episode 5 \"Hiding in the Light\" of Cosmos: A Space Time Odyssey, which first aired in the USA on 6 April 2014\\. The series was produced by a partnership of the National Geographic Channel and FOX, and was written by Ann Druyan and Steven Soter, and narrated by Neil deGrasse Tyson.\n* Picture THIS, Podcast \\#1: The Ancient Camera (Camera Obscura). Hosted by Chelsea and Tony Northrup, The Art and Science of Photography, 25 January 2016"
] |
### Paleolithic structures
The Lower Paleolithic was a time of early humans such as [Homo habilis](/wiki/Homo_habilis "Homo habilis") and [Homo erectus](/wiki/Homo_erectus "Homo erectus"). Possible indications of the early development of shelter construction during the Lower Paleolithic come from excavations at [Olduvai Gorge](/wiki/Olduvai_Gorge "Olduvai Gorge"),Leakey, M.D. (1971\). Olduvai Gorge, Volume 3: Excavations in beds I \& II 1960–1963\. New York: Cambridge University Press. 24\. Melka Kunturé,Chavaillon, J. (2004\). "The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble." In Studies on the early Paleolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Pont\-de\-Lavaud,Chavaillon, J. (2004\). "The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble." In Studies on the early Palaeolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Isernia La Pineta,Giusberti, G., Guerreschi, A., and Peretto, C. (1983\). "Le strutture d’abitato dell’accampamento Paleolitico di Isernia La Pineta: Prime considerazioni." In Isernia La Pineta: Un accampamento più antico di 700\.000 anni. Calderini: Bologna. 100\. Maozhushan,Fang, Y., Huang, Y., and Shen, C. (2004\). "Pebble semicircle structure from a Lower Palaeolithic site in Southern China." In Eurasian Prehistory 2(2\). 3\-12\. Bilzingsleben,Mania D. and Mania U., (2005\). "The natural and socio\-cultural environment of Homo erectus at Bilzingsleben, Germany." In Gamble and Porr (eds.) The Hominid Individual in Context: Archaeological investigations of Lower and Middle Palaeolithic landscapes, locales, and artefacts. New York: Routledge. 98\-114\. and Terra Amata.de Lumley, H. (1966\). "Les fouilles de Terra Amata à Nice: Premier résultats." In Bulletin du Musée d’Anthropologie Préhistorique de Monaco 13\. 29\-51; de Lumley, H. (1969\). "A Palaeolithic camp at Nice." In Scientific American 22, No. 5\. 33\-41\.
The Middle Paleolithic saw Homo erectus decline as [Homo neanderthalensis](/wiki/Homo_neanderthalensis "Homo neanderthalensis") developed in Eurasia, and [Homo sapiens](/wiki/Homo_sapiens "Homo sapiens") developed in Africa. Possible evidence of shelter construction in the Middle Paleolithic can be found at sites such as Port\-Pignot,Michel, D. (1982\). "Le gisement préhistorique de Port Pignot à Fermanville (Manche)." In Gallia Préhistoire, Vol. 25, Issue 1\. 1\-68; Michel, D. (1983\). "Structures d’habitat du paléolithique inférieur du Nord Cotentin." In Bulletin de la Société Normande d’Etudes Préhistoriques et Historiques, XLVIII. 11\-13\. Saint\-Vaast\-la\-Hougue,Fosse, G. (1981\). "Le site moustérien de Saint\-Vaast\-la\-Hougue (Manche): Premiers résultats at problématiques generals." In Gallia Préhistoire 24, 2\. 383\-386\. Le Lazaret,de Lumley, H. (1969\). "Une Cabane Acheuléenne dans la Grotte du Lazaret (Nice)." In Mémoires de la Société Préhistorique Française, vol. 7 Paris. La Baume des Peyrards,de Lumley, H. (1957\). "Le Moustérien de la Baume des Peyrards (Vaucluse): Note Préliminaire." In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 1\-23\.
de Lumley, H. (1962\). "Paléolithique ancien et moyen en Vaucluse: notes préliminaires (1957\-1962\)." In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 29\-79\. Combe Grenal,Mellars, P. (1995\). The Neanderthal legacy: An archaeological perspective from Western Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 292\-308\. La Butte d’Arvigny,Gouédo, J\-M., Bats, J\-C., Krier, V., Pernot, P., and Ricard, J\-L. (1994\). "Le Gisement Moustérien de la ‘Butte d’Arvigny’ Commune de Moissy\-Cramayel (Seine\-et\-Marne): Premiers Résultats." In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française, Vol. 91, Issue 6\. 369\-377\. La Folie,Bourguignon, L., Sellami, F., Deloze, V., Sellier\-Segard, N., Beyries, S., and Emery\-Barbier, A. (2012\). "L’habitat moustérien de « La Folie » (Poitiers, Vienne): synthèse des premiers résultats." In Paleo: Revue d’archéologie Préhistorique vol 14\. 29\-48\. La Ferrassie,Peyrony, D. (1934\) "La Ferrassie" in Préhistoire III. Paris. 1\-92\. Biśnek,Cyrek, K. (2003\). "Biśnik Cave: A reconstruction of the site’s occupation in the context of environmental changes." In Eurasian Prehistory 1(1\). 5\-29\. Vilas Ruivas,Zilhão, J. (2001\). "Middle Palaeolithic Settlement Patterns in Portugal." In Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age (Nicholas Conard, ed.) Tübingen: Kerns Verlag. 597\-608\. Ripiceni\-Izvor,Păunescu, A. (1965\). "Sur la succession des habitats paléolithiques et post\-paléolithiques de Ripiceni Izvor." In Dacia N.S. 9\. 5–31\. and Molodava I.Demay, L., Péan, S., and [Patou\-Mathis](/wiki/Maryl%C3%A8ne_Patou-Mathis "Marylène Patou-Mathis"), M. (2012\). "Mammoths used as food and building resources by Neanderthals: Zooarchaeological study applied to layer 4, Molodova I (Ukraine)." In Quaternary International vol. 276\-277\. 212\-226\.
The Upper Paleolithic saw the expansion of Homo sapiens and the dwindling and ultimate extinction of Homo neanderthalensis. The best examples of Upper Paleolithic shelter practices come from excavations at such places as Kostienki,Sinitsyn, A. (2007\). "Variabilité du Gravettien de Kostienki (Bassin moyen du Don) et des territoires associés." In Paléo, 19\. 181\-201; Hoffecker, J., Holliday, V., Anikovich, M.V., Sinitsyn, A.A. and Popov, V.V. (2009\). Early Palaeolithic Settlement at Kostenki, Russia. A Research Report to the National Geographic Society: Grant 8528\-08\. Cueva Morín,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\). "Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain)." In Nature, 226\. 722\-726\. Grotte du Renne,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\). "Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain)." In Nature, 226\. 722\-726\. Vigne\-Brune,Combier, J. (1988\). "L’Organisation de l’espace habité des hommes du Paléolithique Supérieur en France." In Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, Serie I, Number I, Prehistoria y Arqueología. 111\-124\.; Digan, M. (2008\). "New technological and economic data from La Vigne\-Brun (unit KL19\), Loire: a contribution to the identification of early Gravettian lithic technological expertise." In Quartär 55\. 115\-125\. Dolní Věstonice,Martin Oliva, M. (2014\). "Dolní Věstonice (1922\-1942\): Karel Absolon, Hans Freising, and Assien Bohmers." In Anthropos\-Studies, Vol. 37 N.S. 29 (2014\). Les Peyrugues,Allard, M. (2006\). "25\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues" (C67\-16\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\); Allard, M. (1993\). "Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot)." In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\. 179\-191\. Mezin,Allard, M. (2006\). "25\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues" (C67\-16\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\).
Allard, M. (1993\). "Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot)." In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\. 179\-191\. Ohalo II,Nadel, D., Weiss, E., Simchoni, O., Tsatskin, A., Danin, A., and Kislev, M. (2004\). "Stone age hut in Israel yields world’s oldest evidence of bedding." In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) vol. 101 no. 17\. 6821\- 6826 Mal'ta,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\). "Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta." in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Le Cerisier,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\). "Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta." in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Plateau Perrain,Gaussen, J. (1994\). "Le Plateau Parrain: l’orginisation." In L’Anthropologie 98 (2\-3\). 418\-426\. Gontsy,Iakovleva, L., Djindjian, F., Maschenko, E.N., Konik, S., Moigne, A.\-M. (2012\). "The late Upper Palaeolithic site of Gontsy (Ukraine): A reference for the reconstruction of the hunter\-gatherer system based on a mammoth economy." In Quaternary International 255\. 86\-93\. Mezhirich,Soffer, O., Adovasio, J., Kornietz, N., Velichko, A., Gribchenko, Y., Lenz, B., and Suntsov, V. (1997\). "Cultural Stratigraphy at Mezhirich, an Upper Palaeolithic Site in Ukraine with Multiple Occupations" in Antiquity 71\. 48\-62\.
Svoboda, J., Péan, S., and Wojtal, P. (2005\). "Mammoth Bone Deposits and Subsistence Practices during Mid\-Upper Palaeolithic in Central Europe: Three cases from Moravia and Poland." In Quaternary International 126–128\. 209\-221\.
Gladkikh, M.I., Kornietz, N.L., and Soffer, O. (1984\). "Mammoth Bone Dwellings on the Russian Plain." In Scientific American (November, 1984\). 164\-75\. Gönnersdorf,Bosinski, G. (2008\). Tierdarstellungen von Gönnersdorf: Nachträge zu Mammut und Pferd sowie die übrigen Tierdarstellungen, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 9\. Mainz: RGZM.
Bosinski, G., d'Errico, F., and Schiller, P. (2001\). Die gravierten Frauendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 8\. Stuttgart: Steiner.
Franken, E. and Veil, S. (1983\). Die Steinartefakte von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 7\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Terberger, T. (1997\). Die Siedlungsbefunde von Gönnersdorf: Konzentrationen III und IV, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 6\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1980\). Mammut\- und Pferdedarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 5\. Weisbaden: Steiner, 1980\.
Brunnacker, K. (1978\). Geowissenschaftliche Untersuchungen in Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 4\. Weisbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. (1978\) Die Ausgrabungen in Gönnersdorf 1968\-1976 und die Siedlungsbefunde der Grabung 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 3\. Weisbaden: Steiner.
F. Poplin, F. (1976\). Les grands vertébrés de Gönnersdorf, Fouilles 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 2\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.
Bosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1974\). Die Menschendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf der Ausgrabung von 1968, Der Magdalénien\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 1\. Wiesbaden: Steiner. Pincevent,Leroi\-Gourhan, A. (1984\). Pincevent: Campement magdalénien de chasseurs de rennes. Guides Archeologiques de la France: L'Imprimerie Nationale.
Leroi\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1972\). "Fouilles de Pincevent: Essai d’analyse ethnographique d’un habitat magdalénien (la section 36\)." In Gallia Préhistoire, supplement VIIè.
Leroi\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1966\). "L'habitation magdalénienne n° 1 de Pincevent près Monterau (Seine\-et\-Marne)." In Gallia Préhistoire Vol. 9, Issue 9\-2\. 263\-385\.
To learn more about the distribution of materials see Enloe, J.G., David, F. and Hare, T. (1994\). "Patterns of Faunal Processing at Section 27 of Pincevent: The use of spatial analysis and ethnoarchaeological data in the interpretation of archaeological site structure." In the Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 13\. 105\-124\. and Borneck.Rust, A. (1962\). Vor 20 000 Jahren: Rentierjäger der Eiszeit. Neumünster: Karl Wachholtz Verlag. Fischer, A. and Tauber, H. (1986\). "New C\-14 Datings of Late Palaeolithic Cultures from Northwestern Europe" in Journal of Danish Archaeology, Vol. 5\. 7\-13\.
#### Taphonomy
The actual physical evidence of Paleolithic shelters is limited to permanent materials like stone and bone. No wooden post or animal hide has been found, because these materials disintegrate over the course of time. But the existence of the perishable elements can be established. Postholes prove the existence of the wooden supports. The alignment of the holes or a circle of support stones describes a footprint of a framework. The area covered by flint scattered from blade work, and other household activities, further demarcates the interior shape of the structure.
The types of stones, bones, and minerals found at the campsites further describe the use of animal hides as tent covering. Butchered and burned animal bones found around the fire pit show which types of animals were hunted and eaten. Stone tools such as hide scrapers and deposits of minerals employed in preparing skins show the routine use of animal hides. In addition, there are a host of ethnographic parallels, as indigenous cultures throughout the world relied on animal hides as a shelter covering material until the onset of the modern era.
#### Lifeways
The people of the Paleolithic existed prior to agriculture and the domestication of animals, and they would have lived as small bands of [hunter\-gatherers](/wiki/Hunter-gatherers "Hunter-gatherers"), moving from place to place, exploiting plant, animal, and mineral resources. Two of the factors that influenced choice of location were proximity to fresh water and animal migration routes.Bahn, P.G. (1985\). Pyrenean Prehistory: A Palaeoeconomic Survey of the French Sites. Warminster: Aris \& Phillips. 336\. Paleolithic foragers would also set up camp overlooking fields inhabited by herds of hoofed herbivores.Lambert, D. (1987\). The Field Guide to Early Man. New York: Diagram Group. 164\.
Paleolithic campsites were characterized by repeated, seasonal, short\-term occupation. While the inhabitants were quite mobile, without beasts of burden, shelters were not transported. A tent might stand at its location for a few years before it deteriorated and had to be rebuilt. The archaeological record describes shelters rebuilt over\-and\-over on roughly the same spot. Bands of Paleolithic hunter\-gatherers followed an annual circuit with shelters built at strategic points along the way.
#### Hearths
Paleolithic campsites were dotted with external fire pits and internal hearths. The internal hearths were not open\-burning fires, but were hollow areas that held heated stones and charcoal.Leesch, D. and Bullinger, J. (2012\). "Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest." In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 167\-168\.
Leesch and Bullinger also cite Coudret, P., Larrière, M., and Valentine, B. (1989\) "Comparer des Foyers: Une entreprise difficile." In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.). Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du [Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\-de\-France](/wiki/Mus%C3%A9e_de_Pr%C3%A9histoire_d%27%C3%8Ele-de-France "Musée de Préhistoire d'Île-de-France") 2\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\-de\-France, Nemours, 37\-45\.
Valentin, B. (1989\). "Nature et Fonction des Foyers de l’habitation n°1 à Pincevent." In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.) Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\-de\-France 2\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\-de\-France, Nemours, 209\-219\.
Valentin, B. and Bodu, P. (1991\). "Perspectives de l’expérimentation appliquée à l’étude des foyers paléolithiques: Le cas des foyers del’habitation n°1 à Pincevent (Seine\-et\-Marne)." In Archéologie Experimentale\-2, l’os et la pierre, la Maison et les champs. Colloque International ‘Expérimentation en Archéologie: bilan et perspectives’, Archéodrome de Beaune, 6–9 April 1988\. Editions Errance: Paris. 138\-145\.
Leesch, D. (1997\). "Hauterive\-Champréveyres, 10\. Un campement magdalénien au bord du lac de Neuchâtel: cadre chronologique et culturel, mobilier et structures (secteur 1\)." In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 19 (Musée Cantonal d’archéologie, Neuchâtel, 1997\) 170\-172\.
Plumettaz, N. (2007\). "Le site magdalénien de Monruz, 2\. Étude des foyers à partir de l’analyse des pierres de leurs remontages." In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 38\. Office et Musée Cantonal d’Archéologie Neuchâtel. The hearths acted as heat sinks, or heat traps, where thermal energy was stored and released slowly over time, to keep the dwelling warm. Hot stones and charcoals would be rolled, with sticks or bones, onto a thick animal hide and conveyed a couple of meters from the fire pit to the hearth. The next day the task would be repeated: hearths were taken apart and reassembled routinely. Frequent heating caused the rocks to discolor and crumble. Once a rock was no longer effective at holding heat, it was thrown in a nearby refuse pit along with animal bones and other household waste. An internal stone hearth is an effective strategy for staying warm, but it did not provide any light.Leesch, D., and Bullinger, J. (2012\). "Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest." In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 168\. The interiors of the tents were then dim places, where ancient people would have witnessed the camera obscura effect.
|
[
"### Paleolithic structures",
"The Lower Paleolithic was a time of early humans such as [Homo habilis](/wiki/Homo_habilis \"Homo habilis\") and [Homo erectus](/wiki/Homo_erectus \"Homo erectus\"). Possible indications of the early development of shelter construction during the Lower Paleolithic come from excavations at [Olduvai Gorge](/wiki/Olduvai_Gorge \"Olduvai Gorge\"),Leakey, M.D. (1971\\). Olduvai Gorge, Volume 3: Excavations in beds I \\& II 1960–1963\\. New York: Cambridge University Press. 24\\. Melka Kunturé,Chavaillon, J. (2004\\). \"The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble.\" In Studies on the early Paleolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Pont\\-de\\-Lavaud,Chavaillon, J. (2004\\). \"The site of Gomboré I: Discovery, geological introduction and study of percussion material and tools on pebble.\" In Studies on the early Palaeolithic site of Melka Konturé, Ethiopia. (Chavaillon, J. and Piperno, M., eds.) Origines. Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protoistoria: Firenze. 263 Isernia La Pineta,Giusberti, G., Guerreschi, A., and Peretto, C. (1983\\). \"Le strutture d’abitato dell’accampamento Paleolitico di Isernia La Pineta: Prime considerazioni.\" In Isernia La Pineta: Un accampamento più antico di 700\\.000 anni. Calderini: Bologna. 100\\. Maozhushan,Fang, Y., Huang, Y., and Shen, C. (2004\\). \"Pebble semicircle structure from a Lower Palaeolithic site in Southern China.\" In Eurasian Prehistory 2(2\\). 3\\-12\\. Bilzingsleben,Mania D. and Mania U., (2005\\). \"The natural and socio\\-cultural environment of Homo erectus at Bilzingsleben, Germany.\" In Gamble and Porr (eds.) The Hominid Individual in Context: Archaeological investigations of Lower and Middle Palaeolithic landscapes, locales, and artefacts. New York: Routledge. 98\\-114\\. and Terra Amata.de Lumley, H. (1966\\). \"Les fouilles de Terra Amata à Nice: Premier résultats.\" In Bulletin du Musée d’Anthropologie Préhistorique de Monaco 13\\. 29\\-51; de Lumley, H. (1969\\). \"A Palaeolithic camp at Nice.\" In Scientific American 22, No. 5\\. 33\\-41\\.",
"The Middle Paleolithic saw Homo erectus decline as [Homo neanderthalensis](/wiki/Homo_neanderthalensis \"Homo neanderthalensis\") developed in Eurasia, and [Homo sapiens](/wiki/Homo_sapiens \"Homo sapiens\") developed in Africa. Possible evidence of shelter construction in the Middle Paleolithic can be found at sites such as Port\\-Pignot,Michel, D. (1982\\). \"Le gisement préhistorique de Port Pignot à Fermanville (Manche).\" In Gallia Préhistoire, Vol. 25, Issue 1\\. 1\\-68; Michel, D. (1983\\). \"Structures d’habitat du paléolithique inférieur du Nord Cotentin.\" In Bulletin de la Société Normande d’Etudes Préhistoriques et Historiques, XLVIII. 11\\-13\\. Saint\\-Vaast\\-la\\-Hougue,Fosse, G. (1981\\). \"Le site moustérien de Saint\\-Vaast\\-la\\-Hougue (Manche): Premiers résultats at problématiques generals.\" In Gallia Préhistoire 24, 2\\. 383\\-386\\. Le Lazaret,de Lumley, H. (1969\\). \"Une Cabane Acheuléenne dans la Grotte du Lazaret (Nice).\" In Mémoires de la Société Préhistorique Française, vol. 7 Paris. La Baume des Peyrards,de Lumley, H. (1957\\). \"Le Moustérien de la Baume des Peyrards (Vaucluse): Note Préliminaire.\" In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 1\\-23\\.\nde Lumley, H. (1962\\). \"Paléolithique ancien et moyen en Vaucluse: notes préliminaires (1957\\-1962\\).\" In Bulletin de la Société d’Etude des Sciences naturelles de Vaucluse. 29\\-79\\. Combe Grenal,Mellars, P. (1995\\). The Neanderthal legacy: An archaeological perspective from Western Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 292\\-308\\. La Butte d’Arvigny,Gouédo, J\\-M., Bats, J\\-C., Krier, V., Pernot, P., and Ricard, J\\-L. (1994\\). \"Le Gisement Moustérien de la ‘Butte d’Arvigny’ Commune de Moissy\\-Cramayel (Seine\\-et\\-Marne): Premiers Résultats.\" In Bulletin de la Société Préhistorique Française, Vol. 91, Issue 6\\. 369\\-377\\. La Folie,Bourguignon, L., Sellami, F., Deloze, V., Sellier\\-Segard, N., Beyries, S., and Emery\\-Barbier, A. (2012\\). \"L’habitat moustérien de « La Folie » (Poitiers, Vienne): synthèse des premiers résultats.\" In Paleo: Revue d’archéologie Préhistorique vol 14\\. 29\\-48\\. La Ferrassie,Peyrony, D. (1934\\) \"La Ferrassie\" in Préhistoire III. Paris. 1\\-92\\. Biśnek,Cyrek, K. (2003\\). \"Biśnik Cave: A reconstruction of the site’s occupation in the context of environmental changes.\" In Eurasian Prehistory 1(1\\). 5\\-29\\. Vilas Ruivas,Zilhão, J. (2001\\). \"Middle Palaeolithic Settlement Patterns in Portugal.\" In Settlement Dynamics of the Middle Palaeolithic and Middle Stone Age (Nicholas Conard, ed.) Tübingen: Kerns Verlag. 597\\-608\\. Ripiceni\\-Izvor,Păunescu, A. (1965\\). \"Sur la succession des habitats paléolithiques et post\\-paléolithiques de Ripiceni Izvor.\" In Dacia N.S. 9\\. 5–31\\. and Molodava I.Demay, L., Péan, S., and [Patou\\-Mathis](/wiki/Maryl%C3%A8ne_Patou-Mathis \"Marylène Patou-Mathis\"), M. (2012\\). \"Mammoths used as food and building resources by Neanderthals: Zooarchaeological study applied to layer 4, Molodova I (Ukraine).\" In Quaternary International vol. 276\\-277\\. 212\\-226\\.",
"The Upper Paleolithic saw the expansion of Homo sapiens and the dwindling and ultimate extinction of Homo neanderthalensis. The best examples of Upper Paleolithic shelter practices come from excavations at such places as Kostienki,Sinitsyn, A. (2007\\). \"Variabilité du Gravettien de Kostienki (Bassin moyen du Don) et des territoires associés.\" In Paléo, 19\\. 181\\-201; Hoffecker, J., Holliday, V., Anikovich, M.V., Sinitsyn, A.A. and Popov, V.V. (2009\\). Early Palaeolithic Settlement at Kostenki, Russia. A Research Report to the National Geographic Society: Grant 8528\\-08\\. Cueva Morín,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\\). \"Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain).\" In Nature, 226\\. 722\\-726\\. Grotte du Renne,Freeman, L.G. and González Echegaray, J. (1970\\). \"Aurignacian Structural Features and Burials at Cueva Morín (Santander, Spain).\" In Nature, 226\\. 722\\-726\\. Vigne\\-Brune,Combier, J. (1988\\). \"L’Organisation de l’espace habité des hommes du Paléolithique Supérieur en France.\" In Espacio, Tiempo y Forma, Serie I, Number I, Prehistoria y Arqueología. 111\\-124\\.; Digan, M. (2008\\). \"New technological and economic data from La Vigne\\-Brun (unit KL19\\), Loire: a contribution to the identification of early Gravettian lithic technological expertise.\" In Quartär 55\\. 115\\-125\\. Dolní Věstonice,Martin Oliva, M. (2014\\). \"Dolní Věstonice (1922\\-1942\\): Karel Absolon, Hans Freising, and Assien Bohmers.\" In Anthropos\\-Studies, Vol. 37 N.S. 29 (2014\\). Les Peyrugues,Allard, M. (2006\\). \"25\\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues\" (C67\\-16\\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\\); Allard, M. (1993\\). \"Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot).\" In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\\. 179\\-191\\. Mezin,Allard, M. (2006\\). \"25\\.000 years old architecture: Habitat 22 of Les Peyrugues\" (C67\\-16\\) presented in Session 67 ‘Settlement dynamics and environment resources in the Palaeolithic of Southwest France: The case of the Quercy region’ at the XV Congress of the International Union for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Sciences, Lisbon, (4–9 September 2006\\). \nAllard, M. (1993\\). \"Remontage lithique exceptionnel dans le Solutréen inférieur des Peyrugues (Orniac, Lot).\" In Paléo, Vol. 5, Issue 5\\. 179\\-191\\. Ohalo II,Nadel, D., Weiss, E., Simchoni, O., Tsatskin, A., Danin, A., and Kislev, M. (2004\\). \"Stone age hut in Israel yields world’s oldest evidence of bedding.\" In Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) vol. 101 no. 17\\. 6821\\- 6826 Mal'ta,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\\). \"Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta.\" in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Le Cerisier,Gerasimov, M.M. (1935\\). \"Raskopi Paleoliticheskoi Stoianki Mal’ta.\" in Paleolit SSSR. Moscow. Plateau Perrain,Gaussen, J. (1994\\). \"Le Plateau Parrain: l’orginisation.\" In L’Anthropologie 98 (2\\-3\\). 418\\-426\\. Gontsy,Iakovleva, L., Djindjian, F., Maschenko, E.N., Konik, S., Moigne, A.\\-M. (2012\\). \"The late Upper Palaeolithic site of Gontsy (Ukraine): A reference for the reconstruction of the hunter\\-gatherer system based on a mammoth economy.\" In Quaternary International 255\\. 86\\-93\\. Mezhirich,Soffer, O., Adovasio, J., Kornietz, N., Velichko, A., Gribchenko, Y., Lenz, B., and Suntsov, V. (1997\\). \"Cultural Stratigraphy at Mezhirich, an Upper Palaeolithic Site in Ukraine with Multiple Occupations\" in Antiquity 71\\. 48\\-62\\. \nSvoboda, J., Péan, S., and Wojtal, P. (2005\\). \"Mammoth Bone Deposits and Subsistence Practices during Mid\\-Upper Palaeolithic in Central Europe: Three cases from Moravia and Poland.\" In Quaternary International 126–128\\. 209\\-221\\.\nGladkikh, M.I., Kornietz, N.L., and Soffer, O. (1984\\). \"Mammoth Bone Dwellings on the Russian Plain.\" In Scientific American (November, 1984\\). 164\\-75\\. Gönnersdorf,Bosinski, G. (2008\\). Tierdarstellungen von Gönnersdorf: Nachträge zu Mammut und Pferd sowie die übrigen Tierdarstellungen, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 9\\. Mainz: RGZM.\nBosinski, G., d'Errico, F., and Schiller, P. (2001\\). Die gravierten Frauendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 8\\. Stuttgart: Steiner.\nFranken, E. and Veil, S. (1983\\). Die Steinartefakte von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 7\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nTerberger, T. (1997\\). Die Siedlungsbefunde von Gönnersdorf: Konzentrationen III und IV, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 6\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1980\\). Mammut\\- und Pferdedarstellungen von Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 5\\. Weisbaden: Steiner, 1980\\.\nBrunnacker, K. (1978\\). Geowissenschaftliche Untersuchungen in Gönnersdorf, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 4\\. Weisbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. (1978\\) Die Ausgrabungen in Gönnersdorf 1968\\-1976 und die Siedlungsbefunde der Grabung 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 3\\. Weisbaden: Steiner.\nF. Poplin, F. (1976\\). Les grands vertébrés de Gönnersdorf, Fouilles 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 2\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner.\nBosinski, G. and Fischer, G. (1974\\). Die Menschendarstellungen von Gönnersdorf der Ausgrabung von 1968, Der Magdalénien\\-Fundplatz Gönnersdorf Volume 1\\. Wiesbaden: Steiner. Pincevent,Leroi\\-Gourhan, A. (1984\\). Pincevent: Campement magdalénien de chasseurs de rennes. Guides Archeologiques de la France: L'Imprimerie Nationale.\nLeroi\\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1972\\). \"Fouilles de Pincevent: Essai d’analyse ethnographique d’un habitat magdalénien (la section 36\\).\" In Gallia Préhistoire, supplement VIIè.\nLeroi\\-Gourhan, A. and Brézillon, M. (1966\\). \"L'habitation magdalénienne n° 1 de Pincevent près Monterau (Seine\\-et\\-Marne).\" In Gallia Préhistoire Vol. 9, Issue 9\\-2\\. 263\\-385\\. \nTo learn more about the distribution of materials see Enloe, J.G., David, F. and Hare, T. (1994\\). \"Patterns of Faunal Processing at Section 27 of Pincevent: The use of spatial analysis and ethnoarchaeological data in the interpretation of archaeological site structure.\" In the Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 13\\. 105\\-124\\. and Borneck.Rust, A. (1962\\). Vor 20 000 Jahren: Rentierjäger der Eiszeit. Neumünster: Karl Wachholtz Verlag. Fischer, A. and Tauber, H. (1986\\). \"New C\\-14 Datings of Late Palaeolithic Cultures from Northwestern Europe\" in Journal of Danish Archaeology, Vol. 5\\. 7\\-13\\.",
"#### Taphonomy",
"The actual physical evidence of Paleolithic shelters is limited to permanent materials like stone and bone. No wooden post or animal hide has been found, because these materials disintegrate over the course of time. But the existence of the perishable elements can be established. Postholes prove the existence of the wooden supports. The alignment of the holes or a circle of support stones describes a footprint of a framework. The area covered by flint scattered from blade work, and other household activities, further demarcates the interior shape of the structure.",
"The types of stones, bones, and minerals found at the campsites further describe the use of animal hides as tent covering. Butchered and burned animal bones found around the fire pit show which types of animals were hunted and eaten. Stone tools such as hide scrapers and deposits of minerals employed in preparing skins show the routine use of animal hides. In addition, there are a host of ethnographic parallels, as indigenous cultures throughout the world relied on animal hides as a shelter covering material until the onset of the modern era.",
"#### Lifeways",
"The people of the Paleolithic existed prior to agriculture and the domestication of animals, and they would have lived as small bands of [hunter\\-gatherers](/wiki/Hunter-gatherers \"Hunter-gatherers\"), moving from place to place, exploiting plant, animal, and mineral resources. Two of the factors that influenced choice of location were proximity to fresh water and animal migration routes.Bahn, P.G. (1985\\). Pyrenean Prehistory: A Palaeoeconomic Survey of the French Sites. Warminster: Aris \\& Phillips. 336\\. Paleolithic foragers would also set up camp overlooking fields inhabited by herds of hoofed herbivores.Lambert, D. (1987\\). The Field Guide to Early Man. New York: Diagram Group. 164\\.",
"Paleolithic campsites were characterized by repeated, seasonal, short\\-term occupation. While the inhabitants were quite mobile, without beasts of burden, shelters were not transported. A tent might stand at its location for a few years before it deteriorated and had to be rebuilt. The archaeological record describes shelters rebuilt over\\-and\\-over on roughly the same spot. Bands of Paleolithic hunter\\-gatherers followed an annual circuit with shelters built at strategic points along the way.",
"#### Hearths",
"Paleolithic campsites were dotted with external fire pits and internal hearths. The internal hearths were not open\\-burning fires, but were hollow areas that held heated stones and charcoal.Leesch, D. and Bullinger, J. (2012\\). \"Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest.\" In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 167\\-168\\. \nLeesch and Bullinger also cite Coudret, P., Larrière, M., and Valentine, B. (1989\\) \"Comparer des Foyers: Une entreprise difficile.\" In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.). Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du [Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\\-de\\-France](/wiki/Mus%C3%A9e_de_Pr%C3%A9histoire_d%27%C3%8Ele-de-France \"Musée de Préhistoire d'Île-de-France\") 2\\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\\-de\\-France, Nemours, 37\\-45\\. \nValentin, B. (1989\\). \"Nature et Fonction des Foyers de l’habitation n°1 à Pincevent.\" In Nature et Fonction des Foyers Prehistoriques (M. Olive and Y. Taborin, eds.) Colloque International de Nemours, 12–14 May 1987 (Mémoires du Musée de Préhistoire d’Ile\\-de\\-France 2\\) Association pour la Promotion de la Recherche Archéologique en Ile\\-de\\-France, Nemours, 209\\-219\\.\nValentin, B. and Bodu, P. (1991\\). \"Perspectives de l’expérimentation appliquée à l’étude des foyers paléolithiques: Le cas des foyers del’habitation n°1 à Pincevent (Seine\\-et\\-Marne).\" In Archéologie Experimentale\\-2, l’os et la pierre, la Maison et les champs. Colloque International ‘Expérimentation en Archéologie: bilan et perspectives’, Archéodrome de Beaune, 6–9 April 1988\\. Editions Errance: Paris. 138\\-145\\.\nLeesch, D. (1997\\). \"Hauterive\\-Champréveyres, 10\\. Un campement magdalénien au bord du lac de Neuchâtel: cadre chronologique et culturel, mobilier et structures (secteur 1\\).\" In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 19 (Musée Cantonal d’archéologie, Neuchâtel, 1997\\) 170\\-172\\.\nPlumettaz, N. (2007\\). \"Le site magdalénien de Monruz, 2\\. Étude des foyers à partir de l’analyse des pierres de leurs remontages.\" In Archéologie Neuchâteloise 38\\. Office et Musée Cantonal d’Archéologie Neuchâtel. The hearths acted as heat sinks, or heat traps, where thermal energy was stored and released slowly over time, to keep the dwelling warm. Hot stones and charcoals would be rolled, with sticks or bones, onto a thick animal hide and conveyed a couple of meters from the fire pit to the hearth. The next day the task would be repeated: hearths were taken apart and reassembled routinely. Frequent heating caused the rocks to discolor and crumble. Once a rock was no longer effective at holding heat, it was thrown in a nearby refuse pit along with animal bones and other household waste. An internal stone hearth is an effective strategy for staying warm, but it did not provide any light.Leesch, D., and Bullinger, J. (2012\\). \"Identifying dwellings in Upper Palaeolithic open\\-air sites: The Magdalenian site at Monruz (Switzerland) and its contribution to analysing palimpsest.\" In A Mind Set on Flint: Studies in Honour of Dick Stapert (Niekus, M., Barton, N., Street, M., Terberger, T., eds.) Groningen Archaeological Studies, Vol. 16\\. Groningen: Barkhuis. 168\\. The interiors of the tents were then dim places, where ancient people would have witnessed the camera obscura effect.",
""
] |
### Implications
The likely prevalence of prehistoric camera obscuras throughout the human experience suggests several important implications for the development of art, religious beliefs, philosophy and existing cave art.
#### Art
The origins of art have been a significant mystery, because art, as a form of communication, is largely a [social construct](/wiki/Social_constructionism "Social constructionism"). The core issue is that there can be no intention to represent an object or scene without first knowing that such a depiction is possible.Davidson, I. and Noble, W. (1989\). "The Archaeology of Perception: Traces of Depiction and Language." In Current Anthropology 30\. 129\. Researchers have encountered great difficulty coming up with explanations of how prehistoric people first stumbled upon the idea of the possibility of representation.Lewis\-Williams, D. (2002\). Mind in the Cave. London: Thames \& Hudson, 2002\. 184\. The archaeo\-optical explanation is that images projected inside a dwelling space provided, according to Cambridge professor Nigel Spivey, "… a prototypical visual experience that triggers the concept of representation…"Personal correspondence, E\-mail from Nigel Spivey to Matt Gatton sent on Monday, 6 March 2006\. In addition, the images would be shared experiences, visible by everyone in the tent or structure at the same time.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W., and Scott, V. (2010\). "The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic." In the Official Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Lisbon 2006, Global State of the Art\-\-SO7 (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) Oxford: Archaeopress. 138\. The group could thus collectively experience, discuss, verify, confirm, investigate, and interpret the images projected on the surfaces before them. It is the communal aspect of the images that makes the development of visual art socially feasible.
"A randomly projected image stands for a real object; it says bison without being a flesh and blood bison, planting the idea of a referent, the conceptual beginning of art." \-Matt GattonGatton, M. "First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura" in Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\.
#### Faith
It is also possible that camera obscura images could have fostered religious belief. A broad definition of religion is a belief in an alternative realm that influences physical reality. Theologian Rudolf Otto held that the origins of religion are to be found in the concept of the sacred, the divine presenting itself as something "wholly other" (ganz andere).Otto, R. (1950 ed.). [The Idea of the Holy](/wiki/The_Idea_of_the_Holy "The Idea of the Holy"); an inquiry into the non\-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational \[Harvey, J.W., trans.]. New York: Oxford University Press, 1950 ed. Originally published in German as Das Heilige (1917\). The images projected in Paleolithic tents would have offered an early gateway to the concept of an alternative realm, a glimpse of an "other", that initiated a belief in something that was not seen moment to moment. The images, once seen, lingered in the mind, and took root in the culture.
> “The camera’s image instantly splits a quasi\-reality away from reality, peeling off an ‘other’ from the ‘is’; instilling the very idea that animals, plants, and humans have existences in other forms, spirits, on other planes.” \- Matt GattonGatton, M. (2010\). “Paleo\-camera and the Concept of Representation." In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\.
Once the concept of an alternative realm had taken root, it would have provided a domain for agents of an "other" world to intervene in human affairs. The notion of spirit forms is the very root of animism, the oldest known, and perhaps first, form of religion. The incidental image is possibly the first glimpse of the "divine".Gatton, M. (2010\). "Paleo\-camera and the Concept of Representation." In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\.
#### Philosophy
The core issue of metaphysics is the investigation of the nature of reality. The images in a Paleolithic tent would trigger a cascade of thoughts about the essence of reality: What is *that* plane of existence? And reflexively, what is *this* plane?Gatton, M. (2009\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\. Only by glimpsing an alternative reality does this reality become open to question — the very start of abstract examination.
#### Schematicized distortions
The projections by camera obscura can also explain some common features among cave paintings of animals and people. Paleolithic [cave art](/wiki/Cave_painting "Cave painting") is well known for iconic, schematicized figures, usually with extremely small heads and enormous, often bowed, bodies. Examples of the core elements of some Paleolithic cultures’ visual lexicon — repetition, disconnection, movement, superimposition, and distortion — are expressed in engravings on flat stones and bones within the habitation sites and also on the walls of deep caves.Gatton, M. (2010\). “The Camera and the Cave: Understanding the style of Palaeolithic art.” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 5 (Feliks, J., ed.) September–October.
Gatton, M. (2010\). “Paleo\-camera, Phase II: Projected images in art and ritual (or why European Upper Palaeolithic art looks the way it does).” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 4 (Feliks, J., ed.) July–August.
In May 2005, Matt Gatton, Walter Brock, and Dylan Brock set up a room\-sized camera obscura on a farm in Harrodsburg, Kentucky. The image of a horse was projected on to a small flat stone. It was natural for the artist to catch the image with his torso, the engraving stone secured against the body, and the eyes looking down on the inverted image. In this scenario it was advantageous to tilt the stone slightly. The more the stone was tilted the more the image of the animal distorted, the animal's head reducing in size and the stomach bowing downward, quite like the distortions seen in some deep cave art.Gatton, M. (2009\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \-\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 151\. This distortion is known as the [keystone effect](/wiki/Keystone_effect "Keystone effect"). Gatton proposed that the deep cave distortions may have resulted from the camera obscura effects within the tents.Gatton, M. (2005\). “Drawing experiments” in “Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville.” In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> May 2005\.
|
[
"### Implications",
"The likely prevalence of prehistoric camera obscuras throughout the human experience suggests several important implications for the development of art, religious beliefs, philosophy and existing cave art.",
"#### Art",
"The origins of art have been a significant mystery, because art, as a form of communication, is largely a [social construct](/wiki/Social_constructionism \"Social constructionism\"). The core issue is that there can be no intention to represent an object or scene without first knowing that such a depiction is possible.Davidson, I. and Noble, W. (1989\\). \"The Archaeology of Perception: Traces of Depiction and Language.\" In Current Anthropology 30\\. 129\\. Researchers have encountered great difficulty coming up with explanations of how prehistoric people first stumbled upon the idea of the possibility of representation.Lewis\\-Williams, D. (2002\\). Mind in the Cave. London: Thames \\& Hudson, 2002\\. 184\\. The archaeo\\-optical explanation is that images projected inside a dwelling space provided, according to Cambridge professor Nigel Spivey, \"… a prototypical visual experience that triggers the concept of representation…\"Personal correspondence, E\\-mail from Nigel Spivey to Matt Gatton sent on Monday, 6 March 2006\\. In addition, the images would be shared experiences, visible by everyone in the tent or structure at the same time.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W., and Scott, V. (2010\\). \"The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic.\" In the Official Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Lisbon 2006, Global State of the Art\\-\\-SO7 (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) Oxford: Archaeopress. 138\\. The group could thus collectively experience, discuss, verify, confirm, investigate, and interpret the images projected on the surfaces before them. It is the communal aspect of the images that makes the development of visual art socially feasible.",
"\"A randomly projected image stands for a real object; it says bison without being a flesh and blood bison, planting the idea of a referent, the conceptual beginning of art.\" \\-Matt GattonGatton, M. \"First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura\" in Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\\.",
"#### Faith",
"It is also possible that camera obscura images could have fostered religious belief. A broad definition of religion is a belief in an alternative realm that influences physical reality. Theologian Rudolf Otto held that the origins of religion are to be found in the concept of the sacred, the divine presenting itself as something \"wholly other\" (ganz andere).Otto, R. (1950 ed.). [The Idea of the Holy](/wiki/The_Idea_of_the_Holy \"The Idea of the Holy\"); an inquiry into the non\\-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational \\[Harvey, J.W., trans.]. New York: Oxford University Press, 1950 ed. Originally published in German as Das Heilige (1917\\). The images projected in Paleolithic tents would have offered an early gateway to the concept of an alternative realm, a glimpse of an \"other\", that initiated a belief in something that was not seen moment to moment. The images, once seen, lingered in the mind, and took root in the culture.",
"",
"> “The camera’s image instantly splits a quasi\\-reality away from reality, peeling off an ‘other’ from the ‘is’; instilling the very idea that animals, plants, and humans have existences in other forms, spirits, on other planes.” \\- Matt GattonGatton, M. (2010\\). “Paleo\\-camera and the Concept of Representation.\" In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\\.",
"Once the concept of an alternative realm had taken root, it would have provided a domain for agents of an \"other\" world to intervene in human affairs. The notion of spirit forms is the very root of animism, the oldest known, and perhaps first, form of religion. The incidental image is possibly the first glimpse of the \"divine\".Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Paleo\\-camera and the Concept of Representation.\" In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 3 (Feliks, J., ed.) May–June. 5\\.",
"#### Philosophy",
"The core issue of metaphysics is the investigation of the nature of reality. The images in a Paleolithic tent would trigger a cascade of thoughts about the essence of reality: What is *that* plane of existence? And reflexively, what is *this* plane?Gatton, M. (2009\\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 153\\. Only by glimpsing an alternative reality does this reality become open to question — the very start of abstract examination.",
"#### Schematicized distortions",
"The projections by camera obscura can also explain some common features among cave paintings of animals and people. Paleolithic [cave art](/wiki/Cave_painting \"Cave painting\") is well known for iconic, schematicized figures, usually with extremely small heads and enormous, often bowed, bodies. Examples of the core elements of some Paleolithic cultures’ visual lexicon — repetition, disconnection, movement, superimposition, and distortion — are expressed in engravings on flat stones and bones within the habitation sites and also on the walls of deep caves.Gatton, M. (2010\\). “The Camera and the Cave: Understanding the style of Palaeolithic art.” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 5 (Feliks, J., ed.) September–October.\nGatton, M. (2010\\). “Paleo\\-camera, Phase II: Projected images in art and ritual (or why European Upper Palaeolithic art looks the way it does).” In Pleistocene Coalition News, Vol. 2: Issue 4 (Feliks, J., ed.) July–August.",
"In May 2005, Matt Gatton, Walter Brock, and Dylan Brock set up a room\\-sized camera obscura on a farm in Harrodsburg, Kentucky. The image of a horse was projected on to a small flat stone. It was natural for the artist to catch the image with his torso, the engraving stone secured against the body, and the eyes looking down on the inverted image. In this scenario it was advantageous to tilt the stone slightly. The more the stone was tilted the more the image of the animal distorted, the animal's head reducing in size and the stomach bowing downward, quite like the distortions seen in some deep cave art.Gatton, M. (2009\\). “First Light: Inside the Palaeolithic camera obscura.” In Acts of Seeing: Artists, Scientists and the History of the Visual \\-\\- a volume dedicated to Martin Kemp (Kaniari, A. and Wallace, M., eds.) London: Zidane. 151\\. This distortion is known as the [keystone effect](/wiki/Keystone_effect \"Keystone effect\"). Gatton proposed that the deep cave distortions may have resulted from the camera obscura effects within the tents.Gatton, M. (2005\\). “Drawing experiments” in “Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The case for image projection in the Palaeolithic, first presented at the University of Louisville.” In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> May 2005\\.",
""
] |
Neolithic archaeological optics
-------------------------------
The [Neolithic](/wiki/Neolithic "Neolithic") period offers the possibility to explore optical image projections within built architecture. Neolithic structures range from modest houses to enormous enclosures and mounds, and were constructed using combinations of earth, timber and stone. Archaeo\-optic fieldwork has focused upon [megalithic](/wiki/Megalithic "Megalithic") monuments.
### Megalithic structures
Megaliths, or large stones, come in two main types of architectural presentations: freestanding and earth\-covered. Individual and groupings of standing stones — in formations of circles, lines, ovals, ‘U’\-shapes, or rectangles — were not employed to support the weight of soil above them, but served as markers. Megalithic chambers designed to bear the weight of a mound of earth, turf, rubble or stone have been classified into groups, including [dolmens](/wiki/Dolmen "Dolmen"), portal dolmens, [gallery graves](/wiki/Gallery_grave "Gallery grave"), [wedge tombs](/wiki/Wedge-shaped_gallery_grave "Wedge-shaped gallery grave"), [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_tomb "Passage tomb"), and [court tombs](/wiki/Court_cairn "Court cairn"). The term "dolmen" describes groupings of erected stones supporting one large, flat roof stone, like an oversized rudimentary table. "Portal dolmens" have an angled stone slab supported by uprights that define a chamber, often with an entrance. "Gallery" graves are elongated dolmens consisting of two rows of upright stones (orthostats) supporting a series of flat roof stones (lintels). "Wedge" tombs are wider at the mouth, and narrower as they recede inward. "Passage tombs" have a long boulder\-built passage that leads to a buried chamber. "Court" tombs are so\-named because they have what appears to be a courtyard encircled by standing stones in front of the tomb chamber. Although many of these structures now appear as freestanding monuments, their stones were often the skeletal substructures of mounds removed by erosion or human action.
A major focus for megalithic chambers is in western Europe: Scandinavia, the British Isles, France, and Iberia. Their origin, chronology and purpose is a subject of ongoing research and debate. In fact, they are not limited to Europe, and are found across Eurasia and the entire globe. Their significance in past cultures is suggested by the labor and resources required to create them. The painstakingly and intricately constructed mounds were significant feats, requiring tens of thousands of hours to construct. For example, it has been speculated that a workforce of 400 working continuously for two months every year would have taken around 16 years to construct the 200,000 tonne cairn at Newgrange.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London: Thames and Hudson. 117\-8\.
In the British Isles it is possible that many different kinds of chambered monument, including those constructed from timber, may have been suited to the creation of optical phenomenon. Recent studies have focused upon one format in particular: the megalithic passage tomb.
#### Passage tombs
Passage tombs comprise a single stone\-built passageway that gives access to a central chamber, and there may be adjoining chambers or cells. This structure is entirely covered by a mound that might consist of earth, rubble, turf or clay. Their distribution extends across the west of Europe. Determining the exact numbers of these sites is problematic due to the poor preservation of many. There are over one hundred and fifty proven passage tombs in Ireland, with an overall estimate of over three hundred in total,Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. 24\-5\. roughly five hundred in Denmark,Nualláin, S.Ó. (1979\). "The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland" in Expedition 21, no. 3, University of Pennsylvania. 11\. See also Møder med Danmarks oldtid (2011\) (exhibition). National Museet, Copenhagen. and over 250 in Scotland.Henshall, A.S. and Ritchie, J.N.G. (2001\). The Chambered Cairns of the Central Highlands. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 98\. Their classification has been further divided into groups such as the Orkney\-Cromarty, Maeshowe and Clava traditions, but all retain the same fundamental format. Their construction likely began in the earlier Neolithic soon after 5600 BPDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1991\). The Chambered Cairns of Caithness. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 83\-4\. and extends to around 4000 BP at excavated examples of Clava Cairn passage tombs,Bradley, R. (2000\). The Good Stones: A new investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\. 160\. but this need not imply that they were constructed or used throughout this time.
#### Passage tomb Preservation
The survival of passage tombs is variable and dependent upon many factors. The excavation of two later Neolithic passage graves at Balnuaran of Clava demonstrated that their architecture was inherently unstable and would have likely collapsed within decades of their construction.Bradley. R. (1998\). "Architecture, Imagination and the Neolithic world." In Creativity in Human Evolution and Prehistory, (Mithen, S., ed.). London: Routledge. 227\-240\. Earlier examples, including the Orkney\-Cromarty format, appear to generally have been more robust. Passage tombs could also be reused in later times, including the Iron Age and early Medieval, and their Neolithic content was sometimes removed. Some were destroyed when new structures were built upon them.Hingley, R. (1996\). "Ancestors and identity in the later prehistory of Atlantic Scotland: the reuse and reinvention of Neolithic monuments and material culture." In World Archaeology 28\. 231\-43\. Most have required consolidation, reconstruction or strengthening to allow public access. In the Boyne Valley, Newgrange and Knowth have undergone significant excavation and restoration.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson.Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. In Orkney, the roof of the chamber within Maeshowe has been restored following damage caused by Vikings in the twelfth century.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\-3\. In some cases, recent building work has significantly altered their appearance, a critical factor that has to be taken into account when observing and interpreting optical phenomena within their passages and chambers.
#### Conundrum of use
Passage tombs across Europe have long been a focus for myths and legends. Medieval lore has it that wizards, giants, witches, or demons erected the great stones, and that the mounds were the homes of gnomes, elves, faeries, and goblins.Burl, A. (1999\). Circles of Stone: The Prehistoric Rings of Britain and Ireland. London: Harvill Press. 9\-11\. In Denmark, passage graves are still referred to as jættestuer (troll houses). An analysis of Irish folk tales revealed that megalithic mounds both served as the burial places of ancient heroes, and were the abodes of supernatural beings.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \& Hudson. 45\.
Many passage tombs do indeed contain the remains of the dead—sometimes in significant quantities. For example, excavations at [Quanterness](/wiki/Chambered_cairn%23Maeshowe "Chambered cairn#Maeshowe") revealed the bones of 157 individuals of various ages, but the total number held within the tomb may have been nearer to 400\.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 154\. Animal remains and artifacts are also found at some sites, including beads, stone balls and pottery.
It appears that burial was not the sole function of passage "tombs". Some sites contain little evidence of human remains, although this could reflect their subsequent histories, while others have evidence for activities by the living. Fires were burnt within sites in OrkneyDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 59\. and at Knowth, Dowth and Newgrange in Ireland there are examples where images were carved in situ upon stones within their interiors.Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson.Jones, A. (2004\). "By Way of Illustration: Art, Memory and Materiality in the Irish Sea and Beyond." In The Neolithic of the Irish Sea: Materiality and Traditions of Practice, (Cummings, V. and Fowler, C., eds.) Oxford: Oxbow. 202\-13\. The passages at a number of sites align with sunrise or sunset at pivotal times of the year causing their otherwise darkened chambers to be illuminated. Many demonstrate extraordinary acoustic properties. Together, these factors suggest that passage tombs might be interpreted as venues for diverse activities that involved both the living and the dead.
### The use of passage tombs as camera obscuras
The principal fieldwork exploring the optical properties of passage tombs has been conducted by Matt Gatton in Denmark, Morgan Saletta in France, Aaron Watson in Wales, Aaron Watson and Ronnie Scott in Scotland, and Eva Bosch in Spain.
#### Format
The format of passage tombs is uniquely suited to the creation and control of optical projections. These structures reproduce the fundamental format of a camera obscuraGatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\. and fieldwork has demonstrated that they can indeed have remarkable projection capabilities.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H. eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press. The chamber offers a dark space while the single passageway enables the movement of light to be closely controlled. In some cases their basic configuration alone is sufficient to cast a projection,Saletta, M. (2011\). "The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion." In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\. 370\-1\. and a small number offer mechanisms through which light can be closely controlled. For example, the roof\-box at Newgrange has evidence for the repeated relocation of quartz blocks that could have been used to manipulate optical projections.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \& Hudson. 96\. In the majority of cases, however, additional apertures were required.
#### Restricted access
The entrances at many passage tombs appear to have been temporarily sealed in a variety of ways: boulders, slabs, blocks, planks or wooden frameworks, as evidenced by postholes by the entrance. Maeshowe has a recess near to the passage entrance that holds a carefully balanced portal stone that can be pivoted into place.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 51\.
This leaves a narrow gap between the top of this block and the passage lintels, thereby allowing light to enter even when the passageway is impassable to people.Ruggles, C. (1999\). Astronomy in Prehistoric Britain and Ireland. London: Yale University Press. 129\. In contrast, the roof box at Newgrange is situated above the passageway, as is a comparable feature within Cairn G at Carrowkeel. These apertures could be operated independently to the passages. Even in the absence of such devices only minor additions \- stone blocks, a hole in a wooden plank, or an animal hide hung between posts at the entrance \- are required to convert the monument into an operational camera obscura. The passage serves as a conduit for light and the rear of the chamber acts as a projection surface.
#### Aperture plane
The character of optical projections within passage tombs is determined by a number of interconnected factors. Lighting inside the monument needs to be low but total darkness is not always required, depending on the relative brightness outside.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Palaeo\-camera and the Concept of Representation." In Pleistocene Coalition News 2 (3\). 5\.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W. and Scott, V. (2010\). "The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The Case for Image Projection in the Palaeolithic." In Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Global State of the Art (SO7\), BAR S2108, (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) 135\-41\. Oxford: Archaeopress. Observations at the Grey Cairns of Camster by Aaron Watson and Ronnie Scott showed that it was possible to cast projections in fog, rain and under heavy cloud, but that such conditions significantly impaired their clarity.Watson, A. (2016\). "Archaeo\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic." In \<www.monumental.uk.com\>. The size and brightness of projections can be adjusted both by modifying the size of the aperture and moving the aperture plane itself in relation to the focal plane, which is frequently the wall of the chamber aligned with the passageway. Increasing the focal distance by moving the aperture along the passage increases the size of the projection but also reduces its brightness. Reducing the aperture diameter results in a more focused, but increasingly dark, image. A further contributing factor is the texture of the surface upon which the image is projected. For example, observations by Aaron Watson have revealed that the slab that constitutes the back wall of the chamber at Bryn Celli Ddu is smooth enough to carry a detailed image.Watson, A. (2016\). "Archaeo\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic." In \<www.monumental.uk.com\>. In contrast, projections inside Cuween Hill fall upon rough stone walling, requiring the distance between the aperture and focal plane to be increased, thereby enlarging the image in order to render it visible.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H. eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
### Types of images projected within Neolithic passage tombs
#### Images of the sun
When aligned upon the sun, a properly configured passage tomb is capable of casting an enlarged image of the solar disc. As long as the aperture remains static this projected solar disc will move along the wall as the sun moves across the sky. During sunrise, for example, the sun's image will appear to travel across the chamber and then out along the walls of the passageway. Gatton has suggested that images carved upon the chamber walls of Cairn T at Loughcrew may reproduce these movements of the sun's disc.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\.
In 2011, archaeologist Morgan Saletta reported solar projections within the sites of Grotte de Bounias and Grotte de la Source during equinoctial sunsets. These were a result of the architectural format of these monuments creating sufficiently restricted apertures to cast a distinct, though unfocused, projection.Saletta, M. (2011\). "The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion." In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\. 370\-1\.
During the time of midsummer sunrise in 2014 and 2015, Aaron Watson documented solar projections within Bryn Celli Ddu. By locating the aperture close to the chamber it was possible to cast a distinct image of nearby trees and the rising sun, together framed by the outline of the passage. In contrast, relocating the aperture to the passage entrance significantly enlarged the sun's disc to a diameter of 10 cm.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
#### Images of aligned monuments
If a passage tomb is aligned upon another monument, the camera obscura method can be used to project recognisable images of that monument into the chamber. For example, while the setting sun shines directly into Maeshowe's chamber when the sun is at its southwestern extreme (winter solstice sunset), there is also a reverse alignment (summer solstice sunrise) when the sun is at its northeastern extreme. This will illuminate the distant Barnhouse Stone such that its image could be projected inside Maeshowe's chamber.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\.
At Balnuaran of Clava, two neighbouring passage tombs share a south\-westerly axis in order that their passageways open towards the midwinter sunset.See Bradley, R. (2000\). The Good Stones: A New Investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\. Not only does the cairn to the south\-west appear centrally framed when looking down the passage from that to the north\-east, but fieldwork by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips has documented how the midwinter setting sun appears to descend directly into the apex of its roof.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\). "Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel." In Current Archaeology 165\. 332\-335\.
#### Images of the landscape
Many passage tombs are set in elevated situations with extensive views, or even focused upon distinctive topographic features. These would therefore appear within optical projections inside their chambers. Aaron Watson has documented optical projections inside Cuween Hill, Orkney, that feature expansive views across the Bay of Firth. Inside the Dwarfie Stane, also in Orkney, it is possible to cast a panoramic image of the uplands of Hoy.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
While the majority of passage tombs may have lost their lintels and roofs it is possible to consider the views that may originally have been projected into their chambers. For example, the ruinous site of Badnabay, north\-west Scotland, appears to be aligned upon a mountain with a distinctive profile.Watson, A. (2016\). "Archaeo\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic." In \<www.monumental.uk.com\>.
#### Images of people
Reflected sunlight can illuminate people located within passage tomb forecourts, creating what Gatton has described as "spirit" projections due to their ephemeral, spectral qualities.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\. When backlit these figures appear as dark silhouettes, but at those times when the sun is behind the monument, and the forecourt area brightly lit, they are enhanced in color and detail. Aaron Watson has photographed optical projections of people inside Cuween Hill, Wideford Hill, Vinquoy Hill, the Dwarfie Stane and the Grey Cairns of Camster.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Camera obscura projections move in real time, although projected human figures appear upside down and back to front. This creates distinctive illusions where individuals, or even groups of people, can appear to emerge from the chamber wall. As the angles between the external subject and the aperture become increasingly oblique, projections can also be cast upon the floor, walls and ceiling of a monument. This can create the illusion of a human shadow moving through the passage tomb.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
### Immersive multisensory experiences within passage tombs
Passage tomb architecture spatially constrains the number of people who can simultaneously occupy their chambers, effectively restricting access to specialist kinds of knowledgeThomas, J. (1992\). "Monuments, Movement and the Context of Megalithic Art." In Vessels for the Ancestors, (Sharples, N. and Sheridan, A., Eds.) Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\-76\. and unusual combinations of sensory experience. Whether these sites embody astronomical orientations, occupy special places in the landscape, or acted as the receptacles for ancestral remains, the camera obscura theory expands the significance and meaning of light entering these monuments.
Inverted images of the outside world, viewed by people located in the depths of a megalithic cairn, would very effectively generate a sense of "otherness".Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press. Furthermore, people in the Neolithic did not share present\-day knowledge of optical physics, and would have had their own understandings. Even from a scientific perspective, however, the act of witnessing the projection of the sun's disc, or human figures emerging from a stone wall, is rather suggestive of an encounter with the supernatural. It has been suggested that projections of the sun may have been interpreted as the manifestation of a Neolithic solar deity.Saletta, M. (2011\). "The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion." In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\. 371\.
Finally, optical projections converge with other sensory qualities of these places, potentially including the presence of the remains of the dead, rock art, and dynamic archaeo\-acoustic sound effects. There is also a possibility that these kinds of experiences were combined and choreographed in order to maximize their theatrical impact upon an audience.Watson, A. (2001\). "The Sounds of Transformation: Acoustics, Monuments and Ritual in the British Neolithic." In The Archaeology of Shamanism, (Price, N., ed.) London: Routledge. 178\-92\. Rather than silent places of the death, passage tombs may have acted as places where people could engage with powerful multi\-sensory experiences.
|
[
"Neolithic archaeological optics\n-------------------------------",
"The [Neolithic](/wiki/Neolithic \"Neolithic\") period offers the possibility to explore optical image projections within built architecture. Neolithic structures range from modest houses to enormous enclosures and mounds, and were constructed using combinations of earth, timber and stone. Archaeo\\-optic fieldwork has focused upon [megalithic](/wiki/Megalithic \"Megalithic\") monuments.",
"### Megalithic structures",
"Megaliths, or large stones, come in two main types of architectural presentations: freestanding and earth\\-covered. Individual and groupings of standing stones — in formations of circles, lines, ovals, ‘U’\\-shapes, or rectangles — were not employed to support the weight of soil above them, but served as markers. Megalithic chambers designed to bear the weight of a mound of earth, turf, rubble or stone have been classified into groups, including [dolmens](/wiki/Dolmen \"Dolmen\"), portal dolmens, [gallery graves](/wiki/Gallery_grave \"Gallery grave\"), [wedge tombs](/wiki/Wedge-shaped_gallery_grave \"Wedge-shaped gallery grave\"), [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_tomb \"Passage tomb\"), and [court tombs](/wiki/Court_cairn \"Court cairn\"). The term \"dolmen\" describes groupings of erected stones supporting one large, flat roof stone, like an oversized rudimentary table. \"Portal dolmens\" have an angled stone slab supported by uprights that define a chamber, often with an entrance. \"Gallery\" graves are elongated dolmens consisting of two rows of upright stones (orthostats) supporting a series of flat roof stones (lintels). \"Wedge\" tombs are wider at the mouth, and narrower as they recede inward. \"Passage tombs\" have a long boulder\\-built passage that leads to a buried chamber. \"Court\" tombs are so\\-named because they have what appears to be a courtyard encircled by standing stones in front of the tomb chamber. Although many of these structures now appear as freestanding monuments, their stones were often the skeletal substructures of mounds removed by erosion or human action.",
"A major focus for megalithic chambers is in western Europe: Scandinavia, the British Isles, France, and Iberia. Their origin, chronology and purpose is a subject of ongoing research and debate. In fact, they are not limited to Europe, and are found across Eurasia and the entire globe. Their significance in past cultures is suggested by the labor and resources required to create them. The painstakingly and intricately constructed mounds were significant feats, requiring tens of thousands of hours to construct. For example, it has been speculated that a workforce of 400 working continuously for two months every year would have taken around 16 years to construct the 200,000 tonne cairn at Newgrange.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London: Thames and Hudson. 117\\-8\\.",
"In the British Isles it is possible that many different kinds of chambered monument, including those constructed from timber, may have been suited to the creation of optical phenomenon. Recent studies have focused upon one format in particular: the megalithic passage tomb.",
"#### Passage tombs",
"Passage tombs comprise a single stone\\-built passageway that gives access to a central chamber, and there may be adjoining chambers or cells. This structure is entirely covered by a mound that might consist of earth, rubble, turf or clay. Their distribution extends across the west of Europe. Determining the exact numbers of these sites is problematic due to the poor preservation of many. There are over one hundred and fifty proven passage tombs in Ireland, with an overall estimate of over three hundred in total,Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. 24\\-5\\. roughly five hundred in Denmark,Nualláin, S.Ó. (1979\\). \"The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland\" in Expedition 21, no. 3, University of Pennsylvania. 11\\. See also Møder med Danmarks oldtid (2011\\) (exhibition). National Museet, Copenhagen. and over 250 in Scotland.Henshall, A.S. and Ritchie, J.N.G. (2001\\). The Chambered Cairns of the Central Highlands. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 98\\. Their classification has been further divided into groups such as the Orkney\\-Cromarty, Maeshowe and Clava traditions, but all retain the same fundamental format. Their construction likely began in the earlier Neolithic soon after 5600 BPDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1991\\). The Chambered Cairns of Caithness. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 83\\-4\\. and extends to around 4000 BP at excavated examples of Clava Cairn passage tombs,Bradley, R. (2000\\). The Good Stones: A new investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\\. 160\\. but this need not imply that they were constructed or used throughout this time.",
"#### Passage tomb Preservation",
"The survival of passage tombs is variable and dependent upon many factors. The excavation of two later Neolithic passage graves at Balnuaran of Clava demonstrated that their architecture was inherently unstable and would have likely collapsed within decades of their construction.Bradley. R. (1998\\). \"Architecture, Imagination and the Neolithic world.\" In Creativity in Human Evolution and Prehistory, (Mithen, S., ed.). London: Routledge. 227\\-240\\. Earlier examples, including the Orkney\\-Cromarty format, appear to generally have been more robust. Passage tombs could also be reused in later times, including the Iron Age and early Medieval, and their Neolithic content was sometimes removed. Some were destroyed when new structures were built upon them.Hingley, R. (1996\\). \"Ancestors and identity in the later prehistory of Atlantic Scotland: the reuse and reinvention of Neolithic monuments and material culture.\" In World Archaeology 28\\. 231\\-43\\. Most have required consolidation, reconstruction or strengthening to allow public access. In the Boyne Valley, Newgrange and Knowth have undergone significant excavation and restoration.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson.Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. In Orkney, the roof of the chamber within Maeshowe has been restored following damage caused by Vikings in the twelfth century.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\\-3\\. In some cases, recent building work has significantly altered their appearance, a critical factor that has to be taken into account when observing and interpreting optical phenomena within their passages and chambers.",
"#### Conundrum of use",
"Passage tombs across Europe have long been a focus for myths and legends. Medieval lore has it that wizards, giants, witches, or demons erected the great stones, and that the mounds were the homes of gnomes, elves, faeries, and goblins.Burl, A. (1999\\). Circles of Stone: The Prehistoric Rings of Britain and Ireland. London: Harvill Press. 9\\-11\\. In Denmark, passage graves are still referred to as jættestuer (troll houses). An analysis of Irish folk tales revealed that megalithic mounds both served as the burial places of ancient heroes, and were the abodes of supernatural beings.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \\& Hudson. 45\\.",
"Many passage tombs do indeed contain the remains of the dead—sometimes in significant quantities. For example, excavations at [Quanterness](/wiki/Chambered_cairn%23Maeshowe \"Chambered cairn#Maeshowe\") revealed the bones of 157 individuals of various ages, but the total number held within the tomb may have been nearer to 400\\.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 154\\. Animal remains and artifacts are also found at some sites, including beads, stone balls and pottery.",
"It appears that burial was not the sole function of passage \"tombs\". Some sites contain little evidence of human remains, although this could reflect their subsequent histories, while others have evidence for activities by the living. Fires were burnt within sites in OrkneyDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 59\\. and at Knowth, Dowth and Newgrange in Ireland there are examples where images were carved in situ upon stones within their interiors.Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson.Jones, A. (2004\\). \"By Way of Illustration: Art, Memory and Materiality in the Irish Sea and Beyond.\" In The Neolithic of the Irish Sea: Materiality and Traditions of Practice, (Cummings, V. and Fowler, C., eds.) Oxford: Oxbow. 202\\-13\\. The passages at a number of sites align with sunrise or sunset at pivotal times of the year causing their otherwise darkened chambers to be illuminated. Many demonstrate extraordinary acoustic properties. Together, these factors suggest that passage tombs might be interpreted as venues for diverse activities that involved both the living and the dead.",
"### The use of passage tombs as camera obscuras",
"The principal fieldwork exploring the optical properties of passage tombs has been conducted by Matt Gatton in Denmark, Morgan Saletta in France, Aaron Watson in Wales, Aaron Watson and Ronnie Scott in Scotland, and Eva Bosch in Spain.",
"#### Format",
"The format of passage tombs is uniquely suited to the creation and control of optical projections. These structures reproduce the fundamental format of a camera obscuraGatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\. and fieldwork has demonstrated that they can indeed have remarkable projection capabilities.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H. eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press. The chamber offers a dark space while the single passageway enables the movement of light to be closely controlled. In some cases their basic configuration alone is sufficient to cast a projection,Saletta, M. (2011\\). \"The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion.\" In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\\. 370\\-1\\. and a small number offer mechanisms through which light can be closely controlled. For example, the roof\\-box at Newgrange has evidence for the repeated relocation of quartz blocks that could have been used to manipulate optical projections.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \\& Hudson. 96\\. In the majority of cases, however, additional apertures were required.",
"#### Restricted access",
"The entrances at many passage tombs appear to have been temporarily sealed in a variety of ways: boulders, slabs, blocks, planks or wooden frameworks, as evidenced by postholes by the entrance. Maeshowe has a recess near to the passage entrance that holds a carefully balanced portal stone that can be pivoted into place.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 51\\.\n This leaves a narrow gap between the top of this block and the passage lintels, thereby allowing light to enter even when the passageway is impassable to people.Ruggles, C. (1999\\). Astronomy in Prehistoric Britain and Ireland. London: Yale University Press. 129\\. In contrast, the roof box at Newgrange is situated above the passageway, as is a comparable feature within Cairn G at Carrowkeel. These apertures could be operated independently to the passages. Even in the absence of such devices only minor additions \\- stone blocks, a hole in a wooden plank, or an animal hide hung between posts at the entrance \\- are required to convert the monument into an operational camera obscura. The passage serves as a conduit for light and the rear of the chamber acts as a projection surface.",
"#### Aperture plane",
"The character of optical projections within passage tombs is determined by a number of interconnected factors. Lighting inside the monument needs to be low but total darkness is not always required, depending on the relative brightness outside.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Palaeo\\-camera and the Concept of Representation.\" In Pleistocene Coalition News 2 (3\\). 5\\.Gatton, M., Carreon, L., Cawein, M., Brock, W. and Scott, V. (2010\\). \"The Camera Obscura and the Origin of Art: The Case for Image Projection in the Palaeolithic.\" In Proceedings of the XV World Congress of the Union Internationale des Sciences Préhistoriques et Protohistoriques (UISPP) 35, Global State of the Art (SO7\\), BAR S2108, (Kumar, G. and Bednarik, R., eds.) 135\\-41\\. Oxford: Archaeopress. Observations at the Grey Cairns of Camster by Aaron Watson and Ronnie Scott showed that it was possible to cast projections in fog, rain and under heavy cloud, but that such conditions significantly impaired their clarity.Watson, A. (2016\\). \"Archaeo\\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic.\" In \\<www.monumental.uk.com\\>. The size and brightness of projections can be adjusted both by modifying the size of the aperture and moving the aperture plane itself in relation to the focal plane, which is frequently the wall of the chamber aligned with the passageway. Increasing the focal distance by moving the aperture along the passage increases the size of the projection but also reduces its brightness. Reducing the aperture diameter results in a more focused, but increasingly dark, image. A further contributing factor is the texture of the surface upon which the image is projected. For example, observations by Aaron Watson have revealed that the slab that constitutes the back wall of the chamber at Bryn Celli Ddu is smooth enough to carry a detailed image.Watson, A. (2016\\). \"Archaeo\\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic.\" In \\<www.monumental.uk.com\\>. In contrast, projections inside Cuween Hill fall upon rough stone walling, requiring the distance between the aperture and focal plane to be increased, thereby enlarging the image in order to render it visible.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H. eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"### Types of images projected within Neolithic passage tombs",
"#### Images of the sun",
"When aligned upon the sun, a properly configured passage tomb is capable of casting an enlarged image of the solar disc. As long as the aperture remains static this projected solar disc will move along the wall as the sun moves across the sky. During sunrise, for example, the sun's image will appear to travel across the chamber and then out along the walls of the passageway. Gatton has suggested that images carved upon the chamber walls of Cairn T at Loughcrew may reproduce these movements of the sun's disc.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\.",
"In 2011, archaeologist Morgan Saletta reported solar projections within the sites of Grotte de Bounias and Grotte de la Source during equinoctial sunsets. These were a result of the architectural format of these monuments creating sufficiently restricted apertures to cast a distinct, though unfocused, projection.Saletta, M. (2011\\). \"The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion.\" In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\\. 370\\-1\\.",
"During the time of midsummer sunrise in 2014 and 2015, Aaron Watson documented solar projections within Bryn Celli Ddu. By locating the aperture close to the chamber it was possible to cast a distinct image of nearby trees and the rising sun, together framed by the outline of the passage. In contrast, relocating the aperture to the passage entrance significantly enlarged the sun's disc to a diameter of 10 cm.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"#### Images of aligned monuments",
"If a passage tomb is aligned upon another monument, the camera obscura method can be used to project recognisable images of that monument into the chamber. For example, while the setting sun shines directly into Maeshowe's chamber when the sun is at its southwestern extreme (winter solstice sunset), there is also a reverse alignment (summer solstice sunrise) when the sun is at its northeastern extreme. This will illuminate the distant Barnhouse Stone such that its image could be projected inside Maeshowe's chamber.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\.",
"At Balnuaran of Clava, two neighbouring passage tombs share a south\\-westerly axis in order that their passageways open towards the midwinter sunset.See Bradley, R. (2000\\). The Good Stones: A New Investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\\. Not only does the cairn to the south\\-west appear centrally framed when looking down the passage from that to the north\\-east, but fieldwork by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips has documented how the midwinter setting sun appears to descend directly into the apex of its roof.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\\). \"Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel.\" In Current Archaeology 165\\. 332\\-335\\.",
"#### Images of the landscape",
"Many passage tombs are set in elevated situations with extensive views, or even focused upon distinctive topographic features. These would therefore appear within optical projections inside their chambers. Aaron Watson has documented optical projections inside Cuween Hill, Orkney, that feature expansive views across the Bay of Firth. Inside the Dwarfie Stane, also in Orkney, it is possible to cast a panoramic image of the uplands of Hoy.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"While the majority of passage tombs may have lost their lintels and roofs it is possible to consider the views that may originally have been projected into their chambers. For example, the ruinous site of Badnabay, north\\-west Scotland, appears to be aligned upon a mountain with a distinctive profile.Watson, A. (2016\\). \"Archaeo\\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic.\" In \\<www.monumental.uk.com\\>.",
"#### Images of people",
"Reflected sunlight can illuminate people located within passage tomb forecourts, creating what Gatton has described as \"spirit\" projections due to their ephemeral, spectral qualities.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\. When backlit these figures appear as dark silhouettes, but at those times when the sun is behind the monument, and the forecourt area brightly lit, they are enhanced in color and detail. Aaron Watson has photographed optical projections of people inside Cuween Hill, Wideford Hill, Vinquoy Hill, the Dwarfie Stane and the Grey Cairns of Camster.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"Camera obscura projections move in real time, although projected human figures appear upside down and back to front. This creates distinctive illusions where individuals, or even groups of people, can appear to emerge from the chamber wall. As the angles between the external subject and the aperture become increasingly oblique, projections can also be cast upon the floor, walls and ceiling of a monument. This can create the illusion of a human shadow moving through the passage tomb.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"### Immersive multisensory experiences within passage tombs",
"Passage tomb architecture spatially constrains the number of people who can simultaneously occupy their chambers, effectively restricting access to specialist kinds of knowledgeThomas, J. (1992\\). \"Monuments, Movement and the Context of Megalithic Art.\" In Vessels for the Ancestors, (Sharples, N. and Sheridan, A., Eds.) Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\\-76\\. and unusual combinations of sensory experience. Whether these sites embody astronomical orientations, occupy special places in the landscape, or acted as the receptacles for ancestral remains, the camera obscura theory expands the significance and meaning of light entering these monuments.",
"Inverted images of the outside world, viewed by people located in the depths of a megalithic cairn, would very effectively generate a sense of \"otherness\".Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press. Furthermore, people in the Neolithic did not share present\\-day knowledge of optical physics, and would have had their own understandings. Even from a scientific perspective, however, the act of witnessing the projection of the sun's disc, or human figures emerging from a stone wall, is rather suggestive of an encounter with the supernatural. It has been suggested that projections of the sun may have been interpreted as the manifestation of a Neolithic solar deity.Saletta, M. (2011\\). \"The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion.\" In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\\. 371\\.",
"Finally, optical projections converge with other sensory qualities of these places, potentially including the presence of the remains of the dead, rock art, and dynamic archaeo\\-acoustic sound effects. There is also a possibility that these kinds of experiences were combined and choreographed in order to maximize their theatrical impact upon an audience.Watson, A. (2001\\). \"The Sounds of Transformation: Acoustics, Monuments and Ritual in the British Neolithic.\" In The Archaeology of Shamanism, (Price, N., ed.) London: Routledge. 178\\-92\\. Rather than silent places of the death, passage tombs may have acted as places where people could engage with powerful multi\\-sensory experiences.",
""
] |
### Megalithic structures
Megaliths, or large stones, come in two main types of architectural presentations: freestanding and earth\-covered. Individual and groupings of standing stones — in formations of circles, lines, ovals, ‘U’\-shapes, or rectangles — were not employed to support the weight of soil above them, but served as markers. Megalithic chambers designed to bear the weight of a mound of earth, turf, rubble or stone have been classified into groups, including [dolmens](/wiki/Dolmen "Dolmen"), portal dolmens, [gallery graves](/wiki/Gallery_grave "Gallery grave"), [wedge tombs](/wiki/Wedge-shaped_gallery_grave "Wedge-shaped gallery grave"), [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_tomb "Passage tomb"), and [court tombs](/wiki/Court_cairn "Court cairn"). The term "dolmen" describes groupings of erected stones supporting one large, flat roof stone, like an oversized rudimentary table. "Portal dolmens" have an angled stone slab supported by uprights that define a chamber, often with an entrance. "Gallery" graves are elongated dolmens consisting of two rows of upright stones (orthostats) supporting a series of flat roof stones (lintels). "Wedge" tombs are wider at the mouth, and narrower as they recede inward. "Passage tombs" have a long boulder\-built passage that leads to a buried chamber. "Court" tombs are so\-named because they have what appears to be a courtyard encircled by standing stones in front of the tomb chamber. Although many of these structures now appear as freestanding monuments, their stones were often the skeletal substructures of mounds removed by erosion or human action.
A major focus for megalithic chambers is in western Europe: Scandinavia, the British Isles, France, and Iberia. Their origin, chronology and purpose is a subject of ongoing research and debate. In fact, they are not limited to Europe, and are found across Eurasia and the entire globe. Their significance in past cultures is suggested by the labor and resources required to create them. The painstakingly and intricately constructed mounds were significant feats, requiring tens of thousands of hours to construct. For example, it has been speculated that a workforce of 400 working continuously for two months every year would have taken around 16 years to construct the 200,000 tonne cairn at Newgrange.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London: Thames and Hudson. 117\-8\.
In the British Isles it is possible that many different kinds of chambered monument, including those constructed from timber, may have been suited to the creation of optical phenomenon. Recent studies have focused upon one format in particular: the megalithic passage tomb.
#### Passage tombs
Passage tombs comprise a single stone\-built passageway that gives access to a central chamber, and there may be adjoining chambers or cells. This structure is entirely covered by a mound that might consist of earth, rubble, turf or clay. Their distribution extends across the west of Europe. Determining the exact numbers of these sites is problematic due to the poor preservation of many. There are over one hundred and fifty proven passage tombs in Ireland, with an overall estimate of over three hundred in total,Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. 24\-5\. roughly five hundred in Denmark,Nualláin, S.Ó. (1979\). "The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland" in Expedition 21, no. 3, University of Pennsylvania. 11\. See also Møder med Danmarks oldtid (2011\) (exhibition). National Museet, Copenhagen. and over 250 in Scotland.Henshall, A.S. and Ritchie, J.N.G. (2001\). The Chambered Cairns of the Central Highlands. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 98\. Their classification has been further divided into groups such as the Orkney\-Cromarty, Maeshowe and Clava traditions, but all retain the same fundamental format. Their construction likely began in the earlier Neolithic soon after 5600 BPDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1991\). The Chambered Cairns of Caithness. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 83\-4\. and extends to around 4000 BP at excavated examples of Clava Cairn passage tombs,Bradley, R. (2000\). The Good Stones: A new investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\. 160\. but this need not imply that they were constructed or used throughout this time.
#### Passage tomb Preservation
The survival of passage tombs is variable and dependent upon many factors. The excavation of two later Neolithic passage graves at Balnuaran of Clava demonstrated that their architecture was inherently unstable and would have likely collapsed within decades of their construction.Bradley. R. (1998\). "Architecture, Imagination and the Neolithic world." In Creativity in Human Evolution and Prehistory, (Mithen, S., ed.). London: Routledge. 227\-240\. Earlier examples, including the Orkney\-Cromarty format, appear to generally have been more robust. Passage tombs could also be reused in later times, including the Iron Age and early Medieval, and their Neolithic content was sometimes removed. Some were destroyed when new structures were built upon them.Hingley, R. (1996\). "Ancestors and identity in the later prehistory of Atlantic Scotland: the reuse and reinvention of Neolithic monuments and material culture." In World Archaeology 28\. 231\-43\. Most have required consolidation, reconstruction or strengthening to allow public access. In the Boyne Valley, Newgrange and Knowth have undergone significant excavation and restoration.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson.Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. In Orkney, the roof of the chamber within Maeshowe has been restored following damage caused by Vikings in the twelfth century.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\-3\. In some cases, recent building work has significantly altered their appearance, a critical factor that has to be taken into account when observing and interpreting optical phenomena within their passages and chambers.
#### Conundrum of use
Passage tombs across Europe have long been a focus for myths and legends. Medieval lore has it that wizards, giants, witches, or demons erected the great stones, and that the mounds were the homes of gnomes, elves, faeries, and goblins.Burl, A. (1999\). Circles of Stone: The Prehistoric Rings of Britain and Ireland. London: Harvill Press. 9\-11\. In Denmark, passage graves are still referred to as jættestuer (troll houses). An analysis of Irish folk tales revealed that megalithic mounds both served as the burial places of ancient heroes, and were the abodes of supernatural beings.O’Kelly, M. (1982\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \& Hudson. 45\.
Many passage tombs do indeed contain the remains of the dead—sometimes in significant quantities. For example, excavations at [Quanterness](/wiki/Chambered_cairn%23Maeshowe "Chambered cairn#Maeshowe") revealed the bones of 157 individuals of various ages, but the total number held within the tomb may have been nearer to 400\.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 154\. Animal remains and artifacts are also found at some sites, including beads, stone balls and pottery.
It appears that burial was not the sole function of passage "tombs". Some sites contain little evidence of human remains, although this could reflect their subsequent histories, while others have evidence for activities by the living. Fires were burnt within sites in OrkneyDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 59\. and at Knowth, Dowth and Newgrange in Ireland there are examples where images were carved in situ upon stones within their interiors.Eogan, G. (1986\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson.Jones, A. (2004\). "By Way of Illustration: Art, Memory and Materiality in the Irish Sea and Beyond." In The Neolithic of the Irish Sea: Materiality and Traditions of Practice, (Cummings, V. and Fowler, C., eds.) Oxford: Oxbow. 202\-13\. The passages at a number of sites align with sunrise or sunset at pivotal times of the year causing their otherwise darkened chambers to be illuminated. Many demonstrate extraordinary acoustic properties. Together, these factors suggest that passage tombs might be interpreted as venues for diverse activities that involved both the living and the dead.
|
[
"### Megalithic structures",
"Megaliths, or large stones, come in two main types of architectural presentations: freestanding and earth\\-covered. Individual and groupings of standing stones — in formations of circles, lines, ovals, ‘U’\\-shapes, or rectangles — were not employed to support the weight of soil above them, but served as markers. Megalithic chambers designed to bear the weight of a mound of earth, turf, rubble or stone have been classified into groups, including [dolmens](/wiki/Dolmen \"Dolmen\"), portal dolmens, [gallery graves](/wiki/Gallery_grave \"Gallery grave\"), [wedge tombs](/wiki/Wedge-shaped_gallery_grave \"Wedge-shaped gallery grave\"), [passage tombs](/wiki/Passage_tomb \"Passage tomb\"), and [court tombs](/wiki/Court_cairn \"Court cairn\"). The term \"dolmen\" describes groupings of erected stones supporting one large, flat roof stone, like an oversized rudimentary table. \"Portal dolmens\" have an angled stone slab supported by uprights that define a chamber, often with an entrance. \"Gallery\" graves are elongated dolmens consisting of two rows of upright stones (orthostats) supporting a series of flat roof stones (lintels). \"Wedge\" tombs are wider at the mouth, and narrower as they recede inward. \"Passage tombs\" have a long boulder\\-built passage that leads to a buried chamber. \"Court\" tombs are so\\-named because they have what appears to be a courtyard encircled by standing stones in front of the tomb chamber. Although many of these structures now appear as freestanding monuments, their stones were often the skeletal substructures of mounds removed by erosion or human action.",
"A major focus for megalithic chambers is in western Europe: Scandinavia, the British Isles, France, and Iberia. Their origin, chronology and purpose is a subject of ongoing research and debate. In fact, they are not limited to Europe, and are found across Eurasia and the entire globe. Their significance in past cultures is suggested by the labor and resources required to create them. The painstakingly and intricately constructed mounds were significant feats, requiring tens of thousands of hours to construct. For example, it has been speculated that a workforce of 400 working continuously for two months every year would have taken around 16 years to construct the 200,000 tonne cairn at Newgrange.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London: Thames and Hudson. 117\\-8\\.",
"In the British Isles it is possible that many different kinds of chambered monument, including those constructed from timber, may have been suited to the creation of optical phenomenon. Recent studies have focused upon one format in particular: the megalithic passage tomb.",
"#### Passage tombs",
"Passage tombs comprise a single stone\\-built passageway that gives access to a central chamber, and there may be adjoining chambers or cells. This structure is entirely covered by a mound that might consist of earth, rubble, turf or clay. Their distribution extends across the west of Europe. Determining the exact numbers of these sites is problematic due to the poor preservation of many. There are over one hundred and fifty proven passage tombs in Ireland, with an overall estimate of over three hundred in total,Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. 24\\-5\\. roughly five hundred in Denmark,Nualláin, S.Ó. (1979\\). \"The Megalithic Tombs of Ireland\" in Expedition 21, no. 3, University of Pennsylvania. 11\\. See also Møder med Danmarks oldtid (2011\\) (exhibition). National Museet, Copenhagen. and over 250 in Scotland.Henshall, A.S. and Ritchie, J.N.G. (2001\\). The Chambered Cairns of the Central Highlands. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 98\\. Their classification has been further divided into groups such as the Orkney\\-Cromarty, Maeshowe and Clava traditions, but all retain the same fundamental format. Their construction likely began in the earlier Neolithic soon after 5600 BPDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1991\\). The Chambered Cairns of Caithness. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 83\\-4\\. and extends to around 4000 BP at excavated examples of Clava Cairn passage tombs,Bradley, R. (2000\\). The Good Stones: A new investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\\. 160\\. but this need not imply that they were constructed or used throughout this time.",
"#### Passage tomb Preservation",
"The survival of passage tombs is variable and dependent upon many factors. The excavation of two later Neolithic passage graves at Balnuaran of Clava demonstrated that their architecture was inherently unstable and would have likely collapsed within decades of their construction.Bradley. R. (1998\\). \"Architecture, Imagination and the Neolithic world.\" In Creativity in Human Evolution and Prehistory, (Mithen, S., ed.). London: Routledge. 227\\-240\\. Earlier examples, including the Orkney\\-Cromarty format, appear to generally have been more robust. Passage tombs could also be reused in later times, including the Iron Age and early Medieval, and their Neolithic content was sometimes removed. Some were destroyed when new structures were built upon them.Hingley, R. (1996\\). \"Ancestors and identity in the later prehistory of Atlantic Scotland: the reuse and reinvention of Neolithic monuments and material culture.\" In World Archaeology 28\\. 231\\-43\\. Most have required consolidation, reconstruction or strengthening to allow public access. In the Boyne Valley, Newgrange and Knowth have undergone significant excavation and restoration.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange. Archaeology, Art and Legend. London, Thames and Hudson.Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson. In Orkney, the roof of the chamber within Maeshowe has been restored following damage caused by Vikings in the twelfth century.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 62\\-3\\. In some cases, recent building work has significantly altered their appearance, a critical factor that has to be taken into account when observing and interpreting optical phenomena within their passages and chambers.",
"#### Conundrum of use",
"Passage tombs across Europe have long been a focus for myths and legends. Medieval lore has it that wizards, giants, witches, or demons erected the great stones, and that the mounds were the homes of gnomes, elves, faeries, and goblins.Burl, A. (1999\\). Circles of Stone: The Prehistoric Rings of Britain and Ireland. London: Harvill Press. 9\\-11\\. In Denmark, passage graves are still referred to as jættestuer (troll houses). An analysis of Irish folk tales revealed that megalithic mounds both served as the burial places of ancient heroes, and were the abodes of supernatural beings.O’Kelly, M. (1982\\). Newgrange: Archaeology, art and legend. London: Thames \\& Hudson. 45\\.",
"Many passage tombs do indeed contain the remains of the dead—sometimes in significant quantities. For example, excavations at [Quanterness](/wiki/Chambered_cairn%23Maeshowe \"Chambered cairn#Maeshowe\") revealed the bones of 157 individuals of various ages, but the total number held within the tomb may have been nearer to 400\\.Davidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 154\\. Animal remains and artifacts are also found at some sites, including beads, stone balls and pottery.",
"It appears that burial was not the sole function of passage \"tombs\". Some sites contain little evidence of human remains, although this could reflect their subsequent histories, while others have evidence for activities by the living. Fires were burnt within sites in OrkneyDavidson, J.L. and Henshall, A.S. (1989\\). The Chambered Cairns of Orkney. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. 59\\. and at Knowth, Dowth and Newgrange in Ireland there are examples where images were carved in situ upon stones within their interiors.Eogan, G. (1986\\). Knowth and the passage tombs of Ireland. London: Thames and Hudson.Jones, A. (2004\\). \"By Way of Illustration: Art, Memory and Materiality in the Irish Sea and Beyond.\" In The Neolithic of the Irish Sea: Materiality and Traditions of Practice, (Cummings, V. and Fowler, C., eds.) Oxford: Oxbow. 202\\-13\\. The passages at a number of sites align with sunrise or sunset at pivotal times of the year causing their otherwise darkened chambers to be illuminated. Many demonstrate extraordinary acoustic properties. Together, these factors suggest that passage tombs might be interpreted as venues for diverse activities that involved both the living and the dead.",
""
] |
### Types of images projected within Neolithic passage tombs
#### Images of the sun
When aligned upon the sun, a properly configured passage tomb is capable of casting an enlarged image of the solar disc. As long as the aperture remains static this projected solar disc will move along the wall as the sun moves across the sky. During sunrise, for example, the sun's image will appear to travel across the chamber and then out along the walls of the passageway. Gatton has suggested that images carved upon the chamber walls of Cairn T at Loughcrew may reproduce these movements of the sun's disc.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\.
In 2011, archaeologist Morgan Saletta reported solar projections within the sites of Grotte de Bounias and Grotte de la Source during equinoctial sunsets. These were a result of the architectural format of these monuments creating sufficiently restricted apertures to cast a distinct, though unfocused, projection.Saletta, M. (2011\). "The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion." In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\. 370\-1\.
During the time of midsummer sunrise in 2014 and 2015, Aaron Watson documented solar projections within Bryn Celli Ddu. By locating the aperture close to the chamber it was possible to cast a distinct image of nearby trees and the rising sun, together framed by the outline of the passage. In contrast, relocating the aperture to the passage entrance significantly enlarged the sun's disc to a diameter of 10 cm.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
#### Images of aligned monuments
If a passage tomb is aligned upon another monument, the camera obscura method can be used to project recognisable images of that monument into the chamber. For example, while the setting sun shines directly into Maeshowe's chamber when the sun is at its southwestern extreme (winter solstice sunset), there is also a reverse alignment (summer solstice sunrise) when the sun is at its northeastern extreme. This will illuminate the distant Barnhouse Stone such that its image could be projected inside Maeshowe's chamber.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\.
At Balnuaran of Clava, two neighbouring passage tombs share a south\-westerly axis in order that their passageways open towards the midwinter sunset.See Bradley, R. (2000\). The Good Stones: A New Investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\. Not only does the cairn to the south\-west appear centrally framed when looking down the passage from that to the north\-east, but fieldwork by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips has documented how the midwinter setting sun appears to descend directly into the apex of its roof.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\). "Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel." In Current Archaeology 165\. 332\-335\.
#### Images of the landscape
Many passage tombs are set in elevated situations with extensive views, or even focused upon distinctive topographic features. These would therefore appear within optical projections inside their chambers. Aaron Watson has documented optical projections inside Cuween Hill, Orkney, that feature expansive views across the Bay of Firth. Inside the Dwarfie Stane, also in Orkney, it is possible to cast a panoramic image of the uplands of Hoy.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
While the majority of passage tombs may have lost their lintels and roofs it is possible to consider the views that may originally have been projected into their chambers. For example, the ruinous site of Badnabay, north\-west Scotland, appears to be aligned upon a mountain with a distinctive profile.Watson, A. (2016\). "Archaeo\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic." In \<www.monumental.uk.com\>.
#### Images of people
Reflected sunlight can illuminate people located within passage tomb forecourts, creating what Gatton has described as "spirit" projections due to their ephemeral, spectral qualities.Gatton, M. (2010\). "Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life." In \<Paleo\-camera.com\> 9 March 2010\. When backlit these figures appear as dark silhouettes, but at those times when the sun is behind the monument, and the forecourt area brightly lit, they are enhanced in color and detail. Aaron Watson has photographed optical projections of people inside Cuween Hill, Wideford Hill, Vinquoy Hill, the Dwarfie Stane and the Grey Cairns of Camster.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Camera obscura projections move in real time, although projected human figures appear upside down and back to front. This creates distinctive illusions where individuals, or even groups of people, can appear to emerge from the chamber wall. As the angles between the external subject and the aperture become increasingly oblique, projections can also be cast upon the floor, walls and ceiling of a monument. This can create the illusion of a human shadow moving through the passage tomb.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\). "Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland." In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
|
[
"### Types of images projected within Neolithic passage tombs",
"#### Images of the sun",
"When aligned upon the sun, a properly configured passage tomb is capable of casting an enlarged image of the solar disc. As long as the aperture remains static this projected solar disc will move along the wall as the sun moves across the sky. During sunrise, for example, the sun's image will appear to travel across the chamber and then out along the walls of the passageway. Gatton has suggested that images carved upon the chamber walls of Cairn T at Loughcrew may reproduce these movements of the sun's disc.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\.",
"In 2011, archaeologist Morgan Saletta reported solar projections within the sites of Grotte de Bounias and Grotte de la Source during equinoctial sunsets. These were a result of the architectural format of these monuments creating sufficiently restricted apertures to cast a distinct, though unfocused, projection.Saletta, M. (2011\\). \"The Archaeoastronomy of the Megalithic Monuments of Arles\\-Fontvieille: The Equinox, the Pleiades and Orion.\" In Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union 7\\. 370\\-1\\.",
"During the time of midsummer sunrise in 2014 and 2015, Aaron Watson documented solar projections within Bryn Celli Ddu. By locating the aperture close to the chamber it was possible to cast a distinct image of nearby trees and the rising sun, together framed by the outline of the passage. In contrast, relocating the aperture to the passage entrance significantly enlarged the sun's disc to a diameter of 10 cm.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"#### Images of aligned monuments",
"If a passage tomb is aligned upon another monument, the camera obscura method can be used to project recognisable images of that monument into the chamber. For example, while the setting sun shines directly into Maeshowe's chamber when the sun is at its southwestern extreme (winter solstice sunset), there is also a reverse alignment (summer solstice sunrise) when the sun is at its northeastern extreme. This will illuminate the distant Barnhouse Stone such that its image could be projected inside Maeshowe's chamber.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\.",
"At Balnuaran of Clava, two neighbouring passage tombs share a south\\-westerly axis in order that their passageways open towards the midwinter sunset.See Bradley, R. (2000\\). The Good Stones: A New Investigation of the Clava Cairns. Edinburgh: Society of Antiquaries of Scotland Monograph 17\\. Not only does the cairn to the south\\-west appear centrally framed when looking down the passage from that to the north\\-east, but fieldwork by Ronnie Scott and Tim Phillips has documented how the midwinter setting sun appears to descend directly into the apex of its roof.Scott, R. and Phillips, T. (1999\\). \"Clava: Light at the End of the Tunnel.\" In Current Archaeology 165\\. 332\\-335\\.",
"#### Images of the landscape",
"Many passage tombs are set in elevated situations with extensive views, or even focused upon distinctive topographic features. These would therefore appear within optical projections inside their chambers. Aaron Watson has documented optical projections inside Cuween Hill, Orkney, that feature expansive views across the Bay of Firth. Inside the Dwarfie Stane, also in Orkney, it is possible to cast a panoramic image of the uplands of Hoy.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"While the majority of passage tombs may have lost their lintels and roofs it is possible to consider the views that may originally have been projected into their chambers. For example, the ruinous site of Badnabay, north\\-west Scotland, appears to be aligned upon a mountain with a distinctive profile.Watson, A. (2016\\). \"Archaeo\\-optics and image projection in the Neolithic.\" In \\<www.monumental.uk.com\\>.",
"#### Images of people",
"Reflected sunlight can illuminate people located within passage tomb forecourts, creating what Gatton has described as \"spirit\" projections due to their ephemeral, spectral qualities.Gatton, M. (2010\\). \"Excerpts from — The Camera Obscura and the Megalithic Tomb: The role of projected solar images in the symbolic renewal of Life.\" In \\<Paleo\\-camera.com\\> 9 March 2010\\. When backlit these figures appear as dark silhouettes, but at those times when the sun is behind the monument, and the forecourt area brightly lit, they are enhanced in color and detail. Aaron Watson has photographed optical projections of people inside Cuween Hill, Wideford Hill, Vinquoy Hill, the Dwarfie Stane and the Grey Cairns of Camster.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
"Camera obscura projections move in real time, although projected human figures appear upside down and back to front. This creates distinctive illusions where individuals, or even groups of people, can appear to emerge from the chamber wall. As the angles between the external subject and the aperture become increasingly oblique, projections can also be cast upon the floor, walls and ceiling of a monument. This can create the illusion of a human shadow moving through the passage tomb.Watson, A. and Scott, R. (2016\\). \"Materialising Light, Making Worlds: Optical Image Projection within the Megalithic Passage Tombs of Britain and Ireland.\" In The Oxford Handbook of Light in Archaeology (Papadopoulos, C. and Moyes, H., eds.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.",
""
] |
History
-------
[thumb\|left\|The first plant of Bauxites du Midi in Guinea.](/wiki/File:Usine_de_midi.jpg "Usine de midi.jpg")
[left\|thumb\|CBG in [Kamsar](/wiki/Kamsar "Kamsar").](/wiki/File:CBG_a_Kamsar_Guin%C3%A9e_39.jpg "CBG a Kamsar Guinée 39.jpg")
Early on, the country attracted prospectors. [Bauxites du Midi](/wiki/Bauxites_du_Midi "Bauxites du Midi"), founded in 1912 in Paris, began mining operations on {{interlanguage link\|Île Tamara\|fr}} in 1937, preceded by a prospecting voyage in 1936\-1937*L'avenir de la Guinée Française*, par Roland Pré, Gouverneur du Territoire , 1951, Éditions guinéennes. Conakry. 1951 <http://www.webguinee.net/bibliotheque/general/rPre/problInd.html>
On July 24, 1948, 20 mining exploration permits were awarded to the company. They discovered that the bauxite deposits of guinea consisted of surface deposits which are entirely exploitable using mining pits and heavy vehicles. [Bauxites du Midi](/wiki/Bauxites_du_Midi "Bauxites du Midi") partnered with the Canadian company [Aluminum Laboratories](/wiki/Aluminum_Laboratories "Aluminum Laboratories"), which proffered the necessary funds and materials for the deposit facilities in Guinea, and additionally worked to provide the specialists required to construct an enrichment plant on {{interlanguage link\|Île de Kassa\|fr}}.
In 1948 and 1950 the Guinean bauxite from the [Îles de Los](/wiki/%C3%8Eles_de_Los "Îles de Los") was shipped in small quantities to the Aluminum plants of [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan "Alcan") in [Saguenay\-Lac\-Saint\-Jean](/wiki/Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean "Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean") in Québec, but in November 1966, that deposit was depleted, as was expected, despite nationalization.
Under the leadership of Pierre Jochyms, the planning of the utilization of significant deposits of bauxite (in Kassa, Boké and [Fria](/wiki/Fria "Fria")), Iron ore (on the [Kaloum](/wiki/Kaloum "Kaloum") peninsula and the Nimba\-Simandou island chain) gold and diamonds was begun. The exceptional hydroelectric potential of the Konkouré watershed had already been identified, and two large dams were being researched (Grandes Chutes and Souapiti){{cite journal\|title\=Dossier : Crise d'électricité – Les ratés historiques de l'aménagement du fleuve Konkouré (3e partie)\|journal\=Guinée News\|url\=http://guineenews.org/dossier\-crise\-delectricite\-les\-rates\-historiques\-de\-lamenagement\-du\-fleuve\-konkoure\-3eme\-partie/\|access\-date\=2021\-10\-12\|archive\-date\=2018\-08\-06\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180806124230/http://guineenews.org/dossier\-crise\-delectricite\-les\-rates\-historiques\-de\-lamenagement\-du\-fleuve\-konkoure\-3eme\-partie/\|url\-status\=dead}}
CBG began its first excavations in January, 1955, then suspended them for one year. Pechiney Ugine began its major project in 1957, on the site of [Fria](/wiki/Fria "Fria").« Le secteur de la bauxite en République de Guinée : ajustement structurel et restructuration internationale de l'industrie de l'aluminium », par Bonnie Campbell, dans la revue *Tiers\-Monde* en 1993 [http://www.persee.fr/doc/tiers\_0040\-7356\_1993\_num\_34\_133\_4833](http://www.persee.fr/doc/tiers_0040-7356_1993_num_34_133_4833) Studies were done on the hydroelectric project in [Konkouré](/wiki/Konkour%C3%A9 "Konkouré"), to the east of [Fria](/wiki/Fria "Fria"), but following a referendum on September 28, 1958, they were kept secret by the colonial authorities.
In November, 1961, the government took possession of the sites of Kassa and Boké due to the failure of *Bauxites du Midi* (a wholly owned subsidiary of [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan "Alcan")) to respect its agreement to refine its bauxite into aluminum locally after 1964\. In 1962, Guinea joined the [World Bank](/wiki/World_Bank "World Bank") and CBG resumed its excavations on October 1, 1963, under the banner of the Compagnie des bauxites de Guinée, of which 49% ownership was held by the state of Guinea, and 51% by [Harvey Aluminium of Delaware](/wiki/Harvey_Aluminium_of_Delaware "Harvey Aluminium of Delaware").{{cite news\|author\= \|title\=GUINEA EASES POLICY ON FOREIGN CAPITAL\|date\=January 20, 1964\|work\=The New York Times\|location\=Conakry, Guinea\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/1964/01/20/archives/guinea\-eases\-policy\-on\-foreign\-capital.html}}
Bauxite exports began in 1973\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.cbg\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/origine\-de\-la\-cbg\|title\=Origine de la CBG\|website\=Cbg\-guinee.com\|access\-date\=2021\-10\-12\|archive\-date\=2015\-11\-25\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20151125103753/http://www.cbg\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/origine\-de\-la\-cbg\|url\-status\=dead}} The first ship loaded with Guinean bauxite left the port of [Kamsar](/wiki/Kamsar "Kamsar") on August 2, 1973, with 19,000 tons of ore on board.{{cite web\|url\=http://dww.cbg\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/historique\-industriel\|title\=Historique industriel\|website\=Cbg\-guinee.com\|access\-date\=2021\-10\-12\|archive\-date\=2015\-11\-25\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20151125093959/http://dww.cbg\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/historique\-industriel\|url\-status\=dead}} In the 1970s, Africa's portion of global bauxite production tripled.
In 1965, the Boké Improvement Office (OFAB) was created to construct and manage CBG's infrastructures.
In 1967, the participation of Harvey Aluminum of Delaware was divided amongst several players in the mining sector: [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan "Alcan") took 33%, [Alcoa](/wiki/Alcoa "Alcoa") 27%, [Martin Marietta](/wiki/Martin_Marietta "Martin Marietta") 14%, [Péchiney](/wiki/P%C3%A9chiney "Péchiney") 10%, and [Edison\-Montecani](/wiki/Edison_%28company%29 "Edison (company)") 6%. At the end of the 70's, Fria exported more than 600,000 tons of alumina annually, of which a part went to the Pechiney's facilities at [Edea](/wiki/Ed%C3%A9a "Edéa") in Cameroon, with two large foreign investors: [Noranda](/wiki/Noranda_%28mining_company%29 "Noranda (mining company)") (Canada) 38\.5% and Pechiney Ugine Kuhlman (France) 36\.5%.
Simultaneously, the site of Débélé in the region of the Kindia mine was made operational before 1974 after an agreement in November 1969, by a joint project of the Soviet Union and the Guinean government, which established the price of ore and announced that the Guinean state is fully the proprietor of said capital, the Soviet Union having assured the purchase of 90% of the ore. Exports passed from 2 million tons in 1974, to more than 3 million in 1988\.
At the Boké site, the quantity of exports shifted from around 5 million tons in 1975 to 11 million in 1990\.
In November, 2012, CBG signed a historic agreement with the [Mubadala Investment Company](/wiki/Mubadala_Investment_Company "Mubadala Investment Company") to supply the [United Arab Emirates](/wiki/United_Arab_Emirates "United Arab Emirates") with bauxite {{Cite web\|url\=http://www.agenceecofin.com/investissement/0611\-7439\-le\-fonds\-mubadala\-signe\-un\-accord\-majeur\-avec\-la\-compagnie\-des\-bauxites\-de\-guinee\|website\=agenceecofin.com\|title\=Le fonds mubadala signe un accord majeur avec la compagnie des bauxites de guinee}}
In December, 2013, Namory Conde, then regional director of [BHP Billiton](/wiki/BHP "BHP"), was named director\-general of CBG {{Cite web\|url\=http://www.kalenews.org/index.php/2013\-08\-08\-21\-15\-11/441\-la\-cbg\-compagnie\-des\-bauxites\-de\-guinee\-a\-un\-nouveau\-directeur\-general\|title\=La cbg compagnie des bauxites de guinee a un nouveau directeur general\|website\=Kalenews.org}}
|
[
"History\n-------",
"[thumb\\|left\\|The first plant of Bauxites du Midi in Guinea.](/wiki/File:Usine_de_midi.jpg \"Usine de midi.jpg\")\n[left\\|thumb\\|CBG in [Kamsar](/wiki/Kamsar \"Kamsar\").](/wiki/File:CBG_a_Kamsar_Guin%C3%A9e_39.jpg \"CBG a Kamsar Guinée 39.jpg\")",
"Early on, the country attracted prospectors. [Bauxites du Midi](/wiki/Bauxites_du_Midi \"Bauxites du Midi\"), founded in 1912 in Paris, began mining operations on {{interlanguage link\\|Île Tamara\\|fr}} in 1937, preceded by a prospecting voyage in 1936\\-1937*L'avenir de la Guinée Française*, par Roland Pré, Gouverneur du Territoire , 1951, Éditions guinéennes. Conakry. 1951 <http://www.webguinee.net/bibliotheque/general/rPre/problInd.html>",
"On July 24, 1948, 20 mining exploration permits were awarded to the company. They discovered that the bauxite deposits of guinea consisted of surface deposits which are entirely exploitable using mining pits and heavy vehicles. [Bauxites du Midi](/wiki/Bauxites_du_Midi \"Bauxites du Midi\") partnered with the Canadian company [Aluminum Laboratories](/wiki/Aluminum_Laboratories \"Aluminum Laboratories\"), which proffered the necessary funds and materials for the deposit facilities in Guinea, and additionally worked to provide the specialists required to construct an enrichment plant on {{interlanguage link\\|Île de Kassa\\|fr}}.\nIn 1948 and 1950 the Guinean bauxite from the [Îles de Los](/wiki/%C3%8Eles_de_Los \"Îles de Los\") was shipped in small quantities to the Aluminum plants of [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan \"Alcan\") in [Saguenay\\-Lac\\-Saint\\-Jean](/wiki/Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean \"Saguenay-Lac-Saint-Jean\") in Québec, but in November 1966, that deposit was depleted, as was expected, despite nationalization.",
"Under the leadership of Pierre Jochyms, the planning of the utilization of significant deposits of bauxite (in Kassa, Boké and [Fria](/wiki/Fria \"Fria\")), Iron ore (on the [Kaloum](/wiki/Kaloum \"Kaloum\") peninsula and the Nimba\\-Simandou island chain) gold and diamonds was begun. The exceptional hydroelectric potential of the Konkouré watershed had already been identified, and two large dams were being researched (Grandes Chutes and Souapiti){{cite journal\\|title\\=Dossier : Crise d'électricité – Les ratés historiques de l'aménagement du fleuve Konkouré (3e partie)\\|journal\\=Guinée News\\|url\\=http://guineenews.org/dossier\\-crise\\-delectricite\\-les\\-rates\\-historiques\\-de\\-lamenagement\\-du\\-fleuve\\-konkoure\\-3eme\\-partie/\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-10\\-12\\|archive\\-date\\=2018\\-08\\-06\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180806124230/http://guineenews.org/dossier\\-crise\\-delectricite\\-les\\-rates\\-historiques\\-de\\-lamenagement\\-du\\-fleuve\\-konkoure\\-3eme\\-partie/\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"CBG began its first excavations in January, 1955, then suspended them for one year. Pechiney Ugine began its major project in 1957, on the site of [Fria](/wiki/Fria \"Fria\").« Le secteur de la bauxite en République de Guinée : ajustement structurel et restructuration internationale de l'industrie de l'aluminium », par Bonnie Campbell, dans la revue *Tiers\\-Monde* en 1993 [http://www.persee.fr/doc/tiers\\_0040\\-7356\\_1993\\_num\\_34\\_133\\_4833](http://www.persee.fr/doc/tiers_0040-7356_1993_num_34_133_4833) Studies were done on the hydroelectric project in [Konkouré](/wiki/Konkour%C3%A9 \"Konkouré\"), to the east of [Fria](/wiki/Fria \"Fria\"), but following a referendum on September 28, 1958, they were kept secret by the colonial authorities.",
"In November, 1961, the government took possession of the sites of Kassa and Boké due to the failure of *Bauxites du Midi* (a wholly owned subsidiary of [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan \"Alcan\")) to respect its agreement to refine its bauxite into aluminum locally after 1964\\. In 1962, Guinea joined the [World Bank](/wiki/World_Bank \"World Bank\") and CBG resumed its excavations on October 1, 1963, under the banner of the Compagnie des bauxites de Guinée, of which 49% ownership was held by the state of Guinea, and 51% by [Harvey Aluminium of Delaware](/wiki/Harvey_Aluminium_of_Delaware \"Harvey Aluminium of Delaware\").{{cite news\\|author\\= \\|title\\=GUINEA EASES POLICY ON FOREIGN CAPITAL\\|date\\=January 20, 1964\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|location\\=Conakry, Guinea\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/1964/01/20/archives/guinea\\-eases\\-policy\\-on\\-foreign\\-capital.html}}",
"Bauxite exports began in 1973\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.cbg\\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/origine\\-de\\-la\\-cbg\\|title\\=Origine de la CBG\\|website\\=Cbg\\-guinee.com\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-10\\-12\\|archive\\-date\\=2015\\-11\\-25\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20151125103753/http://www.cbg\\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/origine\\-de\\-la\\-cbg\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} The first ship loaded with Guinean bauxite left the port of [Kamsar](/wiki/Kamsar \"Kamsar\") on August 2, 1973, with 19,000 tons of ore on board.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://dww.cbg\\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/historique\\-industriel\\|title\\=Historique industriel\\|website\\=Cbg\\-guinee.com\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-10\\-12\\|archive\\-date\\=2015\\-11\\-25\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20151125093959/http://dww.cbg\\-guinee.com/cbgguinee/historique/historique\\-industriel\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} In the 1970s, Africa's portion of global bauxite production tripled.",
"In 1965, the Boké Improvement Office (OFAB) was created to construct and manage CBG's infrastructures.",
"In 1967, the participation of Harvey Aluminum of Delaware was divided amongst several players in the mining sector: [Alcan](/wiki/Alcan \"Alcan\") took 33%, [Alcoa](/wiki/Alcoa \"Alcoa\") 27%, [Martin Marietta](/wiki/Martin_Marietta \"Martin Marietta\") 14%, [Péchiney](/wiki/P%C3%A9chiney \"Péchiney\") 10%, and [Edison\\-Montecani](/wiki/Edison_%28company%29 \"Edison (company)\") 6%. At the end of the 70's, Fria exported more than 600,000 tons of alumina annually, of which a part went to the Pechiney's facilities at [Edea](/wiki/Ed%C3%A9a \"Edéa\") in Cameroon, with two large foreign investors: [Noranda](/wiki/Noranda_%28mining_company%29 \"Noranda (mining company)\") (Canada) 38\\.5% and Pechiney Ugine Kuhlman (France) 36\\.5%.",
"Simultaneously, the site of Débélé in the region of the Kindia mine was made operational before 1974 after an agreement in November 1969, by a joint project of the Soviet Union and the Guinean government, which established the price of ore and announced that the Guinean state is fully the proprietor of said capital, the Soviet Union having assured the purchase of 90% of the ore. Exports passed from 2 million tons in 1974, to more than 3 million in 1988\\.",
"At the Boké site, the quantity of exports shifted from around 5 million tons in 1975 to 11 million in 1990\\.",
"In November, 2012, CBG signed a historic agreement with the [Mubadala Investment Company](/wiki/Mubadala_Investment_Company \"Mubadala Investment Company\") to supply the [United Arab Emirates](/wiki/United_Arab_Emirates \"United Arab Emirates\") with bauxite {{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.agenceecofin.com/investissement/0611\\-7439\\-le\\-fonds\\-mubadala\\-signe\\-un\\-accord\\-majeur\\-avec\\-la\\-compagnie\\-des\\-bauxites\\-de\\-guinee\\|website\\=agenceecofin.com\\|title\\=Le fonds mubadala signe un accord majeur avec la compagnie des bauxites de guinee}}",
"In December, 2013, Namory Conde, then regional director of [BHP Billiton](/wiki/BHP \"BHP\"), was named director\\-general of CBG {{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.kalenews.org/index.php/2013\\-08\\-08\\-21\\-15\\-11/441\\-la\\-cbg\\-compagnie\\-des\\-bauxites\\-de\\-guinee\\-a\\-un\\-nouveau\\-directeur\\-general\\|title\\=La cbg compagnie des bauxites de guinee a un nouveau directeur general\\|website\\=Kalenews.org}}",
""
] |
College career
--------------
Newsome accepted a football scholarship from [Winston\-Salem State University](/wiki/Winston-Salem_State_University "Winston-Salem State University"). As a freshman, he was converted into a [running back](/wiki/Running_back "Running back"). As a sophomore in 1977, Newsome rushed for 998 yards and 14 touchdowns.
As a junior in 1978, he posted 1,377 rushing yards (second in Division II), a 7\.5\-yard average and 14 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown"). As a senior in 1979, he tallied 987 rushing yards and nine [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown").
The 1977 and 1978 football teams, which were coached by [Bill Hayes](/wiki/Bill_Hayes_%28American_football%29 "Bill Hayes (American football)"), were two of the best teams in school history. They went undefeated each season and were led by Newsome and fellow [running backs](/wiki/Running_back "Running back") Arrington Jones and Randy Bolton, employing the [Veer offense](/wiki/Veer "Veer").{{cite web\| url\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid\=2205\&dat\=19870523\&id\=eVJAAAAAIBAJ\&sjid\=TAMGAAAAIBAJ\&pg\=2618,3728191 \| title\=Former Ram Newsome: It's good to be home \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}}
Those Rams teams dominated their competition. In 1977, they went 11–0 but bypassed the [Division II](/wiki/NCAA_Division_II "NCAA Division II") playoffs to play in the Gold Bowl in Richmond, Virginia, where they lost to [South Carolina State University](/wiki/South_Carolina_State_University "South Carolina State University") 10–7\. In 1978, they went 11–0 again, won their first playoff game (17–0 over [California State Poly](/wiki/California_State_Polytechnic_University%2C_Pomona "California State Polytechnic University, Pomona")), then lost to [Delaware State](/wiki/Delaware_State_University "Delaware State University"), 41–0 in the second round.
In his last three seasons, Newsome was the ClAA's leading rusher and scorer. He finished his college career as the leading rusher in school history with 3,843 yards (6\.1\-yard average) and 38 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown"). Newsome also was one of the leading all\-time rushers in the history of the [Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association](/wiki/Central_Intercollegiate_Athletic_Association "Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association") (CIAA). In 1978 and 1979, he was named to the Sheridan All America Black College Football Team and was the Black College Football Offensive Player of the Year (1978\).
In 1993, he was inducted into the [CIAA](/wiki/Central_Intercollegiate_Athletic_Association "Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association") Hall of Fame and the Winston\-Salem State University Athletic Hall Of Fame. In 2019, he was inducted into the Black College Football Hall of Fame.{{cite web\| url\=https://www.journalnow.com/sports/wssu/timmy\-newsome\-a\-former\-wssu\-star\-heading\-to\-the\-black/article\_619cabcd\-364e\-5ac7\-b5c6\-ca3ec3bfc890\.html \| title\=Timmy Newsome, a former WSSU star, heading to the Black College Football Hall of Fame \| date\=15 November 2018 \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}} In 2022, he was inducted into the North Carolina Sports Hall of Fame.
|
[
"College career\n--------------",
"Newsome accepted a football scholarship from [Winston\\-Salem State University](/wiki/Winston-Salem_State_University \"Winston-Salem State University\"). As a freshman, he was converted into a [running back](/wiki/Running_back \"Running back\"). As a sophomore in 1977, Newsome rushed for 998 yards and 14 touchdowns.",
"As a junior in 1978, he posted 1,377 rushing yards (second in Division II), a 7\\.5\\-yard average and 14 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\"). As a senior in 1979, he tallied 987 rushing yards and nine [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\").",
"The 1977 and 1978 football teams, which were coached by [Bill Hayes](/wiki/Bill_Hayes_%28American_football%29 \"Bill Hayes (American football)\"), were two of the best teams in school history. They went undefeated each season and were led by Newsome and fellow [running backs](/wiki/Running_back \"Running back\") Arrington Jones and Randy Bolton, employing the [Veer offense](/wiki/Veer \"Veer\").{{cite web\\| url\\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid\\=2205\\&dat\\=19870523\\&id\\=eVJAAAAAIBAJ\\&sjid\\=TAMGAAAAIBAJ\\&pg\\=2618,3728191 \\| title\\=Former Ram Newsome: It's good to be home \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}}",
"Those Rams teams dominated their competition. In 1977, they went 11–0 but bypassed the [Division II](/wiki/NCAA_Division_II \"NCAA Division II\") playoffs to play in the Gold Bowl in Richmond, Virginia, where they lost to [South Carolina State University](/wiki/South_Carolina_State_University \"South Carolina State University\") 10–7\\. In 1978, they went 11–0 again, won their first playoff game (17–0 over [California State Poly](/wiki/California_State_Polytechnic_University%2C_Pomona \"California State Polytechnic University, Pomona\")), then lost to [Delaware State](/wiki/Delaware_State_University \"Delaware State University\"), 41–0 in the second round.",
"In his last three seasons, Newsome was the ClAA's leading rusher and scorer. He finished his college career as the leading rusher in school history with 3,843 yards (6\\.1\\-yard average) and 38 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\"). Newsome also was one of the leading all\\-time rushers in the history of the [Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association](/wiki/Central_Intercollegiate_Athletic_Association \"Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association\") (CIAA). In 1978 and 1979, he was named to the Sheridan All America Black College Football Team and was the Black College Football Offensive Player of the Year (1978\\).",
"In 1993, he was inducted into the [CIAA](/wiki/Central_Intercollegiate_Athletic_Association \"Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association\") Hall of Fame and the Winston\\-Salem State University Athletic Hall Of Fame. In 2019, he was inducted into the Black College Football Hall of Fame.{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.journalnow.com/sports/wssu/timmy\\-newsome\\-a\\-former\\-wssu\\-star\\-heading\\-to\\-the\\-black/article\\_619cabcd\\-364e\\-5ac7\\-b5c6\\-ca3ec3bfc890\\.html \\| title\\=Timmy Newsome, a former WSSU star, heading to the Black College Football Hall of Fame \\| date\\=15 November 2018 \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}} In 2022, he was inducted into the North Carolina Sports Hall of Fame.",
""
] |
Professional career
-------------------
Newsome was selected by the [Dallas Cowboys](/wiki/Dallas_Cowboys "Dallas Cowboys") in the sixth round (162nd overall) of the [1980 NFL draft](/wiki/1980_NFL_draft "1980 NFL draft"). He made the roster by beating out [Scott Laidlaw](/wiki/Scott_Laidlaw "Scott Laidlaw"). Because the team already had [Tony Dorsett](/wiki/Tony_Dorsett "Tony Dorsett") as the starter at [running back](/wiki/Running_back "Running back"), as a rookie he was moved to [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)"). He had 2 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown") against the [San Diego Chargers](/wiki/San_Diego_Chargers "San Diego Chargers").{{cite web\| url\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1980/10/27/Dallas\-turned\-a\-series\-of\-bizarre\-and\-spectacular\-plays/5489341470800/ \| title\=Dallas turned a series of bizarre and spectacular plays... \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}}
In [1981](/wiki/1981_NFL_season "1981 NFL season"), he suffered a severe hamstring pull on the first day of training camp, which limited his chances competing for the starting [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)") job against [Ron Springs](/wiki/Ron_Springs "Ron Springs").{{cite web\| url\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1981/07/24/Dallas\-Cowboys\-coach\-Tom\-Landry\-looking\-for\-starters\-in/9777364795200/ \| title\=Dallas Cowboys coach Tom Landry, looking for starters in... \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}}
In [1982](/wiki/1982_NFL_season "1982 NFL season"), he was moved back to [running back](/wiki/Running_back "Running back") after two seasons of struggles, which prompted him to leave training camp for a few days.{{cite web\| url\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1982/08/12/Dallas\-Cowboy\-officials\-Thursday\-said\-veteran\-fullback\-Timmy\-Newsome/3329397972800/ \| title\=Dallas Cowboy officials Thursday said veteran fullback Timmy Newsome,... \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}} In a 24–10 win against the [Washington Redskins](/wiki/Washington_Redskins "Washington Redskins") he had an 18\-yard touchdown run. In the 37–7 win against the [Houston Oilers](/wiki/Houston_Oilers "Houston Oilers"), he had a 43\-yard reception and a 46\-yard touchdown reception. In the 37–26 playoff win against the [Green Bay Packers](/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers "Green Bay Packers"), he had 7 receptions for 70 yards and a two\-yard touchdown run, while sharing fullback duties with [Robert Newhouse](/wiki/Robert_Newhouse "Robert Newhouse") in place of an injured Springs.
In [1983](/wiki/1983_NFL_season "1983 NFL season"), he registered 185 rushing yards, 250 receiving yards and 6 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown"). In the 27–24 win against the [Tampa Bay Buccaneers](/wiki/Tampa_Bay_Buccaneers "Tampa Bay Buccaneers"), he turned a short pass into a 52\-yard touchdown to send the game into overtime with 47 seconds left. In [1984](/wiki/1984_NFL_season "1984 NFL season"), he started at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)") in the last 4 games of the season.
In [1985](/wiki/1985_NFL_season "1985 NFL season"), he started 14 games (missed 2 with injuries) at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)") after Springs was released. He had 88 carries for 252 yards, 46 receptions (tied for fourth on the team) for 361 yards (fifth on the team) and 3 touchdowns.
In [1986](/wiki/1986_NFL_season "1986 NFL season"), he started 12 games at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)"), until making way for [Herschel Walker](/wiki/Herschel_Walker "Herschel Walker") to start alongside Dorsett late in the year. He teamed with Dorsett and Walker to form [Tom Landry](/wiki/Tom_Landry "Tom Landry")'s latest offensive innovation \- the full\-house backfield. He also served as the third [tight end](/wiki/Tight_end "Tight end"). He finished with 48 receptions (third on the team) for 421 yards (fourth on the team), 34 carries for 110 yards and 5 touchdowns.
In [1987](/wiki/1987_NFL_season "1987 NFL season"), he started 8 games at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 "Fullback (American football)"), after Walker was given the team's main running back role. In a 17–27 loss against the [Detroit Lions](/wiki/Detroit_Lions "Detroit Lions"), he rushed for 2 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown"). In the 14–20 loss against the [Miami Dolphins](/wiki/Miami_Dolphins "Miami Dolphins"), he had 2 receptions for [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown").
In [1988](/wiki/1988_NFL_season "1988 NFL season"), he had a promising start, but suffered a season\-ending calf injury in a practice following the ninth game of the season. Through the first half, he led the team in rushing touchdowns with 3 and was on a pace for a career\-high 53 receptions. He also moved into ninth place on the Cowboys All\-time receiving list with 212 receptions.{{cite web\| url\=https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/16724023/ \| title\=Newsome released by Cowboys \| date\=31 August 1989 \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}}
In [1989](/wiki/1989_NFL_season "1989 NFL season"), with the arrival of new head coach [Jimmy Johnson](/wiki/Jimmy_Johnson_%28American_football_coach%29 "Jimmy Johnson (American football coach)"), he was released as part of a youth movement on August 30\.{{cite web\| url\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/08/30/Cowboys\-say\-theyll\-cut\-Newsome/9044620452800/ \| title\=Cowboys say they'll cut Newsome \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}} He spent most of his 9 seasons as a blocker and receiver out of the backfield, behind Cowboys legends [Dorsett](/wiki/Tony_Dorsett "Tony Dorsett") and [Walker](/wiki/Herschel_Walker "Herschel Walker"). He rushed for 1,226 yards with 19 rushing [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown") and had 1,966 receiving yards with 11 receiving [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown "Touchdown").
During his career he became an all\-purpose utility back, playing also snaps at [tight end](/wiki/Tight_end "Tight end").{{cite web\| url\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid\=861\&dat\=19870808\&id\=\_p1HAAAAIBAJ\&sjid\=ZX8MAAAAIBAJ\&pg\=1844,6131910 \| title\=Newsome Enjoys Being Cowboys' Quiet Handyman \| accessdate\=February 19, 2022}} In [1990](/wiki/1990_NFL_season "1990 NFL season"), he was selected to the [Dallas Cowboys](/wiki/Dallas_Cowboys "Dallas Cowboys") all\-decade team by the Dallas Cowboys Weekly Newspaper.
|
[
"Professional career\n-------------------",
"Newsome was selected by the [Dallas Cowboys](/wiki/Dallas_Cowboys \"Dallas Cowboys\") in the sixth round (162nd overall) of the [1980 NFL draft](/wiki/1980_NFL_draft \"1980 NFL draft\"). He made the roster by beating out [Scott Laidlaw](/wiki/Scott_Laidlaw \"Scott Laidlaw\"). Because the team already had [Tony Dorsett](/wiki/Tony_Dorsett \"Tony Dorsett\") as the starter at [running back](/wiki/Running_back \"Running back\"), as a rookie he was moved to [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\"). He had 2 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\") against the [San Diego Chargers](/wiki/San_Diego_Chargers \"San Diego Chargers\").{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1980/10/27/Dallas\\-turned\\-a\\-series\\-of\\-bizarre\\-and\\-spectacular\\-plays/5489341470800/ \\| title\\=Dallas turned a series of bizarre and spectacular plays... \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}}",
"In [1981](/wiki/1981_NFL_season \"1981 NFL season\"), he suffered a severe hamstring pull on the first day of training camp, which limited his chances competing for the starting [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\") job against [Ron Springs](/wiki/Ron_Springs \"Ron Springs\").{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1981/07/24/Dallas\\-Cowboys\\-coach\\-Tom\\-Landry\\-looking\\-for\\-starters\\-in/9777364795200/ \\| title\\=Dallas Cowboys coach Tom Landry, looking for starters in... \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}}",
"In [1982](/wiki/1982_NFL_season \"1982 NFL season\"), he was moved back to [running back](/wiki/Running_back \"Running back\") after two seasons of struggles, which prompted him to leave training camp for a few days.{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1982/08/12/Dallas\\-Cowboy\\-officials\\-Thursday\\-said\\-veteran\\-fullback\\-Timmy\\-Newsome/3329397972800/ \\| title\\=Dallas Cowboy officials Thursday said veteran fullback Timmy Newsome,... \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}} In a 24–10 win against the [Washington Redskins](/wiki/Washington_Redskins \"Washington Redskins\") he had an 18\\-yard touchdown run. In the 37–7 win against the [Houston Oilers](/wiki/Houston_Oilers \"Houston Oilers\"), he had a 43\\-yard reception and a 46\\-yard touchdown reception. In the 37–26 playoff win against the [Green Bay Packers](/wiki/Green_Bay_Packers \"Green Bay Packers\"), he had 7 receptions for 70 yards and a two\\-yard touchdown run, while sharing fullback duties with [Robert Newhouse](/wiki/Robert_Newhouse \"Robert Newhouse\") in place of an injured Springs.",
"In [1983](/wiki/1983_NFL_season \"1983 NFL season\"), he registered 185 rushing yards, 250 receiving yards and 6 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\"). In the 27–24 win against the [Tampa Bay Buccaneers](/wiki/Tampa_Bay_Buccaneers \"Tampa Bay Buccaneers\"), he turned a short pass into a 52\\-yard touchdown to send the game into overtime with 47 seconds left. In [1984](/wiki/1984_NFL_season \"1984 NFL season\"), he started at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\") in the last 4 games of the season.",
"In [1985](/wiki/1985_NFL_season \"1985 NFL season\"), he started 14 games (missed 2 with injuries) at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\") after Springs was released. He had 88 carries for 252 yards, 46 receptions (tied for fourth on the team) for 361 yards (fifth on the team) and 3 touchdowns.",
"In [1986](/wiki/1986_NFL_season \"1986 NFL season\"), he started 12 games at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\"), until making way for [Herschel Walker](/wiki/Herschel_Walker \"Herschel Walker\") to start alongside Dorsett late in the year. He teamed with Dorsett and Walker to form [Tom Landry](/wiki/Tom_Landry \"Tom Landry\")'s latest offensive innovation \\- the full\\-house backfield. He also served as the third [tight end](/wiki/Tight_end \"Tight end\"). He finished with 48 receptions (third on the team) for 421 yards (fourth on the team), 34 carries for 110 yards and 5 touchdowns.",
"In [1987](/wiki/1987_NFL_season \"1987 NFL season\"), he started 8 games at [fullback](/wiki/Fullback_%28American_football%29 \"Fullback (American football)\"), after Walker was given the team's main running back role. In a 17–27 loss against the [Detroit Lions](/wiki/Detroit_Lions \"Detroit Lions\"), he rushed for 2 [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\"). In the 14–20 loss against the [Miami Dolphins](/wiki/Miami_Dolphins \"Miami Dolphins\"), he had 2 receptions for [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\").",
"In [1988](/wiki/1988_NFL_season \"1988 NFL season\"), he had a promising start, but suffered a season\\-ending calf injury in a practice following the ninth game of the season. Through the first half, he led the team in rushing touchdowns with 3 and was on a pace for a career\\-high 53 receptions. He also moved into ninth place on the Cowboys All\\-time receiving list with 212 receptions.{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/16724023/ \\| title\\=Newsome released by Cowboys \\| date\\=31 August 1989 \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}}",
"In [1989](/wiki/1989_NFL_season \"1989 NFL season\"), with the arrival of new head coach [Jimmy Johnson](/wiki/Jimmy_Johnson_%28American_football_coach%29 \"Jimmy Johnson (American football coach)\"), he was released as part of a youth movement on August 30\\.{{cite web\\| url\\=https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/08/30/Cowboys\\-say\\-theyll\\-cut\\-Newsome/9044620452800/ \\| title\\=Cowboys say they'll cut Newsome \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}} He spent most of his 9 seasons as a blocker and receiver out of the backfield, behind Cowboys legends [Dorsett](/wiki/Tony_Dorsett \"Tony Dorsett\") and [Walker](/wiki/Herschel_Walker \"Herschel Walker\"). He rushed for 1,226 yards with 19 rushing [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\") and had 1,966 receiving yards with 11 receiving [touchdowns](/wiki/Touchdown \"Touchdown\").",
"During his career he became an all\\-purpose utility back, playing also snaps at [tight end](/wiki/Tight_end \"Tight end\").{{cite web\\| url\\=https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid\\=861\\&dat\\=19870808\\&id\\=\\_p1HAAAAIBAJ\\&sjid\\=ZX8MAAAAIBAJ\\&pg\\=1844,6131910 \\| title\\=Newsome Enjoys Being Cowboys' Quiet Handyman \\| accessdate\\=February 19, 2022}} In [1990](/wiki/1990_NFL_season \"1990 NFL season\"), he was selected to the [Dallas Cowboys](/wiki/Dallas_Cowboys \"Dallas Cowboys\") all\\-decade team by the Dallas Cowboys Weekly Newspaper.",
""
] |
Demographics
------------
As of the [census](/wiki/Census "Census"){{cite web \|url\=https://www.census.gov \|publisher\=\[\[United States Census Bureau]] \|title\=U.S. Census website }} of 2020, there were 22,366 people living in the township. The population density was {{convert\|538\.2\|PD/sqmi\|PD/km2\|sp\=us\|adj\=off}}. The racial makeup of the township was 88\.7% white, 4\.2% black, 1\.1% Asian, 1\.6% Native American, and 4\.4% from other races. 4\.3% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.
As of the [census](/wiki/Census "Census") of 2010, there were 21,078 people living in the township. The population density was {{convert\|507\.2\|PD/sqmi\|PD/km2\|sp\=us\|adj\=off}}. The racial makeup of the township was 93\.6% white, 3\.0% black, 0\.8% Asian, 0\.6% Native American, and 2% from other races. 2\.3% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.
As of the [census](/wiki/Census "Census") of 2000, there were 18,074 people, 6,999 households, and 5,256 families living in the township. The population density was {{convert\|430\.4\|PD/sqmi\|PD/km2\|sp\=us\|adj\=off}}. There were 7,217 housing units at an average density of {{convert\|171\.8\|/mi2\|/km2\|disp\=preunit\|units \|units\|}}. The racial makeup of the township was 97\.25% [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 "White (U.S. Census)"), 0\.92% [African American](/wiki/African_American_%28U.S._Census%29 "African American (U.S. Census)"), 0\.19% [Native American](/wiki/Native_American_%28U.S._Census%29 "Native American (U.S. Census)"), 0\.43% [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 "Asian (U.S. Census)"), 0\.01% [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Pacific_Islander_%28U.S._Census%29 "Pacific Islander (U.S. Census)"), 0\.51% from [other races](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 "Race (United States Census)"), and 0\.69% from two or more races. [Hispanic](/wiki/Hispanic_%28U.S._Census%29 "Hispanic (U.S. Census)") or [Latino](/wiki/Latino_%28U.S._Census%29 "Latino (U.S. Census)") of any race were 1\.03% of the population.
There were 6,999 households, out of which 33\.6% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 63\.0% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage "Marriage") living together, 7\.8% had a female householder with no husband present, and 24\.9% were non\-families. 20\.2% of all households were made up of individuals, and 7\.7% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2\.55 and the average family size was 2\.93\.
In the township the population was spread out, with 24\.2% under the age of 18, 6\.7% from 18 to 24, 31\.1% from 25 to 44, 25\.3% from 45 to 64, and 12\.7% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 38 years. For every 100 females, there were 98\.0 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 95\.5 males.
The median income for a household in the township was $46,845, and the median income for a family was $53,252\. Males had a median income of $36,478 versus $23,787 for females. The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income "Per capita income") for the township was $20,513\. About 2\.8% of families and 4\.2% of the population were below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line "Poverty line"), including 5\.2% of those under age 18 and 4\.4% of those age 65 or over.
|
[
"Demographics\n------------",
"As of the [census](/wiki/Census \"Census\"){{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.census.gov \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Census Bureau]] \\|title\\=U.S. Census website }} of 2020, there were 22,366 people living in the township. The population density was {{convert\\|538\\.2\\|PD/sqmi\\|PD/km2\\|sp\\=us\\|adj\\=off}}. The racial makeup of the township was 88\\.7% white, 4\\.2% black, 1\\.1% Asian, 1\\.6% Native American, and 4\\.4% from other races. 4\\.3% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.",
"As of the [census](/wiki/Census \"Census\") of 2010, there were 21,078 people living in the township. The population density was {{convert\\|507\\.2\\|PD/sqmi\\|PD/km2\\|sp\\=us\\|adj\\=off}}. The racial makeup of the township was 93\\.6% white, 3\\.0% black, 0\\.8% Asian, 0\\.6% Native American, and 2% from other races. 2\\.3% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race.",
"As of the [census](/wiki/Census \"Census\") of 2000, there were 18,074 people, 6,999 households, and 5,256 families living in the township. The population density was {{convert\\|430\\.4\\|PD/sqmi\\|PD/km2\\|sp\\=us\\|adj\\=off}}. There were 7,217 housing units at an average density of {{convert\\|171\\.8\\|/mi2\\|/km2\\|disp\\=preunit\\|units \\|units\\|}}. The racial makeup of the township was 97\\.25% [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 \"White (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.92% [African American](/wiki/African_American_%28U.S._Census%29 \"African American (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.19% [Native American](/wiki/Native_American_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Native American (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.43% [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Asian (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.01% [Pacific Islander](/wiki/Pacific_Islander_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Pacific Islander (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.51% from [other races](/wiki/Race_%28United_States_Census%29 \"Race (United States Census)\"), and 0\\.69% from two or more races. [Hispanic](/wiki/Hispanic_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Hispanic (U.S. Census)\") or [Latino](/wiki/Latino_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Latino (U.S. Census)\") of any race were 1\\.03% of the population.",
"There were 6,999 households, out of which 33\\.6% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 63\\.0% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage \"Marriage\") living together, 7\\.8% had a female householder with no husband present, and 24\\.9% were non\\-families. 20\\.2% of all households were made up of individuals, and 7\\.7% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2\\.55 and the average family size was 2\\.93\\.",
"In the township the population was spread out, with 24\\.2% under the age of 18, 6\\.7% from 18 to 24, 31\\.1% from 25 to 44, 25\\.3% from 45 to 64, and 12\\.7% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 38 years. For every 100 females, there were 98\\.0 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 95\\.5 males.",
"The median income for a household in the township was $46,845, and the median income for a family was $53,252\\. Males had a median income of $36,478 versus $23,787 for females. The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income \"Per capita income\") for the township was $20,513\\. About 2\\.8% of families and 4\\.2% of the population were below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line \"Poverty line\"), including 5\\.2% of those under age 18 and 4\\.4% of those age 65 or over.",
""
] |
Plot summary
------------
### First Book
Aurora describes her childhood in [Florence](/wiki/Florence "Florence"), growing up as the daughter of a Tuscan mother and an English father. Her mother died when she was four, leaving her father to raise her. He was a scholar and imparted to her knowledge of Greek and Latin and a love of learning. Her father died when she was thirteen, and she was sent to England to live with his sister, her aunt, in Leigh Hall, her family's ancestral home. Her aunt tried to educate her in what she considered a ladylike manner, but Aurora discovered her father's old library and read scholarly books on her own.
She read many of Shakespeare's famous works and fell in love with his writing style, and aspired to be a great writer like him one day in her life.
### Second Book
This book starts on Aurora's twentieth birthday. Her cousin, Romney Leigh, proposes marriage to her. He is skeptical about her poetic ability, telling her that women do not have the passion, intellectual capacity, or redemptive qualities to be true artists. Because of this, and because she feels that he is too wrapped up in his social work and ideals to be a good husband, she angrily rejects him. Aurora's aunt chastises her for refusing him, telling her that because he is the male heir, he will inherit all of the estate and Aurora will be left with nothing. Shortly afterwards, her aunt dies. Romney attempts to give Aurora money, but she refuses it, deciding to go to London to make her living as a poet.
### Third Book
This book opens in Aurora's London apartment. She has been writing small popular poems for magazines, which have earned her an enthusiastic following among romantic young men and women, but she is dissatisfied. The great works of art of which she felt she was capable have arrived stillborn – she has the inspiration, but somehow cannot get it onto the page. While she works, frustrated, a visitor arrives for her, a Lady Waldemar. She is beautiful but sharp and sarcastic, and Aurora does not like her. Lady Waldemar explains to Aurora that she is in love with Romney, so much so that she lowers herself to do charity work with him, but Romney has decided to marry instead one of his [lower\-class](/wiki/Working_class "Working class") "projects", Marian Erle (whose name is a pun). She wants Aurora to speak to Marian and then to Romney and convince them of their foolishness. Aurora, partly out of curiosity and partly concern for Romney, goes to visit Marian and hears her life story: Marian's drunken mother tried to sell her into prostitution, and to escape it she ran away and became ill, eventually being taken into a poor hospital. There Romney found her and assisted her in getting work as a seamstress.
### Fourth Book
Marian continues her story, relating how Romney continued to aid her and ultimately proposed marriage to her. Aurora asks her if she is sure he truly loves her, to which Marian replies that Romney loves everything. She assures Aurora that despite her lower\-class status, she will be a loving and devoted wife to him. Before Aurora can answer, Romney enters Marian's room. He and Aurora awkwardly trade words, and she tells him she approves of Marian. He walks her home, and during their conversation she becomes confused about her own feelings for him. A month passes, and it is time for Romney and Marian's wedding – but Marian sends a letter in her place to the ceremony, telling Romney that she is not good enough for him. The crowd at the wedding assume that Romney has seduced and abandoned her, and attack him. Romney is devastated, and searches for Marian for days, but cannot find her. He and Aurora have a conversation about their respective disappointments with their missions; Romney can neither make a dent in the poverty he sees all around him nor gain the respect of the people he tries to help, while Aurora still has not succeeded in writing a real work of Art.
### Fifth Book
Aurora discusses her further attempts to write. She tells how she is determined not to be constricted by her woman's role but is doubtful that the modern age presents opportunities for epic poetry, writing, "Ay, but every age / Appears to souls who live in't (ask [Carlyle](/wiki/Thomas_Carlyle "Thomas Carlyle")) / Most unheroic". As the book continues, she grows more and more desperate, crying out to her muses and gods for inspiration. She confides that she has not seen Romney Leigh for almost two years, but she has heard that he has turned Leigh Hall into a refuge for the poor. At a stifling, insipid evening party at one of her well\-born friend's houses, she learns that Romney is engaged to marry Lady Waldemar, and bitterly reflects that "He loved not Marian, more than once he loved/Aurora." She decides that to find inspiration, she must travel to Italy, her mother's land, and in order to get the money sells some of her father's old books, as well as her own unfinished manuscript.
### Sixth Book
This book begins with Aurora in France, presumably on a stop\-over on the way to Italy. She wanders Paris with her head in the clouds, enjoying the atmosphere of history and the beauty that surrounds her. Suddenly, she catches a glimpse of a familiar face – it is Marian Erle. Frantically, Aurora follows her, losing her in the crowd eventually, but not before seeing that Marian is carrying a child. She is shocked, but resolves not to judge her harshly and tries for a week to find her, finally running into her by chance at a flower market. Marian takes her to her poor room, where she shows Aurora her baby boy. Aurora reproaches Marian for being promiscuous, but Marian angrily replies that far from it, she was attacked and raped and left pregnant. She explains to Aurora that Lady Waldemar convinced her that Romney did not truly love her, and sent her to France with her [lady's maid](/wiki/Lady%27s_maid "Lady's maid"). The lady's maid left her in a [brothel](/wiki/Brothel "Brothel"), where she was raped and almost driven insane, but she managed to escape.
### Seventh Book
Marian continues to tell Aurora her story: she was taken in by a kind lady as a maid, but was summarily fired when her pregnancy became apparent. Despite this, she could not bring herself to be unhappy: she was overjoyed that out of her dreadful experience, she could have the wonderful experience of motherhood. Aurora, after hearing Marian's story, apologizes profusely to her for misjudging her and offers her a "marriage" of sorts – she will protect Marian and her son and take them to Italy with her. Marian gratefully accepts. Aurora decides not to inform Romney that she has found Marian, but writes an angry letter to Lady Waldemar, telling her she knows of her disgraceful conduct towards Marian. Marian's presence, however, constantly brings Romney to Aurora's thoughts. She is surprised when a friend writes to her to congratulate her on her book – the manuscript she sold to get to Italy. She decides that perhaps it was better than she thought. She finds no particular inspiration in Italy, however, finding instead constant bittersweet memories of her childhood.
### Eighth Book
Several years have passed. Aurora, Marian, and the boy are living in a villa in Florence. Suddenly, Romney Leigh arrives, having discovered their whereabouts through a friend of Aurora's. Aurora, believing him to be married to Lady Waldemar, is cold with him. He tells her that he has read her book and believes it to be good and true Art, and tells her that he has reconsidered the judgmental strictures he passed on her previously. He relates to her the story failure of his attempts at social reform: after he converted Leigh Hall into a refuge, stories went around the village that it was a prison and a mob burned the whole thing to the ground. Aurora expresses her sympathy, but tells him she still cannot think well of his wife. Romney is surprised, and tells her that he is not married to Lady Waldemar, although he has a message from her to Aurora. Aurora tears it open, and reads it.
### Ninth Book
Aurora reads Lady Waldemar's letter, which claims that she did not intend to hurt Marian, only to remove her. Her scheme did not work; even after Marian was gone, Romney did not love her. She tells Aurora, in a vitriolic tone, that she, by her letter forcing Lady Waldemar to tell Romney that Marian lived, has doomed him to a loveless life with her, when he is truly in love with Aurora. Aurora, somewhat shocked both by the letter's contents and the angry rhetoric, dazedly asks Romney what he will do now, and he answers that he will marry Marian and raise her child as his own. Marian refuses him, however, stating that she prefers to remain as her child's only guardian and devote her life to him, rather than a husband, and that she has realized that what she thought was love for Romney was rather hero\-worship. She leaves, urging Romney to talk to Aurora. They converse, and forgive each other for any wrongs they have done to each other over the years. Romney admits to Aurora that he is blind. Aurora, in tears, confesses to Romney that she loves him, and has finally realized it; and also realizes that, in loving him, she will be able to complete herself and find her poetic muse once more. The poem ends with Aurora and Romney in a loving embrace, as she describes the landscape for his unseeing eyes in [Biblical](/wiki/Bible "Bible") metaphors.
|
[
"Plot summary\n------------",
"### First Book",
"Aurora describes her childhood in [Florence](/wiki/Florence \"Florence\"), growing up as the daughter of a Tuscan mother and an English father. Her mother died when she was four, leaving her father to raise her. He was a scholar and imparted to her knowledge of Greek and Latin and a love of learning. Her father died when she was thirteen, and she was sent to England to live with his sister, her aunt, in Leigh Hall, her family's ancestral home. Her aunt tried to educate her in what she considered a ladylike manner, but Aurora discovered her father's old library and read scholarly books on her own.",
"She read many of Shakespeare's famous works and fell in love with his writing style, and aspired to be a great writer like him one day in her life.",
"### Second Book",
"This book starts on Aurora's twentieth birthday. Her cousin, Romney Leigh, proposes marriage to her. He is skeptical about her poetic ability, telling her that women do not have the passion, intellectual capacity, or redemptive qualities to be true artists. Because of this, and because she feels that he is too wrapped up in his social work and ideals to be a good husband, she angrily rejects him. Aurora's aunt chastises her for refusing him, telling her that because he is the male heir, he will inherit all of the estate and Aurora will be left with nothing. Shortly afterwards, her aunt dies. Romney attempts to give Aurora money, but she refuses it, deciding to go to London to make her living as a poet.",
"### Third Book",
"This book opens in Aurora's London apartment. She has been writing small popular poems for magazines, which have earned her an enthusiastic following among romantic young men and women, but she is dissatisfied. The great works of art of which she felt she was capable have arrived stillborn – she has the inspiration, but somehow cannot get it onto the page. While she works, frustrated, a visitor arrives for her, a Lady Waldemar. She is beautiful but sharp and sarcastic, and Aurora does not like her. Lady Waldemar explains to Aurora that she is in love with Romney, so much so that she lowers herself to do charity work with him, but Romney has decided to marry instead one of his [lower\\-class](/wiki/Working_class \"Working class\") \"projects\", Marian Erle (whose name is a pun). She wants Aurora to speak to Marian and then to Romney and convince them of their foolishness. Aurora, partly out of curiosity and partly concern for Romney, goes to visit Marian and hears her life story: Marian's drunken mother tried to sell her into prostitution, and to escape it she ran away and became ill, eventually being taken into a poor hospital. There Romney found her and assisted her in getting work as a seamstress.",
"### Fourth Book",
"Marian continues her story, relating how Romney continued to aid her and ultimately proposed marriage to her. Aurora asks her if she is sure he truly loves her, to which Marian replies that Romney loves everything. She assures Aurora that despite her lower\\-class status, she will be a loving and devoted wife to him. Before Aurora can answer, Romney enters Marian's room. He and Aurora awkwardly trade words, and she tells him she approves of Marian. He walks her home, and during their conversation she becomes confused about her own feelings for him. A month passes, and it is time for Romney and Marian's wedding – but Marian sends a letter in her place to the ceremony, telling Romney that she is not good enough for him. The crowd at the wedding assume that Romney has seduced and abandoned her, and attack him. Romney is devastated, and searches for Marian for days, but cannot find her. He and Aurora have a conversation about their respective disappointments with their missions; Romney can neither make a dent in the poverty he sees all around him nor gain the respect of the people he tries to help, while Aurora still has not succeeded in writing a real work of Art.",
"### Fifth Book",
"Aurora discusses her further attempts to write. She tells how she is determined not to be constricted by her woman's role but is doubtful that the modern age presents opportunities for epic poetry, writing, \"Ay, but every age / Appears to souls who live in't (ask [Carlyle](/wiki/Thomas_Carlyle \"Thomas Carlyle\")) / Most unheroic\". As the book continues, she grows more and more desperate, crying out to her muses and gods for inspiration. She confides that she has not seen Romney Leigh for almost two years, but she has heard that he has turned Leigh Hall into a refuge for the poor. At a stifling, insipid evening party at one of her well\\-born friend's houses, she learns that Romney is engaged to marry Lady Waldemar, and bitterly reflects that \"He loved not Marian, more than once he loved/Aurora.\" She decides that to find inspiration, she must travel to Italy, her mother's land, and in order to get the money sells some of her father's old books, as well as her own unfinished manuscript.",
"### Sixth Book",
"This book begins with Aurora in France, presumably on a stop\\-over on the way to Italy. She wanders Paris with her head in the clouds, enjoying the atmosphere of history and the beauty that surrounds her. Suddenly, she catches a glimpse of a familiar face – it is Marian Erle. Frantically, Aurora follows her, losing her in the crowd eventually, but not before seeing that Marian is carrying a child. She is shocked, but resolves not to judge her harshly and tries for a week to find her, finally running into her by chance at a flower market. Marian takes her to her poor room, where she shows Aurora her baby boy. Aurora reproaches Marian for being promiscuous, but Marian angrily replies that far from it, she was attacked and raped and left pregnant. She explains to Aurora that Lady Waldemar convinced her that Romney did not truly love her, and sent her to France with her [lady's maid](/wiki/Lady%27s_maid \"Lady's maid\"). The lady's maid left her in a [brothel](/wiki/Brothel \"Brothel\"), where she was raped and almost driven insane, but she managed to escape.",
"### Seventh Book",
"Marian continues to tell Aurora her story: she was taken in by a kind lady as a maid, but was summarily fired when her pregnancy became apparent. Despite this, she could not bring herself to be unhappy: she was overjoyed that out of her dreadful experience, she could have the wonderful experience of motherhood. Aurora, after hearing Marian's story, apologizes profusely to her for misjudging her and offers her a \"marriage\" of sorts – she will protect Marian and her son and take them to Italy with her. Marian gratefully accepts. Aurora decides not to inform Romney that she has found Marian, but writes an angry letter to Lady Waldemar, telling her she knows of her disgraceful conduct towards Marian. Marian's presence, however, constantly brings Romney to Aurora's thoughts. She is surprised when a friend writes to her to congratulate her on her book – the manuscript she sold to get to Italy. She decides that perhaps it was better than she thought. She finds no particular inspiration in Italy, however, finding instead constant bittersweet memories of her childhood.",
"### Eighth Book",
"Several years have passed. Aurora, Marian, and the boy are living in a villa in Florence. Suddenly, Romney Leigh arrives, having discovered their whereabouts through a friend of Aurora's. Aurora, believing him to be married to Lady Waldemar, is cold with him. He tells her that he has read her book and believes it to be good and true Art, and tells her that he has reconsidered the judgmental strictures he passed on her previously. He relates to her the story failure of his attempts at social reform: after he converted Leigh Hall into a refuge, stories went around the village that it was a prison and a mob burned the whole thing to the ground. Aurora expresses her sympathy, but tells him she still cannot think well of his wife. Romney is surprised, and tells her that he is not married to Lady Waldemar, although he has a message from her to Aurora. Aurora tears it open, and reads it.",
"### Ninth Book",
"Aurora reads Lady Waldemar's letter, which claims that she did not intend to hurt Marian, only to remove her. Her scheme did not work; even after Marian was gone, Romney did not love her. She tells Aurora, in a vitriolic tone, that she, by her letter forcing Lady Waldemar to tell Romney that Marian lived, has doomed him to a loveless life with her, when he is truly in love with Aurora. Aurora, somewhat shocked both by the letter's contents and the angry rhetoric, dazedly asks Romney what he will do now, and he answers that he will marry Marian and raise her child as his own. Marian refuses him, however, stating that she prefers to remain as her child's only guardian and devote her life to him, rather than a husband, and that she has realized that what she thought was love for Romney was rather hero\\-worship. She leaves, urging Romney to talk to Aurora. They converse, and forgive each other for any wrongs they have done to each other over the years. Romney admits to Aurora that he is blind. Aurora, in tears, confesses to Romney that she loves him, and has finally realized it; and also realizes that, in loving him, she will be able to complete herself and find her poetic muse once more. The poem ends with Aurora and Romney in a loving embrace, as she describes the landscape for his unseeing eyes in [Biblical](/wiki/Bible \"Bible\") metaphors.",
""
] |
Ideas
-----
### Soft energy paths
[thumb\|Solar energy technologies, such as [solar water heaters](/wiki/Solar_water_heater "Solar water heater"), located on or near the buildings which they supply with energy, are a prime example of a soft energy technology.](/wiki/File:Solar_heater_dsc00632.jpg "Solar heater dsc00632.jpg")
Amory Lovins published an article in *[Foreign Affairs](/wiki/Foreign_Affairs "Foreign Affairs")* called "Energy Strategy: The Road Not Taken?" in 1976\. Lovins argued that the United States had arrived at an important crossroads and could take one of two paths. The first, supported by U.S. policy, promised a future of steadily increasing reliance on [fossil fuels](/wiki/Fossil_fuel "Fossil fuel") and [nuclear fission](/wiki/Nuclear_fission "Nuclear fission"), and had serious environmental risks. The alternative, which Lovins called "the soft path", favored "benign" sources of renewable energy like [wind power](/wiki/Wind_power "Wind power") and [solar power](/wiki/Solar_power "Solar power"), along with a heightened commitment to energy conservation and energy efficiency. In October 1977, *[The Atlantic](/wiki/The_Atlantic "The Atlantic")* ran a cover story on Lovins' ideas.{{cite magazine \|url\=https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/07/the\-elusive\-green\-economy/7554/ \|title\=The Elusive Green Economy \|last\=Green \|first\=Joshua \|date\=July–August 2009 \|magazine\=\[\[The Atlantic]] }} Residential solar energy technologies are prime examples of soft energy technologies and rapid deployment of simple, energy conserving, residential solar energy technologies is fundamental to a soft energy strategy.
Lovins has described the "hard energy path" as involving inefficient energy use and centralized, non\-renewable energy sources such as [fossil fuels](/wiki/Fossil_fuels "Fossil fuels"). He believes soft path impacts are more "gentle, pleasant and manageable," than hard path impacts. These impacts range from the individual and household level to those affecting the very fabric of society at the national and international level.Amory Lovins (1977\). *Soft Energy Paths: Towards a Durable Peace* {{ISBN\|0\-06\-090653\-7}}
*Lovins on the Soft Path* is a [documentary film](/wiki/Documentary_film "Documentary film") made by Amory and Hunter Lovins. It received "Best Science and Technology Film, [San Francisco International Film Festival](/wiki/San_Francisco_International_Film_Festival "San Francisco International Film Festival"), 1983; Blue Ribbon, [American Film Festival](/wiki/American_Film_Festival "American Film Festival"), 1982; Best of the Festival, Environmental Education Film Festival, 1982; Best Energy Film, International Environmental Film Festival, 1982; and Chris Bronze Plaque, Columbus International Film Festival, 1982\."*Lovins on the Soft Path: A Guide to the Film*, [RMI](/wiki/Rocky_Mountain_Institute "Rocky Mountain Institute"), 1985\.
### Nuclear power limitations
Lovins wrote (as an attempt to balance the inherently intermittent nature of solar and wind) that nuclear power plants are [intermittent](/wiki/Intermittent_power_source "Intermittent power source") in that they will sometimes fail unexpectedly, often for long periods of time.{{cite web\|first1\=Amory \|last1\=Lovins \|first2\=Imran \|last2\=Sheikh \|first3\=Alex \|last3\=Markevich \|date\=2009 \|url\=http://www.rmi.org/rmi/Library/E09\-01\_NuclearPowerClimateFixOrFolly \|title\=Nuclear Power:Climate Fix or Folly \|publisher\=\[\[Rocky Mountain Institute]] \|page\=10 \|quote\=All sources of electricity sometimes fail, differing only in how predictably, why, how often, how much, and for how long. Even the most reliable giant power plants are intermittent: they fail unexpectedly in billion\-watt chunks, often for long periods. \|access\-date\=October 20, 2012 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110927101054/http://www.rmi.org/rmi/Library/E09\-01\_NuclearPowerClimateFixOrFolly \|archive\-date\=September 27, 2011 }} For example, in the United States, 132 nuclear plants were built, and 21% were permanently and prematurely closed due to reliability or cost problems, while another 27% have at least once completely failed for a year or more.{{citation needed\|date\=February 2022}} The remaining U.S. nuclear plants produce approximately 90% of their full\-time full\-load potential, but even they must shut down (on average) for about 1 out of each 18 months for scheduled refueling and maintenance. To cope with such intermittence by nuclear (and centralized fossil\-fueled) power plants, utilities install a "reserve margin" of roughly 15% extra capacity spinning ready for instant use.
Lovins also argues that nuclear plants have an additional disadvantage: for safety, they must instantly shut down in a power failure, but due to the inherent nuclear\-physics of the systems, they can't be restarted quickly. For example, during the [Northeast Blackout of 2003](/wiki/Northeast_Blackout_of_2003 "Northeast Blackout of 2003"), nine operating U.S. nuclear units had to shut down temporarily. During the first three days after restarting, their output was less than 3% of normal. After twelve days of restart, their average capacity loss had exceeded 50 percent.
Lovins provided his general assessment of nuclear power in a 2011 *Huffington Post* article, saying that "Nuclear power is the only energy source where mishap or malice can kill so many people so far away; the only one whose ingredients can help make and hide nuclear bombs; the only climate solution that substitutes proliferation, accident, and high\-level radioactive waste dangers. Indeed, nuclear plants are so slow and costly to build that they reduce and retard climate protection". With respect to the [2011 Japanese nuclear accidents](/wiki/2011_Japanese_nuclear_accidents "2011 Japanese nuclear accidents"), Lovins wrote: "An earthquake\-and\-tsunami zone crowded with 127 million people is an unwise place for 54 reactors".{{cite news \|last\=Lovins \|first\=Amory \|date\=March 18, 2011 \|title\=With Nuclear Power, "No Acts of God Can Be Permitted" \|newspaper\=Huffington Post \|url\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/amory\-lovins/nuclear\-power\-fukushima\-\_b\_837643\.html }}
Regarding nuclear power in the United Kingdom, Amory Lovins commented in 2014 that:
> Britain's plan for a fleet of new nuclear power stations is ... unbelievable ... It is economically daft. The guaranteed price \[being offered to French state company EDF] is over seven times the unsubsidized price of new wind in the US, four or five times the unsubsidized price of new solar power in the US. Nuclear prices only go up. Renewable energy prices come down. There is absolutely no business case for nuclear. The British policy has nothing to do with economic or any other rational base for decision making.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/feb/17/amory\-lovins\-renewable\-energy \|title\= Amory Lovins: energy visionary sees renewables revolution in full swing \|first\=John \|last\=Vidal \|date\=18 February 2014 \|newspaper\=The Guardian }}
### Negawatt revolution
[thumb\|A "negawatt revolution" would involve the rapid deployment of electricity\-saving technologies, such as [compact fluorescent lamps](/wiki/Compact_fluorescent_lamps "Compact fluorescent lamps").](/wiki/File:Energiesparlampe_01_retouched.jpg "Energiesparlampe 01 retouched.jpg")
A [negawatt](/wiki/Negawatt "Negawatt") is a unit in watts of power saved. It is basically the opposite of a [watt](/wiki/Watt "Watt"). Amory Lovins has advocated a "negawatt revolution", arguing that utility customers don't want [kilowatt\-hours](/wiki/Kilowatt-hours "Kilowatt-hours") of electricity; they want energy services such as hot showers, cold beer, lit rooms, and spinning shafts, which can come more cheaply if electricity is used more efficiently.Amory B. Lovins. [The Negawatt Revolution](http://www.rmi.org/images/other/Energy/E90-20_NegawattRevolution.pdf) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120222042330/http://www.rmi.org/images/other/Energy/E90\-20\_NegawattRevolution.pdf\|date\=February 22, 2012}} *Across the Board*, Vol. XXVII No. 9, September 1990, pp. 21–22\.
### Hypercar
In 1994, Amory Lovins developed the design concept of the [Hypercar](/wiki/Hypercar_%28concept_car%29 "Hypercar (concept car)"). This vehicle would have ultra\-light construction with an [aerodynamic](/wiki/Aerodynamics "Aerodynamics") body using advanced [composite materials](/wiki/Composite_material "Composite material"), low\-[drag](/wiki/Drag_%28physics%29 "Drag (physics)") design, and [hybrid drive](/wiki/Hybrid_vehicle "Hybrid vehicle").[Hypercars, hydrogen, and the automotive transition](http://www.rmi.org/images/PDFs/Transportation/T04-01_HypercarH2AutoTrans.pdf) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130704183949/http://www.rmi.org/images/PDFs/Transportation/T04\-01\_HypercarH2AutoTrans.pdf \|date\=July 4, 2013 }} *International Journal of Vehicle Design*, Vol. 35, Nos. 1/2, 2004\. Designers of the Hypercar claim that it would achieve a three\- to fivefold improvement in [fuel economy](/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_automobiles "Fuel economy in automobiles"), equal or better performance, safety, amenity, and affordability, compared with today's [cars](/wiki/Automobile "Automobile").Diesendorf, Mark (2007\). *[Greenhouse Solutions with Sustainable Energy](/wiki/Greenhouse_Solutions_with_Sustainable_Energy "Greenhouse Solutions with Sustainable Energy")*, [UNSW Press](/wiki/UNSW_Press "UNSW Press"), pp. 191–192\.
In 1999, RMI took this process a step further by launching a for\-profit venture, Hypercar Inc. in which RMI has a minority interest.[What is a Hypercar Vehicle?](http://www.hypercar.com/) {{webarchive\|url\=http://webarchive.loc.gov/all/20021129183918/http%3A//www.hypercar.com/ \|date\=November 29, 2002 }} from Hypercar.com In 2004, Hypercar Inc. changed its name to [Fiberforge](/wiki/Fiberforge "Fiberforge") to better reflect the company's new goal of lowering the cost of high\-volume advanced\-composite structures by leveraging the patents of David F. Taggart, one of the founders of Hypercar, Inc.
Lovins says the commercialization of the Hypercar began in 2014, with the production of the all\-carbon electric [BMW i3](/wiki/BMW_i3 "BMW i3") family and the 313 miles per gallon [Volkswagen XL1](/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car%232011_model "Volkswagen 1-litre car#2011 model").
### Citizen participation
Lovins does not see his energy ideas as green or left\-wing, and he is an advocate of [private enterprise](/wiki/Private_enterprise "Private enterprise") and [free market economics](/wiki/Free_market_economics "Free market economics"). He notes that [Rupert Murdoch](/wiki/Rupert_Murdoch "Rupert Murdoch") has made News Corporation carbon\-neutral, with savings of millions of dollars. But, says Lovins, large institutions are becoming more "gridlocked and moribund", and he supports the rise of "citizen organizations" around the world.
> [Paul Hawken](/wiki/Paul_Hawken "Paul Hawken")'s *[Blessed Unrest](/wiki/Blessed_Unrest "Blessed Unrest")* chronicles the rise of millions of non\-profit citizen organizations around the world — the greatest [social movement](/wiki/Social_movement "Social movement") in history. As central institutions become more gridlocked and moribund, a new vitality is beginning to spread renewal through the stem to the flower.Amory Lovins, *[Reinventing Fire: Bold Business Solutions for the New Energy Era](/wiki/Reinventing_Fire:Bold_Business_Solutions_for_the_New_Energy_Era "Bold Business Solutions for the New Energy Era")* (2011\) p. 251 {{ISBN\|978\-1\-60358\-371\-8}}
|
[
"Ideas\n-----",
"### Soft energy paths",
"[thumb\\|Solar energy technologies, such as [solar water heaters](/wiki/Solar_water_heater \"Solar water heater\"), located on or near the buildings which they supply with energy, are a prime example of a soft energy technology.](/wiki/File:Solar_heater_dsc00632.jpg \"Solar heater dsc00632.jpg\")",
"Amory Lovins published an article in *[Foreign Affairs](/wiki/Foreign_Affairs \"Foreign Affairs\")* called \"Energy Strategy: The Road Not Taken?\" in 1976\\. Lovins argued that the United States had arrived at an important crossroads and could take one of two paths. The first, supported by U.S. policy, promised a future of steadily increasing reliance on [fossil fuels](/wiki/Fossil_fuel \"Fossil fuel\") and [nuclear fission](/wiki/Nuclear_fission \"Nuclear fission\"), and had serious environmental risks. The alternative, which Lovins called \"the soft path\", favored \"benign\" sources of renewable energy like [wind power](/wiki/Wind_power \"Wind power\") and [solar power](/wiki/Solar_power \"Solar power\"), along with a heightened commitment to energy conservation and energy efficiency. In October 1977, *[The Atlantic](/wiki/The_Atlantic \"The Atlantic\")* ran a cover story on Lovins' ideas.{{cite magazine \\|url\\=https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/07/the\\-elusive\\-green\\-economy/7554/ \\|title\\=The Elusive Green Economy \\|last\\=Green \\|first\\=Joshua \\|date\\=July–August 2009 \\|magazine\\=\\[\\[The Atlantic]] }} Residential solar energy technologies are prime examples of soft energy technologies and rapid deployment of simple, energy conserving, residential solar energy technologies is fundamental to a soft energy strategy.",
"Lovins has described the \"hard energy path\" as involving inefficient energy use and centralized, non\\-renewable energy sources such as [fossil fuels](/wiki/Fossil_fuels \"Fossil fuels\"). He believes soft path impacts are more \"gentle, pleasant and manageable,\" than hard path impacts. These impacts range from the individual and household level to those affecting the very fabric of society at the national and international level.Amory Lovins (1977\\). *Soft Energy Paths: Towards a Durable Peace* {{ISBN\\|0\\-06\\-090653\\-7}}",
"*Lovins on the Soft Path* is a [documentary film](/wiki/Documentary_film \"Documentary film\") made by Amory and Hunter Lovins. It received \"Best Science and Technology Film, [San Francisco International Film Festival](/wiki/San_Francisco_International_Film_Festival \"San Francisco International Film Festival\"), 1983; Blue Ribbon, [American Film Festival](/wiki/American_Film_Festival \"American Film Festival\"), 1982; Best of the Festival, Environmental Education Film Festival, 1982; Best Energy Film, International Environmental Film Festival, 1982; and Chris Bronze Plaque, Columbus International Film Festival, 1982\\.\"*Lovins on the Soft Path: A Guide to the Film*, [RMI](/wiki/Rocky_Mountain_Institute \"Rocky Mountain Institute\"), 1985\\.",
"### Nuclear power limitations",
"Lovins wrote (as an attempt to balance the inherently intermittent nature of solar and wind) that nuclear power plants are [intermittent](/wiki/Intermittent_power_source \"Intermittent power source\") in that they will sometimes fail unexpectedly, often for long periods of time.{{cite web\\|first1\\=Amory \\|last1\\=Lovins \\|first2\\=Imran \\|last2\\=Sheikh \\|first3\\=Alex \\|last3\\=Markevich \\|date\\=2009 \\|url\\=http://www.rmi.org/rmi/Library/E09\\-01\\_NuclearPowerClimateFixOrFolly \\|title\\=Nuclear Power:Climate Fix or Folly \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Rocky Mountain Institute]] \\|page\\=10 \\|quote\\=All sources of electricity sometimes fail, differing only in how predictably, why, how often, how much, and for how long. Even the most reliable giant power plants are intermittent: they fail unexpectedly in billion\\-watt chunks, often for long periods. \\|access\\-date\\=October 20, 2012 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110927101054/http://www.rmi.org/rmi/Library/E09\\-01\\_NuclearPowerClimateFixOrFolly \\|archive\\-date\\=September 27, 2011 }} For example, in the United States, 132 nuclear plants were built, and 21% were permanently and prematurely closed due to reliability or cost problems, while another 27% have at least once completely failed for a year or more.{{citation needed\\|date\\=February 2022}} The remaining U.S. nuclear plants produce approximately 90% of their full\\-time full\\-load potential, but even they must shut down (on average) for about 1 out of each 18 months for scheduled refueling and maintenance. To cope with such intermittence by nuclear (and centralized fossil\\-fueled) power plants, utilities install a \"reserve margin\" of roughly 15% extra capacity spinning ready for instant use.",
"Lovins also argues that nuclear plants have an additional disadvantage: for safety, they must instantly shut down in a power failure, but due to the inherent nuclear\\-physics of the systems, they can't be restarted quickly. For example, during the [Northeast Blackout of 2003](/wiki/Northeast_Blackout_of_2003 \"Northeast Blackout of 2003\"), nine operating U.S. nuclear units had to shut down temporarily. During the first three days after restarting, their output was less than 3% of normal. After twelve days of restart, their average capacity loss had exceeded 50 percent.",
"Lovins provided his general assessment of nuclear power in a 2011 *Huffington Post* article, saying that \"Nuclear power is the only energy source where mishap or malice can kill so many people so far away; the only one whose ingredients can help make and hide nuclear bombs; the only climate solution that substitutes proliferation, accident, and high\\-level radioactive waste dangers. Indeed, nuclear plants are so slow and costly to build that they reduce and retard climate protection\". With respect to the [2011 Japanese nuclear accidents](/wiki/2011_Japanese_nuclear_accidents \"2011 Japanese nuclear accidents\"), Lovins wrote: \"An earthquake\\-and\\-tsunami zone crowded with 127 million people is an unwise place for 54 reactors\".{{cite news \\|last\\=Lovins \\|first\\=Amory \\|date\\=March 18, 2011 \\|title\\=With Nuclear Power, \"No Acts of God Can Be Permitted\" \\|newspaper\\=Huffington Post \\|url\\=https://www.huffingtonpost.com/amory\\-lovins/nuclear\\-power\\-fukushima\\-\\_b\\_837643\\.html }}",
"Regarding nuclear power in the United Kingdom, Amory Lovins commented in 2014 that:",
"",
"> Britain's plan for a fleet of new nuclear power stations is ... unbelievable ... It is economically daft. The guaranteed price \\[being offered to French state company EDF] is over seven times the unsubsidized price of new wind in the US, four or five times the unsubsidized price of new solar power in the US. Nuclear prices only go up. Renewable energy prices come down. There is absolutely no business case for nuclear. The British policy has nothing to do with economic or any other rational base for decision making.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/feb/17/amory\\-lovins\\-renewable\\-energy \\|title\\= Amory Lovins: energy visionary sees renewables revolution in full swing \\|first\\=John \\|last\\=Vidal \\|date\\=18 February 2014 \\|newspaper\\=The Guardian }}",
"### Negawatt revolution",
"[thumb\\|A \"negawatt revolution\" would involve the rapid deployment of electricity\\-saving technologies, such as [compact fluorescent lamps](/wiki/Compact_fluorescent_lamps \"Compact fluorescent lamps\").](/wiki/File:Energiesparlampe_01_retouched.jpg \"Energiesparlampe 01 retouched.jpg\")",
"A [negawatt](/wiki/Negawatt \"Negawatt\") is a unit in watts of power saved. It is basically the opposite of a [watt](/wiki/Watt \"Watt\"). Amory Lovins has advocated a \"negawatt revolution\", arguing that utility customers don't want [kilowatt\\-hours](/wiki/Kilowatt-hours \"Kilowatt-hours\") of electricity; they want energy services such as hot showers, cold beer, lit rooms, and spinning shafts, which can come more cheaply if electricity is used more efficiently.Amory B. Lovins. [The Negawatt Revolution](http://www.rmi.org/images/other/Energy/E90-20_NegawattRevolution.pdf) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120222042330/http://www.rmi.org/images/other/Energy/E90\\-20\\_NegawattRevolution.pdf\\|date\\=February 22, 2012}} *Across the Board*, Vol. XXVII No. 9, September 1990, pp. 21–22\\.",
"### Hypercar",
"In 1994, Amory Lovins developed the design concept of the [Hypercar](/wiki/Hypercar_%28concept_car%29 \"Hypercar (concept car)\"). This vehicle would have ultra\\-light construction with an [aerodynamic](/wiki/Aerodynamics \"Aerodynamics\") body using advanced [composite materials](/wiki/Composite_material \"Composite material\"), low\\-[drag](/wiki/Drag_%28physics%29 \"Drag (physics)\") design, and [hybrid drive](/wiki/Hybrid_vehicle \"Hybrid vehicle\").[Hypercars, hydrogen, and the automotive transition](http://www.rmi.org/images/PDFs/Transportation/T04-01_HypercarH2AutoTrans.pdf) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130704183949/http://www.rmi.org/images/PDFs/Transportation/T04\\-01\\_HypercarH2AutoTrans.pdf \\|date\\=July 4, 2013 }} *International Journal of Vehicle Design*, Vol. 35, Nos. 1/2, 2004\\. Designers of the Hypercar claim that it would achieve a three\\- to fivefold improvement in [fuel economy](/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_automobiles \"Fuel economy in automobiles\"), equal or better performance, safety, amenity, and affordability, compared with today's [cars](/wiki/Automobile \"Automobile\").Diesendorf, Mark (2007\\). *[Greenhouse Solutions with Sustainable Energy](/wiki/Greenhouse_Solutions_with_Sustainable_Energy \"Greenhouse Solutions with Sustainable Energy\")*, [UNSW Press](/wiki/UNSW_Press \"UNSW Press\"), pp. 191–192\\.",
"In 1999, RMI took this process a step further by launching a for\\-profit venture, Hypercar Inc. in which RMI has a minority interest.[What is a Hypercar Vehicle?](http://www.hypercar.com/) {{webarchive\\|url\\=http://webarchive.loc.gov/all/20021129183918/http%3A//www.hypercar.com/ \\|date\\=November 29, 2002 }} from Hypercar.com In 2004, Hypercar Inc. changed its name to [Fiberforge](/wiki/Fiberforge \"Fiberforge\") to better reflect the company's new goal of lowering the cost of high\\-volume advanced\\-composite structures by leveraging the patents of David F. Taggart, one of the founders of Hypercar, Inc.",
"Lovins says the commercialization of the Hypercar began in 2014, with the production of the all\\-carbon electric [BMW i3](/wiki/BMW_i3 \"BMW i3\") family and the 313 miles per gallon [Volkswagen XL1](/wiki/Volkswagen_1-litre_car%232011_model \"Volkswagen 1-litre car#2011 model\").",
"### Citizen participation",
"Lovins does not see his energy ideas as green or left\\-wing, and he is an advocate of [private enterprise](/wiki/Private_enterprise \"Private enterprise\") and [free market economics](/wiki/Free_market_economics \"Free market economics\"). He notes that [Rupert Murdoch](/wiki/Rupert_Murdoch \"Rupert Murdoch\") has made News Corporation carbon\\-neutral, with savings of millions of dollars. But, says Lovins, large institutions are becoming more \"gridlocked and moribund\", and he supports the rise of \"citizen organizations\" around the world.",
"",
"> [Paul Hawken](/wiki/Paul_Hawken \"Paul Hawken\")'s *[Blessed Unrest](/wiki/Blessed_Unrest \"Blessed Unrest\")* chronicles the rise of millions of non\\-profit citizen organizations around the world — the greatest [social movement](/wiki/Social_movement \"Social movement\") in history. As central institutions become more gridlocked and moribund, a new vitality is beginning to spread renewal through the stem to the flower.Amory Lovins, *[Reinventing Fire: Bold Business Solutions for the New Energy Era](/wiki/Reinventing_Fire:Bold_Business_Solutions_for_the_New_Energy_Era \"Bold Business Solutions for the New Energy Era\")* (2011\\) p. 251 {{ISBN\\|978\\-1\\-60358\\-371\\-8}}",
""
] |
History
-------
### Formation
The AK Party was established by a wide range of politicians of various political parties and a number of new politicians in 2001\. The core of the party was formed from the reformist faction of the Islamist [Virtue Party](/wiki/Virtue_Party "Virtue Party"), including people such as [Abdullah Gül](/wiki/Abdullah_G%C3%BCl "Abdullah Gül") and [Bülent Arınç](/wiki/B%C3%BClent_Ar%C4%B1n%C3%A7 "Bülent Arınç"), while a second founding group consisted of members of the social conservative [Motherland Party](/wiki/Motherland_Party_%28Turkey%29 "Motherland Party (Turkey)") who had been close to [Turgut Özal](/wiki/Turgut_%C3%96zal "Turgut Özal"), such as [Cemil Çiçek](/wiki/Cemil_%C3%87i%C3%A7ek "Cemil Çiçek") and [Abdülkadir Aksu](/wiki/Abd%C3%BClkadir_Aksu "Abdülkadir Aksu").{{Cite web\|title\=Erdoğan AKP'nin genleriyle oynadı\|url\=http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120317052525/http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\|archive\-date\=17 March 2012\|access\-date\=24 March 2011}} Historically the party was described as [liberal conservative](/wiki/Liberal_conservatism "Liberal conservatism"),{{Cite book\|title\=Turkey between Nationalism and Globalization\|first\=Riva\|last\=Kastoryano\|year\=2013\|publisher\=Routledge\|page\=97}} [conservative liberal](/wiki/Conservative_liberalism "Conservative liberalism"),{{refn\|{{cite book\|title\=Sexualities in World Politics\|publisher\=Routledge\|page\=126\|first\=Manuela\|last\=Picq\|year\=2015}}{{cite book\|first\=Ayse\|last\=Bugra\|title\=New Capitalism in Turkey: The Relationship between Politics, Religion and Business\|year\=2014\|page\=49\|publisher\=Edward Elgar Publishing}}{{cite book\|first\=Birol\|last\=Yesilada\|title\=Islamization of Turkey under the AK Party Rule\|page\=63\|publisher\=Routledge\|year\=2013}}}} [economically liberal](/wiki/Economic_liberalism "Economic liberalism"),{{cite book\|title\=On the Road to EU Membership: The Economic Transformation of Turkey\|publisher\=Brussels University Press\|year\=2011\|page\=63\|first\=Selen Sarisoy\|last\=Guerin}}{{cite book\|first\=Ayse\|last\=Bugra\|title\=New Capitalism in Turkey: The Relationship between Politics, Religion and Business\|year\=2014\|page\=60\|publisher\=Edward Elgar Publishing}} [pro\-European](/wiki/Pro-Europeanism "Pro-Europeanism"),{{Cite news \|date\=2022\-05\-13 \|title\=When democratic spin conceals a descent into dictatorship \|work\=Financial Times \|url\=https://www.ft.com/content/ff757408\-d955\-433b\-af8d\-f58085998c1b \|archive\-url\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20221210/https://www.ft.com/content/ff757408\-d955\-433b\-af8d\-f58085998c1b \|archive\-date\=10 December 2022 \|access\-date\=2022\-05\-13\|url\-access\=subscription}}{{Cite web \|title\=Are the fortunes of Turkey's AK Party on the wane? \|url\=https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/global\-extremes/are\-the\-fortunes\-of\-turkeys\-akp\-on\-the\-wane/ \|access\-date\=2022\-05\-13 \|website\=openDemocracy \|language\=en}} and [center\-right](/wiki/Center-right_politics "Center-right politics").{{Cite journal\|url\=https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10\.1080/13569770410001701233\&ved\=2ahUKEwi3h\-up0\-DxAhVzgf0HHfQtCmgQFnoECCIQAQ\&usg\=AOvVaw1LCaXIU5XyicT\_dv4DMXsW\|doi \= 10\.1080/13569770410001701233\|title \= Center\-right politics in Turkey after the November 2002 general election: Neo\-liberalism with a Muslim face\|year \= 2004\|last1 \= Coşar\|first1 \= Simten\|last2 \= Özman\|first2 \= Aylin\|journal \= Contemporary Politics\|volume \= 10\|pages \= 57–74\|s2cid \= 143771719\|url\-access \= subscription}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.britannica.com/place/Turkey/Rise\-of\-the\-AKP\-in\-the\-21st\-century\&ved\=2ahUKEwj\-5\_r20\-DxAhWOg\_0HHRgYBrAQFnoECBAQAQ\&usg\=AOvVaw1Z\_vxFoBjXeg\-Ej4jw9FOb\|title\=Turkey \| Location, Geography, People, Economy, Culture, \& History\|date\=14 June 2023}}
Some members of the [True Path Party](/wiki/True_Path_Party_%28Turkey%29 "True Path Party (Turkey)"), such as [Hüseyin Çelik](/wiki/H%C3%BCseyin_%C3%87elik "Hüseyin Çelik") and [Köksal Toptan](/wiki/K%C3%B6ksal_Toptan "Köksal Toptan"), joined the AK Party. Some members, such as [Kürşad Tüzmen](/wiki/K%C3%BCr%C5%9Fad_T%C3%BCzmen "Kürşad Tüzmen") or [Ertuğrul Günay](/wiki/Ertu%C4%9Frul_G%C3%BCnay "Ertuğrul Günay"), had [nationalist](/wiki/Turkish_nationalism "Turkish nationalism") or [center\-left](/wiki/Center-left "Center-left") backgrounds respectively, while representatives of the nascent, more clearly anti\-capitalist 'Muslim left' current were largely excluded.{{Cite web\|title\=Erdoğan AK Parti'nin genleriyle oynadı\|url\=http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120317052525/http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\|archive\-date\=17 March 2012\|access\-date\=24 March 2011}} In addition, a large number of people joined a political party for the first time, such as [Ali Babacan](/wiki/Ali_Babacan "Ali Babacan"), [Nimet Baş](/wiki/Nimet_Ba%C5%9F "Nimet Baş"), [Egemen Bağış](/wiki/Egemen_Ba%C4%9F%C4%B1%C5%9F "Egemen Bağış") and [Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu](/wiki/Mevl%C3%BCt_%C3%87avu%C5%9Fo%C4%9Flu "Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu").
### Closure cases
{{See also\|Secularism in Turkey}}
Controversies over whether the party remains committed to [secular principles](/wiki/Secularism "Secularism") enshrined in the [Turkish constitution](/wiki/Turkish_constitution "Turkish constitution") have dominated Turkish politics since 2002\. Turkey's constitution established the country as a secular state and prohibits any political parties that promote [Islamism](/wiki/Islamism "Islamism") or [shariah law](/wiki/Shariah_law "Shariah law").
Since coming to power, the party has brought about tighter regulations on [abortion](/wiki/Abortion "Abortion") and higher taxes on [alcohol consumption](/wiki/Alcohol_laws_of_Turkey "Alcohol laws of Turkey"), leading to allegations that it is covertly undermining Turkish secularism. Some activists, commentators, opponents and government officials have accused the party of Islamism. The Justice and Development Party has faced two "closure cases" (attempts to officially ban the party, usually for Islamist practices) in 2002 and 2008\.
Just 10 days before the [national elections of 2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election "2002 Turkish general election"), Turkey's chief prosecutor, Sabih Kanadoğlu, asked the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey "Constitutional Court of Turkey") to close the Justice and Development Party, which was leading in the polls at that time. The chief prosecutor charged the Justice and Development Party with abusing the law and justice. He based his case on the fact that the party's leader had been banned from political life for reading an Islamist poem, and thus the party had no standing in elections. The [European Commission](/wiki/European_Commission "European Commission") had previously criticized Turkey for banning the party's leader from participating in elections.{{cite news\|title\=Turkey mulls banning leading party before elections\|url\=http://www.euractiv.com/en/enlargement/turkey\-mulls\-banning\-leading\-party\-elections/article\-111091\|date\=23 October 2002\|publisher\=EurActiv\|access\-date\=15 February 2011\|archive\-date\=12 May 2011\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110512070624/http://www.euractiv.com/en/enlargement/turkey\-mulls\-banning\-leading\-party\-elections/article\-111091\|url\-status\=dead}}
[300px\|thumb\|The [Republic Protests](/wiki/Republic_Protests "Republic Protests") took place in 2007 in support of the [Kemalist reforms](/wiki/Kemalism "Kemalism"), particularly [state secularism](/wiki/Secular_state "Secular state") and [democracy](/wiki/Democracy "Democracy"), against the perceived [Islamization](/wiki/Islamization "Islamization") of Turkey under the ruling Justice and Development Party.](/wiki/File:Protect_Your_Republic_Protest_-_1_%282007-04-14%29.jpg "Protect Your Republic Protest - 1 (2007-04-14).jpg")
The party again faced a [closure trial in 2008](/wiki/2008_Justice_and_Development_Party_closure_trial "2008 Justice and Development Party closure trial") brought about by the lifting of a long\-standing university ban on headscarves.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/jul/30/turkey.nato1\|title\=Turkey's governing party avoids being shut down for anti\-secularism \|author\=Robert Tait\|newspaper\=The Guardian \|access\-date\=7 June 2015\|date\=30 July 2008}} At an international press conference in Spain, Erdoğan answered a question of a journalist by saying, "What if the headscarf is a symbol? Even if it were a political symbol, does that give \[one the] right to ban it? Could you bring prohibitions to symbols?" These statements led to a joint proposal of the Justice and Development Party and the far\-right [Nationalist Movement Party](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party "Nationalist Movement Party") for changing the constitution and the law to lift a ban on women wearing headscarves at state universities.
Soon afterwards, Turkey's chief prosecutor, [Abdurrahman Yalçınkaya](/wiki/Abdurrahman_Yal%C3%A7%C4%B1nkaya "Abdurrahman Yalçınkaya"), asked the [Constitutional Court of Turkey](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey "Constitutional Court of Turkey") to close down the party on charges of violating the [separation of religion and state](/wiki/Secularism_in_Turkey "Secularism in Turkey") in Turkey.{{cite news \|url\=http://arama.hurriyet.com.tr/arsivnews.aspx?id\=\-634073 \|title\=From landmark success to closure: AK Party's journey \|work\=\[\[Turkish Daily News]] \|access\-date\=11 August 2008 \|date\=22 July 2008 \|first\=Izgi \|last\=Gungor }}{{dead link\|date\=November 2017 \|bot\=InternetArchiveBot \|fix\-attempted\=yes }}
{{cite news\|url\=http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\-web/detaylar.do?load\=detay\&link\=136476\|access\-date\=16 November 2008\|title\=Closure case against ruling party creates shockwaves\|date\=15 March 2008\|work\=\[\[Today's Zaman]]\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080421214216/http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\-web/detaylar.do?load\=detay\&link\=136476\|archive\-date\=21 April 2008}}
{{cite news\|url\=http://i.milliyet.com.tr/akpsavunma/default.aspx?ver\=59\|access\-date\=4 September 2008\|title\=Full text of testimony\|work\=\[\[Milliyet]]\|language\=tr\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110512171455/http://i.milliyet.com.tr/akpsavunma/default.aspx?ver\=59\|archive\-date\=12 May 2011\|url\-status\=dead}} The closure request failed by only one vote, as only six of the 11 judges ruled in favor, with seven required; however, 10 out of 11 judges agreed that the Justice and Development Party had become "a center for anti\-secular activities", leading to a loss of 50% of the state funding for the party.*[Today's Zaman](/wiki/Today%27s_Zaman "Today's Zaman")*, 19 August 2013, [AK Party to ask for retrial by Constitutional Court](http://todayszaman.com/news-323934-ak-party-to-ask-for-retrial-by-constitutional-court.html) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130820065944/http://todayszaman.com/news\-323934\-ak\-party\-to\-ask\-for\-retrial\-by\-constitutional\-court.html \|date\=20 August 2013 }}
### Elections
{{Outdated\|part\=2023 and 2024 elections\|date\=March 2024\|reason\=The 2023 and 2024 elections have concluded}}
The party has won pluralities in the seven most recent legislative elections, those of [2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election "2002 Turkish general election"), [2007](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election "2007 Turkish general election"), [2011](/wiki/2011_Turkish_general_election "2011 Turkish general election"), [June 2015](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election "June 2015 Turkish general election"), [November 2015](/wiki/November_2015_Turkish_general_election "November 2015 Turkish general election"), [2018](/wiki/2018_Turkish_parliamentary_election "2018 Turkish parliamentary election") and [2023](/wiki/2023_Turkish_parliamentary_election "2023 Turkish parliamentary election"). The party held a majority of seats for 13 years, but lost it in June 2015, only to regain it in the snap election of November 2015 but then lose it again in 2018\. Its past electoral success has been mirrored in the three local elections held since the party's establishment, coming first in [2004](/wiki/2004_Turkish_local_elections "2004 Turkish local elections"), [2009](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections") and [2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_local_elections "2014 Turkish local elections") respectively. However, the party lost most of Turkey's biggest cities including [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul") and [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") in [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections "2019 Turkish local elections"), which has been attributed to the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 "Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)"), accusations of authoritarianism, as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey "Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey").
#### 2002 general elections
The AK Party won a sweeping victory in the [2002 elections](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election "2002 Turkish general election"), which saw every party previously represented in the Grand National Assembly ejected from the chamber. In the process, it won a two\-thirds majority of seats, becoming the first Turkish party in 11 years to win an outright majority. Erdoğan, as the leader of the biggest party in parliament, would have been normally given the task to form a cabinet.
However, according to the Turkish Constitution Article 109 the prime ministers had to be also a representative of the Turkish Parliament. Erdoğan, who was banned from holding any political office after a 1994 incident in which he read a poem deemed pro\-Islamist by judges, was therefore not. As a result, Gül became prime minister.
It survived the crisis over the [2003 invasion of Iraq](/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq "2003 invasion of Iraq") despite a massive back bench rebellion where over a hundred AK Party MPs joined those of the opposition [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party "Republican People's Party") (CHP) in parliament to prevent the government from allowing the [United States](/wiki/United_States "United States") to launch a Northern offensive in Iraq from Turkish territory. Later, Erdoğan's ban was lifted with the help of the CHP and Erdoğan became prime minister by being elected to the parliament after a [by\-election in Siirt](/wiki/2003_Siirt_Province_by-election "2003 Siirt Province by-election").
The AK Party has undertaken structural reforms, and during its rule Turkey has seen rapid growth and an end to its three decade long period of high inflation rates. Inflation had fallen to 8\.8% by 2004\.
Influential business publications such as *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist "The Economist")* consider the AK Party's government the most successful in Turkey in decades.{{cite news \|url\=http://www.economist.com/opinion/displaystory.cfm?story\_id\=9116747 \|access\-date\=22 July 2008 \|title\=The battle for Turkey's soul (Democracy v secularism in Turkey) \|date\=3 May 2007 \|newspaper\=\[\[The Economist]] \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180812111802/https://www.economist.com/leaders/2007/05/03/the\-battle\-for\-turkeys\-soul\|archive\-date\=12 August 2018}}
#### 2004 local elections
In the local elections of 2004, the AK Party won 42% of the votes, making inroads against the secular [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party "Republican People's Party") (CHP) on the South and West Coasts, and against the [Social Democratic People's Party](/wiki/Social_Democratic_People%27s_Party_%28Turkey%29 "Social Democratic People's Party (Turkey)"), which is supported by some [Kurds](/wiki/Kurds "Kurds") in the South\-East of Turkey.
In January 2005, the AK Party was admitted as an observer member in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party "European People's Party") (EPP). However, it left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_European_Conservatives_and_Reformists "Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists") (AECR) in 2013\.
#### 2007 elections
[250px\|thumb\|Voter base by monthly household income. AK Party is the largest party in group 1, 2, 3 and 4, while CHP is the largest in group 5, the richest 20% of Turkey.](/wiki/File:Se%C3%A7menin_gelir_d%C3%BCzeyine_g%C3%B6re_oy_da%C4%9F%C4%B1l%C4%B1m%C4%B1.PNG "Seçmenin gelir düzeyine göre oy dağılımı.PNG")
On 14 April 2007, an estimated 300,000 people marched in [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") to protest the possible candidacy of Erdoğan in the [2007 presidential election](/wiki/2007_Turkish_presidential_election "2007 Turkish presidential election"), afraid that if elected as president, he would alter the secular nature of the Turkish state."[Secular rally targets Turkish PM](http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6554851.stm)," BBC News, 14 April 2007\. Erdoğan announced on 24 April 2007 that the party had decided to nominate Abdullah Gül as the AK Party candidate in the presidential election."[Turkey's ruling party announces FM Gul as presidential candidate](http://english.people.com.cn/200704/24/eng20070424_369332.html)," [Xinhua](/wiki/Xinhua "Xinhua"), 24 April 2007\. The protests continued over the next several weeks, with over one million reported at an 29 April rally in Istanbul,{{cite news\|url\=http://www.afp.fr/english/news/stories/070429134050\.kd2e8gv7\.html\|title\=More than one million rally in Turkey for secularism, democracy\|publisher\=\[\[Agence France\-Presse]]\|access\-date\=29 April 2007}}{{dead link\|date\=December 2017 \|bot\=InternetArchiveBot \|fix\-attempted\=yes }}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSL2910950920070429\|title\=One million Turks rally against government\|work\=\[\[Reuters]]\|access\-date\=30 April 2007 \|date\=29 April 2007}} tens of thousands reported at separate protests on 4 May in [Manisa](/wiki/Manisa "Manisa") and [Çanakkale](/wiki/%C3%87anakkale "Çanakkale"),{{cite web\|url\=http://www.milliyet.com.tr/2007/05/04/guncel/axgun01\.html \|title\=Saylan: Manisa mitingi önemli\|work\=\[\[Milliyet]]\|language\=tr\|access\-date\=4 May 2007}} and one million in [İzmir](/wiki/%C4%B0zmir "İzmir") on 13 May.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\_protest\_ahead\_of\_early\_elections.html?siteSect\=143\&sid\=7813908\&cKey\=1179061645000\|title\=Turks protest ahead of early elections\|work\=\[\[Swissinfo]]\|access\-date\=13 May 2007 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070930222218/http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\_protest\_ahead\_of\_early\_elections.html?siteSect\=143\&sid\=7813908\&cKey\=1179061645000 \|archive\-date\=30 September 2007}}
Early [parliamentary elections](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election "2007 Turkish general election") were called after the failure of the parties in parliament to agree on the next Turkish president. The opposition parties boycotted the parliamentary vote and deadlocked the election process. At the same time, Erdoğan claimed the failure to elect a president was a failure of the Turkish political system and proposed to modify the constitution.
The AK Party achieved a significant victory in the rescheduled 22 July 2007 elections with 46\.6% of the vote, translating into control of 341 of the 550 available parliamentary seats. Although the AK Party received significantly more votes in 2007 than in 2002, the number of parliamentary seats they controlled decreased due to the rules of the [Turkish electoral system](/wiki/Elections_in_Turkey "Elections in Turkey"). However, they retained a comfortable ruling majority.
Nationally, the elections of 2007 saw a major advance for the AK Party, with the party outpolling the pro\-Kurdish [Democratic Society Party](/wiki/Democratic_Society_Party "Democratic Society Party") in traditional Kurdish strongholds such as [Van](/wiki/Van_Province "Van Province") and [Mardin](/wiki/Mardin_Province "Mardin Province"), as well as outpolling the secular\-left CHP in traditionally secular areas such as [Antalya](/wiki/Antalya_Province "Antalya Province") and [Artvin](/wiki/Artvin_Province "Artvin Province"). Overall, the AK Party secured a plurality of votes in 68 of Turkey's 81 provinces, with its strongest vote of 71% coming from [Bingöl](/wiki/Bing%C3%B6l_Province "Bingöl Province"). Its weakest vote, a mere 12%, came from [Tunceli](/wiki/Tunceli_Province "Tunceli Province"), the only Turkish province where the [Alevi](/wiki/Alevism "Alevism") form a majority.{{cite news \|url\=http://www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/indepth/story/2007/07/070719\_election\_results\_en.shtml \|title\=Turkey: 22 July 2007 – Election Results \|publisher\=BBC Turkish \|date\=23 July 2007 \|access\-date\=22 July 2008}} Abdullah Gül was elected as the President in late August with 339 votes in the third round – the first at which a [simple majority](/wiki/Plurality_%28voting%29 "Plurality (voting)") is required – after deadlock in the first two rounds, in which a two\-thirds majority was needed.
#### 2007 constitutional referendum
{{Main article\|2007 Turkish constitutional referendum}}
[thumb\|right\|270px\|A rally of the Justice and Development Party in 2007](/wiki/File:Ak_parti_miting.jpg "Ak parti miting.jpg")
After the opposition parties deadlocked the 2007 presidential election by boycotting the parliament, the ruling AK Party proposed a constitutional reform package. The reform package was first vetoed by [President Sezer](/wiki/Ahmet_Necdet_Sezer "Ahmet Necdet Sezer"). Then he applied to the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey "Constitutional Court of Turkey") about the reform package, because the president is unable to veto amendments for the second time. The court did not find any problems in the package and 69% of the voters supported the constitutional changes.
The reforms consisted of:
* electing the president by popular vote instead of by parliament;
* reducing the presidential term from seven years to five;
* allowing the president to stand for re\-election for a second term;
* holding general elections every four years instead of five;
* reducing the quorum of lawmakers needed for parliamentary decisions from 367 to 184\.
#### 2009 local elections
The [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections") took place in March 2009, during the [Great Recession](/wiki/Great_Recession "Great Recession"). After the success of the AK Party in the 2007 general elections, the party saw a decline in the [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections"). In these elections the AK Party received 39% of the vote, 3% less than in the local elections of 2004\. Still, the AK Party remained the dominating party in Turkey. The second party CHP received 23% of the vote and the third party [MHP](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party "Nationalist Movement Party") received 16% of the vote. The AK Party won in Turkey's largest cities: [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") and [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul").{{cite news \|url\=http://secim2009\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090329100431/http://secim2009\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-date\=29 March 2009 \|access\-date\=29 March 2009 \|title\=Turkish local elections, 2009 \|date\=29 March 2009 \|publisher\=\[\[NTV\-MSNBC]] \|department\=International / Europe }}
#### 2010 constitutional referendum
{{Main article\|2010 Turkish constitutional referendum}}
Reforming the Constitution was one of the main pledges of the AK Party during the 2007 election campaign. The main opposition party CHP was not interested in altering the Constitution on a big scale, making it impossible to form a [Constitutional Commission](/wiki/Constitutional_Commission "Constitutional Commission") (*Anayasa Uzlaşma Komisyonu*).{{cite news \|url\=http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/475685\.asp \|title\=AK Parti'nin Anayasa hedefi 15 madde \|publisher\=NTVMSNBC \|date\=17 February 2009 \|access\-date\=17 February 2009}} The amendments lacked the two\-thirds majority needed to instantly become law, but secured 336 votes in the 550 seat parliament – enough to put the proposals to a referendum.
The reform package included a number of issues: such as the right of individuals to appeal to the highest court, the creation of the [ombudsman](/wiki/Ombudsman "Ombudsman")'s office, the possibility to negotiate a nationwide labour contract, positive exceptions for female citizens, the ability of civilian courts to convict members of the military, the right of civil servants to go on strike, a privacy law, and the structure of the Constitutional Court. The referendum was agreed by a majority of 58%.
#### 2011 Turkish general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2014 elections
In the [presidential election of 2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_presidential_election "2014 Turkish presidential election"), the AK Party's long time leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was elected president. In the party's [first extraordinary congress](/wiki/2014_Justice_and_Development_Party_Extraordinary_Congress "2014 Justice and Development Party Extraordinary Congress"), former foreign minister [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu "Ahmet Davutoğlu") was unanimously elected unopposed as party leader and took over as prime minister on 28 August 2014\. Davutoğlu stepped down as prime minister on 4 May 2016 following policy disagreements with President Erdoğan. Presidential aide Cemil Ertem said to Turkish TV that the country and its economy would stabilize further "when a prime minister more closely aligned with President Erdoğan takes office".{{cite news\|title\=Turkey PM Ahmet Davutoğlu to quit amid reports of Erdoğan rift\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-36213401\|publisher\=BBC\|access\-date\=5 May 2016\|work\=BBC News\|date\=5 May 2016}}
#### June 2015 general election
In the [general election](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election "June 2015 Turkish general election") held on 7 June, the AK Party gained 40\.87% of the vote and 258 seats in the [Grand National Assembly of Turkey](/wiki/Grand_National_Assembly_of_Turkey "Grand National Assembly of Turkey") (Turkish: Türkiye Büyük Millet Meclisi, TBMM). Though it still remains the biggest party in Turkey, the AK Party lost its status as the majority party and the power to form a single\-party government. Until then it had held this majority without interruption for 13 years since it had come to power in 2002\. In this election, the AK Party was pushing to gain 330 seats in the Grand National Assembly so that it could put a series of constitutional changes to a referendum, one of them was to switch Turkey from the current parliamentary government to an American\-style executive presidency government.
This pursuit met with a series of oppositions and criticism from the opposition parties and their supporters, fearing the measure would give more unchecked power to the current President of Turkey [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan "Recep Tayyip Erdoğan"), who has drawn fierce criticisms both from home and abroad for his active role in the election, abandoning the traditional presidential role of maintaining a more neutral and impartial position in elections by his predecessors in the office. The result of the Kurdish issues\-centered [Peoples' Democratic Party](/wiki/Peoples%27_Democratic_Party_%28Turkey%29 "Peoples' Democratic Party (Turkey)"), HDP, breaking through the 10% threshold to achieve 13\.12% out of the total votes cast and gaining 80 seats in the Grand National Assembly in the election, which caused the AK Party to lose its parliamentary majority.
#### November 2015 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2018 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2019 local elections
In the [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections "2019 Turkish local elections"), the ruling party AK Party lost control of Istanbul and Ankara for the first time in 15 years, as well as five of Turkey's six largest cities. The loss has been widely attributed to AK Party's mismanagement of the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 "Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)"), rising authoritarianism as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey "Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\-istanbul\-mayor\-election\-intl/index.html\|title\=Istanbul election rerun won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\|author\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\|website\=CNN\|date\=23 June 2019\|access\-date\=20 August 2019}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\-mayor\-election\-erdogan.html\|title\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\|last\=Gall\|first\=Carlotta\|date\=23 June 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=20 August 2019\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0362\-4331}} Soon after the elections, the Turkish government ordered a [re\-election in Istanbul](/wiki/June_2019_Istanbul_mayoral_election "June 2019 Istanbul mayoral election"). The decision led to a downfall on AK Party's popularity and it lost the elections again in June with an even greater margin.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-48739256\|title\=Turkey's ruling party loses Istanbul election\|work\=BBC News\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\-istanbul\-mayor\-election\-intl/index.html\|title\=Istanbul election rerun set to be won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\|author\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\|website\=CNN\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/in\-setback\-for\-erdogan\-opposition\-candidate\-wins\-istanbul\-mayor\-seat\-11561309654\|title\=In Setback for Erdogan, Opposition Candidate Wins Istanbul Mayor Seat\|last\=Gauthier\-Villars\|first\=David\|newspaper\=Wall Street Journal\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2019/dunya/son\-dakika\-financial\-timestan\-sok\-istanbul\-secimi\-yorumu\-5194106/\|title\=Son dakika… Financial Times'tan şok İstanbul seçimi yorumu\|website\=www.sozcu.com.tr\|date\=27 June 2019 }}
The result was seen as a huge blow to Erdoğan, who had once said that if his party 'lost Istanbul, we would lose Turkey.'{{Cite web\|url\=https://tele1\.com.tr/erdogan\-istanbulda\-teklersek\-turkiyede\-tokezleriz\-44258/\|title\=Erdoğan: 'İstanbul'da teklersek, Türkiye'de tökezleriz'\|date\=2 April 2019\|website\=Tele1}} The opposition's landslide was characterized as the 'beginning of the end' for Erdoğan,{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-48744733\|title\=Can Erdogan bounce back from big Turkey defeat?\|last\=Lowen\|first\=Mark\|date\=24 June 2019\|access\-date\=6 August 2019\|language\=en\-GB}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.thenational.ae/opinion/editorial/the\-beginning\-of\-the\-end\-for\-erdogan\-1\.878567\|title\=The beginning of the end for Erdogan?\|website\=The National\|date\=24 June 2019\|language\=en\|access\-date\=6 August 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.euronews.com/2019/06/24/could\-imamoglu\-victory\-in\-istanbul\-be\-beginning\-of\-the\-end\-for\-erdogan\|title\=Could Imamoglu victory in Istanbul be 'beginning of the end' for Erdogan?\|date\=24 June 2019\|website\=euronews\|language\=en\|access\-date\=6 August 2019}} with international commentators calling the re\-run a huge government miscalculation that can lead to a potential İmamoğlu candidacy in the next scheduled [presidential election](/wiki/2023_Turkish_general_election "2023 Turkish general election"). It is suspected that the scale of the government's defeat could provoke a cabinet reshuffle and early general elections, currently scheduled for June 2023\.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/06/24/turkeys\-erdogan\-suffers\-election\-blow\-but\-vote\-sparks\-hope\-for\-change.html\|title\=Turkey's Erdogan suffers election blow, sparking hope for change\|first\=Holly\|last\=Ellyatt\|date\=24 June 2019\|website\=CNBC}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\-mayor\-election\-erdogan.html\|title\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\|last\=Gall\|first\=Carlotta\|date\=23 June 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=6 August 2019\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0362\-4331}}
#### 2023 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2024 local elections
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Formation",
"The AK Party was established by a wide range of politicians of various political parties and a number of new politicians in 2001\\. The core of the party was formed from the reformist faction of the Islamist [Virtue Party](/wiki/Virtue_Party \"Virtue Party\"), including people such as [Abdullah Gül](/wiki/Abdullah_G%C3%BCl \"Abdullah Gül\") and [Bülent Arınç](/wiki/B%C3%BClent_Ar%C4%B1n%C3%A7 \"Bülent Arınç\"), while a second founding group consisted of members of the social conservative [Motherland Party](/wiki/Motherland_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"Motherland Party (Turkey)\") who had been close to [Turgut Özal](/wiki/Turgut_%C3%96zal \"Turgut Özal\"), such as [Cemil Çiçek](/wiki/Cemil_%C3%87i%C3%A7ek \"Cemil Çiçek\") and [Abdülkadir Aksu](/wiki/Abd%C3%BClkadir_Aksu \"Abdülkadir Aksu\").{{Cite web\\|title\\=Erdoğan AKP'nin genleriyle oynadı\\|url\\=http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120317052525/http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\\|archive\\-date\\=17 March 2012\\|access\\-date\\=24 March 2011}} Historically the party was described as [liberal conservative](/wiki/Liberal_conservatism \"Liberal conservatism\"),{{Cite book\\|title\\=Turkey between Nationalism and Globalization\\|first\\=Riva\\|last\\=Kastoryano\\|year\\=2013\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|page\\=97}} [conservative liberal](/wiki/Conservative_liberalism \"Conservative liberalism\"),{{refn\\|{{cite book\\|title\\=Sexualities in World Politics\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|page\\=126\\|first\\=Manuela\\|last\\=Picq\\|year\\=2015}}{{cite book\\|first\\=Ayse\\|last\\=Bugra\\|title\\=New Capitalism in Turkey: The Relationship between Politics, Religion and Business\\|year\\=2014\\|page\\=49\\|publisher\\=Edward Elgar Publishing}}{{cite book\\|first\\=Birol\\|last\\=Yesilada\\|title\\=Islamization of Turkey under the AK Party Rule\\|page\\=63\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|year\\=2013}}}} [economically liberal](/wiki/Economic_liberalism \"Economic liberalism\"),{{cite book\\|title\\=On the Road to EU Membership: The Economic Transformation of Turkey\\|publisher\\=Brussels University Press\\|year\\=2011\\|page\\=63\\|first\\=Selen Sarisoy\\|last\\=Guerin}}{{cite book\\|first\\=Ayse\\|last\\=Bugra\\|title\\=New Capitalism in Turkey: The Relationship between Politics, Religion and Business\\|year\\=2014\\|page\\=60\\|publisher\\=Edward Elgar Publishing}} [pro\\-European](/wiki/Pro-Europeanism \"Pro-Europeanism\"),{{Cite news \\|date\\=2022\\-05\\-13 \\|title\\=When democratic spin conceals a descent into dictatorship \\|work\\=Financial Times \\|url\\=https://www.ft.com/content/ff757408\\-d955\\-433b\\-af8d\\-f58085998c1b \\|archive\\-url\\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20221210/https://www.ft.com/content/ff757408\\-d955\\-433b\\-af8d\\-f58085998c1b \\|archive\\-date\\=10 December 2022 \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-05\\-13\\|url\\-access\\=subscription}}{{Cite web \\|title\\=Are the fortunes of Turkey's AK Party on the wane? \\|url\\=https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/global\\-extremes/are\\-the\\-fortunes\\-of\\-turkeys\\-akp\\-on\\-the\\-wane/ \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-05\\-13 \\|website\\=openDemocracy \\|language\\=en}} and [center\\-right](/wiki/Center-right_politics \"Center-right politics\").{{Cite journal\\|url\\=https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10\\.1080/13569770410001701233\\&ved\\=2ahUKEwi3h\\-up0\\-DxAhVzgf0HHfQtCmgQFnoECCIQAQ\\&usg\\=AOvVaw1LCaXIU5XyicT\\_dv4DMXsW\\|doi \\= 10\\.1080/13569770410001701233\\|title \\= Center\\-right politics in Turkey after the November 2002 general election: Neo\\-liberalism with a Muslim face\\|year \\= 2004\\|last1 \\= Coşar\\|first1 \\= Simten\\|last2 \\= Özman\\|first2 \\= Aylin\\|journal \\= Contemporary Politics\\|volume \\= 10\\|pages \\= 57–74\\|s2cid \\= 143771719\\|url\\-access \\= subscription}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.britannica.com/place/Turkey/Rise\\-of\\-the\\-AKP\\-in\\-the\\-21st\\-century\\&ved\\=2ahUKEwj\\-5\\_r20\\-DxAhWOg\\_0HHRgYBrAQFnoECBAQAQ\\&usg\\=AOvVaw1Z\\_vxFoBjXeg\\-Ej4jw9FOb\\|title\\=Turkey \\| Location, Geography, People, Economy, Culture, \\& History\\|date\\=14 June 2023}}",
"Some members of the [True Path Party](/wiki/True_Path_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"True Path Party (Turkey)\"), such as [Hüseyin Çelik](/wiki/H%C3%BCseyin_%C3%87elik \"Hüseyin Çelik\") and [Köksal Toptan](/wiki/K%C3%B6ksal_Toptan \"Köksal Toptan\"), joined the AK Party. Some members, such as [Kürşad Tüzmen](/wiki/K%C3%BCr%C5%9Fad_T%C3%BCzmen \"Kürşad Tüzmen\") or [Ertuğrul Günay](/wiki/Ertu%C4%9Frul_G%C3%BCnay \"Ertuğrul Günay\"), had [nationalist](/wiki/Turkish_nationalism \"Turkish nationalism\") or [center\\-left](/wiki/Center-left \"Center-left\") backgrounds respectively, while representatives of the nascent, more clearly anti\\-capitalist 'Muslim left' current were largely excluded.{{Cite web\\|title\\=Erdoğan AK Parti'nin genleriyle oynadı\\|url\\=http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120317052525/http://haber.gazetevatan.com/0/122728/4/Yazarlar/73\\|archive\\-date\\=17 March 2012\\|access\\-date\\=24 March 2011}} In addition, a large number of people joined a political party for the first time, such as [Ali Babacan](/wiki/Ali_Babacan \"Ali Babacan\"), [Nimet Baş](/wiki/Nimet_Ba%C5%9F \"Nimet Baş\"), [Egemen Bağış](/wiki/Egemen_Ba%C4%9F%C4%B1%C5%9F \"Egemen Bağış\") and [Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu](/wiki/Mevl%C3%BCt_%C3%87avu%C5%9Fo%C4%9Flu \"Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu\").",
"### Closure cases",
"{{See also\\|Secularism in Turkey}}\nControversies over whether the party remains committed to [secular principles](/wiki/Secularism \"Secularism\") enshrined in the [Turkish constitution](/wiki/Turkish_constitution \"Turkish constitution\") have dominated Turkish politics since 2002\\. Turkey's constitution established the country as a secular state and prohibits any political parties that promote [Islamism](/wiki/Islamism \"Islamism\") or [shariah law](/wiki/Shariah_law \"Shariah law\").",
"Since coming to power, the party has brought about tighter regulations on [abortion](/wiki/Abortion \"Abortion\") and higher taxes on [alcohol consumption](/wiki/Alcohol_laws_of_Turkey \"Alcohol laws of Turkey\"), leading to allegations that it is covertly undermining Turkish secularism. Some activists, commentators, opponents and government officials have accused the party of Islamism. The Justice and Development Party has faced two \"closure cases\" (attempts to officially ban the party, usually for Islamist practices) in 2002 and 2008\\.",
"Just 10 days before the [national elections of 2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election \"2002 Turkish general election\"), Turkey's chief prosecutor, Sabih Kanadoğlu, asked the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey \"Constitutional Court of Turkey\") to close the Justice and Development Party, which was leading in the polls at that time. The chief prosecutor charged the Justice and Development Party with abusing the law and justice. He based his case on the fact that the party's leader had been banned from political life for reading an Islamist poem, and thus the party had no standing in elections. The [European Commission](/wiki/European_Commission \"European Commission\") had previously criticized Turkey for banning the party's leader from participating in elections.{{cite news\\|title\\=Turkey mulls banning leading party before elections\\|url\\=http://www.euractiv.com/en/enlargement/turkey\\-mulls\\-banning\\-leading\\-party\\-elections/article\\-111091\\|date\\=23 October 2002\\|publisher\\=EurActiv\\|access\\-date\\=15 February 2011\\|archive\\-date\\=12 May 2011\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110512070624/http://www.euractiv.com/en/enlargement/turkey\\-mulls\\-banning\\-leading\\-party\\-elections/article\\-111091\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"[300px\\|thumb\\|The [Republic Protests](/wiki/Republic_Protests \"Republic Protests\") took place in 2007 in support of the [Kemalist reforms](/wiki/Kemalism \"Kemalism\"), particularly [state secularism](/wiki/Secular_state \"Secular state\") and [democracy](/wiki/Democracy \"Democracy\"), against the perceived [Islamization](/wiki/Islamization \"Islamization\") of Turkey under the ruling Justice and Development Party.](/wiki/File:Protect_Your_Republic_Protest_-_1_%282007-04-14%29.jpg \"Protect Your Republic Protest - 1 (2007-04-14).jpg\")\nThe party again faced a [closure trial in 2008](/wiki/2008_Justice_and_Development_Party_closure_trial \"2008 Justice and Development Party closure trial\") brought about by the lifting of a long\\-standing university ban on headscarves.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2008/jul/30/turkey.nato1\\|title\\=Turkey's governing party avoids being shut down for anti\\-secularism \\|author\\=Robert Tait\\|newspaper\\=The Guardian \\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015\\|date\\=30 July 2008}} At an international press conference in Spain, Erdoğan answered a question of a journalist by saying, \"What if the headscarf is a symbol? Even if it were a political symbol, does that give \\[one the] right to ban it? Could you bring prohibitions to symbols?\" These statements led to a joint proposal of the Justice and Development Party and the far\\-right [Nationalist Movement Party](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party \"Nationalist Movement Party\") for changing the constitution and the law to lift a ban on women wearing headscarves at state universities.",
"Soon afterwards, Turkey's chief prosecutor, [Abdurrahman Yalçınkaya](/wiki/Abdurrahman_Yal%C3%A7%C4%B1nkaya \"Abdurrahman Yalçınkaya\"), asked the [Constitutional Court of Turkey](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey \"Constitutional Court of Turkey\") to close down the party on charges of violating the [separation of religion and state](/wiki/Secularism_in_Turkey \"Secularism in Turkey\") in Turkey.{{cite news \\|url\\=http://arama.hurriyet.com.tr/arsivnews.aspx?id\\=\\-634073 \\|title\\=From landmark success to closure: AK Party's journey \\|work\\=\\[\\[Turkish Daily News]] \\|access\\-date\\=11 August 2008 \\|date\\=22 July 2008 \\|first\\=Izgi \\|last\\=Gungor }}{{dead link\\|date\\=November 2017 \\|bot\\=InternetArchiveBot \\|fix\\-attempted\\=yes }} \n{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\\-web/detaylar.do?load\\=detay\\&link\\=136476\\|access\\-date\\=16 November 2008\\|title\\=Closure case against ruling party creates shockwaves\\|date\\=15 March 2008\\|work\\=\\[\\[Today's Zaman]]\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20080421214216/http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\\-web/detaylar.do?load\\=detay\\&link\\=136476\\|archive\\-date\\=21 April 2008}} \n{{cite news\\|url\\=http://i.milliyet.com.tr/akpsavunma/default.aspx?ver\\=59\\|access\\-date\\=4 September 2008\\|title\\=Full text of testimony\\|work\\=\\[\\[Milliyet]]\\|language\\=tr\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110512171455/http://i.milliyet.com.tr/akpsavunma/default.aspx?ver\\=59\\|archive\\-date\\=12 May 2011\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} The closure request failed by only one vote, as only six of the 11 judges ruled in favor, with seven required; however, 10 out of 11 judges agreed that the Justice and Development Party had become \"a center for anti\\-secular activities\", leading to a loss of 50% of the state funding for the party.*[Today's Zaman](/wiki/Today%27s_Zaman \"Today's Zaman\")*, 19 August 2013, [AK Party to ask for retrial by Constitutional Court](http://todayszaman.com/news-323934-ak-party-to-ask-for-retrial-by-constitutional-court.html) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130820065944/http://todayszaman.com/news\\-323934\\-ak\\-party\\-to\\-ask\\-for\\-retrial\\-by\\-constitutional\\-court.html \\|date\\=20 August 2013 }}",
"### Elections",
"{{Outdated\\|part\\=2023 and 2024 elections\\|date\\=March 2024\\|reason\\=The 2023 and 2024 elections have concluded}}\nThe party has won pluralities in the seven most recent legislative elections, those of [2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election \"2002 Turkish general election\"), [2007](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election \"2007 Turkish general election\"), [2011](/wiki/2011_Turkish_general_election \"2011 Turkish general election\"), [June 2015](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election \"June 2015 Turkish general election\"), [November 2015](/wiki/November_2015_Turkish_general_election \"November 2015 Turkish general election\"), [2018](/wiki/2018_Turkish_parliamentary_election \"2018 Turkish parliamentary election\") and [2023](/wiki/2023_Turkish_parliamentary_election \"2023 Turkish parliamentary election\"). The party held a majority of seats for 13 years, but lost it in June 2015, only to regain it in the snap election of November 2015 but then lose it again in 2018\\. Its past electoral success has been mirrored in the three local elections held since the party's establishment, coming first in [2004](/wiki/2004_Turkish_local_elections \"2004 Turkish local elections\"), [2009](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\") and [2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_local_elections \"2014 Turkish local elections\") respectively. However, the party lost most of Turkey's biggest cities including [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\") and [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") in [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections \"2019 Turkish local elections\"), which has been attributed to the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 \"Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)\"), accusations of authoritarianism, as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey \"Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey\").",
"#### 2002 general elections",
"The AK Party won a sweeping victory in the [2002 elections](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election \"2002 Turkish general election\"), which saw every party previously represented in the Grand National Assembly ejected from the chamber. In the process, it won a two\\-thirds majority of seats, becoming the first Turkish party in 11 years to win an outright majority. Erdoğan, as the leader of the biggest party in parliament, would have been normally given the task to form a cabinet.",
"However, according to the Turkish Constitution Article 109 the prime ministers had to be also a representative of the Turkish Parliament. Erdoğan, who was banned from holding any political office after a 1994 incident in which he read a poem deemed pro\\-Islamist by judges, was therefore not. As a result, Gül became prime minister.",
"It survived the crisis over the [2003 invasion of Iraq](/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq \"2003 invasion of Iraq\") despite a massive back bench rebellion where over a hundred AK Party MPs joined those of the opposition [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party \"Republican People's Party\") (CHP) in parliament to prevent the government from allowing the [United States](/wiki/United_States \"United States\") to launch a Northern offensive in Iraq from Turkish territory. Later, Erdoğan's ban was lifted with the help of the CHP and Erdoğan became prime minister by being elected to the parliament after a [by\\-election in Siirt](/wiki/2003_Siirt_Province_by-election \"2003 Siirt Province by-election\").",
"The AK Party has undertaken structural reforms, and during its rule Turkey has seen rapid growth and an end to its three decade long period of high inflation rates. Inflation had fallen to 8\\.8% by 2004\\.",
"Influential business publications such as *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist \"The Economist\")* consider the AK Party's government the most successful in Turkey in decades.{{cite news \\|url\\=http://www.economist.com/opinion/displaystory.cfm?story\\_id\\=9116747 \\|access\\-date\\=22 July 2008 \\|title\\=The battle for Turkey's soul (Democracy v secularism in Turkey) \\|date\\=3 May 2007 \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Economist]] \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180812111802/https://www.economist.com/leaders/2007/05/03/the\\-battle\\-for\\-turkeys\\-soul\\|archive\\-date\\=12 August 2018}}",
"#### 2004 local elections",
"In the local elections of 2004, the AK Party won 42% of the votes, making inroads against the secular [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party \"Republican People's Party\") (CHP) on the South and West Coasts, and against the [Social Democratic People's Party](/wiki/Social_Democratic_People%27s_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"Social Democratic People's Party (Turkey)\"), which is supported by some [Kurds](/wiki/Kurds \"Kurds\") in the South\\-East of Turkey.",
"In January 2005, the AK Party was admitted as an observer member in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party \"European People's Party\") (EPP). However, it left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_European_Conservatives_and_Reformists \"Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists\") (AECR) in 2013\\.",
"#### 2007 elections",
"[250px\\|thumb\\|Voter base by monthly household income. AK Party is the largest party in group 1, 2, 3 and 4, while CHP is the largest in group 5, the richest 20% of Turkey.](/wiki/File:Se%C3%A7menin_gelir_d%C3%BCzeyine_g%C3%B6re_oy_da%C4%9F%C4%B1l%C4%B1m%C4%B1.PNG \"Seçmenin gelir düzeyine göre oy dağılımı.PNG\")",
"On 14 April 2007, an estimated 300,000 people marched in [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") to protest the possible candidacy of Erdoğan in the [2007 presidential election](/wiki/2007_Turkish_presidential_election \"2007 Turkish presidential election\"), afraid that if elected as president, he would alter the secular nature of the Turkish state.\"[Secular rally targets Turkish PM](http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6554851.stm),\" BBC News, 14 April 2007\\. Erdoğan announced on 24 April 2007 that the party had decided to nominate Abdullah Gül as the AK Party candidate in the presidential election.\"[Turkey's ruling party announces FM Gul as presidential candidate](http://english.people.com.cn/200704/24/eng20070424_369332.html),\" [Xinhua](/wiki/Xinhua \"Xinhua\"), 24 April 2007\\. The protests continued over the next several weeks, with over one million reported at an 29 April rally in Istanbul,{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.afp.fr/english/news/stories/070429134050\\.kd2e8gv7\\.html\\|title\\=More than one million rally in Turkey for secularism, democracy\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Agence France\\-Presse]]\\|access\\-date\\=29 April 2007}}{{dead link\\|date\\=December 2017 \\|bot\\=InternetArchiveBot \\|fix\\-attempted\\=yes }}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSL2910950920070429\\|title\\=One million Turks rally against government\\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]]\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2007 \\|date\\=29 April 2007}} tens of thousands reported at separate protests on 4 May in [Manisa](/wiki/Manisa \"Manisa\") and [Çanakkale](/wiki/%C3%87anakkale \"Çanakkale\"),{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.milliyet.com.tr/2007/05/04/guncel/axgun01\\.html \\|title\\=Saylan: Manisa mitingi önemli\\|work\\=\\[\\[Milliyet]]\\|language\\=tr\\|access\\-date\\=4 May 2007}} and one million in [İzmir](/wiki/%C4%B0zmir \"İzmir\") on 13 May.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\\_protest\\_ahead\\_of\\_early\\_elections.html?siteSect\\=143\\&sid\\=7813908\\&cKey\\=1179061645000\\|title\\=Turks protest ahead of early elections\\|work\\=\\[\\[Swissinfo]]\\|access\\-date\\=13 May 2007 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070930222218/http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\\_protest\\_ahead\\_of\\_early\\_elections.html?siteSect\\=143\\&sid\\=7813908\\&cKey\\=1179061645000 \\|archive\\-date\\=30 September 2007}}",
"Early [parliamentary elections](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election \"2007 Turkish general election\") were called after the failure of the parties in parliament to agree on the next Turkish president. The opposition parties boycotted the parliamentary vote and deadlocked the election process. At the same time, Erdoğan claimed the failure to elect a president was a failure of the Turkish political system and proposed to modify the constitution.",
"The AK Party achieved a significant victory in the rescheduled 22 July 2007 elections with 46\\.6% of the vote, translating into control of 341 of the 550 available parliamentary seats. Although the AK Party received significantly more votes in 2007 than in 2002, the number of parliamentary seats they controlled decreased due to the rules of the [Turkish electoral system](/wiki/Elections_in_Turkey \"Elections in Turkey\"). However, they retained a comfortable ruling majority.",
"Nationally, the elections of 2007 saw a major advance for the AK Party, with the party outpolling the pro\\-Kurdish [Democratic Society Party](/wiki/Democratic_Society_Party \"Democratic Society Party\") in traditional Kurdish strongholds such as [Van](/wiki/Van_Province \"Van Province\") and [Mardin](/wiki/Mardin_Province \"Mardin Province\"), as well as outpolling the secular\\-left CHP in traditionally secular areas such as [Antalya](/wiki/Antalya_Province \"Antalya Province\") and [Artvin](/wiki/Artvin_Province \"Artvin Province\"). Overall, the AK Party secured a plurality of votes in 68 of Turkey's 81 provinces, with its strongest vote of 71% coming from [Bingöl](/wiki/Bing%C3%B6l_Province \"Bingöl Province\"). Its weakest vote, a mere 12%, came from [Tunceli](/wiki/Tunceli_Province \"Tunceli Province\"), the only Turkish province where the [Alevi](/wiki/Alevism \"Alevism\") form a majority.{{cite news \\|url\\=http://www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/indepth/story/2007/07/070719\\_election\\_results\\_en.shtml \\|title\\=Turkey: 22 July 2007 – Election Results \\|publisher\\=BBC Turkish \\|date\\=23 July 2007 \\|access\\-date\\=22 July 2008}} Abdullah Gül was elected as the President in late August with 339 votes in the third round – the first at which a [simple majority](/wiki/Plurality_%28voting%29 \"Plurality (voting)\") is required – after deadlock in the first two rounds, in which a two\\-thirds majority was needed.",
"#### 2007 constitutional referendum",
"{{Main article\\|2007 Turkish constitutional referendum}}\n[thumb\\|right\\|270px\\|A rally of the Justice and Development Party in 2007](/wiki/File:Ak_parti_miting.jpg \"Ak parti miting.jpg\")\nAfter the opposition parties deadlocked the 2007 presidential election by boycotting the parliament, the ruling AK Party proposed a constitutional reform package. The reform package was first vetoed by [President Sezer](/wiki/Ahmet_Necdet_Sezer \"Ahmet Necdet Sezer\"). Then he applied to the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey \"Constitutional Court of Turkey\") about the reform package, because the president is unable to veto amendments for the second time. The court did not find any problems in the package and 69% of the voters supported the constitutional changes.",
"The reforms consisted of:\n* electing the president by popular vote instead of by parliament;\n* reducing the presidential term from seven years to five;\n* allowing the president to stand for re\\-election for a second term;\n* holding general elections every four years instead of five;\n* reducing the quorum of lawmakers needed for parliamentary decisions from 367 to 184\\.",
"#### 2009 local elections",
"The [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\") took place in March 2009, during the [Great Recession](/wiki/Great_Recession \"Great Recession\"). After the success of the AK Party in the 2007 general elections, the party saw a decline in the [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\"). In these elections the AK Party received 39% of the vote, 3% less than in the local elections of 2004\\. Still, the AK Party remained the dominating party in Turkey. The second party CHP received 23% of the vote and the third party [MHP](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party \"Nationalist Movement Party\") received 16% of the vote. The AK Party won in Turkey's largest cities: [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") and [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\").{{cite news \\|url\\=http://secim2009\\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090329100431/http://secim2009\\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-date\\=29 March 2009 \\|access\\-date\\=29 March 2009 \\|title\\=Turkish local elections, 2009 \\|date\\=29 March 2009 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[NTV\\-MSNBC]] \\|department\\=International / Europe }}",
"#### 2010 constitutional referendum",
"{{Main article\\|2010 Turkish constitutional referendum}}\nReforming the Constitution was one of the main pledges of the AK Party during the 2007 election campaign. The main opposition party CHP was not interested in altering the Constitution on a big scale, making it impossible to form a [Constitutional Commission](/wiki/Constitutional_Commission \"Constitutional Commission\") (*Anayasa Uzlaşma Komisyonu*).{{cite news \\|url\\=http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/475685\\.asp \\|title\\=AK Parti'nin Anayasa hedefi 15 madde \\|publisher\\=NTVMSNBC \\|date\\=17 February 2009 \\|access\\-date\\=17 February 2009}} The amendments lacked the two\\-thirds majority needed to instantly become law, but secured 336 votes in the 550 seat parliament – enough to put the proposals to a referendum.",
"The reform package included a number of issues: such as the right of individuals to appeal to the highest court, the creation of the [ombudsman](/wiki/Ombudsman \"Ombudsman\")'s office, the possibility to negotiate a nationwide labour contract, positive exceptions for female citizens, the ability of civilian courts to convict members of the military, the right of civil servants to go on strike, a privacy law, and the structure of the Constitutional Court. The referendum was agreed by a majority of 58%.",
"#### 2011 Turkish general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2014 elections",
"In the [presidential election of 2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_presidential_election \"2014 Turkish presidential election\"), the AK Party's long time leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was elected president. In the party's [first extraordinary congress](/wiki/2014_Justice_and_Development_Party_Extraordinary_Congress \"2014 Justice and Development Party Extraordinary Congress\"), former foreign minister [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu \"Ahmet Davutoğlu\") was unanimously elected unopposed as party leader and took over as prime minister on 28 August 2014\\. Davutoğlu stepped down as prime minister on 4 May 2016 following policy disagreements with President Erdoğan. Presidential aide Cemil Ertem said to Turkish TV that the country and its economy would stabilize further \"when a prime minister more closely aligned with President Erdoğan takes office\".{{cite news\\|title\\=Turkey PM Ahmet Davutoğlu to quit amid reports of Erdoğan rift\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-36213401\\|publisher\\=BBC\\|access\\-date\\=5 May 2016\\|work\\=BBC News\\|date\\=5 May 2016}}",
"#### June 2015 general election",
"In the [general election](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election \"June 2015 Turkish general election\") held on 7 June, the AK Party gained 40\\.87% of the vote and 258 seats in the [Grand National Assembly of Turkey](/wiki/Grand_National_Assembly_of_Turkey \"Grand National Assembly of Turkey\") (Turkish: Türkiye Büyük Millet Meclisi, TBMM). Though it still remains the biggest party in Turkey, the AK Party lost its status as the majority party and the power to form a single\\-party government. Until then it had held this majority without interruption for 13 years since it had come to power in 2002\\. In this election, the AK Party was pushing to gain 330 seats in the Grand National Assembly so that it could put a series of constitutional changes to a referendum, one of them was to switch Turkey from the current parliamentary government to an American\\-style executive presidency government.",
"This pursuit met with a series of oppositions and criticism from the opposition parties and their supporters, fearing the measure would give more unchecked power to the current President of Turkey [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan \"Recep Tayyip Erdoğan\"), who has drawn fierce criticisms both from home and abroad for his active role in the election, abandoning the traditional presidential role of maintaining a more neutral and impartial position in elections by his predecessors in the office. The result of the Kurdish issues\\-centered [Peoples' Democratic Party](/wiki/Peoples%27_Democratic_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"Peoples' Democratic Party (Turkey)\"), HDP, breaking through the 10% threshold to achieve 13\\.12% out of the total votes cast and gaining 80 seats in the Grand National Assembly in the election, which caused the AK Party to lose its parliamentary majority.",
"#### November 2015 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2018 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2019 local elections",
"In the [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections \"2019 Turkish local elections\"), the ruling party AK Party lost control of Istanbul and Ankara for the first time in 15 years, as well as five of Turkey's six largest cities. The loss has been widely attributed to AK Party's mismanagement of the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 \"Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)\"), rising authoritarianism as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey \"Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Istanbul election rerun won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\\|author\\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\\|website\\=CNN\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|access\\-date\\=20 August 2019}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-erdogan.html\\|title\\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\\|last\\=Gall\\|first\\=Carlotta\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=20 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}} Soon after the elections, the Turkish government ordered a [re\\-election in Istanbul](/wiki/June_2019_Istanbul_mayoral_election \"June 2019 Istanbul mayoral election\"). The decision led to a downfall on AK Party's popularity and it lost the elections again in June with an even greater margin.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-48739256\\|title\\=Turkey's ruling party loses Istanbul election\\|work\\=BBC News\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Istanbul election rerun set to be won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\\|author\\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\\|website\\=CNN\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/in\\-setback\\-for\\-erdogan\\-opposition\\-candidate\\-wins\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-seat\\-11561309654\\|title\\=In Setback for Erdogan, Opposition Candidate Wins Istanbul Mayor Seat\\|last\\=Gauthier\\-Villars\\|first\\=David\\|newspaper\\=Wall Street Journal\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2019/dunya/son\\-dakika\\-financial\\-timestan\\-sok\\-istanbul\\-secimi\\-yorumu\\-5194106/\\|title\\=Son dakika… Financial Times'tan şok İstanbul seçimi yorumu\\|website\\=www.sozcu.com.tr\\|date\\=27 June 2019 }}",
"The result was seen as a huge blow to Erdoğan, who had once said that if his party 'lost Istanbul, we would lose Turkey.'{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://tele1\\.com.tr/erdogan\\-istanbulda\\-teklersek\\-turkiyede\\-tokezleriz\\-44258/\\|title\\=Erdoğan: 'İstanbul'da teklersek, Türkiye'de tökezleriz'\\|date\\=2 April 2019\\|website\\=Tele1}} The opposition's landslide was characterized as the 'beginning of the end' for Erdoğan,{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-48744733\\|title\\=Can Erdogan bounce back from big Turkey defeat?\\|last\\=Lowen\\|first\\=Mark\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-GB}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.thenational.ae/opinion/editorial/the\\-beginning\\-of\\-the\\-end\\-for\\-erdogan\\-1\\.878567\\|title\\=The beginning of the end for Erdogan?\\|website\\=The National\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.euronews.com/2019/06/24/could\\-imamoglu\\-victory\\-in\\-istanbul\\-be\\-beginning\\-of\\-the\\-end\\-for\\-erdogan\\|title\\=Could Imamoglu victory in Istanbul be 'beginning of the end' for Erdogan?\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|website\\=euronews\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019}} with international commentators calling the re\\-run a huge government miscalculation that can lead to a potential İmamoğlu candidacy in the next scheduled [presidential election](/wiki/2023_Turkish_general_election \"2023 Turkish general election\"). It is suspected that the scale of the government's defeat could provoke a cabinet reshuffle and early general elections, currently scheduled for June 2023\\.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/06/24/turkeys\\-erdogan\\-suffers\\-election\\-blow\\-but\\-vote\\-sparks\\-hope\\-for\\-change.html\\|title\\=Turkey's Erdogan suffers election blow, sparking hope for change\\|first\\=Holly\\|last\\=Ellyatt\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|website\\=CNBC}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-erdogan.html\\|title\\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\\|last\\=Gall\\|first\\=Carlotta\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}}",
"#### 2023 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2024 local elections",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
""
] |
### Elections
{{Outdated\|part\=2023 and 2024 elections\|date\=March 2024\|reason\=The 2023 and 2024 elections have concluded}}
The party has won pluralities in the seven most recent legislative elections, those of [2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election "2002 Turkish general election"), [2007](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election "2007 Turkish general election"), [2011](/wiki/2011_Turkish_general_election "2011 Turkish general election"), [June 2015](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election "June 2015 Turkish general election"), [November 2015](/wiki/November_2015_Turkish_general_election "November 2015 Turkish general election"), [2018](/wiki/2018_Turkish_parliamentary_election "2018 Turkish parliamentary election") and [2023](/wiki/2023_Turkish_parliamentary_election "2023 Turkish parliamentary election"). The party held a majority of seats for 13 years, but lost it in June 2015, only to regain it in the snap election of November 2015 but then lose it again in 2018\. Its past electoral success has been mirrored in the three local elections held since the party's establishment, coming first in [2004](/wiki/2004_Turkish_local_elections "2004 Turkish local elections"), [2009](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections") and [2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_local_elections "2014 Turkish local elections") respectively. However, the party lost most of Turkey's biggest cities including [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul") and [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") in [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections "2019 Turkish local elections"), which has been attributed to the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 "Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)"), accusations of authoritarianism, as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey "Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey").
#### 2002 general elections
The AK Party won a sweeping victory in the [2002 elections](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election "2002 Turkish general election"), which saw every party previously represented in the Grand National Assembly ejected from the chamber. In the process, it won a two\-thirds majority of seats, becoming the first Turkish party in 11 years to win an outright majority. Erdoğan, as the leader of the biggest party in parliament, would have been normally given the task to form a cabinet.
However, according to the Turkish Constitution Article 109 the prime ministers had to be also a representative of the Turkish Parliament. Erdoğan, who was banned from holding any political office after a 1994 incident in which he read a poem deemed pro\-Islamist by judges, was therefore not. As a result, Gül became prime minister.
It survived the crisis over the [2003 invasion of Iraq](/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq "2003 invasion of Iraq") despite a massive back bench rebellion where over a hundred AK Party MPs joined those of the opposition [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party "Republican People's Party") (CHP) in parliament to prevent the government from allowing the [United States](/wiki/United_States "United States") to launch a Northern offensive in Iraq from Turkish territory. Later, Erdoğan's ban was lifted with the help of the CHP and Erdoğan became prime minister by being elected to the parliament after a [by\-election in Siirt](/wiki/2003_Siirt_Province_by-election "2003 Siirt Province by-election").
The AK Party has undertaken structural reforms, and during its rule Turkey has seen rapid growth and an end to its three decade long period of high inflation rates. Inflation had fallen to 8\.8% by 2004\.
Influential business publications such as *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist "The Economist")* consider the AK Party's government the most successful in Turkey in decades.{{cite news \|url\=http://www.economist.com/opinion/displaystory.cfm?story\_id\=9116747 \|access\-date\=22 July 2008 \|title\=The battle for Turkey's soul (Democracy v secularism in Turkey) \|date\=3 May 2007 \|newspaper\=\[\[The Economist]] \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180812111802/https://www.economist.com/leaders/2007/05/03/the\-battle\-for\-turkeys\-soul\|archive\-date\=12 August 2018}}
#### 2004 local elections
In the local elections of 2004, the AK Party won 42% of the votes, making inroads against the secular [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party "Republican People's Party") (CHP) on the South and West Coasts, and against the [Social Democratic People's Party](/wiki/Social_Democratic_People%27s_Party_%28Turkey%29 "Social Democratic People's Party (Turkey)"), which is supported by some [Kurds](/wiki/Kurds "Kurds") in the South\-East of Turkey.
In January 2005, the AK Party was admitted as an observer member in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party "European People's Party") (EPP). However, it left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_European_Conservatives_and_Reformists "Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists") (AECR) in 2013\.
#### 2007 elections
[250px\|thumb\|Voter base by monthly household income. AK Party is the largest party in group 1, 2, 3 and 4, while CHP is the largest in group 5, the richest 20% of Turkey.](/wiki/File:Se%C3%A7menin_gelir_d%C3%BCzeyine_g%C3%B6re_oy_da%C4%9F%C4%B1l%C4%B1m%C4%B1.PNG "Seçmenin gelir düzeyine göre oy dağılımı.PNG")
On 14 April 2007, an estimated 300,000 people marched in [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") to protest the possible candidacy of Erdoğan in the [2007 presidential election](/wiki/2007_Turkish_presidential_election "2007 Turkish presidential election"), afraid that if elected as president, he would alter the secular nature of the Turkish state."[Secular rally targets Turkish PM](http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6554851.stm)," BBC News, 14 April 2007\. Erdoğan announced on 24 April 2007 that the party had decided to nominate Abdullah Gül as the AK Party candidate in the presidential election."[Turkey's ruling party announces FM Gul as presidential candidate](http://english.people.com.cn/200704/24/eng20070424_369332.html)," [Xinhua](/wiki/Xinhua "Xinhua"), 24 April 2007\. The protests continued over the next several weeks, with over one million reported at an 29 April rally in Istanbul,{{cite news\|url\=http://www.afp.fr/english/news/stories/070429134050\.kd2e8gv7\.html\|title\=More than one million rally in Turkey for secularism, democracy\|publisher\=\[\[Agence France\-Presse]]\|access\-date\=29 April 2007}}{{dead link\|date\=December 2017 \|bot\=InternetArchiveBot \|fix\-attempted\=yes }}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSL2910950920070429\|title\=One million Turks rally against government\|work\=\[\[Reuters]]\|access\-date\=30 April 2007 \|date\=29 April 2007}} tens of thousands reported at separate protests on 4 May in [Manisa](/wiki/Manisa "Manisa") and [Çanakkale](/wiki/%C3%87anakkale "Çanakkale"),{{cite web\|url\=http://www.milliyet.com.tr/2007/05/04/guncel/axgun01\.html \|title\=Saylan: Manisa mitingi önemli\|work\=\[\[Milliyet]]\|language\=tr\|access\-date\=4 May 2007}} and one million in [İzmir](/wiki/%C4%B0zmir "İzmir") on 13 May.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\_protest\_ahead\_of\_early\_elections.html?siteSect\=143\&sid\=7813908\&cKey\=1179061645000\|title\=Turks protest ahead of early elections\|work\=\[\[Swissinfo]]\|access\-date\=13 May 2007 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070930222218/http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\_protest\_ahead\_of\_early\_elections.html?siteSect\=143\&sid\=7813908\&cKey\=1179061645000 \|archive\-date\=30 September 2007}}
Early [parliamentary elections](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election "2007 Turkish general election") were called after the failure of the parties in parliament to agree on the next Turkish president. The opposition parties boycotted the parliamentary vote and deadlocked the election process. At the same time, Erdoğan claimed the failure to elect a president was a failure of the Turkish political system and proposed to modify the constitution.
The AK Party achieved a significant victory in the rescheduled 22 July 2007 elections with 46\.6% of the vote, translating into control of 341 of the 550 available parliamentary seats. Although the AK Party received significantly more votes in 2007 than in 2002, the number of parliamentary seats they controlled decreased due to the rules of the [Turkish electoral system](/wiki/Elections_in_Turkey "Elections in Turkey"). However, they retained a comfortable ruling majority.
Nationally, the elections of 2007 saw a major advance for the AK Party, with the party outpolling the pro\-Kurdish [Democratic Society Party](/wiki/Democratic_Society_Party "Democratic Society Party") in traditional Kurdish strongholds such as [Van](/wiki/Van_Province "Van Province") and [Mardin](/wiki/Mardin_Province "Mardin Province"), as well as outpolling the secular\-left CHP in traditionally secular areas such as [Antalya](/wiki/Antalya_Province "Antalya Province") and [Artvin](/wiki/Artvin_Province "Artvin Province"). Overall, the AK Party secured a plurality of votes in 68 of Turkey's 81 provinces, with its strongest vote of 71% coming from [Bingöl](/wiki/Bing%C3%B6l_Province "Bingöl Province"). Its weakest vote, a mere 12%, came from [Tunceli](/wiki/Tunceli_Province "Tunceli Province"), the only Turkish province where the [Alevi](/wiki/Alevism "Alevism") form a majority.{{cite news \|url\=http://www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/indepth/story/2007/07/070719\_election\_results\_en.shtml \|title\=Turkey: 22 July 2007 – Election Results \|publisher\=BBC Turkish \|date\=23 July 2007 \|access\-date\=22 July 2008}} Abdullah Gül was elected as the President in late August with 339 votes in the third round – the first at which a [simple majority](/wiki/Plurality_%28voting%29 "Plurality (voting)") is required – after deadlock in the first two rounds, in which a two\-thirds majority was needed.
#### 2007 constitutional referendum
{{Main article\|2007 Turkish constitutional referendum}}
[thumb\|right\|270px\|A rally of the Justice and Development Party in 2007](/wiki/File:Ak_parti_miting.jpg "Ak parti miting.jpg")
After the opposition parties deadlocked the 2007 presidential election by boycotting the parliament, the ruling AK Party proposed a constitutional reform package. The reform package was first vetoed by [President Sezer](/wiki/Ahmet_Necdet_Sezer "Ahmet Necdet Sezer"). Then he applied to the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey "Constitutional Court of Turkey") about the reform package, because the president is unable to veto amendments for the second time. The court did not find any problems in the package and 69% of the voters supported the constitutional changes.
The reforms consisted of:
* electing the president by popular vote instead of by parliament;
* reducing the presidential term from seven years to five;
* allowing the president to stand for re\-election for a second term;
* holding general elections every four years instead of five;
* reducing the quorum of lawmakers needed for parliamentary decisions from 367 to 184\.
#### 2009 local elections
The [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections") took place in March 2009, during the [Great Recession](/wiki/Great_Recession "Great Recession"). After the success of the AK Party in the 2007 general elections, the party saw a decline in the [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections "2009 Turkish local elections"). In these elections the AK Party received 39% of the vote, 3% less than in the local elections of 2004\. Still, the AK Party remained the dominating party in Turkey. The second party CHP received 23% of the vote and the third party [MHP](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party "Nationalist Movement Party") received 16% of the vote. The AK Party won in Turkey's largest cities: [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara "Ankara") and [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul").{{cite news \|url\=http://secim2009\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090329100431/http://secim2009\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-date\=29 March 2009 \|access\-date\=29 March 2009 \|title\=Turkish local elections, 2009 \|date\=29 March 2009 \|publisher\=\[\[NTV\-MSNBC]] \|department\=International / Europe }}
#### 2010 constitutional referendum
{{Main article\|2010 Turkish constitutional referendum}}
Reforming the Constitution was one of the main pledges of the AK Party during the 2007 election campaign. The main opposition party CHP was not interested in altering the Constitution on a big scale, making it impossible to form a [Constitutional Commission](/wiki/Constitutional_Commission "Constitutional Commission") (*Anayasa Uzlaşma Komisyonu*).{{cite news \|url\=http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/475685\.asp \|title\=AK Parti'nin Anayasa hedefi 15 madde \|publisher\=NTVMSNBC \|date\=17 February 2009 \|access\-date\=17 February 2009}} The amendments lacked the two\-thirds majority needed to instantly become law, but secured 336 votes in the 550 seat parliament – enough to put the proposals to a referendum.
The reform package included a number of issues: such as the right of individuals to appeal to the highest court, the creation of the [ombudsman](/wiki/Ombudsman "Ombudsman")'s office, the possibility to negotiate a nationwide labour contract, positive exceptions for female citizens, the ability of civilian courts to convict members of the military, the right of civil servants to go on strike, a privacy law, and the structure of the Constitutional Court. The referendum was agreed by a majority of 58%.
#### 2011 Turkish general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2014 elections
In the [presidential election of 2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_presidential_election "2014 Turkish presidential election"), the AK Party's long time leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was elected president. In the party's [first extraordinary congress](/wiki/2014_Justice_and_Development_Party_Extraordinary_Congress "2014 Justice and Development Party Extraordinary Congress"), former foreign minister [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu "Ahmet Davutoğlu") was unanimously elected unopposed as party leader and took over as prime minister on 28 August 2014\. Davutoğlu stepped down as prime minister on 4 May 2016 following policy disagreements with President Erdoğan. Presidential aide Cemil Ertem said to Turkish TV that the country and its economy would stabilize further "when a prime minister more closely aligned with President Erdoğan takes office".{{cite news\|title\=Turkey PM Ahmet Davutoğlu to quit amid reports of Erdoğan rift\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-36213401\|publisher\=BBC\|access\-date\=5 May 2016\|work\=BBC News\|date\=5 May 2016}}
#### June 2015 general election
In the [general election](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election "June 2015 Turkish general election") held on 7 June, the AK Party gained 40\.87% of the vote and 258 seats in the [Grand National Assembly of Turkey](/wiki/Grand_National_Assembly_of_Turkey "Grand National Assembly of Turkey") (Turkish: Türkiye Büyük Millet Meclisi, TBMM). Though it still remains the biggest party in Turkey, the AK Party lost its status as the majority party and the power to form a single\-party government. Until then it had held this majority without interruption for 13 years since it had come to power in 2002\. In this election, the AK Party was pushing to gain 330 seats in the Grand National Assembly so that it could put a series of constitutional changes to a referendum, one of them was to switch Turkey from the current parliamentary government to an American\-style executive presidency government.
This pursuit met with a series of oppositions and criticism from the opposition parties and their supporters, fearing the measure would give more unchecked power to the current President of Turkey [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan "Recep Tayyip Erdoğan"), who has drawn fierce criticisms both from home and abroad for his active role in the election, abandoning the traditional presidential role of maintaining a more neutral and impartial position in elections by his predecessors in the office. The result of the Kurdish issues\-centered [Peoples' Democratic Party](/wiki/Peoples%27_Democratic_Party_%28Turkey%29 "Peoples' Democratic Party (Turkey)"), HDP, breaking through the 10% threshold to achieve 13\.12% out of the total votes cast and gaining 80 seats in the Grand National Assembly in the election, which caused the AK Party to lose its parliamentary majority.
#### November 2015 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2018 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2019 local elections
In the [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections "2019 Turkish local elections"), the ruling party AK Party lost control of Istanbul and Ankara for the first time in 15 years, as well as five of Turkey's six largest cities. The loss has been widely attributed to AK Party's mismanagement of the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 "Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)"), rising authoritarianism as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey "Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey").{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\-istanbul\-mayor\-election\-intl/index.html\|title\=Istanbul election rerun won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\|author\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\|website\=CNN\|date\=23 June 2019\|access\-date\=20 August 2019}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\-mayor\-election\-erdogan.html\|title\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\|last\=Gall\|first\=Carlotta\|date\=23 June 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=20 August 2019\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0362\-4331}} Soon after the elections, the Turkish government ordered a [re\-election in Istanbul](/wiki/June_2019_Istanbul_mayoral_election "June 2019 Istanbul mayoral election"). The decision led to a downfall on AK Party's popularity and it lost the elections again in June with an even greater margin.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-48739256\|title\=Turkey's ruling party loses Istanbul election\|work\=BBC News\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\-istanbul\-mayor\-election\-intl/index.html\|title\=Istanbul election rerun set to be won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\|author\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\|website\=CNN\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/in\-setback\-for\-erdogan\-opposition\-candidate\-wins\-istanbul\-mayor\-seat\-11561309654\|title\=In Setback for Erdogan, Opposition Candidate Wins Istanbul Mayor Seat\|last\=Gauthier\-Villars\|first\=David\|newspaper\=Wall Street Journal\|date\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2019/dunya/son\-dakika\-financial\-timestan\-sok\-istanbul\-secimi\-yorumu\-5194106/\|title\=Son dakika… Financial Times'tan şok İstanbul seçimi yorumu\|website\=www.sozcu.com.tr\|date\=27 June 2019 }}
The result was seen as a huge blow to Erdoğan, who had once said that if his party 'lost Istanbul, we would lose Turkey.'{{Cite web\|url\=https://tele1\.com.tr/erdogan\-istanbulda\-teklersek\-turkiyede\-tokezleriz\-44258/\|title\=Erdoğan: 'İstanbul'da teklersek, Türkiye'de tökezleriz'\|date\=2 April 2019\|website\=Tele1}} The opposition's landslide was characterized as the 'beginning of the end' for Erdoğan,{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-48744733\|title\=Can Erdogan bounce back from big Turkey defeat?\|last\=Lowen\|first\=Mark\|date\=24 June 2019\|access\-date\=6 August 2019\|language\=en\-GB}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.thenational.ae/opinion/editorial/the\-beginning\-of\-the\-end\-for\-erdogan\-1\.878567\|title\=The beginning of the end for Erdogan?\|website\=The National\|date\=24 June 2019\|language\=en\|access\-date\=6 August 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.euronews.com/2019/06/24/could\-imamoglu\-victory\-in\-istanbul\-be\-beginning\-of\-the\-end\-for\-erdogan\|title\=Could Imamoglu victory in Istanbul be 'beginning of the end' for Erdogan?\|date\=24 June 2019\|website\=euronews\|language\=en\|access\-date\=6 August 2019}} with international commentators calling the re\-run a huge government miscalculation that can lead to a potential İmamoğlu candidacy in the next scheduled [presidential election](/wiki/2023_Turkish_general_election "2023 Turkish general election"). It is suspected that the scale of the government's defeat could provoke a cabinet reshuffle and early general elections, currently scheduled for June 2023\.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/06/24/turkeys\-erdogan\-suffers\-election\-blow\-but\-vote\-sparks\-hope\-for\-change.html\|title\=Turkey's Erdogan suffers election blow, sparking hope for change\|first\=Holly\|last\=Ellyatt\|date\=24 June 2019\|website\=CNBC}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\-mayor\-election\-erdogan.html\|title\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\|last\=Gall\|first\=Carlotta\|date\=23 June 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=6 August 2019\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0362\-4331}}
#### 2023 general election
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
#### 2024 local elections
{{Expand section\|date\=April 2024}}
|
[
"### Elections",
"{{Outdated\\|part\\=2023 and 2024 elections\\|date\\=March 2024\\|reason\\=The 2023 and 2024 elections have concluded}}\nThe party has won pluralities in the seven most recent legislative elections, those of [2002](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election \"2002 Turkish general election\"), [2007](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election \"2007 Turkish general election\"), [2011](/wiki/2011_Turkish_general_election \"2011 Turkish general election\"), [June 2015](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election \"June 2015 Turkish general election\"), [November 2015](/wiki/November_2015_Turkish_general_election \"November 2015 Turkish general election\"), [2018](/wiki/2018_Turkish_parliamentary_election \"2018 Turkish parliamentary election\") and [2023](/wiki/2023_Turkish_parliamentary_election \"2023 Turkish parliamentary election\"). The party held a majority of seats for 13 years, but lost it in June 2015, only to regain it in the snap election of November 2015 but then lose it again in 2018\\. Its past electoral success has been mirrored in the three local elections held since the party's establishment, coming first in [2004](/wiki/2004_Turkish_local_elections \"2004 Turkish local elections\"), [2009](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\") and [2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_local_elections \"2014 Turkish local elections\") respectively. However, the party lost most of Turkey's biggest cities including [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\") and [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") in [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections \"2019 Turkish local elections\"), which has been attributed to the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 \"Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)\"), accusations of authoritarianism, as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey \"Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey\").",
"#### 2002 general elections",
"The AK Party won a sweeping victory in the [2002 elections](/wiki/2002_Turkish_general_election \"2002 Turkish general election\"), which saw every party previously represented in the Grand National Assembly ejected from the chamber. In the process, it won a two\\-thirds majority of seats, becoming the first Turkish party in 11 years to win an outright majority. Erdoğan, as the leader of the biggest party in parliament, would have been normally given the task to form a cabinet.",
"However, according to the Turkish Constitution Article 109 the prime ministers had to be also a representative of the Turkish Parliament. Erdoğan, who was banned from holding any political office after a 1994 incident in which he read a poem deemed pro\\-Islamist by judges, was therefore not. As a result, Gül became prime minister.",
"It survived the crisis over the [2003 invasion of Iraq](/wiki/2003_invasion_of_Iraq \"2003 invasion of Iraq\") despite a massive back bench rebellion where over a hundred AK Party MPs joined those of the opposition [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party \"Republican People's Party\") (CHP) in parliament to prevent the government from allowing the [United States](/wiki/United_States \"United States\") to launch a Northern offensive in Iraq from Turkish territory. Later, Erdoğan's ban was lifted with the help of the CHP and Erdoğan became prime minister by being elected to the parliament after a [by\\-election in Siirt](/wiki/2003_Siirt_Province_by-election \"2003 Siirt Province by-election\").",
"The AK Party has undertaken structural reforms, and during its rule Turkey has seen rapid growth and an end to its three decade long period of high inflation rates. Inflation had fallen to 8\\.8% by 2004\\.",
"Influential business publications such as *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist \"The Economist\")* consider the AK Party's government the most successful in Turkey in decades.{{cite news \\|url\\=http://www.economist.com/opinion/displaystory.cfm?story\\_id\\=9116747 \\|access\\-date\\=22 July 2008 \\|title\\=The battle for Turkey's soul (Democracy v secularism in Turkey) \\|date\\=3 May 2007 \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Economist]] \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180812111802/https://www.economist.com/leaders/2007/05/03/the\\-battle\\-for\\-turkeys\\-soul\\|archive\\-date\\=12 August 2018}}",
"#### 2004 local elections",
"In the local elections of 2004, the AK Party won 42% of the votes, making inroads against the secular [Republican People's Party](/wiki/Republican_People%27s_Party \"Republican People's Party\") (CHP) on the South and West Coasts, and against the [Social Democratic People's Party](/wiki/Social_Democratic_People%27s_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"Social Democratic People's Party (Turkey)\"), which is supported by some [Kurds](/wiki/Kurds \"Kurds\") in the South\\-East of Turkey.",
"In January 2005, the AK Party was admitted as an observer member in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party \"European People's Party\") (EPP). However, it left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_European_Conservatives_and_Reformists \"Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists\") (AECR) in 2013\\.",
"#### 2007 elections",
"[250px\\|thumb\\|Voter base by monthly household income. AK Party is the largest party in group 1, 2, 3 and 4, while CHP is the largest in group 5, the richest 20% of Turkey.](/wiki/File:Se%C3%A7menin_gelir_d%C3%BCzeyine_g%C3%B6re_oy_da%C4%9F%C4%B1l%C4%B1m%C4%B1.PNG \"Seçmenin gelir düzeyine göre oy dağılımı.PNG\")",
"On 14 April 2007, an estimated 300,000 people marched in [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") to protest the possible candidacy of Erdoğan in the [2007 presidential election](/wiki/2007_Turkish_presidential_election \"2007 Turkish presidential election\"), afraid that if elected as president, he would alter the secular nature of the Turkish state.\"[Secular rally targets Turkish PM](http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/6554851.stm),\" BBC News, 14 April 2007\\. Erdoğan announced on 24 April 2007 that the party had decided to nominate Abdullah Gül as the AK Party candidate in the presidential election.\"[Turkey's ruling party announces FM Gul as presidential candidate](http://english.people.com.cn/200704/24/eng20070424_369332.html),\" [Xinhua](/wiki/Xinhua \"Xinhua\"), 24 April 2007\\. The protests continued over the next several weeks, with over one million reported at an 29 April rally in Istanbul,{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.afp.fr/english/news/stories/070429134050\\.kd2e8gv7\\.html\\|title\\=More than one million rally in Turkey for secularism, democracy\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Agence France\\-Presse]]\\|access\\-date\\=29 April 2007}}{{dead link\\|date\\=December 2017 \\|bot\\=InternetArchiveBot \\|fix\\-attempted\\=yes }}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSL2910950920070429\\|title\\=One million Turks rally against government\\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]]\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2007 \\|date\\=29 April 2007}} tens of thousands reported at separate protests on 4 May in [Manisa](/wiki/Manisa \"Manisa\") and [Çanakkale](/wiki/%C3%87anakkale \"Çanakkale\"),{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.milliyet.com.tr/2007/05/04/guncel/axgun01\\.html \\|title\\=Saylan: Manisa mitingi önemli\\|work\\=\\[\\[Milliyet]]\\|language\\=tr\\|access\\-date\\=4 May 2007}} and one million in [İzmir](/wiki/%C4%B0zmir \"İzmir\") on 13 May.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\\_protest\\_ahead\\_of\\_early\\_elections.html?siteSect\\=143\\&sid\\=7813908\\&cKey\\=1179061645000\\|title\\=Turks protest ahead of early elections\\|work\\=\\[\\[Swissinfo]]\\|access\\-date\\=13 May 2007 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070930222218/http://www.swissinfo.org/eng/international/ticker/detail/Turks\\_protest\\_ahead\\_of\\_early\\_elections.html?siteSect\\=143\\&sid\\=7813908\\&cKey\\=1179061645000 \\|archive\\-date\\=30 September 2007}}",
"Early [parliamentary elections](/wiki/2007_Turkish_general_election \"2007 Turkish general election\") were called after the failure of the parties in parliament to agree on the next Turkish president. The opposition parties boycotted the parliamentary vote and deadlocked the election process. At the same time, Erdoğan claimed the failure to elect a president was a failure of the Turkish political system and proposed to modify the constitution.",
"The AK Party achieved a significant victory in the rescheduled 22 July 2007 elections with 46\\.6% of the vote, translating into control of 341 of the 550 available parliamentary seats. Although the AK Party received significantly more votes in 2007 than in 2002, the number of parliamentary seats they controlled decreased due to the rules of the [Turkish electoral system](/wiki/Elections_in_Turkey \"Elections in Turkey\"). However, they retained a comfortable ruling majority.",
"Nationally, the elections of 2007 saw a major advance for the AK Party, with the party outpolling the pro\\-Kurdish [Democratic Society Party](/wiki/Democratic_Society_Party \"Democratic Society Party\") in traditional Kurdish strongholds such as [Van](/wiki/Van_Province \"Van Province\") and [Mardin](/wiki/Mardin_Province \"Mardin Province\"), as well as outpolling the secular\\-left CHP in traditionally secular areas such as [Antalya](/wiki/Antalya_Province \"Antalya Province\") and [Artvin](/wiki/Artvin_Province \"Artvin Province\"). Overall, the AK Party secured a plurality of votes in 68 of Turkey's 81 provinces, with its strongest vote of 71% coming from [Bingöl](/wiki/Bing%C3%B6l_Province \"Bingöl Province\"). Its weakest vote, a mere 12%, came from [Tunceli](/wiki/Tunceli_Province \"Tunceli Province\"), the only Turkish province where the [Alevi](/wiki/Alevism \"Alevism\") form a majority.{{cite news \\|url\\=http://www.bbc.co.uk/turkish/indepth/story/2007/07/070719\\_election\\_results\\_en.shtml \\|title\\=Turkey: 22 July 2007 – Election Results \\|publisher\\=BBC Turkish \\|date\\=23 July 2007 \\|access\\-date\\=22 July 2008}} Abdullah Gül was elected as the President in late August with 339 votes in the third round – the first at which a [simple majority](/wiki/Plurality_%28voting%29 \"Plurality (voting)\") is required – after deadlock in the first two rounds, in which a two\\-thirds majority was needed.",
"#### 2007 constitutional referendum",
"{{Main article\\|2007 Turkish constitutional referendum}}\n[thumb\\|right\\|270px\\|A rally of the Justice and Development Party in 2007](/wiki/File:Ak_parti_miting.jpg \"Ak parti miting.jpg\")\nAfter the opposition parties deadlocked the 2007 presidential election by boycotting the parliament, the ruling AK Party proposed a constitutional reform package. The reform package was first vetoed by [President Sezer](/wiki/Ahmet_Necdet_Sezer \"Ahmet Necdet Sezer\"). Then he applied to the [Turkish constitutional court](/wiki/Constitutional_Court_of_Turkey \"Constitutional Court of Turkey\") about the reform package, because the president is unable to veto amendments for the second time. The court did not find any problems in the package and 69% of the voters supported the constitutional changes.",
"The reforms consisted of:\n* electing the president by popular vote instead of by parliament;\n* reducing the presidential term from seven years to five;\n* allowing the president to stand for re\\-election for a second term;\n* holding general elections every four years instead of five;\n* reducing the quorum of lawmakers needed for parliamentary decisions from 367 to 184\\.",
"#### 2009 local elections",
"The [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\") took place in March 2009, during the [Great Recession](/wiki/Great_Recession \"Great Recession\"). After the success of the AK Party in the 2007 general elections, the party saw a decline in the [2009 Turkish local elections](/wiki/2009_Turkish_local_elections \"2009 Turkish local elections\"). In these elections the AK Party received 39% of the vote, 3% less than in the local elections of 2004\\. Still, the AK Party remained the dominating party in Turkey. The second party CHP received 23% of the vote and the third party [MHP](/wiki/Nationalist_Movement_Party \"Nationalist Movement Party\") received 16% of the vote. The AK Party won in Turkey's largest cities: [Ankara](/wiki/Ankara \"Ankara\") and [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\").{{cite news \\|url\\=http://secim2009\\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20090329100431/http://secim2009\\.ntvmsnbc.com/default.htm \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-date\\=29 March 2009 \\|access\\-date\\=29 March 2009 \\|title\\=Turkish local elections, 2009 \\|date\\=29 March 2009 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[NTV\\-MSNBC]] \\|department\\=International / Europe }}",
"#### 2010 constitutional referendum",
"{{Main article\\|2010 Turkish constitutional referendum}}\nReforming the Constitution was one of the main pledges of the AK Party during the 2007 election campaign. The main opposition party CHP was not interested in altering the Constitution on a big scale, making it impossible to form a [Constitutional Commission](/wiki/Constitutional_Commission \"Constitutional Commission\") (*Anayasa Uzlaşma Komisyonu*).{{cite news \\|url\\=http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/475685\\.asp \\|title\\=AK Parti'nin Anayasa hedefi 15 madde \\|publisher\\=NTVMSNBC \\|date\\=17 February 2009 \\|access\\-date\\=17 February 2009}} The amendments lacked the two\\-thirds majority needed to instantly become law, but secured 336 votes in the 550 seat parliament – enough to put the proposals to a referendum.",
"The reform package included a number of issues: such as the right of individuals to appeal to the highest court, the creation of the [ombudsman](/wiki/Ombudsman \"Ombudsman\")'s office, the possibility to negotiate a nationwide labour contract, positive exceptions for female citizens, the ability of civilian courts to convict members of the military, the right of civil servants to go on strike, a privacy law, and the structure of the Constitutional Court. The referendum was agreed by a majority of 58%.",
"#### 2011 Turkish general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2014 elections",
"In the [presidential election of 2014](/wiki/2014_Turkish_presidential_election \"2014 Turkish presidential election\"), the AK Party's long time leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan was elected president. In the party's [first extraordinary congress](/wiki/2014_Justice_and_Development_Party_Extraordinary_Congress \"2014 Justice and Development Party Extraordinary Congress\"), former foreign minister [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu \"Ahmet Davutoğlu\") was unanimously elected unopposed as party leader and took over as prime minister on 28 August 2014\\. Davutoğlu stepped down as prime minister on 4 May 2016 following policy disagreements with President Erdoğan. Presidential aide Cemil Ertem said to Turkish TV that the country and its economy would stabilize further \"when a prime minister more closely aligned with President Erdoğan takes office\".{{cite news\\|title\\=Turkey PM Ahmet Davutoğlu to quit amid reports of Erdoğan rift\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-36213401\\|publisher\\=BBC\\|access\\-date\\=5 May 2016\\|work\\=BBC News\\|date\\=5 May 2016}}",
"#### June 2015 general election",
"In the [general election](/wiki/June_2015_Turkish_general_election \"June 2015 Turkish general election\") held on 7 June, the AK Party gained 40\\.87% of the vote and 258 seats in the [Grand National Assembly of Turkey](/wiki/Grand_National_Assembly_of_Turkey \"Grand National Assembly of Turkey\") (Turkish: Türkiye Büyük Millet Meclisi, TBMM). Though it still remains the biggest party in Turkey, the AK Party lost its status as the majority party and the power to form a single\\-party government. Until then it had held this majority without interruption for 13 years since it had come to power in 2002\\. In this election, the AK Party was pushing to gain 330 seats in the Grand National Assembly so that it could put a series of constitutional changes to a referendum, one of them was to switch Turkey from the current parliamentary government to an American\\-style executive presidency government.",
"This pursuit met with a series of oppositions and criticism from the opposition parties and their supporters, fearing the measure would give more unchecked power to the current President of Turkey [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan \"Recep Tayyip Erdoğan\"), who has drawn fierce criticisms both from home and abroad for his active role in the election, abandoning the traditional presidential role of maintaining a more neutral and impartial position in elections by his predecessors in the office. The result of the Kurdish issues\\-centered [Peoples' Democratic Party](/wiki/Peoples%27_Democratic_Party_%28Turkey%29 \"Peoples' Democratic Party (Turkey)\"), HDP, breaking through the 10% threshold to achieve 13\\.12% out of the total votes cast and gaining 80 seats in the Grand National Assembly in the election, which caused the AK Party to lose its parliamentary majority.",
"#### November 2015 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2018 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2019 local elections",
"In the [2019 local elections](/wiki/2019_Turkish_local_elections \"2019 Turkish local elections\"), the ruling party AK Party lost control of Istanbul and Ankara for the first time in 15 years, as well as five of Turkey's six largest cities. The loss has been widely attributed to AK Party's mismanagement of the [Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/Turkish_economic_crisis_%282018%E2%80%93current%29 \"Turkish economic crisis (2018–current)\"), rising authoritarianism as well as alleged government inaction on the [Syrian refugee crisis](/wiki/Refugees_of_the_Syrian_Civil_War_in_Turkey \"Refugees of the Syrian Civil War in Turkey\").{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Istanbul election rerun won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\\|author\\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\\|website\\=CNN\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|access\\-date\\=20 August 2019}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-erdogan.html\\|title\\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\\|last\\=Gall\\|first\\=Carlotta\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=20 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}} Soon after the elections, the Turkish government ordered a [re\\-election in Istanbul](/wiki/June_2019_Istanbul_mayoral_election \"June 2019 Istanbul mayoral election\"). The decision led to a downfall on AK Party's popularity and it lost the elections again in June with an even greater margin.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-48739256\\|title\\=Turkey's ruling party loses Istanbul election\\|work\\=BBC News\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/23/europe/turkey\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Istanbul election rerun set to be won by opposition, in blow to Erdogan\\|author\\=Isil Sariyuce and Ivana Kottasová\\|website\\=CNN\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/in\\-setback\\-for\\-erdogan\\-opposition\\-candidate\\-wins\\-istanbul\\-mayor\\-seat\\-11561309654\\|title\\=In Setback for Erdogan, Opposition Candidate Wins Istanbul Mayor Seat\\|last\\=Gauthier\\-Villars\\|first\\=David\\|newspaper\\=Wall Street Journal\\|date\\=23 June 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2019/dunya/son\\-dakika\\-financial\\-timestan\\-sok\\-istanbul\\-secimi\\-yorumu\\-5194106/\\|title\\=Son dakika… Financial Times'tan şok İstanbul seçimi yorumu\\|website\\=www.sozcu.com.tr\\|date\\=27 June 2019 }}",
"The result was seen as a huge blow to Erdoğan, who had once said that if his party 'lost Istanbul, we would lose Turkey.'{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://tele1\\.com.tr/erdogan\\-istanbulda\\-teklersek\\-turkiyede\\-tokezleriz\\-44258/\\|title\\=Erdoğan: 'İstanbul'da teklersek, Türkiye'de tökezleriz'\\|date\\=2 April 2019\\|website\\=Tele1}} The opposition's landslide was characterized as the 'beginning of the end' for Erdoğan,{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-48744733\\|title\\=Can Erdogan bounce back from big Turkey defeat?\\|last\\=Lowen\\|first\\=Mark\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-GB}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.thenational.ae/opinion/editorial/the\\-beginning\\-of\\-the\\-end\\-for\\-erdogan\\-1\\.878567\\|title\\=The beginning of the end for Erdogan?\\|website\\=The National\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.euronews.com/2019/06/24/could\\-imamoglu\\-victory\\-in\\-istanbul\\-be\\-beginning\\-of\\-the\\-end\\-for\\-erdogan\\|title\\=Could Imamoglu victory in Istanbul be 'beginning of the end' for Erdogan?\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|website\\=euronews\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019}} with international commentators calling the re\\-run a huge government miscalculation that can lead to a potential İmamoğlu candidacy in the next scheduled [presidential election](/wiki/2023_Turkish_general_election \"2023 Turkish general election\"). It is suspected that the scale of the government's defeat could provoke a cabinet reshuffle and early general elections, currently scheduled for June 2023\\.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/06/24/turkeys\\-erdogan\\-suffers\\-election\\-blow\\-but\\-vote\\-sparks\\-hope\\-for\\-change.html\\|title\\=Turkey's Erdogan suffers election blow, sparking hope for change\\|first\\=Holly\\|last\\=Ellyatt\\|date\\=24 June 2019\\|website\\=CNBC}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/23/world/europe/istanbul\\-mayor\\-election\\-erdogan.html\\|title\\=Turkey's President Suffers Stinging Defeat in Istanbul Election Redo\\|last\\=Gall\\|first\\=Carlotta\\|date\\=23 June 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=6 August 2019\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}}",
"#### 2023 general election",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
"#### 2024 local elections",
"{{Expand section\\|date\\=April 2024}}",
""
] |
Ideology and policies
---------------------
Although the party is described as an Islamist party in some media, party officials reject those claims.{{cite encyclopedia\|title\=Justice and Development Party\|url\=https://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/1018363/Justice\-and\-Development\-Party\|publisher\=Britannica.com\|encyclopedia\=Encyclopædia Britannica\|access\-date\=21 July 2014\|quote\=Unlike its predecessors, the AK Party didn't centre its image around an Islamic identity; indeed, its leaders underscored that it was not an Islamist party and emphasized that its focus was democratization, not the politicization of religion.}} According to former minister [Hüseyin Çelik](/wiki/H%C3%BCseyin_%C3%87elik "Hüseyin Çelik"), "In the [Western](/wiki/Western_world "Western world") press, when the AK Party administration – the ruling party of the Turkish Republic – is being named, most of the time 'Islamic,' 'Islamist,' 'mildly Islamist,' 'Islamic\-oriented,' 'Islamic\-based' or 'with an Islamic agenda,' and similar language is being used. These characterizations do not reflect the truth, and they sadden us." Çelik added, "The AK Party is a conservative democratic party. The AK Party's conservatism is limited to moral and social issues."{{cite web\|date\=28 March 2010\|title\=AK Party explains charter changes, slams foreign descriptions\|url\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/default.aspx?pageid\=438\&n\=akp\-explains\-charter\-changes\-slams\-foreign\-descriptions\-2010\-03\-28\|access\-date\=21 July 2014\|work\=Hürriyet Daily News\|location\=Istanbul\|quote\="In the Western press, when the AK Party administration, the ruling party of the Turkish Republic, is being named, unfortunately most of the time Islamic agenda,' and similar language is being used. These characterizations do not reflect the truth, and they sadden us," Çelik said. "Yes, the AK Party is a conservative democratic party. The AK Party's conservatism is limited to moral and social issues."}} Also in a separate speech made in 2005, Prime Minister [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan "Recep Tayyip Erdoğan") stated, "We are not an Islamic party, and we also refuse labels such as Muslim\-democrat." Erdogan went on to say that the AK Party's agenda is limited to "[conservative democracy](/wiki/Conservative_democracy "Conservative democracy")".{{cite report \|last\=Taşpınar\|first\=Ömer\|date\=24 April 2012\|title\=Turkey: The New Model?\|url\=http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2012/04/24\-turkey\-new\-model\-taspinar\|website\=\[\[Brookings Institution]]}}
On the other hand, according to at least one observer ([Mustafa Akyol](/wiki/Mustafa_Akyol "Mustafa Akyol")), under the AK Party government of [Recep Tayyip Erdogan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdogan "Recep Tayyip Erdogan"), starting in 2007, "hundreds of secularist officers and their civilian allies" were jailed, and by 2012 the "old secularist guard" in positions of authority was replaced by members/supporters of the AK Party and the [Islamic](/wiki/Islam "Islam") [Gülen movement](/wiki/G%C3%BClen_movement "Gülen movement").{{cite news\|last1\=Akyol\|first1\=Mustafa\|title\=Who Was Behind the Coup Attempt in Turkey?\|work\=The New York Times \|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/22/opinion/who\-was\-behind\-the\-coup\-attempt\-in\-turkey.html?\_r\=0\|access\-date\=23 July 2016\|agency\=New York Times\|date\=July 22, 2016}} On 25 April 2016, the Turkish Parliament Speaker [İsmail Kahraman](/wiki/%C4%B0smail_Kahraman "İsmail Kahraman") told a conference of Islamic scholars and writers in Istanbul that "secularism would not have a place in a new constitution”, as Turkey is “a Muslim country and so we should have a religious constitution". (One of the duties of Parliament Speaker is to pen a new draft constitution for Turkey).{{cite news \|title\=Secularism must be removed from constitution, Turkey's Parliament Speaker says \|url\=https://www.milliyet.com.tr/en/vadim\-the\-suicide\-bomber\-2271599 \|access\-date\=31 January 2021 \|agency\=Milliyet \|date\=27 April 2016}} As of 2023, some sources define the party as being "rooted in political Islam" and an "Islamist\-rooted party".{{cite news \|last\= Kirby \|first\= Paul \|date\= 28 April 2023 \|title\= Turkish elections: Simple guide to Erdogan's toughest election battle \|url\= https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\-europe\-65239092 \|work\= BBC News \|access\-date\= 12 May 2023 \|quote\= His AK Party is rooted in political Islam, but he has forged an alliance with the ultra\-nationalist MHP.}}{{cite news \|last\= Kirby \|first\= Paul \|date\= 11 May 2023 \|title\= Turkey elections: Erdogan and Kilicdaroglu offer stark choices for presidency \|url\= https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\-europe\-65483654 \|work\= BBC News \|access\-date\= 12 May 2023 \|quote\= The president accuses his opponents of being "pro\-LGBT", while his Islamist\-rooted party positions itself as on the side of the family.}}
In recent years, the ideology of the party has shifted more towards [Turkish nationalism](/wiki/Turkish_nationalism "Turkish nationalism"),{{cite web\|date\=13 December 2018\|title\=Erdogan The Nationalist Vs Erdogan The Islamist\|url\=https://www.hoover.org/research/erdogan\-nationalist\-vs\-erdogan\-islamist\|work\=\[\[Hoover Institution]]}}{{Cite news\|date\=18 June 2019\|title\=Turkey's Hour of Nationalism: The Deeper Sources of Political Realignment\|work\=\[\[The American Interest]]\|url\=https://www.the\-american\-interest.com/2019/06/18/turkeys\-hour\-of\-nationalism\-the\-deeper\-sources\-of\-political\-realignment/}} causing liberals such as [Ali Babacan](/wiki/Ali_Babacan "Ali Babacan") and some conservatives such as [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu "Ahmet Davutoğlu") and [Abdullah Gül](/wiki/Abdullah_G%C3%BCl "Abdullah Gül") to leave the party.{{cite web\|date\=5 December 2019\|title\=Turkish Conservatives' Loyalty to Erdoğan and Views on Potential Successors\|url\=https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/security/news/2019/12/05/478087/turkish\-conservatives\-loyalty\-erdogan\-views\-potential\-successors/\|work\=\[\[Center for American Progress]]}} Several writers have also labelled the party as being [right\-wing populist](/wiki/Right-wing_populism "Right-wing populism") since 2007\.
The party's foreign policy has also been widely described as [Neo\-Ottomanist](/wiki/Neo-Ottomanism "Neo-Ottomanism"),{{cite web\|last\=Taşpınar\|first\=Ömer\|date\=September 2008\|title\=Turkey's Middle East Policies: Between Neo\-Ottomanism and Kemalism\|url\=http://www.carnegieendowment.org/publications/index.cfm?fa\=view\&id\=22209\|access\-date\=5 June 2010\|publisher\=Carnegie Endowment for International Peace}} an ideology that promotes renewed Turkish political engagement in the former territories of its predecessor state, the [Ottoman Empire](/wiki/Ottoman_Empire "Ottoman Empire"). However, the party's leadership has also rejected this label.{{cite news\|date\=25 November 2009\|title\=I am not a neo\-Ottoman, Davutoğlu says\|newspaper\=Today's Zaman\|location\=Turkey\|url\=http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\-web/news\-193944\-i\-am\-not\-a\-neo\-ottoman\-davutoglu\-says.html\|url\-status\=dead\|access\-date\=9 January 2012\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20131025025036/http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\-web/news\-193944\-i\-am\-not\-a\-neo\-ottoman\-davutoglu\-says.html\|archive\-date\=25 October 2013}} The party's relationship with the [Muslim Brotherhood](/wiki/Muslim_Brotherhood "Muslim Brotherhood") has drawn allegations of [Islamism](/wiki/Islamism "Islamism").
The AK Party favors a strong centralized leadership, having long advocated for a [presidential system](/wiki/Presidential_system "Presidential system") of government and significantly [reduced the number of elected local government positions](/wiki/2013_Turkish_local_government_reorganisation "2013 Turkish local government reorganisation") in 2013\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/presidential\-system\-tops\-akps\-election\-campaign.aspx?pageID\=238\&nID\=77644\&NewsCatID\=338\|title\=Presidential system tops AK Party's election campaign \|last1\=Babacan \|first1\=Nuray \|work\=Hurriet Daily News \|date\=30 January 2015 \|access\-date\=7 June 2015}}
The party was an observer in the centre\-right [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party "European People's Party") between 2005 and 2013 and a member of the [Eurosceptic](/wiki/Euroscepticism "Euroscepticism") [Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe](/wiki/Alliance_of_Conservatives_and_Reformists_in_Europe "Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe") (ACRE) from 2013{{cite web\|url\=http://www.euractiv.com/uk\-europe/erdogan\-akp\-party\-joins\-cameron\-news\-531645\|title\=Erdoğan's AK Party joins Cameron's conservative political family\|website\=EURACTIV.com\|date\=13 November 2013}} to 2018\.
### European affiliation
[thumb\|Picture of [Erdogan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan "Recep Tayyip Erdoğan") among other leaders at the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party "European People's Party") Congress in 2009](/wiki/File:Flickr_-_europeanpeoplesparty_-_EPP_Congress_Bonn_%28836%29.jpg "Flickr - europeanpeoplesparty - EPP Congress Bonn (836).jpg")
In 2005, the party was granted observer membership in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party "European People's Party") (EPP).
In November 2013, the party left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_Conservatives_and_Reformists_in_Europe "Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe") (now European Conservatives and Reformists Party) instead.{{cite web\|date\=13 November 2013\|title\=Erdoğan's AKP party joins Cameron's conservative political family\|url\=http://www.euractiv.com/uk\-europe/erdogan\-akp\-party\-joins\-cameron\-news\-531645\|access\-date\=14 January 2015\|work\=EurActiv}} This move was attributed to the AK Party's disappointment to not to be granted full membership in the EPP, while it was admitted as a full member of the AECR.{{cite web\|last\=Lagendijk\|first\=Joost\|author\-link\=Joost Lagendijk\|date\=12 November 2013\|title\=AK Party looking for new European friends\|url\=http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist/joost\-lagendijk/akp\-looking\-for\-new\-european\-friends\_331272\.html\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150211120343/http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist/joost\-lagendijk/akp\-looking\-for\-new\-european\-friends\_331272\.html\|archive\-date\=11 February 2015\|access\-date\=14 January 2015\|work\=\[\[Today's Zaman]]}} It drew criticism in both national and European discourses, as the driving force of Turkey's aspirations to become a member of the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union "European Union") decided to join a largely [eurosceptic](/wiki/Euroscepticism "Euroscepticism") alliance, abandoning the more influential pro\-European EPP, feeding suspicions that AK Party wants to join a watered down, not a closely integrated EU.{{cite web\|last\=Yinanç\|first\=Barçin\|date\=19 November 2013\|title\=By abandoning conservatives AK Party helps anti\-Turkey bloc in EU\|url\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/by\-abandoning\-conservatives\-akp\-helps\-anti\-turkey\-bloc\-in\-eu.aspx?pageID\=449\&nID\=58139\&NewsCatID\=412\|access\-date\=14 January 2015\|work\=\[\[Hürriyet Daily News]]}} The AK Party withdrew from AECR in 2018\.
### Legislation and positions
From 2002 to 2011 the party passed series of reforms to increase accessibility to healthcare and housing, distribute food subsidies, increased funding for students, improved infrastructure in poorer districts, and improved rights for religious and ethnic minorities. AK Party is also widely accredited for overcoming the [2001 Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/2001_Turkish_economic_crisis "2001 Turkish economic crisis") by following [International Monetary Fund](/wiki/International_Monetary_Fund "International Monetary Fund") guidelines, as well as successfully weathering the [2007–2008 financial crisis](/wiki/2007%E2%80%932008_financial_crisis "2007–2008 financial crisis"). From 2002 to 2011, the Turkish economy grew on average by 7\.5 percent annually, thanks to lower inflation and interest rates. The government under AK Party also backed extensive [privatization](/wiki/Privatization "Privatization") programs. In fact, 88% of the privatizations in Turkey were carried out under AK Party rule.{{cite web\|date\=2018\-06\-07\|title\=Sattırmayan Erdoğan ve gerçekler: Türkiye'deki özelleştirmelerin yüzde 88'i AK Parti döneminde yapıldı\|url\=https://sendika.org/2018/06/sattirmayan\-erdogan\-ve\-gercekler\-turkiyedeki\-ozellestirmelerin\-yuzde\-88i\-akp\-doneminde\-yapildi\-496395\|work\=Sendika.org\|accessdate\=2024\-01\-02}} The average income in Turkey rose from $2,800 U.S. in 2001 to around $10,000 U.S. in 2011, higher than income in some of the new EU member states. Other reforms included increasing civilian representation over military in areas of national security, education and media, and grant broadcasting and increased cultural [rights to Kurds](/wiki/Kurds_in_Turkey "Kurds in Turkey"). On Cyprus, AK Party supported [unification of Cyprus](/wiki/Cyprus_reunification "Cyprus reunification"), something deeply opposed by the [Turkish military](/wiki/Turkish_Armed_Forces "Turkish Armed Forces"). Other AK Party reforms included lifting bans on religious and conservative dress, such as [headscarves](/wiki/Headscarf "Headscarf"), in universities and public institutions. AK Party also ended discrimination against students from religious high schools, who previously had to meet additional criteria in areas of education and upon entry to universities. AK Party is also accredited for bringing the Turkish military under civilian rule, a paradigm shift for a country that had experienced constant military meddling for almost a century.
More recently, [nationwide protests](/wiki/Gezi_Park_protests "Gezi Park protests") broke out against the alleged [authoritarianism](/wiki/Authoritarianism "Authoritarianism") of the AK Party in 2013, with the party's perceived heavy\-handed response receiving western condemnation and stalling the party's once championed EU accession negotiations.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\-europe\-23044600\|title\=EU delays Turkey membership talks after German pressure\|work\=BBC News\|access\-date\=7 June 2015\|date\=25 June 2013}} In addition to its alleged attempts to promote Islamism, the party is accused by some of restricting some civil liberties and [internet use](/wiki/Internet_regulation_in_Turkey "Internet regulation in Turkey") in Turkey, having temporarily blocked access to [Twitter](/wiki/Twitter "Twitter") and [YouTube](/wiki/YouTube "YouTube") in March 2014\.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/21/turkey\-blocks\-twitter\-prime\-minister\|title\=Turkey blocks use of Twitter after prime minister attacks social media site\|author\=Kevin Rawlinson\|newspaper\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=7 June 2015\|date\=21 March 2014}} Especially after the [government corruption scandal](/wiki/2013_corruption_scandal_in_Turkey "2013 corruption scandal in Turkey") involving several AKP ministers in 2013, the party has been increasingly accused of [crony capitalism](/wiki/Crony_capitalism "Crony capitalism").{{cite web\|url\=http://politiikasta.fi/artikkeli/mass\-murder\-soma\-mine\-crony\-capitalism\-and\-fetish\-growth\-turkey\|title\=Mass Murder in Soma Mine: Crony Capitalism and Fetish of Growth in Turkey\|publisher\=politiikasta.fi\|access\-date\=7 June 2015\|archive\-date\=1 June 2015\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150601000223/http://politiikasta.fi/artikkeli/mass\-murder\-soma\-mine\-crony\-capitalism\-and\-fetish\-growth\-turkey\|url\-status\=dead}} The AK Party favors a strong centralized leadership, having long advocated for a [presidential system](/wiki/Presidential_system "Presidential system") of government and significantly [reduced the number of elected local government positions](/wiki/2013_Turkish_local_government_reorganisation "2013 Turkish local government reorganisation") in 2013\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/presidential\-system\-tops\-akps\-election\-campaign.aspx?pageID\=238\&nID\=77644\&NewsCatID\=338\|title\=Presidential system tops AK Party's election campaign \|work\=Hurriet Daily News\|date\=30 January 2015 \|access\-date\=7 June 2015}}
|
[
"Ideology and policies\n---------------------",
"Although the party is described as an Islamist party in some media, party officials reject those claims.{{cite encyclopedia\\|title\\=Justice and Development Party\\|url\\=https://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/1018363/Justice\\-and\\-Development\\-Party\\|publisher\\=Britannica.com\\|encyclopedia\\=Encyclopædia Britannica\\|access\\-date\\=21 July 2014\\|quote\\=Unlike its predecessors, the AK Party didn't centre its image around an Islamic identity; indeed, its leaders underscored that it was not an Islamist party and emphasized that its focus was democratization, not the politicization of religion.}} According to former minister [Hüseyin Çelik](/wiki/H%C3%BCseyin_%C3%87elik \"Hüseyin Çelik\"), \"In the [Western](/wiki/Western_world \"Western world\") press, when the AK Party administration – the ruling party of the Turkish Republic – is being named, most of the time 'Islamic,' 'Islamist,' 'mildly Islamist,' 'Islamic\\-oriented,' 'Islamic\\-based' or 'with an Islamic agenda,' and similar language is being used. These characterizations do not reflect the truth, and they sadden us.\" Çelik added, \"The AK Party is a conservative democratic party. The AK Party's conservatism is limited to moral and social issues.\"{{cite web\\|date\\=28 March 2010\\|title\\=AK Party explains charter changes, slams foreign descriptions\\|url\\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/default.aspx?pageid\\=438\\&n\\=akp\\-explains\\-charter\\-changes\\-slams\\-foreign\\-descriptions\\-2010\\-03\\-28\\|access\\-date\\=21 July 2014\\|work\\=Hürriyet Daily News\\|location\\=Istanbul\\|quote\\=\"In the Western press, when the AK Party administration, the ruling party of the Turkish Republic, is being named, unfortunately most of the time Islamic agenda,' and similar language is being used. These characterizations do not reflect the truth, and they sadden us,\" Çelik said. \"Yes, the AK Party is a conservative democratic party. The AK Party's conservatism is limited to moral and social issues.\"}} Also in a separate speech made in 2005, Prime Minister [Recep Tayyip Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan \"Recep Tayyip Erdoğan\") stated, \"We are not an Islamic party, and we also refuse labels such as Muslim\\-democrat.\" Erdogan went on to say that the AK Party's agenda is limited to \"[conservative democracy](/wiki/Conservative_democracy \"Conservative democracy\")\".{{cite report \\|last\\=Taşpınar\\|first\\=Ömer\\|date\\=24 April 2012\\|title\\=Turkey: The New Model?\\|url\\=http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2012/04/24\\-turkey\\-new\\-model\\-taspinar\\|website\\=\\[\\[Brookings Institution]]}}",
"On the other hand, according to at least one observer ([Mustafa Akyol](/wiki/Mustafa_Akyol \"Mustafa Akyol\")), under the AK Party government of [Recep Tayyip Erdogan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdogan \"Recep Tayyip Erdogan\"), starting in 2007, \"hundreds of secularist officers and their civilian allies\" were jailed, and by 2012 the \"old secularist guard\" in positions of authority was replaced by members/supporters of the AK Party and the [Islamic](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\") [Gülen movement](/wiki/G%C3%BClen_movement \"Gülen movement\").{{cite news\\|last1\\=Akyol\\|first1\\=Mustafa\\|title\\=Who Was Behind the Coup Attempt in Turkey?\\|work\\=The New York Times \\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/22/opinion/who\\-was\\-behind\\-the\\-coup\\-attempt\\-in\\-turkey.html?\\_r\\=0\\|access\\-date\\=23 July 2016\\|agency\\=New York Times\\|date\\=July 22, 2016}} On 25 April 2016, the Turkish Parliament Speaker [İsmail Kahraman](/wiki/%C4%B0smail_Kahraman \"İsmail Kahraman\") told a conference of Islamic scholars and writers in Istanbul that \"secularism would not have a place in a new constitution”, as Turkey is “a Muslim country and so we should have a religious constitution\". (One of the duties of Parliament Speaker is to pen a new draft constitution for Turkey).{{cite news \\|title\\=Secularism must be removed from constitution, Turkey's Parliament Speaker says \\|url\\=https://www.milliyet.com.tr/en/vadim\\-the\\-suicide\\-bomber\\-2271599 \\|access\\-date\\=31 January 2021 \\|agency\\=Milliyet \\|date\\=27 April 2016}} As of 2023, some sources define the party as being \"rooted in political Islam\" and an \"Islamist\\-rooted party\".{{cite news \\|last\\= Kirby \\|first\\= Paul \\|date\\= 28 April 2023 \\|title\\= Turkish elections: Simple guide to Erdogan's toughest election battle \\|url\\= https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\\-europe\\-65239092 \\|work\\= BBC News \\|access\\-date\\= 12 May 2023 \\|quote\\= His AK Party is rooted in political Islam, but he has forged an alliance with the ultra\\-nationalist MHP.}}{{cite news \\|last\\= Kirby \\|first\\= Paul \\|date\\= 11 May 2023 \\|title\\= Turkey elections: Erdogan and Kilicdaroglu offer stark choices for presidency \\|url\\= https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\\-europe\\-65483654 \\|work\\= BBC News \\|access\\-date\\= 12 May 2023 \\|quote\\= The president accuses his opponents of being \"pro\\-LGBT\", while his Islamist\\-rooted party positions itself as on the side of the family.}}",
"In recent years, the ideology of the party has shifted more towards [Turkish nationalism](/wiki/Turkish_nationalism \"Turkish nationalism\"),{{cite web\\|date\\=13 December 2018\\|title\\=Erdogan The Nationalist Vs Erdogan The Islamist\\|url\\=https://www.hoover.org/research/erdogan\\-nationalist\\-vs\\-erdogan\\-islamist\\|work\\=\\[\\[Hoover Institution]]}}{{Cite news\\|date\\=18 June 2019\\|title\\=Turkey's Hour of Nationalism: The Deeper Sources of Political Realignment\\|work\\=\\[\\[The American Interest]]\\|url\\=https://www.the\\-american\\-interest.com/2019/06/18/turkeys\\-hour\\-of\\-nationalism\\-the\\-deeper\\-sources\\-of\\-political\\-realignment/}} causing liberals such as [Ali Babacan](/wiki/Ali_Babacan \"Ali Babacan\") and some conservatives such as [Ahmet Davutoğlu](/wiki/Ahmet_Davuto%C4%9Flu \"Ahmet Davutoğlu\") and [Abdullah Gül](/wiki/Abdullah_G%C3%BCl \"Abdullah Gül\") to leave the party.{{cite web\\|date\\=5 December 2019\\|title\\=Turkish Conservatives' Loyalty to Erdoğan and Views on Potential Successors\\|url\\=https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/security/news/2019/12/05/478087/turkish\\-conservatives\\-loyalty\\-erdogan\\-views\\-potential\\-successors/\\|work\\=\\[\\[Center for American Progress]]}} Several writers have also labelled the party as being [right\\-wing populist](/wiki/Right-wing_populism \"Right-wing populism\") since 2007\\.",
"The party's foreign policy has also been widely described as [Neo\\-Ottomanist](/wiki/Neo-Ottomanism \"Neo-Ottomanism\"),{{cite web\\|last\\=Taşpınar\\|first\\=Ömer\\|date\\=September 2008\\|title\\=Turkey's Middle East Policies: Between Neo\\-Ottomanism and Kemalism\\|url\\=http://www.carnegieendowment.org/publications/index.cfm?fa\\=view\\&id\\=22209\\|access\\-date\\=5 June 2010\\|publisher\\=Carnegie Endowment for International Peace}} an ideology that promotes renewed Turkish political engagement in the former territories of its predecessor state, the [Ottoman Empire](/wiki/Ottoman_Empire \"Ottoman Empire\"). However, the party's leadership has also rejected this label.{{cite news\\|date\\=25 November 2009\\|title\\=I am not a neo\\-Ottoman, Davutoğlu says\\|newspaper\\=Today's Zaman\\|location\\=Turkey\\|url\\=http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\\-web/news\\-193944\\-i\\-am\\-not\\-a\\-neo\\-ottoman\\-davutoglu\\-says.html\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|access\\-date\\=9 January 2012\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20131025025036/http://www.todayszaman.com/tz\\-web/news\\-193944\\-i\\-am\\-not\\-a\\-neo\\-ottoman\\-davutoglu\\-says.html\\|archive\\-date\\=25 October 2013}} The party's relationship with the [Muslim Brotherhood](/wiki/Muslim_Brotherhood \"Muslim Brotherhood\") has drawn allegations of [Islamism](/wiki/Islamism \"Islamism\").",
"The AK Party favors a strong centralized leadership, having long advocated for a [presidential system](/wiki/Presidential_system \"Presidential system\") of government and significantly [reduced the number of elected local government positions](/wiki/2013_Turkish_local_government_reorganisation \"2013 Turkish local government reorganisation\") in 2013\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/presidential\\-system\\-tops\\-akps\\-election\\-campaign.aspx?pageID\\=238\\&nID\\=77644\\&NewsCatID\\=338\\|title\\=Presidential system tops AK Party's election campaign \\|last1\\=Babacan \\|first1\\=Nuray \\|work\\=Hurriet Daily News \\|date\\=30 January 2015 \\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015}}",
"The party was an observer in the centre\\-right [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party \"European People's Party\") between 2005 and 2013 and a member of the [Eurosceptic](/wiki/Euroscepticism \"Euroscepticism\") [Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe](/wiki/Alliance_of_Conservatives_and_Reformists_in_Europe \"Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe\") (ACRE) from 2013{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.euractiv.com/uk\\-europe/erdogan\\-akp\\-party\\-joins\\-cameron\\-news\\-531645\\|title\\=Erdoğan's AK Party joins Cameron's conservative political family\\|website\\=EURACTIV.com\\|date\\=13 November 2013}} to 2018\\.",
"### European affiliation",
"[thumb\\|Picture of [Erdogan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan \"Recep Tayyip Erdoğan\") among other leaders at the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party \"European People's Party\") Congress in 2009](/wiki/File:Flickr_-_europeanpeoplesparty_-_EPP_Congress_Bonn_%28836%29.jpg \"Flickr - europeanpeoplesparty - EPP Congress Bonn (836).jpg\")\nIn 2005, the party was granted observer membership in the [European People's Party](/wiki/European_People%27s_Party \"European People's Party\") (EPP).",
"In November 2013, the party left the EPP to join the [Alliance of European Conservatives and Reformists](/wiki/Alliance_of_Conservatives_and_Reformists_in_Europe \"Alliance of Conservatives and Reformists in Europe\") (now European Conservatives and Reformists Party) instead.{{cite web\\|date\\=13 November 2013\\|title\\=Erdoğan's AKP party joins Cameron's conservative political family\\|url\\=http://www.euractiv.com/uk\\-europe/erdogan\\-akp\\-party\\-joins\\-cameron\\-news\\-531645\\|access\\-date\\=14 January 2015\\|work\\=EurActiv}} This move was attributed to the AK Party's disappointment to not to be granted full membership in the EPP, while it was admitted as a full member of the AECR.{{cite web\\|last\\=Lagendijk\\|first\\=Joost\\|author\\-link\\=Joost Lagendijk\\|date\\=12 November 2013\\|title\\=AK Party looking for new European friends\\|url\\=http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist/joost\\-lagendijk/akp\\-looking\\-for\\-new\\-european\\-friends\\_331272\\.html\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150211120343/http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist/joost\\-lagendijk/akp\\-looking\\-for\\-new\\-european\\-friends\\_331272\\.html\\|archive\\-date\\=11 February 2015\\|access\\-date\\=14 January 2015\\|work\\=\\[\\[Today's Zaman]]}} It drew criticism in both national and European discourses, as the driving force of Turkey's aspirations to become a member of the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union \"European Union\") decided to join a largely [eurosceptic](/wiki/Euroscepticism \"Euroscepticism\") alliance, abandoning the more influential pro\\-European EPP, feeding suspicions that AK Party wants to join a watered down, not a closely integrated EU.{{cite web\\|last\\=Yinanç\\|first\\=Barçin\\|date\\=19 November 2013\\|title\\=By abandoning conservatives AK Party helps anti\\-Turkey bloc in EU\\|url\\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/by\\-abandoning\\-conservatives\\-akp\\-helps\\-anti\\-turkey\\-bloc\\-in\\-eu.aspx?pageID\\=449\\&nID\\=58139\\&NewsCatID\\=412\\|access\\-date\\=14 January 2015\\|work\\=\\[\\[Hürriyet Daily News]]}} The AK Party withdrew from AECR in 2018\\.",
"### Legislation and positions",
"From 2002 to 2011 the party passed series of reforms to increase accessibility to healthcare and housing, distribute food subsidies, increased funding for students, improved infrastructure in poorer districts, and improved rights for religious and ethnic minorities. AK Party is also widely accredited for overcoming the [2001 Turkish economic crisis](/wiki/2001_Turkish_economic_crisis \"2001 Turkish economic crisis\") by following [International Monetary Fund](/wiki/International_Monetary_Fund \"International Monetary Fund\") guidelines, as well as successfully weathering the [2007–2008 financial crisis](/wiki/2007%E2%80%932008_financial_crisis \"2007–2008 financial crisis\"). From 2002 to 2011, the Turkish economy grew on average by 7\\.5 percent annually, thanks to lower inflation and interest rates. The government under AK Party also backed extensive [privatization](/wiki/Privatization \"Privatization\") programs. In fact, 88% of the privatizations in Turkey were carried out under AK Party rule.{{cite web\\|date\\=2018\\-06\\-07\\|title\\=Sattırmayan Erdoğan ve gerçekler: Türkiye'deki özelleştirmelerin yüzde 88'i AK Parti döneminde yapıldı\\|url\\=https://sendika.org/2018/06/sattirmayan\\-erdogan\\-ve\\-gercekler\\-turkiyedeki\\-ozellestirmelerin\\-yuzde\\-88i\\-akp\\-doneminde\\-yapildi\\-496395\\|work\\=Sendika.org\\|accessdate\\=2024\\-01\\-02}} The average income in Turkey rose from $2,800 U.S. in 2001 to around $10,000 U.S. in 2011, higher than income in some of the new EU member states. Other reforms included increasing civilian representation over military in areas of national security, education and media, and grant broadcasting and increased cultural [rights to Kurds](/wiki/Kurds_in_Turkey \"Kurds in Turkey\"). On Cyprus, AK Party supported [unification of Cyprus](/wiki/Cyprus_reunification \"Cyprus reunification\"), something deeply opposed by the [Turkish military](/wiki/Turkish_Armed_Forces \"Turkish Armed Forces\"). Other AK Party reforms included lifting bans on religious and conservative dress, such as [headscarves](/wiki/Headscarf \"Headscarf\"), in universities and public institutions. AK Party also ended discrimination against students from religious high schools, who previously had to meet additional criteria in areas of education and upon entry to universities. AK Party is also accredited for bringing the Turkish military under civilian rule, a paradigm shift for a country that had experienced constant military meddling for almost a century.",
"More recently, [nationwide protests](/wiki/Gezi_Park_protests \"Gezi Park protests\") broke out against the alleged [authoritarianism](/wiki/Authoritarianism \"Authoritarianism\") of the AK Party in 2013, with the party's perceived heavy\\-handed response receiving western condemnation and stalling the party's once championed EU accession negotiations.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\\-europe\\-23044600\\|title\\=EU delays Turkey membership talks after German pressure\\|work\\=BBC News\\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015\\|date\\=25 June 2013}} In addition to its alleged attempts to promote Islamism, the party is accused by some of restricting some civil liberties and [internet use](/wiki/Internet_regulation_in_Turkey \"Internet regulation in Turkey\") in Turkey, having temporarily blocked access to [Twitter](/wiki/Twitter \"Twitter\") and [YouTube](/wiki/YouTube \"YouTube\") in March 2014\\.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/mar/21/turkey\\-blocks\\-twitter\\-prime\\-minister\\|title\\=Turkey blocks use of Twitter after prime minister attacks social media site\\|author\\=Kevin Rawlinson\\|newspaper\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015\\|date\\=21 March 2014}} Especially after the [government corruption scandal](/wiki/2013_corruption_scandal_in_Turkey \"2013 corruption scandal in Turkey\") involving several AKP ministers in 2013, the party has been increasingly accused of [crony capitalism](/wiki/Crony_capitalism \"Crony capitalism\").{{cite web\\|url\\=http://politiikasta.fi/artikkeli/mass\\-murder\\-soma\\-mine\\-crony\\-capitalism\\-and\\-fetish\\-growth\\-turkey\\|title\\=Mass Murder in Soma Mine: Crony Capitalism and Fetish of Growth in Turkey\\|publisher\\=politiikasta.fi\\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015\\|archive\\-date\\=1 June 2015\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150601000223/http://politiikasta.fi/artikkeli/mass\\-murder\\-soma\\-mine\\-crony\\-capitalism\\-and\\-fetish\\-growth\\-turkey\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} The AK Party favors a strong centralized leadership, having long advocated for a [presidential system](/wiki/Presidential_system \"Presidential system\") of government and significantly [reduced the number of elected local government positions](/wiki/2013_Turkish_local_government_reorganisation \"2013 Turkish local government reorganisation\") in 2013\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/presidential\\-system\\-tops\\-akps\\-election\\-campaign.aspx?pageID\\=238\\&nID\\=77644\\&NewsCatID\\=338\\|title\\=Presidential system tops AK Party's election campaign \\|work\\=Hurriet Daily News\\|date\\=30 January 2015 \\|access\\-date\\=7 June 2015}}",
""
] |
History
-------
In the early years the lands of which is now Josefina was part of the [Municipality of Aurora](/wiki/Aurora%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur "Aurora, Zamboanga del Sur"). In later years, [Molave](/wiki/Molave%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur "Molave, Zamboanga del Sur") separated from Aurora and became a town; at that time [Tambulig](/wiki/Tambulig%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur "Tambulig, Zamboanga del Sur") and the area now within the jurisdiction of the present municipality were still part of the former. Some years later Tambulig became independent and was recognized as a township with the land of Josefina still tagged as part of its territories. During this time the first Visayan settlers came to live in the area. These settlers came from [Tudela, Misamis Occidental](/wiki/Tudela%2C_Misamis_Occidental "Tudela, Misamis Occidental"), a barrio part of Tambulig was established and was named Bagong Tudela.
Some years passed and the Paredes family, one of the first settlers, was able to acquire properties there and named it "Salug Estate". A member of the family was a rubber technologist at that time and worked in Borneo. He brought along his lessons and expertise and together with the locals, "the Subanen", planted his land with Rubber Trees. By then the Rubber Technologist, Nicholas Paredes, coined the name "New Town" for the new rubber plantation.
With the rubber plantation, the place was then locally called as "Gumahan". This became a new trading center and small businesses came bustling. With the increased activity in this new location it was then christened as "Upper Bagong Tudela". This eventually became the center of the new community.
In the early 1970s, the people of Gumahan and its outlying barrios made a move, through the leadership of Nicholas Paredes, to create a town. They were able to submit the proposal to congress, through the sponsorship of then Cong. Cerilles, and it passed the 2nd congressional reading. When scheduled for the 3rd and final congressional reading, [Martial Law was declared](/wiki/Proclamation_No._1081 "Proclamation No. 1081") dissolving the Congress.
On November 11, 1978, by virtue of Presidential Decree 1240, 13 barangays of Tambulig were separated and formed into the independent municipality Josefina.{{cite web\|title\=Presidential Decree No. 1240: Creating the Municipality of Josefina in the Province of Zamboanga del Sur\|url\=http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/presdecs/pd1977/pd\_1240\_1977\.html\|website\=The Lawphil Project\|publisher\=Arellano Law Foundation, Inc.\|accessdate\=21 July 2014}} During this time Nicholas Paredes (who was the point person of the township proposal) stood as the first Mayor (appointed). Mayor Paredes donated the land where now stands the Market Area, the school, the Municipal Hall and the Catholic Church. The town center is also located within the properties of the Paredes family.
Josefina was named after the mother of Congressman Cerilles, who was a known educator in Zamboanga Del Sur.
As to this day Josefina is still commonly known as "Gumahan".
|
[
"History\n-------",
"In the early years the lands of which is now Josefina was part of the [Municipality of Aurora](/wiki/Aurora%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur \"Aurora, Zamboanga del Sur\"). In later years, [Molave](/wiki/Molave%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur \"Molave, Zamboanga del Sur\") separated from Aurora and became a town; at that time [Tambulig](/wiki/Tambulig%2C_Zamboanga_del_Sur \"Tambulig, Zamboanga del Sur\") and the area now within the jurisdiction of the present municipality were still part of the former. Some years later Tambulig became independent and was recognized as a township with the land of Josefina still tagged as part of its territories. During this time the first Visayan settlers came to live in the area. These settlers came from [Tudela, Misamis Occidental](/wiki/Tudela%2C_Misamis_Occidental \"Tudela, Misamis Occidental\"), a barrio part of Tambulig was established and was named Bagong Tudela.",
"Some years passed and the Paredes family, one of the first settlers, was able to acquire properties there and named it \"Salug Estate\". A member of the family was a rubber technologist at that time and worked in Borneo. He brought along his lessons and expertise and together with the locals, \"the Subanen\", planted his land with Rubber Trees. By then the Rubber Technologist, Nicholas Paredes, coined the name \"New Town\" for the new rubber plantation.",
"With the rubber plantation, the place was then locally called as \"Gumahan\". This became a new trading center and small businesses came bustling. With the increased activity in this new location it was then christened as \"Upper Bagong Tudela\". This eventually became the center of the new community.",
"In the early 1970s, the people of Gumahan and its outlying barrios made a move, through the leadership of Nicholas Paredes, to create a town. They were able to submit the proposal to congress, through the sponsorship of then Cong. Cerilles, and it passed the 2nd congressional reading. When scheduled for the 3rd and final congressional reading, [Martial Law was declared](/wiki/Proclamation_No._1081 \"Proclamation No. 1081\") dissolving the Congress.",
"On November 11, 1978, by virtue of Presidential Decree 1240, 13 barangays of Tambulig were separated and formed into the independent municipality Josefina.{{cite web\\|title\\=Presidential Decree No. 1240: Creating the Municipality of Josefina in the Province of Zamboanga del Sur\\|url\\=http://www.lawphil.net/statutes/presdecs/pd1977/pd\\_1240\\_1977\\.html\\|website\\=The Lawphil Project\\|publisher\\=Arellano Law Foundation, Inc.\\|accessdate\\=21 July 2014}} During this time Nicholas Paredes (who was the point person of the township proposal) stood as the first Mayor (appointed). Mayor Paredes donated the land where now stands the Market Area, the school, the Municipal Hall and the Catholic Church. The town center is also located within the properties of the Paredes family.",
"Josefina was named after the mother of Congressman Cerilles, who was a known educator in Zamboanga Del Sur.",
"As to this day Josefina is still commonly known as \"Gumahan\".",
""
] |
Demographics
------------
{{US Census population
\|align\=right
\|2000\= 410
\|2010\= 439
\|2020\= 417
\|estyear\=2021
\|estimate\=414
\|estref\=
\|footnote\=U.S. Decennial Census{{cite web\|url\=https://www.census.gov/programs\-surveys/decennial\-census.html\|title\=Census of Population and Housing\|publisher\=Census.gov\|access\-date\=June 4, 2016}}
}}
As of the [census](/wiki/Census "Census"){{cite web \|url\=https://www.census.gov \|publisher\=\[\[United States Census Bureau]] \|access\-date\=January 31, 2008 \|title\=U.S. Census website }} of 2000, there were 410 people, 157 households, and 114 families residing in the township.
The [population density](/wiki/Population_density "Population density") was 4\.8 people per square mile (1\.9/km{{sup\|2}}). There were 325 housing units at an average density of 3\.8/sq mi (1\.5/km{{sup\|2}}).
The racial makeup of the township was 99\.27% [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 "White (U.S. Census)"), 0\.24% [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 "Asian (U.S. Census)"), and 0\.49% from two or more races.
There were 157 households, out of which 26\.8% had children under the age of eighteen living with them; 63\.1% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage "Marriage") living together, 6\.4% had a female householder with no husband present, and 26\.8% were non\-families. 21\.0% of all households were made up of individuals, and 11\.5% had someone living alone who was sixty\-five years of age or older.
The average household size was 2\.61 and the average family size was 3\.07\.
In the township the population was spread out, with 22\.4% under the age of eighteen, 8\.8% from eighteen to twenty\-four, 28\.0% from twenty\-five to forty\-four, 27\.6% from forty\-five to sixty\-four, and 13\.2% who were sixty\-five years of age or older. The median age was thirty\-nine years.
For every one hundred females, there were 102\.0 males. For every one hundred females who were aged eighteen or older, there were 109\.2 males.
The median income for a household in the township was $31,786, and the median income for a family was $41,786\. Males had a median income of $26,250 compared with that of $18,438 for females.
The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income "Per capita income") for the township was $21,195\.
Roughly 10\.5% of families and 14\.0% of the population were living below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line "Poverty line"), including 22\.2% of those who were under the age of eighteen and 14\.7% of those who were aged sixty\-five or older.
|
[
"Demographics\n------------",
"{{US Census population\n\\|align\\=right\n\\|2000\\= 410\n\\|2010\\= 439\n\\|2020\\= 417\n\\|estyear\\=2021\n\\|estimate\\=414\n\\|estref\\=\n\\|footnote\\=U.S. Decennial Census{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.census.gov/programs\\-surveys/decennial\\-census.html\\|title\\=Census of Population and Housing\\|publisher\\=Census.gov\\|access\\-date\\=June 4, 2016}}\n}}\nAs of the [census](/wiki/Census \"Census\"){{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.census.gov \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Census Bureau]] \\|access\\-date\\=January 31, 2008 \\|title\\=U.S. Census website }} of 2000, there were 410 people, 157 households, and 114 families residing in the township.",
"The [population density](/wiki/Population_density \"Population density\") was 4\\.8 people per square mile (1\\.9/km{{sup\\|2}}). There were 325 housing units at an average density of 3\\.8/sq mi (1\\.5/km{{sup\\|2}}).",
"The racial makeup of the township was 99\\.27% [White](/wiki/White_%28U.S._Census%29 \"White (U.S. Census)\"), 0\\.24% [Asian](/wiki/Asian_%28U.S._Census%29 \"Asian (U.S. Census)\"), and 0\\.49% from two or more races.",
"There were 157 households, out of which 26\\.8% had children under the age of eighteen living with them; 63\\.1% were [married couples](/wiki/Marriage \"Marriage\") living together, 6\\.4% had a female householder with no husband present, and 26\\.8% were non\\-families. 21\\.0% of all households were made up of individuals, and 11\\.5% had someone living alone who was sixty\\-five years of age or older.",
"The average household size was 2\\.61 and the average family size was 3\\.07\\.",
"In the township the population was spread out, with 22\\.4% under the age of eighteen, 8\\.8% from eighteen to twenty\\-four, 28\\.0% from twenty\\-five to forty\\-four, 27\\.6% from forty\\-five to sixty\\-four, and 13\\.2% who were sixty\\-five years of age or older. The median age was thirty\\-nine years.",
"For every one hundred females, there were 102\\.0 males. For every one hundred females who were aged eighteen or older, there were 109\\.2 males.",
"The median income for a household in the township was $31,786, and the median income for a family was $41,786\\. Males had a median income of $26,250 compared with that of $18,438 for females.",
"The [per capita income](/wiki/Per_capita_income \"Per capita income\") for the township was $21,195\\.",
"Roughly 10\\.5% of families and 14\\.0% of the population were living below the [poverty line](/wiki/Poverty_line \"Poverty line\"), including 22\\.2% of those who were under the age of eighteen and 14\\.7% of those who were aged sixty\\-five or older.",
""
] |
Life and career
---------------
Gerhard Schwabenitzky{{Theaterlexikon\|Gerhard Klingenberg\|2\|1001\|1002\|Autor\=Julia Danielczyk\|language\=de}} was born in Vienna on 11 May 1929\. His father came from a worker's family of Polish origin and worked for [Fiat](/wiki/Fiat "Fiat"), his mother was born in Bohemia.
He took private classes in acting in [Salzburg](/wiki/Salzburg "Salzburg") after World War II and was accepted to study at the [Max Reinhardt Seminar](/wiki/Max_Reinhardt_Seminar "Max Reinhardt Seminar"); he studied acting and directing also in the drama class of the [Vienna Conservatory](/wiki/Music_and_Arts_University_of_the_City_of_Vienna "Music and Arts University of the City of Vienna"). He made money as an actor with the Landesbühne Burgenland; this occupation was prohibited for students, and he therefore took the stage name Klingenberg, which he kept for life. At age 18 he stepped in to play Camille in Büchner's *[Dantons Tod](/wiki/Danton%27s_Death "Danton's Death")* at the [Burgtheater](/wiki/Burgtheater "Burgtheater") in Vienna. He received an offer from the [Stadttheater Klagenfurt](/wiki/Stadttheater_Klagenfurt "Stadttheater Klagenfurt") already while studying, and directed there in March 1948 *[Das Haus in Montevideo](/wiki/The_House_in_Montevideo_%28play%29 "The House in Montevideo (play)")* by Curt Goetz. He then had engagements at the newly opened [Stadttheater St. Pölten](/wiki/Landestheater_Nieder%C3%B6sterreich "Landestheater Niederösterreich") and later at the [Tyrolean State Theatre](/wiki/Tyrolean_State_Theatre "Tyrolean State Theatre") in Innsbruck, where he played roles such as Franz Moor in Schiller's *[Die Räuber](/wiki/Die_R%C3%A4uber "Die Räuber")*.
In 1956 Klingenberg was invited by [Bertold Brecht](/wiki/Bertold_Brecht "Bertold Brecht") for his [Berliner Ensemble](/wiki/Berliner_Ensemble "Berliner Ensemble") in [East Germany](/wiki/East_Germany "East Germany"), to work on the world premiere of his *[Die Tage der Commune](/wiki/Die_Tage_der_Commune "Die Tage der Commune")*. [Helene Weigel](/wiki/Helene_Weigel "Helene Weigel") hired him as stage director after Brecht's death.{{cite web\| url \= https://www.defa\-stiftung.de/defa/biografien/kuenstlerin/gerhard\-klingenberg \| title \= Gerhard Klingenberg – Schauspieler, Regisseur\| last \= Schenk\| first \= Ralf\| date \= April 2021\| website \= defa\-stiftung.de\| access\-date \= 19 June 2024 }} As he was getting little work there, he also worked for [Deutscher Fernsehfunk](/wiki/Deutscher_Fernsehfunk "Deutscher Fernsehfunk") (DFF), where he directed [television plays](/wiki/Television_play "Television play") and theatrical recordings. In 1959, he directed the crime comedy *Spuk in Villa Sonnenschein* in the first co\-production by [DEFA](/wiki/DEFA "DEFA") and DFF. Soon afterwards, Klingenberg filmed the stage play *[Was wäre, wenn...?](/wiki/Was_w%C3%A4re%2C_wenn...%3F "Was wäre, wenn...?")* by [Hedda Zinner](/wiki/Hedda_Zinner "Hedda Zinner"). After the [Berlin Wall](/wiki/Berlin_Wall "Berlin Wall") was built in 1961, Klingenberg feared for his [freedom of movement](/wiki/Freedom_of_movement "Freedom of movement") and chose to return to Austria.{{cite news \| last \= Schenk \| first \= Ralf \| url \= https://www.berliner\-zeitung.de/kultur\-vergnuegen/der\-westen\-leuchtet\-die\-karrieren\-des\-gerhard\-klingenberg\-li.192322 \| title \= Der Westen leuchtet \| newspaper \= \[\[Berliner Zeitung]] \| date \= 8 November 2021 \| language \= de}}
From 1962 to 1968, Klingenberg directed at the [Städtische Bühnen Köln](/wiki/St%C3%A4dtische_B%C3%BChnen_K%C3%B6ln "Städtische Bühnen Köln"), the [Schauspiel Frankfurt](/wiki/Schauspiel_Frankfurt "Schauspiel Frankfurt"), and the [Schauspielhaus Hamburg](/wiki/Schauspielhaus_Hamburg "Schauspielhaus Hamburg"), as well as at the [Schillertheater](/wiki/Schillertheater "Schillertheater") in Berlin, the [Düsseldorfer Schauspielhaus](/wiki/D%C3%BCsseldorfer_Schauspielhaus "Düsseldorfer Schauspielhaus"), the [Schauspielhaus Zürich](/wiki/Schauspielhaus_Z%C3%BCrich "Schauspielhaus Zürich") and the [Münchner Kammerspiele](/wiki/M%C3%BCnchner_Kammerspiele "Münchner Kammerspiele"). His first stage direction at the Burgtheater was in 1968, and he became theatre manager in 1971, holding the position until 1976\. He brought [avant\-garde](/wiki/Avant-garde "Avant-garde") European directors to Vienna, including [Giorgio Strehler](/wiki/Giorgio_Strehler "Giorgio Strehler"), [Peter Hall](/wiki/Peter_Hall_%28director%29 "Peter Hall (director)"), [Luca Ronconi](/wiki/Luca_Ronconi "Luca Ronconi"), [Jean\-Louis Barrault](/wiki/Jean-Louis_Barrault "Jean-Louis Barrault"), [Peter Wood](/wiki/Peter_Wood_%28director%29 "Peter Wood (director)"), {{ill\|Roberto Guicciardini\|it}}, [Otomar Krejča](/wiki/Otomar_Krej%C4%8Da "Otomar Krejča") and {{ill\|Claus Peymann\|de}}.{{cite web \|title\=Mourning for Gerhard Klingenberg (1929–2024\) \|url\=https://www\-burgtheater\-at.translate.goog/trauer\-um\-gerhard\-klingenberg?\_x\_tr\_sl\=de\&\_x\_tr\_tl\=en\&\_x\_tr\_hl\=en\&\_x\_tr\_pto\=sc \|website\=Burgtheater Newsletter \|access\-date\=20 June 2024 \|date\=19 June 2024}} He introduced plays by authors such as [Thomas Bernhard](/wiki/Thomas_Bernhard "Thomas Bernhard") whose *{{ill\|Die Jagdgesellschaft\|de\|Die Jagdgesellschaft (Drama)}}* caused controversies in 1974, [Harold Pinter](/wiki/Harold_Pinter "Harold Pinter") and [Tom Stoppard](/wiki/Tom_Stoppard "Tom Stoppard") to the house repertoire. He directed there Hebbel's *[Judith](/wiki/Judith_%28Hebbel%29 "Judith (Hebbel)")* with {{ill\|Rolf Boysen\|de}} as Holofernes in 1973, Grillparzer's *[König Ottokars Glück und Ende](/wiki/K%C3%B6nig_Ottokars_Gl%C3%BCck_und_Ende "König Ottokars Glück und Ende")* in 1976 with [Heinz Reincke](/wiki/Heinz_Reincke "Heinz Reincke") in the title role, often with political analogies to a divided Europe.
Klingenberg returned to the Schauspielhaus Zürich where he was theatre manager from 1977 to 1982, where he directed Schillers *[Wilhelm Tell](/wiki/Wilhelm_Tell_%28play%29 "Wilhelm Tell (play)")* and Dürrenmatt's *[Romulus der Große](/wiki/Romulus_der_Gro%C3%9Fe "Romulus der Große")*.{{cite web \|last \= Pohl \|first \= Ronald \|title\=Ehemaliger Burgtheaterdirektor Gerhard Klingenberg gestorben \|url\=https://www.derstandard.at/story/3000000225010/ehemaliger\-burgtheater\-direktor\-klingenberg\-95\-jaehrig\-gestorben \|newspaper\=Der Standard \|access\-date\=21 June 2024 \|date\=19 June 2024 \|language\=de }} He was *[Intendant](/wiki/Intendant_%28theatre%29 "Intendant (theatre)")* at Berlin's {{ill\|Renaissance\-Theater, Berlin\|de\|Renaissance\-Theater (Berlin)\|lt\=Renaissance\-Theater}}. Thereafter, he worked as a freelance director.
Alongside his theatre work, Klingenberg participated in television productions{{cite web \|access\-date\=19 June 2024 \|language\=de\-DE \|title\=Lida Winiewicz \|url\=https://www.medienpreise.at/awardees/lida\-winiewicz/ \|website\=Medienpreise der Erwachsenenbildung}} as an actor, director and scriptwriter. He authored books such as *Das gefesselte Burgtheater* (2003\) and *Aus vergangenen Burgtheater Tagen* (2009\) as well as an autobiography, *Kein Blatt vor dem Mund* (1998\).
### Personal life
Klingenberg was the father of director [Reinhard Schwabenitzky](/wiki/Reinhard_Schwabenitzky "Reinhard Schwabenitzky"), who was married to the German\-Austrian actress [Elfi Eschke](/wiki/Elfi_Eschke "Elfi Eschke").{{cite news \|title\=Elfi Eschke freut sich Österreicherin zu sein \|url\=https://www.salzburg24\.at/news/salzburg/stadt/elfi\-eschke\-freut\-sich\-oesterreicherin\-zu\-sein\-44993275 \|date\=22 March 2014 \|last\=Posch \|first\=Michaela \|work\=Salzburg24 \|access\-date\=5 April 2022\| language\=de}}
Klingenberg died in [Villach](/wiki/Villach "Villach") on 18 June 2024, at the age of 95\.{{cite news \|last\=Leyrer \|first\=Georg \|date\=19 June 2024 \|title\=Ehemaliger Burgtheater\-Direktor Gerhard Klingenberg gestorben \|url\=https://kurier.at/kultur/todesfall\-burgtheater\-direktor\-gerhard\-klingenberg\-95\-jaehrig/402915092 \|access\-date\=19 June 2024 \|newspaper\=\[\[Kurier]] \|language\=de \|archive\-date\=19 June 2024 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20240619100847/https://kurier.at/kultur/todesfall\-burgtheater\-direktor\-gerhard\-klingenberg\-95\-jaehrig/402915092 \|url\-status\=live }}{{cite news \|date\=19 June 2024 \|title\=Theaterdirektor Gerhard Klingenberg ist tot \|url\=https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2024\-06/theaterdirektor\-regisseur\-gerhard\-klingenberg \|access\-date\=21 June 2024 \|newspaper\=\[\[Die Zeit]] \|language\=de }}{{cite news \|date\=19 June 2024 \|language\=de \|title\=Ehemaliger Burgtheater\-Direktor Klingenberg 95\-jährig gestorben \|url\=https://www.oe24\.at/oesterreich/chronik/ehemaliger\-burgtheater\-direktor\-klingenberg\-95\-jaehrig\-gestorben/598261629 \|newspaper\=\[\[Österreich (newspaper)\|Österreich]] \|access\-date\=19 June 2024 }}
|
[
"Life and career\n---------------",
"Gerhard Schwabenitzky{{Theaterlexikon\\|Gerhard Klingenberg\\|2\\|1001\\|1002\\|Autor\\=Julia Danielczyk\\|language\\=de}} was born in Vienna on 11 May 1929\\. His father came from a worker's family of Polish origin and worked for [Fiat](/wiki/Fiat \"Fiat\"), his mother was born in Bohemia.",
"He took private classes in acting in [Salzburg](/wiki/Salzburg \"Salzburg\") after World War II and was accepted to study at the [Max Reinhardt Seminar](/wiki/Max_Reinhardt_Seminar \"Max Reinhardt Seminar\"); he studied acting and directing also in the drama class of the [Vienna Conservatory](/wiki/Music_and_Arts_University_of_the_City_of_Vienna \"Music and Arts University of the City of Vienna\"). He made money as an actor with the Landesbühne Burgenland; this occupation was prohibited for students, and he therefore took the stage name Klingenberg, which he kept for life. At age 18 he stepped in to play Camille in Büchner's *[Dantons Tod](/wiki/Danton%27s_Death \"Danton's Death\")* at the [Burgtheater](/wiki/Burgtheater \"Burgtheater\") in Vienna. He received an offer from the [Stadttheater Klagenfurt](/wiki/Stadttheater_Klagenfurt \"Stadttheater Klagenfurt\") already while studying, and directed there in March 1948 *[Das Haus in Montevideo](/wiki/The_House_in_Montevideo_%28play%29 \"The House in Montevideo (play)\")* by Curt Goetz. He then had engagements at the newly opened [Stadttheater St. Pölten](/wiki/Landestheater_Nieder%C3%B6sterreich \"Landestheater Niederösterreich\") and later at the [Tyrolean State Theatre](/wiki/Tyrolean_State_Theatre \"Tyrolean State Theatre\") in Innsbruck, where he played roles such as Franz Moor in Schiller's *[Die Räuber](/wiki/Die_R%C3%A4uber \"Die Räuber\")*.",
"In 1956 Klingenberg was invited by [Bertold Brecht](/wiki/Bertold_Brecht \"Bertold Brecht\") for his [Berliner Ensemble](/wiki/Berliner_Ensemble \"Berliner Ensemble\") in [East Germany](/wiki/East_Germany \"East Germany\"), to work on the world premiere of his *[Die Tage der Commune](/wiki/Die_Tage_der_Commune \"Die Tage der Commune\")*. [Helene Weigel](/wiki/Helene_Weigel \"Helene Weigel\") hired him as stage director after Brecht's death.{{cite web\\| url \\= https://www.defa\\-stiftung.de/defa/biografien/kuenstlerin/gerhard\\-klingenberg \\| title \\= Gerhard Klingenberg – Schauspieler, Regisseur\\| last \\= Schenk\\| first \\= Ralf\\| date \\= April 2021\\| website \\= defa\\-stiftung.de\\| access\\-date \\= 19 June 2024 }} As he was getting little work there, he also worked for [Deutscher Fernsehfunk](/wiki/Deutscher_Fernsehfunk \"Deutscher Fernsehfunk\") (DFF), where he directed [television plays](/wiki/Television_play \"Television play\") and theatrical recordings. In 1959, he directed the crime comedy *Spuk in Villa Sonnenschein* in the first co\\-production by [DEFA](/wiki/DEFA \"DEFA\") and DFF. Soon afterwards, Klingenberg filmed the stage play *[Was wäre, wenn...?](/wiki/Was_w%C3%A4re%2C_wenn...%3F \"Was wäre, wenn...?\")* by [Hedda Zinner](/wiki/Hedda_Zinner \"Hedda Zinner\"). After the [Berlin Wall](/wiki/Berlin_Wall \"Berlin Wall\") was built in 1961, Klingenberg feared for his [freedom of movement](/wiki/Freedom_of_movement \"Freedom of movement\") and chose to return to Austria.{{cite news \\| last \\= Schenk \\| first \\= Ralf \\| url \\= https://www.berliner\\-zeitung.de/kultur\\-vergnuegen/der\\-westen\\-leuchtet\\-die\\-karrieren\\-des\\-gerhard\\-klingenberg\\-li.192322 \\| title \\= Der Westen leuchtet \\| newspaper \\= \\[\\[Berliner Zeitung]] \\| date \\= 8 November 2021 \\| language \\= de}}",
"From 1962 to 1968, Klingenberg directed at the [Städtische Bühnen Köln](/wiki/St%C3%A4dtische_B%C3%BChnen_K%C3%B6ln \"Städtische Bühnen Köln\"), the [Schauspiel Frankfurt](/wiki/Schauspiel_Frankfurt \"Schauspiel Frankfurt\"), and the [Schauspielhaus Hamburg](/wiki/Schauspielhaus_Hamburg \"Schauspielhaus Hamburg\"), as well as at the [Schillertheater](/wiki/Schillertheater \"Schillertheater\") in Berlin, the [Düsseldorfer Schauspielhaus](/wiki/D%C3%BCsseldorfer_Schauspielhaus \"Düsseldorfer Schauspielhaus\"), the [Schauspielhaus Zürich](/wiki/Schauspielhaus_Z%C3%BCrich \"Schauspielhaus Zürich\") and the [Münchner Kammerspiele](/wiki/M%C3%BCnchner_Kammerspiele \"Münchner Kammerspiele\"). His first stage direction at the Burgtheater was in 1968, and he became theatre manager in 1971, holding the position until 1976\\. He brought [avant\\-garde](/wiki/Avant-garde \"Avant-garde\") European directors to Vienna, including [Giorgio Strehler](/wiki/Giorgio_Strehler \"Giorgio Strehler\"), [Peter Hall](/wiki/Peter_Hall_%28director%29 \"Peter Hall (director)\"), [Luca Ronconi](/wiki/Luca_Ronconi \"Luca Ronconi\"), [Jean\\-Louis Barrault](/wiki/Jean-Louis_Barrault \"Jean-Louis Barrault\"), [Peter Wood](/wiki/Peter_Wood_%28director%29 \"Peter Wood (director)\"), {{ill\\|Roberto Guicciardini\\|it}}, [Otomar Krejča](/wiki/Otomar_Krej%C4%8Da \"Otomar Krejča\") and {{ill\\|Claus Peymann\\|de}}.{{cite web \\|title\\=Mourning for Gerhard Klingenberg (1929–2024\\) \\|url\\=https://www\\-burgtheater\\-at.translate.goog/trauer\\-um\\-gerhard\\-klingenberg?\\_x\\_tr\\_sl\\=de\\&\\_x\\_tr\\_tl\\=en\\&\\_x\\_tr\\_hl\\=en\\&\\_x\\_tr\\_pto\\=sc \\|website\\=Burgtheater Newsletter \\|access\\-date\\=20 June 2024 \\|date\\=19 June 2024}} He introduced plays by authors such as [Thomas Bernhard](/wiki/Thomas_Bernhard \"Thomas Bernhard\") whose *{{ill\\|Die Jagdgesellschaft\\|de\\|Die Jagdgesellschaft (Drama)}}* caused controversies in 1974, [Harold Pinter](/wiki/Harold_Pinter \"Harold Pinter\") and [Tom Stoppard](/wiki/Tom_Stoppard \"Tom Stoppard\") to the house repertoire. He directed there Hebbel's *[Judith](/wiki/Judith_%28Hebbel%29 \"Judith (Hebbel)\")* with {{ill\\|Rolf Boysen\\|de}} as Holofernes in 1973, Grillparzer's *[König Ottokars Glück und Ende](/wiki/K%C3%B6nig_Ottokars_Gl%C3%BCck_und_Ende \"König Ottokars Glück und Ende\")* in 1976 with [Heinz Reincke](/wiki/Heinz_Reincke \"Heinz Reincke\") in the title role, often with political analogies to a divided Europe.",
"Klingenberg returned to the Schauspielhaus Zürich where he was theatre manager from 1977 to 1982, where he directed Schillers *[Wilhelm Tell](/wiki/Wilhelm_Tell_%28play%29 \"Wilhelm Tell (play)\")* and Dürrenmatt's *[Romulus der Große](/wiki/Romulus_der_Gro%C3%9Fe \"Romulus der Große\")*.{{cite web \\|last \\= Pohl \\|first \\= Ronald \\|title\\=Ehemaliger Burgtheaterdirektor Gerhard Klingenberg gestorben \\|url\\=https://www.derstandard.at/story/3000000225010/ehemaliger\\-burgtheater\\-direktor\\-klingenberg\\-95\\-jaehrig\\-gestorben \\|newspaper\\=Der Standard \\|access\\-date\\=21 June 2024 \\|date\\=19 June 2024 \\|language\\=de }} He was *[Intendant](/wiki/Intendant_%28theatre%29 \"Intendant (theatre)\")* at Berlin's {{ill\\|Renaissance\\-Theater, Berlin\\|de\\|Renaissance\\-Theater (Berlin)\\|lt\\=Renaissance\\-Theater}}. Thereafter, he worked as a freelance director.",
"Alongside his theatre work, Klingenberg participated in television productions{{cite web \\|access\\-date\\=19 June 2024 \\|language\\=de\\-DE \\|title\\=Lida Winiewicz \\|url\\=https://www.medienpreise.at/awardees/lida\\-winiewicz/ \\|website\\=Medienpreise der Erwachsenenbildung}} as an actor, director and scriptwriter. He authored books such as *Das gefesselte Burgtheater* (2003\\) and *Aus vergangenen Burgtheater Tagen* (2009\\) as well as an autobiography, *Kein Blatt vor dem Mund* (1998\\).",
"### Personal life",
"Klingenberg was the father of director [Reinhard Schwabenitzky](/wiki/Reinhard_Schwabenitzky \"Reinhard Schwabenitzky\"), who was married to the German\\-Austrian actress [Elfi Eschke](/wiki/Elfi_Eschke \"Elfi Eschke\").{{cite news \\|title\\=Elfi Eschke freut sich Österreicherin zu sein \\|url\\=https://www.salzburg24\\.at/news/salzburg/stadt/elfi\\-eschke\\-freut\\-sich\\-oesterreicherin\\-zu\\-sein\\-44993275 \\|date\\=22 March 2014 \\|last\\=Posch \\|first\\=Michaela \\|work\\=Salzburg24 \\|access\\-date\\=5 April 2022\\| language\\=de}}",
"Klingenberg died in [Villach](/wiki/Villach \"Villach\") on 18 June 2024, at the age of 95\\.{{cite news \\|last\\=Leyrer \\|first\\=Georg \\|date\\=19 June 2024 \\|title\\=Ehemaliger Burgtheater\\-Direktor Gerhard Klingenberg gestorben \\|url\\=https://kurier.at/kultur/todesfall\\-burgtheater\\-direktor\\-gerhard\\-klingenberg\\-95\\-jaehrig/402915092 \\|access\\-date\\=19 June 2024 \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Kurier]] \\|language\\=de \\|archive\\-date\\=19 June 2024 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20240619100847/https://kurier.at/kultur/todesfall\\-burgtheater\\-direktor\\-gerhard\\-klingenberg\\-95\\-jaehrig/402915092 \\|url\\-status\\=live }}{{cite news \\|date\\=19 June 2024 \\|title\\=Theaterdirektor Gerhard Klingenberg ist tot \\|url\\=https://www.zeit.de/kultur/2024\\-06/theaterdirektor\\-regisseur\\-gerhard\\-klingenberg \\|access\\-date\\=21 June 2024 \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Die Zeit]] \\|language\\=de }}{{cite news \\|date\\=19 June 2024 \\|language\\=de \\|title\\=Ehemaliger Burgtheater\\-Direktor Klingenberg 95\\-jährig gestorben \\|url\\=https://www.oe24\\.at/oesterreich/chronik/ehemaliger\\-burgtheater\\-direktor\\-klingenberg\\-95\\-jaehrig\\-gestorben/598261629 \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Österreich (newspaper)\\|Österreich]] \\|access\\-date\\=19 June 2024 }}",
""
] |
History
-------
### Early history
Although it is thought the area has had [human settlements](/wiki/Human_settlements "Human settlements") since [pre\-historic](/wiki/Pre-historic "Pre-historic") times, evidence of human activity prior to the [Roman period](/wiki/Roman_period "Roman period") is sparse.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.queenelizabetholympicpark.co.uk/\~/media/lldc/conservation%20areas/caa\_mg\_fihws\_140127lldc.pdf\|title\=Fish Island and Hackney Wick South \- Conservation Area Appraisal \& Draft Management Guidelines\|website\=Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park\|first\=Robert\|last\=Bevan\|date\=January 2014\|access\-date\=July 18, 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lamas.org.uk/images/documents/Transactions59/039\-060%20Crown%20Wharf.pdf\|title\=Bridging the Lea: Ecavations at Crown Wharf, Dace Road, Tower Hamlets\|website\=London \& Middlesex Archaeological Society\|first\=Angus\|last\=Stephenson\|date\=January 2014\|access\-date\=July 18, 2019}}
Evidence from the Roman period, however, is abundant. The exact nature of the Roman settlements is undetermined, though there is evidence that the area was occupied until the end of the 4th or 5th century and, according to the [London and Middlesex Archaeological Society](/wiki/London_and_Middlesex_Archaeological_Society "London and Middlesex Archaeological Society") (LAMAS) "it produced large quantities of [Roman pottery](/wiki/Roman_pottery "Roman pottery"), [coins](/wiki/Roman_currency "Roman currency"), burials, ditches, pits and animal bones, particularly of cattle".
[Pye Road](/wiki/Pye_Road "Pye Road"), the main Roman road linking London to [Colchester](/wiki/Colchester "Colchester"), passed through the area and would likely have crossed the river Lea at what is now Fish Island, though the nature or exact location of the crossing point is not fully understood.
Immediately after the Roman period, little is known of what became of the local settlements. In the [Domesday Book](/wiki/Domesday_Book "Domesday Book") of 1086, the wider area is known [Old Ford](/wiki/Old_Ford "Old Ford") and is listed as part of [the Manor of Stepney](/wiki/Stepney "Stepney") and remained as such until at least the early 1300s.
At some point the Roman road and crossing will have fallen into disrepair, though the area remained the main crossing point between London and Essex until the early 12th century, at which point a stone bridge was constructed approximately half a mile downstream.{{Cite web\|url\=https://romanroadlondon.com/history\-fish\-island/\|title\=The fishy tale of Fish Island\|website\=Roman Road London\|date\=June 20, 2018\|last\=Agnew\|first\=Megan\|access\-date\=July 16, 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.hackney.gov.uk/media/3271/Hackney\-Wick\-and\-Fish\-Island\-baseline\-and\-key\-issues\-report\-April\-2008/pdf/Hackney\_Wick\_and\_Fish\_Island\_Baseline\_and\_Key\_Issues\_Report\_April\_2008\|title\=Hackney Wick and Fish Island \- Baseline and Key Issues Report\|website\=Hackney Council\|date\=April 2008\|access\-date\=July 18, 2019}}
There are few historical references of the area from the [medieval](/wiki/Medieval "Medieval") and [post\-medieval](/wiki/Post-medieval "Post-medieval") periods. The first known map of the area, from 1665, shows what is now Fish Island as an undeveloped [marshland](/wiki/Marshland "Marshland") only sparsely populated.
### Industrialisation
In the late 18th and early 19th century, the [Hackney Cut](/wiki/Hackney_Cut "Hackney Cut") and the [Hertford Union Canal](/wiki/Hertford_Union_Canal "Hertford Union Canal") were cut into the local marshes and a series of railway lines were established through the area which precipitated the shift from [rural](/wiki/Rural "Rural") to [industrial](/wiki/Industrialisation "Industrialisation"). Crown Wharf, the oldest industrial site in the area, was developed from 1853 onwards, with a wallpaper works located there by E.M. Coley and an ironworks subsequently being established next door. Toxic processing plants for commodities such as [crude oil](/wiki/Crude_oil "Crude oil") and [coal tar](/wiki/Coal_tar "Coal tar") were set up along the Hertford Union Canal. These factories were soon followed by others using these materials to produce things like [printing ink](/wiki/Printing_ink "Printing ink"), [rubber](/wiki/Rubber "Rubber") and [dry cleaning](/wiki/Dry_cleaning "Dry cleaning"). The waterways were a vital part of this industry, allowing for raw materials and finished products to be moved to and from the docks. It was at one point London's largest waterside industrial area.
In 1865, a 30\-acre plot of surplus railway land in the area was purchased by the Imperial Gas Light \& Co. in order to establish a new [gasworks](/wiki/Gasworks "Gasworks"). However, a decision was made to set up the new works in a different location and so the land was sold on to the [Gas Light and Coke Company](/wiki/Gas_Light_and_Coke_Company "Gas Light and Coke Company") (separate company). They instead used the land to build a [factory town](/wiki/Factory_town "Factory town") comprising a series of small houses and multi\-storey [factories](/wiki/Factories "Factories") and a network of new roads. These roads were given the names of fresh water fish (Dace, Bream, Roach) and, as the local area had been known to residents as "the Island", it eventually became known as Fish Island.{{cite book\|author1\=Bridget Cherry\|author2\=Charles O'Brien\|author3\=Nikolaus Pevsner\|title\=London: East\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=EW7k2KA4UkwC\&pg\=PA626\|year\=2005\|publisher\=Yale University Press\|isbn\=978\-0\-300\-10701\-2\|page\=626}}
By the end of the 19th century, Fish Island had become an area of intense and diverse industrial activity, often dangerous or noxious in nature. At this time the area had a population of approximately 6,000 inhabitants, mostly consisting of local workers and their families and although local living conditions were improving towards the beginning of the 20th century, most residents of Fish Island lived in poverty and squalor in makeshift accommodation.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.hackneywicked.co.uk/pdf/Hackney\-Wick\-Heritage\-Scoping\-report\-Edmund\-Bird.pdf\|title\=Design for London \- Heritage Scoping Report for Hackney Wick\|website\=Hackney Wicked\|date\=November 2009\|access\-date\=July 24, 2019\|last\=Bird\|first\=Edmund}}
During [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II "World War II"), Fish Island suffered extensive [bomb damage](/wiki/The_Blitz "The Blitz") with many of the buildings either completely destroyed or seriously damaged.
### Post\-war and recent regeneration
[thumb\|right\|Fish tail sculptures at the junction of Monier Road and Wansbeck Road](/wiki/File:Fish_island_sculptures.jpg "Fish island sculptures.jpg")
Following the war, the area changed greatly as local industries shifted to "low employment uses", such as [waste disposal](/wiki/Waste_disposal "Waste disposal"), [timber yards](/wiki/Lumber_yard "Lumber yard") and [warehouses](/wiki/Warehouses "Warehouses"), and much of the population left the area. Houses and local amenities were cleared and converted to industrial use. As a result, by the 1970s, the area became almost exclusively [light industrial](/wiki/Light_industrial "Light industrial") in nature and was virtually devoid of other uses, with many waste disposal sites and warehouses.
During the 1990s, the area saw an expansion of new [creative industries](/wiki/Creative_industries "Creative industries") and an influx of artists, who converted old and dilapidated warehouses into studios or lofts. It is claimed that the area had the highest density of artists in Europe in the 1990s and Fish Island, together with neighbouring Hackney Wick, became better known for its local art scene than its industry.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/house\-prices/welcome\-to\-fish\-island\-the\-new\-shoreditch/\|title\=Welcome to Fish Island, the new Shoreditch\|website\=\[\[The Daily Telegraph\|The Telegraph]]\|date\=October 2, 2016\|access\-date\=July 24, 2019\|last\=Fraser\|first\=Isabelle}}
In the early 2000s, Fish Island received new attention given its proximity to the site of the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park, the venue for the London [2012 Olympics](/wiki/2012_Olympics "2012 Olympics"). Local councils identified Fish Island, together with Hackney Wick, as key areas for regeneration as part of the development for the Olympic Games. As a result, the area saw the construction of a number of large residential and [mixed use](/wiki/Mixed_use "Mixed use") buildings, with more planned for completion in later years.{{Cite web\|url\=http://hidden\-london.com/gazetteer/fish\-island/\|title\=Fish Island, Tower Hamlets\|website\=Hidden London\|access\-date\=July 18, 2019}} This regeneration of the area and the associated increase in living cost and property prices led many to draw parallels with the [gentrification](/wiki/Gentrification "Gentrification") of [Shoreditch](/wiki/Shoreditch "Shoreditch") in the late 1990s, with the Daily Telegraph calling Fish Island "the new Shoreditch" in 2016\.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Early history",
"Although it is thought the area has had [human settlements](/wiki/Human_settlements \"Human settlements\") since [pre\\-historic](/wiki/Pre-historic \"Pre-historic\") times, evidence of human activity prior to the [Roman period](/wiki/Roman_period \"Roman period\") is sparse.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.queenelizabetholympicpark.co.uk/\\~/media/lldc/conservation%20areas/caa\\_mg\\_fihws\\_140127lldc.pdf\\|title\\=Fish Island and Hackney Wick South \\- Conservation Area Appraisal \\& Draft Management Guidelines\\|website\\=Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park\\|first\\=Robert\\|last\\=Bevan\\|date\\=January 2014\\|access\\-date\\=July 18, 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lamas.org.uk/images/documents/Transactions59/039\\-060%20Crown%20Wharf.pdf\\|title\\=Bridging the Lea: Ecavations at Crown Wharf, Dace Road, Tower Hamlets\\|website\\=London \\& Middlesex Archaeological Society\\|first\\=Angus\\|last\\=Stephenson\\|date\\=January 2014\\|access\\-date\\=July 18, 2019}}",
"Evidence from the Roman period, however, is abundant. The exact nature of the Roman settlements is undetermined, though there is evidence that the area was occupied until the end of the 4th or 5th century and, according to the [London and Middlesex Archaeological Society](/wiki/London_and_Middlesex_Archaeological_Society \"London and Middlesex Archaeological Society\") (LAMAS) \"it produced large quantities of [Roman pottery](/wiki/Roman_pottery \"Roman pottery\"), [coins](/wiki/Roman_currency \"Roman currency\"), burials, ditches, pits and animal bones, particularly of cattle\".",
"[Pye Road](/wiki/Pye_Road \"Pye Road\"), the main Roman road linking London to [Colchester](/wiki/Colchester \"Colchester\"), passed through the area and would likely have crossed the river Lea at what is now Fish Island, though the nature or exact location of the crossing point is not fully understood.",
"Immediately after the Roman period, little is known of what became of the local settlements. In the [Domesday Book](/wiki/Domesday_Book \"Domesday Book\") of 1086, the wider area is known [Old Ford](/wiki/Old_Ford \"Old Ford\") and is listed as part of [the Manor of Stepney](/wiki/Stepney \"Stepney\") and remained as such until at least the early 1300s.",
"At some point the Roman road and crossing will have fallen into disrepair, though the area remained the main crossing point between London and Essex until the early 12th century, at which point a stone bridge was constructed approximately half a mile downstream.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://romanroadlondon.com/history\\-fish\\-island/\\|title\\=The fishy tale of Fish Island\\|website\\=Roman Road London\\|date\\=June 20, 2018\\|last\\=Agnew\\|first\\=Megan\\|access\\-date\\=July 16, 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.hackney.gov.uk/media/3271/Hackney\\-Wick\\-and\\-Fish\\-Island\\-baseline\\-and\\-key\\-issues\\-report\\-April\\-2008/pdf/Hackney\\_Wick\\_and\\_Fish\\_Island\\_Baseline\\_and\\_Key\\_Issues\\_Report\\_April\\_2008\\|title\\=Hackney Wick and Fish Island \\- Baseline and Key Issues Report\\|website\\=Hackney Council\\|date\\=April 2008\\|access\\-date\\=July 18, 2019}}",
"There are few historical references of the area from the [medieval](/wiki/Medieval \"Medieval\") and [post\\-medieval](/wiki/Post-medieval \"Post-medieval\") periods. The first known map of the area, from 1665, shows what is now Fish Island as an undeveloped [marshland](/wiki/Marshland \"Marshland\") only sparsely populated.",
"### Industrialisation",
"In the late 18th and early 19th century, the [Hackney Cut](/wiki/Hackney_Cut \"Hackney Cut\") and the [Hertford Union Canal](/wiki/Hertford_Union_Canal \"Hertford Union Canal\") were cut into the local marshes and a series of railway lines were established through the area which precipitated the shift from [rural](/wiki/Rural \"Rural\") to [industrial](/wiki/Industrialisation \"Industrialisation\"). Crown Wharf, the oldest industrial site in the area, was developed from 1853 onwards, with a wallpaper works located there by E.M. Coley and an ironworks subsequently being established next door. Toxic processing plants for commodities such as [crude oil](/wiki/Crude_oil \"Crude oil\") and [coal tar](/wiki/Coal_tar \"Coal tar\") were set up along the Hertford Union Canal. These factories were soon followed by others using these materials to produce things like [printing ink](/wiki/Printing_ink \"Printing ink\"), [rubber](/wiki/Rubber \"Rubber\") and [dry cleaning](/wiki/Dry_cleaning \"Dry cleaning\"). The waterways were a vital part of this industry, allowing for raw materials and finished products to be moved to and from the docks. It was at one point London's largest waterside industrial area.",
"In 1865, a 30\\-acre plot of surplus railway land in the area was purchased by the Imperial Gas Light \\& Co. in order to establish a new [gasworks](/wiki/Gasworks \"Gasworks\"). However, a decision was made to set up the new works in a different location and so the land was sold on to the [Gas Light and Coke Company](/wiki/Gas_Light_and_Coke_Company \"Gas Light and Coke Company\") (separate company). They instead used the land to build a [factory town](/wiki/Factory_town \"Factory town\") comprising a series of small houses and multi\\-storey [factories](/wiki/Factories \"Factories\") and a network of new roads. These roads were given the names of fresh water fish (Dace, Bream, Roach) and, as the local area had been known to residents as \"the Island\", it eventually became known as Fish Island.{{cite book\\|author1\\=Bridget Cherry\\|author2\\=Charles O'Brien\\|author3\\=Nikolaus Pevsner\\|title\\=London: East\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=EW7k2KA4UkwC\\&pg\\=PA626\\|year\\=2005\\|publisher\\=Yale University Press\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-300\\-10701\\-2\\|page\\=626}}",
"By the end of the 19th century, Fish Island had become an area of intense and diverse industrial activity, often dangerous or noxious in nature. At this time the area had a population of approximately 6,000 inhabitants, mostly consisting of local workers and their families and although local living conditions were improving towards the beginning of the 20th century, most residents of Fish Island lived in poverty and squalor in makeshift accommodation.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.hackneywicked.co.uk/pdf/Hackney\\-Wick\\-Heritage\\-Scoping\\-report\\-Edmund\\-Bird.pdf\\|title\\=Design for London \\- Heritage Scoping Report for Hackney Wick\\|website\\=Hackney Wicked\\|date\\=November 2009\\|access\\-date\\=July 24, 2019\\|last\\=Bird\\|first\\=Edmund}}",
"During [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II \"World War II\"), Fish Island suffered extensive [bomb damage](/wiki/The_Blitz \"The Blitz\") with many of the buildings either completely destroyed or seriously damaged.",
"### Post\\-war and recent regeneration",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Fish tail sculptures at the junction of Monier Road and Wansbeck Road](/wiki/File:Fish_island_sculptures.jpg \"Fish island sculptures.jpg\")",
"Following the war, the area changed greatly as local industries shifted to \"low employment uses\", such as [waste disposal](/wiki/Waste_disposal \"Waste disposal\"), [timber yards](/wiki/Lumber_yard \"Lumber yard\") and [warehouses](/wiki/Warehouses \"Warehouses\"), and much of the population left the area. Houses and local amenities were cleared and converted to industrial use. As a result, by the 1970s, the area became almost exclusively [light industrial](/wiki/Light_industrial \"Light industrial\") in nature and was virtually devoid of other uses, with many waste disposal sites and warehouses.",
"During the 1990s, the area saw an expansion of new [creative industries](/wiki/Creative_industries \"Creative industries\") and an influx of artists, who converted old and dilapidated warehouses into studios or lofts. It is claimed that the area had the highest density of artists in Europe in the 1990s and Fish Island, together with neighbouring Hackney Wick, became better known for its local art scene than its industry.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/house\\-prices/welcome\\-to\\-fish\\-island\\-the\\-new\\-shoreditch/\\|title\\=Welcome to Fish Island, the new Shoreditch\\|website\\=\\[\\[The Daily Telegraph\\|The Telegraph]]\\|date\\=October 2, 2016\\|access\\-date\\=July 24, 2019\\|last\\=Fraser\\|first\\=Isabelle}}",
"In the early 2000s, Fish Island received new attention given its proximity to the site of the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park, the venue for the London [2012 Olympics](/wiki/2012_Olympics \"2012 Olympics\"). Local councils identified Fish Island, together with Hackney Wick, as key areas for regeneration as part of the development for the Olympic Games. As a result, the area saw the construction of a number of large residential and [mixed use](/wiki/Mixed_use \"Mixed use\") buildings, with more planned for completion in later years.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://hidden\\-london.com/gazetteer/fish\\-island/\\|title\\=Fish Island, Tower Hamlets\\|website\\=Hidden London\\|access\\-date\\=July 18, 2019}} This regeneration of the area and the associated increase in living cost and property prices led many to draw parallels with the [gentrification](/wiki/Gentrification \"Gentrification\") of [Shoreditch](/wiki/Shoreditch \"Shoreditch\") in the late 1990s, with the Daily Telegraph calling Fish Island \"the new Shoreditch\" in 2016\\.",
""
] |
Plot
----
Reverend Michael Hill ([Edward Herrmann](/wiki/Edward_Herrmann "Edward Herrmann")) and his two children arrive in the fictional [California](/wiki/California "California") town, New Campton. He is there to serve as the new minister at the North Avenue Presbyterian Church. The secretary/music director for the church, Anne ([Susan Clark](/wiki/Susan_Clark "Susan Clark")), is wary of the changes Hill intends to implement. Hill wants to get people involved, and asks Mrs. Rose Rafferty ([Patsy Kelly](/wiki/Patsy_Kelly "Patsy Kelly"), in her final movie role) to handle the church's [sinking fund](/wiki/Sinking_fund "Sinking fund"), which consisted of $1,206 ($4,967 in 2022 dollars). It turns out being an awful mistake, because she has a husband who is a reckless gambler.
On his first Sunday, Hill learns from Mrs. Rafferty that her husband Delaney ([Douglas Fowley](/wiki/Douglas_Fowley "Douglas Fowley")) bet all the sinking fund money on a horse race. Hill delivers a sermon less than 15 seconds long, then rapidly escorts Mrs. Rafferty out the church as astonished worshipers watch. She leads him to the [bookie](/wiki/Bookie "Bookie"), hidden behind a dry\-cleaning shop owned by Sam the Tailor ([Carl Ballantine](/wiki/Carl_Ballantine "Carl Ballantine")), and meets Harry the Hat ([Alan Hale, Jr.](/wiki/Alan_Hale%2C_Jr. "Alan Hale, Jr.")), who recommends that Hill let the bet ride. Hill's horse, Sundae Treat, loses and he is thrown out of the betting parlor. Hill summons the police, but the booking joint has been skillfully removed.
That evening, Hill delivers a tirade against the [organized crime](/wiki/Organized_crime "Organized crime") in the city during a local television broadcast. He is chastised by his presbytery superiors for the tirade, and is urged to go out and build church membership in the area. His only success is with a rock band called Strawberry Shortcake, who he recruits to "jazz up" the music at church; Anne resigns as music director. Then, two treasury agents for the US government arrive: Marvin Fogleman ([Michael Constantine](/wiki/Michael_Constantine "Michael Constantine")) and Tom Voohries ([Steve Franken](/wiki/Steve_Franken "Steve Franken")). They want Hill to help them close down the gambling racket by recruiting some men from the church to place bets that the agents will watch. Hill cannot find any men to help, but hits upon the idea of using women. Five women from his congregation attempt to place bets in the company of the Treasury agents, but ending up in some kind of disastrously clumsy result.
The team changes tactics to try to go after the "bank" that the gangsters use, tailing the mob's deliverymen through town while Hill coordinates using a map at the church office.
Two gangsters subsequently appear at the church during services and identify one of the women, Claire Porter ([Cloris Leachman](/wiki/Cloris_Leachman "Cloris Leachman")). They report that to Max Roca ([Frank Campanella](/wiki/Frank_Campanella "Frank Campanella")), their crime boss, who advises them to threaten intimidation.
Anne discovers the operation, even as Hill defends the Irregulars as keeping the gangsters off balance. Anne resigns from the secretary position, and soon after, the gangsters firebomb the church.
Hill is shocked at the gangsters' act, and seems ready to give in, but to his surprise, Anne wants to join the fight. They do so, and continue to hammer the gangsters' movements around town. Meanwhile, Hill receives word that the pulpit has been declared vacant and North Avenue will be discontinued as a church entity.
Dr. Victor Fulton ([Herb Voland](/wiki/Herb_Voland "Herb Voland")), a representative from presbytery, arrives to discuss the closure with Hill. Anne picks up two more presbytery representatives at the airport, Dr. Rheems ([Ruth Buzzi](/wiki/Ruth_Buzzi "Ruth Buzzi")) and Reverend Wainwright ([Ivor Francis](/wiki/Ivor_Francis "Ivor Francis")), but while bringing them to the church, she recognizes one of the mob's deliverymen and realizes she may be able to find the bank. She tracks the deliveryman to an isolated compound. Within minutes, all the Irregulars besiege the place as the gangsters attempt a frantic escape with their bank. A demolition derby ensues, the crooks are stopped, and the evidence is seized.
The following Sunday, Hill's congregation gathers outside the ravaged church while he delivers news of the indictments against the mob and of the closing of the church. However, Dr. Fulton steps in to proclaim that North Avenue has a new lease on life—it will be rebuilt. The youthful band starts the music again as everyone rejoices.
|
[
"Plot\n----",
"Reverend Michael Hill ([Edward Herrmann](/wiki/Edward_Herrmann \"Edward Herrmann\")) and his two children arrive in the fictional [California](/wiki/California \"California\") town, New Campton. He is there to serve as the new minister at the North Avenue Presbyterian Church. The secretary/music director for the church, Anne ([Susan Clark](/wiki/Susan_Clark \"Susan Clark\")), is wary of the changes Hill intends to implement. Hill wants to get people involved, and asks Mrs. Rose Rafferty ([Patsy Kelly](/wiki/Patsy_Kelly \"Patsy Kelly\"), in her final movie role) to handle the church's [sinking fund](/wiki/Sinking_fund \"Sinking fund\"), which consisted of $1,206 ($4,967 in 2022 dollars). It turns out being an awful mistake, because she has a husband who is a reckless gambler.",
"On his first Sunday, Hill learns from Mrs. Rafferty that her husband Delaney ([Douglas Fowley](/wiki/Douglas_Fowley \"Douglas Fowley\")) bet all the sinking fund money on a horse race. Hill delivers a sermon less than 15 seconds long, then rapidly escorts Mrs. Rafferty out the church as astonished worshipers watch. She leads him to the [bookie](/wiki/Bookie \"Bookie\"), hidden behind a dry\\-cleaning shop owned by Sam the Tailor ([Carl Ballantine](/wiki/Carl_Ballantine \"Carl Ballantine\")), and meets Harry the Hat ([Alan Hale, Jr.](/wiki/Alan_Hale%2C_Jr. \"Alan Hale, Jr.\")), who recommends that Hill let the bet ride. Hill's horse, Sundae Treat, loses and he is thrown out of the betting parlor. Hill summons the police, but the booking joint has been skillfully removed.",
"That evening, Hill delivers a tirade against the [organized crime](/wiki/Organized_crime \"Organized crime\") in the city during a local television broadcast. He is chastised by his presbytery superiors for the tirade, and is urged to go out and build church membership in the area. His only success is with a rock band called Strawberry Shortcake, who he recruits to \"jazz up\" the music at church; Anne resigns as music director. Then, two treasury agents for the US government arrive: Marvin Fogleman ([Michael Constantine](/wiki/Michael_Constantine \"Michael Constantine\")) and Tom Voohries ([Steve Franken](/wiki/Steve_Franken \"Steve Franken\")). They want Hill to help them close down the gambling racket by recruiting some men from the church to place bets that the agents will watch. Hill cannot find any men to help, but hits upon the idea of using women. Five women from his congregation attempt to place bets in the company of the Treasury agents, but ending up in some kind of disastrously clumsy result.",
"The team changes tactics to try to go after the \"bank\" that the gangsters use, tailing the mob's deliverymen through town while Hill coordinates using a map at the church office.",
"Two gangsters subsequently appear at the church during services and identify one of the women, Claire Porter ([Cloris Leachman](/wiki/Cloris_Leachman \"Cloris Leachman\")). They report that to Max Roca ([Frank Campanella](/wiki/Frank_Campanella \"Frank Campanella\")), their crime boss, who advises them to threaten intimidation.",
"Anne discovers the operation, even as Hill defends the Irregulars as keeping the gangsters off balance. Anne resigns from the secretary position, and soon after, the gangsters firebomb the church.",
"Hill is shocked at the gangsters' act, and seems ready to give in, but to his surprise, Anne wants to join the fight. They do so, and continue to hammer the gangsters' movements around town. Meanwhile, Hill receives word that the pulpit has been declared vacant and North Avenue will be discontinued as a church entity.",
"Dr. Victor Fulton ([Herb Voland](/wiki/Herb_Voland \"Herb Voland\")), a representative from presbytery, arrives to discuss the closure with Hill. Anne picks up two more presbytery representatives at the airport, Dr. Rheems ([Ruth Buzzi](/wiki/Ruth_Buzzi \"Ruth Buzzi\")) and Reverend Wainwright ([Ivor Francis](/wiki/Ivor_Francis \"Ivor Francis\")), but while bringing them to the church, she recognizes one of the mob's deliverymen and realizes she may be able to find the bank. She tracks the deliveryman to an isolated compound. Within minutes, all the Irregulars besiege the place as the gangsters attempt a frantic escape with their bank. A demolition derby ensues, the crooks are stopped, and the evidence is seized.",
"The following Sunday, Hill's congregation gathers outside the ravaged church while he delivers news of the indictments against the mob and of the closing of the church. However, Dr. Fulton steps in to proclaim that North Avenue has a new lease on life—it will be rebuilt. The youthful band starts the music again as everyone rejoices.",
""
] |
History
-------
### Atlético Mexiquense
Atlético Mexiquense was founded during the "Invierno 97" season, when the team Deportivo Toluca F.C. decided to purchase the team "Toltécas" from "Atlético Hidalgo", (which were created in the "Invierno 96" season as part of the expansion of the Primera División A). The team was bought and were brought to play in Toluca under the name of Atlético Mexiquense. By this, they became affiliated to Deportivo Toluca F.C., who plays in Primera División de Mexico.
The objective of Atlético Mexiquense is to form players that can incorporate themselves from short or medium time to Deportivo Toluca F.C., and to make sure they understand how the Mexican League works.
Atlético Mexiquense, in their short history, has had moments of glory, such as in their first season, (Invierno 97\), where they finished as number 1 in the standings, with a total of 47 points. They were led by manager Marco Antonio Trejo. Also, in the Clausura 2004 season, Atlético Mexiquense finished 2nd place in the standings and played for the first time in the Primera A Championship in their history against San Luis F.C., (who won and eventually ascended to the Primera División).
The team does not have a special nickname, although some call them the "Diablitos" (Little Devils), "pingos", and "demonios" (Demons).
Atlético Mexiquense for the 2009–2010 season did not complete in the new Liga de Ascenso since according to the FEMEXFUT did not meet the requirements to continue taking their place, and was relegated to the Second Division, also as part of this division also cuts out Socio Águila, Monterrey, Chihuahua Indians, Santos Laguna, Tigres "B" Jaguares de Tapachula, Tampico Madero, Academic Atlas, Tecos UAG and Mérida "B" (newly promoted).
### Restructuring
In the restructuring that occurred in Deportivo Toluca, Atlético Mexiquense became the subsidiary team of Toluca and the official U17 and U20 teams are named Atlético Mexiquense U17 and U20\.
For the start of the Apertura 2015 season, The Segunda División de México was expanded to include 1 affiliate club for every team currently in the Liga MX. Each team will be named after the first division affiliate followed by "Premier". Toluca Premier will consist mainly of players moving up from the U20 team or young players who have been promoted but are finding minutes in the top flight hard to come by.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Atlético Mexiquense",
"Atlético Mexiquense was founded during the \"Invierno 97\" season, when the team Deportivo Toluca F.C. decided to purchase the team \"Toltécas\" from \"Atlético Hidalgo\", (which were created in the \"Invierno 96\" season as part of the expansion of the Primera División A). The team was bought and were brought to play in Toluca under the name of Atlético Mexiquense. By this, they became affiliated to Deportivo Toluca F.C., who plays in Primera División de Mexico.",
"The objective of Atlético Mexiquense is to form players that can incorporate themselves from short or medium time to Deportivo Toluca F.C., and to make sure they understand how the Mexican League works.",
"Atlético Mexiquense, in their short history, has had moments of glory, such as in their first season, (Invierno 97\\), where they finished as number 1 in the standings, with a total of 47 points. They were led by manager Marco Antonio Trejo. Also, in the Clausura 2004 season, Atlético Mexiquense finished 2nd place in the standings and played for the first time in the Primera A Championship in their history against San Luis F.C., (who won and eventually ascended to the Primera División).",
"The team does not have a special nickname, although some call them the \"Diablitos\" (Little Devils), \"pingos\", and \"demonios\" (Demons).",
"Atlético Mexiquense for the 2009–2010 season did not complete in the new Liga de Ascenso since according to the FEMEXFUT did not meet the requirements to continue taking their place, and was relegated to the Second Division, also as part of this division also cuts out Socio Águila, Monterrey, Chihuahua Indians, Santos Laguna, Tigres \"B\" Jaguares de Tapachula, Tampico Madero, Academic Atlas, Tecos UAG and Mérida \"B\" (newly promoted).",
"### Restructuring",
"In the restructuring that occurred in Deportivo Toluca, Atlético Mexiquense became the subsidiary team of Toluca and the official U17 and U20 teams are named Atlético Mexiquense U17 and U20\\.",
"For the start of the Apertura 2015 season, The Segunda División de México was expanded to include 1 affiliate club for every team currently in the Liga MX. Each team will be named after the first division affiliate followed by \"Premier\". Toluca Premier will consist mainly of players moving up from the U20 team or young players who have been promoted but are finding minutes in the top flight hard to come by.",
""
] |
### Atlético Mexiquense
Atlético Mexiquense was founded during the "Invierno 97" season, when the team Deportivo Toluca F.C. decided to purchase the team "Toltécas" from "Atlético Hidalgo", (which were created in the "Invierno 96" season as part of the expansion of the Primera División A). The team was bought and were brought to play in Toluca under the name of Atlético Mexiquense. By this, they became affiliated to Deportivo Toluca F.C., who plays in Primera División de Mexico.
The objective of Atlético Mexiquense is to form players that can incorporate themselves from short or medium time to Deportivo Toluca F.C., and to make sure they understand how the Mexican League works.
Atlético Mexiquense, in their short history, has had moments of glory, such as in their first season, (Invierno 97\), where they finished as number 1 in the standings, with a total of 47 points. They were led by manager Marco Antonio Trejo. Also, in the Clausura 2004 season, Atlético Mexiquense finished 2nd place in the standings and played for the first time in the Primera A Championship in their history against San Luis F.C., (who won and eventually ascended to the Primera División).
The team does not have a special nickname, although some call them the "Diablitos" (Little Devils), "pingos", and "demonios" (Demons).
Atlético Mexiquense for the 2009–2010 season did not complete in the new Liga de Ascenso since according to the FEMEXFUT did not meet the requirements to continue taking their place, and was relegated to the Second Division, also as part of this division also cuts out Socio Águila, Monterrey, Chihuahua Indians, Santos Laguna, Tigres "B" Jaguares de Tapachula, Tampico Madero, Academic Atlas, Tecos UAG and Mérida "B" (newly promoted).
|
[
"### Atlético Mexiquense",
"Atlético Mexiquense was founded during the \"Invierno 97\" season, when the team Deportivo Toluca F.C. decided to purchase the team \"Toltécas\" from \"Atlético Hidalgo\", (which were created in the \"Invierno 96\" season as part of the expansion of the Primera División A). The team was bought and were brought to play in Toluca under the name of Atlético Mexiquense. By this, they became affiliated to Deportivo Toluca F.C., who plays in Primera División de Mexico.",
"The objective of Atlético Mexiquense is to form players that can incorporate themselves from short or medium time to Deportivo Toluca F.C., and to make sure they understand how the Mexican League works.",
"Atlético Mexiquense, in their short history, has had moments of glory, such as in their first season, (Invierno 97\\), where they finished as number 1 in the standings, with a total of 47 points. They were led by manager Marco Antonio Trejo. Also, in the Clausura 2004 season, Atlético Mexiquense finished 2nd place in the standings and played for the first time in the Primera A Championship in their history against San Luis F.C., (who won and eventually ascended to the Primera División).",
"The team does not have a special nickname, although some call them the \"Diablitos\" (Little Devils), \"pingos\", and \"demonios\" (Demons).",
"Atlético Mexiquense for the 2009–2010 season did not complete in the new Liga de Ascenso since according to the FEMEXFUT did not meet the requirements to continue taking their place, and was relegated to the Second Division, also as part of this division also cuts out Socio Águila, Monterrey, Chihuahua Indians, Santos Laguna, Tigres \"B\" Jaguares de Tapachula, Tampico Madero, Academic Atlas, Tecos UAG and Mérida \"B\" (newly promoted).",
""
] |
Biography
---------
One of nine children, the son of a village baker was born on 3 November 1803 at [Württemberg](/wiki/W%C3%BCrttemberg "Württemberg"), Germany—Württemberg, his birthplace was one of the few places notorious for [Pietistic](/wiki/Pietistic "Pietistic") form of [Evangelism](/wiki/Evangelism "Evangelism"), influenced by [Pietistic Lutherans](/wiki/Pietism "Pietism") like [J.A. Bengel](/wiki/Johann_Albrecht_Bengel "Johann Albrecht Bengel") and [F.C. Oetinger](/wiki/Friedrich_Christoph_Oetinger "Friedrich Christoph Oetinger"). Pfander attended a local [Latin school](/wiki/Latin_school "Latin school"), and then grammar school in [Stuttgart](/wiki/Stuttgart "Stuttgart"). At the age of sixteen, he had already decided to become a Protestant Christian [missionary](/wiki/Missionary "Missionary"); accordingly, he got his missionary training in Germany between 1819 and 1821\. In due course, he was accepted for training at the newly established Evangelical Institute at [Basel](/wiki/Basel "Basel") in [Switzerland](/wiki/Switzerland "Switzerland") between 1821 and 1825, and became fluent in [Persian](/wiki/Persian_language "Persian language"), [Turkish](/wiki/Turkish_language "Turkish language"), and [Arabic](/wiki/Arabic_language "Arabic language") languages. Karl Gottlieb Pfander was ordained as a Lutheran priest, with his holy orders being conferred in the state church. During his first appointment with the [Basel Mission](/wiki/Basel_Mission "Basel Mission") (BM) \[*German:* Evangelische Missions Gasellschaft] at [Shusha](/wiki/Shusha "Shusha") in [Karabakh Khanate](/wiki/Karabakh_Khanate "Karabakh Khanate"), Azerbaijan, he quickly learned [Armenian](/wiki/Armenian_language "Armenian language") and [Azerbaijani](/wiki/Azerbaijani_language "Azerbaijani language") languages, and fine\-tuned his [Persian language](/wiki/Persian_language "Persian language") skills; he served for twelve years at BM society between 1825 and 1837, studying the [Arabic language](/wiki/Arabic_language "Arabic language") and [Quran](/wiki/Quran "Quran"). He married Sophia Reuss, first wife; a [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans"), in Moscow on 11 July 1834; however, she died in a childbed in Shusha on 12 May 12, 1835\. In 1837, he joined the [Church Missionary Society](/wiki/Church_Missionary_Society "Church Missionary Society") (CMS) when BM was closed by [Russia](/wiki/Russia "Russia") in Central Asia; consequently, he was sent to [India](/wiki/India "India") for sixteen years between 1837 and 1857\. He married Emily Swinburne, second wife; an English woman, in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta") on 19 January 1841, who bore him three boys and three girls. In 1858, he was sent to [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul") by CMS following an uprising against the [British rule in India](/wiki/British_Raj "British Raj"). Pfander returned to Britain when CMS activity in the city was suspended as [Ottoman](/wiki/Ottoman_Empire "Ottoman Empire") opposed his controversialist approach. He died on 1 December 1865 at [Richmond, London](/wiki/Richmond%2C_London "Richmond, London").
He is buried at [St Andrew's Church](/wiki/St_Andrew%27s_Church%2C_Ham "St Andrew's Church, Ham"), [Ham Common](/wiki/Ham_Common%2C_London "Ham Common, London"). His epitaph reads that he was "a leading champion in the great controversy between Christianity and Islam."
[thumb](/wiki/File:Charles_Gottlieb_Pfander_grave_in_St_Andrews_Church%2C_Ham%2C_Richmond.jpg "Charles Gottlieb Pfander grave in St Andrews Church, Ham, Richmond.jpg")
### South Caucasus (1825–1836\)
In 1825, after Pfander was [ordained](/wiki/Ordained "Ordained"), he was stationed at [Shusha](/wiki/Shusha "Shusha"), provincial\-capital of [Karabakh](/wiki/Karabakh "Karabakh"), [Transcaucasus](/wiki/Transcaucasus "Transcaucasus")—also called [South Caucasus](/wiki/South_Caucasus "South Caucasus") – north of [Russia](/wiki/Russia "Russia"), west of [Turkey](/wiki/Turkey "Turkey"), and south of [Iran](/wiki/Iran "Iran") – All of [Azerbaijan](/wiki/Azerbaijan "Azerbaijan"). Pfander did missionary work in Karabakh and neighbouring lands. Out of several Basel Mission missionaries, some missionaries concentrated on reforming [Armenian Orthodox Church](/wiki/Armenian_Orthodox_Church "Armenian Orthodox Church"), which they believed to be corrupt and bankrupt—one\-third of the local population were [Armenian Christians](/wiki/Armenian_Apostolic_Church "Armenian Apostolic Church")—this newly established province had migration of [Armenian people](/wiki/Armenian_people "Armenian people") before and after 1828 from [Persia](/wiki/Persia "Persia") (*present* [Iran](/wiki/Iran "Iran")).
Pfander, on behalf of Basel Mission concentrated in [evangelizing](/wiki/Evangelism "Evangelism") and communicating [Gospel](/wiki/Gospel "Gospel") to local [Muslims](/wiki/Muslims "Muslims")—about two\-thirds of local population were Muslims. Pfander believed that if Muslims read [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament "New Testament") translated into [Persian language](/wiki/Persian_language "Persian language"), their preferred language, they would automatically abandon [Islam](/wiki/Islam "Islam") and acknowledge its superiority and truth. For this, Pfander made several excursions to [Iran](/wiki/Iran "Iran") and also spent a year at [Baghdad](/wiki/Baghdad "Baghdad"), Iraq, to master Persian language. From 1825 to 1829, he worked in Shusha and neighbouring lands.
In 1835, Russia forbade all missionary operations in Shusha except those of the Greek church; consequently, he was forced to leave Shusha. He returned to Shusha in 1836 after he went to [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul "Istanbul") in 1835, but left to [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta"), India, in 1837\.
### Central Asia (1829–1835\)
{{expand section\|date\=May 2012}}
Between 1829 and 1831, he worked with [Anthony Norris Groves](/wiki/Anthony_Norris_Groves "Anthony Norris Groves"), [Baghdad](/wiki/Baghdad "Baghdad"), and for a year assisted Groves' efforts to establish a mission base and school there. From March 1831, he worked in Persia, and returned to Shusha. While working in [Trans\-Caucasus](/wiki/South_Caucasus "South Caucasus"), he made several visits to Central Asia – [Iran](/wiki/Iran "Iran")—to master Persian language.
### Colonial India: Agra Province (1841–1855\)
{{expand section\|date\=May 2012}}
With [British parliament](/wiki/British_parliament "British parliament") opening up for Protestant [missionary](/wiki/Missionary "Missionary") activities in 1813 in India, several missionaries started operating in India that were under control of the [East India Company](/wiki/East_India_Company "East India Company"). In 1814, the first [Anglican](/wiki/Anglican "Anglican") [bishop](/wiki/Bishop "Bishop") was secretly [consecrated](/wiki/Consecrated "Consecrated") in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta"). From 1832, non\-British missionaries were also allowed to operate in the [Indian subcontinent](/wiki/Indian_subcontinent "Indian subcontinent"). Agra, famous for Islamic learning and culture, had been transformed into an administrative centre for India's [North\-West province](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces "North-Western Provinces") by the [British government](/wiki/British_government "British government"). Both [Agra](/wiki/Agra "Agra") and [Lucknow](/wiki/Lucknow "Lucknow") became home to missionaries who engaged in interfaith dialogue with the local Muslim [ulema](/wiki/Ulema "Ulema") and published [polemical](/wiki/Polemical "Polemical") books against the Islamic creed. Stationed here at the time included former Muslim convert to Christianity [Abdul Masih](/wiki/Abdul_Masih_%28missionary%29 "Abdul Masih (missionary)") and [Joseph Wolff](/wiki/Joseph_Wolff "Joseph Wolff").Powell, A. A.; Muslims and Missionaries in Pre\-mutiny India, 1993; Routledge, Pages 115–116, 128Wolff, J.; Travels and Adventures of the Rev. Joseph Wolff, Cambridge University Press, 2012; Page 411
After a disastrous famine in 1837, a large [orphanage](/wiki/Orphanage "Orphanage") was opened by the authorities in Agra and several orphaned children were taken in and subsequently [baptized](/wiki/Baptized "Baptized") as Christians.
With the financial success of the orphanage, the East India Company launched Orphan Press, employing the orphans at Agra. The success of [Serampore](/wiki/Serampore "Serampore") Baptist Press for the East India Company in lower [Bengal](/wiki/Bengal "Bengal") by [Serampore Trio](/wiki/Serampore_Trio "Serampore Trio") was soon replicated at [Sikandra](/wiki/Sikandara "Sikandara") in the 1840s for printing [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu "Urdu") and [Persian](/wiki/Persia "Persia") tracts in criticism of [Islam](/wiki/Islam "Islam"). This further escalated with the transfer of "Sadr courts" from [Allahabad](/wiki/Allahabad "Allahabad") to [Agra](/wiki/Agra "Agra").
At the heart of this new publishing activity, CMS recruited Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans") [Pietistic Lutheran](/wiki/Pietism "Pietism") missionary with [Swiss](/wiki/Switzerland "Switzerland") missionary training and considerable [linguistic skills](/wiki/Rhetoric "Rhetoric") combined with experience in preaching on the Persian frontier (Central Asia). Pfander had been posted to Agra to [evangelize](/wiki/Evangelize "Evangelize") Muslims and also to assist the already working German missionary colleagues, who like Pfander had been exiled from Central Asia by the [Tsar](/wiki/Tsar "Tsar")'s prohibition on any further Pietist missionary activity.Schirrmacher, Christine: Mit den Waffen des Gegners. Christlich\-muslimische Kontroversen im 19\. und 20\. Jahrhundert, dargestellt am Beispiel der Auseinandersetzung um Karl Gottlieb Pfanders „Mizan al\-haqq“ und Rahmatullah ibn Halil al\-´Utmani al Karanawis „Izhar al\-haqq“ und der Diskussion über das Barnabasevangelium. ([Islamkundliche Untersuchungen](/wiki/Islamkundliche_Untersuchungen "Islamkundliche Untersuchungen"); 162\). Berlin, 1992\.
Pfander started to India in 1837 and arrived at [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta") (*present* [Kolkata](/wiki/Kolkata "Kolkata")) on 1 October 1838, due to closure of his previous mission station in the Russian Caucasus—South Caucasus. On his arrival, he had an impression that Muslims in India were on the verge of turning to Christianity; accordingly, he translated some of the books on Islam and Christianity which he had already written during the previous years into [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu_language "Urdu language"). *Mizan al\-Haqq* was one such book that was used as starting point at Agra, and it was translated into several other languages of the Muslim world as well. With consent from the Basel Mission, he joined CMS on 12 February 1840\.
In January 1841, the CMS posted Pfander to Agra in [Northern India](/wiki/Northern_India "Northern India"). After he took his new job at Agra, he immediately began engaging local Muslims through written letters, sending copies of the Persian and Arabic Bibles. The East India Company also posted administrators who were sympathetic to [evangelicalism](/wiki/Evangelicalism "Evangelicalism"), such as [James Thomason](/wiki/James_Thomason "James Thomason"), the [Lieutenant general](/wiki/Lieutenant_general "Lieutenant general") of [North\-West Provinces](/wiki/North-West_Provinces "North-West Provinces"), and [William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir "William Muir"). These new Company recruits provided ***unofficial*** support for Protestant missionary preaching, publishing, and educational initiatives. Stephen Wheler, a [Colonel](/wiki/Colonel "Colonel") notorious for his provocative role in preaching to [Sepoys](/wiki/Sepoy "Sepoy") at [Barrackpore](/wiki/Barrackpore "Barrackpore"), meanwhile started a second orphanage at [Fatehgarh](/wiki/Fatehgarh "Fatehgarh") (near Agra) in 1838 — with his departure, he handed over Orphanage maintenance to American [Presbyterian](/wiki/Presbyterian "Presbyterian") missionaries. In 1854, under these circumstances, Pfander engaged in a famous public debate with leading Islamic scholars in Agra.
#### Pfander vs. Rahmatullah debate
While in India, he engaged with Muslim religious leaders in a famous public debate at Agra on 10 and 11 April 1854 at the invitation of Islamic scholar [Rahmatullah Kairanawi](/wiki/Rahmatullah_Kairanawi "Rahmatullah Kairanawi"). Several hundred Muslims and Christians gathered in the school room of Agra's Church Missionary Society to listen to a series of public debates between Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans") CMS Protestant missionary, and Kairanawi, a [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni "Sunni") [theologian](/wiki/Theologian "Theologian"). Pfander supporters included [British East Indian Company](/wiki/East_India_Company "East India Company") servants, who represented India's colonial power and its protection of European missionaries; Pfander's co\-workers including [Thomas Valpy French](/wiki/Thomas_Valpy_French "Thomas Valpy French"), who later became the first bishop of Lahore; local Christian converts from Islam, and representatives of the [Anglican Church](/wiki/Anglican_Church "Anglican Church"). Local [Shi'ites](/wiki/Shia_Islam "Shia Islam") and [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni_Islam "Sunni Islam") audiences; [Muhammad Wazîr Khân](/wiki/Muhammad_Waz%C3%AEr_Kh%C3%A2n "Muhammad Wazîr Khân"), a physician in British\-run medical hospital; and prolific Islamic writer and scholar [Imad ud\-din Lahiz](/wiki/Imad_ud-din_Lahiz "Imad ud-din Lahiz") were in the crowd on Kairanawi's side. Local [Catholic missionaries](/wiki/Catholic_missions "Catholic missions") were present as well.
Although the debate had been slated to address the topics of the [Quran](/wiki/Quran "Quran") as the word of God, the [Trinity](/wiki/Trinity "Trinity") and the sending of [Muhammad](/wiki/Muhammad "Muhammad"), the debate centered around a single point, the authenticity of Christian scriptures. Pfander, well versed in the traditional argument, defended the integrity of the [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament "New Testament") and [Old Testament](/wiki/Old_Testament "Old Testament"), while Kairanawi insisted that the [Christian scriptures](/wiki/Christian_scriptures "Christian scriptures") had been abrogated using the apocryphal 16th century [Gospel of Barnabas](/wiki/Gospel_of_Barnabas "Gospel of Barnabas") as his main source, which he thought was the only authentic Gospel. Pfander was surprised by Kairanwi's use of European biblical critics.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\-02/1996\-02\-076\-bennett.pdf\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190712095542/http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\-02/1996\-02\-076\-bennett.pdf\|url\-status\=usurped\|archive\-date\=July 12, 2019\|title\=The Legacy of Karl Gottlieb Pfander\|last\=Bennet\|first\=C.\|date\=1996\|website\=}}
[William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir "William Muir"), Secretary to the Government of the [North West Provinces](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces "North-Western Provinces"), described these debates between Pfander and Kairanawi in an article published by the "Calcutta Review," along with recent history of Christian mission to Muslims. Having observed the debate by himself, he later labeled these articles as *The Mohammedan Controversy* in 1897\.{{citation needed\|date\=February 2016}}
### Colonial India: Peshawar (1855–1857\)
{{expand section\|date\=May 2012}}
In 1837 the CMS relocated Pfander to [Peshawar](/wiki/Peshawar "Peshawar"), in the [north\-west frontier of India](/wiki/North-West_Frontier_Province "North-West Frontier Province"), where he continued his distribution of literature and his apologetics discussions. At the outbreak of the [Indian Rebellion of 1857](/wiki/Indian_Rebellion_of_1857 "Indian Rebellion of 1857"), he "went on preaching in the streets right through the most anxious time, when plots to murder all the Europeans were revealed by intercepted letters."Stock, Eugene, *The History of the Church Missionary Society* (London, Church Missionary Society, 1899\), p. 220 That same year he received the degree of Doctor of Divinity from Cambridge University in recognition of his scholarship.
### Istanbul (1858–1865\)
He was sent as CMS missionary to Istanbulin 1859\. When he arrived at Istanbul, many [Turks](/wiki/Turkish_people "Turkish people") showed interest in the doctrines of Christianity for the first few years.{{cite web\|url\= http://www.centurymysteries.com/mission/mission77\.html\|title\= The Armenians. 1864–1866\.\|quote\= But when copies of Dr. Pfander's book were brought to Constantinople, which defended Christianity against Mohammedanism, and assailed the latter, it was detained at the custom\-house; yet copies got abroad in some way, without foreign agency, and were sought by Mohammedans who were interested in the great question it discussed.\|publisher\= centurymysteries.com\|access\-date\= May 22, 2012\|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20160304091046/http://www.centurymysteries.com/mission/mission77\.html\|archive\-date\= March 4, 2016\|url\-status\= dead}} When in Istanbul, then\-Ottoman capital, while he was on Middle Eastern mission, he commented:
{{cquote\|If Istanbul were to be in the hands of a Christian government and a Christian people, it would with its unquestionably propitious surroundings be one of the most beautiful and fascinating places in the world.
}}
The Turks soon retaliated violently against Christian missions, confiscating printing presses used by the missionaries, closed rooms and bookstores of the missionaries, including imprisonment of the missionaries, spurring{{Citation needed\|date\=July 2013}} the [British government](/wiki/British_government "British government") to interfere to free the missionaries. The mission never recovered, and forbade Istanbul for good.
{{cite web \|url\= http://justus.anglican.org/resources/bcp/Muss\-Arnolt/part3b.htm \|title\= Arabo\-Turkish and Armeno\-Turkish Versions \|quote\= In 1859 the C.M.S. sent to Constantinople the ablest of their Mohammedan missionaries, Dr. Karl Gottlieb Pfander and Koelle. Pfander (1803–1865\) \|publisher\= justus.anglican.org \|access\-date\=May 14, 2012}}{{cite book \|last\= Cox \|first\= Jeffrey \|title\= Imperial Fault Lines: Christianity and Colonial Power in India, 1818–1940 \|publisher\= Stanford University Press \|url\= https://books.google.com/books?id\=z9c3AcIDCKkC\&pg\=PA59 \|year\=2002 \|pages\=59–60 \|isbn\=978\-0\-8047\-4318\-1}}
|
[
"Biography\n---------",
"One of nine children, the son of a village baker was born on 3 November 1803 at [Württemberg](/wiki/W%C3%BCrttemberg \"Württemberg\"), Germany—Württemberg, his birthplace was one of the few places notorious for [Pietistic](/wiki/Pietistic \"Pietistic\") form of [Evangelism](/wiki/Evangelism \"Evangelism\"), influenced by [Pietistic Lutherans](/wiki/Pietism \"Pietism\") like [J.A. Bengel](/wiki/Johann_Albrecht_Bengel \"Johann Albrecht Bengel\") and [F.C. Oetinger](/wiki/Friedrich_Christoph_Oetinger \"Friedrich Christoph Oetinger\"). Pfander attended a local [Latin school](/wiki/Latin_school \"Latin school\"), and then grammar school in [Stuttgart](/wiki/Stuttgart \"Stuttgart\"). At the age of sixteen, he had already decided to become a Protestant Christian [missionary](/wiki/Missionary \"Missionary\"); accordingly, he got his missionary training in Germany between 1819 and 1821\\. In due course, he was accepted for training at the newly established Evangelical Institute at [Basel](/wiki/Basel \"Basel\") in [Switzerland](/wiki/Switzerland \"Switzerland\") between 1821 and 1825, and became fluent in [Persian](/wiki/Persian_language \"Persian language\"), [Turkish](/wiki/Turkish_language \"Turkish language\"), and [Arabic](/wiki/Arabic_language \"Arabic language\") languages. Karl Gottlieb Pfander was ordained as a Lutheran priest, with his holy orders being conferred in the state church. During his first appointment with the [Basel Mission](/wiki/Basel_Mission \"Basel Mission\") (BM) \\[*German:* Evangelische Missions Gasellschaft] at [Shusha](/wiki/Shusha \"Shusha\") in [Karabakh Khanate](/wiki/Karabakh_Khanate \"Karabakh Khanate\"), Azerbaijan, he quickly learned [Armenian](/wiki/Armenian_language \"Armenian language\") and [Azerbaijani](/wiki/Azerbaijani_language \"Azerbaijani language\") languages, and fine\\-tuned his [Persian language](/wiki/Persian_language \"Persian language\") skills; he served for twelve years at BM society between 1825 and 1837, studying the [Arabic language](/wiki/Arabic_language \"Arabic language\") and [Quran](/wiki/Quran \"Quran\"). He married Sophia Reuss, first wife; a [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\"), in Moscow on 11 July 1834; however, she died in a childbed in Shusha on 12 May 12, 1835\\. In 1837, he joined the [Church Missionary Society](/wiki/Church_Missionary_Society \"Church Missionary Society\") (CMS) when BM was closed by [Russia](/wiki/Russia \"Russia\") in Central Asia; consequently, he was sent to [India](/wiki/India \"India\") for sixteen years between 1837 and 1857\\. He married Emily Swinburne, second wife; an English woman, in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\") on 19 January 1841, who bore him three boys and three girls. In 1858, he was sent to [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\") by CMS following an uprising against the [British rule in India](/wiki/British_Raj \"British Raj\"). Pfander returned to Britain when CMS activity in the city was suspended as [Ottoman](/wiki/Ottoman_Empire \"Ottoman Empire\") opposed his controversialist approach. He died on 1 December 1865 at [Richmond, London](/wiki/Richmond%2C_London \"Richmond, London\").",
"He is buried at [St Andrew's Church](/wiki/St_Andrew%27s_Church%2C_Ham \"St Andrew's Church, Ham\"), [Ham Common](/wiki/Ham_Common%2C_London \"Ham Common, London\"). His epitaph reads that he was \"a leading champion in the great controversy between Christianity and Islam.\"\n[thumb](/wiki/File:Charles_Gottlieb_Pfander_grave_in_St_Andrews_Church%2C_Ham%2C_Richmond.jpg \"Charles Gottlieb Pfander grave in St Andrews Church, Ham, Richmond.jpg\")",
"### South Caucasus (1825–1836\\)",
"In 1825, after Pfander was [ordained](/wiki/Ordained \"Ordained\"), he was stationed at [Shusha](/wiki/Shusha \"Shusha\"), provincial\\-capital of [Karabakh](/wiki/Karabakh \"Karabakh\"), [Transcaucasus](/wiki/Transcaucasus \"Transcaucasus\")—also called [South Caucasus](/wiki/South_Caucasus \"South Caucasus\") – north of [Russia](/wiki/Russia \"Russia\"), west of [Turkey](/wiki/Turkey \"Turkey\"), and south of [Iran](/wiki/Iran \"Iran\") – All of [Azerbaijan](/wiki/Azerbaijan \"Azerbaijan\"). Pfander did missionary work in Karabakh and neighbouring lands. Out of several Basel Mission missionaries, some missionaries concentrated on reforming [Armenian Orthodox Church](/wiki/Armenian_Orthodox_Church \"Armenian Orthodox Church\"), which they believed to be corrupt and bankrupt—one\\-third of the local population were [Armenian Christians](/wiki/Armenian_Apostolic_Church \"Armenian Apostolic Church\")—this newly established province had migration of [Armenian people](/wiki/Armenian_people \"Armenian people\") before and after 1828 from [Persia](/wiki/Persia \"Persia\") (*present* [Iran](/wiki/Iran \"Iran\")).",
"Pfander, on behalf of Basel Mission concentrated in [evangelizing](/wiki/Evangelism \"Evangelism\") and communicating [Gospel](/wiki/Gospel \"Gospel\") to local [Muslims](/wiki/Muslims \"Muslims\")—about two\\-thirds of local population were Muslims. Pfander believed that if Muslims read [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament \"New Testament\") translated into [Persian language](/wiki/Persian_language \"Persian language\"), their preferred language, they would automatically abandon [Islam](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\") and acknowledge its superiority and truth. For this, Pfander made several excursions to [Iran](/wiki/Iran \"Iran\") and also spent a year at [Baghdad](/wiki/Baghdad \"Baghdad\"), Iraq, to master Persian language. From 1825 to 1829, he worked in Shusha and neighbouring lands.",
"In 1835, Russia forbade all missionary operations in Shusha except those of the Greek church; consequently, he was forced to leave Shusha. He returned to Shusha in 1836 after he went to [Istanbul](/wiki/Istanbul \"Istanbul\") in 1835, but left to [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\"), India, in 1837\\.",
"### Central Asia (1829–1835\\)",
"{{expand section\\|date\\=May 2012}}\nBetween 1829 and 1831, he worked with [Anthony Norris Groves](/wiki/Anthony_Norris_Groves \"Anthony Norris Groves\"), [Baghdad](/wiki/Baghdad \"Baghdad\"), and for a year assisted Groves' efforts to establish a mission base and school there. From March 1831, he worked in Persia, and returned to Shusha. While working in [Trans\\-Caucasus](/wiki/South_Caucasus \"South Caucasus\"), he made several visits to Central Asia – [Iran](/wiki/Iran \"Iran\")—to master Persian language.",
"### Colonial India: Agra Province (1841–1855\\)",
"{{expand section\\|date\\=May 2012}}\nWith [British parliament](/wiki/British_parliament \"British parliament\") opening up for Protestant [missionary](/wiki/Missionary \"Missionary\") activities in 1813 in India, several missionaries started operating in India that were under control of the [East India Company](/wiki/East_India_Company \"East India Company\"). In 1814, the first [Anglican](/wiki/Anglican \"Anglican\") [bishop](/wiki/Bishop \"Bishop\") was secretly [consecrated](/wiki/Consecrated \"Consecrated\") in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\"). From 1832, non\\-British missionaries were also allowed to operate in the [Indian subcontinent](/wiki/Indian_subcontinent \"Indian subcontinent\"). Agra, famous for Islamic learning and culture, had been transformed into an administrative centre for India's [North\\-West province](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces \"North-Western Provinces\") by the [British government](/wiki/British_government \"British government\"). Both [Agra](/wiki/Agra \"Agra\") and [Lucknow](/wiki/Lucknow \"Lucknow\") became home to missionaries who engaged in interfaith dialogue with the local Muslim [ulema](/wiki/Ulema \"Ulema\") and published [polemical](/wiki/Polemical \"Polemical\") books against the Islamic creed. Stationed here at the time included former Muslim convert to Christianity [Abdul Masih](/wiki/Abdul_Masih_%28missionary%29 \"Abdul Masih (missionary)\") and [Joseph Wolff](/wiki/Joseph_Wolff \"Joseph Wolff\").Powell, A. A.; Muslims and Missionaries in Pre\\-mutiny India, 1993; Routledge, Pages 115–116, 128Wolff, J.; Travels and Adventures of the Rev. Joseph Wolff, Cambridge University Press, 2012; Page 411",
"After a disastrous famine in 1837, a large [orphanage](/wiki/Orphanage \"Orphanage\") was opened by the authorities in Agra and several orphaned children were taken in and subsequently [baptized](/wiki/Baptized \"Baptized\") as Christians.\nWith the financial success of the orphanage, the East India Company launched Orphan Press, employing the orphans at Agra. The success of [Serampore](/wiki/Serampore \"Serampore\") Baptist Press for the East India Company in lower [Bengal](/wiki/Bengal \"Bengal\") by [Serampore Trio](/wiki/Serampore_Trio \"Serampore Trio\") was soon replicated at [Sikandra](/wiki/Sikandara \"Sikandara\") in the 1840s for printing [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu \"Urdu\") and [Persian](/wiki/Persia \"Persia\") tracts in criticism of [Islam](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\"). This further escalated with the transfer of \"Sadr courts\" from [Allahabad](/wiki/Allahabad \"Allahabad\") to [Agra](/wiki/Agra \"Agra\").",
"At the heart of this new publishing activity, CMS recruited Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\") [Pietistic Lutheran](/wiki/Pietism \"Pietism\") missionary with [Swiss](/wiki/Switzerland \"Switzerland\") missionary training and considerable [linguistic skills](/wiki/Rhetoric \"Rhetoric\") combined with experience in preaching on the Persian frontier (Central Asia). Pfander had been posted to Agra to [evangelize](/wiki/Evangelize \"Evangelize\") Muslims and also to assist the already working German missionary colleagues, who like Pfander had been exiled from Central Asia by the [Tsar](/wiki/Tsar \"Tsar\")'s prohibition on any further Pietist missionary activity.Schirrmacher, Christine: Mit den Waffen des Gegners. Christlich\\-muslimische Kontroversen im 19\\. und 20\\. Jahrhundert, dargestellt am Beispiel der Auseinandersetzung um Karl Gottlieb Pfanders „Mizan al\\-haqq“ und Rahmatullah ibn Halil al\\-´Utmani al Karanawis „Izhar al\\-haqq“ und der Diskussion über das Barnabasevangelium. ([Islamkundliche Untersuchungen](/wiki/Islamkundliche_Untersuchungen \"Islamkundliche Untersuchungen\"); 162\\). Berlin, 1992\\.",
"Pfander started to India in 1837 and arrived at [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\") (*present* [Kolkata](/wiki/Kolkata \"Kolkata\")) on 1 October 1838, due to closure of his previous mission station in the Russian Caucasus—South Caucasus. On his arrival, he had an impression that Muslims in India were on the verge of turning to Christianity; accordingly, he translated some of the books on Islam and Christianity which he had already written during the previous years into [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu_language \"Urdu language\"). *Mizan al\\-Haqq* was one such book that was used as starting point at Agra, and it was translated into several other languages of the Muslim world as well. With consent from the Basel Mission, he joined CMS on 12 February 1840\\.",
"In January 1841, the CMS posted Pfander to Agra in [Northern India](/wiki/Northern_India \"Northern India\"). After he took his new job at Agra, he immediately began engaging local Muslims through written letters, sending copies of the Persian and Arabic Bibles. The East India Company also posted administrators who were sympathetic to [evangelicalism](/wiki/Evangelicalism \"Evangelicalism\"), such as [James Thomason](/wiki/James_Thomason \"James Thomason\"), the [Lieutenant general](/wiki/Lieutenant_general \"Lieutenant general\") of [North\\-West Provinces](/wiki/North-West_Provinces \"North-West Provinces\"), and [William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir \"William Muir\"). These new Company recruits provided ***unofficial*** support for Protestant missionary preaching, publishing, and educational initiatives. Stephen Wheler, a [Colonel](/wiki/Colonel \"Colonel\") notorious for his provocative role in preaching to [Sepoys](/wiki/Sepoy \"Sepoy\") at [Barrackpore](/wiki/Barrackpore \"Barrackpore\"), meanwhile started a second orphanage at [Fatehgarh](/wiki/Fatehgarh \"Fatehgarh\") (near Agra) in 1838 — with his departure, he handed over Orphanage maintenance to American [Presbyterian](/wiki/Presbyterian \"Presbyterian\") missionaries. In 1854, under these circumstances, Pfander engaged in a famous public debate with leading Islamic scholars in Agra.",
"#### Pfander vs. Rahmatullah debate",
"While in India, he engaged with Muslim religious leaders in a famous public debate at Agra on 10 and 11 April 1854 at the invitation of Islamic scholar [Rahmatullah Kairanawi](/wiki/Rahmatullah_Kairanawi \"Rahmatullah Kairanawi\"). Several hundred Muslims and Christians gathered in the school room of Agra's Church Missionary Society to listen to a series of public debates between Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\") CMS Protestant missionary, and Kairanawi, a [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni \"Sunni\") [theologian](/wiki/Theologian \"Theologian\"). Pfander supporters included [British East Indian Company](/wiki/East_India_Company \"East India Company\") servants, who represented India's colonial power and its protection of European missionaries; Pfander's co\\-workers including [Thomas Valpy French](/wiki/Thomas_Valpy_French \"Thomas Valpy French\"), who later became the first bishop of Lahore; local Christian converts from Islam, and representatives of the [Anglican Church](/wiki/Anglican_Church \"Anglican Church\"). Local [Shi'ites](/wiki/Shia_Islam \"Shia Islam\") and [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni_Islam \"Sunni Islam\") audiences; [Muhammad Wazîr Khân](/wiki/Muhammad_Waz%C3%AEr_Kh%C3%A2n \"Muhammad Wazîr Khân\"), a physician in British\\-run medical hospital; and prolific Islamic writer and scholar [Imad ud\\-din Lahiz](/wiki/Imad_ud-din_Lahiz \"Imad ud-din Lahiz\") were in the crowd on Kairanawi's side. Local [Catholic missionaries](/wiki/Catholic_missions \"Catholic missions\") were present as well.",
"Although the debate had been slated to address the topics of the [Quran](/wiki/Quran \"Quran\") as the word of God, the [Trinity](/wiki/Trinity \"Trinity\") and the sending of [Muhammad](/wiki/Muhammad \"Muhammad\"), the debate centered around a single point, the authenticity of Christian scriptures. Pfander, well versed in the traditional argument, defended the integrity of the [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament \"New Testament\") and [Old Testament](/wiki/Old_Testament \"Old Testament\"), while Kairanawi insisted that the [Christian scriptures](/wiki/Christian_scriptures \"Christian scriptures\") had been abrogated using the apocryphal 16th century [Gospel of Barnabas](/wiki/Gospel_of_Barnabas \"Gospel of Barnabas\") as his main source, which he thought was the only authentic Gospel. Pfander was surprised by Kairanwi's use of European biblical critics.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\\-02/1996\\-02\\-076\\-bennett.pdf\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190712095542/http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\\-02/1996\\-02\\-076\\-bennett.pdf\\|url\\-status\\=usurped\\|archive\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|title\\=The Legacy of Karl Gottlieb Pfander\\|last\\=Bennet\\|first\\=C.\\|date\\=1996\\|website\\=}}",
"[William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir \"William Muir\"), Secretary to the Government of the [North West Provinces](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces \"North-Western Provinces\"), described these debates between Pfander and Kairanawi in an article published by the \"Calcutta Review,\" along with recent history of Christian mission to Muslims. Having observed the debate by himself, he later labeled these articles as *The Mohammedan Controversy* in 1897\\.{{citation needed\\|date\\=February 2016}}",
"### Colonial India: Peshawar (1855–1857\\)",
"{{expand section\\|date\\=May 2012}}\nIn 1837 the CMS relocated Pfander to [Peshawar](/wiki/Peshawar \"Peshawar\"), in the [north\\-west frontier of India](/wiki/North-West_Frontier_Province \"North-West Frontier Province\"), where he continued his distribution of literature and his apologetics discussions. At the outbreak of the [Indian Rebellion of 1857](/wiki/Indian_Rebellion_of_1857 \"Indian Rebellion of 1857\"), he \"went on preaching in the streets right through the most anxious time, when plots to murder all the Europeans were revealed by intercepted letters.\"Stock, Eugene, *The History of the Church Missionary Society* (London, Church Missionary Society, 1899\\), p. 220 That same year he received the degree of Doctor of Divinity from Cambridge University in recognition of his scholarship.",
"### Istanbul (1858–1865\\)",
"He was sent as CMS missionary to Istanbulin 1859\\. When he arrived at Istanbul, many [Turks](/wiki/Turkish_people \"Turkish people\") showed interest in the doctrines of Christianity for the first few years.{{cite web\\|url\\= http://www.centurymysteries.com/mission/mission77\\.html\\|title\\= The Armenians. 1864–1866\\.\\|quote\\= But when copies of Dr. Pfander's book were brought to Constantinople, which defended Christianity against Mohammedanism, and assailed the latter, it was detained at the custom\\-house; yet copies got abroad in some way, without foreign agency, and were sought by Mohammedans who were interested in the great question it discussed.\\|publisher\\= centurymysteries.com\\|access\\-date\\= May 22, 2012\\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20160304091046/http://www.centurymysteries.com/mission/mission77\\.html\\|archive\\-date\\= March 4, 2016\\|url\\-status\\= dead}} When in Istanbul, then\\-Ottoman capital, while he was on Middle Eastern mission, he commented:\n{{cquote\\|If Istanbul were to be in the hands of a Christian government and a Christian people, it would with its unquestionably propitious surroundings be one of the most beautiful and fascinating places in the world.\n}}",
"The Turks soon retaliated violently against Christian missions, confiscating printing presses used by the missionaries, closed rooms and bookstores of the missionaries, including imprisonment of the missionaries, spurring{{Citation needed\\|date\\=July 2013}} the [British government](/wiki/British_government \"British government\") to interfere to free the missionaries. The mission never recovered, and forbade Istanbul for good.\n{{cite web \\|url\\= http://justus.anglican.org/resources/bcp/Muss\\-Arnolt/part3b.htm \\|title\\= Arabo\\-Turkish and Armeno\\-Turkish Versions \\|quote\\= In 1859 the C.M.S. sent to Constantinople the ablest of their Mohammedan missionaries, Dr. Karl Gottlieb Pfander and Koelle. Pfander (1803–1865\\) \\|publisher\\= justus.anglican.org \\|access\\-date\\=May 14, 2012}}{{cite book \\|last\\= Cox \\|first\\= Jeffrey \\|title\\= Imperial Fault Lines: Christianity and Colonial Power in India, 1818–1940 \\|publisher\\= Stanford University Press \\|url\\= https://books.google.com/books?id\\=z9c3AcIDCKkC\\&pg\\=PA59 \\|year\\=2002 \\|pages\\=59–60 \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-8047\\-4318\\-1}}",
""
] |
### Colonial India: Agra Province (1841–1855\)
{{expand section\|date\=May 2012}}
With [British parliament](/wiki/British_parliament "British parliament") opening up for Protestant [missionary](/wiki/Missionary "Missionary") activities in 1813 in India, several missionaries started operating in India that were under control of the [East India Company](/wiki/East_India_Company "East India Company"). In 1814, the first [Anglican](/wiki/Anglican "Anglican") [bishop](/wiki/Bishop "Bishop") was secretly [consecrated](/wiki/Consecrated "Consecrated") in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta"). From 1832, non\-British missionaries were also allowed to operate in the [Indian subcontinent](/wiki/Indian_subcontinent "Indian subcontinent"). Agra, famous for Islamic learning and culture, had been transformed into an administrative centre for India's [North\-West province](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces "North-Western Provinces") by the [British government](/wiki/British_government "British government"). Both [Agra](/wiki/Agra "Agra") and [Lucknow](/wiki/Lucknow "Lucknow") became home to missionaries who engaged in interfaith dialogue with the local Muslim [ulema](/wiki/Ulema "Ulema") and published [polemical](/wiki/Polemical "Polemical") books against the Islamic creed. Stationed here at the time included former Muslim convert to Christianity [Abdul Masih](/wiki/Abdul_Masih_%28missionary%29 "Abdul Masih (missionary)") and [Joseph Wolff](/wiki/Joseph_Wolff "Joseph Wolff").Powell, A. A.; Muslims and Missionaries in Pre\-mutiny India, 1993; Routledge, Pages 115–116, 128Wolff, J.; Travels and Adventures of the Rev. Joseph Wolff, Cambridge University Press, 2012; Page 411
After a disastrous famine in 1837, a large [orphanage](/wiki/Orphanage "Orphanage") was opened by the authorities in Agra and several orphaned children were taken in and subsequently [baptized](/wiki/Baptized "Baptized") as Christians.
With the financial success of the orphanage, the East India Company launched Orphan Press, employing the orphans at Agra. The success of [Serampore](/wiki/Serampore "Serampore") Baptist Press for the East India Company in lower [Bengal](/wiki/Bengal "Bengal") by [Serampore Trio](/wiki/Serampore_Trio "Serampore Trio") was soon replicated at [Sikandra](/wiki/Sikandara "Sikandara") in the 1840s for printing [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu "Urdu") and [Persian](/wiki/Persia "Persia") tracts in criticism of [Islam](/wiki/Islam "Islam"). This further escalated with the transfer of "Sadr courts" from [Allahabad](/wiki/Allahabad "Allahabad") to [Agra](/wiki/Agra "Agra").
At the heart of this new publishing activity, CMS recruited Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans") [Pietistic Lutheran](/wiki/Pietism "Pietism") missionary with [Swiss](/wiki/Switzerland "Switzerland") missionary training and considerable [linguistic skills](/wiki/Rhetoric "Rhetoric") combined with experience in preaching on the Persian frontier (Central Asia). Pfander had been posted to Agra to [evangelize](/wiki/Evangelize "Evangelize") Muslims and also to assist the already working German missionary colleagues, who like Pfander had been exiled from Central Asia by the [Tsar](/wiki/Tsar "Tsar")'s prohibition on any further Pietist missionary activity.Schirrmacher, Christine: Mit den Waffen des Gegners. Christlich\-muslimische Kontroversen im 19\. und 20\. Jahrhundert, dargestellt am Beispiel der Auseinandersetzung um Karl Gottlieb Pfanders „Mizan al\-haqq“ und Rahmatullah ibn Halil al\-´Utmani al Karanawis „Izhar al\-haqq“ und der Diskussion über das Barnabasevangelium. ([Islamkundliche Untersuchungen](/wiki/Islamkundliche_Untersuchungen "Islamkundliche Untersuchungen"); 162\). Berlin, 1992\.
Pfander started to India in 1837 and arrived at [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta "Calcutta") (*present* [Kolkata](/wiki/Kolkata "Kolkata")) on 1 October 1838, due to closure of his previous mission station in the Russian Caucasus—South Caucasus. On his arrival, he had an impression that Muslims in India were on the verge of turning to Christianity; accordingly, he translated some of the books on Islam and Christianity which he had already written during the previous years into [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu_language "Urdu language"). *Mizan al\-Haqq* was one such book that was used as starting point at Agra, and it was translated into several other languages of the Muslim world as well. With consent from the Basel Mission, he joined CMS on 12 February 1840\.
In January 1841, the CMS posted Pfander to Agra in [Northern India](/wiki/Northern_India "Northern India"). After he took his new job at Agra, he immediately began engaging local Muslims through written letters, sending copies of the Persian and Arabic Bibles. The East India Company also posted administrators who were sympathetic to [evangelicalism](/wiki/Evangelicalism "Evangelicalism"), such as [James Thomason](/wiki/James_Thomason "James Thomason"), the [Lieutenant general](/wiki/Lieutenant_general "Lieutenant general") of [North\-West Provinces](/wiki/North-West_Provinces "North-West Provinces"), and [William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir "William Muir"). These new Company recruits provided ***unofficial*** support for Protestant missionary preaching, publishing, and educational initiatives. Stephen Wheler, a [Colonel](/wiki/Colonel "Colonel") notorious for his provocative role in preaching to [Sepoys](/wiki/Sepoy "Sepoy") at [Barrackpore](/wiki/Barrackpore "Barrackpore"), meanwhile started a second orphanage at [Fatehgarh](/wiki/Fatehgarh "Fatehgarh") (near Agra) in 1838 — with his departure, he handed over Orphanage maintenance to American [Presbyterian](/wiki/Presbyterian "Presbyterian") missionaries. In 1854, under these circumstances, Pfander engaged in a famous public debate with leading Islamic scholars in Agra.
#### Pfander vs. Rahmatullah debate
While in India, he engaged with Muslim religious leaders in a famous public debate at Agra on 10 and 11 April 1854 at the invitation of Islamic scholar [Rahmatullah Kairanawi](/wiki/Rahmatullah_Kairanawi "Rahmatullah Kairanawi"). Several hundred Muslims and Christians gathered in the school room of Agra's Church Missionary Society to listen to a series of public debates between Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans "Germans") CMS Protestant missionary, and Kairanawi, a [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni "Sunni") [theologian](/wiki/Theologian "Theologian"). Pfander supporters included [British East Indian Company](/wiki/East_India_Company "East India Company") servants, who represented India's colonial power and its protection of European missionaries; Pfander's co\-workers including [Thomas Valpy French](/wiki/Thomas_Valpy_French "Thomas Valpy French"), who later became the first bishop of Lahore; local Christian converts from Islam, and representatives of the [Anglican Church](/wiki/Anglican_Church "Anglican Church"). Local [Shi'ites](/wiki/Shia_Islam "Shia Islam") and [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni_Islam "Sunni Islam") audiences; [Muhammad Wazîr Khân](/wiki/Muhammad_Waz%C3%AEr_Kh%C3%A2n "Muhammad Wazîr Khân"), a physician in British\-run medical hospital; and prolific Islamic writer and scholar [Imad ud\-din Lahiz](/wiki/Imad_ud-din_Lahiz "Imad ud-din Lahiz") were in the crowd on Kairanawi's side. Local [Catholic missionaries](/wiki/Catholic_missions "Catholic missions") were present as well.
Although the debate had been slated to address the topics of the [Quran](/wiki/Quran "Quran") as the word of God, the [Trinity](/wiki/Trinity "Trinity") and the sending of [Muhammad](/wiki/Muhammad "Muhammad"), the debate centered around a single point, the authenticity of Christian scriptures. Pfander, well versed in the traditional argument, defended the integrity of the [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament "New Testament") and [Old Testament](/wiki/Old_Testament "Old Testament"), while Kairanawi insisted that the [Christian scriptures](/wiki/Christian_scriptures "Christian scriptures") had been abrogated using the apocryphal 16th century [Gospel of Barnabas](/wiki/Gospel_of_Barnabas "Gospel of Barnabas") as his main source, which he thought was the only authentic Gospel. Pfander was surprised by Kairanwi's use of European biblical critics.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\-02/1996\-02\-076\-bennett.pdf\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190712095542/http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\-02/1996\-02\-076\-bennett.pdf\|url\-status\=usurped\|archive\-date\=July 12, 2019\|title\=The Legacy of Karl Gottlieb Pfander\|last\=Bennet\|first\=C.\|date\=1996\|website\=}}
[William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir "William Muir"), Secretary to the Government of the [North West Provinces](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces "North-Western Provinces"), described these debates between Pfander and Kairanawi in an article published by the "Calcutta Review," along with recent history of Christian mission to Muslims. Having observed the debate by himself, he later labeled these articles as *The Mohammedan Controversy* in 1897\.{{citation needed\|date\=February 2016}}
|
[
"### Colonial India: Agra Province (1841–1855\\)",
"{{expand section\\|date\\=May 2012}}\nWith [British parliament](/wiki/British_parliament \"British parliament\") opening up for Protestant [missionary](/wiki/Missionary \"Missionary\") activities in 1813 in India, several missionaries started operating in India that were under control of the [East India Company](/wiki/East_India_Company \"East India Company\"). In 1814, the first [Anglican](/wiki/Anglican \"Anglican\") [bishop](/wiki/Bishop \"Bishop\") was secretly [consecrated](/wiki/Consecrated \"Consecrated\") in [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\"). From 1832, non\\-British missionaries were also allowed to operate in the [Indian subcontinent](/wiki/Indian_subcontinent \"Indian subcontinent\"). Agra, famous for Islamic learning and culture, had been transformed into an administrative centre for India's [North\\-West province](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces \"North-Western Provinces\") by the [British government](/wiki/British_government \"British government\"). Both [Agra](/wiki/Agra \"Agra\") and [Lucknow](/wiki/Lucknow \"Lucknow\") became home to missionaries who engaged in interfaith dialogue with the local Muslim [ulema](/wiki/Ulema \"Ulema\") and published [polemical](/wiki/Polemical \"Polemical\") books against the Islamic creed. Stationed here at the time included former Muslim convert to Christianity [Abdul Masih](/wiki/Abdul_Masih_%28missionary%29 \"Abdul Masih (missionary)\") and [Joseph Wolff](/wiki/Joseph_Wolff \"Joseph Wolff\").Powell, A. A.; Muslims and Missionaries in Pre\\-mutiny India, 1993; Routledge, Pages 115–116, 128Wolff, J.; Travels and Adventures of the Rev. Joseph Wolff, Cambridge University Press, 2012; Page 411",
"After a disastrous famine in 1837, a large [orphanage](/wiki/Orphanage \"Orphanage\") was opened by the authorities in Agra and several orphaned children were taken in and subsequently [baptized](/wiki/Baptized \"Baptized\") as Christians.\nWith the financial success of the orphanage, the East India Company launched Orphan Press, employing the orphans at Agra. The success of [Serampore](/wiki/Serampore \"Serampore\") Baptist Press for the East India Company in lower [Bengal](/wiki/Bengal \"Bengal\") by [Serampore Trio](/wiki/Serampore_Trio \"Serampore Trio\") was soon replicated at [Sikandra](/wiki/Sikandara \"Sikandara\") in the 1840s for printing [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu \"Urdu\") and [Persian](/wiki/Persia \"Persia\") tracts in criticism of [Islam](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\"). This further escalated with the transfer of \"Sadr courts\" from [Allahabad](/wiki/Allahabad \"Allahabad\") to [Agra](/wiki/Agra \"Agra\").",
"At the heart of this new publishing activity, CMS recruited Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\") [Pietistic Lutheran](/wiki/Pietism \"Pietism\") missionary with [Swiss](/wiki/Switzerland \"Switzerland\") missionary training and considerable [linguistic skills](/wiki/Rhetoric \"Rhetoric\") combined with experience in preaching on the Persian frontier (Central Asia). Pfander had been posted to Agra to [evangelize](/wiki/Evangelize \"Evangelize\") Muslims and also to assist the already working German missionary colleagues, who like Pfander had been exiled from Central Asia by the [Tsar](/wiki/Tsar \"Tsar\")'s prohibition on any further Pietist missionary activity.Schirrmacher, Christine: Mit den Waffen des Gegners. Christlich\\-muslimische Kontroversen im 19\\. und 20\\. Jahrhundert, dargestellt am Beispiel der Auseinandersetzung um Karl Gottlieb Pfanders „Mizan al\\-haqq“ und Rahmatullah ibn Halil al\\-´Utmani al Karanawis „Izhar al\\-haqq“ und der Diskussion über das Barnabasevangelium. ([Islamkundliche Untersuchungen](/wiki/Islamkundliche_Untersuchungen \"Islamkundliche Untersuchungen\"); 162\\). Berlin, 1992\\.",
"Pfander started to India in 1837 and arrived at [Calcutta](/wiki/Calcutta \"Calcutta\") (*present* [Kolkata](/wiki/Kolkata \"Kolkata\")) on 1 October 1838, due to closure of his previous mission station in the Russian Caucasus—South Caucasus. On his arrival, he had an impression that Muslims in India were on the verge of turning to Christianity; accordingly, he translated some of the books on Islam and Christianity which he had already written during the previous years into [Urdu](/wiki/Urdu_language \"Urdu language\"). *Mizan al\\-Haqq* was one such book that was used as starting point at Agra, and it was translated into several other languages of the Muslim world as well. With consent from the Basel Mission, he joined CMS on 12 February 1840\\.",
"In January 1841, the CMS posted Pfander to Agra in [Northern India](/wiki/Northern_India \"Northern India\"). After he took his new job at Agra, he immediately began engaging local Muslims through written letters, sending copies of the Persian and Arabic Bibles. The East India Company also posted administrators who were sympathetic to [evangelicalism](/wiki/Evangelicalism \"Evangelicalism\"), such as [James Thomason](/wiki/James_Thomason \"James Thomason\"), the [Lieutenant general](/wiki/Lieutenant_general \"Lieutenant general\") of [North\\-West Provinces](/wiki/North-West_Provinces \"North-West Provinces\"), and [William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir \"William Muir\"). These new Company recruits provided ***unofficial*** support for Protestant missionary preaching, publishing, and educational initiatives. Stephen Wheler, a [Colonel](/wiki/Colonel \"Colonel\") notorious for his provocative role in preaching to [Sepoys](/wiki/Sepoy \"Sepoy\") at [Barrackpore](/wiki/Barrackpore \"Barrackpore\"), meanwhile started a second orphanage at [Fatehgarh](/wiki/Fatehgarh \"Fatehgarh\") (near Agra) in 1838 — with his departure, he handed over Orphanage maintenance to American [Presbyterian](/wiki/Presbyterian \"Presbyterian\") missionaries. In 1854, under these circumstances, Pfander engaged in a famous public debate with leading Islamic scholars in Agra.",
"#### Pfander vs. Rahmatullah debate",
"While in India, he engaged with Muslim religious leaders in a famous public debate at Agra on 10 and 11 April 1854 at the invitation of Islamic scholar [Rahmatullah Kairanawi](/wiki/Rahmatullah_Kairanawi \"Rahmatullah Kairanawi\"). Several hundred Muslims and Christians gathered in the school room of Agra's Church Missionary Society to listen to a series of public debates between Pfander, a [German](/wiki/Germans \"Germans\") CMS Protestant missionary, and Kairanawi, a [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni \"Sunni\") [theologian](/wiki/Theologian \"Theologian\"). Pfander supporters included [British East Indian Company](/wiki/East_India_Company \"East India Company\") servants, who represented India's colonial power and its protection of European missionaries; Pfander's co\\-workers including [Thomas Valpy French](/wiki/Thomas_Valpy_French \"Thomas Valpy French\"), who later became the first bishop of Lahore; local Christian converts from Islam, and representatives of the [Anglican Church](/wiki/Anglican_Church \"Anglican Church\"). Local [Shi'ites](/wiki/Shia_Islam \"Shia Islam\") and [Sunni](/wiki/Sunni_Islam \"Sunni Islam\") audiences; [Muhammad Wazîr Khân](/wiki/Muhammad_Waz%C3%AEr_Kh%C3%A2n \"Muhammad Wazîr Khân\"), a physician in British\\-run medical hospital; and prolific Islamic writer and scholar [Imad ud\\-din Lahiz](/wiki/Imad_ud-din_Lahiz \"Imad ud-din Lahiz\") were in the crowd on Kairanawi's side. Local [Catholic missionaries](/wiki/Catholic_missions \"Catholic missions\") were present as well.",
"Although the debate had been slated to address the topics of the [Quran](/wiki/Quran \"Quran\") as the word of God, the [Trinity](/wiki/Trinity \"Trinity\") and the sending of [Muhammad](/wiki/Muhammad \"Muhammad\"), the debate centered around a single point, the authenticity of Christian scriptures. Pfander, well versed in the traditional argument, defended the integrity of the [New Testament](/wiki/New_Testament \"New Testament\") and [Old Testament](/wiki/Old_Testament \"Old Testament\"), while Kairanawi insisted that the [Christian scriptures](/wiki/Christian_scriptures \"Christian scriptures\") had been abrogated using the apocryphal 16th century [Gospel of Barnabas](/wiki/Gospel_of_Barnabas \"Gospel of Barnabas\") as his main source, which he thought was the only authentic Gospel. Pfander was surprised by Kairanwi's use of European biblical critics.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\\-02/1996\\-02\\-076\\-bennett.pdf\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190712095542/http://www.internationalbulletin.org/issues/1996\\-02/1996\\-02\\-076\\-bennett.pdf\\|url\\-status\\=usurped\\|archive\\-date\\=July 12, 2019\\|title\\=The Legacy of Karl Gottlieb Pfander\\|last\\=Bennet\\|first\\=C.\\|date\\=1996\\|website\\=}}",
"[William Muir](/wiki/William_Muir \"William Muir\"), Secretary to the Government of the [North West Provinces](/wiki/North-Western_Provinces \"North-Western Provinces\"), described these debates between Pfander and Kairanawi in an article published by the \"Calcutta Review,\" along with recent history of Christian mission to Muslims. Having observed the debate by himself, he later labeled these articles as *The Mohammedan Controversy* in 1897\\.{{citation needed\\|date\\=February 2016}}",
""
] |
List of winners
---------------
### 2006–07
* [C. K. Nayudu Award for Lifetime Achievement](/wiki/C._K._Nayudu_Lifetime_Achievement_Award "C. K. Nayudu Lifetime Achievement Award"): [Nari Contractor](/wiki/Nari_Contractor "Nari Contractor") (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar "Sachin Tendulkar") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Uthappa](/wiki/Robin_Uthappa "Robin Uthappa") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ranadeb Bose](/wiki/Ranadeb_Bose "Ranadeb Bose") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association "Mumbai Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-15 cricketer: [Mandeep Singh](/wiki/Mandeep_Singh "Mandeep Singh") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-17 cricketer: [Ajay Rana](/wiki/Ajay_Rana "Ajay Rana") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Ajinkya Rahane](/wiki/Ajinkya_Rahane "Ajinkya Rahane") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Manoj Tiwary](/wiki/Manoj_Tiwary_%28cricketer%29 "Manoj Tiwary (cricketer)") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Jaya Sharma](/wiki/Jaya_Sharma "Jaya Sharma") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
Other awards
* [Jhulan Goswami](/wiki/Jhulan_Goswami "Jhulan Goswami") was awarded a trophy and a cheque for Rs one lakh for becoming the [ICC Women's Cricketer of the Year 2007](/wiki/ICC_Awards%23Men%27s_awards "ICC Awards#Men's awards").
* [Anju Jain](/wiki/Anju_Jain "Anju Jain") and [Anjum Chopra](/wiki/Anjum_Chopra "Anjum Chopra") were given a trophy each for winning the [Arjuna Award](/wiki/Arjuna_Award "Arjuna Award") in women's cricket for 2006 and 2007 respectively.
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Seniors honoured at BCCI awards\|url\=http://www.rediff.com/cricket/report/awards/20071216\.htm\|publisher\=Rediff\|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2007–08
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Gundappa Viswanath](/wiki/Gundappa_Viswanath "Gundappa Viswanath") (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virender Sehwag](/wiki/Virender_Sehwag "Virender Sehwag") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Cheteshwar Pujara](/wiki/Cheteshwar_Pujara "Cheteshwar Pujara") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Sudeep Tyagi](/wiki/Sudeep_Tyagi "Sudeep Tyagi") (trophy and ₹ 100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association "Maharashtra Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-15 cricketer: [Ankit Bawne](/wiki/Ankit_Bawne "Ankit Bawne") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-17 cricketer: [Mandeep Singh](/wiki/Mandeep_Singh "Mandeep Singh") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Bhuvneshwar Kumar](/wiki/Bhuvneshwar_Kumar "Bhuvneshwar Kumar") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Rahul Dewan](/wiki/Rahul_Dewan "Rahul Dewan") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj "Mithali Raj") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
Other awards
* [Mahendra Singh Dhoni](/wiki/Mahendra_Singh_Dhoni "Mahendra Singh Dhoni") was handed a special award for winning the [Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna](/wiki/Rajiv_Gandhi_Khel_Ratna "Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna") and the [Padma Shri](/wiki/Padma_Shri "Padma Shri").
* [Harbhajan Singh](/wiki/Harbhajan_Singh "Harbhajan Singh") was handed a special award for taking 300 Test wickets and winning the Padma Shri.
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Sehwag wins BCCI's top award\|url\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci/content/story/389865\.html\|publisher\=ESPNcricinfo\|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2008–09
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Mohinder Amarnath](/wiki/Mohinder_Amarnath "Mohinder Amarnath") (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Gautam Gambhir](/wiki/Gautam_Gambhir "Gautam Gambhir") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Wasim Jaffer](/wiki/Wasim_Jaffer "Wasim Jaffer") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Dhawal Kulkarni](/wiki/Dhawal_Kulkarni "Dhawal Kulkarni") \& [Ravindra Jadeja](/wiki/Ravindra_Jadeja "Ravindra Jadeja") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association "Mumbai Cricket Association") \& [Punjab](/wiki/Punjab_Cricket_Association "Punjab Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Chirag Khurana](/wiki/Chirag_Khurana "Chirag Khurana") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Harpreet Singh](/wiki/Harpreet_Singh_%28cricketer%2C_born_1991%29 "Harpreet Singh (cricketer, born 1991)") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Neelkanth Das](/wiki/Neelkanth_Das "Neelkanth Das") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Reema Malhotra](/wiki/Reema_Malhotra "Reema Malhotra") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Poonam Raut](/wiki/Poonam_Raut "Poonam Raut") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [Amish Saheba](/wiki/Amish_Saheba "Amish Saheba") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
Other awards
* [Rahul Dravid](/wiki/Rahul_Dravid "Rahul Dravid") was handed a special award for taking the most catches.
* [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar "Sachin Tendulkar") was handed a special award for completing two decades of international cricket.
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Gambhir, Amarnath hog limelight at BCCI awards function\|url\=http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/119934\-gambhir\-amarnath\-hog\-limelight\-at\-bcci\-awards\-function\|publisher\=NDTV\|access\-date\=2 January 2015\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150102052955/http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/119934\-gambhir\-amarnath\-hog\-limelight\-at\-bcci\-awards\-function\|archive\-date\=2 January 2015\|url\-status\=dead}}
### 2009–10
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Salim Durani](/wiki/Salim_Durani "Salim Durani") (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar "Sachin Tendulkar") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Manish Pandey](/wiki/Manish_Pandey "Manish Pandey") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Abhimanyu Mithun](/wiki/Abhimanyu_Mithun "Abhimanyu Mithun") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association "Maharashtra Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Baba Aparajith](/wiki/Baba_Aparajith "Baba Aparajith") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Bhargav Merai](/wiki/Bhargav_Merai "Bhargav Merai") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Natraj Behera](/wiki/Natraj_Behera "Natraj Behera") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini "Thirush Kamini") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Reva Arora](/wiki/Reva_Arora "Reva Arora") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [K. Hariharan](/wiki/Krishna_Hariharan "Krishna Hariharan") (trophy and Rs 50,000\)
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Tendulkar, Durani honoured at BCCI awards\|url\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/story/517352\.html\|publisher\=ESPNcricinfo\|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2010–11
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Ajit Wadekar](/wiki/Ajit_Wadekar "Ajit Wadekar") (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Rahul Dravid](/wiki/Rahul_Dravid "Rahul Dravid") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Subramaniam Badrinath](/wiki/Subramaniam_Badrinath "Subramaniam Badrinath") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Bhargav Bhatt](/wiki/Bhargav_Bhatt_%28cricketer%29 "Bhargav Bhatt (cricketer)") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Railways](/wiki/Railways_Cricket_Association "Railways Cricket Association") \& [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_District_Cricket_Association "Delhi District Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Vijay Zol](/wiki/Vijay_Zol "Vijay Zol") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Avi Barot](/wiki/Avi_Barot "Avi Barot") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Suryakumar Yadav](/wiki/Suryakumar_Yadav "Suryakumar Yadav") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Jhulan Goswami](/wiki/Jhulan_Goswami "Jhulan Goswami") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Mona Meshram](/wiki/Mona_Meshram "Mona Meshram") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [S. Ravi](/wiki/S._Ravi_%28umpire%29 "S. Ravi (umpire)") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Iqbal Abdulla](/wiki/Iqbal_Abdulla "Iqbal Abdulla") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Sumit Narwal](/wiki/Sumit_Narwal "Sumit Narwal") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
Other awards
* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2011 Test series in the West Indies: [Ishant Sharma](/wiki/Ishant_Sharma "Ishant Sharma")
* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2011 Test series against the West Indies: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin "Ravichandran Ashwin")
Ref:{{cite news\|title\=BCCI awards: Dravid to get 'Polly Umrigar' Trophy\|url\=http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/top\-stories/BCCI\-awards\-Dravid\-to\-get\-Polly\-Umrigar\-Trophy/articleshow/10840912\.cms\|newspaper\=Times of India\|date\=23 November 2011 \|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2011–12
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Sunil Gavaskar](/wiki/Sunil_Gavaskar "Sunil Gavaskar") (trophy and ₹ 1\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli "Virat Kohli") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Bist](/wiki/Robin_Bist "Robin Bist") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ashok Dinda](/wiki/Ashok_Dinda "Ashok Dinda") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_District_Cricket_Association "Delhi District Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Mohammad Saif](/wiki/Mohammad_Saif_%28cricketer%2C_born_1996%29 "Mohammad Saif (cricketer, born 1996)") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Vijay Zol](/wiki/Vijay_Zol "Vijay Zol") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-22 cricketer: [Satyam Choudhary](/wiki/Satyam_Choudhary "Satyam Choudhary") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Anagha Deshpande](/wiki/Anagha_Deshpande "Anagha Deshpande") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [S. Ravi](/wiki/S._Ravi_%28umpire%29 "S. Ravi (umpire)") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Stuart Binny](/wiki/Stuart_Binny "Stuart Binny") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Laxmi Ratan Shukla](/wiki/Laxmi_Ratan_Shukla "Laxmi Ratan Shukla") (trophy and ₹100,000\)
Other awards
* [VVS Laxman](/wiki/VVS_Laxman "VVS Laxman") was handed a special award for his achievements in international cricket.
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Kohli takes top BCCI award for 2011–12\|url\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/story/592403\.html\|publisher\=ESPNcricinfo\|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2012–13
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Kapil Dev](/wiki/Kapil_Dev "Kapil Dev") (trophy and ₹ 2\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin "Ravichandran Ashwin") (trophy and ₹ 500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Jiwanjot Singh](/wiki/Jiwanjot_Singh "Jiwanjot Singh") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ishwar Pandey](/wiki/Ishwar_Pandey "Ishwar Pandey") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association "Mumbai Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Arman Jaffer](/wiki/Arman_Jaffer "Arman Jaffer") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Akshar Patel](/wiki/Akshar_Patel "Akshar Patel") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-25 cricketer: [Karn Sharma](/wiki/Karn_Sharma "Karn Sharma") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini "Thirush Kamini") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [Chettithody Shamshuddin](/wiki/Chettithody_Shamshuddin "Chettithody Shamshuddin") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Abhishek Nayar](/wiki/Abhishek_Nayar "Abhishek Nayar") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Laxmi Ratan Shukla](/wiki/Laxmi_Ratan_Shukla "Laxmi Ratan Shukla") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
Other awards
* [Bapu Nadkarni](/wiki/Bapu_Nadkarni "Bapu Nadkarni"), [Farokh Engineer](/wiki/Farokh_Engineer "Farokh Engineer"), late [Eknath Solkar](/wiki/Eknath_Solkar "Eknath Solkar") were handed special awards for outstanding contribution to Indian cricket (trophy and ₹1\.5 million)
* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2013 Test series against the West Indies: [Rohit Sharma](/wiki/Rohit_Sharma "Rohit Sharma") (trophy and ₹500,000{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.sportskeeda.com/cricket/bcci\-awards\-rohit\-sharma\-ashwin\-ishwar\-pandey\|title\=BCCI Awards: Rohit Sharma, R Ashwin and Ishwar Pandey awarded for their contributions}})
Ref:{{cite news\|title\=Polly Umrigar award for Ashwin\|url\=http://www.thehindu.com/sport/cricket/poly\-umrigar\-award\-for\-ashwin/article5503936\.ece\|work\=The Hindu\|date\=26 December 2013\|access\-date\=2 January 2015}}
### 2013–14
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Dilip Vengsarkar](/wiki/Dilip_Vengsarkar "Dilip Vengsarkar") (trophy and ₹2\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Bhuvneshwar Kumar](/wiki/Bhuvneshwar_Kumar "Bhuvneshwar Kumar") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Kedar Jadhav](/wiki/Kedar_Jadhav "Kedar Jadhav") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Rishi Dhawan](/wiki/Rishi_Dhawan "Rishi Dhawan") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association "Maharashtra Cricket Association") \& [Railways](/wiki/Railways_Cricket_Association "Railways Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Shubman Gill](/wiki/Shubman_Gill "Shubman Gill") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Balchander Anirudh](/wiki/Balchander_Anirudh "Balchander Anirudh") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-25 cricketer: [Rahul Tripathi](/wiki/Rahul_Tripathi "Rahul Tripathi") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini "Thirush Kamini") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Best umpire: [Anil Chaudhary](/wiki/Anil_Chaudhary_%28umpire%29 "Anil Chaudhary (umpire)") (trophy and 50,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Parvez Rasool](/wiki/Parvez_Rasool "Parvez Rasool") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Vinay Kumar](/wiki/Vinay_Kumar "Vinay Kumar") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
Other awards
* [Rohit Sharma](/wiki/Rohit_Sharma "Rohit Sharma") was handed a special award for scoring the highest ODI individual score of 264\.
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Dilip Vengsarkar, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Rohit Sharma Receive BCCI Awards\|url\=http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/233427\-dilip\-vengsarkar\-bhuvneshwar\-kumar\-rohit\-sharma\-receive\-bcci\-awards\|publisher\=\[\[NDTV]]\|access\-date\=2 January 2015\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150102052940/http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/233427\-dilip\-vengsarkar\-bhuvneshwar\-kumar\-rohit\-sharma\-receive\-bcci\-awards\|archive\-date\=2 January 2015\|url\-status\=dead}}
### 2014–15
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Syed Kirmani](/wiki/Syed_Kirmani "Syed Kirmani") (trophy and ₹ 2\.5 million)
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli "Virat Kohli") (trophy and ₹500,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Uthappa](/wiki/Robin_Uthappa "Robin Uthappa") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Vinay Kumar](/wiki/Vinay_Kumar "Vinay Kumar") \& [Shardul Thakur](/wiki/Shardul_Thakur "Shardul Thakur") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Karnataka](/wiki/Karnataka_State_Cricket_Association "Karnataka State Cricket Association") (trophy)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-16 cricketer: [Shubman Gill](/wiki/Shubman_Gill "Shubman Gill") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-19 cricketer: [Anmolpreet Singh](/wiki/Anmolpreet_Singh "Anmolpreet Singh") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\-23 cricketer: [Almas Shaukat](/wiki/Almas_Shaukat "Almas Shaukat") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj "Mithali Raj") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Devika Vaidya](/wiki/Devika_Vaidya "Devika Vaidya") (trophy and ₹ 50,000\)
* Best umpire: [O. Nandan](/wiki/O._Nandan "O. Nandan") (trophy and ₹50,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena "Jalaj Saxena") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Deepak Hooda](/wiki/Deepak_Hooda "Deepak Hooda") (trophy and ₹250,000\)
Ref:{{cite news\|title\=BCCI's top award for Kohli\|url\=http://www.thehindu.com/sport/cricket/bccis\-top\-award\-for\-virat\-kohli/article8051042\.ece\|work\=The Hindu\|date\=31 December 2015\|access\-date\=3 January 2016}}
### 2015–16
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Rajinder Goel](/wiki/Rajinder_Goel "Rajinder Goel") and [Padmakar Shivalkar](/wiki/Padmakar_Shivalkar "Padmakar Shivalkar")
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli "Virat Kohli")
* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Shanta Rangaswamy](/wiki/Shanta_Rangaswamy "Shanta Rangaswamy")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Shreyas Iyer](/wiki/Shreyas_Iyer "Shreyas Iyer")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Shahbaz Nadeem](/wiki/Shahbaz_Nadeem "Shahbaz Nadeem")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena "Jalaj Saxena")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Axar Patel](/wiki/Axar_Patel "Axar Patel")
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association "Mumbai Cricket Association")
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest scorer in Under\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Jay Bista](/wiki/Jay_Bista "Jay Bista")
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Satyajeet Bachhav](/wiki/Satyajeet_Bachhav "Satyajeet Bachhav")
* N K P Salve Award for highest scorer in Under\-19 [Cooch Behar Trophy](/wiki/Cooch_Behar_Trophy "Cooch Behar Trophy"): [Armaan Jaffer](/wiki/Armaan_Jaffer "Armaan Jaffer")
* N K P Salve Award for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-19 Cooch Behar Trophy: [Ninad Rathva](/wiki/Ninad_Rathva "Ninad Rathva")
* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest scorer in Under\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Abhishek Sharma](/wiki/Abhishek_Sharma_%28cricketer%2C_born_2000%29 "Abhishek Sharma (cricketer, born 2000)")
* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Abhishek Sharma](/wiki/Abhishek_Sharma_%28cricketer%2C_born_2000%29 "Abhishek Sharma (cricketer, born 2000)")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj "Mithali Raj")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman junior cricketer: [Deepti Sharma](/wiki/Deepti_Sharma "Deepti Sharma")
* Best umpire: [Nitin Menon](/wiki/Nitin_Menon "Nitin Menon")
Other awards
* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2016 Test series in the West Indies: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin "Ravichandran Ashwin")
* [Vaman Kumar](/wiki/Vaman_Kumar "Vaman Kumar") and late [Ramakant Desai](/wiki/Ramakant_Desai "Ramakant Desai") were handed special awards for outstanding contribution to Indian cricket
Ref:{{cite web\|title\=Kohli, Ashwin win big at BCCI awards\|url\=http://www.wisdenindia.com/cricket\-news/kohli\-ashwin\-win\-big\-at\-bcci\-awards/245005\|publisher\=Wisden India\|access\-date\=7 April 2017\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170407234436/http://www.wisdenindia.com/cricket\-news/kohli\-ashwin\-win\-big\-at\-bcci\-awards/245005\|archive\-date\=7 April 2017\|url\-status\=dead}}
### 2016–17
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Pankaj Roy](/wiki/Pankaj_Roy "Pankaj Roy")
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli "Virat Kohli")
* Best international woman cricketer: [Harmanpreet Kaur](/wiki/Harmanpreet_Kaur "Harmanpreet Kaur")
* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Diana Edulji](/wiki/Diana_Edulji "Diana Edulji")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Priyank Panchal](/wiki/Priyank_Panchal "Priyank Panchal")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Shahbaz Nadeem](/wiki/Shahbaz_Nadeem "Shahbaz Nadeem")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Parvez Rasool](/wiki/Parvez_Rasool "Parvez Rasool")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Krunal Pandya](/wiki/Krunal_Pandya "Krunal Pandya")
* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association "Mumbai Cricket Association")
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest scorer in Under\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Ekant Sen](/wiki/Ekant_Sen "Ekant Sen")
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Karan Kaila](/wiki/Karan_Kaila "Karan Kaila")
* N K P Salve Award for highest scorer in Under\-19 [Cooch Behar Trophy](/wiki/Cooch_Behar_Trophy "Cooch Behar Trophy"): [Jonty Sidhu](/wiki/Jonty_Sidhu "Jonty Sidhu")
* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-19 Cooch Behar Trophy: [Rahul Singh (Assam cricketer)](/wiki/Rahul_Singh_%28Assam_cricketer%29 "Rahul Singh (Assam cricketer)")
* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest scorer in Under\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [N Thakur Tilak](/wiki/N_Thakur_Tilak "N Thakur Tilak")
* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest wicket\-taker in Under\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Rohit Dattatraya](/wiki/Rohit_Dattatraya "Rohit Dattatraya")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman cricketer (Sr Domestic): [Punam Raut](/wiki/Punam_Raut "Punam Raut")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman junior cricketer: [Jemimah Rodrigues](/wiki/Jemimah_Rodrigues "Jemimah Rodrigues")
* Best umpire: [Anil Dandekar](/wiki/Anil_Dandekar "Anil Dandekar"){{Cite web\|url\=https://www.thequint.com/sports/cricket/virat\-kohli\-full\-list\-bcci\-awards\|title\=Virat Kohli Bags Polly Umrigar Award: Full List of BCCI Awardees\|date\=12 June 2018}}
### 2017–18
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Anshuman Gaekwad](/wiki/Anshuman_Gaekwad "Anshuman Gaekwad")
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli "Virat Kohli")
* Best international woman cricketer: [Smriti Mandhana](/wiki/Smriti_Mandhana "Smriti Mandhana")
* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Sudha Shah](/wiki/Sudha_Shah "Sudha Shah")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Mayank Agarwal](/wiki/Mayank_Agarwal "Mayank Agarwal")
* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena "Jalaj Saxena")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena "Jalaj Saxena")
* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\-rounder in limited\-overs tournaments: [Diwesh Pathania](/wiki/Diwesh_Pathania "Diwesh Pathania")
* BCCI special award : [Budhi Kunderan](/wiki/Budhi_Kunderan "Budhi Kunderan")
* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest run\-scorer in C. K. Nayudu Trophy: [Aryaman Birla](/wiki/Aryaman_Birla "Aryaman Birla")
* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in C. K. Nayudu Trophy: [Tejas Baroka](/wiki/Tejas_Baroka "Tejas Baroka")
* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest run\-scorer in Cooch Behar Trophy: [Yash Rathod](/wiki/Yash_Rathod "Yash Rathod")
* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in Cooch Behar Trophy: [Ayush Jamwal](/wiki/Ayush_Jamwal "Ayush Jamwal")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for highest run\-scorer in Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Nithish Kumar](/wiki/Nithish_Kumar "Nithish Kumar")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for highest wicket\-taker in Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Reshu Raj](/wiki/Reshu_Raj "Reshu Raj")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for best woman cricketer (domestic): [Deepti Sharma](/wiki/Deepti_Sharma "Deepti Sharma")
* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for best junior women's player (domestic): [Jemimah Rodrigues](/wiki/Jemimah_Rodrigues "Jemimah Rodrigues")
* Best umpire in domestic cricket: [Yeshwant Barde](/wiki/Yeshwant_Barde "Yeshwant Barde")
* Best performances in domestic tournaments: [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_%26_District_Cricket_Association "Delhi & District Cricket Association")
Ref:{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.bcci.tv/news/2018/bcci\-news/17299/committee\-recommends\-names\-for\-bcci\-annual\-awards\|title\=The Board of Control for Cricket in India}}
### 2018–2019
* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Kris Srikanth](/wiki/Krishnamachari_Srikkanth "Krishnamachari Srikkanth")
* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Jasprit Bumrah](/wiki/Jasprit_Bumrah "Jasprit Bumrah")
* Best international woman cricketer: [Poonam Yadav](/wiki/Poonam_Yadav "Poonam Yadav")
* Best umpire in domestic cricket: [Virender Sharma](/wiki/Virender_Sharma "Virender Sharma")
* Best performances in domestic tournaments: [Vidarbha](/wiki/Vidarbha_cricket_team "Vidarbha cricket team")
|
[
"List of winners\n---------------",
"### 2006–07",
"* [C. K. Nayudu Award for Lifetime Achievement](/wiki/C._K._Nayudu_Lifetime_Achievement_Award \"C. K. Nayudu Lifetime Achievement Award\"): [Nari Contractor](/wiki/Nari_Contractor \"Nari Contractor\") (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar \"Sachin Tendulkar\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Uthappa](/wiki/Robin_Uthappa \"Robin Uthappa\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ranadeb Bose](/wiki/Ranadeb_Bose \"Ranadeb Bose\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association \"Mumbai Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-15 cricketer: [Mandeep Singh](/wiki/Mandeep_Singh \"Mandeep Singh\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-17 cricketer: [Ajay Rana](/wiki/Ajay_Rana \"Ajay Rana\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Ajinkya Rahane](/wiki/Ajinkya_Rahane \"Ajinkya Rahane\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Manoj Tiwary](/wiki/Manoj_Tiwary_%28cricketer%29 \"Manoj Tiwary (cricketer)\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Jaya Sharma](/wiki/Jaya_Sharma \"Jaya Sharma\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [Jhulan Goswami](/wiki/Jhulan_Goswami \"Jhulan Goswami\") was awarded a trophy and a cheque for Rs one lakh for becoming the [ICC Women's Cricketer of the Year 2007](/wiki/ICC_Awards%23Men%27s_awards \"ICC Awards#Men's awards\").\n* [Anju Jain](/wiki/Anju_Jain \"Anju Jain\") and [Anjum Chopra](/wiki/Anjum_Chopra \"Anjum Chopra\") were given a trophy each for winning the [Arjuna Award](/wiki/Arjuna_Award \"Arjuna Award\") in women's cricket for 2006 and 2007 respectively.",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Seniors honoured at BCCI awards\\|url\\=http://www.rediff.com/cricket/report/awards/20071216\\.htm\\|publisher\\=Rediff\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2007–08",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Gundappa Viswanath](/wiki/Gundappa_Viswanath \"Gundappa Viswanath\") (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virender Sehwag](/wiki/Virender_Sehwag \"Virender Sehwag\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Cheteshwar Pujara](/wiki/Cheteshwar_Pujara \"Cheteshwar Pujara\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Sudeep Tyagi](/wiki/Sudeep_Tyagi \"Sudeep Tyagi\") (trophy and ₹ 100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association \"Maharashtra Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-15 cricketer: [Ankit Bawne](/wiki/Ankit_Bawne \"Ankit Bawne\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-17 cricketer: [Mandeep Singh](/wiki/Mandeep_Singh \"Mandeep Singh\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Bhuvneshwar Kumar](/wiki/Bhuvneshwar_Kumar \"Bhuvneshwar Kumar\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Rahul Dewan](/wiki/Rahul_Dewan \"Rahul Dewan\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj \"Mithali Raj\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [Mahendra Singh Dhoni](/wiki/Mahendra_Singh_Dhoni \"Mahendra Singh Dhoni\") was handed a special award for winning the [Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna](/wiki/Rajiv_Gandhi_Khel_Ratna \"Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna\") and the [Padma Shri](/wiki/Padma_Shri \"Padma Shri\").\n* [Harbhajan Singh](/wiki/Harbhajan_Singh \"Harbhajan Singh\") was handed a special award for taking 300 Test wickets and winning the Padma Shri.",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Sehwag wins BCCI's top award\\|url\\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/ci/content/story/389865\\.html\\|publisher\\=ESPNcricinfo\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2008–09",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Mohinder Amarnath](/wiki/Mohinder_Amarnath \"Mohinder Amarnath\") (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Gautam Gambhir](/wiki/Gautam_Gambhir \"Gautam Gambhir\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Wasim Jaffer](/wiki/Wasim_Jaffer \"Wasim Jaffer\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Dhawal Kulkarni](/wiki/Dhawal_Kulkarni \"Dhawal Kulkarni\") \\& [Ravindra Jadeja](/wiki/Ravindra_Jadeja \"Ravindra Jadeja\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association \"Mumbai Cricket Association\") \\& [Punjab](/wiki/Punjab_Cricket_Association \"Punjab Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Chirag Khurana](/wiki/Chirag_Khurana \"Chirag Khurana\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Harpreet Singh](/wiki/Harpreet_Singh_%28cricketer%2C_born_1991%29 \"Harpreet Singh (cricketer, born 1991)\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Neelkanth Das](/wiki/Neelkanth_Das \"Neelkanth Das\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Reema Malhotra](/wiki/Reema_Malhotra \"Reema Malhotra\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Poonam Raut](/wiki/Poonam_Raut \"Poonam Raut\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [Amish Saheba](/wiki/Amish_Saheba \"Amish Saheba\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [Rahul Dravid](/wiki/Rahul_Dravid \"Rahul Dravid\") was handed a special award for taking the most catches.\n* [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar \"Sachin Tendulkar\") was handed a special award for completing two decades of international cricket.",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Gambhir, Amarnath hog limelight at BCCI awards function\\|url\\=http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/119934\\-gambhir\\-amarnath\\-hog\\-limelight\\-at\\-bcci\\-awards\\-function\\|publisher\\=NDTV\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150102052955/http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/119934\\-gambhir\\-amarnath\\-hog\\-limelight\\-at\\-bcci\\-awards\\-function\\|archive\\-date\\=2 January 2015\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"### 2009–10",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Salim Durani](/wiki/Salim_Durani \"Salim Durani\") (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Sachin Tendulkar](/wiki/Sachin_Tendulkar \"Sachin Tendulkar\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Manish Pandey](/wiki/Manish_Pandey \"Manish Pandey\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Abhimanyu Mithun](/wiki/Abhimanyu_Mithun \"Abhimanyu Mithun\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association \"Maharashtra Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Baba Aparajith](/wiki/Baba_Aparajith \"Baba Aparajith\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Bhargav Merai](/wiki/Bhargav_Merai \"Bhargav Merai\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Natraj Behera](/wiki/Natraj_Behera \"Natraj Behera\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini \"Thirush Kamini\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Reva Arora](/wiki/Reva_Arora \"Reva Arora\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [K. Hariharan](/wiki/Krishna_Hariharan \"Krishna Hariharan\") (trophy and Rs 50,000\\)",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Tendulkar, Durani honoured at BCCI awards\\|url\\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/story/517352\\.html\\|publisher\\=ESPNcricinfo\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2010–11",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Ajit Wadekar](/wiki/Ajit_Wadekar \"Ajit Wadekar\") (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Rahul Dravid](/wiki/Rahul_Dravid \"Rahul Dravid\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Subramaniam Badrinath](/wiki/Subramaniam_Badrinath \"Subramaniam Badrinath\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Bhargav Bhatt](/wiki/Bhargav_Bhatt_%28cricketer%29 \"Bhargav Bhatt (cricketer)\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Railways](/wiki/Railways_Cricket_Association \"Railways Cricket Association\") \\& [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_District_Cricket_Association \"Delhi District Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Vijay Zol](/wiki/Vijay_Zol \"Vijay Zol\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Avi Barot](/wiki/Avi_Barot \"Avi Barot\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Suryakumar Yadav](/wiki/Suryakumar_Yadav \"Suryakumar Yadav\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Jhulan Goswami](/wiki/Jhulan_Goswami \"Jhulan Goswami\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Mona Meshram](/wiki/Mona_Meshram \"Mona Meshram\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [S. Ravi](/wiki/S._Ravi_%28umpire%29 \"S. Ravi (umpire)\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Iqbal Abdulla](/wiki/Iqbal_Abdulla \"Iqbal Abdulla\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Sumit Narwal](/wiki/Sumit_Narwal \"Sumit Narwal\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2011 Test series in the West Indies: [Ishant Sharma](/wiki/Ishant_Sharma \"Ishant Sharma\")\n* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2011 Test series against the West Indies: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin \"Ravichandran Ashwin\")",
"Ref:{{cite news\\|title\\=BCCI awards: Dravid to get 'Polly Umrigar' Trophy\\|url\\=http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/top\\-stories/BCCI\\-awards\\-Dravid\\-to\\-get\\-Polly\\-Umrigar\\-Trophy/articleshow/10840912\\.cms\\|newspaper\\=Times of India\\|date\\=23 November 2011 \\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2011–12",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Sunil Gavaskar](/wiki/Sunil_Gavaskar \"Sunil Gavaskar\") (trophy and ₹ 1\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli \"Virat Kohli\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Bist](/wiki/Robin_Bist \"Robin Bist\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ashok Dinda](/wiki/Ashok_Dinda \"Ashok Dinda\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_District_Cricket_Association \"Delhi District Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Mohammad Saif](/wiki/Mohammad_Saif_%28cricketer%2C_born_1996%29 \"Mohammad Saif (cricketer, born 1996)\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Vijay Zol](/wiki/Vijay_Zol \"Vijay Zol\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-22 cricketer: [Satyam Choudhary](/wiki/Satyam_Choudhary \"Satyam Choudhary\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Anagha Deshpande](/wiki/Anagha_Deshpande \"Anagha Deshpande\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [S. Ravi](/wiki/S._Ravi_%28umpire%29 \"S. Ravi (umpire)\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Stuart Binny](/wiki/Stuart_Binny \"Stuart Binny\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Laxmi Ratan Shukla](/wiki/Laxmi_Ratan_Shukla \"Laxmi Ratan Shukla\") (trophy and ₹100,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [VVS Laxman](/wiki/VVS_Laxman \"VVS Laxman\") was handed a special award for his achievements in international cricket.",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Kohli takes top BCCI award for 2011–12\\|url\\=http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/story/592403\\.html\\|publisher\\=ESPNcricinfo\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2012–13",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Kapil Dev](/wiki/Kapil_Dev \"Kapil Dev\") (trophy and ₹ 2\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin \"Ravichandran Ashwin\") (trophy and ₹ 500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Jiwanjot Singh](/wiki/Jiwanjot_Singh \"Jiwanjot Singh\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Ishwar Pandey](/wiki/Ishwar_Pandey \"Ishwar Pandey\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association \"Mumbai Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Arman Jaffer](/wiki/Arman_Jaffer \"Arman Jaffer\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Akshar Patel](/wiki/Akshar_Patel \"Akshar Patel\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-25 cricketer: [Karn Sharma](/wiki/Karn_Sharma \"Karn Sharma\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini \"Thirush Kamini\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [Chettithody Shamshuddin](/wiki/Chettithody_Shamshuddin \"Chettithody Shamshuddin\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Abhishek Nayar](/wiki/Abhishek_Nayar \"Abhishek Nayar\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Laxmi Ratan Shukla](/wiki/Laxmi_Ratan_Shukla \"Laxmi Ratan Shukla\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [Bapu Nadkarni](/wiki/Bapu_Nadkarni \"Bapu Nadkarni\"), [Farokh Engineer](/wiki/Farokh_Engineer \"Farokh Engineer\"), late [Eknath Solkar](/wiki/Eknath_Solkar \"Eknath Solkar\") were handed special awards for outstanding contribution to Indian cricket (trophy and ₹1\\.5 million)\n* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2013 Test series against the West Indies: [Rohit Sharma](/wiki/Rohit_Sharma \"Rohit Sharma\") (trophy and ₹500,000{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.sportskeeda.com/cricket/bcci\\-awards\\-rohit\\-sharma\\-ashwin\\-ishwar\\-pandey\\|title\\=BCCI Awards: Rohit Sharma, R Ashwin and Ishwar Pandey awarded for their contributions}})",
"Ref:{{cite news\\|title\\=Polly Umrigar award for Ashwin\\|url\\=http://www.thehindu.com/sport/cricket/poly\\-umrigar\\-award\\-for\\-ashwin/article5503936\\.ece\\|work\\=The Hindu\\|date\\=26 December 2013\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015}}",
"### 2013–14",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Dilip Vengsarkar](/wiki/Dilip_Vengsarkar \"Dilip Vengsarkar\") (trophy and ₹2\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Bhuvneshwar Kumar](/wiki/Bhuvneshwar_Kumar \"Bhuvneshwar Kumar\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Kedar Jadhav](/wiki/Kedar_Jadhav \"Kedar Jadhav\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Rishi Dhawan](/wiki/Rishi_Dhawan \"Rishi Dhawan\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Maharashtra](/wiki/Maharashtra_Cricket_Association \"Maharashtra Cricket Association\") \\& [Railways](/wiki/Railways_Cricket_Association \"Railways Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Shubman Gill](/wiki/Shubman_Gill \"Shubman Gill\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Balchander Anirudh](/wiki/Balchander_Anirudh \"Balchander Anirudh\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-25 cricketer: [Rahul Tripathi](/wiki/Rahul_Tripathi \"Rahul Tripathi\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Thirush Kamini](/wiki/Thirush_Kamini \"Thirush Kamini\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [Anil Chaudhary](/wiki/Anil_Chaudhary_%28umpire%29 \"Anil Chaudhary (umpire)\") (trophy and 50,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Parvez Rasool](/wiki/Parvez_Rasool \"Parvez Rasool\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Vinay Kumar](/wiki/Vinay_Kumar \"Vinay Kumar\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)",
"Other awards\n* [Rohit Sharma](/wiki/Rohit_Sharma \"Rohit Sharma\") was handed a special award for scoring the highest ODI individual score of 264\\.",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Dilip Vengsarkar, Bhuvneshwar Kumar, Rohit Sharma Receive BCCI Awards\\|url\\=http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/233427\\-dilip\\-vengsarkar\\-bhuvneshwar\\-kumar\\-rohit\\-sharma\\-receive\\-bcci\\-awards\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[NDTV]]\\|access\\-date\\=2 January 2015\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20150102052940/http://sports.ndtv.com/cricket/news/233427\\-dilip\\-vengsarkar\\-bhuvneshwar\\-kumar\\-rohit\\-sharma\\-receive\\-bcci\\-awards\\|archive\\-date\\=2 January 2015\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"### 2014–15",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Syed Kirmani](/wiki/Syed_Kirmani \"Syed Kirmani\") (trophy and ₹ 2\\.5 million)\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli \"Virat Kohli\") (trophy and ₹500,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Robin Uthappa](/wiki/Robin_Uthappa \"Robin Uthappa\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Vinay Kumar](/wiki/Vinay_Kumar \"Vinay Kumar\") \\& [Shardul Thakur](/wiki/Shardul_Thakur \"Shardul Thakur\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Karnataka](/wiki/Karnataka_State_Cricket_Association \"Karnataka State Cricket Association\") (trophy)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-16 cricketer: [Shubman Gill](/wiki/Shubman_Gill \"Shubman Gill\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-19 cricketer: [Anmolpreet Singh](/wiki/Anmolpreet_Singh \"Anmolpreet Singh\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best Under\\-23 cricketer: [Almas Shaukat](/wiki/Almas_Shaukat \"Almas Shaukat\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj \"Mithali Raj\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for best woman junior cricketer: [Devika Vaidya](/wiki/Devika_Vaidya \"Devika Vaidya\") (trophy and ₹ 50,000\\)\n* Best umpire: [O. Nandan](/wiki/O._Nandan \"O. Nandan\") (trophy and ₹50,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena \"Jalaj Saxena\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Deepak Hooda](/wiki/Deepak_Hooda \"Deepak Hooda\") (trophy and ₹250,000\\)",
"Ref:{{cite news\\|title\\=BCCI's top award for Kohli\\|url\\=http://www.thehindu.com/sport/cricket/bccis\\-top\\-award\\-for\\-virat\\-kohli/article8051042\\.ece\\|work\\=The Hindu\\|date\\=31 December 2015\\|access\\-date\\=3 January 2016}}",
"### 2015–16",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Rajinder Goel](/wiki/Rajinder_Goel \"Rajinder Goel\") and [Padmakar Shivalkar](/wiki/Padmakar_Shivalkar \"Padmakar Shivalkar\")\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli \"Virat Kohli\")\n* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Shanta Rangaswamy](/wiki/Shanta_Rangaswamy \"Shanta Rangaswamy\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Shreyas Iyer](/wiki/Shreyas_Iyer \"Shreyas Iyer\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Shahbaz Nadeem](/wiki/Shahbaz_Nadeem \"Shahbaz Nadeem\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena \"Jalaj Saxena\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Axar Patel](/wiki/Axar_Patel \"Axar Patel\")\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association \"Mumbai Cricket Association\")\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest scorer in Under\\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Jay Bista](/wiki/Jay_Bista \"Jay Bista\")\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Satyajeet Bachhav](/wiki/Satyajeet_Bachhav \"Satyajeet Bachhav\")\n* N K P Salve Award for highest scorer in Under\\-19 [Cooch Behar Trophy](/wiki/Cooch_Behar_Trophy \"Cooch Behar Trophy\"): [Armaan Jaffer](/wiki/Armaan_Jaffer \"Armaan Jaffer\")\n* N K P Salve Award for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-19 Cooch Behar Trophy: [Ninad Rathva](/wiki/Ninad_Rathva \"Ninad Rathva\")\n* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest scorer in Under\\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Abhishek Sharma](/wiki/Abhishek_Sharma_%28cricketer%2C_born_2000%29 \"Abhishek Sharma (cricketer, born 2000)\")\n* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Abhishek Sharma](/wiki/Abhishek_Sharma_%28cricketer%2C_born_2000%29 \"Abhishek Sharma (cricketer, born 2000)\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman cricketer: [Mithali Raj](/wiki/Mithali_Raj \"Mithali Raj\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman junior cricketer: [Deepti Sharma](/wiki/Deepti_Sharma \"Deepti Sharma\")\n* Best umpire: [Nitin Menon](/wiki/Nitin_Menon \"Nitin Menon\")",
"Other awards\n* Dilip Sardesai Award for India's best cricketer in the 2016 Test series in the West Indies: [Ravichandran Ashwin](/wiki/Ravichandran_Ashwin \"Ravichandran Ashwin\")\n* [Vaman Kumar](/wiki/Vaman_Kumar \"Vaman Kumar\") and late [Ramakant Desai](/wiki/Ramakant_Desai \"Ramakant Desai\") were handed special awards for outstanding contribution to Indian cricket",
"Ref:{{cite web\\|title\\=Kohli, Ashwin win big at BCCI awards\\|url\\=http://www.wisdenindia.com/cricket\\-news/kohli\\-ashwin\\-win\\-big\\-at\\-bcci\\-awards/245005\\|publisher\\=Wisden India\\|access\\-date\\=7 April 2017\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170407234436/http://www.wisdenindia.com/cricket\\-news/kohli\\-ashwin\\-win\\-big\\-at\\-bcci\\-awards/245005\\|archive\\-date\\=7 April 2017\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"### 2016–17",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Pankaj Roy](/wiki/Pankaj_Roy \"Pankaj Roy\")\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli \"Virat Kohli\")\n* Best international woman cricketer: [Harmanpreet Kaur](/wiki/Harmanpreet_Kaur \"Harmanpreet Kaur\")\n* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Diana Edulji](/wiki/Diana_Edulji \"Diana Edulji\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Priyank Panchal](/wiki/Priyank_Panchal \"Priyank Panchal\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Shahbaz Nadeem](/wiki/Shahbaz_Nadeem \"Shahbaz Nadeem\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Parvez Rasool](/wiki/Parvez_Rasool \"Parvez Rasool\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Krunal Pandya](/wiki/Krunal_Pandya \"Krunal Pandya\")\n* Best Cricket Association of the Year for overall performance: [Mumbai](/wiki/Mumbai_Cricket_Association \"Mumbai Cricket Association\")\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest scorer in Under\\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Ekant Sen](/wiki/Ekant_Sen \"Ekant Sen\")\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-23 CK Nayudu Trophy: [Karan Kaila](/wiki/Karan_Kaila \"Karan Kaila\")\n* N K P Salve Award for highest scorer in Under\\-19 [Cooch Behar Trophy](/wiki/Cooch_Behar_Trophy \"Cooch Behar Trophy\"): [Jonty Sidhu](/wiki/Jonty_Sidhu \"Jonty Sidhu\")\n* M A Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-19 Cooch Behar Trophy: [Rahul Singh (Assam cricketer)](/wiki/Rahul_Singh_%28Assam_cricketer%29 \"Rahul Singh (Assam cricketer)\")\n* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest scorer in Under\\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [N Thakur Tilak](/wiki/N_Thakur_Tilak \"N Thakur Tilak\")\n* Raj Singh Dungarpur Award for highest wicket\\-taker in Under\\-16 Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Rohit Dattatraya](/wiki/Rohit_Dattatraya \"Rohit Dattatraya\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman cricketer (Sr Domestic): [Punam Raut](/wiki/Punam_Raut \"Punam Raut\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Award for best woman junior cricketer: [Jemimah Rodrigues](/wiki/Jemimah_Rodrigues \"Jemimah Rodrigues\")\n* Best umpire: [Anil Dandekar](/wiki/Anil_Dandekar \"Anil Dandekar\"){{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.thequint.com/sports/cricket/virat\\-kohli\\-full\\-list\\-bcci\\-awards\\|title\\=Virat Kohli Bags Polly Umrigar Award: Full List of BCCI Awardees\\|date\\=12 June 2018}}",
"### 2017–18",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Anshuman Gaekwad](/wiki/Anshuman_Gaekwad \"Anshuman Gaekwad\")\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Virat Kohli](/wiki/Virat_Kohli \"Virat Kohli\")\n* Best international woman cricketer: [Smriti Mandhana](/wiki/Smriti_Mandhana \"Smriti Mandhana\")\n* BCCI Lifetime Achievement Award For Women: [Sudha Shah](/wiki/Sudha_Shah \"Sudha Shah\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most runs in Ranji Trophy: [Mayank Agarwal](/wiki/Mayank_Agarwal \"Mayank Agarwal\")\n* Madhavrao Scindia Award for most wickets in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena \"Jalaj Saxena\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in Ranji Trophy: [Jalaj Saxena](/wiki/Jalaj_Saxena \"Jalaj Saxena\")\n* Lala Amarnath Award for best all\\-rounder in limited\\-overs tournaments: [Diwesh Pathania](/wiki/Diwesh_Pathania \"Diwesh Pathania\")\n* BCCI special award : [Budhi Kunderan](/wiki/Budhi_Kunderan \"Budhi Kunderan\")\n* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest run\\-scorer in C. K. Nayudu Trophy: [Aryaman Birla](/wiki/Aryaman_Birla \"Aryaman Birla\")\n* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in C. K. Nayudu Trophy: [Tejas Baroka](/wiki/Tejas_Baroka \"Tejas Baroka\")\n* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest run\\-scorer in Cooch Behar Trophy: [Yash Rathod](/wiki/Yash_Rathod \"Yash Rathod\")\n* M.A. Chidambaram Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in Cooch Behar Trophy: [Ayush Jamwal](/wiki/Ayush_Jamwal \"Ayush Jamwal\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for highest run\\-scorer in Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Nithish Kumar](/wiki/Nithish_Kumar \"Nithish Kumar\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for highest wicket\\-taker in Vijay Merchant Trophy: [Reshu Raj](/wiki/Reshu_Raj \"Reshu Raj\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for best woman cricketer (domestic): [Deepti Sharma](/wiki/Deepti_Sharma \"Deepti Sharma\")\n* Jagmohan Dalmiya Trophy for best junior women's player (domestic): [Jemimah Rodrigues](/wiki/Jemimah_Rodrigues \"Jemimah Rodrigues\")\n* Best umpire in domestic cricket: [Yeshwant Barde](/wiki/Yeshwant_Barde \"Yeshwant Barde\")\n* Best performances in domestic tournaments: [Delhi](/wiki/Delhi_%26_District_Cricket_Association \"Delhi & District Cricket Association\")\nRef:{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.bcci.tv/news/2018/bcci\\-news/17299/committee\\-recommends\\-names\\-for\\-bcci\\-annual\\-awards\\|title\\=The Board of Control for Cricket in India}}",
"### 2018–2019",
"* CK Nayudu Award for lifetime achievement: [Kris Srikanth](/wiki/Krishnamachari_Srikkanth \"Krishnamachari Srikkanth\")\n* Polly Umrigar Award for international cricketer of the year: [Jasprit Bumrah](/wiki/Jasprit_Bumrah \"Jasprit Bumrah\")\n* Best international woman cricketer: [Poonam Yadav](/wiki/Poonam_Yadav \"Poonam Yadav\")\n* Best umpire in domestic cricket: [Virender Sharma](/wiki/Virender_Sharma \"Virender Sharma\")\n* Best performances in domestic tournaments: [Vidarbha](/wiki/Vidarbha_cricket_team \"Vidarbha cricket team\")"
] |
History
-------
Since 1992, North has grown into the sixth\-largest independent, non\-bank merchant acquirer in [North America](/wiki/North_America "North America").
In 2008, the Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) recommended that the Michigan Economic Growth Authority (MEGA) approve a $21\.5 million state tax credit to North.{{Cite web \|title\=All the Latest MEDC News {{!}} Michigan Business \|url\=https://www.michiganbusiness.org/news/ \|access\-date\=2024\-08\-05 \|website\=Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) \|language\=en}}
The following year, 2009, the company moved its headquarters to a 105,000\-square\-foot (9,800 m2) building in Troy, MI.{{Cite news \|last\=Duggan \|first\=Daniel \|date\=November 9, 2009 \|title\=North American Bancard moves into new Troy HQ \|url\=https://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20091109/FREE/911099974/north\-american\-bancard\-moves\-into\-new\-troy\-hq}}
In 2010, the company acquired public\-sector\-payment company Point \& Pay, as well as merchant services technology provider CDI Tech.
In January 2011, North announced the launch of [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere "PayAnywhere"), a mobile payment processing tool. The acquisition of payment services company Velocity occurred in 2013\.
In 2014, the company acquired payment processor Electronic Payment Exchange.\[9] In June 2015, North announced the launch of the newest version of its [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere "PayAnywhere") Mobile credit card reader, a 3\-in\-1 credit card reader that was launched in Apple Stores. This version is compatible with iOS devices.{{Cite news \|title\=North American Bancard Acquires Electronic Payment Exchange (EPX) \|url\=https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20141024005068/en/North\-American\-Bancard\-Acquires\-Electronic\-Payment\-Exchange}}
2014 also saw the launch of the Payanywhere Storefront, and the acquisition of Rapid Capital Funding, Electronic Payment Exchange, and Argus Payments (which changed its name to Inovio in 2016\).
In 2016, North reached 1,000 employees for the first time. In 2017, the company acquired Total Merchant Services. Hospitality payment service provider SALIDO was acquired in 2019\.
Growth and acquisitions continued in the new decade, with the acquisition of HMSKC in 2020; the acquisition of Signature Payments and B2B gateway provider PayTrace occurred the following year. 2021 was also the year that North launched its signature Developer Portal, an online tool for the sourcing and crafting of bespoke software solutions. In 2022, North added CardWorks Acquiring (CWA) to its roster.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"Since 1992, North has grown into the sixth\\-largest independent, non\\-bank merchant acquirer in [North America](/wiki/North_America \"North America\").",
"In 2008, the Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) recommended that the Michigan Economic Growth Authority (MEGA) approve a $21\\.5 million state tax credit to North.{{Cite web \\|title\\=All the Latest MEDC News {{!}} Michigan Business \\|url\\=https://www.michiganbusiness.org/news/ \\|access\\-date\\=2024\\-08\\-05 \\|website\\=Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) \\|language\\=en}}",
"The following year, 2009, the company moved its headquarters to a 105,000\\-square\\-foot (9,800 m2) building in Troy, MI.{{Cite news \\|last\\=Duggan \\|first\\=Daniel \\|date\\=November 9, 2009 \\|title\\=North American Bancard moves into new Troy HQ \\|url\\=https://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20091109/FREE/911099974/north\\-american\\-bancard\\-moves\\-into\\-new\\-troy\\-hq}}",
"In 2010, the company acquired public\\-sector\\-payment company Point \\& Pay, as well as merchant services technology provider CDI Tech.",
"In January 2011, North announced the launch of [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere \"PayAnywhere\"), a mobile payment processing tool. The acquisition of payment services company Velocity occurred in 2013\\.",
"In 2014, the company acquired payment processor Electronic Payment Exchange.\\[9] In June 2015, North announced the launch of the newest version of its [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere \"PayAnywhere\") Mobile credit card reader, a 3\\-in\\-1 credit card reader that was launched in Apple Stores. This version is compatible with iOS devices.{{Cite news \\|title\\=North American Bancard Acquires Electronic Payment Exchange (EPX) \\|url\\=https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20141024005068/en/North\\-American\\-Bancard\\-Acquires\\-Electronic\\-Payment\\-Exchange}}",
"2014 also saw the launch of the Payanywhere Storefront, and the acquisition of Rapid Capital Funding, Electronic Payment Exchange, and Argus Payments (which changed its name to Inovio in 2016\\).",
"In 2016, North reached 1,000 employees for the first time. In 2017, the company acquired Total Merchant Services. Hospitality payment service provider SALIDO was acquired in 2019\\.",
"Growth and acquisitions continued in the new decade, with the acquisition of HMSKC in 2020; the acquisition of Signature Payments and B2B gateway provider PayTrace occurred the following year. 2021 was also the year that North launched its signature Developer Portal, an online tool for the sourcing and crafting of bespoke software solutions. In 2022, North added CardWorks Acquiring (CWA) to its roster.",
""
] |
Recognition
-----------
Founder/CEO/President Marc Gardner received the Ernst \& Young’s Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2008\.{{Cite news \|last\=Boyd \|first\=Leah \|date\=June 13, 2008 \|title\=Entrepreneur of the Year winners announced \|url\=https://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20080613/SUB/872254891/entrepreneur\-of\-the\-year\-winners\-announced}}
The Detroit Regional Chamber selected Gardner as a guest speaker at the 2009 Mackinac Policy Conference to discuss Michigan’s economic future and Gardner’s success as an entrepreneur.{{Cite web \|title\=Marc Gardner Guest Panelist at Mackinac Policy Conference \|url\=https://www.prlog.org/10320275\-marc\-gardner\-guest\-panelist\-at\-mackinac\-policy\-conference.html \|access\-date\=2024\-08\-05 \|website\=PRLog}}
The American Heart Association named North American Bancard as a 2010 Fit Friendly Gold Status company for their comprehensive wellness initiatives for their employees.
North and its brand [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere "PayAnywhere") were awarded for the category Design in Electronic and Digital Communications \- Website by the International Association of Business Communicators Detroit in June 2011\.
North American Bancard was named ETA ISO of the Year in 2014 — the company would win the same award in 2022\.
In 2021, North was twice honored by the Strawhecker Group (TSG), as the Restaurant Smart Terminal Provider of the Year and at the eCommerce Merchant Experience Awards. TSG also named North in its 2023 “Best of Breed” API Awards
In 2023, North was named a Best Place To Work by business tech giant Built In. The annual honors include companies of all sizes based in large tech markets across the U.S. North earned spots on the lists for Best Large Places to Work in both the Los Angeles and New York areas.
That same year, Nilson’s ranking of Top U.S. Merchant Acquirers had North’s name on it in three different categories: Top 5 in Card Not Present (CNP) Acquiring; Top 6 in Purchase Transactions (nonbank); and Top 8 in Purchase Volume (nonbank).
August of 2023 saw North receive the Global Sustainability Award from the Business Intelligence Group. The award goes to organizations whose actions prove sustainability is a core business objective.
September of 2023 brought North honors at *Corp!* magazine’s Salute to Diversity Awards. The ceremony put a spotlight on organizations that champion diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives and achievements.{{Cite web \|last\=Blanchard \|first\=Richard \|date\=2012\-10\-10 \|title\=Wellness Program Champions Reap Benefits of a Culture of Health {{!}} Corp! Magazine \|url\=https://www.corpmagazine.com/features/cover\-stories/wellness\-program\-champions\-reap\-benefits\-of\-a\-culture\-of\-health/ \|access\-date\=2024\-08\-05 \|website\=www.corpmagazine.com \|language\=en\-US}}
In November of 2023, North earned the Best Employer Award at the 2023 U.S. FinTech Awards.
|
[
"Recognition\n-----------",
"Founder/CEO/President Marc Gardner received the Ernst \\& Young’s Entrepreneur of the Year award in 2008\\.{{Cite news \\|last\\=Boyd \\|first\\=Leah \\|date\\=June 13, 2008 \\|title\\=Entrepreneur of the Year winners announced \\|url\\=https://www.crainsdetroit.com/article/20080613/SUB/872254891/entrepreneur\\-of\\-the\\-year\\-winners\\-announced}}",
"The Detroit Regional Chamber selected Gardner as a guest speaker at the 2009 Mackinac Policy Conference to discuss Michigan’s economic future and Gardner’s success as an entrepreneur.{{Cite web \\|title\\=Marc Gardner Guest Panelist at Mackinac Policy Conference \\|url\\=https://www.prlog.org/10320275\\-marc\\-gardner\\-guest\\-panelist\\-at\\-mackinac\\-policy\\-conference.html \\|access\\-date\\=2024\\-08\\-05 \\|website\\=PRLog}}",
"The American Heart Association named North American Bancard as a 2010 Fit Friendly Gold Status company for their comprehensive wellness initiatives for their employees.",
"North and its brand [Payanywhere](/wiki/PayAnywhere \"PayAnywhere\") were awarded for the category Design in Electronic and Digital Communications \\- Website by the International Association of Business Communicators Detroit in June 2011\\.",
"North American Bancard was named ETA ISO of the Year in 2014 — the company would win the same award in 2022\\.",
"In 2021, North was twice honored by the Strawhecker Group (TSG), as the Restaurant Smart Terminal Provider of the Year and at the eCommerce Merchant Experience Awards. TSG also named North in its 2023 “Best of Breed” API Awards",
"In 2023, North was named a Best Place To Work by business tech giant Built In. The annual honors include companies of all sizes based in large tech markets across the U.S. North earned spots on the lists for Best Large Places to Work in both the Los Angeles and New York areas.",
"That same year, Nilson’s ranking of Top U.S. Merchant Acquirers had North’s name on it in three different categories: Top 5 in Card Not Present (CNP) Acquiring; Top 6 in Purchase Transactions (nonbank); and Top 8 in Purchase Volume (nonbank).",
"August of 2023 saw North receive the Global Sustainability Award from the Business Intelligence Group. The award goes to organizations whose actions prove sustainability is a core business objective.",
"September of 2023 brought North honors at *Corp!* magazine’s Salute to Diversity Awards. The ceremony put a spotlight on organizations that champion diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives and achievements.{{Cite web \\|last\\=Blanchard \\|first\\=Richard \\|date\\=2012\\-10\\-10 \\|title\\=Wellness Program Champions Reap Benefits of a Culture of Health {{!}} Corp! Magazine \\|url\\=https://www.corpmagazine.com/features/cover\\-stories/wellness\\-program\\-champions\\-reap\\-benefits\\-of\\-a\\-culture\\-of\\-health/ \\|access\\-date\\=2024\\-08\\-05 \\|website\\=www.corpmagazine.com \\|language\\=en\\-US}}",
"In November of 2023, North earned the Best Employer Award at the 2023 U.S. FinTech Awards.",
""
] |
Architecture and history
------------------------
### Construction as a railroad hotel
The San Dimas Hotel was built as a "railroad hotel" on land that was part of the San Jose Rancho. In 1885, the transcontinental [Santa Fe Railway](/wiki/Santa_Fe_Railway "Santa Fe Railway") completed its tracks between Los Angeles and [San Bernardino](/wiki/San_Bernardino%2C_California "San Bernardino, California"), and there were expectations that a land boom would develop along the path of the railroad. In anticipation of the boom, the San Jose Ranch Co., a company operated by Moses Wicks and other investors, built the San Dimas Hotel. It was one of many hotels built in each town along the railroad between Pasadena and San Bernardino.{{cite news\|author\=Nisha Gutierrez\|title\=Historic hotel never had a real guest\|publisher\=San Gabriel Valley Tribune\|date\=2006\-05\-22}} It was only the second building in San Dimas, and is reported to be the only surviving 1880s era railroad hotel in Southern California.
The owners hired one of the state's most prestigious architects, Joseph Cather Newsom, to design the structure. Newsom and his brother, [Samuel](/wiki/Samuel_Newsom "Samuel Newsom"), created the firm Newsom \& Newsom and built many prestigious buildings throughout California in the late 19th century, including the [Carson Mansion](/wiki/Carson_Mansion "Carson Mansion") in [Eureka, California](/wiki/Eureka%2C_California "Eureka, California").{{Cite web\|last\=\|first\=\|date\=\|title\=Walker House\|url\=https://www.laconservancy.org/locations/walker\-house\|archive\-url\=\|archive\-date\=\|access\-date\=2021\-01\-09\|website\=Los Angeles Conservancy}} The lumber used to build the hotel was floated down the coast from [Oregon](/wiki/Oregon "Oregon") and [Northern California](/wiki/Northern_California "Northern California") on large lumber rafts, and hauled from [San Pedro](/wiki/San_Pedro%2C_Los_Angeles%2C_California "San Pedro, Los Angeles, California") to San Dimas. The [Victorian architecture](/wiki/Victorian_architecture "Victorian architecture") [Queen Anne style](/wiki/Queen_Anne_style_architecture "Queen Anne style architecture") structure had {{convert\|15000\|sqft\|m2}} and was completed in 1887\. It was designed with a variety of surface materials, including diamond patterned shingles. Ten tons of shingles were used on the gable roof. It also had a sunburst medallion, an ornamental [cupola](/wiki/Cupola "Cupola"), balconies, corner towers, seven chimneys for 14 fireplaces, a large front porch, {{convert\|140\|ft\|m}} of [veranda](/wiki/Veranda "Veranda"), {{convert\|12\|ft\|m\|adj\=on}} ceilings, 18 bedrooms (33 rooms in all), and colored glass windows.
However, by the time the hotel was completed, an economic depression had hit Southern California, and the hotel never had any paying guests.{{cite news\|author\=Ann Frank\|title\=Sheltered Six Generations: Hotel That Never Had Guests San Dimas Landmark Since 1887\|work\=Los Angeles Times\|date\=1961\-09\-21}} Its original occupants were Moses Wicks and his partners in the San Jose Ranch Co.{{cite news\|author\=Ursula Vils\|title\=Home Sweet Home Is a Hotel\|work\=Los Angeles Times\|date\=1975\-08\-18}} In April 1889, the *Los Angeles Times* described the hotel as "one of the boom enterprises that never paid as an investment, because there was no need of a hotel there."{{cite news\|title\=For and Odd Fellows' Home: A Project to Purchase the San Dimas Hotel\|work\=Los Angeles Times\|date\=1889\-04\-25}} At that time, the owner, Mr. Wicks, was in negotiations to sell the property to the [Odd Fellows](/wiki/Odd_Fellows "Odd Fellows") for use as "an eleemosynary institution."
### Ninety years as the Walker and Carruthers family home
James W. Walker, a prosperous merchant from Kentucky, purchased the hotel and {{convert\|40\|acre\|m2}} surrounding for use as his family home in 1889\. Walker became a successful citrus grower, and the house became a center of community life in San Dimas and the East [San Gabriel Valley](/wiki/San_Gabriel_Valley "San Gabriel Valley"). Many of the area's clubs and social groups met at the home, and it was also the site of the first school and the first church services in San Dimas. For 90 years from 1889 to 1978, six generations of the Walker family lived at the converted hotel. From the 1910s through the 1960s, the home was occupied by Mrs. Raymond I. Carruthers, the granddaughter of James M. Walker. During this time, the house was commonly known as the "Carruthers Home." In 1961, Mrs. Carruthers noted that the cost of upkeep was enormous: "Anytime I have a repair bill, I feel as if it is a hotel." She died in August 1967\.
Even in the mid\-1970s, the Walker\-Carruthers\-Brunner family preserved the old structure. In 1975, residents of the house included Jim Carruthers, his sister, Sue Brunner, her husband, Fred Brunner, and their children. The old hotel desk, decorated with [wood turnings](/wiki/Wood_turning "Wood turning"), still sat at the base of the large staircase. In 2005, an old resident of San Dimas recalled that a butler wearing a tuxedo and white gloves would greet guests at the mansion.{{cite news\|author\=Karen Rubin\|title\=Landmark in distress\|publisher\=San Gabriel Valley Tribune\|date\=2005\-06\-13}}
### Conversion to restaurant
In 1979, the house was leased to Don Wilcott, who renamed the property the "San Dimas Mansion" and opened an elegant dining restaurant called the Mansion Inn.{{cite news\|author\=Taylor Kingsbury\|title\=Walker House Captures San Dimas' Past\|publisher\=LaVerne Magazine\|date\=Summer 2003}} Extensive changes were made to the structure to accommodate the restaurant. The restaurant was a success for a time, serving meals to [John Wayne](/wiki/John_Wayne "John Wayne") and [Richard Nixon](/wiki/Richard_Nixon "Richard Nixon"), though it closed in the late 1980s. The Carruthers family remained the owners and leased the old mansion for private functions for several years.
### Vacancy and restoration
The building was vacant starting in 1997\. In 1998, the San Dimas Festival of Western Arts acquired a lease\-option on the property, which was later assigned to the City of San Dimas. The City eventually purchased the house in 2000\. During the decade that the house was left vacant, area residents and preservationists complained that "the single most historical building in the city" was being left to rot. The City of San Dimas purchased the property and undertook an extensive plan to renovate the structure as a community asset for use by the San Dimas Festival of Arts and other community organizations. The renovation and construction work got under way in 2007 and was expected to be completed by the end of 2008\.{{cite web\|title\=Walker House\|publisher\=City of San Dimas\|url\=http://www.cityofsandimas.com/ps.quicklinks.cfm?ID\=1535}} The cost of the renovation was $6\.5 million, with a portion being funded by a preservation grant from the [J. Paul Getty Trust](/wiki/J._Paul_Getty_Trust "J. Paul Getty Trust").
|
[
"Architecture and history\n------------------------",
"### Construction as a railroad hotel",
"The San Dimas Hotel was built as a \"railroad hotel\" on land that was part of the San Jose Rancho. In 1885, the transcontinental [Santa Fe Railway](/wiki/Santa_Fe_Railway \"Santa Fe Railway\") completed its tracks between Los Angeles and [San Bernardino](/wiki/San_Bernardino%2C_California \"San Bernardino, California\"), and there were expectations that a land boom would develop along the path of the railroad. In anticipation of the boom, the San Jose Ranch Co., a company operated by Moses Wicks and other investors, built the San Dimas Hotel. It was one of many hotels built in each town along the railroad between Pasadena and San Bernardino.{{cite news\\|author\\=Nisha Gutierrez\\|title\\=Historic hotel never had a real guest\\|publisher\\=San Gabriel Valley Tribune\\|date\\=2006\\-05\\-22}} It was only the second building in San Dimas, and is reported to be the only surviving 1880s era railroad hotel in Southern California.",
"The owners hired one of the state's most prestigious architects, Joseph Cather Newsom, to design the structure. Newsom and his brother, [Samuel](/wiki/Samuel_Newsom \"Samuel Newsom\"), created the firm Newsom \\& Newsom and built many prestigious buildings throughout California in the late 19th century, including the [Carson Mansion](/wiki/Carson_Mansion \"Carson Mansion\") in [Eureka, California](/wiki/Eureka%2C_California \"Eureka, California\").{{Cite web\\|last\\=\\|first\\=\\|date\\=\\|title\\=Walker House\\|url\\=https://www.laconservancy.org/locations/walker\\-house\\|archive\\-url\\=\\|archive\\-date\\=\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-01\\-09\\|website\\=Los Angeles Conservancy}} The lumber used to build the hotel was floated down the coast from [Oregon](/wiki/Oregon \"Oregon\") and [Northern California](/wiki/Northern_California \"Northern California\") on large lumber rafts, and hauled from [San Pedro](/wiki/San_Pedro%2C_Los_Angeles%2C_California \"San Pedro, Los Angeles, California\") to San Dimas. The [Victorian architecture](/wiki/Victorian_architecture \"Victorian architecture\") [Queen Anne style](/wiki/Queen_Anne_style_architecture \"Queen Anne style architecture\") structure had {{convert\\|15000\\|sqft\\|m2}} and was completed in 1887\\. It was designed with a variety of surface materials, including diamond patterned shingles. Ten tons of shingles were used on the gable roof. It also had a sunburst medallion, an ornamental [cupola](/wiki/Cupola \"Cupola\"), balconies, corner towers, seven chimneys for 14 fireplaces, a large front porch, {{convert\\|140\\|ft\\|m}} of [veranda](/wiki/Veranda \"Veranda\"), {{convert\\|12\\|ft\\|m\\|adj\\=on}} ceilings, 18 bedrooms (33 rooms in all), and colored glass windows.",
"However, by the time the hotel was completed, an economic depression had hit Southern California, and the hotel never had any paying guests.{{cite news\\|author\\=Ann Frank\\|title\\=Sheltered Six Generations: Hotel That Never Had Guests San Dimas Landmark Since 1887\\|work\\=Los Angeles Times\\|date\\=1961\\-09\\-21}} Its original occupants were Moses Wicks and his partners in the San Jose Ranch Co.{{cite news\\|author\\=Ursula Vils\\|title\\=Home Sweet Home Is a Hotel\\|work\\=Los Angeles Times\\|date\\=1975\\-08\\-18}} In April 1889, the *Los Angeles Times* described the hotel as \"one of the boom enterprises that never paid as an investment, because there was no need of a hotel there.\"{{cite news\\|title\\=For and Odd Fellows' Home: A Project to Purchase the San Dimas Hotel\\|work\\=Los Angeles Times\\|date\\=1889\\-04\\-25}} At that time, the owner, Mr. Wicks, was in negotiations to sell the property to the [Odd Fellows](/wiki/Odd_Fellows \"Odd Fellows\") for use as \"an eleemosynary institution.\"",
"### Ninety years as the Walker and Carruthers family home",
"James W. Walker, a prosperous merchant from Kentucky, purchased the hotel and {{convert\\|40\\|acre\\|m2}} surrounding for use as his family home in 1889\\. Walker became a successful citrus grower, and the house became a center of community life in San Dimas and the East [San Gabriel Valley](/wiki/San_Gabriel_Valley \"San Gabriel Valley\"). Many of the area's clubs and social groups met at the home, and it was also the site of the first school and the first church services in San Dimas. For 90 years from 1889 to 1978, six generations of the Walker family lived at the converted hotel. From the 1910s through the 1960s, the home was occupied by Mrs. Raymond I. Carruthers, the granddaughter of James M. Walker. During this time, the house was commonly known as the \"Carruthers Home.\" In 1961, Mrs. Carruthers noted that the cost of upkeep was enormous: \"Anytime I have a repair bill, I feel as if it is a hotel.\" She died in August 1967\\.",
"Even in the mid\\-1970s, the Walker\\-Carruthers\\-Brunner family preserved the old structure. In 1975, residents of the house included Jim Carruthers, his sister, Sue Brunner, her husband, Fred Brunner, and their children. The old hotel desk, decorated with [wood turnings](/wiki/Wood_turning \"Wood turning\"), still sat at the base of the large staircase. In 2005, an old resident of San Dimas recalled that a butler wearing a tuxedo and white gloves would greet guests at the mansion.{{cite news\\|author\\=Karen Rubin\\|title\\=Landmark in distress\\|publisher\\=San Gabriel Valley Tribune\\|date\\=2005\\-06\\-13}}",
"### Conversion to restaurant",
"In 1979, the house was leased to Don Wilcott, who renamed the property the \"San Dimas Mansion\" and opened an elegant dining restaurant called the Mansion Inn.{{cite news\\|author\\=Taylor Kingsbury\\|title\\=Walker House Captures San Dimas' Past\\|publisher\\=LaVerne Magazine\\|date\\=Summer 2003}} Extensive changes were made to the structure to accommodate the restaurant. The restaurant was a success for a time, serving meals to [John Wayne](/wiki/John_Wayne \"John Wayne\") and [Richard Nixon](/wiki/Richard_Nixon \"Richard Nixon\"), though it closed in the late 1980s. The Carruthers family remained the owners and leased the old mansion for private functions for several years.",
"### Vacancy and restoration",
"The building was vacant starting in 1997\\. In 1998, the San Dimas Festival of Western Arts acquired a lease\\-option on the property, which was later assigned to the City of San Dimas. The City eventually purchased the house in 2000\\. During the decade that the house was left vacant, area residents and preservationists complained that \"the single most historical building in the city\" was being left to rot. The City of San Dimas purchased the property and undertook an extensive plan to renovate the structure as a community asset for use by the San Dimas Festival of Arts and other community organizations. The renovation and construction work got under way in 2007 and was expected to be completed by the end of 2008\\.{{cite web\\|title\\=Walker House\\|publisher\\=City of San Dimas\\|url\\=http://www.cityofsandimas.com/ps.quicklinks.cfm?ID\\=1535}} The cost of the renovation was $6\\.5 million, with a portion being funded by a preservation grant from the [J. Paul Getty Trust](/wiki/J._Paul_Getty_Trust \"J. Paul Getty Trust\").",
""
] |
History
-------
In 1916, hairdresser [Charles Jundt](/wiki/Charles_Jundt "Charles Jundt") took over the [Manhattan](/wiki/Manhattan "Manhattan") beauty salon of the New York City Ritz (later the [Ritz\-Carlton](/wiki/Ritz-Carlton_Hotel_%28New_York%29 "Ritz-Carlton Hotel (New York)")) hotel. He founded his own cosmetics company in 1919, and in 1926, began marketing beauty products under the name "Charles of the Ritz". Perfume was added to this line in 1927\.
In 1932, at the age of 24, Richard B. Salomon was named president of Charles of the Ritz, Inc. Twenty years later, he was elected chairman and chief executive officer. Salomon became known internationally as a businessman, philanthropist and humanitarian. He also served as chancellor of [Brown University](/wiki/Brown_University "Brown University") from 1979\-88\.
In 1935, Charles of the Ritz launched the highly successful Jean Naté line of body splashes and fragrance. They later acquired the cosmetics company Alexandra de Markoff.
### Expansion
Charles of the Ritz expanded distribution from upscale salons into upper\-end [department stores](/wiki/Department_store "Department store") like [Saks Fifth Avenue](/wiki/Saks_Fifth_Avenue "Saks Fifth Avenue") and [Neiman Marcus](/wiki/Neiman_Marcus "Neiman Marcus"). In the early 1950s, he was said to have mocked [Estée Lauder](/wiki/Est%C3%A9e_Lauder_%28person%29 "Estée Lauder (person)") and her practice of free samples and gifts with purchase, saying "You will never go anywhere in this industry."
In 1963, Ritz acquired 80% of the house of [Yves Saint Laurent](/wiki/Yves_Saint_Laurent_%28brand%29 "Yves Saint Laurent (brand)"). Ritz launched an entire line of skincare and makeup under the Yves Saint Laurent Beaute brand. In 1964 Charles of the Ritz merged with the [Lanvin](/wiki/Lanvin_%28clothing%29 "Lanvin (clothing)") group. It was from then on known as Lanvin\-Charles of the Ritz. In 1969 the prominent makeup artist [Way Bandy](/wiki/Way_Bandy "Way Bandy") joined Charles of the Ritz as the salon director of makeup.
### Ownership changes
In 1972, Richard B. Salomon retired, and the company was acquired by [pharmaceutical](/wiki/Pharmaceutical "Pharmaceutical") company [E.R. Squibb](/wiki/Bristol-Myers_Squibb "Bristol-Myers Squibb"), with a market value of $100 million.
In 1977, Yves Saint Laurent Beaute launched [Opium](/wiki/Opium_%28perfume%29 "Opium (perfume)"). In 1978, Ritz introduced a new women's fragrance, Enjoli, designed (as noted in its popular [television commercials](/wiki/Television_commercial "Television commercial")) as "the eight hour perfume for the 24\-hour woman"; the commercial's theme song was a remake of [Peggy Lee](/wiki/Peggy_Lee "Peggy Lee")'s 1963 hit song "[I'm A Woman](/wiki/I%27m_a_Woman_%28song%29 "I'm a Woman (song)")". In 1984 Charles of the Ritz launched Forever Krystle and Carrington, successful fragrances based on American television drama *[Dynasty](/wiki/Dynasty_%281981_TV_series%29 "Dynasty (1981 TV series)")* characters.
In 1986, Squibb sold the entire division back to Yves Saint Laurent for $500 million, who invested heavily in a new men's fragrance called Jazz. Jazz was not particularly successful and, coupled with the October 1987 market crash, Yves Saint Laurent sold Charles of the Ritz Incorporated (excluding Yves Saint Laurent Beaute) to [Revlon](/wiki/Revlon "Revlon") in 1987\. Still reeling from its unsuccessful takeover attempt of [Gillette](/wiki/Gillette "Gillette") in 1983, Revlon declared they were interested in several acquisitions and also bought [Max Factor](/wiki/Max_Factor "Max Factor"), [Almay](/wiki/Almay "Almay"), [Halston](/wiki/Halston "Halston"), [Borghese](/wiki/Borghese "Borghese"), and [Germaine Monteil](/wiki/Germaine_Monteil "Germaine Monteil").
Under Revlon, the brand Charles of the Ritz began to slip in image and prestige. In 1991 they launched a line called Express, aimed at a more savvy customer. The brand became associated with mid\-price stores like [J. C. Penney](/wiki/J._C._Penney "J. C. Penney") and maintained a focus on the "mature" customer. After several years of unsuccessful revival attempts (including an endorsement deal with [Kathie Lee Gifford](/wiki/Kathie_Lee_Gifford "Kathie Lee Gifford") for their Timeless line) and facing massive debt, Revlon put (among many others) the line for sale, but had no takers. Analysts suggested the very name — Charles of the Ritz — lacked consumer recognition.
### Demise
Revlon shut down Charles of the Ritz in 2002\.{{Cite web\|title\=Cosmetics and Skin: Charles of the Ritz (post\-1936\)\|url\=http://www.cosmeticsandskin.com/companies/charles\-ritz\-1936\.php\|access\-date\=2020\-07\-06\|website\=www.cosmeticsandskin.com}} Many of the former Ritz fragrances, such as Enjoli, are sold today under the Revlon name.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"In 1916, hairdresser [Charles Jundt](/wiki/Charles_Jundt \"Charles Jundt\") took over the [Manhattan](/wiki/Manhattan \"Manhattan\") beauty salon of the New York City Ritz (later the [Ritz\\-Carlton](/wiki/Ritz-Carlton_Hotel_%28New_York%29 \"Ritz-Carlton Hotel (New York)\")) hotel. He founded his own cosmetics company in 1919, and in 1926, began marketing beauty products under the name \"Charles of the Ritz\". Perfume was added to this line in 1927\\.",
"In 1932, at the age of 24, Richard B. Salomon was named president of Charles of the Ritz, Inc. Twenty years later, he was elected chairman and chief executive officer. Salomon became known internationally as a businessman, philanthropist and humanitarian. He also served as chancellor of [Brown University](/wiki/Brown_University \"Brown University\") from 1979\\-88\\.",
"In 1935, Charles of the Ritz launched the highly successful Jean Naté line of body splashes and fragrance. They later acquired the cosmetics company Alexandra de Markoff.",
"### Expansion",
"Charles of the Ritz expanded distribution from upscale salons into upper\\-end [department stores](/wiki/Department_store \"Department store\") like [Saks Fifth Avenue](/wiki/Saks_Fifth_Avenue \"Saks Fifth Avenue\") and [Neiman Marcus](/wiki/Neiman_Marcus \"Neiman Marcus\"). In the early 1950s, he was said to have mocked [Estée Lauder](/wiki/Est%C3%A9e_Lauder_%28person%29 \"Estée Lauder (person)\") and her practice of free samples and gifts with purchase, saying \"You will never go anywhere in this industry.\"",
"In 1963, Ritz acquired 80% of the house of [Yves Saint Laurent](/wiki/Yves_Saint_Laurent_%28brand%29 \"Yves Saint Laurent (brand)\"). Ritz launched an entire line of skincare and makeup under the Yves Saint Laurent Beaute brand. In 1964 Charles of the Ritz merged with the [Lanvin](/wiki/Lanvin_%28clothing%29 \"Lanvin (clothing)\") group. It was from then on known as Lanvin\\-Charles of the Ritz. In 1969 the prominent makeup artist [Way Bandy](/wiki/Way_Bandy \"Way Bandy\") joined Charles of the Ritz as the salon director of makeup.",
"### Ownership changes",
"In 1972, Richard B. Salomon retired, and the company was acquired by [pharmaceutical](/wiki/Pharmaceutical \"Pharmaceutical\") company [E.R. Squibb](/wiki/Bristol-Myers_Squibb \"Bristol-Myers Squibb\"), with a market value of $100 million.",
"In 1977, Yves Saint Laurent Beaute launched [Opium](/wiki/Opium_%28perfume%29 \"Opium (perfume)\"). In 1978, Ritz introduced a new women's fragrance, Enjoli, designed (as noted in its popular [television commercials](/wiki/Television_commercial \"Television commercial\")) as \"the eight hour perfume for the 24\\-hour woman\"; the commercial's theme song was a remake of [Peggy Lee](/wiki/Peggy_Lee \"Peggy Lee\")'s 1963 hit song \"[I'm A Woman](/wiki/I%27m_a_Woman_%28song%29 \"I'm a Woman (song)\")\". In 1984 Charles of the Ritz launched Forever Krystle and Carrington, successful fragrances based on American television drama *[Dynasty](/wiki/Dynasty_%281981_TV_series%29 \"Dynasty (1981 TV series)\")* characters.",
"In 1986, Squibb sold the entire division back to Yves Saint Laurent for $500 million, who invested heavily in a new men's fragrance called Jazz. Jazz was not particularly successful and, coupled with the October 1987 market crash, Yves Saint Laurent sold Charles of the Ritz Incorporated (excluding Yves Saint Laurent Beaute) to [Revlon](/wiki/Revlon \"Revlon\") in 1987\\. Still reeling from its unsuccessful takeover attempt of [Gillette](/wiki/Gillette \"Gillette\") in 1983, Revlon declared they were interested in several acquisitions and also bought [Max Factor](/wiki/Max_Factor \"Max Factor\"), [Almay](/wiki/Almay \"Almay\"), [Halston](/wiki/Halston \"Halston\"), [Borghese](/wiki/Borghese \"Borghese\"), and [Germaine Monteil](/wiki/Germaine_Monteil \"Germaine Monteil\").",
"Under Revlon, the brand Charles of the Ritz began to slip in image and prestige. In 1991 they launched a line called Express, aimed at a more savvy customer. The brand became associated with mid\\-price stores like [J. C. Penney](/wiki/J._C._Penney \"J. C. Penney\") and maintained a focus on the \"mature\" customer. After several years of unsuccessful revival attempts (including an endorsement deal with [Kathie Lee Gifford](/wiki/Kathie_Lee_Gifford \"Kathie Lee Gifford\") for their Timeless line) and facing massive debt, Revlon put (among many others) the line for sale, but had no takers. Analysts suggested the very name — Charles of the Ritz — lacked consumer recognition.",
"### Demise",
"Revlon shut down Charles of the Ritz in 2002\\.{{Cite web\\|title\\=Cosmetics and Skin: Charles of the Ritz (post\\-1936\\)\\|url\\=http://www.cosmeticsandskin.com/companies/charles\\-ritz\\-1936\\.php\\|access\\-date\\=2020\\-07\\-06\\|website\\=www.cosmeticsandskin.com}} Many of the former Ritz fragrances, such as Enjoli, are sold today under the Revlon name.",
""
] |
2019 events
-----------
### Inauguration of Maduro
In January 2019, [Leopoldo López](/wiki/Leopoldo_L%C3%B3pez "Leopoldo López")'s [Popular Will](/wiki/Popular_Will "Popular Will") party attained the leadership of the [National Assembly of Venezuela](/wiki/National_Assembly_%28Venezuela%29 "National Assembly (Venezuela)") according to a rotation agreement made by opposition parties, naming [Juan Guaidó](/wiki/Juan_Guaid%C3%B3 "Juan Guaidó") as [president of the legislative body](/wiki/President_of_the_National_Assembly_of_Venezuela "President of the National Assembly of Venezuela").{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|p\=210 \|loc\= Chapter 23: "Swearing In"}}
[left\|thumb\|Juan Guaidó surrounded by members of the opposition during the public assembly on 11 January 2019](/wiki/File:Juan_Guaid%C3%B3_open_cabildo_11_January_2019.jpg "Juan Guaidó open cabildo 11 January 2019.jpg")
Guaidó began motions to form a [provisional government](/wiki/Provisional_government "Provisional government") shortly after assuming his new role on 5 January 2019, stating that whether or not Maduro began his new term on the 10th, the country would not have a legitimately elected president in either case,{{cite web \|title\=Asamblea Nacional arranca proceso para Ley de Transicion \|url\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\_asamblea\-nacional\-arranca\-proceso\-para\-ley\-de\-transicion \|url\-status\=live \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190109052303/http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\_asamblea\-nacional\-arranca\-proceso\-para\-ley\-de\-transicion \|archive\-date\=9 January 2019 \|access\-date\=10 January 2019}}{{Primary source inline\|date\=September 2023}} calling for soldiers to "enforce the Constitution"{{cite web \|title\=AN se declara en emergencia ante la usurpación de Nicolás Maduro en el cargo de la Presidencia de la República \|url\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\_an\-se\-declara\-en\-emergencia\-ante\-la\-usurpacion\-de\-nicolas\-maduro\-en\-el\-cargo\-de\-la\-presidencia\-de\-la \|url\-status\=live \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111021840/http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\_an\-se\-declara\-en\-emergencia\-ante\-la\-usurpacion\-de\-nicolas\-maduro\-en\-el\-cargo\-de\-la\-presidencia\-de\-la \|archive\-date\=11 January 2019 \|access\-date\=10 January 2019 \|website\=Asambleanacional.gob.ve \|language\=es}}{{Primary source inline\|date\=September 2023}} Signs of impending crisis showed when a [Supreme Court](/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_Venezuela "Supreme Court of Venezuela") Justice and Electoral Justice seen as close to Maduro defected to the United States just a few days before the 10 January 2019 [second inauguration of Nicolás Maduro](/wiki/Second_inauguration_of_Nicol%C3%A1s_Maduro "Second inauguration of Nicolás Maduro"). The justice, {{ill\|Christian Zerpa\|es\|Christian Zerpa}}, said that Maduro was "incompetent" and "illegitimate".{{cite news \|date\=10 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela Swears in an illegitimate President \|website\=Financial Times \|url\=https://www.ft.com/content/401e52a0\-1405\-11e9\-a581\-4ff78404524e \|access\-date\=11 January 2019}}{{Cite news \|last1\=Herrero \|first1\=Ana Vanessa \|last2\=Specia \|first2\=Megan \|date\=10 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela Is in Crisis. So How Did Maduro Secure a Second Term? \|newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]] \|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/10/world/americas/venezuela\-maduro\-inauguration.html \|url\-status\=live \|access\-date\=11 January 2019 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111012015/https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/10/world/americas/venezuela\-maduro\-inauguration.html \|archive\-date\=11 January 2019 \|issn\=0362\-4331}}
{{cite web \|title\=Peru, Paraguay recall diplomats over Maduro inauguration {{!}} Venezuela News \|url\=https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/peru\-paraguay\-recall\-diplomats\-maduro\-inauguration\-190110180310100\.html \|url\-status\=live \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190110232447/https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/peru\-paraguay\-recall\-diplomats\-maduro\-inauguration\-190110180310100\.html \|archive\-date\=10 January 2019 \|access\-date\=11 January 2019 \|website\=Aljazeera.com}}* Minutes after Maduro took the oath as president of Venezuela, the OAS approved a resolution in a special session of its Permanent Council declaring Maduro's presidency illegitimate and urging new elections.{{cite news \|date\=10 January 2019 \|title\=La OEA aprobó la resolución que declara ilegítimo al nuevo gobierno de Nicolás Maduro \|language\=es \|trans\-title\=The OAS approved the resolution that declared the new government of Nicolás Maduro illegitimate \|work\=Infobae \|url\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/01/10/en\-vivo\-la\-oea\-debate\-en\-sesion\-extraordinaria\-la\-asuncion\-de\-nicolas\-maduro/}} Maduro's election was supported by Turkey, Russia, China, and the Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of Our America ([ALBA](/wiki/ALBA "ALBA")).
Guaidó announced a public assembly, referred to as an [open cabildo](/wiki/Open_cabildo "Open cabildo"), on 11 January, a rally in the streets of Caracas, where Guaidó spoke on behalf of the National Assembly saying that the country had fallen into a *[de facto](/wiki/De_facto "De facto")* dictatorship and had no leader.{{cite web \|last\=Smith \|first\=Scott \|date\=10 January 2019 \|title\=Isolation greets Maduro's new term as Venezuela's president \|url\=https://apnews.com/f1df9924783f49859874f5fc97f0f534 \|url\-status\=live \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111004811/https://apnews.com/f1df9924783f49859874f5fc97f0f534 \|archive\-date\=11 January 2019 \|access\-date\=11 January 2019 \|website\=AP News}}{{cite web \|title\=El Tiempo {{!}} Venezuela {{!}} Asamblea Nacional se declaró en emergencia y convocó a cabildo abierto {{!}} El Periódico del Pueblo Oriental \|url\=https://eltiempo.com.ve/2019/01/10/asamblea\-nacional\-se\-declaro\-en\-emergencia\-y\-convoco\-a\-cabildo\-abierto/ \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111175356/https://eltiempo.com.ve/2019/01/10/asamblea\-nacional\-se\-declaro\-en\-emergencia\-y\-convoco\-a\-cabildo\-abierto/ \|archive\-date\=11 January 2019 \|access\-date\=11 January 2019 \|website\=eltiempo.com.ve \|publisher\=Global Host \|language\=es}} Guaidó said that the National Assembly would "take the responsibility that touches us". Leaders of other political parties, trade unions, women, and students also spoke at the rally.{{cite web \|date\=11 January 2019 \|title\=Juan Guaidó: Me apego a los artículos 333, 350 y 233 para lograr el cese de la usurpación y convocar elecciones libres con la unión del pueblo, FAN y comunidad internacional \|url\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\_juan\-guaido\-me\-apego\-a\-los\-articulos\-333\-350\-y\-233 \|access\-date\=11 January 2019 \|work\=Asamblea Nacional de la República Bolivariana de Venezuela \|language\=es}}{{Primary source inline\|date\=September 2023}} The opposition considered assuming the powers of the executive branch legitimate based on constitutional processes; The National Assembly specifically invoked Articles 233, 333, and 350 of the Constitution.{{Cite news \|author\=Phillips, Tom \|date\=11 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela: opposition leader declares himself ready to assume presidency \|newspaper\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/11/venezuela\-maduro\-juan\-guaido\-assume\-presidency \|url\-status\=live \|access\-date\=12 January 2019 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190113100401/https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/11/venezuela\-maduro\-juan\-guaido\-assume\-presidency \|archive\-date\=13 January 2019 \|issn\=0261\-3077}} Guaidó announced [nationwide protests](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests "2019 Venezuelan protests") to be held on 23 January—the same day as the [removal of Marcos Pérez Jiménez in 1958](/wiki/1958_Venezuelan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat "1958 Venezuelan coup d'état")—using a slogan chant of *¡[Sí se puede](/wiki/S%C3%AD_se_puede "Sí se puede")!*.{{cite web \|date\=11 January 2019 \|title\=Parallel government emerging in Venezuela \|url\=https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news/1826647\-parallel\-government\-emerging\-in\-venezuela\-update \|access\-date\=12 January 2019 \|website\=Argus Media}} The National Assembly worked with the coalition *Frente Amplio Venezuela Libre* to create a plan for the demonstrations, organizing a unified national force.{{cite web \|date\=12 January 2019 \|title\=Juan Guaidó y FAVL afinan agenda única para movilización del 23Ene \|url\=https://www.analitica.com/actualidad/actualidad\-nacional/juan\-guaido\-y\-favl\-afinan\-agenda\-unica\-para\-movilizacion\-del\-23ene/ \|access\-date\=12 January 2019 \|website\=Analitica \|language\=es}} On 11 January, plans to offer incentives for the armed forces to disavow Maduro were announced.{{Cite news \|date\=11 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela opposition plans incentives for officers who disavow Maduro \|website\=Uk.reuters.com \|url\=https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk\-venezuela\-military\-idUKKCN1P52HF \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190112065020/https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk\-venezuela\-military\-idUKKCN1P52HF \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-date\=12 January 2019 \|access\-date\=11 January 2019}}
#### Guaidó declared acting president
[thumb\|Agreement approved by the National Assembly to declare the usurpation of the presidency by Nicolás Maduro on 15 January 2019\.During](/wiki/File:Acuerdo_sobre_la_declaratoria_de_usurpaci%C3%B3n_de_la_presidencia_de_la_rep%C3%BAblica_por_parte_de_Nicolas_Maduro_Moros_y_el_restablecimiento_de_la_vigencia_de_la_constituci%C3%B3n_-_P%C3%A1gina_1.jpg "Acuerdo sobre la declaratoria de usurpación de la presidencia de la república por parte de Nicolas Maduro Moros y el restablecimiento de la vigencia de la constitución - Página 1.jpg") Guaidó's speech, he said he was "willing to assume command ... only possible with the help of Venezuelans". Following Guaidó's speech, the National Assembly released a press statement saying that Guaidó had assumed the role of acting president. The Assembly retracted the statement later published another clarifying Guaidó's position as "willing to assume command ... only possible with the help of Venezuelans".
Maduro's response was to call the opposition a group of "little boys", describing Guaidó as "immature". The Minister for Prison Services, [Iris Varela](/wiki/Iris_Varela "Iris Varela"), threatened that she had picked out a prison cell for Guaidó and asked him to be quick in naming his cabinet so she could prepare prison cells for them as well.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/venezuela\-congress\-leader\-challenges\-maduro\-presidency\-190111181122362\.html\|title\=Venezuela congress leader challenges Maduro's right to presidency\|website\=Al Jazeera\|access\-date\=12 January 2019}}
The president of the [Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela in exile](/wiki/Supreme_Tribunal_of_Justice_of_Venezuela_in_exile "Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela in exile"), based in Panama, wrote to Guaidó, requesting him to become acting president of Venezuela.{{cite web \|date\=12 January 2019 \|title\=Tribunal Supremo de Justicia pide a Asamblea Nacional tomar la presidencia de Venezuela \|url\=https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/internacional/557234/tribunal\-supremo\-de\-justicia\-pide\-a\-asamblea\-nacional\-tomar\-la\-presidencia\-de\-venezuela/ \|access\-date\=12 January 2019 \|website\=El Salvador noticias \|language\=es}} OAS Secretary\-General [Luis Almagro](/wiki/Luis_Almagro "Luis Almagro") was the first to give international official support to Guaidó's claim, tweeting "We welcome the assumption of Juan Guaidó as interim president of Venezuela in accordance with Article 233 of the Political Constitution. You have our support, that of the international community and of the people of Venezuela." Later that day, Brazil and Colombia gave their support to Guaidó as acting president of Venezuela.{{cite web \|title\=Juan Guaidó se declara presidente da venezuela e tem apoio do brasil \|url\=https://veja.abril.com.br/mundo/juan\-guaido\-se\-declara\-presidente\-da\-venezuela\-e\-tem\-apoio\-do\-brasil/ \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190112180134/https://veja.abril.com.br/mundo/juan\-guaido\-se\-declara\-presidente\-da\-venezuela\-e\-tem\-apoio\-do\-brasil/ \|archive\-date\=12 January 2019 \|access\-date\=12 January 2019 \|website\=VEJA \|language\=es}}
#### Guaidó briefly detained, plans continue
{{see also\|2019 Venezuelan protests}}
Guaidó was detained on 13 January by the [Bolivarian Intelligence Service](/wiki/Bolivarian_Intelligence_Service "Bolivarian Intelligence Service") (SEBIN){{cite web \|last\=Semana \|date\=3 August 2003 \|title\=Alejandro Baena, candidato liberal a la alcaldía de Cali \|url\=https://www.semana.com/noticias/articulo/alejandro\-baena\-candidato\-liberal\-alcaldia\-cali/59772\-3 \|website\=Alejandro Baena, candidato liberal a la alcaldía de Cali}} and released 45 minutes later.{{cite news \|title\=Venezuela's opposition is gambling it all on a young and untested activist named Juan Guaidó \|newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]] \|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\_americas/venezuelas\-opposition\-is\-gambling\-it\-all\-on\-a\-young\-and\-untested\-activist\-named\-juan\-guaido/2019/01/14/90156b76\-16a4\-11e9\-ab79\-30cd4f7926f2\_story.html \|access\-date\=15 January 2019}} The SEBIN agents who intercepted his car and took him into custody were fired.{{Cite news \|date\=13 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela opposition leader briefly detained \|work\=\[\[BBC News]] \|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-latin\-america\-46857643 \|access\-date\=14 January 2019}}{{cite news \|date\=13 January 2019 \|title\=Gobierno Maduro destituyó a agentes que detuvieron a Juan Guaidó en un procedimiento "irregular" \|language\=es \|publisher\=Noticias Caracol \|agency\=EFE \|url\=https://noticias.caracoltv.com/mundo/gobierno\-maduro\-destituyo\-agentes\-que\-detuvieron\-juan\-guaido\-en\-un\-procedimiento\-irregular \|access\-date\=15 January 2019}} The Information Minister, [Jorge Rodríguez](/wiki/Jorge_Rodr%C3%ADguez_%28Venezuelan_politician%29 "Jorge Rodríguez (Venezuelan politician)"), said the agents did not have instructions and the arrest was orchestrated by Guaidó as a "media stunt" to gain popularity; [BBC News](/wiki/BBC_News "BBC News") correspondents said that it appeared to be a genuine ambush to send a message to the opposition. Almagro condemned the arrest, which he called a "kidnapping", while Pompeo referred to it as an "arbitrary detention".{{Cite news \|author\=Phillips, Tom \|date\=13 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela opposition leader briefly detained after challenging Maduro \|newspaper\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/13/venezuela\-opposition\-leader\-briefly\-detained\-juan\-guaido\-maduro \|access\-date\=14 January 2019 \|issn\=0261\-3077}} After his detention, Guaidó said that Rodríguez's admission that the SEBIN agents acted independently showed that the government had lost control of its security forces; he called [Miraflores](/wiki/Miraflores_Palace "Miraflores Palace") (the presidential palace) "desperate", and stated: "There is one legitimate president of the National Assembly and of all Venezuela."{{cite web \|date\=13 January 2019 \|title\=Juan Guaidó desde Vargas: 'Hay un presidente legítimo de la AN y de toda Venezuela' \|trans\-title\=Juan Guaidó from Vargas: 'There is a legitimate president of the NA and of all Venezuela' \|url\=https://albertonews.com/principales/juan\-guaido\-desde\-vargas\-hay\-un\-presidente\-legitimo\-de\-la\-an\-y\-de\-toda\-venezuela/ \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190114153207/https://albertonews.com/principales/juan\-guaido\-desde\-vargas\-hay\-un\-presidente\-legitimo\-de\-la\-an\-y\-de\-toda\-venezuela/ \|archive\-date\=14 January 2019 \|access\-date\=13 May 2019 \|website\=albertonews.com}}
On 15 January 2019, the National Assembly approved legislation to work with dozens of foreign countries to request that these nations freeze Maduro administration bank accounts.{{cite news \|date\=15 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela congress asks foreign countries to freeze Maduro\-linked accounts \|work\=Reuters \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-freeze\-idUSKCN1P92G3 \|access\-date\=15 January 2019}} Guaidó wrote a 15 January 2019 opinion piece in *[The Washington Post](/wiki/The_Washington_Post "The Washington Post")* entitled "Maduro is a usurper. It's time to restore [democracy in Venezuela](/wiki/Democracy_in_Venezuela "Democracy in Venezuela")"; he outlined Venezuela's erosion of democracy and his reasoning for the need to replace Maduro on an interim basis according to Venezuela's constitution.{{cite news \|author\=Guaidó, Juan \|title\=Maduro is a usurper. It's time to restore democracy in Venezuela. \|newspaper\=The Washington Post \|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/01/15/maduro\-is\-usurper\-its\-time\-restore\-democracy\-venezuela/?noredirect\=on \|access\-date\=20 January 2019}}
On 21 January, over two dozen National Guardsmen participated in a mutiny against Maduro with the assistance of residents in the area during the early morning hours. Government forces repressed the protestors tear gas and the officers were later captured.{{Cite news \|date\=21 January 2019 \|title\=Venezuela: Reprimen a vecinos que respaldan levantamiento militar contra Maduro \|language\=es \|website\=\[\[El Comercio (Peru)\|El Comercio]] \|url\=https://elcomercio.pe/mundo/venezuela/cotiza\-reprimen\-vecinos\-respaldan\-levantamiento\-guardia\-nacional\-bolivariana\-gnb\-nicolas\-maduro\-videos\-noticia\-599586\-noticia/ \|access\-date\=1 February 2020}}{{Cite news \|last\=Phillips \|first\=Tom \|date\=2019\-01\-22 \|title\=Venezuela claims it has foiled attempted military uprising \|language\=en\-GB \|work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/21/venezuela\-claims\-foiled\-attempted\-military\-uprising \|access\-date\=2019\-01\-22 \|issn\=0261\-3077}} During the night, over thirty communities in Caracas and surrounding areas participated in strong protests against the Maduro government.{{Cite web \|date\=2019\-01\-22 \|title\=Seguid el ejemplo que Caracas dio: Confirman protestas nocturnas contra Maduro en 30 comunidades capitalinas \|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/22/seguid\-el\-ejemplo\-que\-caracas\-dio\-confirman\-protestas\-nocturnas\-contra\-maduro\-en\-30\-comunidades\-capitalinas/ \|access\-date\=2019\-01\-22 \|website\=\[\[La Patilla]] \|language\=es\-ES}} The strongest protests occurred in San José de Cotiza, where the rebel National Guardsmen were arrested, with demonstrations spreading throughout nearby communities, with [cacerolazos](/wiki/Cacerolazo "Cacerolazo") heard throughout Caracas. One woman who was confused for a protester was killed in San José de Cotiza by members of a [colectivo](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 "Colectivo (Venezuela)"), who stole her phone.{{Cite web \|date\=2019\-01\-21 \|title\=Mujer fue asesinada en la puerta de su casa por un colectivo en Cotiza \|url\=http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/sucesos/mujer\-fue\-asesinada\-puerta\-casa\-por\-colectivo\-cotiza\_267452 \|access\-date\=2019\-01\-22 \|website\=\[\[El Nacional (Caracas)\|El Nacional]] \|language\=es}} On 22 January, Vice President [Mike Pence](/wiki/Mike_Pence "Mike Pence") called Guaidó personally and assured him that the United States would support his declaration.{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|pp\=211\-217 \|loc\= Chapter 23: "Swearing In"}}
### Guaidó declares himself acting president
[thumb\|left\|23 January 2019 march in Caracas](/wiki/File:23_Jan_2019_venezuela_protest_march_vid.webm "23 Jan 2019 venezuela protest march vid.webm")
On 23 January, Guaidó swore to serve as acting president. On that morning, Guaidó tweeted, "The world's eyes are on our homeland today."{{cite web \|url\= https://twitter.com/jguaido/status/1088048732967501824 \|publisher\= Twitter \|author\= Guaido, Juan \|title\= Juan Guaidó on Twitter \|date\= 23 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 7 February 2019}} On that day, millions of Venezuelans{{cite web\|url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/revolt\-in\-venezuela\-11548289111\|title\=Revolt in Venezuela\|newspaper\=\[\[Wall Street Journal]]\|access\-date\=24 January 2019\|date\= 23 January 2019}} demonstrated across the country and world in support of Guaidó,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\-america\-latina\-46979531 \|work\= BBC News Mundo \|language\=es \|title\= Protestas en Venezuela: miles de personas participan en manifestaciones masivas contra el gobierno de Maduro \|date\= 23 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 January 2019}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/01/24/las\-50\-fotos\-de\-las\-masivas\-marchas\-contra\-la\-dictadura\-de\-nicolas\-maduro\-en\-venezuela\-y\-latinoamerica/ \|language\=es \|title\= Las 50 fotos de las masivas marchas contra la dictadura de Nicolás Maduro en Venezuela y Latinoamérica \|work\= Infobae \|date\= 24 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 January 2019}} with a few hundred supporting Maduro outside Miraflores.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/23/americas/venezuela\-protests/index.html \|title\= Maduro defiant as Venezuelan opposition leader declares himself acting president \|author\= Sanchez, Ray and Nicole Chavez \|work\= CNN \|date\= 23 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 January 2019}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/23/enezuela\-trump\-president\-juan\-guaido\-maduro\-recognition\-news\-latest\|title\=Venezuela: Trump recognises opposition leader as president\|last\=Daniels\|first\=Joe Parkin\|date\=23 January 2019\|newspaper\=\[\[The Guardian]]\|access\-date\=23 January 2019\|issn\=0261\-3077}} At one end of the blocked street was a stage where Guaidó spoke and took an oath to serve as interim president.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\-01\-23/venezuelans\-heed\-call\-to\-hit\-streets\-with\-maduro\-under\-pressure\|title\=Venezuelans heed call to hit the streets with Maduro under pressure\|website\=Bloomberg.com\|date\=23 January 2019 \|access\-date\=23 January 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\_americas/venezuela\-opposition\-leader\-juan\-guaido\-declares\-himself\-interim\-president\-before\-thousands\-cheering\-in\-support/2019/01/23/9f5e7f32\-1f37\-11e9\-a759\-2b8541bbbe20\_story.html\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190123180113/https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\_americas/venezuela\-opposition\-leader\-juan\-guaido\-declares\-himself\-interim\-president\-before\-thousands\-cheering\-in\-support/2019/01/23/9f5e7f32\-1f37\-11e9\-a759\-2b8541bbbe20\_story.html\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-date\=23 January 2019\|title\=Venezuela opposition leader Juan Guaido declares himself interim president before thousands cheering in support\|newspaper\=\[\[Washington Post]]\|access\-date\=23 January 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/americas/live\-news/venezuela\-protests\-2019/index.html\|title\=Violent protests in Venezuela: Live updates\|date\=23 January 2019\|website\=CNN\|access\-date\=23 January 2019}} Minutes after his speech, the United States announced that it recognized Guaidó as interim president while presidents [Iván Duque](/wiki/Iv%C3%A1n_Duque "Iván Duque") of Colombia and [Jair Bolsonaro](/wiki/Jair_Bolsonaro "Jair Bolsonaro") of Brazil, beside deputy Canadian prime minister [Chrystia Freeland](/wiki/Chrystia_Freeland "Chrystia Freeland"), announced at the [World Economic Forum](/wiki/World_Economic_Forum "World Economic Forum") that they too recognized him.{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|pp\=211\-217 \|loc\= Chapter 23: "Swearing In"}}
The [Venezuelan National Guard](/wiki/Venezuelan_National_Guard "Venezuelan National Guard") used tear gas on gathering crowds at other locations, and [blocked protesters from arriving](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests "2019 Venezuelan protests").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/23/venezuela\-protests\-thousands\-march\-against\-maduro\-as\-opposition\-sees\-chance\-for\-change\|title\=Venezuela protests: thousands march as military faces call to abandon Maduro\|author\=Daniels, Joe Parkin\|date\=23 January 2019\|newspaper\=\[\[The Guardian]]\|access\-date\=23 January 2019\|issn\=0261\-3077}} Some protests grew violent,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/gallery/2019/jan/24/venezuela\-protests\-as\-two\-leaders\-vie\-to\-be\-president\-in\-pictures\|title\=Venezuela protests as two leaders vie to be president – in pictures\|website\=The Guardian\|date\=24 January 2019 \|access\-date\=24 January 2019}} and at least 13 people were killed.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/23/reportan\-13\-fallecidos\-tras\-ultimas\-protestas\-en\-todo\-el\-pais\-23ene/\|title\=Reportan 13 fallecidos tras últimas protestas en todo el país \#23Ene\|date\=23 January 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=24 January 2019}} [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet "Michelle Bachelet") of the [United Nations](/wiki/United_Nations "United Nations") requested a UN investigation into the security forces' use of violence.{{cite web\|url\=https://edition.cnn.com/2019/01/25/americas/venezuela\-maduro\-guaido\-us\-embassy\-consulates/index.html\|title\=UN calls for Venezuela investigation\|website\=CNN\|date\=25 January 2019 \|access\-date\=25 January 2019}}
[thumb\|[Mike Pence](/wiki/Mike_Pence "Mike Pence") meets with Carlos Vecchio, [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges "Julio Borges"), and other Washington\-based Venezuelan representatives on 29 January 2019](/wiki/File:Mike_Pence_meets_with_Carlos_Vecchio%2C_Julio_Borges_y_Venezuelan_gov%27t_in_exile.png "Mike Pence meets with Carlos Vecchio, Julio Borges y Venezuelan gov't in exile.png")
Guaidó began to appoint individuals in late January to serve as aides or diplomats, including [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio "Carlos Vecchio") as the Guaidó administration's diplomatic envoy to the US,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-usa/trump\-administration\-accepts\-guaido\-ally\-as\-venezuela\-envoy\-in\-us\-idUSKCN1PL0TO \|title\= Trump administration accepts Guaido ally as Venezuela envoy in U.S.\|work\= Reuters \|date\= 27 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 27 January 2019}} [Gustavo Tarre](/wiki/Gustavo_Tarre "Gustavo Tarre") to the OAS,{{cite web \|url\= https://www.csis.org/events/conversation\-venezuelas\-new\-permanent\-representative\-oas\-special\-ambassador\-gustavo\-tarre \|publisher\= Center for Strategic and International Studies \|title\= A Conversation with Venezuela's New Permanent Representative to the OAS, Special Ambassador Gustavo Tarre \|date\= 29 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 29 January 2019}} and [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges "Julio Borges") to represent Venezuela in the [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group "Lima Group").{{cite news \|url\= http://noticias.alianzanews.com/309\_hispanic\-world/5924526\_venezuelan\-parliament\-oks\-guaido\-s\-diplomatic\-appointments.html \|title\= Venezuelan Parliament OKs Guaido's diplomatic appointments \|date\= 29 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 January 2019 \|work\= Alianza News \|archive\-date\= 30 January 2019 \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190130110641/http://noticias.alianzanews.com/309\_hispanic\-world/5924526\_venezuelan\-parliament\-oks\-guaido\-s\-diplomatic\-appointments.html \|url\-status\= dead }} He announced that the National Assembly had approved a commission to implement a plan for the reconstruction of Venezuela,{{cite news \|url\= https://elcomercio.pe/mundo/venezuela/juan\-guaido\-vivo\-presenta\-plan\-pais\-rescatar\-venezuela\-noticia\-603012 \|title\= En vivo: Juan Guaidó presenta su Plan País para rescatar a Venezuela \|work\= El Comercio \|date\= 31 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 31 January 2019}}{{cite news \|url\= http://caraboboesnoticia.com/instalada\-comision\-plan\-pais\-de\-la\-asamblea\-nacional/ \|language\= es \|work\= Caraboboes Noticia \|date\= 31 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 31 January 2019 \|title\= Instalada Comision Plan Pais de la Asamblea Nacional \|archive\-date\= 22 April 2019 \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190422193805/http://caraboboesnoticia.com/instalada\-comision\-plan\-pais\-de\-la\-asamblea\-nacional/ \|url\-status\= dead }} called [Plan País](/wiki/Plan_Pa%C3%ADs "Plan País") (Plan for the Country),{{cite news \|url\= https://www.univision.com/univision\-news/latin\-america/venezuelas\-guaido\-to\-announce\-national\-reconstruction\-plan\-for\-the\-day\-after \|date\= 30 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 February 2019 \|title\= Venezuela's Guaidó to announce national reconstruction plan 'for the day after' \|author\= Adams, David and Tamoa Calzadilla \|work\= Univision}} and he offered an [Amnesty law](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_Amnesty_Law "2019 Venezuelan Amnesty Law"), approved by the National Assembly, for military personnel and authorities who help to "restore constitutional order".{{cite news \|url\= http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/juan\-guaido\-ofrecio\-detalles\-sobre\-ley\-amnistia\_268057 \|language\=es \| title\= Juan Guaidó ofreció detalles sobre Ley de Amnistía \|work\= El Nacional \|date\= 25 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 28 January 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-latin\-america\-46997555\|title\=Venezuela's Maduro 'could get amnesty'\|date\=25 January 2019\|work\=BBC News\|access\-date\=25 January 2019}} The [Statute Governing the Transition to Democracy](/wiki/Statute_Governing_the_Transition_to_Democracy "Statute Governing the Transition to Democracy") was approved by the National Assembly on 5 February.{{cite news \|url\= http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/estatuto\-que\-rige\-transicion\-entro\-vigencia\-martes\_269938 \|title\= El estatuto que rige la transición entró en vigencia el martes \|trans\-title\= The statute governing the transition took effect on Tuesday \|language\= es \|work\= El Nacional \|date\= 8 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 9 March 2019 \| author\= Brito, Estefani}}
As of July 2019, the National Assembly had approved Juan Guaidó's appointment has named 37 ambassadors and foreign representatives to international organizations and nations abroad.{{cite web\|title\=Asamblea Nacional nombra "representantes diplomáticos" del gobierno de Guaidó ante el hemisferio\|url\=https://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/mundo/america\-latina/venezuela\-es/article225236365\.html\|access\-date\=30 January 2019\|website\=elnuevoherald\|language\=en}}{{cite news\|date\=29 January 2019\|title\=El Parlamento de Venezuela nombra "representantes diplomáticos" ante una decena de países y el Grupo de Lima\|work\=Europa Press\|agency\=Reuters\|url\=https://www.europapress.es/internacional/noticia\-parlamento\-venezuela\-nombra\-representantes\-diplomaticos\-decena\-paises\-grupo\-lima\-20190129191705\.html\|access\-date\=30 January 2019}}{{cite web\|date\=5 February 2019\|title\=AN designó nuevos embajadores de Venezuela en Brasil, Paraguay y Guatemala\|url\=https://noticiero52\.com/an\-realizo\-sesion\-ordinaria\-este\-martes/\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190207020447/https://noticiero52\.com/an\-realizo\-sesion\-ordinaria\-este\-martes/\|archive\-date\=7 February 2019\|access\-date\=6 February 2019\|website\=Noticiero 52}}{{cite web\|last\=Manzi\|first\=Waleska\|date\=19 February 2019\|title\=Designados por la Asamblea Nacional 17 nuevos embajadores venezolanos\|url\=https://evtvmiami.com/designados\-por\-la\-asamblea\-nacional\-17\-nuevos\-embajadores\-venezolanos/\|access\-date\=20 February 2019\|website\=EvTV\|archive\-date\=21 February 2019\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190221054722/https://evtvmiami.com/designados\-por\-la\-asamblea\-nacional\-17\-nuevos\-embajadores\-venezolanos/\|url\-status\=dead}}
| Organization/country | Official |
| --- | --- |
| {{Flag\|OAS}} | [Gustavo Tarre Briceño](/wiki/Gustavo_Tarre_Brice%C3%B1o "Gustavo Tarre Briceño") |
| [Inter\-American Development Bank](/wiki/Inter-American_Development_Bank "Inter-American Development Bank") | [Alejandro Plaz](/wiki/Alejandro_Plaz "Alejandro Plaz"){{efn\|name\="Resignations"\|In August 2019, ambassador to the Czech Republic, \[\[Tamara Sujú]], resigned. On September, \[\[Ricardo Hausmann]] also resigned as the Venezuelan representative to the \[\[Inter\-American Development Bank]].{{Cite web \|date\=2019\-09\-27 \|title\=Ricardo Haussmann renuncia a representación de Venezuela por Guaidó ante el BID \|trans\-title\=Ricardo Haussmann resigns to Venezuela's representation for Guaidó at the IDB \|url\=https://runrun.es/noticias/389456/ricardo\-haussmann\-renuncia\-a\-representacion\-de\-venezuela\-por\-guaido\-ante\-el\-bid/ \|access\-date\=2022\-11\-15 \|website\=\[\[Runrunes]] \|publisher\=\[\[El Pitazo]]}}{{Cite web \|date\=2019\-09\-27 \|title\=Ricardo Hausmann renuncia a responsabilidades en el BID \|trans\-title\=Ricardo Hausmann resigns from responsibilities at the IDB \|url\=https://www.elnacional.com/venezuela/ricardo\-hausmann\-renuncia\-a\-responsabilidades\-en\-el\-bid/ \|access\-date\=2022\-11\-15 \|website\=\[\[El Nacional (Venezuela)\|El Nacional]] \|language\=es}}}} |
| Lima Group | [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges "Julio Borges") |
| {{Flag\|Andorra}} | [Carmen Alguindingue](/wiki/Carmen_Alguindingue "Carmen Alguindingue") |
| {{Flag\|Argentina}} | [Elisa Trotta Gamus](/wiki/Elisa_Trotta_Gamus "Elisa Trotta Gamus") (2019–2020\){{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-argentina\-venezuela\-trotta\-idUSKBN1Z62IM\|title\=Argentina revokes credentials of representative for Venezuela's Guaido\|date\=7 January 2020\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=10 January 2020\|language\=en}} |
| {{Flag\|Australia}} | Alejandro Martínez |
| {{Flag\|Belgium}} | {{ill\|Mary Ponte\|es}} |
| {{Flag\|Brasil}} | [María Teresa Belandria](/wiki/Mar%C3%ADa_Teresa_Belandria "María Teresa Belandria") |
| {{Flag\|Bulgaria}} | {{ill\|Estefanía Meléndez\|es}} |
| {{Flag\|Canada}} | Orlando Viera Blanco |
| {{Flag\|Chile}} | {{ill\|Guarequena Gutiérrez\|es}} |
| {{Flag\|Colombia}} | *Vacant*{{efn\|On 26 November 2019, Guaidó dismissed his ambassador in Colombia, \[\[Humberto Calderón Berti\|Humberto Calderón]], citing plans to change foreign policy.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.diariolasamericas.com/america\-latina/guaido\-destituyo\-humberto\-calderon\-berti\-como\-embajador\-venezuela\-colombia\-n4188404\|title\=Guaidó destituyó al embajador de Venezuela en Colombia\|date\=27 November 2019\|website\=Diario las Américas\|language\=es\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191128213134/https://www.diariolasamericas.com/america\-latina/guaido\-destituyo\-humberto\-calderon\-berti\-como\-embajador\-venezuela\-colombia\-n4188404\|archive\-date\=28 November 2019\|access\-date\=1 December 2019}} Venezuelan diplomat \[\[Diego Arria]] condemned the dismissal, calling it a "huge mistake."{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.elimpulso.com/2019/11/27/diego\-arria\-rechazo\-destitucion\-humberto\-calderon\-berti\-es\-todo\-un\-desproposito\-27nov/\|title\=Diego Arria rechazó destitución Humberto Calderón Berti: Es todo un despropósito \#27Nov\|last\=Vidal\|first\=Brian\|date\=27 November 2019\|website\=El Impulso\|language\=es\|access\-date\=1 December 2019}}}} |
| {{Flag\|Costa Rica}} | María Faría |
| {{Flag\|Czech Republic}} | *Vacant*{{efn\|name\="Resignations"}} |
| {{Flag\|Denmark}} | Enrique Ser Horst |
| {{Flag\|Dominican Republic}} | Eusebio Carlino |
| {{Flag\|Ecuador}} | René de Sola |
| {{Flag\|France}} | [Isadora Zubillaga](/wiki/Isadora_Zubillaga "Isadora Zubillaga") |
| {{Flag\|Germany}} | Otto Gebauer |
| {{Flag\|Greece}} | [Eduardo Fernando Massieu](/wiki/Eduardo_Fernando_Massieu "Eduardo Fernando Massieu") |
| {{Flag\|Guatemala}} | {{ill\|María Teresa Romero\|es\|María Teresa Romero (politóloga)}} |
| {{Flag\|Honduras}} | Claudio Sandoval |
| {{Flag\|Hungary}} | Enrique Alvarado |
| {{Flag\|Israel}} | [Pynchas Brener](/wiki/Pynchas_Brener "Pynchas Brener") |
| {{Flag\|Luxembourg}} | [Angelina Jaffe](/wiki/Angelina_Jaffe "Angelina Jaffe") |
| {{Flag\|Malta}} | Felipe Zoghbi |
| {{Flag\|Morocco}} | José Ignacio Guédez |
| {{Flag\|Netherlands}} | [Gloria Notaro](/wiki/Gloria_Notaro "Gloria Notaro") |
| {{Flag\|Panama}} | [Fabiola Zavarce](/wiki/Fabiola_Zavarce "Fabiola Zavarce") |
| {{Flag\|Paraguay}} | David Olsen |
| {{Flag\|Peru}} | Carlos Scull |
| {{Flag\|Poland}} | [Ana Medina](/wiki/Ana_Medina "Ana Medina") |
| {{Flag\|Portugal}} | José Rafael Cotas |
| {{Flag\|Romania}} | Memo Mazzone |
| {{Flag\|Spain}} | {{ill\|Antonio Ecarri Bolívar\|es}} |
| {{Flag\|Sweden}} | León Poblete |
| {{Flag\|Switzerland}} | {{ill\|María Alejandra Aristeguieta\|es}} |
| {{Flag\|United Kingdom}} | [Vanessa Neumann](/wiki/Vanessa_Neumann "Vanessa Neumann") |
| {{Flag\|United States}} | [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio "Carlos Vecchio") |
#### Maduro response
Maduro accused the United States of backing a coup and said he would cut ties with them.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/23/americas/venezuela\-protests/index.html\|title\=Maduro defiant as Venezuelan opposition leader declares himself acting president\|author\=Sanchez, Ray and Nicole Chavez \|work\= CNN\|date\=23 January 2019\|access\-date\= 28 January 2019}} He said Guaidó's actions were part of a "well\-written script from Washington" to create a [puppet state](/wiki/Puppet_state "Puppet state") of the United States,{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\-rueda\-prensa/\|title\=Maduro: Hay un golpe mediático internacional contra Venezuela para desfigurar la situación real\|date\=25 January 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=26 January 2019}} and appealed to the American people in a 31 January video, asking them not to "convert Venezuela into another Vietnam".{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cbsnews.com/news/venezuela\-nicolas\-maduros\-military\-us\-backed\-juan\-guaido\-calls\-for\-support/\|title\=Venezuela power struggle hinges on Nicolas Maduro's military\|date\=31 January 2019\|work\=CBS News\|access\-date\=2 February 2019}}
Maduro asked for dialogue with Guaidó, saying "if I have to go meet this boy in the [Pico Humboldt](/wiki/Pico_Humboldt "Pico Humboldt") at three in the morning I am going, \[...] if I have to go naked, I am going, \[I believe] that today, sooner rather than later, the way is open for a reasonable, sincere dialogue".{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\-reunion\-guaido\-desnudo/\|title\=Maduro está dispuesto a reunirse con Guaidó "desnudo o a las tres de la mañana en el Humboldt"\|date\=25 January 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=26 January 2019}} He stated he would not leave the presidential office, saying that he was elected in compliance with the Venezuelan constitution.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\-no\-dejare\-cargo/\|title\=Maduro se atornilló en la silla: No he abandonado, ni dejaré el cargo\|date\=25 January 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=26 January 2019}} With the two giving speeches to supporters at the same time, Guaidó replied to Maduro's call for dialogue, saying he would not initiate diplomatic talks with Maduro because he believed it would be a farce and fake diplomacy that could not achieve anything.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\-latin\-america\-47009301\|title\=Venezuela crisis: Guaidó rejects calls to talk with Maduro\|work\=BBC News \|date\=25 January 2019 \|access\-date\=25 January 2019}}
On 18 February, Maduro's government expelled a group of Members of the [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament "European Parliament") that planned to meet Guaidó.{{cite news\|url\=http://efectococuyo.com/principales/espana\-y\-francia\-condenan\-la\-expulsion\-de\-eurodiputados\-de\-venezuela/\|title\=España y Francia condenan la expulsión de eurodiputados de Venezuela\|date\=18 February 2019\|access\-date\=20 February 2019\|agency\=\[\[Efecto Cocuyo]]\|language\=es}} The expulsion was condemned by Guaidó as well as [Pablo Casado](/wiki/Pablo_Casado "Pablo Casado"), president of the [Spanish People's Party](/wiki/People%27s_Party_%28Spain%29 "People's Party (Spain)"), and the Colombian government.{{Cite news\|url\=http://efectococuyo.com/internacionales/expulsion\-de\-europarlamentarios\-recibe\-condena\-nacional\-e\-internacional/\|title\=Expulsión de europarlamentarios recibe condena nacional e internacional\|last\=Fermín Kancev\|first\=María Victoria\|date\=17 February 2019\|work\=Efecto Cocuyo\|access\-date\=4 March 2019\|language\=es}} Maduro's Foreign Minister [Jorge Arreaza](/wiki/Jorge_Arreaza "Jorge Arreaza") defended the expulsions,{{Cite tweet \|user\=jaarreaza \|number\=1097290259551977472 \|date \= 17 February 2019 \|title\=Por vías oficiales diplomáticas, las autoridades del Gobierno Bolivariano de Venezuela le notificaron hace varios días al grupo de eurodiputados que pretendía visitar el país con fines conspirativos, que no serían admitidos y se les instó a desistir y evitar así otra provocación \[Through official diplomatic channels, the authorities of the Bolivarian Government of Venezuela notified him several days ago to the group of MEPs who intended to visit the country for conspiratorial purposes, who would not be admitted and were urged to desist and avoid another provocation.]}} saying that the constitutional government of Venezuela "will not allow the European extreme right to disturb the peace and stability of the country with another of its gross interventionist actions."{{Cite tweet \|user\=jaarreaza \|number\=1097290265763741696 \|date \= 17 February 2019 \|title\=El Gobierno Constitucional de la República Bolivariana de Venezuela no permitirá que la extrema derecha europea perturbe la paz y estabilidad del país con otra de sus groseras acciones injerencistas. ¡Venezuela se Respeta! \[The Constitutional Government of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela will not allow the European extreme right to disturb the peace and stability of the country with another of its gross interventionist actions. Venezuela must be respected!]}}
### Humanitarian aid crisis
{{main\|2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela}}
{{Location map\+ \| Venezuela
\| caption \= Location of the proposed entry points for humanitarian aid.
\| places \=
{{Location map\~ \| Venezuela
\| label \= {{flagicon\|Colombia}} Cúcuta
\| lat\_deg \= 7\.54
\| lon\_deg \= \-72\.30 }}
{{Location map\~ \| Venezuela
\| label \= {{flagicon\|Brazil}} Pacaraima
\| lat\_deg \= 4\.25
\| lon\_deg \= \-61\.08 }}
{{Location map\~ \| Venezuela
\| label \= {{flagicon\|Kingdom of the Netherlands}} Curaçao
\| lat\_deg \= 12\.11
\| lon\_deg \= \-69\.00 }}
}}
[Shortages in Venezuela](/wiki/Shortages_in_Venezuela "Shortages in Venezuela") have been present since 2007 during the presidency of [Hugo Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez "Hugo Chávez").{{cite news\|url\=http://www.eluniversal.com/economia/120106/shortage\-at\-its\-highest\-since\-may\-2008\|title\=Shortage at its highest since May 2008\|date\=6 January 2012\|access\-date\=3 December 2014\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170806145021/http://www.eluniversal.com/economia/120106/shortage\-at\-its\-highest\-since\-may\-2008\|archive\-date\=6 August 2017\|url\-status\=bot: unknown\|agency\=El Universal}} In 2016, the [National Assembly of Venezuela](/wiki/National_Assembly_of_Venezuela "National Assembly of Venezuela") declared a humanitarian crisis, asking Maduro's government to provide access to essential medicines and medical supplies. Before the presidential crisis, the Maduro government denied several offers of aid, stating that there was not a humanitarian crisis and that such claims were used to justify foreign intervention.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.lapatilla.com/2018/09/26/maduro\-niega\-la\-diaspora\-venezolana\-en\-la\-onu\-se\-ha\-fabricado\-por\-distintas\-vias\-una\-crisis\-migratoria\-que\-se\-cae\-por\-su\-propio\-peso/\|title\=Maduro niega la diáspora venezolana en la ONU: Se ha fabricado por distintas vías una crisis migratoria \- LaPatilla.com\|date\=26 September 2018\|work\=\[\[LaPatilla.com]]\|access\-date\=20 February 2019\|language\=es\-ES}}
\* {{cite news\|url\=http://www.cnn.com/2016/10/13/americas/cnnphotos\-venezuela\-food\-crisis/\|title\=The face of hunger in Venezuela\|author\=Charner, Flora\|date\=15 October 2016\|work\=\[\[CNN]]\|access\-date\=20 February 2019}}
\* {{Cite news\|url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/venezuelans\-die\-as\-maduro\-government\-refuses\-medical\-aid\-1523025805\|title\=Venezuelans Die as Maduro Government Refuses Medical Aid\|author\=Vyas, Kejal and Ryan Dube\|date\=6 April 2018\|work\=\[\[The Wall Street Journal]]\|access\-date\=20 February 2019\|issn\=0099\-9660}}
\* {{Cite news\|url\=http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/the\-country\-of\-hunger\-inside\-the\-deep\-suffering\-in\-venezuela\-s\-hospitals\-a\-1221061\.html\|title\=The Country of Hunger: A State of Deep Suffering in Venezuela's Hospitals\|author\=Glüsing, Jens\|date\=8 August 2018\|work\=\[\[Der Spiegel]]\|access\-date\=20 February 2019}} Maduro's refusal of aid worsened the effects of Venezuela's crisis. During the presidential crisis, Maduro initially refused aid, stating that Venezuela is not a country of "beggars".{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/02/19/la\-contradiccion\-de\-nicolas\-maduro\-sobre\-la\-ayuda\-humanitaria\-en\-14\-dias/\|title\=La contradicción de Nicolás Maduro sobre la ayuda humanitaria en 14 días\|date\=19 February 2019\|website\=\[\[Infobae]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=20 February 2019}}
Guaidó made bringing humanitarian aid to the country a priority.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.france24\.com/en/20190205\-venezuela\-opposition\-warns\-military\-against\-preventing\-entry\-aid\|title\=Venezuela opposition warns military against preventing entry of aid\|date\=5 February 2019\|work\=France24\|access\-date\=5 February 2019}} In early February, Maduro prevented the American\-sponsored aid from entering Venezuela via Colombia,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.foxnews.com/world/venezuela\-military\-sets\-up\-blockade\-on\-bridge\-to\-stop\-aid\-from\-colombia\|title\=Venezuela military sets up blockade on bridge to stop aid from Colombia\|author\=Suarez Sang, Lucia I.\|date\=6 February 2019\|work\=Fox News\|access\-date\=6 February 2019}} and Venezuela's communications minister, Jorge Rodriguez, said there was a plot between Colombia, the [CIA](/wiki/CIA "CIA") and exiled Venezuelan politician [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges "Julio Borges") to oust Maduro.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.apnews.com/b5481d5ad47d4ec2be132ed51b72e483\|title\=US emergency aid for Venezuela arrives at Colombian border\|author\=Armario, Christine \|author2\= \[\[Leonardo Haberkorn]]\|date\=7 February 2019\|access\-date\=7 February 2019\|work\=Associated Press}} Humanitarian aid intended for Venezuela was also stockpiled on the Brazilian border,{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/20/maduro\-envia\-tanquetas\-a\-santa\-elena\-de\-uairen\-para\-evitar\-ingreso\-de\-ayuda\-desde\-brasil\-fotos/\|title\=Maduro envía tanquetas a Santa Elena de Uairén para evitar ingreso de ayuda desde Brasil (FOTOS)\|date\=20 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=22 February 2019}} and two indigenous [Pemon](/wiki/Pemon "Pemon") people were killed as they attempted to block military vehicles from entering the area, when members of armed forces loyal to Maduro fired upon them with live ammunition.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/22/reportan\-que\-la\-fanb\-tiroteo\-a\-indigenas\-en\-la\-gran\-sabana/\|title\=Militares de Maduro tirotearon a indígenas pemón en la Gran Sabana: Una mujer asesinada y doce heridos (fotos)\|date\=22 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=22 February 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/22/pemones\-heridos\-en\-ataque\-de\-la\-gnb\-son\-trasladados\-a\-hospital\-en\-brasil\-por\-falta\-de\-insumos\-en\-venezuela\-foto\-y\-video/\|title\=Pemones heridos en ataque de la GNB son trasladados a hospital en Brasil por falta de insumos en Venezuela (FOTO y VIDEO)\|date\=22 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=22 February 2019}}{{Cite web\|url\=http://news.trust.org/item/20190222215031\-a8xxv/\|title\=As tensions over aid rise, Venezuelan troops fire on villagers, kill two\|date\=22 February 2019\|website\=\[\[Thomson Reuters Foundation]]\|access\-date\=23 February 2019}}
Guaidó issued an ultimatum to the Venezuelan Armed Forces, stating that humanitarian aid would enter Venezuela on 23 February and that the armed forces "will have to decide if it will be on the side of the Venezuelans and the Constitution or the usurper".{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/12/guaido\-en\-11\-dias\-la\-fanb\-tendra\-que\-decidir\-si\-estan\-del\-lado\-de\-los\-venezolanos\-y\-la\-constitucion\-o\-del\-usurpador/\|title\=Guaidó: En 11 días la Fanb tendrá que decidir si están del lado de los venezolanos y la Constitución o del usurpador\|date\=12 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=13 February 2019}} Guaidó defied the restriction imposed by the Maduro administration on him leaving Venezuela, secretly crossed the border,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/venezuelan\-opposition\-looks\-to\-foreign\-allies\-for\-further\-steps\-to\-unseat\-maduro/2019/02/24/3f046ce4\-37bc\-11e9\-8375\-e3dcf6b68558\_story.html\|title\=Venezuelan opposition looks to foreign allies for further steps to unseat Maduro\|author1\=Faiola, Anthony \|author2\=Rachelle Krygier \|author3\=Dylan Baddour \|date\=24 February 2019\|newspaper\=Washington Post\|access\-date\=24 February 2019}} saying that with the help of the Venezuelan military,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\=XPMqIDVjaZI\|title\=Guaidó dice que Fuerzas Armadas de Venezuela le ayudaron a entrar a Colombia\|date\=22 February 2019\|work\=Noticias Caracol\|access\-date\=24 February 2019\|publisher\=YouTube official channel\|language\=es}} and appeared at the [Venezuela Aid Live](/wiki/Venezuela_Aid_Live "Venezuela Aid Live") concert in Cúcuta, Colombia on 22 February,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.apnews.com/0c1c016d7e3d4e5594e5ef53b84a2c53\|title\=The Latest: Venezuela's Guaido shows up at benefit concert\|date\=22 February 2019\|work\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=22 February 2019}} also to be present for the [planned delivery of humanitarian aid](/wiki/2019_shipping_of_humanitarian_aid_to_Venezuela "2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela").{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/23/world/americas/venezuela\-aid\-live.html\|title\=Venezuela Aid Standoff Turns Deadly, Maduro Severs Ties with Colombia\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=24 February 2019\|quote\=Mr. Guaidó, standing alongside the presidents of Paraguay, Colombia, and Chile urged the Venezuelan military to allow trucks to cross the border.” and "The presidents of Colombia, Chile and Paraguay attended the concert, rallying support for the opposition and calling for an end to Mr. Maduro's presidency."}} Testing Maduro's authority, he was met by presidents [Iván Duque](/wiki/Iv%C3%A1n_Duque "Iván Duque") of Colombia,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.analitica.com/actualidad/actualidad\-internacional/presidente\-de\-paraguay\-viajo\-a\-cucuta\-para\-entrega\-de\-ayuda\-humanitaria/\|title\=Presidente chileno Sebastián Piñera: La dictadura de Maduro tiene sus días contados\|date\=22 February 2019\|work\=Analitica\|access\-date\=22 February 2019\|language\=es}} [Sebastián Piñera](/wiki/Sebasti%C3%A1n_Pi%C3%B1era "Sebastián Piñera") from Chile,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.elpais.com.co/colombia/maduro\-es\-parte\-del\-problema\-no\-de\-la\-solucion\-pinera\-tras\-aterrizar\-en\-cucuta.html\|title\='Maduro es parte del problema, no de la solución': Piñera tras aterrizar en Cúcuta\|date\=22 February 2019\|work\=El Paid\|access\-date\=22 February 2019\|language\=es}} and [Mario Abdo Benítez](/wiki/Mario_Abdo_Ben%C3%ADtez "Mario Abdo Benítez") from Paraguay,{{cite news\|url\=http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/mundo/presidente\-paraguay\-confia\-que\-venezuela\-recuperara\-democracia\_271894\|title\=Presidente de Paraguay confía en que Venezuela recuperará la democracia\|date\=22 February 2019\|work\=El Nacional\|access\-date\=22 February 2019\|language\=es}} as well as the OAS Secretary\-General [Luis Almagro](/wiki/Luis_Almagro "Luis Almagro").
On 23 February, trucks with humanitarian aid attempted to enter Venezuela from Brazil and Colombia;{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/23/americas/venezuela\-brazil\-violence\-intl/index.html\|title\=Venezuela's Maduro breaks relations with Colombia in standoff over aid\|author1\=Smith\-Spark, Laura \|author2\=Jorge Luis Perez Valery, Claudia Dominguez, Christina Maxouris \|date\=23 February 2019\|access\-date\=23 February 2019\|publisher\=CNN}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-latin\-america\-47343918\|title\=Venezuela soldiers abandon posts at Colombia border\|date\=23 February 2019\|access\-date\=23 February 2019\|work\=BBC News}} the attempts failed, with only one truck able to deliver aid.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/24/world/americas/venezuela\-aid\-maduro\-guaido.html\|title\=With aid blocked at border, what's next move for Venezuela's opposition?\|author\=Casey, Nicholas Albinson Linares\|date\=24 February 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=13 May 2019}} At the Colombia–Venezuela border, the caravans were tear\-gassed or shot at with rubber bullets by Venezuelan personnel.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article226723564\.html\|title\=Venezuela border skirmishes continue as questions swirl around torched aid bus\|date\=24 February 2019\|work\=Miami Herald}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2019/feb/23/venezuela\-brazil\-border\-aid\-live\-news\-latest\-updates\|title\=Guaidó: military should disown leader who burns food in front of the hungry – as it happened\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=The Guardian}} The National Guard repressed demonstrations on the Brazilian border and [colectivos](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 "Colectivo (Venezuela)") attacked protesters near the Colombian border,{{Cite news\|url\=http://epmundo.com/2019/colectivos\-armados\-causan\-terror\-en\-san\-antonio\-del\-tachira\-foto/\|title\=Colectivos armados causan terror en San Antonio del Táchira (Foto)\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=EP Mundo\|access\-date\=4 March 2019\|language\=es}}{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/en\-fotos\-mas\-de\-dos\-mil\-indigenas\-intentan\-llegar\-a\-frontera\-con\-brasil\-por\-ayuda/\|title\=En fotos: Más de dos mil indígenas intentan llegar a frontera con Brasil por ayuda\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\|access\-date\=24 February 2019}} leaving at least four dead,{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/aumentan\-a\-cuatro\-fallecidos\-y\-24\-heridos\-todos\-por\-armas\-de\-fuego\-en\-santa\-elena\-de\-uairen/\|title\=Aumentan a cuatro fallecidos y 24 heridos, todos por armas de fuego, en Santa Elena de Uairén\|date\=23 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|access\-date\=23 February 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/23/venezuela\-border\-latest\-maduro\-guaido\|title\=Venezuela: at least four dead and hundreds injured in border standoff\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=24 February 2019}} and more than 285 injured.{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/mas\-de\-285\-heridos\-y\-14\-asesinatos\-por\-represion\-del\-regimen\-de\-maduro\-este\-23feb\-estima\-informe\-de\-la\-oea/\|title\=Más de 285 heridos y 14 asesinatos por represión del régimen de Maduro este \#23Feb, estima informe de la OEA\|date\=23 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=24 February 2019}}
#### Lima Group meeting and Latin American tour
[thumb\|Guaidó, Colombia president Duque, and US vice president Pence during the February 2019 [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group "Lima Group") meeting in Colombia](/wiki/File:Vice_President_Mike_Pence_Travels_to_Colombia_%2832269091507%29.jpg "Vice President Mike Pence Travels to Colombia (32269091507).jpg")
Guaidó traveled from Cúcuta to [Bogotá](/wiki/Bogot%C3%A1 "Bogotá") for a 24 February meeting with US Vice President Mike Pence,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/24/reuters\-america\-update\-2\-us\-to\-announce\-concrete\-steps\-for\-venezuela\-crisis\-on\-monday\-official.html\|title\=US to announce 'concrete steps' for Venezuela crisis on Monday\-official\|author\=Rampton, Roberta\|date\=24 February 2019\|work\=CNBC\|access\-date\=24 February 2019\|publisher\=Reuters\|archive\-date\=24 February 2019\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190224233515/https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/24/reuters\-america\-update\-2\-us\-to\-announce\-concrete\-steps\-for\-venezuela\-crisis\-on\-monday\-official.html\|url\-status\=dead}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.eltiempo.com/mundo/venezuela/declaraciones\-de\-duque\-y\-guaido\-sobre\-entrega\-de\-ayuda\-humanitaria\-330614\|title\='El mundo vio la peor cara de la dictadura venezolana': Guaidó\|date\=23 February 2019\|work\=El Tiempo\|access\-date\=24 February 2019\|language\=es}} and a 25 February meeting of the Lima Group.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.latimes.com/world/la\-fg\-venezuela\-pence\-20190225\-story.html \|title\= Pence says U.S. will up the ante as it seeks ouster of Venezuelan President Maduro \|author\= Kraul, Chris and Patrick J. McDonnell \|date\= 25 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|work\= Los Angeles Times}} The group urged the [International Criminal Court](/wiki/International_Criminal_Court "International Criminal Court") to pursue charges of crimes against humanity for the Maduro administration's use of violence against civilians and blockade of humanitarian aid.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.france24\.com/en/20190225\-trump\-usa\-pence\-maduro\-venezuela\-guaido \|work\= France 24 \|date\= 25 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|title\= Trump is 'with you 100 percent', Pence tells Venezuelan opposition leader Guaido}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/government\-economy/lima\-group\-urges\-icc\-to\-declare\-venezuela\-aid\-blockade\-crime\-against\-humanity \|work\= Business Times \|title\= Lima Group urges ICC to declare Venezuela aid blockade 'crime against humanity' \|date\= 26 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019}}
Pence did not rule out the use of US military force. The Venezuelan government responded saying that Pence was trying to order others to take the country's assets, and saying that its basic rights were being disregarded in a campaign to unseat Maduro. Brazil's vice president said it would not permit its territory to be used to invade Venezuela,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-brazil/brazil\-will\-not\-allow\-u\-s\-use\-its\-territory\-to\-invade\-venezuela\-vice\-president\-idUSKCN1QE2DS \|date\= 25 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|title\= Brazil will not allow U.S. use its territory to invade Venezuela: vice president \|work\= Reuters}} and the European Union cautioned against the use of military force.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/25/eu\-warns\-against\-military\-action\-venezuela\-mike\-pence\-juan\-guaido/ \|archive\-url\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220112/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/25/eu\-warns\-against\-military\-action\-venezuela\-mike\-pence\-juan\-guaido/ \|archive\-date\=12 January 2022 \|url\-access\=subscription \|url\-status\=live \|author\= Alexander, Harriett \|date\= 26 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|work\= The Telegraph \|title\= EU warns against military action in Venezuela as Mike Pence and Juan Guaido meet at emergency summit}}{{cbignore}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.voanews.com/a/lima\-group\-says\-serious\-credible\-threats\-juan\-guaido\-life/4804009\.html \|title\= Lima Group: There Are 'Serious and Credible' Threats on Guaido's Life \|work\= VOA news \|date\= 26 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 }} The Lima Group rejected the use of force as well. The US [FAA](/wiki/Federal_Aviation_Administration "Federal Aviation Administration") warned pilots not to fly below 26,000 feet over Venezuela,{{cite news \|url\= https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wireStory/faa\-tells\-pilots\-caution\-flying\-venezuela\-61302473 \|title\= FAA tells pilots to use caution when flying over Venezuela \|work\= ABC News \|date\= 25 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|publisher\= Associated Press \|author \= Koenig, David }} and [US military](/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces "United States Armed Forces") officials said they had flown [reconnaissance](/wiki/Reconnaissance "Reconnaissance") flights off the coast of Venezuela to gather classified intelligence about Maduro.{{cite news \| url\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/25/americas/venezuela\-developments/index.html \|work\= CNN \|title\= US flying more reconnaissance flights off Venezuela, military sources say \|date\= 26 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 26 February 2019 \|author\= Starr, Barbara and Ralph Ellis}}
From Bogotá, Guaidó embarked on a regional tour to meet with the presidents of Brazil, Paraguay, Argentina, and Ecuador,{{cite news\|url\=https://finance.yahoo.com/news/facing\-jail\-caracas\-guaido\-travels\-183624466\.html\|title\=Facing jail in Caracas, Guaido travels across South America\|author\=Rosati, Andrew and Ken Parks\|date\=1 March 2019\|work\=Yahoo news\|access\-date\=1 March 2019\|publisher\=Bloomberg\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190302001909/https://finance.yahoo.com/news/facing\-jail\-caracas\-guaido\-travels\-183624466\.html\|archive\-date\=2 March 2019\|url\-status\=dead}} to discuss ways to rebuild Venezuela and defeat Maduro.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/01/venezuela\-crisis\-guaido\-vows\-to\-return\-despite\-life\-threatening\-risks.html\|title\=Venezuela's Guaido vows to return to Caracas despite 'life\-threatening' risks\|author\=Meredith, Sam\|date\=1 March 2019\|work\=CNBC\|access\-date\=1 March 2019}} Guaidó's trip was approved by Venezuela's [National Assembly](/wiki/National_Assembly_%28Venezuela%29 "National Assembly (Venezuela)"), as required by the Constitution of Venezuela,{{cite news\|url\=http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/juan\-guaido\-visitara\-paraguay\-este\-viernes\_272853\|title\=Juan Guaidó visitará Paraguay este viernes\|date\=28 February 2019\|work\=El Nacional\|access\-date\=2 March 2019\|language\=es}} but he faced the possibility of being imprisoned when returning to Venezuela because of the travel restriction placed upon him by the Maduro administration.{{Cite news\|url\=https://abcnews.go.com/International/venezuelan\-president\-nicolas\-maduros\-defiant\-interview\-tom\-llamas/story?id\=61318540\|title\=Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's defiant interview with Tom Llamas: TRANSCRIPT\|author\=Llamas, Tom\|date\=28 February 2019\|work\=\[\[ABC News (United States)\|ABC News]]\|access\-date\=1 March 2019}}
\* {{Cite news\|url\=https://news.yahoo.com/venezuelas\-guaido\-meet\-brazils\-president\-anti\-maduro\-push\-142229605\-\-finance.html\|title\=Venezuela's Guaido vows to return to Caracas despite threat of prison\|author\=Boadle, Anthony\|date\=1 March 2019\|agency\=\[\[Reuters]]\|access\-date\=1 March 2019}} He re\-entered Venezuela on 4 March, via [Simón Bolívar International Airport](/wiki/Sim%C3%B3n_Bol%C3%ADvar_International_Airport_%28Venezuela%29 "Simón Bolívar International Airport (Venezuela)") in [Maiquetía](/wiki/Maiquet%C3%ADa "Maiquetía"), and was received at the airport by diplomats{{efn\|Diplomats from Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Ecuador, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Spain and the United States received Guaidó at the airport.}} and in Caracas by a crowd of supporters.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1QL0A6\|title\=In jab at Maduro, Guaido makes triumphant return to Venezuela\|date\=4 March 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=4 March 2019\|language\=en}} German ambassador Daniel Kriener was accused of interference in internal affairs and expelled from Venezuela because of his role in helping Guaidó re\-enter.{{Cite news\|url\= https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-latin\-america\-47474317\|title\=Venezuela to expel German ambassador for 'meddling'\|date\=7 March 2019\|work\=\[\[BBC]]\|access\-date\=8 March 2019}}{{Cite news\|url\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/venezuela\-expels\-german\-ambassador\-for\-meddling\-141712\|title\=Venezuela expels German ambassador for 'meddling'\|date\=7 March 2019\|work\=Hurriyet Daily News\|access\-date\=8 March 2019}}
\* {{Cite news\|url\=https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/world/venezuela\-s\-guaido\-urges\-more\-sanctions\-after\-german\-envoy\-s\-expulsion\-11322022\|title\=Venezuela's Guaido urges more sanctions after German envoy's expulsion\|date\=7 March 2019\|work\=\[\[Channel News Asia]]\|access\-date\=8 March 2019\|archive\-date\=7 March 2019\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190307203436/https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/world/venezuela\-s\-guaido\-urges\-more\-sanctions\-after\-german\-envoy\-s\-expulsion\-11322022\|url\-status\=dead}}
### Blackouts
{{further\|2019 Venezuelan blackouts\|Human rights in Venezuela\#2019 OHCHR delegation visit}}
[thumb\|left\|[Guri Dam](/wiki/Guri_Dam "Guri Dam") supplies 80% of Venezuela's electrical power.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/world/americas/venzuela\-blackout\-maduro.html \|work\= New York Times \| title\= No end in sight to Venezuela's blackout, experts warn \|date\= 11 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 18 March 2019}}](/wiki/File:Guri_Dam_in_Venezuela.JPG "Guri Dam in Venezuela.JPG")
In March 2019, [Venezuela experienced a near total electrical blackout](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_blackouts "2019 Venezuelan blackouts"), and lost 150,000 barrels per day in crude oil production during the blackout.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-oil\-opec\-survey/opec\-oil\-output\-hits\-four\-year\-low\-on\-saudi\-cuts\-venezuela\-blackouts\-idUSKCN1RD26N \|work\= Reuters \|author\= Lawler, Alex \|date\= 1 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 7 April 2019 \|title\= OPEC oil output hits four\-year low on Saudi cuts, Venezuela blackouts}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.france24\.com/en/20190328\-blackouts\-savage\-venezuelas\-already\-tattered\-economy \|work\= France 24 \|date\= 28 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 7 April 2019 \|title\= Blackouts savage Venezuela's already tattered economy}} Full recovery of oil production was expected to take months,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.chron.com/business/energy/article/Venezuela\-Blackouts\-Cut\-Oil\-Output\-by\-Half\-13743951\.php \|work\= Houston Chronicle \|date\= 5 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 7 April 2019 \|title\= Venezuela blackouts cut oil output by half in March \|author\= Zerpa, Fabiola \|publisher\= Bloomberg}} but by April, Venezuela's exports were steady at a million barrels daily, "partially due to inventory drains".{{cite news \|title\= Venezuelan PDVSA's oil exports steady in April, flow to Cuba continues \|author\= Parraga, Marianna \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 2 May 2019 \|access\-date\= 3 May 2019 \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/venezuela\-oil\-exports/venezuelan\-pdvsas\-oil\-exports\-steady\-in\-april\-flow\-to\-cuba\-continues\-data\-idUSL1N22E1DX}}
Experts and state\-run [Corpoelec](/wiki/Corpoelec "Corpoelec") (Corporación Eléctrica Nacional) sources attributed the electricity shortages to lack of maintenance, underinvestment, corruption and to a lack of technical expertise in the country resulting from a [brain drain](/wiki/Human_capital_flight "Human capital flight");{{cite news \|author\=Angulo \|first1\=Nataly \|last2\=Batiz \|first2\=César \|author\-link2\=César Batiz \|date\=10 March 2019 \|title\=¿Por qué ocurrió el apagón nacional que provocó el caos en Venezuela? Los expertos explican \|language\=es \|trans\-title\=Why did the national blackout that caused the chaos in Venezuela happen? The experts explain \|work\=Univision \|url\=https://www.univision.com/noticias/america\-latina/por\-que\-ocurrio\-el\-apagon\-nacional\-que\-provoco\-el\-caos\-en\-venezuela\-los\-expertos\-explican \|access\-date\=17 March 2019 \|quote\=Especialistas venezolanos en el tema eléctrico explican que el corte masivo de electricidad se debió a la falta de mantenimiento, desprofesionalización constante del sector en los últimos años del chavismo, falta de inversión y la gran vulnerabilidad que representa depender de un solo embalse: el de Guri, ubicado en el sur del país, en el estado Bolívar.}}
and
{{cite news \|date\=9 March 2019 \|title\=Desmontan versión de ataque cibernético: 'Es como hackear una nevera' \|language\=es \|trans\-title\=Dismantling cyberattack version: 'It's like hacking a fridge' \|work\=El Nacional \|url\=http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/sociedad/desmontan\-version\-ataque\-cibernetico\-como\-hackear\-una\-nevera\_274054 \|access\-date\=17 March 2019 \|quote\=Expertos aseguran que el sistema de El Guri se creó antes de que existiera Internet, por lo que no depende de dicho tipo de conexiones para funcionar.}}
{{Cite web \|author\=Brassesco, Javier and Fernando Nunez\-Noda \|title\=Expediente: Las causas del apagón en Venezuela \|trans\-title\=File: The causes of the blackout in Venezuela \|url\=https://verifikado.com/expediente\-las\-causas\-del\-apagon\-en\-venezuela/ \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190330212845/https://verifikado.com/expediente\-las\-causas\-del\-apagon\-en\-venezuela/ \|archive\-date\=30 March 2019 \|access\-date\=14 March 2019 \|website\=Verifikado \|language\=es \|quote\=Univision recogió opiniones de expertos ...}}* + {{Cite web\|url\=https://es.scribd.com/document/401835067/Origen\-de\-La\-Falla\-v2\|title\=Origen de la falla eléctrica en Venezuela\|last\=Molina Guzmán\|first\=Julio\|date\=12 March 2019\|website\=\[\[Central University of Venezuela]]\|language\=en\|access\-date\=14 March 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/world/americas/venzuela\-blackout\-maduro.html\|title\=No end in sight to Venezuela's blackout, experts warn\|date\=11 March 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=18 March 2019\|quote\=Energy experts, Venezuelan power sector contractors and current and former Corpoelec employees have dismissed accusations of sabotage, saying the blackout was the result of years of underinvestment, corruption and brain drain. (...) Restarting the turbines requires skilled operators who can synchronize the speed of rotation on as many as nine of Guri's operational turbines. Experts said the most experienced operators had long left the company because of meager wages and an atmosphere of paranoia fed by Mr. Maduro's ever\-present secret police.}} [Nicolás Maduro](/wiki/Nicol%C3%A1s_Maduro "Nicolás Maduro")'s administration attributes them to sabotage.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-latin\-america\-47703864\|title\=Venezuela crisis: Fresh power cuts black out Caracas\|date\=26 March 2019\|work\=BBC\|access\-date\=26 March 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.msn.com/en\-au/kids/other/thousands\-join\-rival\-protests\-on\-streets\-of\-venezuela\-as\-power\-cuts\-continue/ar\-BBUzLJ5\|title\=Thousands join rival protests on streets of Venezuela as power cuts continue\|date\=10 March 2019\|work\=MSN\|access\-date\=15 March 2019}}{{cite web\|url\=http://www.presidencia.gob.ve/Site/Web/Principal/paginas/classMostrarEvento3\.php?id\_evento\=12996\|title\=Conformarán una comisión presidencial para investigar el ciberataque y mostrar la verdad\|date\=12 March 2019\|work\=Prensa MPP\|language\=es\|access\-date\=15 March 2019}} Guaidó said that Venezuela's largest\-ever [power outage](/wiki/Power_outage "Power outage") was "the product of the inefficiency, the incapability, the corruption of a regime that doesn't care about the lives of Venezuelans",{{cite news\|author\=Phillips, Tom\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/12/venezuela\-juan\-guaido\-maduro\-sabotage\-blackout\|title\=Guaidó under investigation for sabotage of power grid\|date\=12 March 2019\|work\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=13 March 2019}} Maduro's Attorney General, Tarek William Saab, called for an investigation of Guaidó, alleging that he had "sabotaged" the [electric sector](/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Venezuela "Electricity sector in Venezuela").
While Maduro visited hydroelectric facilities in [Ciudad Guayana](/wiki/Ciudad_Guayana "Ciudad Guayana") on 16 March, promising to restructure the state\-run power company [Corpoelec](/wiki/Corpoelec "Corpoelec"), his Vice President [Delcy Rodríguez](/wiki/Delcy_Rodr%C3%ADguez "Delcy Rodríguez") announced that Maduro would restructure his administration, asking the "entire executive Cabinet to put their roles up for review".{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics/venezuelas\-maduro\-plans\-deep\-restructuring\-of\-government\-vp\-idUSKCN1QY0XC \| work\= Reuters \|date\= 17 March 2019 \|title\= Venezuela's Maduro plans 'deep restructuring' of government: VP \|access\-date\= 18 March 2019}} Guaidó announced he would embark on a tour of the country beginning 16 March, to organize committees for Operation Freedom with the goal to claim the presidential residence, [Miraflores Palace](/wiki/Miraflores_Palace "Miraflores Palace").{{cite news \|url\= http://efectococuyo.com/politica/guaido\-anuncio\-la\-creacion\-de\-comites\-por\-la\-libertad\-para\-pronto\-ir\-a\-miraflores/ \|work\= Efecto Cocuyo \|date\= 16 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 18 March 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= Guaidó anuncia la creación de comités por la libertad para pronto 'ir a Miraflores' \|trans\-title\= Guaidó announces the creation of freedom committees to soon 'go to Miraflores' \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190421013023/http://efectococuyo.com/politica/guaido\-anuncio\-la\-creacion\-de\-comites\-por\-la\-libertad\-para\-pronto\-ir\-a\-miraflores/ \|archive\-date\= 21 April 2019 \|url\-status\= dead }} From the first rally in [Carabobo](/wiki/Carabobo "Carabobo") state, he said, "We will be in each state of Venezuela and for each state we have visited the responsibility will be yours, the leaders, the united, \[to] organize ourselves in freedom commands."
[United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights](/wiki/United_Nations_High_Commissioner_for_Human_Rights "United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights") (OHCHR) commissioner [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet "Michelle Bachelet")'s office sent a five\-person delegation to Venezuela in March.{{cite news \|title\=Delegación de DDHH de ONU comienza reuniones en Venezuela en medio del apagón \|url\=http://efectococuyo.com/principales/delegacion\-de\-ddhh\-de\-onu\-comienza\-reuniones\-en\-venezuela\-en\-medio\-del\-apagon/ \|access\-date\=18 March 2019 \|agency\=\[\[Efecto Cocuyo]] \|date\=11 March 2019 \|language\=es}}{{cite press release \|url\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/03/1034301 \|publisher\= UN News \|title\= UN rights team heading to Venezuela may pave way for official mission led by Bachelet \|date\= 8 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 18 March 2019}} On 20 March, Bachelet delivered a [preliminary oral report before the UN Human Rights Council](/wiki/Human_rights_in_Venezuela%232019_OHCHR_delegation_visit "Human rights in Venezuela#2019 OHCHR delegation visit"),{{cite news \|url\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/03/1035061 \|work\= UN News \|date\= 20 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019 \|title\= Venezuela: 'A worrying destabilizing factor in the region', Bachelet tells Human Rights Council}}{{cite web \|url\= https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID\=24374\&LangID\=E \|publisher\= OHCHR \|date\= 20 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 23 March 2019 \|title\= Oral update on the situation of human rights in the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela}} in which she outlined a "devastating and deteriorating" human rights situation in Venezuela, expressed concern that sanctions would worsen the situation, and called on authorities to show a true commitment to recognizing and resolving the situation.{{cite news \|url\= https://prodavinci.com/10\-claves\-del\-informe\-de\-michelle\-bachelet\-sobre\-venezuela/ \|title\= 10 claves del informe de Michelle Bachelet sobre Venezuela \|trans\-title\= 10 keys if Michelle Bachelet's report on Venezuela \|work\= Prodavinci \|date\= 20 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019 \|language\= es}}
[Elvis Amoroso](/wiki/Elvis_Amoroso "Elvis Amoroso"), Maduro's comptroller, alleged in March that Guaidó had not explained how he paid for his February 2019 Latin American trip,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.yahoo.com/news/venezuelan\-govt\-bars\-guaido\-public\-office\-15\-years\-175729462\.html \|work\= Yahoo \|publisher\= Associated Press \|date\= 28 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 28 March 2019 \|title\= Venezuelan gov't bars Guaido from public office for 15 years \|author\= Rueda, Jorge}} and said Guaidó would be barred from running for public office for fifteen years.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-guaido/venezuela\-bars\-guaido\-from\-holding\-public\-office\-for\-15\-years\-idUSKCN1R9298 \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 28 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 28 March 2019 \| title\= Venezuela bars Guaido from holding public office for 15 years}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.yahoo.com/news/venezuelas\-guaido\-barred\-public\-office\-15\-years\-182929528\.html \|work\= Yahoo \|date\= 28 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 28 March 2019 \|title\= Venezuela blocks Guaido from office as the opposition scoffs \|publisher\= Reuters \|author\= Sequera, Vivian and Luc Cohen}} The comptroller general is not a judicial body; according to constitutional lawyer José Vicente Haro, the [Inter\-American Court of Human Rights](/wiki/Inter-American_Court_of_Human_Rights "Inter-American Court of Human Rights") ruled in 2011 that an administrative body cannot disallow a public servant from running. Constitutional law expert [Juan Manuel Raffalli](/wiki/Juan_Manuel_Raffalli "Juan Manuel Raffalli") stated that Article 65 of Venezuela's Constitution provides that such determinations may only be made by criminal courts, after judgment of criminal activity.{{cite news \|url\= http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/inhabilitacion\-juan\-guaido\-podria\-desencadenar\-medidas\-ante\-cne\_276741 \|work\= El Nacional \| language\= es \|date\= 28 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 28 March 2019 \|title\= Inhabilitación de Juan Guaidó podría desencadenar medidas ante el CNE \|trans\-title\= Disqualification of Juan Guaidó could trigger measures before the CNE \|author\= Diaz Landazabal, Jackelin}}
### Red Cross aid effort
{{further\|2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela\#RedCrossVenAid}}
[thumb \|U.S. Assistant Secretary of State [Kimberly Breier](/wiki/Kimberly_Breier "Kimberly Breier"), Juan Guaidó's wife [Fabiana Rosales](/wiki/Fabiana_Rosales "Fabiana Rosales"), U.S. Special Representative for Venezuela [Elliott Abrams](/wiki/Elliott_Abrams "Elliott Abrams"), and Venezuelan Ambassador to the U.S. [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio "Carlos Vecchio"), and diplomat in Washington, D.C., on 27 March 2019](/wiki/File:Assistant_Secretary_Breier_and_Special_Representative_Abrams_Meets_With_With_Fabiana_Rosales%2C_Wife_of_Interim_President_Guaido_%2840515595993%29.jpg "Assistant Secretary Breier and Special Representative Abrams Meets With With Fabiana Rosales, Wife of Interim President Guaido (40515595993).jpg")
In March, Francesco Rocca, president of the [International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies](/wiki/International_Federation_of_Red_Cross_and_Red_Crescent_Societies "International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies"), announced that the [Red Cross](/wiki/International_Red_Cross_and_Red_Crescent_Movement "International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement") was preparing to bring humanitarian aid to the country in April to help ease both the chronic hunger and the medical crisis.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics/international\-red\-cross\-ready\-for\-venezuela\-humanitarian\-aid\-operation\-idUSKCN1RA1XP \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 29 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 March 2019 \|title\= International Red Cross ready for Venezuela humanitarian aid operation \|author\= Pons, Corina and Brian Ellsworth}} *[The Wall Street Journal](/wiki/The_Wall_Street_Journal "The Wall Street Journal")* said that the acceptance of humanitarian shipments by Maduro was his first acknowledgement that Venezuela is "suffering from an economic collapse."{{cite news \|title\= Red Cross announces Venezuelan aid effort \|work\= Wall Street Journal \|publisher\= Dow Jones Institutional News \|author\= Dube, Ryan \|date\= 29 March 2019 \|via\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://www.wsj.com/articles/red-cross-announces-venezuelan-aid-effort-11553899904){{cite news \|title\= Red Cross ready to aid Venezuela, warns against politics \|author\= Torchia, Christopher \|newspaper\= Washington Post \|publisher \= Associated Press \|date\= 29 March 2019 \|via\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://web.archive.org/web/20190329224812/https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/venezuelas-guaido-makes-renewed-promise-to-deliver-aid/2019/03/29/b993bfba-5237-11e9-bdb7-44f948cc0605_story.html) After a 9 April meeting with the [International Committee of the Red Cross](/wiki/International_Committee_of_the_Red_Cross "International Committee of the Red Cross") (ICRC),{{cite news \|url\= https://www.ntn24\.com/america\-latina/venezuela/maduro\-sostuvo\-encuentro\-con\-representantes\-de\-la\-cruz\-roja\-105757 \|publisher\= NTN24 \|language\= es \|date\= 9 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 10 April 2019 \|title\= Maduro sostuvo encuentro con representantes de la Cruz Roja}} Maduro indicated for the first time that he was prepared to accept international aid.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/04/maduro\-venezuela\-ready\-receive\-international\-aid\-190410083550252\.html \|publisher\= Al Jazeera \|date\= 10 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 10 April 2019 \|title\= Maduro says Venezuela ready to receive international aid}} Guaidó called on Venezuelans to "stay vigilant to make sure incoming aid is not diverted for 'corrupt' purposes".
Following the [joint report from Human Rights Watch and Johns Hopkins](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela%232019_Human_Rights_Watch/Johns_Hopkins_report "Crisis in Venezuela#2019 Human Rights Watch/Johns Hopkins report") in April 2019, increasing announcements from the United Nations about the scale of the humanitarian crisis, and the softening of Maduro's position on receiving aid, the ICRC tripled its budget for aid to Venezuela.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.theguardian.com/global\-development/2019/apr/12/red\-cross\-aid\-to\-venezuela\-to\-triple\-as\-nicolas\-maduro\-stance\-softens \|work\= The Guardian \|access\-date\= 12 April 2019 \|date\= 12 April 2019 \|author\= Beaumont, Peter \|title\= Red Cross aid to Venezuela to triple as Maduro stance softens}} The first Red Cross delivery of supplies for hospitals arrived on 16 April, offering an encouraging sign that the Maduro administration would allow more aid to enter.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-red\-cross/first\-shipment\-of\-red\-cross\-humanitarian\-aid\-arrives\-in\-venezuela\-idUSKCN1RS1VQ \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 16 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 16 April 2019 \|title\= First shipment of Red Cross humanitarian aid arrives in Venezuela}} According to *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times "The New York Times")*, "[armed pro\-government paramilitaries](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 "Colectivo (Venezuela)")" fired weapons to disrupt the first Red Cross delivery, and officials associated with Maduro's party told the Red Cross to leave.{{cite news\|url\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/world/americas/red\-cross\-venezuela\-aid.html \|work\= New York Times \|date\= 17 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 17 April 2019 \|title\= Red Cross grapples with aid distribution in polarized Venezuela \|author\= Herrera, Isayen and Anatoly Kurmanaev}}
According to the [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press "Associated Press"), having long denied that there was a humanitarian crisis in Venezuela, Maduro positioned the delivery "as a necessary measure to confront punishing U.S. economic sanctions." Having "rallied the international community", Guaidó "quickly claimed credit for the effort."{{cite news \|url\= https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/venezuela\-humanitarian\-aid\-arrives\-1\.5100067 \|publisher\=CBC Canada \|access\-date\= 16 April 2019 \|date\= 16 April 2019 \|title\= Humanitarian aid shipment makes it into Venezuela after delays \|agency\= Associated Press}}
### Revocation of Guaidó's parliamentary immunity
Chief justice [Maikel Moreno](/wiki/Maikel_Moreno "Maikel Moreno") asked that the [Constituent Assembly](/wiki/2017_Venezuelan_Constituent_Assembly_election "2017 Venezuelan Constituent Assembly election") (ANC), controlled by Maduro loyalists, remove Guaidó's parliamentary immunity as president of the National Assembly,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\-america\-latina\-47781533\|publisher\=BBC Mundo\|language\= es \|date\= 1 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 April 2019 \|title\= Juan Guaidó: el Tribunal Supremo de Venezuela solicita revocar la inmunidad parlamentaria del líder opositor a la Asamblea controlada por el chavismo \|trans\-title\= Juan Guaidó: the Supreme Court of Venezuela requests that the Assembly controlled by Chavismo revoke the parliamentary immunity of the opposition leader}}{{cite news\|author\=Richard Gonzales\|url\=https://www.npr.org/2019/04/02/709306132/maduro\-allies\-move\-against\-rival\-juan\-guaid\-in\-venezuela\|publisher\=NPR\|date\=April 2, 2019\|title\=Maduro Allies Move Against Rival Juan Guaidó In Venezuela}} moving the Maduro administration a step closer towards prosecuting Guaidó.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.foxnews.com/world/the\-latest\-venezuela\-judge\-seeks\-to\-strip\-guaidos\-immunity \| work\= Fox News \|date\= 1 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 April 2019 \|title\= The Latest: Venezuela judge seeks to strip Guaido's immunity \|publisher\= Associated Press}} Guaidó supporters disagree that the Maduro\-backed institutions have the authority to ban Guaidó from leaving the country and consider acts of the ANC "null and void". The Venezuelan Constitution provides that only the National Assembly can bring the president to trial by approving the legal proceeding in a "merit hearing". On 2 April, after the ANC voted to remove his parliamentary immunity, Guaidó promised to continue fighting "Maduro's 'cowardly, miserable and murderous' regime."{{cite news \|url\= https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/apr/03/venezuela\-juan\-guaido\-stripped\-of\-parliamentary\-immunity \|work\= The Guardian \|date\= 2 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 4 April 2019 \|title\= Venezuela: Juan Guaidó stripped of parliamentary immunity \|author\= Phillips, Tom and Patricia Torres}}
### Military uprising attempt
{{Main\|2019 Venezuelan uprising attempt}}
[thumb\|upright\=1\.5\|[Juan Guaidó](/wiki/Juan_Guaid%C3%B3 "Juan Guaidó") speaks to supporters on 30 April 2019](/wiki/File:2019_Venezuela_uprising_-_Guaid%C3%B3_speaking.png "2019 Venezuela uprising - Guaidó speaking.png")
On 19 April, Guaidó called for a "definite end of the usurpation" and the "largest march in history" on 1 May.{{cite web\|url\=https://talcualdigital.com/index.php/2019/04/19/guaido\-convoca\-a\-la\-marcha\-mas\-grande\-de\-la\-historia\-para\-el\-1\-de\-mayo/\|title\=Guaidó convoca a 'la marcha más grande de la historia' para el 1° de mayo\|author\=Quintero, Luisa\|date\=19 April 2019\|publisher\=Tal Cual Digital\|language\=es\|trans\-title\=Guaidó calls for 'the largest march in history' for 1 May\|access\-date\=14 May 2019}} Coinciding with his speech, [NetBlocks](/wiki/NetBlocks "NetBlocks") stated that state\-run [CANTV](/wiki/CANTV "CANTV") again blocked access to social media in Venezuela.{{cite web\|url\=https://netblocks.org/reports/social\-media\-restricted\-in\-venezuela\-as\-guaido\-speaks\-from\-caracas\-0pA2X5yb\|title\=Social media restricted in Venezuela as Guaido speaks from Caracas\|date\=19 April 2019\|publisher\=\[\[NetBlocks]]\|access\-date\=19 April 2019}} On 30 April 2019, [Leopoldo López](/wiki/Leopoldo_L%C3%B3pez "Leopoldo López"), who was held under house arrest by the Maduro administration, was freed on orders from Guaidó.{{cite web \|author\= Smith, Scott and Christopher Torchia \|title\= Clashes rock Venezuela as Guaido urges opposition uprising \|url\=https://apnews.com/0153cace08c84c8fbf34f9c6a7bdd4dd \|publisher\=\[\[Associated Press]] \|date\= 30 April 2019 \|access\-date\=30 April 2019}} The two men, flanked by members of the Venezuelan armed forces near [La Carlota Air Force Base](/wiki/La_Carlota_airport "La Carlota airport") in Caracas, announced an uprising,{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/04/30/guaido\-le\-habla\-a\-venezuela\-desde\-la\-base\-aerea\-la\-carlota\-video/\|title\=Guaidó le habla a Venezuela desde la Base Aérea La Carlota (VIDEO)\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es \|date\= 30 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 April 2019}} stating that this was the final phase of "Operation Freedom".{{cite news \|author\= Sequera, Vivian and Angus Berwick \|title\=Venezuela's Guaido calls on troops to join him in uprising against Maduro \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics/venezuelas\-guaido\-says\-troops\-join\-him\-for\-coup\-government\-says\-it\-is\-firmly\-in\-control\-idUSKCN1S60ZQ \|work\=\[\[Reuters]] \|date\= 30 April 2019\|access\-date\=30 April 2019}} Though Guaidó said his forces held La Carlota, when supporters approached the base, Guaidó and a few dozen supporters stayed in a nearby overpass outside.{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|pp\=230–234 \|loc\= Chapter 25: "Bubble"}}
Maduro was not seen during the day,{{cite news\|author\=Hansler, Jennifer\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/30/politics/pompeo\-maduro\-russia/index.html\|title\=Pompeo claims Russia stopped Maduro leaving Venezuela for Cuba\|date\=30 April 2019\|access\-date\=30 April 2019\|publisher\=CNN}} but he appeared with his Defense Minister Padrino on that evening's televised broadcast,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-maduro\-sebin/venezuelas\-maduro\-appears\-with\-defense\-minister\-after\-uprising\-idUSKCN1S7315 \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 30 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 May 2019 \|title\= Venezuela's Maduro appears with defense minister after uprising}} and announced he would replace [Manuel Cristopher Figuera](/wiki/Manuel_Cristopher_Figuera "Manuel Cristopher Figuera"), Director General of the [Bolivarian Intelligence Service](/wiki/Bolivarian_Intelligence_Service "Bolivarian Intelligence Service") (SEBIN), who had broken with Maduro during the uprising, saying it was time to "rebuild the country" and that "scoundrels were plundering the country."{{cite news\|author\=Phillips, Tom and Joe Parkin Daniels\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/01/venezuela\-coup\-protests\-what\-happens\-next\-guaido\-maduro\-latest\|title\=Guaidó's uprising seems to have flatlined. What's next for Venezuela?\|date\=1 May 2019\|work\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=2 May 2019}} The United States said Maduro had prepared to leave Venezuela that morning, but Russia and Cuba helped convince him to stay.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/video/2019/04/30/national\-security\-advisor\-john\-bolton\-on\-venezuela\-protests.html\|title\=National Security Advisor John Bolton on Venezuela protests\|date\=30 April 2019\|access\-date\=30 April 2019\|publisher\=CNBC}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/30/world/americas/venezuela\-coup\-guaido\-military.html\|title\=Venezuela crisis live updates: Guaidó calls for uprising as clashes erupt\|date\=30 April 2019\|work\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=30 April 2019}} Both Russia and Maduro denied that he had plans to leave Venezuela.{{cite news\|author\=Picheta, Rob and Meg Wagner\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/americas/live\-news/juan\-guaido\-venezuela\-operation\-freedom\-live\-updates/index.html\|title\=Venezuela's uprising\|date\=30 April 2019\|access\-date\=30 April 2019\|publisher\=CNN}}
Guaidó's supporters were forced to retreat by security forces using tear gas. [Colectivos](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 "Colectivo (Venezuela)") fired on protesters with live ammunition, and one protester was shot in the head and killed. [Human Rights Watch](/wiki/Human_Rights_Watch "Human Rights Watch") said it believed that "security forces fired shotgun pellets at demonstrators and journalists." By the end of the day, one protester had died,{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\_americas/venezuelan\-opposition\-leader\-juan\-guaido\-appears\-to\-stage\-military\-backed\-challenge\-to\-president\-maduro/2019/04/30/c7028eee\-6b35\-11e9\-8f44\-e8d8bb1df986\_story.html?noredirect\=on\|title\=Venezuela's Maduro denies Pompeo's claim that he sought to escape to Cuba after day of clashes that left 1 dead, dozens hurt\|author\= Zuñiga, Mariana\|date\=30 April 2019\|newspaper\=The Washington Post\|access\-date\=30 April 2019}} and López was at the Spanish embassy,{{cite news \|url\= https://www.abc.es/internacional/abci\-leopoldo\-lopez\-refugia\-embajada\-espana\-201905010259\_noticia.html \|publisher\= ABC International \|date\= 1 May 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 May 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= Leopoldo López se refugia en la Embajada de España}} while about 25 military personnel received asylum in the Panamanian embassy in Caracas.{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|pp\=230–234 \|loc\= Chapter 25: "Bubble"}}{{cite news \|url\= https://elpais.com/internacional/2019/04/30/actualidad/1556618727\_875831\.html \|work\= El Pais \|date\= 30 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 30 April 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= Últimas noticias de Venezuela, en vivo: Chile confirma que Leopoldo López está en su Embajada en Caracas \|trans\-title\= Latest news from Venezuela, live: Chile confirms that Leopoldo López is in their Embassy in Caracas}}
Guaidó acknowledged he had received insufficient military backing, but added that "Maduro did not have the support nor the respect of the Armed Forces"{{cite news \|title\=Venezuela: Juan Guaidó asegura que "Maduro no tiene el respaldo ni el respeto de las fuerzas armadas" \|url\=https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\-america\-latina\-48114446 \|access\-date\=2 May 2019 \|agency\=BBC \|date\=1 May 2019 \|language\=es}} and called for strikes beginning on 2 May, with the aim of a general strike later in the month.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/01/world/americas/venezuela\-protests\-guaido\-maduro.html \|work\= The New York Times \|date\= 1 May 2019 \|access\-date\= 2 May 2019 \|author\= Casey, Nicholas \|title\= Rival protests grip Venezuela after Guaidó's failed effort to beckon military}} Russia and the US each charged the other with interference in another country's affairs.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/02/americas/venezuela\-maduro\-guaido\-intl/index.html \|publisher\= CNN \|date\= 2 May 2019 \|access\-date\= 2 May 2019 \|title\= As Guaido admits he needs more military support, Trump warns of worse to come in Venezuela \|author\= Berlinger, Joshua}}
### Negotiations
{{See also\|Negotiations during the Venezuelan crisis\#2019 presidential crisis}}Following the failed military uprising, momentum surrounding Guaidó had subsided and fewer supporters gathered at demonstrations, with Guaidó resorting to negotiations with Maduro.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/21/world/americas/venezuela\-juan\-guaido\-nicolas\-maduro.html\|title\=Venezuela's Opposition Leader Juan Guaidó May Negotiate With Maduro\|last\=Kurmanaev\|first\=Anatoly\|date\=2019\-05\-21\|work\=\[\[The New York Times]]\|access\-date\=2019\-05\-24\|language\=en\-US\|issn\=0362\-4331}} Guaidó's deputy chief Rafael Del Rosario acknowledged that the debacle on 30 April made the prospect of removing Maduro more difficult. Beginning negotiations was a setback for Guaidó's movement, with the [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press "Associated Press") stating, "Participation in the mediation effort is a reversal for the opposition, which has accused Maduro of using negotiations between 2016 and 2018 to play for time". According to the *New York Times*, years of difficulties has made Maduro "adept at managing, if not solving, cascading crises", while Phil Gunson of the [International Crisis Group](/wiki/International_Crisis_Group "International Crisis Group") stated that despite facing issues, Maduro "must be very pleased that he is now in the driving seat", with the ability to use the actions of Guaidó and international actors for propaganda purposes.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.npr.org/2019/05/13/722959304/venezuelan\-president\-nicol\-s\-maduro\-pushes\-back\-against\-u\-s\-support\-to\-unseat\-hi\|title\=Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro Pushes Back Against U.S. Support To Unseat Him\|last\=Reeves\|first\=Philip\|date\=13 May 2019\|website\=\[\[NPR]]\|language\=en\|access\-date\=2019\-05\-24}} By May 2019, Trump had decided that Guaidó was weak; Bolton attributed a change of Trump's position to a comment made by President of Russia [Vladimir Putin](/wiki/Vladimir_Putin "Vladimir Putin") to Trump in a phone call that Guaidó's claim to the presidency would be the equivalent of [Hillary Clinton](/wiki/Hillary_Clinton "Hillary Clinton") declaring herself president following the [2016 United States presidential election](/wiki/2016_United_States_presidential_election "2016 United States presidential election").{{sfn\|Neuman\|2022\|pp\=230–234 \|loc\= Chapter 25: "Bubble"}}
Representatives of Guaidó and Maduro began mediation with the assistance of the Norwegian Centre for Conflict Resolution (NOREF), with [Jorge Rodríguez](/wiki/Jorge_Rodr%C3%ADguez_%28Venezuelan_politician%29 "Jorge Rodríguez (Venezuelan politician)") and [Héctor Rodríguez](/wiki/H%C3%A9ctor_Rodr%C3%ADguez_Castro "Héctor Rodríguez Castro") serving as representatives for Maduro while {{ill\|Gerardo Blyde\|es}} and [Stalin González](/wiki/Stalin_Gonz%C3%A1lez "Stalin González") were representatives for Guaidó. Guaidó confirmed that there was an envoy in Norway, but assured that the opposition would not take part in "any kind of false negotiation" and that talks must lead to Maduro's resignation, a transitional administration and free and fair elections.{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/46613ff2cbaa4712b3dfb09d76ce1bc7\|title\=Mediation in Norway aims to resolve Venezuela crisis\|author\=Torchia, Christopher\|date\=17 May 2019\|work\=\[\[Associated Press]]\|access\-date\=17 May 2019}}{{cite news \|title\=Guaidó confirma contactos y anuncia la 'liberación' de Simonovis \|url\=https://es.euronews.com/2019/05/17/guaido\-confirma\-contactos\-y\-anuncia\-la\-liberacion\-de\-simonovis \|agency\=Euronews \|date\=17 May 2019 \|language\=es}}
In July 2019, Norway's commission carried out a third round of discussions between Guaidó's and Maduro's representatives in [Barbados](/wiki/Barbados "Barbados").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1U61XX\|title\=Norway says Venezuela opposition and government talks to continue\|last\=Brian Ellsworth, Vivian Sequera\|date\=12 July 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=13 July 2019}} By August 2019, the Maduro administration decided to halt talks with Guaidó's commission after Trump administration imposed new additional sanctions on Venezuela, ordering a freeze on all Venezuelan government assets in the [United States](/wiki/United_States "United States") and barred transactions with US citizens and companies.{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/6a178b0f946349d8a12899e0f4b9ca48\|title\=Maduro halts talks with opponents over US asset freeze\|last\=Goodman\|first\=Joshua\|date\=8 August 2019\|website\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=20 August 2019}}
### Second visit of the OHCHR
Ahead of a three\-week session of the [UN Human Rights Council](/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council "United Nations Human Rights Council"), the OHCHR chief, [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet "Michelle Bachelet"), visited Venezuela from 19 to 21 June.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-un\-idUSKCN1TM2BR\|title\=U.N. rights chief Bachelet urges Venezuela to release prisoners\|last1\=Pons\|first1\=Corina\|date\=22 June 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=22 June 2019\|last2\=Castro\|first2\=Shaylim}} The Human Rights Commissioner met separately with both Maduro and Guaidó during her visit, as well as with Maduro's Attorney General [Tarek William Saab](/wiki/Tarek_William_Saab "Tarek William Saab"), several human right activists, and families of victims who experienced torture and state repression.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\-06\-21/protests\-erupt\-in\-caracas\-during\-un\-s\-bachelet\-venezuela\-visit\|title\=Protests Erupt in Caracas During Venezuela Visit by UN's Bachelet\|last\=Laya\|first\=Patricia\|date\=20 June 2019\|work\=Bloomberg\|access\-date\=22 June 2019}} Protests occurred in front of the UN office in Caracas during the last day of the visit, denouncing rights abuses carried out by Maduro's administration. [Gilber Caro](/wiki/Gilber_Caro "Gilber Caro"), who was released two days before the visit, joined the protest.{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/97c6390cb2694098b823fe8766819d4b\|title\=UN human rights chief appeals for dialogue in Venezuela\|last1\=Smith\|first1\=Scott\|last2\=Goodman\|first2\=Joshua\|date\=22 June 2019\|website\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=22 June 2019}} Bachelet announced the creation of a delegation maintained by two UN officials that will remain in Venezuela to monitor the humanitarian situation. Bachelet expressed concern that the recent sanctions on oil exports and gold trade could worsen the crisis that has increased since 2013,{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID\=24722\&LangID\=E\|title\=First UN Human Rights presence in Venezuela\|date\=21 June 2019\|website\=OHCHR\|access\-date\=23 June 2019}} calling the measures "extremely broad" and that they are capable of exacerbating the suffering of the Venezuelan people.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/09/un\-rights\-chief\-decries\-latest\-us\-sanctions\-venezuela\-michelle\-bachelet\|title\=UN rights chief decries latest US sanctions targeting Venezuela\|newspaper\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=9 August 2019}} She also called for the release of political prisoners in Venezuela. This was the first time a [United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights](/wiki/United_Nations_High_Commissioner_of_Human_Rights "United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights") visited Venezuela.
The final published report addressed the extrajudicial executions, torture, [forced disappearances](/wiki/Forced_disappearance "Forced disappearance") and other human rights violations reportedly committed by Venezuelan security forces in the recent years.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1U022E\|title\=On Venezuelan independence day, Maduro calls for dialogue as Guaido slams 'dictatorship'\|date\=5 July 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=10 July 2019}} Bachelet expressed her concerns for the "shockingly high" number of extrajudicial killings and urged for the dissolution of the [Special Action Forces](/wiki/Special_Action_Forces "Special Action Forces") (FAES).{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.france24\.com/en/20190705\-venezuela\-united\-nations\-report\-michelle\-bachelet\-human\-rights\|title\=UN report cites 'shockingly high' number of likely 'executions' in Venezuela\|date\=5 July 2019\|website\=France 24\|access\-date\=10 July 2019}} According to the report, 1,569 cases of executions as consequence as a result of "resistance to authority" were registered by the Venezuelan authorities from 1 January to 19 March. Other 52 deaths that occurred during 2019 protests were attributed to colectivos.{{Cite web\|url\=https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/07/1041902\|title\=UN human rights chief 'hopeful' Venezuelan authorities are ready to address violations, calls for dialogue\|date\=4 July 2019\|website\=UN News\|access\-date\=10 July 2019}} The report also details how the Venezuelan government "aimed at neutralising, repressing and criminalising political opponents and people critical of the government" since 2016\.
Guaidó supported the investigation, stating "the systematic violation of human rights, the repression, the torture... is clearly identified in the (UN) report". Maduro administration described the report as a "biased vision" and demanded it be "corrected".{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/8349d5ca263d494b849923529530ccf4\|title\=Venezuelan envoy rejects 'biased' report at UN rights body\|last\=Keaten\|first\=Jamey\|date\=5 July 2019\|website\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=10 July 2019}} In the words of his foreign minister, "It's a text lacking in scientific rigor, with serious errors in methodology and which seems like a carbon copy of previous reports". Maduro would later state that the OHCHR "has declared itself an enemy" to Maduro and the Bolivarian Revolution.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.dw.com/es/maduro\-llama\-a\-la\-oficina\-de\-bachelet\-enemiga\-de\-venezuela/a\-49642312\|title\=Maduro llama a la oficina de Bachelet "enemiga" de Venezuela {{!}} DW {{!}} 18\.07\.2019\|date\=18 July 2019\|website\=\[\[Deutsche Welle]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=2019\-07\-19}}
Speaking to reporters after the UN Human Rights Council, Bachelet announced the release of 22 Venezuelan prisoners, including 20 students, judge [Maria Lourdes Afiuni](/wiki/Detention_of_Maria_Lourdes_Afiuni "Detention of Maria Lourdes Afiuni"), in her second house arrest since March, and journalist [Braulio Jatar](/wiki/Braulio_Jatar "Braulio Jatar"), arrested in 2016\.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-un\-prisoners\-idUSKCN1U016V\|title\=Venezuela releasing judge, journalist, 20 students – U.N.\|last\=Nebehay\|first\=Stephanie\|date\=5 July 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=10 July 2019}} Bachelet welcomed the conditional releases and the acceptance of the two officers delegation as "the beginning of positive engagement on the country's many human rights issues".
In October 2019, Venezuela competed for one of the two seats to the [United Nations Human Rights Council](/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council "United Nations Human Rights Council"), along with Brazil and Costa Rica, and was elected with 105 votes in a secret ballot by the 193\-member [United Nations General Assembly](/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembly "United Nations General Assembly"). Brazil was re\-elected with 153 votes, while Costa Rica was not having garnered 96 votes and entering the month of the election as competition to Venezuela. The United States, [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group "Lima Group") and human rights groups lobbied against Venezuela's election.{{cite news\|last1\=Nicols\|first1\=Michelle\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-un\-rights\-idUSKBN1WW2I7\|title\=Venezuela wins seat on U.N. rights council despite U.S. opposition\|date\=18 October 2019\|access\-date\=26 March 2020\|publisher\=Reuters}}
On 16 September 2020, the United Nations accused the Maduro government of [crimes against humanity](/wiki/Crimes_against_humanity "Crimes against humanity").{{Cite web\|last\=Geneva\|first\=Staff and agencies in\|date\=2020\-09\-16\|title\=Venezuela: UN accuses Maduro government of crimes against humanity\|url\=http://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/16/venezuela\-un\-report\-crimes\-against\-humanity\-maduro\-government\|access\-date\=2020\-09\-18\|website\=The Guardian\|language\=en}}
### Torture and death of Acosta Arévalo
On 26 June, Maduro said that his government had arrested several defecting military, thus foiling a plot to remove him from power and to assassinate him, his wife and [Diosdado Cabello](/wiki/Diosdado_Cabello "Diosdado Cabello").{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jun/26/venezuela\-government\-says\-foiled\-plot\-to\-assassinate\-president\-maduro\|title\=Venezuela government says it foiled plot to assassinate president Maduro\|date\=26 June 2019\|work\=The Guardian\|access\-date\=27 June 2019\|issn\=0261\-3077}}{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1TR39F\|title\=Venezuela's Maduro says authorities foiled opposition coup plot\|date\=26 June 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=27 June 2019\|language\=en}} The alleged plan also included the rescue of [Raúl Baduel](/wiki/Ra%C3%BAl_Baduel "Raúl Baduel"), a retired general imprisoned for a second time in 2017, to install him as president. Maduro accused Israel, Colombia, Chile and the United States of involvement in the plot.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\-06\-26/venezuela\-regime\-says\-guaido\-two\-dozen\-more\-planned\-coups\|title\=Venezuela Regime Says Guaido, Two Dozen More Planned Coups\|last\=Vasquez\|first\=Alex\|date\=26 June 2019\|website\=Bloomberg\|access\-date\=27 June 2019}} Jorge Rodríguez said that the foiled plan involved the bombing of a government building, the seizing of [La Carlota air base](/wiki/Generalissimo_Francisco_de_Miranda_Air_Base "Generalissimo Francisco de Miranda Air Base"), and a bank robbery. Guaidó dismissed the allegations as lies; opposition members have frequently accused Maduro of coercion of arrested suspects and fabrication of plots for political gain.
In the wake of the coup allegations, an alleged kidnapping attempt directed at members of Guaidó's entourage occurred on a Caracas highway.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.france24\.com/en/20190627\-venezuela\-coup\-nicolas\-maduro\-juan\-guaido\|title\=Venezuela government says it derailed a coup attempt, opposition denies\|date\=26 June 2019\|website\=France 24\|access\-date\=27 June 2019}} Eight armed men on motorcycles dressed as civilians allegedly surrounded a vehicle containing two of Guaidó's aides.{{Cite web\|url\=https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/venezuela\-politica\-guaido\-idLTAKCN1TR38B\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190627125353/https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/venezuela\-politica\-guaido\-idLTAKCN1TR38B\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-date\=27 June 2019\|title\=Guaidó encara a civiles armados, gobierno de Venezuela vuelve a acusar a oposición de terrorismo\|date\=27 June 2019\|website\=Reuters\|access\-date\=27 June 2019\|language\=es}} Guaidó, who was in a car further ahead, spoke with the armed civilians,{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/6d0857bd6fdf42cfbfe89e8ff8ffc01a\|title\=Venezuela gov't says it thwarted plot seeking to kill Maduro\|last\=Smith\|first\=Scott\|date\=26 June 2019\|website\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=27 June 2019}} according to photos and a video released by his press team and published by *[Infobae](/wiki/Infobae "Infobae")*.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/06/26/el\-presidente\-interino\-de\-venezuela\-juan\-guaido\-frustro\-un\-intento\-de\-secuestro\-a\-su\-equipo\-sobre\-una\-autopista/?outputType\=amp\-type\|work\=Infobae\|date\=26 June 2019\|access\-date\=27 June 2019\|title\=El presidente interino Juan Guaidó frustró un intento de secuestro a su equipo sobre una autopista en Venezuela}} According to Guaidó, the group received orders from the Venezuelan Military Counter\-intelligence agency [DGCIM](/wiki/Direcci%C3%B3n_General_de_Contrainteligencia_Militar "Dirección General de Contrainteligencia Militar"), but were not "hostile".
Navy captain [Rafael Acosta Arévalo](/wiki/Rafael_Acosta_Ar%C3%A9valo "Rafael Acosta Arévalo"), who had been arrested on charges related to the alleged foiled coup attempt and transferred to a military hospital, died during detention on 28 June.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1TV0MR\|title\=Venezuela confirms death of detained officer, his wife says he was tortured\|last1\=Sequera\|first1\=Vivian\|date\=30 June 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=1 July 2019\|last2\=Ellsworth\|first2\=Brian}} Maduro administration did not provide a cause of death but announced an investigation on the matter.{{Cite web\|url\=https://apnews.com/31069508ae6b4d84af1b1f4657d2668d\|title\=Death of Venezuelan navy captain draws US condemnation\|date\=30 June 2019\|website\=Associated Press\|access\-date\=1 July 2019}} Acosta Arevalo's wife, human rights advocates, Juan Guaidó and the [US Department of State](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State "United States Department of State") accused Maduro's administration of torturing the captain to death. The Lima Group and the European Union called for an independent investigation.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.dw.com/en/venezuela\-accused\-of\-killing\-naval\-officer/a\-49424685\|title\=Venezuela accused of killing naval officer\|date\=1 July 2019\|website\=Deutsche Welle\|access\-date\=1 July 2019}} The preliminary autopsy determined that Acosta Arévalo's cause of death was "severe [cerebral edema](/wiki/Cerebral_edema "Cerebral edema") \[brain swelling] caused by acute [respiratory failure](/wiki/Respiratory_failure "Respiratory failure") caused by a [pulmonary embolism](/wiki/Pulmonary_embolism "Pulmonary embolism") caused by [rhabdomyolysis](/wiki/Rhabdomyolysis "Rhabdomyolysis") \[a potentially life\-threatening breakdown of muscle fibers] by [multiple trauma](/wiki/Polytrauma "Polytrauma")".{{cite news \|last1\=Phillips \|first1\=Tom \|title\=Venezuela: UN report accuses Maduro of 'gross violations' against dissenters \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/04/venezuela\-un\-report\-nicolas\-maduro\-violations\-against\-dissenters \|access\-date\=11 July 2019 \|agency\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|date\=4 July 2019}}
### Operación Alacrán
{{See also\|Operación Alacrán}}
{{quote box\|width\=250px\|text\=The conditions for any political change in 2020 are getting ever more remote.\|source\=John Magdaleno, Venezuelan consultant}}
An investigation led by [Armando.info](/wiki/Armando.info "Armando.info") reported that nine members of the National Assembly defended individuals sanctioned by the United States for their involvement in the controversial [Local Committees for Supply and Production](/wiki/Local_Committees_for_Supply_and_Production "Local Committees for Supply and Production") (CLAP) program. The investigation reported that the implicated lawmakers had written letters of support to the [United States Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Treasury "United States Treasury") and others to a Colombian man named Carlos Lizcano, who authorities were investigating over his possible links to [Alex Saab](/wiki/Alex_Saab "Alex Saab"), a Colombian businessman associated with the food distribution program and under United States sanctions. According to Armando.info, the lawmakers wrote the letters despite being aware of evidence that tied Lizcano to Saab. Guaidó condemned the actions of the nine legislators, suspending them from their positions and stating that it was "unacceptable to use a state institution to attempt to whitewash the reputation of thieves". The scandal damaged Guaidó's reputation among his supporters in [Venezuela](/wiki/Venezuela "Venezuela"), with some members of the opposition beginning to call for new leadership, according to analysts and those involved.
The Maduro government increased its pressure by "deploying bribes, intimidation and repression" attempting to divide the opposition to maintain power.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\_americas/juan\-guaido\-promised\-to\-save\-venezuela\-a\-year\-later\-the\-flame\-he\-lit\-is\-petering\-out\-his\-us\-backers\-are\-weighing\-their\-options/2019/12/17/48a18186\-1495\-11ea\-80d6\-d0ca7007273f\_story.html\|title\=Juan Guaidó promised to save Venezuela. Now the flame he lit is petering out, and his U.S. backers are weighing their options.\|last\=Faiola\|first\=Anthony\|date\=17 December 2019\|newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]]}}
### Dollarization
Following increased sanctions throughout 2019, the Maduro government abandoned policies established by [Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez "Hugo Chávez") such as price and currency controls. In a November 2019 interview with [José Vicente Rangel](/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Vicente_Rangel "José Vicente Rangel"), President Maduro described [dollarization](/wiki/Currency_substitution "Currency substitution") as an "escape valve" that helps the recovery of the country, the spread of productive forces in the country and the economy. However, Maduro said that the [Venezuelan bolívar](/wiki/Venezuelan_bol%C3%ADvar "Venezuelan bolívar") would still remain as the national currency.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-economy/maduro\-says\-thank\-god\-for\-dollarization\-in\-venezuela\-idUSKBN1XR0RV\|title\=Maduro says 'thank God' for dollarization in Venezuela\|work\=\[\[Reuters]]\|date\=17 November 2019\|access\-date\=18 November 2019}} *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist "The Economist")* wrote that Venezuela had also obtained "extra money from selling gold, both from illegal mines and from its reserves, and narcotics". Its article continued to explain that the improving economy led to more difficulties for Guaidó as Venezuelans who had a better situation were less likely to protest against Maduro.
|
[
"2019 events\n-----------",
"### Inauguration of Maduro",
"In January 2019, [Leopoldo López](/wiki/Leopoldo_L%C3%B3pez \"Leopoldo López\")'s [Popular Will](/wiki/Popular_Will \"Popular Will\") party attained the leadership of the [National Assembly of Venezuela](/wiki/National_Assembly_%28Venezuela%29 \"National Assembly (Venezuela)\") according to a rotation agreement made by opposition parties, naming [Juan Guaidó](/wiki/Juan_Guaid%C3%B3 \"Juan Guaidó\") as [president of the legislative body](/wiki/President_of_the_National_Assembly_of_Venezuela \"President of the National Assembly of Venezuela\").{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|p\\=210 \\|loc\\= Chapter 23: \"Swearing In\"}}\n[left\\|thumb\\|Juan Guaidó surrounded by members of the opposition during the public assembly on 11 January 2019](/wiki/File:Juan_Guaid%C3%B3_open_cabildo_11_January_2019.jpg \"Juan Guaidó open cabildo 11 January 2019.jpg\")",
"Guaidó began motions to form a [provisional government](/wiki/Provisional_government \"Provisional government\") shortly after assuming his new role on 5 January 2019, stating that whether or not Maduro began his new term on the 10th, the country would not have a legitimately elected president in either case,{{cite web \\|title\\=Asamblea Nacional arranca proceso para Ley de Transicion \\|url\\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\\_asamblea\\-nacional\\-arranca\\-proceso\\-para\\-ley\\-de\\-transicion \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190109052303/http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\\_asamblea\\-nacional\\-arranca\\-proceso\\-para\\-ley\\-de\\-transicion \\|archive\\-date\\=9 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=10 January 2019}}{{Primary source inline\\|date\\=September 2023}} calling for soldiers to \"enforce the Constitution\"{{cite web \\|title\\=AN se declara en emergencia ante la usurpación de Nicolás Maduro en el cargo de la Presidencia de la República \\|url\\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\\_an\\-se\\-declara\\-en\\-emergencia\\-ante\\-la\\-usurpacion\\-de\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-en\\-el\\-cargo\\-de\\-la\\-presidencia\\-de\\-la \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111021840/http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\\_an\\-se\\-declara\\-en\\-emergencia\\-ante\\-la\\-usurpacion\\-de\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-en\\-el\\-cargo\\-de\\-la\\-presidencia\\-de\\-la \\|archive\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=10 January 2019 \\|website\\=Asambleanacional.gob.ve \\|language\\=es}}{{Primary source inline\\|date\\=September 2023}} Signs of impending crisis showed when a [Supreme Court](/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_Venezuela \"Supreme Court of Venezuela\") Justice and Electoral Justice seen as close to Maduro defected to the United States just a few days before the 10 January 2019 [second inauguration of Nicolás Maduro](/wiki/Second_inauguration_of_Nicol%C3%A1s_Maduro \"Second inauguration of Nicolás Maduro\"). The justice, {{ill\\|Christian Zerpa\\|es\\|Christian Zerpa}}, said that Maduro was \"incompetent\" and \"illegitimate\".{{cite news \\|date\\=10 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela Swears in an illegitimate President \\|website\\=Financial Times \\|url\\=https://www.ft.com/content/401e52a0\\-1405\\-11e9\\-a581\\-4ff78404524e \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019}}{{Cite news \\|last1\\=Herrero \\|first1\\=Ana Vanessa \\|last2\\=Specia \\|first2\\=Megan \\|date\\=10 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela Is in Crisis. So How Did Maduro Secure a Second Term? \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/10/world/americas/venezuela\\-maduro\\-inauguration.html \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111012015/https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/10/world/americas/venezuela\\-maduro\\-inauguration.html \\|archive\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}}",
"{{cite web \\|title\\=Peru, Paraguay recall diplomats over Maduro inauguration {{!}} Venezuela News \\|url\\=https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/peru\\-paraguay\\-recall\\-diplomats\\-maduro\\-inauguration\\-190110180310100\\.html \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190110232447/https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/peru\\-paraguay\\-recall\\-diplomats\\-maduro\\-inauguration\\-190110180310100\\.html \\|archive\\-date\\=10 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|website\\=Aljazeera.com}}* Minutes after Maduro took the oath as president of Venezuela, the OAS approved a resolution in a special session of its Permanent Council declaring Maduro's presidency illegitimate and urging new elections.{{cite news \\|date\\=10 January 2019 \\|title\\=La OEA aprobó la resolución que declara ilegítimo al nuevo gobierno de Nicolás Maduro \\|language\\=es \\|trans\\-title\\=The OAS approved the resolution that declared the new government of Nicolás Maduro illegitimate \\|work\\=Infobae \\|url\\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/01/10/en\\-vivo\\-la\\-oea\\-debate\\-en\\-sesion\\-extraordinaria\\-la\\-asuncion\\-de\\-nicolas\\-maduro/}} Maduro's election was supported by Turkey, Russia, China, and the Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of Our America ([ALBA](/wiki/ALBA \"ALBA\")).",
"Guaidó announced a public assembly, referred to as an [open cabildo](/wiki/Open_cabildo \"Open cabildo\"), on 11 January, a rally in the streets of Caracas, where Guaidó spoke on behalf of the National Assembly saying that the country had fallen into a *[de facto](/wiki/De_facto \"De facto\")* dictatorship and had no leader.{{cite web \\|last\\=Smith \\|first\\=Scott \\|date\\=10 January 2019 \\|title\\=Isolation greets Maduro's new term as Venezuela's president \\|url\\=https://apnews.com/f1df9924783f49859874f5fc97f0f534 \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111004811/https://apnews.com/f1df9924783f49859874f5fc97f0f534 \\|archive\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|website\\=AP News}}{{cite web \\|title\\=El Tiempo {{!}} Venezuela {{!}} Asamblea Nacional se declaró en emergencia y convocó a cabildo abierto {{!}} El Periódico del Pueblo Oriental \\|url\\=https://eltiempo.com.ve/2019/01/10/asamblea\\-nacional\\-se\\-declaro\\-en\\-emergencia\\-y\\-convoco\\-a\\-cabildo\\-abierto/ \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190111175356/https://eltiempo.com.ve/2019/01/10/asamblea\\-nacional\\-se\\-declaro\\-en\\-emergencia\\-y\\-convoco\\-a\\-cabildo\\-abierto/ \\|archive\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|website\\=eltiempo.com.ve \\|publisher\\=Global Host \\|language\\=es}} Guaidó said that the National Assembly would \"take the responsibility that touches us\". Leaders of other political parties, trade unions, women, and students also spoke at the rally.{{cite web \\|date\\=11 January 2019 \\|title\\=Juan Guaidó: Me apego a los artículos 333, 350 y 233 para lograr el cese de la usurpación y convocar elecciones libres con la unión del pueblo, FAN y comunidad internacional \\|url\\=http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ve/noticias/\\_juan\\-guaido\\-me\\-apego\\-a\\-los\\-articulos\\-333\\-350\\-y\\-233 \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019 \\|work\\=Asamblea Nacional de la República Bolivariana de Venezuela \\|language\\=es}}{{Primary source inline\\|date\\=September 2023}} The opposition considered assuming the powers of the executive branch legitimate based on constitutional processes; The National Assembly specifically invoked Articles 233, 333, and 350 of the Constitution.{{Cite news \\|author\\=Phillips, Tom \\|date\\=11 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela: opposition leader declares himself ready to assume presidency \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/11/venezuela\\-maduro\\-juan\\-guaido\\-assume\\-presidency \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190113100401/https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/11/venezuela\\-maduro\\-juan\\-guaido\\-assume\\-presidency \\|archive\\-date\\=13 January 2019 \\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}} Guaidó announced [nationwide protests](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests \"2019 Venezuelan protests\") to be held on 23 January—the same day as the [removal of Marcos Pérez Jiménez in 1958](/wiki/1958_Venezuelan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat \"1958 Venezuelan coup d'état\")—using a slogan chant of *¡[Sí se puede](/wiki/S%C3%AD_se_puede \"Sí se puede\")!*.{{cite web \\|date\\=11 January 2019 \\|title\\=Parallel government emerging in Venezuela \\|url\\=https://www.argusmedia.com/en/news/1826647\\-parallel\\-government\\-emerging\\-in\\-venezuela\\-update \\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|website\\=Argus Media}} The National Assembly worked with the coalition *Frente Amplio Venezuela Libre* to create a plan for the demonstrations, organizing a unified national force.{{cite web \\|date\\=12 January 2019 \\|title\\=Juan Guaidó y FAVL afinan agenda única para movilización del 23Ene \\|url\\=https://www.analitica.com/actualidad/actualidad\\-nacional/juan\\-guaido\\-y\\-favl\\-afinan\\-agenda\\-unica\\-para\\-movilizacion\\-del\\-23ene/ \\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|website\\=Analitica \\|language\\=es}} On 11 January, plans to offer incentives for the armed forces to disavow Maduro were announced.{{Cite news \\|date\\=11 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela opposition plans incentives for officers who disavow Maduro \\|website\\=Uk.reuters.com \\|url\\=https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk\\-venezuela\\-military\\-idUKKCN1P52HF \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190112065020/https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk\\-venezuela\\-military\\-idUKKCN1P52HF \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=11 January 2019}}",
"#### Guaidó declared acting president",
"[thumb\\|Agreement approved by the National Assembly to declare the usurpation of the presidency by Nicolás Maduro on 15 January 2019\\.During](/wiki/File:Acuerdo_sobre_la_declaratoria_de_usurpaci%C3%B3n_de_la_presidencia_de_la_rep%C3%BAblica_por_parte_de_Nicolas_Maduro_Moros_y_el_restablecimiento_de_la_vigencia_de_la_constituci%C3%B3n_-_P%C3%A1gina_1.jpg \"Acuerdo sobre la declaratoria de usurpación de la presidencia de la república por parte de Nicolas Maduro Moros y el restablecimiento de la vigencia de la constitución - Página 1.jpg\") Guaidó's speech, he said he was \"willing to assume command ... only possible with the help of Venezuelans\". Following Guaidó's speech, the National Assembly released a press statement saying that Guaidó had assumed the role of acting president. The Assembly retracted the statement later published another clarifying Guaidó's position as \"willing to assume command ... only possible with the help of Venezuelans\".",
"Maduro's response was to call the opposition a group of \"little boys\", describing Guaidó as \"immature\". The Minister for Prison Services, [Iris Varela](/wiki/Iris_Varela \"Iris Varela\"), threatened that she had picked out a prison cell for Guaidó and asked him to be quick in naming his cabinet so she could prepare prison cells for them as well.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/venezuela\\-congress\\-leader\\-challenges\\-maduro\\-presidency\\-190111181122362\\.html\\|title\\=Venezuela congress leader challenges Maduro's right to presidency\\|website\\=Al Jazeera\\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019}}",
"The president of the [Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela in exile](/wiki/Supreme_Tribunal_of_Justice_of_Venezuela_in_exile \"Supreme Tribunal of Justice of Venezuela in exile\"), based in Panama, wrote to Guaidó, requesting him to become acting president of Venezuela.{{cite web \\|date\\=12 January 2019 \\|title\\=Tribunal Supremo de Justicia pide a Asamblea Nacional tomar la presidencia de Venezuela \\|url\\=https://www.elsalvador.com/noticias/internacional/557234/tribunal\\-supremo\\-de\\-justicia\\-pide\\-a\\-asamblea\\-nacional\\-tomar\\-la\\-presidencia\\-de\\-venezuela/ \\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|website\\=El Salvador noticias \\|language\\=es}} OAS Secretary\\-General [Luis Almagro](/wiki/Luis_Almagro \"Luis Almagro\") was the first to give international official support to Guaidó's claim, tweeting \"We welcome the assumption of Juan Guaidó as interim president of Venezuela in accordance with Article 233 of the Political Constitution. You have our support, that of the international community and of the people of Venezuela.\" Later that day, Brazil and Colombia gave their support to Guaidó as acting president of Venezuela.{{cite web \\|title\\=Juan Guaidó se declara presidente da venezuela e tem apoio do brasil \\|url\\=https://veja.abril.com.br/mundo/juan\\-guaido\\-se\\-declara\\-presidente\\-da\\-venezuela\\-e\\-tem\\-apoio\\-do\\-brasil/ \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190112180134/https://veja.abril.com.br/mundo/juan\\-guaido\\-se\\-declara\\-presidente\\-da\\-venezuela\\-e\\-tem\\-apoio\\-do\\-brasil/ \\|archive\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=12 January 2019 \\|website\\=VEJA \\|language\\=es}}",
"#### Guaidó briefly detained, plans continue",
"{{see also\\|2019 Venezuelan protests}}\nGuaidó was detained on 13 January by the [Bolivarian Intelligence Service](/wiki/Bolivarian_Intelligence_Service \"Bolivarian Intelligence Service\") (SEBIN){{cite web \\|last\\=Semana \\|date\\=3 August 2003 \\|title\\=Alejandro Baena, candidato liberal a la alcaldía de Cali \\|url\\=https://www.semana.com/noticias/articulo/alejandro\\-baena\\-candidato\\-liberal\\-alcaldia\\-cali/59772\\-3 \\|website\\=Alejandro Baena, candidato liberal a la alcaldía de Cali}} and released 45 minutes later.{{cite news \\|title\\=Venezuela's opposition is gambling it all on a young and untested activist named Juan Guaidó \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]] \\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\\_americas/venezuelas\\-opposition\\-is\\-gambling\\-it\\-all\\-on\\-a\\-young\\-and\\-untested\\-activist\\-named\\-juan\\-guaido/2019/01/14/90156b76\\-16a4\\-11e9\\-ab79\\-30cd4f7926f2\\_story.html \\|access\\-date\\=15 January 2019}} The SEBIN agents who intercepted his car and took him into custody were fired.{{Cite news \\|date\\=13 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela opposition leader briefly detained \\|work\\=\\[\\[BBC News]] \\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-46857643 \\|access\\-date\\=14 January 2019}}{{cite news \\|date\\=13 January 2019 \\|title\\=Gobierno Maduro destituyó a agentes que detuvieron a Juan Guaidó en un procedimiento \"irregular\" \\|language\\=es \\|publisher\\=Noticias Caracol \\|agency\\=EFE \\|url\\=https://noticias.caracoltv.com/mundo/gobierno\\-maduro\\-destituyo\\-agentes\\-que\\-detuvieron\\-juan\\-guaido\\-en\\-un\\-procedimiento\\-irregular \\|access\\-date\\=15 January 2019}} The Information Minister, [Jorge Rodríguez](/wiki/Jorge_Rodr%C3%ADguez_%28Venezuelan_politician%29 \"Jorge Rodríguez (Venezuelan politician)\"), said the agents did not have instructions and the arrest was orchestrated by Guaidó as a \"media stunt\" to gain popularity; [BBC News](/wiki/BBC_News \"BBC News\") correspondents said that it appeared to be a genuine ambush to send a message to the opposition. Almagro condemned the arrest, which he called a \"kidnapping\", while Pompeo referred to it as an \"arbitrary detention\".{{Cite news \\|author\\=Phillips, Tom \\|date\\=13 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela opposition leader briefly detained after challenging Maduro \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/13/venezuela\\-opposition\\-leader\\-briefly\\-detained\\-juan\\-guaido\\-maduro \\|access\\-date\\=14 January 2019 \\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}} After his detention, Guaidó said that Rodríguez's admission that the SEBIN agents acted independently showed that the government had lost control of its security forces; he called [Miraflores](/wiki/Miraflores_Palace \"Miraflores Palace\") (the presidential palace) \"desperate\", and stated: \"There is one legitimate president of the National Assembly and of all Venezuela.\"{{cite web \\|date\\=13 January 2019 \\|title\\=Juan Guaidó desde Vargas: 'Hay un presidente legítimo de la AN y de toda Venezuela' \\|trans\\-title\\=Juan Guaidó from Vargas: 'There is a legitimate president of the NA and of all Venezuela' \\|url\\=https://albertonews.com/principales/juan\\-guaido\\-desde\\-vargas\\-hay\\-un\\-presidente\\-legitimo\\-de\\-la\\-an\\-y\\-de\\-toda\\-venezuela/ \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190114153207/https://albertonews.com/principales/juan\\-guaido\\-desde\\-vargas\\-hay\\-un\\-presidente\\-legitimo\\-de\\-la\\-an\\-y\\-de\\-toda\\-venezuela/ \\|archive\\-date\\=14 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=13 May 2019 \\|website\\=albertonews.com}}",
"On 15 January 2019, the National Assembly approved legislation to work with dozens of foreign countries to request that these nations freeze Maduro administration bank accounts.{{cite news \\|date\\=15 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela congress asks foreign countries to freeze Maduro\\-linked accounts \\|work\\=Reuters \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-freeze\\-idUSKCN1P92G3 \\|access\\-date\\=15 January 2019}} Guaidó wrote a 15 January 2019 opinion piece in *[The Washington Post](/wiki/The_Washington_Post \"The Washington Post\")* entitled \"Maduro is a usurper. It's time to restore [democracy in Venezuela](/wiki/Democracy_in_Venezuela \"Democracy in Venezuela\")\"; he outlined Venezuela's erosion of democracy and his reasoning for the need to replace Maduro on an interim basis according to Venezuela's constitution.{{cite news \\|author\\=Guaidó, Juan \\|title\\=Maduro is a usurper. It's time to restore democracy in Venezuela. \\|newspaper\\=The Washington Post \\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/01/15/maduro\\-is\\-usurper\\-its\\-time\\-restore\\-democracy\\-venezuela/?noredirect\\=on \\|access\\-date\\=20 January 2019}}",
"On 21 January, over two dozen National Guardsmen participated in a mutiny against Maduro with the assistance of residents in the area during the early morning hours. Government forces repressed the protestors tear gas and the officers were later captured.{{Cite news \\|date\\=21 January 2019 \\|title\\=Venezuela: Reprimen a vecinos que respaldan levantamiento militar contra Maduro \\|language\\=es \\|website\\=\\[\\[El Comercio (Peru)\\|El Comercio]] \\|url\\=https://elcomercio.pe/mundo/venezuela/cotiza\\-reprimen\\-vecinos\\-respaldan\\-levantamiento\\-guardia\\-nacional\\-bolivariana\\-gnb\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-videos\\-noticia\\-599586\\-noticia/ \\|access\\-date\\=1 February 2020}}{{Cite news \\|last\\=Phillips \\|first\\=Tom \\|date\\=2019\\-01\\-22 \\|title\\=Venezuela claims it has foiled attempted military uprising \\|language\\=en\\-GB \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/21/venezuela\\-claims\\-foiled\\-attempted\\-military\\-uprising \\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-01\\-22 \\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}} During the night, over thirty communities in Caracas and surrounding areas participated in strong protests against the Maduro government.{{Cite web \\|date\\=2019\\-01\\-22 \\|title\\=Seguid el ejemplo que Caracas dio: Confirman protestas nocturnas contra Maduro en 30 comunidades capitalinas \\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/22/seguid\\-el\\-ejemplo\\-que\\-caracas\\-dio\\-confirman\\-protestas\\-nocturnas\\-contra\\-maduro\\-en\\-30\\-comunidades\\-capitalinas/ \\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-01\\-22 \\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]] \\|language\\=es\\-ES}} The strongest protests occurred in San José de Cotiza, where the rebel National Guardsmen were arrested, with demonstrations spreading throughout nearby communities, with [cacerolazos](/wiki/Cacerolazo \"Cacerolazo\") heard throughout Caracas. One woman who was confused for a protester was killed in San José de Cotiza by members of a [colectivo](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 \"Colectivo (Venezuela)\"), who stole her phone.{{Cite web \\|date\\=2019\\-01\\-21 \\|title\\=Mujer fue asesinada en la puerta de su casa por un colectivo en Cotiza \\|url\\=http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/sucesos/mujer\\-fue\\-asesinada\\-puerta\\-casa\\-por\\-colectivo\\-cotiza\\_267452 \\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-01\\-22 \\|website\\=\\[\\[El Nacional (Caracas)\\|El Nacional]] \\|language\\=es}} On 22 January, Vice President [Mike Pence](/wiki/Mike_Pence \"Mike Pence\") called Guaidó personally and assured him that the United States would support his declaration.{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|pp\\=211\\-217 \\|loc\\= Chapter 23: \"Swearing In\"}}",
"### Guaidó declares himself acting president",
"[thumb\\|left\\|23 January 2019 march in Caracas](/wiki/File:23_Jan_2019_venezuela_protest_march_vid.webm \"23 Jan 2019 venezuela protest march vid.webm\")",
"On 23 January, Guaidó swore to serve as acting president. On that morning, Guaidó tweeted, \"The world's eyes are on our homeland today.\"{{cite web \\|url\\= https://twitter.com/jguaido/status/1088048732967501824 \\|publisher\\= Twitter \\|author\\= Guaido, Juan \\|title\\= Juan Guaidó on Twitter \\|date\\= 23 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 7 February 2019}} On that day, millions of Venezuelans{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/revolt\\-in\\-venezuela\\-11548289111\\|title\\=Revolt in Venezuela\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Wall Street Journal]]\\|access\\-date\\=24 January 2019\\|date\\= 23 January 2019}} demonstrated across the country and world in support of Guaidó,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\\-america\\-latina\\-46979531 \\|work\\= BBC News Mundo \\|language\\=es \\|title\\= Protestas en Venezuela: miles de personas participan en manifestaciones masivas contra el gobierno de Maduro \\|date\\= 23 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 January 2019}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/01/24/las\\-50\\-fotos\\-de\\-las\\-masivas\\-marchas\\-contra\\-la\\-dictadura\\-de\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-en\\-venezuela\\-y\\-latinoamerica/ \\|language\\=es \\|title\\= Las 50 fotos de las masivas marchas contra la dictadura de Nicolás Maduro en Venezuela y Latinoamérica \\|work\\= Infobae \\|date\\= 24 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 January 2019}} with a few hundred supporting Maduro outside Miraflores.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/23/americas/venezuela\\-protests/index.html \\|title\\= Maduro defiant as Venezuelan opposition leader declares himself acting president \\|author\\= Sanchez, Ray and Nicole Chavez \\|work\\= CNN \\|date\\= 23 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 January 2019}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/23/enezuela\\-trump\\-president\\-juan\\-guaido\\-maduro\\-recognition\\-news\\-latest\\|title\\=Venezuela: Trump recognises opposition leader as president\\|last\\=Daniels\\|first\\=Joe Parkin\\|date\\=23 January 2019\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]]\\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2019\\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}} At one end of the blocked street was a stage where Guaidó spoke and took an oath to serve as interim president.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\\-01\\-23/venezuelans\\-heed\\-call\\-to\\-hit\\-streets\\-with\\-maduro\\-under\\-pressure\\|title\\=Venezuelans heed call to hit the streets with Maduro under pressure\\|website\\=Bloomberg.com\\|date\\=23 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\\_americas/venezuela\\-opposition\\-leader\\-juan\\-guaido\\-declares\\-himself\\-interim\\-president\\-before\\-thousands\\-cheering\\-in\\-support/2019/01/23/9f5e7f32\\-1f37\\-11e9\\-a759\\-2b8541bbbe20\\_story.html\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190123180113/https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\\_americas/venezuela\\-opposition\\-leader\\-juan\\-guaido\\-declares\\-himself\\-interim\\-president\\-before\\-thousands\\-cheering\\-in\\-support/2019/01/23/9f5e7f32\\-1f37\\-11e9\\-a759\\-2b8541bbbe20\\_story.html\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-date\\=23 January 2019\\|title\\=Venezuela opposition leader Juan Guaido declares himself interim president before thousands cheering in support\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[Washington Post]]\\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/americas/live\\-news/venezuela\\-protests\\-2019/index.html\\|title\\=Violent protests in Venezuela: Live updates\\|date\\=23 January 2019\\|website\\=CNN\\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2019}} Minutes after his speech, the United States announced that it recognized Guaidó as interim president while presidents [Iván Duque](/wiki/Iv%C3%A1n_Duque \"Iván Duque\") of Colombia and [Jair Bolsonaro](/wiki/Jair_Bolsonaro \"Jair Bolsonaro\") of Brazil, beside deputy Canadian prime minister [Chrystia Freeland](/wiki/Chrystia_Freeland \"Chrystia Freeland\"), announced at the [World Economic Forum](/wiki/World_Economic_Forum \"World Economic Forum\") that they too recognized him.{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|pp\\=211\\-217 \\|loc\\= Chapter 23: \"Swearing In\"}}",
"The [Venezuelan National Guard](/wiki/Venezuelan_National_Guard \"Venezuelan National Guard\") used tear gas on gathering crowds at other locations, and [blocked protesters from arriving](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests \"2019 Venezuelan protests\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/23/venezuela\\-protests\\-thousands\\-march\\-against\\-maduro\\-as\\-opposition\\-sees\\-chance\\-for\\-change\\|title\\=Venezuela protests: thousands march as military faces call to abandon Maduro\\|author\\=Daniels, Joe Parkin\\|date\\=23 January 2019\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]]\\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2019\\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}} Some protests grew violent,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/gallery/2019/jan/24/venezuela\\-protests\\-as\\-two\\-leaders\\-vie\\-to\\-be\\-president\\-in\\-pictures\\|title\\=Venezuela protests as two leaders vie to be president – in pictures\\|website\\=The Guardian\\|date\\=24 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=24 January 2019}} and at least 13 people were killed.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/23/reportan\\-13\\-fallecidos\\-tras\\-ultimas\\-protestas\\-en\\-todo\\-el\\-pais\\-23ene/\\|title\\=Reportan 13 fallecidos tras últimas protestas en todo el país \\#23Ene\\|date\\=23 January 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=24 January 2019}} [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet \"Michelle Bachelet\") of the [United Nations](/wiki/United_Nations \"United Nations\") requested a UN investigation into the security forces' use of violence.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://edition.cnn.com/2019/01/25/americas/venezuela\\-maduro\\-guaido\\-us\\-embassy\\-consulates/index.html\\|title\\=UN calls for Venezuela investigation\\|website\\=CNN\\|date\\=25 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=25 January 2019}}",
"[thumb\\|[Mike Pence](/wiki/Mike_Pence \"Mike Pence\") meets with Carlos Vecchio, [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges \"Julio Borges\"), and other Washington\\-based Venezuelan representatives on 29 January 2019](/wiki/File:Mike_Pence_meets_with_Carlos_Vecchio%2C_Julio_Borges_y_Venezuelan_gov%27t_in_exile.png \"Mike Pence meets with Carlos Vecchio, Julio Borges y Venezuelan gov't in exile.png\")\nGuaidó began to appoint individuals in late January to serve as aides or diplomats, including [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio \"Carlos Vecchio\") as the Guaidó administration's diplomatic envoy to the US,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-usa/trump\\-administration\\-accepts\\-guaido\\-ally\\-as\\-venezuela\\-envoy\\-in\\-us\\-idUSKCN1PL0TO \\|title\\= Trump administration accepts Guaido ally as Venezuela envoy in U.S.\\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 27 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 27 January 2019}} [Gustavo Tarre](/wiki/Gustavo_Tarre \"Gustavo Tarre\") to the OAS,{{cite web \\|url\\= https://www.csis.org/events/conversation\\-venezuelas\\-new\\-permanent\\-representative\\-oas\\-special\\-ambassador\\-gustavo\\-tarre \\|publisher\\= Center for Strategic and International Studies \\|title\\= A Conversation with Venezuela's New Permanent Representative to the OAS, Special Ambassador Gustavo Tarre \\|date\\= 29 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 29 January 2019}} and [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges \"Julio Borges\") to represent Venezuela in the [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group \"Lima Group\").{{cite news \\|url\\= http://noticias.alianzanews.com/309\\_hispanic\\-world/5924526\\_venezuelan\\-parliament\\-oks\\-guaido\\-s\\-diplomatic\\-appointments.html \\|title\\= Venezuelan Parliament OKs Guaido's diplomatic appointments \\|date\\= 29 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 January 2019 \\|work\\= Alianza News \\|archive\\-date\\= 30 January 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190130110641/http://noticias.alianzanews.com/309\\_hispanic\\-world/5924526\\_venezuelan\\-parliament\\-oks\\-guaido\\-s\\-diplomatic\\-appointments.html \\|url\\-status\\= dead }} He announced that the National Assembly had approved a commission to implement a plan for the reconstruction of Venezuela,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://elcomercio.pe/mundo/venezuela/juan\\-guaido\\-vivo\\-presenta\\-plan\\-pais\\-rescatar\\-venezuela\\-noticia\\-603012 \\|title\\= En vivo: Juan Guaidó presenta su Plan País para rescatar a Venezuela \\|work\\= El Comercio \\|date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 31 January 2019}}{{cite news \\|url\\= http://caraboboesnoticia.com/instalada\\-comision\\-plan\\-pais\\-de\\-la\\-asamblea\\-nacional/ \\|language\\= es \\|work\\= Caraboboes Noticia \\|date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|title\\= Instalada Comision Plan Pais de la Asamblea Nacional \\|archive\\-date\\= 22 April 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190422193805/http://caraboboesnoticia.com/instalada\\-comision\\-plan\\-pais\\-de\\-la\\-asamblea\\-nacional/ \\|url\\-status\\= dead }} called [Plan País](/wiki/Plan_Pa%C3%ADs \"Plan País\") (Plan for the Country),{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.univision.com/univision\\-news/latin\\-america/venezuelas\\-guaido\\-to\\-announce\\-national\\-reconstruction\\-plan\\-for\\-the\\-day\\-after \\|date\\= 30 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 February 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela's Guaidó to announce national reconstruction plan 'for the day after' \\|author\\= Adams, David and Tamoa Calzadilla \\|work\\= Univision}} and he offered an [Amnesty law](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_Amnesty_Law \"2019 Venezuelan Amnesty Law\"), approved by the National Assembly, for military personnel and authorities who help to \"restore constitutional order\".{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/juan\\-guaido\\-ofrecio\\-detalles\\-sobre\\-ley\\-amnistia\\_268057 \\|language\\=es \\| title\\= Juan Guaidó ofreció detalles sobre Ley de Amnistía \\|work\\= El Nacional \\|date\\= 25 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 28 January 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-46997555\\|title\\=Venezuela's Maduro 'could get amnesty'\\|date\\=25 January 2019\\|work\\=BBC News\\|access\\-date\\=25 January 2019}} The [Statute Governing the Transition to Democracy](/wiki/Statute_Governing_the_Transition_to_Democracy \"Statute Governing the Transition to Democracy\") was approved by the National Assembly on 5 February.{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/estatuto\\-que\\-rige\\-transicion\\-entro\\-vigencia\\-martes\\_269938 \\|title\\= El estatuto que rige la transición entró en vigencia el martes \\|trans\\-title\\= The statute governing the transition took effect on Tuesday \\|language\\= es \\|work\\= El Nacional \\|date\\= 8 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 9 March 2019 \\| author\\= Brito, Estefani}}",
"As of July 2019, the National Assembly had approved Juan Guaidó's appointment has named 37 ambassadors and foreign representatives to international organizations and nations abroad.{{cite web\\|title\\=Asamblea Nacional nombra \"representantes diplomáticos\" del gobierno de Guaidó ante el hemisferio\\|url\\=https://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/mundo/america\\-latina/venezuela\\-es/article225236365\\.html\\|access\\-date\\=30 January 2019\\|website\\=elnuevoherald\\|language\\=en}}{{cite news\\|date\\=29 January 2019\\|title\\=El Parlamento de Venezuela nombra \"representantes diplomáticos\" ante una decena de países y el Grupo de Lima\\|work\\=Europa Press\\|agency\\=Reuters\\|url\\=https://www.europapress.es/internacional/noticia\\-parlamento\\-venezuela\\-nombra\\-representantes\\-diplomaticos\\-decena\\-paises\\-grupo\\-lima\\-20190129191705\\.html\\|access\\-date\\=30 January 2019}}{{cite web\\|date\\=5 February 2019\\|title\\=AN designó nuevos embajadores de Venezuela en Brasil, Paraguay y Guatemala\\|url\\=https://noticiero52\\.com/an\\-realizo\\-sesion\\-ordinaria\\-este\\-martes/\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190207020447/https://noticiero52\\.com/an\\-realizo\\-sesion\\-ordinaria\\-este\\-martes/\\|archive\\-date\\=7 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=6 February 2019\\|website\\=Noticiero 52}}{{cite web\\|last\\=Manzi\\|first\\=Waleska\\|date\\=19 February 2019\\|title\\=Designados por la Asamblea Nacional 17 nuevos embajadores venezolanos\\|url\\=https://evtvmiami.com/designados\\-por\\-la\\-asamblea\\-nacional\\-17\\-nuevos\\-embajadores\\-venezolanos/\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019\\|website\\=EvTV\\|archive\\-date\\=21 February 2019\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190221054722/https://evtvmiami.com/designados\\-por\\-la\\-asamblea\\-nacional\\-17\\-nuevos\\-embajadores\\-venezolanos/\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"| Organization/country | Official |\n| --- | --- |\n| {{Flag\\|OAS}} | [Gustavo Tarre Briceño](/wiki/Gustavo_Tarre_Brice%C3%B1o \"Gustavo Tarre Briceño\") |\n| [Inter\\-American Development Bank](/wiki/Inter-American_Development_Bank \"Inter-American Development Bank\") | [Alejandro Plaz](/wiki/Alejandro_Plaz \"Alejandro Plaz\"){{efn\\|name\\=\"Resignations\"\\|In August 2019, ambassador to the Czech Republic, \\[\\[Tamara Sujú]], resigned. On September, \\[\\[Ricardo Hausmann]] also resigned as the Venezuelan representative to the \\[\\[Inter\\-American Development Bank]].{{Cite web \\|date\\=2019\\-09\\-27 \\|title\\=Ricardo Haussmann renuncia a representación de Venezuela por Guaidó ante el BID \\|trans\\-title\\=Ricardo Haussmann resigns to Venezuela's representation for Guaidó at the IDB \\|url\\=https://runrun.es/noticias/389456/ricardo\\-haussmann\\-renuncia\\-a\\-representacion\\-de\\-venezuela\\-por\\-guaido\\-ante\\-el\\-bid/ \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-11\\-15 \\|website\\=\\[\\[Runrunes]] \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[El Pitazo]]}}{{Cite web \\|date\\=2019\\-09\\-27 \\|title\\=Ricardo Hausmann renuncia a responsabilidades en el BID \\|trans\\-title\\=Ricardo Hausmann resigns from responsibilities at the IDB \\|url\\=https://www.elnacional.com/venezuela/ricardo\\-hausmann\\-renuncia\\-a\\-responsabilidades\\-en\\-el\\-bid/ \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-11\\-15 \\|website\\=\\[\\[El Nacional (Venezuela)\\|El Nacional]] \\|language\\=es}}}} |\n| Lima Group | [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges \"Julio Borges\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Andorra}} | [Carmen Alguindingue](/wiki/Carmen_Alguindingue \"Carmen Alguindingue\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Argentina}} | [Elisa Trotta Gamus](/wiki/Elisa_Trotta_Gamus \"Elisa Trotta Gamus\") (2019–2020\\){{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-argentina\\-venezuela\\-trotta\\-idUSKBN1Z62IM\\|title\\=Argentina revokes credentials of representative for Venezuela's Guaido\\|date\\=7 January 2020\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=10 January 2020\\|language\\=en}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Australia}} | Alejandro Martínez |\n| {{Flag\\|Belgium}} | {{ill\\|Mary Ponte\\|es}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Brasil}} | [María Teresa Belandria](/wiki/Mar%C3%ADa_Teresa_Belandria \"María Teresa Belandria\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Bulgaria}} | {{ill\\|Estefanía Meléndez\\|es}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Canada}} | Orlando Viera Blanco |\n| {{Flag\\|Chile}} | {{ill\\|Guarequena Gutiérrez\\|es}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Colombia}} | *Vacant*{{efn\\|On 26 November 2019, Guaidó dismissed his ambassador in Colombia, \\[\\[Humberto Calderón Berti\\|Humberto Calderón]], citing plans to change foreign policy.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.diariolasamericas.com/america\\-latina/guaido\\-destituyo\\-humberto\\-calderon\\-berti\\-como\\-embajador\\-venezuela\\-colombia\\-n4188404\\|title\\=Guaidó destituyó al embajador de Venezuela en Colombia\\|date\\=27 November 2019\\|website\\=Diario las Américas\\|language\\=es\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191128213134/https://www.diariolasamericas.com/america\\-latina/guaido\\-destituyo\\-humberto\\-calderon\\-berti\\-como\\-embajador\\-venezuela\\-colombia\\-n4188404\\|archive\\-date\\=28 November 2019\\|access\\-date\\=1 December 2019}} Venezuelan diplomat \\[\\[Diego Arria]] condemned the dismissal, calling it a \"huge mistake.\"{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.elimpulso.com/2019/11/27/diego\\-arria\\-rechazo\\-destitucion\\-humberto\\-calderon\\-berti\\-es\\-todo\\-un\\-desproposito\\-27nov/\\|title\\=Diego Arria rechazó destitución Humberto Calderón Berti: Es todo un despropósito \\#27Nov\\|last\\=Vidal\\|first\\=Brian\\|date\\=27 November 2019\\|website\\=El Impulso\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=1 December 2019}}}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Costa Rica}} | María Faría |\n| {{Flag\\|Czech Republic}} | *Vacant*{{efn\\|name\\=\"Resignations\"}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Denmark}} | Enrique Ser Horst |\n| {{Flag\\|Dominican Republic}} | Eusebio Carlino |\n| {{Flag\\|Ecuador}} | René de Sola |\n| {{Flag\\|France}} | [Isadora Zubillaga](/wiki/Isadora_Zubillaga \"Isadora Zubillaga\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Germany}} | Otto Gebauer |\n| {{Flag\\|Greece}} | [Eduardo Fernando Massieu](/wiki/Eduardo_Fernando_Massieu \"Eduardo Fernando Massieu\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Guatemala}} | {{ill\\|María Teresa Romero\\|es\\|María Teresa Romero (politóloga)}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Honduras}} | Claudio Sandoval |\n| {{Flag\\|Hungary}} | Enrique Alvarado |\n| {{Flag\\|Israel}} | [Pynchas Brener](/wiki/Pynchas_Brener \"Pynchas Brener\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Luxembourg}} | [Angelina Jaffe](/wiki/Angelina_Jaffe \"Angelina Jaffe\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Malta}} | Felipe Zoghbi |\n| {{Flag\\|Morocco}} | José Ignacio Guédez |\n| {{Flag\\|Netherlands}} | [Gloria Notaro](/wiki/Gloria_Notaro \"Gloria Notaro\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Panama}} | [Fabiola Zavarce](/wiki/Fabiola_Zavarce \"Fabiola Zavarce\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Paraguay}} | David Olsen |\n| {{Flag\\|Peru}} | Carlos Scull |\n| {{Flag\\|Poland}} | [Ana Medina](/wiki/Ana_Medina \"Ana Medina\") |\n| {{Flag\\|Portugal}} | José Rafael Cotas |\n| {{Flag\\|Romania}} | Memo Mazzone |\n| {{Flag\\|Spain}} | {{ill\\|Antonio Ecarri Bolívar\\|es}} |\n| {{Flag\\|Sweden}} | León Poblete |\n| {{Flag\\|Switzerland}} | {{ill\\|María Alejandra Aristeguieta\\|es}} |\n| {{Flag\\|United Kingdom}} | [Vanessa Neumann](/wiki/Vanessa_Neumann \"Vanessa Neumann\") |\n| {{Flag\\|United States}} | [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio \"Carlos Vecchio\") |",
"",
"#### Maduro response",
"Maduro accused the United States of backing a coup and said he would cut ties with them.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/23/americas/venezuela\\-protests/index.html\\|title\\=Maduro defiant as Venezuelan opposition leader declares himself acting president\\|author\\=Sanchez, Ray and Nicole Chavez \\|work\\= CNN\\|date\\=23 January 2019\\|access\\-date\\= 28 January 2019}} He said Guaidó's actions were part of a \"well\\-written script from Washington\" to create a [puppet state](/wiki/Puppet_state \"Puppet state\") of the United States,{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\\-rueda\\-prensa/\\|title\\=Maduro: Hay un golpe mediático internacional contra Venezuela para desfigurar la situación real\\|date\\=25 January 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=26 January 2019}} and appealed to the American people in a 31 January video, asking them not to \"convert Venezuela into another Vietnam\".{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cbsnews.com/news/venezuela\\-nicolas\\-maduros\\-military\\-us\\-backed\\-juan\\-guaido\\-calls\\-for\\-support/\\|title\\=Venezuela power struggle hinges on Nicolas Maduro's military\\|date\\=31 January 2019\\|work\\=CBS News\\|access\\-date\\=2 February 2019}}",
"Maduro asked for dialogue with Guaidó, saying \"if I have to go meet this boy in the [Pico Humboldt](/wiki/Pico_Humboldt \"Pico Humboldt\") at three in the morning I am going, \\[...] if I have to go naked, I am going, \\[I believe] that today, sooner rather than later, the way is open for a reasonable, sincere dialogue\".{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\\-reunion\\-guaido\\-desnudo/\\|title\\=Maduro está dispuesto a reunirse con Guaidó \"desnudo o a las tres de la mañana en el Humboldt\"\\|date\\=25 January 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=26 January 2019}} He stated he would not leave the presidential office, saying that he was elected in compliance with the Venezuelan constitution.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/01/25/maduro\\-no\\-dejare\\-cargo/\\|title\\=Maduro se atornilló en la silla: No he abandonado, ni dejaré el cargo\\|date\\=25 January 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=26 January 2019}} With the two giving speeches to supporters at the same time, Guaidó replied to Maduro's call for dialogue, saying he would not initiate diplomatic talks with Maduro because he believed it would be a farce and fake diplomacy that could not achieve anything.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-47009301\\|title\\=Venezuela crisis: Guaidó rejects calls to talk with Maduro\\|work\\=BBC News \\|date\\=25 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=25 January 2019}}",
"On 18 February, Maduro's government expelled a group of Members of the [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament \"European Parliament\") that planned to meet Guaidó.{{cite news\\|url\\=http://efectococuyo.com/principales/espana\\-y\\-francia\\-condenan\\-la\\-expulsion\\-de\\-eurodiputados\\-de\\-venezuela/\\|title\\=España y Francia condenan la expulsión de eurodiputados de Venezuela\\|date\\=18 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019\\|agency\\=\\[\\[Efecto Cocuyo]]\\|language\\=es}} The expulsion was condemned by Guaidó as well as [Pablo Casado](/wiki/Pablo_Casado \"Pablo Casado\"), president of the [Spanish People's Party](/wiki/People%27s_Party_%28Spain%29 \"People's Party (Spain)\"), and the Colombian government.{{Cite news\\|url\\=http://efectococuyo.com/internacionales/expulsion\\-de\\-europarlamentarios\\-recibe\\-condena\\-nacional\\-e\\-internacional/\\|title\\=Expulsión de europarlamentarios recibe condena nacional e internacional\\|last\\=Fermín Kancev\\|first\\=María Victoria\\|date\\=17 February 2019\\|work\\=Efecto Cocuyo\\|access\\-date\\=4 March 2019\\|language\\=es}} Maduro's Foreign Minister [Jorge Arreaza](/wiki/Jorge_Arreaza \"Jorge Arreaza\") defended the expulsions,{{Cite tweet \\|user\\=jaarreaza \\|number\\=1097290259551977472 \\|date \\= 17 February 2019 \\|title\\=Por vías oficiales diplomáticas, las autoridades del Gobierno Bolivariano de Venezuela le notificaron hace varios días al grupo de eurodiputados que pretendía visitar el país con fines conspirativos, que no serían admitidos y se les instó a desistir y evitar así otra provocación \\[Through official diplomatic channels, the authorities of the Bolivarian Government of Venezuela notified him several days ago to the group of MEPs who intended to visit the country for conspiratorial purposes, who would not be admitted and were urged to desist and avoid another provocation.]}} saying that the constitutional government of Venezuela \"will not allow the European extreme right to disturb the peace and stability of the country with another of its gross interventionist actions.\"{{Cite tweet \\|user\\=jaarreaza \\|number\\=1097290265763741696 \\|date \\= 17 February 2019 \\|title\\=El Gobierno Constitucional de la República Bolivariana de Venezuela no permitirá que la extrema derecha europea perturbe la paz y estabilidad del país con otra de sus groseras acciones injerencistas. ¡Venezuela se Respeta! \\[The Constitutional Government of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela will not allow the European extreme right to disturb the peace and stability of the country with another of its gross interventionist actions. Venezuela must be respected!]}}",
"### Humanitarian aid crisis",
"{{main\\|2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela}}\n{{Location map\\+ \\| Venezuela\n\\| caption \\= Location of the proposed entry points for humanitarian aid.\n\\| places \\=\n {{Location map\\~ \\| Venezuela\n \\| label \\= {{flagicon\\|Colombia}} Cúcuta\n \\| lat\\_deg \\= 7\\.54\n \\| lon\\_deg \\= \\-72\\.30 }}\n {{Location map\\~ \\| Venezuela\n \\| label \\= {{flagicon\\|Brazil}} Pacaraima\n \\| lat\\_deg \\= 4\\.25\n \\| lon\\_deg \\= \\-61\\.08 }}\n {{Location map\\~ \\| Venezuela\n \\| label \\= {{flagicon\\|Kingdom of the Netherlands}} Curaçao\n \\| lat\\_deg \\= 12\\.11\n \\| lon\\_deg \\= \\-69\\.00 }}\n}}",
"[Shortages in Venezuela](/wiki/Shortages_in_Venezuela \"Shortages in Venezuela\") have been present since 2007 during the presidency of [Hugo Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez \"Hugo Chávez\").{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.eluniversal.com/economia/120106/shortage\\-at\\-its\\-highest\\-since\\-may\\-2008\\|title\\=Shortage at its highest since May 2008\\|date\\=6 January 2012\\|access\\-date\\=3 December 2014\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170806145021/http://www.eluniversal.com/economia/120106/shortage\\-at\\-its\\-highest\\-since\\-may\\-2008\\|archive\\-date\\=6 August 2017\\|url\\-status\\=bot: unknown\\|agency\\=El Universal}} In 2016, the [National Assembly of Venezuela](/wiki/National_Assembly_of_Venezuela \"National Assembly of Venezuela\") declared a humanitarian crisis, asking Maduro's government to provide access to essential medicines and medical supplies. Before the presidential crisis, the Maduro government denied several offers of aid, stating that there was not a humanitarian crisis and that such claims were used to justify foreign intervention.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.lapatilla.com/2018/09/26/maduro\\-niega\\-la\\-diaspora\\-venezolana\\-en\\-la\\-onu\\-se\\-ha\\-fabricado\\-por\\-distintas\\-vias\\-una\\-crisis\\-migratoria\\-que\\-se\\-cae\\-por\\-su\\-propio\\-peso/\\|title\\=Maduro niega la diáspora venezolana en la ONU: Se ha fabricado por distintas vías una crisis migratoria \\- LaPatilla.com\\|date\\=26 September 2018\\|work\\=\\[\\[LaPatilla.com]]\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019\\|language\\=es\\-ES}} \n\\* {{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.cnn.com/2016/10/13/americas/cnnphotos\\-venezuela\\-food\\-crisis/\\|title\\=The face of hunger in Venezuela\\|author\\=Charner, Flora\\|date\\=15 October 2016\\|work\\=\\[\\[CNN]]\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019}} \n\\* {{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/venezuelans\\-die\\-as\\-maduro\\-government\\-refuses\\-medical\\-aid\\-1523025805\\|title\\=Venezuelans Die as Maduro Government Refuses Medical Aid\\|author\\=Vyas, Kejal and Ryan Dube\\|date\\=6 April 2018\\|work\\=\\[\\[The Wall Street Journal]]\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019\\|issn\\=0099\\-9660}} \n\\* {{Cite news\\|url\\=http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/the\\-country\\-of\\-hunger\\-inside\\-the\\-deep\\-suffering\\-in\\-venezuela\\-s\\-hospitals\\-a\\-1221061\\.html\\|title\\=The Country of Hunger: A State of Deep Suffering in Venezuela's Hospitals\\|author\\=Glüsing, Jens\\|date\\=8 August 2018\\|work\\=\\[\\[Der Spiegel]]\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019}} Maduro's refusal of aid worsened the effects of Venezuela's crisis. During the presidential crisis, Maduro initially refused aid, stating that Venezuela is not a country of \"beggars\".{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/02/19/la\\-contradiccion\\-de\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-sobre\\-la\\-ayuda\\-humanitaria\\-en\\-14\\-dias/\\|title\\=La contradicción de Nicolás Maduro sobre la ayuda humanitaria en 14 días\\|date\\=19 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[Infobae]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=20 February 2019}}",
"Guaidó made bringing humanitarian aid to the country a priority.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190205\\-venezuela\\-opposition\\-warns\\-military\\-against\\-preventing\\-entry\\-aid\\|title\\=Venezuela opposition warns military against preventing entry of aid\\|date\\=5 February 2019\\|work\\=France24\\|access\\-date\\=5 February 2019}} In early February, Maduro prevented the American\\-sponsored aid from entering Venezuela via Colombia,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.foxnews.com/world/venezuela\\-military\\-sets\\-up\\-blockade\\-on\\-bridge\\-to\\-stop\\-aid\\-from\\-colombia\\|title\\=Venezuela military sets up blockade on bridge to stop aid from Colombia\\|author\\=Suarez Sang, Lucia I.\\|date\\=6 February 2019\\|work\\=Fox News\\|access\\-date\\=6 February 2019}} and Venezuela's communications minister, Jorge Rodriguez, said there was a plot between Colombia, the [CIA](/wiki/CIA \"CIA\") and exiled Venezuelan politician [Julio Borges](/wiki/Julio_Borges \"Julio Borges\") to oust Maduro.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.apnews.com/b5481d5ad47d4ec2be132ed51b72e483\\|title\\=US emergency aid for Venezuela arrives at Colombian border\\|author\\=Armario, Christine \\|author2\\= \\[\\[Leonardo Haberkorn]]\\|date\\=7 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=7 February 2019\\|work\\=Associated Press}} Humanitarian aid intended for Venezuela was also stockpiled on the Brazilian border,{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/20/maduro\\-envia\\-tanquetas\\-a\\-santa\\-elena\\-de\\-uairen\\-para\\-evitar\\-ingreso\\-de\\-ayuda\\-desde\\-brasil\\-fotos/\\|title\\=Maduro envía tanquetas a Santa Elena de Uairén para evitar ingreso de ayuda desde Brasil (FOTOS)\\|date\\=20 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019}} and two indigenous [Pemon](/wiki/Pemon \"Pemon\") people were killed as they attempted to block military vehicles from entering the area, when members of armed forces loyal to Maduro fired upon them with live ammunition.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/22/reportan\\-que\\-la\\-fanb\\-tiroteo\\-a\\-indigenas\\-en\\-la\\-gran\\-sabana/\\|title\\=Militares de Maduro tirotearon a indígenas pemón en la Gran Sabana: Una mujer asesinada y doce heridos (fotos)\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/22/pemones\\-heridos\\-en\\-ataque\\-de\\-la\\-gnb\\-son\\-trasladados\\-a\\-hospital\\-en\\-brasil\\-por\\-falta\\-de\\-insumos\\-en\\-venezuela\\-foto\\-y\\-video/\\|title\\=Pemones heridos en ataque de la GNB son trasladados a hospital en Brasil por falta de insumos en Venezuela (FOTO y VIDEO)\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://news.trust.org/item/20190222215031\\-a8xxv/\\|title\\=As tensions over aid rise, Venezuelan troops fire on villagers, kill two\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[Thomson Reuters Foundation]]\\|access\\-date\\=23 February 2019}}",
"Guaidó issued an ultimatum to the Venezuelan Armed Forces, stating that humanitarian aid would enter Venezuela on 23 February and that the armed forces \"will have to decide if it will be on the side of the Venezuelans and the Constitution or the usurper\".{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/12/guaido\\-en\\-11\\-dias\\-la\\-fanb\\-tendra\\-que\\-decidir\\-si\\-estan\\-del\\-lado\\-de\\-los\\-venezolanos\\-y\\-la\\-constitucion\\-o\\-del\\-usurpador/\\|title\\=Guaidó: En 11 días la Fanb tendrá que decidir si están del lado de los venezolanos y la Constitución o del usurpador\\|date\\=12 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=13 February 2019}} Guaidó defied the restriction imposed by the Maduro administration on him leaving Venezuela, secretly crossed the border,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/venezuelan\\-opposition\\-looks\\-to\\-foreign\\-allies\\-for\\-further\\-steps\\-to\\-unseat\\-maduro/2019/02/24/3f046ce4\\-37bc\\-11e9\\-8375\\-e3dcf6b68558\\_story.html\\|title\\=Venezuelan opposition looks to foreign allies for further steps to unseat Maduro\\|author1\\=Faiola, Anthony \\|author2\\=Rachelle Krygier \\|author3\\=Dylan Baddour \\|date\\=24 February 2019\\|newspaper\\=Washington Post\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019}} saying that with the help of the Venezuelan military,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\\=XPMqIDVjaZI\\|title\\=Guaidó dice que Fuerzas Armadas de Venezuela le ayudaron a entrar a Colombia\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|work\\=Noticias Caracol\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019\\|publisher\\=YouTube official channel\\|language\\=es}} and appeared at the [Venezuela Aid Live](/wiki/Venezuela_Aid_Live \"Venezuela Aid Live\") concert in Cúcuta, Colombia on 22 February,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.apnews.com/0c1c016d7e3d4e5594e5ef53b84a2c53\\|title\\=The Latest: Venezuela's Guaido shows up at benefit concert\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|work\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019}} also to be present for the [planned delivery of humanitarian aid](/wiki/2019_shipping_of_humanitarian_aid_to_Venezuela \"2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela\").{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/23/world/americas/venezuela\\-aid\\-live.html\\|title\\=Venezuela Aid Standoff Turns Deadly, Maduro Severs Ties with Colombia\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019\\|quote\\=Mr. Guaidó, standing alongside the presidents of Paraguay, Colombia, and Chile urged the Venezuelan military to allow trucks to cross the border.” and \"The presidents of Colombia, Chile and Paraguay attended the concert, rallying support for the opposition and calling for an end to Mr. Maduro's presidency.\"}} Testing Maduro's authority, he was met by presidents [Iván Duque](/wiki/Iv%C3%A1n_Duque \"Iván Duque\") of Colombia,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.analitica.com/actualidad/actualidad\\-internacional/presidente\\-de\\-paraguay\\-viajo\\-a\\-cucuta\\-para\\-entrega\\-de\\-ayuda\\-humanitaria/\\|title\\=Presidente chileno Sebastián Piñera: La dictadura de Maduro tiene sus días contados\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|work\\=Analitica\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019\\|language\\=es}} [Sebastián Piñera](/wiki/Sebasti%C3%A1n_Pi%C3%B1era \"Sebastián Piñera\") from Chile,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.elpais.com.co/colombia/maduro\\-es\\-parte\\-del\\-problema\\-no\\-de\\-la\\-solucion\\-pinera\\-tras\\-aterrizar\\-en\\-cucuta.html\\|title\\='Maduro es parte del problema, no de la solución': Piñera tras aterrizar en Cúcuta\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|work\\=El Paid\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019\\|language\\=es}} and [Mario Abdo Benítez](/wiki/Mario_Abdo_Ben%C3%ADtez \"Mario Abdo Benítez\") from Paraguay,{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/mundo/presidente\\-paraguay\\-confia\\-que\\-venezuela\\-recuperara\\-democracia\\_271894\\|title\\=Presidente de Paraguay confía en que Venezuela recuperará la democracia\\|date\\=22 February 2019\\|work\\=El Nacional\\|access\\-date\\=22 February 2019\\|language\\=es}} as well as the OAS Secretary\\-General [Luis Almagro](/wiki/Luis_Almagro \"Luis Almagro\").",
"On 23 February, trucks with humanitarian aid attempted to enter Venezuela from Brazil and Colombia;{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/23/americas/venezuela\\-brazil\\-violence\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's Maduro breaks relations with Colombia in standoff over aid\\|author1\\=Smith\\-Spark, Laura \\|author2\\=Jorge Luis Perez Valery, Claudia Dominguez, Christina Maxouris \\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=23 February 2019\\|publisher\\=CNN}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-47343918\\|title\\=Venezuela soldiers abandon posts at Colombia border\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=BBC News}} the attempts failed, with only one truck able to deliver aid.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/24/world/americas/venezuela\\-aid\\-maduro\\-guaido.html\\|title\\=With aid blocked at border, what's next move for Venezuela's opposition?\\|author\\=Casey, Nicholas Albinson Linares\\|date\\=24 February 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=13 May 2019}} At the Colombia–Venezuela border, the caravans were tear\\-gassed or shot at with rubber bullets by Venezuelan personnel.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article226723564\\.html\\|title\\=Venezuela border skirmishes continue as questions swirl around torched aid bus\\|date\\=24 February 2019\\|work\\=Miami Herald}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2019/feb/23/venezuela\\-brazil\\-border\\-aid\\-live\\-news\\-latest\\-updates\\|title\\=Guaidó: military should disown leader who burns food in front of the hungry – as it happened\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=The Guardian}} The National Guard repressed demonstrations on the Brazilian border and [colectivos](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 \"Colectivo (Venezuela)\") attacked protesters near the Colombian border,{{Cite news\\|url\\=http://epmundo.com/2019/colectivos\\-armados\\-causan\\-terror\\-en\\-san\\-antonio\\-del\\-tachira\\-foto/\\|title\\=Colectivos armados causan terror en San Antonio del Táchira (Foto)\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=EP Mundo\\|access\\-date\\=4 March 2019\\|language\\=es}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/en\\-fotos\\-mas\\-de\\-dos\\-mil\\-indigenas\\-intentan\\-llegar\\-a\\-frontera\\-con\\-brasil\\-por\\-ayuda/\\|title\\=En fotos: Más de dos mil indígenas intentan llegar a frontera con Brasil por ayuda\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019}} leaving at least four dead,{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/aumentan\\-a\\-cuatro\\-fallecidos\\-y\\-24\\-heridos\\-todos\\-por\\-armas\\-de\\-fuego\\-en\\-santa\\-elena\\-de\\-uairen/\\|title\\=Aumentan a cuatro fallecidos y 24 heridos, todos por armas de fuego, en Santa Elena de Uairén\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|access\\-date\\=23 February 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/23/venezuela\\-border\\-latest\\-maduro\\-guaido\\|title\\=Venezuela: at least four dead and hundreds injured in border standoff\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019}} and more than 285 injured.{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/23/mas\\-de\\-285\\-heridos\\-y\\-14\\-asesinatos\\-por\\-represion\\-del\\-regimen\\-de\\-maduro\\-este\\-23feb\\-estima\\-informe\\-de\\-la\\-oea/\\|title\\=Más de 285 heridos y 14 asesinatos por represión del régimen de Maduro este \\#23Feb, estima informe de la OEA\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019}}",
"#### Lima Group meeting and Latin American tour",
"[thumb\\|Guaidó, Colombia president Duque, and US vice president Pence during the February 2019 [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group \"Lima Group\") meeting in Colombia](/wiki/File:Vice_President_Mike_Pence_Travels_to_Colombia_%2832269091507%29.jpg \"Vice President Mike Pence Travels to Colombia (32269091507).jpg\")\nGuaidó traveled from Cúcuta to [Bogotá](/wiki/Bogot%C3%A1 \"Bogotá\") for a 24 February meeting with US Vice President Mike Pence,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/24/reuters\\-america\\-update\\-2\\-us\\-to\\-announce\\-concrete\\-steps\\-for\\-venezuela\\-crisis\\-on\\-monday\\-official.html\\|title\\=US to announce 'concrete steps' for Venezuela crisis on Monday\\-official\\|author\\=Rampton, Roberta\\|date\\=24 February 2019\\|work\\=CNBC\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019\\|publisher\\=Reuters\\|archive\\-date\\=24 February 2019\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190224233515/https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/24/reuters\\-america\\-update\\-2\\-us\\-to\\-announce\\-concrete\\-steps\\-for\\-venezuela\\-crisis\\-on\\-monday\\-official.html\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.eltiempo.com/mundo/venezuela/declaraciones\\-de\\-duque\\-y\\-guaido\\-sobre\\-entrega\\-de\\-ayuda\\-humanitaria\\-330614\\|title\\='El mundo vio la peor cara de la dictadura venezolana': Guaidó\\|date\\=23 February 2019\\|work\\=El Tiempo\\|access\\-date\\=24 February 2019\\|language\\=es}} and a 25 February meeting of the Lima Group.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.latimes.com/world/la\\-fg\\-venezuela\\-pence\\-20190225\\-story.html \\|title\\= Pence says U.S. will up the ante as it seeks ouster of Venezuelan President Maduro \\|author\\= Kraul, Chris and Patrick J. McDonnell \\|date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|work\\= Los Angeles Times}} The group urged the [International Criminal Court](/wiki/International_Criminal_Court \"International Criminal Court\") to pursue charges of crimes against humanity for the Maduro administration's use of violence against civilians and blockade of humanitarian aid.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190225\\-trump\\-usa\\-pence\\-maduro\\-venezuela\\-guaido \\|work\\= France 24 \\|date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|title\\= Trump is 'with you 100 percent', Pence tells Venezuelan opposition leader Guaido}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/government\\-economy/lima\\-group\\-urges\\-icc\\-to\\-declare\\-venezuela\\-aid\\-blockade\\-crime\\-against\\-humanity \\|work\\= Business Times \\|title\\= Lima Group urges ICC to declare Venezuela aid blockade 'crime against humanity' \\|date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019}}",
"Pence did not rule out the use of US military force. The Venezuelan government responded saying that Pence was trying to order others to take the country's assets, and saying that its basic rights were being disregarded in a campaign to unseat Maduro. Brazil's vice president said it would not permit its territory to be used to invade Venezuela,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-brazil/brazil\\-will\\-not\\-allow\\-u\\-s\\-use\\-its\\-territory\\-to\\-invade\\-venezuela\\-vice\\-president\\-idUSKCN1QE2DS \\|date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|title\\= Brazil will not allow U.S. use its territory to invade Venezuela: vice president \\|work\\= Reuters}} and the European Union cautioned against the use of military force.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/25/eu\\-warns\\-against\\-military\\-action\\-venezuela\\-mike\\-pence\\-juan\\-guaido/ \\|archive\\-url\\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220112/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/25/eu\\-warns\\-against\\-military\\-action\\-venezuela\\-mike\\-pence\\-juan\\-guaido/ \\|archive\\-date\\=12 January 2022 \\|url\\-access\\=subscription \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|author\\= Alexander, Harriett \\|date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|work\\= The Telegraph \\|title\\= EU warns against military action in Venezuela as Mike Pence and Juan Guaido meet at emergency summit}}{{cbignore}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.voanews.com/a/lima\\-group\\-says\\-serious\\-credible\\-threats\\-juan\\-guaido\\-life/4804009\\.html \\|title\\= Lima Group: There Are 'Serious and Credible' Threats on Guaido's Life \\|work\\= VOA news \\|date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 }} The Lima Group rejected the use of force as well. The US [FAA](/wiki/Federal_Aviation_Administration \"Federal Aviation Administration\") warned pilots not to fly below 26,000 feet over Venezuela,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://abcnews.go.com/Business/wireStory/faa\\-tells\\-pilots\\-caution\\-flying\\-venezuela\\-61302473 \\|title\\= FAA tells pilots to use caution when flying over Venezuela \\|work\\= ABC News \\|date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|publisher\\= Associated Press \\|author \\= Koenig, David }} and [US military](/wiki/United_States_Armed_Forces \"United States Armed Forces\") officials said they had flown [reconnaissance](/wiki/Reconnaissance \"Reconnaissance\") flights off the coast of Venezuela to gather classified intelligence about Maduro.{{cite news \\| url\\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/25/americas/venezuela\\-developments/index.html \\|work\\= CNN \\|title\\= US flying more reconnaissance flights off Venezuela, military sources say \\|date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 26 February 2019 \\|author\\= Starr, Barbara and Ralph Ellis}}",
"From Bogotá, Guaidó embarked on a regional tour to meet with the presidents of Brazil, Paraguay, Argentina, and Ecuador,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://finance.yahoo.com/news/facing\\-jail\\-caracas\\-guaido\\-travels\\-183624466\\.html\\|title\\=Facing jail in Caracas, Guaido travels across South America\\|author\\=Rosati, Andrew and Ken Parks\\|date\\=1 March 2019\\|work\\=Yahoo news\\|access\\-date\\=1 March 2019\\|publisher\\=Bloomberg\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190302001909/https://finance.yahoo.com/news/facing\\-jail\\-caracas\\-guaido\\-travels\\-183624466\\.html\\|archive\\-date\\=2 March 2019\\|url\\-status\\=dead}} to discuss ways to rebuild Venezuela and defeat Maduro.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/01/venezuela\\-crisis\\-guaido\\-vows\\-to\\-return\\-despite\\-life\\-threatening\\-risks.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's Guaido vows to return to Caracas despite 'life\\-threatening' risks\\|author\\=Meredith, Sam\\|date\\=1 March 2019\\|work\\=CNBC\\|access\\-date\\=1 March 2019}} Guaidó's trip was approved by Venezuela's [National Assembly](/wiki/National_Assembly_%28Venezuela%29 \"National Assembly (Venezuela)\"), as required by the Constitution of Venezuela,{{cite news\\|url\\=http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/juan\\-guaido\\-visitara\\-paraguay\\-este\\-viernes\\_272853\\|title\\=Juan Guaidó visitará Paraguay este viernes\\|date\\=28 February 2019\\|work\\=El Nacional\\|access\\-date\\=2 March 2019\\|language\\=es}} but he faced the possibility of being imprisoned when returning to Venezuela because of the travel restriction placed upon him by the Maduro administration.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://abcnews.go.com/International/venezuelan\\-president\\-nicolas\\-maduros\\-defiant\\-interview\\-tom\\-llamas/story?id\\=61318540\\|title\\=Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's defiant interview with Tom Llamas: TRANSCRIPT\\|author\\=Llamas, Tom\\|date\\=28 February 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[ABC News (United States)\\|ABC News]]\\|access\\-date\\=1 March 2019}} \n\\* {{Cite news\\|url\\=https://news.yahoo.com/venezuelas\\-guaido\\-meet\\-brazils\\-president\\-anti\\-maduro\\-push\\-142229605\\-\\-finance.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's Guaido vows to return to Caracas despite threat of prison\\|author\\=Boadle, Anthony\\|date\\=1 March 2019\\|agency\\=\\[\\[Reuters]]\\|access\\-date\\=1 March 2019}} He re\\-entered Venezuela on 4 March, via [Simón Bolívar International Airport](/wiki/Sim%C3%B3n_Bol%C3%ADvar_International_Airport_%28Venezuela%29 \"Simón Bolívar International Airport (Venezuela)\") in [Maiquetía](/wiki/Maiquet%C3%ADa \"Maiquetía\"), and was received at the airport by diplomats{{efn\\|Diplomats from Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Ecuador, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Spain and the United States received Guaidó at the airport.}} and in Caracas by a crowd of supporters.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1QL0A6\\|title\\=In jab at Maduro, Guaido makes triumphant return to Venezuela\\|date\\=4 March 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=4 March 2019\\|language\\=en}} German ambassador Daniel Kriener was accused of interference in internal affairs and expelled from Venezuela because of his role in helping Guaidó re\\-enter.{{Cite news\\|url\\= https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-47474317\\|title\\=Venezuela to expel German ambassador for 'meddling'\\|date\\=7 March 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[BBC]]\\|access\\-date\\=8 March 2019}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/venezuela\\-expels\\-german\\-ambassador\\-for\\-meddling\\-141712\\|title\\=Venezuela expels German ambassador for 'meddling'\\|date\\=7 March 2019\\|work\\=Hurriyet Daily News\\|access\\-date\\=8 March 2019}} \n\\* {{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/world/venezuela\\-s\\-guaido\\-urges\\-more\\-sanctions\\-after\\-german\\-envoy\\-s\\-expulsion\\-11322022\\|title\\=Venezuela's Guaido urges more sanctions after German envoy's expulsion\\|date\\=7 March 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[Channel News Asia]]\\|access\\-date\\=8 March 2019\\|archive\\-date\\=7 March 2019\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190307203436/https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/world/venezuela\\-s\\-guaido\\-urges\\-more\\-sanctions\\-after\\-german\\-envoy\\-s\\-expulsion\\-11322022\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"### Blackouts",
"{{further\\|2019 Venezuelan blackouts\\|Human rights in Venezuela\\#2019 OHCHR delegation visit}}\n[thumb\\|left\\|[Guri Dam](/wiki/Guri_Dam \"Guri Dam\") supplies 80% of Venezuela's electrical power.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/world/americas/venzuela\\-blackout\\-maduro.html \\|work\\= New York Times \\| title\\= No end in sight to Venezuela's blackout, experts warn \\|date\\= 11 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 18 March 2019}}](/wiki/File:Guri_Dam_in_Venezuela.JPG \"Guri Dam in Venezuela.JPG\")",
"In March 2019, [Venezuela experienced a near total electrical blackout](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_blackouts \"2019 Venezuelan blackouts\"), and lost 150,000 barrels per day in crude oil production during the blackout.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-oil\\-opec\\-survey/opec\\-oil\\-output\\-hits\\-four\\-year\\-low\\-on\\-saudi\\-cuts\\-venezuela\\-blackouts\\-idUSKCN1RD26N \\|work\\= Reuters \\|author\\= Lawler, Alex \\|date\\= 1 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 7 April 2019 \\|title\\= OPEC oil output hits four\\-year low on Saudi cuts, Venezuela blackouts}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190328\\-blackouts\\-savage\\-venezuelas\\-already\\-tattered\\-economy \\|work\\= France 24 \\|date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 7 April 2019 \\|title\\= Blackouts savage Venezuela's already tattered economy}} Full recovery of oil production was expected to take months,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.chron.com/business/energy/article/Venezuela\\-Blackouts\\-Cut\\-Oil\\-Output\\-by\\-Half\\-13743951\\.php \\|work\\= Houston Chronicle \\|date\\= 5 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 7 April 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela blackouts cut oil output by half in March \\|author\\= Zerpa, Fabiola \\|publisher\\= Bloomberg}} but by April, Venezuela's exports were steady at a million barrels daily, \"partially due to inventory drains\".{{cite news \\|title\\= Venezuelan PDVSA's oil exports steady in April, flow to Cuba continues \\|author\\= Parraga, Marianna \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 2 May 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 3 May 2019 \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/venezuela\\-oil\\-exports/venezuelan\\-pdvsas\\-oil\\-exports\\-steady\\-in\\-april\\-flow\\-to\\-cuba\\-continues\\-data\\-idUSL1N22E1DX}}",
"Experts and state\\-run [Corpoelec](/wiki/Corpoelec \"Corpoelec\") (Corporación Eléctrica Nacional) sources attributed the electricity shortages to lack of maintenance, underinvestment, corruption and to a lack of technical expertise in the country resulting from a [brain drain](/wiki/Human_capital_flight \"Human capital flight\");{{cite news \\|author\\=Angulo \\|first1\\=Nataly \\|last2\\=Batiz \\|first2\\=César \\|author\\-link2\\=César Batiz \\|date\\=10 March 2019 \\|title\\=¿Por qué ocurrió el apagón nacional que provocó el caos en Venezuela? Los expertos explican \\|language\\=es \\|trans\\-title\\=Why did the national blackout that caused the chaos in Venezuela happen? The experts explain \\|work\\=Univision \\|url\\=https://www.univision.com/noticias/america\\-latina/por\\-que\\-ocurrio\\-el\\-apagon\\-nacional\\-que\\-provoco\\-el\\-caos\\-en\\-venezuela\\-los\\-expertos\\-explican \\|access\\-date\\=17 March 2019 \\|quote\\=Especialistas venezolanos en el tema eléctrico explican que el corte masivo de electricidad se debió a la falta de mantenimiento, desprofesionalización constante del sector en los últimos años del chavismo, falta de inversión y la gran vulnerabilidad que representa depender de un solo embalse: el de Guri, ubicado en el sur del país, en el estado Bolívar.}}",
"and\n {{cite news \\|date\\=9 March 2019 \\|title\\=Desmontan versión de ataque cibernético: 'Es como hackear una nevera' \\|language\\=es \\|trans\\-title\\=Dismantling cyberattack version: 'It's like hacking a fridge' \\|work\\=El Nacional \\|url\\=http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/sociedad/desmontan\\-version\\-ataque\\-cibernetico\\-como\\-hackear\\-una\\-nevera\\_274054 \\|access\\-date\\=17 March 2019 \\|quote\\=Expertos aseguran que el sistema de El Guri se creó antes de que existiera Internet, por lo que no depende de dicho tipo de conexiones para funcionar.}}\n {{Cite web \\|author\\=Brassesco, Javier and Fernando Nunez\\-Noda \\|title\\=Expediente: Las causas del apagón en Venezuela \\|trans\\-title\\=File: The causes of the blackout in Venezuela \\|url\\=https://verifikado.com/expediente\\-las\\-causas\\-del\\-apagon\\-en\\-venezuela/ \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190330212845/https://verifikado.com/expediente\\-las\\-causas\\-del\\-apagon\\-en\\-venezuela/ \\|archive\\-date\\=30 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=14 March 2019 \\|website\\=Verifikado \\|language\\=es \\|quote\\=Univision recogió opiniones de expertos ...}}* + {{Cite web\\|url\\=https://es.scribd.com/document/401835067/Origen\\-de\\-La\\-Falla\\-v2\\|title\\=Origen de la falla eléctrica en Venezuela\\|last\\=Molina Guzmán\\|first\\=Julio\\|date\\=12 March 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[Central University of Venezuela]]\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=14 March 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/11/world/americas/venzuela\\-blackout\\-maduro.html\\|title\\=No end in sight to Venezuela's blackout, experts warn\\|date\\=11 March 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=18 March 2019\\|quote\\=Energy experts, Venezuelan power sector contractors and current and former Corpoelec employees have dismissed accusations of sabotage, saying the blackout was the result of years of underinvestment, corruption and brain drain. (...) Restarting the turbines requires skilled operators who can synchronize the speed of rotation on as many as nine of Guri's operational turbines. Experts said the most experienced operators had long left the company because of meager wages and an atmosphere of paranoia fed by Mr. Maduro's ever\\-present secret police.}} [Nicolás Maduro](/wiki/Nicol%C3%A1s_Maduro \"Nicolás Maduro\")'s administration attributes them to sabotage.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-latin\\-america\\-47703864\\|title\\=Venezuela crisis: Fresh power cuts black out Caracas\\|date\\=26 March 2019\\|work\\=BBC\\|access\\-date\\=26 March 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.msn.com/en\\-au/kids/other/thousands\\-join\\-rival\\-protests\\-on\\-streets\\-of\\-venezuela\\-as\\-power\\-cuts\\-continue/ar\\-BBUzLJ5\\|title\\=Thousands join rival protests on streets of Venezuela as power cuts continue\\|date\\=10 March 2019\\|work\\=MSN\\|access\\-date\\=15 March 2019}}{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.presidencia.gob.ve/Site/Web/Principal/paginas/classMostrarEvento3\\.php?id\\_evento\\=12996\\|title\\=Conformarán una comisión presidencial para investigar el ciberataque y mostrar la verdad\\|date\\=12 March 2019\\|work\\=Prensa MPP\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=15 March 2019}} Guaidó said that Venezuela's largest\\-ever [power outage](/wiki/Power_outage \"Power outage\") was \"the product of the inefficiency, the incapability, the corruption of a regime that doesn't care about the lives of Venezuelans\",{{cite news\\|author\\=Phillips, Tom\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/mar/12/venezuela\\-juan\\-guaido\\-maduro\\-sabotage\\-blackout\\|title\\=Guaidó under investigation for sabotage of power grid\\|date\\=12 March 2019\\|work\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=13 March 2019}} Maduro's Attorney General, Tarek William Saab, called for an investigation of Guaidó, alleging that he had \"sabotaged\" the [electric sector](/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Venezuela \"Electricity sector in Venezuela\").",
"While Maduro visited hydroelectric facilities in [Ciudad Guayana](/wiki/Ciudad_Guayana \"Ciudad Guayana\") on 16 March, promising to restructure the state\\-run power company [Corpoelec](/wiki/Corpoelec \"Corpoelec\"), his Vice President [Delcy Rodríguez](/wiki/Delcy_Rodr%C3%ADguez \"Delcy Rodríguez\") announced that Maduro would restructure his administration, asking the \"entire executive Cabinet to put their roles up for review\".{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics/venezuelas\\-maduro\\-plans\\-deep\\-restructuring\\-of\\-government\\-vp\\-idUSKCN1QY0XC \\| work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 17 March 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela's Maduro plans 'deep restructuring' of government: VP \\|access\\-date\\= 18 March 2019}} Guaidó announced he would embark on a tour of the country beginning 16 March, to organize committees for Operation Freedom with the goal to claim the presidential residence, [Miraflores Palace](/wiki/Miraflores_Palace \"Miraflores Palace\").{{cite news \\|url\\= http://efectococuyo.com/politica/guaido\\-anuncio\\-la\\-creacion\\-de\\-comites\\-por\\-la\\-libertad\\-para\\-pronto\\-ir\\-a\\-miraflores/ \\|work\\= Efecto Cocuyo \\|date\\= 16 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 18 March 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= Guaidó anuncia la creación de comités por la libertad para pronto 'ir a Miraflores' \\|trans\\-title\\= Guaidó announces the creation of freedom committees to soon 'go to Miraflores' \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190421013023/http://efectococuyo.com/politica/guaido\\-anuncio\\-la\\-creacion\\-de\\-comites\\-por\\-la\\-libertad\\-para\\-pronto\\-ir\\-a\\-miraflores/ \\|archive\\-date\\= 21 April 2019 \\|url\\-status\\= dead }} From the first rally in [Carabobo](/wiki/Carabobo \"Carabobo\") state, he said, \"We will be in each state of Venezuela and for each state we have visited the responsibility will be yours, the leaders, the united, \\[to] organize ourselves in freedom commands.\"",
"[United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights](/wiki/United_Nations_High_Commissioner_for_Human_Rights \"United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights\") (OHCHR) commissioner [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet \"Michelle Bachelet\")'s office sent a five\\-person delegation to Venezuela in March.{{cite news \\|title\\=Delegación de DDHH de ONU comienza reuniones en Venezuela en medio del apagón \\|url\\=http://efectococuyo.com/principales/delegacion\\-de\\-ddhh\\-de\\-onu\\-comienza\\-reuniones\\-en\\-venezuela\\-en\\-medio\\-del\\-apagon/ \\|access\\-date\\=18 March 2019 \\|agency\\=\\[\\[Efecto Cocuyo]] \\|date\\=11 March 2019 \\|language\\=es}}{{cite press release \\|url\\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/03/1034301 \\|publisher\\= UN News \\|title\\= UN rights team heading to Venezuela may pave way for official mission led by Bachelet \\|date\\= 8 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 18 March 2019}} On 20 March, Bachelet delivered a [preliminary oral report before the UN Human Rights Council](/wiki/Human_rights_in_Venezuela%232019_OHCHR_delegation_visit \"Human rights in Venezuela#2019 OHCHR delegation visit\"),{{cite news \\|url\\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/03/1035061 \\|work\\= UN News \\|date\\= 20 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela: 'A worrying destabilizing factor in the region', Bachelet tells Human Rights Council}}{{cite web \\|url\\= https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID\\=24374\\&LangID\\=E \\|publisher\\= OHCHR \\|date\\= 20 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 23 March 2019 \\|title\\= Oral update on the situation of human rights in the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela}} in which she outlined a \"devastating and deteriorating\" human rights situation in Venezuela, expressed concern that sanctions would worsen the situation, and called on authorities to show a true commitment to recognizing and resolving the situation.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://prodavinci.com/10\\-claves\\-del\\-informe\\-de\\-michelle\\-bachelet\\-sobre\\-venezuela/ \\|title\\= 10 claves del informe de Michelle Bachelet sobre Venezuela \\|trans\\-title\\= 10 keys if Michelle Bachelet's report on Venezuela \\|work\\= Prodavinci \\|date\\= 20 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019 \\|language\\= es}}",
"[Elvis Amoroso](/wiki/Elvis_Amoroso \"Elvis Amoroso\"), Maduro's comptroller, alleged in March that Guaidó had not explained how he paid for his February 2019 Latin American trip,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.yahoo.com/news/venezuelan\\-govt\\-bars\\-guaido\\-public\\-office\\-15\\-years\\-175729462\\.html \\|work\\= Yahoo \\|publisher\\= Associated Press \\|date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuelan gov't bars Guaido from public office for 15 years \\|author\\= Rueda, Jorge}} and said Guaidó would be barred from running for public office for fifteen years.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-guaido/venezuela\\-bars\\-guaido\\-from\\-holding\\-public\\-office\\-for\\-15\\-years\\-idUSKCN1R9298 \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 28 March 2019 \\| title\\= Venezuela bars Guaido from holding public office for 15 years}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.yahoo.com/news/venezuelas\\-guaido\\-barred\\-public\\-office\\-15\\-years\\-182929528\\.html \\|work\\= Yahoo \\|date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela blocks Guaido from office as the opposition scoffs \\|publisher\\= Reuters \\|author\\= Sequera, Vivian and Luc Cohen}} The comptroller general is not a judicial body; according to constitutional lawyer José Vicente Haro, the [Inter\\-American Court of Human Rights](/wiki/Inter-American_Court_of_Human_Rights \"Inter-American Court of Human Rights\") ruled in 2011 that an administrative body cannot disallow a public servant from running. Constitutional law expert [Juan Manuel Raffalli](/wiki/Juan_Manuel_Raffalli \"Juan Manuel Raffalli\") stated that Article 65 of Venezuela's Constitution provides that such determinations may only be made by criminal courts, after judgment of criminal activity.{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/inhabilitacion\\-juan\\-guaido\\-podria\\-desencadenar\\-medidas\\-ante\\-cne\\_276741 \\|work\\= El Nacional \\| language\\= es \\|date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 28 March 2019 \\|title\\= Inhabilitación de Juan Guaidó podría desencadenar medidas ante el CNE \\|trans\\-title\\= Disqualification of Juan Guaidó could trigger measures before the CNE \\|author\\= Diaz Landazabal, Jackelin}}",
"### Red Cross aid effort",
"{{further\\|2019 shipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela\\#RedCrossVenAid}}\n[thumb \\|U.S. Assistant Secretary of State [Kimberly Breier](/wiki/Kimberly_Breier \"Kimberly Breier\"), Juan Guaidó's wife [Fabiana Rosales](/wiki/Fabiana_Rosales \"Fabiana Rosales\"), U.S. Special Representative for Venezuela [Elliott Abrams](/wiki/Elliott_Abrams \"Elliott Abrams\"), and Venezuelan Ambassador to the U.S. [Carlos Vecchio](/wiki/Carlos_Vecchio \"Carlos Vecchio\"), and diplomat in Washington, D.C., on 27 March 2019](/wiki/File:Assistant_Secretary_Breier_and_Special_Representative_Abrams_Meets_With_With_Fabiana_Rosales%2C_Wife_of_Interim_President_Guaido_%2840515595993%29.jpg \"Assistant Secretary Breier and Special Representative Abrams Meets With With Fabiana Rosales, Wife of Interim President Guaido (40515595993).jpg\")\nIn March, Francesco Rocca, president of the [International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies](/wiki/International_Federation_of_Red_Cross_and_Red_Crescent_Societies \"International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies\"), announced that the [Red Cross](/wiki/International_Red_Cross_and_Red_Crescent_Movement \"International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement\") was preparing to bring humanitarian aid to the country in April to help ease both the chronic hunger and the medical crisis.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics/international\\-red\\-cross\\-ready\\-for\\-venezuela\\-humanitarian\\-aid\\-operation\\-idUSKCN1RA1XP \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 29 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 March 2019 \\|title\\= International Red Cross ready for Venezuela humanitarian aid operation \\|author\\= Pons, Corina and Brian Ellsworth}} *[The Wall Street Journal](/wiki/The_Wall_Street_Journal \"The Wall Street Journal\")* said that the acceptance of humanitarian shipments by Maduro was his first acknowledgement that Venezuela is \"suffering from an economic collapse.\"{{cite news \\|title\\= Red Cross announces Venezuelan aid effort \\|work\\= Wall Street Journal \\|publisher\\= Dow Jones Institutional News \\|author\\= Dube, Ryan \\|date\\= 29 March 2019 \\|via\\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://www.wsj.com/articles/red-cross-announces-venezuelan-aid-effort-11553899904){{cite news \\|title\\= Red Cross ready to aid Venezuela, warns against politics \\|author\\= Torchia, Christopher \\|newspaper\\= Washington Post \\|publisher \\= Associated Press \\|date\\= 29 March 2019 \\|via\\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://web.archive.org/web/20190329224812/https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/venezuelas-guaido-makes-renewed-promise-to-deliver-aid/2019/03/29/b993bfba-5237-11e9-bdb7-44f948cc0605_story.html) After a 9 April meeting with the [International Committee of the Red Cross](/wiki/International_Committee_of_the_Red_Cross \"International Committee of the Red Cross\") (ICRC),{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.ntn24\\.com/america\\-latina/venezuela/maduro\\-sostuvo\\-encuentro\\-con\\-representantes\\-de\\-la\\-cruz\\-roja\\-105757 \\|publisher\\= NTN24 \\|language\\= es \\|date\\= 9 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|title\\= Maduro sostuvo encuentro con representantes de la Cruz Roja}} Maduro indicated for the first time that he was prepared to accept international aid.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/04/maduro\\-venezuela\\-ready\\-receive\\-international\\-aid\\-190410083550252\\.html \\|publisher\\= Al Jazeera \\|date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|title\\= Maduro says Venezuela ready to receive international aid}} Guaidó called on Venezuelans to \"stay vigilant to make sure incoming aid is not diverted for 'corrupt' purposes\".",
"Following the [joint report from Human Rights Watch and Johns Hopkins](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela%232019_Human_Rights_Watch/Johns_Hopkins_report \"Crisis in Venezuela#2019 Human Rights Watch/Johns Hopkins report\") in April 2019, increasing announcements from the United Nations about the scale of the humanitarian crisis, and the softening of Maduro's position on receiving aid, the ICRC tripled its budget for aid to Venezuela.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.theguardian.com/global\\-development/2019/apr/12/red\\-cross\\-aid\\-to\\-venezuela\\-to\\-triple\\-as\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-stance\\-softens \\|work\\= The Guardian \\|access\\-date\\= 12 April 2019 \\|date\\= 12 April 2019 \\|author\\= Beaumont, Peter \\|title\\= Red Cross aid to Venezuela to triple as Maduro stance softens}} The first Red Cross delivery of supplies for hospitals arrived on 16 April, offering an encouraging sign that the Maduro administration would allow more aid to enter.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-red\\-cross/first\\-shipment\\-of\\-red\\-cross\\-humanitarian\\-aid\\-arrives\\-in\\-venezuela\\-idUSKCN1RS1VQ \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 16 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 16 April 2019 \\|title\\= First shipment of Red Cross humanitarian aid arrives in Venezuela}} According to *[The New York Times](/wiki/The_New_York_Times \"The New York Times\")*, \"[armed pro\\-government paramilitaries](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 \"Colectivo (Venezuela)\")\" fired weapons to disrupt the first Red Cross delivery, and officials associated with Maduro's party told the Red Cross to leave.{{cite news\\|url\\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/world/americas/red\\-cross\\-venezuela\\-aid.html \\|work\\= New York Times \\|date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|title\\= Red Cross grapples with aid distribution in polarized Venezuela \\|author\\= Herrera, Isayen and Anatoly Kurmanaev}}",
"According to the [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press \"Associated Press\"), having long denied that there was a humanitarian crisis in Venezuela, Maduro positioned the delivery \"as a necessary measure to confront punishing U.S. economic sanctions.\" Having \"rallied the international community\", Guaidó \"quickly claimed credit for the effort.\"{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/venezuela\\-humanitarian\\-aid\\-arrives\\-1\\.5100067 \\|publisher\\=CBC Canada \\|access\\-date\\= 16 April 2019 \\|date\\= 16 April 2019 \\|title\\= Humanitarian aid shipment makes it into Venezuela after delays \\|agency\\= Associated Press}}",
"### Revocation of Guaidó's parliamentary immunity",
"Chief justice [Maikel Moreno](/wiki/Maikel_Moreno \"Maikel Moreno\") asked that the [Constituent Assembly](/wiki/2017_Venezuelan_Constituent_Assembly_election \"2017 Venezuelan Constituent Assembly election\") (ANC), controlled by Maduro loyalists, remove Guaidó's parliamentary immunity as president of the National Assembly,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\\-america\\-latina\\-47781533\\|publisher\\=BBC Mundo\\|language\\= es \\|date\\= 1 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 April 2019 \\|title\\= Juan Guaidó: el Tribunal Supremo de Venezuela solicita revocar la inmunidad parlamentaria del líder opositor a la Asamblea controlada por el chavismo \\|trans\\-title\\= Juan Guaidó: the Supreme Court of Venezuela requests that the Assembly controlled by Chavismo revoke the parliamentary immunity of the opposition leader}}{{cite news\\|author\\=Richard Gonzales\\|url\\=https://www.npr.org/2019/04/02/709306132/maduro\\-allies\\-move\\-against\\-rival\\-juan\\-guaid\\-in\\-venezuela\\|publisher\\=NPR\\|date\\=April 2, 2019\\|title\\=Maduro Allies Move Against Rival Juan Guaidó In Venezuela}} moving the Maduro administration a step closer towards prosecuting Guaidó.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.foxnews.com/world/the\\-latest\\-venezuela\\-judge\\-seeks\\-to\\-strip\\-guaidos\\-immunity \\| work\\= Fox News \\|date\\= 1 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 April 2019 \\|title\\= The Latest: Venezuela judge seeks to strip Guaido's immunity \\|publisher\\= Associated Press}} Guaidó supporters disagree that the Maduro\\-backed institutions have the authority to ban Guaidó from leaving the country and consider acts of the ANC \"null and void\". The Venezuelan Constitution provides that only the National Assembly can bring the president to trial by approving the legal proceeding in a \"merit hearing\". On 2 April, after the ANC voted to remove his parliamentary immunity, Guaidó promised to continue fighting \"Maduro's 'cowardly, miserable and murderous' regime.\"{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/apr/03/venezuela\\-juan\\-guaido\\-stripped\\-of\\-parliamentary\\-immunity \\|work\\= The Guardian \\|date\\= 2 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 4 April 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela: Juan Guaidó stripped of parliamentary immunity \\|author\\= Phillips, Tom and Patricia Torres}}",
"### Military uprising attempt",
"{{Main\\|2019 Venezuelan uprising attempt}}\n[thumb\\|upright\\=1\\.5\\|[Juan Guaidó](/wiki/Juan_Guaid%C3%B3 \"Juan Guaidó\") speaks to supporters on 30 April 2019](/wiki/File:2019_Venezuela_uprising_-_Guaid%C3%B3_speaking.png \"2019 Venezuela uprising - Guaidó speaking.png\")\nOn 19 April, Guaidó called for a \"definite end of the usurpation\" and the \"largest march in history\" on 1 May.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://talcualdigital.com/index.php/2019/04/19/guaido\\-convoca\\-a\\-la\\-marcha\\-mas\\-grande\\-de\\-la\\-historia\\-para\\-el\\-1\\-de\\-mayo/\\|title\\=Guaidó convoca a 'la marcha más grande de la historia' para el 1° de mayo\\|author\\=Quintero, Luisa\\|date\\=19 April 2019\\|publisher\\=Tal Cual Digital\\|language\\=es\\|trans\\-title\\=Guaidó calls for 'the largest march in history' for 1 May\\|access\\-date\\=14 May 2019}} Coinciding with his speech, [NetBlocks](/wiki/NetBlocks \"NetBlocks\") stated that state\\-run [CANTV](/wiki/CANTV \"CANTV\") again blocked access to social media in Venezuela.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://netblocks.org/reports/social\\-media\\-restricted\\-in\\-venezuela\\-as\\-guaido\\-speaks\\-from\\-caracas\\-0pA2X5yb\\|title\\=Social media restricted in Venezuela as Guaido speaks from Caracas\\|date\\=19 April 2019\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[NetBlocks]]\\|access\\-date\\=19 April 2019}} On 30 April 2019, [Leopoldo López](/wiki/Leopoldo_L%C3%B3pez \"Leopoldo López\"), who was held under house arrest by the Maduro administration, was freed on orders from Guaidó.{{cite web \\|author\\= Smith, Scott and Christopher Torchia \\|title\\= Clashes rock Venezuela as Guaido urges opposition uprising \\|url\\=https://apnews.com/0153cace08c84c8fbf34f9c6a7bdd4dd \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Associated Press]] \\|date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019}} The two men, flanked by members of the Venezuelan armed forces near [La Carlota Air Force Base](/wiki/La_Carlota_airport \"La Carlota airport\") in Caracas, announced an uprising,{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/04/30/guaido\\-le\\-habla\\-a\\-venezuela\\-desde\\-la\\-base\\-aerea\\-la\\-carlota\\-video/\\|title\\=Guaidó le habla a Venezuela desde la Base Aérea La Carlota (VIDEO)\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es \\|date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 April 2019}} stating that this was the final phase of \"Operation Freedom\".{{cite news \\|author\\= Sequera, Vivian and Angus Berwick \\|title\\=Venezuela's Guaido calls on troops to join him in uprising against Maduro \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics/venezuelas\\-guaido\\-says\\-troops\\-join\\-him\\-for\\-coup\\-government\\-says\\-it\\-is\\-firmly\\-in\\-control\\-idUSKCN1S60ZQ \\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\|date\\= 30 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019}} Though Guaidó said his forces held La Carlota, when supporters approached the base, Guaidó and a few dozen supporters stayed in a nearby overpass outside.{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|pp\\=230–234 \\|loc\\= Chapter 25: \"Bubble\"}}",
"Maduro was not seen during the day,{{cite news\\|author\\=Hansler, Jennifer\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/30/politics/pompeo\\-maduro\\-russia/index.html\\|title\\=Pompeo claims Russia stopped Maduro leaving Venezuela for Cuba\\|date\\=30 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019\\|publisher\\=CNN}} but he appeared with his Defense Minister Padrino on that evening's televised broadcast,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-maduro\\-sebin/venezuelas\\-maduro\\-appears\\-with\\-defense\\-minister\\-after\\-uprising\\-idUSKCN1S7315 \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 May 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela's Maduro appears with defense minister after uprising}} and announced he would replace [Manuel Cristopher Figuera](/wiki/Manuel_Cristopher_Figuera \"Manuel Cristopher Figuera\"), Director General of the [Bolivarian Intelligence Service](/wiki/Bolivarian_Intelligence_Service \"Bolivarian Intelligence Service\") (SEBIN), who had broken with Maduro during the uprising, saying it was time to \"rebuild the country\" and that \"scoundrels were plundering the country.\"{{cite news\\|author\\=Phillips, Tom and Joe Parkin Daniels\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/may/01/venezuela\\-coup\\-protests\\-what\\-happens\\-next\\-guaido\\-maduro\\-latest\\|title\\=Guaidó's uprising seems to have flatlined. What's next for Venezuela?\\|date\\=1 May 2019\\|work\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=2 May 2019}} The United States said Maduro had prepared to leave Venezuela that morning, but Russia and Cuba helped convince him to stay.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/video/2019/04/30/national\\-security\\-advisor\\-john\\-bolton\\-on\\-venezuela\\-protests.html\\|title\\=National Security Advisor John Bolton on Venezuela protests\\|date\\=30 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019\\|publisher\\=CNBC}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/30/world/americas/venezuela\\-coup\\-guaido\\-military.html\\|title\\=Venezuela crisis live updates: Guaidó calls for uprising as clashes erupt\\|date\\=30 April 2019\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019}} Both Russia and Maduro denied that he had plans to leave Venezuela.{{cite news\\|author\\=Picheta, Rob and Meg Wagner\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/americas/live\\-news/juan\\-guaido\\-venezuela\\-operation\\-freedom\\-live\\-updates/index.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's uprising\\|date\\=30 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019\\|publisher\\=CNN}}",
"Guaidó's supporters were forced to retreat by security forces using tear gas. [Colectivos](/wiki/Colectivo_%28Venezuela%29 \"Colectivo (Venezuela)\") fired on protesters with live ammunition, and one protester was shot in the head and killed. [Human Rights Watch](/wiki/Human_Rights_Watch \"Human Rights Watch\") said it believed that \"security forces fired shotgun pellets at demonstrators and journalists.\" By the end of the day, one protester had died,{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\\_americas/venezuelan\\-opposition\\-leader\\-juan\\-guaido\\-appears\\-to\\-stage\\-military\\-backed\\-challenge\\-to\\-president\\-maduro/2019/04/30/c7028eee\\-6b35\\-11e9\\-8f44\\-e8d8bb1df986\\_story.html?noredirect\\=on\\|title\\=Venezuela's Maduro denies Pompeo's claim that he sought to escape to Cuba after day of clashes that left 1 dead, dozens hurt\\|author\\= Zuñiga, Mariana\\|date\\=30 April 2019\\|newspaper\\=The Washington Post\\|access\\-date\\=30 April 2019}} and López was at the Spanish embassy,{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.abc.es/internacional/abci\\-leopoldo\\-lopez\\-refugia\\-embajada\\-espana\\-201905010259\\_noticia.html \\|publisher\\= ABC International \\|date\\= 1 May 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 May 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= Leopoldo López se refugia en la Embajada de España}} while about 25 military personnel received asylum in the Panamanian embassy in Caracas.{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|pp\\=230–234 \\|loc\\= Chapter 25: \"Bubble\"}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://elpais.com/internacional/2019/04/30/actualidad/1556618727\\_875831\\.html \\|work\\= El Pais \\|date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= Últimas noticias de Venezuela, en vivo: Chile confirma que Leopoldo López está en su Embajada en Caracas \\|trans\\-title\\= Latest news from Venezuela, live: Chile confirms that Leopoldo López is in their Embassy in Caracas}}",
"Guaidó acknowledged he had received insufficient military backing, but added that \"Maduro did not have the support nor the respect of the Armed Forces\"{{cite news \\|title\\=Venezuela: Juan Guaidó asegura que \"Maduro no tiene el respaldo ni el respeto de las fuerzas armadas\" \\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\\-america\\-latina\\-48114446 \\|access\\-date\\=2 May 2019 \\|agency\\=BBC \\|date\\=1 May 2019 \\|language\\=es}} and called for strikes beginning on 2 May, with the aim of a general strike later in the month.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/01/world/americas/venezuela\\-protests\\-guaido\\-maduro.html \\|work\\= The New York Times \\|date\\= 1 May 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019 \\|author\\= Casey, Nicholas \\|title\\= Rival protests grip Venezuela after Guaidó's failed effort to beckon military}} Russia and the US each charged the other with interference in another country's affairs.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/02/americas/venezuela\\-maduro\\-guaido\\-intl/index.html \\|publisher\\= CNN \\|date\\= 2 May 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019 \\|title\\= As Guaido admits he needs more military support, Trump warns of worse to come in Venezuela \\|author\\= Berlinger, Joshua}}",
"### Negotiations",
"{{See also\\|Negotiations during the Venezuelan crisis\\#2019 presidential crisis}}Following the failed military uprising, momentum surrounding Guaidó had subsided and fewer supporters gathered at demonstrations, with Guaidó resorting to negotiations with Maduro.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/21/world/americas/venezuela\\-juan\\-guaido\\-nicolas\\-maduro.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's Opposition Leader Juan Guaidó May Negotiate With Maduro\\|last\\=Kurmanaev\\|first\\=Anatoly\\|date\\=2019\\-05\\-21\\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]]\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-05\\-24\\|language\\=en\\-US\\|issn\\=0362\\-4331}} Guaidó's deputy chief Rafael Del Rosario acknowledged that the debacle on 30 April made the prospect of removing Maduro more difficult. Beginning negotiations was a setback for Guaidó's movement, with the [Associated Press](/wiki/Associated_Press \"Associated Press\") stating, \"Participation in the mediation effort is a reversal for the opposition, which has accused Maduro of using negotiations between 2016 and 2018 to play for time\". According to the *New York Times*, years of difficulties has made Maduro \"adept at managing, if not solving, cascading crises\", while Phil Gunson of the [International Crisis Group](/wiki/International_Crisis_Group \"International Crisis Group\") stated that despite facing issues, Maduro \"must be very pleased that he is now in the driving seat\", with the ability to use the actions of Guaidó and international actors for propaganda purposes.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.npr.org/2019/05/13/722959304/venezuelan\\-president\\-nicol\\-s\\-maduro\\-pushes\\-back\\-against\\-u\\-s\\-support\\-to\\-unseat\\-hi\\|title\\=Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro Pushes Back Against U.S. Support To Unseat Him\\|last\\=Reeves\\|first\\=Philip\\|date\\=13 May 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[NPR]]\\|language\\=en\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-05\\-24}} By May 2019, Trump had decided that Guaidó was weak; Bolton attributed a change of Trump's position to a comment made by President of Russia [Vladimir Putin](/wiki/Vladimir_Putin \"Vladimir Putin\") to Trump in a phone call that Guaidó's claim to the presidency would be the equivalent of [Hillary Clinton](/wiki/Hillary_Clinton \"Hillary Clinton\") declaring herself president following the [2016 United States presidential election](/wiki/2016_United_States_presidential_election \"2016 United States presidential election\").{{sfn\\|Neuman\\|2022\\|pp\\=230–234 \\|loc\\= Chapter 25: \"Bubble\"}}",
"Representatives of Guaidó and Maduro began mediation with the assistance of the Norwegian Centre for Conflict Resolution (NOREF), with [Jorge Rodríguez](/wiki/Jorge_Rodr%C3%ADguez_%28Venezuelan_politician%29 \"Jorge Rodríguez (Venezuelan politician)\") and [Héctor Rodríguez](/wiki/H%C3%A9ctor_Rodr%C3%ADguez_Castro \"Héctor Rodríguez Castro\") serving as representatives for Maduro while {{ill\\|Gerardo Blyde\\|es}} and [Stalin González](/wiki/Stalin_Gonz%C3%A1lez \"Stalin González\") were representatives for Guaidó. Guaidó confirmed that there was an envoy in Norway, but assured that the opposition would not take part in \"any kind of false negotiation\" and that talks must lead to Maduro's resignation, a transitional administration and free and fair elections.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/46613ff2cbaa4712b3dfb09d76ce1bc7\\|title\\=Mediation in Norway aims to resolve Venezuela crisis\\|author\\=Torchia, Christopher\\|date\\=17 May 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[Associated Press]]\\|access\\-date\\=17 May 2019}}{{cite news \\|title\\=Guaidó confirma contactos y anuncia la 'liberación' de Simonovis \\|url\\=https://es.euronews.com/2019/05/17/guaido\\-confirma\\-contactos\\-y\\-anuncia\\-la\\-liberacion\\-de\\-simonovis \\|agency\\=Euronews \\|date\\=17 May 2019 \\|language\\=es}}",
"In July 2019, Norway's commission carried out a third round of discussions between Guaidó's and Maduro's representatives in [Barbados](/wiki/Barbados \"Barbados\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1U61XX\\|title\\=Norway says Venezuela opposition and government talks to continue\\|last\\=Brian Ellsworth, Vivian Sequera\\|date\\=12 July 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=13 July 2019}} By August 2019, the Maduro administration decided to halt talks with Guaidó's commission after Trump administration imposed new additional sanctions on Venezuela, ordering a freeze on all Venezuelan government assets in the [United States](/wiki/United_States \"United States\") and barred transactions with US citizens and companies.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/6a178b0f946349d8a12899e0f4b9ca48\\|title\\=Maduro halts talks with opponents over US asset freeze\\|last\\=Goodman\\|first\\=Joshua\\|date\\=8 August 2019\\|website\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=20 August 2019}}",
"### Second visit of the OHCHR",
"Ahead of a three\\-week session of the [UN Human Rights Council](/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council \"United Nations Human Rights Council\"), the OHCHR chief, [Michelle Bachelet](/wiki/Michelle_Bachelet \"Michelle Bachelet\"), visited Venezuela from 19 to 21 June.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-un\\-idUSKCN1TM2BR\\|title\\=U.N. rights chief Bachelet urges Venezuela to release prisoners\\|last1\\=Pons\\|first1\\=Corina\\|date\\=22 June 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=22 June 2019\\|last2\\=Castro\\|first2\\=Shaylim}} The Human Rights Commissioner met separately with both Maduro and Guaidó during her visit, as well as with Maduro's Attorney General [Tarek William Saab](/wiki/Tarek_William_Saab \"Tarek William Saab\"), several human right activists, and families of victims who experienced torture and state repression.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\\-06\\-21/protests\\-erupt\\-in\\-caracas\\-during\\-un\\-s\\-bachelet\\-venezuela\\-visit\\|title\\=Protests Erupt in Caracas During Venezuela Visit by UN's Bachelet\\|last\\=Laya\\|first\\=Patricia\\|date\\=20 June 2019\\|work\\=Bloomberg\\|access\\-date\\=22 June 2019}} Protests occurred in front of the UN office in Caracas during the last day of the visit, denouncing rights abuses carried out by Maduro's administration. [Gilber Caro](/wiki/Gilber_Caro \"Gilber Caro\"), who was released two days before the visit, joined the protest.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/97c6390cb2694098b823fe8766819d4b\\|title\\=UN human rights chief appeals for dialogue in Venezuela\\|last1\\=Smith\\|first1\\=Scott\\|last2\\=Goodman\\|first2\\=Joshua\\|date\\=22 June 2019\\|website\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=22 June 2019}} Bachelet announced the creation of a delegation maintained by two UN officials that will remain in Venezuela to monitor the humanitarian situation. Bachelet expressed concern that the recent sanctions on oil exports and gold trade could worsen the crisis that has increased since 2013,{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID\\=24722\\&LangID\\=E\\|title\\=First UN Human Rights presence in Venezuela\\|date\\=21 June 2019\\|website\\=OHCHR\\|access\\-date\\=23 June 2019}} calling the measures \"extremely broad\" and that they are capable of exacerbating the suffering of the Venezuelan people.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/aug/09/un\\-rights\\-chief\\-decries\\-latest\\-us\\-sanctions\\-venezuela\\-michelle\\-bachelet\\|title\\=UN rights chief decries latest US sanctions targeting Venezuela\\|newspaper\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=9 August 2019}} She also called for the release of political prisoners in Venezuela. This was the first time a [United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights](/wiki/United_Nations_High_Commissioner_of_Human_Rights \"United Nations High Commissioner of Human Rights\") visited Venezuela.",
"The final published report addressed the extrajudicial executions, torture, [forced disappearances](/wiki/Forced_disappearance \"Forced disappearance\") and other human rights violations reportedly committed by Venezuelan security forces in the recent years.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1U022E\\|title\\=On Venezuelan independence day, Maduro calls for dialogue as Guaido slams 'dictatorship'\\|date\\=5 July 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2019}} Bachelet expressed her concerns for the \"shockingly high\" number of extrajudicial killings and urged for the dissolution of the [Special Action Forces](/wiki/Special_Action_Forces \"Special Action Forces\") (FAES).{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190705\\-venezuela\\-united\\-nations\\-report\\-michelle\\-bachelet\\-human\\-rights\\|title\\=UN report cites 'shockingly high' number of likely 'executions' in Venezuela\\|date\\=5 July 2019\\|website\\=France 24\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2019}} According to the report, 1,569 cases of executions as consequence as a result of \"resistance to authority\" were registered by the Venezuelan authorities from 1 January to 19 March. Other 52 deaths that occurred during 2019 protests were attributed to colectivos.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/07/1041902\\|title\\=UN human rights chief 'hopeful' Venezuelan authorities are ready to address violations, calls for dialogue\\|date\\=4 July 2019\\|website\\=UN News\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2019}} The report also details how the Venezuelan government \"aimed at neutralising, repressing and criminalising political opponents and people critical of the government\" since 2016\\.",
"Guaidó supported the investigation, stating \"the systematic violation of human rights, the repression, the torture... is clearly identified in the (UN) report\". Maduro administration described the report as a \"biased vision\" and demanded it be \"corrected\".{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/8349d5ca263d494b849923529530ccf4\\|title\\=Venezuelan envoy rejects 'biased' report at UN rights body\\|last\\=Keaten\\|first\\=Jamey\\|date\\=5 July 2019\\|website\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2019}} In the words of his foreign minister, \"It's a text lacking in scientific rigor, with serious errors in methodology and which seems like a carbon copy of previous reports\". Maduro would later state that the OHCHR \"has declared itself an enemy\" to Maduro and the Bolivarian Revolution.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.dw.com/es/maduro\\-llama\\-a\\-la\\-oficina\\-de\\-bachelet\\-enemiga\\-de\\-venezuela/a\\-49642312\\|title\\=Maduro llama a la oficina de Bachelet \"enemiga\" de Venezuela {{!}} DW {{!}} 18\\.07\\.2019\\|date\\=18 July 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[Deutsche Welle]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-07\\-19}}",
"Speaking to reporters after the UN Human Rights Council, Bachelet announced the release of 22 Venezuelan prisoners, including 20 students, judge [Maria Lourdes Afiuni](/wiki/Detention_of_Maria_Lourdes_Afiuni \"Detention of Maria Lourdes Afiuni\"), in her second house arrest since March, and journalist [Braulio Jatar](/wiki/Braulio_Jatar \"Braulio Jatar\"), arrested in 2016\\.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-un\\-prisoners\\-idUSKCN1U016V\\|title\\=Venezuela releasing judge, journalist, 20 students – U.N.\\|last\\=Nebehay\\|first\\=Stephanie\\|date\\=5 July 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=10 July 2019}} Bachelet welcomed the conditional releases and the acceptance of the two officers delegation as \"the beginning of positive engagement on the country's many human rights issues\".",
"In October 2019, Venezuela competed for one of the two seats to the [United Nations Human Rights Council](/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council \"United Nations Human Rights Council\"), along with Brazil and Costa Rica, and was elected with 105 votes in a secret ballot by the 193\\-member [United Nations General Assembly](/wiki/United_Nations_General_Assembly \"United Nations General Assembly\"). Brazil was re\\-elected with 153 votes, while Costa Rica was not having garnered 96 votes and entering the month of the election as competition to Venezuela. The United States, [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group \"Lima Group\") and human rights groups lobbied against Venezuela's election.{{cite news\\|last1\\=Nicols\\|first1\\=Michelle\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-un\\-rights\\-idUSKBN1WW2I7\\|title\\=Venezuela wins seat on U.N. rights council despite U.S. opposition\\|date\\=18 October 2019\\|access\\-date\\=26 March 2020\\|publisher\\=Reuters}}",
"On 16 September 2020, the United Nations accused the Maduro government of [crimes against humanity](/wiki/Crimes_against_humanity \"Crimes against humanity\").{{Cite web\\|last\\=Geneva\\|first\\=Staff and agencies in\\|date\\=2020\\-09\\-16\\|title\\=Venezuela: UN accuses Maduro government of crimes against humanity\\|url\\=http://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/16/venezuela\\-un\\-report\\-crimes\\-against\\-humanity\\-maduro\\-government\\|access\\-date\\=2020\\-09\\-18\\|website\\=The Guardian\\|language\\=en}}",
"### Torture and death of Acosta Arévalo",
"On 26 June, Maduro said that his government had arrested several defecting military, thus foiling a plot to remove him from power and to assassinate him, his wife and [Diosdado Cabello](/wiki/Diosdado_Cabello \"Diosdado Cabello\").{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jun/26/venezuela\\-government\\-says\\-foiled\\-plot\\-to\\-assassinate\\-president\\-maduro\\|title\\=Venezuela government says it foiled plot to assassinate president Maduro\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|work\\=The Guardian\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019\\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}}{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1TR39F\\|title\\=Venezuela's Maduro says authorities foiled opposition coup plot\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019\\|language\\=en}} The alleged plan also included the rescue of [Raúl Baduel](/wiki/Ra%C3%BAl_Baduel \"Raúl Baduel\"), a retired general imprisoned for a second time in 2017, to install him as president. Maduro accused Israel, Colombia, Chile and the United States of involvement in the plot.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\\-06\\-26/venezuela\\-regime\\-says\\-guaido\\-two\\-dozen\\-more\\-planned\\-coups\\|title\\=Venezuela Regime Says Guaido, Two Dozen More Planned Coups\\|last\\=Vasquez\\|first\\=Alex\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|website\\=Bloomberg\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019}} Jorge Rodríguez said that the foiled plan involved the bombing of a government building, the seizing of [La Carlota air base](/wiki/Generalissimo_Francisco_de_Miranda_Air_Base \"Generalissimo Francisco de Miranda Air Base\"), and a bank robbery. Guaidó dismissed the allegations as lies; opposition members have frequently accused Maduro of coercion of arrested suspects and fabrication of plots for political gain.",
"In the wake of the coup allegations, an alleged kidnapping attempt directed at members of Guaidó's entourage occurred on a Caracas highway.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190627\\-venezuela\\-coup\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-juan\\-guaido\\|title\\=Venezuela government says it derailed a coup attempt, opposition denies\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|website\\=France 24\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019}} Eight armed men on motorcycles dressed as civilians allegedly surrounded a vehicle containing two of Guaidó's aides.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/venezuela\\-politica\\-guaido\\-idLTAKCN1TR38B\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190627125353/https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/venezuela\\-politica\\-guaido\\-idLTAKCN1TR38B\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-date\\=27 June 2019\\|title\\=Guaidó encara a civiles armados, gobierno de Venezuela vuelve a acusar a oposición de terrorismo\\|date\\=27 June 2019\\|website\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019\\|language\\=es}} Guaidó, who was in a car further ahead, spoke with the armed civilians,{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/6d0857bd6fdf42cfbfe89e8ff8ffc01a\\|title\\=Venezuela gov't says it thwarted plot seeking to kill Maduro\\|last\\=Smith\\|first\\=Scott\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|website\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019}} according to photos and a video released by his press team and published by *[Infobae](/wiki/Infobae \"Infobae\")*.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2019/06/26/el\\-presidente\\-interino\\-de\\-venezuela\\-juan\\-guaido\\-frustro\\-un\\-intento\\-de\\-secuestro\\-a\\-su\\-equipo\\-sobre\\-una\\-autopista/?outputType\\=amp\\-type\\|work\\=Infobae\\|date\\=26 June 2019\\|access\\-date\\=27 June 2019\\|title\\=El presidente interino Juan Guaidó frustró un intento de secuestro a su equipo sobre una autopista en Venezuela}} According to Guaidó, the group received orders from the Venezuelan Military Counter\\-intelligence agency [DGCIM](/wiki/Direcci%C3%B3n_General_de_Contrainteligencia_Militar \"Dirección General de Contrainteligencia Militar\"), but were not \"hostile\".",
"Navy captain [Rafael Acosta Arévalo](/wiki/Rafael_Acosta_Ar%C3%A9valo \"Rafael Acosta Arévalo\"), who had been arrested on charges related to the alleged foiled coup attempt and transferred to a military hospital, died during detention on 28 June.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1TV0MR\\|title\\=Venezuela confirms death of detained officer, his wife says he was tortured\\|last1\\=Sequera\\|first1\\=Vivian\\|date\\=30 June 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=1 July 2019\\|last2\\=Ellsworth\\|first2\\=Brian}} Maduro administration did not provide a cause of death but announced an investigation on the matter.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://apnews.com/31069508ae6b4d84af1b1f4657d2668d\\|title\\=Death of Venezuelan navy captain draws US condemnation\\|date\\=30 June 2019\\|website\\=Associated Press\\|access\\-date\\=1 July 2019}} Acosta Arevalo's wife, human rights advocates, Juan Guaidó and the [US Department of State](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State \"United States Department of State\") accused Maduro's administration of torturing the captain to death. The Lima Group and the European Union called for an independent investigation.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.dw.com/en/venezuela\\-accused\\-of\\-killing\\-naval\\-officer/a\\-49424685\\|title\\=Venezuela accused of killing naval officer\\|date\\=1 July 2019\\|website\\=Deutsche Welle\\|access\\-date\\=1 July 2019}} The preliminary autopsy determined that Acosta Arévalo's cause of death was \"severe [cerebral edema](/wiki/Cerebral_edema \"Cerebral edema\") \\[brain swelling] caused by acute [respiratory failure](/wiki/Respiratory_failure \"Respiratory failure\") caused by a [pulmonary embolism](/wiki/Pulmonary_embolism \"Pulmonary embolism\") caused by [rhabdomyolysis](/wiki/Rhabdomyolysis \"Rhabdomyolysis\") \\[a potentially life\\-threatening breakdown of muscle fibers] by [multiple trauma](/wiki/Polytrauma \"Polytrauma\")\".{{cite news \\|last1\\=Phillips \\|first1\\=Tom \\|title\\=Venezuela: UN report accuses Maduro of 'gross violations' against dissenters \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/04/venezuela\\-un\\-report\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-violations\\-against\\-dissenters \\|access\\-date\\=11 July 2019 \\|agency\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|date\\=4 July 2019}}",
"### Operación Alacrán",
"{{See also\\|Operación Alacrán}}",
"{{quote box\\|width\\=250px\\|text\\=The conditions for any political change in 2020 are getting ever more remote.\\|source\\=John Magdaleno, Venezuelan consultant}}\nAn investigation led by [Armando.info](/wiki/Armando.info \"Armando.info\") reported that nine members of the National Assembly defended individuals sanctioned by the United States for their involvement in the controversial [Local Committees for Supply and Production](/wiki/Local_Committees_for_Supply_and_Production \"Local Committees for Supply and Production\") (CLAP) program. The investigation reported that the implicated lawmakers had written letters of support to the [United States Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Treasury \"United States Treasury\") and others to a Colombian man named Carlos Lizcano, who authorities were investigating over his possible links to [Alex Saab](/wiki/Alex_Saab \"Alex Saab\"), a Colombian businessman associated with the food distribution program and under United States sanctions. According to Armando.info, the lawmakers wrote the letters despite being aware of evidence that tied Lizcano to Saab. Guaidó condemned the actions of the nine legislators, suspending them from their positions and stating that it was \"unacceptable to use a state institution to attempt to whitewash the reputation of thieves\". The scandal damaged Guaidó's reputation among his supporters in [Venezuela](/wiki/Venezuela \"Venezuela\"), with some members of the opposition beginning to call for new leadership, according to analysts and those involved.",
"The Maduro government increased its pressure by \"deploying bribes, intimidation and repression\" attempting to divide the opposition to maintain power.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the\\_americas/juan\\-guaido\\-promised\\-to\\-save\\-venezuela\\-a\\-year\\-later\\-the\\-flame\\-he\\-lit\\-is\\-petering\\-out\\-his\\-us\\-backers\\-are\\-weighing\\-their\\-options/2019/12/17/48a18186\\-1495\\-11ea\\-80d6\\-d0ca7007273f\\_story.html\\|title\\=Juan Guaidó promised to save Venezuela. Now the flame he lit is petering out, and his U.S. backers are weighing their options.\\|last\\=Faiola\\|first\\=Anthony\\|date\\=17 December 2019\\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]]}}",
"### Dollarization",
"Following increased sanctions throughout 2019, the Maduro government abandoned policies established by [Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez \"Hugo Chávez\") such as price and currency controls. In a November 2019 interview with [José Vicente Rangel](/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Vicente_Rangel \"José Vicente Rangel\"), President Maduro described [dollarization](/wiki/Currency_substitution \"Currency substitution\") as an \"escape valve\" that helps the recovery of the country, the spread of productive forces in the country and the economy. However, Maduro said that the [Venezuelan bolívar](/wiki/Venezuelan_bol%C3%ADvar \"Venezuelan bolívar\") would still remain as the national currency.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-economy/maduro\\-says\\-thank\\-god\\-for\\-dollarization\\-in\\-venezuela\\-idUSKBN1XR0RV\\|title\\=Maduro says 'thank God' for dollarization in Venezuela\\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]]\\|date\\=17 November 2019\\|access\\-date\\=18 November 2019}} *[The Economist](/wiki/The_Economist \"The Economist\")* wrote that Venezuela had also obtained \"extra money from selling gold, both from illegal mines and from its reserves, and narcotics\". Its article continued to explain that the improving economy led to more difficulties for Guaidó as Venezuelans who had a better situation were less likely to protest against Maduro.",
""
] |
Recognition, reactions, and public opinion
------------------------------------------
{{main\|Responses to the Venezuelan presidential crisis}}
[thumb\|350px\|Nations recognizing presidential legitimacy as of 8 February 2019, during the year of Guaidó's height of recognition.
{{legend\|black\|Venezuela}}
{{legend\|\#999999\|Neutral countries}}
{{legend\|\#E0E0E0\|No statement}}
{{legend\|green\|Countries recognizing Guaidó}}
{{legend\|\#55FF55\|Countries supporting the opposition National Assembly}}
{{legend\|red\|Countries recognizing Maduro}}](/wiki/File:Venezuela_president_recognition_map_2019-.svg "Venezuela president recognition map 2019-.svg")
[thumb\|350px\|Nations recognizing presidential legitimacy as of 5 January 2023, before Guaidó's interim government dissolution was made effective:
{{legend\|\#000000\|Venezuela}}
{{legend\|\#535D6C\|Neutral}}
{{legend\|\#E0E0E0\|No statement}}
{{legend\|blue\|Recognize Guaidó}}
{{legend\|\#5599FF\|Support \[\[IV National Assembly of Venezuela\|opposition National Assembly]]}}
{{legend\|\#ff0000\|Recognize Maduro}}
\|alt\=](/wiki/File:Venezuela_president_recognition_map.svg "Venezuela president recognition map.svg")
At his peak, Guaidó's claim as the interim president of Venezuela was recognized 57 countries,{{cite news\|url\=https://www.venezuelablog.org/interactive\-map\-degrees\-of\-diplomatic\-recognition\-of\-guaido\-and\-maduro/\|title\=Interactive Map: Degrees of Diplomatic Recognition of Guaidó and Maduro\|last1\=Martinez\-Gugerli\|first1\=Kristen\|date\=15 October 2020\|publisher\=Venezuela Blog\|access\-date\=14 June 2022}} "including the US, Canada and most Latin American and European countries".{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/12/how\-a\-nationwide\-protest\-against\-maduro\-could\-shape\-venezuelas\-future.html\|title\=How a nationwide protest against Maduro could shape Venezuela's future\|author\=Meredith, Sam\|date\= 12 February 2019\|work\=\[\[CNBC]]\|access\-date\=12 February 2019}} Other countries were divided between a neutral position, support for the National Assembly in general without endorsing Guaidó, and support for Maduro's presidency; internationally, support followed traditional geopolitical lines, with Russia, China, Iran, Syria, Cuba, and Turkey supporting Maduro, and the US, Canada, and most of Western Europe supporting Guaidó.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/24/americas/russia\-turkey\-china\-support\-nicolas\-maduro\-venezuela\-intl/index.html \|title\= 'Pouring gas on fire': Russia slams Trump's stance in Venezuela \|author\= Britton, Bianca \|publisher\= CNN \|date\= 24 January 2019 \|access\-date\= 25 February 2019}}
The [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament "European Parliament") recognized Guaidó as interim president.{{cite news \|title\= EU parliament recognizes Guaido as Venezuelan interim president \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-eu/eu\-parliament\-recognizes\-guaido\-as\-venezuelan\-interim\-president\-idUSKCN1PP1HQ \|access\-date\= 31 January 2019 \|work\=\[\[Reuters]] \|date\= 31 January 2019}}{{Cite web\|date\=2021\-01\-21\|title\=MEPs: Juan Guaidó is the legitimate interim President of Venezuela\|url\=https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press\-room/20210114IPR95633/meps\-juan\-guaido\-is\-the\-legitimate\-interim\-president\-of\-venezuela\|access\-date\=2021\-01\-25\|website\=\[\[European Parliament]]}} In 2019, the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union "European Union") unanimously recognized the National Assembly,{{cite news \| author\=Hanke, Jakob and Hans von der Burchard \|title\=Brussels caught off\-guard by Venezuela's political turmoil \|url\=https://www.politico.eu/article/brussels\-caught\-off\-guard\-by\-venezuelas\-political\-turmoil\-nicolas\-maduro/ \|website\=POLITICO \|access\-date\= 26 January 2019 \|date\= 24 January 2019 \|quote\=In a declaration published late Wednesday, EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini said the EU ... “fully supports the national assembly as the democratically elected institution whose powers need to be restored and respected.” ... Kocijančič said Mogherini's statement had been “agreed with all 28 member states" ... }} but Italy dissented on recognizing Guaidó.{{cite news \|work\=Reuters \|title\= Divided Italy blocks EU statement on recognizing Venezuela's Guaido \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-italy/divided\-italy\-blocks\-eu\-statement\-on\-recognizing\-venezuelas\-guaido\-idUSKCN1PT15G\|access\-date\=8 February 2019\|date\=4 February 2019}} In January 2021, the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union "European Union") stopped recognizing Guaidó's claim, but still did not recognize Maduro as the legitimate president;{{Cite news \|date\=2021\-01\-25 \|title\=EU states no longer recognise Guaido as Venezuela's interim president \|language\=en \|work\=Reuters \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-eu\-idUSKBN29U1A3 \|access\-date\=2023\-01\-05}} the [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament "European Parliament") reaffirmed its recognition of Guaidó as president, and the EU threatened with further [sanctions](/wiki/International_sanctions_during_the_Venezuelan_crisis "International sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis").
The OAS approved a resolution on 10 January 2019 "to not recognize the legitimacy of Nicolás Maduro's new term".{{cite press release \|url\= http://www.oas.org/en/media\_center/press\_release.asp?sCodigo\=E\-001/19 \|title\= OAS Permanent Council Agrees 'to not recognize the legitimacy of Nicolas Maduro's new term' \|publisher \= Organization of American States \|access\-date\= 27 January 2019 \|date\= 10 January 2019}} In a 24 January special OAS session, sixteen countries including the US recognized Guaidó as interim president, but they did not achieve the majority needed for a resolution.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.eltiempo.com/mundo/eeuu\-y\-canada/en\-la\-oea\-no\-logran\-mayoria\-para\-reconocer\-a\-guaido\-como\-presidente\-318494 \|title\= En la OEA 16 países reconocen a Guaidó como presidente de Venezuela \|work\= El Tiempo \|access\-date\= 27 January 2019 \| date\= 25 January 2019 \|author\= Gómez Maseri, Sergio \|language\=es}} The United Nations called for dialogue and deescalation of tension, but could not agree on any other path for resolving the crisis.{{Cite news \|url\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/01/1031382 \|title\= UN political chief calls for dialogue to ease tensions in Venezuela; Security Council divided over path to end crisis \|work\=UN News \|date\= 26 January 2019 \|access\-date\=29 January 2019}} Twelve of the fourteen members of the [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group "Lima Group") recognize Guaidó;{{cite news \|url\= https://www.latimes.com/world/la\-fg\-venezuela\-pence\-20190225\-story.html \|work\= Los Angeles Times \|author\= Kraul, Chris \|date\= 25 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 25 February 2019 \|title\= Pence says U.S. will up the ante as it seeks ouster of Venezuelan President Maduro}} [Beatriz Becerra](/wiki/Beatriz_Becerra "Beatriz Becerra")—on the day after she retired as head of the human rights subcommittee for the European Parliament—said that the [International Contact Group](/wiki/International_Conference_on_the_Situation_in_Venezuela "International Conference on the Situation in Venezuela"), jointly sponsored by Uruguay and Mexico, had been of no use and "has been an artifact that has served no purpose since it was created". She said there had been no progress on the 90\-day deadline for elections that the group established when it was formed, and she considered that the Contact Group should be terminated and efforts coordinated through the Lima Group.{{cite news \|url\= http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/mundo/beatriz\-becerra\-grupo\-contacto\-servido\-para\-nada\-venezuela\_279632 \|publisher\= El Nacional \|date\= 18 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 18 April 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= Beatriz Becerra: El Grupo de Contacto no ha servido para nada en Venezuela \|trans\-title\= Beatriz Becerra: The Contact Group has not served in Venezuela at all}} During the 49th [General Assembly of the Organization of American States](/wiki/General_Assembly_of_the_Organization_of_American_States "General Assembly of the Organization of American States"), on 27 June, Guaidó's presidency was recognized by the organization.
The Venezuelan Observatory of Social Conflictivity stated that there were on average 69 [protests daily in Venezuela](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests "2019 Venezuelan protests") during the first three months of 2019, for a total of 6,211 protests, representing a significant increase over previous years (157% of protests for the same period in 2018, and 395% relative to the number in 2017\).{{cite web \|url\= https://www.observatoriodeconflictos.org.ve/tendencias\-de\-la\-conflictividad/6\-211\-protestas\-en\-venezuela\-durante\-el\-primer\-trimestre\-de\-2019 \|publisher\= Venezuelan Observatory of Social Conflict \|title\= 6\.211 protestas en Venezuela durante el primer trimestre de 2019 \|date\= 15 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 17 April 2019 \|trans\-title\= 6,211 protests in Venezuela during the first quarter of 2019}}
Following the failed uprising on 30 April, support for Guaidó declined, attendance to his demonstrations subsided and participants in committees organized by Guaidó stated that there has been little progress.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-analysis\-idUSKCN1TW3ME\|title\=Disappointed Venezuelans lose patience with Guaido as Maduro hangs on\|date\=2 July 2019\|work\=\[\[Reuters]]\|access\-date\=3 July 2019\|author1\= Angus Berwick\|author2\= Mircely Guanipa}}{{bullet}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://politi.co/2J9PRjd\|title\=We are going to take over the premises\|author\=Rodríguez, Jesús A\|date\=8 May 2019\|website\=\[\[POLITICO Magazine]]\|access\-date\=10 May 2019\|quote\=In Venezuela, though the number of people who say they recognize Guaidó as the legitimate president has dwindled to about 50 percent since January, his approval remains much stronger than Maduro's abysmal 4 percent.}}
{{cite news\|url\=https://www.chicagotribune.com/sns\-tns\-bc\-venezuela\-guaido\-20190506\-story.html\|title\=As Guaido's popularity in Venezuela begins to dwindle, what's next for the opposition?\|author\=Wyss, Jim\|date\=6 May 2019\|work\=\[\[Miami Herald]]\|access\-date\=10 May 2019\|agency\=\[\[Chicago Tribune]]\|quote\=... last week's failed military uprising and a spate of violent but fruitless demonstrations have some wondering if Guaido, and the opposition at large, have what it takes to oust Maduro ... A poll released Monday by Caracas\-based Meganalisis found that Guaido's approval ratings dropped to 50 percent, down from 84 percent in January. He's still far more popular than Maduro whose approval rating is at 4 percent but the precipitous drop can't be ignored ...\|archive\-date\=10 May 2019\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190510035820/https://www.chicagotribune.com/sns\-tns\-bc\-venezuela\-guaido\-20190506\-story.html\|url\-status\=dead}}
{{cite news\|url\=https://www.cisiamo.info/mondo/2019/05/07/venezuela\-gradimento\-guaido/\|title\=Venezuela, il gradimento di Guaidò cala a picco: meno 34% in soli tre mesi\|last1\=Casoni\|first1\=Giampiero\|date\=7 May 2019\|work\=Ci Siamo\|access\-date\=10 May 2019\|language\=it\-IT\|quote\=The popularity of Juan Guaidò is in sharp decline and the 'liberator' of Venezuela seems to have exhausted the original propulsive thrust ... At the center of this drop in consensus, especially the failure (because of its failure) of the coup in recent weeks ...\|archive\-date\=10 May 2019\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190510035824/https://www.cisiamo.info/mondo/2019/05/07/venezuela\-gradimento\-guaido/\|url\-status\=dead}}* + *Reuters* reported in June that analysts have predicted that Maduro would maintain his position as he gains confidence that his actions against the opposition go "relatively unpunished".
By the end of 2019, support for Guaidó dropped, with protests organized by his movement resulting with low participation.{{Cite news \|date\=2019\-11\-23 \|title\=After Venezuelan opposition call for mass rallies, street protests underwhelm \|language\=en \|work\=\[\[Reuters]] \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKBN1XW209 \|access\-date\=2019\-12\-04}} Pollster Datanálisis published figures showing that support for Guaidó decreased from 61% in February to 42% in November 2019\. According to Jesús Seguías, the head of the Venezuelan analysis firm Datincorp, "For years Washington and the Venezuelan opposition have said that Nicolás Maduro, and before him Hugo Chávez, were weak and about to fall \[...] but it's clear that's not the case".{{Cite web \|last\=Wyss \|first\=Jim \|date\=30 October 2019 \|title\=South America's wretched month has been great for one man: Venezuela's Maduro \|url\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article236791333\.html \|access\-date\=4 December 2019 \|website\=\[\[The Miami Herald]]}} Analyst Carlos Pina stated that as "\[t]he military support to President Maduro remains intact", the opposition will need to "rethink its strategy" and that "Guaidó has also been very limited in suggesting or proposing a strategy that could change the current \[status quo]." Into December 2019, Venezuelan pollster Meganálisis surveys showed that 10% of respondents approved of Guaidó, compared to 9% who supported Maduro.{{Cite web \|last\=Wyss \|first\=Jim \|date\=4 December 2019 \|title\=Poll shows Venezuela's Guaidó is losing popularity and has sunk to Maduro level \|url\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\-world/world/americas/article238040219\.html \|access\-date\=9 December 2019 \|website\=\[\[The Miami Herald]]}}
As of January 2023, following the opposition vote to dissolve Guaidó's interim government, the United States stopped recognizing Guaidó's presidential claim. A spokesperson for the [White House](/wiki/White_House "White House") and [State Department](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State "United States Department of State") said that the US "recognized the National Assembly elected in 2015, which Guaidó had led, as Venezuela's 'only remaining democratically elected institution'."
### Defections
{{main\|Venezuelan crisis defection}}
The *Miami Herald* reported that dozens of arrests were made in anticipation of a military uprising, and Defense Minister [Vladimir Padrino López](/wiki/Vladimir_Padrino_L%C3%B3pez "Vladimir Padrino López") ordered a counterintelligence effort to locate conspirators or possible defectors.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article225548780\.html \|work\= Miami Herald \|title\= Venezuela's Nicolás Maduro orders multiple arrests within military to squelch dissent \|author\= Maria Delgado, Antonio \|date\= 5 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 6 February 2019}} According to *France 24*, Maduro declared "military deserters who fled to Colombia have become mercenaries" as part of a "US\-backed coup".{{cite news\|url\=https://www.france24\.com/en/20190206\-trump\-discuss\-venezuela\-with\-colombian\-president\-white\-house\|title\=Trump to discuss Venezuela with Colombian president: White House\|date\=6 February 2019\|work\=France 24\|access\-date\=6 February 2019}} Guaidó declared that the opposition had held secret meetings with military officials to discuss the [Amnesty Law](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_Amnesty_Law "2019 Venezuelan Amnesty Law").{{cite news\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/31/world/americas/venezuelan\-juan\-guaido\-military.html\|title\=Juan Guaidó says Venezuelan opposition had secret talks with military\|website\=The New York Times\|access\-date\=1 February 2019 \|author\= Specia, Megan and Nicholas Casey \|date\= 31 January 2019}}
[Hugo Carvajal](/wiki/Hugo_Carvajal "Hugo Carvajal"), the head of [Venezuela's military intelligence](/wiki/Direcci%C3%B3n_de_Inteligencia_Militar "Dirección de Inteligencia Militar") for ten years during [Hugo Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez "Hugo Chávez")'s presidency and "one of the government's most prominent figures",{{cite news \|title\= Venezuela's Ex\-Spy Chief Breaks With Maduro: 'You Have Killed Hundreds' \|author\= Herrero, Ana Vanessa and Nicholas Casey \|work\= New York Times \|edition\= Late Edition (East Coast) \|date\= 22 February 2019 \|page\= A.6 \|via\=ProQuest}} Also [available online.](https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/21/world/americas/hugo-carvajal-maduro-venezuela.html) publicly broke with Maduro and endorsed Guaidó as acting president.{{Cite news \|title\= Venezuelan Official Breaks With Maduro; Hugo Carvajal, the former military\-intelligence chief, pledges support for opposition leader Juan Guaidó and says humanitarian aid should be let into the country \|author\=Dube, Ryan and Kejal Vyas\|date\= 21 February 2019\|work\=The Wall Street Journal\| via\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://www.wsj.com/articles/venezuelan-official-breaks-with-maduro-11550791292) During the [30 April 2019 uprising attempt](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_uprising_attempt "2019 Venezuelan uprising attempt"), Manuel Cristopher Figuera, the Director General of Venezuela's National Intelligence Service, [SEBIN](/wiki/SEBIN "SEBIN"), broke with Maduro.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.foxnews.com/world/venezuela\-secret\-police\-head\-breaks\-with\-maduro \|publisher\= Fox News \|date\= 30 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 1 May 2019 \|title\= Head of Venezuela's secret police breaks with Maduro \|author\= Chamberlain, Samuel}}
Certain top military figures recognized Guaidó,{{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/02/en\-video\-general\-de\-division\-del\-alto\-mando\-militar\-de\-la\-aviacion\-reconoce\-a\-guaido\-como\-presidente\-e/\|title\=EN VIDEO: General de división del Alto Mando Militar de la aviación reconoce a Guaidó como presidente (e)\|date\=2 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\-ES\|access\-date\=2 February 2019}}
\* {{Cite news\|url\=http://www.el\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/general\-fuerza\-aerea\-envio\-mensaje\-personal\-militar\_269281\|title\=General de la Fuerza Aérea envió un mensaje al personal militar\|date\=2 February 2019\|work\=El Nacional\|access\-date\=3 February 2019\|language\=es}}
\* {{cite web\|url\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/02/mayor\-general\-jorge\-oropeza\-se\-pronuncia\-contra\-el\-regimen\-de\-maduro\-y\-en\-respaldo\-a\-guaido\-video/\|title\=Mayor General Jorge Oropeza se pronuncia contra el régimen de Maduro y en respaldo a Guaidó (VIDEO)\|date\=2 February 2019\|website\=\[\[La Patilla]]\|language\=es\|access\-date\=3 February 2019}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.lanacion.com.ar/2222999\-67\-militares\-cambian\-de\-bando\-y\-un\-general\-de\-peso\-reconoce\-a\-guaido\-como\-presidente \|work\= La Nacion \|language\= es \|title\= 67 militares cambian de bando y un general de peso reconoce a Guaidó como presidente \|author\= Lozano, Daniel \|date\= 23 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 27 February 2019 \|archive\-date\= 28 February 2019 \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190228010055/https://www.lanacion.com.ar/2222999\-67\-militares\-cambian\-de\-bando\-y\-un\-general\-de\-peso\-reconoce\-a\-guaido\-como\-presidente \|url\-status\= dead }}
\* {{cite news \|last1\=Oatis \|first1\=Jonathan \|last2\=Adler \|first2\=Leslie \|title\=U.S.\-sanctioned Venezuelan defects to Colombia, slams Maduro \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-general/u\-s\-sanctioned\-venezuelan\-defects\-to\-colombia\-slams\-maduro\-idUSKCN1QZ1YB?il\=0 \|access\-date\=19 March 2019 \|work\=Reuters \|date\=18 March 2019 }} and around 1,400 military personnel have defected to Colombia, but the top military command stays loyal to the government.{{cite news\|author\=Guy, Jack\|url\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/03/americas/venezuela\-lopez\-opposition\-intl/index.html\|title\=Venezuela's Leopoldo Lopez says he met generals during house arrest\|date\=3 May 2019\|access\-date\=3 May 2019\|publisher\=CNN}}
Following the 23 January events, some Venezuelan diplomats in the United States supported Guaidó; the majority returned to Venezuela on Maduro's orders.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/mundo/america\-latina/venezuela\-es/article225227915\.html\|title\=Otra diplomática venezolana en EEUU reconoce a Guaidó como presidente\|date\=29 January 2019\|website\=\[\[El Nuevo Herald]]\|language\=es\|access\-date\=1 February 2019}}
### Foreign military involvement
{{main\|Foreign involvement during the Venezuelan presidential crisis}}
[thumb\|On 18 February 2019, President [Donald Trump](/wiki/Donald_Trump "Donald Trump") advised Venezuelan soldiers to renounce loyalty to Nicolás Maduro.{{cite news \|title\=Ditch Maduro or lose everything, Trump tells Venezuelan army \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/18/trump\-venezuela\-nicolas\-maduro\-juan\-guaido \|work\=The Guardian \|date\=18 February 2019}}](/wiki/File:President_Trump_Delivers_Remarks_to_the_Venezuelan_American_Community_%2846422484424%29.jpg "President Trump Delivers Remarks to the Venezuelan American Community (46422484424).jpg")
In early 2019, with Cuban and Russian\-backed security forces in the country, United States military involvement became the subject of speculation.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.elmundo.es/internacional/2019/02/04/5c56e08b21efa0380b8b4665\.html\|title\=¿Cómo sería una invasión de Estados Unidos en Venezuela?\|author\=Pardo, Paul\|date\=4 February 2019\|website\=\[\[El Mundo (Spain)\|El Mundo]]\|language\=es\|access\-date\=5 February 2019}} Senior U.S. officials have declared that "all options are on the table",{{cite news \|url\= https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/venezuela/2019\-04\-17/will\-guaido\-call\-us\-military\-intervention \|work\= Foreign Affairs \|date\= 17 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 17 April 2019 \|author\= Fiorella, Giancarlo \|title\= Will Guaidó call for U.S. military intervention?}} but they have also said that "our objective is a [peaceful transfer of power](/wiki/Peaceful_transition_of_power "Peaceful transition of power")".{{Cite news \|url\= https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/02/01/john\_bolton\_all\_options\_are\_on\_the\_table\_for\_venezuela\_transfer\_of\_power.html \|title\=John Bolton: "All Options Are On The Table" For Venezuela; Hope For "Peaceful" Transfer Of Power\|author\=Hains, Tim\|date\=1 February 2019\|work\=Real Clear Politics\|access\-date\=5 February 2019}} Colombian guerrillas from [National Liberation Army](/wiki/National_Liberation_Army_%28Colombia%29 "National Liberation Army (Colombia)") (ELN) have vowed to defend Maduro, with ELN leaders in Cuba stating that they have been drafting plans to provide military assistance to Maduro.{{cite news \|author\=Charles, Mathew \|title\=ELN interview: Colombian Marxist guerrillas 'will fight' US troops if they invade Venezuela \|url\=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/02/eln\-interview\-colombian\-marxist\-guerrillas\-will\-fight\-us\-troops/ \|archive\-url\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220112/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/02/eln\-interview\-colombian\-marxist\-guerrillas\-will\-fight\-us\-troops/ \|archive\-date\=12 January 2022 \|url\-access\=subscription \|url\-status\=live \|access\-date\=2 February 2019 \|work\=\[\[The Daily Telegraph]] \|date\=2 February 2019}}{{cbignore}}
Article 187 of the [Venezuelan Constitution](/wiki/Constitution_of_Venezuela "Constitution of Venezuela") provides that "\[i]t shall be the function of the National Assembly: (11\) To authorize the operation of Venezuelan military missions abroad or foreign military missions within the country." In every demonstration summoned by Guaidó, there have been numerous signs demanding the application of Article 187, and a March poll showed 87\.5% support for foreign intervention.{{efn\|''Foreign Affairs'' states "this figure is likely inflated—the surveys do not define what a military intervention under 187(11\) would look like.}}{{cite news\|author\=Paola Martínez, Sammy\|url\=https://elpitazo.net/reportajes/expertos\-senalan\-que\-la\-aplicacion\-del\-articulo\-187\-11\-no\-implica\-una\-intervencion\-militar/\|title\=Expertos señalan que la aplicación del artículo 187\.11 no implica una intervención militar\|date\=14 April 2019\|access\-date\=19 April 2019\|agency\=El Pitazo\|language\=es\|trans\-title\=Experts point out that the application of article 187\.11 does not imply a military intervention}} Venezuelan politicians such [María Corina Machado](/wiki/Mar%C3%ADa_Corina_Machado "María Corina Machado") and [Antonio Ledezma](/wiki/Antonio_Ledezma "Antonio Ledezma"), former mayor of Caracas, have also demanded the application of the article.
According to Giancarlo Fiorella, writing in *[Foreign Affairs](/wiki/Foreign_Affairs "Foreign Affairs")*, the "loudest calls for intervention are coming not from the White House and its media mouthpieces but from some members of the Venezuelan opposition and from residents of the country desperate for a solution—any solution—to their years\-long plight." Fiorella states that "talk of invoking article 187(11\) has become commonplace" in Venezuela, adding that "the push for a military intervention in Venezuela is most intense not among hawks in Washington but inside the country itself."
Guaidó has said he would call for intervention "when the time comes", but in media interviews, he has not stated he supports removing Maduro by force. The National Assembly approved in July 2019 the reincorporation of Venezuela to the [Inter\-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance](/wiki/Inter-American_Treaty_of_Reciprocal_Assistance "Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance"), a mutual defense pact signed in 1947 that has never been enacted and from which Venezuela retired in 2013\.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-idUSKCN1UI2JX\|title\=Venezuela rejoins regional defense treaty but Guaido warns it's no 'magic' solution\|date\=23 July 2019\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=23 July 2019}}{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\-america\-latina\-48186726\|title\=Crisis en Venezuela: qué es el TIAR, el pacto interamericano de defensa mutua al que quiere sumarse la oposición de Venezuela\|date\=7 May 2019\|access\-date\=8 May 2019\|publisher\=BBC\|language\=es\|trans\-title\=Crisis in Venezuela: what is TIAR, the inter\-American pact of mutual defense which Venezuela's opposition wants to join}} Venezuela's reincorporation to the pact "can be used to request military assistance against foreign troops inside the country."{{cite news \|url\= http://www.eluniversal.com/politica/39442/an\-aprueba\-reintegracion\-de\-venezuela\-al\-tiar \|work\= El Universal \|date\= 8 May 2019 \|access\-date\= 8 May 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= AN aprueba reintegración de Venezuela al TIAR \|author\= Sayago, Gabriel \|trans\-title\= NA approves reintegration of Venezuela to the TIAR}}
In a 4 December 2019 interview with [Vox](/wiki/Vox_%28website%29 "Vox (website)"), Guaidó stated: "We sense a firm commitment from the United States. \[...] I think they're doing everything they could be doing under these circumstances, as are Colombia and Brazil."{{Cite web \|last\=Ward \|first\=Alex \|date\=2019\-12\-06 \|title\=Venezuela's opposition leader failed to depose Maduro. He explains why he's not giving up. \|url\=https://www.vox.com/world/2019/12/6/20998988/venezuela\-juan\-guaido\-interview\-maduro\-trump \|access\-date\=2019\-12\-09 \|website\=\[\[Vox (website)\|Vox]] \|language\=en}} When asked if he was nearer from removing Maduro from power than in January 2019, Guaidó replied: "Absolutely. Back then we didn't have multiple countries recognizing and supporting us. \[...] Today, we have way more tools at our disposal than we did one year ago." [Bloomberg News](/wiki/Bloomberg_News "Bloomberg News") reported two days later that the [Trump administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Donald_Trump "Presidency of Donald Trump") began to doubt that an opposition led by Guaidó would remove Maduro from office. The United States reportedly had no military option regarding Venezuela, although it began to debate on whether to partner with Russia to encourage Maduro to leave office or to increase pressure on Cuba, which is the Maduro government's main supporter.
#### Cuban presence
According to professor Erick Langer of [Georgetown University](/wiki/Georgetown_University "Georgetown University"), "Cuba and Russia have already intervened." A Cuban military presence of at least 15,000 personnel was in Venezuela in early 2018,{{cite news\|url\=http://foreignpolicy.com/2018/02/07/cuba\-is\-making\-the\-crisis\-in\-venezuela\-worse/\|title\=Cuba Is Making the Crisis in Venezuela Worse\|date\=7 February 2018\|work\=\[\[Foreign Policy]]\|access\-date\=8 February 2018}} while estimates ranging from hundreds to thousands of Cuban security forces were reported in 2019\. In April 2019, Trump threatened a "full and complete embargo, together with highest\-level sanctions" on Cuba if its troops do not cease operations in Venezuela.{{cite news \|title\=Trump threatens 'full' embargo on Cuba over Venezuela security support \|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-trump\-tweet/trump\-threatens\-sanctions\-on\-cuba\-over\-military\-support\-for\-venezuelas\-maduro\-idUSKCN1S62PD \|work\=Reuters \|date\=30 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 2 May 2019}}
#### Russian presence
Two nuclear weapon\-capable Russian planes landed in Venezuela in December 2018 in what Reuters called a "show of support for Maduro's socialist government."
According to the Kremlin, there are about 100 Russian military personnel in Venezuela "to repair equipment and provide technical co\-operation".{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/world/moscow\-refuses\-to\-withdraw\-troops\-from\-venezuela\-after\-president\-trump\-says\-get\-out\-ng\-58d41adfdad23c57d38002155b9da4e8\|title\=Russian bravado 'may lead to war'\|date\=1 April 2019\|website\=PerthNow\|access\-date\= 2 May 2019}} On 23 March 2019, two Russian planes landed in Venezuela carrying 99 troops{{cite news \|title\= As Maduro confronts a crisis, Russia's footprint in Venezuela grows: Moscow is seizing an opportunity to stick a finger in Washington's eye, experts say \|author\= Zuñiga, Mariana and Anthony Faiola \|newspaper\= The Washington Post \|date\= 30 March 2019 \|via\= ProQuest}} and 35 tonnes of [matériel](/wiki/Materiel "Materiel").{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics/russian\-air\-force\-planes\-land\-in\-venezuela\-carrying\-troops\-report\-idUSKCN1R50NB \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 24 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 24 March 2019 \|title\= Russian air force planes land in Venezuela carrying troops: report}} Alexey Seredin from the Russian Embassy in Caracas said the two planes were "part of an effort to maintain Maduro's defense apparatus, which includes [Sukhoi](/wiki/Sukhoi "Sukhoi") fighter jets and anti\-aircraft systems purchased from Russia."
National Assembly deputy Williams Dávila said the National Assembly would investigate the "penetration of foreign forces in Venezuela."{{Cite news \|url\= https://www.lavanguardia.com/politica/20190324/461210616315/militares\-rusos\-copan\-la\-escena\-en\-jornada\-libre\-para\-maduro\-y\-guaido.html\|title\= Militares rusos copan la escena en jornada libre para Maduro y Guaidó\|date\=24 March 2019\|work\=\[\[La Vanguardia]]\|access\-date\= 24 March 2019\|language\=es \|trans\-title\= Russian military take over the stage on a free day for Maduro and Guaidó \|author\=González, Ron}}
### Assets and reserves
Venezuela's third\-largest export (after crude oil and refined petroleum products) is gold.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.ccn.com/venezuela\-maduro\-340\-million\-gold\-8\-tons \|title\= Maduro scoops 8 Tons of Venezuelan Central Bank gold for illegal $340 million cash swap \|work\= CCN Norway \|author\= Emen, Mark \|date\= 1 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019}} The [World Gold Council](/wiki/World_Gold_Council "World Gold Council") reported in January 2019 that Venezuela's foreign\-held gold reserves had fallen by 69% to US$8\.4 billion during Maduro's presidency.{{cite news \|author\= Millan Lombrana, Laura \|title\= In Maduro's Venezuela, even counting gold bars is a challenge \|work\= Bloomberg Wire Service \|date\= 31 January 2019 \|via\= ProQuest}} In 2018, Maduro's government exported $900 million worth of gold out of Venezuela into [Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan "Recep Tayyip Erdoğan")'s Turkey.{{Cite web \|last\=Oner \|first\=Imdat \|title\=Venezuela, Turkey using gold to evade U.S. sanctions \|website\=\[\[Miami Herald]] \|url\=https://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/op\-ed/article224594180\.html }}{{cite news \|title\=As gold trade booms, Venezuela eyes stronger Turkey ties \|url\=https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/gold\-trade\-booms\-venezuela\-eyes\-stronger\-turkey\-ties\-190117084423511\.html \|work\=Al\-Jazeera \|date\=17 January 2019\|access\-date\= 2 May 2019}} In April 2019, Rubio warned the United Arab Emirates and Turkey not be "accomplices" in the "outrageous crime" of exporting Venezuela's gold.{{cite news \|title\=Turkey warned over Venezuela gold trade \|url\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\-europe\-47092784 \|publisher\=BBC News \|date\=2 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 2 May 2019 \|author\= Lowen, Mark}}
In mid\-December 2018, a Venezuelan delegation went to London to arrange for the [Bank of England](/wiki/Bank_of_England "Bank of England") to return the $1\.2 billion in gold bullion that Venezuela stores at the bank. Unnamed sources told Bloomberg that the Bank of England declined the transfer due to a request from US Secretary of State Pompeo and National Security Adviser Bolton, who wanted to "cut off the regime from its overseas assets".{{cite news\|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\-01\-28/u\-k\-leaves\-fate\-of\-venezuela\-s\-gold\-up\-to\-the\-bank\-of\-england\|title\=U.K. Leaves Fate of Venezuela's Gold Up to the Bank of England\|author\=Biggs, Stuart and Jess Shankleman\|date\=29 January 2019\|access\-date\=19 February 2019\|publisher\=Bloomberg\|quote\= According to a person familiar with the matter, the BOE declined the withdrawal request after U.S. Secretary of State Michael Pompeo and National Security Adviser John Bolton lobbied their U.K. counterparts to help cut off the regime from its overseas assets.}} In his memoir *[The Room Where It Happened](/wiki/The_Room_Where_It_Happened "The Room Where It Happened")*, Bolton said UK Foreign Minister [Jeremy Hunt](/wiki/Jeremy_Hunt "Jeremy Hunt") was "delighted to cooperate on steps they could take, for example freezing Venezuela's gold deposits in the Bank of England, so the regime could not sell the gold to keep itself going".{{cite book \|last1\=Bolton \|first1\=John R. \|title\=The room where it happened : a White House memoir \|date\=2020 \|location\=New York \|isbn\=9781982148058 \|pages\=257 \|edition\=First Simon \& Schuster hardcover \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=QjTMDwAAQBAJ \|access\-date\=14 April 2021}} In an interview with the BBC, Maduro asked Britain to return the gold instead of sending humanitarian aid, saying that the gold was "legally Venezuela's, it belongs to the [Central Bank of Venezuela](/wiki/Central_Bank_of_Venezuela "Central Bank of Venezuela")" and could be used to solve the country's problems. Guaidó asked the British government to ensure that the Bank of England does not provide the gold to the Maduro government. Maduro also said that the US has frozen $10 billion in Venezuelan accounts through its sanctions.{{cite news\|url\=https://news.yahoo.com/maduro\-calls\-return\-venezuelas\-uk\-deposited\-gold\-165317545\.html\|title\=Maduro calls for return of Venezuela's UK\-deposited gold\|date\=13 February 2019\|access\-date\=19 February 2019\|publisher\=Yahoo}}
In mid\-February 2019, a National Assembly legislator Ángel Alvarado said that eight tonnes of gold worth over US$340 million had been taken from the vault while the head of the Central Bank was abroad.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-gold\-exclusive/exclusive\-venezuela\-removed\-8\-tons\-of\-central\-bank\-gold\-last\-week\-legislator\-idUSKCN1QG2QG \|title\= Exclusive: Venezuela removed 8 tons of central bank gold last week – legislator \|author\= Pons, Corina and Mayela Armas \|work\= Reuters \|date\= 27 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019}} In March, Ugandan investigators reported that the gold could have been smuggled into that country.{{cite news \|url\= https://af.reuters.com/article/topNews/idAFKCN1QV0TG\-OZATP \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190402154542/https://af.reuters.com/article/topNews/idAFKCN1QV0TG\-OZATP \|url\-status\= dead \|archive\-date\= 2 April 2019 \|date\= 14 March 2019 \|title\= Uganda probes refinery over alleged smuggling of gold \|author\= Biryabarema, Elias \|work\= Reuters \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019}} Government sources said another eight tonnes of gold was taken out of the Central Bank in the first week of April 2019; the government source said that there were 100 tonnes left. The gold was removed while minimal staff was present and the bank was not fully operational because of the [ongoing, widespread power outages](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_blackouts "2019 Venezuelan blackouts"); the destination of the gold was not known.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-gold/exclusive\-venezuela\-removes\-eight\-tonnes\-of\-gold\-from\-central\-bank\-sources\-idUSKCN1RL247 \|publisher\= Reuters \|date\= 9 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 9 April 2019\|title\= Exclusive: Venezuela removes eight tonnes of gold from central bank – sources \|author\= Armas, Mayela}}{{cite news \|url\= https://www.voanoticias.com/a/denuncia\-que\-gobierno\-en\-disputa\-de\-venezuela\-saca\-otras\-ocho\-toneladas\-de\-oro\-del\-banco\-central/4868771\.html \|work\= VOA News \|publisher\= Reuters \|language\= es \|date\= 9 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 9 April 2019 \|title\= Denuncian retiro de más lingotes de oro del Banco Central de Venezuela}}
In 2009, Venezuela's [foreign reserves](/wiki/Foreign-exchange_reserves "Foreign-exchange reserves") peaked at US$43 billion; by July 2017, they had fallen below $10 billion "for the first time in 15 years",{{cite news \|url\= https://www.ft.com/content/33efd9ce\-625c\-11e7\-91a7\-502f7ee26895 \|work\= Financial Times \|date\= 14 July 2017 \|access\-date\= 10 April 2019 \|title\= Venezuela's crisis drains its foreign reserves\|quote\= Venezuela's foreign reserves have dropped below $10bn for the first time in 15 years as chronic mismanagement, corruption and subdued oil prices continue to batter what used to be the wealthiest country in South America. The reserves stood at $9\.983bn, according to figures published on Friday from the central bank, representing a 77 per cent decrease since January 2009 when they hit a peak of $43bn.}} and as of March 2019, they had dropped to US$8 billion.{{cite news \|url\= https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/world\-bank\-venezuela\-pay\-conoco\-billion\-61567799 \|title\= World Bank: Venezuela must pay Conoco more than $8 billion \|author\= Lugo, Luis Alonso \|work\= ABC News \|publisher\= Associated Press \|date\= 8 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 6 April 2019}} About two\-thirds of Venezuela's reserves are in gold.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\-04\-10/imf\-freezes\-venezuela\-funds\-as\-members\-debate\-who\-s\-president \|publisher\= Bloomberg \|date\= 10 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 10 April 2019 \|title\= Maduro is cut off from $400 million in cash held at the IMF \|author\= Arrioja, Jose Enrique and Ben Bartenstein \|quote\= The International Monetary Fund suspended the Venezuelan leader's access to almost $400 million of special drawing rights, citing political chaos since National Assembly President Juan Guaido claimed in January that he was the nation's rightful leader, said two people familiar with the matter. Venezuela already whittled its SDR holdings down from almost $1 billion in March 2018\. Almost two\-thirds of Venezuela's $9 billion in foreign reserves are in the form of gold, which has been difficult to liquidate because of U.S. sanctions.}} Part of Venezuela's remaining reserves are held by the [International Monetary Fund](/wiki/International_Monetary_Fund "International Monetary Fund") (IMF) in financial instruments called [SDRs](/wiki/Special_drawing_rights "Special drawing rights"). In 2018, Venezuela had almost $1 billion in IMF SDRs, but it had drawn US$600 million in one year. To access SDR reserves, IMF rules require than a government be recognized by a majority of IMF members, and there is no majority recognition for either man claiming the Venezuelan presidency; the IMF denied Maduro access to the remaining US$400 million—"one of the regime's last remaining sources of cash" according to Bloomberg. The IMF has not recognized Guaidó;{{cite news\|url\=https://uk.reuters.com/article/us\-imf\-worldbank\-venezuela/venezuela\-leadership\-issue\-still\-blocking\-imf\-world\-bank\-aid\-idUKKCN1RN1TH\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190412090428/https://uk.reuters.com/article/us\-imf\-worldbank\-venezuela/venezuela\-leadership\-issue\-still\-blocking\-imf\-world\-bank\-aid\-idUKKCN1RN1TH\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-date\=12 April 2019\|title\=Venezuela leadership issue still blocking IMF, World Bank aid\|date\=11 April 2019\|access\-date\=14 April 2019\|author\=Campos, Rodrigo\|author2\=Lawder, David\|publisher\=\[\[Reuters]] UK}} [Ricardo Hausmann](/wiki/Ricardo_Hausmann "Ricardo Hausmann")—Guaidó's representative recognized by the [Inter\-American Development Bank](/wiki/Inter-American_Development_Bank "Inter-American Development Bank")—said the "IMF is safeguarding the assets until a new government takes over. 'Those funds will be available when this usurpation ends.'" The US has given Guaidó control of "key Venezuelan bank accounts", and has said it will give Guaidó control of US assets once his administration is in power.
The Portuguese bank [Novo Banco](/wiki/Novo_Banco "Novo Banco") stopped Maduro's attempt to transfer over US$1 billion{{cite news \|url\= https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/idLTAKCN1PT210 \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190205084651/https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/idLTAKCN1PT210 \|url\-status\= dead \|archive\-date\= 5 February 2019 \|publisher\= Reuters \|date\= 4 February 2019 \|access\-date\= 10 April 2019 \|title\= Maduro intenta mover hasta 1\.200 mln dlr a Uruguay: líder opositor Venezuela \|language\= es}} through [BANDES](/wiki/BANDES "BANDES") subsidiary, Banco Bandes Uruguay, in early 2019\.{{citation needed\|date\=September 2020}} Over two months later, Maduro responded that Portugal had illegally blocked the money, and asked that it be returned to buy food and medicine.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.ntn24\.com/america\-latina/venezuela/maduro\-pide\-portugal\-devolver\-venezuela\-1700\-millones\-de\-dolares\-para \|publisher\= NTN24 \|date\= 17 April 2019 \|access\-date\= 17 April 2019 \|language\= es \|title\= Maduro pide a Portugal devolver a Venezuela 1\.700 millones de dólares para medicinas \|trans\-title\= Maduro asks Portugal to return to Venezuela $1\.700 million for medicine}}
In 2020, the English High Court ruled in favor of Juan Guaidó in a hearing over whether Guaidó or Nicolás Maduro should control $1 billion of its gold stored in the Bank of London.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-gold\-britain/uk\-court\-recognises\-guaido\-as\-venezuelas\-president\-in\-gold\-dispute\-idUSKBN2431CG\|title\=UK court recognises Guaido as Venezuela's president in gold dispute\|work\=Reuters\|date\= 2 July 2020}}
In 2022, the [United Kingdom Supreme Court](/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_the_United_Kingdom "Supreme Court of the United Kingdom") ruled in favor of Juan Guaidó again regarding the control of the gold stored in the Bank of London.{{Cite web \|title\=Venezuelan opposition government wins another round in U.K. gold dispute \|url\=https://www.law.com/international\-edition/2022/07/29/uk\-high\-court\-again\-favors\-venezuelan\-opposition\-in\-2b\-gold\-case/ \|access\-date\=2022\-08\-10 \|website\=Law.com International \|language\=en\-us}}{{Cite news \|date\=2022\-07\-29 \|title\=Bank of England $1 Billion Gold Cache Not Maduro's, Says Judge \|language\=en \|work\=\[\[Bloomberg News\|Bloomberg]] \|url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022\-07\-29/bank\-of\-england\-1\-billion\-gold\-cache\-not\-maduro\-s\-says\-judge \|access\-date\=2022\-08\-10}}
### Sanctions
{{main\|International sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis\|U.S. sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis}}
[thumb\|400x400px\|A map of countries that have introduced sanctions against Venezuela in response to the outgoing [crisis in Venezuela](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela "Crisis in Venezuela"){{legend\|\#242d7eff\|Venezuela}}{{Legend\|\#11b060ff\|Countries that introduced sanctions}}{{Legend\|darkgreen\|European Union\-countries that have collectively introduced sanctions}}{{Legend\|lime\|Non\-EU European countries that aligned with EU sanctions}}{{legend\|\#ff0000ff\|Countries introducing entry bans on Maduro government officials}}](/wiki/File:Countries_that_sanctioned_Venezuela.svg "Countries that sanctioned Venezuela.svg")
During the [crisis in Venezuela](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela "Crisis in Venezuela"), the United States, Canada, Mexico, Panama, Switzerland individually, and the countries of the European Union collectively, have applied sanctions against people associated with Maduro's administration, including government officials, members of the military and security forces, and private individuals.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.pri.org/stories/2019\-01\-31/us\-sanctions\-squeezed\-venezuelas\-chavismo\-elites\-time\-its\-oil \|work\= Public Radio International \|title\= US sanctions squeezed Venezuela's Chavismo elites. This time, it's oil \|date\= 31 January 2019 \|author\= Vidal, Laura and Jessica Carrillo Mazzali}} As of 27 March 2018, the Washington Office on Latin America said 78 Venezuelans associated with Maduro had been sanctioned by several countries.{{cite news \|url\= http://www.laht.com/article.asp?ArticleId\=2453678\&CategoryId\=10717 \|work\= Latin American Herald Tribune \|date\= 27 March 2018 \|access\-date\= 3 April 2019 \|title\= Panama sanctions Venezuela, including Maduro \& 1st Lady family companies \|author\= Camacho, Carlos \|archive\-date\= 24 February 2021 \|archive\-url\= https://web.archive.org/web/20210224235201/http://www.laht.com/article.asp?ArticleId\=2453678\&CategoryId\=10717 \|url\-status\= dead }}
On 15 January 2019, the National Assembly approved legislation to work with dozens of foreign countries to request that these nations freeze Maduro administration bank accounts.
Through April 2019, the U.S. sanctioned more than 150 companies, vessels and individuals, in addition to revoking visas of 718 individuals associated with Maduro.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.apnews.com/b0c023c3897f402a93f54481d63b175a\|title\=Treasury sanctions Venezuelan business to isolate Maduro\|date\=12 April 2019\|access\-date\=12 April 2019\|publisher\=AP News}}
Christian Krüger Sarmiento, director of [Colombia Migration](/wiki/Colombia_Migration "Colombia Migration"), announced on 30 January 2019 that the Colombian government maintained a list of people banned from entering Colombia or subject to expulsion. As of January 2019, the list had 200 people with a "close relationship and support for the Nicolás Maduro regime", but Krüger said the initial list could increase or decrease.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.eltiempo.com/politica/gobierno/colombia\-prohibe\-el\-ingreso\-al\-pais\-a\-200\-personas\-cercanas\-a\-maduro\-320994\|title\=Maduro encabeza lista de 200 venezolanos que no pueden entrar al país\|date\=30 January 2019\|work\=El Tiempo\|access\-date\=13 April 2019\|language\=es\|trans\-title\=Maduro tops list of 200 Venezuelans who can not enter the country}}
As the humanitarian crisis deepened and expanded, the Trump administration levied more serious economic sanctions against Venezuela. In January 2019, during the presidential crisis, the United States imposed sanctions on the Venezuelan state\-owned oil and natural gas company [PDVSA](/wiki/PDVSA "PDVSA") to pressure Maduro to resign.{{cite news \|author\=Lee, Matthew and Deb Riechmann \|title\=US hits Venezuela with oil sanctions to pressure Maduro \|url\=https://news.yahoo.com/us\-hits\-venezuela\-state\-owned\-oil\-company\-sanctions\-205443848\.html \|access\-date\=12 March 2019 \|agency\=AP \|date\=29 January 2019}}
On 15 April 2019, [Canada](/wiki/Canada "Canada") announced that another round of sanctions on 43 individuals were applied on 12 April based on the *Special Economic Measures Act*.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.international.gc.ca/world\-monde/international\_relations\-relations\_internationales/sanctions/venezuela\_regulations\-reglement\_venezuela.aspx?lang\=eng\|title\=Regulations Amending the Special Economic Measures (Venezuela) Regulations\|date\=12 April 2019\|publisher\=Government of Canada\|access\-date\=15 April 2019}}{{Dead link\|date\=January 2020\|bot\=InternetArchiveBot\|fix\-attempted\=yes}} The government statement said those sanctioned are "high ranking officials of the Maduro regime, regional governors and/or directly implicated in activities undermining democratic institutions".{{cite press release\|url\=https://www.canada.ca/en/global\-affairs/news/2019/04/canada\-imposes\-additional\-sanctions\-on\-the\-maduro\-regime\-in\-venezuela.html?hootPostID\=f7b222671141199fbee13657e3cee3ef\|publisher\=Government of Canada\|date\=15 April 2019\|access\-date\=17 April 2019\|title\=Canada imposes additional sanctions on the Maduro regime in Venezuela}}
The [United States Department of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasury "United States Department of the Treasury") has also placed restrictions on transactions with digital currency emitted by or in the name of the government of Venezuela, referencing "[Petro](/wiki/Petro_%28cryptocurrency%29 "Petro (cryptocurrency)")", a DIGITAL token.{{cite news\|title\=Estados Unidos prohibió las operaciones con el Petro, la criptomoneda venezolana\|url\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2018/03/19/estados\-unidos\-prohibio\-las\-operaciones\-con\-el\-petro\-la\-criptomoneda\-venezolana/\|access\-date\= 2 April 2019\|work\=Infobae\|language\= es \|date\= 19 March 2018}} and on Venezuela's gold industry.{{cite news \|url\= https://www.miamiherald.com/latest\-news/article228119714\.html \|work\= Miami Herald \|title\= Washington hits Venezuela's gold sector with new sanctions \|author\= Wyss, Jim \|date\= 19 March 2019 \|access\-date\= 20 March 2019}} After the detention of Guaidó's chief of staff, [Roberto Marrero](/wiki/Roberto_Marrero "Roberto Marrero"), in March 2019, the US also sanctioned the Venezuelan bank [BANDES](/wiki/BANDES "BANDES") and its subsidiaries.{{cite news\|url\=https://www.france24\.com/en/20190322\-us\-slaps\-sanctions\-venezuelan\-bank\|title\=US slaps sanctions on Venezuelan bank\|date\=22 March 2019\|work\=France 24\|access\-date\=22 March 2019}}
The Treasury Department sanctioned seven additional individuals for their involvement in the [disputed internal parliamentary elections](/wiki/2020_Venezuelan_National_Assembly_Delegated_Committee_election "2020 Venezuelan National Assembly Delegated Committee election") of the National Assembly in January 2020\.{{Cite news\|url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-venezuela\-politics\-usa\-idUSKBN1ZC1LY\|title\=U.S. targets Maduro\-picked top legislator, six others in fresh Venezuelan sanctions\|date\=2020\-01\-13\|work\=Reuters\|access\-date\=2020\-01\-13\|language\=en}}
An October 2020 report published by the [Washington Office on Latin America](/wiki/Washington_Office_on_Latin_America "Washington Office on Latin America") (WOLA) by Venezuelan economist Luis Oliveros found that "while Venezuela's economic crisis began before the first U.S. sectoral sanctions were imposed in 2017, these measures 'directly contributed to its deep decline, and to the further deterioration of the quality of life of Venezuelans' ". The report concluded that economic sanctions "have cost Venezuela's government as much as $31 billion since 2017"{{cite news\|date\=29 October 2020\|title\=New Report Documents How U.S. Sanctions Have Directly Aggravated Venezuela's Economic Crisis\|work\=WOLA\|url\=https://www.wola.org/2020/10/new\-report\-us\-sanctions\-aggravated\-venezuelas\-economic\-crisis/\|access\-date\=13 March 2021}}{{cite news\|last1\=Jakes\|first1\=Lara\|last2\=Kurmanaev\|first2\=Anatoly\|date\=8 March 2021\|title\=Biden Grants Protections for Venezuelans to Remain in U.S.\|work\=The New York Times\|url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/08/us/politics/biden\-venezuela\-maduro.html\|access\-date\=13 March 2021}}
|
[
"Recognition, reactions, and public opinion\n------------------------------------------",
"{{main\\|Responses to the Venezuelan presidential crisis}}\n[thumb\\|350px\\|Nations recognizing presidential legitimacy as of 8 February 2019, during the year of Guaidó's height of recognition.\n{{legend\\|black\\|Venezuela}}\n{{legend\\|\\#999999\\|Neutral countries}}\n{{legend\\|\\#E0E0E0\\|No statement}}\n{{legend\\|green\\|Countries recognizing Guaidó}} \n{{legend\\|\\#55FF55\\|Countries supporting the opposition National Assembly}} \n{{legend\\|red\\|Countries recognizing Maduro}}](/wiki/File:Venezuela_president_recognition_map_2019-.svg \"Venezuela president recognition map 2019-.svg\")\n[thumb\\|350px\\|Nations recognizing presidential legitimacy as of 5 January 2023, before Guaidó's interim government dissolution was made effective:\n{{legend\\|\\#000000\\|Venezuela}}\n{{legend\\|\\#535D6C\\|Neutral}}\n{{legend\\|\\#E0E0E0\\|No statement}}\n{{legend\\|blue\\|Recognize Guaidó}}\n{{legend\\|\\#5599FF\\|Support \\[\\[IV National Assembly of Venezuela\\|opposition National Assembly]]}}\n{{legend\\|\\#ff0000\\|Recognize Maduro}}\n\\|alt\\=](/wiki/File:Venezuela_president_recognition_map.svg \"Venezuela president recognition map.svg\")\nAt his peak, Guaidó's claim as the interim president of Venezuela was recognized 57 countries,{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.venezuelablog.org/interactive\\-map\\-degrees\\-of\\-diplomatic\\-recognition\\-of\\-guaido\\-and\\-maduro/\\|title\\=Interactive Map: Degrees of Diplomatic Recognition of Guaidó and Maduro\\|last1\\=Martinez\\-Gugerli\\|first1\\=Kristen\\|date\\=15 October 2020\\|publisher\\=Venezuela Blog\\|access\\-date\\=14 June 2022}} \"including the US, Canada and most Latin American and European countries\".{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/12/how\\-a\\-nationwide\\-protest\\-against\\-maduro\\-could\\-shape\\-venezuelas\\-future.html\\|title\\=How a nationwide protest against Maduro could shape Venezuela's future\\|author\\=Meredith, Sam\\|date\\= 12 February 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[CNBC]]\\|access\\-date\\=12 February 2019}} Other countries were divided between a neutral position, support for the National Assembly in general without endorsing Guaidó, and support for Maduro's presidency; internationally, support followed traditional geopolitical lines, with Russia, China, Iran, Syria, Cuba, and Turkey supporting Maduro, and the US, Canada, and most of Western Europe supporting Guaidó.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.cnn.com/2019/01/24/americas/russia\\-turkey\\-china\\-support\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-venezuela\\-intl/index.html \\|title\\= 'Pouring gas on fire': Russia slams Trump's stance in Venezuela \\|author\\= Britton, Bianca \\|publisher\\= CNN \\|date\\= 24 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 25 February 2019}}",
"The [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament \"European Parliament\") recognized Guaidó as interim president.{{cite news \\|title\\= EU parliament recognizes Guaido as Venezuelan interim president \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-eu/eu\\-parliament\\-recognizes\\-guaido\\-as\\-venezuelan\\-interim\\-president\\-idUSKCN1PP1HQ \\|access\\-date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\|date\\= 31 January 2019}}{{Cite web\\|date\\=2021\\-01\\-21\\|title\\=MEPs: Juan Guaidó is the legitimate interim President of Venezuela\\|url\\=https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press\\-room/20210114IPR95633/meps\\-juan\\-guaido\\-is\\-the\\-legitimate\\-interim\\-president\\-of\\-venezuela\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-01\\-25\\|website\\=\\[\\[European Parliament]]}} In 2019, the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union \"European Union\") unanimously recognized the National Assembly,{{cite news \\| author\\=Hanke, Jakob and Hans von der Burchard \\|title\\=Brussels caught off\\-guard by Venezuela's political turmoil \\|url\\=https://www.politico.eu/article/brussels\\-caught\\-off\\-guard\\-by\\-venezuelas\\-political\\-turmoil\\-nicolas\\-maduro/ \\|website\\=POLITICO \\|access\\-date\\= 26 January 2019 \\|date\\= 24 January 2019 \\|quote\\=In a declaration published late Wednesday, EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini said the EU ... “fully supports the national assembly as the democratically elected institution whose powers need to be restored and respected.” ... Kocijančič said Mogherini's statement had been “agreed with all 28 member states\" ... }} but Italy dissented on recognizing Guaidó.{{cite news \\|work\\=Reuters \\|title\\= Divided Italy blocks EU statement on recognizing Venezuela's Guaido \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-italy/divided\\-italy\\-blocks\\-eu\\-statement\\-on\\-recognizing\\-venezuelas\\-guaido\\-idUSKCN1PT15G\\|access\\-date\\=8 February 2019\\|date\\=4 February 2019}} In January 2021, the [European Union](/wiki/European_Union \"European Union\") stopped recognizing Guaidó's claim, but still did not recognize Maduro as the legitimate president;{{Cite news \\|date\\=2021\\-01\\-25 \\|title\\=EU states no longer recognise Guaido as Venezuela's interim president \\|language\\=en \\|work\\=Reuters \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-eu\\-idUSKBN29U1A3 \\|access\\-date\\=2023\\-01\\-05}} the [European Parliament](/wiki/European_Parliament \"European Parliament\") reaffirmed its recognition of Guaidó as president, and the EU threatened with further [sanctions](/wiki/International_sanctions_during_the_Venezuelan_crisis \"International sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis\").",
"The OAS approved a resolution on 10 January 2019 \"to not recognize the legitimacy of Nicolás Maduro's new term\".{{cite press release \\|url\\= http://www.oas.org/en/media\\_center/press\\_release.asp?sCodigo\\=E\\-001/19 \\|title\\= OAS Permanent Council Agrees 'to not recognize the legitimacy of Nicolas Maduro's new term' \\|publisher \\= Organization of American States \\|access\\-date\\= 27 January 2019 \\|date\\= 10 January 2019}} In a 24 January special OAS session, sixteen countries including the US recognized Guaidó as interim president, but they did not achieve the majority needed for a resolution.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.eltiempo.com/mundo/eeuu\\-y\\-canada/en\\-la\\-oea\\-no\\-logran\\-mayoria\\-para\\-reconocer\\-a\\-guaido\\-como\\-presidente\\-318494 \\|title\\= En la OEA 16 países reconocen a Guaidó como presidente de Venezuela \\|work\\= El Tiempo \\|access\\-date\\= 27 January 2019 \\| date\\= 25 January 2019 \\|author\\= Gómez Maseri, Sergio \\|language\\=es}} The United Nations called for dialogue and deescalation of tension, but could not agree on any other path for resolving the crisis.{{Cite news \\|url\\= https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/01/1031382 \\|title\\= UN political chief calls for dialogue to ease tensions in Venezuela; Security Council divided over path to end crisis \\|work\\=UN News \\|date\\= 26 January 2019 \\|access\\-date\\=29 January 2019}} Twelve of the fourteen members of the [Lima Group](/wiki/Lima_Group \"Lima Group\") recognize Guaidó;{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.latimes.com/world/la\\-fg\\-venezuela\\-pence\\-20190225\\-story.html \\|work\\= Los Angeles Times \\|author\\= Kraul, Chris \\|date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 25 February 2019 \\|title\\= Pence says U.S. will up the ante as it seeks ouster of Venezuelan President Maduro}} [Beatriz Becerra](/wiki/Beatriz_Becerra \"Beatriz Becerra\")—on the day after she retired as head of the human rights subcommittee for the European Parliament—said that the [International Contact Group](/wiki/International_Conference_on_the_Situation_in_Venezuela \"International Conference on the Situation in Venezuela\"), jointly sponsored by Uruguay and Mexico, had been of no use and \"has been an artifact that has served no purpose since it was created\". She said there had been no progress on the 90\\-day deadline for elections that the group established when it was formed, and she considered that the Contact Group should be terminated and efforts coordinated through the Lima Group.{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/mundo/beatriz\\-becerra\\-grupo\\-contacto\\-servido\\-para\\-nada\\-venezuela\\_279632 \\|publisher\\= El Nacional \\|date\\= 18 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 18 April 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= Beatriz Becerra: El Grupo de Contacto no ha servido para nada en Venezuela \\|trans\\-title\\= Beatriz Becerra: The Contact Group has not served in Venezuela at all}} During the 49th [General Assembly of the Organization of American States](/wiki/General_Assembly_of_the_Organization_of_American_States \"General Assembly of the Organization of American States\"), on 27 June, Guaidó's presidency was recognized by the organization.",
"The Venezuelan Observatory of Social Conflictivity stated that there were on average 69 [protests daily in Venezuela](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_protests \"2019 Venezuelan protests\") during the first three months of 2019, for a total of 6,211 protests, representing a significant increase over previous years (157% of protests for the same period in 2018, and 395% relative to the number in 2017\\).{{cite web \\|url\\= https://www.observatoriodeconflictos.org.ve/tendencias\\-de\\-la\\-conflictividad/6\\-211\\-protestas\\-en\\-venezuela\\-durante\\-el\\-primer\\-trimestre\\-de\\-2019 \\|publisher\\= Venezuelan Observatory of Social Conflict \\|title\\= 6\\.211 protestas en Venezuela durante el primer trimestre de 2019 \\|date\\= 15 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|trans\\-title\\= 6,211 protests in Venezuela during the first quarter of 2019}}",
"Following the failed uprising on 30 April, support for Guaidó declined, attendance to his demonstrations subsided and participants in committees organized by Guaidó stated that there has been little progress.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-analysis\\-idUSKCN1TW3ME\\|title\\=Disappointed Venezuelans lose patience with Guaido as Maduro hangs on\\|date\\=2 July 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]]\\|access\\-date\\=3 July 2019\\|author1\\= Angus Berwick\\|author2\\= Mircely Guanipa}}{{bullet}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://politi.co/2J9PRjd\\|title\\=We are going to take over the premises\\|author\\=Rodríguez, Jesús A\\|date\\=8 May 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[POLITICO Magazine]]\\|access\\-date\\=10 May 2019\\|quote\\=In Venezuela, though the number of people who say they recognize Guaidó as the legitimate president has dwindled to about 50 percent since January, his approval remains much stronger than Maduro's abysmal 4 percent.}}",
"{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.chicagotribune.com/sns\\-tns\\-bc\\-venezuela\\-guaido\\-20190506\\-story.html\\|title\\=As Guaido's popularity in Venezuela begins to dwindle, what's next for the opposition?\\|author\\=Wyss, Jim\\|date\\=6 May 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[Miami Herald]]\\|access\\-date\\=10 May 2019\\|agency\\=\\[\\[Chicago Tribune]]\\|quote\\=... last week's failed military uprising and a spate of violent but fruitless demonstrations have some wondering if Guaido, and the opposition at large, have what it takes to oust Maduro ... A poll released Monday by Caracas\\-based Meganalisis found that Guaido's approval ratings dropped to 50 percent, down from 84 percent in January. He's still far more popular than Maduro whose approval rating is at 4 percent but the precipitous drop can't be ignored ...\\|archive\\-date\\=10 May 2019\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190510035820/https://www.chicagotribune.com/sns\\-tns\\-bc\\-venezuela\\-guaido\\-20190506\\-story.html\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}\n {{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.cisiamo.info/mondo/2019/05/07/venezuela\\-gradimento\\-guaido/\\|title\\=Venezuela, il gradimento di Guaidò cala a picco: meno 34% in soli tre mesi\\|last1\\=Casoni\\|first1\\=Giampiero\\|date\\=7 May 2019\\|work\\=Ci Siamo\\|access\\-date\\=10 May 2019\\|language\\=it\\-IT\\|quote\\=The popularity of Juan Guaidò is in sharp decline and the 'liberator' of Venezuela seems to have exhausted the original propulsive thrust ... At the center of this drop in consensus, especially the failure (because of its failure) of the coup in recent weeks ...\\|archive\\-date\\=10 May 2019\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190510035824/https://www.cisiamo.info/mondo/2019/05/07/venezuela\\-gradimento\\-guaido/\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}* + *Reuters* reported in June that analysts have predicted that Maduro would maintain his position as he gains confidence that his actions against the opposition go \"relatively unpunished\".",
"By the end of 2019, support for Guaidó dropped, with protests organized by his movement resulting with low participation.{{Cite news \\|date\\=2019\\-11\\-23 \\|title\\=After Venezuelan opposition call for mass rallies, street protests underwhelm \\|language\\=en \\|work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKBN1XW209 \\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-12\\-04}} Pollster Datanálisis published figures showing that support for Guaidó decreased from 61% in February to 42% in November 2019\\. According to Jesús Seguías, the head of the Venezuelan analysis firm Datincorp, \"For years Washington and the Venezuelan opposition have said that Nicolás Maduro, and before him Hugo Chávez, were weak and about to fall \\[...] but it's clear that's not the case\".{{Cite web \\|last\\=Wyss \\|first\\=Jim \\|date\\=30 October 2019 \\|title\\=South America's wretched month has been great for one man: Venezuela's Maduro \\|url\\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article236791333\\.html \\|access\\-date\\=4 December 2019 \\|website\\=\\[\\[The Miami Herald]]}} Analyst Carlos Pina stated that as \"\\[t]he military support to President Maduro remains intact\", the opposition will need to \"rethink its strategy\" and that \"Guaidó has also been very limited in suggesting or proposing a strategy that could change the current \\[status quo].\" Into December 2019, Venezuelan pollster Meganálisis surveys showed that 10% of respondents approved of Guaidó, compared to 9% who supported Maduro.{{Cite web \\|last\\=Wyss \\|first\\=Jim \\|date\\=4 December 2019 \\|title\\=Poll shows Venezuela's Guaidó is losing popularity and has sunk to Maduro level \\|url\\=https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\\-world/world/americas/article238040219\\.html \\|access\\-date\\=9 December 2019 \\|website\\=\\[\\[The Miami Herald]]}}",
"As of January 2023, following the opposition vote to dissolve Guaidó's interim government, the United States stopped recognizing Guaidó's presidential claim. A spokesperson for the [White House](/wiki/White_House \"White House\") and [State Department](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State \"United States Department of State\") said that the US \"recognized the National Assembly elected in 2015, which Guaidó had led, as Venezuela's 'only remaining democratically elected institution'.\"",
"### Defections",
"{{main\\|Venezuelan crisis defection}}\nThe *Miami Herald* reported that dozens of arrests were made in anticipation of a military uprising, and Defense Minister [Vladimir Padrino López](/wiki/Vladimir_Padrino_L%C3%B3pez \"Vladimir Padrino López\") ordered a counterintelligence effort to locate conspirators or possible defectors.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation\\-world/world/americas/venezuela/article225548780\\.html \\|work\\= Miami Herald \\|title\\= Venezuela's Nicolás Maduro orders multiple arrests within military to squelch dissent \\|author\\= Maria Delgado, Antonio \\|date\\= 5 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 6 February 2019}} According to *France 24*, Maduro declared \"military deserters who fled to Colombia have become mercenaries\" as part of a \"US\\-backed coup\".{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190206\\-trump\\-discuss\\-venezuela\\-with\\-colombian\\-president\\-white\\-house\\|title\\=Trump to discuss Venezuela with Colombian president: White House\\|date\\=6 February 2019\\|work\\=France 24\\|access\\-date\\=6 February 2019}} Guaidó declared that the opposition had held secret meetings with military officials to discuss the [Amnesty Law](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_Amnesty_Law \"2019 Venezuelan Amnesty Law\").{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/31/world/americas/venezuelan\\-juan\\-guaido\\-military.html\\|title\\=Juan Guaidó says Venezuelan opposition had secret talks with military\\|website\\=The New York Times\\|access\\-date\\=1 February 2019 \\|author\\= Specia, Megan and Nicholas Casey \\|date\\= 31 January 2019}}",
"[Hugo Carvajal](/wiki/Hugo_Carvajal \"Hugo Carvajal\"), the head of [Venezuela's military intelligence](/wiki/Direcci%C3%B3n_de_Inteligencia_Militar \"Dirección de Inteligencia Militar\") for ten years during [Hugo Chávez](/wiki/Hugo_Ch%C3%A1vez \"Hugo Chávez\")'s presidency and \"one of the government's most prominent figures\",{{cite news \\|title\\= Venezuela's Ex\\-Spy Chief Breaks With Maduro: 'You Have Killed Hundreds' \\|author\\= Herrero, Ana Vanessa and Nicholas Casey \\|work\\= New York Times \\|edition\\= Late Edition (East Coast) \\|date\\= 22 February 2019 \\|page\\= A.6 \\|via\\=ProQuest}} Also [available online.](https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/21/world/americas/hugo-carvajal-maduro-venezuela.html) publicly broke with Maduro and endorsed Guaidó as acting president.{{Cite news \\|title\\= Venezuelan Official Breaks With Maduro; Hugo Carvajal, the former military\\-intelligence chief, pledges support for opposition leader Juan Guaidó and says humanitarian aid should be let into the country \\|author\\=Dube, Ryan and Kejal Vyas\\|date\\= 21 February 2019\\|work\\=The Wall Street Journal\\| via\\= ProQuest}} Also available [online.](https://www.wsj.com/articles/venezuelan-official-breaks-with-maduro-11550791292) During the [30 April 2019 uprising attempt](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_uprising_attempt \"2019 Venezuelan uprising attempt\"), Manuel Cristopher Figuera, the Director General of Venezuela's National Intelligence Service, [SEBIN](/wiki/SEBIN \"SEBIN\"), broke with Maduro.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.foxnews.com/world/venezuela\\-secret\\-police\\-head\\-breaks\\-with\\-maduro \\|publisher\\= Fox News \\|date\\= 30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 1 May 2019 \\|title\\= Head of Venezuela's secret police breaks with Maduro \\|author\\= Chamberlain, Samuel}}",
"Certain top military figures recognized Guaidó,{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/02/en\\-video\\-general\\-de\\-division\\-del\\-alto\\-mando\\-militar\\-de\\-la\\-aviacion\\-reconoce\\-a\\-guaido\\-como\\-presidente\\-e/\\|title\\=EN VIDEO: General de división del Alto Mando Militar de la aviación reconoce a Guaidó como presidente (e)\\|date\\=2 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\-ES\\|access\\-date\\=2 February 2019}} \n\\* {{Cite news\\|url\\=http://www.el\\-nacional.com/noticias/politica/general\\-fuerza\\-aerea\\-envio\\-mensaje\\-personal\\-militar\\_269281\\|title\\=General de la Fuerza Aérea envió un mensaje al personal militar\\|date\\=2 February 2019\\|work\\=El Nacional\\|access\\-date\\=3 February 2019\\|language\\=es}} \n\\* {{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.lapatilla.com/2019/02/02/mayor\\-general\\-jorge\\-oropeza\\-se\\-pronuncia\\-contra\\-el\\-regimen\\-de\\-maduro\\-y\\-en\\-respaldo\\-a\\-guaido\\-video/\\|title\\=Mayor General Jorge Oropeza se pronuncia contra el régimen de Maduro y en respaldo a Guaidó (VIDEO)\\|date\\=2 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[La Patilla]]\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=3 February 2019}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.lanacion.com.ar/2222999\\-67\\-militares\\-cambian\\-de\\-bando\\-y\\-un\\-general\\-de\\-peso\\-reconoce\\-a\\-guaido\\-como\\-presidente \\|work\\= La Nacion \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= 67 militares cambian de bando y un general de peso reconoce a Guaidó como presidente \\|author\\= Lozano, Daniel \\|date\\= 23 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 27 February 2019 \\|archive\\-date\\= 28 February 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190228010055/https://www.lanacion.com.ar/2222999\\-67\\-militares\\-cambian\\-de\\-bando\\-y\\-un\\-general\\-de\\-peso\\-reconoce\\-a\\-guaido\\-como\\-presidente \\|url\\-status\\= dead }} \n\\* {{cite news \\|last1\\=Oatis \\|first1\\=Jonathan \\|last2\\=Adler \\|first2\\=Leslie \\|title\\=U.S.\\-sanctioned Venezuelan defects to Colombia, slams Maduro \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-general/u\\-s\\-sanctioned\\-venezuelan\\-defects\\-to\\-colombia\\-slams\\-maduro\\-idUSKCN1QZ1YB?il\\=0 \\|access\\-date\\=19 March 2019 \\|work\\=Reuters \\|date\\=18 March 2019 }} and around 1,400 military personnel have defected to Colombia, but the top military command stays loyal to the government.{{cite news\\|author\\=Guy, Jack\\|url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2019/05/03/americas/venezuela\\-lopez\\-opposition\\-intl/index.html\\|title\\=Venezuela's Leopoldo Lopez says he met generals during house arrest\\|date\\=3 May 2019\\|access\\-date\\=3 May 2019\\|publisher\\=CNN}}",
"Following the 23 January events, some Venezuelan diplomats in the United States supported Guaidó; the majority returned to Venezuela on Maduro's orders.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.elnuevoherald.com/noticias/mundo/america\\-latina/venezuela\\-es/article225227915\\.html\\|title\\=Otra diplomática venezolana en EEUU reconoce a Guaidó como presidente\\|date\\=29 January 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[El Nuevo Herald]]\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=1 February 2019}}",
"### Foreign military involvement",
"{{main\\|Foreign involvement during the Venezuelan presidential crisis}}\n[thumb\\|On 18 February 2019, President [Donald Trump](/wiki/Donald_Trump \"Donald Trump\") advised Venezuelan soldiers to renounce loyalty to Nicolás Maduro.{{cite news \\|title\\=Ditch Maduro or lose everything, Trump tells Venezuelan army \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/18/trump\\-venezuela\\-nicolas\\-maduro\\-juan\\-guaido \\|work\\=The Guardian \\|date\\=18 February 2019}}](/wiki/File:President_Trump_Delivers_Remarks_to_the_Venezuelan_American_Community_%2846422484424%29.jpg \"President Trump Delivers Remarks to the Venezuelan American Community (46422484424).jpg\")",
"In early 2019, with Cuban and Russian\\-backed security forces in the country, United States military involvement became the subject of speculation.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.elmundo.es/internacional/2019/02/04/5c56e08b21efa0380b8b4665\\.html\\|title\\=¿Cómo sería una invasión de Estados Unidos en Venezuela?\\|author\\=Pardo, Paul\\|date\\=4 February 2019\\|website\\=\\[\\[El Mundo (Spain)\\|El Mundo]]\\|language\\=es\\|access\\-date\\=5 February 2019}} Senior U.S. officials have declared that \"all options are on the table\",{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/venezuela/2019\\-04\\-17/will\\-guaido\\-call\\-us\\-military\\-intervention \\|work\\= Foreign Affairs \\|date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|author\\= Fiorella, Giancarlo \\|title\\= Will Guaidó call for U.S. military intervention?}} but they have also said that \"our objective is a [peaceful transfer of power](/wiki/Peaceful_transition_of_power \"Peaceful transition of power\")\".{{Cite news \\|url\\= https://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2019/02/01/john\\_bolton\\_all\\_options\\_are\\_on\\_the\\_table\\_for\\_venezuela\\_transfer\\_of\\_power.html \\|title\\=John Bolton: \"All Options Are On The Table\" For Venezuela; Hope For \"Peaceful\" Transfer Of Power\\|author\\=Hains, Tim\\|date\\=1 February 2019\\|work\\=Real Clear Politics\\|access\\-date\\=5 February 2019}} Colombian guerrillas from [National Liberation Army](/wiki/National_Liberation_Army_%28Colombia%29 \"National Liberation Army (Colombia)\") (ELN) have vowed to defend Maduro, with ELN leaders in Cuba stating that they have been drafting plans to provide military assistance to Maduro.{{cite news \\|author\\=Charles, Mathew \\|title\\=ELN interview: Colombian Marxist guerrillas 'will fight' US troops if they invade Venezuela \\|url\\=https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/02/eln\\-interview\\-colombian\\-marxist\\-guerrillas\\-will\\-fight\\-us\\-troops/ \\|archive\\-url\\=https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220112/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/02/02/eln\\-interview\\-colombian\\-marxist\\-guerrillas\\-will\\-fight\\-us\\-troops/ \\|archive\\-date\\=12 January 2022 \\|url\\-access\\=subscription \\|url\\-status\\=live \\|access\\-date\\=2 February 2019 \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Daily Telegraph]] \\|date\\=2 February 2019}}{{cbignore}}",
"Article 187 of the [Venezuelan Constitution](/wiki/Constitution_of_Venezuela \"Constitution of Venezuela\") provides that \"\\[i]t shall be the function of the National Assembly: (11\\) To authorize the operation of Venezuelan military missions abroad or foreign military missions within the country.\" In every demonstration summoned by Guaidó, there have been numerous signs demanding the application of Article 187, and a March poll showed 87\\.5% support for foreign intervention.{{efn\\|''Foreign Affairs'' states \"this figure is likely inflated—the surveys do not define what a military intervention under 187(11\\) would look like.}}{{cite news\\|author\\=Paola Martínez, Sammy\\|url\\=https://elpitazo.net/reportajes/expertos\\-senalan\\-que\\-la\\-aplicacion\\-del\\-articulo\\-187\\-11\\-no\\-implica\\-una\\-intervencion\\-militar/\\|title\\=Expertos señalan que la aplicación del artículo 187\\.11 no implica una intervención militar\\|date\\=14 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=19 April 2019\\|agency\\=El Pitazo\\|language\\=es\\|trans\\-title\\=Experts point out that the application of article 187\\.11 does not imply a military intervention}} Venezuelan politicians such [María Corina Machado](/wiki/Mar%C3%ADa_Corina_Machado \"María Corina Machado\") and [Antonio Ledezma](/wiki/Antonio_Ledezma \"Antonio Ledezma\"), former mayor of Caracas, have also demanded the application of the article.",
"According to Giancarlo Fiorella, writing in *[Foreign Affairs](/wiki/Foreign_Affairs \"Foreign Affairs\")*, the \"loudest calls for intervention are coming not from the White House and its media mouthpieces but from some members of the Venezuelan opposition and from residents of the country desperate for a solution—any solution—to their years\\-long plight.\" Fiorella states that \"talk of invoking article 187(11\\) has become commonplace\" in Venezuela, adding that \"the push for a military intervention in Venezuela is most intense not among hawks in Washington but inside the country itself.\"",
"Guaidó has said he would call for intervention \"when the time comes\", but in media interviews, he has not stated he supports removing Maduro by force. The National Assembly approved in July 2019 the reincorporation of Venezuela to the [Inter\\-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance](/wiki/Inter-American_Treaty_of_Reciprocal_Assistance \"Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance\"), a mutual defense pact signed in 1947 that has never been enacted and from which Venezuela retired in 2013\\.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-idUSKCN1UI2JX\\|title\\=Venezuela rejoins regional defense treaty but Guaido warns it's no 'magic' solution\\|date\\=23 July 2019\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=23 July 2019}}{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/mundo/noticias\\-america\\-latina\\-48186726\\|title\\=Crisis en Venezuela: qué es el TIAR, el pacto interamericano de defensa mutua al que quiere sumarse la oposición de Venezuela\\|date\\=7 May 2019\\|access\\-date\\=8 May 2019\\|publisher\\=BBC\\|language\\=es\\|trans\\-title\\=Crisis in Venezuela: what is TIAR, the inter\\-American pact of mutual defense which Venezuela's opposition wants to join}} Venezuela's reincorporation to the pact \"can be used to request military assistance against foreign troops inside the country.\"{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.eluniversal.com/politica/39442/an\\-aprueba\\-reintegracion\\-de\\-venezuela\\-al\\-tiar \\|work\\= El Universal \\|date\\= 8 May 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 8 May 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= AN aprueba reintegración de Venezuela al TIAR \\|author\\= Sayago, Gabriel \\|trans\\-title\\= NA approves reintegration of Venezuela to the TIAR}}",
"In a 4 December 2019 interview with [Vox](/wiki/Vox_%28website%29 \"Vox (website)\"), Guaidó stated: \"We sense a firm commitment from the United States. \\[...] I think they're doing everything they could be doing under these circumstances, as are Colombia and Brazil.\"{{Cite web \\|last\\=Ward \\|first\\=Alex \\|date\\=2019\\-12\\-06 \\|title\\=Venezuela's opposition leader failed to depose Maduro. He explains why he's not giving up. \\|url\\=https://www.vox.com/world/2019/12/6/20998988/venezuela\\-juan\\-guaido\\-interview\\-maduro\\-trump \\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-12\\-09 \\|website\\=\\[\\[Vox (website)\\|Vox]] \\|language\\=en}} When asked if he was nearer from removing Maduro from power than in January 2019, Guaidó replied: \"Absolutely. Back then we didn't have multiple countries recognizing and supporting us. \\[...] Today, we have way more tools at our disposal than we did one year ago.\" [Bloomberg News](/wiki/Bloomberg_News \"Bloomberg News\") reported two days later that the [Trump administration](/wiki/Presidency_of_Donald_Trump \"Presidency of Donald Trump\") began to doubt that an opposition led by Guaidó would remove Maduro from office. The United States reportedly had no military option regarding Venezuela, although it began to debate on whether to partner with Russia to encourage Maduro to leave office or to increase pressure on Cuba, which is the Maduro government's main supporter.",
"#### Cuban presence",
"According to professor Erick Langer of [Georgetown University](/wiki/Georgetown_University \"Georgetown University\"), \"Cuba and Russia have already intervened.\" A Cuban military presence of at least 15,000 personnel was in Venezuela in early 2018,{{cite news\\|url\\=http://foreignpolicy.com/2018/02/07/cuba\\-is\\-making\\-the\\-crisis\\-in\\-venezuela\\-worse/\\|title\\=Cuba Is Making the Crisis in Venezuela Worse\\|date\\=7 February 2018\\|work\\=\\[\\[Foreign Policy]]\\|access\\-date\\=8 February 2018}} while estimates ranging from hundreds to thousands of Cuban security forces were reported in 2019\\. In April 2019, Trump threatened a \"full and complete embargo, together with highest\\-level sanctions\" on Cuba if its troops do not cease operations in Venezuela.{{cite news \\|title\\=Trump threatens 'full' embargo on Cuba over Venezuela security support \\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-trump\\-tweet/trump\\-threatens\\-sanctions\\-on\\-cuba\\-over\\-military\\-support\\-for\\-venezuelas\\-maduro\\-idUSKCN1S62PD \\|work\\=Reuters \\|date\\=30 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019}}",
"#### Russian presence",
"Two nuclear weapon\\-capable Russian planes landed in Venezuela in December 2018 in what Reuters called a \"show of support for Maduro's socialist government.\"",
"According to the Kremlin, there are about 100 Russian military personnel in Venezuela \"to repair equipment and provide technical co\\-operation\".{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.perthnow.com.au/news/world/moscow\\-refuses\\-to\\-withdraw\\-troops\\-from\\-venezuela\\-after\\-president\\-trump\\-says\\-get\\-out\\-ng\\-58d41adfdad23c57d38002155b9da4e8\\|title\\=Russian bravado 'may lead to war'\\|date\\=1 April 2019\\|website\\=PerthNow\\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019}} On 23 March 2019, two Russian planes landed in Venezuela carrying 99 troops{{cite news \\|title\\= As Maduro confronts a crisis, Russia's footprint in Venezuela grows: Moscow is seizing an opportunity to stick a finger in Washington's eye, experts say \\|author\\= Zuñiga, Mariana and Anthony Faiola \\|newspaper\\= The Washington Post \\|date\\= 30 March 2019 \\|via\\= ProQuest}} and 35 tonnes of [matériel](/wiki/Materiel \"Materiel\").{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics/russian\\-air\\-force\\-planes\\-land\\-in\\-venezuela\\-carrying\\-troops\\-report\\-idUSKCN1R50NB \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 24 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 24 March 2019 \\|title\\= Russian air force planes land in Venezuela carrying troops: report}} Alexey Seredin from the Russian Embassy in Caracas said the two planes were \"part of an effort to maintain Maduro's defense apparatus, which includes [Sukhoi](/wiki/Sukhoi \"Sukhoi\") fighter jets and anti\\-aircraft systems purchased from Russia.\"",
"National Assembly deputy Williams Dávila said the National Assembly would investigate the \"penetration of foreign forces in Venezuela.\"{{Cite news \\|url\\= https://www.lavanguardia.com/politica/20190324/461210616315/militares\\-rusos\\-copan\\-la\\-escena\\-en\\-jornada\\-libre\\-para\\-maduro\\-y\\-guaido.html\\|title\\= Militares rusos copan la escena en jornada libre para Maduro y Guaidó\\|date\\=24 March 2019\\|work\\=\\[\\[La Vanguardia]]\\|access\\-date\\= 24 March 2019\\|language\\=es \\|trans\\-title\\= Russian military take over the stage on a free day for Maduro and Guaidó \\|author\\=González, Ron}}",
"### Assets and reserves",
"Venezuela's third\\-largest export (after crude oil and refined petroleum products) is gold.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.ccn.com/venezuela\\-maduro\\-340\\-million\\-gold\\-8\\-tons \\|title\\= Maduro scoops 8 Tons of Venezuelan Central Bank gold for illegal $340 million cash swap \\|work\\= CCN Norway \\|author\\= Emen, Mark \\|date\\= 1 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019}} The [World Gold Council](/wiki/World_Gold_Council \"World Gold Council\") reported in January 2019 that Venezuela's foreign\\-held gold reserves had fallen by 69% to US$8\\.4 billion during Maduro's presidency.{{cite news \\|author\\= Millan Lombrana, Laura \\|title\\= In Maduro's Venezuela, even counting gold bars is a challenge \\|work\\= Bloomberg Wire Service \\|date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|via\\= ProQuest}} In 2018, Maduro's government exported $900 million worth of gold out of Venezuela into [Erdoğan](/wiki/Recep_Tayyip_Erdo%C4%9Fan \"Recep Tayyip Erdoğan\")'s Turkey.{{Cite web \\|last\\=Oner \\|first\\=Imdat \\|title\\=Venezuela, Turkey using gold to evade U.S. sanctions \\|website\\=\\[\\[Miami Herald]] \\|url\\=https://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/op\\-ed/article224594180\\.html }}{{cite news \\|title\\=As gold trade booms, Venezuela eyes stronger Turkey ties \\|url\\=https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/gold\\-trade\\-booms\\-venezuela\\-eyes\\-stronger\\-turkey\\-ties\\-190117084423511\\.html \\|work\\=Al\\-Jazeera \\|date\\=17 January 2019\\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019}} In April 2019, Rubio warned the United Arab Emirates and Turkey not be \"accomplices\" in the \"outrageous crime\" of exporting Venezuela's gold.{{cite news \\|title\\=Turkey warned over Venezuela gold trade \\|url\\=https://www.bbc.com/news/world\\-europe\\-47092784 \\|publisher\\=BBC News \\|date\\=2 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 2 May 2019 \\|author\\= Lowen, Mark}}",
"In mid\\-December 2018, a Venezuelan delegation went to London to arrange for the [Bank of England](/wiki/Bank_of_England \"Bank of England\") to return the $1\\.2 billion in gold bullion that Venezuela stores at the bank. Unnamed sources told Bloomberg that the Bank of England declined the transfer due to a request from US Secretary of State Pompeo and National Security Adviser Bolton, who wanted to \"cut off the regime from its overseas assets\".{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\\-01\\-28/u\\-k\\-leaves\\-fate\\-of\\-venezuela\\-s\\-gold\\-up\\-to\\-the\\-bank\\-of\\-england\\|title\\=U.K. Leaves Fate of Venezuela's Gold Up to the Bank of England\\|author\\=Biggs, Stuart and Jess Shankleman\\|date\\=29 January 2019\\|access\\-date\\=19 February 2019\\|publisher\\=Bloomberg\\|quote\\= According to a person familiar with the matter, the BOE declined the withdrawal request after U.S. Secretary of State Michael Pompeo and National Security Adviser John Bolton lobbied their U.K. counterparts to help cut off the regime from its overseas assets.}} In his memoir *[The Room Where It Happened](/wiki/The_Room_Where_It_Happened \"The Room Where It Happened\")*, Bolton said UK Foreign Minister [Jeremy Hunt](/wiki/Jeremy_Hunt \"Jeremy Hunt\") was \"delighted to cooperate on steps they could take, for example freezing Venezuela's gold deposits in the Bank of England, so the regime could not sell the gold to keep itself going\".{{cite book \\|last1\\=Bolton \\|first1\\=John R. \\|title\\=The room where it happened : a White House memoir \\|date\\=2020 \\|location\\=New York \\|isbn\\=9781982148058 \\|pages\\=257 \\|edition\\=First Simon \\& Schuster hardcover \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=QjTMDwAAQBAJ \\|access\\-date\\=14 April 2021}} In an interview with the BBC, Maduro asked Britain to return the gold instead of sending humanitarian aid, saying that the gold was \"legally Venezuela's, it belongs to the [Central Bank of Venezuela](/wiki/Central_Bank_of_Venezuela \"Central Bank of Venezuela\")\" and could be used to solve the country's problems. Guaidó asked the British government to ensure that the Bank of England does not provide the gold to the Maduro government. Maduro also said that the US has frozen $10 billion in Venezuelan accounts through its sanctions.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://news.yahoo.com/maduro\\-calls\\-return\\-venezuelas\\-uk\\-deposited\\-gold\\-165317545\\.html\\|title\\=Maduro calls for return of Venezuela's UK\\-deposited gold\\|date\\=13 February 2019\\|access\\-date\\=19 February 2019\\|publisher\\=Yahoo}}",
"In mid\\-February 2019, a National Assembly legislator Ángel Alvarado said that eight tonnes of gold worth over US$340 million had been taken from the vault while the head of the Central Bank was abroad.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-gold\\-exclusive/exclusive\\-venezuela\\-removed\\-8\\-tons\\-of\\-central\\-bank\\-gold\\-last\\-week\\-legislator\\-idUSKCN1QG2QG \\|title\\= Exclusive: Venezuela removed 8 tons of central bank gold last week – legislator \\|author\\= Pons, Corina and Mayela Armas \\|work\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 27 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019}} In March, Ugandan investigators reported that the gold could have been smuggled into that country.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://af.reuters.com/article/topNews/idAFKCN1QV0TG\\-OZATP \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190402154542/https://af.reuters.com/article/topNews/idAFKCN1QV0TG\\-OZATP \\|url\\-status\\= dead \\|archive\\-date\\= 2 April 2019 \\|date\\= 14 March 2019 \\|title\\= Uganda probes refinery over alleged smuggling of gold \\|author\\= Biryabarema, Elias \\|work\\= Reuters \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019}} Government sources said another eight tonnes of gold was taken out of the Central Bank in the first week of April 2019; the government source said that there were 100 tonnes left. The gold was removed while minimal staff was present and the bank was not fully operational because of the [ongoing, widespread power outages](/wiki/2019_Venezuelan_blackouts \"2019 Venezuelan blackouts\"); the destination of the gold was not known.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-gold/exclusive\\-venezuela\\-removes\\-eight\\-tonnes\\-of\\-gold\\-from\\-central\\-bank\\-sources\\-idUSKCN1RL247 \\|publisher\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 9 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 9 April 2019\\|title\\= Exclusive: Venezuela removes eight tonnes of gold from central bank – sources \\|author\\= Armas, Mayela}}{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.voanoticias.com/a/denuncia\\-que\\-gobierno\\-en\\-disputa\\-de\\-venezuela\\-saca\\-otras\\-ocho\\-toneladas\\-de\\-oro\\-del\\-banco\\-central/4868771\\.html \\|work\\= VOA News \\|publisher\\= Reuters \\|language\\= es \\|date\\= 9 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 9 April 2019 \\|title\\= Denuncian retiro de más lingotes de oro del Banco Central de Venezuela}}",
"In 2009, Venezuela's [foreign reserves](/wiki/Foreign-exchange_reserves \"Foreign-exchange reserves\") peaked at US$43 billion; by July 2017, they had fallen below $10 billion \"for the first time in 15 years\",{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.ft.com/content/33efd9ce\\-625c\\-11e7\\-91a7\\-502f7ee26895 \\|work\\= Financial Times \\|date\\= 14 July 2017 \\|access\\-date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|title\\= Venezuela's crisis drains its foreign reserves\\|quote\\= Venezuela's foreign reserves have dropped below $10bn for the first time in 15 years as chronic mismanagement, corruption and subdued oil prices continue to batter what used to be the wealthiest country in South America. The reserves stood at $9\\.983bn, according to figures published on Friday from the central bank, representing a 77 per cent decrease since January 2009 when they hit a peak of $43bn.}} and as of March 2019, they had dropped to US$8 billion.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/world\\-bank\\-venezuela\\-pay\\-conoco\\-billion\\-61567799 \\|title\\= World Bank: Venezuela must pay Conoco more than $8 billion \\|author\\= Lugo, Luis Alonso \\|work\\= ABC News \\|publisher\\= Associated Press \\|date\\= 8 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 6 April 2019}} About two\\-thirds of Venezuela's reserves are in gold.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019\\-04\\-10/imf\\-freezes\\-venezuela\\-funds\\-as\\-members\\-debate\\-who\\-s\\-president \\|publisher\\= Bloomberg \\|date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|title\\= Maduro is cut off from $400 million in cash held at the IMF \\|author\\= Arrioja, Jose Enrique and Ben Bartenstein \\|quote\\= The International Monetary Fund suspended the Venezuelan leader's access to almost $400 million of special drawing rights, citing political chaos since National Assembly President Juan Guaido claimed in January that he was the nation's rightful leader, said two people familiar with the matter. Venezuela already whittled its SDR holdings down from almost $1 billion in March 2018\\. Almost two\\-thirds of Venezuela's $9 billion in foreign reserves are in the form of gold, which has been difficult to liquidate because of U.S. sanctions.}} Part of Venezuela's remaining reserves are held by the [International Monetary Fund](/wiki/International_Monetary_Fund \"International Monetary Fund\") (IMF) in financial instruments called [SDRs](/wiki/Special_drawing_rights \"Special drawing rights\"). In 2018, Venezuela had almost $1 billion in IMF SDRs, but it had drawn US$600 million in one year. To access SDR reserves, IMF rules require than a government be recognized by a majority of IMF members, and there is no majority recognition for either man claiming the Venezuelan presidency; the IMF denied Maduro access to the remaining US$400 million—\"one of the regime's last remaining sources of cash\" according to Bloomberg. The IMF has not recognized Guaidó;{{cite news\\|url\\=https://uk.reuters.com/article/us\\-imf\\-worldbank\\-venezuela/venezuela\\-leadership\\-issue\\-still\\-blocking\\-imf\\-world\\-bank\\-aid\\-idUKKCN1RN1TH\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190412090428/https://uk.reuters.com/article/us\\-imf\\-worldbank\\-venezuela/venezuela\\-leadership\\-issue\\-still\\-blocking\\-imf\\-world\\-bank\\-aid\\-idUKKCN1RN1TH\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-date\\=12 April 2019\\|title\\=Venezuela leadership issue still blocking IMF, World Bank aid\\|date\\=11 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=14 April 2019\\|author\\=Campos, Rodrigo\\|author2\\=Lawder, David\\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] UK}} [Ricardo Hausmann](/wiki/Ricardo_Hausmann \"Ricardo Hausmann\")—Guaidó's representative recognized by the [Inter\\-American Development Bank](/wiki/Inter-American_Development_Bank \"Inter-American Development Bank\")—said the \"IMF is safeguarding the assets until a new government takes over. 'Those funds will be available when this usurpation ends.'\" The US has given Guaidó control of \"key Venezuelan bank accounts\", and has said it will give Guaidó control of US assets once his administration is in power.",
"The Portuguese bank [Novo Banco](/wiki/Novo_Banco \"Novo Banco\") stopped Maduro's attempt to transfer over US$1 billion{{cite news \\|url\\= https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/idLTAKCN1PT210 \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20190205084651/https://lta.reuters.com/articulo/idLTAKCN1PT210 \\|url\\-status\\= dead \\|archive\\-date\\= 5 February 2019 \\|publisher\\= Reuters \\|date\\= 4 February 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 10 April 2019 \\|title\\= Maduro intenta mover hasta 1\\.200 mln dlr a Uruguay: líder opositor Venezuela \\|language\\= es}} through [BANDES](/wiki/BANDES \"BANDES\") subsidiary, Banco Bandes Uruguay, in early 2019\\.{{citation needed\\|date\\=September 2020}} Over two months later, Maduro responded that Portugal had illegally blocked the money, and asked that it be returned to buy food and medicine.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.ntn24\\.com/america\\-latina/venezuela/maduro\\-pide\\-portugal\\-devolver\\-venezuela\\-1700\\-millones\\-de\\-dolares\\-para \\|publisher\\= NTN24 \\|date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 17 April 2019 \\|language\\= es \\|title\\= Maduro pide a Portugal devolver a Venezuela 1\\.700 millones de dólares para medicinas \\|trans\\-title\\= Maduro asks Portugal to return to Venezuela $1\\.700 million for medicine}}",
"In 2020, the English High Court ruled in favor of Juan Guaidó in a hearing over whether Guaidó or Nicolás Maduro should control $1 billion of its gold stored in the Bank of London.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-gold\\-britain/uk\\-court\\-recognises\\-guaido\\-as\\-venezuelas\\-president\\-in\\-gold\\-dispute\\-idUSKBN2431CG\\|title\\=UK court recognises Guaido as Venezuela's president in gold dispute\\|work\\=Reuters\\|date\\= 2 July 2020}}",
"In 2022, the [United Kingdom Supreme Court](/wiki/Supreme_Court_of_the_United_Kingdom \"Supreme Court of the United Kingdom\") ruled in favor of Juan Guaidó again regarding the control of the gold stored in the Bank of London.{{Cite web \\|title\\=Venezuelan opposition government wins another round in U.K. gold dispute \\|url\\=https://www.law.com/international\\-edition/2022/07/29/uk\\-high\\-court\\-again\\-favors\\-venezuelan\\-opposition\\-in\\-2b\\-gold\\-case/ \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-08\\-10 \\|website\\=Law.com International \\|language\\=en\\-us}}{{Cite news \\|date\\=2022\\-07\\-29 \\|title\\=Bank of England $1 Billion Gold Cache Not Maduro's, Says Judge \\|language\\=en \\|work\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News\\|Bloomberg]] \\|url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022\\-07\\-29/bank\\-of\\-england\\-1\\-billion\\-gold\\-cache\\-not\\-maduro\\-s\\-says\\-judge \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-08\\-10}}",
"### Sanctions",
"{{main\\|International sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis\\|U.S. sanctions during the Venezuelan crisis}}\n[thumb\\|400x400px\\|A map of countries that have introduced sanctions against Venezuela in response to the outgoing [crisis in Venezuela](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela \"Crisis in Venezuela\"){{legend\\|\\#242d7eff\\|Venezuela}}{{Legend\\|\\#11b060ff\\|Countries that introduced sanctions}}{{Legend\\|darkgreen\\|European Union\\-countries that have collectively introduced sanctions}}{{Legend\\|lime\\|Non\\-EU European countries that aligned with EU sanctions}}{{legend\\|\\#ff0000ff\\|Countries introducing entry bans on Maduro government officials}}](/wiki/File:Countries_that_sanctioned_Venezuela.svg \"Countries that sanctioned Venezuela.svg\")",
"During the [crisis in Venezuela](/wiki/Crisis_in_Venezuela \"Crisis in Venezuela\"), the United States, Canada, Mexico, Panama, Switzerland individually, and the countries of the European Union collectively, have applied sanctions against people associated with Maduro's administration, including government officials, members of the military and security forces, and private individuals.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.pri.org/stories/2019\\-01\\-31/us\\-sanctions\\-squeezed\\-venezuelas\\-chavismo\\-elites\\-time\\-its\\-oil \\|work\\= Public Radio International \\|title\\= US sanctions squeezed Venezuela's Chavismo elites. This time, it's oil \\|date\\= 31 January 2019 \\|author\\= Vidal, Laura and Jessica Carrillo Mazzali}} As of 27 March 2018, the Washington Office on Latin America said 78 Venezuelans associated with Maduro had been sanctioned by several countries.{{cite news \\|url\\= http://www.laht.com/article.asp?ArticleId\\=2453678\\&CategoryId\\=10717 \\|work\\= Latin American Herald Tribune \\|date\\= 27 March 2018 \\|access\\-date\\= 3 April 2019 \\|title\\= Panama sanctions Venezuela, including Maduro \\& 1st Lady family companies \\|author\\= Camacho, Carlos \\|archive\\-date\\= 24 February 2021 \\|archive\\-url\\= https://web.archive.org/web/20210224235201/http://www.laht.com/article.asp?ArticleId\\=2453678\\&CategoryId\\=10717 \\|url\\-status\\= dead }}",
"On 15 January 2019, the National Assembly approved legislation to work with dozens of foreign countries to request that these nations freeze Maduro administration bank accounts.",
"Through April 2019, the U.S. sanctioned more than 150 companies, vessels and individuals, in addition to revoking visas of 718 individuals associated with Maduro.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.apnews.com/b0c023c3897f402a93f54481d63b175a\\|title\\=Treasury sanctions Venezuelan business to isolate Maduro\\|date\\=12 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=12 April 2019\\|publisher\\=AP News}}",
"Christian Krüger Sarmiento, director of [Colombia Migration](/wiki/Colombia_Migration \"Colombia Migration\"), announced on 30 January 2019 that the Colombian government maintained a list of people banned from entering Colombia or subject to expulsion. As of January 2019, the list had 200 people with a \"close relationship and support for the Nicolás Maduro regime\", but Krüger said the initial list could increase or decrease.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.eltiempo.com/politica/gobierno/colombia\\-prohibe\\-el\\-ingreso\\-al\\-pais\\-a\\-200\\-personas\\-cercanas\\-a\\-maduro\\-320994\\|title\\=Maduro encabeza lista de 200 venezolanos que no pueden entrar al país\\|date\\=30 January 2019\\|work\\=El Tiempo\\|access\\-date\\=13 April 2019\\|language\\=es\\|trans\\-title\\=Maduro tops list of 200 Venezuelans who can not enter the country}}",
"As the humanitarian crisis deepened and expanded, the Trump administration levied more serious economic sanctions against Venezuela. In January 2019, during the presidential crisis, the United States imposed sanctions on the Venezuelan state\\-owned oil and natural gas company [PDVSA](/wiki/PDVSA \"PDVSA\") to pressure Maduro to resign.{{cite news \\|author\\=Lee, Matthew and Deb Riechmann \\|title\\=US hits Venezuela with oil sanctions to pressure Maduro \\|url\\=https://news.yahoo.com/us\\-hits\\-venezuela\\-state\\-owned\\-oil\\-company\\-sanctions\\-205443848\\.html \\|access\\-date\\=12 March 2019 \\|agency\\=AP \\|date\\=29 January 2019}}",
"On 15 April 2019, [Canada](/wiki/Canada \"Canada\") announced that another round of sanctions on 43 individuals were applied on 12 April based on the *Special Economic Measures Act*.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.international.gc.ca/world\\-monde/international\\_relations\\-relations\\_internationales/sanctions/venezuela\\_regulations\\-reglement\\_venezuela.aspx?lang\\=eng\\|title\\=Regulations Amending the Special Economic Measures (Venezuela) Regulations\\|date\\=12 April 2019\\|publisher\\=Government of Canada\\|access\\-date\\=15 April 2019}}{{Dead link\\|date\\=January 2020\\|bot\\=InternetArchiveBot\\|fix\\-attempted\\=yes}} The government statement said those sanctioned are \"high ranking officials of the Maduro regime, regional governors and/or directly implicated in activities undermining democratic institutions\".{{cite press release\\|url\\=https://www.canada.ca/en/global\\-affairs/news/2019/04/canada\\-imposes\\-additional\\-sanctions\\-on\\-the\\-maduro\\-regime\\-in\\-venezuela.html?hootPostID\\=f7b222671141199fbee13657e3cee3ef\\|publisher\\=Government of Canada\\|date\\=15 April 2019\\|access\\-date\\=17 April 2019\\|title\\=Canada imposes additional sanctions on the Maduro regime in Venezuela}}",
"The [United States Department of the Treasury](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_the_Treasury \"United States Department of the Treasury\") has also placed restrictions on transactions with digital currency emitted by or in the name of the government of Venezuela, referencing \"[Petro](/wiki/Petro_%28cryptocurrency%29 \"Petro (cryptocurrency)\")\", a DIGITAL token.{{cite news\\|title\\=Estados Unidos prohibió las operaciones con el Petro, la criptomoneda venezolana\\|url\\=https://www.infobae.com/america/venezuela/2018/03/19/estados\\-unidos\\-prohibio\\-las\\-operaciones\\-con\\-el\\-petro\\-la\\-criptomoneda\\-venezolana/\\|access\\-date\\= 2 April 2019\\|work\\=Infobae\\|language\\= es \\|date\\= 19 March 2018}} and on Venezuela's gold industry.{{cite news \\|url\\= https://www.miamiherald.com/latest\\-news/article228119714\\.html \\|work\\= Miami Herald \\|title\\= Washington hits Venezuela's gold sector with new sanctions \\|author\\= Wyss, Jim \\|date\\= 19 March 2019 \\|access\\-date\\= 20 March 2019}} After the detention of Guaidó's chief of staff, [Roberto Marrero](/wiki/Roberto_Marrero \"Roberto Marrero\"), in March 2019, the US also sanctioned the Venezuelan bank [BANDES](/wiki/BANDES \"BANDES\") and its subsidiaries.{{cite news\\|url\\=https://www.france24\\.com/en/20190322\\-us\\-slaps\\-sanctions\\-venezuelan\\-bank\\|title\\=US slaps sanctions on Venezuelan bank\\|date\\=22 March 2019\\|work\\=France 24\\|access\\-date\\=22 March 2019}}",
"The Treasury Department sanctioned seven additional individuals for their involvement in the [disputed internal parliamentary elections](/wiki/2020_Venezuelan_National_Assembly_Delegated_Committee_election \"2020 Venezuelan National Assembly Delegated Committee election\") of the National Assembly in January 2020\\.{{Cite news\\|url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-venezuela\\-politics\\-usa\\-idUSKBN1ZC1LY\\|title\\=U.S. targets Maduro\\-picked top legislator, six others in fresh Venezuelan sanctions\\|date\\=2020\\-01\\-13\\|work\\=Reuters\\|access\\-date\\=2020\\-01\\-13\\|language\\=en}}",
"An October 2020 report published by the [Washington Office on Latin America](/wiki/Washington_Office_on_Latin_America \"Washington Office on Latin America\") (WOLA) by Venezuelan economist Luis Oliveros found that \"while Venezuela's economic crisis began before the first U.S. sectoral sanctions were imposed in 2017, these measures 'directly contributed to its deep decline, and to the further deterioration of the quality of life of Venezuelans' \". The report concluded that economic sanctions \"have cost Venezuela's government as much as $31 billion since 2017\"{{cite news\\|date\\=29 October 2020\\|title\\=New Report Documents How U.S. Sanctions Have Directly Aggravated Venezuela's Economic Crisis\\|work\\=WOLA\\|url\\=https://www.wola.org/2020/10/new\\-report\\-us\\-sanctions\\-aggravated\\-venezuelas\\-economic\\-crisis/\\|access\\-date\\=13 March 2021}}{{cite news\\|last1\\=Jakes\\|first1\\=Lara\\|last2\\=Kurmanaev\\|first2\\=Anatoly\\|date\\=8 March 2021\\|title\\=Biden Grants Protections for Venezuelans to Remain in U.S.\\|work\\=The New York Times\\|url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/08/us/politics/biden\\-venezuela\\-maduro.html\\|access\\-date\\=13 March 2021}}",
""
] |
History
-------
The Colorforms concept was developed by Harry and Patricia Kislevitz in 1951,{{cite news \|last\=Hatala \|first\=Greg \|url\= https://www.nj.com/business/2013/09/made\_in\_jersey\_colorforms\_vint.html \|title\=Made in Jersey: Colorforms \- vintage vinyl never goes out of style \|work\=\[\[The Star\-Ledger]] \|date\=September 30, 2013 \|accessdate\=April 21, 2019}} firmly rooted in the [Modernist](/wiki/Modernism "Modernism") design ethos and reflecting the [Color Field](/wiki/Color_Field "Color Field") abstract style prevalent at the time.
The basic concept behind Colorforms is the ability to adhere and reposition abstract and geometric color form shapes on random surfaces to create art. Both recent art students, the couple discovered the idea when they acquired several rolls of flexible paper\-thin colored vinyl used to manufacture plastic pocketbooks and found that it would stick to the glossy paint in their bathroom and allow them to reposition it at will without affecting either surface. Simply cutting shapes out of the material and sticking them to the wall turned out to be amusing enough that they left extra vinyl with a pair of scissors for guests to add to their creations. The positive reactions they got to the project led Harry to believe there was market potential for such a product.
The original Colorforms sets were spiral\-bound booklets hand\-assembled by the husband\-and\-wife team in their New York City apartment. The first 1,000 sets were sold "[on concept](/wiki/Proof_of_concept "Proof of concept")" to the [FAO Schwarz](/wiki/FAO_Schwarz "FAO Schwarz") toy store.{{cite news \|last\=Schmidt \|first\=Gregory \|url\= https://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/12/business/media/toy\-firms\-turn\-to\-nostalgia\-to\-mark\-anniversaries.html \|title\=Toy Companies Turn to Nostalgia to Celebrate Anniversaries \|work\=\[\[The New York Times]] \|date\=July 11, 2011 \|accessdate\=April 21, 2019}} Shallow boxed sets containing screen\-printed, die\-cut pieces, and illustrated backgrounds began appearing soon after. The company used the slogan "It's More Fun To Play The Colorforms Way!" in print ads and television commercials to promote their products. Prominent graphic designer [Paul Rand](/wiki/Paul_Rand "Paul Rand") was commissioned to create the company logo that remains in use today;{{cite news \|last\=Meier \|first\=Allison \|url\= https://hyperallergic.com/199417/the\-man\-who\-harmonized\-form\-function\-and\-friendliness\-in\-corporate\-design/ \|title\=The Man Who Harmonized Form, Function, and Friendliness in Corporate Design \|work\=\[\[Hyperallergic]] \|date\=May 26, 2015 \|accessdate\=April 21, 2019}} he also gave input for a "signature\-edition" playset.
The company rarely employed an in\-house creative staff, relying instead on the Kislevitz' own artistic direction provided to top freelance illustrators for layouts and finished work. Indeed, even the company's [creative director](/wiki/Creative_director "Creative director") from 1965 until 1986, toy designer and inventor [Mel Birnkrant](/wiki/Mel_Birnkrant "Mel Birnkrant") was not a formal Colorforms employee, working instead for a [royalty](/wiki/Royalties "Royalties") percentage.
The defining feature of most Colorforms playsets is their signature plastic "Stick\-Ons" that can be placed and repositioned on top of graphic backgrounds to create endless scenes and scenarios at a child's whim.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"The Colorforms concept was developed by Harry and Patricia Kislevitz in 1951,{{cite news \\|last\\=Hatala \\|first\\=Greg \\|url\\= https://www.nj.com/business/2013/09/made\\_in\\_jersey\\_colorforms\\_vint.html \\|title\\=Made in Jersey: Colorforms \\- vintage vinyl never goes out of style \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Star\\-Ledger]] \\|date\\=September 30, 2013 \\|accessdate\\=April 21, 2019}} firmly rooted in the [Modernist](/wiki/Modernism \"Modernism\") design ethos and reflecting the [Color Field](/wiki/Color_Field \"Color Field\") abstract style prevalent at the time.",
"The basic concept behind Colorforms is the ability to adhere and reposition abstract and geometric color form shapes on random surfaces to create art. Both recent art students, the couple discovered the idea when they acquired several rolls of flexible paper\\-thin colored vinyl used to manufacture plastic pocketbooks and found that it would stick to the glossy paint in their bathroom and allow them to reposition it at will without affecting either surface. Simply cutting shapes out of the material and sticking them to the wall turned out to be amusing enough that they left extra vinyl with a pair of scissors for guests to add to their creations. The positive reactions they got to the project led Harry to believe there was market potential for such a product.",
"The original Colorforms sets were spiral\\-bound booklets hand\\-assembled by the husband\\-and\\-wife team in their New York City apartment. The first 1,000 sets were sold \"[on concept](/wiki/Proof_of_concept \"Proof of concept\")\" to the [FAO Schwarz](/wiki/FAO_Schwarz \"FAO Schwarz\") toy store.{{cite news \\|last\\=Schmidt \\|first\\=Gregory \\|url\\= https://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/12/business/media/toy\\-firms\\-turn\\-to\\-nostalgia\\-to\\-mark\\-anniversaries.html \\|title\\=Toy Companies Turn to Nostalgia to Celebrate Anniversaries \\|work\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\|date\\=July 11, 2011 \\|accessdate\\=April 21, 2019}} Shallow boxed sets containing screen\\-printed, die\\-cut pieces, and illustrated backgrounds began appearing soon after. The company used the slogan \"It's More Fun To Play The Colorforms Way!\" in print ads and television commercials to promote their products. Prominent graphic designer [Paul Rand](/wiki/Paul_Rand \"Paul Rand\") was commissioned to create the company logo that remains in use today;{{cite news \\|last\\=Meier \\|first\\=Allison \\|url\\= https://hyperallergic.com/199417/the\\-man\\-who\\-harmonized\\-form\\-function\\-and\\-friendliness\\-in\\-corporate\\-design/ \\|title\\=The Man Who Harmonized Form, Function, and Friendliness in Corporate Design \\|work\\=\\[\\[Hyperallergic]] \\|date\\=May 26, 2015 \\|accessdate\\=April 21, 2019}} he also gave input for a \"signature\\-edition\" playset.",
"The company rarely employed an in\\-house creative staff, relying instead on the Kislevitz' own artistic direction provided to top freelance illustrators for layouts and finished work. Indeed, even the company's [creative director](/wiki/Creative_director \"Creative director\") from 1965 until 1986, toy designer and inventor [Mel Birnkrant](/wiki/Mel_Birnkrant \"Mel Birnkrant\") was not a formal Colorforms employee, working instead for a [royalty](/wiki/Royalties \"Royalties\") percentage.",
"The defining feature of most Colorforms playsets is their signature plastic \"Stick\\-Ons\" that can be placed and repositioned on top of graphic backgrounds to create endless scenes and scenarios at a child's whim.",
""
] |
History
-------
Wolston House comprises the homestead and garden from the Wolston Estate, a large pastoral property originally established by Dr [Stephen Simpson](/wiki/Stephen_Simpson_%28doctor%29 "Stephen Simpson (doctor)") in 1852 and extended during the 1860s by Matthew Goggs.
[thumb\|left\|Stephen Simpson](/wiki/File:Stephen_Simpson.jpg "Stephen Simpson.jpg")
Stephen Simpson was appointed Commissioner for Crown Lands for the [Moreton Bay](/wiki/Moreton_Bay "Moreton Bay") District in 1842 when the area was first opened up for free settlement following the closure of the penal colony. He was a cultured man, a doctor of medicine, a Justice of the Peace, a Police Magistrate and a founding [Member of the Queensland Legislative Council](/wiki/Member_of_the_Queensland_Legislative_Council "Member of the Queensland Legislative Council") following Separation from [New South Wales](/wiki/New_South_Wales "New South Wales"). His first home in the colony was at [Woogaroo](/wiki/Woogaroo "Woogaroo") (now known as [Goodna](/wiki/Goodna "Goodna")), situated between [Brisbane](/wiki/Brisbane "Brisbane") and [Ipswich](/wiki/Ipswich%2C_Queensland "Ipswich, Queensland") on what was to become the site of the Wolston Park Hospital. In 1851, when the opportunity to buy land in the area arose, he purchased {{convert\|640\|acre\|km2}} to the east of his first house on land overlooking the [Brisbane River](/wiki/Brisbane_River "Brisbane River").
The new property, which included stockyard, stables, outbuildings and a house and garden, was laid out by surveyor [William Pettigrew](/wiki/William_Pettigrew_%28politician%29 "William Pettigrew (politician)") in 1852\. The garden was planned with care. Pettigrew recorded planting fruit trees there in his diary and Simpson was known for his interest in plants and gardening. It is possible that the fig trees at Wolston were planted by Simpson.
The house that Simpson lived in was much smaller than the Wolston homestead that now exists. He had arrived in Brisbane as a recent widower and lived simply, so that a large or formal dwelling would have been unnecessary to him. He constructed a two\-room brick cottage over a sandstone basement. The house was shingled and had a detached kitchen. This cottage now forms the core of the house. The existing sandstone kitchen which adjoins this section may have been added by Simpson before he sold the house in 1860 or it may have been added by Goggs.
After his wife and child died, Simpson had designated his nephew, John Ommaney (for whom [Mount Ommaney](/wiki/Mount_Ommaney%2C_Queensland "Mount Ommaney, Queensland") is named) as his heir. On 11 March 1856 the young man, aged 20, was riding from Wolston station and was thrown from his horse. The horse returned to Wolson and a search was undertaken. Ommaney was found on the ground insensible and, despite medical attention, died. His body was taken by steamer to be buried in the Church of England cemetery at [Paddington](/wiki/Paddington%2C_Queensland "Paddington, Queensland").Queensland Index of Deaths, 1856/B9 John Ommanney{{cite news \|url\=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news\-article20908344 \|title\=MOUNT OMMANEY. \|newspaper\=\[\[The Brisbane Courier]] \|date\=1 April 1925 \|accessdate\=27 December 2014 \|page\=6 \|publisher\=National Library of Australia}}{{cite news \|url\=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news\-article18652826 \|title\=STEAM POSTAL COMMUNICATION. \|newspaper\=\[\[The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser]] \|location\=NSW \|date\=26 March 1856 \|accessdate\=27 December 2014 \|page\=2 \|publisher\=National Library of Australia}} This may have affected Simpson's commitment to remaining in the colony and a few years later, he put the Wolston estate up for sale and returned to England. According to the auction notice which appeared in the [Moreton Bay Courier](/wiki/Moreton_Bay_Courier "Moreton Bay Courier") of 3 January 1860 the estate was by then well established with {{convert\|2000\|acre\|km2}} of fenced land, an extensive garden and orchards and 250 head of horses and 400 of cattle.
Wolston was purchased by Matthew Buscall Goggs in October 1860\. He continued to operate the estate as a cattle and horse breeding station and extended the holding to {{convert\|100000\|acre\|km2}}. Goggs, who was a farmer's son, had emigrated to Australia in 1841 and took up land at [Chinchilla](/wiki/Chinchilla%2C_Queensland "Chinchilla, Queensland") with his first wife. He purchased Wolston following his second marriage to Anne Gedge and they had a family of ten children. Goggs built a sandstone extension to the house in the 1860s to accommodate the needs of his family and in the 1870s a cedar annexe was added containing children's bedrooms. Goggs died in 1882 and was buried in a mausoleum which he had had built in the grounds of the estate. This was damaged in the 1893 floods and the bodies of Goggs and two infants were reburied at [Toowong Cemetery](/wiki/Toowong_Cemetery "Toowong Cemetery").
Following Gogg's death, his eldest son, also named Matthew Buscall, ran the estate until around 1890 when he moved to Brisbane. A Mr Thomas Matthews is recorded in Post Office Directories as having lived at Wolston between 1890 and 1893 and may have leased the property from the Goggs family. Over the years the family had bought and sold land and by 1907 the Wolston property had been reduced to {{convert\|650\|acre\|km2}} of land around Wolston House.
[thumb\|Wolston House, 1890In](/wiki/File:Wolston_House_in_the_suburb_of_Wacol_an_early_stone_farmhouse%2C_1890.jpg "Wolston House in the suburb of Wacol an early stone farmhouse, 1890.jpg") 1907 the Grindle family purchased the property. They built it up and operated a successful dairy, milking 120 cows a day and selling the milk to Brisbane. They covered the shingle roof with corrugated iron and rationalised the spacing of the verandah posts which had previously been irregularly spaced, reflecting the stages in which the house was extended.
In 1956 the estate was purchased by Robert Hurley. By this time the property had become run down and the house was inhabited by three elderly Grindle brothers who were no longer able to run the property. At the time this consisted of {{convert\|117\|acre}} of freehold land in poor condition. The Hurleys built up the property again establishing an intensive dairying business.
In 1960 the [Queensland Department of Agriculture and Stock](/wiki/Queensland_Department_of_Agriculture_and_Stock "Queensland Department of Agriculture and Stock") resumed the property to establish a tick research centre. They demolished the farm outbuildings and intended to demolish the homestead also, however this was saved following an intensive campaign by the [Queensland Women's Historical Association](/wiki/Queensland_Women%27s_Historical_Association "Queensland Women's Historical Association"), the [Royal Historical Society of Queensland](/wiki/Royal_Historical_Society_of_Queensland "Royal Historical Society of Queensland") and the newly formed [National Trust of Queensland](/wiki/National_Trust_of_Queensland "National Trust of Queensland"). In 1965, the house was transferred to the National Trust and became their first property. Sir [Raphael Cilento](/wiki/Raphael_Cilento "Raphael Cilento"), who was to become the second president of the Trust between 1966 and 1971, and the architect [Karl Langer](/wiki/Karl_Langer "Karl Langer"), were prominent in the acquisition of the homestead and in its interpretation.
This interpretation rested on the occupation of the property by Dr Stephen Simpson and so it was decided to demolish the timber section at the rear, which was clearly of a later period. When acquired by the Trust, the house was in poor condition. Along with urgent repairs, extensive reconstruction was also carried out. While reflecting the philosophies of the early 1960s, this approach is not acceptable today. Current conservation philosophy, in line with the recommendations of the [Burra Charter](/wiki/Burra_Charter "Burra Charter"), favours minimal intervention and interpretation embraces the whole life of the house and its setting. Wolston House has now been owned by the Trust for over thirty years, and is still open to the public as a museum, so that the effects of changes in conservation philosophies and methods over this period can be studied.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"Wolston House comprises the homestead and garden from the Wolston Estate, a large pastoral property originally established by Dr [Stephen Simpson](/wiki/Stephen_Simpson_%28doctor%29 \"Stephen Simpson (doctor)\") in 1852 and extended during the 1860s by Matthew Goggs.",
"[thumb\\|left\\|Stephen Simpson](/wiki/File:Stephen_Simpson.jpg \"Stephen Simpson.jpg\")\nStephen Simpson was appointed Commissioner for Crown Lands for the [Moreton Bay](/wiki/Moreton_Bay \"Moreton Bay\") District in 1842 when the area was first opened up for free settlement following the closure of the penal colony. He was a cultured man, a doctor of medicine, a Justice of the Peace, a Police Magistrate and a founding [Member of the Queensland Legislative Council](/wiki/Member_of_the_Queensland_Legislative_Council \"Member of the Queensland Legislative Council\") following Separation from [New South Wales](/wiki/New_South_Wales \"New South Wales\"). His first home in the colony was at [Woogaroo](/wiki/Woogaroo \"Woogaroo\") (now known as [Goodna](/wiki/Goodna \"Goodna\")), situated between [Brisbane](/wiki/Brisbane \"Brisbane\") and [Ipswich](/wiki/Ipswich%2C_Queensland \"Ipswich, Queensland\") on what was to become the site of the Wolston Park Hospital. In 1851, when the opportunity to buy land in the area arose, he purchased {{convert\\|640\\|acre\\|km2}} to the east of his first house on land overlooking the [Brisbane River](/wiki/Brisbane_River \"Brisbane River\").",
"The new property, which included stockyard, stables, outbuildings and a house and garden, was laid out by surveyor [William Pettigrew](/wiki/William_Pettigrew_%28politician%29 \"William Pettigrew (politician)\") in 1852\\. The garden was planned with care. Pettigrew recorded planting fruit trees there in his diary and Simpson was known for his interest in plants and gardening. It is possible that the fig trees at Wolston were planted by Simpson.",
"The house that Simpson lived in was much smaller than the Wolston homestead that now exists. He had arrived in Brisbane as a recent widower and lived simply, so that a large or formal dwelling would have been unnecessary to him. He constructed a two\\-room brick cottage over a sandstone basement. The house was shingled and had a detached kitchen. This cottage now forms the core of the house. The existing sandstone kitchen which adjoins this section may have been added by Simpson before he sold the house in 1860 or it may have been added by Goggs.",
"After his wife and child died, Simpson had designated his nephew, John Ommaney (for whom [Mount Ommaney](/wiki/Mount_Ommaney%2C_Queensland \"Mount Ommaney, Queensland\") is named) as his heir. On 11 March 1856 the young man, aged 20, was riding from Wolston station and was thrown from his horse. The horse returned to Wolson and a search was undertaken. Ommaney was found on the ground insensible and, despite medical attention, died. His body was taken by steamer to be buried in the Church of England cemetery at [Paddington](/wiki/Paddington%2C_Queensland \"Paddington, Queensland\").Queensland Index of Deaths, 1856/B9 John Ommanney{{cite news \\|url\\=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news\\-article20908344 \\|title\\=MOUNT OMMANEY. \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Brisbane Courier]] \\|date\\=1 April 1925 \\|accessdate\\=27 December 2014 \\|page\\=6 \\|publisher\\=National Library of Australia}}{{cite news \\|url\\=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news\\-article18652826 \\|title\\=STEAM POSTAL COMMUNICATION. \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser]] \\|location\\=NSW \\|date\\=26 March 1856 \\|accessdate\\=27 December 2014 \\|page\\=2 \\|publisher\\=National Library of Australia}} This may have affected Simpson's commitment to remaining in the colony and a few years later, he put the Wolston estate up for sale and returned to England. According to the auction notice which appeared in the [Moreton Bay Courier](/wiki/Moreton_Bay_Courier \"Moreton Bay Courier\") of 3 January 1860 the estate was by then well established with {{convert\\|2000\\|acre\\|km2}} of fenced land, an extensive garden and orchards and 250 head of horses and 400 of cattle.",
"Wolston was purchased by Matthew Buscall Goggs in October 1860\\. He continued to operate the estate as a cattle and horse breeding station and extended the holding to {{convert\\|100000\\|acre\\|km2}}. Goggs, who was a farmer's son, had emigrated to Australia in 1841 and took up land at [Chinchilla](/wiki/Chinchilla%2C_Queensland \"Chinchilla, Queensland\") with his first wife. He purchased Wolston following his second marriage to Anne Gedge and they had a family of ten children. Goggs built a sandstone extension to the house in the 1860s to accommodate the needs of his family and in the 1870s a cedar annexe was added containing children's bedrooms. Goggs died in 1882 and was buried in a mausoleum which he had had built in the grounds of the estate. This was damaged in the 1893 floods and the bodies of Goggs and two infants were reburied at [Toowong Cemetery](/wiki/Toowong_Cemetery \"Toowong Cemetery\").",
"Following Gogg's death, his eldest son, also named Matthew Buscall, ran the estate until around 1890 when he moved to Brisbane. A Mr Thomas Matthews is recorded in Post Office Directories as having lived at Wolston between 1890 and 1893 and may have leased the property from the Goggs family. Over the years the family had bought and sold land and by 1907 the Wolston property had been reduced to {{convert\\|650\\|acre\\|km2}} of land around Wolston House.",
"[thumb\\|Wolston House, 1890In](/wiki/File:Wolston_House_in_the_suburb_of_Wacol_an_early_stone_farmhouse%2C_1890.jpg \"Wolston House in the suburb of Wacol an early stone farmhouse, 1890.jpg\") 1907 the Grindle family purchased the property. They built it up and operated a successful dairy, milking 120 cows a day and selling the milk to Brisbane. They covered the shingle roof with corrugated iron and rationalised the spacing of the verandah posts which had previously been irregularly spaced, reflecting the stages in which the house was extended.",
"In 1956 the estate was purchased by Robert Hurley. By this time the property had become run down and the house was inhabited by three elderly Grindle brothers who were no longer able to run the property. At the time this consisted of {{convert\\|117\\|acre}} of freehold land in poor condition. The Hurleys built up the property again establishing an intensive dairying business.",
"In 1960 the [Queensland Department of Agriculture and Stock](/wiki/Queensland_Department_of_Agriculture_and_Stock \"Queensland Department of Agriculture and Stock\") resumed the property to establish a tick research centre. They demolished the farm outbuildings and intended to demolish the homestead also, however this was saved following an intensive campaign by the [Queensland Women's Historical Association](/wiki/Queensland_Women%27s_Historical_Association \"Queensland Women's Historical Association\"), the [Royal Historical Society of Queensland](/wiki/Royal_Historical_Society_of_Queensland \"Royal Historical Society of Queensland\") and the newly formed [National Trust of Queensland](/wiki/National_Trust_of_Queensland \"National Trust of Queensland\"). In 1965, the house was transferred to the National Trust and became their first property. Sir [Raphael Cilento](/wiki/Raphael_Cilento \"Raphael Cilento\"), who was to become the second president of the Trust between 1966 and 1971, and the architect [Karl Langer](/wiki/Karl_Langer \"Karl Langer\"), were prominent in the acquisition of the homestead and in its interpretation.",
"This interpretation rested on the occupation of the property by Dr Stephen Simpson and so it was decided to demolish the timber section at the rear, which was clearly of a later period. When acquired by the Trust, the house was in poor condition. Along with urgent repairs, extensive reconstruction was also carried out. While reflecting the philosophies of the early 1960s, this approach is not acceptable today. Current conservation philosophy, in line with the recommendations of the [Burra Charter](/wiki/Burra_Charter \"Burra Charter\"), favours minimal intervention and interpretation embraces the whole life of the house and its setting. Wolston House has now been owned by the Trust for over thirty years, and is still open to the public as a museum, so that the effects of changes in conservation philosophies and methods over this period can be studied.",
""
] |
Heritage listing
----------------
Wolston House was listed on the [Queensland Heritage Register](/wiki/Queensland_Heritage_Register "Queensland Heritage Register") on 21 October 1992 having satisfied the following criteria.
**The place is important in demonstrating the evolution or pattern of Queensland's history.**
It is also associated with the formation of the National Trust of Queensland and with Sir Raphael Cilento and Karl Langer, who played major roles in the acquisition of Wolston House as the Trust's foundation property.
**The place demonstrates rare, uncommon or endangered aspects of Queensland's cultural heritage.**
Wolston House is a rare surviving early homestead, mainly constructed in the 1860s but incorporating an 1852 cottage. The materials and workmanship which survive from these stages of building illustrate techniques not commonly found in small rural buildings of this period.
**The place is important in demonstrating the principal characteristics of a particular class of cultural places.**
By its form and the lack of a formal entry, the building demonstrates something of the way of life of the first European settlers of the district.
**The place is important because of its aesthetic significance.**
The nature of the building and its relationship with the landscape has considerable aesthetic appeal which is well liked by the community.
**The place has a special association with the life or work of a particular person, group or organisation of importance in Queensland's history.**
The earliest part of the house is associated with Dr Stephen Simpson (1792\-1869\), a man prominent in public life during the first years of Brisbane. It is also associated with the formation of the National Trust of Queensland and with Sir Raphael Cilento and Karl Langer, who played major roles in the acquisition of Wolston House as the Trust's foundation property.
|
[
"Heritage listing\n----------------",
"Wolston House was listed on the [Queensland Heritage Register](/wiki/Queensland_Heritage_Register \"Queensland Heritage Register\") on 21 October 1992 having satisfied the following criteria.",
"**The place is important in demonstrating the evolution or pattern of Queensland's history.**",
"It is also associated with the formation of the National Trust of Queensland and with Sir Raphael Cilento and Karl Langer, who played major roles in the acquisition of Wolston House as the Trust's foundation property.",
"**The place demonstrates rare, uncommon or endangered aspects of Queensland's cultural heritage.**",
"Wolston House is a rare surviving early homestead, mainly constructed in the 1860s but incorporating an 1852 cottage. The materials and workmanship which survive from these stages of building illustrate techniques not commonly found in small rural buildings of this period.",
"**The place is important in demonstrating the principal characteristics of a particular class of cultural places.**",
"By its form and the lack of a formal entry, the building demonstrates something of the way of life of the first European settlers of the district.",
"**The place is important because of its aesthetic significance.**",
"The nature of the building and its relationship with the landscape has considerable aesthetic appeal which is well liked by the community.",
"**The place has a special association with the life or work of a particular person, group or organisation of importance in Queensland's history.**",
"The earliest part of the house is associated with Dr Stephen Simpson (1792\\-1869\\), a man prominent in public life during the first years of Brisbane. It is also associated with the formation of the National Trust of Queensland and with Sir Raphael Cilento and Karl Langer, who played major roles in the acquisition of Wolston House as the Trust's foundation property.",
""
] |
Political career
----------------
Cristina, a member of the [Nationalist Party](/wiki/Nationalist_Party_%28Malta%29 "Nationalist Party (Malta)"), stood as a candidate in the [1996 general election](/wiki/1996_Maltese_general_election "1996 Maltese general election"). She briefly became Mayor of [Swieqi](/wiki/Swieqi "Swieqi") in April 1998 before being elected to Parliament from the 10th District in the [September 1998 general election](/wiki/1999_Maltese_general_election "1999 Maltese general election").
Cristina was re\-elected to Parliament from the 9th District in the [April 2003 general election](/wiki/2003_Maltese_general_election "2003 Maltese general election"). Subsequently she was appointed as Parliamentary Secretary within the Ministry of Social Policy, with a special focus on Social Housing and Gender Equality. She was later appointed as Minister for the Family and Social Solidarity in a cabinet reshuffle on 23 March 2004, with a portfolio including Social Policy, Family Policy, Child Policy, Solidarity Services, Social Security, Social Housing and Equality.
After the Nationalist victory in the [March 2008 general election](/wiki/2008_Maltese_general_election "2008 Maltese general election"), Cristina was appointed as Minister for Education and Culture, replacing the unelected former minister [Louis Galea](/wiki/Louis_Galea "Louis Galea").["New Cabinet sworn in"](http://www.timesofmalta.com/election2008/view/20080312/news/new-cabinet-sworn-in), *Times of Malta*, March 12, 2008\.
Dolores Cristina was Acting President of Malta from March 2013 to June 2022\. She first assumed this role in absence of the [president of Malta](/wiki/President_of_Malta "President of Malta"), [H.E. Dr. George Abela](/wiki/George_Abela "George Abela"), when the latter led a delegation to the [Vatican City](/wiki/Vatican_City "Vatican City"), to assist to the [papal inauguration of Pope Francis](/wiki/Papal_inauguration_of_Pope_Francis "Papal inauguration of Pope Francis").["Dolores Cristina to be acting President next week"](http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130315/local/dolores-cristina-to-be-acting-president-next-week.461621), *Times of Malta*, March 12, 2008\.
On 13 December 2022, at the traditional Republic Day ceremony, Dolores Cristina became the first woman to be appointed Companion of the National Order of Merit, Malta's highest honour.
|
[
"Political career\n----------------",
"Cristina, a member of the [Nationalist Party](/wiki/Nationalist_Party_%28Malta%29 \"Nationalist Party (Malta)\"), stood as a candidate in the [1996 general election](/wiki/1996_Maltese_general_election \"1996 Maltese general election\"). She briefly became Mayor of [Swieqi](/wiki/Swieqi \"Swieqi\") in April 1998 before being elected to Parliament from the 10th District in the [September 1998 general election](/wiki/1999_Maltese_general_election \"1999 Maltese general election\").",
"Cristina was re\\-elected to Parliament from the 9th District in the [April 2003 general election](/wiki/2003_Maltese_general_election \"2003 Maltese general election\"). Subsequently she was appointed as Parliamentary Secretary within the Ministry of Social Policy, with a special focus on Social Housing and Gender Equality. She was later appointed as Minister for the Family and Social Solidarity in a cabinet reshuffle on 23 March 2004, with a portfolio including Social Policy, Family Policy, Child Policy, Solidarity Services, Social Security, Social Housing and Equality.",
"After the Nationalist victory in the [March 2008 general election](/wiki/2008_Maltese_general_election \"2008 Maltese general election\"), Cristina was appointed as Minister for Education and Culture, replacing the unelected former minister [Louis Galea](/wiki/Louis_Galea \"Louis Galea\").[\"New Cabinet sworn in\"](http://www.timesofmalta.com/election2008/view/20080312/news/new-cabinet-sworn-in), *Times of Malta*, March 12, 2008\\.",
"Dolores Cristina was Acting President of Malta from March 2013 to June 2022\\. She first assumed this role in absence of the [president of Malta](/wiki/President_of_Malta \"President of Malta\"), [H.E. Dr. George Abela](/wiki/George_Abela \"George Abela\"), when the latter led a delegation to the [Vatican City](/wiki/Vatican_City \"Vatican City\"), to assist to the [papal inauguration of Pope Francis](/wiki/Papal_inauguration_of_Pope_Francis \"Papal inauguration of Pope Francis\").[\"Dolores Cristina to be acting President next week\"](http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20130315/local/dolores-cristina-to-be-acting-president-next-week.461621), *Times of Malta*, March 12, 2008\\.",
"On 13 December 2022, at the traditional Republic Day ceremony, Dolores Cristina became the first woman to be appointed Companion of the National Order of Merit, Malta's highest honour.",
""
] |
Service history
---------------
### World War II
#### 1944
The destroyer was fitted out at the [New York Navy Yard](/wiki/New_York_Navy_Yard "New York Navy Yard") until 3 March when she got underway for shakedown training in the waters around [Bermuda](/wiki/Bermuda "Bermuda"). *Allen M. Sumner* returned to New York on 8 April and commenced post\-shakedown availability. Repairs were completed on 3 May, and the warship stood out of New York bound for [Norfolk, Virginia](/wiki/Norfolk%2C_Virginia "Norfolk, Virginia"). She arrived there the following day and began two months of duty as a training platform for destroyer nucleus crews. The warship headed north on 5 July and arrived back at New York the next day. Following a five\-week availability at the navy yard there, *Allen M. Sumner* put to sea on 12 August, bound ultimately for the Pacific. Along the way, she conducted antisubmarine warfare and antiair warfare exercises, stopped briefly at Norfolk, and transited the [Panama Canal](/wiki/Panama_Canal "Panama Canal") on 29 August. The destroyer stayed overnight at [San Diego](/wiki/San_Diego "San Diego") on 7 and 8 September before continuing on to Hawaii. She arrived at [Pearl Harbor](/wiki/Pearl_Harbor "Pearl Harbor") on 14 September and began five weeks of exercises in the Hawaiian operating area.
[thumb\|left\|*Allen M. Sumner* in the Atlantic, 26 March 1944](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_in_the_Atlantic_Ocean_on_26_March_1944_%28NH_86272%29.jpg "USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway in the Atlantic Ocean on 26 March 1944 (NH 86272).jpg")
Her stay in Hawaii lasted until 23 October when she steamed out of Pearl Harbor in company with the [battleship](/wiki/Battleship "Battleship") {{USS\|North Carolina\|BB\-55\|2}}, bound for duty in the western Pacific with the [Fast Carrier Task Force](/wiki/Fast_Carrier_Task_Force "Fast Carrier Task Force"). Steaming via [Eniwetok](/wiki/Eniwetok "Eniwetok"), the destroyer entered [Ulithi](/wiki/Ulithi "Ulithi") lagoon on 5 November. *Allen M. Sumner* remained at Ulithi until 19 November at which time she departed the atoll to join Task Group (TG) 38\.4 at sea. After rendezvousing with the carriers, she accompanied them to waters near [Yap Island](/wiki/Yap_Island "Yap Island") whence the [aircraft carriers](/wiki/Aircraft_carrier "Aircraft carrier") launched air strikes on 22 November before reentering Ulithi that same day. The destroyer remained there for 5 days and then returned to sea, bound for [newly invaded Leyte](/wiki/Battle_of_Leyte "Battle of Leyte") in the Philippines. She arrived in [San Pedro Bay](/wiki/San_Pedro_Bay_%28Philippines%29 "San Pedro Bay (Philippines)") on 29 November and began patrolling Leyte Gulf. That duty—punctuated intermittently by air alerts—lasted until the evening of 2 December when *Allen M. Sumner* set course for Ormoc Bay in company with the destroyers {{USS\|Moale\|DD\-693\|2}} and {{USS\|Cooper\|DD\-695\|2}}.
Reports from American aircraft earlier that day had indicated that an enemy reinforcement convoy was entering the bay that night, and the three warships were sent to destroy it. Just after 2300 that night, the destroyers suffered the first of many air attacks when a [Mitsubishi Ki\-46](/wiki/Mitsubishi_Ki-46 "Mitsubishi Ki-46") "Dinah" – a fast, twin\-engine, reconnaissance plane – dropped a bomb which near\-missed *Allen M. Sumner* about {{convert\|30\|yd\|m}} from the ship's starboard bow, pierced her hull with fragments, and started a fire on board. Bomb fragments also wounded one officer and 12 men.
Air attacks continued; but, just after midnight, the three destroyers made surface radar contact on a pair of Japanese destroyers later identified as {{Ship\|Japanese destroyer\|Kuwa\|1944\|2}} and {{Ship\|Japanese destroyer\|Take\|1944\|2}}. Less than 10 minutes into the battle, *Kuwa* succumbed to the combined fire of the two destroyers, and the wrecked and burning mass began to sink. *Take*, however, evened the score just as *Allen M. Sumner* and *Cooper* joined *Moale* in firing on the remaining Japanese warship. One of her torpedoes slammed into *Cooper* amidships, broke that American destroyer's back, and sank her almost immediately. Less than half of *Cooper*{{'}}s crew managed to get off the ship. Most of those were later rescued—but by [PBY Catalinas](/wiki/PBY_Catalina "PBY Catalina") rather than by *Cooper*{{'}}s division mates who were still being subjected to heavy shore battery fire and air raids. Any attempt at rescue by *Allen M. Sumner* and *Moale* would have made them virtually stationary targets. At about 0145 on the 3rd, the two remaining American warships began retirement from [Ormoc Bay](/wiki/Ormoc_Bay "Ormoc Bay") and set a course for San Pedro Bay where they arrived later that day.
*Allen M. Sumner* spent the next nine days in San Pedro Bay undergoing upkeep and repairing the minor damage that she had suffered in the action at Ormoc Bay. Though the area was subjected to intermittent air raids throughout that period, *Allen M. Sumner* recorded only one, long\-range—in excess of {{convert\|9000\|yd\|m}}—approach by an enemy aircraft on 6 December. On 12 December, she departed San Pedro Bay and joined the screen of TG 78\.3, bound for the landings on [Mindoro Island](/wiki/Mindoro_Island "Mindoro Island"). That task group constituted [Rear Admiral](/wiki/Rear_Admiral "Rear Admiral") [Arthur D. Struble](/wiki/Arthur_D._Struble "Arthur D. Struble")'s Mindoro Attack Group. Although the group came under air attack during the transit, *Allen M. Sumner* escaped damage. On 15 December, she moved in with the close covering group to participate in the preinvasion shore bombardment, and the subsequent landings went forward against negligible opposition. Some enemy aircraft attempted to attack the invasion force, and *Allen M. Sumner* joined *Moale* and {{USS\|Ingraham\|DD\-694\|2}} in splashing an enemy light bomber. On the following day, the destroyer departed Mindoro to return to Leyte where she arrived on 18 December. Between 26 and 29 December, the warship escorted a resupply echelon to Mindoro and back to San Pedro Bay.
#### 1945
On 2 January 1945, the destroyer stood out of San Pedro Bay, bound for the [invasion of Luzon](/wiki/Battle_of_Luzon "Battle of Luzon") at [Lingayen Gulf](/wiki/Lingayen_Gulf "Lingayen Gulf") in the screen for the [cruisers](/wiki/Cruiser "Cruiser") and battleships of [Vice Admiral](/wiki/Vice_Admiral "Vice Admiral") [Jesse B. Oldendorf](/wiki/Jesse_B._Oldendorf "Jesse B. Oldendorf")'s Bombardment and Fire Support Group (TG 77\.2\). Early on 6 January, *Allen M. Sumner* moved into Lingayen Gulf to support minesweeping operations. Around noon, her unit came under air attack by *[kamikazes](/wiki/Kamikaze "Kamikaze")*. The first plane retreated in the face of a heavy antiaircraft barrage while the second attacker hovered just out of range as a decoy to mask a run in by a third suicider. The latter plane dove on *Allen M. Sumner* strafing as he came. He swooped in out of the sun on the destroyer's port bow and crashed into her near the after stack and after torpedo mount. The warship lost 14 men killed and 19 injured. Extensive damage required her to retire from the gulf and join the heavy units of TG 77\.2\. Nevertheless, *Allen M. Sumner* remained in action with that unit and supported the Lingayen operation until 14 January.
On that day, she began a long and somewhat circuitous voyage back to the United States for repairs. She arrived at [Manus](/wiki/Manus_Island "Manus Island") in the Admiralties on 18 January and remained there for nine days. She got underway again on 27 January in company with the [escort carrier](/wiki/Escort_carrier "Escort carrier") {{USS\|Kadashan Bay\|CVE\-76\|2}} and, after stopping at [Majuro](/wiki/Majuro "Majuro") en route, arrived in Pearl Harbor on 6 February. She departed [Oahu](/wiki/Oahu "Oahu") the next day and arrived at [Hunters Point](/wiki/Bayview-Hunters_Point%2C_San_Francisco "Bayview-Hunters Point, San Francisco"), California, on 13 February to begin repairs. Her renewal work was completed on 10 April and, four days later, she began duty training prospective destroyer crews along the west coast. Just over three months later, on 17 July, she was relieved of training duty and departed [San Francisco](/wiki/San_Francisco "San Francisco") to return to the western Pacific. The destroyer arrived at Oahu on the 23rd and began three weeks of training operations out of Pearl Harbor.
On 12 August, *Allen M. Summer* stood out of Hawaii to return to the war zone. However, when she was two days out, the Japanese capitulated. Nevertheless, the warship continued her voyage west. Following a two\-day stop at Eniwetok, she got underway again on 21 August and, six\-days later, rendezvoused with TG 38\.3 in Japanese waters. After some three weeks of postwar patrols, first with TG 38\.3 and later with TG 38\.1, the destroyer put into [Tokyo Bay](/wiki/Tokyo_Bay "Tokyo Bay") on 16 September. She remained there only six days before getting underway for the Marianas on 22 August. The ship reached [Saipan](/wiki/Saipan "Saipan") three days later but soon resumed her voyage back to the United States arriving on the west coast in October and assuming duty as a training platform for prospective destroyer crews.
### 1946 to 1952
These operations continued until May 1946 when the destroyer departed the west coast, bound for the Central Pacific to support [Operation Crossroads](/wiki/Operation_Crossroads "Operation Crossroads"), the atomic bomb tests conducted at [Bikini Atoll](/wiki/Bikini_Atoll "Bikini Atoll") in the Marshall Islands. At the conclusion of that assignment late that summer, she returned to her former west coast duty. On 23 February 1947, *Allen M. Sumner* began an extended cruise to the Far East which included visits to Australia, the Marianas, the Philippines, China, and Japan before her return to the west coast for an overhaul and subsequent local operations.
That duty continued until early in 1949 at which time the ship was reassigned to the Atlantic Fleet. She transited the Panama Canal in mid\-April and arrived in [Hampton Roads](/wiki/Hampton_Roads "Hampton Roads"), Virginia, on 20 April. Between the spring of 1949 and the spring of 1953, the destroyer conducted normal peacetime operations out of Norfolk. That routine was broken only by a tour of duty in the Mediterranean Sea with the [6th Fleet](/wiki/United_States_Sixth_Fleet "United States Sixth Fleet") between November 1950 and March 1951\. Otherwise, she cruised along the eastern seaboard and in the West Indies conducting training—particularly in antisubmarine warfare.
### 1953 to 1966
On 24 April 1953, the destroyer stood out of Norfolk, bound for her only assignment in the war zone during the [Korean War](/wiki/Korean_War "Korean War"). Steaming by way of the Mediterranean Sea, the [Suez Canal](/wiki/Suez_Canal "Suez Canal"), and Indian Ocean, *Allen M. Sumner* arrived in [Yokosuka, Japan](/wiki/Yokosuka%2C_Japan "Yokosuka, Japan"), early in June. After 10 days in port, she joined Task Force (TF) 77 in the Sea of Japan and began two months of duty as a plane guard and antisubmarine screening ship for the fast carriers while they sent their aircraft against targets in [North Korea](/wiki/North_Korea "North Korea"). While she was assigned those tasks, the armistice of 27 July ended the Korean War. Following a tour of duty with TF 95 patrolling the southern coast of Korea and a brief stop at Yokosuka, the warship headed back to the United States via the Pacific, the west coast, and the Panama Canal. She arrived back in Norfolk on 27 October.
Over the next eight years, *Allen M. Sumner* alternated east coast and West Indies operations with seven deployments to European waters. During the first two—conducted in the fall of 1954 and the summer of 1955, respectively—she visited northern European waters to participate in exercises with units of other [NATO](/wiki/NATO "NATO") navies. The third European deployment—to the Mediterranean—came in July 1956\. During that four\-month assignment, the [Suez crisis](/wiki/Suez_crisis "Suez crisis") erupted, and *Allen M. Sumner* supported the evacuation of American citizens from Egypt at [Alexandria](/wiki/Alexandria "Alexandria"). On the fourth deployment of the period, she returned to northern European waters in September and October 1957\. In February 1958, she embarked upon another deployment to the Mediterranean that lasted until July. After a period of normal east coast operations, the destroyer once again headed toward the "middle sea" in February 1958\. That tour of duty differed from those preceding in that *Allen M. Sumner* was assigned to independent duty in the [Persian Gulf](/wiki/Persian_Gulf "Persian Gulf") and in the western portion of the Indian Ocean. She returned to the United States on 30 August and began a year of normal operations in the western Atlantic. In September 1960, the warship voyaged to the Mediterranean once more and again served on independent duty in the Persian Gulf and in the western Indian Ocean. She returned to the United States on 19 April 1961 and, on 17 May, began a fleet rehabilitation and modernization overhaul during which her antisubmarine warfare capabilities were improved and updated.
*Allen M. Sumner* completed her overhaul on 2 January 1962 and resumed her schedule of east coast operations alternated with Mediterranean cruises. Between March and September 1962, she served with the 6th Fleet. Soon after her return to American waters, President [John F. Kennedy](/wiki/John_F._Kennedy "John F. Kennedy") declared a "quarantine" of [Cuba](/wiki/Cuba "Cuba") in response to the siting of offensive [Soviet](/wiki/Soviet "Soviet") missiles on that island. *Allen M. Sumner* was one of the first warships to take up station off Cuba in October 1962\. At the successful conclusion of that operation, she resumed normal duty out of [Mayport, Florida](/wiki/Naval_Station_Mayport "Naval Station Mayport"). That employment—including frequent duty as school ship for the Fleet Sonar School—continued through 1963 and into 1964\. In June and July 1964, the destroyer made a brief deployment to the Mediterranean for a midshipman cruise. Upon her return to the western hemisphere, she resumed normal duty out of Mayport. In the spring of 1965, political unrest in the [Dominican Republic](/wiki/Dominican_Republic "Dominican Republic") took her to the waters around that troubled island. Upon concluding that assignment, the destroyer returned to Mayport and resumed operations out of that port. In October, she embarked upon another deployment in the Mediterranean. After a routine tour of duty with the 6th Fleet in the "middle sea," *Allen M. Sumner* returned to Mayport on 8 March 1966 and began 11 months of operations out of her home port which included duty as a support ship for the Gemini 10 space shot in July.
### Vietnam
\[\[File:QH\-50 hovering DD\-692\.jpg\|thumb\|A [Gyrodyne QH\-50 DASH](/wiki/Gyrodyne_QH-50_DASH "Gyrodyne QH-50 DASH") drone hovering over *Allen M. Sumner'''s flight deck, 1969\.]]
On 7 February 1967, the destroyer departed Mayport on her way to her first and only deployment to the [Vietnam](/wiki/Vietnam "Vietnam") war zone. Steaming via the Panama Canal and Hawaii, she arrived in Yokosuka, Japan, on 14 March. Four days later, she got underway for the coast of Vietnam. On her first tour in the Gulf of Tonkin,* Allen M. Sumner *served as "shotgun" (screening ship) for {{USS\|Long Beach\|CGN\-9\|2}} while the nuclear\-powered [guided missile cruiser](/wiki/Guided_missile_cruiser "Guided missile cruiser") served on positive identification radar advisory zone duty in the gulf. She was relieved of that assignment on 5 April to participate in [Operation Seadragon](/wiki/Operation_Seadragon "Operation Seadragon"), the interdiction of communist waterborne logistics operations. That assignment lasted until 11 April, when she joined the screen of the aircraft carrier {{USS\|Hancock\|CVA\-19\|2}} for a voyage to Sasebo, Japan. She remained at Sasebo from 15 to 22 April before heading back to the [Gulf of Tonkin](/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin "Gulf of Tonkin") again in company with* Hancock*. Upon her return to Vietnamese waters,* Allen M. Sumner *moved inshore with the Australian cruiser {{HMAS\|Hobart\|1939\|2}} to resume "Sea\-dragon" duty and, later, to provide shore bombardment support for marines engaged in [Operation Beau Charger](/wiki/Operation_Beau_Charger "Operation Beau Charger"), a combined waterborne and airborne amphibious assault conducted near the demilitarized zone late in May.*
At the end of May, she rejoined the fast carriers on Yankee Station and screened them until 10 June when she resumed "Seadragon" duty. Her work closer to the Vietnam coast lasted for 12 days. On 22 June, she departed Vietnamese waters and set a course for [Kaohsiung](/wiki/Kaohsiung "Kaohsiung"), Taiwan, where she visited from 26 June to 2 July. Departing Kaohsiung on the latter day, Allen M. Sumner *called at [Hong Kong](/wiki/Hong_Kong "Hong Kong") from 7 to 9 July. On 11 July, she returned to the coast of Vietnam and began a nine\-day gunfire support mission. Leaving Vietnamese waters on 20 July, the destroyer made a six\-day stop at [Subic Bay](/wiki/Subic_Bay "Subic Bay") in the Philippines from 22 to 28 July before returning to the gunline from 30 July to 1 August. She then began her voyage back to the United States; stopped at Yokosuka, Hawaii, and [Acapulco](/wiki/Acapulco "Acapulco"), in Mexico; transited the Panama Canal on 7 September, and reached Mayport on 10 September.*
### Post\-Vietnam
[thumb\|*Allen M. Sumner* in 1970\.](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_at_sea_on_28_August_1970_%28NH_96635%29.jpg "USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway at sea on 28 August 1970 (NH 96635).jpg")
The destroyer resumed normal operations out of Mayport in October. Throughout 1968, she cruised the waters of the West Indies, frequently providing support for the encircled naval base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. Similar duty carried her through the first four months of 1969\. In May, she voyaged to England and northern European waters to participate in a NATO review celebrating the 20th anniversary of the alliance. On 22 May, she headed for the Mediterranean and a normal tour of duty with the 6th Fleet. She concluded that assignment at Mayport on 10 October. Following 10 months of normal operations put of Mayport, Allen M. Sumner *embarked upon the final Mediterranean deployment of her career on 27 August 1970\. The destroyer returned to Mayport on 28 February 1971 and briefly resumed normal duty out of her home port. On 1 July 1971, she was reassigned to duty as a Naval Reserve training ship. In mid\-August, she moved to [Baltimore](/wiki/Baltimore "Baltimore"), Maryland, where she began her Naval Reserve training duties. That employment remained her assignment until 15 August 1973 at which time* Allen M. Sumner *was decommissioned at [Philadelphia](/wiki/Philadelphia "Philadelphia"). On 16 October 1974, she was sold to the Union Minerals \& Alloy Corp. for scrapping.*
Awards
------
Allen M. Sumner'' earned two [battle stars](/wiki/Battle_star "Battle star") during World War II, one during the Korean War, and two during the Vietnam War.
|
[
"Service history\n---------------",
"### World War II",
"#### 1944",
"The destroyer was fitted out at the [New York Navy Yard](/wiki/New_York_Navy_Yard \"New York Navy Yard\") until 3 March when she got underway for shakedown training in the waters around [Bermuda](/wiki/Bermuda \"Bermuda\"). *Allen M. Sumner* returned to New York on 8 April and commenced post\\-shakedown availability. Repairs were completed on 3 May, and the warship stood out of New York bound for [Norfolk, Virginia](/wiki/Norfolk%2C_Virginia \"Norfolk, Virginia\"). She arrived there the following day and began two months of duty as a training platform for destroyer nucleus crews. The warship headed north on 5 July and arrived back at New York the next day. Following a five\\-week availability at the navy yard there, *Allen M. Sumner* put to sea on 12 August, bound ultimately for the Pacific. Along the way, she conducted antisubmarine warfare and antiair warfare exercises, stopped briefly at Norfolk, and transited the [Panama Canal](/wiki/Panama_Canal \"Panama Canal\") on 29 August. The destroyer stayed overnight at [San Diego](/wiki/San_Diego \"San Diego\") on 7 and 8 September before continuing on to Hawaii. She arrived at [Pearl Harbor](/wiki/Pearl_Harbor \"Pearl Harbor\") on 14 September and began five weeks of exercises in the Hawaiian operating area.",
"[thumb\\|left\\|*Allen M. Sumner* in the Atlantic, 26 March 1944](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_in_the_Atlantic_Ocean_on_26_March_1944_%28NH_86272%29.jpg \"USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway in the Atlantic Ocean on 26 March 1944 (NH 86272).jpg\")",
"Her stay in Hawaii lasted until 23 October when she steamed out of Pearl Harbor in company with the [battleship](/wiki/Battleship \"Battleship\") {{USS\\|North Carolina\\|BB\\-55\\|2}}, bound for duty in the western Pacific with the [Fast Carrier Task Force](/wiki/Fast_Carrier_Task_Force \"Fast Carrier Task Force\"). Steaming via [Eniwetok](/wiki/Eniwetok \"Eniwetok\"), the destroyer entered [Ulithi](/wiki/Ulithi \"Ulithi\") lagoon on 5 November. *Allen M. Sumner* remained at Ulithi until 19 November at which time she departed the atoll to join Task Group (TG) 38\\.4 at sea. After rendezvousing with the carriers, she accompanied them to waters near [Yap Island](/wiki/Yap_Island \"Yap Island\") whence the [aircraft carriers](/wiki/Aircraft_carrier \"Aircraft carrier\") launched air strikes on 22 November before reentering Ulithi that same day. The destroyer remained there for 5 days and then returned to sea, bound for [newly invaded Leyte](/wiki/Battle_of_Leyte \"Battle of Leyte\") in the Philippines. She arrived in [San Pedro Bay](/wiki/San_Pedro_Bay_%28Philippines%29 \"San Pedro Bay (Philippines)\") on 29 November and began patrolling Leyte Gulf. That duty—punctuated intermittently by air alerts—lasted until the evening of 2 December when *Allen M. Sumner* set course for Ormoc Bay in company with the destroyers {{USS\\|Moale\\|DD\\-693\\|2}} and {{USS\\|Cooper\\|DD\\-695\\|2}}.",
"Reports from American aircraft earlier that day had indicated that an enemy reinforcement convoy was entering the bay that night, and the three warships were sent to destroy it. Just after 2300 that night, the destroyers suffered the first of many air attacks when a [Mitsubishi Ki\\-46](/wiki/Mitsubishi_Ki-46 \"Mitsubishi Ki-46\") \"Dinah\" – a fast, twin\\-engine, reconnaissance plane – dropped a bomb which near\\-missed *Allen M. Sumner* about {{convert\\|30\\|yd\\|m}} from the ship's starboard bow, pierced her hull with fragments, and started a fire on board. Bomb fragments also wounded one officer and 12 men.",
"Air attacks continued; but, just after midnight, the three destroyers made surface radar contact on a pair of Japanese destroyers later identified as {{Ship\\|Japanese destroyer\\|Kuwa\\|1944\\|2}} and {{Ship\\|Japanese destroyer\\|Take\\|1944\\|2}}. Less than 10 minutes into the battle, *Kuwa* succumbed to the combined fire of the two destroyers, and the wrecked and burning mass began to sink. *Take*, however, evened the score just as *Allen M. Sumner* and *Cooper* joined *Moale* in firing on the remaining Japanese warship. One of her torpedoes slammed into *Cooper* amidships, broke that American destroyer's back, and sank her almost immediately. Less than half of *Cooper*{{'}}s crew managed to get off the ship. Most of those were later rescued—but by [PBY Catalinas](/wiki/PBY_Catalina \"PBY Catalina\") rather than by *Cooper*{{'}}s division mates who were still being subjected to heavy shore battery fire and air raids. Any attempt at rescue by *Allen M. Sumner* and *Moale* would have made them virtually stationary targets. At about 0145 on the 3rd, the two remaining American warships began retirement from [Ormoc Bay](/wiki/Ormoc_Bay \"Ormoc Bay\") and set a course for San Pedro Bay where they arrived later that day.",
"*Allen M. Sumner* spent the next nine days in San Pedro Bay undergoing upkeep and repairing the minor damage that she had suffered in the action at Ormoc Bay. Though the area was subjected to intermittent air raids throughout that period, *Allen M. Sumner* recorded only one, long\\-range—in excess of {{convert\\|9000\\|yd\\|m}}—approach by an enemy aircraft on 6 December. On 12 December, she departed San Pedro Bay and joined the screen of TG 78\\.3, bound for the landings on [Mindoro Island](/wiki/Mindoro_Island \"Mindoro Island\"). That task group constituted [Rear Admiral](/wiki/Rear_Admiral \"Rear Admiral\") [Arthur D. Struble](/wiki/Arthur_D._Struble \"Arthur D. Struble\")'s Mindoro Attack Group. Although the group came under air attack during the transit, *Allen M. Sumner* escaped damage. On 15 December, she moved in with the close covering group to participate in the preinvasion shore bombardment, and the subsequent landings went forward against negligible opposition. Some enemy aircraft attempted to attack the invasion force, and *Allen M. Sumner* joined *Moale* and {{USS\\|Ingraham\\|DD\\-694\\|2}} in splashing an enemy light bomber. On the following day, the destroyer departed Mindoro to return to Leyte where she arrived on 18 December. Between 26 and 29 December, the warship escorted a resupply echelon to Mindoro and back to San Pedro Bay.",
"#### 1945",
"On 2 January 1945, the destroyer stood out of San Pedro Bay, bound for the [invasion of Luzon](/wiki/Battle_of_Luzon \"Battle of Luzon\") at [Lingayen Gulf](/wiki/Lingayen_Gulf \"Lingayen Gulf\") in the screen for the [cruisers](/wiki/Cruiser \"Cruiser\") and battleships of [Vice Admiral](/wiki/Vice_Admiral \"Vice Admiral\") [Jesse B. Oldendorf](/wiki/Jesse_B._Oldendorf \"Jesse B. Oldendorf\")'s Bombardment and Fire Support Group (TG 77\\.2\\). Early on 6 January, *Allen M. Sumner* moved into Lingayen Gulf to support minesweeping operations. Around noon, her unit came under air attack by *[kamikazes](/wiki/Kamikaze \"Kamikaze\")*. The first plane retreated in the face of a heavy antiaircraft barrage while the second attacker hovered just out of range as a decoy to mask a run in by a third suicider. The latter plane dove on *Allen M. Sumner* strafing as he came. He swooped in out of the sun on the destroyer's port bow and crashed into her near the after stack and after torpedo mount. The warship lost 14 men killed and 19 injured. Extensive damage required her to retire from the gulf and join the heavy units of TG 77\\.2\\. Nevertheless, *Allen M. Sumner* remained in action with that unit and supported the Lingayen operation until 14 January.",
"On that day, she began a long and somewhat circuitous voyage back to the United States for repairs. She arrived at [Manus](/wiki/Manus_Island \"Manus Island\") in the Admiralties on 18 January and remained there for nine days. She got underway again on 27 January in company with the [escort carrier](/wiki/Escort_carrier \"Escort carrier\") {{USS\\|Kadashan Bay\\|CVE\\-76\\|2}} and, after stopping at [Majuro](/wiki/Majuro \"Majuro\") en route, arrived in Pearl Harbor on 6 February. She departed [Oahu](/wiki/Oahu \"Oahu\") the next day and arrived at [Hunters Point](/wiki/Bayview-Hunters_Point%2C_San_Francisco \"Bayview-Hunters Point, San Francisco\"), California, on 13 February to begin repairs. Her renewal work was completed on 10 April and, four days later, she began duty training prospective destroyer crews along the west coast. Just over three months later, on 17 July, she was relieved of training duty and departed [San Francisco](/wiki/San_Francisco \"San Francisco\") to return to the western Pacific. The destroyer arrived at Oahu on the 23rd and began three weeks of training operations out of Pearl Harbor.",
"On 12 August, *Allen M. Summer* stood out of Hawaii to return to the war zone. However, when she was two days out, the Japanese capitulated. Nevertheless, the warship continued her voyage west. Following a two\\-day stop at Eniwetok, she got underway again on 21 August and, six\\-days later, rendezvoused with TG 38\\.3 in Japanese waters. After some three weeks of postwar patrols, first with TG 38\\.3 and later with TG 38\\.1, the destroyer put into [Tokyo Bay](/wiki/Tokyo_Bay \"Tokyo Bay\") on 16 September. She remained there only six days before getting underway for the Marianas on 22 August. The ship reached [Saipan](/wiki/Saipan \"Saipan\") three days later but soon resumed her voyage back to the United States arriving on the west coast in October and assuming duty as a training platform for prospective destroyer crews.",
"### 1946 to 1952",
"These operations continued until May 1946 when the destroyer departed the west coast, bound for the Central Pacific to support [Operation Crossroads](/wiki/Operation_Crossroads \"Operation Crossroads\"), the atomic bomb tests conducted at [Bikini Atoll](/wiki/Bikini_Atoll \"Bikini Atoll\") in the Marshall Islands. At the conclusion of that assignment late that summer, she returned to her former west coast duty. On 23 February 1947, *Allen M. Sumner* began an extended cruise to the Far East which included visits to Australia, the Marianas, the Philippines, China, and Japan before her return to the west coast for an overhaul and subsequent local operations.",
"That duty continued until early in 1949 at which time the ship was reassigned to the Atlantic Fleet. She transited the Panama Canal in mid\\-April and arrived in [Hampton Roads](/wiki/Hampton_Roads \"Hampton Roads\"), Virginia, on 20 April. Between the spring of 1949 and the spring of 1953, the destroyer conducted normal peacetime operations out of Norfolk. That routine was broken only by a tour of duty in the Mediterranean Sea with the [6th Fleet](/wiki/United_States_Sixth_Fleet \"United States Sixth Fleet\") between November 1950 and March 1951\\. Otherwise, she cruised along the eastern seaboard and in the West Indies conducting training—particularly in antisubmarine warfare.",
"### 1953 to 1966",
"On 24 April 1953, the destroyer stood out of Norfolk, bound for her only assignment in the war zone during the [Korean War](/wiki/Korean_War \"Korean War\"). Steaming by way of the Mediterranean Sea, the [Suez Canal](/wiki/Suez_Canal \"Suez Canal\"), and Indian Ocean, *Allen M. Sumner* arrived in [Yokosuka, Japan](/wiki/Yokosuka%2C_Japan \"Yokosuka, Japan\"), early in June. After 10 days in port, she joined Task Force (TF) 77 in the Sea of Japan and began two months of duty as a plane guard and antisubmarine screening ship for the fast carriers while they sent their aircraft against targets in [North Korea](/wiki/North_Korea \"North Korea\"). While she was assigned those tasks, the armistice of 27 July ended the Korean War. Following a tour of duty with TF 95 patrolling the southern coast of Korea and a brief stop at Yokosuka, the warship headed back to the United States via the Pacific, the west coast, and the Panama Canal. She arrived back in Norfolk on 27 October.",
"Over the next eight years, *Allen M. Sumner* alternated east coast and West Indies operations with seven deployments to European waters. During the first two—conducted in the fall of 1954 and the summer of 1955, respectively—she visited northern European waters to participate in exercises with units of other [NATO](/wiki/NATO \"NATO\") navies. The third European deployment—to the Mediterranean—came in July 1956\\. During that four\\-month assignment, the [Suez crisis](/wiki/Suez_crisis \"Suez crisis\") erupted, and *Allen M. Sumner* supported the evacuation of American citizens from Egypt at [Alexandria](/wiki/Alexandria \"Alexandria\"). On the fourth deployment of the period, she returned to northern European waters in September and October 1957\\. In February 1958, she embarked upon another deployment to the Mediterranean that lasted until July. After a period of normal east coast operations, the destroyer once again headed toward the \"middle sea\" in February 1958\\. That tour of duty differed from those preceding in that *Allen M. Sumner* was assigned to independent duty in the [Persian Gulf](/wiki/Persian_Gulf \"Persian Gulf\") and in the western portion of the Indian Ocean. She returned to the United States on 30 August and began a year of normal operations in the western Atlantic. In September 1960, the warship voyaged to the Mediterranean once more and again served on independent duty in the Persian Gulf and in the western Indian Ocean. She returned to the United States on 19 April 1961 and, on 17 May, began a fleet rehabilitation and modernization overhaul during which her antisubmarine warfare capabilities were improved and updated.",
"*Allen M. Sumner* completed her overhaul on 2 January 1962 and resumed her schedule of east coast operations alternated with Mediterranean cruises. Between March and September 1962, she served with the 6th Fleet. Soon after her return to American waters, President [John F. Kennedy](/wiki/John_F._Kennedy \"John F. Kennedy\") declared a \"quarantine\" of [Cuba](/wiki/Cuba \"Cuba\") in response to the siting of offensive [Soviet](/wiki/Soviet \"Soviet\") missiles on that island. *Allen M. Sumner* was one of the first warships to take up station off Cuba in October 1962\\. At the successful conclusion of that operation, she resumed normal duty out of [Mayport, Florida](/wiki/Naval_Station_Mayport \"Naval Station Mayport\"). That employment—including frequent duty as school ship for the Fleet Sonar School—continued through 1963 and into 1964\\. In June and July 1964, the destroyer made a brief deployment to the Mediterranean for a midshipman cruise. Upon her return to the western hemisphere, she resumed normal duty out of Mayport. In the spring of 1965, political unrest in the [Dominican Republic](/wiki/Dominican_Republic \"Dominican Republic\") took her to the waters around that troubled island. Upon concluding that assignment, the destroyer returned to Mayport and resumed operations out of that port. In October, she embarked upon another deployment in the Mediterranean. After a routine tour of duty with the 6th Fleet in the \"middle sea,\" *Allen M. Sumner* returned to Mayport on 8 March 1966 and began 11 months of operations out of her home port which included duty as a support ship for the Gemini 10 space shot in July.",
"### Vietnam",
"\\[\\[File:QH\\-50 hovering DD\\-692\\.jpg\\|thumb\\|A [Gyrodyne QH\\-50 DASH](/wiki/Gyrodyne_QH-50_DASH \"Gyrodyne QH-50 DASH\") drone hovering over *Allen M. Sumner'''s flight deck, 1969\\.]]\nOn 7 February 1967, the destroyer departed Mayport on her way to her first and only deployment to the [Vietnam](/wiki/Vietnam \"Vietnam\") war zone. Steaming via the Panama Canal and Hawaii, she arrived in Yokosuka, Japan, on 14 March. Four days later, she got underway for the coast of Vietnam. On her first tour in the Gulf of Tonkin,* Allen M. Sumner *served as \"shotgun\" (screening ship) for {{USS\\|Long Beach\\|CGN\\-9\\|2}} while the nuclear\\-powered [guided missile cruiser](/wiki/Guided_missile_cruiser \"Guided missile cruiser\") served on positive identification radar advisory zone duty in the gulf. She was relieved of that assignment on 5 April to participate in [Operation Seadragon](/wiki/Operation_Seadragon \"Operation Seadragon\"), the interdiction of communist waterborne logistics operations. That assignment lasted until 11 April, when she joined the screen of the aircraft carrier {{USS\\|Hancock\\|CVA\\-19\\|2}} for a voyage to Sasebo, Japan. She remained at Sasebo from 15 to 22 April before heading back to the [Gulf of Tonkin](/wiki/Gulf_of_Tonkin \"Gulf of Tonkin\") again in company with* Hancock*. Upon her return to Vietnamese waters,* Allen M. Sumner *moved inshore with the Australian cruiser {{HMAS\\|Hobart\\|1939\\|2}} to resume \"Sea\\-dragon\" duty and, later, to provide shore bombardment support for marines engaged in [Operation Beau Charger](/wiki/Operation_Beau_Charger \"Operation Beau Charger\"), a combined waterborne and airborne amphibious assault conducted near the demilitarized zone late in May.*",
"At the end of May, she rejoined the fast carriers on Yankee Station and screened them until 10 June when she resumed \"Seadragon\" duty. Her work closer to the Vietnam coast lasted for 12 days. On 22 June, she departed Vietnamese waters and set a course for [Kaohsiung](/wiki/Kaohsiung \"Kaohsiung\"), Taiwan, where she visited from 26 June to 2 July. Departing Kaohsiung on the latter day, Allen M. Sumner *called at [Hong Kong](/wiki/Hong_Kong \"Hong Kong\") from 7 to 9 July. On 11 July, she returned to the coast of Vietnam and began a nine\\-day gunfire support mission. Leaving Vietnamese waters on 20 July, the destroyer made a six\\-day stop at [Subic Bay](/wiki/Subic_Bay \"Subic Bay\") in the Philippines from 22 to 28 July before returning to the gunline from 30 July to 1 August. She then began her voyage back to the United States; stopped at Yokosuka, Hawaii, and [Acapulco](/wiki/Acapulco \"Acapulco\"), in Mexico; transited the Panama Canal on 7 September, and reached Mayport on 10 September.*",
"### Post\\-Vietnam",
"[thumb\\|*Allen M. Sumner* in 1970\\.](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_at_sea_on_28_August_1970_%28NH_96635%29.jpg \"USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway at sea on 28 August 1970 (NH 96635).jpg\")\nThe destroyer resumed normal operations out of Mayport in October. Throughout 1968, she cruised the waters of the West Indies, frequently providing support for the encircled naval base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. Similar duty carried her through the first four months of 1969\\. In May, she voyaged to England and northern European waters to participate in a NATO review celebrating the 20th anniversary of the alliance. On 22 May, she headed for the Mediterranean and a normal tour of duty with the 6th Fleet. She concluded that assignment at Mayport on 10 October. Following 10 months of normal operations put of Mayport, Allen M. Sumner *embarked upon the final Mediterranean deployment of her career on 27 August 1970\\. The destroyer returned to Mayport on 28 February 1971 and briefly resumed normal duty out of her home port. On 1 July 1971, she was reassigned to duty as a Naval Reserve training ship. In mid\\-August, she moved to [Baltimore](/wiki/Baltimore \"Baltimore\"), Maryland, where she began her Naval Reserve training duties. That employment remained her assignment until 15 August 1973 at which time* Allen M. Sumner *was decommissioned at [Philadelphia](/wiki/Philadelphia \"Philadelphia\"). On 16 October 1974, she was sold to the Union Minerals \\& Alloy Corp. for scrapping.*",
"Awards\n------",
"Allen M. Sumner'' earned two [battle stars](/wiki/Battle_star \"Battle star\") during World War II, one during the Korean War, and two during the Vietnam War.",
""
] |
### World War II
#### 1944
The destroyer was fitted out at the [New York Navy Yard](/wiki/New_York_Navy_Yard "New York Navy Yard") until 3 March when she got underway for shakedown training in the waters around [Bermuda](/wiki/Bermuda "Bermuda"). *Allen M. Sumner* returned to New York on 8 April and commenced post\-shakedown availability. Repairs were completed on 3 May, and the warship stood out of New York bound for [Norfolk, Virginia](/wiki/Norfolk%2C_Virginia "Norfolk, Virginia"). She arrived there the following day and began two months of duty as a training platform for destroyer nucleus crews. The warship headed north on 5 July and arrived back at New York the next day. Following a five\-week availability at the navy yard there, *Allen M. Sumner* put to sea on 12 August, bound ultimately for the Pacific. Along the way, she conducted antisubmarine warfare and antiair warfare exercises, stopped briefly at Norfolk, and transited the [Panama Canal](/wiki/Panama_Canal "Panama Canal") on 29 August. The destroyer stayed overnight at [San Diego](/wiki/San_Diego "San Diego") on 7 and 8 September before continuing on to Hawaii. She arrived at [Pearl Harbor](/wiki/Pearl_Harbor "Pearl Harbor") on 14 September and began five weeks of exercises in the Hawaiian operating area.
[thumb\|left\|*Allen M. Sumner* in the Atlantic, 26 March 1944](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_in_the_Atlantic_Ocean_on_26_March_1944_%28NH_86272%29.jpg "USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway in the Atlantic Ocean on 26 March 1944 (NH 86272).jpg")
Her stay in Hawaii lasted until 23 October when she steamed out of Pearl Harbor in company with the [battleship](/wiki/Battleship "Battleship") {{USS\|North Carolina\|BB\-55\|2}}, bound for duty in the western Pacific with the [Fast Carrier Task Force](/wiki/Fast_Carrier_Task_Force "Fast Carrier Task Force"). Steaming via [Eniwetok](/wiki/Eniwetok "Eniwetok"), the destroyer entered [Ulithi](/wiki/Ulithi "Ulithi") lagoon on 5 November. *Allen M. Sumner* remained at Ulithi until 19 November at which time she departed the atoll to join Task Group (TG) 38\.4 at sea. After rendezvousing with the carriers, she accompanied them to waters near [Yap Island](/wiki/Yap_Island "Yap Island") whence the [aircraft carriers](/wiki/Aircraft_carrier "Aircraft carrier") launched air strikes on 22 November before reentering Ulithi that same day. The destroyer remained there for 5 days and then returned to sea, bound for [newly invaded Leyte](/wiki/Battle_of_Leyte "Battle of Leyte") in the Philippines. She arrived in [San Pedro Bay](/wiki/San_Pedro_Bay_%28Philippines%29 "San Pedro Bay (Philippines)") on 29 November and began patrolling Leyte Gulf. That duty—punctuated intermittently by air alerts—lasted until the evening of 2 December when *Allen M. Sumner* set course for Ormoc Bay in company with the destroyers {{USS\|Moale\|DD\-693\|2}} and {{USS\|Cooper\|DD\-695\|2}}.
Reports from American aircraft earlier that day had indicated that an enemy reinforcement convoy was entering the bay that night, and the three warships were sent to destroy it. Just after 2300 that night, the destroyers suffered the first of many air attacks when a [Mitsubishi Ki\-46](/wiki/Mitsubishi_Ki-46 "Mitsubishi Ki-46") "Dinah" – a fast, twin\-engine, reconnaissance plane – dropped a bomb which near\-missed *Allen M. Sumner* about {{convert\|30\|yd\|m}} from the ship's starboard bow, pierced her hull with fragments, and started a fire on board. Bomb fragments also wounded one officer and 12 men.
Air attacks continued; but, just after midnight, the three destroyers made surface radar contact on a pair of Japanese destroyers later identified as {{Ship\|Japanese destroyer\|Kuwa\|1944\|2}} and {{Ship\|Japanese destroyer\|Take\|1944\|2}}. Less than 10 minutes into the battle, *Kuwa* succumbed to the combined fire of the two destroyers, and the wrecked and burning mass began to sink. *Take*, however, evened the score just as *Allen M. Sumner* and *Cooper* joined *Moale* in firing on the remaining Japanese warship. One of her torpedoes slammed into *Cooper* amidships, broke that American destroyer's back, and sank her almost immediately. Less than half of *Cooper*{{'}}s crew managed to get off the ship. Most of those were later rescued—but by [PBY Catalinas](/wiki/PBY_Catalina "PBY Catalina") rather than by *Cooper*{{'}}s division mates who were still being subjected to heavy shore battery fire and air raids. Any attempt at rescue by *Allen M. Sumner* and *Moale* would have made them virtually stationary targets. At about 0145 on the 3rd, the two remaining American warships began retirement from [Ormoc Bay](/wiki/Ormoc_Bay "Ormoc Bay") and set a course for San Pedro Bay where they arrived later that day.
*Allen M. Sumner* spent the next nine days in San Pedro Bay undergoing upkeep and repairing the minor damage that she had suffered in the action at Ormoc Bay. Though the area was subjected to intermittent air raids throughout that period, *Allen M. Sumner* recorded only one, long\-range—in excess of {{convert\|9000\|yd\|m}}—approach by an enemy aircraft on 6 December. On 12 December, she departed San Pedro Bay and joined the screen of TG 78\.3, bound for the landings on [Mindoro Island](/wiki/Mindoro_Island "Mindoro Island"). That task group constituted [Rear Admiral](/wiki/Rear_Admiral "Rear Admiral") [Arthur D. Struble](/wiki/Arthur_D._Struble "Arthur D. Struble")'s Mindoro Attack Group. Although the group came under air attack during the transit, *Allen M. Sumner* escaped damage. On 15 December, she moved in with the close covering group to participate in the preinvasion shore bombardment, and the subsequent landings went forward against negligible opposition. Some enemy aircraft attempted to attack the invasion force, and *Allen M. Sumner* joined *Moale* and {{USS\|Ingraham\|DD\-694\|2}} in splashing an enemy light bomber. On the following day, the destroyer departed Mindoro to return to Leyte where she arrived on 18 December. Between 26 and 29 December, the warship escorted a resupply echelon to Mindoro and back to San Pedro Bay.
#### 1945
On 2 January 1945, the destroyer stood out of San Pedro Bay, bound for the [invasion of Luzon](/wiki/Battle_of_Luzon "Battle of Luzon") at [Lingayen Gulf](/wiki/Lingayen_Gulf "Lingayen Gulf") in the screen for the [cruisers](/wiki/Cruiser "Cruiser") and battleships of [Vice Admiral](/wiki/Vice_Admiral "Vice Admiral") [Jesse B. Oldendorf](/wiki/Jesse_B._Oldendorf "Jesse B. Oldendorf")'s Bombardment and Fire Support Group (TG 77\.2\). Early on 6 January, *Allen M. Sumner* moved into Lingayen Gulf to support minesweeping operations. Around noon, her unit came under air attack by *[kamikazes](/wiki/Kamikaze "Kamikaze")*. The first plane retreated in the face of a heavy antiaircraft barrage while the second attacker hovered just out of range as a decoy to mask a run in by a third suicider. The latter plane dove on *Allen M. Sumner* strafing as he came. He swooped in out of the sun on the destroyer's port bow and crashed into her near the after stack and after torpedo mount. The warship lost 14 men killed and 19 injured. Extensive damage required her to retire from the gulf and join the heavy units of TG 77\.2\. Nevertheless, *Allen M. Sumner* remained in action with that unit and supported the Lingayen operation until 14 January.
On that day, she began a long and somewhat circuitous voyage back to the United States for repairs. She arrived at [Manus](/wiki/Manus_Island "Manus Island") in the Admiralties on 18 January and remained there for nine days. She got underway again on 27 January in company with the [escort carrier](/wiki/Escort_carrier "Escort carrier") {{USS\|Kadashan Bay\|CVE\-76\|2}} and, after stopping at [Majuro](/wiki/Majuro "Majuro") en route, arrived in Pearl Harbor on 6 February. She departed [Oahu](/wiki/Oahu "Oahu") the next day and arrived at [Hunters Point](/wiki/Bayview-Hunters_Point%2C_San_Francisco "Bayview-Hunters Point, San Francisco"), California, on 13 February to begin repairs. Her renewal work was completed on 10 April and, four days later, she began duty training prospective destroyer crews along the west coast. Just over three months later, on 17 July, she was relieved of training duty and departed [San Francisco](/wiki/San_Francisco "San Francisco") to return to the western Pacific. The destroyer arrived at Oahu on the 23rd and began three weeks of training operations out of Pearl Harbor.
On 12 August, *Allen M. Summer* stood out of Hawaii to return to the war zone. However, when she was two days out, the Japanese capitulated. Nevertheless, the warship continued her voyage west. Following a two\-day stop at Eniwetok, she got underway again on 21 August and, six\-days later, rendezvoused with TG 38\.3 in Japanese waters. After some three weeks of postwar patrols, first with TG 38\.3 and later with TG 38\.1, the destroyer put into [Tokyo Bay](/wiki/Tokyo_Bay "Tokyo Bay") on 16 September. She remained there only six days before getting underway for the Marianas on 22 August. The ship reached [Saipan](/wiki/Saipan "Saipan") three days later but soon resumed her voyage back to the United States arriving on the west coast in October and assuming duty as a training platform for prospective destroyer crews.
|
[
"### World War II",
"#### 1944",
"The destroyer was fitted out at the [New York Navy Yard](/wiki/New_York_Navy_Yard \"New York Navy Yard\") until 3 March when she got underway for shakedown training in the waters around [Bermuda](/wiki/Bermuda \"Bermuda\"). *Allen M. Sumner* returned to New York on 8 April and commenced post\\-shakedown availability. Repairs were completed on 3 May, and the warship stood out of New York bound for [Norfolk, Virginia](/wiki/Norfolk%2C_Virginia \"Norfolk, Virginia\"). She arrived there the following day and began two months of duty as a training platform for destroyer nucleus crews. The warship headed north on 5 July and arrived back at New York the next day. Following a five\\-week availability at the navy yard there, *Allen M. Sumner* put to sea on 12 August, bound ultimately for the Pacific. Along the way, she conducted antisubmarine warfare and antiair warfare exercises, stopped briefly at Norfolk, and transited the [Panama Canal](/wiki/Panama_Canal \"Panama Canal\") on 29 August. The destroyer stayed overnight at [San Diego](/wiki/San_Diego \"San Diego\") on 7 and 8 September before continuing on to Hawaii. She arrived at [Pearl Harbor](/wiki/Pearl_Harbor \"Pearl Harbor\") on 14 September and began five weeks of exercises in the Hawaiian operating area.",
"[thumb\\|left\\|*Allen M. Sumner* in the Atlantic, 26 March 1944](/wiki/File:USS_Allen_M._Sumner_%28DD-692%29_underway_in_the_Atlantic_Ocean_on_26_March_1944_%28NH_86272%29.jpg \"USS Allen M. Sumner (DD-692) underway in the Atlantic Ocean on 26 March 1944 (NH 86272).jpg\")",
"Her stay in Hawaii lasted until 23 October when she steamed out of Pearl Harbor in company with the [battleship](/wiki/Battleship \"Battleship\") {{USS\\|North Carolina\\|BB\\-55\\|2}}, bound for duty in the western Pacific with the [Fast Carrier Task Force](/wiki/Fast_Carrier_Task_Force \"Fast Carrier Task Force\"). Steaming via [Eniwetok](/wiki/Eniwetok \"Eniwetok\"), the destroyer entered [Ulithi](/wiki/Ulithi \"Ulithi\") lagoon on 5 November. *Allen M. Sumner* remained at Ulithi until 19 November at which time she departed the atoll to join Task Group (TG) 38\\.4 at sea. After rendezvousing with the carriers, she accompanied them to waters near [Yap Island](/wiki/Yap_Island \"Yap Island\") whence the [aircraft carriers](/wiki/Aircraft_carrier \"Aircraft carrier\") launched air strikes on 22 November before reentering Ulithi that same day. The destroyer remained there for 5 days and then returned to sea, bound for [newly invaded Leyte](/wiki/Battle_of_Leyte \"Battle of Leyte\") in the Philippines. She arrived in [San Pedro Bay](/wiki/San_Pedro_Bay_%28Philippines%29 \"San Pedro Bay (Philippines)\") on 29 November and began patrolling Leyte Gulf. That duty—punctuated intermittently by air alerts—lasted until the evening of 2 December when *Allen M. Sumner* set course for Ormoc Bay in company with the destroyers {{USS\\|Moale\\|DD\\-693\\|2}} and {{USS\\|Cooper\\|DD\\-695\\|2}}.",
"Reports from American aircraft earlier that day had indicated that an enemy reinforcement convoy was entering the bay that night, and the three warships were sent to destroy it. Just after 2300 that night, the destroyers suffered the first of many air attacks when a [Mitsubishi Ki\\-46](/wiki/Mitsubishi_Ki-46 \"Mitsubishi Ki-46\") \"Dinah\" – a fast, twin\\-engine, reconnaissance plane – dropped a bomb which near\\-missed *Allen M. Sumner* about {{convert\\|30\\|yd\\|m}} from the ship's starboard bow, pierced her hull with fragments, and started a fire on board. Bomb fragments also wounded one officer and 12 men.",
"Air attacks continued; but, just after midnight, the three destroyers made surface radar contact on a pair of Japanese destroyers later identified as {{Ship\\|Japanese destroyer\\|Kuwa\\|1944\\|2}} and {{Ship\\|Japanese destroyer\\|Take\\|1944\\|2}}. Less than 10 minutes into the battle, *Kuwa* succumbed to the combined fire of the two destroyers, and the wrecked and burning mass began to sink. *Take*, however, evened the score just as *Allen M. Sumner* and *Cooper* joined *Moale* in firing on the remaining Japanese warship. One of her torpedoes slammed into *Cooper* amidships, broke that American destroyer's back, and sank her almost immediately. Less than half of *Cooper*{{'}}s crew managed to get off the ship. Most of those were later rescued—but by [PBY Catalinas](/wiki/PBY_Catalina \"PBY Catalina\") rather than by *Cooper*{{'}}s division mates who were still being subjected to heavy shore battery fire and air raids. Any attempt at rescue by *Allen M. Sumner* and *Moale* would have made them virtually stationary targets. At about 0145 on the 3rd, the two remaining American warships began retirement from [Ormoc Bay](/wiki/Ormoc_Bay \"Ormoc Bay\") and set a course for San Pedro Bay where they arrived later that day.",
"*Allen M. Sumner* spent the next nine days in San Pedro Bay undergoing upkeep and repairing the minor damage that she had suffered in the action at Ormoc Bay. Though the area was subjected to intermittent air raids throughout that period, *Allen M. Sumner* recorded only one, long\\-range—in excess of {{convert\\|9000\\|yd\\|m}}—approach by an enemy aircraft on 6 December. On 12 December, she departed San Pedro Bay and joined the screen of TG 78\\.3, bound for the landings on [Mindoro Island](/wiki/Mindoro_Island \"Mindoro Island\"). That task group constituted [Rear Admiral](/wiki/Rear_Admiral \"Rear Admiral\") [Arthur D. Struble](/wiki/Arthur_D._Struble \"Arthur D. Struble\")'s Mindoro Attack Group. Although the group came under air attack during the transit, *Allen M. Sumner* escaped damage. On 15 December, she moved in with the close covering group to participate in the preinvasion shore bombardment, and the subsequent landings went forward against negligible opposition. Some enemy aircraft attempted to attack the invasion force, and *Allen M. Sumner* joined *Moale* and {{USS\\|Ingraham\\|DD\\-694\\|2}} in splashing an enemy light bomber. On the following day, the destroyer departed Mindoro to return to Leyte where she arrived on 18 December. Between 26 and 29 December, the warship escorted a resupply echelon to Mindoro and back to San Pedro Bay.",
"#### 1945",
"On 2 January 1945, the destroyer stood out of San Pedro Bay, bound for the [invasion of Luzon](/wiki/Battle_of_Luzon \"Battle of Luzon\") at [Lingayen Gulf](/wiki/Lingayen_Gulf \"Lingayen Gulf\") in the screen for the [cruisers](/wiki/Cruiser \"Cruiser\") and battleships of [Vice Admiral](/wiki/Vice_Admiral \"Vice Admiral\") [Jesse B. Oldendorf](/wiki/Jesse_B._Oldendorf \"Jesse B. Oldendorf\")'s Bombardment and Fire Support Group (TG 77\\.2\\). Early on 6 January, *Allen M. Sumner* moved into Lingayen Gulf to support minesweeping operations. Around noon, her unit came under air attack by *[kamikazes](/wiki/Kamikaze \"Kamikaze\")*. The first plane retreated in the face of a heavy antiaircraft barrage while the second attacker hovered just out of range as a decoy to mask a run in by a third suicider. The latter plane dove on *Allen M. Sumner* strafing as he came. He swooped in out of the sun on the destroyer's port bow and crashed into her near the after stack and after torpedo mount. The warship lost 14 men killed and 19 injured. Extensive damage required her to retire from the gulf and join the heavy units of TG 77\\.2\\. Nevertheless, *Allen M. Sumner* remained in action with that unit and supported the Lingayen operation until 14 January.",
"On that day, she began a long and somewhat circuitous voyage back to the United States for repairs. She arrived at [Manus](/wiki/Manus_Island \"Manus Island\") in the Admiralties on 18 January and remained there for nine days. She got underway again on 27 January in company with the [escort carrier](/wiki/Escort_carrier \"Escort carrier\") {{USS\\|Kadashan Bay\\|CVE\\-76\\|2}} and, after stopping at [Majuro](/wiki/Majuro \"Majuro\") en route, arrived in Pearl Harbor on 6 February. She departed [Oahu](/wiki/Oahu \"Oahu\") the next day and arrived at [Hunters Point](/wiki/Bayview-Hunters_Point%2C_San_Francisco \"Bayview-Hunters Point, San Francisco\"), California, on 13 February to begin repairs. Her renewal work was completed on 10 April and, four days later, she began duty training prospective destroyer crews along the west coast. Just over three months later, on 17 July, she was relieved of training duty and departed [San Francisco](/wiki/San_Francisco \"San Francisco\") to return to the western Pacific. The destroyer arrived at Oahu on the 23rd and began three weeks of training operations out of Pearl Harbor.",
"On 12 August, *Allen M. Summer* stood out of Hawaii to return to the war zone. However, when she was two days out, the Japanese capitulated. Nevertheless, the warship continued her voyage west. Following a two\\-day stop at Eniwetok, she got underway again on 21 August and, six\\-days later, rendezvoused with TG 38\\.3 in Japanese waters. After some three weeks of postwar patrols, first with TG 38\\.3 and later with TG 38\\.1, the destroyer put into [Tokyo Bay](/wiki/Tokyo_Bay \"Tokyo Bay\") on 16 September. She remained there only six days before getting underway for the Marianas on 22 August. The ship reached [Saipan](/wiki/Saipan \"Saipan\") three days later but soon resumed her voyage back to the United States arriving on the west coast in October and assuming duty as a training platform for prospective destroyer crews.",
""
] |
History
-------
### Medieval origins
Tver's foundation year is officially accepted to be 1135\.Charter of Tver, Article 1 Originally a minor settlement of [Novgorodian](/wiki/Novgorod_Republic "Novgorod Republic") traders, it passed to the [grand prince of Vladimir](/wiki/Grand_prince_of_Vladimir "Grand prince of Vladimir") in 1209\. In 1246, [Alexander Nevsky](/wiki/Alexander_Nevsky "Alexander Nevsky") granted it to his younger brother [Yaroslav Yaroslavich](/wiki/Yaroslav_of_Tver "Yaroslav of Tver") ({{died in\|1271}}), from whom a dynasty of local princes descended. Four of them were killed by the [Golden Horde](/wiki/Golden_Horde "Golden Horde") and were proclaimed saints by the [Russian Orthodox church](/wiki/Russian_Orthodox_church "Russian Orthodox church").
Formerly a land of woods and bogs, the [Principality of Tver](/wiki/Principality_of_Tver "Principality of Tver") was quickly transformed into one of the richest and most populous Russian states. As the area was hardly accessible for [Tatar](/wiki/Tatars "Tatars") raids, there was a great influx of population from the recently devastated south. By the end of the century, it vied with [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow "Moscow") for supremacy in Russia. Both Tver and Moscow were recently founded cities, so the outcome of their rivalry was far from certain.
### Grand princedom
{{Main\|Principality of Tver}}
[Mikhail Yaroslavich](/wiki/Mikhail_of_Tver "Mikhail of Tver"), the [prince of Tver](/wiki/Prince_of_Tver "Prince of Tver"), who ascended the throne of [Vladimir](/wiki/Vladimir%2C_Russia "Vladimir, Russia") in 1305, was one of the most revered medieval Russian rulers. His policy of open conflict with the [Golden Horde](/wiki/Golden_Horde "Golden Horde") led to his assassination there in 1318\. His son, [Dmitry Mikhailovich](/wiki/Dmitry_of_Tver "Dmitry of Tver") ("the Terrible Eyes"), succeeded him and, concluding an [alliance](/wiki/Military_alliance "Military alliance") with the mighty [Grand Duchy of Lithuania](/wiki/Grand_Duchy_of_Lithuania "Grand Duchy of Lithuania"), managed to raise Tver's prestige even higher.
Exasperated by Dmitry's influence, [Ivan Kalita](/wiki/Ivan_I_of_Moscow "Ivan I of Moscow"), the [prince of Moscow](/wiki/Prince_of_Moscow "Prince of Moscow"), engineered his murder by the Mongols in 1326\. On hearing the news of this crime, the city [revolted against the Mongol Horde](/wiki/Tver_Uprising_of_1327 "Tver Uprising of 1327"). The Horde joined its forces with the Muscovites and brutally repressed the [rebellion](/wiki/Rebellion "Rebellion"). Many citizens were killed, enslaved or deported. This was the fatal blow to Tver's aspirations for supremacy in Russia.
In the second half of the 14th century, Tver was further weakened by [dynastic](/wiki/Dynastic "Dynastic") struggles between its princes. Two senior branches of the ruling house, those of [Kashin](/wiki/Kashin_%28town%29 "Kashin (town)") and [Kholmsky](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast "Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast"), asserted their claims to the grand princely throne. The claimers were backed up by Moscow and eventually settled at the [Moscow Kremlin](/wiki/Moscow_Kremlin "Moscow Kremlin") court.
During the [Great Feudal War](/wiki/Muscovite_Civil_War "Muscovite Civil War") in the [Grand Duchy of Moscow](/wiki/Grand_Duchy_of_Moscow "Grand Duchy of Moscow"), Tver again rose to prominence and concluded defensive alliances with Lithuania, Novgorod, [Byzantium](/wiki/Byzantium "Byzantium"), and the Golden Horde. [Boris of Tver](/wiki/Boris_of_Tver "Boris of Tver") sent one of his men, [Afanasy Nikitin](/wiki/Afanasy_Nikitin "Afanasy Nikitin"), to search for gold and diamonds as far as [India](/wiki/India "India"). [Nikitin's travelogue](/wiki/A_Journey_Beyond_the_Three_Seas "A Journey Beyond the Three Seas"), describing his journey from 1466 to 1472, is one of the first ever firsthand accounts of India by a European. A monument to Nikitin was opened on the Volga embankment in 1955\.
### Later history
On 12 September 1485, the forces of [Ivan III](/wiki/Ivan_III_of_Russia "Ivan III of Russia") seized the city, leading to it to be formally annexed by Moscow. The [principality](/wiki/Principality_of_Tver "Principality of Tver") was given as an [appanage](/wiki/Appanage "Appanage") to Ivan's son, [Ivan the Young](/wiki/Ivan_the_Young "Ivan the Young"),{{cite book \|last1\=Bushkovitch \|first1\=Paul \|title\=Succession to the Throne in Early Modern Russia: The Transfer of Power 1450–1725 \|date\=18 March 2021 \|publisher\=Cambridge University Press \|isbn\=978\-1\-108\-47934\-9 \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=pAEbEAAAQBAJ \|language\=en}} only to be abolished several decades later. The last scions of the ruling dynasty were executed by [Ivan the Terrible](/wiki/Ivan_the_Terrible "Ivan the Terrible") during the *[oprichnina](/wiki/Oprichnina "Oprichnina")*. During that turbulent time, Tver was ruled by [Simeon Bekbulatovich](/wiki/Simeon_Bekbulatovich "Simeon Bekbulatovich"), a former khan of [Kasimov](/wiki/Kasimov "Kasimov"). The only remnant of his ephemeral reign is a graceful [tent\-like church](/wiki/Tent-like_church "Tent-like church") in the village of [Kushalino](/wiki/Kushalino "Kushalino"), {{convert\|28\|km}} northeast of Tver.
### 18th century
[thumb\|left\|A palace built for [Catherine the Great](/wiki/Catherine_the_Great "Catherine the Great")](/wiki/File:Tver._Travel_Palace_P7221294_2350.jpg "Tver. Travel Palace P7221294 2350.jpg")
The city's decline was not irrevocable, however. With the foundation of [St. Petersburg](/wiki/Saint_Petersburg "Saint Petersburg"), Tver gained importance as a principal station on the highway (and later railway) en route from Moscow. It was much visited by [Russian royalty](/wiki/Russian_royalty "Russian royalty") and [nobility](/wiki/Russian_nobility "Russian nobility") traveling from the old capital to the new one and back.
In the course of the [administrative reform](/wiki/Administrative_divisions_of_Russia_in_1708%E2%80%931710 "Administrative divisions of Russia in 1708–1710") carried out in 1708 by [Peter the Great](/wiki/Peter_the_Great "Peter the Great"), Tver was included into [Ingermanlandia Governorate](/wiki/Saint_Petersburg_Governorate "Saint Petersburg Governorate") (since 1710 known as Saint Petersburg Governorate). In 1727 it was transferred to the newly established [Novgorod Governorate](/wiki/Novgorod_Governorate "Novgorod Governorate"). In 1775, [Tver Viceroyalty](/wiki/Tver_Viceroyalty "Tver Viceroyalty") was formed from the lands which previously belonged to Moscow and Novgorod Governorates, and the whole area was transferred to Tver Viceroyalty, which in 1796 was transformed to [Tver Governorate](/wiki/Tver_Governorate "Tver Governorate"). Tver was the center of [Tverskoy Uyezd](/wiki/Tverskoy_Uyezd "Tverskoy Uyezd").{{cite book\|last1\=Малыгин\|first1\=П. Д.\|last2\=Смирнов\|first2\=С. Н.\|title\=История административно\-территориального деления Тверской Области\|url\=http://geoportal.tversu.ru/Atlas/tutorial/History\_TO\_divisions.pdf\|year\=2007\|location\=Tver\|oclc\=540329541\|page\=13\|access\-date\=March 31, 2016\|archive\-date\=August 29, 2021\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210829194006/http://geoportal.tversu.ru/Atlas/tutorial/History\_TO\_divisions.pdf\|url\-status\=dead}}
Following a devastating fire of 1763, the city was rebuilt in a [Neoclassical style](/wiki/Neoclassical_architecture "Neoclassical architecture"). Under [Catherine the Great](/wiki/Catherine_the_Great "Catherine the Great"), the central part was thoroughly reconstructed. Crumbling medieval buildings were razed and replaced with imposing Neoclassical buildings. The most important of these are the Travel Palace of the Empress (designed by the celebrated [Matvei Kazakov](/wiki/Matvei_Kazakov "Matvei Kazakov")), and the Ascension church (designed by [Nikolay Lvov](/wiki/Nikolay_Lvov "Nikolay Lvov") and consecrated in 1813\).
### 19th century
In 1809, a committee was established to improve the city.{{Cite web \|title\=The XIX century \|url\=https://www.tver.ru/en/about/history/xix.php \|access\-date\=2022\-08\-22 \|website\=Официальный сайт администрации города Твери}} An architect designed the Cathedral of Christ and houses on the waterfront and in the city center (30 buildings), and rebuilt the summer palace. [Catherine Pavlovna](/wiki/Catherine_Pavlovna_of_Russia "Catherine Pavlovna of Russia") (a sister of [Alexander I](/wiki/Alexander_I_of_Russia "Alexander I of Russia")) was married to the governor of Tver, and the palace was a social center and [literary salon](/wiki/Literary_salon "Literary salon") for Tver and visitors from Moscow and St. Petersburg. Writer and historian [Nikolay Karamzin](/wiki/Nikolay_Karamzin "Nikolay Karamzin") read excerpts from his *History of the Russian State* to Alexander.[Новый город: Тверь — история](http://www.novgor.ru/ltver.html) {{webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110903161736/http://www.novgor.ru/ltver.html \|date\=September 3, 2011 }} Napoleon was near Tver in 1812\.
### 20th century
[thumb\|left\|The Tver cavalry school](/wiki/File:%D0%A2%D0%9A%D0%A3_1.jpg "ТКУ 1.jpg")
On 12 July 1929, the governorates and uyezds were abolished. Tverskoy District, with the administrative centre in Tver, was established within [Tver Okrug](/wiki/Tver_Okrug "Tver Okrug") of [Moscow Oblast](/wiki/Moscow_Oblast "Moscow Oblast").{{cite book \|last1\=Colton \|first1\=Timothy J. \|title\=Moscow: Governing the Socialist Metropolis \|date\=1995 \|publisher\=Harvard University Press \|isbn\=978\-0\-674\-58749\-6 \|page\=188 \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=lXM2H6tWHskC \|language\=en}} On 23 July 1930, the okrugs were abolished, and the districts were directly subordinated to the oblast.{{cite web\|url\=http://guides.rusarchives.ru/browse/guidebook.html?bid\=225\&sid\=767186\|script\-title\=ru:Справка об изменениях в административно\-территориальном делении Тверской губернии – Калининской области\|publisher\=Архивы России\|language\=ru\|access\-date\=29 March 2014\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120419140741/http://guides.rusarchives.ru/browse/guidebook.html?bid\=225\&sid\=767186\|archive\-date\=April 19, 2012\|df\=mdy\-all}}
On 20 November 1931, the city was renamed *Kalinin* after the nominal head of state (1919–1946\) and affiliate of [Joseph Stalin](/wiki/Joseph_Stalin "Joseph Stalin"), [Mikhail Kalinin](/wiki/Mikhail_Kalinin "Mikhail Kalinin"), who had been born nearby.Official website of Tver. [History of Tver. Pre\-War Period](http://www.tver.ru/about/history/before_war.html) {{Webarchive\|url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130928031356/http://www.tver.ru/about/history/before\_war.html \|date\=September 28, 2013 }} {{in lang\|ru}}{{cite book \|last1\=Shimotomai \|first1\=Nobuo \|last2\=Aronson \|first2\=Elliot \|title\=Moscow under Stalinist Rule, 1931\-34 \|date\=27 July 2016 \|publisher\=Springer \|isbn\=978\-1\-349\-21607\-9 \|page\=5 \|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=se2\-DAAAQBAJ \|language\=en}} Simultaneously, Tverskoy District was renamed Kalininsky District. On 29 January 1935, [Kalinin Oblast](/wiki/Tver_Oblast "Tver Oblast") was established, and Kalininsky District was transferred to Kalinin Oblast.
The last vestige of the pre\-Petrine epoch, the Saviour Cathedral, was blown up in 1936\. In 1940, the [NKVD](/wiki/NKVD "NKVD") executed more than 6,200 Polish policemen and prisoners of war from [Ostashkov](/wiki/Ostashkov "Ostashkov") camp.
The [Wehrmacht](/wiki/Wehrmacht "Wehrmacht") entered Kalinin on Monday 13 October 1941 according to MI9 photographs, occupied Kalinin for two months from Monday 13 October 1941/Tuesday, 14 October to 19 December 1941, leaving the city in ashes. Kalinin was the first major city in [Europe](/wiki/Europe "Europe") to be retaken from the Wehrmacht.
During the [Cold War](/wiki/Cold_War "Cold War"), Kalinin was home to the [Kryuchkovo](/wiki/Kryuchkovo "Kryuchkovo") air base, which is no longer in service. The city's historic name of Tver was restored on 17 July 1990\.Decree of 17 July 1990{{cite news \|title\=17 июля 1990 года Калинин стал Тверью \|url\=https://tvernews.ru/news/273486/ \|work\=Tvernews \|date\=17 July 2021 \|language\=ru}}
Apart from the suburban White Trinity Church (1564\) ({{lang\-ru\|Храм Троицы Живоначальной}}, the Temple of the Lifegiving Trinity), there are no ancient monuments left in Tver. The central part is graced with Catharinian and Soviet edifices, bridges, and embankments. Tver's most notable industries are [rolling stock](/wiki/Rolling_stock "Rolling stock") manufacturer [Tver Carriage Works](/wiki/Tver_Carriage_Works "Tver Carriage Works"), opened in 1898, an [excavator](/wiki/Excavator "Excavator") factory, and a glass factory. Tver is home to [Migalovo](/wiki/Migalovo "Migalovo"), which is one of Russia's biggest military airlift facilities.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Medieval origins",
"Tver's foundation year is officially accepted to be 1135\\.Charter of Tver, Article 1 Originally a minor settlement of [Novgorodian](/wiki/Novgorod_Republic \"Novgorod Republic\") traders, it passed to the [grand prince of Vladimir](/wiki/Grand_prince_of_Vladimir \"Grand prince of Vladimir\") in 1209\\. In 1246, [Alexander Nevsky](/wiki/Alexander_Nevsky \"Alexander Nevsky\") granted it to his younger brother [Yaroslav Yaroslavich](/wiki/Yaroslav_of_Tver \"Yaroslav of Tver\") ({{died in\\|1271}}), from whom a dynasty of local princes descended. Four of them were killed by the [Golden Horde](/wiki/Golden_Horde \"Golden Horde\") and were proclaimed saints by the [Russian Orthodox church](/wiki/Russian_Orthodox_church \"Russian Orthodox church\").",
"Formerly a land of woods and bogs, the [Principality of Tver](/wiki/Principality_of_Tver \"Principality of Tver\") was quickly transformed into one of the richest and most populous Russian states. As the area was hardly accessible for [Tatar](/wiki/Tatars \"Tatars\") raids, there was a great influx of population from the recently devastated south. By the end of the century, it vied with [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow \"Moscow\") for supremacy in Russia. Both Tver and Moscow were recently founded cities, so the outcome of their rivalry was far from certain.",
"### Grand princedom",
"{{Main\\|Principality of Tver}}",
"[Mikhail Yaroslavich](/wiki/Mikhail_of_Tver \"Mikhail of Tver\"), the [prince of Tver](/wiki/Prince_of_Tver \"Prince of Tver\"), who ascended the throne of [Vladimir](/wiki/Vladimir%2C_Russia \"Vladimir, Russia\") in 1305, was one of the most revered medieval Russian rulers. His policy of open conflict with the [Golden Horde](/wiki/Golden_Horde \"Golden Horde\") led to his assassination there in 1318\\. His son, [Dmitry Mikhailovich](/wiki/Dmitry_of_Tver \"Dmitry of Tver\") (\"the Terrible Eyes\"), succeeded him and, concluding an [alliance](/wiki/Military_alliance \"Military alliance\") with the mighty [Grand Duchy of Lithuania](/wiki/Grand_Duchy_of_Lithuania \"Grand Duchy of Lithuania\"), managed to raise Tver's prestige even higher.",
"Exasperated by Dmitry's influence, [Ivan Kalita](/wiki/Ivan_I_of_Moscow \"Ivan I of Moscow\"), the [prince of Moscow](/wiki/Prince_of_Moscow \"Prince of Moscow\"), engineered his murder by the Mongols in 1326\\. On hearing the news of this crime, the city [revolted against the Mongol Horde](/wiki/Tver_Uprising_of_1327 \"Tver Uprising of 1327\"). The Horde joined its forces with the Muscovites and brutally repressed the [rebellion](/wiki/Rebellion \"Rebellion\"). Many citizens were killed, enslaved or deported. This was the fatal blow to Tver's aspirations for supremacy in Russia.",
"In the second half of the 14th century, Tver was further weakened by [dynastic](/wiki/Dynastic \"Dynastic\") struggles between its princes. Two senior branches of the ruling house, those of [Kashin](/wiki/Kashin_%28town%29 \"Kashin (town)\") and [Kholmsky](/wiki/Kholm%2C_Kholmsky_District%2C_Novgorod_Oblast \"Kholm, Kholmsky District, Novgorod Oblast\"), asserted their claims to the grand princely throne. The claimers were backed up by Moscow and eventually settled at the [Moscow Kremlin](/wiki/Moscow_Kremlin \"Moscow Kremlin\") court.",
"During the [Great Feudal War](/wiki/Muscovite_Civil_War \"Muscovite Civil War\") in the [Grand Duchy of Moscow](/wiki/Grand_Duchy_of_Moscow \"Grand Duchy of Moscow\"), Tver again rose to prominence and concluded defensive alliances with Lithuania, Novgorod, [Byzantium](/wiki/Byzantium \"Byzantium\"), and the Golden Horde. [Boris of Tver](/wiki/Boris_of_Tver \"Boris of Tver\") sent one of his men, [Afanasy Nikitin](/wiki/Afanasy_Nikitin \"Afanasy Nikitin\"), to search for gold and diamonds as far as [India](/wiki/India \"India\"). [Nikitin's travelogue](/wiki/A_Journey_Beyond_the_Three_Seas \"A Journey Beyond the Three Seas\"), describing his journey from 1466 to 1472, is one of the first ever firsthand accounts of India by a European. A monument to Nikitin was opened on the Volga embankment in 1955\\.",
"### Later history",
"On 12 September 1485, the forces of [Ivan III](/wiki/Ivan_III_of_Russia \"Ivan III of Russia\") seized the city, leading to it to be formally annexed by Moscow. The [principality](/wiki/Principality_of_Tver \"Principality of Tver\") was given as an [appanage](/wiki/Appanage \"Appanage\") to Ivan's son, [Ivan the Young](/wiki/Ivan_the_Young \"Ivan the Young\"),{{cite book \\|last1\\=Bushkovitch \\|first1\\=Paul \\|title\\=Succession to the Throne in Early Modern Russia: The Transfer of Power 1450–1725 \\|date\\=18 March 2021 \\|publisher\\=Cambridge University Press \\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-108\\-47934\\-9 \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=pAEbEAAAQBAJ \\|language\\=en}} only to be abolished several decades later. The last scions of the ruling dynasty were executed by [Ivan the Terrible](/wiki/Ivan_the_Terrible \"Ivan the Terrible\") during the *[oprichnina](/wiki/Oprichnina \"Oprichnina\")*. During that turbulent time, Tver was ruled by [Simeon Bekbulatovich](/wiki/Simeon_Bekbulatovich \"Simeon Bekbulatovich\"), a former khan of [Kasimov](/wiki/Kasimov \"Kasimov\"). The only remnant of his ephemeral reign is a graceful [tent\\-like church](/wiki/Tent-like_church \"Tent-like church\") in the village of [Kushalino](/wiki/Kushalino \"Kushalino\"), {{convert\\|28\\|km}} northeast of Tver.",
"### 18th century",
"[thumb\\|left\\|A palace built for [Catherine the Great](/wiki/Catherine_the_Great \"Catherine the Great\")](/wiki/File:Tver._Travel_Palace_P7221294_2350.jpg \"Tver. Travel Palace P7221294 2350.jpg\")\nThe city's decline was not irrevocable, however. With the foundation of [St. Petersburg](/wiki/Saint_Petersburg \"Saint Petersburg\"), Tver gained importance as a principal station on the highway (and later railway) en route from Moscow. It was much visited by [Russian royalty](/wiki/Russian_royalty \"Russian royalty\") and [nobility](/wiki/Russian_nobility \"Russian nobility\") traveling from the old capital to the new one and back.",
"In the course of the [administrative reform](/wiki/Administrative_divisions_of_Russia_in_1708%E2%80%931710 \"Administrative divisions of Russia in 1708–1710\") carried out in 1708 by [Peter the Great](/wiki/Peter_the_Great \"Peter the Great\"), Tver was included into [Ingermanlandia Governorate](/wiki/Saint_Petersburg_Governorate \"Saint Petersburg Governorate\") (since 1710 known as Saint Petersburg Governorate). In 1727 it was transferred to the newly established [Novgorod Governorate](/wiki/Novgorod_Governorate \"Novgorod Governorate\"). In 1775, [Tver Viceroyalty](/wiki/Tver_Viceroyalty \"Tver Viceroyalty\") was formed from the lands which previously belonged to Moscow and Novgorod Governorates, and the whole area was transferred to Tver Viceroyalty, which in 1796 was transformed to [Tver Governorate](/wiki/Tver_Governorate \"Tver Governorate\"). Tver was the center of [Tverskoy Uyezd](/wiki/Tverskoy_Uyezd \"Tverskoy Uyezd\").{{cite book\\|last1\\=Малыгин\\|first1\\=П. Д.\\|last2\\=Смирнов\\|first2\\=С. Н.\\|title\\=История административно\\-территориального деления Тверской Области\\|url\\=http://geoportal.tversu.ru/Atlas/tutorial/History\\_TO\\_divisions.pdf\\|year\\=2007\\|location\\=Tver\\|oclc\\=540329541\\|page\\=13\\|access\\-date\\=March 31, 2016\\|archive\\-date\\=August 29, 2021\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210829194006/http://geoportal.tversu.ru/Atlas/tutorial/History\\_TO\\_divisions.pdf\\|url\\-status\\=dead}}",
"Following a devastating fire of 1763, the city was rebuilt in a [Neoclassical style](/wiki/Neoclassical_architecture \"Neoclassical architecture\"). Under [Catherine the Great](/wiki/Catherine_the_Great \"Catherine the Great\"), the central part was thoroughly reconstructed. Crumbling medieval buildings were razed and replaced with imposing Neoclassical buildings. The most important of these are the Travel Palace of the Empress (designed by the celebrated [Matvei Kazakov](/wiki/Matvei_Kazakov \"Matvei Kazakov\")), and the Ascension church (designed by [Nikolay Lvov](/wiki/Nikolay_Lvov \"Nikolay Lvov\") and consecrated in 1813\\).",
"### 19th century",
"In 1809, a committee was established to improve the city.{{Cite web \\|title\\=The XIX century \\|url\\=https://www.tver.ru/en/about/history/xix.php \\|access\\-date\\=2022\\-08\\-22 \\|website\\=Официальный сайт администрации города Твери}} An architect designed the Cathedral of Christ and houses on the waterfront and in the city center (30 buildings), and rebuilt the summer palace. [Catherine Pavlovna](/wiki/Catherine_Pavlovna_of_Russia \"Catherine Pavlovna of Russia\") (a sister of [Alexander I](/wiki/Alexander_I_of_Russia \"Alexander I of Russia\")) was married to the governor of Tver, and the palace was a social center and [literary salon](/wiki/Literary_salon \"Literary salon\") for Tver and visitors from Moscow and St. Petersburg. Writer and historian [Nikolay Karamzin](/wiki/Nikolay_Karamzin \"Nikolay Karamzin\") read excerpts from his *History of the Russian State* to Alexander.[Новый город: Тверь — история](http://www.novgor.ru/ltver.html) {{webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20110903161736/http://www.novgor.ru/ltver.html \\|date\\=September 3, 2011 }} Napoleon was near Tver in 1812\\.",
"### 20th century",
"[thumb\\|left\\|The Tver cavalry school](/wiki/File:%D0%A2%D0%9A%D0%A3_1.jpg \"ТКУ 1.jpg\") \nOn 12 July 1929, the governorates and uyezds were abolished. Tverskoy District, with the administrative centre in Tver, was established within [Tver Okrug](/wiki/Tver_Okrug \"Tver Okrug\") of [Moscow Oblast](/wiki/Moscow_Oblast \"Moscow Oblast\").{{cite book \\|last1\\=Colton \\|first1\\=Timothy J. \\|title\\=Moscow: Governing the Socialist Metropolis \\|date\\=1995 \\|publisher\\=Harvard University Press \\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-674\\-58749\\-6 \\|page\\=188 \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=lXM2H6tWHskC \\|language\\=en}} On 23 July 1930, the okrugs were abolished, and the districts were directly subordinated to the oblast.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://guides.rusarchives.ru/browse/guidebook.html?bid\\=225\\&sid\\=767186\\|script\\-title\\=ru:Справка об изменениях в административно\\-территориальном делении Тверской губернии – Калининской области\\|publisher\\=Архивы России\\|language\\=ru\\|access\\-date\\=29 March 2014\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20120419140741/http://guides.rusarchives.ru/browse/guidebook.html?bid\\=225\\&sid\\=767186\\|archive\\-date\\=April 19, 2012\\|df\\=mdy\\-all}}",
"On 20 November 1931, the city was renamed *Kalinin* after the nominal head of state (1919–1946\\) and affiliate of [Joseph Stalin](/wiki/Joseph_Stalin \"Joseph Stalin\"), [Mikhail Kalinin](/wiki/Mikhail_Kalinin \"Mikhail Kalinin\"), who had been born nearby.Official website of Tver. [History of Tver. Pre\\-War Period](http://www.tver.ru/about/history/before_war.html) {{Webarchive\\|url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130928031356/http://www.tver.ru/about/history/before\\_war.html \\|date\\=September 28, 2013 }} {{in lang\\|ru}}{{cite book \\|last1\\=Shimotomai \\|first1\\=Nobuo \\|last2\\=Aronson \\|first2\\=Elliot \\|title\\=Moscow under Stalinist Rule, 1931\\-34 \\|date\\=27 July 2016 \\|publisher\\=Springer \\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-349\\-21607\\-9 \\|page\\=5 \\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=se2\\-DAAAQBAJ \\|language\\=en}} Simultaneously, Tverskoy District was renamed Kalininsky District. On 29 January 1935, [Kalinin Oblast](/wiki/Tver_Oblast \"Tver Oblast\") was established, and Kalininsky District was transferred to Kalinin Oblast.",
"The last vestige of the pre\\-Petrine epoch, the Saviour Cathedral, was blown up in 1936\\. In 1940, the [NKVD](/wiki/NKVD \"NKVD\") executed more than 6,200 Polish policemen and prisoners of war from [Ostashkov](/wiki/Ostashkov \"Ostashkov\") camp.",
"The [Wehrmacht](/wiki/Wehrmacht \"Wehrmacht\") entered Kalinin on Monday 13 October 1941 according to MI9 photographs, occupied Kalinin for two months from Monday 13 October 1941/Tuesday, 14 October to 19 December 1941, leaving the city in ashes. Kalinin was the first major city in [Europe](/wiki/Europe \"Europe\") to be retaken from the Wehrmacht.",
"During the [Cold War](/wiki/Cold_War \"Cold War\"), Kalinin was home to the [Kryuchkovo](/wiki/Kryuchkovo \"Kryuchkovo\") air base, which is no longer in service. The city's historic name of Tver was restored on 17 July 1990\\.Decree of 17 July 1990{{cite news \\|title\\=17 июля 1990 года Калинин стал Тверью \\|url\\=https://tvernews.ru/news/273486/ \\|work\\=Tvernews \\|date\\=17 July 2021 \\|language\\=ru}}",
"Apart from the suburban White Trinity Church (1564\\) ({{lang\\-ru\\|Храм Троицы Живоначальной}}, the Temple of the Lifegiving Trinity), there are no ancient monuments left in Tver. The central part is graced with Catharinian and Soviet edifices, bridges, and embankments. Tver's most notable industries are [rolling stock](/wiki/Rolling_stock \"Rolling stock\") manufacturer [Tver Carriage Works](/wiki/Tver_Carriage_Works \"Tver Carriage Works\"), opened in 1898, an [excavator](/wiki/Excavator \"Excavator\") factory, and a glass factory. Tver is home to [Migalovo](/wiki/Migalovo \"Migalovo\"), which is one of Russia's biggest military airlift facilities.",
""
] |
Politics
--------
[thumb\|Seat of the Tver City Duma and City Administration on Lenin Square](/wiki/File:Tver_duma_dusk.JPG "Tver duma dusk.JPG")
The [Tver City Duma](/wiki/Tver_City_Duma "Tver City Duma"), the local [parliament](/wiki/Parliament "Parliament") is composed of 33 deputies. The executive branch is the Administration of Tver. The structure consists of the mayor (since 2017 – Alexey Ogonkov), his deputies, industry bodies (departments of architecture and construction, housing and communal services, health and social policy, property management and land resources; economy, investment and industrial policy, a number of departments and divisions), as well as the administration of the four districts: Zavolzhsky, Moskovsky, Proletarsky and Tsentralny. A considerable part of the government buildings of the city of Tver and the Tver Oblast lay along Sovetskaya Street: the building on the square of [St. Michael](/wiki/Mikhail_of_Tver "Mikhail of Tver") (Sovetskaya, 44\) is the residence of the Governor of the Oblast, and a former Regional Party Committee (Sovetskaya, 33\) is The [Legislative Assembly of Tver Oblast](/wiki/Legislative_Assembly_of_Tver_Oblast "Legislative Assembly of Tver Oblast").
Tver City Duma as a representative body of the city existed from 1785 to 1918, was reconstituted after the dissolution of [councils](/wiki/Soviet_%28council%29 "Soviet (council)") and adoption of the new [Constitution of Russia](/wiki/Constitution_of_Russia "Constitution of Russia") in 1993\. On 20 March 1994, elections were held in the House of Representatives, which on 26 May was renamed Tver City Duma. On 7 June deputies were able to hold the first meeting, and on 14 June Valery Matitsyn was elected a speaker (later this post was held by Valery Pavlov, Victor Pochtaryov, Dmitry Bazhenov, Igor Serdyuk, Andrei Borisenko, Lyudmila Polosina, Vladimir Babichev). In 1996, deputies adopted the founding document of the city – the Charter of the city of Tver, putting in it the principle of rotation in the Duma elections. Second election based on it was held on 27 October 1996 . In the future years elections held every two years in the "even" and "odd" electoral districts. In 2007, 12 former deputies (including the former chairman of the Duma Victor Pochtaryov) were convicted of taking bribes for decisions in favor of Rosvodokanal and other utilities. In October 2008, the elections of some deputies have already passed on party lists, and in March 2009 the entire City Duma has been transferred to this system, while discontinued the practice of rotation of deputies. In the elections of 2009, the best result (49 % of the vote) was shown by [local communists](/wiki/Communist_Party_of_the_Russian_Federation "Communist Party of the Russian Federation").
On 27 October 1996 simultaneously with elections to the City Duma passed the first general elections of the head of the city, won by Alexander Belousov, who led the municipal administration since 1991 and received more than 50 % of the vote. On 30 October 2000 he was reelected to a second term, and on 9 April 2003 he died of a heart attack. On 26 July 2001 in early Mayoral elections opposition candidate Oleg Lebedev won. On 2 December 2007 when he was supported by the pro\-government party [United Russia](/wiki/United_Russia "United Russia"), he was re\-elected for a second term, receiving more than 70 % of the vote. On 11 April 2008 he was suspended by the Tsentralny District Court in connection with a criminal case opened in 2005, closed in 2006 and renewed by the [Prosecutor General of Russia](/wiki/Prosecutor_General_of_Russia "Prosecutor General of Russia") in March 2008 (Lebedev was accused of hindering the work of the investigation against his deputy Oleg Kudryashov). On 2 May Oleg Lebedev was reinstated, and on 3 June, again dismissed, and on 25 June he was taken into custody and transported to [Kashin](/wiki/Kashin_%28town%29 "Kashin (town)"), where he was convicted by visiting college of Tver Regional Court jury to eighteen years’ imprisonment, which automatically meant the termination of his powers. In 2009, he was released on parole, but the position was not restored.
In late 2008, Tver City Duma adopted amendments to the charter of the city, under which direct elections of the Mayor were abolished and a new position of head of the city administration introduced. This amendment to the charter of the city was met with a mixed public reaction and local attempts to bring the issue by the Communists to citywide referendum were not supported by City Duma. In March 2009, City Duma elected Vladimir Babichev as the new mayor (now ceremonial post), and in May the same year, Vasily Toloko was appointed as the head of the city administration. He had previously been the first deputy governor of the Tver Oblast. The mayor and the head of the local administration were elected with a thin majority of seventeen votes (United Russia, Fair Russia and the Liberal Democratic Party) against sixteen (Communist Party). On 27 December 2011 by a majority vote (22 for, six against) City Council voted in favor of early termination of Vasily Toloko. On 29 March 2012 the Tver City Duma (25 for, 4 against) appointed Valery Pavlov to the post of Head of the Administration. He had previously held the post of the first deputy head of Cuty Administration.
On 2 November 2012 Alexander Korzin was appointed as mayor of the city. In 2014, he left his post, and on May 28, 2014, by the decision of the Tver City Duma, Yury Timofeev was appointed to this post, previously working for 10 years as the head of the [Zapadnodvinsky District](/wiki/Zapadnodvinsky_District "Zapadnodvinsky District"). On 22 September 2016, immediately after [Igor Rudenya](/wiki/Igor_Rudenya "Igor Rudenya") assumed the post of governor, Timofeev resigned and Alexey Ogonkov, who claimed this position in 2014, became acting Mayor.
In August 2017, the Tver City Duma adopted amendments to the Charter of the city, according to which the Mayor also heads the administration. Thus, the "two\-headed management" system introduced in 2008 was abolished. The amendments entered into force on November 2, 2017, after Alexander Korzin's term as Mayor has expired. Thus, from 2 November 2017 Alexey Ogonykov became the Mayor.
|
[
"Politics\n--------",
"[thumb\\|Seat of the Tver City Duma and City Administration on Lenin Square](/wiki/File:Tver_duma_dusk.JPG \"Tver duma dusk.JPG\")",
"The [Tver City Duma](/wiki/Tver_City_Duma \"Tver City Duma\"), the local [parliament](/wiki/Parliament \"Parliament\") is composed of 33 deputies. The executive branch is the Administration of Tver. The structure consists of the mayor (since 2017 – Alexey Ogonkov), his deputies, industry bodies (departments of architecture and construction, housing and communal services, health and social policy, property management and land resources; economy, investment and industrial policy, a number of departments and divisions), as well as the administration of the four districts: Zavolzhsky, Moskovsky, Proletarsky and Tsentralny. A considerable part of the government buildings of the city of Tver and the Tver Oblast lay along Sovetskaya Street: the building on the square of [St. Michael](/wiki/Mikhail_of_Tver \"Mikhail of Tver\") (Sovetskaya, 44\\) is the residence of the Governor of the Oblast, and a former Regional Party Committee (Sovetskaya, 33\\) is The [Legislative Assembly of Tver Oblast](/wiki/Legislative_Assembly_of_Tver_Oblast \"Legislative Assembly of Tver Oblast\").",
"Tver City Duma as a representative body of the city existed from 1785 to 1918, was reconstituted after the dissolution of [councils](/wiki/Soviet_%28council%29 \"Soviet (council)\") and adoption of the new [Constitution of Russia](/wiki/Constitution_of_Russia \"Constitution of Russia\") in 1993\\. On 20 March 1994, elections were held in the House of Representatives, which on 26 May was renamed Tver City Duma. On 7 June deputies were able to hold the first meeting, and on 14 June Valery Matitsyn was elected a speaker (later this post was held by Valery Pavlov, Victor Pochtaryov, Dmitry Bazhenov, Igor Serdyuk, Andrei Borisenko, Lyudmila Polosina, Vladimir Babichev). In 1996, deputies adopted the founding document of the city – the Charter of the city of Tver, putting in it the principle of rotation in the Duma elections. Second election based on it was held on 27 October 1996 . In the future years elections held every two years in the \"even\" and \"odd\" electoral districts. In 2007, 12 former deputies (including the former chairman of the Duma Victor Pochtaryov) were convicted of taking bribes for decisions in favor of Rosvodokanal and other utilities. In October 2008, the elections of some deputies have already passed on party lists, and in March 2009 the entire City Duma has been transferred to this system, while discontinued the practice of rotation of deputies. In the elections of 2009, the best result (49 % of the vote) was shown by [local communists](/wiki/Communist_Party_of_the_Russian_Federation \"Communist Party of the Russian Federation\").",
"On 27 October 1996 simultaneously with elections to the City Duma passed the first general elections of the head of the city, won by Alexander Belousov, who led the municipal administration since 1991 and received more than 50 % of the vote. On 30 October 2000 he was reelected to a second term, and on 9 April 2003 he died of a heart attack. On 26 July 2001 in early Mayoral elections opposition candidate Oleg Lebedev won. On 2 December 2007 when he was supported by the pro\\-government party [United Russia](/wiki/United_Russia \"United Russia\"), he was re\\-elected for a second term, receiving more than 70 % of the vote. On 11 April 2008 he was suspended by the Tsentralny District Court in connection with a criminal case opened in 2005, closed in 2006 and renewed by the [Prosecutor General of Russia](/wiki/Prosecutor_General_of_Russia \"Prosecutor General of Russia\") in March 2008 (Lebedev was accused of hindering the work of the investigation against his deputy Oleg Kudryashov). On 2 May Oleg Lebedev was reinstated, and on 3 June, again dismissed, and on 25 June he was taken into custody and transported to [Kashin](/wiki/Kashin_%28town%29 \"Kashin (town)\"), where he was convicted by visiting college of Tver Regional Court jury to eighteen years’ imprisonment, which automatically meant the termination of his powers. In 2009, he was released on parole, but the position was not restored.",
"In late 2008, Tver City Duma adopted amendments to the charter of the city, under which direct elections of the Mayor were abolished and a new position of head of the city administration introduced. This amendment to the charter of the city was met with a mixed public reaction and local attempts to bring the issue by the Communists to citywide referendum were not supported by City Duma. In March 2009, City Duma elected Vladimir Babichev as the new mayor (now ceremonial post), and in May the same year, Vasily Toloko was appointed as the head of the city administration. He had previously been the first deputy governor of the Tver Oblast. The mayor and the head of the local administration were elected with a thin majority of seventeen votes (United Russia, Fair Russia and the Liberal Democratic Party) against sixteen (Communist Party). On 27 December 2011 by a majority vote (22 for, six against) City Council voted in favor of early termination of Vasily Toloko. On 29 March 2012 the Tver City Duma (25 for, 4 against) appointed Valery Pavlov to the post of Head of the Administration. He had previously held the post of the first deputy head of Cuty Administration.",
"On 2 November 2012 Alexander Korzin was appointed as mayor of the city. In 2014, he left his post, and on May 28, 2014, by the decision of the Tver City Duma, Yury Timofeev was appointed to this post, previously working for 10 years as the head of the [Zapadnodvinsky District](/wiki/Zapadnodvinsky_District \"Zapadnodvinsky District\"). On 22 September 2016, immediately after [Igor Rudenya](/wiki/Igor_Rudenya \"Igor Rudenya\") assumed the post of governor, Timofeev resigned and Alexey Ogonkov, who claimed this position in 2014, became acting Mayor.",
"In August 2017, the Tver City Duma adopted amendments to the Charter of the city, according to which the Mayor also heads the administration. Thus, the \"two\\-headed management\" system introduced in 2008 was abolished. The amendments entered into force on November 2, 2017, after Alexander Korzin's term as Mayor has expired. Thus, from 2 November 2017 Alexey Ogonykov became the Mayor.",
""
] |
Transportation
--------------
[thumb\|Tver railway depot and [roundhouse](/wiki/Railway_roundhouse "Railway roundhouse"), ca. 1860\. Photo courtesy [SMU](/wiki/Southern_Methodist_University "Southern Methodist University").](/wiki/File:Tver_depot_and_roundhouse.jpg "Tver depot and roundhouse.jpg")
[thumb\|Tver [KSM\-2 factory railway](/wiki/Narrow_gauge_railway_of_KSM-2_factory "Narrow gauge railway of KSM-2 factory")](/wiki/File:KSM-2_railway_TU7-1703_with_freight_train.jpg "KSM-2 railway TU7-1703 with freight train.jpg")
### Railway
The [Oktyabrskaya Railway](/wiki/Oktyabrskaya_Railway "Oktyabrskaya Railway") linking Moscow and St. Petersburg crosses the city. Since 1850, there has been a railway connection between Tver and Moscow.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.nnov\-airport.ru/rus/wokzal\_tver.html\|title\=Train Station in Tver\|language\=ru\|access\-date\=March 29, 2018\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20160313004927/http://nnov\-airport.ru/rus/wokzal\_tver.html\|archive\-date\=March 13, 2016\|df\=mdy\-all}} The primary Tver Railway Station has a locomotive and car shed, allowing it to service both passenger and cargo trains. In addition to the Tver Central Station, there are four minor stations within the city perimeter: Lazurnaya, Proletarskaya, Doroshikha and PPGT. The suburban railway service links Tver to [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow "Moscow"), [Bologoye](/wiki/Bologoye%2C_Tver_Oblast "Bologoye, Tver Oblast"), [Torzhok](/wiki/Torzhok "Torzhok"). Most trains passing from Moscow to the north\-west regions make a short stop in Tver. The high\-speed train [Sapsan](/wiki/Sapsan "Sapsan"), which connects Moscow with St. Petersburg, also makes stops in Tver, as well as the [Tolstoy train](/wiki/Tolstoy "Tolstoy") connecting Moscow to [Helsinki](/wiki/Helsinki "Helsinki"), Finland.
The newly designed high\-speed railway line between Moscow and St Petersburg is expected to have a "New Tver'" station several kilometres southward of the city border.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.izvestia.ru/news/363476\|title\=Триллион "Сапсана"\|date\=July 7, 2010\|access\-date\=March 29, 2018}}
The [narrow gauge railway of KSM\-2 factory](/wiki/Narrow_gauge_railway_of_KSM-2_factory "Narrow gauge railway of KSM-2 factory"), Tver plant of building materials No.2\.
### Roads
The major [M10 Highway](/wiki/M10_highway_%28Russia%29 "M10 highway (Russia)") linking Moscow and St. Petersburg also crosses the city. This motorway is a part of the [Pan\-European corridors](/wiki/Pan-European_corridors "Pan-European corridors") system. The roads to [Rzhev](/wiki/Rzhev "Rzhev") (A112\), [Vesyegonsk](/wiki/Vesyegonsk "Vesyegonsk") (P84\) and [Volokolamsk](/wiki/Volokolamsk "Volokolamsk") (P90\), along with many smaller regional roads, originate in the city. The new highway between Moscow and St. Petersburg, that is designed at the present time, will pass close to the northern border of Tver. Tver is notable for a high number of private cars: there are 288 cars per thousand residents, which is well above average among the other regions of Russia.{{cite web\|url\=http://rating.rbc.ru/article.shtml?2008/09/30/32143066\|title\=РБК 500: Крупнейшие компании России\|access\-date\=March 29, 2018}}
### Public transit
There is a local bus station that interconnects Tver with minor towns of Tver Oblast, neighbouring oblasts, and Moscow.
Local public transit consists of [trolleybuses](/wiki/Trolleybus "Trolleybus"), [trams](/wiki/Tram "Tram"), buses, and *[marshrutkas](/wiki/Marshrutka "Marshrutka")* (routed taxis). The latter two have taken priority during recent years.
In November 2018, the tram traffic in Tver was completely stopped. On August 7, 2019, all car drivers, as well as track fitters and support staff of the trams, left by "mutual agreement".{{Cite web\|title\=Chronology: Tver\|url\=https://transphoto.org/news.php?cid\=8\|access\-date\=2021\-05\-20\|website\=transphoto.org\|language\=en}} At the same time, the dismantling of the contact network and the tracks along the last existing route began. The city administration said that it was necessary to completely repair the roadbed.
In recent years, there has been a tendency to reduce the route network of trolley buses. During the first quarter of 2020, local authorities plan to introduce a new transport model, which implies the elimination of trolleybus traffic and the duplication of its routes with buses. From April 14, 2020, the last of the existing trolleybus routes (No. 2\) was replaced by a bus route 42 on which diesel buses now operate.{{Cite web\|title\=Tver\|url\=https://transphoto.org/city/8/\|access\-date\=2021\-05\-20\|website\=transphoto.org\|language\=en}}
### Air
There are two airfields within the city: [Migalovo](/wiki/Migalovo_air_base "Migalovo air base") [military air base](/wiki/Military_air_base "Military air base") and Zmeyovo airport;
although the nearest airport with regular scheduled commercial service is [Sheremetyevo airport](/wiki/Sheremetyevo_airport "Sheremetyevo airport") in [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow "Moscow").
### Water
The [river station](/wiki/Tver_River_Terminal "Tver River Terminal") (Речной Вокзал, "*rechnoy vokzal*") is located on the left bank of the Volga River, close to the confluence with the river [Tvertsa](/wiki/Tvertsa "Tvertsa"). There is also a small cargo port in the lower part of the Volga. During the summertime, pleasure boats ply up and down the Volga, with their base off the river station.
|
[
"Transportation\n--------------",
"[thumb\\|Tver railway depot and [roundhouse](/wiki/Railway_roundhouse \"Railway roundhouse\"), ca. 1860\\. Photo courtesy [SMU](/wiki/Southern_Methodist_University \"Southern Methodist University\").](/wiki/File:Tver_depot_and_roundhouse.jpg \"Tver depot and roundhouse.jpg\")\n[thumb\\|Tver [KSM\\-2 factory railway](/wiki/Narrow_gauge_railway_of_KSM-2_factory \"Narrow gauge railway of KSM-2 factory\")](/wiki/File:KSM-2_railway_TU7-1703_with_freight_train.jpg \"KSM-2 railway TU7-1703 with freight train.jpg\")",
"### Railway",
"The [Oktyabrskaya Railway](/wiki/Oktyabrskaya_Railway \"Oktyabrskaya Railway\") linking Moscow and St. Petersburg crosses the city. Since 1850, there has been a railway connection between Tver and Moscow.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.nnov\\-airport.ru/rus/wokzal\\_tver.html\\|title\\=Train Station in Tver\\|language\\=ru\\|access\\-date\\=March 29, 2018\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20160313004927/http://nnov\\-airport.ru/rus/wokzal\\_tver.html\\|archive\\-date\\=March 13, 2016\\|df\\=mdy\\-all}} The primary Tver Railway Station has a locomotive and car shed, allowing it to service both passenger and cargo trains. In addition to the Tver Central Station, there are four minor stations within the city perimeter: Lazurnaya, Proletarskaya, Doroshikha and PPGT. The suburban railway service links Tver to [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow \"Moscow\"), [Bologoye](/wiki/Bologoye%2C_Tver_Oblast \"Bologoye, Tver Oblast\"), [Torzhok](/wiki/Torzhok \"Torzhok\"). Most trains passing from Moscow to the north\\-west regions make a short stop in Tver. The high\\-speed train [Sapsan](/wiki/Sapsan \"Sapsan\"), which connects Moscow with St. Petersburg, also makes stops in Tver, as well as the [Tolstoy train](/wiki/Tolstoy \"Tolstoy\") connecting Moscow to [Helsinki](/wiki/Helsinki \"Helsinki\"), Finland.",
"The newly designed high\\-speed railway line between Moscow and St Petersburg is expected to have a \"New Tver'\" station several kilometres southward of the city border.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.izvestia.ru/news/363476\\|title\\=Триллион \"Сапсана\"\\|date\\=July 7, 2010\\|access\\-date\\=March 29, 2018}}",
"The [narrow gauge railway of KSM\\-2 factory](/wiki/Narrow_gauge_railway_of_KSM-2_factory \"Narrow gauge railway of KSM-2 factory\"), Tver plant of building materials No.2\\.",
"### Roads",
"The major [M10 Highway](/wiki/M10_highway_%28Russia%29 \"M10 highway (Russia)\") linking Moscow and St. Petersburg also crosses the city. This motorway is a part of the [Pan\\-European corridors](/wiki/Pan-European_corridors \"Pan-European corridors\") system. The roads to [Rzhev](/wiki/Rzhev \"Rzhev\") (A112\\), [Vesyegonsk](/wiki/Vesyegonsk \"Vesyegonsk\") (P84\\) and [Volokolamsk](/wiki/Volokolamsk \"Volokolamsk\") (P90\\), along with many smaller regional roads, originate in the city. The new highway between Moscow and St. Petersburg, that is designed at the present time, will pass close to the northern border of Tver. Tver is notable for a high number of private cars: there are 288 cars per thousand residents, which is well above average among the other regions of Russia.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://rating.rbc.ru/article.shtml?2008/09/30/32143066\\|title\\=РБК 500: Крупнейшие компании России\\|access\\-date\\=March 29, 2018}}",
"### Public transit",
"There is a local bus station that interconnects Tver with minor towns of Tver Oblast, neighbouring oblasts, and Moscow.",
"Local public transit consists of [trolleybuses](/wiki/Trolleybus \"Trolleybus\"), [trams](/wiki/Tram \"Tram\"), buses, and *[marshrutkas](/wiki/Marshrutka \"Marshrutka\")* (routed taxis). The latter two have taken priority during recent years.",
"In November 2018, the tram traffic in Tver was completely stopped. On August 7, 2019, all car drivers, as well as track fitters and support staff of the trams, left by \"mutual agreement\".{{Cite web\\|title\\=Chronology: Tver\\|url\\=https://transphoto.org/news.php?cid\\=8\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-05\\-20\\|website\\=transphoto.org\\|language\\=en}} At the same time, the dismantling of the contact network and the tracks along the last existing route began. The city administration said that it was necessary to completely repair the roadbed.",
"In recent years, there has been a tendency to reduce the route network of trolley buses. During the first quarter of 2020, local authorities plan to introduce a new transport model, which implies the elimination of trolleybus traffic and the duplication of its routes with buses. From April 14, 2020, the last of the existing trolleybus routes (No. 2\\) was replaced by a bus route 42 on which diesel buses now operate.{{Cite web\\|title\\=Tver\\|url\\=https://transphoto.org/city/8/\\|access\\-date\\=2021\\-05\\-20\\|website\\=transphoto.org\\|language\\=en}}",
"### Air",
"There are two airfields within the city: [Migalovo](/wiki/Migalovo_air_base \"Migalovo air base\") [military air base](/wiki/Military_air_base \"Military air base\") and Zmeyovo airport; \nalthough the nearest airport with regular scheduled commercial service is [Sheremetyevo airport](/wiki/Sheremetyevo_airport \"Sheremetyevo airport\") in [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow \"Moscow\").",
"### Water",
"The [river station](/wiki/Tver_River_Terminal \"Tver River Terminal\") (Речной Вокзал, \"*rechnoy vokzal*\") is located on the left bank of the Volga River, close to the confluence with the river [Tvertsa](/wiki/Tvertsa \"Tvertsa\"). There is also a small cargo port in the lower part of the Volga. During the summertime, pleasure boats ply up and down the Volga, with their base off the river station.",
""
] |
History
-------
### Early years
[thumb\|left\|200px\|Detail of the first membership card of PCd'I in 1921](/wiki/File:Tesserapcd21.jpg "Tesserapcd21.jpg")
{{Communism in Italy}}
The roots of the PCI date back to 1921, when the [I Congress of the Communist Party of Italy](/wiki/I_Congress_of_the_Communist_Party_of_Italy "I Congress of the Communist Party of Italy") was held in Livorno on 21 January, following a split in the [XVII Congress of the Italian Socialist Party](/wiki/XVII_Congress_of_the_Italian_Socialist_Party "XVII Congress of the Italian Socialist Party"). The split occurred after the Congress of Livorno refused to expel the [reformist](/wiki/Reformist "Reformist") group as required by the [Communist International](/wiki/Communist_International "Communist International") (Comintern). The main factions of the new party were L'Ordine Nuovo, based in Turin and led by [Antonio Gramsci](/wiki/Antonio_Gramsci "Antonio Gramsci"), and the Maximalist faction led by [Nicola Bombacci](/wiki/Nicola_Bombacci "Nicola Bombacci"). [Amadeo Bordiga](/wiki/Amadeo_Bordiga "Amadeo Bordiga") was elected secretary of the new party.{{cite book\|last\=Spriano\|first\=Paolo\|date\=1967\|title\=Storia del Partito comunista italiano. Da Bordiga a Gramsci\|language\=it\|volume\=I\|location\=Turin\|publisher\=Einaudi\|isbn\=978\-8\-8060\-8029\-7}}
The party was officially founded as the **Communist Party of Italy – Section of the Communist International** (*Partito Comunista d'Italia – Sezione dell'Internazionale Comunista*), since the Comintern was structured as a single world party according to [Vladimir Lenin](/wiki/Vladimir_Lenin "Vladimir Lenin")'s vision. In the [1921 Italian general election](/wiki/1921_Italian_general_election "1921 Italian general election"), the party obtained 4\.6% of the vote and 15 seats in the country's [Chamber of Deputies](/wiki/Chamber_of_Deputies_%28Kingdom_of_Italy%29 "Chamber of Deputies (Kingdom of Italy)"). At the time, it was an active yet small faction within the Italian political left, which was strongly led by the PSI, while on the international level it was [Soviet](/wiki/Soviet "Soviet")\-led.
During its 2nd Congress in 1922, the new party registered 43,000 members. This was in part due to the entrance of almost the whole Socialist Youth Federation (*Federazione Giovanile Socialista*). The party adopted a slim structure headed by a Central Committee of 15 members, five of whom were also in the Executive Committee (EC), namely Ambrogio Belloni, Nicola Bombacci, Amadeo Bordiga (EC), [Bruno Fortichiari](/wiki/Bruno_Fortichiari "Bruno Fortichiari") (EC), [Egidio Gennari](/wiki/Egidio_Gennari "Egidio Gennari"), Antonio Gramsci, [Ruggero Grieco](/wiki/Ruggero_Grieco "Ruggero Grieco") (EC), Anselmo Marabini, [Francesco Misiano](/wiki/Francesco_Misiano "Francesco Misiano"), Giovanni Parodi, Luigi Polano, Luigi Repossi (EC), Cesare Sessa, Ludovico Tarsia, and Umberto Terracini (EC).
Since its formation, the party strived to organise itself on some bases that were not a mere reproduction of the traditional parties' bases. It then took again some arguments that distinguished the battle within the PSI, namely the idea that it is necessary to form an environment fiercely hostile to bourgeois society and that is an anticipation of the future socialist society. The purpose of this was not considered utopian because already in this society, especially in production, some structures are born on future results. In the first years of the PCd'I, there was no official leader; the accepted leader, first of the faction/tendency and then of the party, was Bordiga (Left) of the [communist left](/wiki/Communist_left "Communist left") current. Leaders of the minority currents were Angelo Tasca (Right) and Gramsci (Centre).
### Conflict between factions
As a territorial section of Comintern, the PCd'I adopted the same program, the same conception of the party and the same tactics adopted by the II Congress in [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow "Moscow") of 1920\. The official program, drawn up in ten points, began with the intrinsically catastrophic nature of the capitalist system and terminated with the extinction of the state. It follows in a synthetic way the model outlined by Lenin for the [Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)](/wiki/Russian_Communist_Party_%28Bolsheviks%29 "Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)"). For a while, this identity resisted, but the fast progress of the reaction in Europe produced a change of tactics in a democratic direction within the Bolshevik party and consequently within the Comintern. This happened in particular regarding the possibility, previously opposed, of an alliance with the social democratic and bourgeois parties. This provoked a tension in the party between the majority (Left) and the minority factions (the Right and the Centre) supported by the Comintern. The proposals of the Left were no longer accepted and the conflict between the factions became irremediable.
### Bolshevisation
[thumb\|150px\|[Antonio Gramsci](/wiki/Antonio_Gramsci "Antonio Gramsci")](/wiki/File:Gramsci.png "Gramsci.png")
In 1923, some members of the party were arrested and put on trial for "conspiracy against the State". This allowed the intense activity of the Communist International to deprive the party's left\-wing of authority and give control to the minority centre which had aligned with Moscow. In 1924–1925, the Comintern began a campaign of [Bolshevisation](/wiki/Bolshevisation "Bolshevisation"), which forced each party to conform to the discipline and orders of Moscow. During the clandestine conference held in Como to ratify the party leadership in May 1924, 35 of the 45 federation secretaries, plus the secretary of the youth federation, voted for Bordiga's Left, four for Gramsci's Centre, and five for Tasca's Right.
Before the Lyon Congress in 1926, the Centre won almost all the votes in the absence of much of the Left, who were unable to attend as a result of fascist controls and lack of Comintern support. Recourse to the Comintern against this evident manoeuvre had little effect. The PCd'I as conceived by the Left terminated. The organisation continued with the support of the Comintern and a new structure and leadership. In 1922, the newspaper *[L'Ordine Nuovo](/wiki/L%27Ordine_Nuovo "L'Ordine Nuovo")* was closed and in 1924 a new Centre newspaper, *[l'Unità](/wiki/L%27Unit%C3%A0 "L'Unità")*, edited by Gramsci, was founded. The Left continued as a faction, principally functioning in exile. It published the newspaper *Bilan*, a monthly theoretical bulletin.
In 1926, Bordiga and Gramsci were arrested and imprisoned on the island of [Ustica](/wiki/Ustica "Ustica"). In 1927, [Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti "Palmiro Togliatti") was elected secretary in place of Gramsci. In 1930, Bordiga was expelled from the Comintern and accused of [Trotskyism](/wiki/Trotskyism "Trotskyism"). After [Joseph Stalin](/wiki/Joseph_Stalin "Joseph Stalin") dissolved the Communist International in 1943, the exiled members of the PCd'I in Moscow changed the party's name to the PCI on 15 May. Under this name, it reorganised in Italy and became a parliamentary party after the fall of Fascism.
### Resistance to fascism
The party and its militants were actively involved in the resistance to [Benito Mussolini](/wiki/Benito_Mussolini "Benito Mussolini")'s regime through clandestine action. They were well prepared for clandestine activity because of the structure of their organisation, and the fact that they had been victims of systematic repression by the authorities; more than three quarters of the political prisoners between 1926 and 1943 were communists. Throughout the dictatorship, the party was able to maintain and feed a clandestine network, distribute propaganda leaflets and newspapers, and infiltrate fascist unions and youth organisations. In 1935, the party led a campaign against the [Second Italo\-Ethiopian War](/wiki/Second_Italo-Ethiopian_War "Second Italo-Ethiopian War").{{cite book\|last1\=Sabbatucci\|first1\=Giovanni\|last2\=Vidotto\|first2\=Vittorio\|date\=2008\|title\=Storia contemporanea. Il Novecento\|publisher\=Editori Laterza\|isbn\=978\-8\-8420\-8742\-7}} The party and communist partisans, among others, then went on to play a major role in the resistance movement that led to the [fall of the Fascist regime in Italy](/wiki/Fall_of_the_Fascist_regime_in_Italy "Fall of the Fascist regime in Italy").
On 15 May 1943, the party changed its official name to the Italian Communist Party (*Partito Comunista Italiano*), often shortened to PCI. This change was not surprising as PCI started being used as the party's acronym around 1924–1925\. This name change also reflected a change in the Comintern's role—it increasingly became a federation of national communist parties. This trend accelerated after Lenin's death and its new name emphasised the party's shift from an international focus to an Italian one. At the time, it was a hotly contested issue for the two major factions of the party. On one side, the Leninist preferred the single world party as it was internationalist and strongly centralised, while on the other side the Italians wanted a party more tailored to their nation's peculiarities and more autonomy.
After the fall of [Fascist Italy](/wiki/Fascist_Italy_%281922%E2%80%931943%29 "Fascist Italy (1922–1943)") on 25 July 1943, the PCI returned to a formally legal status, playing a major role during the national liberation, known in Italy as *[Resistenza](/wiki/Resistenza "Resistenza")* (Resistance) and forming many partisan groups. In April 1944, after the *Svolta di Salerno* ([Salerno](/wiki/Salerno "Salerno")'s turning point), Togliatti, who had returned to Italy the month prior after 18 years of exile,{{cite book\|last\=Agosti\|first\=Aldo\|date\=2012\|chapter\=Les baleines du corset. Togliatti, le PCI et les intellectuels (1944–1947\)\|editor\-last1\=Bechelloni\|editor\-first1\=Antonio\|editor\-last2\=Del Vento\|editor\-first2\=Christian\|editor\-last3\=Tabet\|editor\-first3\=Xavier\|title\=La vie intellectuelle entre fascisme et République 1940–1948\|language\=fr\|issue\=12\|publisher\=ENS éditions\|pages\=17–32\|doi\=10\.4000/laboratoireitalien.633\|isbn\=978\-2\-8478\-8382\-4}} agreed to cooperate with [King Victor Emmanuel III](/wiki/King_Victor_Emmanuel_III "King Victor Emmanuel III") and his [prime minister of Italy](/wiki/Prime_minister_of_Italy "Prime minister of Italy"), the Marshal [Pietro Badoglio](/wiki/Pietro_Badoglio "Pietro Badoglio"). After the turn, the PCI took part in every government during the national liberation and constitutional period from June 1944 to May 1947\.{{cite book\|last1\=Cervi\|first1\=Mario\|last2\=Montanelli\|first2\=Indro\|date\=2003\|title\=Storia d'Italia\|language\=it\|publisher\=Rcs Quotidiani}} Their contribution to the new Italian democratic constitution was decisive. The Gullo decrees of 1944, named after [Fausto Gullo](/wiki/Fausto_Gullo "Fausto Gullo"), sought to improve social and economic conditions in the countryside.{{cite book\|last\=Ginsborg\|first\=Paul\|date\=2003\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\&dq\=Communist\+Gullo\+decrees\+july\+1944\+land\+reform\&pg\=PA60\|title\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\|edition\=illustrated\|publisher\=Palgrave Macmillan\|page\=60\|isbn\=978\-1\-4039\-6153\-2}} During Badoglio and [Ferruccio Parri](/wiki/Ferruccio_Parri "Ferruccio Parri")'s cabinets, Togliatti served as the [Deputy Prime Minister of Italy](/wiki/Deputy_Prime_Minister_of_Italy "Deputy Prime Minister of Italy"). During the Resistance, the PCI became increasingly popular, as the majority of partisans were communists. The [Garibaldi Brigades](/wiki/Garibaldi_Brigades "Garibaldi Brigades"), promoted by the PCI, were among the more numerous partisan forces.{{cite book\|last\=Bianchi\|first\=Giovanni\|date\=\|chapter\=La Resistenza\|editor\-last\=Montanelli\|editor\-first\=Indro\|title\=Storia d'Italia\|language\=it\|volume\=8\|page\=368}}
### Post\-war years
The PCI took part in the [1946 Italian general election](/wiki/1946_Italian_general_election "1946 Italian general election") and the [1946 Italian institutional referendum](/wiki/1946_Italian_institutional_referendum "1946 Italian institutional referendum"), campaigning for a republic. In the election, the PCI was third, behind [Christian Democracy](/wiki/Christian_Democracy_%28Italy%29 "Christian Democracy (Italy)") (DC) and the PSI, gaining almost 19% of votes and electing 104 members of the [Constituent Assembly of Italy](/wiki/Constituent_Assembly_of_Italy "Constituent Assembly of Italy").{{cite web\|url\=https://elezionistorico.interno.gov.it/index.php?tpel\=A\&dtel\=02/06/1946\&tpa\=I\&tpe\=A\&lev0\=0\&levsut0\=0\&es0\=S\&ms\=S\|title\=Assemblea costituente 02/06/1946\|language\=it\|publisher\=Italian Ministry of the Interior\|access\-date\=3 July 2023}} The popular referendum resulted in the replacement of the monarchy with a republic,{{cite web\|url\=https://elezionistorico.interno.gov.it/index.php?tpel\=F\&dtel\=02/06/1946\&tpa\=I\&tpe\=A\&lev0\=0\&levsut0\=0\&es0\=S\&ms\=S\|title\=Referendum 02/06/1946\|language\=it\|publisher\=Italian Ministry of the Interior\|access\-date\=3 July 2023}} after 54% of the votes were in favour and 46% against.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.sturzo.it/edu/l\-italia\-repubblicana\-e\-gli\-anni\-dello\-sviluppo/445\-1\-la\-fondazione\-dell\-italia\-repubblicana/612\-il\-referendum\-istituzionale\-e\-la\-scelta\-repubblicana \|title\=Il referendum istituzionale e la scelta repubblicana \|publisher\=Luigi Sturzo Institute \|language\=it\| access\-date\=8 December 2016 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180305171243/http://www.sturzo.it/edu/l\-italia\-repubblicana\-e\-gli\-anni\-dello\-sviluppo/445\-1\-la\-fondazione\-dell\-italia\-repubblicana/612\-il\-referendum\-istituzionale\-e\-la\-scelta\-repubblicana \|archive\-date\=5 March 2018 \|url\-status\=dead }}{{cite web\|url\=https://www.simone.it/newdiz/newdiz.php?action\=view\&id\=1011\&index\=H\&dizionario\=2\|url\-status\=dead\|title\=Savoia\|website\=Dizionari Simone Online\|access\-date\=12 November 2019\|archive\-date\=7 July 2018\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180707230422/https://www.simone.it/newdiz/newdiz.php?action\=view\&id\=1011\&index\=H\&dizionario\=2}} [Luciano Canfora](/wiki/Luciano_Canfora "Luciano Canfora") saw the Salerno Turn and 1944 as a rebirth of the PCI, and said "the PCI had gradually followed a path which required it, as a historical task, to occupy the space of social democracy in the Italian political panorama."{{cite news\|last\=Fai\|first\=Paolo\|date\=1 February 2021\|url\=https://www.laterza.it/wp\-content/uploads/recensioni/CANFORA\-9\.pdf\|title\=Il Pci rifondato da Togliatti si perde nel berlinguerismo\|work\=La Terza\|page\=12\|access\-date\=5 July 2023}}
As part of the [May 1947 crises](/wiki/May_1947_crises "May 1947 crises"), the PCI was excluded from government. [Alcide De Gasperi](/wiki/Alcide_De_Gasperi "Alcide De Gasperi"), the DC leader and prime minister of Italy, was losing popularity, and feared that the [leftist](/wiki/Leftist "Leftist") coalition would take power. While the PCI was growing particularly fast due to its organising efforts supporting sharecroppers in [Sicily](/wiki/Sicily "Sicily"), [Tuscany](/wiki/Tuscany "Tuscany"), and [Umbria](/wiki/Umbria "Umbria"), movements that were also bolstered by the reforms of [Fausto Gullo](/wiki/Fausto_Gullo "Fausto Gullo"), the [Italian Minister of Agriculture](/wiki/Italian_Minister_of_Agriculture "Italian Minister of Agriculture").{{cite book\|last\=Ginsborg\|first\=Paul\|date\=2003\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\&q\=may\+1947\|title\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\|edition\=illustrated\|publisher\=Palgrave Macmillan\|pages\=106–113\|isbn\=978\-1\-4039\-6153\-2}} On 1 May, the nation was thrown into crisis by the [Portella della Ginestra massacre](/wiki/Portella_della_Ginestra_massacre "Portella della Ginestra massacre"), in which eleven leftist peasants (including four children) were murdered at an [International Workers' Day](/wiki/International_Workers%27_Day "International Workers' Day") parade in [Palermo](/wiki/Palermo "Palermo") by [Salvatore Giuliano](/wiki/Salvatore_Giuliano "Salvatore Giuliano") and his gang. In the political chaos that ensued, the United States government engineered the expulsion of all left\-wing ministers from the cabinet on 31 May. The PCI would not have a national position in government again. De Gasperi did this under pressure from the United States Secretary of State, [George Marshall](/wiki/George_Marshall "George Marshall"), who had informed him that [anti\-communism](/wiki/Anti-communism "Anti-communism") was a pre\-condition for receiving American aid,{{cite book\|last\=Ciment\|first\=James\|date\=2015\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=cpCXBwAAQBAJ\|title\=Encyclopedia of Conflicts Since World War II\|publisher\=Routledge\|page\=\[https://books.google.com/books?id\=cpCXBwAAQBAJ\&q\=forced\+de\+Gasperi\+to\+remove\+the\+Socialists\+and\+Communists\+from\+the\+government\+as\+a\+condition\+of\+receiving\+U.S.\+aid\&pg\=PT2073 2073]\|isbn\=978\-1\-3174\-7185\-1}} and Ambassador [James Clement Dunn](/wiki/James_Clement_Dunn "James Clement Dunn"), who had directly asked de Gasperi to dissolve the parliament and remove the PCI.{{cite book\|last\=Corke\|first\=Sarah\-Jane\|date\=2007\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=FKN8AgAAQBAJ\&q\=James\+C.\+Dunn\+asked.\+1947\&pg\=PA232\|title\=US Covert Operations and Cold War Strategy: Truman, Secret Warfare and the CIA, 1945–53\|publisher\=Routledge\|isbn\=978\-1\-1341\-0413\-0\|pages\=47–48}}{{cite news\|last\=Stazi\|first\=Guido\|date\=30 October 2021\|url\=https://www.milanofinanza.it/news/sessanta\-anni\-senza\-einaudi\-il\-governatore\-che\-da\-chigi\-sali\-al\-colle\-202110301157412373\|title\=Sessanta anni senza Einaudi, il governatore che da Chigi salì al Colle\|work\=MF Milano Finanza\|language\=it\|access\-date\=8 July 2023\|quote\=Einaudi annotava nel suo Diario di una cena a casa dell'Ambasciatore d'Italia in Unione Sovietica Quaroni, in cui si conveniva che gli Stati Uniti gli aiuti veri non li avrebbero concessi con i comunisti ancora al governo.\|trans\-quote\=Einaudi noted in his Diary of a dinner at the home of the Italian Ambassador to the Soviet Union Quaroni, in which it was agreed that the United States would not grant real aid with the Communists still in government.}}
In the [1948 Italian general election](/wiki/1948_Italian_general_election "1948 Italian general election"), the party joined the PSI in the [Popular Democratic Front](/wiki/Popular_Democratic_Front_%28Italy%29 "Popular Democratic Front (Italy)") (FDP) but was defeated by the DC. The United States government provided support to anti\-PCI groups in the election,{{cite book\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=ejrgDj\-SYiUC\&pg\=PA140\|title\=Confronting America: The Cold War between the United States and the Communists in France and Italy\|last\=Brogi\|first\=Alessandro\|date\=2011\|publisher\=UNC Press Books\|isbn\=978\-0\-8078\-7774\-6\|pages\=140–149}} and argued that should the PCI win, the [Marshall Plan](/wiki/Marshall_Plan "Marshall Plan") and other aids could be terminated. It spent $10–20 million on anti\-communist propaganda and other covert operations, much of it through the [Economic Cooperation Administration](/wiki/Economic_Cooperation_Administration "Economic Cooperation Administration") of the Marshall Plan, and then laundered through individual banks.{{cite book\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=FKN8AgAAQBAJ\&pg\=PA54\|title\=US Covert Operations and Cold War Strategy: Truman, Secret Warfare and the CIA, 1945–53\|last\=Corke\|first\=Sarah\-Jane\|date\=2007\|publisher\=Routledge\|isbn\=978\-1\-1341\-0413\-0\|pages\=49–58}} Fearful of the possible FDP's electoral victory, the British and American governments also undermined their campaign for legal justice by tolerating the efforts made by Italy's top authorities to prevent any of the alleged [Italian war criminals](/wiki/Italian_war_criminals "Italian war criminals") from being extradited and taken to court.{{cite news\|last\=Carroll\|first\=Rory\|date\=25 June 2001\|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/education/2001/jun/25/artsandhumanities.highereducation\|title\=Italy's bloody secret\|work\=The Guardian\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130716012326/http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2001/jun/25/artsandhumanities.highereducation\|archive\-date\=16 July 2013\|access\-date\=3 July 2023}}{{cite journal\|last\=Pedaliu\|first\=Effie\|author\-link\=Effie Pedaliu\|date\=2004\|title\=Britain and the 'Hand\-over' of Italian War Criminals to Yugoslavia, 1945–48\|journal\=Journal of Contemporary History\|volume\=39\|issue\=4, Special Issue: Collective Memory\|pages\=503–529\|doi\=10\.1177/0022009404046752 \|jstor\=4141408\|s2cid\=159985182 }} The denial of Italian war crimes was backed up by the Italian state, academe, and media, re\-inventing Italy as only a victim of [Nazism](/wiki/Nazism "Nazism") and the post\-war [Foibe massacres](/wiki/Foibe_massacres "Foibe massacres").
The party gained considerable electoral success during the following years and occasionally supplied external support to the [Organic centre\-left](/wiki/Organic_centre-left "Organic centre-left") governments, although it never directly joined a government. It successfully lobbied [Fiat](/wiki/Fiat "Fiat") to set up the [AvtoVAZ](/wiki/AvtoVAZ "AvtoVAZ") (Lada) car factory in the [Soviet Union](/wiki/Soviet_Union "Soviet Union") (1966\). The party did best in [Emilia\-Romagna](/wiki/Emilia-Romagna "Emilia-Romagna"), Tuscany, and Umbria, where it regularly won the local administrative elections, and in some of the industrialised cities of [Northern Italy](/wiki/Northern_Italy "Northern Italy"). At the city government level during the course of the post\-war period, the PCI demonstrated in cities like [Bologna](/wiki/Bologna "Bologna") and [Florence](/wiki/Florence "Florence") their capacity for uncorrupt, efficient and clean government.{{cite book\|last\=Robertson\|first\=David\|date\=1993\|title\=The Penguin Dictionary of Politics\|edition\=2nd\|publisher\=Penguin\|isbn\=978\-0\-1405\-1276\-2}} After the [1975 Italian local elections](/wiki/1975_Italian_local_elections "1975 Italian local elections"), the PCI was the strongest force in nearly all of the municipal councils of the great cities.{{cite book\|last\=Ginsborg\|first\=Paul\|date\=2003\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\&pg\=PA372\|title\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\|edition\=illustrated\|publisher\=Palgrave Macmillan\|page\=372\|isbn\=978\-1\-4039\-6153\-2}}
### From the 1950s to the 1960s
[thumb\|150px\|[Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti "Palmiro Togliatti")](/wiki/File:Palmiro_Togliatti_Official.jpg "Palmiro Togliatti Official.jpg")
The Soviet Union's brutal suppression of the [Hungarian Revolution of 1956](/wiki/Hungarian_Revolution_of_1956 "Hungarian Revolution of 1956") created a split within the PCI.{{cite web\|last\=Romeo\|first\=Ilaria\|date\=30 October 2022\|url\=https://www.collettiva.it/copertine/internazionale/2022/10/30/news/ungheria\-2454619/\|title\=1956: dopo la repressione sovietica in Ungheria, i contrasti e le rotture all'interno del Pci\|website\=Collettiva\|language\=it\|access\-date\=17 July 2023}} The party leadership, including [Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti "Palmiro Togliatti") and [Giorgio Napolitano](/wiki/Giorgio_Napolitano "Giorgio Napolitano") (who in 2006 became [President of Italy](/wiki/President_of_Italy "President of Italy")), regarded the Hungarian insurgents as counter\-revolutionaries as reported at the time in *[l'Unità](/wiki/L%27Unit%C3%A0 "L'Unità")*, the official PCI newspaper. [Giuseppe Di Vittorio](/wiki/Giuseppe_Di_Vittorio "Giuseppe Di Vittorio"), chief of the communist trade union [Italian General Confederation of Labour](/wiki/Italian_General_Confederation_of_Labour "Italian General Confederation of Labour") (CGIL), repudiated the leadership position, as did prominent party member [Antonio Giolitti](/wiki/Antonio_Giolitti "Antonio Giolitti") and [Italian Socialist Party](/wiki/Italian_Socialist_Party "Italian Socialist Party") national secretary [Pietro Nenni](/wiki/Pietro_Nenni "Pietro Nenni"), a close ally of the PCI. Napolitano later hinted at doubts over the propriety of his decision.{{citation\|date\=October–December 1980\|title\=The Italian Communists: Foreign Bulletin of the P.C.I.\|issue\=4\|location\=Rome\|page\=103}}. He would eventually write in *From the Communist Party to European Socialism. A Political Autobiography* (*Dal Pci al socialismo europeo. Un'autobiografia politica*) that he regretted his justification of the Soviet intervention but quieted his concerns at the time for the sake of party unity and the international leadership of [Soviet Communism](/wiki/Soviet_Communism "Soviet Communism").{{cite book\|last\=Napolitano\|first\=Giorgio\|year\=2005\|title\=Dal Pci al socialismo europeo. Un'autobiografia politica\|publisher\=Laterza\|language\=it\|isbn\=978\-8\-8420\-7715\-2}} Giolitti and Nenni went on to split with the PCI over this issue. Napolitano became a leading member of the *[miglioristi](/wiki/Miglioristi "Miglioristi")* faction within the PCI that promoted a [social\-democratic](/wiki/Social-democratic "Social-democratic") direction in party policy.{{cite web\|last\=Cacace\|first\=Paolo\|date\=15 May 2006\|title\=Napolitano e l'{{'}}utopia mite' dell'Europa\|url\=http://www.toscanaeuropa.it/att\_politica/documenti/dettaglio.asp?id\_doc\=4451\|access\-date\=14 July 2007\|language\=it\|url\-status\=dead\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070929010907/http://www.toscanaeuropa.it/att\_politica/documenti/dettaglio.asp?id\_doc\=4451\|archive\-date\=29 September 2007}}
In the mid\-1960s, the [United States Department of State](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State "United States Department of State") estimated the party membership to be approximately 1,350,000, or 4\.2% of the working age population, making it the largest Communist party in per capita terms in the capitalist world at the time and the largest party at all in the whole of Western Europe with the [Social Democratic Party of Germany](/wiki/Social_Democratic_Party_of_Germany "Social Democratic Party of Germany").{{cite journal\|last1\=Kautsky\|first1\=John H.\|last2\=Benjamin\|first2\=Roger W.\|date\=March 1968\|title\=Communism and Economic Development\|journal\=American Political Science Review\|volume\=62\|issue\=1\|page\=122\|jstor\=1953329}} United States government sources said that the party was receiving $40–50 million per year from the Soviets when their investment in Italy was $5–6 million.{{cite video\|people\=Carl Colby (director)\|date\=September 2011\|title\=The Man Nobody Knew: In Search of My Father, CIA Spymaster Ashley Colby\|url\=http://firstrunfeatures.com/themannobodyknew/\|medium\=Motion picture\|publisher\=Act 4 Entertainment\|location\=New York City\|access\-date\=15 September 2011\|quote\=Edward Luttwak, interview: "\[W]e estimated at the time they were getting $40–50 million a year at a time when we were putting $5–6 million into Italian politics.\|ref\=15 September 2011}} Although the PCI relied on Soviet financial assistance more than any other Communist party supported by Moscow, declassified information shows this to be exaggerated.{{cite journal\|last\=Drake\|first\=Richard\|date\=Summer 2004\|title\=The Soviet Dimension of Italian Communism\|journal\=Journal of Cold War Studies\|volume\=6\|issue\=3\|pages\=115–119\|doi\=10\.1162/1520397041447355 \|jstor\=26925390\|s2cid\=57564743 }}
According to the former [KGB](/wiki/KGB "KGB") archivist [Vasili Mitrokhin](/wiki/Vasili_Mitrokhin "Vasili Mitrokhin"), Longo and other PCI leaders became alarmed at the possibility of a coup in Italy after the Athens Colonel coup in April 1967 that led to the [Greek junta](/wiki/Greek_junta "Greek junta"). These fears were not completely unfounded as there had been two attempted coups in Italy, [Piano Solo](/wiki/Piano_Solo "Piano Solo") in 1964 and [Golpe Borghese](/wiki/Golpe_Borghese "Golpe Borghese") in 1970, by military and [neo\-fascist](/wiki/Neo-fascist "Neo-fascist") groups. The PCI's [Giorgio Amendola](/wiki/Giorgio_Amendola "Giorgio Amendola") formally requested Soviet assistance to prepare the party in case of such an event. The KGB drew up and implemented a plan to provide the PCI with its own intelligence and clandestine signal corps. From 1967 through 1973, PCI members were sent to [East Germany](/wiki/East_Germany "East Germany") and Moscow to receive training in clandestine warfare and information gathering techniques by both the [Stasi](/wiki/Stasi "Stasi") and the KGB. Shortly before the [1972 Italian general election](/wiki/1972_Italian_general_election "1972 Italian general election"), Longo personally wrote to [Leonid Brezhnev](/wiki/Leonid_Brezhnev "Leonid Brezhnev") asking for and receiving an additional $5\.7 million in funding. This was on top of the $3\.5 million that the Soviet Union gave the PCI in 1971\. The Soviets also provided additional funding through the use of [front organisations](/wiki/Front_organisations "Front organisations") providing generous contracts to PCI members.{{cite book\|last1\=Andrew\|first1\=Christopher\|last2\=Mitrokhin\|first2\=Vasili\|date\=2001\|title\=The Sword and the Shield: The Mitrokhin Archive and the Secret History of the KGB\|publisher\=Basic Books}}
### Leadership of Enrico Berlinguer
[thumb\|150px\|[Enrico Berlinguer](/wiki/Enrico_Berlinguer "Enrico Berlinguer")](/wiki/File:Enrico_Berlinguer.jpg "Enrico Berlinguer.jpg")
In 1969, [Enrico Berlinguer](/wiki/Enrico_Berlinguer "Enrico Berlinguer"), the PCI deputy national secretary and later secretary general, took part in the international conference of the communist parties in Moscow, where his delegation disagreed with the official political line and refused to support the final report. Unexpectedly to his hosts, his speech challenged the communist leadership in Moscow. He refused to excommunicate the [Chinese Communist Party](/wiki/Chinese_Communist_Party "Chinese Communist Party") and directly told Brezhnev that the [Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia](/wiki/Warsaw_Pact_invasion_of_Czechoslovakia "Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia"), which he called "the tragedy in Prague", had made clear the considerable differences within the communist movement on fundamental questions, such as national sovereignty, socialist democracy, and the freedom of culture. At the time, the PCI, which had absorbed the PSI's left\-wing, the [Italian Socialist Party of Proletarian Unity](/wiki/Italian_Socialist_Party_of_Proletarian_Unity "Italian Socialist Party of Proletarian Unity"), so strengthening its leadership over the Italian left, was the largest communist party in a [capitalist state](/wiki/Capitalist_state "Capitalist state"), garnering 34\.4% of the vote in the [1976 Italian general election](/wiki/1976_Italian_general_election "1976 Italian general election").
Relationships between the PCI and the Soviet Union gradually fell apart as the party moved away from Soviet obedience and [Marxist–Leninist](/wiki/Marxist%E2%80%93Leninist "Marxist–Leninist") orthodoxy in the 1970s and 1980s and toward [Eurocommunism](/wiki/Eurocommunism "Eurocommunism") and the [Socialist International](/wiki/Socialist_International "Socialist International"). The PCI sought a collaboration with the socialist and Christian democracy parties, a policy known the [Historic Compromise](/wiki/Historic_Compromise "Historic Compromise"). The [kidnapping and murder of Aldo Moro](/wiki/Kidnapping_and_murder_of_Aldo_Moro "Kidnapping and murder of Aldo Moro"), the DC leader, by the [Red Brigades](/wiki/Red_Brigades "Red Brigades") in May 1978 put an end to any hopes of such a compromise. The compromise was largely abandoned as a PCI policy in 1981\. The [Proletarian Unity Party](/wiki/Proletarian_Unity_Party_%28Italy%29 "Proletarian Unity Party (Italy)") merged into the PCI in 1984\.
During the [Years of Lead](/wiki/Years_of_Lead_%28Italy%29 "Years of Lead (Italy)"), the PCI strongly opposed the terrorism and the Red Brigades, who in turn murdered or wounded many PCI members or trade unionists close to the PCI. According to Mitrokhin, the party asked the Soviets to pressure the [StB](/wiki/StB "StB"), Czechoslovakia's State Security, to withdraw their support to the group, which Moscow was unable or unwilling to do. This, along with the [Soviet invasion of Afghanistan](/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Afghanistan "Soviet invasion of Afghanistan"), led to a complete break with Moscow in 1979\. In 1980, the PCI refused to participate in the international conference of Communist parties in Paris; cash payments to the PCI continued until 1984\.
### Dissolution
[Achille Occhetto](/wiki/Achille_Occhetto "Achille Occhetto") became general secretary of the PCI in 1988\. At a 1989 conference in a working\-class section of Bologna, Occhetto stunned the party faithful with a speech heralding the [Revolutions of 1989](/wiki/Revolutions_of_1989 "Revolutions of 1989"), a move now referred to in Italian politics as the *svolta della Bolognina* (Bolognina turning point). The collapse of the Communist governments in the Eastern Europe led Occhetto to conclude that the era of Eurocommunism was over. Under his leadership, the PCI dissolved and refounded itself as the [Democratic Party of the Left](/wiki/Democratic_Party_of_the_Left "Democratic Party of the Left"), which branded itself as a progressive left\-wing and [democratic socialist](/wiki/Democratic_socialist "Democratic socialist") party.{{cite book\|last\=Ignazi\|first\=Pietro\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=\-\-6NAAAAMAAJ\|title\=Dal PCI al PDS\|editor\=Il mulino\|date\=1992\|publisher\=Il mulino \|isbn\=978\-8\-8150\-3413\-7}}{{cite book\|last1\=Bellucci\|first1\=Paolo\|last2\=Maraffi\|first2\=Marco\|last3\=Segatti\|first3\=Paolo\|url\=https://books.google.com/books?id\=ghGg\_mV\_iY8C\|title\=PCI, PDS, DS: la trasformazione dell'identità politica della sinistra di governo\|editor\=Donzelli\|date\=2000\|publisher\=Donzelli Editore \|isbn\=978\-8\-8798\-9547\-7}} A third of the PCI membership, led by [Armando Cossutta](/wiki/Armando_Cossutta "Armando Cossutta"), refused to join the PDS, and instead seceded to form the [Communist Refoundation Party](/wiki/Communist_Refoundation_Party "Communist Refoundation Party").{{cite book\|last\=Kertzer\|first\=David I.\|title\=Politics and Symbols: The Italian Communist Party and the Fall of Communism\|publisher\=Yale University Press\|year\=1998\|isbn\=978\-0\-3000\-7724\-7}}
|
[
"History\n-------",
"### Early years",
"[thumb\\|left\\|200px\\|Detail of the first membership card of PCd'I in 1921](/wiki/File:Tesserapcd21.jpg \"Tesserapcd21.jpg\")\n{{Communism in Italy}}",
"The roots of the PCI date back to 1921, when the [I Congress of the Communist Party of Italy](/wiki/I_Congress_of_the_Communist_Party_of_Italy \"I Congress of the Communist Party of Italy\") was held in Livorno on 21 January, following a split in the [XVII Congress of the Italian Socialist Party](/wiki/XVII_Congress_of_the_Italian_Socialist_Party \"XVII Congress of the Italian Socialist Party\"). The split occurred after the Congress of Livorno refused to expel the [reformist](/wiki/Reformist \"Reformist\") group as required by the [Communist International](/wiki/Communist_International \"Communist International\") (Comintern). The main factions of the new party were L'Ordine Nuovo, based in Turin and led by [Antonio Gramsci](/wiki/Antonio_Gramsci \"Antonio Gramsci\"), and the Maximalist faction led by [Nicola Bombacci](/wiki/Nicola_Bombacci \"Nicola Bombacci\"). [Amadeo Bordiga](/wiki/Amadeo_Bordiga \"Amadeo Bordiga\") was elected secretary of the new party.{{cite book\\|last\\=Spriano\\|first\\=Paolo\\|date\\=1967\\|title\\=Storia del Partito comunista italiano. Da Bordiga a Gramsci\\|language\\=it\\|volume\\=I\\|location\\=Turin\\|publisher\\=Einaudi\\|isbn\\=978\\-8\\-8060\\-8029\\-7}}",
"The party was officially founded as the **Communist Party of Italy – Section of the Communist International** (*Partito Comunista d'Italia – Sezione dell'Internazionale Comunista*), since the Comintern was structured as a single world party according to [Vladimir Lenin](/wiki/Vladimir_Lenin \"Vladimir Lenin\")'s vision. In the [1921 Italian general election](/wiki/1921_Italian_general_election \"1921 Italian general election\"), the party obtained 4\\.6% of the vote and 15 seats in the country's [Chamber of Deputies](/wiki/Chamber_of_Deputies_%28Kingdom_of_Italy%29 \"Chamber of Deputies (Kingdom of Italy)\"). At the time, it was an active yet small faction within the Italian political left, which was strongly led by the PSI, while on the international level it was [Soviet](/wiki/Soviet \"Soviet\")\\-led.",
"During its 2nd Congress in 1922, the new party registered 43,000 members. This was in part due to the entrance of almost the whole Socialist Youth Federation (*Federazione Giovanile Socialista*). The party adopted a slim structure headed by a Central Committee of 15 members, five of whom were also in the Executive Committee (EC), namely Ambrogio Belloni, Nicola Bombacci, Amadeo Bordiga (EC), [Bruno Fortichiari](/wiki/Bruno_Fortichiari \"Bruno Fortichiari\") (EC), [Egidio Gennari](/wiki/Egidio_Gennari \"Egidio Gennari\"), Antonio Gramsci, [Ruggero Grieco](/wiki/Ruggero_Grieco \"Ruggero Grieco\") (EC), Anselmo Marabini, [Francesco Misiano](/wiki/Francesco_Misiano \"Francesco Misiano\"), Giovanni Parodi, Luigi Polano, Luigi Repossi (EC), Cesare Sessa, Ludovico Tarsia, and Umberto Terracini (EC).",
"Since its formation, the party strived to organise itself on some bases that were not a mere reproduction of the traditional parties' bases. It then took again some arguments that distinguished the battle within the PSI, namely the idea that it is necessary to form an environment fiercely hostile to bourgeois society and that is an anticipation of the future socialist society. The purpose of this was not considered utopian because already in this society, especially in production, some structures are born on future results. In the first years of the PCd'I, there was no official leader; the accepted leader, first of the faction/tendency and then of the party, was Bordiga (Left) of the [communist left](/wiki/Communist_left \"Communist left\") current. Leaders of the minority currents were Angelo Tasca (Right) and Gramsci (Centre).",
"### Conflict between factions",
"As a territorial section of Comintern, the PCd'I adopted the same program, the same conception of the party and the same tactics adopted by the II Congress in [Moscow](/wiki/Moscow \"Moscow\") of 1920\\. The official program, drawn up in ten points, began with the intrinsically catastrophic nature of the capitalist system and terminated with the extinction of the state. It follows in a synthetic way the model outlined by Lenin for the [Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)](/wiki/Russian_Communist_Party_%28Bolsheviks%29 \"Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)\"). For a while, this identity resisted, but the fast progress of the reaction in Europe produced a change of tactics in a democratic direction within the Bolshevik party and consequently within the Comintern. This happened in particular regarding the possibility, previously opposed, of an alliance with the social democratic and bourgeois parties. This provoked a tension in the party between the majority (Left) and the minority factions (the Right and the Centre) supported by the Comintern. The proposals of the Left were no longer accepted and the conflict between the factions became irremediable.",
"### Bolshevisation",
"[thumb\\|150px\\|[Antonio Gramsci](/wiki/Antonio_Gramsci \"Antonio Gramsci\")](/wiki/File:Gramsci.png \"Gramsci.png\")",
"In 1923, some members of the party were arrested and put on trial for \"conspiracy against the State\". This allowed the intense activity of the Communist International to deprive the party's left\\-wing of authority and give control to the minority centre which had aligned with Moscow. In 1924–1925, the Comintern began a campaign of [Bolshevisation](/wiki/Bolshevisation \"Bolshevisation\"), which forced each party to conform to the discipline and orders of Moscow. During the clandestine conference held in Como to ratify the party leadership in May 1924, 35 of the 45 federation secretaries, plus the secretary of the youth federation, voted for Bordiga's Left, four for Gramsci's Centre, and five for Tasca's Right.",
"Before the Lyon Congress in 1926, the Centre won almost all the votes in the absence of much of the Left, who were unable to attend as a result of fascist controls and lack of Comintern support. Recourse to the Comintern against this evident manoeuvre had little effect. The PCd'I as conceived by the Left terminated. The organisation continued with the support of the Comintern and a new structure and leadership. In 1922, the newspaper *[L'Ordine Nuovo](/wiki/L%27Ordine_Nuovo \"L'Ordine Nuovo\")* was closed and in 1924 a new Centre newspaper, *[l'Unità](/wiki/L%27Unit%C3%A0 \"L'Unità\")*, edited by Gramsci, was founded. The Left continued as a faction, principally functioning in exile. It published the newspaper *Bilan*, a monthly theoretical bulletin.",
"In 1926, Bordiga and Gramsci were arrested and imprisoned on the island of [Ustica](/wiki/Ustica \"Ustica\"). In 1927, [Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti \"Palmiro Togliatti\") was elected secretary in place of Gramsci. In 1930, Bordiga was expelled from the Comintern and accused of [Trotskyism](/wiki/Trotskyism \"Trotskyism\"). After [Joseph Stalin](/wiki/Joseph_Stalin \"Joseph Stalin\") dissolved the Communist International in 1943, the exiled members of the PCd'I in Moscow changed the party's name to the PCI on 15 May. Under this name, it reorganised in Italy and became a parliamentary party after the fall of Fascism.",
"### Resistance to fascism",
"The party and its militants were actively involved in the resistance to [Benito Mussolini](/wiki/Benito_Mussolini \"Benito Mussolini\")'s regime through clandestine action. They were well prepared for clandestine activity because of the structure of their organisation, and the fact that they had been victims of systematic repression by the authorities; more than three quarters of the political prisoners between 1926 and 1943 were communists. Throughout the dictatorship, the party was able to maintain and feed a clandestine network, distribute propaganda leaflets and newspapers, and infiltrate fascist unions and youth organisations. In 1935, the party led a campaign against the [Second Italo\\-Ethiopian War](/wiki/Second_Italo-Ethiopian_War \"Second Italo-Ethiopian War\").{{cite book\\|last1\\=Sabbatucci\\|first1\\=Giovanni\\|last2\\=Vidotto\\|first2\\=Vittorio\\|date\\=2008\\|title\\=Storia contemporanea. Il Novecento\\|publisher\\=Editori Laterza\\|isbn\\=978\\-8\\-8420\\-8742\\-7}} The party and communist partisans, among others, then went on to play a major role in the resistance movement that led to the [fall of the Fascist regime in Italy](/wiki/Fall_of_the_Fascist_regime_in_Italy \"Fall of the Fascist regime in Italy\").",
"On 15 May 1943, the party changed its official name to the Italian Communist Party (*Partito Comunista Italiano*), often shortened to PCI. This change was not surprising as PCI started being used as the party's acronym around 1924–1925\\. This name change also reflected a change in the Comintern's role—it increasingly became a federation of national communist parties. This trend accelerated after Lenin's death and its new name emphasised the party's shift from an international focus to an Italian one. At the time, it was a hotly contested issue for the two major factions of the party. On one side, the Leninist preferred the single world party as it was internationalist and strongly centralised, while on the other side the Italians wanted a party more tailored to their nation's peculiarities and more autonomy.",
"After the fall of [Fascist Italy](/wiki/Fascist_Italy_%281922%E2%80%931943%29 \"Fascist Italy (1922–1943)\") on 25 July 1943, the PCI returned to a formally legal status, playing a major role during the national liberation, known in Italy as *[Resistenza](/wiki/Resistenza \"Resistenza\")* (Resistance) and forming many partisan groups. In April 1944, after the *Svolta di Salerno* ([Salerno](/wiki/Salerno \"Salerno\")'s turning point), Togliatti, who had returned to Italy the month prior after 18 years of exile,{{cite book\\|last\\=Agosti\\|first\\=Aldo\\|date\\=2012\\|chapter\\=Les baleines du corset. Togliatti, le PCI et les intellectuels (1944–1947\\)\\|editor\\-last1\\=Bechelloni\\|editor\\-first1\\=Antonio\\|editor\\-last2\\=Del Vento\\|editor\\-first2\\=Christian\\|editor\\-last3\\=Tabet\\|editor\\-first3\\=Xavier\\|title\\=La vie intellectuelle entre fascisme et République 1940–1948\\|language\\=fr\\|issue\\=12\\|publisher\\=ENS éditions\\|pages\\=17–32\\|doi\\=10\\.4000/laboratoireitalien.633\\|isbn\\=978\\-2\\-8478\\-8382\\-4}} agreed to cooperate with [King Victor Emmanuel III](/wiki/King_Victor_Emmanuel_III \"King Victor Emmanuel III\") and his [prime minister of Italy](/wiki/Prime_minister_of_Italy \"Prime minister of Italy\"), the Marshal [Pietro Badoglio](/wiki/Pietro_Badoglio \"Pietro Badoglio\"). After the turn, the PCI took part in every government during the national liberation and constitutional period from June 1944 to May 1947\\.{{cite book\\|last1\\=Cervi\\|first1\\=Mario\\|last2\\=Montanelli\\|first2\\=Indro\\|date\\=2003\\|title\\=Storia d'Italia\\|language\\=it\\|publisher\\=Rcs Quotidiani}} Their contribution to the new Italian democratic constitution was decisive. The Gullo decrees of 1944, named after [Fausto Gullo](/wiki/Fausto_Gullo \"Fausto Gullo\"), sought to improve social and economic conditions in the countryside.{{cite book\\|last\\=Ginsborg\\|first\\=Paul\\|date\\=2003\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\\&dq\\=Communist\\+Gullo\\+decrees\\+july\\+1944\\+land\\+reform\\&pg\\=PA60\\|title\\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\\|edition\\=illustrated\\|publisher\\=Palgrave Macmillan\\|page\\=60\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-4039\\-6153\\-2}} During Badoglio and [Ferruccio Parri](/wiki/Ferruccio_Parri \"Ferruccio Parri\")'s cabinets, Togliatti served as the [Deputy Prime Minister of Italy](/wiki/Deputy_Prime_Minister_of_Italy \"Deputy Prime Minister of Italy\"). During the Resistance, the PCI became increasingly popular, as the majority of partisans were communists. The [Garibaldi Brigades](/wiki/Garibaldi_Brigades \"Garibaldi Brigades\"), promoted by the PCI, were among the more numerous partisan forces.{{cite book\\|last\\=Bianchi\\|first\\=Giovanni\\|date\\=\\|chapter\\=La Resistenza\\|editor\\-last\\=Montanelli\\|editor\\-first\\=Indro\\|title\\=Storia d'Italia\\|language\\=it\\|volume\\=8\\|page\\=368}}",
"### Post\\-war years",
"The PCI took part in the [1946 Italian general election](/wiki/1946_Italian_general_election \"1946 Italian general election\") and the [1946 Italian institutional referendum](/wiki/1946_Italian_institutional_referendum \"1946 Italian institutional referendum\"), campaigning for a republic. In the election, the PCI was third, behind [Christian Democracy](/wiki/Christian_Democracy_%28Italy%29 \"Christian Democracy (Italy)\") (DC) and the PSI, gaining almost 19% of votes and electing 104 members of the [Constituent Assembly of Italy](/wiki/Constituent_Assembly_of_Italy \"Constituent Assembly of Italy\").{{cite web\\|url\\=https://elezionistorico.interno.gov.it/index.php?tpel\\=A\\&dtel\\=02/06/1946\\&tpa\\=I\\&tpe\\=A\\&lev0\\=0\\&levsut0\\=0\\&es0\\=S\\&ms\\=S\\|title\\=Assemblea costituente 02/06/1946\\|language\\=it\\|publisher\\=Italian Ministry of the Interior\\|access\\-date\\=3 July 2023}} The popular referendum resulted in the replacement of the monarchy with a republic,{{cite web\\|url\\=https://elezionistorico.interno.gov.it/index.php?tpel\\=F\\&dtel\\=02/06/1946\\&tpa\\=I\\&tpe\\=A\\&lev0\\=0\\&levsut0\\=0\\&es0\\=S\\&ms\\=S\\|title\\=Referendum 02/06/1946\\|language\\=it\\|publisher\\=Italian Ministry of the Interior\\|access\\-date\\=3 July 2023}} after 54% of the votes were in favour and 46% against.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.sturzo.it/edu/l\\-italia\\-repubblicana\\-e\\-gli\\-anni\\-dello\\-sviluppo/445\\-1\\-la\\-fondazione\\-dell\\-italia\\-repubblicana/612\\-il\\-referendum\\-istituzionale\\-e\\-la\\-scelta\\-repubblicana \\|title\\=Il referendum istituzionale e la scelta repubblicana \\|publisher\\=Luigi Sturzo Institute \\|language\\=it\\| access\\-date\\=8 December 2016 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180305171243/http://www.sturzo.it/edu/l\\-italia\\-repubblicana\\-e\\-gli\\-anni\\-dello\\-sviluppo/445\\-1\\-la\\-fondazione\\-dell\\-italia\\-repubblicana/612\\-il\\-referendum\\-istituzionale\\-e\\-la\\-scelta\\-repubblicana \\|archive\\-date\\=5 March 2018 \\|url\\-status\\=dead }}{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.simone.it/newdiz/newdiz.php?action\\=view\\&id\\=1011\\&index\\=H\\&dizionario\\=2\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|title\\=Savoia\\|website\\=Dizionari Simone Online\\|access\\-date\\=12 November 2019\\|archive\\-date\\=7 July 2018\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20180707230422/https://www.simone.it/newdiz/newdiz.php?action\\=view\\&id\\=1011\\&index\\=H\\&dizionario\\=2}} [Luciano Canfora](/wiki/Luciano_Canfora \"Luciano Canfora\") saw the Salerno Turn and 1944 as a rebirth of the PCI, and said \"the PCI had gradually followed a path which required it, as a historical task, to occupy the space of social democracy in the Italian political panorama.\"{{cite news\\|last\\=Fai\\|first\\=Paolo\\|date\\=1 February 2021\\|url\\=https://www.laterza.it/wp\\-content/uploads/recensioni/CANFORA\\-9\\.pdf\\|title\\=Il Pci rifondato da Togliatti si perde nel berlinguerismo\\|work\\=La Terza\\|page\\=12\\|access\\-date\\=5 July 2023}}",
"As part of the [May 1947 crises](/wiki/May_1947_crises \"May 1947 crises\"), the PCI was excluded from government. [Alcide De Gasperi](/wiki/Alcide_De_Gasperi \"Alcide De Gasperi\"), the DC leader and prime minister of Italy, was losing popularity, and feared that the [leftist](/wiki/Leftist \"Leftist\") coalition would take power. While the PCI was growing particularly fast due to its organising efforts supporting sharecroppers in [Sicily](/wiki/Sicily \"Sicily\"), [Tuscany](/wiki/Tuscany \"Tuscany\"), and [Umbria](/wiki/Umbria \"Umbria\"), movements that were also bolstered by the reforms of [Fausto Gullo](/wiki/Fausto_Gullo \"Fausto Gullo\"), the [Italian Minister of Agriculture](/wiki/Italian_Minister_of_Agriculture \"Italian Minister of Agriculture\").{{cite book\\|last\\=Ginsborg\\|first\\=Paul\\|date\\=2003\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\\&q\\=may\\+1947\\|title\\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\\|edition\\=illustrated\\|publisher\\=Palgrave Macmillan\\|pages\\=106–113\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-4039\\-6153\\-2}} On 1 May, the nation was thrown into crisis by the [Portella della Ginestra massacre](/wiki/Portella_della_Ginestra_massacre \"Portella della Ginestra massacre\"), in which eleven leftist peasants (including four children) were murdered at an [International Workers' Day](/wiki/International_Workers%27_Day \"International Workers' Day\") parade in [Palermo](/wiki/Palermo \"Palermo\") by [Salvatore Giuliano](/wiki/Salvatore_Giuliano \"Salvatore Giuliano\") and his gang. In the political chaos that ensued, the United States government engineered the expulsion of all left\\-wing ministers from the cabinet on 31 May. The PCI would not have a national position in government again. De Gasperi did this under pressure from the United States Secretary of State, [George Marshall](/wiki/George_Marshall \"George Marshall\"), who had informed him that [anti\\-communism](/wiki/Anti-communism \"Anti-communism\") was a pre\\-condition for receiving American aid,{{cite book\\|last\\=Ciment\\|first\\=James\\|date\\=2015\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=cpCXBwAAQBAJ\\|title\\=Encyclopedia of Conflicts Since World War II\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|page\\=\\[https://books.google.com/books?id\\=cpCXBwAAQBAJ\\&q\\=forced\\+de\\+Gasperi\\+to\\+remove\\+the\\+Socialists\\+and\\+Communists\\+from\\+the\\+government\\+as\\+a\\+condition\\+of\\+receiving\\+U.S.\\+aid\\&pg\\=PT2073 2073]\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-3174\\-7185\\-1}} and Ambassador [James Clement Dunn](/wiki/James_Clement_Dunn \"James Clement Dunn\"), who had directly asked de Gasperi to dissolve the parliament and remove the PCI.{{cite book\\|last\\=Corke\\|first\\=Sarah\\-Jane\\|date\\=2007\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=FKN8AgAAQBAJ\\&q\\=James\\+C.\\+Dunn\\+asked.\\+1947\\&pg\\=PA232\\|title\\=US Covert Operations and Cold War Strategy: Truman, Secret Warfare and the CIA, 1945–53\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-1341\\-0413\\-0\\|pages\\=47–48}}{{cite news\\|last\\=Stazi\\|first\\=Guido\\|date\\=30 October 2021\\|url\\=https://www.milanofinanza.it/news/sessanta\\-anni\\-senza\\-einaudi\\-il\\-governatore\\-che\\-da\\-chigi\\-sali\\-al\\-colle\\-202110301157412373\\|title\\=Sessanta anni senza Einaudi, il governatore che da Chigi salì al Colle\\|work\\=MF Milano Finanza\\|language\\=it\\|access\\-date\\=8 July 2023\\|quote\\=Einaudi annotava nel suo Diario di una cena a casa dell'Ambasciatore d'Italia in Unione Sovietica Quaroni, in cui si conveniva che gli Stati Uniti gli aiuti veri non li avrebbero concessi con i comunisti ancora al governo.\\|trans\\-quote\\=Einaudi noted in his Diary of a dinner at the home of the Italian Ambassador to the Soviet Union Quaroni, in which it was agreed that the United States would not grant real aid with the Communists still in government.}}",
"In the [1948 Italian general election](/wiki/1948_Italian_general_election \"1948 Italian general election\"), the party joined the PSI in the [Popular Democratic Front](/wiki/Popular_Democratic_Front_%28Italy%29 \"Popular Democratic Front (Italy)\") (FDP) but was defeated by the DC. The United States government provided support to anti\\-PCI groups in the election,{{cite book\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=ejrgDj\\-SYiUC\\&pg\\=PA140\\|title\\=Confronting America: The Cold War between the United States and the Communists in France and Italy\\|last\\=Brogi\\|first\\=Alessandro\\|date\\=2011\\|publisher\\=UNC Press Books\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-8078\\-7774\\-6\\|pages\\=140–149}} and argued that should the PCI win, the [Marshall Plan](/wiki/Marshall_Plan \"Marshall Plan\") and other aids could be terminated. It spent $10–20 million on anti\\-communist propaganda and other covert operations, much of it through the [Economic Cooperation Administration](/wiki/Economic_Cooperation_Administration \"Economic Cooperation Administration\") of the Marshall Plan, and then laundered through individual banks.{{cite book\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=FKN8AgAAQBAJ\\&pg\\=PA54\\|title\\=US Covert Operations and Cold War Strategy: Truman, Secret Warfare and the CIA, 1945–53\\|last\\=Corke\\|first\\=Sarah\\-Jane\\|date\\=2007\\|publisher\\=Routledge\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-1341\\-0413\\-0\\|pages\\=49–58}} Fearful of the possible FDP's electoral victory, the British and American governments also undermined their campaign for legal justice by tolerating the efforts made by Italy's top authorities to prevent any of the alleged [Italian war criminals](/wiki/Italian_war_criminals \"Italian war criminals\") from being extradited and taken to court.{{cite news\\|last\\=Carroll\\|first\\=Rory\\|date\\=25 June 2001\\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/education/2001/jun/25/artsandhumanities.highereducation\\|title\\=Italy's bloody secret\\|work\\=The Guardian\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20130716012326/http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/2001/jun/25/artsandhumanities.highereducation\\|archive\\-date\\=16 July 2013\\|access\\-date\\=3 July 2023}}{{cite journal\\|last\\=Pedaliu\\|first\\=Effie\\|author\\-link\\=Effie Pedaliu\\|date\\=2004\\|title\\=Britain and the 'Hand\\-over' of Italian War Criminals to Yugoslavia, 1945–48\\|journal\\=Journal of Contemporary History\\|volume\\=39\\|issue\\=4, Special Issue: Collective Memory\\|pages\\=503–529\\|doi\\=10\\.1177/0022009404046752 \\|jstor\\=4141408\\|s2cid\\=159985182 }} The denial of Italian war crimes was backed up by the Italian state, academe, and media, re\\-inventing Italy as only a victim of [Nazism](/wiki/Nazism \"Nazism\") and the post\\-war [Foibe massacres](/wiki/Foibe_massacres \"Foibe massacres\").",
"The party gained considerable electoral success during the following years and occasionally supplied external support to the [Organic centre\\-left](/wiki/Organic_centre-left \"Organic centre-left\") governments, although it never directly joined a government. It successfully lobbied [Fiat](/wiki/Fiat \"Fiat\") to set up the [AvtoVAZ](/wiki/AvtoVAZ \"AvtoVAZ\") (Lada) car factory in the [Soviet Union](/wiki/Soviet_Union \"Soviet Union\") (1966\\). The party did best in [Emilia\\-Romagna](/wiki/Emilia-Romagna \"Emilia-Romagna\"), Tuscany, and Umbria, where it regularly won the local administrative elections, and in some of the industrialised cities of [Northern Italy](/wiki/Northern_Italy \"Northern Italy\"). At the city government level during the course of the post\\-war period, the PCI demonstrated in cities like [Bologna](/wiki/Bologna \"Bologna\") and [Florence](/wiki/Florence \"Florence\") their capacity for uncorrupt, efficient and clean government.{{cite book\\|last\\=Robertson\\|first\\=David\\|date\\=1993\\|title\\=The Penguin Dictionary of Politics\\|edition\\=2nd\\|publisher\\=Penguin\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-1405\\-1276\\-2}} After the [1975 Italian local elections](/wiki/1975_Italian_local_elections \"1975 Italian local elections\"), the PCI was the strongest force in nearly all of the municipal councils of the great cities.{{cite book\\|last\\=Ginsborg\\|first\\=Paul\\|date\\=2003\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=cnGQBAAAQBAJ\\&pg\\=PA372\\|title\\=A History of Contemporary Italy: Society and Politics, 1943–1988\\|edition\\=illustrated\\|publisher\\=Palgrave Macmillan\\|page\\=372\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-4039\\-6153\\-2}}",
"### From the 1950s to the 1960s",
"[thumb\\|150px\\|[Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti \"Palmiro Togliatti\")](/wiki/File:Palmiro_Togliatti_Official.jpg \"Palmiro Togliatti Official.jpg\")",
"The Soviet Union's brutal suppression of the [Hungarian Revolution of 1956](/wiki/Hungarian_Revolution_of_1956 \"Hungarian Revolution of 1956\") created a split within the PCI.{{cite web\\|last\\=Romeo\\|first\\=Ilaria\\|date\\=30 October 2022\\|url\\=https://www.collettiva.it/copertine/internazionale/2022/10/30/news/ungheria\\-2454619/\\|title\\=1956: dopo la repressione sovietica in Ungheria, i contrasti e le rotture all'interno del Pci\\|website\\=Collettiva\\|language\\=it\\|access\\-date\\=17 July 2023}} The party leadership, including [Palmiro Togliatti](/wiki/Palmiro_Togliatti \"Palmiro Togliatti\") and [Giorgio Napolitano](/wiki/Giorgio_Napolitano \"Giorgio Napolitano\") (who in 2006 became [President of Italy](/wiki/President_of_Italy \"President of Italy\")), regarded the Hungarian insurgents as counter\\-revolutionaries as reported at the time in *[l'Unità](/wiki/L%27Unit%C3%A0 \"L'Unità\")*, the official PCI newspaper. [Giuseppe Di Vittorio](/wiki/Giuseppe_Di_Vittorio \"Giuseppe Di Vittorio\"), chief of the communist trade union [Italian General Confederation of Labour](/wiki/Italian_General_Confederation_of_Labour \"Italian General Confederation of Labour\") (CGIL), repudiated the leadership position, as did prominent party member [Antonio Giolitti](/wiki/Antonio_Giolitti \"Antonio Giolitti\") and [Italian Socialist Party](/wiki/Italian_Socialist_Party \"Italian Socialist Party\") national secretary [Pietro Nenni](/wiki/Pietro_Nenni \"Pietro Nenni\"), a close ally of the PCI. Napolitano later hinted at doubts over the propriety of his decision.{{citation\\|date\\=October–December 1980\\|title\\=The Italian Communists: Foreign Bulletin of the P.C.I.\\|issue\\=4\\|location\\=Rome\\|page\\=103}}. He would eventually write in *From the Communist Party to European Socialism. A Political Autobiography* (*Dal Pci al socialismo europeo. Un'autobiografia politica*) that he regretted his justification of the Soviet intervention but quieted his concerns at the time for the sake of party unity and the international leadership of [Soviet Communism](/wiki/Soviet_Communism \"Soviet Communism\").{{cite book\\|last\\=Napolitano\\|first\\=Giorgio\\|year\\=2005\\|title\\=Dal Pci al socialismo europeo. Un'autobiografia politica\\|publisher\\=Laterza\\|language\\=it\\|isbn\\=978\\-8\\-8420\\-7715\\-2}} Giolitti and Nenni went on to split with the PCI over this issue. Napolitano became a leading member of the *[miglioristi](/wiki/Miglioristi \"Miglioristi\")* faction within the PCI that promoted a [social\\-democratic](/wiki/Social-democratic \"Social-democratic\") direction in party policy.{{cite web\\|last\\=Cacace\\|first\\=Paolo\\|date\\=15 May 2006\\|title\\=Napolitano e l'{{'}}utopia mite' dell'Europa\\|url\\=http://www.toscanaeuropa.it/att\\_politica/documenti/dettaglio.asp?id\\_doc\\=4451\\|access\\-date\\=14 July 2007\\|language\\=it\\|url\\-status\\=dead\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20070929010907/http://www.toscanaeuropa.it/att\\_politica/documenti/dettaglio.asp?id\\_doc\\=4451\\|archive\\-date\\=29 September 2007}}",
"In the mid\\-1960s, the [United States Department of State](/wiki/United_States_Department_of_State \"United States Department of State\") estimated the party membership to be approximately 1,350,000, or 4\\.2% of the working age population, making it the largest Communist party in per capita terms in the capitalist world at the time and the largest party at all in the whole of Western Europe with the [Social Democratic Party of Germany](/wiki/Social_Democratic_Party_of_Germany \"Social Democratic Party of Germany\").{{cite journal\\|last1\\=Kautsky\\|first1\\=John H.\\|last2\\=Benjamin\\|first2\\=Roger W.\\|date\\=March 1968\\|title\\=Communism and Economic Development\\|journal\\=American Political Science Review\\|volume\\=62\\|issue\\=1\\|page\\=122\\|jstor\\=1953329}} United States government sources said that the party was receiving $40–50 million per year from the Soviets when their investment in Italy was $5–6 million.{{cite video\\|people\\=Carl Colby (director)\\|date\\=September 2011\\|title\\=The Man Nobody Knew: In Search of My Father, CIA Spymaster Ashley Colby\\|url\\=http://firstrunfeatures.com/themannobodyknew/\\|medium\\=Motion picture\\|publisher\\=Act 4 Entertainment\\|location\\=New York City\\|access\\-date\\=15 September 2011\\|quote\\=Edward Luttwak, interview: \"\\[W]e estimated at the time they were getting $40–50 million a year at a time when we were putting $5–6 million into Italian politics.\\|ref\\=15 September 2011}} Although the PCI relied on Soviet financial assistance more than any other Communist party supported by Moscow, declassified information shows this to be exaggerated.{{cite journal\\|last\\=Drake\\|first\\=Richard\\|date\\=Summer 2004\\|title\\=The Soviet Dimension of Italian Communism\\|journal\\=Journal of Cold War Studies\\|volume\\=6\\|issue\\=3\\|pages\\=115–119\\|doi\\=10\\.1162/1520397041447355 \\|jstor\\=26925390\\|s2cid\\=57564743 }}",
"According to the former [KGB](/wiki/KGB \"KGB\") archivist [Vasili Mitrokhin](/wiki/Vasili_Mitrokhin \"Vasili Mitrokhin\"), Longo and other PCI leaders became alarmed at the possibility of a coup in Italy after the Athens Colonel coup in April 1967 that led to the [Greek junta](/wiki/Greek_junta \"Greek junta\"). These fears were not completely unfounded as there had been two attempted coups in Italy, [Piano Solo](/wiki/Piano_Solo \"Piano Solo\") in 1964 and [Golpe Borghese](/wiki/Golpe_Borghese \"Golpe Borghese\") in 1970, by military and [neo\\-fascist](/wiki/Neo-fascist \"Neo-fascist\") groups. The PCI's [Giorgio Amendola](/wiki/Giorgio_Amendola \"Giorgio Amendola\") formally requested Soviet assistance to prepare the party in case of such an event. The KGB drew up and implemented a plan to provide the PCI with its own intelligence and clandestine signal corps. From 1967 through 1973, PCI members were sent to [East Germany](/wiki/East_Germany \"East Germany\") and Moscow to receive training in clandestine warfare and information gathering techniques by both the [Stasi](/wiki/Stasi \"Stasi\") and the KGB. Shortly before the [1972 Italian general election](/wiki/1972_Italian_general_election \"1972 Italian general election\"), Longo personally wrote to [Leonid Brezhnev](/wiki/Leonid_Brezhnev \"Leonid Brezhnev\") asking for and receiving an additional $5\\.7 million in funding. This was on top of the $3\\.5 million that the Soviet Union gave the PCI in 1971\\. The Soviets also provided additional funding through the use of [front organisations](/wiki/Front_organisations \"Front organisations\") providing generous contracts to PCI members.{{cite book\\|last1\\=Andrew\\|first1\\=Christopher\\|last2\\=Mitrokhin\\|first2\\=Vasili\\|date\\=2001\\|title\\=The Sword and the Shield: The Mitrokhin Archive and the Secret History of the KGB\\|publisher\\=Basic Books}}",
"### Leadership of Enrico Berlinguer",
"[thumb\\|150px\\|[Enrico Berlinguer](/wiki/Enrico_Berlinguer \"Enrico Berlinguer\")](/wiki/File:Enrico_Berlinguer.jpg \"Enrico Berlinguer.jpg\")",
"In 1969, [Enrico Berlinguer](/wiki/Enrico_Berlinguer \"Enrico Berlinguer\"), the PCI deputy national secretary and later secretary general, took part in the international conference of the communist parties in Moscow, where his delegation disagreed with the official political line and refused to support the final report. Unexpectedly to his hosts, his speech challenged the communist leadership in Moscow. He refused to excommunicate the [Chinese Communist Party](/wiki/Chinese_Communist_Party \"Chinese Communist Party\") and directly told Brezhnev that the [Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia](/wiki/Warsaw_Pact_invasion_of_Czechoslovakia \"Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia\"), which he called \"the tragedy in Prague\", had made clear the considerable differences within the communist movement on fundamental questions, such as national sovereignty, socialist democracy, and the freedom of culture. At the time, the PCI, which had absorbed the PSI's left\\-wing, the [Italian Socialist Party of Proletarian Unity](/wiki/Italian_Socialist_Party_of_Proletarian_Unity \"Italian Socialist Party of Proletarian Unity\"), so strengthening its leadership over the Italian left, was the largest communist party in a [capitalist state](/wiki/Capitalist_state \"Capitalist state\"), garnering 34\\.4% of the vote in the [1976 Italian general election](/wiki/1976_Italian_general_election \"1976 Italian general election\").",
"Relationships between the PCI and the Soviet Union gradually fell apart as the party moved away from Soviet obedience and [Marxist–Leninist](/wiki/Marxist%E2%80%93Leninist \"Marxist–Leninist\") orthodoxy in the 1970s and 1980s and toward [Eurocommunism](/wiki/Eurocommunism \"Eurocommunism\") and the [Socialist International](/wiki/Socialist_International \"Socialist International\"). The PCI sought a collaboration with the socialist and Christian democracy parties, a policy known the [Historic Compromise](/wiki/Historic_Compromise \"Historic Compromise\"). The [kidnapping and murder of Aldo Moro](/wiki/Kidnapping_and_murder_of_Aldo_Moro \"Kidnapping and murder of Aldo Moro\"), the DC leader, by the [Red Brigades](/wiki/Red_Brigades \"Red Brigades\") in May 1978 put an end to any hopes of such a compromise. The compromise was largely abandoned as a PCI policy in 1981\\. The [Proletarian Unity Party](/wiki/Proletarian_Unity_Party_%28Italy%29 \"Proletarian Unity Party (Italy)\") merged into the PCI in 1984\\.",
"During the [Years of Lead](/wiki/Years_of_Lead_%28Italy%29 \"Years of Lead (Italy)\"), the PCI strongly opposed the terrorism and the Red Brigades, who in turn murdered or wounded many PCI members or trade unionists close to the PCI. According to Mitrokhin, the party asked the Soviets to pressure the [StB](/wiki/StB \"StB\"), Czechoslovakia's State Security, to withdraw their support to the group, which Moscow was unable or unwilling to do. This, along with the [Soviet invasion of Afghanistan](/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Afghanistan \"Soviet invasion of Afghanistan\"), led to a complete break with Moscow in 1979\\. In 1980, the PCI refused to participate in the international conference of Communist parties in Paris; cash payments to the PCI continued until 1984\\.",
"### Dissolution",
"[Achille Occhetto](/wiki/Achille_Occhetto \"Achille Occhetto\") became general secretary of the PCI in 1988\\. At a 1989 conference in a working\\-class section of Bologna, Occhetto stunned the party faithful with a speech heralding the [Revolutions of 1989](/wiki/Revolutions_of_1989 \"Revolutions of 1989\"), a move now referred to in Italian politics as the *svolta della Bolognina* (Bolognina turning point). The collapse of the Communist governments in the Eastern Europe led Occhetto to conclude that the era of Eurocommunism was over. Under his leadership, the PCI dissolved and refounded itself as the [Democratic Party of the Left](/wiki/Democratic_Party_of_the_Left \"Democratic Party of the Left\"), which branded itself as a progressive left\\-wing and [democratic socialist](/wiki/Democratic_socialist \"Democratic socialist\") party.{{cite book\\|last\\=Ignazi\\|first\\=Pietro\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=\\-\\-6NAAAAMAAJ\\|title\\=Dal PCI al PDS\\|editor\\=Il mulino\\|date\\=1992\\|publisher\\=Il mulino \\|isbn\\=978\\-8\\-8150\\-3413\\-7}}{{cite book\\|last1\\=Bellucci\\|first1\\=Paolo\\|last2\\=Maraffi\\|first2\\=Marco\\|last3\\=Segatti\\|first3\\=Paolo\\|url\\=https://books.google.com/books?id\\=ghGg\\_mV\\_iY8C\\|title\\=PCI, PDS, DS: la trasformazione dell'identità politica della sinistra di governo\\|editor\\=Donzelli\\|date\\=2000\\|publisher\\=Donzelli Editore \\|isbn\\=978\\-8\\-8798\\-9547\\-7}} A third of the PCI membership, led by [Armando Cossutta](/wiki/Armando_Cossutta \"Armando Cossutta\"), refused to join the PDS, and instead seceded to form the [Communist Refoundation Party](/wiki/Communist_Refoundation_Party \"Communist Refoundation Party\").{{cite book\\|last\\=Kertzer\\|first\\=David I.\\|title\\=Politics and Symbols: The Italian Communist Party and the Fall of Communism\\|publisher\\=Yale University Press\\|year\\=1998\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-3000\\-7724\\-7}}",
""
] |
Concerns, litigation, and regulations in specific countries and regions
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
### Arctic
In 2024, research at [McGill University](/wiki/McGill_University "McGill University") in Quebec,Léandri\-Breton, Don\-Jean, et al., *[Winter Tracking Data Suggest that Migratory Seabirds Transport Per\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances to Their Arctic Nesting Site](https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.est.4c02661)*, ACS Publications, July 11, 2024 indicated that PFASs were being brought to the Arctic from polluted southern waters by migrating birds.von Herff, William, *[Migrating Seabirds Are Bringing Forever Chemicals Into the Arctic](https://hakaimagazine.com/news/migrating-seabirds-are-bringing-forever-chemicals-into-the-arctic/)*, [Hakai Magazine](/wiki/Hakai_Magazine "Hakai Magazine"), October 4, 2024 Although it is much less than compared to the introduction by wind and the oceans, the birds become vectors, transmitting the toxic chemicals. Rainer Lohmann, an oceanographer at the [University of Rhode Island](/wiki/University_of_Rhode_Island "University of Rhode Island"), noted that this has a significant localized affect that is devastating for Arctic predators who accumulate toxins in their bodies because the contaminants from the birds often enter the food chain directly since the birds are the prey of many species.
### Australia
In 2017, the [ABC](/wiki/Australian_Broadcasting_Corporation "Australian Broadcasting Corporation")'s current affairs program [*Four Corners*](/wiki/Four_Corners_%28Australian_TV_program%29 "Four Corners (Australian TV program)") reported that the storage and use of firefighting foams containing perfluorinated surfactants at [Australian Defence Force](/wiki/Australian_Defence_Force "Australian Defence Force") facilities around Australia had contaminated nearby water resources.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017\-10\-10/pfas\-chemicals\-katherine\-residents\-shocked\-demand\-action/9034504 \|title\='Shocked and disgusted' Katherine residents demand action on PFAS contamination \| work\=\[\[Australian Broadcasting Corporation]] \|date\=October 10, 2017 \|archive\-date\=October 10, 2017\|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20171010073127/http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017\-10\-10/pfas\-chemicals\-katherine\-residents\-shocked\-demand\-action/9034504\|url\-status\=live}} In 2019, remediation efforts at [RAAF Base Tindal](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Tindal "RAAF Base Tindal") and the adjacent town of Katherine were ongoing.{{cite news \|url\=https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/6527835/tindals\-pfas\-hot\-spots\-record\-startling\-results/ \|title\=Tindal's PFAS hot spots record startling results \| first\=Chris \| last\=McLennan \| work\=Katherine Times \| date\=December 4, 2019 \| archive\-date\=February 21, 2020 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200221111934/https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/6527835/tindals\-pfas\-hot\-spots\-record\-startling\-results/ \| url\-status\=live}} In the 2022 [Australian federal budget](/wiki/Australian_federal_budget "Australian federal budget") $428{{nbsp}}million was allocated for works at [HMAS *Albatross*](/wiki/HMAS_Albatross_%28air_station%29 "HMAS Albatross (air station)"), [RAAF Base Amberley](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Amberley "RAAF Base Amberley"), [RAAF Base Pearce](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Pearce "RAAF Base Pearce") and [RAAF Base Richmond](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Richmond "RAAF Base Richmond") including funding to remediate PFAS contamination.{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/airbases\-to\-get\-428\-million\-upgrade\-as\-government\-switches\-back\-to\-national\-security\-20220421\-p5af77\.html \| first\=Katina \| last\=Curtis \| title\=Airbases to get $428 million upgrade as government switches back to national security \| work\=\[\[The Sydney Morning Herald]] \| date\=April 21, 2022}}
### Canada
Although PFASs are not manufactured in Canada, they may be present in imported goods and products. In 2008, products containing PFOS as well as PFOA were banned in Canada, with exceptions for products used in firefighting, the military, and some forms of ink and photo media.{{cite web \| url\=https://ncceh.ca/resources/blog/keeping\-drinking\-water\-safe\-new\-guidelines\-pfas\-canada \| first\=Juliette \| last\=O'Keeffe \|title\=Keeping Drinking Water Safe: New Guidelines for PFASs in Canada \| website\=National Collaborating Centre for Environmental Health \| archive\-date\=August 7, 2020 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200807233146/https://ncceh.ca/content/blog/keeping\-drinking\-water\-safe\-new\-guidelines\-pfas\-canada \| url\-status\=live}}
Health Canada has published drinking water guidelines for maximum concentrations of PFOS and PFOA to protect the health of Canadians, including children, over a lifetime's exposure to these substances. The maximum allowable concentration for PFOS under the guidelines is 0\.0002 milligrams per liter. The maximum allowable concentration for PFOA is 0\.0006 milligrams per liter.{{cite web \| url\=https://www.canada.ca/en/services/health/publications/healthy\-living/water\-talk\-drinking\-water\-screening\-values\-perfluoroalkylated\-substances.html \| title\=Perfluoroalkylated substances in drinking water \| publisher\=\[\[Government of Canada]] \| date\=April 2019 \| archive\-date\=August 15, 2020 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200815112519/https://www.canada.ca/en/services/health/publications/healthy\-living/water\-talk\-drinking\-water\-screening\-values\-perfluoroalkylated\-substances.html \| url\-status\=live}} In August 2024, Health Canada established an objective of 30 ng/L for the sum of the concentration of 25 PFASs[PFCAs](/wiki/PFCAs "PFCAs"): [C4](/wiki/Perfluorobutanoic_acid "Perfluorobutanoic acid")–C12; [PFSAs](/wiki/PFSAs "PFSAs"): [C4](/wiki/Perfluorobutanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorobutanesulfonic acid")–[C8](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid"); PFECAs: [PFMOPrA](/wiki/d:Q81977241 "Q81977241"), [PFMOBA](/wiki/d:Q81977612 "Q81977612"), [3,6\-OPFHpA](/wiki/d:Q81977557 "Q81977557"), [HFPO\-DA](/wiki/HFPO-DA "HFPO-DA"), [DONA](/wiki/d:Q81981675 "Q81981675"); PFESAs: [6:2 Cl\-PFESA](/wiki/d:Q81982190 "Q81982190"), [8:2 Cl\-PFESA](/wiki/d:Q81982192 "Q81982192"), [PFEESA](/wiki/d:Q81985827 "Q81985827"); FTSs: [4:2 FTS](/wiki/d:Q81981864 "Q81981864"), [6:2 FTS](/wiki/6:2_FTS "2 FTS"), [8:2 FTS](/wiki/d:Q66828157 "Q66828157") detected in drinking water.{{Cite web \|last\= \|first\= \|date\=2024\-08\-09 \|title\=Objective for Canadian drinking water quality per\- and polyfluoroalkyl substances \|url\=https://www.canada.ca/en/health\-canada/services/publications/healthy\-living/objective\-drinking\-water\-quality\-per\-polyfluoroalkyl\-substances.html \|access\-date\=2024\-08\-18 \|website\=www.canada.ca \|publisher\=Health Canada}}
### New Zealand
The New Zealand Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has banned the use of per\- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in cosmetic products starting from 31 December 2026\. This will make the country one of the first in the world to take this step on PFAS to protect people and the environment.{{cite press release \| url\=https://www.epa.govt.nz/news\-and\-alerts/latest\-news/epa\-bans\-forever\-chemicals\-in\-cosmetic\-products/ \| title\=EPA bans 'forever chemicals' in cosmetic products \|publisher\=\[\[Environmental Protection Authority (New Zealand)]] \| date\=30 January 2024}}
### United Kingdom
The environmental consequences of PFAS, especially from firefighting activities, have been recognized since the mid\-1990s and came to prominence after the [Buncefield explosion](/wiki/Buncefield_explosion "Buncefield explosion") on 11 December 2005\. The Environment Agency has undertaken a series of projects to understand the scale and nature of PFAS in the environment. The Drinking Water Inspectorate requires water companies to report concentrations of 47 PFAS.{{Cite web \| url\=https://dwi\-content.s3\.eu\-west\-2\.amazonaws.com/wp\-content/uploads/2021/10/04203217/Information\-Letter\-PFAS\-Monitoring.pdf \| title\=Requirements for PFAS monitoring by water companies in England and Wales \| work\=\[\[Drinking Water Inspectorate]] \| date\=1 October 2021}}
### European Union
Many PFASs are either not covered by European legislation or are excluded from registration obligations under the EU [Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals](/wiki/Registration%2C_Evaluation%2C_Authorisation_and_Restriction_of_Chemicals "Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals") (REACH) chemical regulation.{{cite web \| url\=https://www.env\-health.org/the\-forever\-chemicals\-that\-are\-harming\-our\-health\-pfas/ \|title\=The "forever chemicals" that are harming our health: PFAS \|date\=February 4, 2020 \|website\=Health and Environment Alliance \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200206122946/https://www.env\-health.org/the\-forever\-chemicals\-that\-are\-harming\-our\-health\-pfas/ \| archive\-date\=February 6, 2020 \| url\-status\=live}} Several PFASs have been detected in drinking water,{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Thomaidi VS, Tsahouridou A, Matsoukas C, Stasinakis AS, Petreas M, Kalantzi OI \| title\=Risk assessment of PFASs in drinking water using a probabilistic risk quotient methodology \| journal\=The Science of the Total Environment \| volume\=712 \| pages\=136485 \| date\=April 2020 \| pmid\=31927447 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.scitotenv.2019\.136485 \| bibcode\=2020ScTEn.71236485T \| s2cid\=210167277}} municipal wastewater,{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Arvaniti OS, Stasinakis AS \| title\=Review on the occurrence, fate and removal of perfluorinated compounds during wastewater treatment \| journal\=The Science of the Total Environment \| volume\=524\-525 \| pages\=81–92 \| date\=August 2015 \| pmid\=25889547 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.scitotenv.2015\.04\.023 \| bibcode\=2015ScTEn.524\...81A}} and landfill leachates{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Nika MC, Ntaiou K, Elytis K, Thomaidi VS, Gatidou G, Kalantzi OI, Thomaidis NS, Stasinakis AS \| display\-authors\=6 \| title\=Wide\-scope target analysis of emerging contaminants in landfill leachates and risk assessment using Risk Quotient methodology \| journal\=Journal of Hazardous Materials \| volume\=394 \| pages\=122493 \| date\=July 2020 \| pmid\=32240898 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.jhazmat.2020\.122493 \| bibcode\=2020JHzM..39422493N \| s2cid\=214766390}} worldwide.
In 2019, the [European Council](/wiki/European_Council "European Council") requested the [European Commission](/wiki/European_Commission "European Commission") to develop an action plan to eliminate all non\-essential uses of PFAS due to the growing evidence of adverse effects caused by exposure to these substances; the evidence for the widespread occurrence of PFAS in water, soil, articles, and waste; and the threat it can pose to drinking water.{{cite press release \| website\=\[\[European Council]] \| title\=Council Conclusions on Chemicals \| url\=https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press\-releases/2019/06/26/council\-conclusions\-on\-chemicals/}} Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, and Sweden submitted a so\-called restriction proposal based on the REACH regulation to achieve a European ban on the production, use, sale and import of PFAS.{{cite web \| website\=RIVM \| title\=PFAS \| url\=https://www.rivm.nl/pfas}} The proposal states that a ban is necessary for all use of PFAS, with different periods for different applications when the ban takes effect (immediately after the restriction comes into force, five years afterward, or 12 years afterward), depending on the function and the availability of alternatives. The proposal has not assessed the use of PFAS in medicines, plant protection products, and biocides because specific regulations apply to those substances (Biocidal Products Regulation, [Plant Protection Products Regulation](/wiki/Plant_Protection_Products_Regulation "Plant Protection Products Regulation"), Medicinal Products Regulation) that have an explicit authorization procedure that focuses on risk for health and the environment.
The proposal was submitted on 13 January 2023 and published by the [European Chemicals Agency](/wiki/European_Chemicals_Agency "European Chemicals Agency") (ECHA) on 7 February. From 22 March to 21 September, citizens, companies, and other organizations commented on the proposal during a public consultation.{{cite web \| url\=https://echa.europa.eu/\-/echa\-publishes\-pfas\-restriction\-proposal \| title\=ECHA publishes PFAS restriction proposal \| publisher\=\[\[European Chemicals Agency]]}} Based on the information in the restriction proposal and the consultation, two committees from ECHA formulate an opinion on the risk and socio\-economic aspects of the proposed restriction. Within a year of publication, the opinions are sent to the European Commission, which makes a final proposal that is submitted to the EU Member States for discussion and decision.{{cite web \| url\=https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/reach/restrictions/restriction\-procedure \| title\=Restriction procedure \| publisher\=\[\[European Chemicals Agency]]}} Eighteen months after the publication of the restriction decision (which may differ from the original proposal), it will enter into force.
### Italy
127,000 residents in the [Veneto](/wiki/Veneto "Veneto") region are estimated to have been exposed to contamination through tap water, and it is thought to be Europe's biggest PFAS\-related environmental disaster.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.who.int/europe/publications/i/item/9789289052467 \|title\=Keeping our water clean: the case of water contamination in the Veneto Region, Italy \| website\=www.who.int}} While Italy's National Health Institute (ISS, *Istituto Superiore di Sanità*) set the threshold limit of PFOA in the bloodstream at 8 nanograms per milliliter (ng/mL), some residents had reached 262 and some industrial employees reach 91,900 ng/mL. In 2021 some data was disclosed by [Greenpeace](/wiki/Greenpeace "Greenpeace") and local citizens after a long legal battle against the Veneto Region and ISS, which for years has denied access to data, despite values known since or even before 2017\. The Veneto region has not carried out further monitoring or taken resolutive actions to eliminate pollution and reduce, at least gradually, the contamination of non\-potable water. Although in 2020 the [European Food Safety Agency](/wiki/European_Food_Safety_Agency "European Food Safety Agency") (EFSA) has reduced by more than four times the maximum tolerable limit of PFAS that can be taken through the diet, the region has not carried out new assessments or implemented concrete actions to protect the population and the agri\-food and livestock sectors. Some limits were added to monitoring the geographical area, which does not include the orange zone and other areas affected by contamination, as well as the insufficiency of analysis on important productions widespread in the areas concerned: eggs (up to 37,100 ng/kg), fish (18,600 ng/kg) spinach and [radicchio](/wiki/Radicchio "Radicchio") (only one sampling carried out), kiwis, melons, watermelons, cereals (only one sample was analyzed), soy, wines and apples.[PFAS negli alimenti dell’area rossa del Veneto](https://www.greenpeace.org/static/planet4-italy-stateless/2021/09/7818ce34-pfas-negli-alimenti-dellarea-rossa-del-veneto.pdf), Greenpeace.
### Japan
A study of public water bodies ending in March 2022 showed that the sum of PFOS and PFOA concentrations exceeded 50 ng/L in 81 out of 1,133 test sites and in some cases are present at elevated levels in blood. This has led to pressure to increase regulations.{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2023/05/28/national/japan\-pfas\-risks\-growing\-awareness/ \| title\=Japan slowly wakes up to health risks of PFAS 'forever chemicals' \| first\=TOMOKO \| last\=OTAKE \| work\=\[\[The Japan Times]] \| date\=May 28, 2023}}
### Sweden
Highly contaminated drinking water has been detected at several locations in Sweden. Such locations include Arvidsjaur, Lulnäset, Uppsala and Visby.{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Gyllenhammar I, Berger U, Sundström M, McCleaf P, Eurén K, Eriksson S, Ahlgren S, Lignell S, Aune M, Kotova N, Glynn A \| display\-authors\=6 \| title\=Influence of contaminated drinking water on perfluoroalkyl acid levels in human serum\-\-A case study from Uppsala, Sweden \| journal\=Environmental Research \| volume\=140 \| pages\=673–683 \| date\=July 2015 \| pmid\=26079316 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.envres.2015\.05\.019 \| bibcode\=2015ER....140\..673G}}{{cite journal \| title\=Quantitative relationships of perfluoroalkyl acids in drinking water associated with serum concentrations above background in adults living near contamination hotspots in Sweden \| journal\=Environmental Research \| first1\=Gunnar \| last1\=Johanson \| first2\=Irina \| last2\=Gyllenhammar \| first3\=Carl \| last3\=Ekstrand\| first4\=Andrei \| last4\=Pyko \| first5\=Yiyi \| last5\=Xu \| first6\=Ying \| last6\=Li \| first7\=Karin \| last7\=Norström \| first8\=Karl \| last8\=Lilja \| first9\=Christian \| last9\=Lindh \| first10\=Jonathan P \| last10\=Benskin \| first11\=Antonios \| last11\=Georgelis \| first12\=Karl \| last12\=Forsell \| first13\=Kristina \| last13\=Jakobsson \| first14\=Anders \| last14\=Glynn \| first15\=Carolina \| last15\=Vogs \| volume\=219 \| pages\=115024 \| date\=February 2023 \| pmid\=36535390 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.envres.2022\.115024 \| doi\-access\=free \| bibcode\=2023ER....21915024J}} In 2013, PFAS were detected at high concentrations in one of the two municipality drinking water treatment plants in the town of Ronneby, in southern Sweden. Concentrations of [PFHxS](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid") and [PFOS](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid") were found at 1700 ng/L and 8000 ng/L, respectively.{{Cite web \|url\=https://sodrasjukvardsregionen.se/download/exponering\-for\-perfluorerade\-amnen\-pfas\-i\-dricksvatten\-i\-ronneby\-kommun/?wpdmdl\=2485\&refresh\=5fc8b036ccf3e1606987830 \| first1\=Kristina \| last1\=Jakobsson \| first2\=Kerstin Kronholm \| last2\=Diab \| first3\=Christian \| last3\=Lindh \| first4\=Bodil \| last4\=Persson \| first5\=Bo \| last5\=Jönsson \| title\=Exponering för perfluorerade ämnen (PFAS) i dricksvatten i Ronneby kommun \|date\=June 12, 2014}} The source of contamination was later found to be a military fire\-fighting exercise site in which PFAS containing fire\-fighting foam had been used since the mid\-1980s.{{cite journal \| first1\=Ying \|last1\=Li \| first2\=Axel \| last2\=Andersson \| first3\=Yiyi \| last3\=Xu \| first4\=Daniela \| last4\=Pineda \| first5\=Carina A \| last5\=Nilsson \| first6\=Christian H \| last6\=Lindh \| first7\=Kristina \| last7\=Jakobsson \| first8\=Tony \| last8\=Fletcher \| title\=Determinants of serum half\-lives for linear and branched perfluoroalkyl substances after long\-term high exposure\-A study in Ronneby, Sweden \| journal\=Environment International \| volume\=163 \| pages\=107198 \| date\=May 2022 \| pmid\=35447437 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.envint.2022\.107198 \| s2cid\=248247530 \| doi\-access\=free \| bibcode\=2022EnInt.16307198L}}
Additionally, low\-level contaminated drinking water has also been shown to be a significant exposure source of [PFOA](/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid "Perfluorooctanoic acid"), [PFNA](/wiki/Perfluorononanoic_acid "Perfluorononanoic acid"), [PFHxS](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid") and [PFOS](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid") for Swedish adolescents (ages 10–21\). Even though the median concentrations in the municipality drinking water were below one ng/L for each individual PFAS, positive associations were found between adolescent serum PFAS concentrations and PFAS concentrations in drinking water.{{cite journal \| first1\=Jennifer \| last1\=Nyström\-Kandola \| first2\=Lutz \| last2\=Ahrens \| first3\=Anders \| last3\=Glynn \| first4\=Gunnar \| last4\=Johanson \| first5\=Jonathan P \| last5\=Benskin \| first6\=Irina \| last6\=Gyllenhammar \|first7\=Sanna \| last7\=Lignell \| first8\=Carolina \| last8\=Vogs \| title\=Low concentrations of perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) in municipal drinking water associated with serum PFAA concentrations in Swedish adolescents \| journal\=Environment International \| volume\=180 \| pages\=108166 \| date\=October 2023 \| pmid\=37708812 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.envint.2023\.108166 \| s2cid\=261156749 \| doi\-access\=free \| bibcode\=2023EnInt.18008166N}}
### United States
An estimated 26,000 U.S. sites are contaminated with PFASs.{{cite journal \|url\=http://online.fliphtml5\.com/fedq/bohi/\#p\=63 \| last\=Timmis \| first\=Andrew \| title\=Using Dredged Materials to Improve a Salt Marsh \| journal\=\[\[Society of American Military Engineers]] \| volume\=110 \| issue\=712 \| page\=61 \| date\=January 2018 \|archive\-date\=November 7, 2018 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181107202305/http://online.fliphtml5\.com/fedq/bohi/\#p\=63 \|url\-status\=live}}{{cite journal \| first1\=Xindi C. \| last1\=Hu \| first2\=David Q. \| last2\=Andrews \| first3\=Andrew B. \| last3\=Lindstrom\| first4\=Thomas A. \| last4\=Bruton \| first5\=Laurel A. \| last5\=Schaider \| first6\=Philippe \| last6\=Grandjean \| first7\=Rainer \| last7\=Lohmann\| first8\=Courtney C. \| last8\=Carignan \| first9\=Arlene \| last9\=Blum \| authorlink9\=Arlene Blum \| first10\=Simona A. \| last10\=Balan \| first11\=Christopher P. \| last11\=Higgins○ \| first12\=Elsie M. \| last12\=Sunderland \|title\=Detection of Poly\- and Perfluoroalkyl Substances (PFASs) in U.S. Drinking Water Linked to Industrial Sites, Military Fire Training Areas, and Wastewater Treatment Plants \|journal\=Environmental Science \& Technology Letters \|volume\=3 \|issue\=10 \|pages\=344–350 \|date\=October 2016 \|pmid\=27752509 \|pmc\=5062567 \| doi\=10\.1021/acs.estlett.6b00260\|bibcode\=2016EnSTL...3\..344H}} More than 200 million Americans are estimated to live in places where the PFAS level in tap water, including [PFOA](/wiki/PFOA "PFOA") and [PFOS](/wiki/PFOS "PFOS") levels, exceeds the 1 ppt (part per trillion) limit set in 2022 by the EPA.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/forever\-chemicals\-are\-widespread\-in\-u\-s\-drinking\-water/ \| author\=Sneed A \|title\=Forever Chemicals Are Widespread in U.S. Drinking Water: Experts hope that with the incoming Biden administration, the federal government will finally regulate a class of chemicals known as PFASs \| work\=\[\[Scientific American]] \| date\=January 22, 2021}}
Based on tap water studies from 716 locations from 2016 and 2021, the [U.S. Geological Survey](/wiki/U.S._Geological_Survey "U.S. Geological Survey") (USGS) found that the PFAS levels exceeded the EPA advisories in approximately 75% of the samples from urban areas and in approximately 25% of the rural area samples.{{Cite press release \|title\=Tap water study detects PFAS 'forever chemicals' across the US \|url\=https://www.usgs.gov/news/national\-news\-release/tap\-water\-study\-detects\-pfas\-forever\-chemicals\-across\-us \|publisher\=\[\[U.S. Geological Survey]] \|id\=National News Release \|date\=July 5, 2023}}
Certain PFASs are no longer manufactured in the United States as a result of phase\-outs including the PFOA Stewardship Program (2010–2015\), in which eight major chemical manufacturers agreed to eliminate the use of PFOA and PFOA\-related chemicals in their products and emissions from their facilities. However, they are still produced internationally and are imported into the U.S. in consumer goods.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/assessing\-and\-managing\-chemicals\-under\-tsca/fact\-sheet\-20102015\-pfoa\-stewardship\-program \|title\=Fact Sheet: 2010/2015 PFOA Stewardship Program \|date\=August 9, 2018 \|website\=Assessing and Managing Chemicals under TSCA \|publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \|archive\-date\=December 8, 2018 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181208160450/https://www.epa.gov/assessing\-and\-managing\-chemicals\-under\-tsca/fact\-sheet\-20102015\-pfoa\-stewardship\-program \|url\-status\=live}}{{cite web \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic\-information\-pfas \|title\=Basic Information on PFAS \|date\=30 March 2016 \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| archive\-date\=December 23, 2018 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181223025822/https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic\-information\-pfas \|url\-status\=live}} Some types of PFAS are voluntarily not included in [food packaging](/wiki/Food_packaging "Food packaging").{{cite web \|url\=https://www.fda.gov/news\-events/press\-announcements/fda\-announces\-voluntary\-agreement\-manufacturers\-phase\-out\-certain\-short\-chain\-pfas\-used\-food \|publisher\=\[\[Food and Drug Administration]] \| last\=Hahn \| first\=Stephen M. \|title\=FDA Announces Voluntary Agreement with Manufacturers to Phase Out Certain Short\-Chain PFAS Used in Food Packaging \|date\=31 July 2020 \| archive\-date\=August 2, 2020 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200802044359/https://www.fda.gov/news\-events/press\-announcements/fda\-announces\-voluntary\-agreement\-manufacturers\-phase\-out\-certain\-short\-chain\-pfas\-used\-food \|url\-status\=live}}
In 2021, Senators [Susan Collins](/wiki/Susan_Collins "Susan Collins") of Maine and [Richard Blumenthal](/wiki/Richard_Blumenthal "Richard Blumenthal") of Connecticut proposed the No PFAS in Cosmetics Act in the [United States Senate](/wiki/United_States_Senate "United States Senate").{{cite news \|title\=Senate bill would ban toxic 'forever chemicals' in makeup, which new study found are often unlabeled \| url\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate\-environment/2021/06/15/toxic\-pfas\-makeup/ \| last\=Root \| first\=Tik \|newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]] \|date\=June 15, 2021 \|archive\-date\=June 16, 2021 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210616161229/https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate\-environment/2021/06/15/toxic\-pfas\-makeup/ \|url\-status\=live}} It was also introduced in the [United States House of Representatives](/wiki/United_States_House_of_Representatives "United States House of Representatives") by Michigan Representative [Debbie Dingell](/wiki/Debbie_Dingell "Debbie Dingell"),{{Cite web \| url\=https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/15/health/makeup\-toxic\-chemicals\-wellness/index.html \| author\=LaMotte S \|title\=Makeup may contain potentially toxic chemicals called PFAS, study finds \| work\=CNN \| date\=June 15, 2021 \|archive\-date\=June 29, 2021 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210629021146/https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/15/health/makeup\-toxic\-chemicals\-wellness/index.html \|url\-status\=live}} but the [Republican Party](/wiki/Republican_Party_%28United_States%29 "Republican Party (United States)"), supported by the U.S. chemical industry [filibustered](/wiki/Filibuster "Filibuster") the bill.{{Cite news \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/13/pfas\-toxic\-forever\-chemicals\-republican\-house \| last\=Perkins \| first\=Tom \| title\=Bills to regulate toxic 'forever chemicals' died in Congress – with Republican help \| work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \| date\=January 13, 2023 \|issn\=0261\-3077}}
#### Military bases
The water in and around at least 126 U.S. military bases has been contaminated by high levels of PFASs because of their use of firefighting foams since the 1970s, according to a study by the [U.S. Department of Defense](/wiki/U.S._Department_of_Defense "U.S. Department of Defense"). Of these, 90 bases reported PFAS contamination that had spread to drinking water or groundwater off the base.{{cite web \| title\=DoD: At Least 126 Bases Report Water Contaminants Linked to Cancer, Birth Defects \| url\=https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your\-military/2018/04/26/dod\-126\-bases\-report\-water\-contaminants\-harmful\-to\-infant\-development\-tied\-to\-cancers/ \|work\=\[\[Military Times]] \|date\=April 26, 2018 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200506043631/https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your\-military/2018/04/26/dod\-126\-bases\-report\-water\-contaminants\-harmful\-to\-infant\-development\-tied\-to\-cancers/ \| archive\-date\=May 6, 2020 \| url\-status\=live}}
In 2022, a report by the Pentagon acknowledged that approximately 175,000 U.S. military personnel at two dozen American military facilities drank water contaminated by PFAS that exceeded the U.S. EPA limit. However, according to the [Environmental Working Group](/wiki/Environmental_Working_Group "Environmental Working Group"), the Pentagon report downplayed the number of people exposed to PFAS, which was probably over 640,000 at 116 military facilities. The EWG found that the Pentagon also omitted from its report some types of diseases that are likely to be caused by PFAS exposure, such as [testicular cancer](/wiki/Testicular_cancer "Testicular cancer"), kidney disease, and fetal abnormalities.{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\-news/2022/dec/23/us\-soldiers\-pfas\-forever\-chemicals\-higher\-rate\-pentagon\-military \| title\=US Military 'Downplayed' The Number of Soldiers Exposed to 'Forever Chemicals'—Analysis of Pentagon Report Reveals that Soldiers Exposed to PFAS Pollution at Much Higher Rate than Military Claims \| work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \| date\=23 December 2022}}
#### Environmental Protection Agency actions
The [United States Environmental Protection Agency](/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency "United States Environmental Protection Agency") has published non\-enforceable [drinking water health advisories](/wiki/Safe_Drinking_Water_Act%23Health_advisories "Safe Drinking Water Act#Health advisories") for PFOA and PFOS.{{cite web \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/ground\-water\-and\-drinking\-water/drinking\-water\-health\-advisories\-pfoa\-and\-pfos \|title\=Drinking Water Health Advisories for PFOA and PFOS \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \|date\=December 9, 2020 \| archive\-date\=December 28, 2020 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201228004056/https://www.epa.gov/ground\-water\-and\-drinking\-water/drinking\-water\-health\-advisories\-pfoa\-and\-pfos \|url\-status\=live}}{{cite web \| title\=Fact Sheet; PFOA \& PFOS Drinking Water Health Advisories \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/ground\-water\-and\-drinking\-water/supporting\-documents\-drinking\-water\-health\-advisories\-pfoa\-and\-pfos \| date\=November 2016 \|id\=EPA 800\-F\-16\-003 \|archive\-date\=December 26, 2020 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201226125900/https://www.epa.gov/ground\-water\-and\-drinking\-water/supporting\-documents\-drinking\-water\-health\-advisories\-pfoa\-and\-pfos \|url\-status\=live}} In March 2021 EPA announced that it would develop national drinking water standards for PFOA and PFOS.EPA (2021\-03\-03\). "Announcement of Final Regulatory Determinations for Contaminants on the Fourth Drinking Water Contaminant Candidate List." *Federal Register,* {{usfr\|86\|12272}} Drinking water utilities are required to monitor PFAS levels and may receive subsidies to do so.EPA (2021\-12\-27\). "Revisions to the Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule (UCMR 5\) for Public Water Systems and Announcement of Public Meetings." *Federal Register,* {{USFR\|86\|73131}}{{cite web \|title\=Fifth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/dwucmr/fifth\-unregulated\-contaminant\-monitoring\-rule \| date\=February 22, 2022 \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}} There are also regulations regarding wastewater ([effluent guidelines](/wiki/Effluent_guidelines "Effluent guidelines")) for industries that use PFASs in the manufacturing process as well as [biosolids](/wiki/Biosolids "Biosolids") (processed wastewater [sludge](/wiki/Sludge "Sludge") used as fertilizer).{{cite web \|title\=Organic Chemicals, Plastics and Synthetic Fibers Effluent Guidelines \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/eg/organic\-chemicals\-plastics\-and\-synthetic\-fibers\-effluent\-guidelines \|publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| date\=July 13, 2021}}{{cite web \|title\=Metal Finishing Effluent Guidelines \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/eg/metal\-finishing\-effluent\-guidelines \|publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \|date\=September 24, 2021}}{{cite web \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/pfas\-strategic\-roadmap\-epas\-commitments\-action\-2021\-2024 \| title\=PFAS Strategic Roadmap: EPA's Commitments to Action 2021\-2024 \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| date\=January 27, 2022}}{{cite web \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/biosolids/risk\-assessment\-pollutants\-biosolids \|title\=Risk Assessment of Pollutants in Biosolids \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| date\=May 3, 2022}}{{cite web \| title\=Meaningful and Achievable Steps You Can Take to Reduce Your Risk \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/meaningful\-and\-achievable\-steps\-you\-can\-take\-reduce\-your\-risk \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| date\=August 18, 2022}}
The EPA issued health advisories for four specific PFASs in June 2022, significantly lowering their safe threshold levels for drinking water. PFOA was reduced from 70 ppt to 0\.004 ppt, while PFOS was reduced from 70 ppt to 0\.02 ppt. A safe level for the compound [GenX](/wiki/GenX "GenX") was set at 10 ppt, while that for [PFBS](/wiki/PFBS "PFBS") was set at 2000 ppt. While not enforceable, these health advisories are intended to be acted on by states in setting their own drinking water standards.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/epa\-lowers\-bar\-for\-pfas\-contamination\-11655318054 \|title\=EPA Lowers Bar for Toxic Chemicals Contamination \| last\=Maher \| first\=Kris \| work\=\[\[The Wall Street Journal]] \| date\=June 15, 2022 \| url\-access\=subscription}}
In August 2022, the EPA proposed to add PFOA and PFOS to its list of hazardous substances under the [Superfund](/wiki/Superfund "Superfund") law.{{cite news \| last\=Grandoni \| first\=Dino \| title\=EPA finally moves to label some 'forever chemicals' as hazardous \| url\=https://washingtonpost.com/climate\-environment/2022/08/26/forever\-chemicals\-epa\-cleanup\-rule/ \| newspaper\=\[\[The Washington Post]] \| date\=August 26, 2022 \| url\-access\=limited}} EPA issued a final rule in April 2024, which requires that polluters pay for investigations and cleanup of these substances.{{cite web \|title\=Designation of Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) and Perfluorooctanesulfonic Acid (PFOS) as CERCLA Hazardous Substances \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/superfund/designation\-perfluorooctanoic\-acid\-pfoa\-and\-perfluorooctanesulfonic\-acid\-pfos\-cercla \| date\=May 8, 2024 \| website\=\[\[Superfund]] \|publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}}{{cite news \| url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/19/climate/epa\-pfas\-superfund\-cleanup.html \| title\=E.P.A. Will Make Polluters Pay to Clean Up Two 'Forever Chemicals' \| first\=Coral \| last\=Davenport \| newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]] \| date\=April 19, 2024 \| url\-access\=limited}}
[thumb\|upright\=1\.35\|USGS map showing the number of PFAS detections in tap water samples from select sites across the US.](/wiki/File:PFAS-Tapwater_DetectionMap_1.png "PFAS-Tapwater DetectionMap 1.png")
In April 2024, the EPA issued a final drinking water rule for PFOA, PFOS, [GenX](/wiki/GenX "GenX"), PFBS, PFNA, and PFHxS. Within three years, [public water systems](/wiki/Public_water_system "Public water system") must remove these six PFAS to near\-zero levels. States may be awarded grants up to $1 billion in aid to help with the initial testing and treatment of water for this purpose.[United States Environmental Protection Agency](/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency "United States Environmental Protection Agency") (April 26, 2024\). "PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation." *Federal Register,* {{USFR\|89\|32532}}{{cite web \|title\=Final PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation \|url\=https://www.epa.gov/sdwa/and\-polyfluoroalkyl\-substances\-pfas \|date\=May 22, 2024 \|publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}}{{cite news \| url\=https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/10/climate/epa\-pfas\-drinking\-water.html \| title\=E.P.A. Says 'Forever Chemicals' Must Be Removed From Tap Water \| first\=Lisa \| last\=Friedman \| newspaper\=\[\[The New York Times]] \| date\=April 10, 2024 \| url\-access\=limited}}{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health\-news/epa\-limits\-pfas\-chemicals\-drinking\-water\-first\-time\-rcna147000 \| title\=EPA imposes first national limits on 'forever chemicals' in drinking water \| first\=Aria \| last\=Bendix \| work\=\[\[NBC News]] \| date\=April 10, 2024}}{{Cite press release \| url\=https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/biden\-harris\-administration\-finalizes\-first\-ever\-national\-drinking\-water\-standard \| title\=Biden\-Harris Administration Finalizes First\-Ever National Drinking Water Standard to Protect 100M People from PFAS Pollution \| publisher\=\[\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \| date\=April 10, 2024}}
#### Legal actions
In February 2017, DuPont and [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours "Chemours") (a DuPont [spin\-off](/wiki/Corporate_spin-off "Corporate spin-off")) agreed to pay $671 million to settle lawsuits arising from 3,550 personal injury claims related to the releasing of PFASs from their [Parkersburg, West Virginia](/wiki/Parkersburg%2C_West_Virginia "Parkersburg, West Virginia"), plant into the drinking water of several thousand residents.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-du\-pont\-lawsuit\-west\-virginia\-idUSKBN15S18U \| title\=DuPont settles lawsuits over leak of chemical used to make Teflon \| first\=Arathy S. \| last\=Nair \| work\=\[\[Reuters]] \| date\=February 13, 2017 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190608111323/https://www.reuters.com/article/us\-du\-pont\-lawsuit\-west\-virginia\-idUSKBN15S18U \| archive\-date\=June 8, 2019 \| url\-status\=live}} This was after a court\-created independent scientific panel—the C8 Science Panel—found a "probable link" between C8 exposure and six illnesses: kidney and testicular cancer, ulcerative colitis, thyroid disease, pregnancy\-induced hypertension and high cholesterol.
In October 2018, a [class action suit](/wiki/Class_action_suit "Class action suit") was filed by an Ohio firefighter against several producers of fluorosurfactants, including 3M and DuPont, on behalf of all U.S. residents who may have adverse health effects from exposure to PFASs.{{cite web \| date\=October 6, 2018 \|title\=Nationwide class action lawsuit targets Dupont, Chemours, 3M, and other makers of PFAS chemicals \|url\=https://theintercept.com/2018/10/06/dupont\-pfas\-chemicals\-lawsuit/ \| website\=\[\[The Intercept]] \|author\=Lerner S \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181007111157/https://theintercept.com/2018/10/06/dupont\-pfas\-chemicals\-lawsuit/ \| archive\-date\=October 7, 2018 \|url\-status\=live }} The story is told in the film *[Dark Waters](/wiki/Dark_Waters_%282019_film%29 "Dark Waters (2019 film)")*.{{cite news \|title\='Dark Waters': 7 of the Film's Stars and Their Real\-Life Inspirations \|url\=https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/lists/true\-story\-dark\-waters\-how\-accurate\-are\-characters\-1254811/ \|last\=Piña \| first\=Christy \|work\=\[\[The Hollywood Reporter]] \| date\=30 November 2019}}
In June 2023, [3M](/wiki/3M "3M") reached a US$10\.3 [billion](/wiki/Billion "Billion") settlement with several US public water providers to resolve water pollution claims tied to PFAS, while [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours "Chemours"), [DuPont](/wiki/DuPont "DuPont") and [Corteva](/wiki/Corteva "Corteva") settled similar claims for $1\.19 billion.{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jun/22/3m\-settlement\-municipal\-water\-systems\-pfas\-contamination \| title\=3M pays $10\.3bn to settle water pollution suit over 'forever chemicals' \|work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \| date\=June 22, 2023 \| issn\=0261\-3077}}
In December 2023, as part of a four\-year legal battle, the EPA banned Inhance, a Houston, Texas\-based manufacturer that produces an estimated 200 million containers annually with a process that creates PFOA, from using the manufacturing process.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\-news/2024/mar/30/pfas\-ban\-plastic\-containers\-court \|last\=Perkins \| first\=Tom \| title\=US appeals court kills ban on plastic containers contaminated with PFAS \| work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|date\=March 30, 2024}}{{cite news \| url\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jun/01/pfas\-lawsuit\-epa\-plastic\-containers\-health\-danger \| last\=Perkins \| first\=Tom \| title\=Plastic containers still distributed across the US are a potential health disaster \| work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \| date\=June 1, 2023}} In March 2024, the [United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit](/wiki/United_States_Court_of_Appeals_for_the_Fifth_Circuit "United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit") overturned the ban. While the court did not deny the containers’ health risks, it said that the EPA could not regulate the manufactured containers under [Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976](/wiki/Toxic_Substances_Control_Act_of_1976 "Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976"), which only addresses "new" chemicals.{{Cite news \| url\=https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us\-appeals\-court\-curtails\-epas\-ability\-regulate\-pfas\-under\-toxic\-substances\-law\-2024\-03\-22/ \| title\=US appeals court curtails EPA's ability to regulate PFAS under toxic substances law \| first\=Clark \| last\=Mindock \| work\=\[\[Reuters]] \| date\=March 22, 2024}}
#### State actions
In 2021, [Maine](/wiki/Maine "Maine") became the first U.S. state to ban these compounds in all products by 2030, except for instances deemed "currently unavoidable".{{cite news \| last\=Perkins \| first\=Tom \|title\=Maine bans toxic 'forever chemicals' under groundbreaking new law \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\-news/2021/jul/15/maine\-law\-pfas\-forever\-chemicals\-ban \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210716071833/https://www.theguardian.com/us\-news/2021/jul/15/maine\-law\-pfas\-forever\-chemicals\-ban \|archive\-date\=July 16, 2021 \|work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \|date\=July 16, 2021}}{{Cite journal \|url\=https://www.science.org/content/article/maine\-s\-ban\-forever\-chemicals\-marks\-big\-win\-some\-scientists \| first\=XIAOZHI \| last\=LIM \|date\=2021\-08\-27 \|title\=Maine's ban on 'forever chemicals' marks a big win for some scientists \|journal\=\[\[Science (journal)\|Science]] \|doi\=10\.1126/science.abm1382 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210831164644/https://www.science.org/news/2021/08/maine\-s\-ban\-forever\-chemicals\-marks\-big\-win\-some\-scientists \|archive\-date\=31 August 2021 \|url\-status\=live }}
{{As of\|October 2020}}, the states of California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Vermont, and Wisconsin had enforceable drinking water standards for between two and six types of PFAS. The six chemicals (termed by the [Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection](/wiki/Massachusetts_Department_of_Environmental_Protection "Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection") as PFAS6\) are measured either individually or summed as a group depending on the standard; they are:{{cite web \|url\=https://mecc.memberclicks.net/assets/Presentations/I\-495%20PFAS6%20MCL%2010\-21\-2020\.pdf \|title\=MassDEP's PFAS6 Drinking Water Standard \|date\=October 21, 2020 \|author\=\[\[Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection]]}}
* [Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid") (PFOS)
* [Perfluorooctanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid "Perfluorooctanoic acid") (PFOA)
* [Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid "Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid") (PFHxS)
* [Perfluorononanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorononanoic_acid "Perfluorononanoic acid") (PFNA)
* [Perfluoroheptanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluoroheptanoic_acid "Perfluoroheptanoic acid") (PFHpA)
* [Perfluorodecanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorodecanoic_acid "Perfluorodecanoic acid") (PFDA)
##### California
In 2021 California banned PFASs for use in food packaging and from infant and children's products and also required PFAS cookware in the state to carry a warning label.{{cite news \| vauthors\=Duggan T \|url\=https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/California\-bans\-PFAS\-chemicals\-from\-baby\-products\-16512091\.php \|title\=California bans PFAS chemicals from baby products and food packaging \|date\=2021\-10\-05 \|work\=San Francisco Chronicle}}
##### Maine
A program licensed and promoted by the Maine Department of Environmental Protection that provided free municipal wastewater [sludge](/wiki/Sludge "Sludge") ([biosolids](/wiki/Biosolids "Biosolids")) to farmers as fertilizer has resulted in PFAS contamination of local drinking water and farm\-grown produce.{{cite news \| title\='I don't know how we'll survive': the farmers facing ruin in America's 'forever chemicals' crisis \|url\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/mar/22/i\-dont\-know\-how\-well\-survive\-the\-farmers\-facing\-ruin\-in\-americas\-forever\-chemicals\-crisis \| first\=Tom \| last\=Perkins \| work\=\[\[The Guardian]] \| date\=March 22, 2022}}{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.mainepublic.org/environment\-and\-outdoors/2022\-02\-07/complete\-crisis\-as\-pfas\-discovery\-upends\-life\-and\-livelihood\-of\-young\-maine\-farming\-family\|title\='Complete crisis' as PFAS discovery upends life and livelihood of young Maine farming family\|date\=7 February 2022\|website\=Maine Public}}
##### Michigan
The [Michigan](/wiki/Michigan "Michigan") PFAS Action Response Team (MPART) was launched in 2017 and is the first multi\-agency action team of its kind in the nation. Agencies representing health, environment, and other branches of state government have joined together to investigate sources and locations of PFAS contamination in the state, take action to protect people's drinking water, and keep the public informed. Groundwater is tested at locations throughout the state by various parties to ensure safety, compliance with regulations, and proactively detect and remedy potential problems. In 2010, the [Michigan Department of Environmental Quality](/wiki/Michigan_Department_of_Environmental_Quality "Michigan Department of Environmental Quality") (MDEQ) discovered levels of PFASs in groundwater monitoring wells at the former [Wurtsmith Air Force Base](/wiki/Wurtsmith_Air_Force_Base "Wurtsmith Air Force Base").{{Cite web \| url\=https://www.circleofblue.org/2018/world/fear\-and\-fury\-in\-michigan\-town\-where\-air\-force\-contaminated\-water/ \|last\=Walton \|first\=Brett \| date\=April 11, 2018 \|title\=Fear and Fury in Michigan Town Where Air Force Contaminated Water \| website\=Circle of Blue \|language\=en\-US}} In 2024, citizen\-led testing near the base in [Oscoda](/wiki/Oscoda%2C_Michigan "Oscoda, Michigan") discovered high levels of PFAS in foam along the shore of [Lake Huron](/wiki/Lake_Huron "Lake Huron").{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan\-environment\-watch/pfas\-tainted\-foam\-lake\-huron\-prompts\-citizen\-outcry\|title\=PFAS\-tainted foam in Lake Huron prompts citizen outcry \| work\=\[\[Bridge Michigan]] \|date\=May 22, 2024}} As additional information became available from other national testing, Michigan expanded its investigations into other locations where PFAS compounds were potentially used. In 2018, the MDEQ's Remediation and Redevelopment Division (RRD) established cleanup criteria for groundwater used as drinking water of 70 ppt of PFOA and PFOS, individually or combined. The RRD staff are responsible for implementing these criteria as part of their ongoing efforts to clean up sites of environmental contamination. The RRD staff are the lead investigators at most of the PFAS sites on the MPART website and also conduct interim response activities, such as coordinating bottled water or filter installations with local health departments at sites under investigation or with known PFAS concerns. Most of the groundwater sampling at PFAS sites under RRD's lead is conducted by contractors familiar with PFAS sampling techniques. The RRD also has a Geologic Services Unit, with staff who install monitoring wells and are also well versed with PFAS sampling techniques. The MDEQ has been conducting environmental clean\-up of regulated contaminants for decades. Due to the evolving nature of PFAS regulations as new science becomes available, the RRD is evaluating the need for regular PFAS sampling at [Superfund](/wiki/Superfund "Superfund") sites and is including an evaluation of PFAS sampling needs as part of a Baseline Environmental Assessment review. Earlier in 2018, the RRD purchased lab equipment that will allow the MDEQ Environmental Lab to conduct analyses of certain PFAS samples. (Currently, most samples are shipped to one of the few labs in the country that conduct PFAS analysis, in California, although private labs in other parts of the country, including Michigan, are starting to offer these services.) As of August 2018, RRD has hired additional staff to work on developing the methodology and conducting PFAS analyses.{{cite web \|title\=Michigan PFAS Action Response Team (MPART) \|url\=https://www.michigan.gov/pfasresponse/ \|publisher\=Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy \|location\=Lansing, MI \| archive\-date\=December 18, 2018 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181218193515/https://www.michigan.gov/pfasresponse/ \|url\-status\=live}}
In 2020 Michigan Attorney General [Dana Nessel](/wiki/Dana_Nessel "Dana Nessel") filed a lawsuit against 17 companies, including 3M, Chemours, and DuPont, for hiding known health and environmental risks from the state and its residents. Nessel's complaint identifies 37 sites with known contamination.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan\-government/dana\-nessel\-sues\-3m\-dupont\-over\-unconscionable\-pfas\-pollution\-michigan \| title\=Dana Nessel sues 3M, DuPont over 'unconscionable' PFAS pollution in Michigan \| work\=\[\[Bridge Michigan]] \| date\=January 14, 2020}} The [Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy](/wiki/Michigan_Department_of_Environment%2C_Great_Lakes%2C_and_Energy "Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy") introduced some of the strictest drinking water standards in the country for PFAS, setting [maximum contaminant levels](/wiki/Maximum_contaminant_level "Maximum contaminant level") (MCLs) for PFOA and PFOS to 8 and 16 ppt respectively (down from previous existing groundwater cleanup standards of 70 ppt for both), and introducing MCLs for five other previously unregulated PFAS compounds, limiting PFNA to six ppt, PFHxA to 400,000 ppt, PFHxS to 51 ppt, PFBS to 420 ppt and [HFPO\-DA](/wiki/FRD-903 "FRD-903") to 370 ppt.{{Cite web \| url\=https://www.michigan.gov/egle/0,9429,7\-135\-\-534660\-\-,00\.html \| title\=EGLE \- Michigan adopts strict PFAS in drinking water standards \| website\=www.michigan.gov \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20220310020229/https://www.michigan.gov/egle/0,9429,7\-135\-\-534660\-\-,00\.html \| archive\-date\=March 10, 2022}} The change adds 38 additional sites to the state's list of known PFAS contaminated areas, bringing the total number of known sites to 137\. About half of these sites are [landfills](/wiki/Landfill "Landfill") and 13 are former [plating facilities](/wiki/Chrome_plating "Chrome plating").{{Cite news \| title\=Michigan's drinking water standards for these chemicals now among toughest in nation \| url\=https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2020/08/03/tougher\-pfas\-standards\-drinking\-water\-michigan/5574268002/ \| vauthors\=Matheny K \| website\=Detroit Free Press \| date\=August 3, 2020}}
In 2022 PFOS was found in beef produced at a Michigan farm: the cattle had been fed crops fertilized with contaminated biosolids. State agencies issued a consumption advisory, but did not order a recall, because there currently is no PFOS contamination in beef government standards.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.abc12\.com/news/toxic\-forever\-chemicals\-found\-in\-michigan\-farms\-beef/article\_e7f880e2\-8115\-11ec\-a9ab\-738b364fb600\.html \| title\=Toxic 'forever chemicals' found in Michigan farm's beef \| first\=Christine \| last\=Winter \| agency\=\[\[Associated Press]] \| work\=\[\[ABC News (United States)\|ABC News]] \| date\=January 29, 2022}}
A 2024 study found that "atmospheric deposition could be a significant environmental pathway, particularly for the Great Lakes."{{Cite journal \|last1\=Xia \|first1\=Chunjie \|last2\=Capozzi \| first2\=Staci L. \| last3\=Romanak \| first3\=Kevin A. \| last4\=Lehman \| first4\=Daniel C. \| last5\=Dove \|first5\=Alice \| last6\=Richardson \| first6\=Violeta \| last7\=Greenberg \|first7\=Tracie \| last8\=McGoldrick \| first8\=Daryl \| last9\=Venier \| first9\=Marta \|date\=2024\-05\-16 \|title\=The Ins and Outs of Per\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in the Great Lakes: The Role of Atmospheric Deposition \| journal\=Environmental Science \& Technology \| volume\=58 \| issue\=21 \| pages\=9303–9313 \| language\=en \|doi\=10\.1021/acs.est.3c10098 \| issn\=0013\-936X \| doi\-access\=free \| pmid\=38752648 \| pmc\=11137863 \|bibcode\=2024EnST...58\.9303X}}{{Cite web \| url\=https://www.greatlakesnow.org/2024/05/pfas\-news\-roundup\-3m\-scientist\-exposes\-50\-years\-of\-pfas\-deceit\-just\-as\-the\-forever\-chemicals\-are\-found\-in\-great\-lakes\-precipitation/ \| last\=Litzenberg \| first\=Mia \| title\=PFAS News Roundup: 3M scientist exposes 50 years of PFAS deceit just as the 'forever chemicals' are found in Great Lakes precipitation \| website\=\[\[Great Lakes Now]] \| date\=May 23, 2024}}
##### Minnesota
In February 2018, 3M settled a lawsuit for $850 million related to contaminated drinking water in Minnesota.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018\-02\-20/3m\-is\-said\-to\-settle\-minnesota\-lawsuit\-for\-up\-to\-1\-billion \| title\=3M Settles Minnesota Lawsuit for $850 Million \| first\=Tiffany \| last\=Kary \| work\=\[\[Bloomberg News]] \| date\=June 7, 2019 \| url\-access\=subscription \| archive\-date\=June 8, 2019 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190608111342/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018\-02\-20/3m\-is\-said\-to\-settle\-minnesota\-lawsuit\-for\-up\-to\-1\-billion \|url\-status\=live}}
##### New Jersey
In 2018 the [New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection](/wiki/New_Jersey_Department_of_Environmental_Protection "New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection") (NJDEP) published a drinking water standard for PFNA. [Public water systems](/wiki/Public_water_system "Public water system") in New Jersey are required to meet an MCL standard of 13 ppt.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/environment/2018/09/06/new\-jersey\-first\-state\-regulate\-dangerous\-chemical\-pfna\-pfoa/1210328002/ \| last\=Fallon \| first\=Scott \| title\=New Jersey becomes first state to regulate dangerous chemical PFNA in drinking water \| work\=\[\[The Record (North Jersey)\|The Record]] \|date\=September 6, 2018 \| archive\-date\=November 29, 2020 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201129081254/https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/environment/2018/09/06/new\-jersey\-first\-state\-regulate\-dangerous\-chemical\-pfna\-pfoa/1210328002/ \| url\-status\=live}}{{cite web \| url\=https://advance.lexis.com/api/document/collection/administrative\-codes/id/5T61\-TR60\-01XC\-F17T\-00008\-00?cite\=50%20N.J.R.%201939(a)\&context\=1000516 \| title\=Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for Perfluorononanoic Acid and 1,2,3\-Trichloropropane; Private Well Testing for Arsenic, Gross Alpha Particle Activity, and Certain Synthetic Organic Compounds \|publisher\=\[\[New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection]] \| id\=50 N.J.R. 1939(a) \| date\=September 4, 2018 \| archive\-date\=October 6, 2021 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20211006204818/https://signin.lexisnexis.com/lnaccess/app/signin?back\=https%3A%2F%2Fadvance.lexis.com%3A443%2Flaapi%2Fdocument%3Fcite%3D50%2BN.J.R.%2B1939%28a%29%26context%3D1000516%26collection%3Dadministrative\-codes%26id%3D5T61\-TR60\-01XC\-F17T\-00008\-00\&aci\=la \| url\-status\=live}} In 2020 the state set a PFOA standard at 14 ppt and a PFOS standard at 13 ppt.{{cite web \| url\=https://www.state.nj.us/dep/srp/srra/listserv\_archives/2020/20200601\_srra.html \| title\=Adoption of ground water quality standards and maximum contaminant levels for perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) \|publisher\=\[\[New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection]] \| date\=June 1, 2020 \| archive\-date\=June 25, 2021 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210625164516/https://www.state.nj.us/dep/srp/srra/listserv\_archives/2020/20200601\_srra.html \| url\-status\=live}}
In 2019 NJDEP filed lawsuits against the owners of two plants that had manufactured PFASs, and two plants that were cited for water pollution from other chemicals. The companies cited are DuPont, [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours "Chemours"), and 3M.{{cite press release \| url\=https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190327a.html \| title\=AG Grewal, DEP Commissioner Announce 4 New Environmental Lawsuits Focused on Contamination Allegedly Linked to DuPont, Chemours, 3M \|publisher\=\[\[New Jersey attorney general]] \| date\=March 27, 2019 \|archive\-date\=January 13, 2021 \| archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210113223236/https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190327a.html \| url\-status\=live}} NJDEP also declared five companies to be financially responsible for statewide remediation of the chemicals. Among the companies accused were [Arkema](/wiki/Arkema "Arkema") and [Solvay](/wiki/Solvay_S.A. "Solvay S.A.") regarding a [West Deptford](/wiki/West_Deptford_Township%2C_New_Jersey "West Deptford Township, New Jersey") Facility in [Gloucester County](/wiki/Gloucester_County%2C_New_Jersey "Gloucester County, New Jersey"), where Arkema manufactured PFASs, but Solvay claims to have never manufactured but only handled PFASs.{{cite letter \| vauthors\=Norton GP \|recipient\=Shawn LaTourette \|subject\=Re: Statewide PFAS Directive, Information Request and Notice to Insurers \|date\=April 17, 2019 \|via\=Internet Archive \|url\=https://archive.org/details/5999826\-SolvayNJDEPLetter\-4\-17\-2019/}} The companies denied liability and contested the directive.{{cite news \| url\=https://www.nj.com/news/2019/05/state\-ordered\-chemical\-companies\-to\-pay\-for\-pollution\-clean\-up\-they\-say\-no\-way.html \|title\=State ordered chemical companies to pay for pollution clean\-up. They say, no way! \| first\=Michael Sol \| last\=Warren \|work\=\[\[NJ.com]] \|date\=May 13, 2019 \| archive\-date\=October 19, 2019 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191019015403/https://www.nj.com/news/2019/05/state\-ordered\-chemical\-companies\-to\-pay\-for\-pollution\-clean\-up\-they\-say\-no\-way.html \|url\-status\=live}} In June 2020, the EPA and New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection published a paper reporting that a unique family of PFAS used by Solvay, chloroperfluoropolyether carboxylates (ClPFPECAs), were contaminating the soils of New Jersey as far from the Solvay facility as 150 km.{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Washington JW, Rosal CG, McCord JP, Strynar MJ, Lindstrom AB, Bergman EL, Goodrow SM, Tadesse HK, Pilant AN, Washington BJ, Davis MJ, Stuart BG, Jenkins TM \| display\-authors\=6 \| title\=Nontargeted mass\-spectral detection of chloroperfluoropolyether carboxylates in New Jersey soils \| journal\=\[\[Science (journal)\|Science]] \| volume\=368 \| issue\=6495 \| pages\=1103–1107 \| date\=June 2020 \| pmid\=32499438 \| pmc\=7814412 \| doi\=10\.1126/science.aba7127 \| bibcode\=2020Sci...368\.1103W}} and the ClPFPECAs were found in water as well.{{cite journal \| vauthors\=McCord JP, Strynar MJ, Washington JW, Bergman EL, Goodrow SM \| title\=Emerging Chlorinated Polyfluorinated Polyether Compounds Impacting the Waters of Southwestern New Jersey Identified by Use of Nontargeted Analysis \| journal\=Environmental Science \& Technology Letters \| volume\=7 \| issue\=12 \| pages\=903–908 \| date\=December 2020 \| pmid\=33553465 \| pmc\=7863629 \| doi\=10\.1021/acs.estlett.0c00640 \| bibcode\=2020EnSTL...7\..903M}}
Later in 2020, the New Jersey state attorney general filed suit in the New Jersey Superior Court against Solvay regarding PFAS contamination of the state's environment.New Jersey DEP plaintiffs v. Solvay Specialty Chemicals USA and Arkema Inc. defendants. GLO\-L\-001239\-20\. Trans ID 20202023975 In May 2021, Solvay issued a press release that the company is "discontinuing the use of fluorosurfactants in the U.S.".{{Cite press release \|url\=https://www.solvay.com/en/press\-release/solvay\-launches\-non\-fluorosurfactant\-technologies\-in\-us \|title\=Solvay Launches Non\-Fluorosurfactant Technologies in the U.S. \| publisher\=\[\[Solvay S.A.]] \|date\=May 5, 2021}}
##### New York
In 2016, New York, along with Vermont and New Hampshire, acknowledged PFOA contamination by requesting the EPA to release water quality guidance measures. Contamination has been observed by the [New York State Department of Environmental Conservation](/wiki/New_York_State_Department_of_Environmental_Conservation "New York State Department of Environmental Conservation") in Hoosick Falls, Newburgh, Petersburgh, Poestenkill, Mahopac, and Armonk.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.dec.ny.gov/chemical/108831\.html \| title\=Per\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) \| publisher\=\[\[New York State Department of Environmental Conservation]]}}
After a class action lawsuit, in 2021, the village of Hoosick Falls received a $65\.25 million settlement from Saint\-Gobain Performance Plastics, Honeywell, 3M, and DuPont due to the disposal of PFAS chemicals into the groundwater of the local [water treatment](/wiki/Water_treatment "Water treatment") plant.{{Cite news \| first\=Brendan J. \| last\=Lyons \|title\=$65M settlement filed in Hoosick Falls PFOA water contamination \| url\=https://www.timesunion.com/state/article/hoosick\-falls\-pfoa\-settlement\-16326755\.php \| work\=\[\[Times Union (Albany)\|Times Union]] \| date\=July 21, 2021}}
##### Washington
Five military installations in Washington State have been identified by the [United States Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works](/wiki/United_States_Senate_Committee_on_Environment_and_Public_Works "United States Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works") as having PFAS contamination.{{Cite web \| url\=https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/superfund\-sites\-identified\-by\-epa\-to\-have\-pfas\-contamination \| title\=SUPERFUND SITES IDENTIFIED BY EPA TO HAVE PFAS CONTAMINATION}} Toward environmental and consumer protections, the [Washington State Department of Ecology](/wiki/Washington_State_Department_of_Ecology "Washington State Department of Ecology") published a [Chemical Action Plan](https://apps.ecology.wa.gov/publications/summarypages/2104048.html) in November 2021, and in June 2022 the governor tasked the Washington State Department of Ecology with [phasing out manufacture and import of products containing PFASs](https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=70A.350.090). Initial steps taken by the [Washington State Department of Health](/wiki/Washington_State_Department_of_Health "Washington State Department of Health") to protect the public from exposure through drinking water have included setting [State Action Levels](https://doh.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2022-02/PFAS%20Rule%20Adoption%20Notice%20and%20Adopted%20Rule%20Language.pdf?uid=62c866e64514c) for five PFASs (PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFHxS, and PFBS), which were implemented in November 2021\.{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Joyce Dinglasan\-Panlilio M, Prakash SS, Baker JE \|date\=January 2014 \| title\=Perfluorinated compounds in the surface waters of Puget Sound, Washington and Clayoquot and Barkley Sounds, British Columbia \| journal\=Marine Pollution Bulletin \|volume\=78 \|issue\=1–2 \| pages\=173–180 \| bibcode\=2014MarPB..78\..173J \| doi\=10\.1016/j.marpolbul.2013\.10\.046 \|pmid\=24262211}}{{cite journal \|vauthors\=Meador JP, Yeh A, Gallagher EP \| date\=November 2017 \|title\=Determining potential adverse effects in marine fish exposed to pharmaceuticals and personal care products with the fish plasma model and whole\-body tissue concentrations \| journal\=Environmental Pollution \|volume\=230 \| pages\=1018–1029 \| doi\=10\.1016/j.envpol.2017\.07\.047 \| pmc\=5595653 \| pmid\=28764109 \|bibcode\=2017EPoll.230\.1018M}}{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Strivens JE, Kuo LJ, Liu Y, Noor KL \|date\=June 2021 \|title\=Spatial and temporal baseline of perfluorooctanesulfonic acid retained in sediment core samples from Puget Sound, Washington, USA \|journal\=Marine Pollution Bulletin \|volume\=167 \|pages\=112381 \| bibcode\=2021MarPB.16712381S \|doi\=10\.1016/j.marpolbul.2021\.112381 \|pmid\=33962256 \|s2cid\=233999063 \|doi\-access\=free}}
### United Nations
In 2009, PFOS, its salts, and [perfluorooctanesulfonyl fluoride](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonyl_fluoride "Perfluorooctanesulfonyl fluoride"), as well as PFOA and PFHxS, were listed as [persistent organic pollutants](/wiki/Persistent_organic_pollutant "Persistent organic pollutant") under the [Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants](/wiki/Stockholm_Convention_on_Persistent_Organic_Pollutants "Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants") due to their ubiquitous, [persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic](/wiki/Persistent%2C_bioaccumulative%2C_and_toxic "Persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic") nature.{{cite journal \| vauthors\=Blum A, Balan SA, Scheringer M, Trier X, Goldenman G, Cousins IT, Diamond M, Fletcher T, Higgins C, Lindeman AE, Peaslee G, de Voogt P, Wang Z, Weber R \| display\-authors\=6 \| title\=The Madrid Statement on Poly\- and Perfluoroalkyl Substances (PFASs) \| journal\=Environmental Health Perspectives \| volume\=123 \| issue\=5 \| pages\=A107\-111 \| date\=May 2015 \| pmid\=25932614 \| pmc\=4421777 \| doi\=10\.1289/ehp.1509934}}{{cite web \|url\=https://www.oecd.org/chemicalsafety/portal\-perfluorinated\-chemicals/webinars/Presentation%203\_Melisa.pdf \| title\=Phasing out PFOS under the Stockholm Convention \| first\=Melisa \| last\=Lin \| work\=\[\[OECD]] \| date\=May 2014}} The convention has been ratified by 186 jurisdictions, but has most notably not been ratified by the United States, Israel, and Malaysia.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.pops.int/TheConvention/ThePOPs/AllPOPs/tabid/2509/ \| title\=All POPs listed in the Stockholm Convention \| website\=pops.int}} The long\-chain (C9–C21) PFCAs are currently under review for listing.{{Cite web \|url\=https://www.pops.int/TheConvention/ThePOPs/ChemicalsProposedforListing/tabid/2510/
\|title\=Chemicals proposed for listing under the Convention \|website\=pops.int}}
|
[
"Concerns, litigation, and regulations in specific countries and regions\n-----------------------------------------------------------------------",
"### Arctic",
"In 2024, research at [McGill University](/wiki/McGill_University \"McGill University\") in Quebec,Léandri\\-Breton, Don\\-Jean, et al., *[Winter Tracking Data Suggest that Migratory Seabirds Transport Per\\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances to Their Arctic Nesting Site](https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.est.4c02661)*, ACS Publications, July 11, 2024 indicated that PFASs were being brought to the Arctic from polluted southern waters by migrating birds.von Herff, William, *[Migrating Seabirds Are Bringing Forever Chemicals Into the Arctic](https://hakaimagazine.com/news/migrating-seabirds-are-bringing-forever-chemicals-into-the-arctic/)*, [Hakai Magazine](/wiki/Hakai_Magazine \"Hakai Magazine\"), October 4, 2024 Although it is much less than compared to the introduction by wind and the oceans, the birds become vectors, transmitting the toxic chemicals. Rainer Lohmann, an oceanographer at the [University of Rhode Island](/wiki/University_of_Rhode_Island \"University of Rhode Island\"), noted that this has a significant localized affect that is devastating for Arctic predators who accumulate toxins in their bodies because the contaminants from the birds often enter the food chain directly since the birds are the prey of many species.",
"### Australia",
"In 2017, the [ABC](/wiki/Australian_Broadcasting_Corporation \"Australian Broadcasting Corporation\")'s current affairs program [*Four Corners*](/wiki/Four_Corners_%28Australian_TV_program%29 \"Four Corners (Australian TV program)\") reported that the storage and use of firefighting foams containing perfluorinated surfactants at [Australian Defence Force](/wiki/Australian_Defence_Force \"Australian Defence Force\") facilities around Australia had contaminated nearby water resources.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.abc.net.au/news/2017\\-10\\-10/pfas\\-chemicals\\-katherine\\-residents\\-shocked\\-demand\\-action/9034504 \\|title\\='Shocked and disgusted' Katherine residents demand action on PFAS contamination \\| work\\=\\[\\[Australian Broadcasting Corporation]] \\|date\\=October 10, 2017 \\|archive\\-date\\=October 10, 2017\\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20171010073127/http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017\\-10\\-10/pfas\\-chemicals\\-katherine\\-residents\\-shocked\\-demand\\-action/9034504\\|url\\-status\\=live}} In 2019, remediation efforts at [RAAF Base Tindal](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Tindal \"RAAF Base Tindal\") and the adjacent town of Katherine were ongoing.{{cite news \\|url\\=https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/6527835/tindals\\-pfas\\-hot\\-spots\\-record\\-startling\\-results/ \\|title\\=Tindal's PFAS hot spots record startling results \\| first\\=Chris \\| last\\=McLennan \\| work\\=Katherine Times \\| date\\=December 4, 2019 \\| archive\\-date\\=February 21, 2020 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200221111934/https://www.katherinetimes.com.au/story/6527835/tindals\\-pfas\\-hot\\-spots\\-record\\-startling\\-results/ \\| url\\-status\\=live}} In the 2022 [Australian federal budget](/wiki/Australian_federal_budget \"Australian federal budget\") $428{{nbsp}}million was allocated for works at [HMAS *Albatross*](/wiki/HMAS_Albatross_%28air_station%29 \"HMAS Albatross (air station)\"), [RAAF Base Amberley](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Amberley \"RAAF Base Amberley\"), [RAAF Base Pearce](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Pearce \"RAAF Base Pearce\") and [RAAF Base Richmond](/wiki/RAAF_Base_Richmond \"RAAF Base Richmond\") including funding to remediate PFAS contamination.{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/airbases\\-to\\-get\\-428\\-million\\-upgrade\\-as\\-government\\-switches\\-back\\-to\\-national\\-security\\-20220421\\-p5af77\\.html \\| first\\=Katina \\| last\\=Curtis \\| title\\=Airbases to get $428 million upgrade as government switches back to national security \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Sydney Morning Herald]] \\| date\\=April 21, 2022}}",
"### Canada",
"Although PFASs are not manufactured in Canada, they may be present in imported goods and products. In 2008, products containing PFOS as well as PFOA were banned in Canada, with exceptions for products used in firefighting, the military, and some forms of ink and photo media.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://ncceh.ca/resources/blog/keeping\\-drinking\\-water\\-safe\\-new\\-guidelines\\-pfas\\-canada \\| first\\=Juliette \\| last\\=O'Keeffe \\|title\\=Keeping Drinking Water Safe: New Guidelines for PFASs in Canada \\| website\\=National Collaborating Centre for Environmental Health \\| archive\\-date\\=August 7, 2020 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200807233146/https://ncceh.ca/content/blog/keeping\\-drinking\\-water\\-safe\\-new\\-guidelines\\-pfas\\-canada \\| url\\-status\\=live}}",
"Health Canada has published drinking water guidelines for maximum concentrations of PFOS and PFOA to protect the health of Canadians, including children, over a lifetime's exposure to these substances. The maximum allowable concentration for PFOS under the guidelines is 0\\.0002 milligrams per liter. The maximum allowable concentration for PFOA is 0\\.0006 milligrams per liter.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.canada.ca/en/services/health/publications/healthy\\-living/water\\-talk\\-drinking\\-water\\-screening\\-values\\-perfluoroalkylated\\-substances.html \\| title\\=Perfluoroalkylated substances in drinking water \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[Government of Canada]] \\| date\\=April 2019 \\| archive\\-date\\=August 15, 2020 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200815112519/https://www.canada.ca/en/services/health/publications/healthy\\-living/water\\-talk\\-drinking\\-water\\-screening\\-values\\-perfluoroalkylated\\-substances.html \\| url\\-status\\=live}} In August 2024, Health Canada established an objective of 30 ng/L for the sum of the concentration of 25 PFASs[PFCAs](/wiki/PFCAs \"PFCAs\"): [C4](/wiki/Perfluorobutanoic_acid \"Perfluorobutanoic acid\")–C12; [PFSAs](/wiki/PFSAs \"PFSAs\"): [C4](/wiki/Perfluorobutanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorobutanesulfonic acid\")–[C8](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid\"); PFECAs: [PFMOPrA](/wiki/d:Q81977241 \"Q81977241\"), [PFMOBA](/wiki/d:Q81977612 \"Q81977612\"), [3,6\\-OPFHpA](/wiki/d:Q81977557 \"Q81977557\"), [HFPO\\-DA](/wiki/HFPO-DA \"HFPO-DA\"), [DONA](/wiki/d:Q81981675 \"Q81981675\"); PFESAs: [6:2 Cl\\-PFESA](/wiki/d:Q81982190 \"Q81982190\"), [8:2 Cl\\-PFESA](/wiki/d:Q81982192 \"Q81982192\"), [PFEESA](/wiki/d:Q81985827 \"Q81985827\"); FTSs: [4:2 FTS](/wiki/d:Q81981864 \"Q81981864\"), [6:2 FTS](/wiki/6:2_FTS \"2 FTS\"), [8:2 FTS](/wiki/d:Q66828157 \"Q66828157\") detected in drinking water.{{Cite web \\|last\\= \\|first\\= \\|date\\=2024\\-08\\-09 \\|title\\=Objective for Canadian drinking water quality per\\- and polyfluoroalkyl substances \\|url\\=https://www.canada.ca/en/health\\-canada/services/publications/healthy\\-living/objective\\-drinking\\-water\\-quality\\-per\\-polyfluoroalkyl\\-substances.html \\|access\\-date\\=2024\\-08\\-18 \\|website\\=www.canada.ca \\|publisher\\=Health Canada}}",
"### New Zealand",
"The New Zealand Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has banned the use of per\\- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in cosmetic products starting from 31 December 2026\\. This will make the country one of the first in the world to take this step on PFAS to protect people and the environment.{{cite press release \\| url\\=https://www.epa.govt.nz/news\\-and\\-alerts/latest\\-news/epa\\-bans\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-in\\-cosmetic\\-products/ \\| title\\=EPA bans 'forever chemicals' in cosmetic products \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Environmental Protection Authority (New Zealand)]] \\| date\\=30 January 2024}}",
"### United Kingdom",
"The environmental consequences of PFAS, especially from firefighting activities, have been recognized since the mid\\-1990s and came to prominence after the [Buncefield explosion](/wiki/Buncefield_explosion \"Buncefield explosion\") on 11 December 2005\\. The Environment Agency has undertaken a series of projects to understand the scale and nature of PFAS in the environment. The Drinking Water Inspectorate requires water companies to report concentrations of 47 PFAS.{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://dwi\\-content.s3\\.eu\\-west\\-2\\.amazonaws.com/wp\\-content/uploads/2021/10/04203217/Information\\-Letter\\-PFAS\\-Monitoring.pdf \\| title\\=Requirements for PFAS monitoring by water companies in England and Wales \\| work\\=\\[\\[Drinking Water Inspectorate]] \\| date\\=1 October 2021}}",
"### European Union",
"Many PFASs are either not covered by European legislation or are excluded from registration obligations under the EU [Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals](/wiki/Registration%2C_Evaluation%2C_Authorisation_and_Restriction_of_Chemicals \"Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals\") (REACH) chemical regulation.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.env\\-health.org/the\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-that\\-are\\-harming\\-our\\-health\\-pfas/ \\|title\\=The \"forever chemicals\" that are harming our health: PFAS \\|date\\=February 4, 2020 \\|website\\=Health and Environment Alliance \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200206122946/https://www.env\\-health.org/the\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-that\\-are\\-harming\\-our\\-health\\-pfas/ \\| archive\\-date\\=February 6, 2020 \\| url\\-status\\=live}} Several PFASs have been detected in drinking water,{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Thomaidi VS, Tsahouridou A, Matsoukas C, Stasinakis AS, Petreas M, Kalantzi OI \\| title\\=Risk assessment of PFASs in drinking water using a probabilistic risk quotient methodology \\| journal\\=The Science of the Total Environment \\| volume\\=712 \\| pages\\=136485 \\| date\\=April 2020 \\| pmid\\=31927447 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.scitotenv.2019\\.136485 \\| bibcode\\=2020ScTEn.71236485T \\| s2cid\\=210167277}} municipal wastewater,{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Arvaniti OS, Stasinakis AS \\| title\\=Review on the occurrence, fate and removal of perfluorinated compounds during wastewater treatment \\| journal\\=The Science of the Total Environment \\| volume\\=524\\-525 \\| pages\\=81–92 \\| date\\=August 2015 \\| pmid\\=25889547 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.scitotenv.2015\\.04\\.023 \\| bibcode\\=2015ScTEn.524\\...81A}} and landfill leachates{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Nika MC, Ntaiou K, Elytis K, Thomaidi VS, Gatidou G, Kalantzi OI, Thomaidis NS, Stasinakis AS \\| display\\-authors\\=6 \\| title\\=Wide\\-scope target analysis of emerging contaminants in landfill leachates and risk assessment using Risk Quotient methodology \\| journal\\=Journal of Hazardous Materials \\| volume\\=394 \\| pages\\=122493 \\| date\\=July 2020 \\| pmid\\=32240898 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.jhazmat.2020\\.122493 \\| bibcode\\=2020JHzM..39422493N \\| s2cid\\=214766390}} worldwide.",
"In 2019, the [European Council](/wiki/European_Council \"European Council\") requested the [European Commission](/wiki/European_Commission \"European Commission\") to develop an action plan to eliminate all non\\-essential uses of PFAS due to the growing evidence of adverse effects caused by exposure to these substances; the evidence for the widespread occurrence of PFAS in water, soil, articles, and waste; and the threat it can pose to drinking water.{{cite press release \\| website\\=\\[\\[European Council]] \\| title\\=Council Conclusions on Chemicals \\| url\\=https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press\\-releases/2019/06/26/council\\-conclusions\\-on\\-chemicals/}} Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, and Sweden submitted a so\\-called restriction proposal based on the REACH regulation to achieve a European ban on the production, use, sale and import of PFAS.{{cite web \\| website\\=RIVM \\| title\\=PFAS \\| url\\=https://www.rivm.nl/pfas}} The proposal states that a ban is necessary for all use of PFAS, with different periods for different applications when the ban takes effect (immediately after the restriction comes into force, five years afterward, or 12 years afterward), depending on the function and the availability of alternatives. The proposal has not assessed the use of PFAS in medicines, plant protection products, and biocides because specific regulations apply to those substances (Biocidal Products Regulation, [Plant Protection Products Regulation](/wiki/Plant_Protection_Products_Regulation \"Plant Protection Products Regulation\"), Medicinal Products Regulation) that have an explicit authorization procedure that focuses on risk for health and the environment.",
"The proposal was submitted on 13 January 2023 and published by the [European Chemicals Agency](/wiki/European_Chemicals_Agency \"European Chemicals Agency\") (ECHA) on 7 February. From 22 March to 21 September, citizens, companies, and other organizations commented on the proposal during a public consultation.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://echa.europa.eu/\\-/echa\\-publishes\\-pfas\\-restriction\\-proposal \\| title\\=ECHA publishes PFAS restriction proposal \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[European Chemicals Agency]]}} Based on the information in the restriction proposal and the consultation, two committees from ECHA formulate an opinion on the risk and socio\\-economic aspects of the proposed restriction. Within a year of publication, the opinions are sent to the European Commission, which makes a final proposal that is submitted to the EU Member States for discussion and decision.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/reach/restrictions/restriction\\-procedure \\| title\\=Restriction procedure \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[European Chemicals Agency]]}} Eighteen months after the publication of the restriction decision (which may differ from the original proposal), it will enter into force.",
"### Italy",
"127,000 residents in the [Veneto](/wiki/Veneto \"Veneto\") region are estimated to have been exposed to contamination through tap water, and it is thought to be Europe's biggest PFAS\\-related environmental disaster.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.who.int/europe/publications/i/item/9789289052467 \\|title\\=Keeping our water clean: the case of water contamination in the Veneto Region, Italy \\| website\\=www.who.int}} While Italy's National Health Institute (ISS, *Istituto Superiore di Sanità*) set the threshold limit of PFOA in the bloodstream at 8 nanograms per milliliter (ng/mL), some residents had reached 262 and some industrial employees reach 91,900 ng/mL. In 2021 some data was disclosed by [Greenpeace](/wiki/Greenpeace \"Greenpeace\") and local citizens after a long legal battle against the Veneto Region and ISS, which for years has denied access to data, despite values known since or even before 2017\\. The Veneto region has not carried out further monitoring or taken resolutive actions to eliminate pollution and reduce, at least gradually, the contamination of non\\-potable water. Although in 2020 the [European Food Safety Agency](/wiki/European_Food_Safety_Agency \"European Food Safety Agency\") (EFSA) has reduced by more than four times the maximum tolerable limit of PFAS that can be taken through the diet, the region has not carried out new assessments or implemented concrete actions to protect the population and the agri\\-food and livestock sectors. Some limits were added to monitoring the geographical area, which does not include the orange zone and other areas affected by contamination, as well as the insufficiency of analysis on important productions widespread in the areas concerned: eggs (up to 37,100 ng/kg), fish (18,600 ng/kg) spinach and [radicchio](/wiki/Radicchio \"Radicchio\") (only one sampling carried out), kiwis, melons, watermelons, cereals (only one sample was analyzed), soy, wines and apples.[PFAS negli alimenti dell’area rossa del Veneto](https://www.greenpeace.org/static/planet4-italy-stateless/2021/09/7818ce34-pfas-negli-alimenti-dellarea-rossa-del-veneto.pdf), Greenpeace.",
"### Japan",
"A study of public water bodies ending in March 2022 showed that the sum of PFOS and PFOA concentrations exceeded 50 ng/L in 81 out of 1,133 test sites and in some cases are present at elevated levels in blood. This has led to pressure to increase regulations.{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2023/05/28/national/japan\\-pfas\\-risks\\-growing\\-awareness/ \\| title\\=Japan slowly wakes up to health risks of PFAS 'forever chemicals' \\| first\\=TOMOKO \\| last\\=OTAKE \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Japan Times]] \\| date\\=May 28, 2023}}",
"### Sweden",
"Highly contaminated drinking water has been detected at several locations in Sweden. Such locations include Arvidsjaur, Lulnäset, Uppsala and Visby.{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Gyllenhammar I, Berger U, Sundström M, McCleaf P, Eurén K, Eriksson S, Ahlgren S, Lignell S, Aune M, Kotova N, Glynn A \\| display\\-authors\\=6 \\| title\\=Influence of contaminated drinking water on perfluoroalkyl acid levels in human serum\\-\\-A case study from Uppsala, Sweden \\| journal\\=Environmental Research \\| volume\\=140 \\| pages\\=673–683 \\| date\\=July 2015 \\| pmid\\=26079316 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.envres.2015\\.05\\.019 \\| bibcode\\=2015ER....140\\..673G}}{{cite journal \\| title\\=Quantitative relationships of perfluoroalkyl acids in drinking water associated with serum concentrations above background in adults living near contamination hotspots in Sweden \\| journal\\=Environmental Research \\| first1\\=Gunnar \\| last1\\=Johanson \\| first2\\=Irina \\| last2\\=Gyllenhammar \\| first3\\=Carl \\| last3\\=Ekstrand\\| first4\\=Andrei \\| last4\\=Pyko \\| first5\\=Yiyi \\| last5\\=Xu \\| first6\\=Ying \\| last6\\=Li \\| first7\\=Karin \\| last7\\=Norström \\| first8\\=Karl \\| last8\\=Lilja \\| first9\\=Christian \\| last9\\=Lindh \\| first10\\=Jonathan P \\| last10\\=Benskin \\| first11\\=Antonios \\| last11\\=Georgelis \\| first12\\=Karl \\| last12\\=Forsell \\| first13\\=Kristina \\| last13\\=Jakobsson \\| first14\\=Anders \\| last14\\=Glynn \\| first15\\=Carolina \\| last15\\=Vogs \\| volume\\=219 \\| pages\\=115024 \\| date\\=February 2023 \\| pmid\\=36535390 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.envres.2022\\.115024 \\| doi\\-access\\=free \\| bibcode\\=2023ER....21915024J}} In 2013, PFAS were detected at high concentrations in one of the two municipality drinking water treatment plants in the town of Ronneby, in southern Sweden. Concentrations of [PFHxS](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid\") and [PFOS](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid\") were found at 1700 ng/L and 8000 ng/L, respectively.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://sodrasjukvardsregionen.se/download/exponering\\-for\\-perfluorerade\\-amnen\\-pfas\\-i\\-dricksvatten\\-i\\-ronneby\\-kommun/?wpdmdl\\=2485\\&refresh\\=5fc8b036ccf3e1606987830 \\| first1\\=Kristina \\| last1\\=Jakobsson \\| first2\\=Kerstin Kronholm \\| last2\\=Diab \\| first3\\=Christian \\| last3\\=Lindh \\| first4\\=Bodil \\| last4\\=Persson \\| first5\\=Bo \\| last5\\=Jönsson \\| title\\=Exponering för perfluorerade ämnen (PFAS) i dricksvatten i Ronneby kommun \\|date\\=June 12, 2014}} The source of contamination was later found to be a military fire\\-fighting exercise site in which PFAS containing fire\\-fighting foam had been used since the mid\\-1980s.{{cite journal \\| first1\\=Ying \\|last1\\=Li \\| first2\\=Axel \\| last2\\=Andersson \\| first3\\=Yiyi \\| last3\\=Xu \\| first4\\=Daniela \\| last4\\=Pineda \\| first5\\=Carina A \\| last5\\=Nilsson \\| first6\\=Christian H \\| last6\\=Lindh \\| first7\\=Kristina \\| last7\\=Jakobsson \\| first8\\=Tony \\| last8\\=Fletcher \\| title\\=Determinants of serum half\\-lives for linear and branched perfluoroalkyl substances after long\\-term high exposure\\-A study in Ronneby, Sweden \\| journal\\=Environment International \\| volume\\=163 \\| pages\\=107198 \\| date\\=May 2022 \\| pmid\\=35447437 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.envint.2022\\.107198 \\| s2cid\\=248247530 \\| doi\\-access\\=free \\| bibcode\\=2022EnInt.16307198L}}",
"Additionally, low\\-level contaminated drinking water has also been shown to be a significant exposure source of [PFOA](/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid \"Perfluorooctanoic acid\"), [PFNA](/wiki/Perfluorononanoic_acid \"Perfluorononanoic acid\"), [PFHxS](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid\") and [PFOS](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid\") for Swedish adolescents (ages 10–21\\). Even though the median concentrations in the municipality drinking water were below one ng/L for each individual PFAS, positive associations were found between adolescent serum PFAS concentrations and PFAS concentrations in drinking water.{{cite journal \\| first1\\=Jennifer \\| last1\\=Nyström\\-Kandola \\| first2\\=Lutz \\| last2\\=Ahrens \\| first3\\=Anders \\| last3\\=Glynn \\| first4\\=Gunnar \\| last4\\=Johanson \\| first5\\=Jonathan P \\| last5\\=Benskin \\| first6\\=Irina \\| last6\\=Gyllenhammar \\|first7\\=Sanna \\| last7\\=Lignell \\| first8\\=Carolina \\| last8\\=Vogs \\| title\\=Low concentrations of perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) in municipal drinking water associated with serum PFAA concentrations in Swedish adolescents \\| journal\\=Environment International \\| volume\\=180 \\| pages\\=108166 \\| date\\=October 2023 \\| pmid\\=37708812 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.envint.2023\\.108166 \\| s2cid\\=261156749 \\| doi\\-access\\=free \\| bibcode\\=2023EnInt.18008166N}}",
"### United States",
"An estimated 26,000 U.S. sites are contaminated with PFASs.{{cite journal \\|url\\=http://online.fliphtml5\\.com/fedq/bohi/\\#p\\=63 \\| last\\=Timmis \\| first\\=Andrew \\| title\\=Using Dredged Materials to Improve a Salt Marsh \\| journal\\=\\[\\[Society of American Military Engineers]] \\| volume\\=110 \\| issue\\=712 \\| page\\=61 \\| date\\=January 2018 \\|archive\\-date\\=November 7, 2018 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181107202305/http://online.fliphtml5\\.com/fedq/bohi/\\#p\\=63 \\|url\\-status\\=live}}{{cite journal \\| first1\\=Xindi C. \\| last1\\=Hu \\| first2\\=David Q. \\| last2\\=Andrews \\| first3\\=Andrew B. \\| last3\\=Lindstrom\\| first4\\=Thomas A. \\| last4\\=Bruton \\| first5\\=Laurel A. \\| last5\\=Schaider \\| first6\\=Philippe \\| last6\\=Grandjean \\| first7\\=Rainer \\| last7\\=Lohmann\\| first8\\=Courtney C. \\| last8\\=Carignan \\| first9\\=Arlene \\| last9\\=Blum \\| authorlink9\\=Arlene Blum \\| first10\\=Simona A. \\| last10\\=Balan \\| first11\\=Christopher P. \\| last11\\=Higgins○ \\| first12\\=Elsie M. \\| last12\\=Sunderland \\|title\\=Detection of Poly\\- and Perfluoroalkyl Substances (PFASs) in U.S. Drinking Water Linked to Industrial Sites, Military Fire Training Areas, and Wastewater Treatment Plants \\|journal\\=Environmental Science \\& Technology Letters \\|volume\\=3 \\|issue\\=10 \\|pages\\=344–350 \\|date\\=October 2016 \\|pmid\\=27752509 \\|pmc\\=5062567 \\| doi\\=10\\.1021/acs.estlett.6b00260\\|bibcode\\=2016EnSTL...3\\..344H}} More than 200 million Americans are estimated to live in places where the PFAS level in tap water, including [PFOA](/wiki/PFOA \"PFOA\") and [PFOS](/wiki/PFOS \"PFOS\") levels, exceeds the 1 ppt (part per trillion) limit set in 2022 by the EPA.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/forever\\-chemicals\\-are\\-widespread\\-in\\-u\\-s\\-drinking\\-water/ \\| author\\=Sneed A \\|title\\=Forever Chemicals Are Widespread in U.S. Drinking Water: Experts hope that with the incoming Biden administration, the federal government will finally regulate a class of chemicals known as PFASs \\| work\\=\\[\\[Scientific American]] \\| date\\=January 22, 2021}}",
"Based on tap water studies from 716 locations from 2016 and 2021, the [U.S. Geological Survey](/wiki/U.S._Geological_Survey \"U.S. Geological Survey\") (USGS) found that the PFAS levels exceeded the EPA advisories in approximately 75% of the samples from urban areas and in approximately 25% of the rural area samples.{{Cite press release \\|title\\=Tap water study detects PFAS 'forever chemicals' across the US \\|url\\=https://www.usgs.gov/news/national\\-news\\-release/tap\\-water\\-study\\-detects\\-pfas\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-across\\-us \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[U.S. Geological Survey]] \\|id\\=National News Release \\|date\\=July 5, 2023}}",
"Certain PFASs are no longer manufactured in the United States as a result of phase\\-outs including the PFOA Stewardship Program (2010–2015\\), in which eight major chemical manufacturers agreed to eliminate the use of PFOA and PFOA\\-related chemicals in their products and emissions from their facilities. However, they are still produced internationally and are imported into the U.S. in consumer goods.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/assessing\\-and\\-managing\\-chemicals\\-under\\-tsca/fact\\-sheet\\-20102015\\-pfoa\\-stewardship\\-program \\|title\\=Fact Sheet: 2010/2015 PFOA Stewardship Program \\|date\\=August 9, 2018 \\|website\\=Assessing and Managing Chemicals under TSCA \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\|archive\\-date\\=December 8, 2018 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181208160450/https://www.epa.gov/assessing\\-and\\-managing\\-chemicals\\-under\\-tsca/fact\\-sheet\\-20102015\\-pfoa\\-stewardship\\-program \\|url\\-status\\=live}}{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic\\-information\\-pfas \\|title\\=Basic Information on PFAS \\|date\\=30 March 2016 \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| archive\\-date\\=December 23, 2018 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181223025822/https://www.epa.gov/pfas/basic\\-information\\-pfas \\|url\\-status\\=live}} Some types of PFAS are voluntarily not included in [food packaging](/wiki/Food_packaging \"Food packaging\").{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.fda.gov/news\\-events/press\\-announcements/fda\\-announces\\-voluntary\\-agreement\\-manufacturers\\-phase\\-out\\-certain\\-short\\-chain\\-pfas\\-used\\-food \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[Food and Drug Administration]] \\| last\\=Hahn \\| first\\=Stephen M. \\|title\\=FDA Announces Voluntary Agreement with Manufacturers to Phase Out Certain Short\\-Chain PFAS Used in Food Packaging \\|date\\=31 July 2020 \\| archive\\-date\\=August 2, 2020 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200802044359/https://www.fda.gov/news\\-events/press\\-announcements/fda\\-announces\\-voluntary\\-agreement\\-manufacturers\\-phase\\-out\\-certain\\-short\\-chain\\-pfas\\-used\\-food \\|url\\-status\\=live}}",
"In 2021, Senators [Susan Collins](/wiki/Susan_Collins \"Susan Collins\") of Maine and [Richard Blumenthal](/wiki/Richard_Blumenthal \"Richard Blumenthal\") of Connecticut proposed the No PFAS in Cosmetics Act in the [United States Senate](/wiki/United_States_Senate \"United States Senate\").{{cite news \\|title\\=Senate bill would ban toxic 'forever chemicals' in makeup, which new study found are often unlabeled \\| url\\=https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate\\-environment/2021/06/15/toxic\\-pfas\\-makeup/ \\| last\\=Root \\| first\\=Tik \\|newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]] \\|date\\=June 15, 2021 \\|archive\\-date\\=June 16, 2021 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210616161229/https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate\\-environment/2021/06/15/toxic\\-pfas\\-makeup/ \\|url\\-status\\=live}} It was also introduced in the [United States House of Representatives](/wiki/United_States_House_of_Representatives \"United States House of Representatives\") by Michigan Representative [Debbie Dingell](/wiki/Debbie_Dingell \"Debbie Dingell\"),{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/15/health/makeup\\-toxic\\-chemicals\\-wellness/index.html \\| author\\=LaMotte S \\|title\\=Makeup may contain potentially toxic chemicals called PFAS, study finds \\| work\\=CNN \\| date\\=June 15, 2021 \\|archive\\-date\\=June 29, 2021 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210629021146/https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/15/health/makeup\\-toxic\\-chemicals\\-wellness/index.html \\|url\\-status\\=live}} but the [Republican Party](/wiki/Republican_Party_%28United_States%29 \"Republican Party (United States)\"), supported by the U.S. chemical industry [filibustered](/wiki/Filibuster \"Filibuster\") the bill.{{Cite news \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jan/13/pfas\\-toxic\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-republican\\-house \\| last\\=Perkins \\| first\\=Tom \\| title\\=Bills to regulate toxic 'forever chemicals' died in Congress – with Republican help \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\| date\\=January 13, 2023 \\|issn\\=0261\\-3077}}",
"#### Military bases",
"The water in and around at least 126 U.S. military bases has been contaminated by high levels of PFASs because of their use of firefighting foams since the 1970s, according to a study by the [U.S. Department of Defense](/wiki/U.S._Department_of_Defense \"U.S. Department of Defense\"). Of these, 90 bases reported PFAS contamination that had spread to drinking water or groundwater off the base.{{cite web \\| title\\=DoD: At Least 126 Bases Report Water Contaminants Linked to Cancer, Birth Defects \\| url\\=https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your\\-military/2018/04/26/dod\\-126\\-bases\\-report\\-water\\-contaminants\\-harmful\\-to\\-infant\\-development\\-tied\\-to\\-cancers/ \\|work\\=\\[\\[Military Times]] \\|date\\=April 26, 2018 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20200506043631/https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your\\-military/2018/04/26/dod\\-126\\-bases\\-report\\-water\\-contaminants\\-harmful\\-to\\-infant\\-development\\-tied\\-to\\-cancers/ \\| archive\\-date\\=May 6, 2020 \\| url\\-status\\=live}}",
"In 2022, a report by the Pentagon acknowledged that approximately 175,000 U.S. military personnel at two dozen American military facilities drank water contaminated by PFAS that exceeded the U.S. EPA limit. However, according to the [Environmental Working Group](/wiki/Environmental_Working_Group \"Environmental Working Group\"), the Pentagon report downplayed the number of people exposed to PFAS, which was probably over 640,000 at 116 military facilities. The EWG found that the Pentagon also omitted from its report some types of diseases that are likely to be caused by PFAS exposure, such as [testicular cancer](/wiki/Testicular_cancer \"Testicular cancer\"), kidney disease, and fetal abnormalities.{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\\-news/2022/dec/23/us\\-soldiers\\-pfas\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-higher\\-rate\\-pentagon\\-military \\| title\\=US Military 'Downplayed' The Number of Soldiers Exposed to 'Forever Chemicals'—Analysis of Pentagon Report Reveals that Soldiers Exposed to PFAS Pollution at Much Higher Rate than Military Claims \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\| date\\=23 December 2022}}",
"#### Environmental Protection Agency actions",
"The [United States Environmental Protection Agency](/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency \"United States Environmental Protection Agency\") has published non\\-enforceable [drinking water health advisories](/wiki/Safe_Drinking_Water_Act%23Health_advisories \"Safe Drinking Water Act#Health advisories\") for PFOA and PFOS.{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/ground\\-water\\-and\\-drinking\\-water/drinking\\-water\\-health\\-advisories\\-pfoa\\-and\\-pfos \\|title\\=Drinking Water Health Advisories for PFOA and PFOS \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\|date\\=December 9, 2020 \\| archive\\-date\\=December 28, 2020 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201228004056/https://www.epa.gov/ground\\-water\\-and\\-drinking\\-water/drinking\\-water\\-health\\-advisories\\-pfoa\\-and\\-pfos \\|url\\-status\\=live}}{{cite web \\| title\\=Fact Sheet; PFOA \\& PFOS Drinking Water Health Advisories \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/ground\\-water\\-and\\-drinking\\-water/supporting\\-documents\\-drinking\\-water\\-health\\-advisories\\-pfoa\\-and\\-pfos \\| date\\=November 2016 \\|id\\=EPA 800\\-F\\-16\\-003 \\|archive\\-date\\=December 26, 2020 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201226125900/https://www.epa.gov/ground\\-water\\-and\\-drinking\\-water/supporting\\-documents\\-drinking\\-water\\-health\\-advisories\\-pfoa\\-and\\-pfos \\|url\\-status\\=live}} In March 2021 EPA announced that it would develop national drinking water standards for PFOA and PFOS.EPA (2021\\-03\\-03\\). \"Announcement of Final Regulatory Determinations for Contaminants on the Fourth Drinking Water Contaminant Candidate List.\" *Federal Register,* {{usfr\\|86\\|12272}} Drinking water utilities are required to monitor PFAS levels and may receive subsidies to do so.EPA (2021\\-12\\-27\\). \"Revisions to the Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule (UCMR 5\\) for Public Water Systems and Announcement of Public Meetings.\" *Federal Register,* {{USFR\\|86\\|73131}}{{cite web \\|title\\=Fifth Unregulated Contaminant Monitoring Rule \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/dwucmr/fifth\\-unregulated\\-contaminant\\-monitoring\\-rule \\| date\\=February 22, 2022 \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}} There are also regulations regarding wastewater ([effluent guidelines](/wiki/Effluent_guidelines \"Effluent guidelines\")) for industries that use PFASs in the manufacturing process as well as [biosolids](/wiki/Biosolids \"Biosolids\") (processed wastewater [sludge](/wiki/Sludge \"Sludge\") used as fertilizer).{{cite web \\|title\\=Organic Chemicals, Plastics and Synthetic Fibers Effluent Guidelines \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/eg/organic\\-chemicals\\-plastics\\-and\\-synthetic\\-fibers\\-effluent\\-guidelines \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| date\\=July 13, 2021}}{{cite web \\|title\\=Metal Finishing Effluent Guidelines \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/eg/metal\\-finishing\\-effluent\\-guidelines \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\|date\\=September 24, 2021}}{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/pfas\\-strategic\\-roadmap\\-epas\\-commitments\\-action\\-2021\\-2024 \\| title\\=PFAS Strategic Roadmap: EPA's Commitments to Action 2021\\-2024 \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| date\\=January 27, 2022}}{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/biosolids/risk\\-assessment\\-pollutants\\-biosolids \\|title\\=Risk Assessment of Pollutants in Biosolids \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| date\\=May 3, 2022}}{{cite web \\| title\\=Meaningful and Achievable Steps You Can Take to Reduce Your Risk \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/pfas/meaningful\\-and\\-achievable\\-steps\\-you\\-can\\-take\\-reduce\\-your\\-risk \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| date\\=August 18, 2022}}",
"The EPA issued health advisories for four specific PFASs in June 2022, significantly lowering their safe threshold levels for drinking water. PFOA was reduced from 70 ppt to 0\\.004 ppt, while PFOS was reduced from 70 ppt to 0\\.02 ppt. A safe level for the compound [GenX](/wiki/GenX \"GenX\") was set at 10 ppt, while that for [PFBS](/wiki/PFBS \"PFBS\") was set at 2000 ppt. While not enforceable, these health advisories are intended to be acted on by states in setting their own drinking water standards.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.wsj.com/articles/epa\\-lowers\\-bar\\-for\\-pfas\\-contamination\\-11655318054 \\|title\\=EPA Lowers Bar for Toxic Chemicals Contamination \\| last\\=Maher \\| first\\=Kris \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Wall Street Journal]] \\| date\\=June 15, 2022 \\| url\\-access\\=subscription}}",
"In August 2022, the EPA proposed to add PFOA and PFOS to its list of hazardous substances under the [Superfund](/wiki/Superfund \"Superfund\") law.{{cite news \\| last\\=Grandoni \\| first\\=Dino \\| title\\=EPA finally moves to label some 'forever chemicals' as hazardous \\| url\\=https://washingtonpost.com/climate\\-environment/2022/08/26/forever\\-chemicals\\-epa\\-cleanup\\-rule/ \\| newspaper\\=\\[\\[The Washington Post]] \\| date\\=August 26, 2022 \\| url\\-access\\=limited}} EPA issued a final rule in April 2024, which requires that polluters pay for investigations and cleanup of these substances.{{cite web \\|title\\=Designation of Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) and Perfluorooctanesulfonic Acid (PFOS) as CERCLA Hazardous Substances \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/superfund/designation\\-perfluorooctanoic\\-acid\\-pfoa\\-and\\-perfluorooctanesulfonic\\-acid\\-pfos\\-cercla \\| date\\=May 8, 2024 \\| website\\=\\[\\[Superfund]] \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}}{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/19/climate/epa\\-pfas\\-superfund\\-cleanup.html \\| title\\=E.P.A. Will Make Polluters Pay to Clean Up Two 'Forever Chemicals' \\| first\\=Coral \\| last\\=Davenport \\| newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\| date\\=April 19, 2024 \\| url\\-access\\=limited}}",
"[thumb\\|upright\\=1\\.35\\|USGS map showing the number of PFAS detections in tap water samples from select sites across the US.](/wiki/File:PFAS-Tapwater_DetectionMap_1.png \"PFAS-Tapwater DetectionMap 1.png\")\nIn April 2024, the EPA issued a final drinking water rule for PFOA, PFOS, [GenX](/wiki/GenX \"GenX\"), PFBS, PFNA, and PFHxS. Within three years, [public water systems](/wiki/Public_water_system \"Public water system\") must remove these six PFAS to near\\-zero levels. States may be awarded grants up to $1 billion in aid to help with the initial testing and treatment of water for this purpose.[United States Environmental Protection Agency](/wiki/United_States_Environmental_Protection_Agency \"United States Environmental Protection Agency\") (April 26, 2024\\). \"PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation.\" *Federal Register,* {{USFR\\|89\\|32532}}{{cite web \\|title\\=Final PFAS National Primary Drinking Water Regulation \\|url\\=https://www.epa.gov/sdwa/and\\-polyfluoroalkyl\\-substances\\-pfas \\|date\\=May 22, 2024 \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]]}}{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/10/climate/epa\\-pfas\\-drinking\\-water.html \\| title\\=E.P.A. Says 'Forever Chemicals' Must Be Removed From Tap Water \\| first\\=Lisa \\| last\\=Friedman \\| newspaper\\=\\[\\[The New York Times]] \\| date\\=April 10, 2024 \\| url\\-access\\=limited}}{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health\\-news/epa\\-limits\\-pfas\\-chemicals\\-drinking\\-water\\-first\\-time\\-rcna147000 \\| title\\=EPA imposes first national limits on 'forever chemicals' in drinking water \\| first\\=Aria \\| last\\=Bendix \\| work\\=\\[\\[NBC News]] \\| date\\=April 10, 2024}}{{Cite press release \\| url\\=https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/biden\\-harris\\-administration\\-finalizes\\-first\\-ever\\-national\\-drinking\\-water\\-standard \\| title\\=Biden\\-Harris Administration Finalizes First\\-Ever National Drinking Water Standard to Protect 100M People from PFAS Pollution \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[United States Environmental Protection Agency]] \\| date\\=April 10, 2024}}",
"#### Legal actions",
"In February 2017, DuPont and [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours \"Chemours\") (a DuPont [spin\\-off](/wiki/Corporate_spin-off \"Corporate spin-off\")) agreed to pay $671 million to settle lawsuits arising from 3,550 personal injury claims related to the releasing of PFASs from their [Parkersburg, West Virginia](/wiki/Parkersburg%2C_West_Virginia \"Parkersburg, West Virginia\"), plant into the drinking water of several thousand residents.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-du\\-pont\\-lawsuit\\-west\\-virginia\\-idUSKBN15S18U \\| title\\=DuPont settles lawsuits over leak of chemical used to make Teflon \\| first\\=Arathy S. \\| last\\=Nair \\| work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\| date\\=February 13, 2017 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190608111323/https://www.reuters.com/article/us\\-du\\-pont\\-lawsuit\\-west\\-virginia\\-idUSKBN15S18U \\| archive\\-date\\=June 8, 2019 \\| url\\-status\\=live}} This was after a court\\-created independent scientific panel—the C8 Science Panel—found a \"probable link\" between C8 exposure and six illnesses: kidney and testicular cancer, ulcerative colitis, thyroid disease, pregnancy\\-induced hypertension and high cholesterol.",
"In October 2018, a [class action suit](/wiki/Class_action_suit \"Class action suit\") was filed by an Ohio firefighter against several producers of fluorosurfactants, including 3M and DuPont, on behalf of all U.S. residents who may have adverse health effects from exposure to PFASs.{{cite web \\| date\\=October 6, 2018 \\|title\\=Nationwide class action lawsuit targets Dupont, Chemours, 3M, and other makers of PFAS chemicals \\|url\\=https://theintercept.com/2018/10/06/dupont\\-pfas\\-chemicals\\-lawsuit/ \\| website\\=\\[\\[The Intercept]] \\|author\\=Lerner S \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181007111157/https://theintercept.com/2018/10/06/dupont\\-pfas\\-chemicals\\-lawsuit/ \\| archive\\-date\\=October 7, 2018 \\|url\\-status\\=live }} The story is told in the film *[Dark Waters](/wiki/Dark_Waters_%282019_film%29 \"Dark Waters (2019 film)\")*.{{cite news \\|title\\='Dark Waters': 7 of the Film's Stars and Their Real\\-Life Inspirations \\|url\\=https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/lists/true\\-story\\-dark\\-waters\\-how\\-accurate\\-are\\-characters\\-1254811/ \\|last\\=Piña \\| first\\=Christy \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Hollywood Reporter]] \\| date\\=30 November 2019}}",
"In June 2023, [3M](/wiki/3M \"3M\") reached a US$10\\.3 [billion](/wiki/Billion \"Billion\") settlement with several US public water providers to resolve water pollution claims tied to PFAS, while [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours \"Chemours\"), [DuPont](/wiki/DuPont \"DuPont\") and [Corteva](/wiki/Corteva \"Corteva\") settled similar claims for $1\\.19 billion.{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jun/22/3m\\-settlement\\-municipal\\-water\\-systems\\-pfas\\-contamination \\| title\\=3M pays $10\\.3bn to settle water pollution suit over 'forever chemicals' \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\| date\\=June 22, 2023 \\| issn\\=0261\\-3077}}",
"In December 2023, as part of a four\\-year legal battle, the EPA banned Inhance, a Houston, Texas\\-based manufacturer that produces an estimated 200 million containers annually with a process that creates PFOA, from using the manufacturing process.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\\-news/2024/mar/30/pfas\\-ban\\-plastic\\-containers\\-court \\|last\\=Perkins \\| first\\=Tom \\| title\\=US appeals court kills ban on plastic containers contaminated with PFAS \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|date\\=March 30, 2024}}{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jun/01/pfas\\-lawsuit\\-epa\\-plastic\\-containers\\-health\\-danger \\| last\\=Perkins \\| first\\=Tom \\| title\\=Plastic containers still distributed across the US are a potential health disaster \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\| date\\=June 1, 2023}} In March 2024, the [United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit](/wiki/United_States_Court_of_Appeals_for_the_Fifth_Circuit \"United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit\") overturned the ban. While the court did not deny the containers’ health risks, it said that the EPA could not regulate the manufactured containers under [Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976](/wiki/Toxic_Substances_Control_Act_of_1976 \"Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976\"), which only addresses \"new\" chemicals.{{Cite news \\| url\\=https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/us\\-appeals\\-court\\-curtails\\-epas\\-ability\\-regulate\\-pfas\\-under\\-toxic\\-substances\\-law\\-2024\\-03\\-22/ \\| title\\=US appeals court curtails EPA's ability to regulate PFAS under toxic substances law \\| first\\=Clark \\| last\\=Mindock \\| work\\=\\[\\[Reuters]] \\| date\\=March 22, 2024}}",
"#### State actions",
"In 2021, [Maine](/wiki/Maine \"Maine\") became the first U.S. state to ban these compounds in all products by 2030, except for instances deemed \"currently unavoidable\".{{cite news \\| last\\=Perkins \\| first\\=Tom \\|title\\=Maine bans toxic 'forever chemicals' under groundbreaking new law \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/us\\-news/2021/jul/15/maine\\-law\\-pfas\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-ban \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210716071833/https://www.theguardian.com/us\\-news/2021/jul/15/maine\\-law\\-pfas\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-ban \\|archive\\-date\\=July 16, 2021 \\|work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\|date\\=July 16, 2021}}{{Cite journal \\|url\\=https://www.science.org/content/article/maine\\-s\\-ban\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-marks\\-big\\-win\\-some\\-scientists \\| first\\=XIAOZHI \\| last\\=LIM \\|date\\=2021\\-08\\-27 \\|title\\=Maine's ban on 'forever chemicals' marks a big win for some scientists \\|journal\\=\\[\\[Science (journal)\\|Science]] \\|doi\\=10\\.1126/science.abm1382 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210831164644/https://www.science.org/news/2021/08/maine\\-s\\-ban\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-marks\\-big\\-win\\-some\\-scientists \\|archive\\-date\\=31 August 2021 \\|url\\-status\\=live }}",
"{{As of\\|October 2020}}, the states of California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Vermont, and Wisconsin had enforceable drinking water standards for between two and six types of PFAS. The six chemicals (termed by the [Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection](/wiki/Massachusetts_Department_of_Environmental_Protection \"Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection\") as PFAS6\\) are measured either individually or summed as a group depending on the standard; they are:{{cite web \\|url\\=https://mecc.memberclicks.net/assets/Presentations/I\\-495%20PFAS6%20MCL%2010\\-21\\-2020\\.pdf \\|title\\=MassDEP's PFAS6 Drinking Water Standard \\|date\\=October 21, 2020 \\|author\\=\\[\\[Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection]]}}\n* [Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid\") (PFOS)\n* [Perfluorooctanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid \"Perfluorooctanoic acid\") (PFOA)\n* [Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid](/wiki/Perfluorohexanesulfonic_acid \"Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid\") (PFHxS)\n* [Perfluorononanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorononanoic_acid \"Perfluorononanoic acid\") (PFNA)\n* [Perfluoroheptanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluoroheptanoic_acid \"Perfluoroheptanoic acid\") (PFHpA)\n* [Perfluorodecanoic acid](/wiki/Perfluorodecanoic_acid \"Perfluorodecanoic acid\") (PFDA)",
"##### California",
"In 2021 California banned PFASs for use in food packaging and from infant and children's products and also required PFAS cookware in the state to carry a warning label.{{cite news \\| vauthors\\=Duggan T \\|url\\=https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/California\\-bans\\-PFAS\\-chemicals\\-from\\-baby\\-products\\-16512091\\.php \\|title\\=California bans PFAS chemicals from baby products and food packaging \\|date\\=2021\\-10\\-05 \\|work\\=San Francisco Chronicle}}",
"##### Maine",
"A program licensed and promoted by the Maine Department of Environmental Protection that provided free municipal wastewater [sludge](/wiki/Sludge \"Sludge\") ([biosolids](/wiki/Biosolids \"Biosolids\")) to farmers as fertilizer has resulted in PFAS contamination of local drinking water and farm\\-grown produce.{{cite news \\| title\\='I don't know how we'll survive': the farmers facing ruin in America's 'forever chemicals' crisis \\|url\\=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/mar/22/i\\-dont\\-know\\-how\\-well\\-survive\\-the\\-farmers\\-facing\\-ruin\\-in\\-americas\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-crisis \\| first\\=Tom \\| last\\=Perkins \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Guardian]] \\| date\\=March 22, 2022}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.mainepublic.org/environment\\-and\\-outdoors/2022\\-02\\-07/complete\\-crisis\\-as\\-pfas\\-discovery\\-upends\\-life\\-and\\-livelihood\\-of\\-young\\-maine\\-farming\\-family\\|title\\='Complete crisis' as PFAS discovery upends life and livelihood of young Maine farming family\\|date\\=7 February 2022\\|website\\=Maine Public}}",
"##### Michigan",
"The [Michigan](/wiki/Michigan \"Michigan\") PFAS Action Response Team (MPART) was launched in 2017 and is the first multi\\-agency action team of its kind in the nation. Agencies representing health, environment, and other branches of state government have joined together to investigate sources and locations of PFAS contamination in the state, take action to protect people's drinking water, and keep the public informed. Groundwater is tested at locations throughout the state by various parties to ensure safety, compliance with regulations, and proactively detect and remedy potential problems. In 2010, the [Michigan Department of Environmental Quality](/wiki/Michigan_Department_of_Environmental_Quality \"Michigan Department of Environmental Quality\") (MDEQ) discovered levels of PFASs in groundwater monitoring wells at the former [Wurtsmith Air Force Base](/wiki/Wurtsmith_Air_Force_Base \"Wurtsmith Air Force Base\").{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://www.circleofblue.org/2018/world/fear\\-and\\-fury\\-in\\-michigan\\-town\\-where\\-air\\-force\\-contaminated\\-water/ \\|last\\=Walton \\|first\\=Brett \\| date\\=April 11, 2018 \\|title\\=Fear and Fury in Michigan Town Where Air Force Contaminated Water \\| website\\=Circle of Blue \\|language\\=en\\-US}} In 2024, citizen\\-led testing near the base in [Oscoda](/wiki/Oscoda%2C_Michigan \"Oscoda, Michigan\") discovered high levels of PFAS in foam along the shore of [Lake Huron](/wiki/Lake_Huron \"Lake Huron\").{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan\\-environment\\-watch/pfas\\-tainted\\-foam\\-lake\\-huron\\-prompts\\-citizen\\-outcry\\|title\\=PFAS\\-tainted foam in Lake Huron prompts citizen outcry \\| work\\=\\[\\[Bridge Michigan]] \\|date\\=May 22, 2024}} As additional information became available from other national testing, Michigan expanded its investigations into other locations where PFAS compounds were potentially used. In 2018, the MDEQ's Remediation and Redevelopment Division (RRD) established cleanup criteria for groundwater used as drinking water of 70 ppt of PFOA and PFOS, individually or combined. The RRD staff are responsible for implementing these criteria as part of their ongoing efforts to clean up sites of environmental contamination. The RRD staff are the lead investigators at most of the PFAS sites on the MPART website and also conduct interim response activities, such as coordinating bottled water or filter installations with local health departments at sites under investigation or with known PFAS concerns. Most of the groundwater sampling at PFAS sites under RRD's lead is conducted by contractors familiar with PFAS sampling techniques. The RRD also has a Geologic Services Unit, with staff who install monitoring wells and are also well versed with PFAS sampling techniques. The MDEQ has been conducting environmental clean\\-up of regulated contaminants for decades. Due to the evolving nature of PFAS regulations as new science becomes available, the RRD is evaluating the need for regular PFAS sampling at [Superfund](/wiki/Superfund \"Superfund\") sites and is including an evaluation of PFAS sampling needs as part of a Baseline Environmental Assessment review. Earlier in 2018, the RRD purchased lab equipment that will allow the MDEQ Environmental Lab to conduct analyses of certain PFAS samples. (Currently, most samples are shipped to one of the few labs in the country that conduct PFAS analysis, in California, although private labs in other parts of the country, including Michigan, are starting to offer these services.) As of August 2018, RRD has hired additional staff to work on developing the methodology and conducting PFAS analyses.{{cite web \\|title\\=Michigan PFAS Action Response Team (MPART) \\|url\\=https://www.michigan.gov/pfasresponse/ \\|publisher\\=Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy \\|location\\=Lansing, MI \\| archive\\-date\\=December 18, 2018 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20181218193515/https://www.michigan.gov/pfasresponse/ \\|url\\-status\\=live}}",
"In 2020 Michigan Attorney General [Dana Nessel](/wiki/Dana_Nessel \"Dana Nessel\") filed a lawsuit against 17 companies, including 3M, Chemours, and DuPont, for hiding known health and environmental risks from the state and its residents. Nessel's complaint identifies 37 sites with known contamination.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan\\-government/dana\\-nessel\\-sues\\-3m\\-dupont\\-over\\-unconscionable\\-pfas\\-pollution\\-michigan \\| title\\=Dana Nessel sues 3M, DuPont over 'unconscionable' PFAS pollution in Michigan \\| work\\=\\[\\[Bridge Michigan]] \\| date\\=January 14, 2020}} The [Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy](/wiki/Michigan_Department_of_Environment%2C_Great_Lakes%2C_and_Energy \"Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy\") introduced some of the strictest drinking water standards in the country for PFAS, setting [maximum contaminant levels](/wiki/Maximum_contaminant_level \"Maximum contaminant level\") (MCLs) for PFOA and PFOS to 8 and 16 ppt respectively (down from previous existing groundwater cleanup standards of 70 ppt for both), and introducing MCLs for five other previously unregulated PFAS compounds, limiting PFNA to six ppt, PFHxA to 400,000 ppt, PFHxS to 51 ppt, PFBS to 420 ppt and [HFPO\\-DA](/wiki/FRD-903 \"FRD-903\") to 370 ppt.{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://www.michigan.gov/egle/0,9429,7\\-135\\-\\-534660\\-\\-,00\\.html \\| title\\=EGLE \\- Michigan adopts strict PFAS in drinking water standards \\| website\\=www.michigan.gov \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20220310020229/https://www.michigan.gov/egle/0,9429,7\\-135\\-\\-534660\\-\\-,00\\.html \\| archive\\-date\\=March 10, 2022}} The change adds 38 additional sites to the state's list of known PFAS contaminated areas, bringing the total number of known sites to 137\\. About half of these sites are [landfills](/wiki/Landfill \"Landfill\") and 13 are former [plating facilities](/wiki/Chrome_plating \"Chrome plating\").{{Cite news \\| title\\=Michigan's drinking water standards for these chemicals now among toughest in nation \\| url\\=https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2020/08/03/tougher\\-pfas\\-standards\\-drinking\\-water\\-michigan/5574268002/ \\| vauthors\\=Matheny K \\| website\\=Detroit Free Press \\| date\\=August 3, 2020}}",
"In 2022 PFOS was found in beef produced at a Michigan farm: the cattle had been fed crops fertilized with contaminated biosolids. State agencies issued a consumption advisory, but did not order a recall, because there currently is no PFOS contamination in beef government standards.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.abc12\\.com/news/toxic\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-found\\-in\\-michigan\\-farms\\-beef/article\\_e7f880e2\\-8115\\-11ec\\-a9ab\\-738b364fb600\\.html \\| title\\=Toxic 'forever chemicals' found in Michigan farm's beef \\| first\\=Christine \\| last\\=Winter \\| agency\\=\\[\\[Associated Press]] \\| work\\=\\[\\[ABC News (United States)\\|ABC News]] \\| date\\=January 29, 2022}}",
"A 2024 study found that \"atmospheric deposition could be a significant environmental pathway, particularly for the Great Lakes.\"{{Cite journal \\|last1\\=Xia \\|first1\\=Chunjie \\|last2\\=Capozzi \\| first2\\=Staci L. \\| last3\\=Romanak \\| first3\\=Kevin A. \\| last4\\=Lehman \\| first4\\=Daniel C. \\| last5\\=Dove \\|first5\\=Alice \\| last6\\=Richardson \\| first6\\=Violeta \\| last7\\=Greenberg \\|first7\\=Tracie \\| last8\\=McGoldrick \\| first8\\=Daryl \\| last9\\=Venier \\| first9\\=Marta \\|date\\=2024\\-05\\-16 \\|title\\=The Ins and Outs of Per\\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances in the Great Lakes: The Role of Atmospheric Deposition \\| journal\\=Environmental Science \\& Technology \\| volume\\=58 \\| issue\\=21 \\| pages\\=9303–9313 \\| language\\=en \\|doi\\=10\\.1021/acs.est.3c10098 \\| issn\\=0013\\-936X \\| doi\\-access\\=free \\| pmid\\=38752648 \\| pmc\\=11137863 \\|bibcode\\=2024EnST...58\\.9303X}}{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://www.greatlakesnow.org/2024/05/pfas\\-news\\-roundup\\-3m\\-scientist\\-exposes\\-50\\-years\\-of\\-pfas\\-deceit\\-just\\-as\\-the\\-forever\\-chemicals\\-are\\-found\\-in\\-great\\-lakes\\-precipitation/ \\| last\\=Litzenberg \\| first\\=Mia \\| title\\=PFAS News Roundup: 3M scientist exposes 50 years of PFAS deceit just as the 'forever chemicals' are found in Great Lakes precipitation \\| website\\=\\[\\[Great Lakes Now]] \\| date\\=May 23, 2024}}",
"##### Minnesota",
"In February 2018, 3M settled a lawsuit for $850 million related to contaminated drinking water in Minnesota.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018\\-02\\-20/3m\\-is\\-said\\-to\\-settle\\-minnesota\\-lawsuit\\-for\\-up\\-to\\-1\\-billion \\| title\\=3M Settles Minnesota Lawsuit for $850 Million \\| first\\=Tiffany \\| last\\=Kary \\| work\\=\\[\\[Bloomberg News]] \\| date\\=June 7, 2019 \\| url\\-access\\=subscription \\| archive\\-date\\=June 8, 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20190608111342/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018\\-02\\-20/3m\\-is\\-said\\-to\\-settle\\-minnesota\\-lawsuit\\-for\\-up\\-to\\-1\\-billion \\|url\\-status\\=live}}",
"##### New Jersey",
"In 2018 the [New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection](/wiki/New_Jersey_Department_of_Environmental_Protection \"New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection\") (NJDEP) published a drinking water standard for PFNA. [Public water systems](/wiki/Public_water_system \"Public water system\") in New Jersey are required to meet an MCL standard of 13 ppt.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/environment/2018/09/06/new\\-jersey\\-first\\-state\\-regulate\\-dangerous\\-chemical\\-pfna\\-pfoa/1210328002/ \\| last\\=Fallon \\| first\\=Scott \\| title\\=New Jersey becomes first state to regulate dangerous chemical PFNA in drinking water \\| work\\=\\[\\[The Record (North Jersey)\\|The Record]] \\|date\\=September 6, 2018 \\| archive\\-date\\=November 29, 2020 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20201129081254/https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/environment/2018/09/06/new\\-jersey\\-first\\-state\\-regulate\\-dangerous\\-chemical\\-pfna\\-pfoa/1210328002/ \\| url\\-status\\=live}}{{cite web \\| url\\=https://advance.lexis.com/api/document/collection/administrative\\-codes/id/5T61\\-TR60\\-01XC\\-F17T\\-00008\\-00?cite\\=50%20N.J.R.%201939(a)\\&context\\=1000516 \\| title\\=Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for Perfluorononanoic Acid and 1,2,3\\-Trichloropropane; Private Well Testing for Arsenic, Gross Alpha Particle Activity, and Certain Synthetic Organic Compounds \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection]] \\| id\\=50 N.J.R. 1939(a) \\| date\\=September 4, 2018 \\| archive\\-date\\=October 6, 2021 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20211006204818/https://signin.lexisnexis.com/lnaccess/app/signin?back\\=https%3A%2F%2Fadvance.lexis.com%3A443%2Flaapi%2Fdocument%3Fcite%3D50%2BN.J.R.%2B1939%28a%29%26context%3D1000516%26collection%3Dadministrative\\-codes%26id%3D5T61\\-TR60\\-01XC\\-F17T\\-00008\\-00\\&aci\\=la \\| url\\-status\\=live}} In 2020 the state set a PFOA standard at 14 ppt and a PFOS standard at 13 ppt.{{cite web \\| url\\=https://www.state.nj.us/dep/srp/srra/listserv\\_archives/2020/20200601\\_srra.html \\| title\\=Adoption of ground water quality standards and maximum contaminant levels for perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection]] \\| date\\=June 1, 2020 \\| archive\\-date\\=June 25, 2021 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210625164516/https://www.state.nj.us/dep/srp/srra/listserv\\_archives/2020/20200601\\_srra.html \\| url\\-status\\=live}}",
"In 2019 NJDEP filed lawsuits against the owners of two plants that had manufactured PFASs, and two plants that were cited for water pollution from other chemicals. The companies cited are DuPont, [Chemours](/wiki/Chemours \"Chemours\"), and 3M.{{cite press release \\| url\\=https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190327a.html \\| title\\=AG Grewal, DEP Commissioner Announce 4 New Environmental Lawsuits Focused on Contamination Allegedly Linked to DuPont, Chemours, 3M \\|publisher\\=\\[\\[New Jersey attorney general]] \\| date\\=March 27, 2019 \\|archive\\-date\\=January 13, 2021 \\| archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20210113223236/https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases19/pr20190327a.html \\| url\\-status\\=live}} NJDEP also declared five companies to be financially responsible for statewide remediation of the chemicals. Among the companies accused were [Arkema](/wiki/Arkema \"Arkema\") and [Solvay](/wiki/Solvay_S.A. \"Solvay S.A.\") regarding a [West Deptford](/wiki/West_Deptford_Township%2C_New_Jersey \"West Deptford Township, New Jersey\") Facility in [Gloucester County](/wiki/Gloucester_County%2C_New_Jersey \"Gloucester County, New Jersey\"), where Arkema manufactured PFASs, but Solvay claims to have never manufactured but only handled PFASs.{{cite letter \\| vauthors\\=Norton GP \\|recipient\\=Shawn LaTourette \\|subject\\=Re: Statewide PFAS Directive, Information Request and Notice to Insurers \\|date\\=April 17, 2019 \\|via\\=Internet Archive \\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/5999826\\-SolvayNJDEPLetter\\-4\\-17\\-2019/}} The companies denied liability and contested the directive.{{cite news \\| url\\=https://www.nj.com/news/2019/05/state\\-ordered\\-chemical\\-companies\\-to\\-pay\\-for\\-pollution\\-clean\\-up\\-they\\-say\\-no\\-way.html \\|title\\=State ordered chemical companies to pay for pollution clean\\-up. They say, no way! \\| first\\=Michael Sol \\| last\\=Warren \\|work\\=\\[\\[NJ.com]] \\|date\\=May 13, 2019 \\| archive\\-date\\=October 19, 2019 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20191019015403/https://www.nj.com/news/2019/05/state\\-ordered\\-chemical\\-companies\\-to\\-pay\\-for\\-pollution\\-clean\\-up\\-they\\-say\\-no\\-way.html \\|url\\-status\\=live}} In June 2020, the EPA and New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection published a paper reporting that a unique family of PFAS used by Solvay, chloroperfluoropolyether carboxylates (ClPFPECAs), were contaminating the soils of New Jersey as far from the Solvay facility as 150 km.{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Washington JW, Rosal CG, McCord JP, Strynar MJ, Lindstrom AB, Bergman EL, Goodrow SM, Tadesse HK, Pilant AN, Washington BJ, Davis MJ, Stuart BG, Jenkins TM \\| display\\-authors\\=6 \\| title\\=Nontargeted mass\\-spectral detection of chloroperfluoropolyether carboxylates in New Jersey soils \\| journal\\=\\[\\[Science (journal)\\|Science]] \\| volume\\=368 \\| issue\\=6495 \\| pages\\=1103–1107 \\| date\\=June 2020 \\| pmid\\=32499438 \\| pmc\\=7814412 \\| doi\\=10\\.1126/science.aba7127 \\| bibcode\\=2020Sci...368\\.1103W}} and the ClPFPECAs were found in water as well.{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=McCord JP, Strynar MJ, Washington JW, Bergman EL, Goodrow SM \\| title\\=Emerging Chlorinated Polyfluorinated Polyether Compounds Impacting the Waters of Southwestern New Jersey Identified by Use of Nontargeted Analysis \\| journal\\=Environmental Science \\& Technology Letters \\| volume\\=7 \\| issue\\=12 \\| pages\\=903–908 \\| date\\=December 2020 \\| pmid\\=33553465 \\| pmc\\=7863629 \\| doi\\=10\\.1021/acs.estlett.0c00640 \\| bibcode\\=2020EnSTL...7\\..903M}}",
"Later in 2020, the New Jersey state attorney general filed suit in the New Jersey Superior Court against Solvay regarding PFAS contamination of the state's environment.New Jersey DEP plaintiffs v. Solvay Specialty Chemicals USA and Arkema Inc. defendants. GLO\\-L\\-001239\\-20\\. Trans ID 20202023975 In May 2021, Solvay issued a press release that the company is \"discontinuing the use of fluorosurfactants in the U.S.\".{{Cite press release \\|url\\=https://www.solvay.com/en/press\\-release/solvay\\-launches\\-non\\-fluorosurfactant\\-technologies\\-in\\-us \\|title\\=Solvay Launches Non\\-Fluorosurfactant Technologies in the U.S. \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[Solvay S.A.]] \\|date\\=May 5, 2021}}",
"##### New York",
"In 2016, New York, along with Vermont and New Hampshire, acknowledged PFOA contamination by requesting the EPA to release water quality guidance measures. Contamination has been observed by the [New York State Department of Environmental Conservation](/wiki/New_York_State_Department_of_Environmental_Conservation \"New York State Department of Environmental Conservation\") in Hoosick Falls, Newburgh, Petersburgh, Poestenkill, Mahopac, and Armonk.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.dec.ny.gov/chemical/108831\\.html \\| title\\=Per\\- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) \\| publisher\\=\\[\\[New York State Department of Environmental Conservation]]}}",
"After a class action lawsuit, in 2021, the village of Hoosick Falls received a $65\\.25 million settlement from Saint\\-Gobain Performance Plastics, Honeywell, 3M, and DuPont due to the disposal of PFAS chemicals into the groundwater of the local [water treatment](/wiki/Water_treatment \"Water treatment\") plant.{{Cite news \\| first\\=Brendan J. \\| last\\=Lyons \\|title\\=$65M settlement filed in Hoosick Falls PFOA water contamination \\| url\\=https://www.timesunion.com/state/article/hoosick\\-falls\\-pfoa\\-settlement\\-16326755\\.php \\| work\\=\\[\\[Times Union (Albany)\\|Times Union]] \\| date\\=July 21, 2021}}",
"##### Washington",
"Five military installations in Washington State have been identified by the [United States Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works](/wiki/United_States_Senate_Committee_on_Environment_and_Public_Works \"United States Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works\") as having PFAS contamination.{{Cite web \\| url\\=https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/superfund\\-sites\\-identified\\-by\\-epa\\-to\\-have\\-pfas\\-contamination \\| title\\=SUPERFUND SITES IDENTIFIED BY EPA TO HAVE PFAS CONTAMINATION}} Toward environmental and consumer protections, the [Washington State Department of Ecology](/wiki/Washington_State_Department_of_Ecology \"Washington State Department of Ecology\") published a [Chemical Action Plan](https://apps.ecology.wa.gov/publications/summarypages/2104048.html) in November 2021, and in June 2022 the governor tasked the Washington State Department of Ecology with [phasing out manufacture and import of products containing PFASs](https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=70A.350.090). Initial steps taken by the [Washington State Department of Health](/wiki/Washington_State_Department_of_Health \"Washington State Department of Health\") to protect the public from exposure through drinking water have included setting [State Action Levels](https://doh.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2022-02/PFAS%20Rule%20Adoption%20Notice%20and%20Adopted%20Rule%20Language.pdf?uid=62c866e64514c) for five PFASs (PFOA, PFOS, PFNA, PFHxS, and PFBS), which were implemented in November 2021\\.{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Joyce Dinglasan\\-Panlilio M, Prakash SS, Baker JE \\|date\\=January 2014 \\| title\\=Perfluorinated compounds in the surface waters of Puget Sound, Washington and Clayoquot and Barkley Sounds, British Columbia \\| journal\\=Marine Pollution Bulletin \\|volume\\=78 \\|issue\\=1–2 \\| pages\\=173–180 \\| bibcode\\=2014MarPB..78\\..173J \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.marpolbul.2013\\.10\\.046 \\|pmid\\=24262211}}{{cite journal \\|vauthors\\=Meador JP, Yeh A, Gallagher EP \\| date\\=November 2017 \\|title\\=Determining potential adverse effects in marine fish exposed to pharmaceuticals and personal care products with the fish plasma model and whole\\-body tissue concentrations \\| journal\\=Environmental Pollution \\|volume\\=230 \\| pages\\=1018–1029 \\| doi\\=10\\.1016/j.envpol.2017\\.07\\.047 \\| pmc\\=5595653 \\| pmid\\=28764109 \\|bibcode\\=2017EPoll.230\\.1018M}}{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Strivens JE, Kuo LJ, Liu Y, Noor KL \\|date\\=June 2021 \\|title\\=Spatial and temporal baseline of perfluorooctanesulfonic acid retained in sediment core samples from Puget Sound, Washington, USA \\|journal\\=Marine Pollution Bulletin \\|volume\\=167 \\|pages\\=112381 \\| bibcode\\=2021MarPB.16712381S \\|doi\\=10\\.1016/j.marpolbul.2021\\.112381 \\|pmid\\=33962256 \\|s2cid\\=233999063 \\|doi\\-access\\=free}}",
"### United Nations",
"In 2009, PFOS, its salts, and [perfluorooctanesulfonyl fluoride](/wiki/Perfluorooctanesulfonyl_fluoride \"Perfluorooctanesulfonyl fluoride\"), as well as PFOA and PFHxS, were listed as [persistent organic pollutants](/wiki/Persistent_organic_pollutant \"Persistent organic pollutant\") under the [Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants](/wiki/Stockholm_Convention_on_Persistent_Organic_Pollutants \"Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants\") due to their ubiquitous, [persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic](/wiki/Persistent%2C_bioaccumulative%2C_and_toxic \"Persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic\") nature.{{cite journal \\| vauthors\\=Blum A, Balan SA, Scheringer M, Trier X, Goldenman G, Cousins IT, Diamond M, Fletcher T, Higgins C, Lindeman AE, Peaslee G, de Voogt P, Wang Z, Weber R \\| display\\-authors\\=6 \\| title\\=The Madrid Statement on Poly\\- and Perfluoroalkyl Substances (PFASs) \\| journal\\=Environmental Health Perspectives \\| volume\\=123 \\| issue\\=5 \\| pages\\=A107\\-111 \\| date\\=May 2015 \\| pmid\\=25932614 \\| pmc\\=4421777 \\| doi\\=10\\.1289/ehp.1509934}}{{cite web \\|url\\=https://www.oecd.org/chemicalsafety/portal\\-perfluorinated\\-chemicals/webinars/Presentation%203\\_Melisa.pdf \\| title\\=Phasing out PFOS under the Stockholm Convention \\| first\\=Melisa \\| last\\=Lin \\| work\\=\\[\\[OECD]] \\| date\\=May 2014}} The convention has been ratified by 186 jurisdictions, but has most notably not been ratified by the United States, Israel, and Malaysia.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.pops.int/TheConvention/ThePOPs/AllPOPs/tabid/2509/ \\| title\\=All POPs listed in the Stockholm Convention \\| website\\=pops.int}} The long\\-chain (C9–C21) PFCAs are currently under review for listing.{{Cite web \\|url\\=https://www.pops.int/TheConvention/ThePOPs/ChemicalsProposedforListing/tabid/2510/ \n \\|title\\=Chemicals proposed for listing under the Convention \\|website\\=pops.int}}",
""
] |
Judgment
--------
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and directed the convictions of the appellants be set aside.
### The appellate test
In answering the first certified question, the Supreme Court held that section 137(1\) of the 1980 Act must be read so as to comply with the ECHR. This means that the trial court had to consider whether the police's interference with the appellants' Article 10 and 11 rights by arresting them was proportionate. If found to be disproportionate, the appellant would have a defence of lawful excuse to the underlying criminal offence.
The Supreme Court held that the appellate test for the High Court to apply in appeals by way of case stated, including in this case, was whether the court's conclusion was "one which was reasonably open to it", meaning it was not "*[Wednesbury](/wiki/Associated_Provincial_Picture_Houses_Ltd_v_Wednesbury_Corp "Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corp")* irrational or perverse". In this approach, a conclusion of fact would be open to challenge only if it is one that no reasonable court could have reached on the facts, or if there was an error of law that was material to the decision. In accordance with that test, where the statutory defence depends on an assessment of proportionality, the Supreme Court held that "an appeal will lie if there is an error or flaw in the reasoning on the face of the case which undermines the cogency of the conclusion on proportionality".
The Supreme Court held that the appellate test to apply in appeals such as this was whether the decision of the trial court was one that no reasonable court would have made or whether there was an error of law material to the decision. Further, where proportionality was concerned, if there were an error in the trial court's reasoning that undermined the cogency of the conclusion on proportionality, an appeal would be allowed.
### Deliberately obstructive conduct, lawful excuse, and section 137
In answering the second certified question, the Supreme Court reviewed European case law that showed that intentional disruption and obstructive action by protestors benefits from the protections of Article 10 and 11\. However, the extent of the disruption and whether it is intentional are factors to consider in assessing proportionality. The Supreme Court set out other factors that were relevant for the trial court to consider when evaluating proportionality, including whether the action was intended to be peaceful, whether it involved the commission of an offence other than the section 137 offence, whether it was carefully targeted at vehicles heading to the ExCeL Centre, and whether it was of limited duration.
As a result, the Supreme Court concluded that the trial court was right to consider those factors when assessing the proportionality of the interference with the appellant's ECHR rights and in finding the interference to be disproportionate. Further, the trial court made no error or flaw in its reasoning such as would undermine the cogency of its conclusion on proportionality in favour of the appellants.
|
[
"Judgment\n--------",
"The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and directed the convictions of the appellants be set aside.",
"### The appellate test",
"In answering the first certified question, the Supreme Court held that section 137(1\\) of the 1980 Act must be read so as to comply with the ECHR. This means that the trial court had to consider whether the police's interference with the appellants' Article 10 and 11 rights by arresting them was proportionate. If found to be disproportionate, the appellant would have a defence of lawful excuse to the underlying criminal offence.",
"The Supreme Court held that the appellate test for the High Court to apply in appeals by way of case stated, including in this case, was whether the court's conclusion was \"one which was reasonably open to it\", meaning it was not \"*[Wednesbury](/wiki/Associated_Provincial_Picture_Houses_Ltd_v_Wednesbury_Corp \"Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corp\")* irrational or perverse\". In this approach, a conclusion of fact would be open to challenge only if it is one that no reasonable court could have reached on the facts, or if there was an error of law that was material to the decision. In accordance with that test, where the statutory defence depends on an assessment of proportionality, the Supreme Court held that \"an appeal will lie if there is an error or flaw in the reasoning on the face of the case which undermines the cogency of the conclusion on proportionality\".",
"The Supreme Court held that the appellate test to apply in appeals such as this was whether the decision of the trial court was one that no reasonable court would have made or whether there was an error of law material to the decision. Further, where proportionality was concerned, if there were an error in the trial court's reasoning that undermined the cogency of the conclusion on proportionality, an appeal would be allowed.",
"### Deliberately obstructive conduct, lawful excuse, and section 137",
"In answering the second certified question, the Supreme Court reviewed European case law that showed that intentional disruption and obstructive action by protestors benefits from the protections of Article 10 and 11\\. However, the extent of the disruption and whether it is intentional are factors to consider in assessing proportionality. The Supreme Court set out other factors that were relevant for the trial court to consider when evaluating proportionality, including whether the action was intended to be peaceful, whether it involved the commission of an offence other than the section 137 offence, whether it was carefully targeted at vehicles heading to the ExCeL Centre, and whether it was of limited duration.",
"As a result, the Supreme Court concluded that the trial court was right to consider those factors when assessing the proportionality of the interference with the appellant's ECHR rights and in finding the interference to be disproportionate. Further, the trial court made no error or flaw in its reasoning such as would undermine the cogency of its conclusion on proportionality in favour of the appellants.",
""
] |
Religion and art
----------------
At the age of 70, Murray began what art historian [William Arnett](/wiki/William_Arnett "William Arnett") has called "one of the most remarkable and unlikely art 'careers' in the southern vernacular field" after he and his wife separated. After a decade of living alone, Murray dislocated his hip, and was forced to retire from farming and seek new existential perspectives. His first creations were shrinelike piles of found materials, rocks, and other debris strategically placed throughout his yard to repel evil that Murray believed loomed over all facets of life. He then began painting car parts, televisions, and other reflective material that he would then affix to his home in another effort to reflect evil and protect his home. The tradition of adorning one's yard with sculptures and totems, otherwise known as the "yard show," was a very common practice among African American artists, particularly from the south eastern United States. Other artists from northern Georgia, such as [Eldren M. Bailey](/wiki/Eldren_Bailey "Eldren Bailey"), Dilmus Hall, [Ralph Griffin](/wiki/Ralph_Griffin "Ralph Griffin"), and [Howard Finster](/wiki/Howard_Finster "Howard Finster") all created prominent yard shows.
In 1978, Murray experienced a [religious vision](/wiki/Religious_vision "Religious vision") while watering his potatoes which inspired him to produce a remarkable body of abstract paintings and drawings in the last decade of his life. Seeing an eagle descend from the sun, Murray believed that he had been granted a privileged religious insight, which was to be the inspiration for his work as an artist.Mary Pagdelek, ["JB Murray: This Well Grow Deep and Never Run Dry,"](http://rawvision.com/articles/jb-murray-well-grow-deep-and-never-run-dry) in *Raw Vision*, No. 58, p. 42\.
> When I started, I prayed and prayed. And the Lord sent a vision from the sun. Everything I see is from the sun. He showed me signs and seasons and he tells me. He turned around and gave me a question to ask Him and I asked Him to see me mother. He brought her before me and two brothers... See, Spirit will talk with Spirit. And when I left there \[the hospital], the eagle crossed my eye—a Spiritual Eagle. The Eagle can see farther than any bird in the world and that's why I can see things other people can't see. When I see between here and the sun is in a twinkle. It was then that I began to write these letters. Different writing represents different languages and folks. It's the Language of the Holy Spirit, direct from God"
[Illiterate](/wiki/Illiterate "Illiterate"), Murray developed his own personal style of seemingly unintelligible [asemic writing](/wiki/Asemic_writing "Asemic writing"), which he called "spirit script," that he inscribed onto his drawings and paintings."J.B. Murray GPS" McWillie, Judith. p. 1 from *Two Transcend: Drawings by J.B. Murray and Melvin Edward Nelson* Ed. Randall Morris and Shari Cavin. Cavin\-Morris Publishing, 2013 [https://issuu.com/cavinmorris/docs/two\_transcend\-jbm\_catalog\_safarova\_](https://issuu.com/cavinmorris/docs/two_transcend-jbm_catalog_safarova_) Murray's writing gave him a power he believed could be used for benediction and protection of himself and others. As a part of the process, Murray kept a bottle of what he called "holy water" on a table by his bedside, which he would raise towards the sky whenever he prayed. Murray believed that if a person with a pure heart read his "writing" while looking through the bottle of holy water, that person would read messages from God. During the last few years of his life, as his reputation as a mystic grew, Murray would receive visitors on his property who requested ritual readings of the holy water. When writing these holy messages, Murray would often hold the bottle of holy water in one hand and write with the other, keeping his hand as limp as possible, and letting the holy spirit guide it. This process of automatic writing was recorded in a documentary directed and produced by Judith McWillie of the [University of Georgia](/wiki/University_of_Georgia "University of Georgia") toward the end of his life."J. B. Murray: Writing in an Unknown Tongue: Reading Through the Water", directed by Judith McWillie [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\=qjJGl1MGoMs](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjJGl1MGoMs) Although other deeply religious artists wrote in asemic script, such as Joe Light's pseudo\-Arabic and [James Hampton](/wiki/James_Hampton_%28artist%29 "James Hampton (artist)")'s Phoenician\-like script, Murray was the only artist known to read and decipher his writings through water.{{Cite book\|date\=1997\-03\-01\|title\=Pictured in my mind: contemporary American self\-taught art from the collection of Dr. Kurt Gitter and Alice Rae Yelen\|s2cid\=190429331}}
Many scholars have written about West African spiritual and religious influences on religious practices of the African American descendants of enslaved peoples in the southeastern United States.{{Cite book\|title\=African American Religious Cultures\|last\=Pinn\|first\=Anthony B.\|publisher\=ABC CLIO\|year\=2009\|isbn\=978\-1\-57607\-470\-1\|location\=Santa Barbara, CA}}{{Cite journal\|last\=Thompson\|first\=Robert Farris\|date\=Fall 2019\|title\=African Influence on the Art of the United States\|url\=https://scholarworks.umass.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article\=1899\&context\=adan\|journal\=African Diaspora Archaeology Newsletter\|volume\=13}} Murray's work differs from other visionary work in that it has no formal narrative components, and relies primarily on sacred scripts. Thus, despite Murray's commitment to the [Baptist Church](/wiki/Baptists "Baptists"), scholars have connected Murray's practice with [Afro\-Islamic](/wiki/Islam "Islam") traditions. Islamic traditions in western and northern Africa venerate writing, studying and memorizing the Koran and other sacred texts as a power bestowed on man by Allah and can constitute forms of worship.{{Cite book\|title\=(Dis)Forming the American Canon\-\- African\-American Slave Narratives and the Vernacular\|last\=Judy\|first\=Ronald A.T.\|publisher\=University of Minnesota Press\|year\=1993\|location\=Minneapolis\|pages\=173}}{{Cite book\|title\=African Muslims in Ante\-bellum America\-\- A source book\|last\=Austin\|first\=Allen D.\|publisher\=Garland Publishing\|year\=1984\|location\=London and New York}} Interpretation and intercession of sacred texts are used to heal practitioners spiritually and physically. Furthermore, some Afro\-Islamic mystic leaders dissolve the written words of sacred texts or the name of Allah in water then pour the solution into a small vial, which the practitioner drinks or wears in secret around their neck. In his own way, and without lending credit to the similarity, Murray reflected these Islamic practices when he wrote his prophetic "spirit scripts" and interpreted them through his small glass of water for visiting practitioners.
Murray distrusted people who did not believe in God; in his mind, most people had strayed from the Lord's path and were therefore potentially harmful. He also believed that destructive evil spirits populated the world, and thus much of the artwork he created served a protective purpose. His paintings and painted objects functioned as a shield to ward off such harmful forces. His house never became a site for collectors or art historians, as other folk artists' houses had been. However, as his notoriety progressed, a small group of private patrons began exchanging his completed paintings for new supplies and discouraging him from engaging with other interested collectors. It is unknown how much Murray was compensated for his work, if at all. At the end of his career, he had produced nearly 2,000 paintings.
Art historian Mary Padgelek, who wrote a book about Murray's life and works,{{cite web\|url\=http://www.interestingideas.com/out/books1\.htm\|title\=J.B. Murray: Reading Meaning\|work\=The Outsider\|publisher\=Intuit: The Center for Outsider and Intuitive Art\|access\-date\=8 August 2014}} has also written a musical about him: *Visionary Man*, which was presented at the Hudson Mainstage Theater in 2014\.{{cite web\|url\=http://www.broadwayworld.com/los\-angeles/article/Spirited\-Hands\-Productions\-to\-Present\-New\-Musical\-VISIONARY\-MAN\-726\-831\-20140624\#.U\-TS2\_ldWt0\|title\=Spirited Hands Productions to Present New Musical VISIONARY MAN, 7/26\-8/31\|date\=24 June 2014\|publisher\=Broadwayworld.com\|access\-date\=8 August 2014}}{{cite news\|url\=http://lifeinla.com/entertainment/streams/theatre/128\-theatre/18658/visionary\-man\-uplifts\-and\-inspires.html\|title\=Visionary Man Uplifts and Inspires\|last\=Walker\|first\=Alice\-Denise\|date\=31 July 2014\|work\=Life in LA\|access\-date\=8 August 2014}}
### Exposure
Two people helped expand Murray's range of materials and exposure to viewers. One was his general practitioner, Dr. William Rawlings, a local doctor in Sandersville. The other was Andy Nasisse, an art professor at the University of Georgia. Murray and Dr. William Rawlings met as a result of a routine check up for a minor illness. Murray believed that Rawlings offered more than just physical healing, so he frequented Rawlings' office for mental and spiritual advice. Along with these visits, Murray would send hundreds of paintings and spirit scripts to Rawlings, who then began to supply Murray with higher quality art materials. Murray went from painting on discarded building material with house paint purchased at the local convenience store to painting with tempura paints, markers, watercolors, oil paint sticks, etc.
Murray's greatest advocate may have been Krista Lamar, Dr. Rawlings' wife. She bought supplies for Rawlings to give to Murray and even introduced Murray to Andy Nasisse, an art professor at the University of Georgia. Through Nasisse, Murray was introduced to [Phyllis Kind](/wiki/Phyllis_Kind "Phyllis Kind") of the Phyllis Kind Gallery in New York. After she agreed to represent Murray in her gallery, his work became internationally known and exhibited around the world.
Once he was diagnosed with [prostate cancer](/wiki/Prostate_cancer "Prostate cancer") in the mid\-1980's, he began to make work furiously, feeling as though he was running out of time. This and Murray's increased exposure to medical drawings and hospitals, in accordance with his treatment, altered his work in the last four to five years of his life. His work focused more on warfare and biological uncertainty which Murray felt stirring within him. As a result, his once iconic, compartmentalized style began to blur and serpentine shapes manifested over the background. He died at the Memorial Hospital in [Washington County, GA](/wiki/Washington_County%2C_Georgia "Washington County, Georgia") on 18 September 1988\.
### Subject and materials
Murray's lexicon of colors was confined to primary colors, white, and black for the majority of his career. Each color held a specific meaning. Red represented torment or evil, blue represented "good" and positive strength, and yellow and gold indicated a divine presence or energy such as God himself or the sun. White was often added among these colors to denote spiritual purity and black was seldom added to denote death or the afterlife. Murray uses color and "spirit script" in tandem to create "spirit works," what he called his paintings, which showcased the battles between good and evil that Murray saw unfolding in everyday life. His "spirit works" contained messages for visitors and viewers that Murray alone could interpret.
His colors and calligraphy were often compartmentalized into horizontal or vertical registers and square or rectangular spaces. Many historians also note *[horror vacui](/wiki/Horror_vacui_%28art%29 "Horror vacui (art)")* in Murray's work.{{Cite book\|title\=Outsider art : spontaneous alternatives\|last\=Rhodes, Colin.\|date\=2010\|publisher\=Thames \& Hudson\|isbn\=978\-0500203347\|oclc\=880330136\|url\-access\=registration\|url\=https://archive.org/details/outsiderartspont00rhod}} His paintings deviate from the known [American Folk Art](/wiki/Folk_art "Folk art") repertoire in that there is very little representation or interpretation of life. There is no wildlife, Biblical characters, political or patriotic themes, and no narrative obvious to the viewer.
Nearly all of Murray's works were completed on paper, whether that be napkins, receipt paper, construction paper, or poster board, using pens, colored pencils, felt\-tip markers, and acrylic paint.
### Exhibitions and permanent collections
Murray's work has been shown in the following exhibitions:
* *Baking in the Sun: Visionary Images from the South*, 13 Jun.\- 31 Jul 1987, University Art Museum, [Lafayette, LA](/wiki/Lafayette%2C_Louisiana "Lafayette, Louisiana").{{Cite book\|title\=Baking in the Sun: Visionary Images from the South\|author\=University Art Museum\|publisher\=University of Southwestern Louisiana\|year\=1987\|location\=Lafayette, LA\|isbn\=9780936819037\|oclc\=18909093\|url\-access\=registration\|url\=https://archive.org/details/bakinginsunvisio0000unse}}
* *Outside the Mainstream; Folk Art in Our Time.* May–August 1988, High Museum of Art at Georgia Pacific Center, Atlanta, GA.
* *Afro\-American Folk Artists.* 30 Jul.\- 7 Aug. 1988, Berman Gallery, [Atlanta, GA.](/wiki/Atlanta "Atlanta")
* *Gifted Visions:Black American Folk Art,* 1988, Atrium Gallery, [University of Connecticut](/wiki/University_of_Connecticut "University of Connecticut"), [Storrs, CT](/wiki/Storrs%2C_Connecticut "Storrs, Connecticut").
* *American Resources: Selected Works of American American Artists.* 26 Aug\- 24 Sep, 1989, Bernice Steinbaum Gallery, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *Another Face of the Diamond: Pathways Through the Black Atlantic South.* 1989, New Visions Gallery, [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City").
* *Black History, Black Vision: The Visionary Image in Texas*. 27 Jan.\- 19 Mar. 1989, Archer m. Huntington Gallery, [University of Texas at Austin](/wiki/University_of_Texas_at_Austin "University of Texas at Austin"), [Austin, TX](/wiki/Austin%2C_Texas "Austin, Texas").
* *A Density of Passions*, Aug 1989, [New Jersey State Museum](/wiki/New_Jersey_State_Museum "New Jersey State Museum"), [Trenton, NJ](/wiki/Trenton%2C_New_Jersey "Trenton, New Jersey").
* *Gifted Visions: African American Folk Art.* 27 Jan\- 24 Feb. 1990, University Art Gallery, [University of Massachusetts](/wiki/University_of_Massachusetts "University of Massachusetts"), [Dartmouth, MA](/wiki/Dartmouth%2C_Massachusetts "Dartmouth, Massachusetts").
* *J.B. Murry*, 15 Dec. 1990\- 12 Jan, 1991, Phyllis Kind Gallery, [New York.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *Parallel Visions: Modern Artists and Outsider Art.* 18 Oct. 1992\- 3 Jan. 1993, [Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA)](/wiki/Los_Angeles_County_Museum_of_Art "Los Angeles County Museum of Art"), [Los Angeles, CA.](/wiki/Los_Angeles "Los Angeles")
* *Pictured in My Mind: Contemporary American Self\-Taught Art from the collection of Dr. Kurt Gitter and Alice Rae Yelen.* 1995, [Birmingham Museum of Art](/wiki/Birmingham_Museum_of_Art "Birmingham Museum of Art"), [Birmingham, AL](/wiki/Birmingham%2C_Alabama "Birmingham, Alabama").
* *Wrestling with History: A Celebration of African American Self\-Tught Artists from the collection of Ronald and June Shelp,* 1996, [Baruch College](/wiki/Baruch_College "Baruch College"), [CUNY](/wiki/City_University_of_New_York "City University of New York"), [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City").
* *Masterworks by Twentieth Century African\-American Artists.* 17 Jan\- 1 Mar, 1998, Springfield Museum of Art, [Springfield, OH.](/wiki/Springfield%2C_Ohio "Springfield, Ohio")
* *Southern Spirit: The Hill Collection.* 21 Feb \- 31 Mar 2000, Museum of Art, [Tallahassee, FL](/wiki/Tallahassee%2C_Florida "Tallahassee, Florida").
* *Testimony: Vernacular Art of the African American South: the Ronald and June Shelp Collection.* 2001, [Kalamazoo Institute of Arts](/wiki/Kalamazoo_Institute_of_Arts "Kalamazoo Institute of Arts"), [Kalamazoo, MI.](/wiki/Kalamazoo%2C_Michigan "Kalamazoo, Michigan")
* *Define Drawing: Work by Self\-Taught Artists Past and Present.* 14 Jul\- 15 Sep 2001, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA](/wiki/Atlanta "Atlanta").
* *Stories of Community: Self\-Taught Art from the Hill Collection*. 12 Aug\- 30 Oct, 2004\. Museum of Arts and Sciences, [Macon, GA](/wiki/Macon%2C_Georgia "Macon, Georgia").
* *Coming Home: Self\-Taught Artists, the Bible, and the American South.* 19 Jun \- 13 Nov. 2004, Art Museum of the [University of Memphis](/wiki/University_of_Memphis "University of Memphis"), [Memphis, TN.](/wiki/Memphis%2C_Tennessee "Memphis, Tennessee")
* *The Souls of Black Folk: Selections of African American Folk Art from the Museum's Permanent Collection*. 28 Nov. 2004\- ongoing, Museum of African American Life and Culture, [Dallas, TX](/wiki/Dallas "Dallas").
* *Holy H2O: Fluid Universe.* 2 Oct. 2004\- 4 Sep. 2005, [American Visionary Art Museum](/wiki/American_Visionary_Art_Museum "American Visionary Art Museum"), [Baltimore, MD](/wiki/Baltimore "Baltimore").
* *Visual Glossolalia*. 15 Jun \- 15 Jul, 2005, Luise Ross Gallery, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *Parallel Visions II*. 5 Apr.\- 26 May 2006, Galerie St. Etienne, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *Recent Acquisitions*. 6 Jun.\- 8 Sep., 2006, Galerie St. Etienne, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *Amazing Grace: Self\-Taught Artists from the Mullis Collection,* 29, Sep. 2007\- 6 Jan. 2008, [Georgia Museum of Art](/wiki/Georgia_Museum_of_Art "Georgia Museum of Art"), [University of Georgia](/wiki/University_of_Georgia "University of Georgia"), [Athens, GA](/wiki/Athens%2C_Georgia "Athens, Georgia").
* *Crossroads: Spirituality in American Folk Traditions.* 17 Nov, 2007\- 24 Feb, 2008\. Owensboro Museum of Fine Art, [Owensboro, KY](/wiki/Owensboro%2C_Kentucky "Owensboro, Kentucky").
* *Approaching Abstraction.* 6 Oct, 2009\- 6 Sep, 2010, [Museum of American Folk Art](/wiki/American_Folk_Art_Museum "American Folk Art Museum"), [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City")
* *All Folk,* 19 Aug.\- 2 Oct. 2010, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA.](/wiki/Atlanta "Atlanta")
* *Naives, Seers, one Wolves, and World Savers XXIV,* 2 Apr. 2011, Dean Jensen Gallery, [Milwaukee, WI.](/wiki/Milwaukee%2C_WI_1996 "Milwaukee, WI 1996")
* *Outsider Visions: Self\-Taught Southern Artists of the Twentieth Century.* 21 Sep, 2011\- 8 Jan, 2012, Boca Raton Museum of Art, [Boca Raton, FL](/wiki/Boca_Raton%2C_Florida "Boca Raton, Florida").
* *Pure Folk: Celebrating the Folk Art Society of America.* 14 Sep.\- 10 Nov. 2012, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA](/wiki/Atlanta "Atlanta").
* *Voodoo Child: J.B. Murray and Mary Smith.* 2013, abcd, le galerie, [Paris, FR.](/wiki/Paris "Paris")
* *When the Stars Begin to Fall: Imagination in the American South.* 27 Mar\- 29 Jun, 2014, [Studio Museum in Harlem](/wiki/Studio_Museum_in_Harlem "Studio Museum in Harlem"), [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City "New York City").
Murray's works are in the permanent collections of the following museums:
* [Metropolitan Museum of Art](/wiki/Metropolitan_Museum_of_Art "Metropolitan Museum of Art"){{Cite web\|url\=https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/653756?\&searchField\=All\&sortBy\=Relevance\&ft\=John\+B.\+Murray\&offset\=0\&rpp\=20\&pos\=5\|title\=Untitled early 1980s \|publisher\=www.metmuseum.org\|access\-date\=2019\-10\-22}}
* [Minneapolis Institute of Art](/wiki/Minneapolis_Institute_of_Art "Minneapolis Institute of Art"){{Cite web\|url\=http://collections.artsmia.org/art/131458/untitled\-john\-b\-murray\|title\=Untitled, John B. Murray ^ Minneapolis Institute of Art\|publisher\=collections.artsmia.org\|access\-date\=2019\-10\-22}}{{Cite web\|url\=http://www.soulsgrowndeep.org/artist/john\-b\-murray/work/untitled\-8\|title\=Untitled {{!}} Souls Grown Deep Foundation\|publisher\=www.soulsgrowndeep.org\|access\-date\=2019\-10\-22}}
* [Ackland Art Museum](/wiki/Ackland_Art_Museum "Ackland Art Museum"){{Cite web\|url\=http://www.soulsgrowndeep.org/artist/john\-b\-murray/work/untitled\-7\|title\=Untitled {{!}} Souls Grown Deep Foundation\|publisher\=www.soulsgrowndeep.org\|access\-date\=2019\-10\-22}}
* [Smithsonian American Art Museum](/wiki/Smithsonian_American_Art_Museum "Smithsonian American Art Museum")
* [American Folk Art Museum](/wiki/American_Folk_Art_Museum "American Folk Art Museum")
|
[
"Religion and art\n----------------",
"At the age of 70, Murray began what art historian [William Arnett](/wiki/William_Arnett \"William Arnett\") has called \"one of the most remarkable and unlikely art 'careers' in the southern vernacular field\" after he and his wife separated. After a decade of living alone, Murray dislocated his hip, and was forced to retire from farming and seek new existential perspectives. His first creations were shrinelike piles of found materials, rocks, and other debris strategically placed throughout his yard to repel evil that Murray believed loomed over all facets of life. He then began painting car parts, televisions, and other reflective material that he would then affix to his home in another effort to reflect evil and protect his home. The tradition of adorning one's yard with sculptures and totems, otherwise known as the \"yard show,\" was a very common practice among African American artists, particularly from the south eastern United States. Other artists from northern Georgia, such as [Eldren M. Bailey](/wiki/Eldren_Bailey \"Eldren Bailey\"), Dilmus Hall, [Ralph Griffin](/wiki/Ralph_Griffin \"Ralph Griffin\"), and [Howard Finster](/wiki/Howard_Finster \"Howard Finster\") all created prominent yard shows.",
"In 1978, Murray experienced a [religious vision](/wiki/Religious_vision \"Religious vision\") while watering his potatoes which inspired him to produce a remarkable body of abstract paintings and drawings in the last decade of his life. Seeing an eagle descend from the sun, Murray believed that he had been granted a privileged religious insight, which was to be the inspiration for his work as an artist.Mary Pagdelek, [\"JB Murray: This Well Grow Deep and Never Run Dry,\"](http://rawvision.com/articles/jb-murray-well-grow-deep-and-never-run-dry) in *Raw Vision*, No. 58, p. 42\\.",
"",
"> When I started, I prayed and prayed. And the Lord sent a vision from the sun. Everything I see is from the sun. He showed me signs and seasons and he tells me. He turned around and gave me a question to ask Him and I asked Him to see me mother. He brought her before me and two brothers... See, Spirit will talk with Spirit. And when I left there \\[the hospital], the eagle crossed my eye—a Spiritual Eagle. The Eagle can see farther than any bird in the world and that's why I can see things other people can't see. When I see between here and the sun is in a twinkle. It was then that I began to write these letters. Different writing represents different languages and folks. It's the Language of the Holy Spirit, direct from God\"",
"[Illiterate](/wiki/Illiterate \"Illiterate\"), Murray developed his own personal style of seemingly unintelligible [asemic writing](/wiki/Asemic_writing \"Asemic writing\"), which he called \"spirit script,\" that he inscribed onto his drawings and paintings.\"J.B. Murray GPS\" McWillie, Judith. p. 1 from *Two Transcend: Drawings by J.B. Murray and Melvin Edward Nelson* Ed. Randall Morris and Shari Cavin. Cavin\\-Morris Publishing, 2013 [https://issuu.com/cavinmorris/docs/two\\_transcend\\-jbm\\_catalog\\_safarova\\_](https://issuu.com/cavinmorris/docs/two_transcend-jbm_catalog_safarova_) Murray's writing gave him a power he believed could be used for benediction and protection of himself and others. As a part of the process, Murray kept a bottle of what he called \"holy water\" on a table by his bedside, which he would raise towards the sky whenever he prayed. Murray believed that if a person with a pure heart read his \"writing\" while looking through the bottle of holy water, that person would read messages from God. During the last few years of his life, as his reputation as a mystic grew, Murray would receive visitors on his property who requested ritual readings of the holy water. When writing these holy messages, Murray would often hold the bottle of holy water in one hand and write with the other, keeping his hand as limp as possible, and letting the holy spirit guide it. This process of automatic writing was recorded in a documentary directed and produced by Judith McWillie of the [University of Georgia](/wiki/University_of_Georgia \"University of Georgia\") toward the end of his life.\"J. B. Murray: Writing in an Unknown Tongue: Reading Through the Water\", directed by Judith McWillie [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v\\=qjJGl1MGoMs](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjJGl1MGoMs) Although other deeply religious artists wrote in asemic script, such as Joe Light's pseudo\\-Arabic and [James Hampton](/wiki/James_Hampton_%28artist%29 \"James Hampton (artist)\")'s Phoenician\\-like script, Murray was the only artist known to read and decipher his writings through water.{{Cite book\\|date\\=1997\\-03\\-01\\|title\\=Pictured in my mind: contemporary American self\\-taught art from the collection of Dr. Kurt Gitter and Alice Rae Yelen\\|s2cid\\=190429331}}",
"Many scholars have written about West African spiritual and religious influences on religious practices of the African American descendants of enslaved peoples in the southeastern United States.{{Cite book\\|title\\=African American Religious Cultures\\|last\\=Pinn\\|first\\=Anthony B.\\|publisher\\=ABC CLIO\\|year\\=2009\\|isbn\\=978\\-1\\-57607\\-470\\-1\\|location\\=Santa Barbara, CA}}{{Cite journal\\|last\\=Thompson\\|first\\=Robert Farris\\|date\\=Fall 2019\\|title\\=African Influence on the Art of the United States\\|url\\=https://scholarworks.umass.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article\\=1899\\&context\\=adan\\|journal\\=African Diaspora Archaeology Newsletter\\|volume\\=13}} Murray's work differs from other visionary work in that it has no formal narrative components, and relies primarily on sacred scripts. Thus, despite Murray's commitment to the [Baptist Church](/wiki/Baptists \"Baptists\"), scholars have connected Murray's practice with [Afro\\-Islamic](/wiki/Islam \"Islam\") traditions. Islamic traditions in western and northern Africa venerate writing, studying and memorizing the Koran and other sacred texts as a power bestowed on man by Allah and can constitute forms of worship.{{Cite book\\|title\\=(Dis)Forming the American Canon\\-\\- African\\-American Slave Narratives and the Vernacular\\|last\\=Judy\\|first\\=Ronald A.T.\\|publisher\\=University of Minnesota Press\\|year\\=1993\\|location\\=Minneapolis\\|pages\\=173}}{{Cite book\\|title\\=African Muslims in Ante\\-bellum America\\-\\- A source book\\|last\\=Austin\\|first\\=Allen D.\\|publisher\\=Garland Publishing\\|year\\=1984\\|location\\=London and New York}} Interpretation and intercession of sacred texts are used to heal practitioners spiritually and physically. Furthermore, some Afro\\-Islamic mystic leaders dissolve the written words of sacred texts or the name of Allah in water then pour the solution into a small vial, which the practitioner drinks or wears in secret around their neck. In his own way, and without lending credit to the similarity, Murray reflected these Islamic practices when he wrote his prophetic \"spirit scripts\" and interpreted them through his small glass of water for visiting practitioners.",
"Murray distrusted people who did not believe in God; in his mind, most people had strayed from the Lord's path and were therefore potentially harmful. He also believed that destructive evil spirits populated the world, and thus much of the artwork he created served a protective purpose. His paintings and painted objects functioned as a shield to ward off such harmful forces. His house never became a site for collectors or art historians, as other folk artists' houses had been. However, as his notoriety progressed, a small group of private patrons began exchanging his completed paintings for new supplies and discouraging him from engaging with other interested collectors. It is unknown how much Murray was compensated for his work, if at all. At the end of his career, he had produced nearly 2,000 paintings.",
"Art historian Mary Padgelek, who wrote a book about Murray's life and works,{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.interestingideas.com/out/books1\\.htm\\|title\\=J.B. Murray: Reading Meaning\\|work\\=The Outsider\\|publisher\\=Intuit: The Center for Outsider and Intuitive Art\\|access\\-date\\=8 August 2014}} has also written a musical about him: *Visionary Man*, which was presented at the Hudson Mainstage Theater in 2014\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.broadwayworld.com/los\\-angeles/article/Spirited\\-Hands\\-Productions\\-to\\-Present\\-New\\-Musical\\-VISIONARY\\-MAN\\-726\\-831\\-20140624\\#.U\\-TS2\\_ldWt0\\|title\\=Spirited Hands Productions to Present New Musical VISIONARY MAN, 7/26\\-8/31\\|date\\=24 June 2014\\|publisher\\=Broadwayworld.com\\|access\\-date\\=8 August 2014}}{{cite news\\|url\\=http://lifeinla.com/entertainment/streams/theatre/128\\-theatre/18658/visionary\\-man\\-uplifts\\-and\\-inspires.html\\|title\\=Visionary Man Uplifts and Inspires\\|last\\=Walker\\|first\\=Alice\\-Denise\\|date\\=31 July 2014\\|work\\=Life in LA\\|access\\-date\\=8 August 2014}}",
"### Exposure",
"Two people helped expand Murray's range of materials and exposure to viewers. One was his general practitioner, Dr. William Rawlings, a local doctor in Sandersville. The other was Andy Nasisse, an art professor at the University of Georgia. Murray and Dr. William Rawlings met as a result of a routine check up for a minor illness. Murray believed that Rawlings offered more than just physical healing, so he frequented Rawlings' office for mental and spiritual advice. Along with these visits, Murray would send hundreds of paintings and spirit scripts to Rawlings, who then began to supply Murray with higher quality art materials. Murray went from painting on discarded building material with house paint purchased at the local convenience store to painting with tempura paints, markers, watercolors, oil paint sticks, etc.",
"Murray's greatest advocate may have been Krista Lamar, Dr. Rawlings' wife. She bought supplies for Rawlings to give to Murray and even introduced Murray to Andy Nasisse, an art professor at the University of Georgia. Through Nasisse, Murray was introduced to [Phyllis Kind](/wiki/Phyllis_Kind \"Phyllis Kind\") of the Phyllis Kind Gallery in New York. After she agreed to represent Murray in her gallery, his work became internationally known and exhibited around the world.",
"Once he was diagnosed with [prostate cancer](/wiki/Prostate_cancer \"Prostate cancer\") in the mid\\-1980's, he began to make work furiously, feeling as though he was running out of time. This and Murray's increased exposure to medical drawings and hospitals, in accordance with his treatment, altered his work in the last four to five years of his life. His work focused more on warfare and biological uncertainty which Murray felt stirring within him. As a result, his once iconic, compartmentalized style began to blur and serpentine shapes manifested over the background. He died at the Memorial Hospital in [Washington County, GA](/wiki/Washington_County%2C_Georgia \"Washington County, Georgia\") on 18 September 1988\\.",
"### Subject and materials",
"Murray's lexicon of colors was confined to primary colors, white, and black for the majority of his career. Each color held a specific meaning. Red represented torment or evil, blue represented \"good\" and positive strength, and yellow and gold indicated a divine presence or energy such as God himself or the sun. White was often added among these colors to denote spiritual purity and black was seldom added to denote death or the afterlife. Murray uses color and \"spirit script\" in tandem to create \"spirit works,\" what he called his paintings, which showcased the battles between good and evil that Murray saw unfolding in everyday life. His \"spirit works\" contained messages for visitors and viewers that Murray alone could interpret.",
"His colors and calligraphy were often compartmentalized into horizontal or vertical registers and square or rectangular spaces. Many historians also note *[horror vacui](/wiki/Horror_vacui_%28art%29 \"Horror vacui (art)\")* in Murray's work.{{Cite book\\|title\\=Outsider art : spontaneous alternatives\\|last\\=Rhodes, Colin.\\|date\\=2010\\|publisher\\=Thames \\& Hudson\\|isbn\\=978\\-0500203347\\|oclc\\=880330136\\|url\\-access\\=registration\\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/outsiderartspont00rhod}} His paintings deviate from the known [American Folk Art](/wiki/Folk_art \"Folk art\") repertoire in that there is very little representation or interpretation of life. There is no wildlife, Biblical characters, political or patriotic themes, and no narrative obvious to the viewer.",
"Nearly all of Murray's works were completed on paper, whether that be napkins, receipt paper, construction paper, or poster board, using pens, colored pencils, felt\\-tip markers, and acrylic paint.",
"### Exhibitions and permanent collections",
"Murray's work has been shown in the following exhibitions:",
"* *Baking in the Sun: Visionary Images from the South*, 13 Jun.\\- 31 Jul 1987, University Art Museum, [Lafayette, LA](/wiki/Lafayette%2C_Louisiana \"Lafayette, Louisiana\").{{Cite book\\|title\\=Baking in the Sun: Visionary Images from the South\\|author\\=University Art Museum\\|publisher\\=University of Southwestern Louisiana\\|year\\=1987\\|location\\=Lafayette, LA\\|isbn\\=9780936819037\\|oclc\\=18909093\\|url\\-access\\=registration\\|url\\=https://archive.org/details/bakinginsunvisio0000unse}}\n* *Outside the Mainstream; Folk Art in Our Time.* May–August 1988, High Museum of Art at Georgia Pacific Center, Atlanta, GA.\n* *Afro\\-American Folk Artists.* 30 Jul.\\- 7 Aug. 1988, Berman Gallery, [Atlanta, GA.](/wiki/Atlanta \"Atlanta\")\n* *Gifted Visions:Black American Folk Art,* 1988, Atrium Gallery, [University of Connecticut](/wiki/University_of_Connecticut \"University of Connecticut\"), [Storrs, CT](/wiki/Storrs%2C_Connecticut \"Storrs, Connecticut\").\n* *American Resources: Selected Works of American American Artists.* 26 Aug\\- 24 Sep, 1989, Bernice Steinbaum Gallery, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *Another Face of the Diamond: Pathways Through the Black Atlantic South.* 1989, New Visions Gallery, [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\").\n* *Black History, Black Vision: The Visionary Image in Texas*. 27 Jan.\\- 19 Mar. 1989, Archer m. Huntington Gallery, [University of Texas at Austin](/wiki/University_of_Texas_at_Austin \"University of Texas at Austin\"), [Austin, TX](/wiki/Austin%2C_Texas \"Austin, Texas\").\n* *A Density of Passions*, Aug 1989, [New Jersey State Museum](/wiki/New_Jersey_State_Museum \"New Jersey State Museum\"), [Trenton, NJ](/wiki/Trenton%2C_New_Jersey \"Trenton, New Jersey\").\n* *Gifted Visions: African American Folk Art.* 27 Jan\\- 24 Feb. 1990, University Art Gallery, [University of Massachusetts](/wiki/University_of_Massachusetts \"University of Massachusetts\"), [Dartmouth, MA](/wiki/Dartmouth%2C_Massachusetts \"Dartmouth, Massachusetts\").\n* *J.B. Murry*, 15 Dec. 1990\\- 12 Jan, 1991, Phyllis Kind Gallery, [New York.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *Parallel Visions: Modern Artists and Outsider Art.* 18 Oct. 1992\\- 3 Jan. 1993, [Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA)](/wiki/Los_Angeles_County_Museum_of_Art \"Los Angeles County Museum of Art\"), [Los Angeles, CA.](/wiki/Los_Angeles \"Los Angeles\")\n* *Pictured in My Mind: Contemporary American Self\\-Taught Art from the collection of Dr. Kurt Gitter and Alice Rae Yelen.* 1995, [Birmingham Museum of Art](/wiki/Birmingham_Museum_of_Art \"Birmingham Museum of Art\"), [Birmingham, AL](/wiki/Birmingham%2C_Alabama \"Birmingham, Alabama\").\n* *Wrestling with History: A Celebration of African American Self\\-Tught Artists from the collection of Ronald and June Shelp,* 1996, [Baruch College](/wiki/Baruch_College \"Baruch College\"), [CUNY](/wiki/City_University_of_New_York \"City University of New York\"), [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\").\n* *Masterworks by Twentieth Century African\\-American Artists.* 17 Jan\\- 1 Mar, 1998, Springfield Museum of Art, [Springfield, OH.](/wiki/Springfield%2C_Ohio \"Springfield, Ohio\")\n* *Southern Spirit: The Hill Collection.* 21 Feb \\- 31 Mar 2000, Museum of Art, [Tallahassee, FL](/wiki/Tallahassee%2C_Florida \"Tallahassee, Florida\").\n* *Testimony: Vernacular Art of the African American South: the Ronald and June Shelp Collection.* 2001, [Kalamazoo Institute of Arts](/wiki/Kalamazoo_Institute_of_Arts \"Kalamazoo Institute of Arts\"), [Kalamazoo, MI.](/wiki/Kalamazoo%2C_Michigan \"Kalamazoo, Michigan\")\n* *Define Drawing: Work by Self\\-Taught Artists Past and Present.* 14 Jul\\- 15 Sep 2001, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA](/wiki/Atlanta \"Atlanta\").\n* *Stories of Community: Self\\-Taught Art from the Hill Collection*. 12 Aug\\- 30 Oct, 2004\\. Museum of Arts and Sciences, [Macon, GA](/wiki/Macon%2C_Georgia \"Macon, Georgia\").\n* *Coming Home: Self\\-Taught Artists, the Bible, and the American South.* 19 Jun \\- 13 Nov. 2004, Art Museum of the [University of Memphis](/wiki/University_of_Memphis \"University of Memphis\"), [Memphis, TN.](/wiki/Memphis%2C_Tennessee \"Memphis, Tennessee\")\n* *The Souls of Black Folk: Selections of African American Folk Art from the Museum's Permanent Collection*. 28 Nov. 2004\\- ongoing, Museum of African American Life and Culture, [Dallas, TX](/wiki/Dallas \"Dallas\").\n* *Holy H2O: Fluid Universe.* 2 Oct. 2004\\- 4 Sep. 2005, [American Visionary Art Museum](/wiki/American_Visionary_Art_Museum \"American Visionary Art Museum\"), [Baltimore, MD](/wiki/Baltimore \"Baltimore\").\n* *Visual Glossolalia*. 15 Jun \\- 15 Jul, 2005, Luise Ross Gallery, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *Parallel Visions II*. 5 Apr.\\- 26 May 2006, Galerie St. Etienne, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *Recent Acquisitions*. 6 Jun.\\- 8 Sep., 2006, Galerie St. Etienne, [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *Amazing Grace: Self\\-Taught Artists from the Mullis Collection,* 29, Sep. 2007\\- 6 Jan. 2008, [Georgia Museum of Art](/wiki/Georgia_Museum_of_Art \"Georgia Museum of Art\"), [University of Georgia](/wiki/University_of_Georgia \"University of Georgia\"), [Athens, GA](/wiki/Athens%2C_Georgia \"Athens, Georgia\").\n* *Crossroads: Spirituality in American Folk Traditions.* 17 Nov, 2007\\- 24 Feb, 2008\\. Owensboro Museum of Fine Art, [Owensboro, KY](/wiki/Owensboro%2C_Kentucky \"Owensboro, Kentucky\").\n* *Approaching Abstraction.* 6 Oct, 2009\\- 6 Sep, 2010, [Museum of American Folk Art](/wiki/American_Folk_Art_Museum \"American Folk Art Museum\"), [New York, NY.](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\")\n* *All Folk,* 19 Aug.\\- 2 Oct. 2010, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA.](/wiki/Atlanta \"Atlanta\")\n* *Naives, Seers, one Wolves, and World Savers XXIV,* 2 Apr. 2011, Dean Jensen Gallery, [Milwaukee, WI.](/wiki/Milwaukee%2C_WI_1996 \"Milwaukee, WI 1996\")\n* *Outsider Visions: Self\\-Taught Southern Artists of the Twentieth Century.* 21 Sep, 2011\\- 8 Jan, 2012, Boca Raton Museum of Art, [Boca Raton, FL](/wiki/Boca_Raton%2C_Florida \"Boca Raton, Florida\").\n* *Pure Folk: Celebrating the Folk Art Society of America.* 14 Sep.\\- 10 Nov. 2012, Barbara Archer Gallery, [Atlanta, GA](/wiki/Atlanta \"Atlanta\").\n* *Voodoo Child: J.B. Murray and Mary Smith.* 2013, abcd, le galerie, [Paris, FR.](/wiki/Paris \"Paris\")\n* *When the Stars Begin to Fall: Imagination in the American South.* 27 Mar\\- 29 Jun, 2014, [Studio Museum in Harlem](/wiki/Studio_Museum_in_Harlem \"Studio Museum in Harlem\"), [New York, NY](/wiki/New_York_City \"New York City\").",
"Murray's works are in the permanent collections of the following museums:",
"* [Metropolitan Museum of Art](/wiki/Metropolitan_Museum_of_Art \"Metropolitan Museum of Art\"){{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/653756?\\&searchField\\=All\\&sortBy\\=Relevance\\&ft\\=John\\+B.\\+Murray\\&offset\\=0\\&rpp\\=20\\&pos\\=5\\|title\\=Untitled early 1980s \\|publisher\\=www.metmuseum.org\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-10\\-22}}\n* [Minneapolis Institute of Art](/wiki/Minneapolis_Institute_of_Art \"Minneapolis Institute of Art\"){{Cite web\\|url\\=http://collections.artsmia.org/art/131458/untitled\\-john\\-b\\-murray\\|title\\=Untitled, John B. Murray ^ Minneapolis Institute of Art\\|publisher\\=collections.artsmia.org\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-10\\-22}}{{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.soulsgrowndeep.org/artist/john\\-b\\-murray/work/untitled\\-8\\|title\\=Untitled {{!}} Souls Grown Deep Foundation\\|publisher\\=www.soulsgrowndeep.org\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-10\\-22}}\n* [Ackland Art Museum](/wiki/Ackland_Art_Museum \"Ackland Art Museum\"){{Cite web\\|url\\=http://www.soulsgrowndeep.org/artist/john\\-b\\-murray/work/untitled\\-7\\|title\\=Untitled {{!}} Souls Grown Deep Foundation\\|publisher\\=www.soulsgrowndeep.org\\|access\\-date\\=2019\\-10\\-22}}\n* [Smithsonian American Art Museum](/wiki/Smithsonian_American_Art_Museum \"Smithsonian American Art Museum\")\n* [American Folk Art Museum](/wiki/American_Folk_Art_Museum \"American Folk Art Museum\")"
] |
Covered bridges
---------------
[thumb\|right\|Gilkey Bridge carries Goar Road over Thomas Creek downstream from [Scio](/wiki/Scio%2C_Oregon "Scio, Oregon").](/wiki/File:Gilkey_Bridge_%287332313808%29.jpg "Gilkey Bridge (7332313808).jpg")
Several [covered bridges](/wiki/Covered_bridge "Covered bridge") have spanned Thomas Creek since the late 19th century, some of them replacements for damaged or demolished bridges at the same spots. Three of these bridges—[Gilkey](/wiki/Gilkey_Bridge "Gilkey Bridge"), [Shimanek](/wiki/Shimanek_Bridge "Shimanek Bridge"), and [Hannah](/wiki/Hannah_Bridge "Hannah Bridge")—still cross the creek, while two—[Weddle](/wiki/Weddle_Bridge "Weddle Bridge") and [Jordan](/wiki/Stayton%E2%80%93Jordan_Bridge "Stayton–Jordan Bridge")—have been moved to cities outside the Thomas Creek watershed. The three that still cross the creek are on the [National Register of Historic Places](/wiki/National_Register_of_Historic_Places "National Register of Historic Places") (NRHP).{{cite web\|title\=Hannah Bridge\|work\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\|url\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\=v.dsp\_siteSummary\&resultDisplay\=44038\|publisher\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\|accessdate\=December 1, 2014}}{{cite web\|title\=Shimanek Bridge\|work\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\|url\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\=v.dsp\_siteSummary\&resultDisplay\=44062\|publisher\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\|accessdate\=December 1, 2014}}{{cite web\|title\=Gilkey Bridge\|work\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\|url\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\=v.dsp\_siteSummary\&resultDisplay\=44061\|publisher\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\|accessdate\=December 1, 2014}} The Weddle Bridge was listed on the NRHP in 1979 but delisted in 1991 after its move to [Sweet Home](/wiki/Sweet_Home%2C_Oregon "Sweet Home, Oregon").{{cite web\|title\=Weddle Bridge\|work\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\|url\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\=v.dsp\_siteSummary\&resultDisplay\=44016\|publisher\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\|accessdate\=December 1, 2014}}
At roughly {{convert\|5\|mi\|km\|0}} upstream of the creek [mouth](/wiki/River_mouth "River mouth"), Gilkey Bridge and a covered railroad bridge next to it crossed the creek at the former community of Gilkey and its Gilkey Station along the tracks of the [Southern Pacific Railroad](/wiki/Southern_Pacific_Railroad_Company "Southern Pacific Railroad Company").{{cite web\|title\=Thomas Creek (Gilkey) Covered Bridge\|url\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Gilkey.pdf\|publisher\=Oregon Department of Transportation\|format\=PDF\|accessdate\=November 30, 2014}} The road bridge, a {{convert\|120\|ft\|m\|adj\=on}} structure of the [Howe truss](/wiki/Howe_truss "Howe truss") type, was built in 1939, damaged and closed in 1997, repaired and re\-opened in 1998\. The companion railroad bridge, a {{convert\|125\|ft\|m\|adj\=on}} Howe truss span, was removed in 1962\.{{cite book\|author\=Cockrell, Bill\|title\=Images of America: Oregon's Covered Bridges\|pages\=112–16\|publisher\=Arcadia Publishing\|year\=2008\|location\=Charleston, South Carolina\|isbn\=978\-0\-7385\-5818\-9}} The Gilkey Covered Bridge carries Goar Road over the creek.
The Weddle Bridge, which replaced an earlier covered bridge at the same site, once crossed Thomas Creek near Scio, at about RM 9\.{{cite web\|title\=Ames Creek (Weddle) Covered Bridge\|publisher\=Oregon Department of Transportation\|url\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Weddle.pdf\|format\=PDF\|accessdate\=November 30, 2014}} A Howe truss span of {{convert\|120\|ft\|m}}, it was built in 1937\. In the late 1980s, the deteriorating structure, no longer in use, was scheduled for destruction. Efforts to save it led the [Oregon Legislative Assembly](/wiki/Oregon_Legislative_Assembly "Oregon Legislative Assembly") to create the Oregon Covered Bridge Program, aimed at preserving the state's covered bridges. Weddle Bridge was the first bridge to win a grant from the program. In 1989, a group in Sweet Home raised additional funds to have the bridge moved and installed across Ames Creek in that city's Sankey Park.
[thumb\|left\|Shimanek Bridge near Scio carries Richardson Gap Road.](/wiki/File:Shimanek_Bridge%2C_Scio%2C_OR_%286563854857%29.jpg "Shimanek Bridge, Scio, OR (6563854857).jpg")
Shimanek Bridge, upstream of Scio at about RM 12, is a {{convert\|130\|ft\|m\|adj\=on}} Howe truss structure built in 1966\. It is the newest and longest covered bridge in Linn County. At least four other covered bridges crossed Thomas Creek at this same spot, the first documented one in 1891\. Storms and floods damaged the earlier bridges.{{cite web\|title\=Thomas Creek (Shimanek) Covered Bridge\|url\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Shimanek.pdf\|format\=PDF\|publisher\=Oregon Department of Transportation\|accessdate\=November 30, 2014}} The Shimanek Bridge carries Richardson Gap Road over the creek.
About {{convert\|1\.5\|mi\|km}} downstream of Jordan, near RM 17, the Hannah Bridge crosses the creek. Built in 1936, it is {{convert\|105\|ft\|m}} long and of the Howe truss type. Another covered bridge, built in 1912, is thought to have crossed the creek slightly upstream of the Hannah Bridge but was torn down and its lumber used in farm buildings.{{cite web\|title\=Thomas Creek (Hannah) Covered Bridge\|url\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Hannah.pdf\|publisher\=Oregon Department of Transportation\|format\=PDF\|accessdate\=November 30, 2014}} Burmester Creek Road crosses the Hannah Bridge.
The Jordan Bridge, built in 1937 at about RM 19, was a {{convert\|90\|ft\|m\|adj\=on}} Howe truss span. Dismantled in 1985, its timbers were moved to [Stayton](/wiki/Stayton%2C_Oregon "Stayton, Oregon") and reassembled in that city's Pioneer Park. Destroyed by fire in 1994, it was rebuilt in the park in 1998\.
|
[
"Covered bridges\n---------------",
"[thumb\\|right\\|Gilkey Bridge carries Goar Road over Thomas Creek downstream from [Scio](/wiki/Scio%2C_Oregon \"Scio, Oregon\").](/wiki/File:Gilkey_Bridge_%287332313808%29.jpg \"Gilkey Bridge (7332313808).jpg\")\nSeveral [covered bridges](/wiki/Covered_bridge \"Covered bridge\") have spanned Thomas Creek since the late 19th century, some of them replacements for damaged or demolished bridges at the same spots. Three of these bridges—[Gilkey](/wiki/Gilkey_Bridge \"Gilkey Bridge\"), [Shimanek](/wiki/Shimanek_Bridge \"Shimanek Bridge\"), and [Hannah](/wiki/Hannah_Bridge \"Hannah Bridge\")—still cross the creek, while two—[Weddle](/wiki/Weddle_Bridge \"Weddle Bridge\") and [Jordan](/wiki/Stayton%E2%80%93Jordan_Bridge \"Stayton–Jordan Bridge\")—have been moved to cities outside the Thomas Creek watershed. The three that still cross the creek are on the [National Register of Historic Places](/wiki/National_Register_of_Historic_Places \"National Register of Historic Places\") (NRHP).{{cite web\\|title\\=Hannah Bridge\\|work\\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\\|url\\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\\=v.dsp\\_siteSummary\\&resultDisplay\\=44038\\|publisher\\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\\|accessdate\\=December 1, 2014}}{{cite web\\|title\\=Shimanek Bridge\\|work\\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\\|url\\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\\=v.dsp\\_siteSummary\\&resultDisplay\\=44062\\|publisher\\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\\|accessdate\\=December 1, 2014}}{{cite web\\|title\\=Gilkey Bridge\\|work\\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\\|url\\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\\=v.dsp\\_siteSummary\\&resultDisplay\\=44061\\|publisher\\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\\|accessdate\\=December 1, 2014}} The Weddle Bridge was listed on the NRHP in 1979 but delisted in 1991 after its move to [Sweet Home](/wiki/Sweet_Home%2C_Oregon \"Sweet Home, Oregon\").{{cite web\\|title\\=Weddle Bridge\\|work\\=Oregon Historic Sites Database\\|url\\=http://heritagedata.prd.state.or.us/historic/index.cfm?do\\=v.dsp\\_siteSummary\\&resultDisplay\\=44016\\|publisher\\=Oregon Parks and Recreation Department\\|accessdate\\=December 1, 2014}}",
"At roughly {{convert\\|5\\|mi\\|km\\|0}} upstream of the creek [mouth](/wiki/River_mouth \"River mouth\"), Gilkey Bridge and a covered railroad bridge next to it crossed the creek at the former community of Gilkey and its Gilkey Station along the tracks of the [Southern Pacific Railroad](/wiki/Southern_Pacific_Railroad_Company \"Southern Pacific Railroad Company\").{{cite web\\|title\\=Thomas Creek (Gilkey) Covered Bridge\\|url\\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Gilkey.pdf\\|publisher\\=Oregon Department of Transportation\\|format\\=PDF\\|accessdate\\=November 30, 2014}} The road bridge, a {{convert\\|120\\|ft\\|m\\|adj\\=on}} structure of the [Howe truss](/wiki/Howe_truss \"Howe truss\") type, was built in 1939, damaged and closed in 1997, repaired and re\\-opened in 1998\\. The companion railroad bridge, a {{convert\\|125\\|ft\\|m\\|adj\\=on}} Howe truss span, was removed in 1962\\.{{cite book\\|author\\=Cockrell, Bill\\|title\\=Images of America: Oregon's Covered Bridges\\|pages\\=112–16\\|publisher\\=Arcadia Publishing\\|year\\=2008\\|location\\=Charleston, South Carolina\\|isbn\\=978\\-0\\-7385\\-5818\\-9}} The Gilkey Covered Bridge carries Goar Road over the creek.",
"The Weddle Bridge, which replaced an earlier covered bridge at the same site, once crossed Thomas Creek near Scio, at about RM 9\\.{{cite web\\|title\\=Ames Creek (Weddle) Covered Bridge\\|publisher\\=Oregon Department of Transportation\\|url\\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Weddle.pdf\\|format\\=PDF\\|accessdate\\=November 30, 2014}} A Howe truss span of {{convert\\|120\\|ft\\|m}}, it was built in 1937\\. In the late 1980s, the deteriorating structure, no longer in use, was scheduled for destruction. Efforts to save it led the [Oregon Legislative Assembly](/wiki/Oregon_Legislative_Assembly \"Oregon Legislative Assembly\") to create the Oregon Covered Bridge Program, aimed at preserving the state's covered bridges. Weddle Bridge was the first bridge to win a grant from the program. In 1989, a group in Sweet Home raised additional funds to have the bridge moved and installed across Ames Creek in that city's Sankey Park.",
"[thumb\\|left\\|Shimanek Bridge near Scio carries Richardson Gap Road.](/wiki/File:Shimanek_Bridge%2C_Scio%2C_OR_%286563854857%29.jpg \"Shimanek Bridge, Scio, OR (6563854857).jpg\")",
"Shimanek Bridge, upstream of Scio at about RM 12, is a {{convert\\|130\\|ft\\|m\\|adj\\=on}} Howe truss structure built in 1966\\. It is the newest and longest covered bridge in Linn County. At least four other covered bridges crossed Thomas Creek at this same spot, the first documented one in 1891\\. Storms and floods damaged the earlier bridges.{{cite web\\|title\\=Thomas Creek (Shimanek) Covered Bridge\\|url\\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Shimanek.pdf\\|format\\=PDF\\|publisher\\=Oregon Department of Transportation\\|accessdate\\=November 30, 2014}} The Shimanek Bridge carries Richardson Gap Road over the creek.",
"About {{convert\\|1\\.5\\|mi\\|km}} downstream of Jordan, near RM 17, the Hannah Bridge crosses the creek. Built in 1936, it is {{convert\\|105\\|ft\\|m}} long and of the Howe truss type. Another covered bridge, built in 1912, is thought to have crossed the creek slightly upstream of the Hannah Bridge but was torn down and its lumber used in farm buildings.{{cite web\\|title\\=Thomas Creek (Hannah) Covered Bridge\\|url\\=http://www.oregon.gov/odot/hwy/bridge/docs/covbrdg/Descriptions/Hannah.pdf\\|publisher\\=Oregon Department of Transportation\\|format\\=PDF\\|accessdate\\=November 30, 2014}} Burmester Creek Road crosses the Hannah Bridge.",
"The Jordan Bridge, built in 1937 at about RM 19, was a {{convert\\|90\\|ft\\|m\\|adj\\=on}} Howe truss span. Dismantled in 1985, its timbers were moved to [Stayton](/wiki/Stayton%2C_Oregon \"Stayton, Oregon\") and reassembled in that city's Pioneer Park. Destroyed by fire in 1994, it was rebuilt in the park in 1998\\.",
""
] |
History
-------
The ancient origins of the town are now very obscure due to the archive record being relatively recent. Any archaeological evidence has been largely destroyed due to intensive coal mining during the 18th and 19th centuries. A possible [Saxon](/wiki/Saxon "Saxon") [castle](/wiki/Castle "Castle") probably existed at Darlaston, which eventually became a timber castle.King, D.J.C., 1983, *[Castellarium Anglicanum](/wiki/Castellarium_Anglicanum "Castellarium Anglicanum")* (London: Kraus) Vol. 2 p. 452 No remains exist today.
Between the 12th and 15th centuries, the de Darlaston family were the landowners, When the de Darlaston family died out, the manor was taken over by the Hayes family and was known as Great Croft.
Darlaston's location on the South Staffordshire coalfield led to the early development of coal mining and associated industrial activities. At first such activity was relatively small scale requiring only a [copyhold permission](/wiki/Copyhold "Copyhold") from the lord of the manor. So, for example, in 1698 Timothy Woodhouse was manager of the coal mines belonging to Mrs. Mary Offley, then the lady of the manor. In the first year, he sold 3,000 sacks of coal and later went into partnership in his own business.
Rapid industrial growth in the early decades of the 19th century brought with it problems of housing, poverty, and deprivation. In December 1839, the parish rector reported approximately 1,500 homes in the parish of Darlaston, most of which were in poor condition and owned by working\-class people. In 1841 the town had a population of 6,000\. Development was driven by the presence of excellent transport links: the [Birmingham Canal Navigations](/wiki/Birmingham_Canal_Navigations "Birmingham Canal Navigations") and [Grand Junction Railway](/wiki/Grand_Junction_Railway "Grand Junction Railway").{{cite book\|title\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \|author\=William Foot \|author2\=Geraldine Beech \|author3\=Rose Mitchell \|year\=2004 \|publisher\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \|pages\=101 \|isbn\=1\-55002\-506\-6}} Much of the mining land was owned by the [Birmingham Coal Company](/wiki/Birmingham_Coal_Company_%28UK%29 "Birmingham Coal Company (UK)"). Artist [Thomas F. Worrall](/wiki/Thomas_Frederick_Worrall "Thomas Frederick Worrall") was born in the Woods Bank area in 1872, where his father worked as a blacksmith.
Notable beneficiaries of nineteenth\-century industrialisation were the Rose family whose fortune had been made by astute [enclosure of common land](/wiki/Enclosure "Enclosure"). Upon the death of Richard Rose in 1870 his estate was valued at over £877\. He bequeathed the land to his wife Hannah. His brother was James Rose, shown in the 1871 census as a latch, bolt, and nut maker, employing 39 people, including 19 children. By the time of the 1881 census, James Rose was 55 and his business had expanded to employ 90 people.{{cite book\|title\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \|author\=William Foot \|author2\=Geraldine Beech \|author3\=Rose Mitchell \|year\=2004 \|publisher\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \|pages\=102 \|isbn\=1\-55002\-506\-6}} James Rose died in 1901\.{{cite book\|title\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \|author\=William Foot \|author2\=Geraldine Beech \|author3\=Rose Mitchell \|year\=2004 \|publisher\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \|pages\=103 \|isbn\=1\-55002\-506\-6}}
In 1894, Darlaston became an [urban district](/wiki/Urban_district_%28Great_Britain_and_Ireland%29 "Urban district (Great Britain and Ireland)"), and the local board became Darlaston Urban District Council. On 1 April 1966 the district was abolished and merged with the [County Borough of Walsall](/wiki/County_Borough_of_Walsall "County Borough of Walsall") and the [County Borough of Wolverhampton](/wiki/County_Borough_of_Wolverhampton "County Borough of Wolverhampton").{{cite web\|url\=https://visionofbritain.org.uk/unit/10041430\|title\=Relationships and changes Darlaston UD through time\|publisher\=A Vision of Britain through Time\|accessdate\=1 October 2024}} The parish was also abolished on 1 April 1966 and merged with Walsall and Wolverhampton.{{cite web\|url\=https://www.ukbmd.org.uk/reg/districts/wednesbury.html\|title\=Wednesbury Registration District\|publisher\=UKBMD\|accessdate\=1 October 2024}} In 1961 the parish had a population of 21,839\.{{cite web\|url\=https://visionofbritain.org.uk/unit/10276871/cube/TOT\_POP\|title\=Population statistics Darlaston AP/CP through time\|publisher\=A Vision of Britain through Time\|accessdate\=1 October 2024}} In 1974 it became part of the [metropolitan county](/wiki/Metropolitan_county "Metropolitan county") of the [West Midlands](/wiki/West_Midlands_%28county%29 "West Midlands (county)").{{cite web\|url\=http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/TownHall.htm \|title\=A New Town Hall \|work\=A Brief History of Darlaston \|author\=Bev Parker \|publisher\=University of Wolverhampton \|access\-date\=2008\-03\-30 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20061008205619/http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/TownHall.htm \|archive\-date\=8 October 2006 }}
Darlaston was subject to several bombing raids in [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II "World War II"). A [Luftwaffe](/wiki/Luftwaffe "Luftwaffe") bombing on 5 June 1941 wrecked several council houses in Lowe Avenue, Rough Hay, and killed 11 people. The bomb had been aimed at [Rubery Owen](/wiki/Rubery_Owen "Rubery Owen")'s factory but missed by some distance. The houses were later rebuilt.{{cite web \|url\=http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/War.htm \|title\=A Brief History of Darlaston \|access\-date\=2010\-05\-05 \|url\-status\=dead \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100514121920/http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/War.htm \|archive\-date\=14 May 2010 }}
Many [Victorian](/wiki/Victorian_architecture "Victorian architecture") [terraced houses](/wiki/Terraced_house "Terraced house") were demolished during the second half of the 20th century, and the [Urban District Council of Darlaston](/wiki/Darlaston_Urban_District "Darlaston Urban District") built thousands of houses and flats to replace them with. From 1966 Darlaston was administered by Walsall borough and is now in the [WS10](/wiki/WS_postcode_area "WS postcode area") postal district which also includes neighbouring [Wednesbury](/wiki/Wednesbury "Wednesbury"). However, since 1999 the council\-owned housing stock has been controlled by Darlaston Housing Trust. In 2001 two of the town's four multi\-story blocks of flats were demolished, and the remaining two were demolished in 2004\. .
By the end of the 1980s, most of the industry in the town had closed and the town is now considered a *ghost town*, with an increasingly high level of unemployment. In 2011 a total of 15 derelict sites in the town were designated as [enterprise zones](/wiki/Urban_Enterprise_Zone "Urban Enterprise Zone") offering tax breaks and relaxed planning laws to any businesses interested in setting up bases in the selected areas. These enterprise zones are expected to create thousands of jobs and ease the town's long\-running unemployment crisis, which has deepened since 2008 as a result of the recession.{{Cite web\|url\=https://www.expressandstar.com/news/2011/10/30/firms\-line\-up\-to\-move\-on\-darlaston\-enterprise\-zone/\|title \= Firms line up to move on Darlaston Enterprise Zone\| date\=30 October 2011 }}
|
[
"History\n-------",
"The ancient origins of the town are now very obscure due to the archive record being relatively recent. Any archaeological evidence has been largely destroyed due to intensive coal mining during the 18th and 19th centuries. A possible [Saxon](/wiki/Saxon \"Saxon\") [castle](/wiki/Castle \"Castle\") probably existed at Darlaston, which eventually became a timber castle.King, D.J.C., 1983, *[Castellarium Anglicanum](/wiki/Castellarium_Anglicanum \"Castellarium Anglicanum\")* (London: Kraus) Vol. 2 p. 452 No remains exist today.",
"Between the 12th and 15th centuries, the de Darlaston family were the landowners, When the de Darlaston family died out, the manor was taken over by the Hayes family and was known as Great Croft.",
"Darlaston's location on the South Staffordshire coalfield led to the early development of coal mining and associated industrial activities. At first such activity was relatively small scale requiring only a [copyhold permission](/wiki/Copyhold \"Copyhold\") from the lord of the manor. So, for example, in 1698 Timothy Woodhouse was manager of the coal mines belonging to Mrs. Mary Offley, then the lady of the manor. In the first year, he sold 3,000 sacks of coal and later went into partnership in his own business.",
"Rapid industrial growth in the early decades of the 19th century brought with it problems of housing, poverty, and deprivation. In December 1839, the parish rector reported approximately 1,500 homes in the parish of Darlaston, most of which were in poor condition and owned by working\\-class people. In 1841 the town had a population of 6,000\\. Development was driven by the presence of excellent transport links: the [Birmingham Canal Navigations](/wiki/Birmingham_Canal_Navigations \"Birmingham Canal Navigations\") and [Grand Junction Railway](/wiki/Grand_Junction_Railway \"Grand Junction Railway\").{{cite book\\|title\\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \\|author\\=William Foot \\|author2\\=Geraldine Beech \\|author3\\=Rose Mitchell \\|year\\=2004 \\|publisher\\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \\|pages\\=101 \\|isbn\\=1\\-55002\\-506\\-6}} Much of the mining land was owned by the [Birmingham Coal Company](/wiki/Birmingham_Coal_Company_%28UK%29 \"Birmingham Coal Company (UK)\"). Artist [Thomas F. Worrall](/wiki/Thomas_Frederick_Worrall \"Thomas Frederick Worrall\") was born in the Woods Bank area in 1872, where his father worked as a blacksmith.",
"Notable beneficiaries of nineteenth\\-century industrialisation were the Rose family whose fortune had been made by astute [enclosure of common land](/wiki/Enclosure \"Enclosure\"). Upon the death of Richard Rose in 1870 his estate was valued at over £877\\. He bequeathed the land to his wife Hannah. His brother was James Rose, shown in the 1871 census as a latch, bolt, and nut maker, employing 39 people, including 19 children. By the time of the 1881 census, James Rose was 55 and his business had expanded to employ 90 people.{{cite book\\|title\\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \\|author\\=William Foot \\|author2\\=Geraldine Beech \\|author3\\=Rose Mitchell \\|year\\=2004 \\|publisher\\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \\|pages\\=102 \\|isbn\\=1\\-55002\\-506\\-6}} James Rose died in 1901\\.{{cite book\\|title\\=Maps for Family and Local History: The Records of the Tithe, Valuation Office and National Farm Surveys of England and Wales, 1836 – 1943 \\|author\\=William Foot \\|author2\\=Geraldine Beech \\|author3\\=Rose Mitchell \\|year\\=2004 \\|publisher\\=Dundurn Press Ltd. \\|pages\\=103 \\|isbn\\=1\\-55002\\-506\\-6}}",
"In 1894, Darlaston became an [urban district](/wiki/Urban_district_%28Great_Britain_and_Ireland%29 \"Urban district (Great Britain and Ireland)\"), and the local board became Darlaston Urban District Council. On 1 April 1966 the district was abolished and merged with the [County Borough of Walsall](/wiki/County_Borough_of_Walsall \"County Borough of Walsall\") and the [County Borough of Wolverhampton](/wiki/County_Borough_of_Wolverhampton \"County Borough of Wolverhampton\").{{cite web\\|url\\=https://visionofbritain.org.uk/unit/10041430\\|title\\=Relationships and changes Darlaston UD through time\\|publisher\\=A Vision of Britain through Time\\|accessdate\\=1 October 2024}} The parish was also abolished on 1 April 1966 and merged with Walsall and Wolverhampton.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://www.ukbmd.org.uk/reg/districts/wednesbury.html\\|title\\=Wednesbury Registration District\\|publisher\\=UKBMD\\|accessdate\\=1 October 2024}} In 1961 the parish had a population of 21,839\\.{{cite web\\|url\\=https://visionofbritain.org.uk/unit/10276871/cube/TOT\\_POP\\|title\\=Population statistics Darlaston AP/CP through time\\|publisher\\=A Vision of Britain through Time\\|accessdate\\=1 October 2024}} In 1974 it became part of the [metropolitan county](/wiki/Metropolitan_county \"Metropolitan county\") of the [West Midlands](/wiki/West_Midlands_%28county%29 \"West Midlands (county)\").{{cite web\\|url\\=http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/TownHall.htm \\|title\\=A New Town Hall \\|work\\=A Brief History of Darlaston \\|author\\=Bev Parker \\|publisher\\=University of Wolverhampton \\|access\\-date\\=2008\\-03\\-30 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20061008205619/http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/TownHall.htm \\|archive\\-date\\=8 October 2006 }}",
"Darlaston was subject to several bombing raids in [World War II](/wiki/World_War_II \"World War II\"). A [Luftwaffe](/wiki/Luftwaffe \"Luftwaffe\") bombing on 5 June 1941 wrecked several council houses in Lowe Avenue, Rough Hay, and killed 11 people. The bomb had been aimed at [Rubery Owen](/wiki/Rubery_Owen \"Rubery Owen\")'s factory but missed by some distance. The houses were later rebuilt.{{cite web \\|url\\=http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/War.htm \\|title\\=A Brief History of Darlaston \\|access\\-date\\=2010\\-05\\-05 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20100514121920/http://www.localhistory.scit.wlv.ac.uk/articles/Darlaston/War.htm \\|archive\\-date\\=14 May 2010 }}",
"Many [Victorian](/wiki/Victorian_architecture \"Victorian architecture\") [terraced houses](/wiki/Terraced_house \"Terraced house\") were demolished during the second half of the 20th century, and the [Urban District Council of Darlaston](/wiki/Darlaston_Urban_District \"Darlaston Urban District\") built thousands of houses and flats to replace them with. From 1966 Darlaston was administered by Walsall borough and is now in the [WS10](/wiki/WS_postcode_area \"WS postcode area\") postal district which also includes neighbouring [Wednesbury](/wiki/Wednesbury \"Wednesbury\"). However, since 1999 the council\\-owned housing stock has been controlled by Darlaston Housing Trust. In 2001 two of the town's four multi\\-story blocks of flats were demolished, and the remaining two were demolished in 2004\\. .",
"By the end of the 1980s, most of the industry in the town had closed and the town is now considered a *ghost town*, with an increasingly high level of unemployment. In 2011 a total of 15 derelict sites in the town were designated as [enterprise zones](/wiki/Urban_Enterprise_Zone \"Urban Enterprise Zone\") offering tax breaks and relaxed planning laws to any businesses interested in setting up bases in the selected areas. These enterprise zones are expected to create thousands of jobs and ease the town's long\\-running unemployment crisis, which has deepened since 2008 as a result of the recession.{{Cite web\\|url\\=https://www.expressandstar.com/news/2011/10/30/firms\\-line\\-up\\-to\\-move\\-on\\-darlaston\\-enterprise\\-zone/\\|title \\= Firms line up to move on Darlaston Enterprise Zone\\| date\\=30 October 2011 }}",
""
] |
Defining the security
---------------------
Formal definitions of commitment schemes vary strongly in notation and in flavour. The first such flavour is whether the commitment scheme provides perfect or computational security with respect to the hiding or binding properties. Another such flavour is whether the commitment is interactive, i.e. whether both the commit phase and the reveal phase can be seen as being executed by a [cryptographic protocol](/wiki/Cryptographic_protocol "Cryptographic protocol") or whether they are non\-interactive, consisting of two algorithms *Commit* and *CheckReveal*. In the latter case *CheckReveal* can often be seen as a derandomised version of *Commit*, with the randomness used by *Commit* constituting the opening information.
If the commitment *C* to a value *x* is computed as *C:\=Commit(x,open)* with *open* being the randomness used for computing the commitment, then *CheckReveal (C,x,open)* reduces to simply verifying the equation *C\=Commit (x,open)*.
Using this notation and some knowledge about [mathematical functions](/wiki/Mathematical_function "Mathematical function") and [probability theory](/wiki/Probability_theory "Probability theory") we formalise different versions of the binding and hiding properties of commitments. The two most important combinations of these properties are perfectly binding and computationally hiding commitment schemes and computationally binding and perfectly hiding commitment schemes. Note that no commitment scheme can be at the same time perfectly binding and perfectly hiding – a computationally unbounded adversary can simply generate *Commit(x,open)* for every value of *x* and *open* until finding a pair that outputs *C*, and in a perfectly binding scheme this uniquely identifies *x*.
### Computational binding
Let *open* be chosen from a set of size 2^k, i.e., it can be represented as a *k* bit string, and let \\text{Commit}\_k be the corresponding commitment scheme. As the size of *k* determines the security of the commitment scheme it is called the [security parameter](/wiki/Security_parameter "Security parameter").
Then for all [non\-uniform](/wiki/Uniformity_%28complexity%29 "Uniformity (complexity)") [probabilistic polynomial time algorithms](/wiki/PP_%28complexity%29 "PP (complexity)") that output x,x' and open, open' of increasing length *k*, the probability that x \\neq x' and \\text{Commit}\_k(x,open)\=\\text{Commit}\_k(x',open') is a [negligible function](/wiki/Negligible_function "Negligible function") in *k*.
This is a form of [asymptotic analysis](/wiki/Asymptotic_analysis "Asymptotic analysis"). It is also possible to state the same requirement using [concrete security](/wiki/Concrete_security "Concrete security"): A commitment scheme *Commit* is (t,\\epsilon) secure, if for all algorithms that run in time *t* and output x,x',open,open' the probability that x \\neq x' and \\text{Commit}(x,open)\=\\text{Commit}(x',open') is at most \\epsilon.
### Perfect, statistical, and computational hiding
Let U\_k be the uniform distribution over the 2^k opening values for security parameter *k*. A commitment scheme is respectively perfect, statistical, or computational hiding, if for all x\\neq x' the [probability ensembles](/wiki/Probability_ensemble "Probability ensemble") \\{\\text{Commit}\_k(x,U\_k)\\}\_{k\\in\\N} and \\{\\text{Commit}\_k(x',U\_k)\\}\_{k\\in\\N} are equal, [statistically close](/wiki/Statistically_close "Statistically close"), or [computationally indistinguishable](/wiki/Computationally_indistinguishable "Computationally indistinguishable").
### Impossibility of universally composable commitment schemes
It is impossible to realize commitment schemes in the [universal composability](/wiki/Universal_composability "Universal composability")
(UC) framework. The reason is that UC commitment has to be *extractable*, as shown by Canetti and FischlinR. Canetti and M. Fischlin. [Universally Composable Commitments.](https://eprint.iacr.org/2001/055) and explained below.
The ideal commitment functionality, denoted here by *F*, works roughly as follows. Committer *C* sends value *m* to *F*, which
stores it and sends "receipt" to receiver *R*. Later, *C* sends "open" to
*F*, which sends *m* to *R*.
Now, assume we have a protocol *π* that realizes this functionality. Suppose that the committer *C* is corrupted. In the UC framework, that essentially means that *C* is now controlled by the environment, which attempts to distinguish protocol execution from the ideal process. Consider an environment that chooses a message *m* and then tells *C* to act as prescribed by *π*, as if it has committed to *m*. Note here that in order to realize *F*, the receiver must, after receiving a commitment, output a message "receipt". After the environment sees this message, it tells *C* to open the commitment.
The protocol is only secure if this scenario is indistinguishable from the ideal case, where the functionality interacts with a simulator *S*. Here, *S* has control of *C*. In particular, whenever *R* outputs "receipt", *F* has to do likewise. The only way to do that is for *S* to tell *C* to send a value to *F*. However, note
that by this point, *m* is not known to *S*. Hence, when the commitment is opened during protocol execution, it is unlikely that *F* will open to *m*, unless *S* can extract *m* from the messages it received from the environment before *R* outputs the receipt.
However a protocol that is extractable in this sense cannot be statistically hiding. Suppose such a simulator *S* exists. Now consider an
environment that, instead of corrupting *C*, corrupts *R* instead. Additionally it runs a copy of *S*. Messages received from *C* are fed into *S*, and replies from *S* are forwarded to *C*.
The environment initially tells *C* to commit to a message *m*. At some point in the interaction, *S* will commit to a value *m′*. This message is handed to *R*, who outputs *m′*. Note that by assumption we have *m' \= m* with high probability. Now in the ideal process the simulator has to come up with *m*. But this is impossible, because at this point the commitment has not been opened yet, so the only message *R* can have received in the ideal process is a "receipt" message. We thus have a contradiction.
|
[
"Defining the security\n---------------------",
"Formal definitions of commitment schemes vary strongly in notation and in flavour. The first such flavour is whether the commitment scheme provides perfect or computational security with respect to the hiding or binding properties. Another such flavour is whether the commitment is interactive, i.e. whether both the commit phase and the reveal phase can be seen as being executed by a [cryptographic protocol](/wiki/Cryptographic_protocol \"Cryptographic protocol\") or whether they are non\\-interactive, consisting of two algorithms *Commit* and *CheckReveal*. In the latter case *CheckReveal* can often be seen as a derandomised version of *Commit*, with the randomness used by *Commit* constituting the opening information.",
"If the commitment *C* to a value *x* is computed as *C:\\=Commit(x,open)* with *open* being the randomness used for computing the commitment, then *CheckReveal (C,x,open)* reduces to simply verifying the equation *C\\=Commit (x,open)*.",
"Using this notation and some knowledge about [mathematical functions](/wiki/Mathematical_function \"Mathematical function\") and [probability theory](/wiki/Probability_theory \"Probability theory\") we formalise different versions of the binding and hiding properties of commitments. The two most important combinations of these properties are perfectly binding and computationally hiding commitment schemes and computationally binding and perfectly hiding commitment schemes. Note that no commitment scheme can be at the same time perfectly binding and perfectly hiding – a computationally unbounded adversary can simply generate *Commit(x,open)* for every value of *x* and *open* until finding a pair that outputs *C*, and in a perfectly binding scheme this uniquely identifies *x*.",
"### Computational binding",
"Let *open* be chosen from a set of size 2^k, i.e., it can be represented as a *k* bit string, and let \\\\text{Commit}\\_k be the corresponding commitment scheme. As the size of *k* determines the security of the commitment scheme it is called the [security parameter](/wiki/Security_parameter \"Security parameter\").",
"Then for all [non\\-uniform](/wiki/Uniformity_%28complexity%29 \"Uniformity (complexity)\") [probabilistic polynomial time algorithms](/wiki/PP_%28complexity%29 \"PP (complexity)\") that output x,x' and open, open' of increasing length *k*, the probability that x \\\\neq x' and \\\\text{Commit}\\_k(x,open)\\=\\\\text{Commit}\\_k(x',open') is a [negligible function](/wiki/Negligible_function \"Negligible function\") in *k*.",
"This is a form of [asymptotic analysis](/wiki/Asymptotic_analysis \"Asymptotic analysis\"). It is also possible to state the same requirement using [concrete security](/wiki/Concrete_security \"Concrete security\"): A commitment scheme *Commit* is (t,\\\\epsilon) secure, if for all algorithms that run in time *t* and output x,x',open,open' the probability that x \\\\neq x' and \\\\text{Commit}(x,open)\\=\\\\text{Commit}(x',open') is at most \\\\epsilon.",
"### Perfect, statistical, and computational hiding",
"Let U\\_k be the uniform distribution over the 2^k opening values for security parameter *k*. A commitment scheme is respectively perfect, statistical, or computational hiding, if for all x\\\\neq x' the [probability ensembles](/wiki/Probability_ensemble \"Probability ensemble\") \\\\{\\\\text{Commit}\\_k(x,U\\_k)\\\\}\\_{k\\\\in\\\\N} and \\\\{\\\\text{Commit}\\_k(x',U\\_k)\\\\}\\_{k\\\\in\\\\N} are equal, [statistically close](/wiki/Statistically_close \"Statistically close\"), or [computationally indistinguishable](/wiki/Computationally_indistinguishable \"Computationally indistinguishable\").",
"### Impossibility of universally composable commitment schemes",
"It is impossible to realize commitment schemes in the [universal composability](/wiki/Universal_composability \"Universal composability\")\n(UC) framework. The reason is that UC commitment has to be *extractable*, as shown by Canetti and FischlinR. Canetti and M. Fischlin. [Universally Composable Commitments.](https://eprint.iacr.org/2001/055) and explained below.",
"The ideal commitment functionality, denoted here by *F*, works roughly as follows. Committer *C* sends value *m* to *F*, which\nstores it and sends \"receipt\" to receiver *R*. Later, *C* sends \"open\" to\n*F*, which sends *m* to *R*.",
"Now, assume we have a protocol *π* that realizes this functionality. Suppose that the committer *C* is corrupted. In the UC framework, that essentially means that *C* is now controlled by the environment, which attempts to distinguish protocol execution from the ideal process. Consider an environment that chooses a message *m* and then tells *C* to act as prescribed by *π*, as if it has committed to *m*. Note here that in order to realize *F*, the receiver must, after receiving a commitment, output a message \"receipt\". After the environment sees this message, it tells *C* to open the commitment.",
"The protocol is only secure if this scenario is indistinguishable from the ideal case, where the functionality interacts with a simulator *S*. Here, *S* has control of *C*. In particular, whenever *R* outputs \"receipt\", *F* has to do likewise. The only way to do that is for *S* to tell *C* to send a value to *F*. However, note\nthat by this point, *m* is not known to *S*. Hence, when the commitment is opened during protocol execution, it is unlikely that *F* will open to *m*, unless *S* can extract *m* from the messages it received from the environment before *R* outputs the receipt.",
"However a protocol that is extractable in this sense cannot be statistically hiding. Suppose such a simulator *S* exists. Now consider an\nenvironment that, instead of corrupting *C*, corrupts *R* instead. Additionally it runs a copy of *S*. Messages received from *C* are fed into *S*, and replies from *S* are forwarded to *C*.",
"The environment initially tells *C* to commit to a message *m*. At some point in the interaction, *S* will commit to a value *m′*. This message is handed to *R*, who outputs *m′*. Note that by assumption we have *m' \\= m* with high probability. Now in the ideal process the simulator has to come up with *m*. But this is impossible, because at this point the commitment has not been opened yet, so the only message *R* can have received in the ideal process is a \"receipt\" message. We thus have a contradiction.",
""
] |
### Impossibility of universally composable commitment schemes
It is impossible to realize commitment schemes in the [universal composability](/wiki/Universal_composability "Universal composability")
(UC) framework. The reason is that UC commitment has to be *extractable*, as shown by Canetti and FischlinR. Canetti and M. Fischlin. [Universally Composable Commitments.](https://eprint.iacr.org/2001/055) and explained below.
The ideal commitment functionality, denoted here by *F*, works roughly as follows. Committer *C* sends value *m* to *F*, which
stores it and sends "receipt" to receiver *R*. Later, *C* sends "open" to
*F*, which sends *m* to *R*.
Now, assume we have a protocol *π* that realizes this functionality. Suppose that the committer *C* is corrupted. In the UC framework, that essentially means that *C* is now controlled by the environment, which attempts to distinguish protocol execution from the ideal process. Consider an environment that chooses a message *m* and then tells *C* to act as prescribed by *π*, as if it has committed to *m*. Note here that in order to realize *F*, the receiver must, after receiving a commitment, output a message "receipt". After the environment sees this message, it tells *C* to open the commitment.
The protocol is only secure if this scenario is indistinguishable from the ideal case, where the functionality interacts with a simulator *S*. Here, *S* has control of *C*. In particular, whenever *R* outputs "receipt", *F* has to do likewise. The only way to do that is for *S* to tell *C* to send a value to *F*. However, note
that by this point, *m* is not known to *S*. Hence, when the commitment is opened during protocol execution, it is unlikely that *F* will open to *m*, unless *S* can extract *m* from the messages it received from the environment before *R* outputs the receipt.
However a protocol that is extractable in this sense cannot be statistically hiding. Suppose such a simulator *S* exists. Now consider an
environment that, instead of corrupting *C*, corrupts *R* instead. Additionally it runs a copy of *S*. Messages received from *C* are fed into *S*, and replies from *S* are forwarded to *C*.
The environment initially tells *C* to commit to a message *m*. At some point in the interaction, *S* will commit to a value *m′*. This message is handed to *R*, who outputs *m′*. Note that by assumption we have *m' \= m* with high probability. Now in the ideal process the simulator has to come up with *m*. But this is impossible, because at this point the commitment has not been opened yet, so the only message *R* can have received in the ideal process is a "receipt" message. We thus have a contradiction.
|
[
"### Impossibility of universally composable commitment schemes",
"It is impossible to realize commitment schemes in the [universal composability](/wiki/Universal_composability \"Universal composability\")\n(UC) framework. The reason is that UC commitment has to be *extractable*, as shown by Canetti and FischlinR. Canetti and M. Fischlin. [Universally Composable Commitments.](https://eprint.iacr.org/2001/055) and explained below.",
"The ideal commitment functionality, denoted here by *F*, works roughly as follows. Committer *C* sends value *m* to *F*, which\nstores it and sends \"receipt\" to receiver *R*. Later, *C* sends \"open\" to\n*F*, which sends *m* to *R*.",
"Now, assume we have a protocol *π* that realizes this functionality. Suppose that the committer *C* is corrupted. In the UC framework, that essentially means that *C* is now controlled by the environment, which attempts to distinguish protocol execution from the ideal process. Consider an environment that chooses a message *m* and then tells *C* to act as prescribed by *π*, as if it has committed to *m*. Note here that in order to realize *F*, the receiver must, after receiving a commitment, output a message \"receipt\". After the environment sees this message, it tells *C* to open the commitment.",
"The protocol is only secure if this scenario is indistinguishable from the ideal case, where the functionality interacts with a simulator *S*. Here, *S* has control of *C*. In particular, whenever *R* outputs \"receipt\", *F* has to do likewise. The only way to do that is for *S* to tell *C* to send a value to *F*. However, note\nthat by this point, *m* is not known to *S*. Hence, when the commitment is opened during protocol execution, it is unlikely that *F* will open to *m*, unless *S* can extract *m* from the messages it received from the environment before *R* outputs the receipt.",
"However a protocol that is extractable in this sense cannot be statistically hiding. Suppose such a simulator *S* exists. Now consider an\nenvironment that, instead of corrupting *C*, corrupts *R* instead. Additionally it runs a copy of *S*. Messages received from *C* are fed into *S*, and replies from *S* are forwarded to *C*.",
"The environment initially tells *C* to commit to a message *m*. At some point in the interaction, *S* will commit to a value *m′*. This message is handed to *R*, who outputs *m′*. Note that by assumption we have *m' \\= m* with high probability. Now in the ideal process the simulator has to come up with *m*. But this is impossible, because at this point the commitment has not been opened yet, so the only message *R* can have received in the ideal process is a \"receipt\" message. We thus have a contradiction.",
""
] |
Construction
------------
A commitment scheme can either be perfectly binding (it is impossible for Alice to alter her commitment after she has made it, even if she has unbounded computational resources); or perfectly concealing (it is impossible for Bob to find out the commitment without Alice revealing it, even if he has unbounded computational resources); or formulated as an instance\-dependent commitment scheme, which is either hiding or binding depending on the solution to another problem.Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (1990\). Perfect zero knowledge in constant round, In Proc. STOC, p. 482–493, cited in Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (2008\). An Equivalence between Zero Knowledge and Commitments, Theory of Cryptography.Toshiya Itoh, Yiji Ohta, Hiroki Shizuya (1997\). A language dependent cryptographic primitive, In J. Cryptol., 10(1\):37\-49, cited in Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (2008\). An Equivalence between Zero Knowledge and Commitments, Theory of Cryptography. A commitment scheme cannot be both perfectly hiding and perfectly binding at the same time.
### Bit\-commitment in the random oracle model
Bit\-commitment schemes are trivial to construct in the [random oracle](/wiki/Random_oracle "Random oracle") model. Given a [hash function](/wiki/Cryptographic_hash_function "Cryptographic hash function") H with a 3*k* bit output, to commit the *k*\-bit message *m*, Alice generates a random *k* bit string *R* and sends Bob H(*R* \|\| *m*). The probability that any *R′*, *m′* exist where *m′* ≠ *m* such that H(*R′* \|\| *m′*) \= H(*R* \|\| *m*) is ≈ 2−*k*, but to test any guess at the message *m* Bob will need to make 2*k* (for an incorrect guess) or 2*k*\-1 (on average, for a correct guess) queries to the random oracle.{{Citation
\| last \= Wagner
\| first \= David
\| year \= 2006
\| title \= Midterm Solution
\| page \= 2
\| url \= http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/\~daw/teaching/cs276\-s06/mtsol.ps
\| access\-date \= 26 October 2015
}} We note that earlier schemes based on hash functions, essentially can be thought of schemes based on idealization of these hash functions as random oracle.
### Bit\-commitment from any one\-way permutation
One can create a bit\-commitment scheme from any [one\-way function](/wiki/One-way_function "One-way function") that is [injective](/wiki/Injective_function "Injective function"). The scheme relies on the fact that every one\-way function can be modified (via the [Goldreich\-Levin theorem](/wiki/Goldreich-Levin_theorem "Goldreich-Levin theorem")) to possess a computationally [hard\-core predicate](/wiki/Hard-core_predicate "Hard-core predicate") (while retaining the injective property).
Let *f* be an injective one\-way function, with *h* a hard\-core predicate. Then to commit to a bit *b* Alice picks a random input *x* and sends the triple
(h,f(x),b \\oplus h(x))
to Bob, where \\oplus denotes XOR, *i.e.*, bitwise addition modulo 2\. To decommit, Alice simply sends *x* to Bob. Bob verifies by computing *f*(*x*) and comparing to the committed value. This scheme is concealing because for Bob to recover *b* he must recover *h*(*x*). Since *h* is a computationally hard\-core predicate, recovering *h*(*x*) from *f*(*x*) with probability greater than one\-half is as hard as inverting *f*. Perfect binding follows from the fact that *f* is injective and thus *f*(*x*) has exactly one preimage.
### Bit\-commitment from a pseudo\-random generator
Note that since we do not know how to construct a one\-way permutation from any one\-way function, this section reduces the strength of the cryptographic assumption necessary to construct a bit\-commitment protocol.
In 1991 Moni Naor showed how to create a bit\-commitment scheme from a [cryptographically secure pseudorandom number generator](/wiki/Cryptographically_secure_pseudorandom_number_generator "Cryptographically secure pseudorandom number generator").{{cite web\|url\=http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/context/22544/0 \|title\=Citations: Bit Commitment using Pseudorandom Generators \- Naor (ResearchIndex) \|publisher\=Citeseer.ist.psu.edu \|access\-date\=2014\-06\-07 \|url\-access\=registration}} The construction is as follows. If *G* is a pseudo\-random generator such that *G* takes *n* bits to 3*n* bits, then if Alice wants to commit to a bit *b*:
* Bob selects a random 3*n*\-bit vector *R* and sends *R* to Alice.
* Alice selects a random *n*\-bit vector *Y* and computes the 3*n*\-bit vector *G*(*Y*).
* If *b*\=1 Alice sends *G*(*Y*) to Bob, otherwise she sends the bitwise [exclusive\-or](/wiki/Exclusive_disjunction "Exclusive disjunction") of *G*(*Y*) and *R* to Bob.
To decommit Alice sends *Y* to Bob, who can then check whether he initially received *G*(*Y*) or *G*(*Y*) \\oplus *R*.
This scheme is statistically binding, meaning that even if Alice is computationally unbounded she cannot cheat with probability greater than 2−*n*. For Alice to cheat, she would need to find a *Y'*, such that *G*(*Y'*) \= *G*(*Y*) \\oplus *R*. If she could find such a value, she could decommit by sending the truth and *Y*, or send the opposite answer and *Y'*. However, *G*(*Y*) and *G*(*Y''') are only able to produce 2*n* possible values each (that's 22*n*) while* R *is picked out of 23*n* values. She does not pick* R*, so there is a 22*n*/23*n* \= 2−*n* probability that a* Y' *satisfying the equation required to cheat will exist.*
The concealing property follows from a standard reduction, if Bob can tell whether Alice committed to a zero or one, he can also distinguish the output of the pseudo\-random generator G *from true\-random, which contradicts the cryptographic security of* G*.*
### A perfectly binding scheme based on the discrete log problem and beyond
Alice chooses a [ring](/wiki/Ring_%28mathematics%29 "Ring (mathematics)") of prime order p*, with multiplicative generator* g*.*
Alice randomly picks a secret value x *from* 0 *to* p*− 1 to commit to and calculates* c *\=* g**x* and publishes* c*. The [discrete logarithm problem](/wiki/Discrete_logarithm_problem "Discrete logarithm problem") dictates that from* c*, it is computationally infeasible to compute* x*, so under this assumption, Bob cannot compute* x*. On the other hand, Alice cannot compute a* x{{prime}} *\<\>* x*, such that* g**x{{prime}}* \=* c*, so the scheme is binding.*
This scheme isn't perfectly concealing as someone could find the commitment if he manages to solve the [discrete logarithm problem](/wiki/Discrete_logarithm_problem "Discrete logarithm problem"). In fact, this scheme isn't hiding at all with respect to the standard hiding game, where an adversary should be unable to guess which of two messages he chose were committed to \- similar to the [IND\-CPA](/wiki/IND-CPA "IND-CPA") game. One consequence of this is that if the space of possible values of x *is small, then an attacker could simply try them all and the commitment would not be hiding.*
A better example of a perfectly binding commitment scheme is one where the commitment is the encryption of x *under a [semantically secure](/wiki/Semantically_secure "Semantically secure"), public\-key encryption scheme with perfect completeness, and the decommitment is the string of random bits used to encrypt* x*. An example of an information\-theoretically hiding commitment scheme is the Pedersen commitment scheme,{{cite book \| last\=Pedersen \| first\=Torben Pryds \| title\=Advances in Cryptology – CRYPTO '91 \| chapter\=Non\-Interactive and Information\-Theoretic Secure Verifiable Secret Sharing \| series\=Lecture Notes in Computer Science \| date\=1992 \| volume\=576 \| publisher\=Springer Berlin Heidelberg \| publication\-place\=Berlin, Heidelberg \| isbn\=978\-3\-540\-55188\-1 \| doi\=10\.1007/3\-540\-46766\-1\_9 \| pages\=129–140}} which is computationally binding under the discrete logarithm assumption.
{{cite conference
\| title \= Automated cryptographic analysis of the pedersen commitment scheme
\| last1 \= Metere
\| first1 \= Roberto
\| last2 \= Dong
\| first2 \= Changyu
\| date \= 2017
\| publisher \= Springer
\| book\-title \= International Conference on Mathematical Methods, Models, and Architectures for Computer Network Security
\| pages \= 275–287
}}
Additionally to the scheme above, it uses another generator* h *of the prime group and a random number* r*. The commitment is set c\=g^x h^r.{{cite journal \|last1\=Tang \|first1\=Chunming \|last2\=Pei \|first2\=Dingyi \|last3\=Liu \|first3\=Zhuojun \|last4\=He \|first4\=Yong \|title\=Pedersen: Non\-interactive and information\-theoretic secure verifiable secret sharing \|url\=https://eprint.iacr.org/2004/201\.pdf \|website\=Cryptology ePrint Archive \|publisher\=Advances in Cryptology CRYPTO 1991 Springer \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170811001441/https://eprint.iacr.org/2004/201\.pdf \|archive\-date\=11 August 2017 \|url\-status\=dead \|language\=en \|date\=16 August 2004 \|access\-date\=2 February 2019 }}*
These constructions are tightly related to and based on the algebraic properties of the underlying groups, and the notion originally seemed to be very much related to the algebra. However, it was shown that basing statistically binding commitment schemes on general unstructured assumption is possible, via the notion of interactive hashing
for commitments from general complexity assumptions (specifically and originally, based on any one way permutation) as in.Moni Naor, Rafail Ostrovsky, Ramarathnam Venkatesan, Moti Yung:
Perfect Zero\-Knowledge Arguments for NP Using Any One\-Way Permutation. J. Cryptology 11(2\): 87–108 (1998\)[https://link.springer.com/article/10\.1007%2Fs001459900037](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs001459900037)
### A perfectly hiding commitment scheme based on RSA
Alice selects N such that N \= p \\cdot q, where p and q are large secret prime numbers. Additionally, she selects a prime e such that e \> N^2 and gcd(e, \\phi(N^2\)) \= 1. Alice then computes a public number g\_m as an element of maximum order in the \\Z^\*\_{N^2} group.{{cite book
\|last1\= Menezes \|first1\= Alfred J
\|last2\= Van Oorschot\|first2\= Paul C
\|last3\= Vanstone \|first3\= Scott A
\|date\= 2018
\|title\= Handbook of applied cryptography
\|publisher\= CRC press}} Finally, Alice commits to her secret m by first generating a random number r from \\Z^\*\_{N^2} and then by computing c\=m^e g\_{m}^{r}.
The security of the above commitment relies on the hardness of the RSA problem and has perfect hiding and computational binding.{{cite journal
\|last1\=Mouris \|first1\=Dimitris
\|last2\=Tsoutsos \|first2\=Nektarios Georgios
\|title\=Masquerade: Verifiable Multi\-Party Aggregation with Secure Multiplicative Commitments
\|url\=https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/1370\.pdf
\|website\=Cryptology ePrint Archive
\|language\=en
\|date\=26 January 2022
}}
### Additive and multiplicative homomorphic properties of commitments
The Pedersen commitment scheme introduces an interesting homomorphic property that allows performing addition between two commitments. More specifically, given two messages m\_1 and m\_2 and randomness r\_1 and r\_2, respectively, it is possible to generate a new commitment such that: C(m\_1, r\_1\) \\cdot C(m\_2, r\_2\) \= C(m\_1 \+ m\_2, r\_1 \+ r\_2\). Formally:
C(m\_1, r\_1\) \\cdot C(m\_2, r\_2\) \= g^{m\_1} h^{r\_1} \\cdot g^{m\_2} h^{r\_2} \= g^{m\_1\+m\_2} h^{r\_1\+r\_2} \= C(m\_1 \+ m\_2, r\_1 \+ r\_2\)
To open the above Pedersen commitment to a new message m\_1 \+ m\_2, the randomness r\_1 and r\_2 has to be added.
Similarly, the RSA\-based commitment mentioned above has a homomorphic property with respect to the multiplication operation. Given two messages m\_1 and m\_2 with randomness r\_1 and r\_2, respectively, one can compute: C(m\_1, r\_1\) \\cdot C(m\_2, r\_2\) \= C(m\_1 \\cdot m\_2, r\_1 \+ r\_2\). Formally:
C(m\_1, r\_1\) \\cdot C(m\_2, r\_2\) \= m\_1^{e} g\_{m}^{r\_1} \\cdot m\_2^{e} g\_{m}^{r\_2} \= (m\_1 \\cdot m\_2\)^{e} g\_{m}^{r\_1 \+ r\_2} \= C(m\_1 \\cdot m\_2, r\_1 \+ r\_2\).
To open the above commitment to a new message m\_1 \\cdot m\_2, the randomness r\_1 and r\_2 has to be added. This newly generated commitment is distributed similarly to a new commitment to m\_1 \\cdot m\_2.
Partial reveal
--------------
Some commitment schemes permit a proof to be given of only a portion of the committed value. In these schemes, the secret value X is a vector of many individually separable values.
X \= (x\_1, x\_2, ..., x\_n)
The commitment C is computed from X in the commit phase. Normally, in the reveal phase, the prover would reveal all of X and some additional proof data (such as R in [simple bit\-commitment](/wiki/%23Bit-commitment_in_the_random_oracle_model "#Bit-commitment in the random oracle model")). Instead, the prover is able to reveal any single value from the X vector, and create an efficient proof that it is the authentic ith element of the original vector that created the commitment C. The proof does not require any values of X other than x\_i to be revealed, and it is impossible to create valid proofs that reveal different values for any of the x\_i than the true one.{{cite book \|last1\=Catalano \|first1\=Dario \|last2\=Fiore \|first2\=Dario \|title\=Public\-Key Cryptography – PKC 2013 \|chapter\=Vector Commitments and Their Applications \|series\=Lecture Notes in Computer Science \|date\=2013 \|volume\=7778 \|pages\=55–72 \|doi\=10\.1007/978\-3\-642\-36362\-7\_5 \|chapter\-url\=https://link.springer.com/chapter/10\.1007/978\-3\-642\-36362\-7\_5 \|isbn\=978\-3\-642\-36362\-7 \|publisher\=Springer Berlin Heidelberg}} {{cite journal \|journal\=International Association for Cryptologic Research \|url\=https://www.iacr.org/archive/pkc2013/77780054/77780054\.pdf \|last1\=Catalano \|first1\=Dario \|last2\=Fiore \|first2\=Dario \|title\=Vector Commitments and Their Applications \|date\=2013}}
### Vector hashing
Vector hashing is a naive vector commitment partial reveal scheme based on bit\-commitment. Values m\_1, m\_2, ... m\_n are chosen randomly. Individual commitments are created by hashing y\_1\=H(x\_1\|\|m\_1\), y\_2\=H(x\_2\|\|m\_2\), .... The overall commitment is computed as
C\=H(y\_1\|\|y\_2\|\|...\|\|y\_n)
In order to prove one element of the vector X, the prover reveals the values
(i, y\_1, y\_2, ..., y\_{i\-1}, x\_i, m\_i, y\_{i\+1}, ..., y\_n)
The verifier is able to compute y\_i from x\_i and m\_i, and then is able to verify that the hash of all y values is the commitment C.
Unfortunately the proof is O(n) in size and verification time. Alternately, if C is the set of all y values, then the commitment is O(n) in size, and the proof is O(1\) in size and verification time. Either way, the commitment or the proof scales with O(n) which is not optimal.
### Merkle tree
A common example of a practical partial reveal scheme is a [Merkle tree](/wiki/Merkle_tree "Merkle tree"), in which a binary hash tree is created of the elements of X. This scheme creates commitments that are O(1\) in size, and proofs that are O(\\log\_2{n}) in size and verification time. The root hash of the tree is the commitment C. To prove that a revealed x\_i is part of the original tree, only \\log\_2{n} hash values from the tree, one from each level, must be revealed as the proof. The verifier is able to follow the path from the claimed leaf node all the way up to the root, hashing in the sibling nodes at each level, and eventually arriving at a root node value that must equal C.{{Cite web \|url\=http://www.emsec.rub.de/media/crypto/attachments/files/2011/04/becker\_1\.pdf \|title\=Merkle Signature Schemes, Merkle Trees and Their Cryptanalysis \|last\=Becker \|first\=Georg \|date\=2008\-07\-18 \|publisher\=Ruhr\-Universität Bochum \|page\=16 \|access\-date\=2013\-11\-20 \|archive\-date\=2014\-12\-22 \|archive\-url\=https://web.archive.org/web/20141222120036/http://www.emsec.rub.de/media/crypto/attachments/files/2011/04/becker\_1\.pdf \|url\-status\=dead }}
### KZG commitment
A Kate\-Zaverucha\-Goldberg commitment uses [pairing\-based cryptography](/wiki/Pairing-based_cryptography "Pairing-based cryptography") to build a partial reveal scheme with O(1\) commitment sizes, proof sizes, and proof verification time. In other words, as n, the number of values in X, increases, the commitments and proofs do not get larger, and the proofs do not take any more effort to verify.
A KZG commitment requires a predetermined set of parameters to create a [pairing](/wiki/Pairing "Pairing"), and a trusted trapdoor element. For example, a [Tate pairing](/wiki/Tate_pairing "Tate pairing") can be used. Assume that \\mathbb{G}\_1, \\mathbb{G}\_2 are the additive groups, and \\mathbb{G}\_T is the multiplicative group of the pairing. In other words, the pairing is the map e: \\mathbb{G}\_1 \\times \\mathbb{G}\_2 \\rightarrow \\mathbb{G}\_T. Let t \\in \\mathbb{F}\_p be the trapdoor element (if p is the prime order of \\mathbb{G}\_1 and \\mathbb{G}\_2), and let G and H be the generators of \\mathbb{G}\_1 and \\mathbb{G}\_2 respectively. As part of the parameter setup, we assume that G \\cdot t^i and H \\cdot t^i are known and shared values for arbitrarily many positive integer values of i, while the trapdoor value t itself is discarded and known to no one.
#### Commit
A KZG commitment reformulates the vector of values to be committed as a polynomial. First, we calculate a polynomial such that p(i)\=x\_i for all values of x\_i in our vector. [Lagrange interpolation](/wiki/Lagrange_interpolation "Lagrange interpolation") allows us to compute that polynomial
p(x)\=\\sum\_{i\=0}^{n\-1}x\_i\\prod\_{0\\leq j \< n, j\\neq i}\\frac{x\-j}{i\-j}
Under this formulation, the polynomial now encodes the vector, where p(0\)\=x\_0, p(1\)\=x\_1, .... Let p\_0, p\_1, ..., p\_{n\-1} be the coefficients of p, such that p(x)\=\\sum\_{i\=0}^{n\-1} p\_i x^i. The commitment is calculated as
C\=\\sum\_{i\=0}^{n\-1} p\_i G t^i
This is computed simply as a [dot product](/wiki/Dot_product "Dot product") between the predetermined values G \\cdot t^i and the polynomial coefficients p\_i. Since \\mathbb{G}\_1 is an additive group with associativity and commutativity, C is equal to simply G \\cdot p(t), since all the additions and multiplications with G can be distributed out of the evaluation. Since the trapdoor value t is unknown, the commitment C is essentially the polynomial evaluated at a number known to no one, with the outcome obfuscated into an opaque element of \\mathbb{G}\_1.
#### Reveal
A KZG proof must demonstrate that the revealed data is the authentic value of x\_i when C was computed. Let y\=x\_i, the revealed value we must prove. Since the vector of x\_i was reformulated into a polynomial, we really need to prove that the polynomial p, when evaluated at i, takes on the value y. Simply, we just need to prove that p(i)\=y. We will do this by demonstrating that subtracting y from p yields a root at i. Define the polynomial q as
q(x)\=\\frac{p(x)\-y}{x\-i}
This polynomial is itself the proof that p(i)\=y, because if q exists, then p(x)\-y is divisible by x\-i, meaning it has a root at i, so p(i)\-y\=0 (or, in other words, p(i)\=y). The KZG proof will demonstrate that q exists and has this property.
The prover computes q through the above polynomial division, then calculates the KZG proof value \\pi
\\pi\=\\sum\_{i\=0}^{n\-1} q\_i G t^i
This is equal to G \\cdot q(t), as above. In other words, the proof value is the polynomial q again evaluated at the trapdoor value t, hidden in the generator G of \\mathbb{G}\_1.
This computation is only possible if the above polynomials were evenly divisible, because in that case the quotient q is a polynomial, not a [rational function](/wiki/Rational_function "Rational function"). Due to the construction of the trapdoor, it is not possible to evaluate a rational function at the trapdoor value, only to evaluate a polynomial using linear combinations of the precomputed known constants of G \\cdot t^i. This is why it is impossible to create a proof for an incorrect value of x\_i.
#### Verify
To verify the proof, the bilinear map of the [pairing](/wiki/Pairing "Pairing") is used to show that the proof value \\pi summarizes a real polynomial q that demonstrates the desired property, which is that p(x)\-y was evenly divided by x\-i. The verification computation checks the equality
e(\\pi, H \\cdot t \- H \\cdot i)\\ \\stackrel{?}{\=}\\ e(C \- G \\cdot y, H)
where e is the bilinear map function as above. H \\cdot t is a precomputed constant, H \\cdot i is computed based on i.
By rewriting the computation in the pairing group \\mathbb{G}\_T, substituting in \\pi\=q(t) \\cdot G and C\=p(t) \\cdot G, and letting \\tau(x)\=e(G,H)^x be a helper function for lifting into the pairing group, the proof verification is more clear.
e(\\pi, H \\cdot t \- H \\cdot i) \= e(C \- G \\cdot y, H)
e(G \\cdot q(t), H \\cdot t \- H \\cdot i) \= e(G \\cdot p(t) \- G \\cdot y, H)
e(G \\cdot q(t), H \\cdot (t\-i)) \= e(G \\cdot (p(t) \- y), H)
e(G, H)^{q(t)\\cdot(t\-i)} \= e(G, H)^{p(t) \- y}
\\tau(q(t) \\cdot (t\-i)) \= \\tau(p(t)\-y)
Assuming that the bilinear map is validly constructed, this demonstrates that q(x)(x\-i) \= p(x)\-y, without the validator knowing what p or q are. The validator can be assured of this because if \\tau(q(t) \\cdot (t\-i)) \= \\tau(p(t)\-y), then the polynomials evaluate to the same output at the trapdoor value x\=t. This demonstrates the polynomials are identical, because, if the parameters were validly constructed, the trapdoor value is known to no one, meaning that engineering a polynomial to have a specific value at the trapdoor is impossible (according to the [Schwartz–Zippel lemma](/wiki/Schwartz%E2%80%93Zippel_lemma "Schwartz–Zippel lemma")). If q(x)(x\-i) \= p(x)\-y is now verified to be true, then q is verified to exist, therefore p(x)\-y must be polynomial\-divisible by (x\-i), so p(i)\-y\=0 due to the [factor theorem](/wiki/Factor_theorem "Factor theorem"). This proves that the ith value of the committed vector must have equaled y, since that is the output of evaluating the committed polynomial at i.
{{hidden
\| Why the bilinear map pairing is used \|
The utility of the bilinear map pairing is to allow the multiplication of q(x) by x\-i to happen securely. These values truly lie in \\mathbb{G}\_1, where division is assumed to be computationally hard. For example, \\mathbb{G}\_1 might be an \[\[elliptic curve]] over a finite field, as is common in \[\[elliptic\-curve cryptography]]. Then, the division assumption is called the \[\[Elliptic\-curve cryptography\#Rationale\|elliptic curve discrete logarithm problem]]{{Broken anchor\|date\=2024\-07\-20\|bot\=User:Cewbot/log/20201008/configuration\|target\_link\=Elliptic\-curve cryptography\#Rationale\|reason\= The anchor (Rationale) \[\[Special:Diff/1148439344\|has been deleted]].}}, and this assumption is also what guards the trapdoor value from being computed, making it also a foundation of KZG commitments. In that case, we want to check if q(x)(x\-i) \= p(x)\-y. This cannot be done without a pairing, because with values on the curve of G \\cdot q(x) and G \\cdot (x\-i), we cannot compute G \\cdot (q(x)(x\-i)). That would violate the \[\[computational Diffie–Hellman assumption]], a foundational assumption in \[\[elliptic\-curve cryptography]]. We instead use a \[\[pairing]] to sidestep this problem. q(x) is still multiplied by G to get G \\cdot q(x), but the other side of the multiplication is done in the paired group \\mathbb{G}\_2, so, H \\cdot (t\-i). We compute e(G \\cdot q(t), H \\cdot (t\-i)), which, due to the \[\[bilinear map\|bilinearity]] of the map, is equal to e(G, H)^{q(t)\\cdot(t\-i)}. In this output group \\mathbb{G}\_T we still have the \[\[Discrete logarithm\#Cryptography\|discrete logarithm problem]], so even though we know that value and e(G, H), we cannot extract the exponent q(t)\\cdot(t\-i), preventing any contradiction with discrete logarithm earlier. This value can be compared to e(G \\cdot (p(t) \- y), H)\=e(G, H)^{p(t) \- y} though, and if e(G, H)^{q(t)\\cdot(t\-i)} \= e(G, H)^{p(t) \- y} we are able to conclude that q(t) \\cdot (t\-i) \= p(t)\-y, without ever knowing what the actual value of t is, let alone q(t)(t\-i).
\|style \= border: 1px solid lightgray;
\|headerstyle \= text\-align:left
}}
Additionally, a KZG commitment can be extended to prove the values of any arbitrary k values of X (not just one value), with the proof size remaining O(1\), but the proof verification time scales with O(k). The proof is the same, but instead of subtracting a constant y, we subtract a polynomial that causes multiple roots, at all the locations we want to prove, and instead of dividing by x\-i we divide by \\prod\_i x\-i for those same locations.{{cite journal \|last1\=Kate \|first1\=Aniket \|last2\=Zaverucha \|first2\=Gregory \|last3\=Goldberg \|first3\=Ian \|title\=Constant\-size commitments to polynomials and their applications. \|journal\=International Conference on the Theory and Application of Cryptology and Information Security \|date\=2010 \|url\=https://www.iacr.org/archive/asiacrypt2010/6477178/6477178\.pdf}}
Quantum bit commitment
----------------------
It is an interesting question in [quantum cryptography](/wiki/Quantum_cryptography "Quantum cryptography") if unconditionally secure'' bit commitment protocols exist on the quantum level, that is, protocols which are (at least asymptotically) binding and concealing even if there are no restrictions on the computational resources. One could hope that there might be a way to exploit the intrinsic properties of [quantum mechanics](/wiki/Quantum_mechanics "Quantum mechanics"), as in the protocols for [unconditionally secure key distribution](/wiki/Quantum_key_distribution "Quantum key distribution").
However, this is impossible, as Dominic Mayers showed in 1996 (seeBrassard, Crépeau, Mayers, Salvail: [A brief review on the impossibility of quantum bit commitment](https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9712023) for the original proof). Any such protocol can be reduced to a protocol where the system is in one of two pure states after the commitment phase, depending on the bit Alice wants to commit. If the protocol is unconditionally concealing, then Alice can unitarily transform these states into each other using the properties of the [Schmidt decomposition](/wiki/Schmidt_decomposition "Schmidt decomposition"), effectively defeating the binding property.
One subtle assumption of the proof is that the commit phase must be finished at some point in time. This leaves room for protocols that require a continuing information flow until the bit is unveiled or the protocol is cancelled, in which case it is not binding anymore.A. Kent: [Secure classical Bit Commitment using Fixed Capacity Communication Channels](https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9906103) More generally, Mayers' proof applies only to protocols that exploit [quantum physics](/wiki/Quantum_physics "Quantum physics") but not [special relativity](/wiki/Special_relativity "Special relativity"). Kent has shown that there exist unconditionally secure protocols for bit commitment that exploit the principle of [special relativity](/wiki/Special_relativity "Special relativity") stating that information cannot travel faster than light.{{Cite journal\|last\=Kent\|first\=A.\|date\= 1999\|title\=Unconditionally Secure Bit Commitment\|journal\=Phys. Rev. Lett.\|language\=en\|volume\=83\|issue\=7\|pages\=1447–1450\|doi\=10\.1103/PhysRevLett.83\.1447\|arxiv\=quant\-ph/9810068\|bibcode\=1999PhRvL..83\.1447K\|s2cid\=8823466}}
|
[
"Construction\n------------",
"A commitment scheme can either be perfectly binding (it is impossible for Alice to alter her commitment after she has made it, even if she has unbounded computational resources); or perfectly concealing (it is impossible for Bob to find out the commitment without Alice revealing it, even if he has unbounded computational resources); or formulated as an instance\\-dependent commitment scheme, which is either hiding or binding depending on the solution to another problem.Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (1990\\). Perfect zero knowledge in constant round, In Proc. STOC, p. 482–493, cited in Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (2008\\). An Equivalence between Zero Knowledge and Commitments, Theory of Cryptography.Toshiya Itoh, Yiji Ohta, Hiroki Shizuya (1997\\). A language dependent cryptographic primitive, In J. Cryptol., 10(1\\):37\\-49, cited in Shien Hin Ong and Salil Vadhan (2008\\). An Equivalence between Zero Knowledge and Commitments, Theory of Cryptography. A commitment scheme cannot be both perfectly hiding and perfectly binding at the same time.",
"### Bit\\-commitment in the random oracle model",
"Bit\\-commitment schemes are trivial to construct in the [random oracle](/wiki/Random_oracle \"Random oracle\") model. Given a [hash function](/wiki/Cryptographic_hash_function \"Cryptographic hash function\") H with a 3*k* bit output, to commit the *k*\\-bit message *m*, Alice generates a random *k* bit string *R* and sends Bob H(*R* \\|\\| *m*). The probability that any *R′*, *m′* exist where *m′* ≠ *m* such that H(*R′* \\|\\| *m′*) \\= H(*R* \\|\\| *m*) is ≈ 2−*k*, but to test any guess at the message *m* Bob will need to make 2*k* (for an incorrect guess) or 2*k*\\-1 (on average, for a correct guess) queries to the random oracle.{{Citation\n\\| last \\= Wagner\n\\| first \\= David\n\\| year \\= 2006\n\\| title \\= Midterm Solution\n\\| page \\= 2\n\\| url \\= http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/\\~daw/teaching/cs276\\-s06/mtsol.ps\n\\| access\\-date \\= 26 October 2015\n}} We note that earlier schemes based on hash functions, essentially can be thought of schemes based on idealization of these hash functions as random oracle.",
"### Bit\\-commitment from any one\\-way permutation",
"One can create a bit\\-commitment scheme from any [one\\-way function](/wiki/One-way_function \"One-way function\") that is [injective](/wiki/Injective_function \"Injective function\"). The scheme relies on the fact that every one\\-way function can be modified (via the [Goldreich\\-Levin theorem](/wiki/Goldreich-Levin_theorem \"Goldreich-Levin theorem\")) to possess a computationally [hard\\-core predicate](/wiki/Hard-core_predicate \"Hard-core predicate\") (while retaining the injective property).",
"Let *f* be an injective one\\-way function, with *h* a hard\\-core predicate. Then to commit to a bit *b* Alice picks a random input *x* and sends the triple\n(h,f(x),b \\\\oplus h(x))\nto Bob, where \\\\oplus denotes XOR, *i.e.*, bitwise addition modulo 2\\. To decommit, Alice simply sends *x* to Bob. Bob verifies by computing *f*(*x*) and comparing to the committed value. This scheme is concealing because for Bob to recover *b* he must recover *h*(*x*). Since *h* is a computationally hard\\-core predicate, recovering *h*(*x*) from *f*(*x*) with probability greater than one\\-half is as hard as inverting *f*. Perfect binding follows from the fact that *f* is injective and thus *f*(*x*) has exactly one preimage.",
"### Bit\\-commitment from a pseudo\\-random generator",
"Note that since we do not know how to construct a one\\-way permutation from any one\\-way function, this section reduces the strength of the cryptographic assumption necessary to construct a bit\\-commitment protocol.",
"In 1991 Moni Naor showed how to create a bit\\-commitment scheme from a [cryptographically secure pseudorandom number generator](/wiki/Cryptographically_secure_pseudorandom_number_generator \"Cryptographically secure pseudorandom number generator\").{{cite web\\|url\\=http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/context/22544/0 \\|title\\=Citations: Bit Commitment using Pseudorandom Generators \\- Naor (ResearchIndex) \\|publisher\\=Citeseer.ist.psu.edu \\|access\\-date\\=2014\\-06\\-07 \\|url\\-access\\=registration}} The construction is as follows. If *G* is a pseudo\\-random generator such that *G* takes *n* bits to 3*n* bits, then if Alice wants to commit to a bit *b*:",
"* Bob selects a random 3*n*\\-bit vector *R* and sends *R* to Alice.\n* Alice selects a random *n*\\-bit vector *Y* and computes the 3*n*\\-bit vector *G*(*Y*).\n* If *b*\\=1 Alice sends *G*(*Y*) to Bob, otherwise she sends the bitwise [exclusive\\-or](/wiki/Exclusive_disjunction \"Exclusive disjunction\") of *G*(*Y*) and *R* to Bob.",
"To decommit Alice sends *Y* to Bob, who can then check whether he initially received *G*(*Y*) or *G*(*Y*) \\\\oplus *R*.",
"This scheme is statistically binding, meaning that even if Alice is computationally unbounded she cannot cheat with probability greater than 2−*n*. For Alice to cheat, she would need to find a *Y'*, such that *G*(*Y'*) \\= *G*(*Y*) \\\\oplus *R*. If she could find such a value, she could decommit by sending the truth and *Y*, or send the opposite answer and *Y'*. However, *G*(*Y*) and *G*(*Y''') are only able to produce 2*n* possible values each (that's 22*n*) while* R *is picked out of 23*n* values. She does not pick* R*, so there is a 22*n*/23*n* \\= 2−*n* probability that a* Y' *satisfying the equation required to cheat will exist.*",
"The concealing property follows from a standard reduction, if Bob can tell whether Alice committed to a zero or one, he can also distinguish the output of the pseudo\\-random generator G *from true\\-random, which contradicts the cryptographic security of* G*.*",
"### A perfectly binding scheme based on the discrete log problem and beyond",
"Alice chooses a [ring](/wiki/Ring_%28mathematics%29 \"Ring (mathematics)\") of prime order p*, with multiplicative generator* g*.*",
"Alice randomly picks a secret value x *from* 0 *to* p*− 1 to commit to and calculates* c *\\=* g**x* and publishes* c*. The [discrete logarithm problem](/wiki/Discrete_logarithm_problem \"Discrete logarithm problem\") dictates that from* c*, it is computationally infeasible to compute* x*, so under this assumption, Bob cannot compute* x*. On the other hand, Alice cannot compute a* x{{prime}} *\\<\\>* x*, such that* g**x{{prime}}* \\=* c*, so the scheme is binding.*",
"This scheme isn't perfectly concealing as someone could find the commitment if he manages to solve the [discrete logarithm problem](/wiki/Discrete_logarithm_problem \"Discrete logarithm problem\"). In fact, this scheme isn't hiding at all with respect to the standard hiding game, where an adversary should be unable to guess which of two messages he chose were committed to \\- similar to the [IND\\-CPA](/wiki/IND-CPA \"IND-CPA\") game. One consequence of this is that if the space of possible values of x *is small, then an attacker could simply try them all and the commitment would not be hiding.*",
"A better example of a perfectly binding commitment scheme is one where the commitment is the encryption of x *under a [semantically secure](/wiki/Semantically_secure \"Semantically secure\"), public\\-key encryption scheme with perfect completeness, and the decommitment is the string of random bits used to encrypt* x*. An example of an information\\-theoretically hiding commitment scheme is the Pedersen commitment scheme,{{cite book \\| last\\=Pedersen \\| first\\=Torben Pryds \\| title\\=Advances in Cryptology – CRYPTO '91 \\| chapter\\=Non\\-Interactive and Information\\-Theoretic Secure Verifiable Secret Sharing \\| series\\=Lecture Notes in Computer Science \\| date\\=1992 \\| volume\\=576 \\| publisher\\=Springer Berlin Heidelberg \\| publication\\-place\\=Berlin, Heidelberg \\| isbn\\=978\\-3\\-540\\-55188\\-1 \\| doi\\=10\\.1007/3\\-540\\-46766\\-1\\_9 \\| pages\\=129–140}} which is computationally binding under the discrete logarithm assumption.\n{{cite conference \n\\| title \\= Automated cryptographic analysis of the pedersen commitment scheme\n\\| last1 \\= Metere\n\\| first1 \\= Roberto \n\\| last2 \\= Dong\n\\| first2 \\= Changyu\n\\| date \\= 2017\n\\| publisher \\= Springer\n\\| book\\-title \\= International Conference on Mathematical Methods, Models, and Architectures for Computer Network Security\n\\| pages \\= 275–287\n}}\nAdditionally to the scheme above, it uses another generator* h *of the prime group and a random number* r*. The commitment is set c\\=g^x h^r.{{cite journal \\|last1\\=Tang \\|first1\\=Chunming \\|last2\\=Pei \\|first2\\=Dingyi \\|last3\\=Liu \\|first3\\=Zhuojun \\|last4\\=He \\|first4\\=Yong \\|title\\=Pedersen: Non\\-interactive and information\\-theoretic secure verifiable secret sharing \\|url\\=https://eprint.iacr.org/2004/201\\.pdf \\|website\\=Cryptology ePrint Archive \\|publisher\\=Advances in Cryptology CRYPTO 1991 Springer \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20170811001441/https://eprint.iacr.org/2004/201\\.pdf \\|archive\\-date\\=11 August 2017 \\|url\\-status\\=dead \\|language\\=en \\|date\\=16 August 2004 \\|access\\-date\\=2 February 2019 }}*",
"These constructions are tightly related to and based on the algebraic properties of the underlying groups, and the notion originally seemed to be very much related to the algebra. However, it was shown that basing statistically binding commitment schemes on general unstructured assumption is possible, via the notion of interactive hashing \nfor commitments from general complexity assumptions (specifically and originally, based on any one way permutation) as in.Moni Naor, Rafail Ostrovsky, Ramarathnam Venkatesan, Moti Yung:\nPerfect Zero\\-Knowledge Arguments for NP Using Any One\\-Way Permutation. J. Cryptology 11(2\\): 87–108 (1998\\)[https://link.springer.com/article/10\\.1007%2Fs001459900037](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs001459900037)\n### A perfectly hiding commitment scheme based on RSA",
"Alice selects N such that N \\= p \\\\cdot q, where p and q are large secret prime numbers. Additionally, she selects a prime e such that e \\> N^2 and gcd(e, \\\\phi(N^2\\)) \\= 1. Alice then computes a public number g\\_m as an element of maximum order in the \\\\Z^\\*\\_{N^2} group.{{cite book\n\\|last1\\= Menezes \\|first1\\= Alfred J\n\\|last2\\= Van Oorschot\\|first2\\= Paul C\n\\|last3\\= Vanstone \\|first3\\= Scott A\n\\|date\\= 2018\n\\|title\\= Handbook of applied cryptography\n\\|publisher\\= CRC press}} Finally, Alice commits to her secret m by first generating a random number r from \\\\Z^\\*\\_{N^2} and then by computing c\\=m^e g\\_{m}^{r}.\nThe security of the above commitment relies on the hardness of the RSA problem and has perfect hiding and computational binding.{{cite journal \n\\|last1\\=Mouris \\|first1\\=Dimitris \n\\|last2\\=Tsoutsos \\|first2\\=Nektarios Georgios \n\\|title\\=Masquerade: Verifiable Multi\\-Party Aggregation with Secure Multiplicative Commitments\n\\|url\\=https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/1370\\.pdf \n\\|website\\=Cryptology ePrint Archive \n\\|language\\=en \n\\|date\\=26 January 2022\n}}\n### Additive and multiplicative homomorphic properties of commitments",
"The Pedersen commitment scheme introduces an interesting homomorphic property that allows performing addition between two commitments. More specifically, given two messages m\\_1 and m\\_2 and randomness r\\_1 and r\\_2, respectively, it is possible to generate a new commitment such that: C(m\\_1, r\\_1\\) \\\\cdot C(m\\_2, r\\_2\\) \\= C(m\\_1 \\+ m\\_2, r\\_1 \\+ r\\_2\\). Formally:\nC(m\\_1, r\\_1\\) \\\\cdot C(m\\_2, r\\_2\\) \\= g^{m\\_1} h^{r\\_1} \\\\cdot g^{m\\_2} h^{r\\_2} \\= g^{m\\_1\\+m\\_2} h^{r\\_1\\+r\\_2} \\= C(m\\_1 \\+ m\\_2, r\\_1 \\+ r\\_2\\)\nTo open the above Pedersen commitment to a new message m\\_1 \\+ m\\_2, the randomness r\\_1 and r\\_2 has to be added.\nSimilarly, the RSA\\-based commitment mentioned above has a homomorphic property with respect to the multiplication operation. Given two messages m\\_1 and m\\_2 with randomness r\\_1 and r\\_2, respectively, one can compute: C(m\\_1, r\\_1\\) \\\\cdot C(m\\_2, r\\_2\\) \\= C(m\\_1 \\\\cdot m\\_2, r\\_1 \\+ r\\_2\\). Formally:\nC(m\\_1, r\\_1\\) \\\\cdot C(m\\_2, r\\_2\\) \\= m\\_1^{e} g\\_{m}^{r\\_1} \\\\cdot m\\_2^{e} g\\_{m}^{r\\_2} \\= (m\\_1 \\\\cdot m\\_2\\)^{e} g\\_{m}^{r\\_1 \\+ r\\_2} \\= C(m\\_1 \\\\cdot m\\_2, r\\_1 \\+ r\\_2\\).\nTo open the above commitment to a new message m\\_1 \\\\cdot m\\_2, the randomness r\\_1 and r\\_2 has to be added. This newly generated commitment is distributed similarly to a new commitment to m\\_1 \\\\cdot m\\_2.\nPartial reveal\n--------------",
"Some commitment schemes permit a proof to be given of only a portion of the committed value. In these schemes, the secret value X is a vector of many individually separable values.\nX \\= (x\\_1, x\\_2, ..., x\\_n)\nThe commitment C is computed from X in the commit phase. Normally, in the reveal phase, the prover would reveal all of X and some additional proof data (such as R in [simple bit\\-commitment](/wiki/%23Bit-commitment_in_the_random_oracle_model \"#Bit-commitment in the random oracle model\")). Instead, the prover is able to reveal any single value from the X vector, and create an efficient proof that it is the authentic ith element of the original vector that created the commitment C. The proof does not require any values of X other than x\\_i to be revealed, and it is impossible to create valid proofs that reveal different values for any of the x\\_i than the true one.{{cite book \\|last1\\=Catalano \\|first1\\=Dario \\|last2\\=Fiore \\|first2\\=Dario \\|title\\=Public\\-Key Cryptography – PKC 2013 \\|chapter\\=Vector Commitments and Their Applications \\|series\\=Lecture Notes in Computer Science \\|date\\=2013 \\|volume\\=7778 \\|pages\\=55–72 \\|doi\\=10\\.1007/978\\-3\\-642\\-36362\\-7\\_5 \\|chapter\\-url\\=https://link.springer.com/chapter/10\\.1007/978\\-3\\-642\\-36362\\-7\\_5 \\|isbn\\=978\\-3\\-642\\-36362\\-7 \\|publisher\\=Springer Berlin Heidelberg}} {{cite journal \\|journal\\=International Association for Cryptologic Research \\|url\\=https://www.iacr.org/archive/pkc2013/77780054/77780054\\.pdf \\|last1\\=Catalano \\|first1\\=Dario \\|last2\\=Fiore \\|first2\\=Dario \\|title\\=Vector Commitments and Their Applications \\|date\\=2013}}\n### Vector hashing",
"Vector hashing is a naive vector commitment partial reveal scheme based on bit\\-commitment. Values m\\_1, m\\_2, ... m\\_n are chosen randomly. Individual commitments are created by hashing y\\_1\\=H(x\\_1\\|\\|m\\_1\\), y\\_2\\=H(x\\_2\\|\\|m\\_2\\), .... The overall commitment is computed as\nC\\=H(y\\_1\\|\\|y\\_2\\|\\|...\\|\\|y\\_n)\nIn order to prove one element of the vector X, the prover reveals the values\n(i, y\\_1, y\\_2, ..., y\\_{i\\-1}, x\\_i, m\\_i, y\\_{i\\+1}, ..., y\\_n)\nThe verifier is able to compute y\\_i from x\\_i and m\\_i, and then is able to verify that the hash of all y values is the commitment C. \nUnfortunately the proof is O(n) in size and verification time. Alternately, if C is the set of all y values, then the commitment is O(n) in size, and the proof is O(1\\) in size and verification time. Either way, the commitment or the proof scales with O(n) which is not optimal.\n### Merkle tree",
"A common example of a practical partial reveal scheme is a [Merkle tree](/wiki/Merkle_tree \"Merkle tree\"), in which a binary hash tree is created of the elements of X. This scheme creates commitments that are O(1\\) in size, and proofs that are O(\\\\log\\_2{n}) in size and verification time. The root hash of the tree is the commitment C. To prove that a revealed x\\_i is part of the original tree, only \\\\log\\_2{n} hash values from the tree, one from each level, must be revealed as the proof. The verifier is able to follow the path from the claimed leaf node all the way up to the root, hashing in the sibling nodes at each level, and eventually arriving at a root node value that must equal C.{{Cite web \\|url\\=http://www.emsec.rub.de/media/crypto/attachments/files/2011/04/becker\\_1\\.pdf \\|title\\=Merkle Signature Schemes, Merkle Trees and Their Cryptanalysis \\|last\\=Becker \\|first\\=Georg \\|date\\=2008\\-07\\-18 \\|publisher\\=Ruhr\\-Universität Bochum \\|page\\=16 \\|access\\-date\\=2013\\-11\\-20 \\|archive\\-date\\=2014\\-12\\-22 \\|archive\\-url\\=https://web.archive.org/web/20141222120036/http://www.emsec.rub.de/media/crypto/attachments/files/2011/04/becker\\_1\\.pdf \\|url\\-status\\=dead }}\n### KZG commitment",
"A Kate\\-Zaverucha\\-Goldberg commitment uses [pairing\\-based cryptography](/wiki/Pairing-based_cryptography \"Pairing-based cryptography\") to build a partial reveal scheme with O(1\\) commitment sizes, proof sizes, and proof verification time. In other words, as n, the number of values in X, increases, the commitments and proofs do not get larger, and the proofs do not take any more effort to verify.\nA KZG commitment requires a predetermined set of parameters to create a [pairing](/wiki/Pairing \"Pairing\"), and a trusted trapdoor element. For example, a [Tate pairing](/wiki/Tate_pairing \"Tate pairing\") can be used. Assume that \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1, \\\\mathbb{G}\\_2 are the additive groups, and \\\\mathbb{G}\\_T is the multiplicative group of the pairing. In other words, the pairing is the map e: \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1 \\\\times \\\\mathbb{G}\\_2 \\\\rightarrow \\\\mathbb{G}\\_T. Let t \\\\in \\\\mathbb{F}\\_p be the trapdoor element (if p is the prime order of \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1 and \\\\mathbb{G}\\_2), and let G and H be the generators of \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1 and \\\\mathbb{G}\\_2 respectively. As part of the parameter setup, we assume that G \\\\cdot t^i and H \\\\cdot t^i are known and shared values for arbitrarily many positive integer values of i, while the trapdoor value t itself is discarded and known to no one.\n#### Commit",
"A KZG commitment reformulates the vector of values to be committed as a polynomial. First, we calculate a polynomial such that p(i)\\=x\\_i for all values of x\\_i in our vector. [Lagrange interpolation](/wiki/Lagrange_interpolation \"Lagrange interpolation\") allows us to compute that polynomial\np(x)\\=\\\\sum\\_{i\\=0}^{n\\-1}x\\_i\\\\prod\\_{0\\\\leq j \\< n, j\\\\neq i}\\\\frac{x\\-j}{i\\-j}\nUnder this formulation, the polynomial now encodes the vector, where p(0\\)\\=x\\_0, p(1\\)\\=x\\_1, .... Let p\\_0, p\\_1, ..., p\\_{n\\-1} be the coefficients of p, such that p(x)\\=\\\\sum\\_{i\\=0}^{n\\-1} p\\_i x^i. The commitment is calculated as\nC\\=\\\\sum\\_{i\\=0}^{n\\-1} p\\_i G t^i\nThis is computed simply as a [dot product](/wiki/Dot_product \"Dot product\") between the predetermined values G \\\\cdot t^i and the polynomial coefficients p\\_i. Since \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1 is an additive group with associativity and commutativity, C is equal to simply G \\\\cdot p(t), since all the additions and multiplications with G can be distributed out of the evaluation. Since the trapdoor value t is unknown, the commitment C is essentially the polynomial evaluated at a number known to no one, with the outcome obfuscated into an opaque element of \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1.\n#### Reveal",
"A KZG proof must demonstrate that the revealed data is the authentic value of x\\_i when C was computed. Let y\\=x\\_i, the revealed value we must prove. Since the vector of x\\_i was reformulated into a polynomial, we really need to prove that the polynomial p, when evaluated at i, takes on the value y. Simply, we just need to prove that p(i)\\=y. We will do this by demonstrating that subtracting y from p yields a root at i. Define the polynomial q as\nq(x)\\=\\\\frac{p(x)\\-y}{x\\-i}\nThis polynomial is itself the proof that p(i)\\=y, because if q exists, then p(x)\\-y is divisible by x\\-i, meaning it has a root at i, so p(i)\\-y\\=0 (or, in other words, p(i)\\=y). The KZG proof will demonstrate that q exists and has this property.\nThe prover computes q through the above polynomial division, then calculates the KZG proof value \\\\pi\n\\\\pi\\=\\\\sum\\_{i\\=0}^{n\\-1} q\\_i G t^i\nThis is equal to G \\\\cdot q(t), as above. In other words, the proof value is the polynomial q again evaluated at the trapdoor value t, hidden in the generator G of \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1.\nThis computation is only possible if the above polynomials were evenly divisible, because in that case the quotient q is a polynomial, not a [rational function](/wiki/Rational_function \"Rational function\"). Due to the construction of the trapdoor, it is not possible to evaluate a rational function at the trapdoor value, only to evaluate a polynomial using linear combinations of the precomputed known constants of G \\\\cdot t^i. This is why it is impossible to create a proof for an incorrect value of x\\_i.\n#### Verify",
"To verify the proof, the bilinear map of the [pairing](/wiki/Pairing \"Pairing\") is used to show that the proof value \\\\pi summarizes a real polynomial q that demonstrates the desired property, which is that p(x)\\-y was evenly divided by x\\-i. The verification computation checks the equality\ne(\\\\pi, H \\\\cdot t \\- H \\\\cdot i)\\\\ \\\\stackrel{?}{\\=}\\\\ e(C \\- G \\\\cdot y, H)\nwhere e is the bilinear map function as above. H \\\\cdot t is a precomputed constant, H \\\\cdot i is computed based on i.\nBy rewriting the computation in the pairing group \\\\mathbb{G}\\_T, substituting in \\\\pi\\=q(t) \\\\cdot G and C\\=p(t) \\\\cdot G, and letting \\\\tau(x)\\=e(G,H)^x be a helper function for lifting into the pairing group, the proof verification is more clear.\ne(\\\\pi, H \\\\cdot t \\- H \\\\cdot i) \\= e(C \\- G \\\\cdot y, H)\ne(G \\\\cdot q(t), H \\\\cdot t \\- H \\\\cdot i) \\= e(G \\\\cdot p(t) \\- G \\\\cdot y, H)\ne(G \\\\cdot q(t), H \\\\cdot (t\\-i)) \\= e(G \\\\cdot (p(t) \\- y), H)\ne(G, H)^{q(t)\\\\cdot(t\\-i)} \\= e(G, H)^{p(t) \\- y}\n\\\\tau(q(t) \\\\cdot (t\\-i)) \\= \\\\tau(p(t)\\-y)\nAssuming that the bilinear map is validly constructed, this demonstrates that q(x)(x\\-i) \\= p(x)\\-y, without the validator knowing what p or q are. The validator can be assured of this because if \\\\tau(q(t) \\\\cdot (t\\-i)) \\= \\\\tau(p(t)\\-y), then the polynomials evaluate to the same output at the trapdoor value x\\=t. This demonstrates the polynomials are identical, because, if the parameters were validly constructed, the trapdoor value is known to no one, meaning that engineering a polynomial to have a specific value at the trapdoor is impossible (according to the [Schwartz–Zippel lemma](/wiki/Schwartz%E2%80%93Zippel_lemma \"Schwartz–Zippel lemma\")). If q(x)(x\\-i) \\= p(x)\\-y is now verified to be true, then q is verified to exist, therefore p(x)\\-y must be polynomial\\-divisible by (x\\-i), so p(i)\\-y\\=0 due to the [factor theorem](/wiki/Factor_theorem \"Factor theorem\"). This proves that the ith value of the committed vector must have equaled y, since that is the output of evaluating the committed polynomial at i.\n{{hidden\n\\| Why the bilinear map pairing is used \\|\nThe utility of the bilinear map pairing is to allow the multiplication of q(x) by x\\-i to happen securely. These values truly lie in \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1, where division is assumed to be computationally hard. For example, \\\\mathbb{G}\\_1 might be an \\[\\[elliptic curve]] over a finite field, as is common in \\[\\[elliptic\\-curve cryptography]]. Then, the division assumption is called the \\[\\[Elliptic\\-curve cryptography\\#Rationale\\|elliptic curve discrete logarithm problem]]{{Broken anchor\\|date\\=2024\\-07\\-20\\|bot\\=User:Cewbot/log/20201008/configuration\\|target\\_link\\=Elliptic\\-curve cryptography\\#Rationale\\|reason\\= The anchor (Rationale) \\[\\[Special:Diff/1148439344\\|has been deleted]].}}, and this assumption is also what guards the trapdoor value from being computed, making it also a foundation of KZG commitments. In that case, we want to check if q(x)(x\\-i) \\= p(x)\\-y. This cannot be done without a pairing, because with values on the curve of G \\\\cdot q(x) and G \\\\cdot (x\\-i), we cannot compute G \\\\cdot (q(x)(x\\-i)). That would violate the \\[\\[computational Diffie–Hellman assumption]], a foundational assumption in \\[\\[elliptic\\-curve cryptography]]. We instead use a \\[\\[pairing]] to sidestep this problem. q(x) is still multiplied by G to get G \\\\cdot q(x), but the other side of the multiplication is done in the paired group \\\\mathbb{G}\\_2, so, H \\\\cdot (t\\-i). We compute e(G \\\\cdot q(t), H \\\\cdot (t\\-i)), which, due to the \\[\\[bilinear map\\|bilinearity]] of the map, is equal to e(G, H)^{q(t)\\\\cdot(t\\-i)}. In this output group \\\\mathbb{G}\\_T we still have the \\[\\[Discrete logarithm\\#Cryptography\\|discrete logarithm problem]], so even though we know that value and e(G, H), we cannot extract the exponent q(t)\\\\cdot(t\\-i), preventing any contradiction with discrete logarithm earlier. This value can be compared to e(G \\\\cdot (p(t) \\- y), H)\\=e(G, H)^{p(t) \\- y} though, and if e(G, H)^{q(t)\\\\cdot(t\\-i)} \\= e(G, H)^{p(t) \\- y} we are able to conclude that q(t) \\\\cdot (t\\-i) \\= p(t)\\-y, without ever knowing what the actual value of t is, let alone q(t)(t\\-i).\n\\|style \\= border: 1px solid lightgray; \n\\|headerstyle \\= text\\-align:left\n}}\nAdditionally, a KZG commitment can be extended to prove the values of any arbitrary k values of X (not just one value), with the proof size remaining O(1\\), but the proof verification time scales with O(k). The proof is the same, but instead of subtracting a constant y, we subtract a polynomial that causes multiple roots, at all the locations we want to prove, and instead of dividing by x\\-i we divide by \\\\prod\\_i x\\-i for those same locations.{{cite journal \\|last1\\=Kate \\|first1\\=Aniket \\|last2\\=Zaverucha \\|first2\\=Gregory \\|last3\\=Goldberg \\|first3\\=Ian \\|title\\=Constant\\-size commitments to polynomials and their applications. \\|journal\\=International Conference on the Theory and Application of Cryptology and Information Security \\|date\\=2010 \\|url\\=https://www.iacr.org/archive/asiacrypt2010/6477178/6477178\\.pdf}}\nQuantum bit commitment\n----------------------",
"It is an interesting question in [quantum cryptography](/wiki/Quantum_cryptography \"Quantum cryptography\") if unconditionally secure'' bit commitment protocols exist on the quantum level, that is, protocols which are (at least asymptotically) binding and concealing even if there are no restrictions on the computational resources. One could hope that there might be a way to exploit the intrinsic properties of [quantum mechanics](/wiki/Quantum_mechanics \"Quantum mechanics\"), as in the protocols for [unconditionally secure key distribution](/wiki/Quantum_key_distribution \"Quantum key distribution\").\nHowever, this is impossible, as Dominic Mayers showed in 1996 (seeBrassard, Crépeau, Mayers, Salvail: [A brief review on the impossibility of quantum bit commitment](https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9712023) for the original proof). Any such protocol can be reduced to a protocol where the system is in one of two pure states after the commitment phase, depending on the bit Alice wants to commit. If the protocol is unconditionally concealing, then Alice can unitarily transform these states into each other using the properties of the [Schmidt decomposition](/wiki/Schmidt_decomposition \"Schmidt decomposition\"), effectively defeating the binding property.",
"One subtle assumption of the proof is that the commit phase must be finished at some point in time. This leaves room for protocols that require a continuing information flow until the bit is unveiled or the protocol is cancelled, in which case it is not binding anymore.A. Kent: [Secure classical Bit Commitment using Fixed Capacity Communication Channels](https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9906103) More generally, Mayers' proof applies only to protocols that exploit [quantum physics](/wiki/Quantum_physics \"Quantum physics\") but not [special relativity](/wiki/Special_relativity \"Special relativity\"). Kent has shown that there exist unconditionally secure protocols for bit commitment that exploit the principle of [special relativity](/wiki/Special_relativity \"Special relativity\") stating that information cannot travel faster than light.{{Cite journal\\|last\\=Kent\\|first\\=A.\\|date\\= 1999\\|title\\=Unconditionally Secure Bit Commitment\\|journal\\=Phys. Rev. Lett.\\|language\\=en\\|volume\\=83\\|issue\\=7\\|pages\\=1447–1450\\|doi\\=10\\.1103/PhysRevLett.83\\.1447\\|arxiv\\=quant\\-ph/9810068\\|bibcode\\=1999PhRvL..83\\.1447K\\|s2cid\\=8823466}}",
""
] |
Fictional character biography
-----------------------------
Walter Newell first appears in the title *[Tales to Astonish](/wiki/Tales_to_Astonish "Tales to Astonish")* as an [oceanographer](/wiki/Oceanography "Oceanography") working for the [United States](/wiki/United_States "United States") government. The character encounters the human/[Atlantean](/wiki/Homo_mermanus "Homo mermanus") [hybrid](/wiki/Hybrid_%28biology%29 "Hybrid (biology)") hero [Namor the Sub\-Mariner](/wiki/Namor "Namor") and his lover [Lady Dorma](/wiki/Lady_Dorma "Lady Dorma"), while supervising the construction of a domed sub\-sea city whose purpose is to harvest food for mankind. The city, however, is destroyed by the villain the [Plunderer](/wiki/Plunderer_%28character%29 "Plunderer (character)").*Tales to Astonish* \#95 (Sep. 1967\). Marvel Comics. Newell becomes a perennial character in the title *Prince Namor, the Sub\-Mariner* and aids the hero and Dorma against the villain [Tiger Shark](/wiki/Tiger_Shark_%28Marvel_Comics%29 "Tiger Shark (Marvel Comics)")*Prince Namor, the Sub\-Mariner* \#16 (Aug. 1969\). Marvel Comics. and is coerced by the government into investigating the disappearance of water from the Earth's oceans. This is attributed to [aliens](/wiki/Extraterrestrial_life "Extraterrestrial life") who are believed to be in league with Namor. Ordered to capture Namor, Newell develops a suit based on the form of the sea creature the [manta ray](/wiki/Manta_ray "Manta ray"), and as 'Stingray' captures Namor, who was weakened at the time. Newell, however, believes Namor to be innocent and allows him to escape.*Prince Namor, the Sub\-Mariner* \#19 (Nov. 1969\). Marvel Comics.
Stingray aids Namor and the [Inhuman](/wiki/Inhumans "Inhumans") [Triton](/wiki/Triton_%28comics%29 "Triton (comics)") against a group of Atlanteans who destroy an [ocean liner](/wiki/Ocean_liner "Ocean liner") and falsely claim to have done so for Namor. The culprit is revealed to be Atlantean [warlord](/wiki/Warlord "Warlord") [Attuma](/wiki/Attuma "Attuma"), who is eventually defeated.*Prince Namor, the Sub\-Mariner* \#31 (Nov. 1970\). Marvel Comics. Stingray assists Namor in a search for his father Leonard Mackenzie, with Mackenzie being accidentally killed in a battle with villains [Llyra](/wiki/Llyra "Llyra") and [Tiger Shark](/wiki/Tiger_Shark_%28Marvel_Comics%29 "Tiger Shark (Marvel Comics)").*Prince Namor, the Sub\-Mariner* \#39 (July 1971\) \& \#41 – 45 (Sep. 1971 – Jan. 1972\). Marvel Comics.
After brief appearances in titles the [Hulk](/wiki/Hulk "Hulk")*Hulk* \#221 (Mar. 1978\). Marvel Comics. and [Defenders](/wiki/Defenders_%28comics%29 "Defenders (comics)"),*Defenders* \#62 – 64 (Aug. – Oct. 1978\). Marvel Comics. Newell becomes a regular guest\-star in the title *[Marvel Two\-In\-One](/wiki/Marvel_Two-In-One "Marvel Two-In-One")*. The character moves his oceanographic facilities and research to [Hydro\-Base](/wiki/Hydro-Base "Hydro-Base"), an artificial island previously used by the insane [ecologist](/wiki/Ecology "Ecology") [Doctor Hydro](/wiki/Doctor_Hydro "Doctor Hydro") (occupied by Dr. Henry Croft and the passengers of an [airplane](/wiki/Airplane "Airplane"), who were captured by Hydro and changed into [merfolk](/wiki/Mermaid "Mermaid") known as the [Hydro\-Men](/wiki/Hydro-Men "Hydro-Men")).*Marvel Two\-In\-One* \#64 (June 1980\). Marvel Comics. As Stingray, Newell aids [Fantastic Four](/wiki/Fantastic_Four "Fantastic Four") member the [Thing](/wiki/Thing_%28comics%29 "Thing (comics)"), Triton, and heroine the [Scarlet Witch](/wiki/Scarlet_Witch "Scarlet Witch") against the villains the [Serpent Squad](/wiki/Serpent_Squad "Serpent Squad") and company [Roxxon Oil](/wiki/Roxxon_Oil "Roxxon Oil") to prevent them from obtaining the [artifact](/wiki/Magic_item "Magic item") the [Serpent Crown](/wiki/Serpent_Crown "Serpent Crown").*Marvel Two\-in\-One* \#64 – 66 (June – Aug. 1980\). Marvel Comics. Stingray is present when [Mister Fantastic](/wiki/Mister_Fantastic "Mister Fantastic") cures Croft and the other passengers, and aids the Thing and Inhumans [Gorgon](/wiki/Gorgon_%28Inhuman%29 "Gorgon (Inhuman)") and [Karnak](/wiki/Karnak_%28comics%29 "Karnak (comics)") against [Maelstrom's Minions](/wiki/Maelstrom%27s_Minions "Maelstrom's Minions"), who steal a dose of the healing compound.*Marvel Two\-in\-One* \#71 (Jan. 1981\). Marvel Comics.
Newell marries **Diane Arliss**, the sister of Todd Arliss (the real name of villain Tiger Shark)*Marvel Two\-in\-One* \#74 (Apr. 1981\). Marvel Comics. and leased part of Hydro\-Base to superhero team the [Avengers](/wiki/Avengers_%28comics%29 "Avengers (comics)"), and becomes an associate member of the team.*Avengers* \#262 (Dec. 1985\). Marvel Comics. During the first "[Armor Wars](/wiki/Armor_Wars "Armor Wars")" storyline, Avenger [Iron Man](/wiki/Iron_Man "Iron Man") confronts Stingray, mistakenly believing that Newell's suit was based on technology stolen from [Stark Enterprises](/wiki/Stark_Industries "Stark Industries"), forcing Stark to publicly fire Iron Man to protect his company from being affected by his current actions after he confirmed that Stingray's suit had been independently created.*Iron Man* \#226 (Jan. 1988\). Marvel Comics. Stingray aids the Avengers when Hydro\-Base is invaded by [Heavy Metal](/wiki/Heavy_Metal_%28Marvel_Comics%29 "Heavy Metal (Marvel Comics)"), a team of [robot](/wiki/Robot "Robot") villains (consisting of the [Super\-Adaptoid](/wiki/Super-Adaptoid "Super-Adaptoid"), [Machine Man](/wiki/Machine_Man "Machine Man"), [Awesome Android](/wiki/Awesome_Android "Awesome Android"), [TESS\-One](/wiki/TESS-One "TESS-One"), and the [Kree](/wiki/Kree "Kree") [Sentry 459](/wiki/Sentry_%28Kree%29 "Sentry (Kree)")).*Avengers* \#289 – 290 (Mar. – Apr. 1988\). Marvel Comics.
During the "[Acts of Vengeance](/wiki/Acts_of_Vengeance "Acts of Vengeance")" storyline, the Hydro\-Base is damaged by an attack from [Doctor Doom](/wiki/Doctor_Doom "Doctor Doom")'s [Doombots](/wiki/Doombot "Doombot") and sinks, with Stingray aiding the Avenger [Quasar](/wiki/Quasar_%28Wendell_Vaughn%29 "Quasar (Wendell Vaughn)") in a [salvage](/wiki/Marine_salvage "Marine salvage") operation,*Quasar* \#5 (Dec. 1989\). Marvel Comics. and then joining a group of reserve Avengers in a battle against the [Mad Thinker](/wiki/Mad_Thinker "Mad Thinker")'s Awesome Android.*Avengers Spotlight* \#27 (Dec. 1989\). Marvel Comics. In the title *[Marvel Comics Presents](/wiki/Marvel_Comics_Presents "Marvel Comics Presents")* Stingray encounters now\-[brother\-in\-law](/wiki/Brother-in-law "Brother-in-law") Tiger Shark and after a battle work together to save Diane Arliss, who is trapped after a [cave\-in](/wiki/Cave-in "Cave-in").*Marvel Comics Presents* \#53 – 54 (July 1990\) \& \#55 – 56 (Aug. 1990\). Marvel Comics. The character aids the Avengers, [Canadian](/wiki/Canadian "Canadian") super team [Alpha Flight](/wiki/Alpha_Flight "Alpha Flight"), and the [People's Protectorate](/wiki/Supreme_Soviets "Supreme Soviets") during *The Crossing Line* storyline*Avengers* \#319 – 324 (July – Oct. 1990\). Marvel Comics. and with Namor battles a [subterranean](/wiki/Subterranea_%28geography%29 "Subterranea (geography)") army.*Namor the Sub\-Mariner* Annual \#1 (Jan. 1991\). Marvel Comics. Diane confirms to him sometime later that she is pregnant, although the details have never been mentioned or seen since.*Namor the Sub\-Mariner* Annual \#4 (July 1994\). Marvel Comics.
After featuring in a *Marvel Comics Presents* solo story*Marvel Comics Presents* \#173 (Feb. 1995\). Marvel Comics. the character appears in the first storyline of the third volume of the title the *Avengers*.*Avengers* \#1 – 3 (Feb. – Apr. 1998\). Marvel Comics. Later, Stingray aids the Avengers in an extended storyline against futuristic villain [Kang the Conqueror](/wiki/Kang_the_Conqueror "Kang the Conqueror");*Avengers* \#43 – 45 (Aug. – Sep. 2001\); \#46 (Nov. 2001\); \#52 – 55 (May – Aug. 2002\). Marvel Comics. appears in the [limited series](/wiki/Limited_series_%28comics%29 "Limited series (comics)") *Avengers/Thunderbolts**Avengers/Thunderbolts* \#3 (June 2004\). Issues \#1 – 6 (May – Sep. 2004\). Marvel Comics. and the final issues of the third volume of the Avengers.*Avengers* \#501 – 503 (Oct. – Dec. 2004\). Marvel Comics.
During the "[Civil War](/wiki/Civil_War_%28comics%29 "Civil War (comics)")" storyline, Stingray is a member of the Secret Avengers – led by [Captain America](/wiki/Captain_America "Captain America") – who oppose the [Superhuman Registration Act](/wiki/Registration_acts_%28comics%29%232006_Superhuman_Registration_Act "Registration acts (comics)#2006 Superhuman Registration Act").*Civil War* \#5 (Nov. 2006\). Issues \# 1 – 7 (July 2007 – Jan. 2007\). Marvel Comics. After Captain America's arrest and subsequent death, Stingray accepts [Tony Stark](/wiki/Iron_Man "Iron Man")'s (Iron Man's [alter ego](/wiki/Alter_ego "Alter ego")) offer of a full pardon, and joins [The Initiative](/wiki/Fifty_State_Initiative "Fifty State Initiative").*Iron Man/Captain America: Casualties of War* \#1 (Feb. 2007\); *Civil War: Battle Damage Report* \#1 (May 2007\); *Avengers: The Initiative* \#1 (June 2007\). Marvel Comics.
The character appears in another solo story in the second volume of *Marvel Comics Presents**Marvel Comics Presents* vol. 2, \#11 (Sep. 2008\) and in an ongoing basis in the title *Avengers: The Initiative*.*Avengers: The Initiative* \#3 (Aug. 2007\); \#8 (Feb. 2008\); \#10 (May 2008\); \#14 – 15 (Aug. – Sep. 2008\); \#21 – 23 (Feb. – Mar. 2009\); \#23 (June 2009\). Marvel Comics.
During the "[AXIS](/wiki/AXIS_%28comics%29 "AXIS (comics)")" storyline, Stingray is among the heroes recruited by an inverted Doctor Doom to join his team of Avengers. This group tries to focus on the innocent people put in danger where Scarlet Witch, now uncaring of morality, attacks Latveria. Stingray does his part by rescuing several people from a debris\-filled river. His actions earn him the respect of U.S. Agent.*Avengers World* \#15 (2015\). Marvel Comics.
As part of the "[All\-New, All\-Different Marvel](/wiki/All-New%2C_All-Different_Marvel "All-New, All-Different Marvel")", Stingray is seen as part of [Deadpool](/wiki/Deadpool "Deadpool")'s [Mercs for Money](/wiki/Mercs_for_Money "Mercs for Money").*Deadpool* vol. 4 \#1\. Marvel Comics. It is later revealed that he is a [double agent](/wiki/Double_agent "Double agent") who Captain America assigned to monitor the team.*Deadpool* vol. 4 \#3\. Marvel Comics.
During the "[Secret Empire](/wiki/Secret_Empire_%282017_comic%29 "Secret Empire (2017 comic)")" storyline, Stingray appears as a member of a resistance against [Hydra](/wiki/Hydra_%28comics%29 "Hydra (comics)") following their takeover of the United States.*Secret Empire* \#1 (June 2017\). Marvel Comics.
Stingray and Diane were later on a cruise that was attacked by Tiger Shark. Their fight took place underwater until Namor crashed it demanding their allegiance. When Stingray tried to reason with Namor, he is attacked by the War Sharks summoned by Namor forcing Tiger Shark to side with Namor. This attack left him near\-death, but he survived as confirmed when the Avengers confronted Namor and the Defenders of the Deep about this action.*Avengers* Vol. 8 \#9–10\. Marvel Comics.
During the "Iron Man 2020" event, Stingray fought Captain Barracuda and his army of Robo\-Buccaneers at the [Bermuda Triangle](/wiki/Bermuda_Triangle "Bermuda Triangle"). The battle was crashed by [Machinesmith](/wiki/Machinesmith "Machinesmith") who persuaded the Robo\-Buccaneers to join the A.I. Army. As the Robo\-Buccaneers take up the offer and leave with Machinesmith, Stingray states to a confused Captain Barracuda that he will have to knock him out now.*Iron Man 2020* Vol. 2 \#2\. Marvel Comics.
|
[
"Fictional character biography\n-----------------------------",
"Walter Newell first appears in the title *[Tales to Astonish](/wiki/Tales_to_Astonish \"Tales to Astonish\")* as an [oceanographer](/wiki/Oceanography \"Oceanography\") working for the [United States](/wiki/United_States \"United States\") government. The character encounters the human/[Atlantean](/wiki/Homo_mermanus \"Homo mermanus\") [hybrid](/wiki/Hybrid_%28biology%29 \"Hybrid (biology)\") hero [Namor the Sub\\-Mariner](/wiki/Namor \"Namor\") and his lover [Lady Dorma](/wiki/Lady_Dorma \"Lady Dorma\"), while supervising the construction of a domed sub\\-sea city whose purpose is to harvest food for mankind. The city, however, is destroyed by the villain the [Plunderer](/wiki/Plunderer_%28character%29 \"Plunderer (character)\").*Tales to Astonish* \\#95 (Sep. 1967\\). Marvel Comics. Newell becomes a perennial character in the title *Prince Namor, the Sub\\-Mariner* and aids the hero and Dorma against the villain [Tiger Shark](/wiki/Tiger_Shark_%28Marvel_Comics%29 \"Tiger Shark (Marvel Comics)\")*Prince Namor, the Sub\\-Mariner* \\#16 (Aug. 1969\\). Marvel Comics. and is coerced by the government into investigating the disappearance of water from the Earth's oceans. This is attributed to [aliens](/wiki/Extraterrestrial_life \"Extraterrestrial life\") who are believed to be in league with Namor. Ordered to capture Namor, Newell develops a suit based on the form of the sea creature the [manta ray](/wiki/Manta_ray \"Manta ray\"), and as 'Stingray' captures Namor, who was weakened at the time. Newell, however, believes Namor to be innocent and allows him to escape.*Prince Namor, the Sub\\-Mariner* \\#19 (Nov. 1969\\). Marvel Comics.",
"Stingray aids Namor and the [Inhuman](/wiki/Inhumans \"Inhumans\") [Triton](/wiki/Triton_%28comics%29 \"Triton (comics)\") against a group of Atlanteans who destroy an [ocean liner](/wiki/Ocean_liner \"Ocean liner\") and falsely claim to have done so for Namor. The culprit is revealed to be Atlantean [warlord](/wiki/Warlord \"Warlord\") [Attuma](/wiki/Attuma \"Attuma\"), who is eventually defeated.*Prince Namor, the Sub\\-Mariner* \\#31 (Nov. 1970\\). Marvel Comics. Stingray assists Namor in a search for his father Leonard Mackenzie, with Mackenzie being accidentally killed in a battle with villains [Llyra](/wiki/Llyra \"Llyra\") and [Tiger Shark](/wiki/Tiger_Shark_%28Marvel_Comics%29 \"Tiger Shark (Marvel Comics)\").*Prince Namor, the Sub\\-Mariner* \\#39 (July 1971\\) \\& \\#41 – 45 (Sep. 1971 – Jan. 1972\\). Marvel Comics.",
"After brief appearances in titles the [Hulk](/wiki/Hulk \"Hulk\")*Hulk* \\#221 (Mar. 1978\\). Marvel Comics. and [Defenders](/wiki/Defenders_%28comics%29 \"Defenders (comics)\"),*Defenders* \\#62 – 64 (Aug. – Oct. 1978\\). Marvel Comics. Newell becomes a regular guest\\-star in the title *[Marvel Two\\-In\\-One](/wiki/Marvel_Two-In-One \"Marvel Two-In-One\")*. The character moves his oceanographic facilities and research to [Hydro\\-Base](/wiki/Hydro-Base \"Hydro-Base\"), an artificial island previously used by the insane [ecologist](/wiki/Ecology \"Ecology\") [Doctor Hydro](/wiki/Doctor_Hydro \"Doctor Hydro\") (occupied by Dr. Henry Croft and the passengers of an [airplane](/wiki/Airplane \"Airplane\"), who were captured by Hydro and changed into [merfolk](/wiki/Mermaid \"Mermaid\") known as the [Hydro\\-Men](/wiki/Hydro-Men \"Hydro-Men\")).*Marvel Two\\-In\\-One* \\#64 (June 1980\\). Marvel Comics. As Stingray, Newell aids [Fantastic Four](/wiki/Fantastic_Four \"Fantastic Four\") member the [Thing](/wiki/Thing_%28comics%29 \"Thing (comics)\"), Triton, and heroine the [Scarlet Witch](/wiki/Scarlet_Witch \"Scarlet Witch\") against the villains the [Serpent Squad](/wiki/Serpent_Squad \"Serpent Squad\") and company [Roxxon Oil](/wiki/Roxxon_Oil \"Roxxon Oil\") to prevent them from obtaining the [artifact](/wiki/Magic_item \"Magic item\") the [Serpent Crown](/wiki/Serpent_Crown \"Serpent Crown\").*Marvel Two\\-in\\-One* \\#64 – 66 (June – Aug. 1980\\). Marvel Comics. Stingray is present when [Mister Fantastic](/wiki/Mister_Fantastic \"Mister Fantastic\") cures Croft and the other passengers, and aids the Thing and Inhumans [Gorgon](/wiki/Gorgon_%28Inhuman%29 \"Gorgon (Inhuman)\") and [Karnak](/wiki/Karnak_%28comics%29 \"Karnak (comics)\") against [Maelstrom's Minions](/wiki/Maelstrom%27s_Minions \"Maelstrom's Minions\"), who steal a dose of the healing compound.*Marvel Two\\-in\\-One* \\#71 (Jan. 1981\\). Marvel Comics.",
"Newell marries **Diane Arliss**, the sister of Todd Arliss (the real name of villain Tiger Shark)*Marvel Two\\-in\\-One* \\#74 (Apr. 1981\\). Marvel Comics. and leased part of Hydro\\-Base to superhero team the [Avengers](/wiki/Avengers_%28comics%29 \"Avengers (comics)\"), and becomes an associate member of the team.*Avengers* \\#262 (Dec. 1985\\). Marvel Comics. During the first \"[Armor Wars](/wiki/Armor_Wars \"Armor Wars\")\" storyline, Avenger [Iron Man](/wiki/Iron_Man \"Iron Man\") confronts Stingray, mistakenly believing that Newell's suit was based on technology stolen from [Stark Enterprises](/wiki/Stark_Industries \"Stark Industries\"), forcing Stark to publicly fire Iron Man to protect his company from being affected by his current actions after he confirmed that Stingray's suit had been independently created.*Iron Man* \\#226 (Jan. 1988\\). Marvel Comics. Stingray aids the Avengers when Hydro\\-Base is invaded by [Heavy Metal](/wiki/Heavy_Metal_%28Marvel_Comics%29 \"Heavy Metal (Marvel Comics)\"), a team of [robot](/wiki/Robot \"Robot\") villains (consisting of the [Super\\-Adaptoid](/wiki/Super-Adaptoid \"Super-Adaptoid\"), [Machine Man](/wiki/Machine_Man \"Machine Man\"), [Awesome Android](/wiki/Awesome_Android \"Awesome Android\"), [TESS\\-One](/wiki/TESS-One \"TESS-One\"), and the [Kree](/wiki/Kree \"Kree\") [Sentry 459](/wiki/Sentry_%28Kree%29 \"Sentry (Kree)\")).*Avengers* \\#289 – 290 (Mar. – Apr. 1988\\). Marvel Comics.",
"During the \"[Acts of Vengeance](/wiki/Acts_of_Vengeance \"Acts of Vengeance\")\" storyline, the Hydro\\-Base is damaged by an attack from [Doctor Doom](/wiki/Doctor_Doom \"Doctor Doom\")'s [Doombots](/wiki/Doombot \"Doombot\") and sinks, with Stingray aiding the Avenger [Quasar](/wiki/Quasar_%28Wendell_Vaughn%29 \"Quasar (Wendell Vaughn)\") in a [salvage](/wiki/Marine_salvage \"Marine salvage\") operation,*Quasar* \\#5 (Dec. 1989\\). Marvel Comics. and then joining a group of reserve Avengers in a battle against the [Mad Thinker](/wiki/Mad_Thinker \"Mad Thinker\")'s Awesome Android.*Avengers Spotlight* \\#27 (Dec. 1989\\). Marvel Comics. In the title *[Marvel Comics Presents](/wiki/Marvel_Comics_Presents \"Marvel Comics Presents\")* Stingray encounters now\\-[brother\\-in\\-law](/wiki/Brother-in-law \"Brother-in-law\") Tiger Shark and after a battle work together to save Diane Arliss, who is trapped after a [cave\\-in](/wiki/Cave-in \"Cave-in\").*Marvel Comics Presents* \\#53 – 54 (July 1990\\) \\& \\#55 – 56 (Aug. 1990\\). Marvel Comics. The character aids the Avengers, [Canadian](/wiki/Canadian \"Canadian\") super team [Alpha Flight](/wiki/Alpha_Flight \"Alpha Flight\"), and the [People's Protectorate](/wiki/Supreme_Soviets \"Supreme Soviets\") during *The Crossing Line* storyline*Avengers* \\#319 – 324 (July – Oct. 1990\\). Marvel Comics. and with Namor battles a [subterranean](/wiki/Subterranea_%28geography%29 \"Subterranea (geography)\") army.*Namor the Sub\\-Mariner* Annual \\#1 (Jan. 1991\\). Marvel Comics. Diane confirms to him sometime later that she is pregnant, although the details have never been mentioned or seen since.*Namor the Sub\\-Mariner* Annual \\#4 (July 1994\\). Marvel Comics.",
"After featuring in a *Marvel Comics Presents* solo story*Marvel Comics Presents* \\#173 (Feb. 1995\\). Marvel Comics. the character appears in the first storyline of the third volume of the title the *Avengers*.*Avengers* \\#1 – 3 (Feb. – Apr. 1998\\). Marvel Comics. Later, Stingray aids the Avengers in an extended storyline against futuristic villain [Kang the Conqueror](/wiki/Kang_the_Conqueror \"Kang the Conqueror\");*Avengers* \\#43 – 45 (Aug. – Sep. 2001\\); \\#46 (Nov. 2001\\); \\#52 – 55 (May – Aug. 2002\\). Marvel Comics. appears in the [limited series](/wiki/Limited_series_%28comics%29 \"Limited series (comics)\") *Avengers/Thunderbolts**Avengers/Thunderbolts* \\#3 (June 2004\\). Issues \\#1 – 6 (May – Sep. 2004\\). Marvel Comics. and the final issues of the third volume of the Avengers.*Avengers* \\#501 – 503 (Oct. – Dec. 2004\\). Marvel Comics.",
"During the \"[Civil War](/wiki/Civil_War_%28comics%29 \"Civil War (comics)\")\" storyline, Stingray is a member of the Secret Avengers – led by [Captain America](/wiki/Captain_America \"Captain America\") – who oppose the [Superhuman Registration Act](/wiki/Registration_acts_%28comics%29%232006_Superhuman_Registration_Act \"Registration acts (comics)#2006 Superhuman Registration Act\").*Civil War* \\#5 (Nov. 2006\\). Issues \\# 1 – 7 (July 2007 – Jan. 2007\\). Marvel Comics. After Captain America's arrest and subsequent death, Stingray accepts [Tony Stark](/wiki/Iron_Man \"Iron Man\")'s (Iron Man's [alter ego](/wiki/Alter_ego \"Alter ego\")) offer of a full pardon, and joins [The Initiative](/wiki/Fifty_State_Initiative \"Fifty State Initiative\").*Iron Man/Captain America: Casualties of War* \\#1 (Feb. 2007\\); *Civil War: Battle Damage Report* \\#1 (May 2007\\); *Avengers: The Initiative* \\#1 (June 2007\\). Marvel Comics.",
"The character appears in another solo story in the second volume of *Marvel Comics Presents**Marvel Comics Presents* vol. 2, \\#11 (Sep. 2008\\) and in an ongoing basis in the title *Avengers: The Initiative*.*Avengers: The Initiative* \\#3 (Aug. 2007\\); \\#8 (Feb. 2008\\); \\#10 (May 2008\\); \\#14 – 15 (Aug. – Sep. 2008\\); \\#21 – 23 (Feb. – Mar. 2009\\); \\#23 (June 2009\\). Marvel Comics.",
"During the \"[AXIS](/wiki/AXIS_%28comics%29 \"AXIS (comics)\")\" storyline, Stingray is among the heroes recruited by an inverted Doctor Doom to join his team of Avengers. This group tries to focus on the innocent people put in danger where Scarlet Witch, now uncaring of morality, attacks Latveria. Stingray does his part by rescuing several people from a debris\\-filled river. His actions earn him the respect of U.S. Agent.*Avengers World* \\#15 (2015\\). Marvel Comics.",
"As part of the \"[All\\-New, All\\-Different Marvel](/wiki/All-New%2C_All-Different_Marvel \"All-New, All-Different Marvel\")\", Stingray is seen as part of [Deadpool](/wiki/Deadpool \"Deadpool\")'s [Mercs for Money](/wiki/Mercs_for_Money \"Mercs for Money\").*Deadpool* vol. 4 \\#1\\. Marvel Comics. It is later revealed that he is a [double agent](/wiki/Double_agent \"Double agent\") who Captain America assigned to monitor the team.*Deadpool* vol. 4 \\#3\\. Marvel Comics.",
"During the \"[Secret Empire](/wiki/Secret_Empire_%282017_comic%29 \"Secret Empire (2017 comic)\")\" storyline, Stingray appears as a member of a resistance against [Hydra](/wiki/Hydra_%28comics%29 \"Hydra (comics)\") following their takeover of the United States.*Secret Empire* \\#1 (June 2017\\). Marvel Comics.",
"Stingray and Diane were later on a cruise that was attacked by Tiger Shark. Their fight took place underwater until Namor crashed it demanding their allegiance. When Stingray tried to reason with Namor, he is attacked by the War Sharks summoned by Namor forcing Tiger Shark to side with Namor. This attack left him near\\-death, but he survived as confirmed when the Avengers confronted Namor and the Defenders of the Deep about this action.*Avengers* Vol. 8 \\#9–10\\. Marvel Comics.",
"During the \"Iron Man 2020\" event, Stingray fought Captain Barracuda and his army of Robo\\-Buccaneers at the [Bermuda Triangle](/wiki/Bermuda_Triangle \"Bermuda Triangle\"). The battle was crashed by [Machinesmith](/wiki/Machinesmith \"Machinesmith\") who persuaded the Robo\\-Buccaneers to join the A.I. Army. As the Robo\\-Buccaneers take up the offer and leave with Machinesmith, Stingray states to a confused Captain Barracuda that he will have to knock him out now.*Iron Man 2020* Vol. 2 \\#2\\. Marvel Comics.",
""
] |
History
-------
In *Pigot's Commercial Directory* of 1837 John Zair is listed as a whip\-maker trading at 8 Exeter Row, Birmingham, in the heart of the manufacturing quarter by [Gas Street Basin](/wiki/Gas_Street_Basin "Gas Street Basin").Prior suggests that he was probably born in [Gnosall](/wiki/Gnosall "Gnosall"), Staffordhire, but in the 1861 census, his place of birth is given as Birmingham. See *In Good Hands*, p. 84\. Recorded still in the 1841 census as whip\-maker, he was by 1849 trading from 280 Great Colmore Street as a "manufacturer of every description of whips".
John Zair was something of a philanthropist: he served as governor of the [Queen's Hospital](/wiki/Birmingham_Accident_Hospital "Birmingham Accident Hospital") and was an annual subscriber to the Lying\-In Hospital and the Eye and Ear Dispensary and made donations to good causes.
His two sons George and John Jr would later take over the business and become the G. and the J. of the company name. They had their own factory built in Bishop Street, possibly based on drawings by the Birmingham firm of architects and surveyors, [James \& Lister Lea](/wiki/James_%26_Lister_Lea "James & Lister Lea"), who managed the building's affairs well into the twentieth century. When John Zair Jr retired in 1893, George carried on with the assistance of his son George Percy.
The silver mark of "G\&J.Z." was registered with the [Birmingham Assay Office](/wiki/Birmingham_Assay_Office "Birmingham Assay Office") in 1884\.
George Percy Zair took over running the firm after his father died in 1914\. Having successfully steered the firm through the war, he incorporated the firm as G. \& J. Zair Ltd in 1924\. By the end of 1926 he and his widowed mother, who between them held most of the shares, decided to sell the company to [Swaine \& Adeney Ltd](/wiki/Swaine_Adeney_Brigg "Swaine Adeney Brigg"). George Percy stayed on as manager of the Birmingham factory with an annual salary and a share bonus and became a director of Swaine \& Adeney Ltd.
The Zair name was kept alive and the whips continued to be made in Birmingham, as well as some other Swaine \& Adeney leather goods. The making of whips for other companies and outlets also continued. The premises on Bishop Street remained in the ownership of George Percy and his mother and were leased out to the new parent company. On George Percy's retirement in 1947 the building was sold to [Sir Robert Gooch, Bt](/wiki/Sir_Robert_Gooch%2C_11th_Baronet "Sir Robert Gooch, 11th Baronet") of [Benacre Hall](/wiki/Benacre_Hall "Benacre Hall"), Suffolk.*In Good Hands*, p. 88\. He leased it to G. \& J. Zair until 1965, when Swaine, Adeney, Brigg \& Sons Ltd took the decision to concentrate their manufacturing at their new Great Chesterford factory in Essex. At that point the use of the Zair name was discontinued.
|
[
"History\n-------",
"In *Pigot's Commercial Directory* of 1837 John Zair is listed as a whip\\-maker trading at 8 Exeter Row, Birmingham, in the heart of the manufacturing quarter by [Gas Street Basin](/wiki/Gas_Street_Basin \"Gas Street Basin\").Prior suggests that he was probably born in [Gnosall](/wiki/Gnosall \"Gnosall\"), Staffordhire, but in the 1861 census, his place of birth is given as Birmingham. See *In Good Hands*, p. 84\\. Recorded still in the 1841 census as whip\\-maker, he was by 1849 trading from 280 Great Colmore Street as a \"manufacturer of every description of whips\".",
"John Zair was something of a philanthropist: he served as governor of the [Queen's Hospital](/wiki/Birmingham_Accident_Hospital \"Birmingham Accident Hospital\") and was an annual subscriber to the Lying\\-In Hospital and the Eye and Ear Dispensary and made donations to good causes.",
"His two sons George and John Jr would later take over the business and become the G. and the J. of the company name. They had their own factory built in Bishop Street, possibly based on drawings by the Birmingham firm of architects and surveyors, [James \\& Lister Lea](/wiki/James_%26_Lister_Lea \"James & Lister Lea\"), who managed the building's affairs well into the twentieth century. When John Zair Jr retired in 1893, George carried on with the assistance of his son George Percy.",
"The silver mark of \"G\\&J.Z.\" was registered with the [Birmingham Assay Office](/wiki/Birmingham_Assay_Office \"Birmingham Assay Office\") in 1884\\.",
"George Percy Zair took over running the firm after his father died in 1914\\. Having successfully steered the firm through the war, he incorporated the firm as G. \\& J. Zair Ltd in 1924\\. By the end of 1926 he and his widowed mother, who between them held most of the shares, decided to sell the company to [Swaine \\& Adeney Ltd](/wiki/Swaine_Adeney_Brigg \"Swaine Adeney Brigg\"). George Percy stayed on as manager of the Birmingham factory with an annual salary and a share bonus and became a director of Swaine \\& Adeney Ltd.",
"The Zair name was kept alive and the whips continued to be made in Birmingham, as well as some other Swaine \\& Adeney leather goods. The making of whips for other companies and outlets also continued. The premises on Bishop Street remained in the ownership of George Percy and his mother and were leased out to the new parent company. On George Percy's retirement in 1947 the building was sold to [Sir Robert Gooch, Bt](/wiki/Sir_Robert_Gooch%2C_11th_Baronet \"Sir Robert Gooch, 11th Baronet\") of [Benacre Hall](/wiki/Benacre_Hall \"Benacre Hall\"), Suffolk.*In Good Hands*, p. 88\\. He leased it to G. \\& J. Zair until 1965, when Swaine, Adeney, Brigg \\& Sons Ltd took the decision to concentrate their manufacturing at their new Great Chesterford factory in Essex. At that point the use of the Zair name was discontinued.",
""
] |
Document Structure and Text
---------------------------
### Preamble
The preamble gives a short explanation of Tasmania's constitutional history, as well as an acknowledgement of [Tasmanian Aboriginals](/wiki/Tasmanian_Aboriginals "Tasmanian Aboriginals") as the island's [indigenous people](/wiki/Indigenous_people "Indigenous people").
### Part I: Preliminary
This part deals with the [short title](/wiki/Short_title "Short title") of the Constitution Act and also provides definitions for key terms used later on.
### Part II: The Crown
[thumb\|200x200px\|[Government House, Hobart](/wiki/Government_House%2C_Hobart "Government House, Hobart") the official residence of the GovernorThis](/wiki/File:Government_House_Hobart2.png "Government House Hobart2.png") part deals with [the Crown in right of Tasmania](/wiki/Commonwealth_realm%23the_Crown_in_Commonwealth_realms "Commonwealth realm#the Crown in Commonwealth realms"). The term 'the Crown' can mean different things depending on the context, but this context it means the [executive government](/wiki/Executive_%28government%29 "Executive (government)") of Tasmania.{{cite journal \|last1\=Saunders \|first1\=Cheryl \|title\=The Concept of the Crown: International Relations and the British Commonwealth \|journal\=Melbourne University Law Review \|date\=2015 \|volume\=38 \|pages\=873–896 \|url\=https://law.unimelb.edu.au/\_\_data/assets/pdf\_file/0004/1587019/383Saunders4\.pdf \|access\-date\=23 January 2024}} Sections 4 to 7 deal with the continuity of government in the event of the [death of the Monarch](/wiki/Demise_of_the_Crown "Demise of the Crown").
Section 8 deals with the appointment of an Administrator or Deputy Lieutenant Governor to act in the place of the Lieutenant Governor or Governor. This means that the Government of Tasmania can continue to be administered in the absence, death or incapacity of the Governor or Lieutenant Governor. Section 8(1\) recognises the continuing legal force of the Letters Patent, which constitutes the office of Governor and Lieutenant Governor, as well as the Executive Council
[thumb\|200x200px\|The Executive Building, 15 Murray Street, Hobart. Location of the Tasmanian Government](/wiki/File:Exec-building-hbt.jpg "Exec-building-hbt.jpg")
Sections 8A to 8I deal with the appointment of ministers, the Attorney General (who is also a minister) and the Cabinet Secretary (who is not a minister).
### Part III: Parliament
#### Division 1: Both Houses
This division deals with issues relating to both houses, specifically dealing with:
* when Parliament shall sit (sections 11, 12 and 13\)
* when the Governor may dissolve the Parliament and issue writs for fresh elections (section 12\)
* the qualifications for candidates to run for Parliament (section 14\)
* how someone may resign their seat in Parliament (section 15\)
* the creation of standing orders by either house (section 17\)
#### Division 2: The Council
This division creates the Legislative Council as the upper chamber. Section 18 states that it shall have 15 members, each elected from a [single member electorates](/wiki/Single_member_electorates "Single member electorates") called Council divisions. This makes it the only Parliament in Australia that uses single member electorates for its upper chamber. Section 19 states the members of the council shall serve for a term of 6 years.
Sections 20 and 21 deal with the [quorum](/wiki/Quorum "Quorum") required to proceed with the business of the Council (which is 7\) and the election of the President, who presides over the Council.
#### Division 3: The Assembly
This division creates the House of Assembly as the lower chamber. According to constitutional convention, this chamber is where a party or coalition must form a majority in order to control the executive government. By convention, [the Premier](/wiki/Premier_of_Tasmania "Premier of Tasmania") is usually a member of the Assembly, but historically this has not always been the case.{{cite web \|title\=Premier and Leader of Opposition \|url\=https://www.parliament.tas.gov.au/resources/about\-parliament/premier\-leader \|website\=Parliament of Tasmania \|date\=13 June 2023 \|access\-date\=23 January 2024}}
Sections 22 and 23 detail that the House of Assembly comprises 35 members elected for a four year term. For the purposes of electing the Assembly, the State is divided into 5 multi\-member electorates, which each return 7 members each. It is the only State Parliament in Australia that has [multi\-member electorates](/wiki/Multiwinner_voting "Multiwinner voting") for its lower chamber called Assembly divisions. The [Australian Capital Territory Legislative Assembly](/wiki/Australian_Capital_Territory_Legislative_Assembly "Australian Capital Territory Legislative Assembly") also uses multi member electorates but it is a territory, [unicameral](/wiki/Unicameral "Unicameral") and is not technically labelled a Parliament. The boundaries of the five assembly districts are the same as Tasmania's five federal electorates for the House of Representatives in the Commonwealth Parliament.{{cite web \|last1\=Stait \|first1\=Bryan \|title\=House of Assembly \|url\=https://www.utas.edu.au/library/companion\_to\_tasmanian\_history/H/House%20of%20Assembly.htm \|website\=The Companion to Tasmanian History \|publisher\=University of Tasmania \|access\-date\=23 January 2024}}
Sections 24 and 25 deal with the quorum required to conduct the business of the Assembly (which is 14\) and the election of the Speaker to preside over the Assembly.
[thumb\|250x250px\|[Parliament House, Hobart](/wiki/Parliament_House%2C_Hobart "Parliament House, Hobart")](/wiki/File:Parliament_House_Hobart_Panorama.jpg "Parliament House Hobart Panorama.jpg")
#### Division 4: Qualifications of electors
This division provides some of the qualifications in order to vote for Parliament, although it also recognises there may be further requirements in the *Electoral Act 2004*. The qualifications include being at least 18 and an Australian citizen. It also provides that someone may only vote for the Council and Assembly division they live in.
#### Division 5: Disqualifications/Vacation of office/Penalty
This division primarily deals with circumstances in which someone shall be disqualified from being a member of Parliament. The following conditions mean that a person shall be incapable holding of office as a Parliamentarian if they:
* are a member of the Commonwealth Parliament, or a Commonwealth Minister (section 31\)
* hold some other government office (other than that of a Tasmanian Minister or Cabinet Secretary) (section 32\)
* are a Tasmanian Supreme Court Judge (section 32\)
* have a contract with the Government in certain circumstances (section 33\)
* fail to attend an entire session of Parliament without being excused by either house (section 34\)
* take any oath, declaration or act of allegiance to a foreign power (section 34\)
* knowingly become a foreign citizen (section 34\)
* are bankrupt (section 34\)
* commit treason, or are sentenced to more than one year in prison (unless pardoned) (section 34\)
* become of unsound mind (section 34\)
Section 30 also details the oath required to become a Parliamentarian.
### Part IV: Money Bills/Power of Houses
This part provides for how money bills shall be enacted by the Parliament. Money bills are proposed laws that allow for the expenditure of money and the imposition of taxes.
Sections 37 and 38 provide that money bills shall only be initiated by the Assembly on the recommendation of the Governor. This power of the Governor is exercised on the advice of Ministers, so effectively this means that Money Bills can only be implemented with the consent of the executive government.
Sections 39 and 40 provide that bills that spend money shall only contain provisions for that purpose. Section 41 provides that bills adjusting land or income taxes shall only deal with land or income taxes. Section 42 limits the powers of the Council to amend Money bills, however it can suggest amendments to the Assembly (which the Assembly may reject).
### Part IVA: Local Government
This part provides for a system of elected councils to act as the local governments of Tasmania.
### Part V: General Provisions
* Section 46 provides for religious freedom and separation of church and state, however this does not prevent the Parliament of Tasmania from overriding this provision.
* Section 47 contains transitional provisions from when the House of Assembly was expanded from 25 to 35 members in 2022\.
### Schedules
* Schedule 1 provides a list of statutes that were repealed by the *Constitution Act 1934*.
* Schedules 2\-3 have been repealed.
* Schedule 4 provides the names and locations of the Assembly districts.
|
[
"Document Structure and Text\n---------------------------",
"### Preamble",
"The preamble gives a short explanation of Tasmania's constitutional history, as well as an acknowledgement of [Tasmanian Aboriginals](/wiki/Tasmanian_Aboriginals \"Tasmanian Aboriginals\") as the island's [indigenous people](/wiki/Indigenous_people \"Indigenous people\").",
"### Part I: Preliminary",
"This part deals with the [short title](/wiki/Short_title \"Short title\") of the Constitution Act and also provides definitions for key terms used later on.",
"### Part II: The Crown",
"[thumb\\|200x200px\\|[Government House, Hobart](/wiki/Government_House%2C_Hobart \"Government House, Hobart\") the official residence of the GovernorThis](/wiki/File:Government_House_Hobart2.png \"Government House Hobart2.png\") part deals with [the Crown in right of Tasmania](/wiki/Commonwealth_realm%23the_Crown_in_Commonwealth_realms \"Commonwealth realm#the Crown in Commonwealth realms\"). The term 'the Crown' can mean different things depending on the context, but this context it means the [executive government](/wiki/Executive_%28government%29 \"Executive (government)\") of Tasmania.{{cite journal \\|last1\\=Saunders \\|first1\\=Cheryl \\|title\\=The Concept of the Crown: International Relations and the British Commonwealth \\|journal\\=Melbourne University Law Review \\|date\\=2015 \\|volume\\=38 \\|pages\\=873–896 \\|url\\=https://law.unimelb.edu.au/\\_\\_data/assets/pdf\\_file/0004/1587019/383Saunders4\\.pdf \\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2024}} Sections 4 to 7 deal with the continuity of government in the event of the [death of the Monarch](/wiki/Demise_of_the_Crown \"Demise of the Crown\").",
"Section 8 deals with the appointment of an Administrator or Deputy Lieutenant Governor to act in the place of the Lieutenant Governor or Governor. This means that the Government of Tasmania can continue to be administered in the absence, death or incapacity of the Governor or Lieutenant Governor. Section 8(1\\) recognises the continuing legal force of the Letters Patent, which constitutes the office of Governor and Lieutenant Governor, as well as the Executive Council\n[thumb\\|200x200px\\|The Executive Building, 15 Murray Street, Hobart. Location of the Tasmanian Government](/wiki/File:Exec-building-hbt.jpg \"Exec-building-hbt.jpg\")",
"Sections 8A to 8I deal with the appointment of ministers, the Attorney General (who is also a minister) and the Cabinet Secretary (who is not a minister).",
"### Part III: Parliament",
"#### Division 1: Both Houses",
"This division deals with issues relating to both houses, specifically dealing with:\n* when Parliament shall sit (sections 11, 12 and 13\\)\n* when the Governor may dissolve the Parliament and issue writs for fresh elections (section 12\\)\n* the qualifications for candidates to run for Parliament (section 14\\)\n* how someone may resign their seat in Parliament (section 15\\)\n* the creation of standing orders by either house (section 17\\)",
"#### Division 2: The Council",
"This division creates the Legislative Council as the upper chamber. Section 18 states that it shall have 15 members, each elected from a [single member electorates](/wiki/Single_member_electorates \"Single member electorates\") called Council divisions. This makes it the only Parliament in Australia that uses single member electorates for its upper chamber. Section 19 states the members of the council shall serve for a term of 6 years.",
"Sections 20 and 21 deal with the [quorum](/wiki/Quorum \"Quorum\") required to proceed with the business of the Council (which is 7\\) and the election of the President, who presides over the Council.",
"#### Division 3: The Assembly",
"This division creates the House of Assembly as the lower chamber. According to constitutional convention, this chamber is where a party or coalition must form a majority in order to control the executive government. By convention, [the Premier](/wiki/Premier_of_Tasmania \"Premier of Tasmania\") is usually a member of the Assembly, but historically this has not always been the case.{{cite web \\|title\\=Premier and Leader of Opposition \\|url\\=https://www.parliament.tas.gov.au/resources/about\\-parliament/premier\\-leader \\|website\\=Parliament of Tasmania \\|date\\=13 June 2023 \\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2024}}",
"Sections 22 and 23 detail that the House of Assembly comprises 35 members elected for a four year term. For the purposes of electing the Assembly, the State is divided into 5 multi\\-member electorates, which each return 7 members each. It is the only State Parliament in Australia that has [multi\\-member electorates](/wiki/Multiwinner_voting \"Multiwinner voting\") for its lower chamber called Assembly divisions. The [Australian Capital Territory Legislative Assembly](/wiki/Australian_Capital_Territory_Legislative_Assembly \"Australian Capital Territory Legislative Assembly\") also uses multi member electorates but it is a territory, [unicameral](/wiki/Unicameral \"Unicameral\") and is not technically labelled a Parliament. The boundaries of the five assembly districts are the same as Tasmania's five federal electorates for the House of Representatives in the Commonwealth Parliament.{{cite web \\|last1\\=Stait \\|first1\\=Bryan \\|title\\=House of Assembly \\|url\\=https://www.utas.edu.au/library/companion\\_to\\_tasmanian\\_history/H/House%20of%20Assembly.htm \\|website\\=The Companion to Tasmanian History \\|publisher\\=University of Tasmania \\|access\\-date\\=23 January 2024}}",
"Sections 24 and 25 deal with the quorum required to conduct the business of the Assembly (which is 14\\) and the election of the Speaker to preside over the Assembly.",
"[thumb\\|250x250px\\|[Parliament House, Hobart](/wiki/Parliament_House%2C_Hobart \"Parliament House, Hobart\")](/wiki/File:Parliament_House_Hobart_Panorama.jpg \"Parliament House Hobart Panorama.jpg\")",
"#### Division 4: Qualifications of electors",
"This division provides some of the qualifications in order to vote for Parliament, although it also recognises there may be further requirements in the *Electoral Act 2004*. The qualifications include being at least 18 and an Australian citizen. It also provides that someone may only vote for the Council and Assembly division they live in.",
"#### Division 5: Disqualifications/Vacation of office/Penalty",
"This division primarily deals with circumstances in which someone shall be disqualified from being a member of Parliament. The following conditions mean that a person shall be incapable holding of office as a Parliamentarian if they:\n* are a member of the Commonwealth Parliament, or a Commonwealth Minister (section 31\\)\n* hold some other government office (other than that of a Tasmanian Minister or Cabinet Secretary) (section 32\\)\n* are a Tasmanian Supreme Court Judge (section 32\\)\n* have a contract with the Government in certain circumstances (section 33\\)\n* fail to attend an entire session of Parliament without being excused by either house (section 34\\)\n* take any oath, declaration or act of allegiance to a foreign power (section 34\\)\n* knowingly become a foreign citizen (section 34\\)\n* are bankrupt (section 34\\)\n* commit treason, or are sentenced to more than one year in prison (unless pardoned) (section 34\\)\n* become of unsound mind (section 34\\)",
"Section 30 also details the oath required to become a Parliamentarian.",
"### Part IV: Money Bills/Power of Houses",
"This part provides for how money bills shall be enacted by the Parliament. Money bills are proposed laws that allow for the expenditure of money and the imposition of taxes.\nSections 37 and 38 provide that money bills shall only be initiated by the Assembly on the recommendation of the Governor. This power of the Governor is exercised on the advice of Ministers, so effectively this means that Money Bills can only be implemented with the consent of the executive government.",
"Sections 39 and 40 provide that bills that spend money shall only contain provisions for that purpose. Section 41 provides that bills adjusting land or income taxes shall only deal with land or income taxes. Section 42 limits the powers of the Council to amend Money bills, however it can suggest amendments to the Assembly (which the Assembly may reject).",
"### Part IVA: Local Government",
"This part provides for a system of elected councils to act as the local governments of Tasmania.",
"### Part V: General Provisions",
"* Section 46 provides for religious freedom and separation of church and state, however this does not prevent the Parliament of Tasmania from overriding this provision.\n* Section 47 contains transitional provisions from when the House of Assembly was expanded from 25 to 35 members in 2022\\.",
"### Schedules",
"* Schedule 1 provides a list of statutes that were repealed by the *Constitution Act 1934*.\n* Schedules 2\\-3 have been repealed.\n* Schedule 4 provides the names and locations of the Assembly districts."
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.